13.10.2016 Views

Maintworld Issue3 2016

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

3/<strong>2016</strong> www.maintworld.com<br />

maintenance & asset management<br />

Industry 4.0<br />

Knocking on Your<br />

Front Door PAGE 42<br />

RELIABILITY IN THE OIL & GAS INDUSTRY PAGE 12 SMARTENING UP OLD EQUIPMENT PAGE 24 REMOTE MONITORING WITH ULTRASOUND PAGE 48


While we’re known for our world-class motion control products, Moog’s ability to<br />

maximize your machine uptime doesn’t stop there. Moog Industrial Services provides<br />

products, services and total support that match your specific O&M needs and<br />

machinery challenges.<br />

Download “Lessons Learned” by a Moog maintenance<br />

expert at info.moog.com/mw.<br />

REPLACEMENT PRODUCTS/SPARES<br />

Ensure like-new performance<br />

with new, authentic Moog<br />

replacement products that meet<br />

today’s technical specifications.<br />

FACTORY REPAIRS<br />

Rely on high-quality servo repair<br />

for less unplanned downtime.<br />

LOCAL SUPPORT<br />

Work with responsive, locallybased<br />

Moog teams who speak your<br />

language and know your industry<br />

and equipment.<br />

WHAT MOVES YOUR WORLD


FLEXIBLE PROGRAMS<br />

Tailor a program for total confidence<br />

that maintenance is always available.<br />

ON-SITE TECHNICAL EXPERTS<br />

Stay productive with quick and<br />

convenient on-site commissioning,<br />

set-up and diagnostics for total<br />

peace of mind.<br />

HANDS-ON TRAINING<br />

Gain motion control expertise<br />

and effectively manage installation<br />

and troubleshooting.<br />

©<strong>2016</strong> Moog Inc. All rights reserved.<br />

moogglobalsupport.com


EDITORIAL<br />

Teksti Martti Hakonen<br />

From Analog<br />

to Digital<br />

Kuva: Antti Verkasalo<br />

LIFE WAS a lot more analogical when I graduated in the late 1970’s. The<br />

first microprocessors were out but programming languages such as<br />

Assembler did not indicate that the new technology would make our<br />

life any easier. Computers had to be started with on-off switches and<br />

a punch tape. Whatever you wanted to do, the limitations in memory<br />

size were a real barrier.<br />

The milestones in industrial maintenance and process automation,<br />

which I studied, were about the same. In the early 1980’s maintenance<br />

started with CMMSs (Computerized Maintenance Management Systems)<br />

and automation with DCSs (Distributed Controlled Systems).<br />

Digitalization entered the field in the latter part of the decade with<br />

measurement instruments for maintenance and automation. However,<br />

the dominant portion still remained analogical.<br />

The process industry started to benefit from the<br />

new generation of high performance electronics, quite<br />

often with extended operational range due to the<br />

increased availability of military grade components.<br />

Later in the 1990’s PC technology jumped in making<br />

our life again easier. We got a brand new offering<br />

of tools for core functionality like configuration and<br />

troubleshooting.<br />

The integration of software and PC-technology boomed after the<br />

Millennium. Most of the main players serving the process industry<br />

released software-based solutions for condition monitoring and asset<br />

management. Some of them only supported core functionalities, but<br />

the most advanced ones included sophisticated modelling features<br />

that help simulate process conditions and guide the user to avoid abnormal<br />

situations.<br />

There is a lot new expected to come out during this decade. Think<br />

about Internet of Things, mobile workers, 3D printing, laser scanning,<br />

wireless tools for condition monitoring and large data-based prognostic<br />

software solutions. Most of the above were available before 2010,<br />

but the real boom only began during the last few years.<br />

Digitalisation is the enabler of the new technologies. Our challenge<br />

is to take benefit from these new possibilities and turn them into improved<br />

reliability in our plants and processes. The good thing is that<br />

you do not have to do it by yourself – partnering and networking is the<br />

way to success.<br />

Last, but not least, I want to introduce the new Editor-in Chief, Nina<br />

Garlo-Melkas. She is an experienced journalist with a background<br />

in economics and science. From now on Nina is responsible for both<br />

<strong>Maintworld</strong> and Promaint magazines and I’ll provide editorial support<br />

as needed. Since February she has already been publishing our newsletters.<br />

Nina’s email is nina.garlo@omnipress.fi.<br />

Martti Hakonen<br />

4 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

Our challenge is to take benefit from new<br />

possibilities and turn them into improved<br />

reliability in our plants and processes.<br />

8<br />

OPC<br />

products available<br />

in the marketplace easily<br />

exceed 10,000; the exact<br />

number is unknown, and the<br />

number of installations is<br />

estimated to be in the tens<br />

of millions.


IN THIS ISSUE 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

24<br />

Researchers estimate that by<br />

2020 there will be as many as 26<br />

billion devices connected to the<br />

Internet.<br />

16<br />

To correctly deploy a<br />

monitoring tool, first<br />

know what to look for<br />

and then choose how to<br />

find it.<br />

6<br />

8<br />

12<br />

16<br />

20<br />

Towards Better Asset<br />

Performance<br />

OPC Unified Architecture<br />

Facilitates the Exchange of<br />

Information in the IoT<br />

Reliability - What Fails and What<br />

Do We Do About It?<br />

Choosing the Right Diagnostic<br />

Tools<br />

Things Many Vibration Analysts<br />

Don’t Do, but Should – Part 2<br />

24<br />

26<br />

30<br />

34<br />

36<br />

Smartening Up Old Equipment<br />

with IoT<br />

Recording - Back to the Future<br />

(Part 2)<br />

Smart Maintenance<br />

Management<br />

The Maintenance Effectiveness<br />

Assessment: A Catalyst for<br />

Change<br />

Reliability and Maintenance<br />

Management Beliefs – Part 1<br />

40<br />

42<br />

46<br />

48<br />

52<br />

Detect Leaks with Thermal<br />

Imaging<br />

Industry 4.0 Knocking on Your<br />

Front Door<br />

Increased reliability through<br />

continuous and remote<br />

substation asset monitoring<br />

Remote Monitoring with<br />

Ultrasound<br />

From Data to Decisions and<br />

Improved Business<br />

Issued by Promaint (Finnish Maintenance Society), Messuaukio 1, 00520 Helsinki, Finland tel. +358 29 007 4570 Publisher<br />

Omnipress Oy, Mäkelänkatu 56, 00510 Helsinki, tel. +358 20 6100, toimitus@omnipress.fi, www.omnipress.fi Editor-in-chief<br />

Nina Garlo-Melkas tel. +358 50 36 46 491, nina.garlo@omnipress.fi, Advertisements Kai Portman, Sales Director, tel. +358 358<br />

44 763 2573, ads@maintworld.com Subscriptions and Change of Address members toimisto@kunnossapito.fi, non-members<br />

tilaajapalvelu@media.fi Printed by Painotalo Plus Digital Oy, www.ppd.fi Frequency 4 issues per year, ISSN L 1798-7024, ISSN<br />

1798-7024 (print), ISSN 1799-8670 (online).<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 5


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

An Immersive Environment for<br />

VISUAL OPERATIONS –<br />

Towards Better Asset Performance<br />

Connecting IT with Operational and Engineering Technology will bring real benefits<br />

to Asset Performance Modelling. Digital engineering modelling will help to generate a<br />

3D reality mesh for the real world data.<br />

BHUPINDER SINGH,<br />

Chief Product Officer,<br />

Bentley Systems,<br />

bhupinder.singh<br />

@bentley.com<br />

IT IS HELPFUL to think of digital engineering<br />

information as the digital DNA<br />

for infrastructure assets – down to every<br />

nut, bolt and screw. Just as doctors can<br />

analyse human DNA to anticipate health<br />

issues and personalize healthcare for<br />

better health outcomes, companies can<br />

harness the digital DNA of their assets to<br />

personalize asset maintenance for better<br />

TOTEX, maximized uptime and more.<br />

As operations technology (OT) leverages<br />

the Industrial Internet of Things<br />

(IIoT) with sensors on operating equipment<br />

and assets producing an enormous<br />

volume of big data, there is a need for<br />

improved security, information sharing<br />

and data management. This, in turn, is<br />

driving an unprecedented convergence<br />

with IT. However, organizations are<br />

struggling to make use of the data from<br />

their OT and IT systems, causing them<br />

to miss opportunities to improve asset<br />

performance. This is due, in part, to the<br />

fact that the digital engineering model<br />

developed during the engineering phase<br />

of capital projects, are typically not playing<br />

a role in operations.<br />

What if owner-operators could use<br />

these models in operations? Imagine<br />

how a digital engineering model − the<br />

engineering technology or ET of an asset<br />

− could help operations and maintenance<br />

people forecast problems, do<br />

better planning, and improve performance.<br />

It is now possible for companies<br />

to converge their IT, OT and ET – and<br />

seamlessly integrate process and information<br />

flows between them – to enable<br />

asset performance modelling to deliver<br />

actionable intelligence for decision support<br />

through an immersive environment<br />

for visual operations.<br />

IIOT IS DRIVING A<br />

CONVERGENCE BETWEEN<br />

OPERATIONAL TECHNOLOGY<br />

AND INFORMATION<br />

TECHNOLOGY.<br />

The Digital Engineering Model<br />

For many years, engineering departments<br />

have been using advanced modelling<br />

and simulation applications that<br />

focus on the process of design and construction<br />

of an infrastructure asset – a<br />

plant, bridge, highway, railway<br />

or utility network<br />

– in a way that improves project delivery<br />

and asset performance. Better project<br />

delivery enables companies to optimize<br />

CAPEX – through both the depth of information<br />

modelling and the breadth of<br />

information mobility for collaboration<br />

during design and construction.<br />

There’s a staggering amount of information<br />

related to assets – detailed<br />

component specifications, precise geolocation,<br />

configuration management,<br />

fabrication details, cost information,<br />

predicted lifetimes, recommended<br />

maintenance and repair information.<br />

Today’s engineering technology makes it<br />

possible to bring all of this information<br />

together within the federated digital<br />

engineering model, making it possible to<br />

track, access, and share with others collaborating<br />

on the project (see Figure 1).<br />

The technology also enables engineers<br />

to model projects in a 3D virtual<br />

setting for design integration and construction<br />

work packaging, so that when<br />

the project is actually constructed in the<br />

real world, the project teams and<br />

stakeholders are able to minimize<br />

unforeseen situations<br />

and keep the project<br />

on track.<br />

6 promaint maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

Ideally, all of this information flows<br />

between applications and project teams<br />

for better project delivery, which is the<br />

key to better CAPEX, and flows through<br />

to operations and maintenance systems<br />

across the entire asset lifecycle, which<br />

is key to reducing OPEX. For example,<br />

when companies can integrate the 3D<br />

models for each discipline involved in a<br />

project, it improves information mobility.<br />

Disciplines can more effectively<br />

communicate critical design details for<br />

operations, detect clashes earlier in the<br />

design phase and before construction<br />

starts, share updates during the engineering<br />

and construction phases, and<br />

hand over accurate and complete information<br />

to ensure successful start-up and<br />

ongoing operations.<br />

The Beginning of<br />

IT/ET/OT Convergence<br />

The Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT)<br />

is driving a convergence between operational<br />

technology and information technology.<br />

Digital engineering models can<br />

accelerate this convergence and add the<br />

visual representation of the real world<br />

needed to aid decision making; this can<br />

have far-reaching impacts on the safety,<br />

productivity, efficiency and operations<br />

of industries worldwide.<br />

For example, consider how South<br />

Australia Water is currently using predictive<br />

and real-time operational analytics<br />

to forecast water demand and improve<br />

customer service while reducing<br />

operational costs. To create a demand<br />

forecasting tool, they needed to pull information<br />

from both the operational and<br />

IT sides of the organization in real time.<br />

Bentley’s predictive analytics software<br />

was chosen as the operational<br />

intelligence platform due to its real-time<br />

ability to connect and capture data from<br />

a wide variety of sources, its ability to<br />

perform complicated calculations and<br />

analysis, and its impressive visualization<br />

capabilities. Real-time monitored sensor<br />

Digital<br />

engineering<br />

models bring together<br />

critical information<br />

in a virtual 3D<br />

environment.<br />

data is brought in from the reservoirs,<br />

water treatment plants, valves, flowmeters,<br />

and pumps spread across the extensive<br />

pipeline network.<br />

This operational data is combined<br />

in real time with climate, energy, cost,<br />

and population data and is displayed on<br />

dashboards. Bringing these data sources<br />

together has resulted in huge benefits,<br />

including improved performance, enhanced<br />

understanding of interrelationships,<br />

and better decision-making and<br />

more accurate predictions of short- and<br />

TYING TOGETHER IT, OT, AND<br />

ET ALLOWS THE COMPANY<br />

TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF<br />

LOWER FORWARD MARKET<br />

PRICING FOR ELECTRICITY.<br />

long-term demand.<br />

South Australia Water also integrated<br />

a demand optimization tool that is used<br />

to optimize the availability and the<br />

movement of clean water around the<br />

network to demand areas quickly and<br />

efficiently. It calculates how to deliver<br />

the water by calculating costs and determining<br />

which pumping stations to use,<br />

which pumps are needed, and so on.<br />

Built-in analytics take the output of<br />

the demand forecasting tool to develop<br />

a live hydraulic model that determines<br />

water pressures and flows throughout<br />

the network. Using this digital engineering<br />

model, South Australia Water can<br />

actively optimize water supply and reliability<br />

to its customers. Customers enjoy<br />

improved water security, and response<br />

times to problems, such as broken water<br />

mains, have been reduced by 90 percent.<br />

Tying together IT, OT, and ET also<br />

allows the company to take advantage<br />

of lower forward market pricing for electricity.<br />

They can use an energy portfolio<br />

management spot-market power price<br />

tool to determine the optimal timing for<br />

pump operations on five pipelines, as<br />

well as when to purchase power in highly<br />

volatile markets. The impact on OPEX<br />

can be significant – a saving of AUD 3<br />

million per year.<br />

The second part of the article will be<br />

released in issue 4/<strong>2016</strong> covering Asset<br />

Performance Modelling and the Integration<br />

of Processes and Information.<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 7


INDUSTRIAL INTERNET<br />

NATHAN POCOCK,<br />

Director of Technology<br />

and Compliance at the<br />

OPC Foundation,<br />

nathan.pocock@<br />

opcfoundation.org<br />

OPC Unified Architecture<br />

Facilitates the Exchange of<br />

Information in the IoT<br />

The Internet of Things (IoT) and Industry 4.0 needs no introduction, everybody<br />

has heard of them, and everybody understands the buzz and the opportunities<br />

ahead. But how are you prepared to benefit from this next technological leap<br />

while maximizing your opportunity with minimal risk and cost?<br />

8 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


The Industrial Interoperability Standard<br />

Much more than a protocol …<br />

that is why it’s recommended<br />

for Industrie 4.0<br />

1<br />

OPC Unified Architecture<br />

Interoperability for Industrie 4.0 and the Internet of Things<br />

OPC UA is a framework for Industrial Interoperability<br />

➞ Modeling of data and interfaces for devices and services<br />

➞ Integrated security by design with confi gurable access rights<br />

for data and services – validated by German BSI security experts<br />

➞ Extendable transport protocols:<br />

Client/Server and Publisher/Subscriber and roadmap for TSN<br />

➞ Scalable from sensor to IT Enterprise & Cloud<br />

➞ Independent from vendor, operating system,<br />

implementation language and vertical markets<br />

Industrie<br />

IoT<br />

4.0<br />

M2M<br />

Download of<br />

Technology brochure:<br />

opcfoundation.org/<br />

resources/brochures/<br />

Information models of different branches are mapped onto OPC UA to make them<br />

interoperable with integrated security. The OPC Foundation closely cooperates<br />

with organizations and associations from various branches:<br />

TM<br />

Verband für Automatische<br />

Datenerfassung, Identifikation und Mobilität<br />

www.opcfoundation.org


INDUSTRIAL XXXXXX INTERNET<br />

SINCE THE 1990’S, technology development has generally focused<br />

on the PC platform. During the past few years, focus has<br />

been on mobile platforms. Today’s focus is two-fold: small scale<br />

devices and large-scale cloud infrastructures, and getting them<br />

and everything in-between to work seamlessly together.<br />

What is driving this change? Data! Successful businesses are<br />

maximizing their efficiency to reduce costs. This means that<br />

important business decisions need to be made much faster<br />

than ever before, with minimum investment, and maximum<br />

effect. Is this possible? It’s always been “possible”, it just wasn’t<br />

cost effective or easy; now it is!<br />

New products are already available that are intelligent, provide<br />

contextual information (discussed in Information Modelling)<br />

to enable rapid decision making (human or automated),<br />

and scale to the needs of the enterprise. Now it’s your turn!<br />

IMPORTANT BUSINESS DECISIONS NEED TO<br />

BE MADE MUCH FASTER THAN EVER BEFORE,<br />

WITH MINIMUM INVESTMENT.<br />

Introducing OPC Unified<br />

Architecture (UA)<br />

The keys to success are adopting open standards such as OPC<br />

UA, a platform-independent technology where interoperability<br />

is assured.<br />

Initially targeting the Industrial Automation industry, OPC<br />

technology emerged in the mid 90’s and was based on Microsoft<br />

technologies, but was revamped in the early 2000’s to be a<br />

future-facing and platform-independent technology. OPC Unified<br />

Architecture harmonizes many existing and widely successful<br />

OPC standards (Data Access, Historical Data, Alarms &<br />

Conditions, Programs, Security, and more) into one cohesive<br />

standard.<br />

OPC products available in the marketplace easily exceed<br />

10,000; the exact number is unknown, and the number of<br />

installations is estimated to be in the tens of millions. OPC is<br />

used in commercial products and in countless internal-only<br />

systems. There is such an abundance of applications such<br />

as visualization, data-logging, alert notifications, or other<br />

business-intelligence applications, which makes a strong case<br />

for adopting OPC UA because your product can integrate with<br />

them all, immediately.<br />

OPC technology is platform independent and is already<br />

implemented on Windows, Linux/*nix, Apple, Android, and in<br />

Embedded controllers such as PLCs, Raspberry PI, and a multitude<br />

of other very small-scale circuitry.<br />

What’s happening now? The number of PC-based applications<br />

is massive, but we are also seeing OPC enabled at the controller<br />

level, from the DCS, PLC, down to the microchip. Companies<br />

such as Beckhoff, GE, Honeywell, Rockwell, Siemens, and<br />

others, all have OPC UA enabled hardware.<br />

OPC has spread beyond Industrial Automation that it has<br />

served so well for the last 2 decades, and is now deeply rooted<br />

in Oil & Gas, Building Automation, and Energy, with more industry<br />

horizontals and verticals following.<br />

What Does OPC Do<br />

Why would you choose OPC technology to share data? Because<br />

that is what it was designed to do!<br />

There are 5 core features of OPC: Browsing: the ability to<br />

locate OPC systems on a network and to connect to them, and<br />

to visually browse the availability of data using a file/folder<br />

methodology; Reading: data-points or objects etc.; Writing:<br />

to one or more data-points, or entire objects; Subscriptions:<br />

receiving update notifications for when data/information<br />

changes; and Eventing: to provide meaningful alert notifications.<br />

These capabilities provide the entire infrastructure necessary<br />

for OPC products to share data/information of any kind,<br />

with one another.<br />

OPC technology has three key standards of which the majority<br />

of products implement: Data Access, for real-time data<br />

sharing; Historical Data/Events, for analytics and reporting<br />

of data and/or events stored in a database/historian; Alarms &<br />

OPC Unified Architecture (OPC UA) is an industrial M2M communication protocol for interoperability developed by the OPC Foundation.<br />

10 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


INDUSTRIAL INTERNET<br />

IIoT Industry 4.0<br />

OPC<br />

UA<br />

M2M<br />

New Era Technologies<br />

Conditions, for alarm events that notify when alarm-triggers<br />

are hit, such as a temperature reaching a Low or High setpoint,<br />

etc. Each of these Profiles serves a purpose; you can simply<br />

pick and choose the feature/functionality you need within<br />

your product(s).<br />

OPC is successful because of its plug-n-play design. An OPC<br />

Client interacts with an OPC Server. The OPC Foundation<br />

Compliance Working Group provides members with Compliance<br />

Test Tools (CTTs) for automated compliance testing, testcase<br />

specifications, and interoperability workshops for faceto-face<br />

testing between different vendors and their products.<br />

The OPC Certification Test Lab conducts vigorous testing to<br />

validate a product is interoperable, compliant, robust, and efficient<br />

with resources. End-users are increasingly demanding<br />

Certified products because it reduces their risk, and increases<br />

the overall reliability of their infrastructure.<br />

SUCCESSFUL BUSINESSES ARE MAXIMIZING<br />

THEIR EFFICIENCY TO REDUCE COSTS.<br />

Security<br />

MTBH? Mean Time Between Hack… will that become a new<br />

KPI? Let’s hope not. Power grids, refineries, utilities, and others,<br />

have been brought to their knees from hackers. How do you<br />

prevent your product from being the cause of such a disaster?<br />

OPC UA provides a significant multi-layer security model<br />

featuring end-to-end encryption and signing: preventing<br />

eavesdropping and message alteration; sequencing: to detect<br />

and request lost messages and to prevent message replay; auditing:<br />

to provide detailed activity logs; user authentication:<br />

for allocation of user permissions; application authentication:<br />

to lock down which systems to communicate with; redundancy:<br />

for failover support in the case of lost communications.<br />

Don’t invent your own security model. Simply adopt OPC<br />

UA and inherit the security which was peer-reviewed by industrial<br />

cyber-security experts and government agencies, and<br />

leverages internationally approved best practices and technologies.<br />

Information Modelling<br />

Data is good, but is not too useful by itself. Data needs context,<br />

and this will become even more important as data/information<br />

flows freely from system to system as the IoT and Industry 4.0<br />

fully deploy.<br />

Information can be defined as structured data, or “objects”.<br />

OPC UA provides a rich information model empowering you to<br />

define your own object types, data types, and modelling rules.<br />

Once you define your type(s) you can simply create “instances”<br />

of them and assure that your data model is always used correctly.<br />

This is the core interest of many collaborations with organizations<br />

such as BACnet, MDIS, and PLCopen, etc. who are<br />

able to define their own object types to represent machines, a<br />

part, a building, or a process etc.<br />

Existing OPC applications can readily consume this “information”<br />

as individual data-points, which is OK for activities<br />

such as data-logging, visualization, or alert notifications etc.<br />

However, smart applications will understand the bigger-picture<br />

of what this information means and will be able to make<br />

more contextual business decisions at higher layers within the<br />

enterprise.<br />

An Abundance of ‘Getting Started’ Materials<br />

The OPC Foundation provides a wealth of information to help<br />

you get started, from Specifications to sample code, and a product<br />

catalogue showing OPC Certified commercial toolkits and<br />

systems etc. Getting started may be simpler than you think.<br />

Sample applications are available for download from the<br />

OPC Foundation website and are intended to demonstrate and<br />

educate the use of the technology. Several OPC Foundation<br />

member companies also offer free applications.<br />

OPC Foundation members can download and use the Compliance<br />

Test Tools during product development in accordance<br />

with Agile/Scrum development methodologies to increase<br />

quality and reduce development and QA costs.<br />

The Future<br />

OPC UA is poised to become the de facto standard for securely<br />

and reliably moving information from the smallest of devices,<br />

up to the largest enterprise or cloud-based systems. OPC UA is<br />

leading the way to being a key enabler of the IoT and Industry<br />

4.0 and we are excited to be a part of it!<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 11


RELIABILITY<br />

RELIABILITY - What Fails<br />

and What Do We Do About It?<br />

Companies in the Oil & Gas industry have been attempting to improve the manufacturing<br />

reliability of their operations to improve financial performance by setting up<br />

effective Asset Performance Management (APM) strategies. The driver of this has<br />

been the potential to realize a 20-25 percent reduction in conversion costs, accompanied<br />

by a 15-25 percent increase, in real production capacity, without additional<br />

capital investment.<br />

PETER BROOSUS,<br />

Senior Consultant,<br />

Nexus Global,<br />

p.broosus@<br />

nexusglobal.com<br />

WHILE THE PRIZE is large, and pressure<br />

on margins is heavy, many efforts made<br />

by companies in the Oil & Gas industry<br />

to improve their manufacturing reliability<br />

through APM will, or already have<br />

failed. (See Figure 1.)<br />

Let’s look at some examples of why<br />

these sort of efforts fall short by looking<br />

12 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

at the following aspects of APM as they<br />

relate to Strategy Management and referring<br />

to Figure 2.<br />

1. What does Reliability mean?<br />

2. What equipment / component to<br />

track?<br />

3. The interactions of behaviour (culture),<br />

work processes, and tools.<br />

1. What does Reliable<br />

Operation mean?<br />

Does a Maintenance department create<br />

or “do” Reliability in your facilities?<br />

Wouldn’t that be the same as expecting<br />

the Safety Department/HSE to “do<br />

safety”?<br />

We need to realize that Reliability of<br />

Operations is an output of a system, supported<br />

by People (culture!), Processes<br />

and Technology (tools!). Just in the same<br />

manner safety is.<br />

Tasking a single department to “do reliability”<br />

will not lead to success. Achieving<br />

Reliable Operations requires at least<br />

four of the core business functions to<br />

work coherently together, toward the<br />

same end goals:<br />

• Engineering<br />

An Engineering Business Function,<br />

should be responsible for selecting<br />

equipment that maximizes design reli-


More Uptime.<br />

Better Returns.<br />

Strategy Management<br />

Zero tolerance for unexpected failures.<br />

Your assets are the value delivery engine of your business. Their most<br />

important function is to operate as engineered for their intended design<br />

life. With predictable performance and predictable results. Maximizing the<br />

return on your capital employed (ROCE), allowing you to bank more of your<br />

turnover. Being less sensitive to uncontrollable external factors such as<br />

commodity price fluctuations, macroeconomics, or monetary policies.<br />

Nexus Global Strategy Management implementations typically result<br />

in a 15%-40% reduction in operational costs with a 5%-10% increase in<br />

capacity utilization while maintaining or improving the risk tolerance of<br />

the business.<br />

Download our whitepaper and learn more at<br />

www.nexusglobal.com/bankonuptime<br />

+31.30.799.5050<br />

europe@nexusglobal.com


RELIABILITY<br />

ability, and in a joint design process with<br />

Production and Maintenance is set up to<br />

be designed for maintainability.<br />

This is where the essential initial<br />

strategies of run-to-failure (design for<br />

maintainability), interval-based maintenance<br />

(maintainability/reliability)<br />

and condition-based maintenance first<br />

need to be planned for. Making access to<br />

components made as easy as possible to<br />

shorten downtime durations.<br />

essentially to take ownership of monitoring<br />

the condition of equipment. Identified<br />

(potential) issues can be processed<br />

into actions in an effective and efficient<br />

manner to execute work that stops completely,<br />

or slows down further degradation<br />

of the equipment.<br />

• Procurement and Logistics<br />

The decisions taken to realizing lowest<br />

cost of ownership are far more complex<br />

it is caused by components that fail. A<br />

compressor does not fail. A bearing in an<br />

electrical motor on a compressor may<br />

fail. Or perhaps an actuator on a valve in<br />

a discharge system may fail.<br />

Traditionally inspections are built<br />

up into text heavy “PM’s” defining fixed<br />

time-based overhaul or inspections of<br />

systems or large assemblies. Results that<br />

allow tracking the condition of equipment<br />

as it may start deteriorating are<br />

Figure 1. APM overview of what is needed for high reliability.<br />

Figure 2. Business Functions<br />

The decisions taken during the Engineering<br />

phase will linger on for years<br />

after decisions are made. Choices for<br />

equipment and systems decided on, or<br />

specified, during this period can affect<br />

upwards of 80 percent of the total lifecycle<br />

ownership costs. Only 20-30 percent<br />

of this cost can be influenced in later<br />

stages of the lifecycle.<br />

• Production<br />

Alongside taking ownership of the<br />

required operating procedures for<br />

start-up-, produce-, switch-over- and<br />

shutdown or equipment and systems,<br />

production teams play an important<br />

role in the early identification of technical<br />

issues, and should be the first line of<br />

defence by conducting operator inspections<br />

of the equipment they operate,<br />

performing daily maintenance tasks<br />

(cleaning, lubricating, etc.), and operating<br />

within the constraints of the operating<br />

specifications of the equipment.<br />

• Maintenance<br />

The role of any maintenance department<br />

towards a Reliable Operation is<br />

than simply choosing the least expensive<br />

piece of equipment. It may be that the<br />

best mid-long term buy is one that costs<br />

most initially but last far longer than a<br />

“similar” item provided by another manufacturer.<br />

The procurement agent must<br />

consider the Total Cost of Ownership<br />

over the lifetime of the equipment.<br />

That the procurement agent is familiar<br />

with the technical complexity<br />

of components is not a reasonable expectation.<br />

Interactions need to be close<br />

between Engineering and Maintenance<br />

to educate and support the procurement<br />

department to develop an understanding<br />

in evaluating technical proposals.<br />

2. What equipment /<br />

component to track?<br />

Most capital projects are focusing on<br />

designing systems based on the production<br />

processes required. Basically these<br />

designs result in a collection of components,<br />

organized into individual pieces<br />

of equipment, which are then coupled<br />

together to form systems.<br />

Seen from the other side this implies<br />

that when our assets fail to function,<br />

either not registered sufficiently, or are<br />

not easily retrievable. Information is lost<br />

and things will go awry fast.<br />

Our inspections should however be focused<br />

on identifying potential problems<br />

with components, and tracking progress<br />

of deterioration. Using that realization<br />

enables us to apply the whole suite of<br />

predictive, preventative and corrective<br />

actions ranging from inspections during<br />

uptime as well as downtime, or inline,<br />

real-time monitoring, for parts or even a<br />

whole piece of equipment or systems.<br />

Industry 4.0 / Internet of Things may<br />

help us in analyzing component failures,<br />

or it may drown us, depending on how<br />

our processes, and the cultures that<br />

drive decision making, are set up.<br />

3. The interactions of<br />

behaviour (culture), work<br />

processes, and tools<br />

Some of our clients have in the past few<br />

years tended to build the focus of their<br />

APM improvement efforts on Redefining<br />

fields in the system, renaming statuses,<br />

or restructuring Master Data. This<br />

we can call the SAP-gap, where the ERP<br />

14 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


RELIABILITY<br />

is seen as the end-all solution to APM.<br />

This does not change the fundamental<br />

premise of moving from the text<br />

heavy “PM Workorder” that inspects or<br />

overhauls systems or large assemblies.<br />

Strategy Management improvements<br />

need to include restructuring inspections<br />

to focus on components and with<br />

tolerance limits set (process). In the<br />

field you need your inspectors to have a<br />

common reference for what is acceptable<br />

(culture). Inspectors will need a<br />

process to report the findings, defining<br />

what information to include. You<br />

will need to have people consistently<br />

executing the process (culture) and<br />

knowing how to prioritize the work. All<br />

those steps should clever information<br />

tools to make them efficient, but could<br />

fundamentally also be executed manually<br />

as well. A good rule of thumb is, if it<br />

wouldn’t work on paper, your IT system<br />

will probably not solve it, simply as the<br />

organization will fail to comprehend the<br />

processes and the information needs to<br />

support them.<br />

Setting Your Strategies May<br />

Require a Restart<br />

To be successful we need to have people<br />

executing the right actions, in the right<br />

way. Whether we equip them with a 10<br />

Euro-tool from the nearby discount<br />

store, or a 50,000 Euro-tool, is irrelevant<br />

until they have the ability and skills to<br />

productively apply the tool in the first<br />

place in an appropriate fashion.<br />

The basic “what” is simple:<br />

• Define your work processes and<br />

create your training and SOP’s to<br />

define behaviours. Set your tools<br />

up to support your work processes,<br />

and coach your organization heavily.<br />

Make sure that the core functions<br />

of the organization all play<br />

their part in inspections, and are<br />

providing their aspects of reliability<br />

to the operations<br />

• Organize your inspections to track<br />

components, know their condition,<br />

effectively prepare your work instructions,<br />

and schedule for effectiveness.<br />

Track what you did, and<br />

restart the circle.<br />

The “how” is not.<br />

TOOLS CANNOT REPLACE<br />

CULTURAL BEHAVIOUR AND<br />

PROCESSES.<br />

Realizing that there are many more<br />

pitfalls to pay attention to, we will need<br />

to park those items for another time. At<br />

last it may however be worthwhile to<br />

touch on how important it is to be open<br />

to taking a step back, looking at the big<br />

picture, and openly asking: “Does what<br />

we have make sense?”<br />

The reluctance to be honest with ourselves<br />

and our coworkers tend to derail<br />

improvement initiatives and sometimes<br />

become a devastating fungus in a company’s<br />

culture.<br />

Appreciating that companies, or<br />

rather the individuals making up the<br />

company, want to pursue success in life.<br />

It is always frustrating to see people being<br />

pushed into Ponzi-like schemes to<br />

satisfy the end of the week, end of the<br />

month, end of the quarter cheat-sheets<br />

related to the personal appraisal structure<br />

to drive one’s career.<br />

Issues in the company’s processes<br />

get chopped up in ever smaller pieces,<br />

cleaned up and stuffed with irrational<br />

arguments to make it palatable as a ”personal<br />

achievement” on the “tick-box-list”.<br />

And “success” is then rewarded based<br />

on having the box ticked whether or not<br />

it has done something to the bottomline<br />

of the business on the long term.<br />

And because such “achievement” is<br />

personal, they obviously become a point<br />

of personal interest for the individual in<br />

question to safeguard them for critique<br />

even when there is proof that it makes<br />

no sense at all.<br />

In the end, such behavior becomes<br />

a root cause for “broken business processes”<br />

and forms artifacts in the culture<br />

making change harder than necessary.<br />

Not surprisingly most of those<br />

“achievements” are coined as “improvements”<br />

and “innovations” and often<br />

relate to the themes like the “SAP gap”<br />

or other nice-to-have tools and gadgets.<br />

Why? Because that is sexy. It is not perceived<br />

as “sexy” to achieve an almost<br />

perfect schedule compliance at the end<br />

of the day or the end of the week. That’s<br />

ordinary “work” and tends to be taken<br />

for granted in the meeting rooms of the<br />

management echelons.<br />

It requires determination and full<br />

support from top- and senior management<br />

to drive the required behaviors<br />

into the right direction.<br />

This then adds one extra point to the<br />

to-do list:<br />

• Make a point of doing the right<br />

work at the right time with the right<br />

people under the right conditions.<br />

Change perceptions and make success<br />

of managing work on a daily,<br />

weekly, monthly quarterly a “sexy”<br />

thing to do!! Because in the end,<br />

growing our business accounts is<br />

one-on-one related to our ability<br />

to reliably deliver quality products<br />

and services to our customers in a<br />

sustainable manner!<br />

BENEFITS OF SUCCESSFULLY IMPLEMENTING ASSET PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT (APM) STRATEGIES:<br />

1. Increased availability of production systems,<br />

and reliability - knowing they will<br />

run when required.<br />

2. Fewer failures of production systems<br />

and equipment<br />

3. Lower costs for system and equipment<br />

maintenance, spare parts inventory, and<br />

capital replacement.<br />

4. Improved product quality associated<br />

with a reduction in costs related to losing<br />

or reprocessing products<br />

5. Higher profits to put in the bank, due to<br />

the compound effect of reduced conversion<br />

costs through factors above.<br />

6. Additional real capacity as operating<br />

units are able to operate at higher yield<br />

levels for sustained periods without<br />

excessive failure rates.<br />

7. Enhanced morale amongst management,<br />

craftspeople, and other employees<br />

as they learn to enjoy a proactive<br />

environment instead of surviving in<br />

chaos.<br />

8. A continuously learning enterprise<br />

resulting from accurate analysis of<br />

equipment maintenance, repair, and<br />

replacement records.<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 15


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

Major bearing manufacturers tell us that between 50 and 80 percent<br />

of all premature bearing failures are cause by lubrication issues.<br />

Choosing the Right<br />

Diagnostic Tools<br />

The human brain is amazing. How many times have you opened a drawer that’s full of<br />

all sorts of things and picked out the one thing that you opened the drawer to find?<br />

THOMAS J.<br />

MURPHY C. ENG,<br />

Corporate Training<br />

Manager, SDT<br />

International,,<br />

tom@sdt.be<br />

WE DO THIS frequently and think little of<br />

it. How much more difficult would that<br />

search be if you did not know what the<br />

object that you wanted to find actually<br />

looked like?<br />

Unfortunately, this happens a lot in<br />

the world of condition monitoring. Companies<br />

go to great lengths, and considerable<br />

expense, to purchase the “right”<br />

equipment or select the “right” contractor<br />

but then put almost no effort into the<br />

most important part of the preparation –<br />

to identify what failures look like. In the<br />

reliability world, this preparatory stage is<br />

called Failure Mode and Effect Analysis.<br />

Having all the right tools and not<br />

knowing what to look for will yield minimal<br />

success – all that new high technology<br />

will end up on a shelf in a couple of<br />

years’ time and quite possibly there will<br />

be a stigma attached along the lines of<br />

“we tried that and it doesn’t work”.<br />

Failure Mode and Effect<br />

Analysis (FMEA)<br />

FMEA is like a formal, structured, version<br />

of Murphy’s Law.<br />

• What system defects are possible?<br />

• How likely are they?<br />

• How significant are they?<br />

• How can we design them out?<br />

• How can we mitigate their effect on<br />

the system reliability?<br />

• Is it cheaper and easier to run to<br />

failure?<br />

• How can we identify their presence?<br />

Condition monitoring is all about<br />

this last question, how to develop a<br />

structured measurement approach that<br />

goes looking for the onset of a particular<br />

failure mode. Included in this strategy<br />

is the realisation that not all failures are<br />

trendable – some failures, a leak is a good<br />

example, are binary. A leak exists or it<br />

doesn’t, it is binary. What would you be<br />

measuring on a pipe fitting that would<br />

predict that it is going to work loose?<br />

My first manager in my professional<br />

career was an old Navy man who taught<br />

me that “to fail to prepare is to prepare<br />

to fail” and that is as true in the application<br />

of condition monitoring as anywhere<br />

else.<br />

To correctly deploy a monitoring<br />

tool, first know what to look for and then<br />

choose how to find it. Choose? Yes, in<br />

many cases there are multiple tools that<br />

can find a problem. Realising that brings<br />

a refreshing freedom: if some of your<br />

team prefer to use one tool over another<br />

and both will find the problem, give your<br />

16 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

team the freedom to use whatever they<br />

enjoy using or are most comfortable using.<br />

The result? Inspection routines are<br />

completed, problems are found, your<br />

expensive tools are used and reliability<br />

increases.<br />

What Can I Do with IR,<br />

Vib and US?<br />

Infrared cameras measure Infrared<br />

radiation from which they compute temperature.<br />

IR cameras provide a full-field<br />

real-time display that allows the user to<br />

see thermal patterns and distributions<br />

far more quickly than can be achieved<br />

using a single point temperature device.<br />

Vibration is a measurement of one of<br />

three things: acceleration (force), velocity<br />

(momentum or energy) or displacement<br />

depending upon the frequency<br />

range and the application. Phase measurement<br />

is a critical part of vibration<br />

measurement that is often overlooked.<br />

The use of phase allows a vibration instrument<br />

to perform balancing, operating<br />

deflection shape and modal testing.<br />

Ultrasound instruments measure<br />

sound at frequencies beyond human<br />

hearing, for example in the frequency<br />

range between 36 and 40kHz. Ultrasound<br />

is particularly good at detecting<br />

three parameters: friction, impacting<br />

and turbulence. There are eight application<br />

pillars of this type of ultrasound<br />

equipment:<br />

• Compressed gas leaks (air, CO2, Nitrogen,<br />

Argon, etc.)<br />

• Steam leaks and steam traps<br />

• Valves<br />

• Hydraulics<br />

• Electrical (LV, MV and HV)<br />

• Tightness<br />

• On-condition lubrication<br />

• Rotating machinery condition<br />

Clearly, from this list, ultrasound offers<br />

tremendous value for money in terms of<br />

problem coverage.<br />

Crossover Applications<br />

It is not uncommon to come across these<br />

crossover applications where multiple<br />

tools are available but a purist will insist<br />

that “this is the right way to find this<br />

problem”. Right way? There is no right<br />

way. If there is a problem and it can be<br />

found, surely that is the primary concern,<br />

not compliance with some unwritten<br />

norm that says “thou shalt use …… to<br />

find this problem”.<br />

FMEA IS LIKE A FORMAL,<br />

STRUCTURED, VERSION OF<br />

MURPHY’S LAW.<br />

Coupling misalignment is a typical<br />

example of a crossover application. It<br />

is possible to take vibration measurements<br />

to deduce that there is coupling<br />

misalignment. If there is line of sight of<br />

the coupling (something which is quite<br />

rare these days) it is possible to identify<br />

that the coupling is warming up, which<br />

is going to be caused by the periodic<br />

friction generated by the misalignment.<br />

Discover<br />

the hidden<br />

treasure in<br />

Maintenance<br />

Discover<br />

the hidden<br />

treasure in<br />

Maintenance<br />

There is value hidden in every maintenance organization. All companies have the potential to further improve, either by reducing<br />

costs, improve safety, work on the lifetime extension of machinery or by smart maintenance solutions that improves uptime. The<br />

question is where maintenance managers should be looking to fi nd these areas of improvement and where they need to start.<br />

You will fi nd the answer to this question at Mainnovation. With Value Driven Maintenance ® and the matching tools like the VDM<br />

Control Panel, the Process Map and our benchmark data base myVDM.com, we will help you to discover the hidden treasure in<br />

your company.<br />

Do you want to discover the hidden treasure in your maintenance organization?<br />

Go to www.mainnovation.com<br />

CONTROLLING MAINTENANCE, CREATING VALUE.


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

Graph 1: The lubrication technician follows a pre-defined path through a group of bearings.<br />

Friction? Ultrasound can hear friction.<br />

So by simply placing an airborne flexible<br />

sensor close to a gap in a coupling guard,<br />

the technician can hear and record the<br />

periodic friction associated with coupling<br />

misalignment.<br />

One highly topical example of a crossover<br />

application is bearing lubrication.<br />

Industry around the world is realising<br />

that there is a problem here. Major bearing<br />

manufacturers tell us that between<br />

50 and 80 percent of all premature<br />

bearing failures are cause by lubrication<br />

issues.<br />

If the manufacturers are correct,<br />

what is the point of taking vibration<br />

readings that are not focussed on finding<br />

lubrication issues? Few, definitely not<br />

all, vibration practitioners have additional<br />

training in lubrication. Those that<br />

do recognise that the higher frequency<br />

measurements associated with ultrasound<br />

provide greater sensitivity to the<br />

frictional condition.<br />

A bearing that needs grease will<br />

warm up, so why not use an IR camera?<br />

This is partially true, but if the environment<br />

that the bearing is operating in<br />

is already hot, it is unlikely that underlubrication<br />

is going to cause a further<br />

elevation in the temperature. Furthermore,<br />

lubrication physics tells us that<br />

under-lubrication and over-lubrication<br />

will both increase friction and therefore<br />

temperature. This will make the use of<br />

an IR camera difficult.<br />

Finally, there may be other defects<br />

TO CORRECTLY DEPLOY A<br />

MONITORING TOOL, FIRST<br />

KNOW WHAT TO LOOK FOR<br />

AND THEN CHOOSE HOW<br />

TO FIND IT.<br />

present – consider a fan bearing next<br />

to a misaligned pulley. Our IR training<br />

tells us that the misalignment will warm<br />

up the pulley. Thermodynamics tells us<br />

that the heat from the warm pulley will<br />

conduct down the shaft and warm up the<br />

pulley bearing. Oh! I have a hot bearing,<br />

I must grease it. Is it possible to lubricate<br />

away pulley misalignment?<br />

FMEA is suggesting that the course of<br />

action is to design out this problem. The<br />

problem springs from the reality that all<br />

bearings do not consume grease at the<br />

same rate, which means that their need<br />

for replenishment is different. Accepting<br />

this reality means that greasing large<br />

groups of bearings in the same way on a<br />

time basis is not logical.<br />

One of the key approaches which is being<br />

used around the world for this major<br />

problem is on-condition lubrication using<br />

ultrasound. In Graph 1 we can see a lubrication<br />

history using ultrasound:<br />

This is a route-based approach. The<br />

lubrication technician follows a pre-defined<br />

path through a group of bearings.<br />

For each bearing there is a history of<br />

readings. If the current reading exceeds<br />

an alarm condition, the technician<br />

1. stores the “before” reading,<br />

2. makes a comment to flag that the<br />

bearing was greased,<br />

3. performs an ultrasonic lubrication<br />

4. records a second “after” reading<br />

The result is a history for every bearing<br />

in the database. When it was greased and<br />

what condition it was left in.<br />

Using ultrasound during the lubrication<br />

process means that the difference<br />

between a bearing that needed grease<br />

(reduction in ultrasound) is clearly different<br />

from a bearing that was already<br />

over-greased (increase in ultrasound).<br />

Using ultrasound for lubrication in<br />

this way has produced some incredible<br />

successes. One mining Company<br />

reported a staggering reduction in<br />

grease consumption from 22 drums<br />

(15Kg each) per month to just 1 drum<br />

per month with a significant increase in<br />

machine reliability. A water treatment<br />

plant reported at the end of 2015 that<br />

since the implementation of their ultrasound<br />

programme, they had not had<br />

an unexpected motor bearing failure in<br />

three years.<br />

Summary<br />

There are many condition monitoring<br />

tools at your disposal. Ensure that you<br />

perform a thorough FMEA in order to<br />

uncover those defects that are most<br />

likely to hurt you and develop your condition<br />

monitoring strategies to deal with<br />

those problems in the most convenient<br />

way for your engineering talents.<br />

FMEAs frequently fail because the<br />

output is corrupted to<br />

1. What tools do we have?<br />

2. What modes will we list then?<br />

Instead of reaching the conclusions of:<br />

1. What needs to be measured?<br />

2. Do we have the tools to find these<br />

modes?<br />

Your future success depends upon<br />

choosing the right tools.<br />

FIGURE 1 and 2: Major bearing manufacturers tell us that between 50 and 80 percent of all premature bearing failures are<br />

caused by lubrication issues.<br />

18 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


The result of 40 years of experience<br />

in ultrasound maintenance<br />

Our policy: Versatility, Simplicity & Profitability<br />

• Leak detection<br />

• Bearing & gear condition<br />

monitoring<br />

• Lubrication optimization<br />

• Valve condition monitoring<br />

• Steam systems inspection<br />

• Vibration velocity & acceleration<br />

monitoring<br />

• Pump cavitation detection<br />

• Localization of electrical faults<br />

SDT International n.v. - s.a.<br />

Humaniteitslaan, 415 - B-1190 Brussel / Bd de l’humanité 415 - B-1190 Bruxelles<br />

info@sdt.be - www.sdt.eu +32 (0) 2 332 32 25


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

Things Many<br />

VIBRATION ANALYSTS<br />

Don’t Do, but Should<br />

JASON TRANTER,<br />

Founder and Managing<br />

Director of Mobius<br />

Institute,<br />

Jason.tranter@<br />

mobiusinstitute.com<br />

In the previous issue of <strong>Maintworld</strong> –magazine we introduced<br />

10 things vibration analysts can do in order<br />

to make their job easier. In this article we will take a<br />

look at six more ways to lessen the burden of the<br />

vibration analysts’ tough job.<br />

THE 10 STATEMENTS introduced in the previous issue of <strong>Maintworld</strong><br />

–magazine and the following six are general observations<br />

of common problems that the author of this article has<br />

observed over the past 30 years. Hopefully you find these suggestions<br />

helpful in your maintenance program.<br />

One: Don’t Rely on Vibration Alone<br />

You should not rely solely on vibration data when diagnosing<br />

faults. Other condition monitoring technologies such as ultrasound,<br />

oil analysis, wear particle analysis, motor current and<br />

voltage testing, infrared analysis and performance data can not<br />

only detect faults that you can miss with vibration data alone,<br />

but they can help to confirm whether your diagnosis of a suspected<br />

fault condition is indeed correct. If you are not collecting<br />

that data, start collecting it. If you are ignoring it because<br />

someone else in the organization collects it, start using it.<br />

How did you decide on the<br />

technologies, settings, and<br />

measurement periods?<br />

CRITICALITY ANALYSIS<br />

Helps you determine whether CBM and CM is justified<br />

FAILURE MODES<br />

Helps you determine which technologies are applicable<br />

P-F INTERVAL (LTTF)<br />

Helps you decide how often tests should be performed<br />

How to decide on the utilised technologies, settings, and<br />

measurement periods.<br />

20 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


MW Vertical Ad.pdf 1 9/7/<strong>2016</strong> 9:39:56 AM<br />

MW Vertical Ad.pdf 1 9/7/<strong>2016</strong> 9:39:56 AM<br />

MW Vertical Ad.pdf 1 9/7/<strong>2016</strong> 9:39:56 AM<br />

?<br />

Other technologies can confirm your<br />

diagnosis & detect faults that you<br />

might otherwise miss:<br />

Infrared<br />

Heat from wear and rubs<br />

Ultrasound<br />

Sound where you can’t measure<br />

Oil & wear debris analysis<br />

Oil lubricated gears & bearings<br />

Motor current/voltage analysis<br />

Rotor, stator, more<br />

Strobes<br />

Motion, rattling, source of vibration<br />

Other technologies that can confirm your diagnosis and<br />

detect possible faults.<br />

Two: Fully Utilize Vibration Analysis<br />

Vibration analysis is a tremendously powerful tool, however,<br />

most people only use it to detect avoidable fault conditions<br />

that require some form of corrective maintenance. C<br />

That is, of course, a very important application and certainly<br />

M<br />

generates an attractive return on investment. But there is so<br />

Y<br />

much more that can be done.<br />

First, vibration analysis can be used to detect the root CM<br />

causes of machine failure. For example, by detecting unbalance,<br />

misalignment, looseness, resonance, installation<br />

MY<br />

CY<br />

problems, lubrication issues, incorrect operation, and more<br />

– and then eliminating those conditions – we can greatly CMY<br />

reduce the likelihood of bearing faults and other conditions<br />

K<br />

that will result in corrective maintenance and possibly<br />

downtime. Sure, you may already react to high vibration due<br />

to serious unbalance, but what we need to do is eliminate<br />

these conditions even when they are not severe.<br />

Second, vibration analysis can be used as a QA tool. As<br />

described above, we can test the machine after it has been<br />

put back in service to ensure the work has been performed<br />

correctly (with precision). But we should also use vibration<br />

analysis as part of an acceptance-testing program. All new/<br />

overhauled machines should be tested based on an agreed<br />

standard in order to ensure that is “fit for purpose” at your<br />

plant. You will be surprised how many problems you detect -<br />

and therefore how many problems you avoid.<br />

Three: Write Useful Reports<br />

One of the most common complaints made by people in<br />

maintenance and operations is that the reports generated<br />

by vibration analysts are too heavy on data with vague suggestions<br />

of fault conditions, and too light on information<br />

and recommendations that can be acted upon. All they want<br />

to know is what to do and when they need to do it.<br />

Four: Design the Program Correctly<br />

After purchasing a vibration monitoring system there can be<br />

a great temptation to measure most of the rotating machinery<br />

in your plant (regardless of actual criticality), using the<br />

“default” settings, collected every 30 days to begin with but<br />

C<br />

M<br />

Y<br />

CM<br />

CM<br />

MY CY<br />

MY<br />

CMY<br />

CY<br />

CY<br />

K<br />

CMY<br />

CMY<br />

K<br />

C<br />

M<br />

C<br />

Y<br />

M<br />

CM<br />

Y<br />

MY<br />

K<br />

MORE THAN<br />

MORE THAN<br />

MORE THAN<br />

MORE THAN<br />

20,000<br />

20,000<br />

20,000<br />

20,000<br />

VIBRATION ANALYSTS<br />

VIBRATION TRAINED* ANALYSTS<br />

*Since 2005, MOBIUS TRAINED*<br />

INSTITUTE has provided classroom training<br />

*Since 2005, MOBIUS INSTITUTE has provided classroom training<br />

to *Since over to over 20,000 20,000<br />

2005, MOBIUS vibration<br />

INSTITUTE analysts. We<br />

has train<br />

provided more<br />

classroom more analysts analysts than<br />

training than<br />

any *Since other 2005, training MOBIUS organization INSTITUTE throughout has provided the classroom world. In addition training<br />

any to other over training 20,000 vibration analysts. We train the more world. analysts In addition than<br />

to over our classroom 20,000 vibration training analysts. in vibration We analysis, train more we analysts have trained than<br />

to any our<br />

thousands any<br />

other classroom other<br />

training<br />

training more<br />

training<br />

through<br />

organization<br />

organization our<br />

in vibration<br />

DISTANCE<br />

throughout<br />

throughout analysis,<br />

LEARNING the<br />

the<br />

world.<br />

world. we<br />

(via In have In<br />

the addition<br />

addition<br />

web),<br />

trained<br />

thousands to to our our our classroom classroom more iLearnVIBRATION through training our in in software. vibration DISTANCE analysis, MOBIUS LEARNING we INSTITUTE we have have (via trained trained the also web),<br />

and provides thousands our iLearnVIBRATION classroom more more through and distance our software. DISTANCE learning MOBIUS LEARNING training in INSTITUTE (via (via RELIABILITY the the web), web), also<br />

provides and IMPROVEMENT, and our our classroom iLearnVIBRATION FIELD and distance BALANCING, software. learning SHAFT MOBIUS training ALIGNMENT, INSTITUTE in RELIABILITY also and also<br />

IMPROVEMENT, CONDITION provides classroom MONITORING FIELD and BALANCING, distance PRACTICES. learning SHAFT training ALIGNMENT, in in RELIABILITY<br />

and<br />

and<br />

CONDITION IMPROVEMENT, MONITORING FIELD BALANCING, PRACTICES. SHAFT ALIGNMENT, and<br />

We CONDITION are ISO/IEC MONITORING 17024 accredited PRACTICES. and provide vibration analysis<br />

training and certification per ISO 18436. Visit our website to find<br />

We We are out We are how ISO/IEC ISO/IEC you can 17024 17024 join the accredited largest and and and most provide provide capable vibration vibration community analysis<br />

analysis of<br />

training VIBRATION training and and ANALYSTS certification that per ISO have 18436. been Visit Visit taught our our website by website MOBIUS to to find to find<br />

out out how INSTITUTE. out how you you can can join join the largest and most capable community of of of<br />

VIBRATION ANALYSTS that have been taught by by by MOBIUS<br />

MOBIUS<br />

INSTITUTE.<br />

INSTITUTE.<br />

AUSTRALIA - BELGIUM<br />

COSTA RICA - UNITED STATES<br />

AUSTRALIA - BELGIUM<br />

COSTA<br />

AUSTRALIA BELGIUM<br />

COSTA www.mobiusinstitute.com<br />

AUSTRALIA RICA - UNITED<br />

RICA UNITED - BELGIUM STATES<br />

STATES<br />

COSTA RICA - UNITED STATES<br />

www.mobiusinstitute.com<br />

Call us<br />

www.mobiusinstitute.com<br />

worldwide at (+1) 615-216-4811 or email us at<br />

www.mobiusinstitute.com<br />

Call us worldwide<br />

learn@mobiusinstitute.com<br />

at (+1) 615-216-4811 or email us at<br />

Call us worldwide learn@mobiusinstitute.com<br />

at (+1) 615-216-4811 or email us at<br />

Call us worldwide learn@mobiusinstitute.com<br />

at (+1) 615-216-4811 or email us at


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

FOTO: STEVE POTTS<br />

then stretching out to 90 days or even less frequently depending<br />

upon the available time to perform measurements. Unfortunately,<br />

this is a recipe for disaster. It can be a disaster because<br />

machines will still fail on your watch, and/or the warnings you<br />

provide will be too short and as a result the maintenance and<br />

operation departments will lose faith in your service.<br />

The answer is to perform a proper criticality analysis to<br />

determine where you can justify the use of vibration analysis<br />

and the overlap of other technologies. You also need to understand<br />

failure modes in order to ensure that a) vibration analysis<br />

should be applied at all, and b) that the settings used are correct,<br />

and c) that the measurement interval matches the lead time to<br />

failure (LTTR), also known as the P-F interval. You do not need<br />

to perform a thorough reliability centred maintenance (RCM)<br />

analysis to make these decisions; a more streamlined approach<br />

can be taken. But you do need to perform some sort of analysis<br />

to ensure your program will deliver maximum value.<br />

Five: Teach Others about VA,<br />

CBM and Reliability<br />

There are so many companies around the world with skilled<br />

vibration analysts working with people who just don’t get it.<br />

This is tremendously frustrating for those analysts, and it is<br />

a waste of a terrific opportunity to reduce maintenance costs<br />

and downtime. It is essential that everyone in the organization<br />

understands the basic capability of vibration analysis (and<br />

the other condition monitoring tools) and the principal of<br />

condition-based maintenance and the principal of reliability<br />

improvement; eliminating the root causes of failure.<br />

This represents a tremendous opportunity for industry.<br />

Everyone should understand these principals, from senior<br />

management down to operators and craftspeople – and that<br />

certainly includes people in maintenance and operations. And<br />

that leads to sixteen.<br />

Six: Sell (and Re-sell) your Program<br />

to Senior Management<br />

Some of the best vibration analysts in the world have come to<br />

work only to find that the company has shut down the condition-monitoring<br />

department because they did not appreciate<br />

the value of the service. I can tell you so many stories. Maybe<br />

you have been through this already. It is simply not enough to<br />

be a skilled vibration analyst.<br />

When the vibration program began it was probably common<br />

for equipment to fail. These failures had everyone’s<br />

attention, including the senior plant management and the<br />

senior executive of the business. Thanks to vibration analysis,<br />

catastrophic failure becomes less common - even nonexistent.<br />

What a great job you’ve done! But what happens when someone<br />

up above decides they need to save some money. Do they<br />

think they need you anymore? Who needs vibration analysis if<br />

you don’t have machines breaking down all the time?<br />

So you need to be proactive. You need to understand how<br />

your service adds value to the business – how your service is<br />

aligned with the goals of the business. And you need to frequently<br />

communicate the importance of your service. Document<br />

the “saves” you have made. Document the costs you have<br />

avoided and the costs you have reduced. Measure your current<br />

state and the progress that has been made since the program<br />

began. Demonstrate how the vibration program has improved<br />

safety, reduced the number of environmental incidents, reduced<br />

maintenance costs, and how your activities reduced<br />

downtime, thus, enabling operations to achieve their targets.<br />

Or you could ignore this suggestion and instead work on<br />

your resume? Just kidding. Sort of…<br />

Final Words<br />

Now, it should be stated that any criticisms made above are not<br />

directed to you personally. These are just general observations<br />

of common problems that the author has observed over the<br />

past 30 years. Hopefully one or two of these suggestions will<br />

help you in your program. And even if all of these suggestions<br />

apply to you, it does not mean you have not been providing<br />

an excellent service to your employer or customer. They are<br />

simply intended to reveal opportunities for providing greater<br />

efficiency and an improved service.<br />

22 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


PRECISION MEETS CONNECTIVITY<br />

INTRODUCING THE<br />

FROM PRUFTECHNIK<br />

The only cloud-enabled touchscreen laser shaft alignment system<br />

with a range of built-in connectivity features.<br />

The industry-leading precision that you’ve come to expect from PRUFTECHNIK<br />

can now be integrated with your workflows, for a more mobile,<br />

more connected way of managing your assets.<br />

Find out more: what-is-coming-next.com


CONDITION XXXXXX MONITORING<br />

Smartening Up Old<br />

Equipment with IoT<br />

The IoT (Internet of Things) proposes that the Internet will link billions<br />

of everyday objects, so that these devices can create and share data through<br />

powerful, global cloud computing platforms.<br />

GLYNN LLOYD,<br />

Moog Inc.,<br />

glloyd@moog.com<br />

RESEARCHERS AT GARTNER, Inc. estimate<br />

that by 2020 there will be as many<br />

as 26 billion devices connected to the<br />

Internet. Such a promise sounds grand.<br />

But what effect, if any, will it have on<br />

maintaining industrial equipment? And<br />

why should maintenance managers<br />

care?<br />

Maintenance and the Internet<br />

of Things<br />

In terms of maintaining industrial<br />

equipment, the IoT means having the<br />

ability to instantly access data about<br />

the condition of industrial products,<br />

machinery and components from anywhere.<br />

In an unobtrusive way, managers<br />

can use the recent advances in wireless<br />

communication and data processing to<br />

gauge the health of their infrastructure.<br />

Different industries will benefit in diverse<br />

ways from using the IoT for maintenance.<br />

Table 1 suggests some examples<br />

from the world of operations and maintenance,<br />

which could offer managers<br />

real advantages when using the IoT.<br />

Another example is an IoT solution<br />

for retrofitting wind turbines, especially<br />

those in remote locations or extreme climates.<br />

IoT solutions in cases like these<br />

help prevent downtime and reduce the<br />

cost of energy.<br />

In fact, the IoT offers a natural benefit<br />

for a maintenance manager concerned<br />

about the cost and time required to<br />

reach and service a wind turbine hub.<br />

Reaching these turbines, which are<br />

typically 80 meters (262 feet) above the<br />

ground and often in remote locations,<br />

can require maintenance technicians to<br />

travel an hour or more by boat or helicopter<br />

to reach the repairs.<br />

Predicting Failure<br />

The battery backup system in a wind turbine<br />

is part of the pitch control system<br />

that is found in the hub of the turbine<br />

(see Figure 1). A 2011 report by Reliawind<br />

and recently conducted research<br />

by Moog and DNV GL Research identified<br />

that the pitch system is the number<br />

one ranked component contributing to<br />

wind turbine failure and downtime.<br />

The reason is that pitch systems are<br />

exposed to harsh ambient conditions inside<br />

the rotating hub, including extreme<br />

temperature, humidity, and vibration<br />

leading to lower reliability compared<br />

to other turbine components. Though<br />

pitch systems represent less than three<br />

percent of wind farm capital expenditure<br />

costs, they account for nearly a<br />

quarter of all downtime in turbines.<br />

While the battery is just one component<br />

in the pitch system, it has been found to<br />

be a factor, particularly in remote installations.<br />

Finding a way to monitor the health<br />

of that battery in an existing wind turbine<br />

requires a retrofit solution. Moog<br />

engineers have worked with wind farm<br />

professionals to develop a solution consisting<br />

of dedicated, high-security monitoring<br />

hardware and flexible remote<br />

connectivity for a turbine’s pitch control<br />

system.<br />

DIFFERENT INDUSTRIES WILL BENEFIT IN DIVERSE<br />

WAYS FROM USING THE IOT FOR MAINTENANCE.<br />

Figure 2: Workers<br />

monitor the<br />

performance of<br />

flight simulators<br />

in a 24/7 training<br />

centre where uptime<br />

is critical and<br />

maintenance crews<br />

have a four-hour<br />

window to perform<br />

maintenance.<br />

24 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


This type of solution provides O&M<br />

managers with online monitoring of<br />

battery conditions for all turbines from<br />

a single desktop or mobile device. Once<br />

installed by a wind turbine technical<br />

expert a system like this can provide<br />

routine health assessments of individual<br />

back-up battery trays.<br />

In addition to improved safety, less<br />

downtime and lower energy costs, a<br />

busy wind farm O&M manager will see<br />

the benefits of IoT in terms of convenient,<br />

secure access to wind turbines that<br />

include:<br />

• Automated email and SMS alerts on<br />

battery health<br />

• Integrated ordering of replacement<br />

battery modules and service visit requests<br />

• Real-time monitoring for other pitch<br />

system errors and condition deterioration<br />

• More rapid response and diagnosis<br />

by technical experts when there are<br />

problems<br />

Better, Faster Diagnosis or<br />

Root-Cause Analysis<br />

In the event a wind turbine has an unplanned<br />

outage, it is very common for<br />

maintenance crews to replace multiple<br />

components together during their site<br />

visit to increase the possibility of a successful<br />

repair, rather than performing<br />

a detailed diagnosis and full root cause<br />

analysis to determine exactly which<br />

component was really at fault.<br />

This means that it is common for fully<br />

working parts to be returned for repair<br />

unnecessarily. With a health monitoring<br />

option like the one described here,<br />

maintenance managers have real-time<br />

root-cause analysis data on their mobile<br />

device and can be equipped with just<br />

the right replacement parts before they<br />

travel.<br />

Even if you’re not managing something<br />

on the scale of a wind turbine<br />

farm, there are still numerous benefits<br />

to IoT for typical operations and maintenance<br />

situations. For instance, in a<br />

flight training centre, remote monitoring<br />

can help maintenance professionals<br />

capture usage statistics, forecast spare<br />

parts usage and make better use of short<br />

maintenance windows. Once a manager<br />

has real-time data about a plant’s motion<br />

control equipment, it becomes possible<br />

to consider a new level of predictive<br />

maintenance for today’s industrial operations.<br />

Preparing Predictive<br />

Maintenance<br />

The IoT helps process the data and give<br />

managers insight that was not previously<br />

possible. It moves maintenance away<br />

from a break-fix mentality. Predictive<br />

maintenance is a journey, though. It can<br />

take several years to go from a break-fix<br />

approach to preventative maintenance<br />

and, ultimately, predictive maintenance;<br />

it requires:<br />

• A willingness to share data<br />

• The patience to perfect the systems<br />

for collecting and processing that data<br />

• The discipline to act on what’s being<br />

collected<br />

As maintenance managers prepare<br />

for the IoT, they will have to adopt a new<br />

mindset rather than a new skillset. Because<br />

of the low cost of IoT components<br />

and the ability to retrofit legacy equipment,<br />

there’s much that can be done,<br />

even on older machinery. For example,<br />

a manager can place an IoT monitor on<br />

a valve and monitor activity (where the<br />

monitor will have no effect on the valve’s<br />

operation).<br />

They may capture temperature or<br />

vibration from a conveyer motor or robotic<br />

actuator, or may simply track cycle<br />

time variations on reciprocating equipment.<br />

Installing retrofit solutions and<br />

hardware upgrades like these will benefit<br />

the user directly, and can also augment a<br />

supplier’s service offerings via extended<br />

warranty plans or holistic maintenance<br />

plans and site service.<br />

Maintenance managers owe it to<br />

themselves to explore the potential of the<br />

information they can capture with the<br />

IoT. They should determine what more<br />

there is to know about their equipment<br />

and processes. Examining opportunities<br />

in this way will help them find the gaps in<br />

data and their missing knowledge.<br />

Figure 1: Cross-section view of a wind<br />

turbine’s blade and hub showing pitch<br />

system and battery backup system.<br />

IOT: SMARTENING UP OLD<br />

EQUIPMENT<br />

IoT sensors on equipment can capture<br />

critical “missing” data and provide<br />

visibility into existing production<br />

processes – particularly where<br />

those processes include older equipment<br />

IoT connectivity provides remote<br />

adjustment of settings, firmware<br />

or performance of machinery with<br />

possibility for repairs to take place<br />

24 hours/7 days without visits into<br />

harsh environments<br />

IoT platforms provide automated<br />

SMS or email alerts to end-users<br />

and technical service teams to flag<br />

when maintenance or intervention<br />

is required<br />

Prediction of the remaining life of a<br />

product can optimize the scheduling<br />

of maintenance and allow customers<br />

to plan for repair downtime<br />

Communication between similar<br />

products enables load balancing for<br />

increased lifetime<br />

The automated detection of overload,<br />

improper use or warranteevoiding<br />

operation of products benefits<br />

suppliers and users because<br />

machinery reliability is improved<br />

and operation is better tailored to<br />

the application<br />

The capture of usage statistics and<br />

detection of operating patterns facilitates<br />

lifecycle analysis, forecasting<br />

of spares inventory and improvements<br />

to future product designs<br />

Table 1: Examples of IoT benefits in<br />

operations and maintenance.<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 25


XXXXXX CONDITION MONITORING<br />

A technician performing machinery<br />

vibration diagnostics.<br />

RECORDING –<br />

Back to the Future (Part 2)<br />

The recording of the raw signal was described in the first part of this article. Now<br />

we will move on to the post-processing of recorded raw signal.<br />

RADOMIR SGLUNDA,<br />

Managing Director,<br />

Adash Ltd.,<br />

sglunda@adash.cz<br />

THE TWO MODES most commonly used<br />

to post-analyse the raw recorded signal<br />

in the Adash firmware is the Analyser<br />

and Run Up/Coast down. You can postanalyse<br />

immediately after recording<br />

in-situ or in the office at a later date. The<br />

Analyser mode offers a wide range of<br />

readings: simple (overall value), commonly<br />

used (time signals, spectrum)<br />

or more advanced readings (frequency<br />

response).<br />

The Run up/Coast down mode enables<br />

readings to be continuously measured<br />

and saved. This means that you can<br />

set up the time interval between two<br />

readings (example: the reading is taken<br />

every second) or the interval depends<br />

26 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

on the speed change (the new reading<br />

is taken when there is a speed change of<br />

more than 1 Hz from the previous saved<br />

reading).<br />

You Can Make Time Run<br />

Faster….<br />

If the record of run up, for example, is 20<br />

minutes long, then post-processing in<br />

normal mode the play back time is real<br />

time (20 minutes). This creates a situation<br />

in which it is the same as if you had<br />

walked back in time and were doing an<br />

evaluation right next to the machine, but<br />

you have the advantage of playing back<br />

multiple times with a different setup<br />

until you have the data analysed at optimum<br />

resolution and frequency.<br />

In the event you do not want to wait<br />

20 minutes to have the data analysed,<br />

then we have developed a very unique<br />

feature – the time can run faster. One<br />

minute can be reduced for example to<br />

only one second. It is done by special<br />

block data access and a bulk current<br />

evaluation algorithm.<br />

The speed up of time is inversely<br />

proportional to the complexity of the required<br />

analysis. In the case of processing<br />

the simple readings like overall values,<br />

we can make the time even 1000 times<br />

faster (it means that 1 hour of recording<br />

is processed in 3 seconds). In the case of<br />

processing more complex readings, such<br />

as order analysis that requires relatively<br />

a long computing time, we can make the<br />

time only typically 50 times faster.<br />

The big advantage coming from this<br />

feature is user freedom to try different<br />

setups and view the different results in a<br />

fraction of the time. It allows the analyst<br />

to “experiment” as if in the field and to<br />

repeat the data collection process on the<br />

equipment.<br />

Virtual Unit in the Computer<br />

Up to this point, we have been talking<br />

about the use of an instrument for recording<br />

and also for analysis. However<br />

there are more options. The recording


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

can be easily transferred from the instrument<br />

memory to the computer (by<br />

USB cable).<br />

A version of the firmware running on<br />

the VA4Pro unit is available to download<br />

and run on your PC or Windows Tablet.<br />

This is the 4410 Virtual Unit VA4Pro<br />

software and it is available free of charge<br />

to download from www.adash.com.<br />

This software is a fully functioning<br />

version of the firmware running on the<br />

VA4Pro unit. Once the virtual software<br />

is loaded onto your PC you will have the<br />

same screen as that which appears on<br />

the A4400 VA4 Pro analyser. Initially it<br />

was developed for marketing purposes,<br />

as it enables a potential customer to<br />

work with a virtual version of the VA-<br />

4Pro Analyser.<br />

WITH RECORDING FUNC-<br />

TION YOU WON’T MISS ANY<br />

IMPORTANT INFORMATION<br />

HIDDEN IN VIBRATIONS.<br />

As a result we quickly saw the benefit<br />

of being able to process the saved<br />

recordings taken in the VA4Pro on the<br />

PC. Although the mouse and keyboard,<br />

(or touch screen if using Window 8 or<br />

10) makes this process much faster and<br />

more user-friendly, the main advantage<br />

is the superior processing speed and<br />

power of most PC’s as compared to the<br />

CPU in the Adash VA4 results in much<br />

faster analysis time.<br />

Share Your Records<br />

The simple explorer-based file architecture<br />

allows you to export the records in<br />

.wav format and share with colleagues so<br />

they can utilize it with various software<br />

platforms. Although you can play the<br />

.wav file by audio output in your computer<br />

and then connect the analyser to<br />

perform the analysis, it is of course not<br />

the best solution because the frequency<br />

range starts at over 20Hz. The conversion<br />

from digital to analogue also is not<br />

painless, but it is better than nothing.<br />

However, an Adash provides a much<br />

more elegant solution on how to share<br />

the recordings with your colleagues<br />

who do not have the VA4 Pro analyser.<br />

Remember – a fully functional version<br />

of the VA4Pro firmware can be downloaded<br />

for free from our website.<br />

Once downloaded onto your PC the<br />

Technology<br />

developed by<br />

Adash can help<br />

you automatically<br />

detect machine<br />

faults such as<br />

unbalance,<br />

looseness,<br />

misalignment<br />

and bearing<br />

faults.<br />

Post-processing of data.<br />

recorded raw data files can be shared<br />

without restrictions and analyzed by<br />

anyone who wishes. This can be a very<br />

powerful tool when the data is collected<br />

(or recorded to be more exact) in one<br />

location, but analysed at will by various<br />

analysts that may have varying perspectives<br />

on what is of interest; then the results<br />

are collaborated and discussed.<br />

The SAB Paired to a Laptop<br />

is the same as the VA4 Pro<br />

analyzer<br />

We don’t necessarily need the VA4Pro<br />

instrument to create the record. The<br />

Adash 4404 SAB (Signal Acquisition<br />

Box) unit, which has the same AC/DC<br />

inputs as A4400 VA4 Pro is available.<br />

Simply upload the license file that corresponds<br />

with the SAB 4 Channel module<br />

into the 4410 Virtual software then<br />

connect the SAB to the laptop or tablet<br />

using a standard Mini-USB and your PC<br />

or table becomes a four channel analyser<br />

with all the features of the VA4.<br />

Many users prefer this alternative as<br />

the navigation is much easier, it can be<br />

shared real time with others by utilizing<br />

the wireless and remote desktop connection.<br />

This application also offers a<br />

unique option to “stack” up to four SAB<br />

units, which turns your PC into a 16<br />

Channel monitor.<br />

The small SAB units are much cheaper<br />

and easier to ship, and they are can<br />

be more conveniently transported in a<br />

backpack with a few sensors and cables<br />

rather than having the burden of a large<br />

hard transport case and all the accessories<br />

needed.<br />

What about the Future,<br />

Recording Only?<br />

The possibility to make a recording is also<br />

available when collecting route data.<br />

It means that you can make a recording<br />

for post-analysis apart from common<br />

route readings (overall, spectra…).<br />

And what is our vision of the future?<br />

Why should we take common readings<br />

such as overall values or spectrum in the<br />

route? Why don’t we just make a recording<br />

of the raw signal and do all analysis<br />

later in the computer interface?<br />

We have been considering these<br />

futuristic visions in our company for<br />

some time. It is obvious that the voices<br />

of opponents will appear and they will be<br />

saying that they need to see the results of<br />

measurements at the site, which is true<br />

for the analyst.<br />

On the other hand there are companies<br />

where the routes are taken by<br />

technicians or even operators who don’t<br />

know much or anything about vibration.<br />

In that instance a record is a better<br />

solution when technically feasible as the<br />

“remote analyst” then has more options.<br />

He/She can review data as in standard<br />

route mode, but also has the option to<br />

post analyse in higher resolution or frequencies<br />

should the need present itself.<br />

We have been cooperating long time<br />

with our customers in the nuclear power<br />

industry to develop this platform for<br />

condition-monitoring. There are thousands<br />

of measurement points at that<br />

site, but only 2 vibration specialists to<br />

analyse the data.<br />

In this case they could not manage<br />

to take all the readings, so maintenance<br />

personnel have simple data collectors to<br />

record the data and then the vibration<br />

specialists can post-analyse. When more<br />

advanced data acquisition is needed<br />

then the vibration specialist would use<br />

advanced analysers and leave his desk.<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 27


Road Map to Operational<br />

Readiness and Asset<br />

Performance<br />

Ensure a Safe, Reliable, and Compliant Operation<br />

Achieve business goals with a risk-based approach to asset management. Bentley will help get you there.<br />

Leveraging 30 years in design and visualization innovations, Bentley is at the forefront of engineering software.<br />

Combining 2D/3D plant models and point clouds with engineering information and asset performance management,<br />

Bentley delivers an enterprise platform to manage assets throughout their entire lifecycle.<br />

The visual workflow supports both greenfield and brownfield operations; bridging the gap between CAPEX and OPEX<br />

and enabling a sustainable business strategy for operational excellence and safety.<br />

© <strong>2016</strong> Bentley Systems, Incorporated. Bentley, the “B” Bentley logo, and AssetWise APM are either registered or unregistered trademarks or service marks of Bentley<br />

Systems, Incorporated or one of its direct or indirect wholly owned subsidiaries. Other brands and product names are trademarks of their respective owners.


Assess risk based on failure severity, likelihood scores,<br />

and confidence assessment.<br />

Visually navigate assets.<br />

Enterprise Platform for Asset Integrity, Reliability,<br />

and Performance:<br />

• Asset strategy development<br />

• Integrity management<br />

• Risk-based inspections<br />

• Reliability-centered maintenance<br />

• Corrosion management<br />

• System reliability<br />

• Process safety<br />

• Asset health indices and dashboards<br />

• Risk assessment and work prioritization<br />

• ISO 55000 implementation<br />

Learn more at www.bentley.com/AssetWise-APM<br />

Or call 1-800-BENTLEY


ASSET MANAGEMENT<br />

Smart<br />

Maintenance<br />

Management<br />

The Internet of Things (IoT) is a way to connect devices, collect data, transform<br />

it to information and distribute it through the organization via internet (cloud)<br />

technology. How can we incorporate and make the best use of IoT in our day-today<br />

maintenance and asset management activities? Moreover, how can we link<br />

machines, technology and humans together to create an innovative and intelligent<br />

maintenance system?<br />

EVELIENE<br />

LANGEDIJK,<br />

Manager Business<br />

development, UVS<br />

Industry Solutions bv<br />

The Netherlands,<br />

info@uvs-is.nl<br />

DUE TO THE Internet of Things, business<br />

models will change. Ageing assets, relocating<br />

production facilities, a shortage of<br />

qualified technical personnel and changing<br />

customer demands. For example,<br />

one-piece production or paying for the<br />

30 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

use of machines instead of paying for<br />

the whole machine. This, combined with<br />

increasing technological innovations,<br />

will shift the way equipment suppliers,<br />

production facilities and end-users<br />

interact. It raises more awareness on<br />

efficiency, ease of use, flexibility, maintenance<br />

needs and, of course, quality of the<br />

equipment.<br />

The biggest shift to be seen in maintenance<br />

models in the coming years will be<br />

the change from corrective to predictive<br />

and condition-based maintenance. And<br />

even in the maturity level of predictive<br />

maintenance there will be a shift from<br />

fixed time-based maintenance to adaptive<br />

maintenance based on real-time and<br />

historical data.<br />

Intelligent maintenance &<br />

asset management system<br />

Due to new technologies and easy access<br />

to the Internet or working in the<br />

Cloud, accessing and remotely monitoring<br />

machines can be done anytime and<br />

anyplace. This asks for reliable remote<br />

monitoring and access. Safety issues also<br />

play a big role in adopting new technologies<br />

using the Cloud or Internet connections.


ASSET MANAGEMENT<br />

Depending on the criticality of equipment,<br />

some equipment needs near to<br />

real-time condition monitoring to ensure<br />

it will not fail causing great losses<br />

or production stops. Critical equipment<br />

has a risk profile indicating that the consequences<br />

of failure are severe. Condition<br />

monitoring, diagnostics and remote<br />

access require an intelligent system to<br />

bring together the extended amount of<br />

data and analysis that is needed in this<br />

next level of maintenance management.<br />

The aggregation of data collection,<br />

storage, analysis and decision making<br />

for smart maintenance is called an intelligent<br />

maintenance system. Monitoring<br />

and analyzing the behaviour of machines<br />

and components of machines has<br />

become possible by means of advanced<br />

sensors, vibration analyses and other<br />

smart technologies.<br />

An intelligent maintenance system<br />

can process the collected data, provide<br />

insights in behaviour, anticipate erroneous<br />

situations, trigger alarms and give<br />

instructions for preventative maintenance.<br />

It combines Big Data and the<br />

Internet of Things, collecting data related<br />

to historic events, the asset health,<br />

performance of machines and machine<br />

parts and can thus effectively reduce operational<br />

and maintenance costs.<br />

IoT enables maintenance systems<br />

in remote monitoring in a much wider<br />

range of devices and machines than was<br />

previously possible. With an intelligent<br />

maintenance system organizations can<br />

gain valuable insight in machines and<br />

specific components of machines.<br />

Unplanned downtime can be eliminated<br />

by the automatic scheduling of<br />

maintenance before equipment failure<br />

happens, and when it does happen you<br />

will know exactly where and how to<br />

solve it. Total availability and performance<br />

of equipment can be improved.<br />

With an intelligent system, standard<br />

supplier data is matched to behaviour<br />

patterns so that optimal maintenance<br />

can be planned. In time this leads to an<br />

optimal reliability and maintenance &<br />

asset lifetime strategy.<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 31


XXXXXX ASSET MANAGEMENT<br />

Making maintenance<br />

management smart<br />

An intelligent maintenance system<br />

brings together technology, data, analyses,<br />

prognosis and resources aiming for<br />

the machines and systems to achieve<br />

highest possible performance levels and<br />

near-zero breakdowns.<br />

To make the most effective use of an<br />

intelligent system you first will need<br />

to think about which data you want to<br />

collect and how. With the right data acquired<br />

from monitoring assets, companies<br />

can obtain a competitive advantage<br />

by gaining relevant insights in the performance<br />

and usage levels of machinery.<br />

By using an intelligent system criticality,<br />

planning, processes, production, use of<br />

resources, maintenance, stock levels and<br />

spare parts can be managed to an optimal<br />

form.<br />

Data collection and remote monitoring<br />

combined with an intelligent maintenance<br />

system enables an informationbased<br />

and future-oriented predictive<br />

and optimal maintenance strategy.<br />

Prognoses and valuable insights can be<br />

created on the future, actual and historical<br />

condition of machines and machine<br />

components.<br />

The ultimate goal of using an intelligent<br />

maintenance system, leading to<br />

32 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

THE ADVANTAGES OF AN<br />

INTELLIGENT MAINTENANCE<br />

MANAGEMENT SYSTEM<br />

• Connecting machines, data, technology<br />

and people throughout the<br />

organization<br />

• Preventative maintenance based on<br />

real-time data, conditions and circumstances<br />

• Transformation of data to information,<br />

to knowledge, to fact-based<br />

maintenance decisions and action<br />

with remote monitoring and diagnostic<br />

systems<br />

• Intelligent decision support tools<br />

• Perform maintenance when the<br />

maintenance activity is most costeffective<br />

• Valuable insights and influence on<br />

machine and components behaviour<br />

predictive maintenance, is to perform<br />

maintenance at a set point in time<br />

when the maintenance activity is most<br />

cost-effective and before the machinery<br />

loses performance within a threshold<br />

of time.<br />

Also of great value is the opportunity<br />

to collect an entire database with diverse<br />

knowledge on certain parts, machines<br />

and suppliers. Knowing how equipment<br />

holds under different circumstances and<br />

usage level. For example, the production<br />

environment, running time, what is processed,<br />

temperature, humidity, operation<br />

of the machine and so on.<br />

Because machines and parts are<br />

monitored for each machine individually,<br />

they are not based on average data<br />

from other machines or supplier specifications.<br />

This has the advantage that the<br />

individual performance curves, circumstances<br />

in production environment, and<br />

the operational strategy and if necessary,<br />

previous data on historical incidents can<br />

be included in the analyses.<br />

Cases<br />

Machine builder case<br />

Together with an international operating<br />

machine builder we started a pilot<br />

project combining sensor data, M2M<br />

communication and an intelligent main-


ASSET MANAGEMENT<br />

tenance software. The goals were to get<br />

a better insight into machine life cycle,<br />

machine and individual components<br />

behaviour, maintenance management<br />

needs and possibilities for remote monitoring<br />

and diagnostics.<br />

For the machine builder, the main<br />

questions were how do our machines<br />

and specific components perform under<br />

different production and environmental<br />

circumstances, processing of different<br />

substances (liquids, granulates and so<br />

forth), general usage, running time. And<br />

accordingly, how can we give our clients<br />

the best possible service and advice on<br />

maintenance management so that the<br />

full potential and performance capability<br />

of our machines is reached.<br />

We started with a pilot project with a<br />

specific type of machine. Sensors were<br />

placed on the machine to measure variabilities<br />

such as environmental data and<br />

the type of product processed by the<br />

machine.<br />

This data was sent to our database using<br />

a remote machine to machine solution<br />

with a one-way data sending option.<br />

This was used to secure the data and<br />

external access to the machine.<br />

We took the raw data and turned it<br />

into valuable insights for both end-user<br />

and our machine building partner. Sensor<br />

data, control data and environmental<br />

circumstances were connected to our<br />

intelligent maintenance and asset management<br />

system. With all of this real<br />

time information about the health and<br />

performance of equipment, valuable<br />

insights were gained for future design,<br />

usage, performance levels, service &<br />

maintenance management and new<br />

business models.<br />

Food processing company case<br />

Together with an international operating<br />

food company we started a project to<br />

change maintenance management from<br />

corrective to condition-based, and even<br />

for some critical assets, predictive maintenance<br />

management.<br />

In this case, vibration analysis, combined<br />

with other data collected from<br />

intelligent remote devices was processed<br />

and analyzed in an intelligent maintenance<br />

system. The result was the creation<br />

of intelligent decision support tools<br />

and an insight into required actions and<br />

critical resources.<br />

Conclusion<br />

The future of maintenance and asset<br />

management in today’s rapidly changing<br />

and increasingly technology-oriented<br />

environment depends heavily on taking<br />

advantage of a new breed of technology<br />

and software that answers not only the<br />

question of what assets do I have, but<br />

also the question of how do I maintain<br />

them. The future tasks will be monitoring<br />

and knowing the health of your<br />

assets, planning maintenance when<br />

you anticipate it is really necessary and<br />

improving performance and effectiveness<br />

of resources. Making maintenance<br />

smart.<br />

Under the patronage of<br />

H. E. Shaikh Mohamed bin Khalifa Al Khalifa<br />

Minister of Oil<br />

Kingdom of Bahrain<br />

Value Driven Maintenance & ReliabilityMAINTCON<br />

4th MIDDLE EAST MAINTENANCE<br />

& RELIABILITY CONFERENCE<br />

12-15 December, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Gulf Hotel, Kingdom of Bahrain<br />

www.maintcon.org<br />

Organized by<br />

Supported by:<br />

Bahrain Society of Engineers, P.O. Box 835, Manama, Kingdom of Bahrain<br />

Tel: +973 1781 0733 Fax: +973 17827475, Email: vivek@mohandis.org


MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT<br />

The Maintenance<br />

Effectiveness Assessment:<br />

A Catalyst for Change<br />

For the maintenance manager there are some words that often evoke feelings of<br />

worry, nervousness, anxiety and even fear. One of the most dreaded words the<br />

maintenance manager can hear is “audit”. There is, however, another tool that is<br />

often used to measure business performance; it’s called the maintenance effectiveness<br />

assessment or MEA.<br />

WHEN THE AUDITOR’S report is out,<br />

those on the receiving end may feel<br />

like they are being cross-examined in a<br />

courtroom. It may not be quite like this<br />

in reality but that is exactly how many<br />

feel when they are on the receiving end<br />

of these types of business audits or examinations.<br />

At the same time, some may argue<br />

that the MEA is nothing but a “Benchmark<br />

Study”. Although they do have<br />

similar outcomes, compared to a benchmark<br />

study an MEA uses different tools,<br />

is usually more comprehensive in scope,<br />

and more focused in defining performance<br />

gaps and a way forward.<br />

Audits and MEA’s are different with<br />

one stark distinction. First of all, the<br />

MEA, compared to the audit has a completely<br />

different purpose, approach, and<br />

philosophy although similar protocol and<br />

methodology. The audit focuses on compliance,<br />

the MEA focus is on improvement.<br />

You would think that maintenance<br />

professionals and leaders would embrace<br />

the MEA more enthusiastically but unfortunately<br />

that is not always the case.<br />

34 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

TRACY STRAWN,<br />

CMRP, President, Oil<br />

and Gas Services,<br />

Marshall Institute,<br />

trawn@<br />

marshallinstitute.com<br />

Figure 1. Assessment & Planning Models.<br />

What Areas of Business Does<br />

the MEA examine?<br />

The MEA, as opposed to the audit, is an<br />

investigation to find ways to improve.<br />

If managed and conducted properly it<br />

should represent a partnership between<br />

the assessors and the maintenance<br />

leadership and the assessors. Thus, the<br />

outcome of the MEA should not be considered<br />

punitive nor something that creates<br />

unnecessary burden.<br />

Just like audits and benchmark studies<br />

the MEA follows a structured methodology.<br />

Listed below are the typical<br />

practice areas that are reviewed:<br />

• Strategic Planning and Policy Deployment<br />

• Maintenance Organization<br />

• Training and development<br />

• Performance Management<br />

• Competence and Skills<br />

• Continuous Improvement & Teams<br />

• Communication<br />

• Work Management<br />

• Shutdown/Outage Management<br />

• Work Execution<br />

• Preventive and Predictive<br />

Maintenance<br />

• Reliability Centred Maintenance<br />

• Root Cause Analysis<br />

• Inventory Management<br />

• Procurement<br />

• Contractor Management<br />

• Operator Care<br />

• Reliability Engineering<br />

• Life Cycle Analysis<br />

• Risk Based Inspection<br />

• Management of Change<br />

• Performance Standards<br />

• Safety Critical Equipment<br />

The above practices may vary from<br />

industry to industry but the ones listed<br />

represent what is needed to manage and<br />

operate an effective and efficient maintenance<br />

organization.<br />

MEA Tools and Techniques<br />

When conducting an MEA the assessors<br />

will use a variety of tools to perform<br />

their evaluation and investigation into<br />

these areas. Some of the tools and methods<br />

used include:<br />

• Maintenance Effectiveness<br />

Assessment questionnaires.<br />

• Interview with plant personnel<br />

• Benchmark Metrics<br />

• Plant and Equipment Observations<br />

• Productivity studies<br />

• Surveys<br />

• Focus Groups interviews (multiple<br />

viewpoints provide a clearer picture of<br />

what’s really going on in the business)<br />

• Documentation review (assessors will<br />

require up to 80 documents in advance<br />

for review and analysis)


MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT<br />

MEA Preparation<br />

Preparation for the MEA can begin as<br />

much as 6-8 weeks before the scheduled<br />

date of the assessment. The more information<br />

gathered upfront, the more time<br />

it gives the assessors to spend on analysis<br />

and less time searching for the data or<br />

documents. More time spent in analysis<br />

results in concise conclusions that meet<br />

minimal resistance and opposition from<br />

the organization being assessed. The end<br />

result should be better improvement<br />

recommendations for the maintenance<br />

organization going forward.<br />

Conducting the MEA<br />

The number of days required to perform<br />

an MEA may range from 3 to as many as<br />

20 depending on the size and complexity<br />

of the business. Assessors will follow<br />

the schedule that the maintenance<br />

organization helps build. The assessors<br />

will analyse daily the results of the interviews,<br />

review the data compiled, and<br />

organize their notes. From the analysis<br />

of data, interviews, questionnaires,<br />

documents, and performance metrics<br />

the assessors will begin building a case<br />

for improvement.<br />

MEA CAN BE A POWERFUL<br />

TOOL FOR IMPROVEMENT<br />

AND A CATALYST FOR<br />

CHANGE.<br />

Figure 2. Sample Assessment Questionnaire.<br />

MEA Report Out<br />

Most organizations will require the<br />

assessor to provide a report out at the<br />

close of the assessment. The report out<br />

will highlight findings to include major<br />

strengths and opportunities for improvement.<br />

In some cases recommendations<br />

may be included in a PowerPoint<br />

presentation. For some organizations<br />

that may be all that’s required for the<br />

report out to the business. Some companies<br />

may require a comprehensive<br />

written report no later than two weeks<br />

after the assessment that can be distributed<br />

throughout the organization and<br />

even to outside stakeholders such as<br />

joint venture partners or even government<br />

agencies. The purpose is to share<br />

the findings and recommendations and<br />

gain consensus on the opportunities for<br />

improvement and the recommendations<br />

going forward. To be most effective<br />

the assessors should build and present<br />

a compelling case to the maintenance<br />

leadership team for adopting the recommendations.<br />

This could be based on cost<br />

savings, greater throughput or even improved<br />

asset integrity.<br />

The MEA as a Catalyst for<br />

Change<br />

The MEA should be viewed as a “Catalyst<br />

for Change” as opposed to some sort<br />

of painful examination that does nothing<br />

but frustrate the maintenance leadership<br />

team and organization. In order<br />

to translate the MEA into a compelling<br />

business case and ultimately a catalyst<br />

for change several things must happen.<br />

1. Leadership must take time to explain<br />

to their maintenance team and<br />

even the operations team that their performance<br />

represents an opportunity for<br />

improvement based on preliminary data<br />

the leadership has compiled.<br />

2. Leadership must communicate to<br />

the maintenance and operations team<br />

that, based on their assessment, they are<br />

engaging an outside party to assess their<br />

maintenance organization and business.<br />

3. Leadership must support and<br />

encourage cooperation with the maintenance<br />

assessors to ensure they get all<br />

the data and information required to<br />

complete their assessment and build a<br />

business case.<br />

4. If leadership believes the assessment<br />

findings were a fair and accurate<br />

representation of their maintenance<br />

practices and organization they must<br />

embrace the assessment conclusions<br />

and proposed way forward.<br />

NOTE: many organizations go<br />

through what maintenance assessors<br />

term the 4 D’s after an assessment:<br />

“Deny, Defend, Decide, and Do”. This<br />

is normal but Leadership can minimize<br />

the “Deny” and “Defend” time by being<br />

openly supportive of the findings. This<br />

will help the maintenance team get to<br />

the “Decide” and “Do” phases quickly.<br />

5. Once the maintenance team has<br />

consensus and alignment on the assessment<br />

findings and recommendations<br />

Leadership should sponsor the<br />

improvement team or steering committee<br />

assigned to build an improvement<br />

plan around the recommendations. If<br />

leadership sponsors the improvement<br />

plan it increases the probability of the<br />

recommendations being completed<br />

thoroughly and on time.<br />

The challenge of maintenance organisations<br />

for today is to not only improve,<br />

but to improve at a rate faster than<br />

ever imagined. Taking years to develop<br />

the behaviours, culture, practices and<br />

processes necessary for a high performing<br />

maintenance organization will be<br />

intolerable, if not fatal. This is where the<br />

MEA can be a powerful tool for improvement<br />

and a catalyst for change if used by<br />

leadership properly.<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 35


MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT<br />

Reliability and<br />

Maintenance<br />

Management Beliefs<br />

CHRISTER<br />

IDHAMMAR,<br />

Founder and CEO<br />

of IDCON INC.,<br />

Raleigh NC, USA,<br />

info@idcon.com<br />

Excellent leadership is the very essential success factor<br />

for lasting results for any improvement initiative an<br />

organization undertakes, including improvements to<br />

Reliability and Maintenance performance.<br />

36 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT<br />

AS A LEADER I have found it very important<br />

to develop and communicate your<br />

beliefs to your organization. These beliefs<br />

will then guide your organization on<br />

its journey to your goals.<br />

In this and the next issue of <strong>Maintworld</strong><br />

–magazine I will share my own<br />

and IDCON’s beliefs related to reliability<br />

and maintenance management in the<br />

hope that they will serve as a guideline to<br />

develop your own beliefs.<br />

BELIEF 1<br />

Cost reduction does not generate<br />

improved reliability. Improved reliability<br />

results in lower costs.<br />

Reliability performance is measured<br />

here as performance of Quality x Time x<br />

Speed. Or Overall Production Efficiency.<br />

(OPE)<br />

To sustainably reduce cost you need<br />

to focus on what drives cost, not cost<br />

alone. Improved production reliability<br />

drives down costs. Even if your production<br />

lines are not sold out the biggest<br />

saving potential is increased production<br />

reliability because it shortens the time<br />

from raw material to finished product.<br />

Remember that improved reliability<br />

also improves safety and energy consumption.<br />

BELIEF 2<br />

People cannot be more productive<br />

than the system that they work in<br />

will allow them to be.<br />

Even with good skills and good wills<br />

people cannot be effective if they work in<br />

a reactive, unplanned and unscheduled<br />

system. As an example training in skills<br />

can be wasted because people will not<br />

be allowed to use their skills to execute<br />

work with precision.<br />

BELIEF 3<br />

It is a leadership obligation to develop,<br />

communicate, and coach implementation<br />

of these processes.<br />

One of the most important things you<br />

can do as a leader is to develop and document<br />

the holistic reliability and maintenance<br />

management system, the processes<br />

in that system and the elements in<br />

the processes.<br />

When this is done you will have a very<br />

well-defined reliability and maintenance<br />

management strategy. You can use this<br />

documented strategy to drive implementation<br />

and to measure progress towards<br />

your vision.<br />

BELIEF 4<br />

It is more important to do the right<br />

things than to do things right.<br />

To decide what the right things to do are<br />

is leadership. To do things right is execution<br />

of these things. When developing<br />

your reliability and maintenance management<br />

strategy you should only focus<br />

on the right things to do and not discuss<br />

how to do them. This is because it is<br />

easier to reach acceptance on the right<br />

things to do than how execute them.<br />

BELIEF 5<br />

The right people are an organization’s<br />

most vital asset.<br />

Many statements declare, “People are<br />

our most valuable asset”. I do not agree<br />

with this statement. It should instead<br />

TO SUSTAINABLY REDUCE<br />

COST YOU NEED TO FOCUS<br />

ON WHAT DRIVES COST, NOT<br />

COST ALONE.<br />

state. “The right people are our most valuable<br />

asset”. That is a statement I would<br />

agree with. Many improvement initiatives<br />

fail because the right people are not<br />

accountable and responsible for the task<br />

they are assigned to. It does not mean<br />

that these people cannot be right for another<br />

position. It is a continuous process<br />

to develop the organization so that the<br />

right people have the right position.


MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT<br />

Illustration of what the basic maintenance<br />

processes are. Looks so simple, but very<br />

few organizations do them well.<br />

BELIEF 6<br />

Busy people are not productive unless<br />

they work on the right thing.<br />

Measurement methods such as<br />

“Wrench time” can therefore not be<br />

right thing to do. In fact a very good<br />

maintenance organization is less busy<br />

with “Wrench time” between shut<br />

-downs. Instead, more time is spent<br />

on Root Cause Problem Elimination<br />

(RCPE) and preparing for the next shut<br />

down. This can be done because there<br />

are very few breakdowns. If work is<br />

planned and then scheduled, people will<br />

work on the right things, so it is more<br />

important to measure the effectiveness<br />

of the processes people work in than to<br />

measure the symptoms of the processes<br />

people work in.<br />

BELIEF 7<br />

People do not mind change, but do<br />

not like to be changed.<br />

My experience is that people do not like,<br />

and seldom buy in to, changes handed<br />

down to people from above without<br />

explanation of what, why and how. But<br />

if people are well informed and listened<br />

to, they will better understand and accept,<br />

the reason for change. Repeated<br />

information and education and training<br />

are essential elements of any improvement<br />

initiative involving people.<br />

BELIEF 8<br />

Basic maintenance processes must<br />

be in place before implementing<br />

more advanced tools.<br />

Many organizations start new improvement<br />

initiatives before they are ready.<br />

Some examples include:<br />

Starting Reliability Centred (RCM)<br />

Training and analyses before they are<br />

ready because they are still too reactive<br />

and they are reactive because they do<br />

not carry out the very basics well.<br />

Train crafts people in precision maintenance<br />

training when they work in a<br />

reactive process. When most work is<br />

urgent, it will lead to a situation where<br />

there will not be enough time to use the<br />

good skills they have learned. In turn<br />

this will lead to disappointment and<br />

skills will be lost.<br />

A VERY GOOD MAINTENANCE<br />

ORGANIZATION IS LESS<br />

BUSY WITH “WRENCH TIME”<br />

BETWEEN SHUT -DOWNS.<br />

Upgrading to an advanced Computerized<br />

Maintenance Management System<br />

(CMMS) before the organization is<br />

ready. A good piece of advice is to always<br />

start with designing the processes first<br />

and then implement the new system.<br />

BELIEF 9<br />

Rapid and sustainable change does<br />

not exist in maintenance because the<br />

change process is “90 percent” about<br />

people and behaviours.<br />

If change is equivalent to sustainable<br />

improvements, then the reply to this<br />

statement is no. Why? Because my experience<br />

has shown that 90 percent of improvement<br />

of maintenance performance<br />

is about people and 10 percent is about<br />

technology and processes. This does not<br />

mean that technology and design of processes<br />

are not important. It is very important<br />

to design the right processes for<br />

people to enable them to become more<br />

productive. But that is the easy part in an<br />

improvement initiative. This part might<br />

take only five to ten percent of the effort<br />

in time and money.<br />

What takes time is to make an oftenundisciplined<br />

reactive organization<br />

to work in a disciplined process. Your<br />

organization might have many maintenance<br />

heroes who value the recognition<br />

they receive when they repair a broken<br />

down piece of equipment. They might also<br />

be rewarded by overtime pay because<br />

of the logic that equipment is more likely<br />

(76 percent) to break down when the full<br />

maintenance crew is not in the mill.<br />

Technology is also very important.<br />

To acquire the right tools for vibration<br />

analyses, precision alignment, and<br />

hand held computers and so on is easy<br />

because most maintenance people love<br />

gadgets and tools. Again, to implement<br />

these tools so that they are used in a disciplined<br />

process is often a challenge. It<br />

might be basic things like taking action<br />

to plan and schedule the correction of<br />

failures in equipment discovered early<br />

by any of these tools. To make that process<br />

work is what takes time.<br />

It will require a close partnership<br />

between operations and maintenance<br />

so priorities of work are done based on<br />

what is most important for the business.<br />

These are just a few examples to<br />

demonstrate that 90 percent of effort to<br />

improve maintenance performance is<br />

about people.<br />

World Class Performance can only be<br />

achieved in a Reliability Partnership Work<br />

System.<br />

BELIEF 10<br />

Operations, Engineering, Maintenance,<br />

and Stores must work in a<br />

partnership to reach excellence.<br />

Most organizations we work with<br />

think they work in a close partnership<br />

between these departments, but not<br />

many do. This is often reflected in the<br />

way performance indicators are used.<br />

Operations are measured by the quality<br />

tons produced, maintenance by the<br />

cost of maintenance, engineering by on<br />

time and within budget for projects, and<br />

stores by turnover and value of inventory.<br />

These examples of performance<br />

indicators do not promote a partnership<br />

between the departments.<br />

If you agree with belief 10 you cannot<br />

only say that: “now we shall all work<br />

together as equal partners in a reliability<br />

partnership”, you need to define, document<br />

and communicate your beliefs, and<br />

then design all work processes according<br />

to these beliefs.<br />

38 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


TYÖTURVALLISUUS


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

Thanks to thermal imaging cameras,<br />

Inspectahire can easily detect gases in<br />

difficult to reach or hazardous locations.<br />

Small leaks can become big ones – that<br />

is why it is important to be able to<br />

detect them in an early stage.<br />

Detect Leaks with<br />

THERMAL IMAGING<br />

Inspectahire relies on<br />

the FLIR GF320 Optical<br />

Gas Imaging camera for<br />

maintenance inspections<br />

and hydrocarbon leak<br />

detection in the offshore<br />

oil and gas industry.<br />

40 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

KRISTOF MADDELEIN,<br />

FLIR Systems,<br />

kristof.maddelein@<br />

flir.com<br />

ESTABLISHED IN 1981, Inspectahire is<br />

a leading international supplier of specialist<br />

remote visual inspection technology<br />

and solutions to companies in many<br />

industries around the world. Supported<br />

by the most advanced technologies<br />

around, Inspectahire helps its customers<br />

manage their safety, profitability<br />

and environmental impact of their assets.<br />

When the company is tasked with<br />

the detection of fugitive hydrocarbon<br />

emissions, FLIR’s GF320 Optical Gas<br />

Imaging (OGI) camera is their preferred<br />

choice of technology.<br />

Inspectahire offers equipment rental,<br />

contracting and project engineering<br />

services supported by a team of skilled<br />

engineers who have a wealth of inspection<br />

knowledge and experience. Their<br />

expertise extends to a wide range of<br />

equipment and assets, both onshore<br />

and offshore, and in all environments


CONDITION MONITORING<br />

SAFETY AND COST ARE TWO OF THE BIGGEST CONCERNS IN<br />

THE OFFSHORE OIL AND GAS INDUSTRY TODAY.<br />

– including harsh and hazardous. All<br />

Inspectahire’s advanced inspection<br />

solutions are carried out in accordance<br />

with the requirements of ISO 9001 best<br />

practice.<br />

Oil and Gas Industry<br />

Having worked for three decades in the<br />

Oil & Gas industry, both in the North Sea<br />

and worldwide, Inspectahire has built up<br />

a strong expertise in this sector. Safety<br />

and cost are two of the biggest concerns<br />

in the offshore oil and gas industry today.<br />

Inspectahire realizes this as no other and<br />

therefore aims to tackle those challenges<br />

by using the best technologies available.<br />

– The offshore oil and gas industry<br />

are proactive in their search for the best<br />

technologies for detecting emissions<br />

that may affect the safety, profitability<br />

and environmental impact of their assets,<br />

comments Cailean Forrester, Managing<br />

Director of Inspectahire.<br />

– At Inspectahire we strive to identify<br />

and offer the best available technological<br />

solutions for all remote inspection<br />

scenarios.<br />

Safety and Economy<br />

Dangerous gas leaks are a concern to<br />

every oil and gas production plant. Not<br />

only do some of the gases harm the environment,<br />

but the leaks also cost companies<br />

substantial amounts of money.<br />

– The company has been using thermal<br />

imaging cameras for a very long time<br />

to detect dangerous gas leaks, comments<br />

Cailean Forrester.<br />

– Thanks to thermal imaging cameras,<br />

we can easily detect gases in difficult<br />

to reach or hazardous locations. And<br />

we can help companies prevent costly<br />

downtime of their production plant.<br />

Contact Measurement<br />

Technologies versus<br />

Thermal Imaging<br />

– We have been using certain contact<br />

measurement tools like laser detectors<br />

or leaks sniffers, says Cailean Forrester.<br />

– But the problem is that you have<br />

to go right up to the object, which is not<br />

always safe or even possible. In other<br />

words, this approach is limited and not<br />

very precise. With a thermal imaging<br />

camera like the GF320 however, you can<br />

keep a safe distance and still detect gas<br />

leaks with great precision.<br />

Accurate and Ergonomic<br />

The Inspectahire team is using the<br />

GF320 optical gas imaging camera for<br />

maintenance inspections and for all its<br />

hydrocarbon detection jobs, in hydrocarbon<br />

production plants or for the inspection<br />

of any material that uses hydrocarbon<br />

as a fuel.<br />

The GF320 camera offers a range<br />

of tangible benefits compared to traditional<br />

hydrocarbon leak sniffers, because<br />

it can scan a broader area much more<br />

rapidly and monitor areas that are diffi-<br />

Inspectahire has been using thermal<br />

imaging cameras for a long time to detect<br />

dangerous gas leaks.<br />

With the GF320 camera, you can keep a<br />

safe distance and still detect gas leaks with<br />

great precision.<br />

cult to reach with contact measurement<br />

tools. The portable camera also greatly<br />

improves operator safety, by detecting<br />

emission at safe distance.<br />

– The camera is very ergonomic and<br />

very sensitive, comments Cailean Forrester.<br />

– If a hydrocarbon leak is there, you<br />

will certainly see it with the GF320 camera,<br />

even if it is a small one. Small leaks<br />

can become big ones – that is why it is<br />

important to be able to detect them at an<br />

early stage. With the GF320, we are sure<br />

of an accurate and reliable detection.<br />

THE FLIR GF320 OPTICAL GAS IMAGING (OGI) CAM<br />

GF320 Optical Gas Imaging (OGI) camera<br />

The FLIR GF320 is an optical gas imaging<br />

camera designed to help the oil and gas<br />

industries better control hydrocarbon emissions,<br />

thereby preserving the environment,<br />

improving operational safety and minimizing<br />

revenue loss.<br />

The thermal imaging camera is designed<br />

for use in harsh industrial environments. It<br />

takes advantage of a state-of-the-art focal<br />

plane array detector and optical systems<br />

tuned to very narrow spectral infrared ranges.<br />

This enables the camera to image infrared<br />

energy absorbed by hydrocarbon gas leaks.<br />

Images are processed and enhanced by<br />

the FLIR High Sensitivity Mode feature to<br />

clearly show the presence of gases against<br />

stationary backgrounds.<br />

Gases detectable by the camera appear<br />

on-screen as smoke plumes. In the offshore<br />

oil and gas industry, the camera offers operators<br />

a preventive maintenance tool to help<br />

spot hydrocarbon leaks in tanks, pipelines<br />

and facilities. The FLIR GF320 can be used<br />

both for finding gas leaks and maintenance<br />

inspections.<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 41


MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT<br />

Screenshot of the Viu More AR BizCard<br />

Experience App1: virtual elements anchored<br />

on a business card in the real world.<br />

Industry 4.0<br />

Knocking on Your<br />

Front Door<br />

Increasing efficiency, faster work execution, smaller error rates, the right<br />

information immediately available on the right spot, a shorter learning curve of new<br />

employees… Aren’t we all facing these challenges in industry today?<br />

BENNY LAUWERS,<br />

CEO, Viu More NV<br />

benny.lauwers@viumore.be<br />

42 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

TODAY, EVERY INDUSTRIAL company is<br />

challenged by the demand to lower production<br />

costs. For years maintenance departments<br />

have needed to do more with<br />

less. This results in an increasing pressure<br />

weighing on the shoulders of every<br />

individual maintenance technician.<br />

As if this is not enough, we will be<br />

faced with another challenge in the near<br />

future when the baby boom generation,<br />

our current technical experts, will leave<br />

the labour market. Maintenance Managers<br />

are already aware of the fact that<br />

they will not easily be replaced. The<br />

result is an increasing amount of less<br />

technically skilled people in maintenance<br />

departments.<br />

These less skilled technicians are<br />

confronted with a decreasing need of<br />

equipment standardization, mostly for<br />

reasons of cost effectiveness. Less standardization<br />

results in less repetitive work,<br />

more diversity in task execution and<br />

more different work instructions. This<br />

leads to the simple fact that technicians<br />

need to remember more. Needless to say,<br />

efficiency will suffer and more errors<br />

will be made.<br />

Augmented and Mixed Reality<br />

Industry 4.0 is knocking on the front<br />

door of our industrial companies, or is<br />

in some cases already well settled in the<br />

daily processes. Augmented Reality is<br />

one of the technologies that can be classified<br />

under the heading of Industry 4.0.<br />

Augmented Reality is the technology<br />

of taking in real time the view of the real<br />

world and adding digital information<br />

on top of it. The digital information can<br />

exist of simple brief text notifications,<br />

videos and even full 3D images.<br />

The technology of Mixed Reality goes<br />

one step further and anchors all virtual<br />

elements to a specific point in the real<br />

world.<br />

For making this possible a sensorpacked<br />

wearable device is needed, such<br />

as a tablet or smartphone, smart glasses<br />

or a smart helmet. A strong evolution is<br />

going on in the market of smart devices<br />

because of the efforts of big technology


MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT<br />

companies, such as Microsoft, Google,<br />

Apple and a few promising technology<br />

start-ups, such as ODG and Magic Leap.<br />

This leads to the increasing success of<br />

Augmented and Mixed Reality in different<br />

fields of use.<br />

Industrial Applications<br />

Industry is one of the domains where<br />

Augmented and Mixed Reality can have<br />

a huge added value. Virtual elements<br />

anchored to the real world can offer<br />

advantages in training new technicians<br />

and supporting technicians in their<br />

daily work. For example, you can train<br />

a relatively inexperienced technician in<br />

replacing the mechanical seal of a centrifugal<br />

pump by a step by step digital<br />

work instruction where the right virtual<br />

tool (screwdriver, socket wrench…) will<br />

be placed on the right real world screw<br />

or bolt. This will increase the learning<br />

curve of new employees and reduce the<br />

risks related to less technically skilled<br />

and experienced technicians performing<br />

dangerous tasks in the field.<br />

Tablet used for augmenting the real world<br />

with digital information.<br />

Virtual screwdriver and 3 arrows anchored<br />

at the 4 screws of the lid of the electrical<br />

box.<br />

The same technique can also be used<br />

to support an experienced technician<br />

in performing a task he or she doesn’t<br />

normally perform often. Or you can<br />

support a technician in solving the<br />

cause of a failure by providing him or<br />

her with a failure-solving algorithm<br />

where the addition of virtual elements<br />

will guide them through the problem<br />

solving process. Even running a simple<br />

checklist with the real world being augmented<br />

by virtual elements gives a lot of<br />

advantages in reducing execution time<br />

and lowering the error rates made by<br />

technicians.<br />

At the same time it is possible to<br />

provide the necessary safety measurements<br />

to the technician as well as every<br />

other digitally available data, such as<br />

plans and schemes, manuals, spare parts<br />

information and equipment status information.<br />

The resulting advantage of this ‘digital<br />

companion’ brings us one step closer to<br />

the necessary gain in efficiency which industrial<br />

companies are looking for today.


XXXXXX MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT<br />

BEMAS Innovation Award<br />

The advantages of Augmented and<br />

Mixed Reality as well as the level of innovation<br />

have been acknowledged by the<br />

jury of the Innovation Award organized<br />

by the Belgian Maintenance Association<br />

(BEMAS). In April this year, Viu More<br />

won this award with their Augmented<br />

Reality applications for industry. Other<br />

finalists were Allied Reliability Group<br />

with their AR-C10 ‘Bridge to better<br />

condition monitoring’ and Prüftechnik<br />

with their Rotalign Touch application for<br />

user-friendly laser alignment.<br />

The jury recognised how the broad<br />

field of application and easy accessibility<br />

of the innovation addressed a very relevant<br />

issue for our industrial companies.<br />

CEO Benny Lauwers<br />

(left) and Chairman<br />

Dirk Roelens (right)<br />

receive the BEMAS<br />

Innovation Award<br />

<strong>2016</strong>.<br />

The Future and Beyond<br />

Augmented and Mixed Reality will definitely<br />

be a big part of our future. Not<br />

only in industry, but also in the consumer<br />

market both technologies are on the<br />

verge of breakthrough. Companies such<br />

as IKEA, L’Oréal and BMW already use<br />

Augmented Reality applications in their<br />

marketing, sales and after-sales process.<br />

Although today a lot is already possible<br />

with Augmented and Mixed Reality<br />

in industry, there are also still a lot of opportunities.<br />

Evolutions on smart devices<br />

specifically designed for industrial applications<br />

have just begun. In addition,<br />

a lot of research is running in the field<br />

of more robust recognition and tracking<br />

algorithms. This is necessary to make<br />

more robust software that can work<br />

independently of the work environment<br />

and weather conditions. After all, we<br />

are dealing here with computer and machine<br />

vision that we want to perform the<br />

same tasks as our own eyes and brains.<br />

And we all know that our eyes and brain<br />

both are complex pieces of nature.<br />

The field of gesture recognition is also<br />

an emerging research field. With gesture<br />

recognition we can guard the maintenance<br />

technician and operator in their<br />

task execution and warn them when<br />

they make a mistake or an error. Or you<br />

can use gestures to call new menu items,<br />

slide between different plans, pick a specific<br />

equipment form the plan, zoom in<br />

and study it in detail.<br />

Fans of Steven Spielberg’s ‘Minority<br />

Report’, the movie with Tom Cruise<br />

taking the leading role probably will see<br />

some similarities. Who knows, within a<br />

Multiple examples of augmented digital information on top of the real world.<br />

AUGMENTED AND MIXED<br />

REALITY WILL DEFINITELY BE<br />

A BIG PART OF OUR FUTURE.<br />

few years, all our maintenance technicians<br />

and operators will make use of the<br />

same tools Tom Cruise has in this wonderful<br />

movie.<br />

Payback Period<br />

New technologies often suffer from the<br />

perception that they are expensive, and<br />

that large investment budgets are needed.<br />

Sometimes this is true, but in many<br />

cases the Return on Investment (ROI)<br />

justifies the initial investment.<br />

The level of efficiency increase when<br />

using Augmented and Mixed Reality<br />

applications is that large that a pay back<br />

period can be reached in a period of 3 to<br />

9 months depending on the application.<br />

There are also some benefits that are<br />

difficult to insert in the calculation of<br />

the ROI and pay back period. For example<br />

savings from a safer task execution<br />

and savings due to a decreasing cost of<br />

damaged equipment and production<br />

losses caused by execution errors. Also<br />

the decreasing risk on image damage<br />

due to HSE issues and production losses<br />

caused by execution errors is not easy to<br />

calculate.<br />

Augmented and Mixed Reality is<br />

knocking at the front door of our industrial<br />

companies and because of its<br />

potential nobody can stop it. So, remember:<br />

“The early bird/adopter catches the<br />

worm”.<br />

The Viu More AR BizCard Experience<br />

can be downloaded in the Google Play<br />

Store. There is also a link available in the<br />

Google Play Store where you can download<br />

our business card. (Only available<br />

for Android devices)<br />

44 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


THE HIGHEST<br />

THERMAL QUALITY<br />

without compromise<br />

YMPÄRISTÖTURVALLISUUS<br />

FLIR T1K HD Thermal Camera<br />

Outstanding image quality: 1024 x 768 px<br />

Best in class optics<br />

Fully radiometric JPEGs & videos<br />

Compact, streamlined design<br />

that's easy to use and carry<br />

Check out the amazing HD thermal video at<br />

www.flir.co.uk/T1K


REMOTE MONITORING<br />

Text Lenny Shaver, Sr. Director, Product Management,<br />

LumaSense technologies Inc., Santa Clara, CA.<br />

Figure 1 TS724DV-PT System in Operation<br />

Increased reliability through<br />

continuous and remote substation<br />

ASSET MONITORING<br />

Conditioned-based maintenance (CBM) is essential for electric utilities and<br />

most utilities have initiatives and investments to realize these goals. The use of<br />

thermography is a well-proven technique for monitoring conditions and detecting<br />

faults in electrical equipment.<br />

FOR MANY YEARS, portable thermal imaging<br />

cameras were known as a reliable<br />

tool in the condition-based and preventative<br />

maintenance of electrical distribution<br />

systems in low-, medium-, and<br />

high-voltage installations, where they<br />

are often used at periodic time intervals.<br />

However, manual thermography<br />

inspections limit the practicality and<br />

scalability of applying CBM. There is a significant<br />

cost related to the inspections and<br />

the data gathered tends to be imprecise.<br />

Finally, even if good data is collected, there<br />

is a shortage of effective tools and resources<br />

required to analyze the data. Advancements<br />

in thermography allow this proven<br />

CBM tool to be automated thus enabling<br />

utilities to better realize CBM.<br />

46 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

Detecting Equipment<br />

Problems before Failure<br />

With a great deal of equipment at electrical<br />

power substations nearing the end of<br />

its useful life, the potential for faults or<br />

the complete failure of these devices due<br />

to their age increases. The use of thermal<br />

imaging in the detection of equipment<br />

problems is attractive because the noncontact<br />

nature of the technique allows<br />

assessments to be done safely while<br />

equipment is kept in operation.<br />

However, manual and periodic inspections<br />

have their limitations. First<br />

of all, they are expensive since workers<br />

need to travel and haul equipment,<br />

which takes them away from other important<br />

work. Manual inspections are<br />

also prone to error and the results are<br />

highly variable depending on load and<br />

weather conditions. In addition, due to<br />

limited resources, the biggest difficulty<br />

may be finding time or the right people<br />

Figure 2 System Network<br />

to interpret the results of the manual<br />

inspections.<br />

Optimized maintenance concepts in<br />

this industry call for automated methods<br />

that are data driven. New advancements<br />

in data anomaly analysis and continuous<br />

monitoring of critical substation connections<br />

and assets, such as transformers,<br />

bushings, disconnects, and capacitor<br />

banks, provide an automated earlywarning<br />

detection of developing failures.<br />

Electric utilities need an automated,<br />

data-driven method to analyze electrical<br />

equipment.


REMOTE MONITORING<br />

Replacing manual inspections that<br />

may be erroneous or periodic with a<br />

more rigorous and continuous automated<br />

monitoring method allows operators<br />

to identify transient thermal events<br />

that were not detectable with manual<br />

inspections. By deploying thermal imaging<br />

systems at critical locations throughout<br />

the electrical power distribution<br />

system, electric utilities have access to<br />

continuous, online monitoring without<br />

the personnel constraints and limited<br />

resources. The end result is the decrease<br />

in maintenance activity and the procurement<br />

of replacement devices becomes a<br />

viable strategy. Furthermore, the safety<br />

and reliability of the substation equipment<br />

is increased and the loss of the<br />

distribution of electrical power from a<br />

major asset failure can be prevented.<br />

Automated & Remote Thermal<br />

Imaging Monitoring<br />

Designed with advanced maintenancefree<br />

electronics, the ThermalSpection<br />

724 system offers a high degree of accuracy<br />

for demanding electric power utilities<br />

while accurately measuring asset temperature<br />

without contact in even the most<br />

adverse environments. This system allows<br />

utilities to continuously monitor the temperature<br />

profile and long-term thermal<br />

trends of assets within an electrical power<br />

substation remotely. This allows for incredible<br />

condition-based maintenance by<br />

allowing operators to automatically detect<br />

temperature deviations from normal<br />

operating conditions in real-time.<br />

The ThermalSpection 724 Dual<br />

Vision – Pan Tilt (TS724 DV-PT) system<br />

includes both thermal and visual<br />

imagers in a hardened enclosure on a<br />

positioner with a continuous 360° pan<br />

range and tilt range of ±45°. The enclosure<br />

protects the cameras from weather<br />

and temperature changes and uses a<br />

solid state cooling system for reliable,<br />

long-term installation. The solution can<br />

combine multiple devices, including<br />

optional fixed thermal imagers and fixed<br />

single point infrared pyrometers, for the<br />

most comprehensive system solution for<br />

monitoring electric power substations.<br />

Figure 4 Substation Thermal Image<br />

serves as the communication link from<br />

the camera to the controller and allows<br />

for quick access to the camera’s thermal<br />

readings and configuration options.<br />

The local controller can be a utilityapproved<br />

computer or a server from<br />

LumaSense, which will run the included<br />

LumaSpec RT software. This software<br />

allows the user to define automated<br />

“inspection tours” of the substation or<br />

industrial setting to monitor multiple areas.<br />

Operators can also use the software<br />

pan and tilt controls for manual positioning.<br />

Data from the controller is also<br />

published to existing data historians, for<br />

example PI from OSIsoft, using Modbus<br />

or OPC protocols.<br />

In parallel, data can optionally be<br />

published to a Microsoft SQL database<br />

using LumaTrend server. This provides<br />

a central repository for data and images<br />

from substation and plants throughout<br />

a user’s enterprise. With such a system,<br />

centralized engineering and operations<br />

staff can easily review data and images<br />

from all cameras from anywhere on the<br />

corporate network. The data collected<br />

by the cameras can be put in the hands<br />

of experts, wherever they may be. The<br />

thermal images and temperature data<br />

can also be setup to trigger alarms, automatically<br />

publish reports, and perform<br />

retrospective analysis.<br />

LumaTrend analyzes that data over<br />

time using built-in industry standard analytics<br />

to help provide early detection of<br />

problems and can use the images to create<br />

time-elapsed video (both infrared and<br />

visual) of the equipment monitored. Because<br />

of this technology, this software can<br />

help identify transient thermal events<br />

not detectable with manual inspections.<br />

Since this software uses authenticated<br />

web browser access, users can capture,<br />

access, and analyze data on managed<br />

assets remotely. Users can set up<br />

email notifications for reports, alarms,<br />

and warnings. Real-time notifications<br />

can be sent to experts who then review<br />

the data, suggest additional investigative<br />

action, and schedule conditioned-based<br />

maintenance.<br />

Realizing CBM Using Fully<br />

Automated Data Collection<br />

and Analysis<br />

By replacing periodic, error-prone<br />

manual inspections with a more rigorous<br />

and continuous automated monitoring<br />

system, utilities can gain a more<br />

accurate picture of the actual condition<br />

of ageing assets and high voltage equipment<br />

in their substations and grid. The<br />

end result is a sustainable, effective conditioned-based<br />

maintenance program<br />

for utilities.<br />

While the Thermalspection 724<br />

system is a very accurate and reliable<br />

solution especially for substations and<br />

electrical switchgear monitoring of<br />

bushings, isolators, breakers, capacitor<br />

banks, busbars, and transformers, it is<br />

also used in industrial settings such as<br />

detecting hot spots in fuel storage facilities<br />

or monitoring for degradation of<br />

refractory in high temperature furnaces<br />

and vessels.<br />

Data Automation and<br />

Informing Users<br />

Each TS724DV-PT system also includes<br />

a stainless steel junction box with all of<br />

the necessary hardware for power and<br />

data transfer, including a hardened umbilical<br />

cable to easily connect the camera<br />

to the junction box. The umbilical cable<br />

Figure 5 System Communication / data exchange<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld 47


REMOTE MONITORING<br />

Remote<br />

Monitoring<br />

with<br />

Ultrasound<br />

Airborne and structure-borne ultrasound<br />

has been around for more than 50 years.<br />

In the technology’s early days, the main application<br />

was compressed air leak detection.<br />

Today more maintenance and reliability personnel<br />

have begun to use ultrasound technology<br />

for more than just compressed air leak detection.<br />

8 channel switch box – an<br />

inspector can quickly monitor<br />

up to 8 testing points.<br />

ADRIAN MESSER,<br />

CMRP,<br />

adrianm@uesystems.com<br />

THREE APPLICATIONS in particular have<br />

seen a large increase in usage: condition<br />

monitoring of bearings and rotating<br />

equipment, condition-based lubrication,<br />

and electrical inspection of energized<br />

electrical equipment.<br />

the I-P-F Curve.<br />

Ultrasound plays a critical role in<br />

helping to extend the life of bearings in<br />

the I-P interval by condition lubrication<br />

of bearings. Studies have shown<br />

that the majority of premature bearing<br />

failures can be attributed to lubrication.<br />

Ultrasound can prevent over- and underlubrication,<br />

thus potentially eliminating<br />

a large number of bearing failures.<br />

When a bearing lacks lubrication,<br />

there is an increase in friction. The<br />

higher friction also increases how much<br />

ultrasonic noise the bearing produces,<br />

indicated by a rise in the decibel (dB)<br />

level. While greasing a bearing that<br />

needs lubrication, one should see a<br />

gradual decrease in the dB level. Once<br />

the dB level has fallen back to a normal<br />

or baseline level, greasing can be ceased.<br />

If the bearing already has a sufficient<br />

amount of grease when greasing, then<br />

Why Remote Monitoring with<br />

Ultrasound?<br />

Remote monitoring with vibration<br />

analysis and temperature has been available<br />

for many years. For ultrasound, it’s<br />

a fairly new addition to the technology’s<br />

repertoire of capabilities.<br />

Ultrasound is a proven technology<br />

that can detect certain mechanical and<br />

electrical faults much sooner than other<br />

technologies. By sensing subtle changes<br />

in ultrasonic amplitude, ultrasound is<br />

adept at finding early stage premature<br />

bearing faults. This is demonstrated by<br />

I-P-F Curve showing ultrasound as an early indicator of a potential problem in bearings<br />

and rotating equipment.<br />

48 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


MECHANICAL INSPECTION<br />

the dB level will slowly begin to rise as<br />

more grease is applied. That’s because<br />

over-lubrication also increases friction<br />

in the bearing housing, thus producing a<br />

higher dB level.<br />

In the P-F interval once a failure has<br />

begun, ultrasound is excellent at finding<br />

it. These are bearing failures that can be<br />

detected even before changes in vibration.<br />

If you are monitoring critical assets,<br />

ultrasound and vibration should be<br />

used together in an effort to potentially<br />

detect multiple failure modes that may<br />

be missed when only using one technology<br />

alone.<br />

Remote Monitoring –<br />

Mechanical Inspection<br />

Remote monitoring of bearings and other<br />

rotating equipment with ultrasound<br />

can be done in one of two ways:<br />

The first is to use wired remote access<br />

sensors (RAS), which are mounted<br />

to the assets when it is safe to do so, and<br />

the cables brought out to a safe area<br />

(outside of guarding) where they can be<br />

connected directly to a portable handheld<br />

ultrasound instrument. The cable<br />

lengths for the ultrasound remote access<br />

sensors can be made to lengths of up to<br />

30 meters.<br />

The ultrasound remote access sensors<br />

can also be connected to a junction<br />

box or switch box. As many as eight<br />

ultrasound RAS’s can be connected to<br />

one switch box. Similar to the way vibration<br />

analysis switch boxes work, the<br />

ultrasound sensors are connected to the<br />

switch box, along with the hand-held<br />

ultrasound instrument. During analysis,<br />

the inspector turns the dial to the next<br />

point to collect a reading.<br />

ULTRASOUND PLAYS A CRITICAL ROLE IN HELPING TO<br />

EXTEND THE LIFE OF BEARINGS.<br />

UE Systems RAS – Remote Access<br />

Sensor – can be permanently attached<br />

to a hard-to-reach bearing and<br />

connected to a switch box for easy<br />

inspection.<br />

ULTRAPROBE 15000 IS ®<br />

The perfect solution for a complete inspection in the Oil & Gas industry<br />

For refineries and off-shore platforms<br />

Complete kit for full inspection:<br />

Access to EX zones? No Problem!<br />

With the Ultraprobe 15000 IS you can test anywhere<br />

• Compressed air / Special gases leak detection<br />

(during commissioning and operation phase)<br />

• Pump Inspection<br />

• Valves & Steam Traps<br />

• Bearings condition monitoring<br />

• Electrical Inspection on switchgear and transformers<br />

• Monitor your equipment’s condition<br />

• Improve asset availability<br />

• Reduce energy waste<br />

Two Powerful Inspection Tools in One Package<br />

The Ultraprobe ® 15000 Touch<br />

for advanced in-field diagnostics<br />

The Ultraprobe ® 9000ATEX<br />

to test in hazardous areas!<br />

UE Systems Europe<br />

Windmolen 20, 7609 NN Almelo, The Netherlands<br />

Tel. +31 546 725 125 • info@uesystems.eu • www.uesystems.eu


XXXXXX REMOTE MONITORING<br />

Arcing as seen in the Time Wave Form view.<br />

Ultra Trak 750 is designed for<br />

continuous remote monitoring.<br />

ULTRASOUND CAN PREVENT OVER- AND UNDER-<br />

LUBRICATION, THUS POTENTIALLY ELIMINATE<br />

BEARING FAILURES.<br />

Remote monitoring with ultrasound<br />

can also be done continuously. For continuous<br />

monitoring with ultrasound, UE<br />

Systems offers a sensor called the Ultra-<br />

Trak 750. This is another stud-mounted<br />

sensor, but instead of connecting directly<br />

to a hand-held ultrasound instrument,<br />

this sensor has a 4-20mA output<br />

that allows for easy connection to existing<br />

plant process monitoring systems.<br />

An audio output also allows for sound<br />

recording for further diagnostics or<br />

comparing baseline sound files to alarm<br />

level sound files. Ideal applications for<br />

this sensor could include: high-pressure<br />

safety relief valves, robotic applications,<br />

early warning of failure for a mechanical<br />

asset, flow disruption, and prompting a<br />

lubrication PM.<br />

Remote Monitoring –<br />

Electrical Inspection<br />

Ultrasound can be used to inspect<br />

almost any energized electrical equipment.<br />

This equipment may include metal-clad<br />

switchgear, transformers, substations,<br />

relays, and motor control centre,<br />

along with many others. Ultrasound can<br />

be used to measure equipment voltages<br />

UE Systems UWC – Ultrasonic Waveform<br />

Concentrator increases the detection range<br />

up to 4x.<br />

from the low end (110 volts) to well over<br />

12000 volts (12kV).<br />

Traditionally, inspection of energized<br />

electrical equipment has been<br />

performed using noncontact infrared<br />

cameras. However, in recent years,<br />

ultrasound has been added to these inspections<br />

for various reasons. One of the<br />

main reasons has been for safety: An ultrasound<br />

inspection of electrical equipment<br />

can be done without the need to<br />

open the energized cabinet or enclosure.<br />

The high frequency sound produced by<br />

corona, tracking, and arcing from inside<br />

of the enclosure will exit through any of<br />

the openings. The inspector will hear the<br />

sound via the headset, and know that an<br />

anomaly is present. The sound can then<br />

be recorded to determine if the condition<br />

is corona, tracking, arcing, or some<br />

type of mechanical looseness.<br />

Corona, by nature, does not produce<br />

significant heat that would be detected<br />

by an infrared camera. However, it does<br />

produce high frequency sound that can<br />

be detected by the ultrasound instrument.<br />

If corona discharge continues to<br />

occur, it can lead to a more severe problem<br />

such as tracking or arcing.<br />

When the sound file of corona is<br />

recorded, there are signature characteristics<br />

visible in the FFT and Time Wave<br />

Form (TWF) that will help to diagnose<br />

the condition. For corona, the discharge<br />

points only occur at the highest voltage<br />

point on the sine wave. This means<br />

that the amplitude peaks in the TWF<br />

are somewhat equally spaced as the<br />

discharges are only at the positive peak<br />

of the sine wave. The result will be welldefined<br />

60Hz or 50Hz harmonics.<br />

For tracking and arcing there are also<br />

certain characteristics to look for. With<br />

tracking, the discharge does not have to<br />

take place at the peak of the waveform.<br />

Instead, it can happen anywhere on the<br />

positive portion of the cycle. The spacing<br />

of the peaks in the TWF would be<br />

similar, but not uniform. As tracking<br />

becomes more severe, there are more<br />

discharge events and therefore more<br />

non-uniformly spaced narrow peaks.<br />

Arcing has the most non-uniform<br />

“look” in the FFT and TWF. Only the<br />

bursts of the discharge can be heard and<br />

these will be seen as wide peaks in the<br />

TWF view.<br />

To inspect electrical equipment that<br />

can’t be easily reachable, one can attach<br />

a parabolic disc to an Ultrasound instrument<br />

and increase the detection range<br />

by 4 times, making it possible to detect<br />

electrical failures at a distance of approximately<br />

50 meters.<br />

Remote Monitoring with<br />

Ultrasound – Conclusions<br />

Remote monitoring with ultrasound is a<br />

viable option for maintenance and reliability<br />

programs that are already monitoring<br />

assets traditionally with handheld<br />

devices, and for programs where<br />

ultrasound is currently not a technology<br />

that is being used. Because it is very<br />

complimentary to vibration analysis<br />

for mechanical inspection and infrared<br />

thermography for electrical inspection,<br />

ultrasound will only enhance conditionmonitoring<br />

efforts already in use.<br />

50 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


There are actually three<br />

certainties in life: death,<br />

taxes and the need for<br />

good maintenance.<br />

We can’t help you with the first two.<br />

www.marshallinstitute.com<br />

001 919-834-3722<br />

Marshall<br />

Institute<br />

...making good companies better


XXXXXX INDUSTRIAL INTERNET<br />

From Data<br />

to Decisions and<br />

Improved business<br />

EMIL ACKERMAN,<br />

Quva Oy,<br />

emil.ackerman@quva.fi<br />

In order to succeed, Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT)<br />

solutions need several technological layers. More<br />

importantly, IIoT needs to be closely knit to the actual<br />

business needs. Only then can new technologies<br />

improve company business.<br />

THERE ARE four important technological<br />

layers which constitute the concept of<br />

Industrial Internet of Things: (1) Sensors<br />

that collect data from products and<br />

operations, (2) reliable, real-time data<br />

transmission, (3) data warehouse, which<br />

combines data from multiple sources,<br />

and (4) analytics that refines data into<br />

meaningful information for decision<br />

support. When these layers are working<br />

seamlessly, it is possible to build new<br />

digital services and business models on<br />

top of them, which enhance old ways of<br />

working and take them to the next level.<br />

In the past few decades, technological<br />

advancements related to sensors, data<br />

transmission, warehousing, and analytics<br />

have been profound. Modern products<br />

and services can produce various<br />

kinds of data from themselves and their<br />

surroundings, which through the IIoT<br />

pipeline end up as meaningful information<br />

for the use of decision support in<br />

near real-time.<br />

Due to technological advancements,<br />

the concept of IIoT is more than the sum<br />

of its parts. Meaningful information is<br />

available more reliably, comprehensively,<br />

and systematically than ever before<br />

and at the right time for the actual need.<br />

This is what IIoT is all about.<br />

IIoT in itself does not make company<br />

success. Instead, it enables companies<br />

to increase productivity and create<br />

new business. The new<br />

technology concept<br />

challenges companies<br />

to renew<br />

traditional<br />

ways of working<br />

and doing<br />

business.<br />

However, the<br />

fundamentals<br />

of conducting business do not change.<br />

It is still crucial to work on defining<br />

the essential questions related to pain<br />

points of business and areas of development.<br />

Many areas benefit from real-time<br />

meaningful information and that is why<br />

IIoT can be taken advantage of in a variety<br />

of ways in companies.<br />

Concrete Benefits of IIoT<br />

Companies can improve their operations<br />

through better utilization of their<br />

own data. IIoT can help companies to<br />

utilize data at least in five different<br />

approaches. First, collecting and<br />

combining data from various<br />

sources and refining it into<br />

meaningful information leads<br />

to a better understanding of<br />

the big picture. It is important<br />

to know exactly what is happening<br />

in company operations<br />

IIOT IN ITSELF DOES NOT MAKE<br />

COMPANY SUCCESS.<br />

52 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong>


INDUSTRIAL INTERNET<br />

Electric Automation<br />

Systems and Components<br />

International Exhibition<br />

Nuremberg, Germany, 24 – 26 November 2015<br />

Answers for automation<br />

Visit SPS IPC Drives and experience the unique<br />

working atmosphere at Europe’s leading exhibition<br />

in the field of electric automation:<br />

• a comprehensive market overview<br />

• more than 1,600 exhibitors including all key players<br />

• products and solutions<br />

• innovations and trends<br />

Your free entry ticket<br />

www.sps-exhibition.com/tickets<br />

sps@mesago.com<br />

www.sps-exhibition.com<br />

3/<strong>2016</strong> maintworld XX


INDUSTRIAL INTERNET<br />

and how different factors and phenomena<br />

have an impact on each other. Due<br />

to the constrained nature of human<br />

perception, it is beneficial to use IIoT<br />

related tools such as advanced analytics<br />

to see the big picture.<br />

Second, one of the key characteristics<br />

of IIoT, automating the refinement of<br />

data, brings more speed and accuracy<br />

during e.g. troubleshooting in manufacturing.<br />

Certain routine tasks such as<br />

gathering data from several sources and<br />

testing of hypotheses can be automated.<br />

This way, experts can focus more on<br />

making decisions based on refined data<br />

Case Zellstoff Pöls AG<br />

CONDITION MONITORING THROUGH IIOT<br />

Seppo Silenius, ANDRITZ OY, seppo.silenius@andritz.com<br />

WITH IIOT A COMPANY CAN TAKE A SIGNIFICANT LEAP FROM<br />

REACTIVE OPERATIONS INTO PROACTIVE WAYS OF WORKING.<br />

ANDRITZ Oy’s Wood Processing and Service units deliver wood, wood chips, bark and<br />

biomass processing technologies and services to the pulp and power plant industries. In<br />

the pulp mill’s wood room, chippers cut wood into chips for cooking pulp.<br />

ChipperEKG real-time operation and condition monitoring of chippers ensures high<br />

availability and chip quality and provides key figures for the wood room’s operating<br />

and condition-monitoring personnel, as well as the supplier’s various interest groups.<br />

Advanced analytics while running the chipper makes it possible to find out, for<br />

example, if one of the chipper knives is damaged. The amount of data received from<br />

the sensors is so large that the key figures relating to condition and operation are calculated<br />

immediately when the data is read.<br />

It is important to inform the operator immediately of knife breakage or a badly<br />

mounted knife, so that the chipper can be stopped. Detecting faults in time can prevent<br />

expensive damage.<br />

For the process and equipment supplier, the availability of key figures of the equipment<br />

is essential. Consequently, technical support can make use of real-time data, and<br />

the current operation of the equipment can also be compared with planned operation.<br />

Case LKAB<br />

ENERGY EFFICIENCY THROUGH IIOT<br />

Jukka Kostiainen, ABB Oy, jukka.kostiainen@fi.abb.com<br />

In 2012 EU’s biggest iron ore manufacturer and ABB, a global leader in power and<br />

automation, decided to join forces to improve LKAB’s energy efficiency.<br />

LKAB initiated an ambitious project in 2011 to improve energy efficiency by 20<br />

percent by 2020. ABB’s cpmPlus Energy Monitoring and Targeting energy management<br />

system was commissioned in 2012 and has proven to be a key element in managing<br />

the process.<br />

The system collects and reports data collected from more than 1200 measurements<br />

from three locations and 12 facilities. In addition, data is collected from real estate and<br />

transportation. The system covers the energy measurement and reporting requirements<br />

set by the ISO 50001 standard.<br />

The reporting and analytics functionalities give LKAB in real time, a holistic view of<br />

the actual energy efficiency compared to targets and actual achievable potential. Problem<br />

areas needing attention are quickly detected and prioritized. The effects of corrective<br />

actions are easy to follow and monitor.<br />

54 maintworld 3/<strong>2016</strong><br />

instead of spending time on doing the<br />

actual data refinement.<br />

The third approach in utilizing data is<br />

proactive operations. Real-time collection<br />

and analysis of data enables companies<br />

to better predict and prevent e.g.<br />

quality defects and unplanned production<br />

stoppages. With IIoT a company can<br />

take a significant leap from reactive operations<br />

into proactive ways of working.<br />

Preventative maintenance, especially,<br />

benefits considerably from new information<br />

and multivariable predictions<br />

brought by IIoT.<br />

Fourth, data can also be utilized in<br />

order to better understand customer<br />

behaviour, which can ultimately lead<br />

to increased revenue. When machine<br />

manufacturers know exactly, how their<br />

customers are using their machines,<br />

it is possible to offer e.g. maintenance<br />

services with better quality than what<br />

customers could do by themselves. In<br />

addition to machine hours, many other<br />

factors affect the timing of the next service<br />

break, such as how the machine has<br />

been operated and in what conditions.<br />

More comprehensive information about<br />

machines and their environment leads<br />

to better business opportunities for machine<br />

manufacturers.<br />

Finally, the fifth way to utilize data is<br />

related to organizations’ tacit knowledge<br />

and its transformation from individual<br />

employees’ minds into the knowledge of<br />

the whole organization. In a company,<br />

employees from different backgrounds<br />

and of varying experience work in the<br />

same tasks such as operating a production<br />

line in multiple shifts. Employees might<br />

adjust production, based on their subjective<br />

perception of what should be done.<br />

With the help of IIoT, data from the production<br />

line can be refined into objective<br />

information to support decisions made by<br />

operators and in a way, standardize operations<br />

throughout the organization.<br />

How to get started?<br />

Accurate and meaningful on-time information<br />

is one of the most important<br />

things in enabling successful business.<br />

Industrial Internet of Things is, no more<br />

and no less, a technology concept, which<br />

makes this type of information available<br />

better than ever before. However, valuable<br />

information for someone might be<br />

useless information for others. Therefore,<br />

it is every company’s and their customers’<br />

own needs, challenges, and goals<br />

that need to be at the centre of any IIoT<br />

solutions. Only this way, IIoT can bring<br />

a company valuable information and<br />

hence improve business.


Vibrio, Vibrio Ex<br />

VA3 Pro<br />

VA4 Pro<br />

A3716 On line


R<br />

R<br />

Asset Asset Integrity<br />

Management<br />

Reduced<br />

Reduced<br />

Maintenance<br />

Maintenance<br />

Costs<br />

Costs<br />

Improved<br />

Improved<br />

Production Production<br />

Capacity Capacity<br />

Developing Developing<br />

a Proactive a Proactive<br />

Maintenance<br />

Strategy Strategy<br />

Developing Developing<br />

Effective Effective Work Work<br />

Procedures<br />

Improved Improved<br />

Equipment Equipment<br />

Reliability Reliability<br />

Availability<br />

THE BRIDGE TO BETTER…<br />

Condition Monitoring<br />

LEARN MORE<br />

LEARN MORE<br />

The market’s first<br />

multi-technology,<br />

The market’s<br />

web-enabled<br />

first<br />

multi-technology, web-enabled<br />

data collection device.<br />

data collection device.<br />

AR-C10<br />

AR-C10<br />

is coming soon!<br />

Allied Reliability Allied Reliability Group Group EMEA EMEA NV | NV +32.16.400.136 | | | info_emea@alliedreliability.com | | eu.AlliedReliability.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!