29.12.2016 Views

e_Paper_Thursday_December 30, 2016

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

SECOND EDITION<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong> | Poush 16, 1423, Rabiul Awwal 29, 1438 | Regd No DA 6238, Vol 4, No 242 | www.dhakatribune.com | 32 pages plus 24-page weekend supplement | Price: Tk10<br />

Investigator details suspicions<br />

of inside help in BB heist › 2<br />

Bangladesh batting<br />

collapse hands Kiwis<br />

ODI series win › 24<br />

Bangladeshi short film awarded<br />

in Mumbai › <strong>30</strong><br />

Pass rates exceed 90%<br />

again in JSC and JDC › 3<br />

Suicide vests in<br />

Ashkona: A new<br />

tool for terror › 5<br />

Porn prohibition<br />

proves<br />

problematic › 32<br />

Bangla Academy to<br />

reconsider Shrabon<br />

Prokashani ban › 32


2<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

News<br />

Investigator details suspicions<br />

of inside help in BB heist<br />

LEAD STORY<br />

• Reuters<br />

A top investigator into the cyber<br />

theft of $81m from Bangladesh<br />

Bank is turning his attention to<br />

some IT technicians from the bank<br />

whom he suspects hooked up its<br />

transactions system to the public<br />

Internet, giving hackers access.<br />

In a series of interviews this<br />

month, Mohammad Shah Alam,<br />

CID deputy inspector general who<br />

is heading investigations, went<br />

into some detail about how insiders<br />

at the central bank may have<br />

helped in the execution of one of<br />

the world’s biggest cyber-heists<br />

last February.<br />

For instance, Alam said he was<br />

focusing on why a password token<br />

protecting the SWIFT international<br />

transactions network at Bangladesh<br />

Bank was left inserted in the<br />

SWIFT server for months leading<br />

up to the heist. It is supposed to<br />

be removed and locked in a secure<br />

vault after business hours each day.<br />

The failure to remove the token<br />

allowed hackers to enter the system<br />

when it was not being monitored,<br />

first to infect it with malware<br />

and then to issue fake transfer orders,<br />

he said.<br />

DIG Shah Alam said the investigation<br />

had instead shown that central<br />

bank IT technicians were most<br />

likely to have provided the inside<br />

help. Asked if he had any proof,<br />

Reserve cyber scam shakes up BB management<br />

• Jebun Nesa Alo<br />

The year <strong>2016</strong> was grim for the financial<br />

sector of Bangladesh – despite economic<br />

progress – as the country’s central<br />

bank was sent scrambling to shore up<br />

security in the wake of the largest cyber<br />

attack in its history.<br />

The Bangladesh Bank reserve heist<br />

was a rude awakening for the the country’s<br />

banking sector, with the issue<br />

widely discussed not only nationally but<br />

all over the world.<br />

The scam triggered major transformations<br />

in Bangladesh Bank’s management<br />

team, with a governor resigning<br />

and replaced almost immediately, without<br />

the usual lengthy selection process.<br />

Cyber criminals tried to steal nearly<br />

$1bn from Bangladesh Bank in February<br />

and made off with $81m, via an account<br />

at the New York Federal Reserve.<br />

The money was transferred to four accounts,<br />

opened under false names, at a<br />

Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation<br />

(RCBC) branch in Manila.<br />

he said: “There were a number of<br />

other things, which if the Bangladesh<br />

Bank people had not done,<br />

the hacking would not have been<br />

possible.”<br />

His comments follow months of<br />

assertions by Bangladesh authorities<br />

that central bank officials were<br />

guilty of nothing more than negligence<br />

in the heist, in which hackers<br />

moved money out of the bank’s account<br />

at the Federal Reserve Bank<br />

of New York and sent it to individual<br />

accounts in the Philippines.<br />

The DIG declined to name any of<br />

the suspects. No one has been arrested<br />

and he did not provide any<br />

further evidence to back up his assertions.<br />

Bangladesh Bank spokesman<br />

Subhankar Saha declined to comment<br />

on the investigation. He said<br />

the bank has not been told of any<br />

<strong>2016</strong><br />

YEAR IN REVIEW<br />

RAJIB DHAR<br />

The cyber theft, however, did not<br />

come to light until March this year.<br />

Bangladesh Bank’s then governor Atiur<br />

Rahman was heavily criticised for his<br />

role in covering up the robbery, before<br />

resigning from his post on March 15<br />

over the incident.<br />

Hours after the resignation of Atiur<br />

Rahman, deputy governors Nazneen<br />

Sultana and Abul Kashem were removed<br />

on the same day, as they were<br />

in charge of related departments. Both<br />

the IT and foreign exchange departments<br />

were under the supervision of<br />

Nazneen, while Kashem presided over<br />

the Security Management Department,<br />

among others.<br />

In a stark change from traditional<br />

operating procedure, the government<br />

then appointed Fazle Kabir as the new<br />

governor the same day. A three-member<br />

probe team was formed to investigate<br />

the heist, headed by Mohammed<br />

Farashuddin.<br />

Due to security concerns raised by<br />

the audacious heist in the banking sector,<br />

all banks and financial institutions<br />

were asked to put more effort on the IT<br />

department to prevent a repeat.<br />

Bangladesh Bank renovated its<br />

internal security system after it was<br />

alarmingly revealed that some foreigners<br />

enjoyed gross oversight, often entering<br />

the building under false pretences<br />

without authorisation.<br />

Recovery efforts have paid partial<br />

dividends, with only a portion of the<br />

money stolen by hackers from the<br />

central bank’s Federal Reserve account<br />

having been retrieved.<br />

Philippine’s authorities handed over<br />

$15.25 million in cash to Bangladesh<br />

Bank following an order of the Philippine’s<br />

regional trial court. The rest was<br />

transferred to Philippine’s RCBC, from<br />

where $46 million found its way into<br />

the lightly regulated Philippines casino<br />

plans to detain any of its employees.<br />

No suspects in the Bangladesh<br />

central bank had been arrested,<br />

Alam said, because investigations<br />

were incomplete. They were under<br />

watch and their movements monitored,<br />

but he was awaiting “specific<br />

information” on any communications<br />

they may have had with the<br />

hackers or with those who received<br />

the funds.<br />

Alam said he believed the IT<br />

technicians connected the Bangladesh<br />

central bank’s SWIFT network<br />

to the public internet last year<br />

while linking the network to the<br />

bank’s domestic payments system,<br />

the Real Time Gross Settlement<br />

System (RTGS). SWIFT is used only<br />

for international transactions.<br />

Linking it to the internet made<br />

the highly secure network accessible<br />

from any outside computer.<br />

The work on linking SWIFT<br />

to the RTGS was supervised by<br />

SWIFT contractors but carried out<br />

by Bangladesh Bank technicians,<br />

Alam and a bank official said.<br />

It was not known who was responsible<br />

for leaving the token that<br />

was supposed to protect the SWIFT<br />

system inserted in the server, Alam<br />

added.<br />

At least half-a-dozen bank officials<br />

shared responsibility for safekeeping<br />

of the token, he said.<br />

Once in the system, the hackers<br />

introduced six types of malware<br />

which captured keystrokes and<br />

screenshots and also delayed detection<br />

of fraudulent transactions,<br />

according to a report by Fireye Inc’s<br />

Mandiant forensics division, which<br />

investigated the heist. Parts of the<br />

report were seen by Reuters for the<br />

first time this month.<br />

The malware was customised<br />

for Bangladesh Bank’s systems,<br />

Alam said, adding someone must<br />

have provided the hackers with<br />

technical details about the central<br />

bank’s computer network.<br />

They needed two types of passwords<br />

to carry out the transactions<br />

– the hardware token and additional<br />

credentials used by bank officials.<br />

These password credentials were<br />

either given to them by someone or<br />

were captured from previous transactions<br />

by the malware that logged<br />

keystrokes, Shah Alam said.<br />

A spokeswoman for SWIFT declined<br />

to comment. •<br />

industry and disappeared. The remaining<br />

$21 million has yet to be traced.<br />

Bangladesh Bank had been demanding<br />

that RCBC compensate it for the<br />

loss, blaming it for ignoring red flags.<br />

RCBC, however, has said it did nothing<br />

wrong. The Manila-based RCBC has repeatedly<br />

refused to take liability for the<br />

heist, instead blaming Bangladesh Bank<br />

for its weak security system.<br />

RCBC authorities are also demanding<br />

disclosure of the Bangladesh government’s<br />

investigation report on the<br />

cyber heist.<br />

Despite providing assurances that<br />

he would disclose the report on several<br />

instances, the finance minister is yet to<br />

do so.<br />

The probe committee formed by<br />

Bangladesh government submitted an<br />

interim report to the finance minister<br />

on April 20 and the final report was<br />

handed in on May <strong>30</strong>. The investigation<br />

team had hinted at the involvement<br />

and negligence of bank insiders in its<br />

report. •<br />

Myanmar may<br />

send special<br />

envoy to discuss<br />

Rohingya issue<br />

• Tribune Desk<br />

Myanmar government might send<br />

a special envoy to Bangladesh to<br />

discuss the Rohingya issue.<br />

Myanmar Ambassador to Bangladesh<br />

Myo Myint Than conveyed the<br />

message during a meeting with Kamrul<br />

Ahsan, secretary for bilateral and<br />

consular affairs at the Foreign Affairs<br />

Ministry, yesterday afternoon.<br />

The Myanmar ambassador was<br />

summoned by the ministry to discuss<br />

his government’s ongoing<br />

crackdown on Rohingya minorities.<br />

Quoting Myo Myint, a high official<br />

of the ministry said Myanmar<br />

government was considering to<br />

send an envoy to discuss the issue<br />

that has raised security concern inside<br />

Bangladesh’s border.<br />

“But it is not clear yet when the<br />

envoy will be sent,” the official said.<br />

At the meeting, Kamrul Ahsan<br />

demanded early repatriation of all<br />

Myanmar citizens from Bangladesh,<br />

said a Foreign Ministry press release.<br />

Expressing deep concerns over<br />

the influx of Rohingya Muslims,<br />

Kamrul said around 50,000 Myanmar<br />

citizens had taken shelter in<br />

Bangladesh since October 9 this<br />

year. Moreover, around <strong>30</strong>0,000<br />

Myanmar nationals had been staying<br />

in Bangladesh for years.<br />

According to the release, the secretary<br />

demanded early repatriation<br />

of the entire Myanmar population<br />

staying in Bangladesh and expressed<br />

Bangladesh’s readiness to engage<br />

with Myanmar to discuss the process<br />

and modalities of repatriation.<br />

Requesting the Myanmar government<br />

to urgently address the “root<br />

cause” of the problem in the Rakhine<br />

state so that Rakhine Muslims<br />

are not regularly forced to desperately<br />

seek shelter across the border.<br />

In the meeting, Bangladesh protested<br />

the unprovoked attack and<br />

firing on Bangladeshi fishing boat<br />

named FV Janiva Khaleda 1 in the<br />

Bay of Bengal near the Saint Martin’s<br />

Island – within Bangladesh’s<br />

territorial water – by a Myanmarese<br />

trawler on <strong>December</strong> 27.<br />

Kamrul protested the attack that<br />

left four Bangladeshi fishermen seriously<br />

injured saying: “The Myanmar’s<br />

trawler with armed people on<br />

board took the Bangladeshi fishing<br />

boat along with all the fishermen<br />

including injured ones to a nearby<br />

patrolling Myanmar Navy vessel.<br />

Myanmar navy personnel seized<br />

the belongings of the fishermen and<br />

released them after four hours.”<br />

Bangladesh demanded appropriate<br />

investigation into the matter<br />

to bring the responsible ones to<br />

book, and sought assurance that<br />

the Myanmar’s navy would abstain<br />

from attacking innocent fishermen<br />

of Bangladesh in future. •


Pass rates exceed 90% again in JSC and JDC<br />

• Sadma Malik, Mohammad<br />

Abu Bakar Siddique<br />

Eductaion minister Nurul Islam<br />

Nahid formally announced the<br />

results of JSC and JDC exams and<br />

showcased this year’s statistics at a<br />

press briefing held yesterday.<br />

The briefing was held at the ministry’s<br />

conference room at noon.<br />

Nurul Islam Nahid said that this<br />

year the pass rate increased by<br />

.73% from the previous year, up to<br />

93.06%<br />

In addition, the number of students<br />

who received a GPA 5 also<br />

increased from the previous year,<br />

with 51,325 more recipients in <strong>2016</strong><br />

Of the total 28,741 educational<br />

institutes, all students passed in<br />

9,450.<br />

Furthermore, there was a pass<br />

rate of 0% in 28 institutes, which is<br />

down from 43 in 2015.<br />

19,93,316 students took part in<br />

the JSC exams, with a pass rate of<br />

92.89%, amounting to an increase<br />

of 0.58%. This included 2,35,059<br />

students who achieved GPA 5,<br />

which is 47,557 more than the previous<br />

year.<br />

Of the eight boards, the highest<br />

pass rate was in Rajshahi, at<br />

97.68%.<br />

Under the madrassa board the<br />

pass rate is 94.02% in <strong>2016</strong>, as opposed<br />

to 92.46% in 2015. Of this<br />

years JDC examinees, 12,529 students<br />

received a GPA-5.<br />

Earlier, the minister handed<br />

over the full report to the prime<br />

minister along with Primary and<br />

Mass Education Minister Mustafizur<br />

Rahman Fizar, who handed in<br />

the PSC and ibtedayee results.<br />

PSC and Ibtedayee exams matched<br />

performance in JSC and JDC<br />

Mustafizur Rahman Fizar announced<br />

the results of the PSC and<br />

ibtedayee exams at a conference at<br />

the ministry’s secretariat at 1pm.<br />

Mustafizur Rahman Fizar said<br />

that this year a total number of<br />

28,<strong>30</strong>,734 students took part in the<br />

primary exams, of whom 12,90,295<br />

were boys, and 15,40,439 were girls.<br />

27,88,432 have passed th exams,<br />

with the pass rate at 98.51%.<br />

2,81,898 students have achieved a<br />

GPA5.<br />

Of the students, the pass rate of<br />

girls, 98.56%, was higher than that<br />

of boys, 98.44%.<br />

Among the education boards,<br />

the highest pass rate was in Barisal,<br />

News 3<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Students of Viqarunnisa Noon School and College in Dhaka celebrate after announcement of the Junior School Certificate<br />

(JSC) examinations results yesterday<br />

MAHMUD HOSSAIN OPU<br />

2500000<br />

2000000<br />

1500000<br />

1000000<br />

500000<br />

0<br />

106,0796<br />

Students appeared (2015) Students appeared (<strong>2016</strong>) Students passed (2015) Students passed (<strong>2016</strong>)<br />

92.33%92.24%<br />

92.42%<br />

Pass 2015<br />

121,1493<br />

2,272,289<br />

93.06%92.92%<br />

93.17%<br />

Pass <strong>2016</strong><br />

1,096,522<br />

1,250,437<br />

196,263<br />

2,346,959<br />

GPA 5 (2015)<br />

978,449<br />

84,960<br />

1,119,633<br />

1,11,<strong>30</strong>3<br />

at 99.09%.<br />

all students passed in 17 upazilas<br />

out of 508.<br />

In the ibtedayee exams, 2,57,500<br />

students sat the exams, of whom<br />

1,<strong>30</strong>,873 were boys, and 1,26,627<br />

were girls. The pass rate was at<br />

Male Female Total<br />

2,098,082<br />

247,588<br />

GPA 5 <strong>2016</strong><br />

1,018,919<br />

1,165,056<br />

1,06,345<br />

2,183,975<br />

1,41,243<br />

ASMAUL HOQUE MAMUN/DT INFOGRAPHIC<br />

95.85% with 5,948 that achieved<br />

GPA-5.<br />

209 students sat for the ibtedayee<br />

exams under special arrangement<br />

and 94.74% have passed.<br />

All ibtedayee students passed in<br />

105 upazilas across the country. •<br />

DT<br />

JSC, JDC<br />

results up from<br />

previous year<br />

• Shadma Malik<br />

Junior School Certificate (JSC) and<br />

Junior Dakhil Certificate (JDC) exams<br />

witnessed a slight rise in pass<br />

rate and number of GPA-5 (highest<br />

grade-point average) holders.<br />

This year, the pass rate stands at<br />

93.06% beating the previous year’s<br />

record by 0.73% which was 92.33%.<br />

The number of GPA-5 holders in<br />

JSC and JDC is 2,47,588, which last<br />

year was 1,96,263. Around 51,325<br />

more students achieved GPA-5 this<br />

year.<br />

A total of 23,46,959 students appeared<br />

in the JSC and JDC this year<br />

while 22,72,289 appeared in the<br />

previous year, increasing the number<br />

of students 74,670 more.<br />

9,450 schools achieved hundred<br />

percent pass rate which was<br />

8,583 in last year, and number<br />

of educational institutions with<br />

0% pass rate is 28, which was 43<br />

last year.<br />

The pass rate this year in PSC<br />

examinations slightly increased to<br />

98.52%, from last year’s 98.51%.•<br />

28 schools see<br />

zero percent<br />

pass rate<br />

• Tribune Desk<br />

Twenty-eight schools saw zero<br />

pass rates in this year’s JSC and JDC<br />

examinations, while the number<br />

was 43 last year.<br />

Of those, six institutions are<br />

from Dinajpur, one from Dhaka and<br />

one from Rajshahi boards while<br />

another 20 are under the Madrasa<br />

Education Board, according to the<br />

results published yesterday.<br />

A total of eight educational institutions<br />

under three general education<br />

boards saw a zero percent<br />

pass rate, while the number was 23<br />

last year. •<br />

96% children with special needs pass PSC<br />

• Shadma Malik<br />

Throughout the country, 4,547<br />

children with special needs took<br />

part in the Primary School Certificate<br />

(PSC) exams this year, of<br />

which 96.14% have passed.<br />

Of the total number of special<br />

needs students, 2,457 are male and<br />

2,090 are female. In addition, 194<br />

of the students achieved GPA 5, including<br />

98 males and 96 females.<br />

Of the students, 1,427 sat the<br />

exam in Dhaka, and 1,371 successfully<br />

navigated the exams – a pass<br />

rate of 95.84%. This included 79<br />

out of the 194 GPA 5 scorers.<br />

A total of 533 students passed<br />

out of 557 in Rajshahi, amounting<br />

to 95.51%, with 19 students<br />

achieving GPA 5.<br />

In Khulna, 575 appeared for the<br />

exams and 559 succeeded, a pass<br />

rate of 97.15%. The total number<br />

of GPA 5 scorers among them is 29.<br />

In Chittagong, 784 children<br />

took part, with 750 succeeding<br />

and 29 GPA 5 achievers . The pass<br />

rate is 95.47 percent.<br />

In Barisal, 175 students passed<br />

out of 178 and 12 students achieved<br />

GPA 5. The pass rate is 98.19%.<br />

In Sylhet, 562 succeeded among<br />

577 students, with the pass rate being<br />

97.27%. Eight students scored<br />

GPA 5. Finally, 449 appeared for<br />

the exams in Rangpur, with 4<strong>30</strong><br />

passing – a rate of 95.49%. Eighteen<br />

students achieved GPA 5. •<br />

Girls top boys in JSC and JDC<br />

• Shadma Malik<br />

The success rate of female students<br />

is higher in Junior School<br />

Certificate (JSC) and Junior Dakhil<br />

Certificate (JDC) examinations.<br />

Among the examinees, 92.92 percents<br />

of male students passed.<br />

However, the success rate of the<br />

female students is 93.17 percents.<br />

Among 10,96,522 male students,<br />

10,18,919 passed under<br />

eight general education boards<br />

and one madrasa board. A total<br />

of 12,50,437 female students<br />

appeared in both JSC and JDC<br />

among which 11,65,056 passed.<br />

Beside, the ratio of GPA-5<br />

achievers in Dhaka, Rajshahi,<br />

Jessore, Barisal, Dinajpur and<br />

Madrasa board is higher. In <strong>2016</strong>,<br />

1,06,345 male students scored<br />

GPA-5 when 1,41,243 female students<br />

scored the same. •


4<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

News<br />

Eviction drive at Tejgaon, AL office demolished<br />

• Abu Hayat Mahmud<br />

Dhaka North City Corporation yesterday<br />

demolished over 150 illegal<br />

makeshift establishments, including<br />

a semi-concrete Awami League<br />

office, built on the footpaths of Tejgaon<br />

industrial area.<br />

A mobile court led by DNCC executive<br />

magistrates Sajid Anwar and<br />

MM Mohiuddin Kabir Mahin carried<br />

out the drive. The eviction started<br />

from near the BTCL Telecentre in<br />

the area in the morning.<br />

During the first phase of the<br />

drive, Baitul Falah Jame Masjid, a<br />

local mosque built in collaboration<br />

with the Islamic Foundation Bangladesh,<br />

and a party office of the<br />

ruling Awami League had been left<br />

untouched.<br />

Challenged by journalists for<br />

the action, the DNCC officials then<br />

contacted the councillor of Ward<br />

24 and later ordered to demolish<br />

the party office. They also said Islamic<br />

Foundation had asked for<br />

time to shift the mosque.<br />

An elderly homeless woman<br />

begged time from the DNCC officials<br />

when they told her to shift her belongings<br />

within two days. Although the<br />

DNCC claimed to have demolished<br />

500 illegal establishments, locals said<br />

the number was not more than 100. •<br />

Dhaka North City Corporation (DNCC) conducts an illegal structure eviction drive in Dhaka's Tejgaon Industrial area yesterday<br />

Customs documents<br />

found in factory in Ctg<br />

• Tribune Desk<br />

Customs Intelligence has<br />

recovered confidential<br />

government records during<br />

a raid in a garments<br />

factory in Chittagong.<br />

Sixty-five secret important<br />

files of Customs House<br />

were found in the offices of<br />

Al-Amin Maritime International<br />

Apparels Fashions in<br />

the port city on Wednesday<br />

night, UNB reported.<br />

Moinul Khan, director<br />

general of Customs Intelligence<br />

Investigation department,<br />

told UNB that<br />

a team of Customs Intelligence<br />

conducted a drive<br />

in the garment factory in<br />

Noyabazar area based on<br />

intelligence information.<br />

They recovered 11 bank<br />

guarantee files, 48 under<br />

trial files and 12 revenue<br />

and other files from the<br />

office room of the factory,<br />

added the DG.<br />

Following this, the National<br />

Board of Revenue<br />

(NBR) yesterday formed<br />

a three-member committee<br />

to inquire into management<br />

of government<br />

records and documents<br />

kept at different customs<br />

stations.<br />

The committee is headed<br />

by DG Moinul Khan. The<br />

other members are NBR<br />

First Secretary (customs<br />

policy) M Fakhrul Alam<br />

and Central Intelligence<br />

Cell Joint Director Abu<br />

Obayda.<br />

“Such incidents are<br />

very dangerous for the security<br />

of customs stations<br />

and for the management<br />

of the records,” NBR said in<br />

a letter sent to all customs<br />

offices.<br />

The committee was<br />

formed to find out whether<br />

similar incidents were happening<br />

in other customs<br />

stations.<br />

The committee will<br />

examine records management<br />

in all customs stations,<br />

find out whether any<br />

records have been stolen or<br />

gone missing. It was asked<br />

to submit a probe report<br />

within <strong>30</strong> days.<br />

The commissioners and<br />

director generals of NBR<br />

would be held responsible<br />

if any record is missing or<br />

stolen resulting in revenue<br />

losses, the letter said. •<br />

MEHEDI HASAN<br />

IOJ and BNF<br />

met president<br />

• Manik Miazee<br />

A 10-member team of Islami Oikya<br />

Jote, led by Abdul Latif Nezami,<br />

chairman of IOJ, met the President<br />

Abdul Hamid at Bangabhaban on<br />

<strong>Thursday</strong>.<br />

During the <strong>30</strong>-minute long meeting,<br />

IOJ requested the president to<br />

form the Election Commission with<br />

eight members instead of existing<br />

five members. A search committee<br />

made of qualified and neutral individuals<br />

was also proposed to the<br />

president in the meeting.<br />

IOJ delegates said people want<br />

to see a reliable and credible EC. A<br />

political problem should be solved<br />

politically, said the leaders of Islami<br />

Oikya Jote.<br />

Earlier, a team of Bangladesh<br />

Nationalist Forum led by Abul Kalam<br />

Azad, president of BNF met the<br />

president.<br />

The team placed a five-point proposal.<br />

Abul proposed to involve a<br />

retired Inspector General of Police<br />

(IGP) in the Election Commission.<br />

“BNF always expects neutral and<br />

strong EC for fair polls,” he said.<br />

President Abdul Hamid took the<br />

initiative to meet the registered<br />

political parties of the country as a<br />

part of the new Election Commission<br />

formation process. The existing<br />

commission would expire in<br />

February. •


News 5<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

Suicide vests in<br />

Ashkona: A new<br />

tool for terror<br />

• Kamrul Hasan<br />

The SWAT team who<br />

she had approached<br />

would have been<br />

harmed substantially<br />

had she not fallen on<br />

her face during the<br />

explosion<br />

Investigators have said that the<br />

grenades they found from the raid<br />

in a terrorist den in city’s Ashkona<br />

area earlier this week were all<br />

handmade, as were the suicide<br />

vests.<br />

Militants at this New JMB den<br />

were using the same sort of materials<br />

and techniques used by JMB for<br />

making the bombs, but they were<br />

connecting several bombs together<br />

in suicide vests to make them<br />

deadlier.<br />

Dhaka Metropolitan Police’s<br />

(DMP) Counter Terrorism and<br />

Transnational (CTTC) Unit recovered<br />

and defused 19 grenades from<br />

that den, 10 of them tied inside two<br />

suicide vests and two unexploded<br />

grenades from the body of the female<br />

militant Shakira.<br />

A CTTC bomb disposal unit official<br />

told the Dhaka Tribune that the<br />

grenades recovered from the den<br />

were similar to the ones found in<br />

Mirpur last year. The bombs were<br />

made using old JMB techniques using<br />

local materials.<br />

However, unlike the old group,<br />

New JMB bomb makers put the<br />

grenades in vests.<br />

The three vests found in<br />

Ashkona, one on the body of<br />

Shakira, who blew herself up<br />

during the police raid, were crudely<br />

sewn by hand.<br />

On the other hand, the two<br />

found in Mirpur last year were<br />

manufactured belts with shoulder<br />

straps, the official said.<br />

The official said militants were<br />

using four to six individual bombs<br />

to make a single vest.<br />

The grenades manufactured<br />

by JMB usually contained pins to<br />

release the pressure, but the grenades<br />

on the Ashokona vests were<br />

connected through wires so that<br />

the bombs could be exploded at the<br />

same time.<br />

To generate required power<br />

within the vest, the militants had<br />

increased the number of batteries<br />

in the grenades.<br />

The grenades were powerful<br />

enough to seriously injure anyone<br />

standing within a 10 metre radius<br />

of the explosion, the official said,<br />

adding that the splintered could<br />

easily cause death if they hit the<br />

upper body.<br />

Another CTTC official present<br />

during the operation said the<br />

female suicide bomber Shakira<br />

had worn a vest that contained<br />

four grenades and two of them<br />

exploded.<br />

The SWAT team who she had approached<br />

would have been harmed<br />

substantially had she not fallen on<br />

her face during the explosion, the<br />

official said.<br />

The official said from the investigation<br />

it appeared that Tanvir<br />

Qadri’s son Afif Qadri and Shakira,<br />

who both died in the raid, were<br />

prepared for suicide attacks.<br />

A police bomb disposal expert<br />

told the Dhaka Tribune that the<br />

strength of the vests were four to<br />

six times more then individual grenades.<br />

They would be deadliest if<br />

exploded in open places.<br />

Meanwhile, after completion of<br />

the first day of seven day remand,<br />

CTTC has gotten very little information<br />

from the two arrested female<br />

militants.<br />

CTTC chief Monirul Islam said<br />

among the two, Moinul Islam alias<br />

Musa’s wife Trisha Moni appeared<br />

to be repenting for her involvement<br />

with militancy and was willing to<br />

talk, but Major Zahidul Islam’s wife<br />

Jebunnahar Islam alias Shila still<br />

seemed to be ambivalent whether<br />

to cooperate with the law or not. •<br />

Stalls are being set up for International Trade Fair 2017. The photo was taken yesterday from the mela premises in Dhaka’s<br />

Sher-E-Bangla Nagar area<br />

MEHEDI HASAN<br />

Nobel laureates and global leaders<br />

urge UN action on Rohingya issue<br />

• Tribune Desk<br />

Twenty-three global figures, including<br />

13 Nobel laureates, politicians and<br />

business leaders, have urged the UN<br />

Security Council to end the Rohingya<br />

crisis in Myanmar.<br />

In an open letter to the council<br />

president and the member states, the<br />

signatories described the situation in<br />

Rakhine state of Myanmar as a human<br />

tragedy amounting to ethnic cleansing<br />

and crimes against humanity.<br />

Among the Nobel laureates are<br />

SIGNATORIES<br />

Professor Muhammad Yunus<br />

2006 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Máiread Maguire<br />

1976 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Archbishop Desmond Tutu<br />

1984 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Jody Williams<br />

1997 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Tawakkol Karman<br />

2011 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Malala Yousafzai<br />

2014 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Elizabeth Blackburn<br />

2009 Nobel Laureate in Medicine<br />

Arianna Huffington<br />

Founder and Editor, Huffington Post<br />

Paul Polman<br />

Business Leader<br />

Richard Curtis<br />

SDG Advocate, Film Director<br />

Jochen Zeitz<br />

Business Leader and Philanthropist<br />

Romano Prodi<br />

Former Italian Prime Minister<br />

Nobel peace laureates Prof Muhammad<br />

Yunus, Malala Yousafzai, Archbishop<br />

Desmond Tutu and Shirin Ebadi.<br />

Hundreds of Rohingya Muslims have<br />

been trying to illegally enter Bangladesh<br />

after Myanmar troops launched a crackdown<br />

in the Rakhine state in response<br />

to attacks on three border posts on October<br />

9 that killed nine police officers.<br />

Bangladesh has stepped up security<br />

along its border with Myanmar to prevent<br />

influx of Rohingyas fleeing the violence<br />

in Rakhine which has killed at least 86<br />

people and displaced <strong>30</strong>,000 others.<br />

José Ramos-Horta<br />

1996 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Betty Williams<br />

1976 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Oscar Arias<br />

1987 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Shirin Ebadi<br />

2003 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Leymah Gbowee<br />

2011 Nobel Peace Laureate<br />

Sir Richard J. Roberts<br />

1993 Nobel Laureate in Medicine<br />

Emma Bonino<br />

Former Italian Foreign minister<br />

Sir Richard Branson<br />

Business Leader and Philanthropist<br />

Mo Ibrahim<br />

Entrepreneur and Philanthropist<br />

Alaa Murabit<br />

Voice of Libyan Women<br />

Kerry Kennedy<br />

Human Rights Activist<br />

The letter quoted Amnesty International<br />

interviews with Rohingya refugees<br />

who described the scenes of horror that<br />

had taken place in their villages.<br />

It said that even if Myanmar<br />

authority’s suspicion that the October<br />

9 attacks were carried out by Rohingya<br />

groups were true, the military’s response<br />

was grossly disproportionate.<br />

“It would be one thing to round up<br />

suspects, interrogate them and put them<br />

on trial. It is quite another to unleash<br />

helicopter gunships on thousands of<br />

ordinary civilians and to rape women and<br />

throw babies into a fire,” the letter said.<br />

It berated Myanmar’s democratic<br />

leader Aung San Suu Kyi, also a Nobel<br />

Peace Laureate, for her inaction in this<br />

matter.<br />

“Despite repeated appeals to Daw<br />

Aung San Suu Kyi we are frustrated<br />

that she has not taken any initiative to<br />

ensure full and equal citizenship rights<br />

of the Rohingyas. Daw Suu Kyi is the<br />

leader and is the one with the primary<br />

responsibility to lead, and lead with<br />

courage, humanity and compassion,”<br />

the letter said.<br />

“Access for journalists and human<br />

rights monitors should also be permitted,<br />

and an independent, international<br />

inquiry to establish the truth about the<br />

current situation should be established,”<br />

they said.<br />

They urged the UN Security Council<br />

to put the Rohingya crisis on its agenda<br />

as a matter of urgency, and to call upon<br />

the UN secretary general to visit Myanmar<br />

in the coming weeks as a priority.<br />

They also called on the international<br />

community to speak out much more<br />

strongly on this crisis. •<br />

TEMPERATURE FORECAST FOR TODAY<br />

Dhaka 28 15 Chittagong 27 19 Rajshahi 26 15 Rangpur 26 14 Khulna 27 14 Barisal 28 15 Sylhet 28 14<br />

Cox’s Bazar 28 19<br />

MODERATE FOG<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong><br />

DHAKA<br />

TODAY<br />

TOMORROW<br />

SUN SETS 5:21PM<br />

SUN RISES 6:40AM<br />

YESTERDAY’S HIGH AND LOW<br />

29.2ºC 10ºC<br />

Teknaf<br />

Tetulia<br />

Source: Accuweather/BMD<br />

PRAYER<br />

TIMES<br />

Fajr: 6:05am | Jumma: 1:15pm<br />

Asr: 4:15pm | Magrib: 5:<strong>30</strong>pm<br />

Esha: 7:<strong>30</strong>pm<br />

Source: Islamic Foundation


6<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

News<br />

Basiron tops school in PSC results<br />

• Tribune Desk<br />

Wearing a white saree sixty five-yearold<br />

Basiron came to her school yesterday<br />

morning to know about her<br />

PSC results with great anxiety.<br />

Accompanied by hundreds of<br />

people, including teachers and students,<br />

she came to her school around<br />

11am to know her results. She became<br />

very happy after knowing her<br />

results, as she topped her school in<br />

the Primary School Certificate examination<br />

results with GPA 3 grade.<br />

She said: “I did not realise that<br />

pass has so much fun. I am understanding<br />

the light of education.”<br />

She later posed with other candidates<br />

and also showed V-sign<br />

while taking photographs.<br />

She also expressed her determination<br />

that she would continue her<br />

education till her death.<br />

Six candidates took part in the<br />

PSC examination from Hogolbaria<br />

Purbopara Primary School this year.<br />

The name of Basiron Nesa, wife of<br />

Rohil Uddin, a resident of Hoglabaria<br />

came to the spotlight when she sat for<br />

the PSC examinations in November.<br />

Selina Khatun MP was also present<br />

during the announcement of<br />

the results. She said: “It is proved<br />

again that if there is a will, there<br />

is a way. She has put a lesson for<br />

us that age does not be a factor to<br />

achieve anything. I am wishing her<br />

all the best.”<br />

Upazila Nirbahi Officer of Gangni<br />

Arifuz Zaman and Chairman of<br />

Motmura union parishad also came<br />

to her school to greet her.<br />

The villagers said they saw the<br />

sexagenarian woman went to Hogolbaria<br />

Purbo Para Government<br />

Primary School in the village with<br />

books accompanied by two other<br />

fifth grade girls.<br />

Basiron is the mother of one son<br />

and two daughters. She stays with<br />

her son Mahiruddin. Her grandchildren<br />

are studying at colleges<br />

and schools. She fell in love with<br />

studying when she saw her grandchildren<br />

studied. She was admitted<br />

to the school in 2011. •<br />

Basiron Nesa is seen celebrating her Victory after the announcement of her PSC results<br />

27,089 secure A + in Dinajpur<br />

• Bipul Sarker Sunny,<br />

Dinajpur<br />

Total 2,01,525 out of 2,21,243<br />

examinees, from 141 educational<br />

institutes have successfully<br />

passed the Junior School<br />

Certificate (JSC) examinations<br />

this year under Dinajpur<br />

Education Board.<br />

A total of 27,089 students<br />

secured GPA-5, the highest<br />

grade point average. The<br />

pass rate of JSC examinations<br />

in Dinajpur board is<br />

92.99 %.<br />

Tofazzur Rahman, exam<br />

controller of Dinajpur Education<br />

Board, yesterday<br />

said: “The GPA 5 holder rate<br />

of female students is higher<br />

than for boys. Total 14, 554<br />

female students secured GPA<br />

5 where 12,535 boys got the<br />

highest point.”<br />

He said: “Female students’<br />

pass rate is 93.41 while males’<br />

pass rate is 92.54 %.”<br />

Earlier, 26 examinees were<br />

expelled from exam halls for<br />

cheating.<br />

Students of Rangpur district<br />

have done the best in the<br />

board. In the district, the pass<br />

rate is 96.42 %. Among others<br />

the pass rate for Gaibandha is<br />

DHAKA TRIBUNE<br />

95.60 %, Thakurgaon 93.79 %,<br />

Kurigram 93.31 %, Panchagarh<br />

93.09 %, Nilphamari 92.66 %,<br />

Lalmonirhat 91.25 % and Dinajpur<br />

is 88.46 %.<br />

Some 7,550 students secured<br />

GPA 5 in Rangpur district,<br />

where 4,539 students in<br />

Dinajpur, 4,196 in Gaibandha,<br />

, 2,849 in Nilphamari, 2,649<br />

in Kurigram, 2,176 in Thakurgaon,<br />

1,455 in Panchagarh,<br />

and 1,675 students in<br />

Lalmonirhat district have secured<br />

GPA 5.<br />

Last year, 16 intuitions had<br />

seen zero percent pass rate in<br />

the board. •<br />

Man burnt to death by in-laws<br />

• Liakat Ali Badal,<br />

Rangpur<br />

A man succumbed to his burn<br />

injuries at Rangpur Medical<br />

College Hospital yesterday<br />

after his wife and mother-inlaw<br />

allegedly set him on fire<br />

following a dispute regarding<br />

the wife’s extra marital<br />

affairs.<br />

Deceased Rony Mohanto,<br />

son of Lakhhan Chandra in<br />

Shahapara area of Badarganj<br />

upazila, tied knot to Ashtami<br />

Rani, daughter of Dipak Mohanto<br />

at adjacent Hajipara<br />

village, one year ago, said locals<br />

and relatives of Rony.<br />

After several months,<br />

Ashtami developed a relation<br />

with her former private<br />

tutor and most of the time,<br />

remained engaged in conversation<br />

with him through<br />

Facebook Messenger.<br />

Rony and Ashtami locked<br />

into an altercation over the<br />

issue very often.<br />

Few days ago, Ashtami<br />

went to her parents’ house<br />

following a dispute with her<br />

husband.<br />

On Wednesday night, Rony<br />

went to his in-laws house,<br />

as his wife called him over<br />

phone in the evening to take<br />

her back.<br />

When he reached there, an<br />

altercation ensued between<br />

Rony and his in-laws family<br />

members, including his wife<br />

and mother-in-law Arati Rani.<br />

At one stage of the quarrel,<br />

Ashtami and her family members<br />

tied Rony’s hands and<br />

legs and set him on fire after<br />

pouring petrol on his body,<br />

alleged the family members<br />

of Rony.<br />

Locals rushed him to the<br />

hospital in critical condition.<br />

Dr Abdul Hamid Polash,<br />

assistant professor of RMCH,<br />

said though 27% of his body<br />

received burn injuries, he<br />

died as his respiratory tract<br />

was burned.<br />

Babul Chandra, elder<br />

brother of the deceased, said<br />

he submitted a written complaint<br />

to Badarganj police station<br />

in this connection.<br />

However, Akhtaruzzaman<br />

Prodhan, officer-in-charge<br />

of the police station, told the<br />

Dhaka Tribune that he had<br />

not received any written complaint<br />

yet. •


News 7<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Pass rate and GPA 5 rise in Chittagong<br />

• FM Mizanur Rahaman,<br />

Chittagong<br />

DT<br />

Breaking last five years’ record,<br />

eighth graders under Chittagong<br />

Board have done excellent job in<br />

Junior School Certificate (JSC) examination<br />

with increased pass rate<br />

and GPA 5.<br />

This year, a total of 90.75% students<br />

passed under the Chittagong<br />

Education Board while a total of<br />

14,135 students secured GPA 5.<br />

The previous year’s pass rate was<br />

85.48% while the GPA 5 holders<br />

were 12,268, said sources at the education<br />

board.<br />

A total number of 181,654 students<br />

had registered for the JSC examination<br />

this year while 179,095<br />

students took part in the examination.<br />

Of them, 162,524 students<br />

successfully came out in the examination.<br />

Examination Controller of Chittagong<br />

Education Board Mahbub<br />

Alam officially announced the results<br />

at board office around 10am.<br />

Expressing happiness, he said<br />

both the pass rate and GPA 5 holders<br />

increased this year, breaking<br />

previous five years’ record from<br />

2013 to <strong>2016</strong> under the board.<br />

“The overall results under the<br />

board have improved and we are<br />

satisfied with the results,” he said,<br />

adding that this year, a total 14,135<br />

eighth graders secured their GPA 5<br />

which are higher than the previous<br />

years.<br />

The pass rate at the metropolitan<br />

area is 94.18% while the pass rate<br />

except the metropolitan are under<br />

Chittagong district is 88.92%, said<br />

the examination controller.<br />

Of the 14,135 GPA 5 holders,<br />

7,820 are female while 6,315 are<br />

Girls secure more GPA 5 in<br />

JSC examinations under<br />

Rajshahi Board<br />

• Abdullah Al Dulal, Rajshahi<br />

(Top) Students at Dr Khastagir<br />

Government Girls’ School in Chittagong<br />

city, who have achieved GPA-5 this<br />

year in Junior School Certificate<br />

examinations, rejoice after their<br />

result published yesterday. (Bottom)<br />

Students at Govt PN Girls’ High School<br />

in Rajshahi city rejoice after their<br />

result of Junior School Certificate<br />

examinations declared yesterday<br />

Girls have earned higher grades<br />

than boys in Junior Certificate (JSC)<br />

examinations under Rajshahi Education<br />

Board this year.<br />

The board authority announced<br />

the results at a press conference at<br />

its conference hall yesterday noon<br />

with Acting Chairman Dr Anwarul<br />

Haque Pramanik in the chair.<br />

A total of 97.68% students passed<br />

the examinations under the board<br />

this year which was 97.47% last year.<br />

A total of 2,26,892 students appeared<br />

in the examinations. Of<br />

them 2,21,617 students came out<br />

successful. 40,471 students including<br />

21,876 girls secured GPA-5 this<br />

year under the board.<br />

According to the result sheet,<br />

the rate of success of girls in all aspects<br />

that is pass-percentage and<br />

GPA 5 rate is higher than boys.<br />

Controller of Examinations Prof<br />

Tarun Kumar Sarker told the pres<br />

conference that 2,26,892 students<br />

including 1,15,086 girls appeared<br />

in the examinations at 211 centers<br />

from 2,891 schools in eight districts<br />

under the board this year.<br />

Dr Anwarul Pramanik, secretary<br />

of Rajshahi Education Board,<br />

Inspector Debeshish Ranjan Roy,<br />

Senior System Analysist Engineer<br />

Shafiqul Islam among others were<br />

present on the occasion.<br />

Rajshahi division also achieved<br />

top position among the seven divisions<br />

in terms of pass rate as 99 per<br />

cent examinees under the division<br />

have become successful in the Primary<br />

School Certificate (PSC) examinations<br />

this year. •<br />

male. Of the overall pass rate, boys<br />

lagged behind the girls with 91.14%<br />

pass rate.<br />

A total number of 192 schools<br />

passed 100% at the JSC examination<br />

in this year, said the board<br />

sources.<br />

97.52% pass in PSC at Ctg board<br />

Meanwhile, this year the pass<br />

rate of fifth grader terminal<br />

examination is 91.52% where a<br />

152,783 students successfully came<br />

out. A total of 156,676 students<br />

took part in this year under PSC<br />

examination.<br />

Apart from that, in Ebtedayee<br />

terminal examination, the pass<br />

rate in Chittagong is 90.86%, said<br />

Chittagong District Primary Education<br />

office. •<br />

GPA 5 achievers in JSC exams<br />

increase under Sylhet Board<br />

• Md Serajul Islam, Sylhet<br />

Number of GPA-5 achievers in Junior<br />

School Certificate (JSC) examinations<br />

under Sylhet Education<br />

Board has increased compared to<br />

last year’s result.<br />

The number of GPA-5 achievers<br />

this year is 10,255 in four districts<br />

under the board. Of them 4,457<br />

are boys and 5,798 are girls.<br />

Last year a total of 4,956 students<br />

got GPA-5.<br />

A total of 1<strong>30</strong>,703 students sat<br />

for the exams. Of them, 122,034<br />

passed. The pass rate is 93.37 percent.<br />

Of the districts, the pass rate is<br />

94.81 percent for Sylhet, 92.75 for<br />

Habiganj, 91.21 for Moulvibazar<br />

and 93.08 for Sunamganj district.<br />

Though the pass rate is 0.22 percent<br />

less than last year, number of<br />

AZAHAR UDDIN<br />

GPA-5 is two times higher this year. Of<br />

1,004 schools, 100 percent students<br />

passed at 288 schools. No students<br />

fails in any school. Md Shamshul Islam,<br />

controller of Sylhet Education<br />

Board declared the result in a press<br />

briefing yesterday morning.<br />

The result of Primary School<br />

RABIN CHOWDHURY<br />

Certificate (PSC) was published in<br />

Sylhet yesterday showing 96.79<br />

percent pass in Sylhet division.<br />

A total of 217,545 out of 237, 270<br />

came out successful in the PSC examinations<br />

in Sylhet division this<br />

year. Among the pass 7941 students<br />

got GPA-5. •


DT<br />

8<br />

World<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

SOUTH ASIA<br />

China to hold first military<br />

drills with Nepal<br />

China will hold its first military<br />

drills with Nepal next year, China’s<br />

Defence Ministry said on <strong>Thursday</strong>,<br />

in a move that could unnerve<br />

neighbouring India. China is<br />

vying to increase its influence in<br />

landlocked Nepal, which serves<br />

as a natural buffer between China<br />

and India, challenging India’s<br />

long-held position as the dominant<br />

outside power. REUTERS<br />

INDIA<br />

AIADMK picks new chief<br />

after death of Jayalalithaa<br />

The party of Jayalalithaa Jayaram,<br />

All India Anna Dravida Munnetra<br />

Kazhagam (AIADMK), picked<br />

one of the former leader’s closest<br />

aides to succeed her on <strong>Thursday</strong>,<br />

ending weeks of speculation. On<br />

<strong>Thursday</strong>, the AIADMK announced<br />

on Twitter that it had elected<br />

her close friend, VK Sasikala, a<br />

59-year-old former video cassette<br />

seller, as its new chief. AFP<br />

CHINA<br />

China warns US against<br />

stopover for Taiwan’s Tsai<br />

Taiwan President Tsai Ing-wen<br />

will pass through the United States<br />

when she visits Latin America next<br />

month, the Taiwan Foreign Ministry<br />

said on <strong>Thursday</strong>, angering<br />

China which urged the US to block<br />

any such stopover. China is deeply<br />

suspicious of Tsai, who it thinks<br />

wants to push for the formal independence<br />

of Taiwan. REUTERS<br />

ASIA PACIFIC<br />

7 killed in drug-related<br />

feud in Philippines<br />

Philippine police say gunmen have<br />

shot dead seven people including<br />

three teens and a pregnant<br />

woman in what they suspect is a<br />

feud involving illegal drugs. Chief<br />

Superintendent Roberto Fajardo<br />

said <strong>Thursday</strong> one of four suspects<br />

in the Caloocan city shooting has<br />

been arrested, pinpointed by a<br />

survivor of the attack. AP<br />

MIDDLE EAST<br />

Oman joins Saudi ‘antiterror’<br />

coalition<br />

Oman, which generally stays<br />

neutral in the face of regional disputes,<br />

has joined a Saudi-led military<br />

coalition aimed at “fighting<br />

terrorism,” official media in Riyadh<br />

said <strong>Thursday</strong>. The Gulf sultanate,<br />

which maintains good ties with<br />

rival powerhouses Iran and Saudi<br />

Arabia, becomes the 41st nation in<br />

the alliance announced last year<br />

by the Saudi defence minister,<br />

Deputy Crown Prince Mohammed<br />

bin Salman. AFP<br />

US set to move against Russia over<br />

vote meddling<br />

• AFP, Washington, DC<br />

President Barack Obama’s administration<br />

is poised to announce<br />

a series of retaliatory measures<br />

against Russia over its cyber-meddling<br />

in the US election, reports<br />

said Wednesday.<br />

Obama has all but accused Russian<br />

President Vladimir Putin of<br />

personally ordering an audacious<br />

cyber hack that many Democrats<br />

believe damaged Hillary Clinton’s<br />

chances in November’s closely<br />

fought election with Republican<br />

foe Donald Trump.<br />

The US intelligence community<br />

has concluded that a hack-and-release<br />

of Democratic Party and Clinton<br />

staff emails was designed to<br />

put Trump – a political neophyte<br />

who has praised Putin – into the<br />

Oval Office.<br />

The Washington Post cited officials<br />

as saying the steps set to be<br />

announced as early as this week<br />

include economic sanctions, diplomatic<br />

censure and covert action<br />

– likely including cyber operations.<br />

People tied to a Russian disinformation<br />

campaign that US intelligence<br />

officials say targeted Clinton’s<br />

campaign may also be named<br />

under the plans, according to CNN.<br />

Republican Senators John Mc-<br />

Cain and Lindsey Graham called<br />

for an even tougher US response to<br />

Russian interference in the American<br />

election.<br />

The US Congress should “increase<br />

the sanctions on Russia for<br />

this misbehaviour,” McCain told<br />

Fox News, pressing for a permanent<br />

American military presence<br />

in the Baltic states, as well as arming<br />

Ukraine with weapons.<br />

“You need to hit Russia in a sustained<br />

fashion,” Graham added,<br />

saying that for Obama to act now<br />

just before he leaves office on January<br />

20 would “send the wrong<br />

signal.”<br />

While suggesting that the Russian<br />

action did not ultimately<br />

change the election results, Mc-<br />

Cain said: “Look, if you’re able to<br />

change the results of an election,<br />

then you have undermined the<br />

very fundamentals of democracy.”<br />

US officials said a key goal of<br />

the future steps to be taken against<br />

Russia was not just to punish, but<br />

to deter.<br />

Prior to November’s election,<br />

the Obama administration warned<br />

Russia via diplomatic channels,<br />

according to the Post. Obama also<br />

spoke with Putin at a G20 summit<br />

in China earlier this year.<br />

And about a week before the<br />

election, Washington sent a message<br />

to Moscow using a special<br />

crisis communication channel for<br />

the first time, asking it to stop targeting<br />

state voter registration and<br />

election systems.<br />

Russia apparently complied, according<br />

to US officials.<br />

CNN cited Russian foreign<br />

ministry spokeswoman Maria<br />

Zakharova as saying that Moscow<br />

will respond to any “hostile steps”<br />

from Washington. •<br />

Trump, Obama disputes spill into the open<br />

• AFP, Palm Beach, US<br />

US President-elect Donald Trump<br />

stirred a simmering dispute with<br />

Barack Obama on Wednesday, accusing<br />

him of derailing a smooth<br />

transition with “inflammatory”<br />

remarks, before appearing to row<br />

back.<br />

Ever since the November 8 election,<br />

Trump and Obama have tried<br />

to bury political differences in favour<br />

of a united public front that<br />

would smooth the transfer of power<br />

on January 20.<br />

But the Republican president-in-waiting<br />

unceremoniously<br />

cast any cordiality aside in a morning<br />

Twitter tirade from his Mar-a-<br />

Lago estate in Florida.<br />

In a declaration that is unprecedented<br />

in its personal condemnation<br />

of a soon-to-be predecessor,<br />

the 70-year-old tweeted: “Doing<br />

my best to disregard the many<br />

inflammatory President O statements<br />

and roadblocks.”<br />

White House spokesman Eric<br />

Schultz said the call “was positive<br />

and focused on continuing a<br />

smooth and effective transition,”<br />

adding the pair planned to keep in<br />

touch over the coming weeks.<br />

US VS RUSSIA: THE POWER DYNAMICS<br />

The US military outguns its Russian rival in most key categories, though Russia’s<br />

nuclear arsenal retains its Soviet-era potency.<br />

Total defense<br />

spending<br />

Ground troops<br />

Tactical aircraft<br />

Long-range<br />

strike aircrafts<br />

Surface<br />

warfare ships<br />

Aircraft carriers<br />

Submarines<br />

US<br />

RUSSIA<br />

Tensions between Trump and<br />

the current White House have<br />

been growing for weeks as Obama<br />

has become more outspoken about<br />

a vitriol-filled election that saw<br />

Democrat Hillary Clinton suffer a<br />

shock defeat.<br />

Obama – who is still the most<br />

popular politician in the country –<br />

recently suggested that he may have<br />

won a third term were he not constitutionally<br />

barred from doing so.<br />

That seems to have irked the<br />

notoriously thin-skinned president-elect.<br />

$1,350,000bn<br />

$157bn<br />

$272bn<br />

$71bn<br />

$3,290bn<br />

$180bn<br />

$217bn<br />

$59bn<br />

$560bn<br />

$845,000bn<br />

$1,200bn<br />

$10bn<br />

Nuclear<br />

warheads<br />

$7,100bn $7,700bn<br />

Sources: Defense department, US Air Force Association, International Institute for Strategic Studies 2015<br />

US President Barack Obama meets with President-elect Donald Trump<br />

$60bn<br />

$1bn<br />

REUTERS<br />

Competing claims<br />

At the same time, the pair have<br />

competed to take credit for solid<br />

economic indicators.<br />

After months of talking down<br />

the world’s largest economy,<br />

Trump has tried to take credit for<br />

a number of economic developments<br />

that are roughly on trend.<br />

Trump claimed Sprint was creating<br />

5,000 US jobs “because of me.”<br />

White House response<br />

While the White House has<br />

seethed behind the scenes, there<br />

has been little public response to<br />

Trump’s forays into US foreign and<br />

domestic policy before he takes office<br />

in less than a month.<br />

But tensions reached something<br />

of a breaking point after the<br />

United States tacitly backed condemnation<br />

of Israeli settlement<br />

activity at the United Nations.<br />

With Washington withholding<br />

its veto, the UN Security Council<br />

passed a resolution demanding a<br />

halt to Israeli settlement building<br />

in the Palestinian territories.<br />

Trump followed up Wednesday’s<br />

early tweet with another two taking<br />

aim at Obama’s policy toward Israel.<br />

Throughout the long election<br />

campaign, Obama made no secret<br />

of his disdain for Trump, describing<br />

him as ill-informed and unfit<br />

for office.<br />

But since a landmark meeting<br />

in the Oval Office a few days after<br />

the election, Obama has tried flattery<br />

in a bid to bind Trump to the<br />

norms of office.<br />

He has praised Trump on a<br />

historic victory and made plain<br />

that millions of Republican voters<br />

would also be hurt if Trump overturns<br />

his landmark health care<br />

law. •


World<br />

Russia, Iran ties with Taliban stoke<br />

Afghan anxiety<br />

• AFP, Kabul<br />

Allegations over Russia and Iran’s<br />

deepening ties with the Taliban<br />

have ignited concerns of a renewed<br />

“Great Game” of proxy warfare in<br />

Afghanistan that could undermine<br />

US-backed troops and push the<br />

country deeper into turmoil.<br />

Moscow and Tehran insist their<br />

contact with insurgents is aimed at<br />

promoting regional security, but local<br />

and US officials who are already<br />

frustrated with Pakistan’s perceived<br />

double-dealing in Afghanistan have<br />

expressed bitter scepticism.<br />

Washington’s long-time nemesis<br />

Iran is accused of covertly aiding<br />

the Taliban, and Russia is back<br />

to what observers call Cold War<br />

shenanigans to derail US gains at a<br />

time when uncertainty reigns over<br />

President-elect Donald Trump’s<br />

Afghanistan policy.<br />

Russia has officially provided<br />

military helicopters for Afghan<br />

forces, but simultaneously<br />

propped up the Taliban with arms,<br />

official and insurgent sources say.<br />

A Taliban commander said the<br />

Russian support had helped the<br />

insurgents overrun the northern<br />

city of Kunduz in October for the<br />

second time in a year.<br />

Taliban representatives in recent<br />

months have also held several<br />

Ten years since Saddam Hussein executed<br />

• AFP, Baghdad<br />

Ousted Iraqi President Saddam Hussein<br />

was hanged inside one of his<br />

own regime’s former torture centres<br />

a decade ago on <strong>December</strong> <strong>30</strong>, 2006.<br />

Following is an account of the<br />

demise of the man who had ruled<br />

Iraq ruthlessly for more than two<br />

decades:<br />

No sign of fear<br />

On <strong>December</strong> <strong>30</strong>, 2006, Saddam<br />

was hanged at the military<br />

intelligence headquarters in the<br />

Kadhimiyah district of northern<br />

Baghdad.<br />

Officials who witnessed the predawn<br />

execution say Saddam, 69,<br />

remained defiant to the end, railing<br />

against his Iranian and American<br />

enemies and praising insurgents<br />

who had pushed Iraq to the<br />

brink of civil war.<br />

“I didn’t see any signs of fear,”<br />

then national security adviser<br />

Mowaffak al-Rubaie, who oversaw<br />

the execution, said in 2013.<br />

“I didn’t hear any regret from<br />

him, I didn’t hear any request for<br />

mercy from God... or request for<br />

pardon,” he said.<br />

Rubaie said he pulled the lever<br />

In this November 2015 file photo, Russia’s President Vladimir Putin, left, meets<br />

with Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei in Tehran, Iran REUTERS<br />

meetings with Russian officials in<br />

Tajikistan and Moscow, sources say.<br />

‘Great fear’<br />

Western diplomats in Kabul have<br />

privately voiced alarm that Russia is<br />

quietly filling its embassy ranks with<br />

Soviet era “old-timers” well versed<br />

in Cold War tactics, as relations with<br />

Washington turn sour over the conflicts<br />

in Syria and Ukraine.<br />

And this week Kabul vented<br />

fury over a summit between Russia,<br />

China and Pakistan in Moscow<br />

SADDAM HUSSEIN<br />

April 28, 1937<br />

Born in Awja,<br />

near Tikrit,<br />

into a Sunni<br />

family<br />

1957<br />

Joins Baath<br />

Party<br />

Photo AFP<br />

to hang Saddam, but it did not<br />

work. An unidentified person then<br />

pulled it a second time, killing him.<br />

Crimes against humanity<br />

The former strongman was executed<br />

after being found guilty of<br />

crimes against humanity for the<br />

1982 killing of 148 Shias in the<br />

town of Dujail. The massacre followed<br />

an assassination attempt<br />

against him there.<br />

His rule was marked by brutal<br />

repression, disastrous wars and<br />

punishing international sanctions.<br />

Saddam disputed the legitimacy<br />

of a special Iraqi tribunal set up<br />

with US support to try him, and<br />

described his October 2005 to July<br />

2006 trial as “a comedy”.<br />

But the execution, in which<br />

which agreed on a “flexible approach”<br />

to remove certain Taliban<br />

figures from sanctions lists.<br />

Alexander Mantytskiy, Russia’s<br />

ambassador to Kabul, insists engagement<br />

with the insurgents is<br />

benign. Lashing out at Nato, he<br />

added the allegations against Russia<br />

were an effort to distract attention<br />

from the worsening conflict<br />

and “put the blame for their failures<br />

on our shoulders”.<br />

Some observers agree that Russian<br />

and Iranian concerns over<br />

1968<br />

Involved in coup<br />

that brings Baath<br />

party to power,<br />

becomes key<br />

figure<br />

1979<br />

Takes power,<br />

purging Baath<br />

party leadership<br />

1980-88<br />

Iran-Iraq<br />

War<br />

March 17/18<br />

1988<br />

Orders chemical<br />

weapons attack<br />

on Kurdish village<br />

of Halabja, killing<br />

nearly 5,000 people<br />

1990-91<br />

Invasion<br />

of Kuwait:<br />

1st Gulf<br />

War<br />

the United States said it played no<br />

part, was slammed by Sunni Iraqis<br />

and governments around the<br />

world – although not by Saddam’s<br />

arch-enemies Israel and Iran.<br />

The day after his execution,<br />

Saddam was buried in the village<br />

of Awja, his birthplace near Tikrit,<br />

160km north of Baghdad.<br />

Islamic State jihadists cannot be<br />

dismissed lightly.<br />

Playground for superpowers<br />

Afghanistan has long been used as a<br />

chessboard for proxy battles – from<br />

the 19th century “Great Game” of rivalry<br />

between Britain and Russia to<br />

the US funnelling weapons through<br />

Pakistan to Afghan rebels fighting<br />

Soviet forces in the 1980s.<br />

It has also served as a proxy war<br />

playground for nuclear-armed rivals<br />

India and Pakistan, which is<br />

also accused of playing a “double<br />

game” by endorsing Washington’s<br />

war on terrorism while providing<br />

sanctuary to the Taliban.<br />

Superpowers jockeying for supremacy<br />

in Afghanistan could sow<br />

further chaos amid the unpredictability<br />

of Trump’s foreign policy,<br />

analysts say.<br />

Trump has given surprisingly<br />

few details on how he will tackle<br />

America’s longest war.<br />

“Russia is waiting to see the<br />

next US move when Trump takes<br />

over,” said Kabul-based analyst<br />

Ahmad Saeedi.<br />

As for Iran, many in Tehran fear<br />

that a potentially hawkish White<br />

House under Trump will try to scrap<br />

its landmark nuclear deal with world<br />

powers, pushing them to retaliate by<br />

deepening ties with the Taliban. •<br />

March 20, 2003<br />

US-led forces<br />

invade Iraq:<br />

2nd Gulf War<br />

April 9<br />

Fall of the<br />

regime<br />

<strong>December</strong> 13<br />

Hussein captured<br />

near Tikrit<br />

2005-2006<br />

Judged by special<br />

Iraqi tribunal<br />

for genocide and<br />

crimes against<br />

humanity,<br />

Death sentence<br />

Dec <strong>30</strong>, 2006<br />

Executed by hanging<br />

in Baghdad<br />

The betrayal<br />

It was also near Tikrit that on the<br />

moonless night of <strong>December</strong> 13,<br />

2003, the former dictator was captured<br />

by US forces. Washington<br />

had offered a $25m reward for his<br />

capture.<br />

After being overthrown by the<br />

US-led invasion, Saddam was on<br />

the run for eight months with the<br />

help of bodyguards from his family,<br />

according to local tribal leaders.<br />

But one betrayed him, leading<br />

American troops to Saddam’s hiding<br />

place after himself being detained.<br />

Far from the luxury of his presidential<br />

palaces, Saddam was found<br />

hiding on a farm down what American<br />

troops called a “rat-hole”, an<br />

underground hideout with enough<br />

space for a person to lie down in,<br />

equipped with an air vent and an<br />

exhaust fan.<br />

As he peered out from his den,<br />

he announced in English: “I am the<br />

president of Iraq and I want to negotiate,”<br />

US army officers said.<br />

“Ladies and gentlemen, we got<br />

him,” a smiling American diplomat<br />

Paul Bremer said the following<br />

afternoon as he announced Saddam’s<br />

capture. •<br />

9<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

USA<br />

Trump issues fresh attack<br />

on United Nations<br />

US President-elect Donald Trump<br />

launched a fresh salvo of accusations<br />

against the UN Wednesday, saying<br />

the world body had not lived up to<br />

its potential and failed to solve global<br />

problems. His comments came<br />

as incoming UN Secretary-General<br />

Antonio Guterres said he wants to<br />

meet Trump “as soon as possible”<br />

and is “determined to establish a<br />

constructive dialogue.” AFP<br />

THE AMERICAS<br />

Lawmakers in Colombia<br />

pass Farc amnesty law<br />

Colombia’s Congress on Wednesday<br />

passed a law granting amnesty<br />

to the Marxist Revolutionary<br />

Armed Forces of Colombia (Farc)<br />

insurgents as part of the country’s<br />

peace deal. The measure grants<br />

special legal treatment, amnesty<br />

and pardons to members of the<br />

Farc accused of political and related<br />

crimes. The Senate passed the<br />

bill 69-0, after the House of Representatives<br />

approved it 121-0. AFP<br />

UK<br />

UK faces legal fight with<br />

Calais child asylum seekers<br />

Dozens of children who sought<br />

asylum in Britain after living in the<br />

Calais jungle camp have launched<br />

a legal challenge against the government’s<br />

handling of their claims,<br />

their lawyers said <strong>Thursday</strong>. They<br />

accuse interior minister Amber<br />

Rudd of breaking the government’s<br />

commitment to welcome<br />

vulnerable minors under section<br />

67 of the Immigration Act, known<br />

as the Dubs amendment. AFP<br />

EUROPE<br />

Turkey detains prominent<br />

journalist over tweets<br />

Turkish authorities on <strong>Thursday</strong><br />

detained a prize-winning journalist<br />

over a succession of tweets and<br />

articles for an opposition daily,<br />

state media said, as alarm grows<br />

over press freedom in the country.<br />

Ahmet Sik was detained on accusations<br />

of making “terror propaganda”<br />

and denigrating the Turkish<br />

Republic, the judicial authorities<br />

and police, according to the staterun<br />

Anadolu news agency. AFP<br />

AFRICA<br />

Floods in southwest<br />

Congo kill at least 50<br />

Flooding this week in the Democratic<br />

Republic of Congo port city<br />

of Boma killed at least 50 people<br />

and left another 10,000 homeless,<br />

authorities told Reuters on Wednesday.<br />

Torrential rain on Monday<br />

night caused the Kalamu River to<br />

overflow, flooding two districts of<br />

the southwestern city, said Therese-Louise<br />

Mambu, health minister<br />

for Kongo Central province. REUTERS


10<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

World<br />

John Kerry’s Middle East peace framework<br />

• AFP, Washington, DC<br />

There was little new in US Secretary<br />

of State John Kerry’s outline<br />

for measures to revive peace talks<br />

between Israel and the Palestinians<br />

presented Wednesday.<br />

Nothing in his speech will bind<br />

incoming US President-elect Donald<br />

Trump, and Kerry’s intervention has<br />

been angrily rejected by Israel.<br />

Here are the “six principles” Kerry<br />

says must underlie a renewed<br />

search for peace based on an Israel-Palestine<br />

two-state solution.<br />

Recognised international borders<br />

On November 22, 1967, after Israel’s<br />

victory in the Six-Day War over its Arab<br />

neighbours, the UN Security Council<br />

(UNSC) passed its Resolution 242. Israel’s<br />

win left it in possession of the<br />

Golan Heights, Gaza, Sinai, the West<br />

Bank and East Jerusalem, in addition<br />

to its original territory. Under UNSC<br />

242, Israel should hand back its new<br />

land and in 1993 the Palestinian Liberation<br />

Organisation agreed that 242<br />

could serve as a basis for talks.<br />

Kerry’s speech insisted that<br />

UNSC 242 has long been “accepted<br />

by both sides” and must be<br />

followed, albeit with “mutually<br />

agreed equivalent swaps.”<br />

‘Two states for two peoples’<br />

Israel did not welcome Kerry’s<br />

speech, but many Israelis will welcome<br />

his second “core principle” for<br />

any deal. While the final settlement<br />

will see the Palestinians installed in<br />

their own state, they must in turn<br />

recognise Israel “as a Jewish state.”<br />

‘Realistic solution for refugees’<br />

There are an estimated 5m Palestinians<br />

claiming descent from<br />

those displaced from their homes<br />

during the creation of Israel. Their<br />

long-standing demand for a “right<br />

of return” to homes in some cases<br />

now within pre-1967 Israel has long<br />

been a stumbling block.<br />

Kerry’s principles acknowledged<br />

that international assistance and<br />

some kind of compensation will be<br />

necessary and fair for these people.<br />

Jerusalem capital of two states<br />

Israel claims the city of Jerusalem as<br />

its “undivided” capital, and Trump<br />

plans to move the US embassy there<br />

in support of this idea.<br />

But the city holds sites holy to<br />

Muslims, Jews and Christians alike<br />

and the Arab world would erupt in<br />

anger if a sole Israeli claim prevailed.<br />

Kerry admitted that the city’s<br />

fate “is the most sensitive issue for<br />

both sides” and suggested it be the<br />

“internationally recognised capital<br />

of the two states.”<br />

Satisfy Israel’s security needs<br />

Israeli forces and residents withdrew<br />

from the Gaza Strip in September<br />

2005, but peace did not<br />

break out there. Gaza has since<br />

fallen under the sway of Hamas, an<br />

armed Islamist movement, and is a<br />

source of periodic attacks on Israel<br />

and a target for harsh retaliation.<br />

Kerry’s fifth principle stated<br />

that the larger West Bank must not<br />

become a similar threat, and that<br />

Israel must retain a right to intervene.<br />

Kerry said that a team led by US<br />

General John Allen had worked on<br />

“innovative approaches to creating<br />

unprecedented, multi-layered border<br />

security.”<br />

Normalised relations<br />

Finally, under Kerry’s vision, a final<br />

status settlement between Israel<br />

and a future Palestine would<br />

see an end to outstanding regional<br />

issues.<br />

“For Israel, this must also bring<br />

broader peace with its Arab neighbours,”<br />

he said. •<br />

FACTBOX<br />

Key crises in US-Israel ties<br />

The latest diplomatic spat between Israel<br />

and Washington over the United<br />

States abstaining in a UN Security Council<br />

resolution on settlements is not the<br />

first crisis between the two allies.<br />

US President Barack Obama’s frosty<br />

relationship with Israeli Prime Minister<br />

Benjamin Netanyahu hit new lows last<br />

week after the UN vote calling for an<br />

end to Israeli settlement building passed<br />

14-0.<br />

And on Wednesday, in a parting shot<br />

from the Obama administration before<br />

US President-elect Donald Trump is<br />

sworn in on January 20, US Secretary of<br />

State John Kerry warned that building<br />

settlements on Palestinian land threatens<br />

Israel’s very future as a democracy.<br />

1975: The Sinai crisis<br />

Perhaps the most significant crisis was<br />

in 1975, when Washington pressed Israel<br />

to withdraw from the Sinai Peninsula,<br />

which it had seized during the 1967 Six-<br />

Day War.<br />

But Israel refused to do so without<br />

a full peace deal with Egypt, prompting<br />

US president Gerald Ford to inform Israeli<br />

prime minister Yitzhak Rabin that<br />

Washington would conduct a “reassessment”<br />

of bilateral ties.<br />

Between March and August of 1975,<br />

US arms shipments to Israel were suspended<br />

– a major step given Washington’s<br />

position as Israel’s biggest provider<br />

of financial and military aid.<br />

1985: The Pollard affair<br />

Washington’s arrest in 1985 of American<br />

intelligence analyst Jonathan Pollard,<br />

who passed classified US information to<br />

Israel, marked a “major low” in the relationship.<br />

It was a regular source of tension<br />

for three decades until his eventual<br />

release in November 2015.<br />

Pollard was sentenced to life imprisonment,<br />

with the affair sparking a<br />

crisis in ties that only ended when Israel<br />

promised to end all espionage activities<br />

on US soil.<br />

1990: White House phone number<br />

In a shaky start to cooperation between<br />

George Bush’s administration<br />

and that of Israeli premier Yitzhak<br />

Shamir, the US secretary of state very<br />

publicly rebuked Israel over conditions<br />

it sought to impose on the Palestinians<br />

in peace talks.<br />

Secretary of state James Baker directed<br />

the following remarks to Shamir<br />

at a meeting with the House Foreign Affairs<br />

Committee:<br />

“I have to tell you that everybody<br />

over there should know that the telephone<br />

number is 1-202-456-1414...<br />

When you’re serious about peace, call<br />

us.”<br />

2015: Netanyahu Congress<br />

address<br />

Two weeks before the March 17 general<br />

election in Israel, Netanyahu travelled to<br />

Washington to give a speech to the US<br />

Congress at the invitation of Republican<br />

House of Representatives speaker John<br />

Boehner, bypassing diplomatic protocol<br />

by not running it through the White<br />

House.<br />

Incensed, Obama and dozens of<br />

Democrats boycotted the speech, in<br />

which Netanyahu railed against an<br />

emerging world deal with Iran over its<br />

nuclear programme.<br />

<strong>2016</strong>: UN vote on settlements<br />

The UN resolution that sparked the latest<br />

crisis, backed unanimously by the<br />

rest of the 15 powers on the Security<br />

Council, effectively declared Israel’s settlements<br />

in areas of east Jerusalem and<br />

the West Bank beyond its 1967 border to<br />

be illegal.<br />

A furious Netanyahu, whose rightwing<br />

coalition is backed by the settler<br />

movement and who has insisted the<br />

home building is no threat to peace, accused<br />

Obama and Kerry of orchestrating<br />

the Security Council vote. •<br />

Source: AFP<br />

Benjamin Netanyahu<br />

subject of criminal<br />

investigation<br />

• Tribune International Desk<br />

Israel’s attorney general has ordered<br />

police to open a criminal<br />

investigation into two unspecified<br />

matters involving the prime minister,<br />

Benjamin Netanyahu.<br />

A spokeswoman for Israel’s justice<br />

ministry declined to respond<br />

to the report. Netanyahu has in<br />

the past denied wrongdoing in the<br />

purchase of submarines from Germany,<br />

where media have reported<br />

a potential conflict of interest involving<br />

his lawyer.<br />

Netanyahu and his family have<br />

been subject to a series of allegations<br />

over the past two decades. In<br />

1997, it was decided that there was<br />

not enough evidence to charge him<br />

over the appointment of an attorney<br />

general, though prosecutors<br />

said they had a “tangible suspicion”<br />

about Netanyahu’s role in the<br />

scandal. •


World<br />

11<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

Boko Haram leader in new video: Group safe, not crushed<br />

• AFP, Kano, Nigeria<br />

Boko Haram’s elusive leader<br />

Abubakar Shekau appeared in a<br />

new video on <strong>Thursday</strong> to dispute<br />

a claim that the jihadist group had<br />

been routed from its Sambisa Forest<br />

stronghold.<br />

“We are safe. We have not been<br />

flushed out of anywhere. And tactics<br />

and strategies cannot reveal our<br />

location except if Allah wills by his<br />

decree,” Shekau said in the 25-minute<br />

video, flanked by masked<br />

armed fighters.<br />

“You should not be telling lies<br />

to the people,” he said, referring to<br />

Nigerian President Muhammadu<br />

Buhari who said on Christmas Eve<br />

that the extremist group had been<br />

defeated and driven away from the<br />

forest, its last known bastion.<br />

“If you indeed crushed us, how<br />

can you see me like this? How many<br />

times have you killed us in your bogus<br />

death?” he asked.<br />

It was not immediately clear<br />

where the new video was shot, but<br />

Shekau who spoke in both Hausa<br />

and Arabic said it was filmed on<br />

Christmas Day.<br />

Shekau last appeared in a video<br />

in September where he disputed a<br />

claim by the Nigerian military that<br />

he had been wounded in battle.<br />

He vowed to continue fighting<br />

on until an Islamic state was imposed<br />

in northern Nigeria.<br />

Buhari had announced that a<br />

months-long military campaign in<br />

the 1,<strong>30</strong>0 square-kilometre forest<br />

in northeastern Borno state had led<br />

to the “final crushing of Boko Haram<br />

terrorists in their last enclave in<br />

Sambisa Forest”. •


DT<br />

12<br />

Business<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

CAPITAL MARKET SNAPSHOT: THURSDAY<br />

DSE Broad Index 5,036.1 0.2% ▲ Index 1,191.9 0.2% ▲ <strong>30</strong> Index 1,810.9 0.1% ▲ Turnover in Mn Tk 10,705.9 14.1% ▲ Turnover in Mn Vol 433.4 12.7% ▲<br />

CSE All Share Index 15,477.7 0.0% ▲ <strong>30</strong> Index 13,583.6 0.0% ▲ Selected Index 9,369.9 0.0% ▲ Turnover in Mn Tk 741.9 21.3% ▲ Turnover in Mn Vol 32.9 18.9% ▲<br />

$167m ADB loan signed for<br />

befitting gas production<br />

• SM Najmus Sakib<br />

The government has signed with<br />

the Asian Development Bank (ADB)<br />

a US$167 million loan agreement<br />

for financing a project to improve<br />

infrastructure and operational efficiency<br />

of the country’s gas sector.<br />

Last month, the ADB approved<br />

the loan to help promote sustainable<br />

economic growth and reduce<br />

poverty in Bangladesh by improving<br />

production efficiency at a key<br />

gas field north of the capital Dhaka<br />

and by expanding transmission infrastructure.<br />

Mohammad Mejbahuddin, senior<br />

secretary to the Economic Relations<br />

Division (ERD) under the<br />

Ministry of Finance, and Kazuhiko<br />

Higuchi, country director of ADB,<br />

signed the agreement on their behalf<br />

at the ERD office in the city<br />

yesterday.<br />

Under the agreement, the<br />

<strong>2016</strong><br />

YEAR IN REVIEW<br />

RMG EXPORT TREND IN<br />

JANUARY-NOVEMBER<br />

Year<br />

Export value<br />

in$ billion<br />

Export<br />

growth in%<br />

2012 17.84 1.75<br />

2013 21.22 18.98<br />

2014 22.25 4.85<br />

2015 23.93 7.55<br />

<strong>2016</strong> 26.09 9.03<br />

Source:EPB<br />

BB appoints observer<br />

to NRBC Bank<br />

• Jebun Nesa Alo<br />

Bangladesh Bank has appointed an<br />

observer to NRB Commercial Bank<br />

in the wake of conflict among the<br />

directors.<br />

Masud Biswas, general manager<br />

of Foreign Exchange Policy, Department<br />

of Bangladesh Bank, has<br />

been appointed as observer to the<br />

bank to closely monitor the director’s<br />

activities.<br />

The decision was taken following<br />

the investigation against<br />

the complaint directors filed with<br />

Bangladesh Bank, said a senior executive<br />

of the central bank.<br />

Following the complaint that<br />

directors made against each other<br />

about various corruption, the central<br />

bank conducted inquiry and<br />

found authenticity, he said.<br />

The BB official said directors<br />

of the bank were divided into two<br />

groups and both groups are involved<br />

into various irregularities.<br />

The directors’ conflict put the<br />

bank at risk. In this circumstances,<br />

the central bank appointed the observer,<br />

he added.<br />

NRBC Bank started its journey in<br />

2013 with the aim to facilitate remittance<br />

inflow from Bangladeshi<br />

expatriates working abroad and<br />

idle and less remunerative fund<br />

held with wealthy NRBs.<br />

As a newcomer, the bank performed<br />

worse as its non-performing<br />

loans were on the rise.<br />

The total default loans of the<br />

bank stood at Tk127 crore as of September<br />

<strong>2016</strong> which was 4.19% of its<br />

total outstanding, according to the<br />

central bank data. •<br />

High-end products, cutting-edge technology to boost<br />

future RMG export volume<br />

• Ibrahim Hossain Ovi<br />

ADB will finance the “Natural<br />

Gas Infrastructure and Efficiency<br />

Improvement Project” at an<br />

interest rate of 2%.<br />

The six-year-long project from<br />

July <strong>2016</strong> to June 2022 has estimated<br />

that the total cost would be US<br />

$453 million, of which the Asian<br />

Infrastructure Investment Bank<br />

(AIIB) will provide $60 million and<br />

the government of Bangladesh US$<br />

226 million.<br />

ADB will provide the rest of the<br />

amount under the agreement.<br />

The Energy and Mineral Resources<br />

Division is the sponsoring<br />

division and Gas Transmission<br />

Company Ltd and Bangladesh Gas<br />

Fields Company Limited are the executing<br />

agencies of the project.<br />

The project aims to improve efficiency<br />

in natural gas production by<br />

installing seven wellhead gas compressors<br />

at the Titas gas field and<br />

expand natural gas transmission<br />

Bangladesh’s RMG exports to the<br />

global market rose by over 9% to<br />

over $26 billion in eleven months<br />

of the outgoing year, thanks to the<br />

safety improvement and increased<br />

production capacity.<br />

The growth is, however, less<br />

than required to attain the $50 billion<br />

export target by 2021 as the<br />

sector needs over 12% growth to<br />

realise the vision.<br />

The sector people attributed remediation<br />

process – which helped<br />

improve safety standards – to the<br />

increased production capacity.<br />

Upon completion of remediation,<br />

some RMG units have received<br />

more orders from buyers<br />

who were satisfied with the safety<br />

progress, they argued.<br />

According to the data of Export<br />

Promotion Bureau (EPB), during January-November<br />

period of the outgoing<br />

year, Bangladesh earned $26.09<br />

billion, exporting clothing products,<br />

which is 9.03% higher compared to<br />

$23.93 billion a year ago.<br />

Knitwear products fetched<br />

$12.56 billion with an 8.22% rise<br />

compared to $11.60 billion in the<br />

previous year while woven products<br />

earned $13.53 billion, which<br />

pipeline capacity by constructing<br />

a 181-kilometre 36-inch parallel gas<br />

transmission pipeline from Chittagong<br />

through Feni to Bakhrabad.<br />

At the signing ceremony, ADB<br />

Country Director Kazuhiko Higuchi<br />

said: “Bangladesh economy has<br />

grown significantly over the last<br />

decade.”<br />

“By increasing natural gas production<br />

and addressing supply<br />

constraint and transmission bottlenecks,<br />

the project will help address<br />

growing energy needs with<br />

additional cleaner energy, and contribute<br />

to the sustained strong economic<br />

growth in Bangladesh.”<br />

The total loan to the socioeconomic<br />

development of ADB in<br />

Bangladesh is more than US$15.5<br />

billion.<br />

In <strong>December</strong>, ADB will mark<br />

50 years of its development<br />

partnership in the Asian and Pacific<br />

region. •<br />

is 9.78% higher compared to $12.32<br />

billion a year ago.<br />

“In <strong>2016</strong>, Bangladesh has seen<br />

a 9% growth in RMG export earning,<br />

but in 2017, we expect a double<br />

digit growth as the production<br />

capacity as well as the volume of<br />

work orders have increased because<br />

of safety improvement and<br />

remediation completion in most<br />

factories,” Exporters Association of<br />

Bangladesh president Abdus Salam<br />

Murshedy told the Dhaka Tribune.<br />

Last year production in many<br />

RMG units were hampered due to<br />

the ongoing remediation to improve<br />

safety standard in workplaces<br />

for ensuring workers’ safety,<br />

Salam said.<br />

After the full-fledged completion<br />

of Corrective Action Plans<br />

(CAPs), the work order flow would<br />

increase and it would be possible to<br />

attain a double-digit growth, added<br />

the business leader.<br />

“In attaining the $50 billion<br />

export target by 2021, the current<br />

growth is not satisfactory as the<br />

sector needs an over 12% growth,”<br />

according to BGMEA vice-president<br />

Mahmud Hasan Khan Babu.<br />

He said in the outgoing year, the<br />

sector has seen less investment as<br />

manufacturers had to spent a lot on<br />

remediation and safety improvement.<br />

But RMG sector requires investment<br />

for expansion of existing<br />

business to increase production<br />

capacity for grabbing more global<br />

market share, he said, adding that<br />

gas connection is a big challenge<br />

for Bangladesh’s RMG.<br />

The country has to put emphasis<br />

on technology upgradation and<br />

high-end products as the demands<br />

for global apparel products have<br />

witnessed downtrend last year.<br />

As per the latest statistics of<br />

World Trade Organisation (WTO),<br />

the global clothing export market<br />

has contracted by around 7.8% to<br />

$445 billion in 2015.<br />

In 2014, the global apparel export<br />

was $483 billion while the global<br />

RMG export market is expected to<br />

reach $650 billion by 2021.<br />

As a newcomer, NRBC<br />

performed worse as<br />

its non-performing<br />

loans rose<br />

“In garbing more global market<br />

share to attain $50 billion export<br />

target from RMG, Bangladesh has<br />

to concentrate on capacity building<br />

and set strategies to move to<br />

high-end and branded fashion segments,<br />

BGMEA senior vice-president<br />

Faruque Hassan told the Dhaka<br />

Tribune.<br />

Currently, about 79% of Bangladesh<br />

export items are concentrated<br />

in five basic products – trouser,<br />

t-shirt, sweater, shirts and jackets<br />

mostly made of cotton.<br />

Hassan said another priority<br />

area is market diversification as<br />

Bangladesh’s apparel exports are<br />

mostly concentrated on EU and<br />

North America.<br />

Non-traditional market is the<br />

key element to enlarge the export<br />

volume. The contribution of<br />

non-traditional markets to total export<br />

was 2% in FY2005-06, which<br />

has increased to 15% in FY’16, he<br />

added.<br />

To tap the opportunity, manufacturers<br />

have to upgrade technology<br />

and modernise their factories<br />

while the government has to ensure<br />

infrastructure development,<br />

i.e. building industrial zone, connectivity<br />

to ports and improving<br />

their efficiency, resolving gas and<br />

electricity crises, added Hassan. •


Business 13<br />

DT<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

RMG makers seek gas price hike exemption<br />

• Asif Showkat Kallol<br />

Apparel sector businessmen have<br />

urged the government to give them<br />

an exemption from the proposed<br />

gas price hike, according to official<br />

sources.<br />

They also requested the government<br />

to devaluate Taka against the<br />

US dollar for the sake of enhancing<br />

their export earning. Besides,<br />

they also wanted the export price<br />

garment items to be fixed in the<br />

Freight-on Board (FOB) instead of<br />

Ready-made garment item for valuation<br />

of export items to giving the<br />

cash incentive.<br />

President of Bangladesh Garment<br />

Manufacturers and Exporters’ Association<br />

(BGMEA) Siddiqur Rahman<br />

placed their demands at a meeting<br />

with Finance Minister AMA Muhith<br />

held at his secretariat office in<br />

the city. Commerce Minister Tofail<br />

Ahmed also attended the meeting.<br />

According to the meeting sources,<br />

the BGMEA leaders also demanded<br />

for the cancellation of audit<br />

by the Bangladesh Bank for getting<br />

cash incentive against their export<br />

volume. RMG leaders also demanded<br />

disbursement of Tk10 crore incentives<br />

for small RMG exporters.<br />

Finance Minister Muhith is<br />

learned to be disagreed with the<br />

BGMEA demands. Meanwhile, the<br />

government has allocated Tk4,500<br />

crore for 22 export items including<br />

RMG items.<br />

During the meeting, RMG exporters<br />

also informed that they<br />

are already providing salary of<br />

Tk10,000 as minimum wage to<br />

their garment factory workers although<br />

the garment factory workers<br />

demanded Tk16,000.<br />

In 2013, the government declared<br />

a minimum wage of Tk5,<strong>30</strong>0<br />

per month for garment industry<br />

workers. Earlier, the figure was<br />

Tk3,000.<br />

Besides, the garment exporters<br />

also demanded the amendment of<br />

the provision of local cloth word replace<br />

with cloth of own enterprises .<br />

Last August, Bangladesh Energy<br />

Regulatory Commission (BERC)<br />

held an eight-day public hearing on<br />

gas transmission tariff and user-end<br />

price hike proposals submitted by<br />

seven state-owned gas transmission<br />

and distribution companies.<br />

The companies initially proposed<br />

a massive 85% price hike<br />

for household users: Tk1,200 per<br />

month for double-burner stoves<br />

and Tk1,100 for single-burner<br />

stoves. In addition, they proposed<br />

a 140% increase for consumers using<br />

meter-based burners, increasing<br />

the price from Tk7 to Tk16.8<br />

per cubic metre of gas. Besides, the<br />

price of a US dollar in curb market<br />

is differed by Tk4 per compared to<br />

official bank rate. •<br />

The currency exchange values placard of a bureau de change in Rio de<br />

Janeiro, Brazil<br />

REUTERS<br />

Fund managers bullish<br />

on emerging markets<br />

• Reuters<br />

A number of global fund<br />

managers say they are buying<br />

emerging market assets<br />

for 2017 after the beating the<br />

sector has taken since the US<br />

election in November, even<br />

though credit rating agencies<br />

have a less positive outlook.<br />

Since the election of Donald<br />

Trump as US president, emerging<br />

market stocks are down<br />

nearly 7%, based on the Morgan<br />

Stanley Capital Index, and the<br />

yield spread of emerging market<br />

bonds over benchmark US<br />

Treasuries is wider by 10 basis<br />

points, reversing some of the<br />

gains seen earlier in the year.<br />

On Nov 8, the date of the<br />

US election, the EMBI Global<br />

year-to-date total return was<br />

14.04%, and a week later, on<br />

Nov 14, it had halved to 7.6%.<br />

Currencies such as Mexican<br />

peso and the Turkish lira<br />

have tumbled 10% or more in<br />

the wake of the election.<br />

US President-elect Trump<br />

has pledged to impose protectionist<br />

trade policies and<br />

restrict immigration which<br />

would likely damage most<br />

emerging market economies.<br />

The Washington, DC bank<br />

lobbying group, the Institute<br />

for International Finance, reported<br />

this week that $23bn has<br />

flowed out of emerging market<br />

funds since Oct 4, with $18bn of<br />

that taking flight since Nov 9.<br />

“The magnitude of outflows<br />

has diminished significantly in<br />

recent weeks, but the direction<br />

has remained persistently negative,”<br />

said Scott Farnham, an<br />

IIF research analyst.<br />

Fund managers positive<br />

BlackRock, the world’s largest<br />

asset manager is expecting<br />

to reap solid gains from<br />

all emerging market asset<br />

classes, especially bonds, the<br />

firm’s chief fixed income strategist,<br />

Jeff Rosenberg said at<br />

the company’s recent global<br />

outlook summit.<br />

Other global fund managers<br />

also see a rebound on the<br />

horizon. Ricardo Adrogué,<br />

head of emerging markets<br />

debt at Baring Asset Management<br />

Ltd, said analysts, including<br />

ratings agencies, are<br />

confusing structural versus<br />

cyclical problems when evaluating<br />

the sector.<br />

“Our assessment of emerging<br />

markets is actually strengthening<br />

at the time that developed<br />

market institutional framework<br />

is weakening,” he said.<br />

Similarly, Michel Del<br />

Buono, head of portfolio strategy<br />

at Makena Capital Management<br />

LLC, who oversees<br />

$18bn across asset classes,<br />

also has a bullish outlook. •


14<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

Business<br />

BOJ Kuroda sees steady Japan recovery next year<br />

• Reuters<br />

Bank of Japan Governor Haruhiko<br />

Kuroda said he expects Japan’s<br />

economy to enjoy a steady recovery<br />

throughout next year as global<br />

headwinds die down, according to<br />

the Nikkei newspaper, reinforcing<br />

market expectations that the central<br />

bank will hold off on expanding<br />

stimulus in the foreseeable future.<br />

“There are many things we<br />

can do if necessary” to jump-start<br />

growth, Kuroda said in an interview<br />

with Nikkei published on<br />

<strong>Thursday</strong>, dismissing views held<br />

by some analysts that the BOJ has<br />

run out of policy ammunition after<br />

more than three years of aggressive<br />

money printing.<br />

But he said brightening prospects<br />

for the global economy,<br />

rising Japanese stock prices and<br />

a reversal of excessive yen gains<br />

will allow Japan’s economy to sustain<br />

a steady economic recovery<br />

throughout next year.<br />

“Overall, both the global and<br />

Japan’s economies are moving in<br />

a positive and more desirable direction,”<br />

he added in an interview<br />

conducted on Tuesday.<br />

Regarding the expected policies<br />

of US President-elect Donald<br />

Trump, Kuroda said he did not<br />

expect the new administration to<br />

implement extreme steps such as<br />

trade restrictions as they would<br />

hurt the US economy as well as well<br />

as the economies of trade rivals.<br />

Kuroda did not respond when<br />

asked if he would be willing to serve<br />

a second term after his five-year tenure<br />

as BOJ governor ends in April<br />

2018, according to the Nikkei. •


Business 15<br />

DT<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Eurozone<br />

lending climbs<br />

in November<br />

• AFP, Frankfurt<br />

Lending to households and<br />

companies picked up in November<br />

in the eurozone, the<br />

European Central Bank yesterday,<br />

signalling that its efforts<br />

to encourage spending and investment<br />

are gaining traction.<br />

Loans to households in the<br />

single currency area grew by<br />

1.9% year-on-year, compared<br />

to 1.8% a month earlier, the<br />

bank said. Lending to firms<br />

accelerated by 2.2%, up from<br />

2.1% in October.<br />

IHS Markit economist<br />

Howard Archer described the<br />

figures as “a pleasing set of<br />

news for the ECB”.<br />

“The ECB will particularly<br />

welcome a pick-up in the<br />

growth rate in eurozone bank<br />

lending to businesses to a<br />

more than five-year high in<br />

November,” he said.<br />

The ECB has embarked on<br />

an unprecedented stimulus<br />

programme to drive up lending<br />

and inflation in the euro<br />

area, and the monthly loan<br />

growth statistics are seen as a<br />

key indicator of the effectiveness<br />

of its measures.<br />

Faced with a still lacklustre<br />

recovery and a string of financial<br />

and political risks on<br />

the horizon in 2017, ECB chief<br />

Mario Draghi announced earlier<br />

CORPORATE NEWS<br />

this month that the bank would<br />

extend a massive bond-buying<br />

scheme aimed at pumping cash<br />

into the economy.<br />

As part of its ultra-loose<br />

monetary policy, the ECB has<br />

also cut interest rates to record<br />

lows and offered cheap loans<br />

to banks -- on the condition<br />

that they lend the funds on to<br />

households and businesses.<br />

Buoyed by <strong>Thursday</strong>’s<br />

data, Archer said the ECB<br />

would be “unlikely to make<br />

any adjustments to monetary<br />

policy for some considerable<br />

time to come following its early-<strong>December</strong><br />

move to extend<br />

its asset purchasing scheme”.<br />

Inflation in the 19-nation<br />

euro area hit a two-and-ahalf-year<br />

high in November<br />

at 0.6%, in another sign that<br />

the central bank’s efforts are<br />

starting to pay off.<br />

But the figure remains far<br />

short of the ECB’s target of an<br />

inflation rate just below 2%.<br />

Eurozone growth was low<br />

but stable in the third quarter,<br />

at 0.3%. The ECB expects the<br />

euro area economy to grow by<br />

1.7% this year.<br />

The bank also announced<br />

<strong>Thursday</strong> that the eurozone’s<br />

overall money supply, known<br />

as M3, increased by 4.8% in<br />

November, compared to October’s<br />

4.4%. •<br />

Social Islami Bank Limited has recently opened its 125th branch at<br />

Motijheel in Dhaka, said a press release. The bank’s chairperson, Major<br />

Dr Md Rezaul Haque (retired) inaugurated the branch<br />

Standard Bank Limited has recently opened its 110th branch at<br />

Madhabdi in Narsingdi, said a press release. The bank’s chairperson,<br />

Kazi Akram Uddin Ahmed inaugurated the branch<br />

Like what you’re reading?<br />

SUBSCRIBE TODAY<br />

Call: 0161-I-WANT-DT (01614926838) | Visit: dhakatribune.com/subscribe<br />

Dhaka Tribune


16<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

Feature<br />

World turned upside down:<br />

World politics in <strong>2016</strong><br />

• Saqib Sarker<br />

‘What a year!’ will be a legitimate<br />

summary for <strong>2016</strong> in world politics.<br />

The dial on the political compass<br />

has tilted, and it is firmly directing<br />

towards the right. The reactionary<br />

movement across Europe and<br />

the US indicate that the political<br />

systems in the western world are<br />

faced with a new era where things<br />

must change. Important changes<br />

Brexit<br />

The Beatles may no longer be<br />

the thing for which Britain<br />

is most famous. The heavily<br />

conflicted issue of leaving the<br />

European Union came to rest by<br />

a referendum on June 23, where<br />

the British people voted the<br />

UK out of the EU. Resentments<br />

have been building among the<br />

working class people since the<br />

last Labour administration<br />

finally caused the public to<br />

blame the economic misfortune<br />

on the immigrant population<br />

and the EU, which allows for a<br />

free movement of the citizens<br />

of EU among the member states.<br />

The result of the referendum<br />

naturally angered EU member<br />

states and caused Prime Minister<br />

David Cameron to resign. The<br />

pound also plummeted following<br />

the referendum. The result of the<br />

Kashmir unrest<br />

The “heaven on earth,” as Kashmir<br />

is often called, has become a<br />

tragic political playground at the<br />

expense of the Kashmiri people.<br />

Self-determination struggles<br />

in Kashmir provoked Indian<br />

authority to clamp down on<br />

political movements in Kashmir<br />

by the natives for decades.<br />

Both India and Pakistan claim<br />

the Muslim-majority region of<br />

Attempted coup d’état in Turkey<br />

President Recep Tayyip Erdogan<br />

has managed to become quite<br />

a controversial figure since his<br />

election to the office in 2014.<br />

His heavy handed treatment<br />

of journalists and civil protests<br />

earned him infamy. But despite his<br />

flaws and propensity for tyranny,<br />

Erdogan remains one of the most<br />

successful elected president,<br />

in Turkey, and some would say<br />

in the world, considering the<br />

troubled split within the country.<br />

The coup attempt in Turkey on<br />

July 15 was therefore a dangerous<br />

development for many reasons.<br />

But Erdogan in a, what is now<br />

famous, FaceTime video call to<br />

CNN Turk called upon the people<br />

of Turkey to take to the streets<br />

resisting the military takeover,<br />

saying, “There is no power higher<br />

than the power of the people. Let<br />

them do what they will at public<br />

squares and airports.” Members of<br />

the general public responded by<br />

actually coming out of their homes<br />

and deifying the coup. Because of<br />

enormous outpouring of people<br />

on the streets the military realised<br />

that it would be simply impossible<br />

to take over against the popular<br />

will of the people. This certainly is<br />

among the most startling political<br />

events in <strong>2016</strong>.<br />

Whatever may happen from as a result of his election into the<br />

highest office of the most powerful country in the world, one<br />

thing is certain: Donald Trump has been hired<br />

have taken place in Africa, Asia,<br />

and the Americas as well. When<br />

we look at the big disruptions in<br />

<strong>2016</strong> in world politics, some of the<br />

news are not good, while some are<br />

good only because they are not<br />

extremely bad, and all are open to<br />

interpretation.<br />

because of scarcity of jobs and<br />

austerity measures. Culminating<br />

into a frustrated anger against<br />

the establishment, the public<br />

sought refuge in the solutions<br />

advocated by far right groups<br />

like Britain First, and the UKIP.<br />

The anti-immigrant rhetoric<br />

vote also inspired other groups<br />

in Europe to push for an exit<br />

from the EU and it also inspired<br />

people in the US to vote for<br />

Trump. But the overall economic<br />

and political implications of this<br />

historic vote will undoubtedly be<br />

far reaching.<br />

PHOTO: BIGSTOCK<br />

Kashmir as their own. Two of the<br />

three wars between India and<br />

Pakistan have been fought over<br />

Kashmir. This year a new surge of<br />

protests ensued after the death of<br />

popular rebel militant commander,<br />

Burhan Wani on July 8. A curfew<br />

was imposed immediately after<br />

his death in the valley to stop<br />

the protests. People came out<br />

on the streets in huge numbers<br />

despite the curfew. Police and<br />

Indian paramilitary forces used<br />

pellet guns, tear gas shells, rubber<br />

bullets and assault rifles against<br />

unarmed protestors, killing at<br />

least 85 civilians. The aggressive<br />

police actions left 13,000 civilians<br />

injured. The protests and<br />

subsequent events created and<br />

escalated tensions between India<br />

and Pakistan and left the subcontinent<br />

in a grave risk of further<br />

militancy.<br />

US election<br />

To end the year of great political<br />

upsets, Donald J Trump,<br />

the haughty reality TV star<br />

and billionaire, won the US<br />

presidential election on the<br />

fateful day of November 8. From<br />

the beginning, his campaign was<br />

met with disbelief and no one was<br />

quite sure what to make of it. But<br />

he won the Republican ticket and<br />

ran against Hillary Clinton. The<br />

massive economic disparity and<br />

the effects of trade treaties that<br />

allowed for American jobs getting<br />

transferred offshore ignited<br />

immense bitterness among the<br />

working class population. The<br />

vote was the only way left for<br />

the people, as the famous film<br />

maker Michael Moore puts it, to<br />

give a big “(expletive) you!” to<br />

the system. And people did it.<br />

With ExxonMobil CEO Tillerson<br />

put as the choice for secretary<br />

of state, among other things,<br />

President-elect Trump has<br />

shown little animosity to the<br />

“system”. Political analysts are<br />

predicting wild things including<br />

impeachment. Whatever may<br />

happen because of his election<br />

into the highest office of the most<br />

powerful country in the world,<br />

one thing is certain: Donald<br />

Trump has been hired. •


Feature<br />

17<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

Government’s hard-core ban on porn sites<br />

• Mahmood Sadi<br />

Midway through the<br />

second season of<br />

Silicon Valley, the<br />

popular HBO series<br />

which skilfully spoofs the Bay Area<br />

tech scene, the plot turns to porn.<br />

Inside the offices of Pied Piper,<br />

the fictional startup at the heart<br />

of the show, the team members<br />

thought of selling their groundbreaking<br />

compressing algorithm to<br />

a porn outfit called Intersite. Citing<br />

reasons, one of the members<br />

of the team said, “Pornography<br />

accounts for 37 percent of all<br />

Internet traffic.”<br />

“Thirty-eight when I’m on it,”<br />

says another member jokingly.<br />

Punchline aside, the truth<br />

is porn accounts for some<br />

astronomically large portion of all<br />

Internet traffic. Porn sites get more<br />

visitors each month than Netflix,<br />

Amazon and Twitter combined,<br />

and these generate equally<br />

enormous sums of money for all<br />

the faceless people who run its<br />

operations.<br />

So, blocking porn websites is<br />

much easier said than done.<br />

Bangladesh government,<br />

however, has started to venture<br />

out this daunting task of blocking<br />

porn websites from Wednesday in<br />

an unprecedented move.<br />

Porn sites get more visitors each month than Netflix,<br />

Amazon and Twitter combined, and these generate equally<br />

enormous sums of money for all the faceless people who<br />

run its operations<br />

Why this ban?<br />

Earlier, the Ministry of Post and<br />

Telecommunication (MoPT)<br />

of Bangladesh listed down<br />

names of 500 porn websites<br />

and sent it to the Bangladesh<br />

Telecommunication Regulatory<br />

Commission (BTRC).<br />

The list is forwarded by the<br />

Telecom regulator to internet<br />

service providers (ISP), as well as<br />

to International Internet Getaway<br />

(IIG) service providers who have<br />

started taking the actions right<br />

away.<br />

About the closure, Tarana<br />

Halim said that initially they<br />

have decided to block around<br />

500 websites that contain<br />

pornography, obscene pictures<br />

and video contents. In the first<br />

phase, they will go for blocking the<br />

locally hosted sites.<br />

About 70 to 80 percent of the<br />

pornography sites, operated from<br />

overseas, would also be blocked in<br />

phases, Tarana added.<br />

The Minister said that she is<br />

aware of accessing porn websites<br />

through virtual private network<br />

(VPN).<br />

A VPN helps someone encrypt<br />

traffic between his/her device<br />

and the VPN server. With VPN,<br />

that person can get access to the<br />

blocked websites.<br />

“I know it is not possible to<br />

completely block all websites<br />

because there will always be ways<br />

of accessing those porn sites. But<br />

we are trying to make it as difficult<br />

as possible for the users.”<br />

Why banning porn websites is<br />

difficult?<br />

Experts concerned in the field<br />

said that aside from VPN, a user<br />

can get access to the blocked<br />

porn websites through proxy<br />

servers. There are a lot of proxies<br />

on the world wide web that allow<br />

someone to use their Internet<br />

connection, thus bypassing<br />

most of the restrictions set<br />

up by the ISPs or the network<br />

administrators.<br />

Cyber expert Hasib Muammar<br />

Rashid said when it comes to<br />

the question of blocking porn<br />

websites, the Government is just<br />

wasting its time.<br />

He said that to block content,<br />

the Bangladesh Government- with<br />

the help of ISPs and IIGs- use a listbased<br />

approach.<br />

This means the list of websites,<br />

with their exact Uniform Resource<br />

Locator (URL), are fed into a<br />

system and then access to those<br />

sites is denied to a user.<br />

It can be easily bypassed if the<br />

blocked website decides to create<br />

a mirror site or if it changes the<br />

name, said Hasib.<br />

“The list-based filtering system<br />

can also be defeated if a website<br />

decides to encrypt the traffic by<br />

using HTTPS instead of HTTP<br />

because then the internet service<br />

providers can’t see what a user is<br />

accessing.”<br />

Is there any way?<br />

Hasib said that the blocks and<br />

content filtering can be made<br />

more robust with keyword-based<br />

filtering or by employing deep<br />

packet inspection of the internet<br />

traffic.<br />

“This is something China or<br />

countries like Saudi Arabia do, but<br />

it is also vastly more expensive<br />

and difficult to maintain.”<br />

Adult websites are just one<br />

part of the internet. There are<br />

other communication protocols<br />

that internet users follow. “For<br />

example, even if websites are<br />

banned, porn can be downloaded<br />

using Bit-Torrent technology.<br />

PHOTO: BIGSTOCK<br />

Similarly, peer-to-peer networks<br />

like eMule or Bulletin Boards can<br />

be used to download and share<br />

files, including porn files.”<br />

“Porn is fairly easily and widely<br />

available on the web and clamping<br />

down on it is near impossible,<br />

unless the Government is willing<br />

to spend crores every year just<br />

to keep an updated web content<br />

filtering system in place,” said<br />

Hasib.<br />

Besides, no Government<br />

generally bans porn sites as<br />

they are the biggest driver of<br />

e-commerce intervention, he<br />

added.<br />

“It is a good intention but the<br />

Government should not bite more<br />

than they can chew.”<br />

Hasib said that the US and<br />

China tried to fight porn and<br />

saw its results and then they<br />

only limited themselves to child<br />

pornography. “In the last two<br />

years, the United Kingdom and<br />

India tried very hard to block porn<br />

websites in their countries but<br />

they have failed.” •


18<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

Feature<br />

Films on writers<br />

•Mahmood Sadi<br />

Hollywood loves making movies about writers – apparently<br />

there is nothing more cinematic than watching an unwashed<br />

nerd sit in front of a computer and think really hard for the<br />

next lines. For aspiring young writers, such films portraying<br />

the lifestyles of writers-their struggles, inspirations and<br />

the need to come up with beautiful narratives can act as an<br />

impetus. Weekend Tribune prepared a list of films, depicting<br />

writers.<br />

by Meryl Streep. The novel itself concerns the story of John<br />

Laroche (played by Chris Cooper), a smug plant dealer<br />

who was arrested in 1994 for poaching rare orchids in the<br />

Fakahatchee Strand State Preserve. As Kaufman struggles to<br />

write the script, his troubles are compounded by the presence<br />

of his twin brother, Donald (also played by Nicolas Cage), who<br />

is Charlie’s exact opposite: reckless, carefree, over-confident<br />

and perhaps even a bit dim. The script for Adaptation darts<br />

back and forth between different moments in time, either<br />

chronicling Kaufman’s screen writing exploits or Orlean’s<br />

experiences in writing her novel. Here Kaufman shows his<br />

mastery in destroying the line between reality and fiction.<br />

endless possibilities. In Wonder Boys, Michael Douglas plays<br />

Grady Tripp, a distracted and downtrodden professor who<br />

is suffering from an epic case of writer’s block. Life’s little<br />

surprises and academic politics aren’t helping the creative<br />

process either. Every writer has been there: when life seems<br />

to be wildly spinning away from you, the only thing you can<br />

control is your writing. Wonder Boys thus asks the question,<br />

what happens when you lose control of the writing too? A<br />

lot occurs in Wonder Boys, and the plot is very labyrinthine,<br />

although it never becomes confused and always keeps its<br />

cool. The characters are perfectly defined and cast. Their<br />

intentions and motives are clear and developed with shape<br />

and gradual effectiveness. Director Curtis Hanson pays<br />

close attention to each separate character, giving them<br />

dimensional qualities, intelligence and depth. It’s a complex,<br />

yet a feel good movie.<br />

Deconstructing Harry (1997)<br />

If one director’s name is being picked for portraying writers<br />

in movies, then it should be Woody Allen. In almost<br />

every Woody Allen film there is a writer character, but it’s<br />

with Deconstructing Harry, where Woody is at his best in<br />

portraying the eccentric lives of writers and it’s not a pretty<br />

sight. Arguably Woody’s best film of the 90’s, Deconstructing<br />

Harry is a study of a hopelessly immature and narcissistic<br />

novelist (played by Woody himself) who leaves a wake of<br />

misery and heartbreak among his friends and family as<br />

he loses the inspiration to write. As a result, he becomes<br />

‘unfocused,’ entangling himself in fact and fiction (ie, he<br />

interacts with his own characters). “You expect the world<br />

to adjust to the distortion you’ve become,” Harry’s analyst<br />

tells him. What follows is a series of skits that interact with<br />

the past and present and the real and imagined – it’s kind<br />

of like watching a Kurt Vonnegut story edited by Quentin<br />

Tarentino.<br />

Adaptation (2002)<br />

Adaptation is another masterpiece by the director Spike<br />

Jonze. But here the real credit goes to Charlie Kaufman, the<br />

screenwriter. Much like Federico Fellini’s classic 1963 film -<br />

8½, from which Kaufman almost certainly drew inspiration,<br />

Adaptation tells the story of its own creation.<br />

Nicolas Cage plays Charlie Kaufman, the lonely, insecure,<br />

and socially awkward screenwriter who is hired to adapt<br />

The Orchid Thief, written by Susan Orlean, who is portrayed<br />

Naked Lunch (1991)<br />

Films about writers and the creative process are not<br />

generally action-packed, but this unusual piece has plenty of<br />

incidents. The action takes place largely inside the mind of<br />

William Lee (William S Burroughs), whose first book Junkie:<br />

Confessions of an Unredeemed Drug Addict, dealt with his<br />

struggle against heroin addiction. The Naked Lunch, set<br />

in the early 1950s, could be described as telling how that<br />

book came to be written. Lee tries to write but suffers from<br />

frequent hallucinations. He imagines his typewriter is a<br />

giant speaking bug whose mission is to act as his “interzone”<br />

spy force controller. He becomes involved with another<br />

expatriate literary couple, Tom and Joan Frost, and imagines<br />

that Tom is trying to kill his wife. Then he discovers he has<br />

a taste for gay sex. Finally, somehow, the book gets written,<br />

and Hank and Martin show up just as Lee is in psychotic<br />

despair. They help him piece it together and head off back to<br />

New York, leaving Lee to “interzone” and his hallucinations.<br />

It takes a bit of discipline to watch this film - never has the<br />

creative process looked quite so destructive of the writer. Yet<br />

the whole thing has a lightness of touch about it.<br />

Wonder Boys (2000)<br />

Writer’s Block always has been a favourite subject of both<br />

the screenwriters and the directors because as a film subject<br />

‘writer’s block’ is complex, multi-dimensional and has<br />

Photos: Internet<br />

Barton Fink (1991)<br />

Another film focusing on writer’s block, this time by the<br />

great Coen brothers. Barton Fink is termed as the most<br />

audacious film about the writing process. For me the clue<br />

to understanding this film was the line “I will show you the<br />

life of the mind,” and I feel that is just what this movie is<br />

about. It’s about the creative process of writing. It shows<br />

how the mind of an artist works. Set in the Hollywood of<br />

1941, struggling playwright Barton Fink (John Turturro) has<br />

had huge success with a play he penned that he despises.<br />

Barton is a man who wants to write material that appeals<br />

to the common man. And when he receives an offer from<br />

a Hollywood film studio to write a script about a wrestling<br />

picture, he doesn’t like the idea of “selling out,” but the offer<br />

is too good to turn down. When he arrives in Hollywood, he<br />

checks into one of the most bizarre hotels. Trapped within<br />

the confines of his tiny room, Barton became a prisoner<br />

of his own imagination. He was struck by a severe case of<br />

writers block. There can be nothing more horrifying to a<br />

writer than a blank page. And that endless image of a blank<br />

page slowly starts to drive Barton mad. It is similar to Stanley<br />

Kubrick’s The Shining. The Coen brothers are known fans<br />

of Kubrick’s work, but I have to say, Barton Fink is a much<br />

better film than the one the Coens’ idol came up with.•


Biz Info<br />

19<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

| contest |<br />

International photography competition by ThirdEye<br />

• Saqib Sarker<br />

Bangladesh International Salon<br />

<strong>2016</strong> has just been successfully<br />

completed. Unfolded on <strong>December</strong><br />

22 this year, the curtain was closed<br />

on <strong>December</strong> 25, at Drik Gallery,<br />

Dhanmondi, Dhaka.<br />

ThirdEye Photographic Society<br />

organised this Salon in <strong>2016</strong>, which<br />

had joint patronages of PSA and<br />

ThirdEye Photographic Society<br />

(TPS). A total of 83 awards were<br />

declared and distributed among<br />

the participants. Sayeeda Khanam,<br />

advisor of ThirdEye Photographic<br />

Society and one of the first female<br />

photo journalists of Bangladesh<br />

was the chief guest in the opening<br />

ceremony.<br />

Syed Shakhawat Kamal,<br />

the newly appointed Country<br />

Membership Director of<br />

Photographic Society of America<br />

(PSA) presented the award<br />

giving ceremony on the final<br />

day. A truly international event,<br />

the completion received over<br />

4000 entries from than 400 plus<br />

entrants from across the globe.<br />

The judging was completed in<br />

two rounds, where nine judges<br />

participated. Out of nine judges<br />

two judges were from USA, one<br />

judges from Saudi Arabia and the<br />

rest of the six judges were from<br />

Bangladesh.<br />

ThirdEye Photographic Society<br />

has established the tradition of<br />

“national photography conference<br />

in Bangladesh. This was the 2nd<br />

time ThirdEye organised this event<br />

in two consecutive years. At the<br />

same time it has introduced the<br />

“Photographer of the year” award<br />

for the first time.<br />

“It was an overwhelming<br />

success for the first event with<br />

PSA and TPS patronages,” said<br />

Syed Shakhawat Kamal. ThirdEye<br />

Photographic Society has<br />

pledged to continue their effort<br />

in promoting photography in<br />

Bangladesh. In their effort, they<br />

will work closely with PSA and<br />

promote PSA in Bangladesh.<br />

When Sheihk Md Atiqul Kabir<br />

received the photographer of the<br />

year award the audience cheered<br />

with tumultuous applause. Kabir<br />

gave a moving acceptance speech<br />

where he related the story behind<br />

his capture that won him the<br />

award. An educator by profession,<br />

Sheikh Kabir manages time for<br />

his passion of photography in<br />

addition to his regular professional<br />

engagements.<br />

“It’s difficult for me to express<br />

how I feel right now,” a tearful<br />

Kabir said to the audience. “I was<br />

in my hotel room the day I took the<br />

picture. It was raining and I was<br />

hesitant whether I would go out<br />

for a shoot. But I thought to myself<br />

that that is why I was there. So, I<br />

grabbed my rain coat, covered my<br />

camera and got out,” he continued.<br />

Kabir’s photo captured a fisherman<br />

struggling to pull in his boat near<br />

the shore against the strong tide. In<br />

beautiful monochrome the photo<br />

displays a silhouetted yet clear<br />

image of the scene.<br />

The photos in the contest<br />

covered a wide array of subjects<br />

including struggles of daily life,<br />

rural Bangladesh, rivers, and<br />

wildlife among others. •<br />

Photos: Courtesy<br />

| celebration |<br />

New Year celebrations at Dhaka Regency<br />

special New Year’s Eve celebrations will kick off<br />

from 6pm onwards with live DJ at Club 13 to make<br />

the night memorable.<br />

Dhaka Regency is also offering a special room<br />

package for the night of the 31st including a wide<br />

spread of buffet breakfast for two persons at the<br />

Grandiose Restaurant. Guests can enjoy the package<br />

only at Tk9,999. The valued members of Dhaka<br />

Regency Premier Club can avail the same package at<br />

Tk8,888.<br />

The New Year’s Eve festivities are very popular<br />

among the people of Dhaka. Keeping this in mind,<br />

Dhaka Regency has planned to celebrate this night<br />

in an alluring, yet conventional manner. •<br />

Photos: Courtesy<br />

| meeting |<br />

Dhaka Regency and Resort holds<br />

9th Annual General Meeting<br />

People can celebrate New Year’s<br />

Eve with their family at the Dhaka<br />

Regency Hotel and Resort, where<br />

they promise this will be a night<br />

to remember. All the outlets of the<br />

hotel will have a bit for everyone<br />

on this night.<br />

The hotel’s most popular and<br />

largest rooftop restaurant Grill On<br />

The Skyline will be welcoming<br />

guests with their family and kids<br />

where they can enjoy the luxurious<br />

ambiance and mouth watering Live<br />

BBQ with music. For music lovers,<br />

Photo: Courtesy<br />

The 9th Annual General Meeting of<br />

Dhaka Regency Hotel and Resort<br />

Limited was held on Sunday,<br />

<strong>December</strong> 29 at the Rendezvous<br />

Lounge of Dhaka Regency.<br />

The meeting was presided over<br />

by Musleh Uddin Ahmed, Chairman<br />

of Dhaka Regency Hotel and<br />

Resort Limited. The meeting was<br />

also attended by Kabir Reza, Managing<br />

Director, other Board Members,<br />

Executive Director, Company<br />

Secretary, respected shareholders<br />

and other Senior Officials of<br />

the company. The shareholders<br />

thanked the board of directors and<br />

the management of the company<br />

for the success and notable growth<br />

during the year. •


DT<br />

20<br />

Editorial<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

TODAY<br />

The long shadow<br />

of Ayub Khan<br />

Srabon protested the decision last year<br />

and so it has been banned from hosting<br />

a stall for the next two years<br />

PAGE 21<br />

Oppressors and<br />

exploiters, be<br />

careful<br />

While the posters are visual<br />

representation of the Santal, taken<br />

from their muddy house walls around<br />

the villages, the messages reflect and<br />

convey the historical roots of their<br />

struggle<br />

PAGE 22<br />

Second time’s a<br />

coronation<br />

The same Ivy registered a preciously<br />

rare show of strength at the ballot box<br />

for the ruling party -- in the form of a<br />

victory unsullied by accusations<br />

PAGE 23<br />

Be heard<br />

Write to Dhaka Tribune<br />

FR Tower, 8/C Panthapath,<br />

Shukrabad, Dhaka-1207<br />

Send us your Op-Ed articles:<br />

opinion.dt@dhakatribune.com<br />

www.dhakatribune.com<br />

Join our Facebook community:<br />

https://www.facebook.com/<br />

DhakaTribune.<br />

The views expressed in opinion<br />

articles are those of the authors<br />

alone and they are not the<br />

official view of Dhaka Tribune<br />

or its publisher.<br />

These bans must end<br />

Bangla Academy’s decision to ban Srabon Prokashoni from the Amar<br />

Ekushey Boi Mela simply cannot be justified.<br />

The publishing house has been barred from participating in the<br />

annual book fair for two years only because of its vocal protest<br />

against the shuttering of Badwip Prokashoni’s stall at this year’s Ekushey Boi<br />

Mela.<br />

Earlier this year, Badwip Prokashoni’s stall was raided by the police in the<br />

Suhrawardy Udyan part of the book fair. Law enforcers justified the raid by<br />

claiming that the publishers had been carrying a book that was said to have<br />

offended a group of religious extremists.<br />

In a country where freedom of expression is a constitutionally protected<br />

fundamental right, the decision to ban Srabon Prokashoni from the book fair<br />

for protesting a ban that they felt was misplaced, is unacceptable.<br />

The rationale expressed by the authorities in placing the ban holds little<br />

water when we consider what an event like the Ekushey Boi Mela represents.<br />

Freedom of thought and expression are the cornerstones of what makes for<br />

a book fair -- to say that a publishing house’s peaceful protest was “upsetting<br />

the soundness of the fair” makes a mockery of the entire concept of a festival<br />

dedicated to free expression.<br />

Frankly, there was very little justification for the original ban on Badwip<br />

Prokashoni to begin with.<br />

To small-time publishers such as Badwip and Srabon Prokashoni, the<br />

Ekushey Boi Mela is a rare chance to make their mark on the industry. And<br />

doing so requires them to go through innumerable hurdles and layers upon<br />

layers of bureaucracy.<br />

Bans such as these are a slap in the face to anyone attempting to break into<br />

the publishing business and have a negative impact far beyond the publishing<br />

houses that are affected.<br />

Instead of shuttering their stall, we believe that the Bangla Academy, and<br />

perhaps the police, should have taken a more nuanced approach to deal with<br />

the issue.<br />

We understand that public sentiment needs to be protected, but there are<br />

ways to do that without compromising the sanctity of an event such as the<br />

Ekushey Boi Mela.<br />

There may be many reasons for a publisher to be banned from the Boi<br />

Mela, but protesting an unjustified decision is not one of them.<br />

Bangla Academy needs to realise this, and lift the ban as soon as possible.<br />

MAHMUD HOSSAIN OPU<br />

There may be many<br />

reasons for a publisher to<br />

be banned from the Boi<br />

Mela, but protesting an<br />

unjustified decision is not<br />

one of them


Opinion 21<br />

DT<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Bangla Academy, the Srabon Publishers<br />

ban, and the long shadow of Ayub Khan<br />

Is Srabon Prokashoni’s ban from the Ekushey Boi Mela a sign of our culture being compromised?<br />

The Ekushey Boi Mela is synonymous with Bengali culture<br />

MAHMUD HOSSAIN OPU<br />

• Afsan Chowdhury<br />

Bangla Academy, in its<br />

infinite wisdom, has<br />

banned Srabon Publishers<br />

from having a stall at the<br />

Ekushey Boi Mela this year.<br />

The excuse is that it disrupted<br />

the book fair last year by<br />

protesting the closure of a stall and<br />

the arrest of a fellow publisher.<br />

This publisher was accused<br />

of publishing books which were<br />

considered anti-religious in nature<br />

by the police, but the legal verdict<br />

is not there.<br />

Srabon protested the decision<br />

last year and so it has been banned<br />

from hosting a stall for the next<br />

two years.<br />

Not only is this decision<br />

insensible but, given the fact that<br />

court judgment on the case is not<br />

out, also illegal.<br />

Guilt has been assumed of a<br />

case still not decided.<br />

* * * * *<br />

Most people are not familiar with<br />

the name of Field Marshall Ayub<br />

Srabon protested the decision last year and so it has been banned from<br />

hosting a stall for the next two years. Not only is this decision insensible<br />

but, given the fact that court judgment on the case is not out, also illegal<br />

Khan, the man who ruled Pakistan<br />

from 1958 to 1969 and basically<br />

killed Pakistan. He did the most of<br />

playing politics with culture.<br />

Ayub tried to ban Tagore,<br />

arrested cultural activists of<br />

East Pakistan, promoted a<br />

military brand of civilian culture,<br />

promoted wealth-making and<br />

wealth concentration, initiated<br />

the Agartala conspiracy against<br />

Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib and<br />

others, and considered Bangalis<br />

uncivilised all in the hope of<br />

strengthening Pakistan.<br />

The result was, of course,<br />

the exact opposite. And East<br />

Pakistanis gave up on whatever<br />

little confidence they had in<br />

Pakistan and began to make their<br />

own plans.<br />

It made Bengali culture strong,<br />

created many resistance points,<br />

and basically initiated the 1969<br />

political movement which ended<br />

his rule.<br />

Ayub was followed by Yahya<br />

Khan’s rule and finally the<br />

elections of 1970 which ended<br />

Pakistan itself.<br />

Among other things, the biggest<br />

lesson from his history is that<br />

don’t play a cultural mastaan in a<br />

neighbourhood which has a long<br />

history of resistance to similar<br />

efforts. Chances are, the mastaan<br />

exits but the neighborhood stays<br />

on.<br />

* * *<br />

If certain rumours are to<br />

be believed, then a political<br />

disservice is done through this<br />

incident as well, and the price may<br />

have to be paid by the party in<br />

power in terms of its popularity.<br />

The Bangla Academy is a<br />

symbol of resistance, and is rooted<br />

in the 21 points of the United<br />

Front of 1954 which birthed and<br />

organised Bengali nationalismbased<br />

politics, so please respect<br />

the spirit of the birth of the<br />

institution.<br />

It’s not always about singing<br />

and dancing and chatting and<br />

walking around the Mela -- it’s<br />

about upholding the cultural<br />

essence of a people who have a<br />

long tradition of not taking it lying<br />

down.<br />

One may not have liked the<br />

fact that Sarabon and others had<br />

protested, but to accept protest as<br />

a valid form of cultural activism is<br />

important.<br />

Compliant culture is impotent.<br />

When protest dies, so does<br />

culture. Srabon is more in line<br />

with the spirit of Ekushey than any<br />

of the parties involved in its ban.<br />

* * * * *<br />

Protest, small or big, will happen<br />

and it may well grow on the issue.<br />

The Bangla Academy belongs to<br />

the people, not the government.<br />

Unless the ban is withdrawn,<br />

which has been put into effect on<br />

such absurd grounds and with the<br />

intent of punishing a dissident<br />

protestor, the consequences will<br />

have an impact on all parties<br />

involved.<br />

History shows that trying to<br />

kill dissidence never works, and<br />

Pakistan and the Soviet Union are<br />

two very good examples. Why try<br />

to be yet another? •<br />

Afsan Chowdhury is a journalist and<br />

researcher.


22<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

Opinion<br />

Oppressors and exploiters, be careful<br />

The plight of the Santals is nothing if not heart-wrenching<br />

• Zahir Ahmed and Fiaz Sharif<br />

It’s winter in late November<br />

<strong>2016</strong>. We are accompanied by<br />

a local Santal young man to<br />

visit the Gobindaganj Santal<br />

villages since the massacre in early<br />

November. There is a sense of an<br />

external intervention instantly<br />

from the wire fence around the<br />

crop fields.<br />

Near the temporary<br />

accommodation given to the<br />

evicted villagers, are posters<br />

written in both Bangla and Santal<br />

languages. Whilst not explained,<br />

these posters have statements<br />

which convey the nature of<br />

dissatisfaction -- they are merely<br />

another form of protest.<br />

While the posters are a visual<br />

representation of the Santal, taken<br />

from their muddy house walls<br />

around the villages, the messages<br />

reflect and convey the historical<br />

roots of their struggle, focusing<br />

on some elements of the glorious<br />

historical movements led by<br />

heroes like Kanu and Sidhu whilst<br />

appealing to the government to<br />

give their land back.<br />

They read: “It is our land, we<br />

used to own it” … “Honorable<br />

administration, find our<br />

disappeared individuals” …<br />

“Stop filing cases against the<br />

Santals” … “It is impossible to stop<br />

indigenous peoples’ movement<br />

with a gun.”<br />

Some slogans are written in<br />

in the Santali language: “Diku<br />

pera janum jati Husiar Husiar”<br />

(the oppressors and exploiters,<br />

be careful); “Sidhu kanu rakapen,<br />

hule hul hule hul, bagda farm hasa<br />

lagit, Hule hul hule hul” (wake up<br />

the successors of Sidhu-Kanu,<br />

wake up the inhabitants of Bagda<br />

farm).<br />

Not surprisingly, the legacy of<br />

the Santals’ current protest is more<br />

complex than the official version<br />

would have us believe.<br />

Some Santal farmers showed<br />

their anger with a grimace when<br />

we wanted to talk more. They<br />

said that the whole affair is a bit<br />

disappointing -- they have been<br />

frequently asked similar questions<br />

by numerous journalists and<br />

activities. Nothing was beneficial<br />

to them. They argue: “All are<br />

with the leaders and the sugar<br />

mill authority. Do you have a<br />

solution?”<br />

Some villagers told us that<br />

they had lost household property.<br />

When the district administration<br />

sent food as relief, the protestors<br />

did not receive it although they<br />

had been hungry for three to four<br />

days.<br />

A group of individuals gave an<br />

Will the Santals ever get their land back?<br />

eloquent description of the recent<br />

massacre: “The political thugs<br />

are obsessed with death and see<br />

it around every corner and our<br />

blood drips from every plant in the<br />

field. The only way to live in such<br />

a terrifying world is to leave our<br />

ancestral lands.”<br />

Mongol Mardee is standing<br />

beside the wire fence, looking at<br />

the paddy fields with blood-thirsty<br />

eyes. We have walked the short<br />

distance here from his demolished<br />

house, with its makeshift<br />

dwelling, where we saw that many<br />

others have been compelled to<br />

lead sub-human lives as attackers<br />

have vandalised and set their<br />

homes ablaze, looted everything,<br />

including food grains, valuable<br />

things, and domestic animals.<br />

Mardee doesn’t like living as<br />

a refugee in his own ancestral<br />

land. He says: “Seeing the wire<br />

fence and giant machine which<br />

has harvested their green paddy,<br />

brings indescribable pain. We met<br />

some mill officials near the fields.<br />

We have asked them a very simple<br />

question: ‘Why are the officials in<br />

the field?’ They replied that the<br />

court had ordered them to harvest<br />

the paddy as early as possible.”<br />

The story highlights how, within<br />

the minority context, the official<br />

statement is motivated. Yet,<br />

whilst land-grabbing politics is<br />

evident, efforts are made to ignore<br />

them. The hidden political view<br />

is rendered apolitical via the<br />

anodyne language and benevolent<br />

efforts. Within this context,<br />

the apparently philanthropic<br />

transcripts of the players involved<br />

in the massacre can be understood<br />

as a form of governance in which<br />

the entitlement rights of the<br />

minority that cause the massacre<br />

are not interrogated, the status<br />

quo remains unquestioned, and<br />

neo-liberal ideologies asserted.<br />

On our return to Dhaka, we<br />

stopped again in front of the wire<br />

fence. Hemonto Tudu of Madarpur<br />

squats patiently in front of the<br />

fence, staring through the barbed<br />

wire into the paddy fields.<br />

It’s a new world to him -- new<br />

management with giant machines<br />

to harvest, a new place where<br />

police are deployed, mill workers<br />

turned into agricultural labourers<br />

with trousers and helmets, and<br />

security regulations strictly<br />

upheld.<br />

A placard near the entrance<br />

declares the area protected.<br />

Further on, a big power tiller is<br />

neatly parked next to paddy straws<br />

to till the land for sugar cane<br />

plantation.<br />

This is a new world to Hemonto,<br />

one beyond his imagination.<br />

He was narrating his past days<br />

when he used to pass this field<br />

across narrow muddy paths that<br />

led him into his Joypur home<br />

village with his cattle. It is because<br />

of this contrast that Hemonto is<br />

MEHEDI HASAN<br />

While the posters are visual representation of the Santal, taken from<br />

their muddy house walls around the villages, the messages reflect<br />

and convey the historical roots of their struggle<br />

here. He could not stop crying<br />

about the recent massacre, about<br />

how brutally demolished were the<br />

houses.<br />

He is now helpless, hanging<br />

around the wire fences with his<br />

matted hair and lunatic eyes.<br />

Before we part towards<br />

Gobindaganj, and Hemonto Tudu<br />

heads back to his temporary<br />

shelter, he takes our hands and<br />

makes a request that, wherever we<br />

have a chance to do something for<br />

them in Dhaka, we should.<br />

His words haunted us as we<br />

later sped down a tarmac road to<br />

Dhaka. •<br />

Dr Zahir Ahmed is a Professor,<br />

Department of Anthropology,<br />

Jahangirnagar University. Fiaz Sharif is<br />

an MPhil Researcher, Department of<br />

Anthropology, Jahangirnagar University.


Opinion 23<br />

Second time’s a coronation<br />

Narayanganj just showed the country how a proper election is carried out<br />

DT<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Have we found a true ‘people’s champion’?<br />

MAHMUD HOSSAIN OPU<br />

to expect the party to lay its fort<br />

out against a proven vote-winner<br />

like Ivy was unreasonable. Almost<br />

whimsical.<br />

The conditions were ripe for a<br />

reconciliation. And there was one,<br />

of sorts. Or as much as there can<br />

be between the two houses laying<br />

claim to the soul of the Awami<br />

League in Narayanganj.<br />

Ignoring its Narayanganj unit’s<br />

recommendations, the centre went<br />

with Ivy, in what was very much<br />

a case of the AL latching onto Ivy<br />

rather than the other way around.<br />

The result was never in doubt, of<br />

course.<br />

The BNP’s fortunes in<br />

Narayanganj have long been on the<br />

wane, and there was nothing to<br />

suggest they were about to arrest<br />

the slide. The fact that Khaleda Zia<br />

didn’t even bother to show up and<br />

lend her support to the campaign<br />

said a lot about the state of play.<br />

Osman, eager to fall in line<br />

with the party command after a<br />

reported telling-off, had taken<br />

it upon himself to prevent that<br />

occurrence, as he did once before,<br />

famously in 1996. But this time<br />

around there was also the distinct<br />

lack of a challenge in the air to stir<br />

the teapot, as it were.<br />

And so, a bit of national-level<br />

anti-incumbency, perhaps, ate into<br />

her winning margin, but it was<br />

never going to be enough.<br />

The BNP, instead of falling<br />

into the trap of looking at it as<br />

a debacle, should plainly state<br />

the hill was always too steep for<br />

them and not read too much into<br />

analysis of why they failed to<br />

win as many votes as -- as what<br />

exactly? As required to win? They<br />

were never going to.<br />

To prevent Ivy from winning<br />

positively wholesome election,<br />

right down to the post-victory<br />

visit by Ivy to her defeated rival’s<br />

residence, sweets in tow.<br />

Not an accusation of voter fraud<br />

in sight, at least not the kind we<br />

may understand as such.<br />

Rakibuddin Ahmad’s outgoing<br />

Election Commission needn’t fish<br />

for compliments, there’s nothing<br />

genuine about whatever has been<br />

on offer.<br />

The country can’t wait to see<br />

their backs. Ivy was accompanied<br />

by her brother, carrying on<br />

a tradition she has wound<br />

since 2003, when she was first<br />

elected chairman of the local<br />

administration in Narayanganj.<br />

She would be elected chairman yet<br />

another time, before Narayanganj<br />

won city corporation status.<br />

In a sense, she is the only<br />

politician the AL, as embodied by<br />

the figure of the prime minister,<br />

has bent to in the last five or six<br />

years, recognising in her a true<br />

people’s champion.<br />

Will that aura brush off now<br />

that she is to be absorbed into<br />

the party central? Or will the AL<br />

allow her to flourish and emerge<br />

onto the national stage, where<br />

she would seem to belong? Might<br />

she get the sense of it herself, and<br />

seek a parliamentary seat in future<br />

perhaps?<br />

That might test the uneasy<br />

compromise struck between the<br />

Osman household, and that of Ali<br />

Ahmed Chunkha in Narayanganj<br />

-- although nothing that a party<br />

leader’s stern hand shouldn’t be<br />

able to sort out. •<br />

Shayan S Khan is Executive Editor,<br />

Dhaka Courier, and Senior News Editor,<br />

UNB.<br />

• Shayan S Khan<br />

Narayanganj’s second city<br />

corporation elections<br />

caused nowhere the<br />

same drama, at least<br />

around the day of the election<br />

itself, as did in its first -- a<br />

memorable contest made all the<br />

more so by the final result.<br />

The 2011 version featured<br />

a thumping victory for rebel<br />

candidate Selina Hayat Ivy, against<br />

the Awami League’s establishment<br />

candidate Shamim Osman, back<br />

from being encamped in India<br />

during the course of the two-year<br />

interregnum summed up as 1/11,<br />

and in pursuit of an elected office.<br />

Having not made it for the 2008<br />

parliamentary cohort, the mayor’s<br />

seat, that too Narayanganj’s first at<br />

having acceded to city corporation<br />

status, presented a welcome<br />

The same Ivy, only this time in what was never a contest but much<br />

more of a coronation, registered a preciously rare show of strength at<br />

the ballot box for the ruling party -- in the form of a victory unsullied by<br />

accusations or indeed, evidence, of electoral malpractice<br />

alternative.<br />

But it was not to be. Ivy<br />

whooped him by over 100,000<br />

votes.<br />

Fast forward to <strong>2016</strong>: The same<br />

Ivy, only this time in what was<br />

never a contest but much more<br />

of a coronation, or some such<br />

ceremony, even as her winning<br />

margin dropped, registered a<br />

preciously rare show of strength at<br />

the ballot box for the ruling party<br />

-- in the form of a victory unsullied<br />

by accusations or indeed,<br />

evidence, of electoral malpractice.<br />

The election was effectively<br />

fought on the day of the AL<br />

nomination, where Osman’s<br />

favoured candidate was snubbed<br />

by the party central command, and<br />

clearly he had been swayed by his<br />

most respected leader’s abiding<br />

wisdom.<br />

He was even back in parliament<br />

now, having snuck in as part of the<br />

unopposed batch in 2014. For him<br />

handsomely? Even that would<br />

have been difficult. To at least<br />

reduce her margin of victory<br />

significantly, showing enough<br />

of a swing away from Ivy as<br />

the AL candidate (compared<br />

to her victory in 2011 as a rebel<br />

candidate), to keep BNP interested<br />

in Narayanganj for the next round<br />

of parliamentary elections in 2019?<br />

At close to <strong>30</strong>,000, that would<br />

seem to have been achieved.<br />

The stage was set also, for a


DT<br />

24<br />

Sport<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

TOP STORIES<br />

A good opportunity<br />

lost, says Mashrafe<br />

Excerpts from the post-match<br />

press conference of Bangladesh<br />

captain Mashrafe bin Mortaza<br />

following their 67-run defeat<br />

against New Zealand in the second<br />

ODI at Saxton Oval in Nelson<br />

yesterday. PAGE 25<br />

Former world No 1<br />

Ivanovic retires<br />

Former French Open champion<br />

Ana Ivanovic of Serbia announced<br />

her retirement from tennis at<br />

the relatively young age of 29 on<br />

Wednesday because she no longer<br />

feels fit enough to compete at the<br />

highest level. PAGE 26<br />

Tevez agrees to join<br />

Shanghai Shenhua<br />

Carlos Tevez became the latest<br />

high-profile international to join<br />

the Chinese Super League when<br />

Shanghai Shenhua confirmed the<br />

signing of the Argentine striker<br />

from his boyhood club Boca<br />

Juniors yesterday. PAGE 27<br />

The good, the bad<br />

and the ugly<br />

In terms of results of the national<br />

team, Bangladesh football will<br />

be closing the chapter of one of<br />

its worst years. However, the<br />

U16 women’s success ensured<br />

Bangladesh had something be<br />

proud of in <strong>2016</strong>. PAGE 28<br />

New Zealand captain Kane Williamson bowls to Bangladesh batsman Mosaddek Hossain as wicket-keeper Luke Ronchi<br />

looks on during their second one-day international at Saxton Oval in Nelson yesterday<br />

AFP<br />

Bangladesh batting collapse<br />

hands Kiwis ODI series win<br />

• Reuters<br />

Recalled batsman Neil Broom<br />

scored his maiden one-day century<br />

and took two crucial catches as<br />

New Zealand completed a 67-run<br />

victory over Bangladesh in the<br />

second one-day international at<br />

Saxton Oval in Nelson yesterday.<br />

The victory allowed New Zealand<br />

to wrap up the three-match<br />

series with a game to spare as captain<br />

Kane Williamson chipped in<br />

with a throw that led to a run out,<br />

a catch and three wickets with his<br />

part-time off-spin.<br />

Chasing 252 for victory, Bangladesh<br />

had been cruising at 105<br />

for one in the 23rd over before<br />

Williamson sparked a collapse<br />

with the run out of Sabbir Rahman<br />

for 38 after he had combined<br />

in a 75-run partnership with<br />

opener Imrul Kayes.<br />

Williamson then had all-rounder<br />

Shakib Al Hasan caught at backward<br />

point by Broom, who also<br />

snapped up Imrul off Tim Southee<br />

for 59, as the visitors slumped<br />

to 141-7 by the 33rd over.<br />

They were eventually bowled<br />

out for 184 in the 43rd over.<br />

Broom, who was recalled for<br />

the series six years after the last<br />

of his 22 previous one-day internationals,<br />

had propped up New<br />

Zealand’s below-par 251 all out<br />

with a composed innings.<br />

The 33-year-old, whose recall<br />

was partly necessitated by Ross<br />

Taylor needing time to recover<br />

from eye surgery, took his time<br />

to set a foundation and patiently<br />

built his innings on a wicket that<br />

was good for batting on when established.<br />

He also combined in a 51-run<br />

partnership with all-rounder Jimmy<br />

Neesham (28) and for 64 runs<br />

with Luke Ronchi (35), but they<br />

both got out when the home side<br />

needed them to stay with Broom<br />

to launch an assault in the final<br />

overs.<br />

Broom, whose previous best<br />

was 71 against the same opposition<br />

in 2010, was on 99 when<br />

Lockie Ferguson was the ninth<br />

wicket to fall in the 47th over.<br />

Trent Boult, however, survived<br />

the last ball of the over and Broom<br />

then pushed a single into the covers<br />

on the first ball of the 48th to<br />

bring up the milestone.<br />

He finished on 109 not out,<br />

having hit eight boundaries and<br />

three sixes.•<br />

New Zealand batsman Neil Broom<br />

celebrates his maiden ODI ton AFP<br />

BDvNZ, 2ND ODI<br />

NEW ZEALAND R B<br />

M. Guptill lbw Mashrafe 0 4<br />

T. Latham lbw Shakib 22 35<br />

K. Williamson c Shakib b Taskin 14 35<br />

N. Broom not out 109 107<br />

J. Neesham st Nurul b Mosaddek 28 31<br />

C. Munro b Mashrafe 3 7<br />

L. Ronchi c Tanveer b Taskin 35 38<br />

M. Santner c Mashrafe b Subashis 9 17<br />

T. Southee c Nurul b Shakib 3 7<br />

L. Ferguson c Nurul b Mashrafe 4 7<br />

T. Boult run out (Nurul/Taskin) 12 12<br />

Extras (b1, lb7, w4) 12<br />

Total (all out, 50 overs) 251<br />

Fall of wickets<br />

1-0 (Guptill), 2-37 (Williamson), 3-47<br />

(Latham), 4-98 (Neesham), 5-107 (Munro),<br />

6-171 (Ronchi), 7-198 (Santner), 8-214<br />

(Southee), 9-228 (Ferguson), 10-251<br />

(Boult)<br />

Bowling<br />

Mashrafe 10-1-49-3 (2w), Subashis 10-1-<br />

45-1 (1w), Taskin 10-1-45-2 (1w), Shakib<br />

10-0-45-2, Tanveer 8-0-47-0, Mosaddek<br />

2-0-12-1<br />

BANGLADESH R B<br />

Tamim c Latham b Southee 16 23<br />

Imrul c Broom b Southee 59 89<br />

Sabbir run out (Williamson/Ronchi) 38 49<br />

Mahmudullah b Ferguson 1 10<br />

Shakib c Broom b Williamson 7 10<br />

Mosaddek c Neesham b Williamson 3 8<br />

Tanveer st Ronchi b Williamson 2 5<br />

Nurul Hasan c Ronchi b Boult 24 31<br />

Mashrafe c Williamson b Boult 17 19<br />

Taskin st Ronchi b Santner 0 4<br />

Subashis not out 1 9<br />

Extras (b1, lb4, w10, nb1) 16<br />

Total (all out; 42.4 overs) 184<br />

Fall of wickets<br />

1-<strong>30</strong> (Tamim Iqbal, 2-105 (Sabbir Rahman),<br />

3-112 (Mahmudullah), 4-128 (Shakib Al<br />

Hasan), 5-134 (Mosaddek Hossain), 6-136<br />

(Imrul Kayes), 7-141 (Tanveer), 8-162<br />

(Mashrafe), 9-175 (Taskin), 10-184 (Nurul)<br />

Bowling<br />

Boult 8.4-0-26-2 (3w), Southee 9-1-33-2<br />

(2w), Munro 2-0-12-0, Ferguson 8-0-53-1<br />

(2w, 1nb), Santner 8-1-20-1 (1w), Neesham<br />

2-0-13-0 (1w), Williamson 5-0-22-3 (1w)<br />

Result: New Zealand won by 67 runs


Sport 25<br />

Bangladesh players watch the screen as a DRS decision is made on New Zealand’s Tom Latham during their second ODI at Saxton Oval in Nelson yesterday<br />

‘A good opportunity lost for Bangladesh’<br />

• Tribune Report<br />

Excerpts from the post-match<br />

press conference of Bangladesh<br />

captain Mashrafe bin Mortaza following<br />

their 67-run defeat against<br />

New Zealand in the second ODI at<br />

Saxton Oval in Nelson yesterday.<br />

“I think losing too many wickets.<br />

If you see, we had 100 runs on<br />

the board for the loss of one wicket.<br />

Then we lost nine scoring 84.<br />

It is very disappointing. It clearly<br />

Tanbir warned for breaching<br />

code of conduct<br />

• Tribune Report<br />

Bangladesh all-rounder Tanbir<br />

Hayder failed to make a<br />

memorable debut after being<br />

included for the second oneday<br />

international against New<br />

Zealand at Saxton Oval in<br />

Nelson yesterday. The lower<br />

middle-order right-handed<br />

batsman scored only two runs<br />

in his maiden appearance for<br />

the Tigers while with the ball,<br />

he gave away 47 runs without<br />

success in eight overs.<br />

His frustration was doubled<br />

when the 25-year old received<br />

an official reprimand<br />

shows that the batting collapse was<br />

the reason behind the loss. I think<br />

the bowling was set up nicely. The<br />

wicket we got was better than the<br />

other match but again, losing wickets<br />

was the key.<br />

“I think he (Kane Williamson)<br />

did really well. He took some of our<br />

vital wickets. We knew he is an occasional<br />

bowler and was not in our<br />

plans. But the way he bowled was<br />

beautiful and credit goes to him.<br />

But I think we could have handled<br />

for breaching Level 1 of the<br />

International Cricket Council’s<br />

code of conduct.<br />

Tanbir was found to have<br />

breached article 2.1.4 of the<br />

ICC’s code of conduct for players<br />

and player support personnel,<br />

which relates to “using<br />

language or a gesture that is<br />

obscene, offensive or insulting<br />

during an international match”.<br />

In addition to the reprimand<br />

for his breach of article<br />

2.1.4, one demerit point has<br />

been added to Tanbir’s disciplinary<br />

record.<br />

If Tanbir reaches four or<br />

more demerit points within a<br />

him better.<br />

“That dismissal (run out mix up<br />

between Imrul Kayes and Sabbir<br />

Rahman) was the game-changer<br />

and key moment for New Zealand.<br />

We were going nicely in the chase<br />

with 100 runs for one wicket and<br />

then 150 runs in 27 overs. It was<br />

nicely set-up for us. The run out<br />

was crucial for us I think.<br />

“We were very confident of<br />

chasing the target, especially because<br />

of the wickets we had in<br />

24-month period, the points<br />

will be converted into suspension<br />

points and he will<br />

be banned. Two suspension<br />

points equate to a ban from one<br />

Test or two ODIs or two Twenty20<br />

internationals, whatever<br />

comes first for the player.<br />

The incident happened in<br />

the last ball of the 19th over<br />

when Tanbir, after being hit for<br />

a four by batsman Neil Broom,<br />

used obscene language which<br />

was heard by the umpires.<br />

Tanbir admitted the offence<br />

and accepted the sanction, as<br />

such, there was no need for a<br />

formal hearing. •<br />

AFP<br />

DT<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Mushfiq a priority for Tests<br />

• Tribune Report<br />

hand. We knew in the second half it<br />

will be going flat and it did, the evidence<br />

was there. In the last match,<br />

there was swing in the wicket in the<br />

second half. So when the ball is not<br />

swinging, it is almost like playing at<br />

home (Bangladesh) conditions. But<br />

the collapse was our undoing. It is<br />

disappointing.<br />

“The sub-continent teams<br />

which come to play here look for<br />

the opportunity that we had [yesterday].<br />

We leaked 40 to 50 runs<br />

Bangladesh wicketkeeper-batsman Mushfiqur<br />

Rahim started a rehab programme<br />

yesterday in a bid to recover from his left<br />

hamstring injury and get ready for the twomatch<br />

Test series, starting from January 12.<br />

Mushfiq, the Bangladesh Test captain,<br />

suffered the injury during the first ODI<br />

against hosts New Zealand at Hagley Oval<br />

in Christchurch last Monday. Mushfiq underwent<br />

an MRI in Nelson yesterday and<br />

the scan report confirmed a grade one tear.<br />

The injury ruled out the right-handed batsman<br />

not only from the ODIs but also from<br />

the three-match Twenty20 international<br />

series, beginning this Tuesday.<br />

“We have received the radiologist’s report<br />

and it shows a minor tear of the left<br />

hamstring,” said Bangladesh physio Dean<br />

Conway in a media release.<br />

“This is a moderate damage in nature<br />

Bangladesh<br />

tour of South<br />

Africa itinerary<br />

announced<br />

• Tribune Report<br />

Bangladesh will tour South Africa<br />

in September-October, 2017, for<br />

two Tests, 3 ODIs and two Twenty20<br />

internationals. Cricket South<br />

Africa yesterday announced the<br />

itinerary of Bangladesh’s tour.<br />

The Test series naming rights<br />

went to Sunfoil, ODI series to Momentum<br />

and T20I series to KFC.<br />

Bangladesh tour of South Africa<br />

Itinerary 2017-18<br />

September 21-23: Three-day tour<br />

match v SA Invitation XI, Benoni<br />

September 28-October 2: First Test,<br />

Senwes Park, Potchefstroom<br />

October 6-10: Second Test, Mangaung<br />

Oval, Bloemfontein<br />

October 12: One-day tour match v SA<br />

Invitation XI, Bloemfontein<br />

October 15: First ODI, Kimberley<br />

October 18: Second ODI, Paarl<br />

October 22: Third ODI, Buffalo Park<br />

October 26: First KFC T20I, Mangaung<br />

Oval, Bloemfontein<br />

October 29: Second KFC T20I, Senwes<br />

Park, Potchefstroom. •<br />

in the first game but still, we had<br />

created our chances of winning<br />

the game. [Yesterday] we had a<br />

flat wicket and were batting as required.<br />

So we had never expected<br />

such a collapse from that point. A<br />

big chance slipped out from our<br />

hands. Winning the game would<br />

have made us comfortable in the<br />

last game of the series. I think the<br />

batsmen could have slowed things<br />

down when we were losing wickets<br />

but it didn’t happen.” •<br />

but means that it could take him around<br />

two weeks, starting from the day of the injury,<br />

to recover. However, we may ease him<br />

into training at some stage over the next<br />

few days,” Conway added.<br />

Conway further said Bangladesh team<br />

management’s priority is to get their skipper<br />

fit before the longer-version matches.<br />

“We will continue to assess and monitor<br />

him to see how he is responding to rehab,”<br />

said Conway.<br />

Mushfiq’s injury saw young stumper-batsman<br />

Nurul Hasan make his ODI debut<br />

in the second of the three ODIs yesterday.<br />

The Tigers lost the match by 67 runs<br />

and in the process, conceded the series 2-0<br />

with a game to spare.<br />

Nurul made a decent enough debut<br />

scoring 24 runs under pressure at No 8 and<br />

took two catches. He also affected a stumping,<br />

that of Jimmy Neesham, off the bowling<br />

of Mosaddek Hossain.•


DT<br />

26<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Mohammedan finish 10th<br />

in top-flight football<br />

Sport<br />

• Tribune Report<br />

Local giant Mohammedan Sporting<br />

Club finished their Bangladesh Premier<br />

League <strong>2016</strong>-17 campaign at<br />

a disappointing 10th position after<br />

they were held to a goalless draw<br />

by Uttar Baridhara Club at Bangabandhu<br />

National Stadium yesterday.<br />

The traditional Black and Whites<br />

got a golden opportunity to break<br />

the deadlock in the ninth minute<br />

but Cameroonian defender Pouemi<br />

Landry’s shot from a Masuj Miah<br />

Jony chip hit the crosspiece.<br />

The Motijheel outfit got another<br />

chance to take the lead moments<br />

later but Aminur Rahman Sajib<br />

failed to tap in from a Ismael Bangoura<br />

through pass.<br />

Baridhara also went close to taking<br />

the lead in the 22nd minute but<br />

Guinean defender Sylla Mansa’s<br />

header from a Khalekuzzaman Sabuj<br />

corner hit the crosspost.<br />

Mohammedan concluded their<br />

campaign with 20 points from 22<br />

matches while Baridhara finished<br />

second from bottom in the 12-team<br />

standings with 18 points from the<br />

same number of outings as the former.<br />

Meanwhile in the other game of<br />

the day at the same venue, Sheikh<br />

Russel Krira Chakra and Sheikh Jamal<br />

Dhanmondi Club played out a<br />

1-1 draw.<br />

Sheikh Jamal finished third with<br />

32 points from 22 outings while<br />

Sheikh Russel ended a disappointing<br />

eighth with 25 points from 22<br />

games.•<br />

Action from the Bangladesh Premier League game between Sheikh Russel Krira Chakra and Sheikh Jamal Dhanmondi Club at<br />

Bangabandhu National Stadium yesterday<br />

MD MANIK<br />

SAFF WOMEN’S CHAMPIONSHIP <strong>2016</strong><br />

Women hit Afghanistan for six<br />

• Tribune Report<br />

The dominant Bangladesh women’s<br />

football team reached the semi-final<br />

of the South Asian Football Federation<br />

Championship after thrashing<br />

Afghanistan 6-0 in Siliguri’s<br />

Kanchanjonga Stadium yesterday.<br />

In Group B, India had earlier<br />

defeated the Afghans 5-1 and Bangladesh’s<br />

huge victory meant it was<br />

them, alongside the hosts, who<br />

made it to the last four.<br />

Captain Sabina Khatun scored<br />

four times for Bangladesh in the<br />

sixth, 15th, 40th and 44th minute.<br />

The women in red and green<br />

will now face India tomorrow to<br />

Double ton-up Nasir shines in run-filled NCL day three<br />

• Tribune Report<br />

All-rounder Nasir Hossain provided<br />

the perfect answer to his critics<br />

after smashing his maiden firstclass<br />

double hundred as Rangpur<br />

took the first-innings lead against<br />

Sylhet in the third day of the ongoing<br />

18th Walton National Cricket<br />

League’s fifth round yesterday.<br />

Chittagong are in the driving<br />

seat and heading towards a huge<br />

target against Rajshahi while Dhaka<br />

will look to stretch their lead<br />

against Khulna.<br />

Dhaka Metropolis, meanwhile,<br />

managed a first-innings lead<br />

against Barisal, despite the former<br />

posting a modest total.<br />

Dhaka Metro v Barisal, BKSP 3<br />

Dhaka Metro took the all-important<br />

first-innings lead after Barisal were<br />

all out for 280 having resumed the<br />

see who finish as group champions.<br />

Bangladesh had also defeated<br />

Afghanistan 6-1 in the last edition<br />

of the tournament in Pakistan two<br />

years ago with the then young sensation<br />

Krishna Rani Sarkar scoring<br />

a hattrick and Sabina netting one.<br />

With that said, Afghanistan are<br />

not the same side they used to be<br />

before as they have improved in<br />

bits and pieces under their American<br />

head coach. They lost 11-0 and<br />

12-0 against three-time champions<br />

India in the last two editions.<br />

This is the fourth edition of the<br />

Saff Women’s Championship, a<br />

tournament in which Bangladesh<br />

have never reached the final.<br />

third and penultimate day’s play<br />

on 165/5. Overnight batsman Al<br />

Amin was the highest scorer with<br />

89 while Salman Hossain added 55.<br />

Fast bowler Abu Haider Rony<br />

and left-arm spinner Elias Sunny<br />

bagged four wickets each for the<br />

bowling side. Dhaka Metro will resume<br />

the fourth day today on 138/4<br />

and will look to extend their 150-<br />

run lead with six wickets in hand.<br />

Dhaka v Khulna, Fatullah<br />

Dhaka concluded yesterday on<br />

103/3 and are leading by 127 runs<br />

in their second innings after Khulna<br />

were dismissed for 342. Veteran<br />

batsman Tushar Imran struck yet<br />

another century and was eventually<br />

dismissed after scoring 141 off<br />

240 balls with 19 fours.<br />

However, Khulna were 24 runs<br />

shy after Dhaka posted 366. Pace<br />

bowler Dewan Sabbir picked up<br />

Prior to the tournament, forward<br />

Sabina wanted to concentrate firmly<br />

on their first game before eventually<br />

setting their sights on the last four.<br />

No doubt yesterday’s performance<br />

will satisfy her a great deal.<br />

This time around, Bangladesh<br />

women’s team are more confident<br />

with their prospects after the under-16<br />

girls’ immense success in<br />

the Asian Football Confederation’s<br />

U-16 Women’s Championship qualifiers<br />

in September this year. Meanwhile,<br />

Group A comprises Nepal,<br />

Bhutan, Maldives and Sri Lanka.<br />

Nepal thrashed Bhutan 8-0 while<br />

Maldives thumped Sri Lanka 5-2 in<br />

the opening day on Monday. •<br />

five wickets for the bowling side.<br />

Sylhet v Rangpur, Sylhet<br />

It was rather a one-man show in<br />

the tier two game where Nasir remained<br />

unbeaten after blasting a<br />

double ton. The right-hander was<br />

finally dismissed for 201 off 343<br />

balls with the help of 24 fours and<br />

three sixes as Rangpur took their<br />

first-innings lead to 126 runs. They<br />

posted 398 in reply to Sylhet’s 272.<br />

Fast bowler Abu Jayed took<br />

five wickets while Khaled Ahmed<br />

picked up four for the bowling<br />

side. However, Sylhet once against<br />

struggled with the bat in the second<br />

innings and will resume the<br />

fourth day on 43/3 with opening<br />

batsman Imtiaz Hossain still at the<br />

crease on 20.<br />

Chittagong v Rajshahi, Chittagong<br />

Chittagong are in the driving seat<br />

Ivanovic retires at age 29<br />

• Reuters, Belgrade<br />

Former French Open champion<br />

Ana Ivanovic announced her retirement<br />

from tennis at the age of<br />

29 on Wednesday because she no<br />

longer feels fit enough to compete<br />

at the highest level.<br />

Ivanovic became the first Serbian<br />

woman to win a grand slam<br />

tournament when she beat Russian<br />

Dinara Safina in the 2008 French<br />

Open final.<br />

“There is no other way to say it. I<br />

have decided to retire from professional<br />

tennis. It has been a difficult<br />

decision but there is so much to<br />

celebrate,” Belgrade-born Ivanovic<br />

said on Facebook.<br />

“I was the world number one<br />

and won Roland Garros in 2008,<br />

after Rajshahi were bundled out for<br />

2<strong>30</strong>. Left-arm spinner Kazi Kamrul<br />

Islam bagged four wickets for the<br />

bowling side.<br />

In reply, Chittagong finished the<br />

third day on 229/3 with Yasir Ali not<br />

out on 78 while centurion of the<br />

first innings, Tasamul Haque, will<br />

resume the fourth day on 59. •<br />

I have seen the heights I never<br />

dreamt of achieving”.<br />

“I played so many memorable<br />

matches. But staying at those<br />

heights in any professional sport<br />

requires top physical form and it’s<br />

well-known that I have been hampered<br />

by injuries,” Ivanovic said.<br />

“I can only play if I perform up<br />

to my own high standards. I can no<br />

longer do that so it’s time to move<br />

on.”•<br />

18TH NCL, RD 5,<br />

DAY 3<br />

DHAKA METROPOLIS 292 & 138/4 in<br />

42 overs (Marshall 54, Mehrab Jr <strong>30</strong>*)<br />

lead BARISAL 280 in 81.2 overs (Al<br />

Amin 89, Rony 4/81) by 150 runs<br />

DHAKA 366 & 103/3 in 32 overs (Saif<br />

26, Raqibul 23) lead KHULNA 342 in<br />

96 overs (Tushar 141, Sabbir 5/58) by<br />

127 runs<br />

CHITTAGONG 315 & 229/3 in 83<br />

overs (Yasir 78*, Tasamul 59*) lead<br />

RAJSHAHI 2<strong>30</strong> in 72.2 overs (Jahurul<br />

90, Kamrul 4/74) by 314 runs<br />

SYLHET 272 & 44/3 in 15 overs (Imtiaz<br />

20*, Kapali 11*) trail RANGPUR 398 in<br />

119 overs (Nasir 201, Jayed 5/112) by 82<br />

runs


Sport 27<br />

DT<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

2ND TEST, DAY 4<br />

PAKISTAN FIRST INNINGS 443-9 DEC<br />

(A. Ali 205 not out, S. Khan 65; J. Hazlewood<br />

3-50, J. Bird 3-113)<br />

AUSTRALIA FIRST INNINGS R B<br />

(278-2 overnight)<br />

U. Khawaja c Sarfraz b Riaz 97 165<br />

S. Smith not out 100 168<br />

P. Handscomb c Sami b Sohail 54 90<br />

N. Maddinson b Yasir Shah 22 55<br />

M. Wade c Shafiq b Sohail 9 27<br />

M. Starc not out 7 8<br />

Extras (b1, lb8, nb13) 22<br />

Total (6 wickets, 113.5 overs) 465<br />

Bowling<br />

Amir 27-5-74-0 (1nb), Sohail 23.5-7-86-2,<br />

Y. Shah 34-2-150-2, Riaz 27-3-135-2 (12nb),<br />

Azhar 2-0-11-0<br />

Skipper Smith caps another big<br />

year with Melbourne ton<br />

• Reuters, Melbourne<br />

Australia captain Steve Smith’s love<br />

affair with the Melbourne Cricket<br />

Ground showed no sign of fading<br />

yesterday as he struck his third<br />

consecutive century in Boxing Day<br />

Tests to flatten Pakistan and finish<br />

another banner year with a bang.<br />

Smith’s unbeaten 100 carried<br />

Australia to 465 for six and a 22-run<br />

first innings lead after lunch on day<br />

four of the second Test before play<br />

was abandoned due to rain.<br />

The innings brought up his<br />

1,000th run in a calendar year for<br />

the third time in succession, a feat<br />

achieved by only one other Australian<br />

batsman, opener Matthew<br />

Hayden, who reached the mark in<br />

five consecutive years from 2001-05.<br />

Out of players who have batted<br />

at least five times at the MCG, only<br />

the great Don Bradman has a higher<br />

average, with 128.53 from his 17 innings<br />

versus the current captain’s<br />

114.60 from eight. With four centuries<br />

this year, Smith has now raced<br />

to 17 tons from a total of 90 innings<br />

in his career, with only Bradman<br />

(50 innings), Sunil Gavaskar (81)<br />

and Hayden (82) reaching the number<br />

faster.•<br />

Tevez agrees to join<br />

Shanghai Shenhua<br />

• Reuters<br />

Carlos Tevez became the latest<br />

high-profile international<br />

player to join the Chinese<br />

Super League when Shanghai<br />

Shenhua confirmed the signing<br />

of the Argentine striker<br />

from his boyhood club Boca<br />

Juniors yesterday.<br />

Although no financial details<br />

of the deal were released,<br />

media reports have suggested<br />

that the Chinese club paid 84<br />

million euros ($87.65 million)<br />

for Tevez, who returned to Argentina<br />

last year after spells in<br />

England and Italy.<br />

The hefty price tag will<br />

make Tevez the world’s sixth<br />

most expensive player, behind<br />

Paul Pogba, Gareth Bale,<br />

Cristiano Ronaldo, Gonzalo<br />

Higuain and Neymar, according<br />

to the German-based soccer<br />

information website transfermarkt.com.<br />

Tevez is also in line to become<br />

the sport’s highest paid<br />

player with the striker reportedly<br />

earning around $753,000<br />

per week on a two-year contract<br />

with Shanghai Shenhua.<br />

Boca Juniors offered Tevez<br />

their best wishes in a statement<br />

announcing his departure.•<br />

Bangladesh Army’s Adjutant General (AG) Major General SM Motiur<br />

Rahman distributes the winning trophy of the Joypurhat Girls Cadet<br />

College inter-house annual sports competition to Rajiya House<br />

yesterday<br />

ISPR<br />

DAY’S WATCH<br />

CRICKET<br />

TEN 3<br />

2:00PM<br />

Sri Lanka Tour of South Africa<br />

1st Test, Day 5<br />

STAR SPORTS 2<br />

5:<strong>30</strong>AM<br />

Pakistan Tour of Australia<br />

2nd Test, Day 5<br />

2:08 PM<br />

KFC T20 Big Bash League<br />

Brisbane Heat v Hobart Hurricanes<br />

STAR SPORTS SELECT HD 1<br />

3:00PM<br />

Premier League <strong>2016</strong>/17<br />

Hull City v Everton


DT<br />

28<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Sport<br />

The good, the bad and the ugly<br />

• Shishir Hoque<br />

In terms of results and performances<br />

of the national team, Bangladesh<br />

football will be closing the chapter<br />

of one of its worst years in recent<br />

times.<br />

However, the outstanding<br />

achievement of the national under-16<br />

women’s team ensured<br />

Bangladesh football had something<br />

be proud of in the year <strong>2016</strong>.<br />

In <strong>2016</strong>, Bangladesh played<br />

the most number of international<br />

matches in their recent history and<br />

at the end of the year, it became<br />

quite clear that the footballers<br />

failed awfully to utilise their chances<br />

in the final third. As a result,<br />

there was a distinct lack of goals as<br />

Bangladesh not only lost seven out<br />

of eight matches in the 2018 World<br />

Cup qualifiers but also failed to<br />

make it into the AFC Cup qualifiers<br />

after conceding their first ever defeat<br />

against minnows Bhutan.<br />

The national men’s team’s first<br />

international assignment this year<br />

was in January in the Bangabandhu<br />

Gold Cup. They won their first<br />

match against Sri Lanka in Jessore<br />

and it turned out to be their only<br />

victory in the whole year. They<br />

failed to reach the final, losing<br />

against an amateur Bahrain U-23<br />

side in the last four. The Bangladesh<br />

U-23 team followed the senior<br />

side almost to a tee, finishing<br />

third in the South Asian Games in<br />

India where they, starting as holders,<br />

eventually delivered a performance<br />

that was clearly not their<br />

best effort.<br />

Bangladesh’s last group stage<br />

match of the 2018 Russia World<br />

Cup qualifiers was held in March<br />

where they fell to one of their most<br />

humbling defeats (8-0) at the hands<br />

of Jordan. They still had chances<br />

to qualify for the Asian Football<br />

Confederation Cup 2019 qualifiers.<br />

The first obstacle was a tough one<br />

against Tajikistan, and they duly<br />

lost 6-0 on aggregate in June.<br />

Their last opponent were Bhutan<br />

against whom Bangladesh<br />

have the finest record among all<br />

the other teams, winning four and<br />

drawing two. Bhutan showed they<br />

are not the same side they used to<br />

be against Bangladesh during the<br />

lacklustre 1-1 draw in the first leg.<br />

In the second leg too, Bangladesh<br />

showed no signs of improvement,<br />

putting up a horrible defensive display<br />

to concede a 3-1 defeat away to<br />

Bhutan in October.<br />

Losing to Bhutan for the first<br />

time in history was not the biggest<br />

concern but what was difficult to<br />

accept was their soulless performance,<br />

despite having an experienced<br />

and qualified coach in the<br />

shape of Belgian Tom Saintfiet.<br />

Bangladesh have no major Fifa/<br />

Afc events at least for the next two<br />

years, right until the beginning of<br />

the qualifying round of the 2022<br />

Bangladesh under-16 women’s football team celebrate after finishing top in their qualifying group in the Asian Football Confederation’s U-16 Women’s Championship at<br />

Bangabandhu National Stadium in September this year<br />

MD MANIK<br />

World Cup and the 2023 Asian Cup<br />

so there is a lot of time for reflection.<br />

The federation’s lack of attention<br />

towards the players’ development<br />

and non-professional behaviour<br />

of the clubs have ensured that<br />

the new generation of footballers<br />

would be vulnerable technically,<br />

physically and psychologically in a<br />

football field. The crisis is nothing<br />

new and after eight long years, the<br />

Bangladesh Football Federation<br />

seemed to have realised its lackings<br />

towards improving the standard of<br />

the game in the country.<br />

In the second week of <strong>December</strong>,<br />

the BFF outlined a long-term<br />

plan with a four-year calendar<br />

filled with more domestic competitions<br />

and youth activities, placing<br />

the utmost importance on the development<br />

of youth football in the<br />

country, set to be effective from the<br />

first month of 2017.<br />

There has been an instability<br />

regarding the head coach’s position<br />

in the national men’s team<br />

throughout the year. The coach<br />

was changed as many as four times<br />

and currently, there has been no<br />

head coach in the senior men’s side<br />

in more than two months. The BFF<br />

election was held in April where<br />

Kazi Salahuddin was elected president<br />

for the third consecutive time.<br />

The country’s top-flight Bangladesh<br />

Premier League was held<br />

across five different venues of the<br />

country for the first time in history<br />

but still, it eventually failed to attract<br />

full-house crowds. This year<br />

marked Dhaka Abahani Limited’s<br />

return to dominance in domestic<br />

football. They were the most consistent<br />

performer in <strong>2016</strong>, reaching<br />

the Independence Cup final,<br />

winning the Federation Cup and<br />

clinching their fifth professional<br />

league title at the end of <strong>December</strong><br />

after a drought of three seasons.<br />

The year also marked the rise<br />

of rising powerhouse Chittagong<br />

Abahani and the fall of big-budget<br />

sides like Sheikh Jamal Dhanmondi<br />

Club and Sheikh Russel Krira<br />

Chakra. This year, Chittagong Mohammedan<br />

returned to second-tier<br />

football, along with Kawran Bazar<br />

and newly-formed Saif Sporting<br />

Club. Bangladesh football’s brightest<br />

month in <strong>2016</strong> was perhaps<br />

September, thanks to the spectacular<br />

displays by Krishna Rani Sarkar<br />

and Co. Followed by their brilliant<br />

achievement in the AFC U-14 Girls’<br />

Regional Championship in the last<br />

two years, the clinical Bangladesh<br />

U-16 girls qualified for the final<br />

round of the AFC U-16 Women’s<br />

Championship, winning all five<br />

matches in a row, that too in some<br />

style. They scored 26 goals against<br />

favourites Iran, Kyrgyzstan, Singapore,<br />

Chinese Taipei and the United<br />

Arab Emirates. They will play<br />

Asia’s top teams in the form of Australia,<br />

Korea and Japan in the final<br />

round in Thailand next year. •<br />

Bangladesh football<br />

team react after<br />

losing against Bahrain<br />

under-23 side in the<br />

semi-final of the <strong>2016</strong><br />

Bangabandhu Gold<br />

Cup at Bangabandhu<br />

National Stadium in<br />

January<br />

MD MANIK


Downtime<br />

29<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

CROSSWORD<br />

CODE-CRACKER<br />

ACROSS<br />

1 Ship of the desert (5)<br />

4 Small nail (4)<br />

7 Top airman (3)<br />

8 By way of (3)<br />

9 Lyrics (5)<br />

12 Prayer ending (4)<br />

13 Unauthorised<br />

absentees (7)<br />

15 Knight’s title (3)<br />

16 Electrical unit (3)<br />

18 Tree (3)<br />

19 Spirit (3)<br />

21 Begins again (7)<br />

24 Woody plant (4)<br />

26 Derogatory (5)<br />

27 Spoil (3)<br />

28 Fresh (3)<br />

29 Companion (4)<br />

<strong>30</strong> Casts off (5)<br />

DOWN<br />

1 Members of a play (4)<br />

2 Fruit of the oak (6)<br />

3 Bill of fare (4)<br />

4 Prejudice (4)<br />

5 Male sheep (3)<br />

6 Durable cloth (5)<br />

10 Fuel (3)<br />

11 Bird (5)<br />

14 Long lock (5)<br />

17 Paid attention (6)<br />

18 Top room (5)<br />

20 Play on words (3)<br />

21 Quantity of paper (4)<br />

22 Pit (4)<br />

23 Works with needle<br />

and thread (4)<br />

25 Flightless bird (3)<br />

How to solve: Each number in our<br />

CODE-CRACKER grid represents a<br />

different letter of the alphabet. For<br />

example, today 11 represents W so fill W<br />

every time the figure 11 appears.<br />

You have two letters in the control<br />

grid to start you off. Enter them in the<br />

appropriate squares in the main grid, then<br />

use your knowledge of words to work out<br />

which letters go in the missing squares.<br />

Some letters of the alphabet may not be<br />

used.<br />

As you get the letters, fill in the other<br />

squares with the same number in the<br />

main grid, and the control grid. Check<br />

off the list of alphabetical letters as you<br />

identify them.<br />

ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ<br />

CALVIN AND HOBBES<br />

SUDOKU<br />

How to solve: Fill in the blank spaces with the<br />

numbers 1 – 9. Every row, column and 3 x 3 box must<br />

contain all nine digits with no number repeating.<br />

PEANUTS<br />

YESTERDAY’S SOLUTIONS<br />

CODE-CRACKER<br />

CROSSWORD<br />

DILBERT<br />

SUDOKU


<strong>30</strong><br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

Showtime<br />

Bangladeshi short film<br />

awarded in Mumbai<br />

PHOTO: COURTESY<br />

When<br />

daddy<br />

Shakti<br />

does not<br />

approve<br />

• Showtime Desk<br />

Bangladeshi short film Kobi<br />

Swamir Mrityur Por Amar<br />

Jobanbondi, won the Special Jury<br />

Award at the 15th Third Eye Asian<br />

Film Festival which took place<br />

from <strong>December</strong> 15 to 22, <strong>2016</strong> in<br />

Mumbai, India.<br />

The award was handed over<br />

by renowned film director Shyam<br />

Bengal in a closing ceremony that<br />

was held yesterday at the Rabindra<br />

Natya Mandir.<br />

Also known as, The Statement<br />

After My Poet Husband’s Death,<br />

the story has been written and<br />

directed by Tasmiah Afrin Mou<br />

and produced by Rubaiyat<br />

Hossain. The short film had its<br />

world premiere held last month at<br />

the Festival Tous Courts in France.<br />

The film has also won the Tareque<br />

Shahriar Best Short Film Award at<br />

the Dhaka International Short and<br />

Independent Film Festival. Last<br />

week, the film was also screened at<br />

Festival Zubroffka, a reputed short<br />

film festival in Poland.<br />

The 15 th Third Eye Film<br />

festival was inaugurated with<br />

the screening of internationally<br />

acclaimed Bangladeshi director<br />

Rubaiyat Hossain’s Under<br />

Construction. Organised by the<br />

Asian Film Foundation, the festival<br />

this year honoured veteran filmmaker,<br />

Govind Nihalani with the<br />

prestigious Film Culture Award. •<br />

Carrie Fisher is one with the Force<br />

• Niloy Alam<br />

SOURCE: INTERNET<br />

Two days ago, I watched Star Wars<br />

– A New Hope Revisited, a highlyedited<br />

special fan edition. It could<br />

have been the 20th or <strong>30</strong>th viewing,<br />

still soaked in every frame, every<br />

blaster fire, every explosion.<br />

Last night, a colleague said<br />

Carrie Fisher died. Dismissing his<br />

claims, citing her cardiac arrest<br />

a few days back, I said she was<br />

fine. Googled. The results were a<br />

staggering blow. Facebook. The<br />

News Feed was flooded with Carrie<br />

Fisher’s iconic poses from the Star<br />

Wars films.<br />

In the words of Obi-Wan<br />

Kenobi, played by the late Sir Alec<br />

Guinness: “There is no death,<br />

there is the Force.<br />

Carrie Fisher was not an actor<br />

who only played the character of<br />

Princess Leia Organa of Alderaan.<br />

She was Princess Leia for all<br />

intents and purposes. Every SW<br />

novel and comic base their<br />

depiction of Leia as that of Carrie.<br />

An avid reader, and a college<br />

dropout, Carrie Fisher was as<br />

much royalty in real life as she was<br />

in the Star Wars franchise. The<br />

moniker “Princess” in the films<br />

was initially a tongue-in-cheek<br />

reference to her status as a royalty<br />

of a planet destroyed, but her<br />

quiet resolve and unwavering aura<br />

of effervescent grace (in a white<br />

gown or bodysuit) earned her<br />

every ounce of respect.<br />

In her life outside the films,<br />

she was as humane as anyone<br />

could be. She was frank about her<br />

demons - her bipolar disorder,<br />

substance abuse, celebrity<br />

marriages – and was all the cooler<br />

for surviving them all.<br />

Carrie Fisher was more than an<br />

actress. She penned Postcards from<br />

the Edge, a semi-autobiographical<br />

work which she turned into a film<br />

to discuss her drug abuse. She<br />

performed Wishful Drinking on<br />

Broadway - a seminal showcase<br />

of her sharp, poignant wit – also<br />

available as a book.<br />

Carrie is not just survived by<br />

her daughter Billie Lourd and she<br />

is survived by her co-workers,<br />

her fans, and every 80s and<br />

90s adolescent whose hearts<br />

unanimously skipped a beat when<br />

she appeared in Return of the Jedi<br />

in a sensual-looking but highly<br />

uncomfortable plastic bikini.<br />

Carrie always wanted the<br />

following line in her obituary. It is<br />

the one service I can do her.<br />

“Carrie Fisher, 60, died in<br />

moonlight, strangled by her own<br />

bra.”•<br />

• Showtime Desk<br />

Children having a relationship<br />

is usually something that most<br />

parents disapprove of. However,<br />

when it comes to celebrities,<br />

most think that they are free<br />

from “common people”<br />

problems. As it happens,<br />

they are not too different<br />

from us.<br />

Word about Shraddha<br />

Kapoor secretly livingin<br />

with her Rock-On 2<br />

co-star and rumoured<br />

lover, Farhan Akhtar<br />

were already making<br />

rounds in the<br />

fraternity.<br />

All was good<br />

until Sunday,<br />

when father<br />

Shakti<br />

Kapoor<br />

and masi<br />

(aunt)<br />

Padmini<br />

Kolhapure<br />

paid a<br />

shocking visit<br />

to Shraddha and<br />

Farhan’s love nest,<br />

which stirred up quite<br />

the controversy.<br />

Their agenda was<br />

clear, they wanted<br />

Shraddha to quit the<br />

live-in relationship<br />

with the “almost<br />

divorced” and<br />

“father of two,” Farhan<br />

Akhter and move back<br />

to their Juhu home. We<br />

don’t know whether she<br />

put up a fight or not but<br />

the episode ended with<br />

Shakti forcibly taking<br />

Shraddha back home.<br />

This was reported by<br />

SpotBoye.<br />

Fathers will always be<br />

possessive of their daughter,<br />

even if you are a<br />

celebrity or not<br />

and Shakti<br />

definitely<br />

proved<br />

that. •<br />

SOURCES: INTERNET


Showtime<br />

Hollywood starlet Debbie<br />

Reynolds dies<br />

• Showtime Desk<br />

Debbie Reynolds, mother of<br />

Carrie Fisher, who just lost her<br />

daughter on Tuesday, has died<br />

after being rushed to the hospital<br />

early on Wednesday, her son<br />

confirmed. She was 84.<br />

Reynolds’ son, Todd Fisher<br />

said, “She’s now with Carrie and<br />

we’re all heartbroken.” He said<br />

the stress of his sister’s death<br />

“was too much” for Reynolds.<br />

“She said, ‘I want to be with<br />

Carrie,’” said Fisher. “And then<br />

she was gone.”<br />

Earlier, it was reported that<br />

Reynolds was at Fisher’s home<br />

in Beverly Hills on Wednesday<br />

morning planning her daughter’s<br />

funeral when she suffered a<br />

stroke. Several sources revealed<br />

that Reynolds had been<br />

distraught since Fisher’s health<br />

declined last week.<br />

“She held it together<br />

beautifully, obviously, for the last<br />

couple of days but she was under<br />

a lot of emotion and stress from<br />

the loss (of Fisher) and it’s pretty<br />

much what triggered this event,”<br />

Todd Fisher added.<br />

Reynolds’ illustrious career in<br />

Hollywood lasted for more than<br />

65 years. The Oscar-nominated<br />

actress starred in memorable<br />

films including 1952’s Singin’ in<br />

the Rain, 1962’s How the West Was<br />

Won and 1956’s Bundle of Joy.<br />

The outspoken Reynolds<br />

was well-known for playing<br />

offbeat mothers on-screen,<br />

alongside Albert Brooks in 1996’s<br />

Mother and on the sitcom Will<br />

& Grace (1999 to 2006) as Debra<br />

Messing’s screen mom. But the<br />

most famous is her true-life<br />

role as Carrie Fisher’s mother,<br />

the subject of Fisher’s semiautobiographical<br />

novel and 1990<br />

film Postcards From the Edge.<br />

Reynolds’ favourite role was<br />

playing Molly Brown in the<br />

musical The Unsinkable Molly<br />

Brown, for which she earned an<br />

Academy Award nomination.<br />

“I loved playing her. She was<br />

sort of like me,” said Reynolds,<br />

who titled her updated 2013<br />

autobiography, Unsinkable: A<br />

Memoir.<br />

Among Reynolds’ biggest<br />

contributions to the public were<br />

her massive movie memorabilia<br />

collection, which she was later<br />

forced to auction, and her Debbie<br />

Reynolds Dance Studios, which<br />

she opened in Los Angeles in the<br />

1970s. Everyone from Michael<br />

Jackson, Justin Timberlake and<br />

Britney Spears to Bette Midler,<br />

Madonna, Usher and Mariah<br />

Carey has trained<br />

or rehearsed at the<br />

studio.<br />

Reynolds is<br />

survived by<br />

her son, Todd<br />

Fisher, and her<br />

granddaughter,<br />

Carrie’s Fisher’s<br />

daughter, Billie<br />

Lourd.•<br />

Nadim Iqbal’s ‘Mother Tongue’ wins Hollywood<br />

In’t Independent Award<br />

31<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

WHAT TO WATCH<br />

Mad Max: Fury Road<br />

HBO 7:10pm<br />

A woman rebels against<br />

a tyrannical ruler in<br />

postapocalyptic Australia<br />

in search for her home-land<br />

with the help of a group of<br />

female prisoners, a psychotic<br />

worshipper, and a drifter<br />

named Max.<br />

Cast: Tom Hardy, Charlize<br />

Theron, Nicholas Hoult,<br />

Hugh Keays-Byrne, Rosie<br />

Huntington-Whiteley, Riley<br />

Keough<br />

Godzilla (1998)<br />

Star Movies 11:51pm<br />

A giant, reptilian monster<br />

surfaces, leaving destruction<br />

in its wake. To stop the<br />

monster (and its babies),<br />

an earthworm scientist, his<br />

reporter ex-girlfriend, and<br />

other unlikely heroes team up<br />

to save their city.<br />

Cast: Matthew Broderick,<br />

Jean Reno, Maria Pitillo, Hank<br />

Azaria, Kevin Dunn<br />

Superman Returns<br />

WB 2:23pm<br />

DT<br />

• Showtime Desk<br />

Bangladeshi born Canadian<br />

film-maker Nadim Iqbal’s<br />

documentary Mother Tongue<br />

scooped an “Award of<br />

Recognition” at the Hollywood<br />

International Independent<br />

Awards.<br />

The 11-minute documentary<br />

of Nadim Iqbal was introduced in<br />

the film festival which garnered<br />

an audience more than 50<br />

thousand and hundreds of filmmakers<br />

from around the world.<br />

This is a story about a man<br />

who risked his life to save his<br />

culture, his heritage and his<br />

language—only to discover<br />

that the sacrifices he has made<br />

are neither appreciated nor<br />

understood by the younger<br />

generation.<br />

The documentary has been<br />

produced, edited and filmed by<br />

Nadim Iqbal himself, while it<br />

also casts poet Asad Chowdhury<br />

and his granddaughter Raidah<br />

Fairooz.<br />

Untill now, the film has<br />

garnered a platinum award,<br />

four best film awards and 24<br />

other accolades from screenings<br />

held in USA, Canada, Denmark,<br />

Spain Germany, Italy, Belgium,<br />

Rumania, Mexico and Portugal.<br />

The film has been selected for<br />

another film festival to be held in<br />

Arizona from January 17 to 19. •<br />

Superman reappears after a<br />

long absence, but is challenged<br />

by an old foe who uses<br />

Kryptonian technology for<br />

world domination.<br />

Cast: Brandon Routh, Kate<br />

Bosworth, Kevin Spacey,<br />

James Marsden, Parker Posey<br />

Knight and Day<br />

Movies Now 2 4:<strong>30</strong>pm<br />

A young woman gets mixed<br />

up with a disgraced spy who is<br />

trying to clear his name.<br />

Cast: Tom Cruise, Cameron<br />

Diaz, Peter Sarsgaard, Jordi<br />

Mollà, Viola Davis


32<br />

FRIDAY, DECEMBER <strong>30</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

DT<br />

$167M ADB LOAN SIGNED FOR<br />

BEFITTING GAS PRODUCTION PAGE 12<br />

Back Page<br />

THE GOOD, THE BAD<br />

AND THE UGLY PAGE 28<br />

Porn prohibition<br />

proves<br />

problematic<br />

• Mahadi Al Hasnat<br />

What constitutes “vulgar and<br />

harmful pornography” remains<br />

undefined by the government body<br />

charged with making this determination,<br />

as the country rolls into its<br />

third day of internet censorship.<br />

Yet that is the criteria being<br />

used to block over 500 sites by a<br />

little-known taskforce whose credentials<br />

for supervising adult entertainment<br />

are unclear.<br />

BTRC Secretary Sarwar Alam<br />

yesterday told the Dhaka Tribune<br />

that the authorities had initially<br />

targeted “vulgar and harmful websites.”<br />

When asked what this meant, he<br />

said: “For example, pornographic<br />

content that may incite viewers to<br />

commit rape.”<br />

He conceded that all adult sites<br />

could not effectively be blocked.<br />

The Pornography Control Act<br />

2012 prohibits the production,<br />

marketing, conservation, supply,<br />

display, filming, purchase and sale<br />

of pornographic material.<br />

It provides for two-year to 10-<br />

year prison sentences and fines<br />

ranging from Tk1 lakh to Tk5 lakh<br />

for violations.<br />

But the law is tantalisingly silent<br />

about internet use.<br />

A technical committee that includes<br />

representatives from the<br />

Information Ministry, the National<br />

Telecommunication Monitoring<br />

Cell (NTMC), internet service<br />

provider organisations and representatives<br />

of the mobile operators<br />

and law enforcement agencies<br />

prepared the list of offending websites.<br />

But there were no representatives<br />

of NGOs, sociologists or other<br />

experts working in this field helping<br />

to shortlist the websites.<br />

The decision to block adult content<br />

has met with mixed reactions.<br />

Some welcomed it while others decried<br />

excessive interference by the<br />

state in private life.<br />

Others, including veteran journalist<br />

and researcher Afsan Chowdhury,<br />

took the opportunity to address<br />

a wider range of weaknesses<br />

in the country's internet infrastructure,<br />

including the apparent inability<br />

of the authorities to effectively<br />

block offending sites.<br />

“It seems the government is<br />

issuing a warning they cannot enforce.<br />

Hundreds of websites containing<br />

sexual content are still accessible<br />

in the country,” Afsan told<br />

the Dhaka Tribune.<br />

A random search of the over<br />

500 sites slated for restriction<br />

sent by the Bangladesh Telecommunications<br />

Regulatory Commission<br />

to internet service providers,<br />

found around 15% of them still<br />

accessible.<br />

These included pornstars' personal<br />

websites, comic strip sites,<br />

movie sites, gay online magazines,<br />

music video sites and escort service<br />

sites.<br />

The list, moreover, failed to include<br />

popular international sites.<br />

“There are thousands of porn<br />

sites on the internet and all of them<br />

cannot be blocked. We have asked<br />

internet service providers and other<br />

authorities concerned to block<br />

offensive websites containing pornography<br />

or sexual content and sent<br />

them a list of sites containing harmful<br />

and provocative content,” BTRC<br />

spokesperson Sarwar Alam said.<br />

There are around 66.86 million<br />

internet subscribers in Bangladesh.<br />

Of this, the lion's share – some<br />

62.968 million subscribers – access<br />

the internet via mobile telephone,<br />

according to BTRC data current as<br />

of September.<br />

One popular porn site held the<br />

17th slot in the Alexa ranking of<br />

top searched-for sites from Bangladesh.<br />

At least six other porn websites<br />

secured positions among the<br />

top 100 websites accessed from<br />

Bangladesh.<br />

Although there is no official data<br />

on how many people in Bangladesh<br />

visit porn sites, a survey conducted<br />

by Manusher Jonno Foundation<br />

estimated that 77% of Dhaka's<br />

school-goers visit porn sites on a<br />

regular basis.<br />

When asked to comment, Internet<br />

Service Provider Association of<br />

Bangladesh (ISPAB) president MA<br />

Hakim and Association of Mobile<br />

Telecom Operators of Bangladesh<br />

(AMTOB) general secretary Nurul<br />

Kabir told the Dhaka Tribune that<br />

the restrictions were welcome.<br />

They said they would comply with<br />

it in the interest younger internet<br />

users. •<br />

University of Dhaka authorities start building a monument named ‘Muktochinta Statue’ in memory of slain writer Avijit Roy at<br />

Teacher-Student Centre (TSC) area where he was murdered<br />

MAHMUD HOSSAIN OPU<br />

Bangla Academy to reconsider<br />

Shrabon Prokashani ban<br />

• SM Najmus Sakib<br />

Bangla Academy today is going to<br />

reconsider its decision of banning<br />

Shrabon Prokashani from Amar<br />

Ekushey book fair for the next two<br />

years, following tough protests<br />

against the move from writers and<br />

publishers, rights and cultural activists.<br />

“The decision on whether Shrabon<br />

Prokashani is going to take part<br />

in Amar Ekushey book fair for the<br />

next two years will be decided in<br />

Bangla Academy’s council meeting<br />

on Friday,” Academy Director<br />

General Prof Shamsuzzaman Khan<br />

yesterday told the Dhaka Tribune.<br />

On November 10, the academy<br />

made the decision banning the<br />

publisher from the annual book<br />

fair “for taking a stance against the<br />

Academy's action.”<br />

The DG said: “We have received<br />

a letter from Shrabon Prokashani<br />

requesting to reconsider the decision.<br />

After getting the letter, the<br />

authorities are going to sit for reconsidering<br />

the decision.”<br />

Shahdin Malik, a lawyer and<br />

rights activist, said: “If Bangla<br />

Academy’s rules mean punishment<br />

for protesting any of its decision,<br />

banning a publishing house from<br />

Ekushey book fair, then the rules<br />

and regulations of Bangla Academy<br />

are authoritarian, undemocratic<br />

and medieval which need to be<br />

changed immediately.”<br />

Urging the Bangla Academy to<br />

cancel the decision, he said: “According<br />

to the constitution, it is<br />

the right of every citizen to protest<br />

whatever one feels wrong.”<br />

Since the academy’s decision<br />

banning Shrabon Prokashoni was<br />

reported in media, a number of<br />

writers and activists, including<br />

Supreme Court lawyer Jyotirmoy<br />

Barua and rights activist Khushi<br />

Kabir, protested the decision, in<br />

person and through social media,<br />

arguing that the Academy and the<br />

DG had no legal authority to ban<br />

any book or any publication house.<br />

Robin Ahsan, owner of Shrabon<br />

Prokashani, earlier termed the DG’s<br />

decision “unjust and based on false<br />

ground.”<br />

Defending his decision the DG<br />

said the owner of Shrabon Prokashani<br />

took part in a protest<br />

which was held against a decision<br />

made by the academy.<br />

Terming the ban “an attack<br />

on free-thinkers,” Udichi General<br />

Secretary Jamshed Anwar Tapan<br />

at a protest programme vowed<br />

to continue the protest until the<br />

government met their demand.<br />

In February, Bangla Academy<br />

closed Ba-Dwip Prakashan's stall<br />

for selling a book that “hurt religious<br />

sentiments.” Later, law enforcers<br />

arrested three people, including<br />

the editor of the book.<br />

At a protest programme, publisher<br />

Robin said: “I had only protested<br />

the way Shamsuzzoha Manik, editor<br />

of the book, was arrested.”<br />

Meantime, Bangla Academy has<br />

decided to take punitive action<br />

against 20 publications on various<br />

charges of violating the Academy's<br />

code of conduct – allegations of<br />

hurting religious sentiments.<br />

They would possibly not get allotment<br />

for setting up stalls in the<br />

book fair in 2017, said an official of<br />

the academy on anonymity.<br />

Authorities of Bangla Academy,<br />

however, refuted to make any comment<br />

in this regard.<br />

Dr Jalal Ahmed, a director of<br />

Bangla Academy and the member<br />

secretary of Amar Ekushey book<br />

fair, told the Dhaka Tribune: “In<br />

<strong>2016</strong>’s book fair, some publishing<br />

houses built stalls violating authority’s<br />

decision. The Academy sent<br />

show cause notices to them, and<br />

as their replies did not convince<br />

the authority, we are going to take<br />

actions against them following the<br />

Academy’s rules and regulations.”<br />

He said a fair committee meeting<br />

in January next year would take<br />

further decision. •<br />

Editor: Zafar Sobhan, Published and Printed by Kazi Anis Ahmed on behalf of 2A Media Limited at Dainik Shakaler Khabar Publications Limited, 153/7, Tejgaon Industrial Area, Dhaka-1208. Editorial, News & Commercial Office: FR Tower,<br />

8/C Panthapath, Shukrabad, Dhaka 1207. Phone: 9132093-94, Advertising: 9132155, Circulation: 9132282, Fax: News-9132192, e-mail: news@dhakatribune.com, info@dhakatribune.com, Website: www.dhakatribune.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!