The Asian Independent 01 - 15 Nov. 2019
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
4<br />
<strong>01</strong>-11-2<strong>01</strong>9 to <strong>15</strong>-11-2<strong>01</strong>9 ASIA<br />
www.theasianindependent.co.uk<br />
<strong>The</strong> festival season is not<br />
over yet now. Something is<br />
today and will continue for next<br />
six days till the Chhath comes.<br />
A careful analysis will tell you<br />
how we celebrate male<br />
supremacy during these festivities.<br />
Just a few days before<br />
Diwali, you have Karwachauth<br />
and now in next one or two<br />
days, you have Bhai dooj and<br />
then Chhath too will give you a<br />
glimpse of celebrations for<br />
sons. India is a continent and<br />
therefore will have more festivals<br />
than anybody else. <strong>The</strong>re<br />
is cultural crisis and cultural<br />
hegemony through festivals<br />
too. Patriarchy too is enforced<br />
through them. Now, lots of<br />
researches and narratives to<br />
justify them.<br />
Many people dont want to<br />
celebrate it because they feel<br />
this is not their identity. Others<br />
suffer in continuous confusion<br />
as to what do you say when<br />
some body ‘greet’ you with ‘<br />
Happy Diwali’. Friends are<br />
confused in it. ‘ How do I<br />
answer their happy diwali<br />
greetings when I am not a<br />
Hindu, said a Buddhist friend.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re are number of them who<br />
are now suggesting that there is<br />
a reference to Deepdanostsav<br />
in Buddhism while other suggest<br />
that such festivals dont<br />
exists in Buddhist countries.<br />
Lots of debate should we be<br />
celebrating Hindu festivals or<br />
not or shouldnt we ?<br />
Now, this crisis is not with<br />
Muslims or Christians as they<br />
are clear about their identity<br />
and hence they participate in<br />
Diwali and Holi in the similar<br />
way, as we might participate in<br />
Eid and Christmas. <strong>The</strong> issue is<br />
so much in our mind that if a<br />
politician greet people ( who is<br />
not expected to celebrate<br />
Diwali), we get disturbed and<br />
blame him as ‘sold out’. I think,<br />
we need to ponder over a few<br />
things on these issues and save<br />
ourselves from tensions and<br />
isolation.<br />
One no festival in India is<br />
celebrated with one narrative<br />
and if you have traveled across<br />
the country and seen how<br />
things are celebrated then you<br />
will find out that most of our<br />
festivals are actually Bahujan<br />
Adivasi festivals and not really<br />
brahmanical as being projected.<br />
<strong>The</strong> brahmanical forces<br />
hijacked them and build their<br />
own narratives around them<br />
otherwise a God like Shiva can<br />
never be a brahmanical god.<br />
Dusshera festival have different<br />
and diverse celebrations<br />
across the country. In Bengal it<br />
is Kali Puja, in Gujarat it is<br />
Durga Puja, in<br />
the north it is<br />
Ram leela and<br />
among the<br />
Adivasis and<br />
many places, it is remembering<br />
Mahishasura. While, the north<br />
Indians dont eat non vegetarian<br />
food during the Navratris,<br />
Bengalis rejoice it. Similarly,<br />
Dipwali is not celebrated in the<br />
same way. In many places in<br />
Maharashtra Diwali is people’s<br />
wish to have ‘ Bali ka raj’.<br />
Most of the festivals had local<br />
cultural practices.<br />
Celebrate or not :<br />
WHOSE FESTIVALS<br />
ARE THEY ?<br />
While people may practice<br />
same religion, it is not necessary<br />
their festivals and cultural<br />
practices are same. Islam and<br />
Christianity too have these<br />
diversities according to regions<br />
and languages. In India,<br />
because all the non Muslims<br />
and Non Christians are termed<br />
as Hindus hence we confuse<br />
this diversity as Hindu festivals.<br />
Most of our festivals have<br />
relations with seasons or crops,<br />
whether it is Diwali, Makar<br />
Sakranti, Baishakhi, Holi,<br />
Dusshera, Basant Panchami but<br />
all these festivals are celebrated<br />
in diverse ways and narratives.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re are no homogeneous narratives<br />
in relation to this and<br />
therefore we need to be careful<br />
when we analyse them.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Dhamma Chakra<br />
Pravartan Diwas is celebrated<br />
on October 14th but equally<br />
important is that a huge number<br />
of people remember it on<br />
Dusshera day which is termed<br />
as Ashoka Vijayadashmi day.<br />
Festivals were used by political<br />
leaders for reaching the bigger<br />
masses and it is true that<br />
Hindutva leaders reached it<br />
first. <strong>The</strong> counter narrative that<br />
By Vidya Bhushan Rawat<br />
social and human rights activist<br />
was built by Dr Baba Saheb<br />
Ambedkar was not repeated by<br />
politicians who swore by his<br />
name.<br />
Every Indian religious<br />
places that has brahmanical<br />
links today, has a Buddhist or<br />
Jain past. Dig any place and<br />
you will find it. Similarly,<br />
every brahmanical festival<br />
today is somewhere a Buddhist<br />
past too. <strong>The</strong> bigger reality is<br />
that diyas and lighting of lamp<br />
was a common way of celebration<br />
in the past the only thing is<br />
the narratives. It is important<br />
for all of us to delink ourselves<br />
with all the brahmanical narratives<br />
and rituals of these festivities<br />
by completely rejecting<br />
them and celebrate them in a<br />
much more rational and egalitarian<br />
way.<br />
Even if you dont want to celebrate<br />
it there is nothing wrong.<br />
People like us move out of<br />
Delhi and be with communities<br />
we love, share our happiness<br />
with them, enjoy moments with<br />
your near dear ones.<br />
Brahmanism have destroyed<br />
the good spirit of the festivals.<br />
Today Diwali Dusshera and<br />
Holi impact our environment<br />
more than anything else but<br />
now the Banias too build up the<br />
narratives with the help of<br />
brahmins and you see the vulgar<br />
display of wealth during<br />
this period. All the campaign in<br />
the name of swachch Bharat<br />
a n d<br />
clean<br />
India<br />
i s<br />
brought to naught by the same<br />
elite which happily pose with a<br />
‘glossy’ ‘jhadu’ in their hand.<br />
I know Delhi must have<br />
become a gas chamber today<br />
and our ‘messiahs’ will be<br />
quiet. he wont speak on this<br />
biggest non-sense that we do.<br />
He he wont speak against how<br />
all these festivals are choking<br />
our lonely planet.<br />
No festival should be<br />
allowed to destroy our lonely<br />
planet. We cant have celebrations<br />
decided by the market<br />
today.<br />
Protection of environment as<br />
well as health is more important.<br />
Destruction of environment<br />
in the name of ‘celebrations’<br />
is ‘unique’ to brahmanical<br />
culture of India. It is time<br />
we wake up, reject these dangerous<br />
practices and enjoy festivities<br />
without bringing God<br />
and god-men in between.<br />
Celebrate festivals without<br />
Gods and their rituals and I can<br />
say, you will able to protect<br />
nature and human race as well.<br />
Vidya Bhushan Rawat is a<br />
social and human rights<br />
activist. He blogs at<br />
www.manukhsi.blogspot.com<br />
twitter @freetohumanity<br />
Email: vbrawat@gmail.com