Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
THETRUCKER.COM<br />
BUSINESS<br />
OCTOBER 2022 • 13<br />
Predicting the future<br />
SUCCESS FOR THE REST OF 2022 MAY DEPEND ON SPOT VS. CONTRACT RATES<br />
CLIFF ABBO<strong>TT</strong> | SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT<br />
Carriers that depend on spot freight rates<br />
for their business are in for a rough go in the<br />
coming months.<br />
On the other hand, carriers that depend<br />
on contract rates for their business are likely<br />
to earn near-record revenues for 2022 and<br />
will have an easier time riding out the coming<br />
recession.<br />
Those two statements seem to be the<br />
consensus among the firms that track and<br />
analyze the data from various resources. It’s<br />
a reasonable prediction, because spot rates<br />
are more volatile than contract rates. Spot<br />
rates can change overnight, while contract<br />
rates depend on — well, as the name suggests,<br />
negotiating a new contract. In summary,<br />
whatever spot rates do, contract rates will<br />
most likely follow, but months later.<br />
At the time of this writing, we’re at a point<br />
in the trucking cycle where spot rates have<br />
been falling steadily for months. According<br />
to DAT Freight and Analytics, dry van spot<br />
rates on their board fell 4.2% in August from<br />
July levels, while flatbed rates fell 7.4% and<br />
refrigerated rates fell 3.3%.<br />
Perhaps a more telling statistic is the<br />
“load-to-truck” ratios reported by DAT. When<br />
truckers have more loads to choose from,<br />
rates tend to rise as competition for trucks<br />
intensifies.<br />
The opposite is occurring now. Load-totruck<br />
ratio for dry van fell 7.9% in August,<br />
the refrigerated ratio fell 2.2% and the flatbed<br />
load-to-truck ratio fell 35.2%. With less<br />
competition to find trucks to move product,<br />
spot rates continued to fall.<br />
Things were a little rosier on the contract<br />
side.<br />
Freight volumes grew by 6.6% in<br />
August, according to data released by Cass<br />
Information Systems. Compared with August<br />
2021, freight volumes grew by 3.6%. The Cass<br />
data includes information from different<br />
modes of transportation, including rail, ship,<br />
barge, air, pipeline, trucking and others.<br />
While freight volumes grew by 3.6%<br />
compared with August 2021, the amount of<br />
money spent on shipping grew by 20.4% as<br />
rates climbed faster.<br />
At ACT Research’s Seminar 67, held<br />
Aug. 23-25 in Columbus, Indiana, ACT Vice<br />
President and Senior Analyst Tim Denoyer<br />
spoke about the trucking industry outlook.<br />
“We’re coming into a rough patch, but<br />
we’re coming from the best ever, and 2022<br />
will end up as probably the third or fourth<br />
best year for carrier profits,” Denoyer said in a<br />
presentation. He cautioned that the data was<br />
taken from quarterly reports of publicly held<br />
trucking companies and may not represent<br />
trucking companies as a whole.<br />
In a September 12 press release, ACT<br />
President and Senior Analyst Kenny Vieth<br />
iStock Photo<br />
Load-to-truck ratio for dry van fell 7.9% in August, the refrigerated ratio fell 2.2% and the flatbed load-to-truck ratio fell 35.2%. With less competition to find trucks to move<br />
product, spot rates continued to fall.<br />
echoed the news for large carriers.<br />
“Carrier profits and profitability were at<br />
record levels in 2021, and contract freight<br />
rates are still expected to rise by high single<br />
digits this year,” Vieth explained.<br />
That’s all part of the trucking industry<br />
cycle. In late 2020 and into 2021, spot rates<br />
were rapidly rising, prompting many owneroperators<br />
to purchase trucks and apply for<br />
their own authority to take advantage of the<br />
boom. Now the cycle has turned downward,<br />
and some of those drivers are surrendering<br />
their authority and leasing on — or hiring<br />
on — to carriers that have freight at contract<br />
rates.<br />
Like all cycles, the cycle of rising contract<br />
rates must end, and that day is coming. The<br />
coming year 2023 may prove to be difficult,<br />
with a recession predicted for the first half<br />
of the year. Denoyer predicts the recession<br />
will be a mild one for trucking and that the<br />
economy will recover in 2024 and 2025.<br />
In his Seminar 67 presentation, Denoyer<br />
addressed some of the factors that are<br />
impacting freight supply. One, he explained,<br />
is that consumer spending is moving back<br />
towards services rather than purchase of<br />
goods. That makes sense, with inflation<br />
running at a 40-year high. After paying bills,<br />
buying groceries and filling up the gas tanks of<br />
their vehicles, there simply isn’t enough cash<br />
left over for a spending spree.<br />
Retailers need to maintain an inventory of<br />
products to keep shelves stocked, and here’s<br />
where the cycle repeats. When people stop<br />
buying due to inflation, retailers order fewer<br />
products to replace their inventories. At a<br />
manufacturing level, inventories of parts and<br />
of completed product are also higher. Fewer<br />
reorders means fewer shipments for trucking.<br />
Another factor involves overseas shipping.<br />
The long lines of ships waiting to get<br />
unloaded at West Coast ports have shortened<br />
considerably. Some ships diverted to East<br />
Coast ports, and there are some wait times<br />
there, but the worst is over.<br />
Trucking has benefited from the railroad<br />
industry’s inability to move those containers<br />
coming into the ports. The railroads needed<br />
more chassis to stack the containers on, and<br />
those weren’t being built fast enough to supply<br />
the demand. The biggest reason was record<br />
steel prices that held up production. Those<br />
days have passed. Steel is cheaper and chassis<br />
are being built again, meaning railroads<br />
can move more containers, leaving less for<br />
trucking.<br />
Interest rates play a part, too. To combat<br />
inflation, the Federal Reserve has already<br />
increased prime interest rates by 75 basis<br />
points, or 3/4 of a percent, twice this year. At<br />
a meeting scheduled for Sept. 21, the Fed is<br />
expected to enact another increase, possibly<br />
of a full percentage point.<br />
Those increased interest rates reverberate<br />
throughout financial markets. For consumers,<br />
it means interest on mortgages, car loans and<br />
credit cards will continue to rise, adding to the<br />
cost of purchases that are already increasing<br />
in price.<br />
When the prices go up, along with the<br />
cost of borrowing money to make purchases,<br />
trucking sees less freight.<br />
Perhaps the only good economic news is<br />
that fuel prices have come down — but they’re<br />
still much higher than they were a year ago.<br />
Many smaller carriers are feeling the pinch.<br />
There is still money to be made in trucking,<br />
but it’s becoming more difficult to maintain a<br />
level of profitability. It won’t be getting any<br />
easier in the coming months. 8