TLA66_AllPages
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Those Who Deliver | Next Gen Executive | HIghway Angels<br />
OFFICIAL PUBLICATION o f t h e Truckload Carriers Association<br />
May/JUne 2024<br />
Benchmarking Success | 18<br />
TCA’s Profitability Program helps carriers survive,<br />
even thrive, regardless of market conditions<br />
Tired of Waiting | 20<br />
Will FMCSA’s latest study of driver<br />
detention generate results?<br />
A foundation for<br />
Success<br />
TCA Chairman John Culp shares thoughts on<br />
industry issues, goals for the year | 24<br />
How MUCH is<br />
TOO Much? | 8<br />
Electrification of the trucking<br />
industry has a price tag of at<br />
least $1 trillion
2 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
PRESIDENT’S PURVIEW<br />
Impacting the Industry<br />
As I reflect on the remarkable gathering we had in late March at the<br />
Truckload Carriers Association’s (TCA) annual convention, I am filled with<br />
immense pride and gratitude for our resilient community. This event not only<br />
brought us together, but it also shone a light on the collective efforts and<br />
individual contributions that drive our industry forward.<br />
We were privileged to honor individuals and their companies who<br />
have dedicated years of service and leadership. Dave Williams, our TCA<br />
chairman for the past year, has been exemplary in his role, steering us<br />
through challenges with insight and determination. His ability to connect<br />
and communicate effectively has been instrumental in identifying and<br />
implementing practical solutions for our industry.<br />
Jim Ward<br />
President<br />
Truckload Carriers Association<br />
jward@truckload.org<br />
We also recognized our members who have stepped into leadership roles<br />
on committees, task forces, and through their industry engagement have helped to recruit new members<br />
into the association. Their leadership truly guides everything we do within the walls of the TCA.<br />
This uptick in engagement is crucial as we continue to grow our membership value proposition<br />
through expanded resources and educational initiatives, like the integration of NATMI certification<br />
materials into our TCA course offerings and the introduction of our new online learning platform.<br />
These enhancements not only increase accessibility, but they also enrich our members’ professional<br />
development.<br />
The launch of the Elevate program highlights our commitment to nurturing the next generation of<br />
industry leaders. With the support of Tenstreet, this initiative promises to cultivate the next generation of<br />
leaders within our industry.<br />
Our advocacy efforts have been robust, with strategic alignments and active participation in<br />
legislative discussions that shape our industry. The recent study from the Clean Freight Coalition on the<br />
electrification of the trucking industry underlines our commitment to environmental stewardship and<br />
active collaboration with lawmakers and regulators to that end.<br />
In closing, I want to extend my deepest thanks to all who attended and contributed to the success of<br />
our annual meeting. Your continued engagement and feedback are vital as we strive to provide value<br />
and support to every member of our community. I look forward to the opportunities and challenges<br />
that lie ahead, confident that together, we will continue to drive our industry forward.<br />
Jim Ward<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | TRUCKLOAD AUTHORITY 3
THE<br />
R<br />
O<br />
AD<br />
M<br />
A<br />
P<br />
PRESIDENT’S PURVIEW<br />
MAY/JUNE 2024<br />
Impacting the Industry with Jim Ward | 3<br />
LEGISLATIVE UPDATE<br />
No ‘Cure-All’ | 6<br />
How Much Is Too Much? | 8<br />
Capitol Recap | 10<br />
TRACKING THE TRENDS<br />
Retaining Training | 16<br />
Benchmarking Success | 18<br />
Tired of Waiting | 20<br />
Know What You’re Paying For | 22<br />
A CHAT WITH THE CHAIRMAN<br />
Foundation for Success with John Culp | 24<br />
TALKING TCA<br />
Those Who Deliver<br />
with Modern Transportation | 30<br />
Next Gen Executives with Jason Douglass | 32<br />
Outstanding Contributions | 34<br />
More Than a Catchphrase | 35<br />
Safe Drivers = Safer Roads | 36<br />
Photographs & Memories | 38<br />
Drivers Making a Difference | 40<br />
Elevate Class of ’24 | 42<br />
Champions Club | 42<br />
TCA Profitability Program | 44<br />
New Members | 46<br />
Looking Forward | 46<br />
555 E. Braddock Road<br />
Alexandria, VA 22314<br />
Phone: (703) 838-1950<br />
Fax: (703) 836-6610<br />
www.truckload.org<br />
CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD<br />
John Culp, President, Maverick Transportation<br />
PRESIDENT<br />
Jim Ward<br />
jward@truckload.org<br />
VP-MEMBERSHIP OUTREACH<br />
Zander Gambill<br />
zgambill@truckload.org<br />
MEMBERSHIP MANAGER<br />
Eric Rivard<br />
erivard@truckload.org<br />
MEMBERSHIP COORDINATOR<br />
Sarah Hammons<br />
shammons@truckload.org<br />
DIGITAL COMMUNICATIONS<br />
MANAGER<br />
Hunter Livesay<br />
hlivesay@truckload.org<br />
FIRST VICE CHAIR<br />
Karen Smerchek, President<br />
Veriha Trucking, Inc.<br />
SECRETARY<br />
Mark Seymour<br />
President/CEO<br />
Kriska Transportation Group<br />
VICE CHAIR TO ATA<br />
Ed Nagle, President<br />
Nagle Toledo, Inc.<br />
Adam Blanchard, CEO<br />
Double Diamond Transport<br />
Amber Edmondson<br />
President/CEO<br />
Trailiner Corp.<br />
The viewpoints and opinions quoted in articles in this<br />
publication are not necessarily those of TCA.<br />
In exclusive partnership with:<br />
1123 S. University, Ave., Suite 325, Little Rock, AR 72204<br />
Phone: (501) 666-0500 • www.TheTrucker.com<br />
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER<br />
Bobby Ralston<br />
bobbyr@thetruckermedia.com<br />
EDITOR EMERITUS<br />
Lyndon Finney<br />
lyndonf@thetruckermedia.com<br />
MANAGING EDITOR<br />
Linda Garner-Bunch<br />
lindag@thetruckermedia.com<br />
WEB NEWS MANAGER<br />
John Worthen<br />
johnw@thetruckermedia.com<br />
STAFF WRITER<br />
Erica N. Guy<br />
ericag@thetruckermedia.com<br />
SENIOR VP-SAFETY &<br />
GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS<br />
Dave Heller<br />
dheller@truckload.org<br />
GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS MANAGER<br />
Hailey Betham<br />
hbetham@truckload.org<br />
TCA PROFITABILITY PROGRAM<br />
FACILITATOR<br />
Amanda Pearson<br />
apearson@truckload.org<br />
SENIOR DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION<br />
Lilly Grossman<br />
lgrossman@truckload.org<br />
MEETINGS COORDINATOR<br />
Amelia Rose<br />
arose@truckload.org<br />
OFFICERS AT LARGE<br />
SECOND VICE CHAIR<br />
Jon Coca<br />
President, Diamond<br />
Transportation System, Inc.<br />
TREASURER<br />
John Culp, President<br />
Maverick USA, Inc.<br />
IMMEDIATE PAST CHAIR<br />
John Elliott, CEO<br />
Load One, LLC<br />
Pete Hill<br />
President<br />
Hill Brothers Transportation, Inc.<br />
Joey Hogan, Board Member<br />
Covenant Transport Services<br />
Trevor Kurtz, General Manager<br />
Brian Kurtz Trucking, LTD<br />
SPECIAL CORRESPONDENTS<br />
Cliff Abbott<br />
Dwain Hebda<br />
Kris Rutherford<br />
PRODUCTION COORDINATOR<br />
Christie McCluer<br />
christie.mccluer@<br />
thetruckermedia.com<br />
NATIONAL SALES MANAGER<br />
Meg Larcinese<br />
megl@thetruckermedia.com<br />
GENERAL MANAGER<br />
Megan Hicks<br />
meganh@thetruckermedia.com<br />
For advertising opportunities, contact Meg Larcinese at<br />
megl@thetruckermedia.com.<br />
© 2024 Wilshire Classifieds LLC, all rights reserved. Reproduction without written permission prohibited. The<br />
publisher assumes no responsibility for unsolicited material. All advertisements and editorial materials are accepted<br />
and published by Truckload Authority and its exclusive partner, The Trucker Media Group, on the representation<br />
that the advertiser, its advertising company and/or the supplier of editorial materials are authorized to<br />
publish the entire contents and subject matter thereof. The publisher reserves the right to accept or reject any art<br />
from client. Such entities and/or their agents will defend, indemnify and hold Truckload Authority, Truckload Carriers<br />
Association, The Trucker Media Group, and its subsidiaries included, by not limited to, The Trucker Media<br />
Group, harmless from and against any loss, expense, or other trademark infringement and any other claims or<br />
suits for libel, violations of privacy, plagiarism, copyright or trademark infringement and any other claims or suits<br />
that may rise out of publication of such advertisements and/or editorial materials. Press releases are expressly<br />
covered within the definition of editorial materials.<br />
4 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024<br />
.COM
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 5
Government affairs<br />
NO<br />
‘CURE-ALL’<br />
Drug & Alcohol<br />
Clearinghouse reports<br />
highlight needs but<br />
offer few solutions<br />
By Cliff Abbott<br />
When it comes to Congressional action, movement is<br />
often excruciatingly slow.<br />
“Unfortunately, it is rather stagnant up there” is<br />
a comment that could have come from a variety of<br />
sources regarding any number of issues awaiting resolution<br />
on Capitol Hill.<br />
In this case, the comment comes from David Heller, senior<br />
vice president of safety and government affairs for the<br />
Truckload Carriers Association (TCA), and the topic is drug<br />
and alcohol testing for commercial drivers.<br />
The admission of oral fluid and hair follicle testing are two<br />
issues that concern Heller. He was involved in the implementation<br />
of last year’s oral fluid testing rulemaking by the<br />
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) and<br />
the addition of hair follicle testing to programs approved by<br />
the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT).<br />
“Certainly, oral fluid testing would be a win-win for the<br />
industry,” Heller said. “We have a rule that went into place in<br />
June, but we still don’t have two laboratories that have been<br />
certified to move forward on this testing mechanism.<br />
“We as an industry continue to wait on government interaction,<br />
and it’s just not happening,” he continued.<br />
Through conversations with TCA membership, Heller has<br />
found that increasing numbers of motor carriers are using<br />
hair follicle testing for controlled substances.<br />
“I think you’re starting to see hair follicle testing trickled<br />
down to mid-sized carriers because of the success that<br />
large carriers have had in implementing this type of program,”<br />
he said.<br />
Yet another leadership change at the FMCSA hasn’t improved<br />
the situation, according to Heller. Acting Administrator<br />
Robin Hutcheson left the agency in January and was<br />
replaced by Executive Director and Chief Safety Officer Sue<br />
Lawless, who addressed TCA members during the association’s<br />
annual convention in March.<br />
In December 2023, the FMCSA’s Drug & Alcohol Clearinghouse<br />
completed its fourth year of operations. Monthly reports<br />
show the total number of Clearinghouse queries, both full and<br />
limited, has grown each year of the program’s existence.<br />
In 2023, a total of 7,134,622 Clearinghouse queries were<br />
conducted. Of those queries, 2,701,444 were full inquiries<br />
for pre-employment purposes. Pre-employment queries<br />
grew by 4.8% from 2022 levels and total queries by 2.7%.<br />
Also rising were the number of drug violations reported.<br />
In 2023, a total of 68,229 violations were reported, representing<br />
a new high. In an interesting twist, however, the<br />
number of positive drug screens actually declined by 5.4%,<br />
down from 57,597 in 2022 to 54,464 in 2023. This is an indication<br />
that increased numbers of specimens were positive<br />
for more than one controlled substance.<br />
While it may seem strange that positive test results declined<br />
while overall violations increased, the difference lies<br />
in the number of test refusals.<br />
In 2023, 12,804 driver refusals to test were reported.<br />
That’s 18% of the year’s total violations. Each year from<br />
2020-2022, the refusal to test rate hovered around 12%.<br />
When only random drug tests are considered, the number<br />
of refusals in 2023 climbed to 21% of all reported violations.<br />
Sponsored by SCALE FUNDING / GETSCALEFUNDING.com / 800.707.4845<br />
6 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
Sponsored by<br />
Heller believes the increased refusals may be evidence that<br />
the Clearinghouse is having its intended effect.<br />
“(Offenders) know that they won’t be allowed to get behind<br />
the wheel, and they choose to find other work,” he said.<br />
The percentage of positive test results attributable to marijuana<br />
(cannabis) has increased each year of the Clearinghouse, reaching<br />
61.3% in 2023. That’s likely a result of the progression of jurisdictions<br />
that have legalized marijuana for recreational or medical use<br />
or have decriminalized its possession or use. The increase in marijuana<br />
use may also help explain the increased number of refusals to<br />
test that the Clearinghouse reported in 2023.<br />
In his State of the Union address on March 6, President Joe<br />
Biden reiterated his October 2022 comments made regarding issuing<br />
a pardon proclamation for thousands of Americans convicted<br />
in federal court of marijuana possession.<br />
“No one should be in jail just for using or possessing<br />
marijuana,” Biden said. An administration-prompted review in<br />
2022 resulted in a U.S. Department of Health and Human Services<br />
recommendation, issued in August 2023, that cannabis be moved<br />
to Schedule III of the Controlled Substances Act.<br />
Another drug that captured an increased percentage of positive<br />
drug screens in 2023 was cocaine. According to Clearinghouse<br />
reports, 16.8% of positives reported were due to<br />
the drug. Unlike marijuana, there is not a nationwide effort to<br />
decriminalize cocaine; however, another testing trend could be<br />
impacting its use.<br />
Opioids such as hydrocodone, hydromorphone, oxycodone,<br />
and oxymorphone have been in the news in recent years as<br />
abuse of these prescription drugs reached epidemic proportions.<br />
As of November 2023, 38 states had enacted restrictions<br />
on the prescribing of opioids. In 2022, the Centers for Disease<br />
Control revamped its previous guidance, issuing new guidelines<br />
for the dispensing of opioids, influencing the policymaking of<br />
legislatures and health organizations.<br />
The four opioids mentioned above were responsible for 8.5%<br />
of all positive results reported to the Clearinghouse in 2020.<br />
That rate has fallen each year, with 2023 results showing the<br />
lowest total number of positives yet with a positive rate of 6.0%.<br />
Positive results for other forms of opioids such as morphine, codeine,<br />
and 6-acetylmorphine have remained relatively constant.<br />
Methamphetamine has also experienced declines in positive<br />
testing, dropping to 7.3% of all positive results reported to the<br />
Clearinghouse in 2023.<br />
One possible cause for the decline in positive results for opioids<br />
and methamphetamine is the increased presence of fentanyl,<br />
which may soon be added to the DOT testing regimen.<br />
In the meantime, it seems many commercial drivers with positive<br />
test results recorded in the Clearinghouse prefer to choose<br />
a new career rather than comply with federal regulations. Of the<br />
226,598 drivers found with at least one violation since the Clearinghouse<br />
became active, 158,330 — that’s 70% — remain in<br />
prohibited status. On top of that, 120,676 (53.2%) have not even<br />
begun the return-to-duty process.<br />
This could be an indication that efforts to solve the issue of<br />
substance abuse will impact another problem cited by many<br />
motor carriers — a shortage of qualified drivers.<br />
In the meantime, it seems, the trucking industry is stuck waiting<br />
in line, hoping for a “prescription” that will cure all ills.<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 7
Government affairs<br />
How MUCH<br />
is TOO Much?<br />
Electrification of the<br />
trucking industry has a price<br />
tag of at least $1 trillion<br />
By John Worthen<br />
The cost of fully electrifying the trucking industry is staggering.<br />
There’s a lot more to consider than simply the cost of new<br />
vehicles — which is considerable in itself. The nation will need<br />
to build a network of charging stations that’s capable of powering<br />
thousands of heavy commercial vehicles each day.<br />
A recent study, commissioned by the Clean Freight Coalition (CFC)<br />
and conducted by Roland Berger, reveals that creating a sufficiently<br />
dense long-haul charging network would require an initial investment<br />
of at least $57 billion investment by fuel retailers.<br />
To electrify all medium- and heavy-duty vehicles, fleets and<br />
charge point operators will need to invest $620 billion into chargers,<br />
site infrastructure, and utility service costs, the study notes.<br />
These figures are swirling around the trucking industry, creating<br />
a firestorm of debate.<br />
That’s because the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)<br />
on Friday, March 29, released strict new emissions standards for<br />
heavy-duty trucks, buses, and other large vehicles. Officials say<br />
the new standards will help clean up some of the nation’s largest<br />
sources of planet-warming greenhouse gases.<br />
According to the EPA, the new rules, which take effect for model<br />
years 2027 through 2032, will avoid up to 1 billion tons of greenhouse<br />
gas emissions over the next three decades and provide $13<br />
billion in net benefits in the form of fewer hospital visits, lost workdays,<br />
and deaths. In particular, the EPA says, the new standards<br />
will benefit an estimated 72 million people in the U.S. who live near<br />
freight routes used by trucks and other heavy vehicles and bear a<br />
disproportionate burden of dangerous air pollution.<br />
The new rules for heavy trucks and buses came just a week after<br />
the EPA announced new automobile emissions standards for passenger<br />
vehicles, which relax initial tailpipe limits proposed last year<br />
but are close to the same strict standards set out by the EPA for<br />
model year 2032.<br />
The rule for trucks is complex, with a range of electric-vehicle or<br />
other non-traditional sales projected, depending on the type of vehicle<br />
and use. For instance, 30% of heavy-duty vocational trucks and<br />
40% of short-haul day cab tractors must be zero-emission by 2032.<br />
Not long after the release of EPA’s statement, trucking industry<br />
stakeholders — including fuel providers and retailers, as well<br />
as motor carriers and others — were firing out responses. Most<br />
lambasted the new standards as unreachable with current electricvehicle<br />
(EV) technology and pointed out a lack of EV charging stations<br />
and power grid capacity limits.<br />
Most groups say the EPA’s new emission standards for heavyduty<br />
trucks have unachievable targets and will carry real consequences<br />
for the U.S. supply chain and movement of freight.<br />
Like others in the trucking industry, Jim Ward, president of the<br />
Truckload Carriers Association (TCA), believes the new EPA rule<br />
will have a significantly negative impact on its members, as well as<br />
the industry as a whole.<br />
“It’s important to recognize the progress that’s been made by<br />
our many TCA members who have tested equipment, trained both<br />
technicians and professional drivers, while incurring additional<br />
costs along the way to complying with EPA regulations instituted<br />
over the past couple of decades,” Ward said.<br />
“The industry has effectively reduced NOx and particulate matters<br />
through the evolution and implementation of new technologies<br />
and remains committed to being a good steward of the environment,”<br />
he continued. “The journey ahead provides for many<br />
alternatives to be considered to lower carbon, such as blended<br />
biodiesel, renewable natural gas, diesel-electric — just to name a<br />
few — to help us bridge the gap to the future.<br />
“We cannot just sit idly by and watch the implementation of a<br />
policy that will have a significant impact on our members’ business,”<br />
he concluded.<br />
NATSO, an organization that represents America’s travel plazas and<br />
truck stops, and SIGMA: America’s Leading Fuel Marketers, said in a<br />
joint statement that while they appreciate that the Biden administration<br />
is working toward reducing carbon emissions, the new EPA rule is<br />
poised to have negative effects on trucking and its related industries.<br />
“The administration’s final rule does not adequately consider<br />
the challenges that fuel retailers face in transitioning to heavy-duty<br />
truck electrification,” the joint statement noted. “The administration’s<br />
final rule also does not recognize the need to support lower<br />
carbon alternatives to diesel fuel that are currently commercially<br />
viable, such as biodiesel and renewable diesel.”<br />
In addition, reports from the American Transportation Research<br />
Institute (ATRI) identify the many challenges facing commercialvehicle<br />
electrification in the areas of U.S. electricity supply and demand,<br />
electric vehicle production, and truck-charging requirements.<br />
“Off-highway refueling locations will need dozens of fast-<br />
Sponsored by SCALE FUNDING / GETSCALEFUNDING.com / 800.707.4845<br />
8 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
chargers to service heavy-duty trucks,” the NATSO/SIGMA<br />
statement read. “The charging capacity required at a single<br />
large truck stop would be roughly equivalent to the electric<br />
load of an entire small town. Considering that utilities will<br />
need to invest $320 billion to upgrade the nation’s power<br />
grid, we remain unconvinced that the electricity providers<br />
will be able to increase generation and transmission activity<br />
to service that kind of load at scale within 10 years.”<br />
The American Trucking Associations (ATA) “opposes this<br />
rule in its current form because the post-2030 targets remain<br />
entirely unachievable given the current state of zeroemission<br />
technology, the lack of charging infrastructure and<br />
restrictions on the power grid,” said Chris Spear, the association’s<br />
president and CEO.<br />
While the EPA’s final rule includes lower zero-emission vehicle<br />
rates for model years 2027-2029, the ATA says forced zeroemission<br />
vehicle penetration rates in the later years will drive<br />
only battery-electric and hydrogen investment, limiting fleets’<br />
choices with early-stage technology that is still unproven.<br />
“The trucking industry is fully committed to the road to<br />
zero emissions, but the path to get there must be paved with<br />
common sense,” Spear said. “While we are disappointed<br />
with today’s rule, we will continue to work with EPA to address<br />
its shortcomings and advance emission-reduction<br />
targets and timelines that are both realistic and durable.”<br />
Jim Mullen, executive director of the Clean Freight Coalition<br />
(CFC), says the organization opposes the new EPA ruling,<br />
noting that today’s zero-emission commercial vehicles<br />
“fail to meet the operational demands of many motor carrier<br />
applications, reduce the payload of trucks, and thereby<br />
require more trucks to haul the same amount of freight and<br />
lack sufficient charging and alternative fueling infrastructure<br />
to support adoption.”<br />
Referring to the Roland Berger study, Mullen pointed out<br />
that currently a diesel Class 8 diesel truck costs roughly<br />
$180,000 compared to an electric truck’s price tag of<br />
$400,000. Those increased costs will ultimately be borne<br />
on the backs of consumers, he said.<br />
“On top of the costs to the truck and bus industries, utilities<br />
and the government will need to invest $370 billion to<br />
upgrade their networks and the power grid to meet the demands<br />
of the commercial vehicle industry alone, putting the<br />
price tag for an electric supply chain at nearly $1 trillion before<br />
one battery-electric commercial vehicle is purchased,”<br />
Mullen said.<br />
Instead of demanding the adoption of technology that<br />
brings “exorbitant costs and operational concerns,” Mullen<br />
believes policymakers should support lower-carbon alternatives<br />
to diesel, such as biodiesel and renewable diesel.<br />
Mullen stresses that the CFC supports sound policies that<br />
promote the sustainable and affordable transition to zeroemission<br />
commercial vehicles — and will embrace any<br />
powertrain to reach these goals and protect the integrity of<br />
the nation’s supply chain — “the Phase 3 GHG rule fails to<br />
meet that standard.”<br />
When the road gets rough,<br />
Scale Funding can help.<br />
Drive your cash flow with our custom<br />
invoice factoring programs.<br />
Factoring with Scale Funding Includes:<br />
Month-to-month agreements<br />
Lines from $50,000 to $10MM<br />
Funding in 24 hours or less<br />
High advances, low rates<br />
Unmatched support: your client<br />
team answers the phone<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 9<br />
www.getscalefunding.com | (800) 707-4845
CAPITOL recap<br />
A REVIEW OF IMPORTANT NEWS, LEGISLATION, REGULATIONS,<br />
AND OTHER FACTORS IMPACTING THE TRUCKING INDUSTRY<br />
Bills that would eliminate the federal excise tax on heavy-duty trucks was introduced in both the U.S. House and Senate in March 2023.<br />
Legislation to repeal the FET still<br />
stalled in Congressional committees<br />
By John Worthen<br />
Since the Modern Clean and Safe Trucks Act of 2023<br />
was introduced in both the House (HR1440) and Senate<br />
(S694) in March 2023, there’s been little movement on the<br />
legislation.<br />
The bill, if passed, would end the federal excise tax, commonly<br />
known as the FET, on the purchase of new big rigs<br />
— a move that’s heralded by many in the trucking industry<br />
as a major step forward.<br />
The act was introduced by a bipartisan coalition of representatives<br />
and senators, led by Reps. Doug LaMalfa (R-<br />
CA), Chris Pappas (D-NH), Earl Blumenauer (D-OR), and<br />
Darin LaHood (R-IL) in the House, and Sens. Ben Cardin<br />
(D-MD) and Todd Young (I-PA) in the Senate.<br />
Bill co-sponsor Pappas said that as a small business<br />
owner, he knows just how challenging it can be to operate<br />
a business and that every potential saving makes a<br />
difference.<br />
The federal excise tax on purchases of new trucks adds,<br />
on average, nearly $25,000 to the cost of new equipment,<br />
slowing deployment of safer and more environmentally<br />
friendly vehicles, according to trucking industry leaders.<br />
“Cutting the federal excise tax on heavy trucks and trailers<br />
will help America’s Main Street economy grow, address<br />
supply chain challenges and shortages, and lower costs for<br />
essential items that families need, including groceries and<br />
gas,” Pappas said.<br />
The legislation “will also support the adoption of newer,<br />
safer, and cleaner trucks that reduce our dependence<br />
on foreign energy. I urge leaders in Congress to take up<br />
our bipartisan bill and act to provide immediate relief to<br />
Sponsored by SCALE FUNDING / GETSCALEFUNDING.com / 800.707.4845<br />
10 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
CAPITOL recap<br />
small businesses and consumers alike,” he added.<br />
The last movement on the bill in the House was on<br />
March 8, 2023, when it was referred to the House Committee<br />
on Ways and Means. Over in the Senate, the bill<br />
was read twice on March 8, 2023, and referred to the<br />
Committee on Finance.<br />
Since then, there’s been no movement on either side<br />
of Congress.<br />
As of now, there is no firm timeline in place for when<br />
the bill will next see movement, said Dave Heller, senior<br />
vice president of safety and government affairs for the<br />
Truckload Carriers Association.<br />
“We would love to get (the FET repealed),” he said,<br />
adding that the tax on heavy trucks, instituted in 1917,<br />
was originally intended to support war efforts during<br />
World War I.<br />
“That war is long gone,” he said. “Why are we still<br />
paying this on new equipment when in reality, it could<br />
encourage further incentive to purchase more modern<br />
tech, etc.? We need to encourage folks to get into the<br />
new vehicle game.”<br />
Adam Blanchard, co-founder and CEO of Double Diamond<br />
Transport, Inc., describes the FET as outdated.<br />
“It disproportionately impacts certain segments of<br />
industry,” Blanchard said. “There is a better way to get<br />
funds into the Highway Trust Fund than this tax. It’s difficult,<br />
especially at a time, too, when equipment costs<br />
have gone up 50% year over year. When you tack on<br />
this tax, it hammers our ability to afford equipment.<br />
“Smaller fleets don’t have the same purchasing<br />
power as larger fleets,” he continued. “It certainly is a<br />
regressive tax that needs to be eliminated.”<br />
The 12% tax on trucks is the highest-percentage excise<br />
tax levied on any product, according to the American<br />
Trucking Associations. This added expense acts as<br />
an impediment to creating jobs, reducing emissions,<br />
and improving highway safety.<br />
“The current federal excise tax has become a barrier<br />
to our progress in encouraging cleaner and greener<br />
technology,” said Senate co-sponsor Cardin. “I am<br />
proud to support tax policy that enables … manufacturers<br />
to innovate and deploy cleaner and safer technologies<br />
in our trucking industry. Our legislation will spur<br />
growth and competitiveness while making our roads<br />
safer and less polluted.”<br />
Albert Gore, executive director of the Zero Emission<br />
Transportation Association, said the tax harms American<br />
truckers and fleet operators by inflating the cost<br />
of heavy-duty trucks and limiting access to the many<br />
economic and public health benefits that come with<br />
transportation electrification.<br />
“Medium- and heavy-duty trucks account for 24% of<br />
all transportation carbon emissions in the U.S. but represent<br />
only 4% of vehicles on the road,” Gore said. “It is<br />
(The FET) disproportionately<br />
impacts certain segments<br />
of industry. ... It’s difficult,<br />
especially at a time, too, when<br />
equipment costs have gone up<br />
50% year over year. When you tack<br />
on this tax, it hammers our ability<br />
to afford equipment. Smaller fleets<br />
don’t have the same purchasing<br />
power as larger fleets.”<br />
— Adam Blanchard<br />
CO-FOUNDER & CEO<br />
DOUBLE DIAMOND TRANSPORT, INC.<br />
time to accelerate our movement towards modernized<br />
transportation fleets, and we must enable our nation’s<br />
fleet operators and truckers to join in this effort.”<br />
Steve Bassett, immediate past chairman of American<br />
Truck Dealers (ATD) and dealer principal of General<br />
Truck Sales in Muncie, Indiana, said dealerships in the<br />
state “commend Sen. Young for his leadership on this<br />
important legislation. Repealing the 106-year-old federal<br />
excise tax on heavy-duty trucks helps keep America<br />
competitive and is key to turning over an aging truck<br />
fleet.”<br />
LaMalfa said that regulators want to shift operators<br />
from older trucks to newer models — but on the other<br />
hand, the tax penalizes them for trying to update their<br />
equipment.<br />
“Repealing the 12% federal excise tax on heavy<br />
trucks and trailers will help all businesses reduce costs,<br />
address supply chain challenges and lower costs for<br />
essential goods for families, especially in rural areas,”<br />
LaMalfa said. “The federal excise tax has outlived its<br />
original purpose by more than a century.”<br />
House co-sponsor LaMalfa noted that truckers are<br />
“an essential cornerstone in our supply chain, yet the<br />
tax code disincentivizes them from purchasing the<br />
most up-to-date equipment.”<br />
“I’m urging Congress to support this common-sense,<br />
bipartisan bill and drop the burdensome tax preventing<br />
our truck drivers from having the most modern, highest<br />
technology, and safest equipment on the road,” he<br />
added.<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 11
CAPITOL recap<br />
If passed, the Truck Parking Safety Improvement Act would provide $755 million over three years to expand truck parking across the U.S.<br />
Proposed legislation offers hope for<br />
better truck parking in the US<br />
By John Worthen<br />
Everyone in the trucking industry wants more parking.<br />
Even though strides are being made to build new sites for<br />
drivers to shut down and rest, there’s still a long way to go<br />
to remedy the shortage.<br />
Proposed legislation has given hope to many in the industry.<br />
Known officially as HR2367, the Truck Parking Safety<br />
Improvement Act would provide $755 million over three<br />
years to expand truck parking capacity. Right now, the act’s<br />
fate is unknown.<br />
David Heller, senior vice president of safety and government<br />
affairs for the Truckload Carriers Association, is optimistic.<br />
“We continue to pitch co-sponsors for the bill,” he told<br />
Truckload Authority in April. “In the Senate, there are 15 cosponsors,<br />
and another recently signed to get this moving<br />
— to make the act something the Senate cannot refuse. Our<br />
target is between 20 and 25 co-sponsors. As we continue<br />
down the road and push for the legislation, it’s still being<br />
talked about. The opportunity could be there in a year-end<br />
spending package.”<br />
On May 23, 2023, the House Committee on Transportation<br />
and Infrastructure passed an amended version of the<br />
act by a vote of 60-4 — and the bill has not moved since.<br />
Heller said he hopes that, if a funding package is introduced<br />
for the act, it won’t be roped into a larger bill filled<br />
with pork-barrel spending.<br />
“This is a problem that needs to be remedied,” he said.<br />
In a statement regarding the Truck Parking Safety Improvement<br />
Act, TCA said it applauds the effort.<br />
“This positive outcome represents a significant step forward<br />
in enhancing driver safety, ensuring compliance with<br />
federal regulations, and improving the operational efficiency<br />
of the trucking industry,” according to TCA’s statement.<br />
Currently, the trucking industry is facing a critical shortage<br />
of parking spaces, with a ratio of just one parking spot<br />
for every 11 drivers.<br />
“This legislation highlights the Committee’s dedication to<br />
resolving the persistent challenge of truck parking shortages,<br />
which have long posed safety risks and hindered the<br />
productivity of supply chains,” the TCA said in its statement.<br />
“Adequate truck parking facilities allow drivers to take necessary<br />
rest breaks, comply with federal Hours of Service<br />
regulations, and effectively manage their schedules, leading<br />
to increased efficiency and improved road safety for all.”<br />
SEE PARKING, PAGE 15<br />
Sponsored by SCALE FUNDING / GETSCALEFUNDING.com / 800.707.4845<br />
12 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
CAPITOL recap<br />
Battle to pass legislation limiting ‘nuclear’<br />
verdicts continues at the state level<br />
By John Worthen<br />
In February, the Wisconsin State Legislature passed a reform<br />
to the state’s civil litigation system that would cap noneconomic<br />
damage awards at $1 million.<br />
However, Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers quickly vetoed the<br />
measure.<br />
In a statement, Evers called the $1 million cap arbitrary<br />
saying, “the law should redress a party’s injury; not repress<br />
an injured party.” Evers also said the bill violates the U.S.<br />
and Wisconsin constitutions’ guarantees of due process and<br />
would conflict with existing state law, inviting “continuous<br />
litigation.”<br />
Meanwhile, West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice has signed<br />
into law a bill capping non-economic damage awards in<br />
CMV-related accidents at $5 million. And in Georgia, Gov.<br />
Brian Kemp is calling for the state to study limiting so-called<br />
“nuclear verdicts.”<br />
Nuclear verdicts are generally understood to be in excess<br />
of $10 million. That said, what constitutes a “nuclear”<br />
amount depends on the level of insurance coverage and the<br />
size of a trucking company.<br />
Many in the trucking industry believe capping these subjective,<br />
nonmonetary losses is critical to ensuring fairness<br />
and balance in civil litigation, and that doing so will the deter<br />
abusive and frivolous lawsuits that have perverted the system<br />
into a profit center for the plaintiffs’ bar.<br />
“The laws on our books make it too easy to bring frivolous<br />
lawsuits against Georgia business owners, which drive up the<br />
price of insurance and stops new, good-paying jobs from ever<br />
coming to communities that need them the most,” Kemp said.<br />
This statement aligns with Kemp’s background as a property<br />
developer. Owners of commercial properties and apartment<br />
complexes have been some of the biggest supporters<br />
of lawsuit limits. Another big backer is the trucking industry.<br />
Kemp called the burdens on those industries unacceptable:<br />
“Local trucking companies either can’t afford the insurance<br />
they’re offered or can’t find a carrier altogether, and business<br />
owners live in fear of being sued for ridiculous claims on<br />
their property,” Kemp said.<br />
Kemp says his call to “level the playing field in our courtrooms”<br />
will cut insurance premiums and help create more<br />
jobs.<br />
The Truckload Carriers Association (TCA) is working to<br />
educate its members about lawsuit abuse reform and to<br />
bring the matter to federal legislators.<br />
“It’s something we always have our eye on,” said Dave<br />
Heller, TCA’s senior vice president of safety and government<br />
affairs.<br />
According to the American Transportation Research<br />
Institute (ATRI), within a recent eight-year period, settlement<br />
amounts in trucking accident cases increased 51.7%<br />
While a few U.S. states have passed laws capping excessive damage awards, the<br />
idea is struggling to gain traction in other areas of the nation.<br />
annually, rising from $2.3 to $23 million. In addition, data<br />
collected over a recent 13-year period revealed that during<br />
the first five years of the period studied, 26 truck accident<br />
lawsuits produced verdicts of over $1 million. In the last five<br />
years of data studied, there were 300.<br />
Neal Kedzie, president of the Wisconsin Motor Carriers<br />
Association, says the legislation knocked down by Evers had<br />
broad support in the state legislature — and across the state<br />
— and expressed disappointment with that the governor’s<br />
veto.<br />
“Wisconsin’s trucking industry is essential to everyone in<br />
our state, and rampant lawsuit abuse is impeding our ability<br />
to do our job safely and efficiently,” Kedzie said. The trucking<br />
industry is a key provider of middle-class jobs in Wisconsin,<br />
employing approximately 183,780 people throughout the<br />
state. More than 77% of Wisconsin communities rely exclusively<br />
on trucks to receive their goods.<br />
Traci Nelson, president of the West Virginia Trucking Association,<br />
lauded the passage of lawsuit abuse reform legislation<br />
in her state and expressed appreciation to lawmakers.<br />
“With approximately 33,890 West Virginians employed in<br />
the trucking industry and 84% of our communities relying<br />
solely on trucks for goods transportation, this legislation is<br />
critical for our state’s economic well-being,” Nelson said.<br />
“When the plaintiffs’ bar perverts civil litigation into a casino<br />
game of ‘jackpot justice,’ the costs are borne by everyone<br />
— not just trucking companies, but consumers too,<br />
in the form of higher insurance rates and higher prices for<br />
everyday goods,” said Chris Spear, president and CEO of the<br />
American Trucking Associations, adding that “reasonable<br />
reform ensures justice and fairness drive accident litigation<br />
outcomes, not profits.”<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 13
CAPITOL recap<br />
$830 million in grants earmarked to help<br />
infrastructure withstand climate change<br />
By John Worthen<br />
The Biden administration has awarded $830 million in grants to fund 80 projects<br />
aimed at toughening the nation’s aging infrastructure against the impacts of<br />
climate change.<br />
As weather events increase in frequency and severity,<br />
the nation’s transportation infrastructure is taking a beating.<br />
A large part of the system was designed and built<br />
before the effects of climate change began to worsen.<br />
In April, the Department of Transportation (DOT) announced<br />
that nearly $830 million in grant funding has<br />
been earmarked for 80 projects across the nation. According<br />
to a statement released by the DOT, the projects<br />
will strengthen surface transportation systems and make<br />
them more resilient to extreme weather.<br />
The grants, touted by the Biden-Harris administration<br />
as the first of their kind, were made possible by the Bipartisan<br />
Infrastructure Law’s Promoting Resilient Operations<br />
for Transformative, Efficient and Cost-saving Transportation<br />
(PROTECT) Discretionary Grant Program, which<br />
complements PROTECT Formula funding.<br />
According to the DOT, PROTECT Grant Program will<br />
fund projects that will strengthen the nation’s surface<br />
transportation system — including roads, bridges, highways,<br />
public transportation, pedestrian facilities, ports,<br />
and intercity passenger rail — against extreme weather<br />
events.<br />
“Every community in America knows the impacts of climate<br />
change and extreme weather, including increasingly<br />
frequent heavy rain and flooding events across the country<br />
and sea-level rise that is inundating infrastructure in<br />
coastal states,” said Shailen Bhatt, administrator of the<br />
Federal Highway Administration.<br />
Bhatt praised the administration’s efforts, noting that<br />
the investment “will ensure our infrastructure is built<br />
to withstand more frequent and unpredictable extreme<br />
weather” and that reliable roads and bridges will help<br />
keep the nation’s economy moving.<br />
“From wildfires shutting down freight rail lines in California<br />
to mudslides closing down a highway in Colorado,<br />
from a drought causing the halt of barge traffic on the<br />
Mississippi River to subways being flooded in New York,<br />
extreme weather, made worse by climate change, is damaging<br />
America’s transportation infrastructure, cutting<br />
people off from getting to where they need to go, and<br />
threatening to raise the cost of goods by disrupting supply<br />
chains,” said Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.<br />
The $830 million will be distributed as follows:<br />
• Planning Grants — 26 projects will receive approximately<br />
$45 million to help grant recipients develop resilience-improvement<br />
plans, resilience planning, predesign<br />
and design activities, capacity-building activities, and<br />
evacuation planning and preparation initiatives.<br />
• Resilience Improvement Grants — 36 projects will<br />
receive approximately $621 million to enhance the resilience<br />
of existing surface-transportation infrastructure<br />
by improving drainage, relocating roadways, elevating<br />
bridges, or incorporating upgrades to allow infrastructure<br />
to meet or exceed design standards.<br />
• Community Resilience and Evacuation Routes —<br />
10 projects will receive approximately $45 million for<br />
improvements to enhance the resilience of evacuation<br />
routes or to enhance their capacity and add redundant<br />
evacuation routes.<br />
• At-risk Coastal Infrastructure — Eight projects will receive<br />
approximately $119 million to protect, strengthen,<br />
or relocate coastal highway and non-rail infrastructure.<br />
The program also will improve equity and further environmental<br />
justice by addressing the needs of disadvantaged<br />
communities that are often the most vulnerable to<br />
hazards. The program encouraged applicants from all levels<br />
of government—from local governments and Tribes<br />
to state DOTs—to apply for PROTECT discretionary-grant<br />
funding, which complements the more than $4.3 billion<br />
in PROTECT formula funding that is already flowing to<br />
states. Consistent with the objectives of the National Climate<br />
Resilience Framework, these awards will help these<br />
communities across the country become not only more<br />
resilient, but also more safe, healthy, equitable, and economically<br />
strong.<br />
Sponsored by SCALE FUNDING / GETSCALEFUNDING.com / 800.707.4845<br />
14 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
CAPITOL recap<br />
PARKING, FROM PAGE 12<br />
At the American Trucking Associations<br />
(ATA), Chris Spear, the association’s president<br />
and CEO, pointed to the parking act<br />
and several other pieces of legislation as<br />
positive measures for the trucking industry.<br />
“(These) comprehensive and bipartisan<br />
bills … would address some of the root<br />
causes of ongoing supply chain challenges<br />
and improve the overall safety, efficiency,<br />
and resiliency of freight transportation,” he<br />
said.<br />
“ATA has repeatedly engaged with Congress<br />
to discuss persistent challenges facing<br />
our industry, and we thank Chairman<br />
Graves for his attention to these issues<br />
and for his leadership of today’s markup,”<br />
Spear continued. “We also commend the<br />
bill sponsors who worked with us and other<br />
key stakeholders to craft solutions that<br />
would benefit our industry, the economy,<br />
and American consumers.”<br />
The Institute for Safer Trucking and Road<br />
Safe America sent a joint letter on October<br />
2, 2023, in favor of the proposed legislation.<br />
“As organizations committed to promoting<br />
truck safety, we are writing to express<br />
our strong support for the Truck Parking<br />
Safety Improvement Act,” the letter said.<br />
“We believe that this legislation is an important<br />
step toward improving the safety<br />
and well-being of commercial truck drivers,<br />
as well as other road users.”<br />
The letter went on to say that the shortage<br />
of safe and accessible truck parking<br />
spaces is a significant problem that affects<br />
drivers across the country. “The lack of<br />
available parking spaces can force drivers<br />
to park in unsafe and illegal locations, such<br />
as highway shoulders and off-ramps. This<br />
creates a dangerous situation for both the<br />
truck drivers themselves and other road users,”<br />
the statement noted.<br />
“If we are truly going to improve safety<br />
throughout the trucking industry, it is essential<br />
to prioritize the safety and wellbeing<br />
of commercial truck drivers. By providing<br />
safe and accessible truck parking facilities,<br />
we can help ensure that drivers can rest and<br />
recharge.<br />
“This will not only improve safety in the<br />
short term by reducing crashes, but it will<br />
also improve it in the long term. By improving<br />
truck drivers’ experiences on the road,<br />
the industry can improve retention of safe,<br />
experienced drivers,” the letter concluded.<br />
Let us show you the<br />
Art of Compliance<br />
through our Proactive<br />
compliance services.<br />
Check out CPSuite today.<br />
Visit www.Fleetworthy.com<br />
or call us at 608-230-8200<br />
to schedule a demo.<br />
Truckload Authority 15
Tracking the trends<br />
Retaining Training<br />
Make sure your team takes<br />
skills, information from the<br />
classroom to the highway<br />
By Dwain Hebda<br />
If it feels like your company’s driver training and other educational<br />
programs are falling on deaf ears when participants leave the<br />
classroom and return to the road, it might not be a case of poor<br />
attitude or an inability to learn on the part of the trainees.<br />
According to training experts, many companies go to great<br />
lengths to educate their employees — only to overlook one critical<br />
part of the process: consistent follow-up.<br />
“You never want to stop educating. You want to have recurrent<br />
education. Communication is huge, and it differs with different<br />
segments of industry,” said Mike Brust, director of safety and loss<br />
prevention for the Arkansas Trucking Association.<br />
“The less-than-truckload side is going to see the drivers faceto-face<br />
quite a bit and you can easily schedule meetings and impart<br />
information,” he explained. “For a truckload carrier, you often<br />
don’t see those drivers for months. In that situation, you have to<br />
discuss things — pat them on the back, let them know they’re<br />
not forgotten, that they’re part of the team. That’s extremely<br />
important.”<br />
Technology offers a great assist<br />
in this process, limited only<br />
by the creativity and imagination<br />
of the training team, Brust<br />
said.<br />
“One item that I’ve seen to<br />
be very successful is the use<br />
of video,” he said. “Use a<br />
phone to video record drivers<br />
performing a job properly,<br />
such as pre- and posttrip<br />
inspections, proper<br />
three points of contact<br />
getting into and out of<br />
a tractor, proper lifting,<br />
proper backing, etc.<br />
“Employees like to see<br />
one of their co-workers<br />
in the videos; I have<br />
used this in the past<br />
with great success,”<br />
he added.<br />
16 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
Brust says the best companies recognize that instructions<br />
from even the best training teams usually pale in<br />
comparison to advice from employees that others look up<br />
to, especially when adopting new materials and adapting<br />
to change. The most successful training programs engage<br />
employees who are respected by their peers early in the<br />
process.<br />
“When I worked for FedEx and other truckload carriers,<br />
we brought those folks in and we explained (the new material)<br />
to them — how it benefits them and how it benefits<br />
the company,” he said. “Whenever we had major changes<br />
going on or something worth looking at, we’d bring those<br />
guys in or contact them through a conference call to get<br />
their feedback and their buy-in. Once you have their buyin,<br />
that goes a long way in how things are perceived and<br />
accepted by everyone else.”<br />
Even with that endorsement,<br />
it’s up to each individual<br />
employee to learn,<br />
accept, and put into practice<br />
whatever new material is being<br />
presented. This can be<br />
difficult to accomplish, no<br />
matter how much benefit the<br />
changes represent.<br />
Dr. Gina Anderson, CEO<br />
of Luma Brighter Learning,<br />
says having an intentional<br />
approach to the presentation<br />
of material, combined with<br />
thorough follow-up, presents<br />
the best chance that the<br />
materials are learned and applied<br />
consistently.<br />
“The first step in the learning<br />
process is to get a learner’s attention — and then you<br />
have to keep it,” she said.<br />
“Our minds quickly begin to wander, so even though<br />
the person is physically in the room where training is happening,<br />
the reality is that their minds most likely are elsewhere,”<br />
she warned. “With safety training, it is imperative<br />
to use information processing encoding strategies to help<br />
learners remember information indefinitely.”<br />
One vital strategy is to focus on the most important information<br />
for learners to retain.<br />
“For example, our cognitive abilities have limits. It is<br />
critical that coaches identify what they want the learner<br />
to remember after the learning session so that those critical<br />
understandings can be reinforced in multiple ways, in<br />
multiple mediums, over time,” Anderson said. “Educational<br />
goals are broad and overarching, while short-term<br />
objectives are measurable steps taken to achieve goals;<br />
You never want to stop<br />
educating. You want<br />
to have recurrent<br />
education. Communication is<br />
huge, and it differs with different<br />
segments of industry.”<br />
therefore, it is more effective to articulate outcomes in<br />
measurable deliverables.”<br />
Anderson says companies should not overlook a final<br />
two-part step following training: Offer recognition of employees<br />
who completed the training and seek ongoing<br />
feedback about the quality of the training itself. This offers<br />
powerful tools to improve both learners and educators.<br />
“It is important to build rewards and recognition into<br />
any learner program,” she said. “Game-based techniques<br />
like company stores, rewards, recognition, leaderboards,<br />
and shout-outs can all contribute to increased engagement<br />
and enjoyment in learning.<br />
“Creating meaningful assessments and feedback loops<br />
can help instructors determine how to improve learning,<br />
which is imperative in building impactful and effective<br />
education,” she continued. “Formative assessments can<br />
be accomplished through<br />
surveys, content ratings,<br />
— Mike Brust<br />
director of safety and loss prevention<br />
Arkansas Trucking Association<br />
and feedback loops, to name<br />
some examples.”<br />
Jeffrey Arnold, executive<br />
director for the North American<br />
Transportation Management<br />
Institute (NATMI), also<br />
suggests several strategies<br />
to ensure learners understand<br />
the material and to reinforce<br />
learning both during<br />
and after training.<br />
“Evaluate the trainee’s recall<br />
of the desired behaviors<br />
by asking the learner to recall<br />
the techniques presented<br />
during the training and repeat<br />
what they remember,”<br />
he said. “Then you can review or reteach any key items<br />
they miss.”<br />
Learning to apply classroom training to situations on the<br />
road is vital.<br />
“You should also ensure that the learning can be applied<br />
in a safe setting where students can practice and you can<br />
observe how effectively the new techniques are being applied,<br />
providing coaching and reinforcement where necessary,”<br />
he said.<br />
Arnold even suggested conducting a ride-along to help<br />
ensure new concepts are being applied under real-world<br />
conditions.<br />
“On a more general note, to reinforce learning, supervisors<br />
should acknowledge progress, celebrate accomplishments<br />
and provide positive feedback, consistently and<br />
frequently,” he said. “Habits are formed through repetition<br />
and reinforcement.”<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 17
Tracking the trends<br />
Benchmarking<br />
Success<br />
TCA’s Profitability Program helps<br />
carriers survive, even thrive,<br />
regardless of market conditions<br />
By Kris Rutherford<br />
There’s no doubt about it: The cost of trucking is on<br />
the rise.<br />
While increasing prices are pretty much par for the<br />
course, recent cost increases have exceeded those<br />
recorded in previous years.<br />
The American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI)<br />
reports that the average cost of operating a truck in 2022<br />
was $2.251 per mile. That was the first time this average<br />
crossed the $2 mark since the organization began tracking<br />
data in 2008. Year over year, operating costs in 2022 increased<br />
21.3% over 2021.<br />
Why? The reasons are many: Freight rates have fallen.<br />
Fuel costs have spiked. The cost of maintenance and repair<br />
on trucks has risen. In addition, driver wages are on the<br />
increase — which is not a bad thing in itself.<br />
Like ATRI, the Truckload Carriers Association (TCA) also<br />
tracks costs; however, TCA does so on a more frequent basis<br />
through its Profitability Program (TPP). The program is<br />
designed to share vital information with member carriers<br />
on a timely basis so companies can compare in-house results<br />
with how the rest of the industry is performing. These<br />
comparisons allow carriers to set benchmarks — standards<br />
against which companies’ performance is measured.<br />
Carriers tend to keep an eye on the successes of the<br />
top performers and learn what changes can be made in<br />
operations to move themselves into the “Best in Class”<br />
competition.<br />
As noted by Dave Broering, president of NCI Integrated<br />
Logistics, “In a softening market, with costs rising at an<br />
unparalleled pace, carrier benchmarking becomes more<br />
critical than ever.”<br />
In a February TCA webinar, “The Benefits of TCA’s Profitability<br />
Program and Benchmarking,” Jack Porter, TCA’s<br />
Profitability Program managing director, provided some<br />
insight into the association’s program, current trends,<br />
and suggestions for cost containment.<br />
The foundation of the TPP is for carriers to seek continuous<br />
improvement, set benchmarks for comparison,<br />
challenge business comfort zones, and navigate trucking<br />
cycles and challenges.<br />
Carriers that participate in the program share a primary<br />
component that is vital to improving a company’s profitability<br />
— a set of stated core values. Those core values go beyond<br />
simply making a profit; they set strategies and develop<br />
action items that stimulate progress. In addition, company<br />
management is dedicated to consistency. Everyone in these<br />
18 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
companies is aware of the core values, and management<br />
decisions can be clearly tied back to one or more values.<br />
Among the top data sources the TPP looks to is the Cass<br />
Freight Index. This index, updated monthly, shows deviation<br />
within the trucking business and is a gauge of supply<br />
and demand. Looking at the index over the past few years,<br />
trends indicate the trucking industry is returning to a historical<br />
level in terms of supply and demand. The COVID-19<br />
pandemic created wide swings in the Cass Index, but since<br />
mid-2022, indicators have begun to drop.<br />
According to TCA’s Porter, the Cass index is all about<br />
capacity, and capacity reflects demand.<br />
In terms of the number of carriers in operation, the figure<br />
has been consistent. But COVID changed that. Many<br />
small (1-5 truck) carriers entered the market to handle<br />
spot demand, and carrier population skyrocketed. Of late,<br />
many of those small carriers have left the market, and the<br />
number is slowly coming down.<br />
During TCA’s webinar, Porter pointed out several<br />
market trends that are currently impacting the trucking<br />
industry:<br />
• Rates are flat.<br />
• Fleet capacity/brokerage is waning.<br />
• Truck orders are stable.<br />
• Equipment-associated costs are rising.<br />
• Productivity is lagging, as figures such as miles per<br />
truck and gross margin per employee fall.<br />
Fortunately, signs indicate the industry is leaving a period<br />
of oversupply of truck capacity and entering one of<br />
balanced recovery.<br />
For carriers to remain competitive in a period of balanced<br />
recovery, Porter says they must adhere to several<br />
priorities:<br />
• Maintain high-quality customer service.<br />
• Know their networks — understand where their customers,<br />
drivers, and equipment are in the marketplace.<br />
• Keep trailers full.<br />
• Watch capacity fallout as small carriers leave the market.<br />
• Monitor equipment costs.<br />
Likewise, in terms of business operations, carriers<br />
must be prepared to revamp customer service and sales<br />
departments, prepare their businesses for an upcoming<br />
recovery, enhance the workforce, align their networks,<br />
and reduce expenses.<br />
To help TCA member carriers not only survive, but also<br />
thrive, the TPP tracks over 400 industry benchmarks, allowing<br />
companies to compare performance against the<br />
standard in hundreds of ways. Currently, trends in some<br />
of the primary benchmark categories indicate the trucking<br />
industry is in the midst of change.<br />
In terms of operating ratio (a measurement of how well<br />
a company can pay off its liabilities with current cash<br />
flow), Porter said, “The best (carriers) are still doing<br />
pretty damn good. The rest have had a really tough couple<br />
of years,” adding that those who have followed the<br />
principles of the profitability program have likely “weathered<br />
the storm and are pretty well off for a rebound.”<br />
As far as revenue per truck is concerned, the current<br />
average is $3,800 to $4,900 per month, a reflection of<br />
demand and the subdued freight rates. Driver wages as<br />
a percentage of revenue are in the 19% to 28% range,<br />
although in several sectors the figure exceeds 30%. This<br />
benchmark hovered at 25% before the COVID-19 pandemic.<br />
Independent contractors rank lowest when considering<br />
income.<br />
Gross profit as a percentage of revenue is currently in<br />
the 12% range. The goal is typically 25%, and the current<br />
profit margin is far below the benchmark. Three years<br />
ago, profit averaged 20% to 25% but has yet to rebound.<br />
According to Porter, the benchmark for gross profit<br />
is the greatest challenge the industry currently faces.<br />
Likewise, gross profit per employee has experienced a<br />
decline. In 2021 and 2022, it hovered around $1,000.<br />
Today, the average is $700-$800. Finally, administrative<br />
expenses as a percentage of revenue are averaging 30%,<br />
although 50% is typical in some sectors.<br />
Porter notes that it’s vital that carriers compare themselves<br />
with benchmarks frequently — perhaps even on<br />
a weekly basis. Operating costs can change quickly, and<br />
variable cost factors are fluid. Successful carriers, he<br />
said, identify and stick to three primary objectives and<br />
ensure these objectives guide management decisions:<br />
• Identify action items on an ongoing basis.<br />
• Share results.<br />
• Reward success.<br />
Benchmarking is something any industry should adopt<br />
as a primary practice, and the TPP is an example of a<br />
well-developed industry benchmarking system that carriers<br />
are invited to join. It allows carriers to evaluate the efficiency<br />
of previous performance, learn what is possible,<br />
identify success factors, and determine how a company<br />
compares to its peers.<br />
To find out more about the program, visit truckload.<br />
org/about-tpp.<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 19
Tracking the trends<br />
Tired of<br />
Waiting<br />
Will FMCSA’s<br />
latest study of<br />
driver detention<br />
generate results?<br />
By Kris Rutherford<br />
When it comes to the topic of driver detention,<br />
Ed Nagle, president and CEO of Ohio-based<br />
Nagle Companies, is direct when expressing<br />
his displeasure with the time his company’s<br />
drivers spend waiting at shipping and receiving<br />
facilities.<br />
“It’s the biggest waste, and a real problem,” he said.<br />
“Right now, two hours of detention time is the standard<br />
before additional fees can be charged.”<br />
Detention costs carriers a tremendous amount of<br />
revenue — and the shippers and receivers responsible<br />
for the inefficient loading/unloading procedures<br />
that create the delay are often not interested in addressing<br />
the issue, he noted. In addition, the responsible<br />
parties are only willing to pay 50% to 70% of the<br />
revenue carriers lose while trucks remain idle.<br />
What’s the solution? Nagle believes one step in the<br />
right direction is to reduce “free” detention time to<br />
one hour rather than the current two.<br />
“The shippers and receivers pay their employees,”<br />
he explained. “Why should a carrier be expected to tell<br />
its drivers they are unpaid for time on the job?”<br />
Nagle is not alone. The issue of driver detention<br />
consistently ranks among the highest frustrations of<br />
trucking industry professionals. Many carriers agree<br />
the unnecessary time drivers spend waiting at shipping<br />
and receiving facilities exposes a major inefficiency.<br />
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration<br />
(FMCSA) is studying the issue, focusing on the impact<br />
of detention time on highway safety. Based on<br />
public comments received by the FMCSA, the problem<br />
is deeper than government officials expected.<br />
In August 2023, the FMCSA posted a notice in the<br />
Federal Register (Docket No. FMCSA–2023–0172),<br />
20 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
inviting public comment on a proposed effort to collect data<br />
for a report titled “Impact of Driver Detention Time on Safety<br />
and Operations.” The FMCSA planned to analyze the data to<br />
determine the frequency and severity of the detention and<br />
assess the usefulness of existing intelligent transportation<br />
systems (ITS) solutions to measure detention time. The notice<br />
provided little background information for respondents<br />
and garnered a total of 176 comments.<br />
This initial comment period brought into focus several issues<br />
related to detention time — enough that the FMCSA organized<br />
comments into 11 categories. Based on the various<br />
issues identified, it is evident the agency had not anticipated<br />
the severity of detention time<br />
on the industry.<br />
The FMCSA’s categories<br />
are: (1) the relationship between<br />
detention time and<br />
driver compensation; (2)<br />
organizational issues at the<br />
shipper/receiver, carrier, and/<br />
or broker; (3) the relationship<br />
between detention time and<br />
pick-up/delivery appointment<br />
times; (4) examples of detention<br />
time characteristics as<br />
experienced by commenters;<br />
(5) the relationship between<br />
detention time and hours of<br />
service regulations; (6) the<br />
impact of detention time on<br />
logistics and the economy;<br />
(7) the impact of detention<br />
time on driver welfare; (8)<br />
the impact of detention time<br />
on driver and roadway user<br />
safety; (9) suggestions and<br />
support for detention timerelated<br />
regulations; (10)<br />
considerations for defining<br />
and quantifying detention<br />
time and collecting necessary<br />
data; and (11) general support for the study.<br />
In February 2024, the FMCSA once again opened the issue<br />
for public comment on the Federal Register. This time, the<br />
posting offered background on detention time along with a<br />
summary of comments received during the initial comment<br />
period. It also highlighted the 11 categories and provided a<br />
high-level summary of the concerns of respondents.<br />
The 2024 posting also included an overview of the data<br />
collection plan and outlined three primary objectives: (1)<br />
assess the frequency and severity of driver detention time<br />
using data that represents the major segments of the motor<br />
carrier industry; (2) assess the utility of existing ITS solutions<br />
to measure detention time; and (3) prepare a final<br />
report that summarizes the findings, answers the research<br />
questions, and offers strategies to reduce detention time.<br />
In addition, the FMCSA noted that the study would now encompass<br />
supply chain efficiency as well as highway safety.<br />
At the close of the comment period on March 19, 143<br />
comments had been received. While FMCSA has not had<br />
time to analyze the responses to the most recent comment<br />
period, a review of the comments reveals a range of opinions<br />
from those involved in the industry.<br />
Numerous comments, assumably from drivers, provided<br />
anecdotal evidence of the problems created by detention<br />
time, with some offering suggestions on how to address the<br />
issue. Others noted that many drivers do not get paid for<br />
detention time, citing this as something carriers and shippers/receivers<br />
must address, and some claimed the use of<br />
ELDs exacerbates the issue. Other commenters — notably a<br />
few trucking organizations<br />
and insurance companies<br />
— simply offered support<br />
for the FMCSA’s approach.<br />
It’s the biggest<br />
waste, and a<br />
real problem. Right<br />
now, two hours of<br />
detention time are<br />
the standard before<br />
additional fees<br />
can be charged.”<br />
— Ed Nagle<br />
ceo, Nagle Companies<br />
Comments from the<br />
Truckload Carrier’s Association<br />
(TCA) supported the<br />
study but highlighted previous<br />
studies on the issue<br />
and the failure of the FMC-<br />
SA to act on the findings.<br />
“The FMCSA needs to<br />
act accordingly upon their<br />
findings, in which they did<br />
not do after the 2001 and<br />
2014 detention time studies.<br />
While we appreciate the<br />
FMCSA’s commitment to<br />
further investigating issues<br />
related to detention time,<br />
we are concerned about<br />
potential delays in addressing<br />
new issues that may be<br />
identified. Given the length<br />
of the initial study, we are<br />
apprehensive that any new<br />
issues that arise may not be<br />
promptly explored, potentially<br />
leading to significant<br />
delays, like the decade-long interval observed in the past,”<br />
read a portion of TCA’s comment.<br />
TCA also focused on the need to use technology, such as<br />
ELDs, that was not available when previous studies were<br />
completed. In addition, the organization noted that the<br />
study should include insight on ways to mitigate detention<br />
time. Finally, TCA recommended that data obtained from the<br />
study be shared openly and transparently with the public —<br />
specifically with the motor carriers who are most impacted<br />
by the issue of driver detention.<br />
“FMCSA’s recommendations for lowering detention could<br />
serve as valuable guidelines for shippers, receivers, carriers,<br />
and drivers seeking to minimize delays and improve<br />
their operations,” TCA commented.<br />
As for Ed Nagle, when asked how detention time impacted<br />
driver safety, his response was simple:<br />
“It makes drivers tired,” he said.<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 21
Tracking the trends<br />
KNOW<br />
what you’re<br />
PAYING for<br />
Predatory towing fees are a growing<br />
issue of concern among motor carriers<br />
By Kris Rutherford<br />
Predatory towing. It’s a term with which all too many<br />
motor carriers and drivers are uncomfortably familiar.<br />
It’s possible your company has been a victim of the<br />
practice, which goes far beyond fees for towing a disabled<br />
vehicle from the side of the road.<br />
For example, let’s imagine one of your tractor-trailers is involved<br />
in a single-vehicle accident, such as a rollover. Law enforcement<br />
at the scene request a tow service, usually selecting<br />
the next towing company on a list used to spread the business<br />
among competitors. The company dispatches the equipment,<br />
spends about an hour and a half cleaning up the scene, and<br />
then disappears with both your equipment and cargo. In short<br />
order, you receive a bill for towing services that requests payment<br />
of tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars for the<br />
release of your equipment.<br />
Predatory towing is an increasing problem in the trucking<br />
industry and has been brought to the attention of the Federal<br />
Trade Commission (FTC), which is studying deceptive business<br />
practices nationwide. Already, several state’s legislatures<br />
have passed or are considering bills to limit predatory fees.<br />
“When a truck driver’s vehicle is towed, they can’t earn<br />
a living until they get it back — leaving them vulnerable to<br />
predatory junk fees from towing companies,” said U.S. Transportation<br />
Secretary Pete Buttigieg. “We support FTC’s efforts<br />
to stand up for truckers by acting to ban junk fees and prevent<br />
predatory towing fees that can cause significant financial<br />
harm.”<br />
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA)<br />
expressed sentiments about the issue in a letter to the FTC.<br />
“The proposed regulation may significantly benefit FMCSA’s<br />
regulated community, specifically as it relates to the predatory<br />
towing practices that have a substantial financial impact on<br />
CMV owners and operators,” wrote Sue Lawless, the agency’s<br />
acting deputy administrator. She went on to highlight the nature<br />
of predatory towing fees, the various ways a tow company<br />
calculates excessive fees, and the hidden charges many<br />
tow companies place on an invoice.<br />
In a Truckload Carriers Association (TCA) webinar on the<br />
issue, Gene Funk, general counsel for Cowan Systems, a Maryland-based<br />
trucking firm, said, “The towing companies send out<br />
these bills just hoping someone is not looking at them.” Funk,<br />
along with Renee Bowen, an attorney with the firm Franklin and<br />
Prokopik, provided several examples of invoices with excessive<br />
charges, one in which the towing company sought $202,000.<br />
22 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
“They’re a creative bunch,” Bowen said, referring to predatory<br />
towing companies.<br />
“(These fees are) made up. They’re fictitious. You have to<br />
challenge these charges,” said Funk in reference to some of<br />
the charges that show up on towing invoices.<br />
As an example, Funk pointed to a certain fuel surcharge.<br />
The line item had no relationship to the amount of fuel the<br />
tow company used in performing the work; instead, it was<br />
charged as a percentage of the total tow bill. In essence, a<br />
$100,000 invoice could have a $6,000 surcharge for fuel<br />
attached.<br />
Another major issue with predatory towing is “per-pound”<br />
billing. In this case, a tow company sets its fee based on the<br />
total weight of the vehicle, trailer, and cargo being hauled.<br />
Often, Funk said, companies will charge a minimum fee based<br />
on an 80,000-pound tractor-trailer — even when the vehicle<br />
involved only weighs 20,000 pounds. One example compared<br />
a per-pound billing invoice to an invoice for the same service<br />
charged at nonpredatory rates. When recalculated, the predatory<br />
$140,000 per-pound invoice dropped to $24,000.<br />
There are several problems with existing towing fee regulations,<br />
which vary from state to state. First, the tow companies<br />
hold all the power. They capitalize on a motor carrier’s<br />
need to retrieve its equipment and cargo. Despite statutes in<br />
place that require tow companies to release cargo, Funk and<br />
Bowen cited instances in which tow company managers simply<br />
ignored the requirement and essentially held equipment<br />
and cargo hostage.<br />
There is also a lack of enforcement of existing regulations.<br />
Often, law enforcement agencies are the ones who call a tow<br />
company — but they are unwilling to get involved in cases<br />
of excessive charges. In addition, there are cases in which a<br />
tow company sends the same invoice to various stakeholders<br />
(carriers, insurance companies, drivers, brokers, etc.).<br />
On occasion, multiple parties pay the same bill — and the<br />
towing companies simply reap the profits.<br />
To help trucking companies guard against predatory billing,<br />
Funk and Bowen offered some warning signs to look for<br />
before writing a check.<br />
• One red flag is per-pound billing, a practice that is actually<br />
outlawed in some states.<br />
• Excessive hourly rates and the number of hours personnel<br />
and equipment are on site should also be inspected. For<br />
example, a tow company may charge an hourly rate but have<br />
a minimum charge policy of four hours, even if less time is<br />
spent at the site.<br />
• Some tow companies charge additional fees for equipment<br />
sent to the site, even if that equipment was neither requested<br />
nor necessary for the towing job.<br />
• Finally, hidden surcharges are common tactics of predatory<br />
tow companies. Charges for weather conditions (temperatures<br />
over 80 degrees, for example), photos, and followup<br />
communications are common. One example of an invoice<br />
presented by Funk and Bowen even charged for “snacks.”<br />
And the snacks were charged at 2% of the total bill, resulting<br />
in a cost of $200 per employee.<br />
As far as solutions to the problem of predatory towing are<br />
concerned, Funk is not optimistic: “There are no good answers<br />
to solve the problem,” he said.<br />
However, Bowen did offer a few suggestions for truckers<br />
and carriers to follow when involved in a towing situation.<br />
• First, no driver should sign any document presented by<br />
a towing company on site. Many times, the driver could be<br />
signing away rates and waivers.<br />
• Drivers should take lots of photos of the site, towing operation,<br />
equipment, and personnel.<br />
“Photographs are incredibly important,” Bowen said.<br />
• It is also recommended that carriers form relationships<br />
with towing companies in the areas in which they operate,<br />
have legal counsel available, and train staff in what to do in<br />
the case of a towing situation.<br />
• Finally, Bowen says, carriers should join and support<br />
state trucking associations. These groups can be excellent<br />
resources when it comes to getting references for reputable<br />
towing companies nationwide.<br />
Ultimately, carriers must be aware that their drivers operate<br />
in different states — and there is no consistency in the<br />
regulations states place on the two companies in relation to<br />
towing fees. The FMCSA suggests the FTC provide guidance<br />
on how deceptive business practices related to towing would<br />
impact state and local laws that govern towing practices.<br />
Perhaps when federal guidance is available, tow companies<br />
will be willing to come to the bargaining table to establish<br />
fair and consistent rates.<br />
“The industry wants fair service for a fair price,” Funk<br />
concluded.<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 23
A CHAT WITH THE CHAIRMAN<br />
Sponsored by by Mcleod software / / McLeodSoftware.com / / 877.362.5363<br />
24 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
Sponsored by<br />
Foundation<br />
For Success<br />
Foreword and Interview by Linda Garner-Bunch<br />
On March 26, 2024, during the closing banquet of the<br />
Truckload Carriers Association (TCA) annual convention,<br />
John Culp, president of Arkansas-based Maverick<br />
Transportation, officially stepped into the role of the association’s<br />
chairman.<br />
As he stepped to the podium, he thanked outgoing chairman<br />
Dave Williams for his service, noting that Williams “set the bar<br />
high” during his tenure. Culp continued, sharing thoughts about<br />
the value TCA brings to its members, including the group’s power<br />
as advocates for the truckload industry on Capitol Hill.<br />
“It’s an ongoing team effort for our staff, our members, and our<br />
lobbyists. Together, we are making a difference,” he noted, urging<br />
any members who have not participated in TCA’s annual Call on<br />
Washington to add their voices to this year’s efforts. Outlining<br />
goals for the coming months, he touched on numerous issues<br />
facing the industry. In closing, he noted that industry leaders<br />
should invest in their greatest assets.<br />
“We all have big investments in rolling stock buildings,<br />
computers, and technology, but our most important asset is our<br />
people — more importantly, our people working as a team is what<br />
makes us successful,” he explained. “In my opinion, investing in<br />
our people is more than just time and money well spent; it’s critical<br />
for building the foundation for continued success in the future.”<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 25
A CHAT WITH THE CHAIRMAN<br />
Incoming TCA Chairman John Culp, right, presents a placque honoring outgoing Chairman Dave Williams, left, for his service to the association. Culp stepped into the role of chairman March 26, 2024.<br />
u First of all, congratulations on stepping into your new role as<br />
TCA chairman! What does this new responsibility mean to you,<br />
both personally and professionally?<br />
Thank you, Linda. It’s an honor to have the opportunity to serve as<br />
TCA’s chairman. Dave Williams leaves big shoes to fill, but our association<br />
is in great shape, and our officers and staff are aligned and on board with<br />
the vision and objectives we’ve been working on for the past several years.<br />
We don’t need to change what we’re doing, but we know we can get better<br />
and that is what we want to do.<br />
u You were formally introduced as this year’s chairman during<br />
TCA’s 2024 convention in Nashville just a few weeks ago. How<br />
did it feel to step up to that podium, look out at the association’s<br />
members, and realize that all those people will be looking to<br />
you for advice, opinions, and solutions during your tenure as<br />
chairman?<br />
It felt good to see a full house. Our annual conference attendance has<br />
been growing over the past several years, and it was great to see so many<br />
people staying for the closing banquet. My position responsibilities are<br />
changing, but we have a great staff and officer group and we work together<br />
as a team in everything we do. I anticipate business as usual for Team TCA.<br />
u For members who haven’t had a chance to get to know you<br />
yet, how and when did you first become interested in the trucking<br />
industry?<br />
I had been working in public accounting for a couple of years after<br />
graduating college when I decided I wanted to move to the private sector.<br />
The first opportunity I had was with Chandler Trailer Convoy, a small carrier<br />
in Little Rock, Arkansas. I made a couple of moves for better opportunities<br />
with other trucking companies in town before I found my dream job at<br />
Maverick. I learned a lot at every company I worked for and am still grateful<br />
for the opportunities I had. I guess it is safe to say that trucking has been<br />
my career of choice since I was young and green between the ears.<br />
u When did you first start working for Maverick, and in what<br />
capacity? What roles have you held with the company?<br />
I joined Maverick in September of 1989 as vice president of finance<br />
and became part of the company’s four-person officer group. We had<br />
70 company trucks and 26 owner-operators at the time. The only<br />
other position I have held since then before becoming president was<br />
executive vice president and CFO.<br />
u How long have you been part of TCA, and what roles have<br />
you held within the association?<br />
I don’t remember exactly the first time I attended a TCA conference,<br />
but it was sometime in the mid ’90s. Maverick’s founder, Steve<br />
Williams, felt it was important for our leaders to become involved in<br />
state and national trucking organizations for educational purposes and<br />
industry knowledge — but also to be actively involved in the efforts<br />
of these organizations to make our industry and our company better. I<br />
have served in various positions in other associations, but my first role<br />
at TCA began when I became an officer in 2019.<br />
u In your opinion, how do industry associations like the TCA<br />
benefit their members? The industry as a whole?<br />
For our members at TCA, we have a value proposition matrix of<br />
five key objectives that form the foundation of our efforts to deliver<br />
membership value:<br />
1. Improving the driving job;<br />
2. Improving roadway safety;<br />
3. Improving financial sustainability for our member companies;<br />
4. Improving our industry image; and<br />
5. Promoting industry environmental stewardship.<br />
In each of these areas, we provide a combination of meetings,<br />
events, programs, and educational opportunities designed to provide<br />
SEE CHAT, PAGE 28<br />
Sponsored by Mcleod software / McLeodSoftware.com / 877.362.5363<br />
26 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 27
A CHAT WITH THE CHAIRMAN<br />
John Culp, center, visits with Lane Kidd, left, and Sam Gill, right, of The Trucking Alliance during the Truckload Carriers Association’s annual convention in Nashville.<br />
CHAT, FROM PAGE 26<br />
value for the dues members pay and the time they invest in TCA.<br />
For me personally, the most valuable and rewarding benefit of TCA<br />
membership is networking and developing relationships with peers and<br />
vendors. It’s helped me tremendously in my career and I feel it has made<br />
me a better leader. But the icing on the cake has been the incredible<br />
friendships I have made, and with that, I have been truly blessed.<br />
For our industry, I would say that our advocacy efforts on The Hill<br />
to address the important issues that impact our industry would be the<br />
biggest value. Our voice is strengthening, and we have plenty of issues to<br />
work on.<br />
u In your opinion, what is the biggest issue faced by the industry<br />
today, and what are some possible solutions?<br />
I really worry about the ever-increasing cost of liability insurance. Both<br />
trucking and insurance companies alike are fighting nuclear verdicts that<br />
are unsustainable. As an industry, we must lead the charge for lawsuit<br />
reform, state by state, to place reasonable limits on non-economic damages<br />
for parties injured in accidents. As an industry, taking responsibility for<br />
injuries we cause is the right thing to do. Every trucking company should<br />
carry adequate insurance to do so; we are not trying to change that, but<br />
today’s out-of-control “jackpot justice” is simply wrong and needs to be<br />
addressed.<br />
u Emissions regulations calling for the trucking industry<br />
to convert to zero-emissions trucks remain a hot topic. Many<br />
groups appear to promote battery-electric vehicles across the<br />
board, while some suggest other options, such as hydrogen fuel<br />
cell batteries or diesel engines powered by renewable natural<br />
gas. What are your thoughts on the proposed timeline for zero<br />
emissions and the available options?<br />
Short answer: It is unreasonable and unrealistic to reach the zeroemissions<br />
targets that have been laid out for our industry. TCA supports<br />
zero-emissions for trucks, but it is going to take a long time. We need<br />
commonsense leaders to realize this and set realistic timelines with an<br />
affordable path.<br />
A recent independent study by Roland Berger, a global consulting<br />
company, estimated the cost to build the electric grid needed to charge an<br />
all-electric truck fleet in the United States is $1 trillion. For most people, that<br />
is “monopoly money,” because it is hard to comprehend exactly how much<br />
that is. One trillion is one thousand times a billion. We have approximately<br />
333 million people in the US. That equates to a cost of $3,000 for every<br />
person in the country. That’s a lot of money, and it is real.<br />
TCA has been a founding partner in the Clean Freight Coalition in its<br />
effort to advocate for sound public policies that transition toward a zeroemission<br />
future in a manner that strategically assures affordable and<br />
reliable freight transportation and protects the nation’s supply chain. If<br />
you want to know more, please feel free to visit cleanfreightcoalition.org.<br />
u It’s now been nearly four-and-a-half years since the FMCSA<br />
launched the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse as a national<br />
database for the results of commercial drivers’ drug and alcohol<br />
screenings. In your eyes, how has having access to this information<br />
changed the face of driver recruitment and retention?<br />
The Clearinghouse has been very effective in removing drivers who<br />
have tested positive for drug and alcohol violations from our highways.<br />
The change in driver recruitment is a big win for trucking companies in that<br />
drivers are no longer able to beat the system when they fail a drug test at<br />
one carrier and later fly under the radar with another company. I don’t think<br />
any carrier wants to hire a driver who has failed a drug test.<br />
The only problem I know of with the Clearinghouse is that the FMCSA<br />
still won’t allow companies that utilize hair follicle testing to report their<br />
results to the Clearinghouse.<br />
u That leads us straight to my next question: Even though<br />
proposals to allow alternate forms of testing, such as oral fluids<br />
Sponsored by Mcleod software / McLeodSoftware.com / 877.362.5363<br />
28 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
and hair follicles, have been introduced, no clear decision<br />
has yet been made. How would allowing the use of such<br />
testing impact the driver workforce?<br />
Maverick is part of a group of carriers that have been utilizing<br />
hair testing for years. Out of 460,568 drivers who underwent both<br />
hair follicle and urine testing from 2017-2022, we have personal<br />
knowledge of positive drug tests for 23,601 drivers who passed<br />
urine tests at the same time. That means 23,601 habitual drug<br />
users were likely able to immediately go to work for a carrier that<br />
does not utilize hair testing. Hair follicle testing identifies drug<br />
users nine times more effectively than urine testing. Researchers<br />
estimate that if that rate were applied to the entire truck driver<br />
population, it is reasonable to estimate that up to 250,000 drivers<br />
who passed a urine test would have failed a hair test at the same<br />
time.<br />
Congress passed the FAST Act in December of 2015, directing<br />
the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) to write the<br />
guidelines for hair follicle testing to enable the FMCSA to add it<br />
as an approved testing method for DOT compliance. Since then,<br />
HHS has delayed the process, blocking the ability for companies<br />
that utilize hair testing to submit known positive drug tests to the<br />
Clearinghouse.<br />
Why, you ask? They claim they have concerns the test may<br />
be racially biased — but there is no research to verify it. On the<br />
other hand, a study analyzing over 70,000 drivers where ethnicity<br />
information from hair testing data was available determined hair<br />
follicle testing is not racially biased.<br />
It seems to me the powers that be at HHS don’t care when<br />
carriers must let someone we know has tested positive for opioids<br />
or fentanyl go unreported to the Clearinghouse and be able to go<br />
to work for a company that does not hair test. For me personally,<br />
it is infuriating when we have to let that happen! It is irresponsible<br />
for the government agencies responsible for the safety of our<br />
motoring public to sit on their hands for nine years and continue<br />
to do nothing.<br />
For the record: TCA supports carriers’ ability to submit hair test results<br />
into the Clearinghouse.<br />
A University of Central Arkansas study came to the following conclusion<br />
regarding a person’s race as it pertains to hair follicle testing:<br />
“Utilizing independently provided urine and hair pre-employment<br />
drug screen data, Researchers were unable to find disparate impacts<br />
of hair testing among the ethnic groups analyzed. Results for each test<br />
in each sample met the required Four-Fifths Rule threshold. Chi-square<br />
tests independently examine urine and hair tests. Chi-square results<br />
indicate that the proportion of drug test failures (positives) are higher for<br />
hair testing across all ethnic groups, but pass/fail rates are significantly<br />
different irrespective of testing method. Given these findings, Researchers<br />
find no disparate impact among ethnic groups by testing method.”<br />
u Here’s another related question: While the federal government<br />
has not changed its policies on the use of cannabis products, many<br />
states have legalized the drug for both medicinal and recreational<br />
use, creating yet another hotbed issue for the trucking industry.<br />
What are your thoughts on this?<br />
The problem with cannabis is very real. Usage is increasing, and there<br />
is no way to test for real-time impairment that law-enforcement officers<br />
can use like they can with alcohol. Until there is, the problem will continue<br />
to grow. Hair follicle, urine and oral testing can detect THC in a driver’s<br />
system but not impairment at the time of the test. At a minimum, until<br />
During Truckload 2024: Nashville, numerous convention attendees — including John Culp — had a bit of fun<br />
and took advantage of a photo op with the legendary Jack Daniels.<br />
impairment can be measured, cannabis needs to stay a Schedule 1 drug<br />
for all drug tests for drivers.<br />
u Let’s take a look at another topic the trucking industry is<br />
watching closely. In 2021, the Modern, Clean, and Safe Trucks<br />
Act reintroduced industry efforts to repeal the federal excise<br />
tax (FET) on heavy-duty trucks and trailers. Since then, both<br />
House and Senate versions of the bill seem to have stalled out in<br />
committee. Do you predict any movement on these measures over<br />
the next year? Why or why not?<br />
Unfortunately, no. The FET is an outdated tax that goes up every year<br />
as tractor and trailer prices go up. And, with the cost to purchase new<br />
equipment being at an all-time high, it is a very regressive tax that makes<br />
it difficult — if not impossible — for many small truckers to purchase new<br />
equipment.<br />
If the tax were repealed, new equipment prices would immediately<br />
decrease by 12%. Emissions for new-generation engines have made<br />
incredible gains, and we could make real changes in clean air if we could<br />
make newer equipment more affordable for truckers to retire their old<br />
trucks and purchase newer technology. It’s a great opportunity, but there<br />
is no agreeable solution in Congress to replace the lost dollars coming out<br />
of the Highway Trust Fund.<br />
u Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for your time. I look forward to<br />
our next conversation.<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 29
TALKING TCA<br />
Those Who Deliver<br />
with Modern Transportation<br />
By Dwain Hebda<br />
One of the most common slogans used to lure new<br />
drivers to a trucking company is the promise of<br />
family time. “Home on weekends” — and even<br />
“Home every night” — have become common<br />
phrases that are appealing to prospective drivers<br />
seeking a balance between home life and work life.<br />
Pennsylvania-based Modern Transportation takes this concept<br />
and kicks it up a gear, promising drivers that they’ll be “Home<br />
SAFE Tonight,” a commitment that’s as ambitious as it is compelling.<br />
“I’ve never worked for a company that cares about its team<br />
members as much as Modern Transportation,” said Woodson<br />
Witt, the carrier’s vice president of safety and human resources.<br />
“The company’s success is built on a culture of care. It’s living<br />
by the mission of, ‘Are you paying your people appropriately? Do<br />
they have enough personal time? And are you making sure you’re<br />
enabling them to feel good about taking that personal time?’<br />
“When we say, ‘We value you and your safety above anything<br />
else’ and that nothing we do is worth hurting ourselves or others,<br />
we absolutely believe that,” he continued. “I mean, that is the first<br />
standard in our mission.”<br />
That corporate mission has evolved over the years since Modern<br />
Transportation was founded as a bulk materials hauler for<br />
western Pennsylvania’s coal mining industry — but the core<br />
operational ethic has remained the same. The company seeks<br />
to provide superior transportation solutions to customers in the<br />
safest, most professional, and efficient manner, Witt shared.<br />
This standard is more than words on a page, he added. It’s a<br />
calling that’s dyed, top to bottom, into the company’s corporate<br />
“fabric” providing a daily challenge to leadership and front-line<br />
workers alike.<br />
“If a team member gets injured, for whatever reason, we have<br />
failed as an organization,” Witt said. “You could say, ‘Oh, it was<br />
because of the neglect of the team member.’ Well, if it’s neglect<br />
on the part of the team member, then what didn’t we do as an<br />
organization to train them appropriately or set expectations?<br />
“There’s always a root cause analysis that’s done on anything<br />
to help us get to that ‘why’ factor,” he explained. “Why did that<br />
happen? What could we do to prevent or reduce the risk of a<br />
non-preventable accident from happening again in the future?<br />
We have to look at it that way.”<br />
Over the past 35 years, Modern Transportation has become an<br />
industry leader in bulk material logistics and trucking, expanding<br />
into liquid and chemical loads as well as petroleum-based products.<br />
The company operates two dozen terminals and supports<br />
shipping lanes in more than 30 states. In every location, the drive<br />
for improvement is constant, manifesting itself in new technology,<br />
precise logistical strategies, and a relentless focus on developing<br />
teamwork that benefits both clients and employees.<br />
“A culture of safety means not only that we want everyone to<br />
be safe out on the road, but also, when you come to work, it’s<br />
a safe place. There’s no contention, there are no silos. We’re all<br />
there for the same purpose,” Witt said. “We walk through those<br />
doors, we’re there for that mission, and that’s what we’re living.<br />
Our pledge to our customers is that we want to be innovative and<br />
creative to improve value for their dollar.”<br />
Achieving this lofty goal requires a mix of the high-tech and<br />
the high touch — being personally involved in every aspect of<br />
the company’s operation. Witt says Modern Transportation has<br />
never shied away from deploying the latest technology, from<br />
TMS and other systems to onboard safety devices and systems<br />
that streamline billing.<br />
But even as it embraces the advantages of new tech, Modern<br />
Transportation never forgets the value of old-fashioned, one-onone<br />
interactions when it comes to solving problems and building<br />
client relationships.<br />
“We had a customer who was doing their annual visit with<br />
us. While they were here, they got the news that one of their<br />
other suppliers had just closed their doors,” Witt said. “They just<br />
looked at us and said, ‘How can you help us?’ We were able to<br />
turn around and pick up that business in a matter of days and get<br />
them right back on track.<br />
30 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
“We like to say that we strive to create a<br />
culture that meets and exceeds their standards<br />
regarding integrity, timeliness, and<br />
competitive pricing,” he continued. “When<br />
they have a problem or they have a situation,<br />
we want to be that partner, that extension,<br />
that’s there to help them. Their problems<br />
are our problems. I think the reason<br />
we’re able to do that is because everyone<br />
at Modern Transportation is aligned. We’re<br />
all moving in the same direction, helping<br />
everyone do their business better.”<br />
The company is equally innovative in the<br />
way it cares for its employees, particularly<br />
drivers, for whom safety isn’t just stressed<br />
behind the wheel or in the shop, but also<br />
through a corporately funded wellness<br />
program that helps participating employees<br />
reduce their insurance costs. This program<br />
is accompanied by a lifestyle savings<br />
account, which operates similar to a health<br />
savings account but with far fewer restrictions.<br />
“The new wellness program we started<br />
this year is a huge thing for us,” Witt said.<br />
“We partnered with a company called<br />
Sonic Boom, which has an app that has all<br />
kinds of health and wellness advice, mental<br />
wellness, financial wellness. I mean, it<br />
covers the entire gamut to show employees<br />
how to improve. As they continue to<br />
earn points in the wellness program, we<br />
will start depositing real dollars in their<br />
lifestyle savings account and they can<br />
spend it on things like gym memberships<br />
or child care.<br />
“We understand that our employees<br />
truly are an investment,” he noted. “If<br />
we cut corners with our team members’<br />
safety and wellness, then it’s gonna haunt<br />
us down the road. We’re gonna pay big<br />
time for that. On the other hand, if they’re<br />
healthier, they’re gonna be happier — and<br />
they’re gonna be with us longer. When you<br />
care about peoples’ well-being, it’s an awesome<br />
feeling to be able to invest in them in<br />
ways that truly improve their lives at work<br />
and overall.”<br />
Leadership Team<br />
Patrick Cozzens<br />
President<br />
Robert Bartolacci<br />
Executive Vice President & CFO<br />
Chris Gallowitz<br />
Vice President-Special Projects<br />
Woodson Witt<br />
Vice President-Safety & Human Resources<br />
Alex Forrest<br />
Vice President-Operations<br />
Bob Smith<br />
Senior Director-Equipment & Maintenance<br />
Bill Campbell<br />
Senior Director<br />
Safety, Risk Management & Payroll<br />
Dan Benacquista<br />
Vice President<br />
Strategic Operations & Planning<br />
Stephen Humbert<br />
Senior Director<br />
Strategic & Business Development<br />
By the Numbers<br />
DRIVERS<br />
315<br />
TRUCKS<br />
235<br />
TRAILERS<br />
462<br />
TOTAL EMPLOYEES<br />
414<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 31
TALKING TCA<br />
Next Gen Executives<br />
TCA’s young leaders take the spotlight, drive the future of trucking<br />
Jason Douglass<br />
For Stokes<br />
Trucking’s Jason<br />
Douglass, driver<br />
retention is key to a<br />
company’s success<br />
By Kris Rutherford<br />
Jason Douglass of Stokes Trucking knows the importance<br />
of driver retention.<br />
The 36-year-old, who serves as director of<br />
recruiting and retention for Tremonton, Utahbased<br />
Stokes Trucking, began his career in the<br />
industry as a driver for a plumbing company before moving<br />
into warehouse management and dispatch, sales, safety<br />
management, and, finally, recruiting.<br />
Because he’s actively worked in so many facets of the<br />
industry, Douglass has first-hand knowledge of many of the<br />
challenges faced by employees. As a trucking executive, he<br />
also knows that many motor carriers are struggling to retain<br />
drivers and experiencing high turnover rates.<br />
While finding qualified drivers is vital, Douglass says the<br />
“retention” portion of his title is the main focus at Stokes —<br />
and that’s exactly the way he likes it.<br />
“Our turnover is super-low,” he told Truckload Authority.<br />
“Anybody can bring drivers in. The importance of my role is<br />
to keep people with the company.”<br />
When he was recruited by Stokes in 2022, he was impressed<br />
by the company’s culture and the mindset of working<br />
to retain valued employees.<br />
“Our cultures matched,” Douglass said. “Stokes’ culture is<br />
clear on its social media pages. It’s like we instantly clicked.”<br />
Currently the company, which specializes in transporting<br />
refrigerated foods, employs 55 drivers and operates 50<br />
trucks and 112 refrigerated trailers — and it is working to<br />
expand. Drivers average 2,800-3,200 miles a week, with<br />
routes designed to allow drivers to enjoy home time weekly.<br />
Of course, he says, driver retention begins with smart<br />
recruiting and hiring.<br />
“If you recruit the right people, you don’t have to recruit<br />
as much,” he explained, adding that he’d rather have an<br />
empty truck than hire the wrong person to drive it.<br />
So, one might ask, how can recruiters make sure they find<br />
the right people? While there’s not a one-size-fits-all answer,<br />
Douglass shared his basic strategy.<br />
When interviewing prospective drivers, he says, the first<br />
few questions are friendly “get to know you” queries. Once<br />
he knows a little about the driver’s personality and goals, he<br />
says, he works to find out exactly what the driver is looking<br />
for in a company. Next, he asks about previous employers.<br />
In some cases, he says, a previous company’s culture<br />
simply wasn’t a good fit for a specific driver (or vice versa).<br />
“There are some people, some companies that I know are<br />
just bad fits,” he said. “Then there are companies I know<br />
have the same hiring criteria as us.”<br />
In short, he says, the initial interview needs to go far<br />
beyond the driver’s skills and qualifications.<br />
“Between those questions, I can pick up red flags. For<br />
instance, a recruit might ask if we do hair follicle drug<br />
testing,” he explained. “If they wince, that’s probably the<br />
biggest red flag I see.<br />
“I start asking qualifying questions,” he continued. “I get<br />
32 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
them to talk, and I get a feeling for their personalities. We’re<br />
not a fit for everybody — and everybody is not a fit for us.”<br />
In addition, Douglass says, he looks at the way a driver<br />
has quit previous jobs.<br />
“We won’t hire anybody unless they put in two weeks’<br />
notice with their current company,” he said. “We don’t want<br />
anyone to do that to us.”<br />
When it comes right down to it, the question isn’t whether<br />
the driver wants to work for Stokes; it’s a question of whether<br />
the company wants to hire a particular driver.<br />
“We don’t just put butts in seats, so I ask questions,” he<br />
said. “Our motto is, ‘Do the right thing,’”<br />
That motto goes both ways. “What’s the right thing to<br />
you? What are your morals?” he said. “There’s no ‘secret<br />
sauce’ in our success. It’s just being genuine.”<br />
As noted earlier, Stokes has a low turnover rate (10%<br />
to 14%). More often a driver is let go rather than quitting,<br />
Douglass said.<br />
“We probably terminate more than quit because we have<br />
a high safety standard,” he explained. “You must have a high<br />
standard in this day and age. You’re always trying to protect<br />
assets.”<br />
Of course, a driver’s experience and safety record are also<br />
important, and Douglass says the recruiting team works<br />
closely with the company’s safety director.<br />
“We both know what we’re looking for in a good driver —<br />
and we know what the company’s looking for,” he said. “We<br />
won’t hire anybody without all of us meeting them.”<br />
Once the team is sure they’ve found a driver who’s a good<br />
fit for the company, the “real” work — retention — begins.<br />
At Stokes, Douglass says, the culture is designed<br />
to ensure the group works together as a team, with a<br />
common goal. Of course, pay is important, but there are<br />
other factors that result in loyal, happy employees.<br />
“Drivers’ checks don’t fluctuate more than 10% weekly,<br />
and we have some drivers that make up to $100,000 a year,”<br />
he said, adding that consistency in freight and miles goes a<br />
long way toward ensuring satisfied drivers.<br />
“In this market, drivers can work anywhere. So, especially<br />
for younger drivers, a carrier needs to be a place they WANT<br />
to work,” he said.<br />
Breaking down traditional business barriers is another<br />
key to success.<br />
“At so many companies, there’s a hierarchy,” Douglass<br />
said. “Drivers are at the bottom, and then there’s office<br />
employees. You must eliminate the hierarchy.”<br />
This involves making sure drivers have a voice in the<br />
company. In addition, he says, drivers appreciate a friendly<br />
environment and decent facilities.<br />
“You can’t make it like drivers are separated from the<br />
office,” Douglass said. “At many companies, management<br />
SAYS they have an open-door policy … but do they really<br />
mean it? Our owner sits with the dispatcher.<br />
“I’m very approachable. I want people to bring up<br />
concerns,” he continued. “However, it doesn’t do any good<br />
if there’s no action. I am proactive about what people bring<br />
me, and I follow up. Once that reputation is set, the job is<br />
easier. People depend on me.”<br />
While the goal of any business is to see a profit, the best<br />
companies are often known for having the “human touch.”<br />
“You have to have empathy in recruiting and retention,”<br />
Douglass shared. “Without it, you’re not of much use. You<br />
need to be able to put yourself in the potential employee’s<br />
position. Some people say, ‘Just tough it up and drive.’<br />
Well, we’re not in that market anymore. We realize that good<br />
drivers can go work somewhere else.”<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 33
TALKING TCA<br />
OUTSTANDING Contributions<br />
TCA Chairmen honor industry leaders<br />
Each year during the Truckload Carriers Association’s<br />
(TCA) convention, two industry leaders are presented<br />
with the coveted Chairman’s Choice and Past Chairmen’s<br />
awards. This year, the recipients were Rence Oliphant,<br />
vice president of global sales for Hendrickson (shown<br />
above, left) and Robert Low, founder and owner of Prime<br />
Inc. (above, right).<br />
CHAIRMAN’S CHOICE AWARD<br />
When presenting the sixth annual Chairman’s Choice<br />
award, outgoing TCA Chairman Dave Williams described<br />
Rence Oliphant as someone who “truly exemplifies the very<br />
idea of this association and its members.”<br />
In 1995, Oliphant left Volvo to join the Hendrickson team<br />
as a district sales manager. During the ensuing years, he<br />
was promoted numerous times. Before stepping into his<br />
current role as vice president of global sales, he served as<br />
the company’s senior director of North American sales.<br />
“While (Rence) will typically shy away from spending<br />
time in the limelight, he is always there to help — Always<br />
the gentleman and a great example to me,” Williams said.<br />
“I have enjoyed watching him excel in his career selling axles<br />
and other products while still finding time to give back to the industry,”<br />
he continued. “He has made sure that TCA programs,<br />
events, and issues have been staunchly supported by his company’s<br />
sponsorship, involvement, and communication.”<br />
PAST CHAIRMEN’S AWARD<br />
The Past Chairmen’s Award is the highest honor given by<br />
TCA. It is presented annually to a recognized industry leader<br />
who has had a strong, positive impact on the truckload industry<br />
and is recognized as a successful businessperson<br />
and association leader.<br />
Contrary to the award’s name, the awardee does not have<br />
to be a past chairman of the association; winners can be<br />
outside the trucking industry as long as they have made a<br />
significant contribution to the truckload industry.<br />
“Anyone who knows our winner knows that he is a generous,<br />
hardworking man, and it is plain to see that trucking<br />
runs in his blood,” said TCA’s Immediate Past Chairman<br />
John Elliott as he presented the award to Low. “His<br />
achievements and contributions to trucking are a tribute to<br />
his overwhelming personal and professional commitment to<br />
the transportation industry.”<br />
Low established Prime Inc. in 1970 at the age of only 19.<br />
Over the next 54 years, he grew the company into an industry<br />
giant that now includes 15 locations, 7,400 tractors,<br />
more than 16,000 trailers, and nearly 1,100 team members.<br />
In addition, Low served as TCA Chairman in 2012-13 and<br />
is currently on the association’s board of directors. He is<br />
also active in the American Trucking Associations, serving<br />
as vice president at-large, an executive committee member,<br />
and a member of the board of directors.<br />
34 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
MORE<br />
than a<br />
catch<br />
phrase<br />
The Truckload Carriers Association’s (TCA) 2024<br />
annual convention, Truckload 2024: Nashville,<br />
culminated with the announcement of the<br />
winners of the 2023 TCA Fleet Safety Awards grand<br />
prize. The honor is given in two divisions — small<br />
carriers (total annual mileage of less than 25 million)<br />
and large carriers (total annual mileage of 25 million<br />
or more).<br />
For each fleet represented in the contest, creating a<br />
culture of safety is more than just a catchphrase; it’s<br />
something that permeates every level of business.<br />
This year’s grand prize in the small carrier division<br />
went to Fortune Transportation, Inc., based in Windom,<br />
Minnesota. In the large carrier division, Bison<br />
Transport, Inc., of Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, took<br />
home top honors.<br />
Both carriers demonstrated exceptional safety programs<br />
and impressive accident frequency ratios over<br />
the past year.<br />
In addition, both companies — along with all the<br />
carriers that placed in the Top 3 of their mileage-based<br />
divisions — will be recognized again during TCA’s<br />
2024 Safety & Security Meeting, scheduled for June<br />
2-4 at The Westin Indianapolis hotel.<br />
“TCA is proud to recognize Fortune Transportation,<br />
Inc., and Bison Transport, Inc., for their outstanding<br />
Fortune,<br />
Bison take<br />
top honors<br />
in TCA’s<br />
Fleet Safety<br />
Awards<br />
achievements in safety,” said TCA President Jim Ward.<br />
Ward congratulated all of the fleets that ranked in<br />
this year’s safety competition, noting that 2023 saw<br />
the most-ever entries in the history of the awards.<br />
“(This shows) that TCA members are truly industry<br />
leaders when it comes to safety,” he noted. “Fortune<br />
and Bison are very deserving of the grand prize as a<br />
symbol of their amazing efforts to improve safety on<br />
our roadways.”<br />
To be eligible for the TCA Fleet Safety Award Grand<br />
Prize, fleets must submit their accident frequency ratio<br />
per million miles driven. The three carriers with the<br />
lowest ratios are identified as the winners for each of<br />
six mileage-based divisions. These carriers then undergo<br />
an audit by independent experts to ensure the<br />
accuracy of their results. TCA announced the names of<br />
the 18 division winners in January and invited the fleets<br />
to submit further documentation about their overall<br />
safety programs, both on and off the highway, to be<br />
eligible for the grand prize. After review by a diverse<br />
industry panel of judges, the winning companies were<br />
deemed to have best demonstrated their commitment<br />
to improving safety on North America’s highways.<br />
TCA’s Fleet Safety Awards are made possible<br />
through the sponsorship of Great West Casualty Co.<br />
and Assured Partners.<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 35
TALKING TCA<br />
SAFE drivers = SAFER roads<br />
FMCSA’s Sue<br />
Lawless shares<br />
goals, stresses<br />
importance of<br />
highway safety<br />
By John Worthen<br />
If truck drivers are safe at work, the nation’s<br />
roadways will be safer, according to Federal Motor<br />
Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) Acting<br />
Deputy Administrator Sue Lawless.<br />
This observation was made Monday, March 26, during<br />
the Truckload Carriers Association’s (TCA) annual<br />
convention in Nashville. Lawless was addressing attendees<br />
during a luncheon and awards ceremony honoring<br />
members of TCA’s Champions Club, winners of<br />
the Past Chairmen’s and Chairman’s Choice awards,<br />
and TCA’s Highway Angels of the Year for 2024-25.<br />
During her speech, she touched on several topics,<br />
including truck parking, the importance of female truck<br />
drivers, and workplace safety. She also complimented<br />
the industry and its stakeholders, many of whom were<br />
gathered to hear her speak.<br />
“You are among the best of the best of safe trucking,”<br />
she said. “Every day, you show us what motor<br />
carriers can do to keep the country moving, and you<br />
do it safely.”<br />
Lawless said the FMCSA and its partners are continually<br />
working toward the goal of zero fatalities on<br />
the nation’s roadways through programs such as the<br />
National Roadway Safety Strategy.<br />
“Zero is an ambitious goal, but we believe it is the<br />
only acceptable number,” Lawless said. “Somebody<br />
told me … that we will never get to zero — that it’s<br />
impossible to get to zero. I disagree.”<br />
Lawless noted she is not naive to the fact that the<br />
goal will be difficult to attain, adding, “Just because<br />
you can’t see something now, it doesn’t mean that it<br />
could not exist in the future.”<br />
Lawless ticked off a list of things she believes can<br />
help move the nation toward zero highway deaths —<br />
advances in technology to assist drivers, improvements<br />
in equipment, improvements in emergency<br />
response, and availability of medical treatment.<br />
“All of those things have the potential to make zero<br />
deaths a reality in our lifetime, and that’s why partnerships with organizations<br />
like TCA, safety advocates, state and local governments, and<br />
others are so critical in our mission,” she said.<br />
In March, the U.S. Department of Transportation released a progress<br />
report on the National Roadway Safety Strategy. Although strides are<br />
being made toward safer highways, Lawless said that the “number of<br />
deaths remains unacceptably and stubbornly high.”<br />
U.S. traffic deaths fell 3.6% last year, but still, almost 41,000 people<br />
were killed on the nation’s roadways, according to full-year estimates<br />
by safety regulators. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration<br />
said it was the second year in a row that fatalities decreased.<br />
“We know that we must do more, and we know that we can’t do it<br />
alone,” Lawless said. “It’s great to see over 160 organizations answer<br />
the department’s call to action campaign, and we thank TCA for being<br />
one of the first partners to answer our call.”<br />
Turning to truck parking, Lawless said progress has been made since<br />
the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law provided millions in federal grant funding<br />
to help states add hundreds of truck parking spaces.<br />
“Those projects included $180 million to the Florida Department of<br />
Transportation for over 900 truck parking spaces, over $92 million to<br />
the Missouri Department of Transportation for a project that includes<br />
both truck parking and truck parking information systems, and over $22<br />
36 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
million to Tennessee for a bridge replacement and additional<br />
truck parking,” Lawless noted.<br />
Lawless also pointed out that the FMCSA has additional<br />
research projects to help advance truck parking availability<br />
information systems. The agency is also analyzing available<br />
data on safety from connected trucks to help identify<br />
areas with the highest demand and need for parking and<br />
how to best target solutions, resources, and methodologies<br />
for stakeholders to calculate the cost and benefit of<br />
investing in parking.<br />
“We know truck parking remains a safety and overall<br />
quality of life issue for drivers, and it remains a priority for<br />
us to partner across the industry to help ease and eventually<br />
eliminate this challenge,” she said. “We have also<br />
launched our driver compensation and driver detention<br />
time studies to address other factors that may make it difficult<br />
to sustain a career as a truck driver. We know that the<br />
longer drivers stay in the industry, the safer they become.”<br />
Switching topics, Lawless discussed the March meeting<br />
of the Truck Leasing Task Force during the Mid-America<br />
Trucking Show, held the week before TCA’s convention.<br />
The task force includes motor carriers, drivers, and others<br />
who are engaged in helping the FMCSA understand<br />
how unfair leasing arrangements could impact the safety<br />
of drivers and motor carriers.<br />
Lawless also spoke about how the FMCSA is working to<br />
modernize its systems in a world in which cybersecurity<br />
is paramount.<br />
“FMCSA (has a) new registration system (that) will<br />
improve the transparency, efficiency, and user experience<br />
with the agency’s registration systems and reduce fraud<br />
in the registration process,” she said. “This is just one of<br />
the steps we’re taking to modernize all FMCSA systems.”<br />
On the rulemaking side, Lawless said the FMCSA is<br />
working to get the heavy-duty automatic emergency braking<br />
rule “over the finish line” and complete other rulemakings.<br />
“Because we believe that technology has the promise of<br />
saving lives, we continue to look for ways to encourage the<br />
adoption of technology that can prevent crashes or reduce<br />
the impact from crashes that happen, including beyondcompliance<br />
initiatives and other ways to encourage carriers<br />
and drivers to use technology that improve safety, but<br />
most importantly makes sense for them,” Lawless said.<br />
Lawless said the FMCSA realizes that distracted driving<br />
of all kinds, along with speed and drug and alcohol use, remain<br />
“stubborn and persistent” causal factors in crashes.<br />
In closing, she noted that the FMCSA is continuing to<br />
seek ways to get the greatest impact from its grant programs<br />
to help the trucking industry grow and prosper.<br />
“Earlier this month, we announced our notes of funding<br />
opportunities for 2024,” she said. “We have more than<br />
$180 million available, including opportunities for CDL and<br />
other driver training and programs specifically for veterans<br />
who want to become truck drivers. I hope that this has<br />
given you some insight into our work at FMCSA. I’m proud<br />
of our work/ I’m encouraged by our partnership.”<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 37
TALKING TCA<br />
Photographs and Memories<br />
Truckload 2024: Nashville<br />
From March 23-26, nearly 1,500 attendees and more than 130 vendors and<br />
exhibitors checked into the Gaylord Opryland Resort in Nashville for the Truckload<br />
Carriers Association’s 2024 convention. In addition to annual committee meetings<br />
and numerous informative educational sessions, the event featured keynote<br />
speaker Kevin O’Leary, aka Mr. Wonderful of TV’s “Shark Tank,” a presentation<br />
by noted statistician Ken Gronbach, a musical performance by Gavin DeGraw<br />
(complete with a surprise appearance by Colbie Caillat), and much more.<br />
38 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 39
TALKING TCA<br />
DRIVERS<br />
making a<br />
DIFFERENCE<br />
2024 TCA Professional Drivers of the Year<br />
TCA’s 2024 drivers of the year, highway angels<br />
of the year represent the ‘best of the best’<br />
During Truckload 2020: Nashville, the Truckload<br />
Carriers Association (TCA) recognized two<br />
groups of exceptional drivers — the 2024 TCA<br />
Professional Drivers of the Year and the 2024 TCA<br />
Highway Angels of the Year. Each of these drivers has made<br />
a difference in the lives of others and in the trucking industry.<br />
2024 PROFESSIONAL DRIVERS OF THE YEAR<br />
TCA, along with program sponsors Cummins Inc. and<br />
Love’s Travel Stops, announced the five winners of the 2024<br />
TCA Professional Driver of the Year on March 26 during the<br />
convention’s closing banquet. This year’s program saw a record<br />
number of drivers nominated for the honor.<br />
The five winners are recognized as the best in class within<br />
the professional driver community. Each of these drivers has<br />
a compelling story to share. In addition, each one is committed<br />
to safety, demonstrates leadership both on and off<br />
the road, and has contributed significantly to the success<br />
of their companies, the trucking industry, and their communities.<br />
Each driver received $20,000 and standing ovations<br />
during the awards ceremony.<br />
“To be selected for this top honor, each of these professional<br />
drivers have truly set an example when it comes to<br />
safety, work ethic, and making a difference in their communities,”<br />
said Jon Archard, vice president of sales for Love’s.<br />
“These drivers represent a lot of the same core values we<br />
aspire to here at Love’s, and we’re excited to see what they’ll<br />
continue to accomplish.”<br />
This year’s top drivers are:<br />
• Tim Chelette, Big G Express<br />
• Rosalinda Tejada, Knight Transportation<br />
• Howard Robinson, NFI Industries<br />
• Clark Reed, Nussbaum Transportation<br />
• James White, P&S Transportation<br />
“At Cummins we are incredibly proud to sponsor this<br />
competition to help highlight the drivers that are the heart-<br />
Tim Chelette Rosalinda Tejada Howard Robinson Clark Reed James White<br />
40 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
2024 TCA Highway Angels of the Year<br />
beat of this great industry,” said José Samperio, vice president and<br />
general manager-North America On Highway for Cummins. “These<br />
drivers represent the impact that they’ve had not only in their workspace<br />
but also to our economy and in our communities.”<br />
To find out more about the TCA Professional Driver of the Year Program,<br />
visit TCAProfessionalDriversoftheYear.com.<br />
2024 TCA HIGHWAY ANGELS OF THE YEAR<br />
For the first time since the 1997 inception of the program, not just<br />
one, but three drivers were honored as the 2024 TCA Highway Angels<br />
of the Year. Each driver was selected because of their selfless acts of<br />
heroism and caring for others in times of crisis while on the road.<br />
TCA Highway Angel sponsors EpicVue and Northland Insurance introduced<br />
this year’s winners during the association’s annual convention<br />
in Nashville.<br />
This year’s TCA Highway Angels of the Year are:<br />
• Tony Blunnie, Knight Transportation<br />
Blunnie was recognized for rescuing a driver who was trapped in<br />
her vehicle following a crash. He was able to extract her from the<br />
wreckage just moments before the vehicle was engulfed in flames.<br />
• Dawna Jacobsen, Erb Transport<br />
When a boy on a snowmobile was struck by a vehicle while attempting<br />
to cross a snowy road in Northern Ontario, Canada, Jacobsen used<br />
her truck to shield the boy from further injury.<br />
• Terry Reavis, Maverick Transportation LLC<br />
Reavis put his experience as a first responder to work, rescuing<br />
three children and providing aid to an injured woman after a pickup<br />
truck, which was driving erratically, T-boned an SUV.<br />
The drivers received a standing ovation from the audience.<br />
Each driver will receive a complimentary EpicVue satellite TV package<br />
that includes a 24-inch flat-screen TV, a DVR, and a one-year subscription<br />
to over 100 channels of DIRECTV programming, including<br />
premium channels such as HBO, Cinemax, Showtime, and the NFL<br />
Sunday Ticket.<br />
To find out more about the TCA Highway Angel program, which<br />
is sponsored by EpicVue, Northland Insurance, and DriverFacts, visit<br />
highwayangel.org.<br />
Tony Blunnie Dawna Jacobsen Terry Reavis<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 41
TALKING TCA<br />
ELEVATE<br />
Class of ’24<br />
TCA leadership program offers unique<br />
opportunities for young professionals<br />
The inaugural class of the Truckload Carriers<br />
Association’s (TCA) Elevate Young Leadership<br />
Program was introduced during the association’s<br />
annual convention, held in Nashville March 23-26.<br />
Designed to empower and nurture the leaders of tomorrow,<br />
TCA’s Elevate program offers young professionals a unique<br />
opportunity to engage with each other and industry mentors,<br />
further their trucking knowledge, and thrive in their careers.<br />
Each member of this year’s group of 15 young transportation<br />
executives was selected from a large, competitive pool<br />
of applicants, and they are to be congratulated for their<br />
selection. The Elevate Class of ’24 is made up of TCA carrier<br />
and associate members:<br />
• Samantha Bodnar, executive team, D.M. Bowman, Inc.<br />
• Sarah Burns, manager of transportation, scheduling and<br />
planning, Swto LLC<br />
• Rayvaun Christenson, vice president, Christenson<br />
Transportation<br />
• Jeff Dorais, operations manager, Brown Dog Carriers<br />
• Ryan Doran, business development, Diamond<br />
Transportation System, Inc.<br />
• Jason Douglass, director of retention and recruiting,<br />
Stokes Trucking<br />
• Alfonso Dozal, cross-border administration, Landstar<br />
Transportation Logistics, Inc.<br />
• Craig Enns, CFO, Arnold Bros Transport Ltd<br />
• Michael Foley, senior transportation specialist, TrueNorth<br />
Companies<br />
• David Hoerres, director of national accounts, Comdata Inc.<br />
• Jennifer Nuest, senior vice president of transportation<br />
practice, Amwins Group<br />
• Tyler Smith, maintenance manager, Wilson Logistics, Inc.<br />
• Derek Vanblargan, president, Northern Logistics<br />
• Molly Vidler, external communications specialist, Tenstreet<br />
• Ryan Whelan, district sales associate, Volvo Truck Group<br />
Members of the Elevate TCA Young Leadership Program<br />
participate in a mix of in-person meetings at TCA events in<br />
addition to six virtual meetings throughout 2024. Tenstreet is<br />
the program’s presenting sponsor.<br />
For more information about the Elevate program, visit<br />
truckload.org/elevate.<br />
42 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
Champions Club<br />
During TCA’s annual convention in Nashville, members of the Champions Club were recognized (from left): Tracy Bogler of Woody Bogler Trucking; Mike Coble<br />
of Recruit, Hire, Retain; Trevor Kurtz of Brian Kurtz Trucking; Jeff McKinney of the GTI Group; Christi Proctor of McLeod Software; and Kim Richardson of KRTS<br />
Transportation Specialists.<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 43
TALKING TCA<br />
Steve Phillips steps into role of TCA<br />
Profitability Program facilitator<br />
In February, the Truckload Carriers Association (TCA) welcomed Steve Phillips to<br />
the team as facilitator for the association’s Profitability Program (TPP).<br />
As program facilitator, he is responsible for bolstering the Best Practice Groups.<br />
Carriers participating in these groups work to identify ways to improve their operations<br />
through benchmarking and in-person meetings.<br />
“We are excited to welcome Steve Phillips to our team as TPP Facilitator,” said TCA<br />
President Jim Ward. “We are confident that his wealth of experience, strategic vision,<br />
and commitment to excellence will be invaluable to our team as we continue to drive<br />
profitability forward in the truckload industry.”<br />
Steve brings over 30 years of experience in transportation management to the program,<br />
having served many years in senior leadership roles at Werner Enterprises and<br />
as senior vice president of over-the-road operations at U.S. Xpress, Inc. Throughout<br />
his career, he has demonstrated an exceptional ability to navigate the challenges and<br />
opportunities of transportation management, leading to significant improvements in<br />
operational efficiencies and profits.<br />
In addition to his leadership roles within carriers, Phillips has served on numerous<br />
boards promoting prosperity in the transportation industry, including the North American<br />
Council for Freight Efficiency (NACFE) and Trucking Profitability Strategies (TPS).<br />
“TCA’s ability to provide robust performance platforms and benchmarking opportunities<br />
through programs such as TPP, make them the premier resource for any company<br />
looking to improve,” Phillips said. “I am thrilled to be joining an organization that<br />
has such a positive impact on the trucking industry.”<br />
Tim Chelette<br />
2 and 4-year college students across the US and<br />
Canada with ties to the truckload industry are<br />
elligible to receive scholarships of up to $6,250!<br />
44 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
Looking forward<br />
The Truckload Carriers Association (TCA)<br />
calendar is filled with exciting opportunities for<br />
member growth and involvement. Here are just<br />
a few upcoming events. Mark your calendar!<br />
June 2-4<br />
2024 Safety & Security Meeting<br />
Indianapolis<br />
July 15-17<br />
2024 Refrigerated Meeting<br />
Stowe, Vermont<br />
September 11-12<br />
The Truckload Carriers Association<br />
welcomes companies that joined the association<br />
in February and March 2024.<br />
ACT Research<br />
Aggressive<br />
Transportation<br />
AIG Insurance<br />
Company of Canada<br />
BlueJay Advisors<br />
Bolt System<br />
BreakerOne9, LLC<br />
Copart<br />
Emerge Career<br />
Enru Logistics &<br />
Postal Optimization<br />
Galloway Johnson<br />
Tompkins Burr Smith<br />
Jay Transport, Inc.<br />
Lion Force Transport<br />
LobLaw<br />
Magnus Technologies<br />
MDMtoGo<br />
Medlog Trucking<br />
Canada<br />
Modern Transportation<br />
Napora<br />
Next Logistics LLC<br />
Openforce<br />
Polaris Transportation<br />
Primary Risk Services<br />
Recruit Hire Retain<br />
Ryder System, Inc.<br />
Seward Motor Freight<br />
Summit Virtual CFO by<br />
Anders<br />
T-Mobile<br />
Trucking Clicks<br />
Trucksafe Consulting<br />
Vulcraft Carrier<br />
Webb Pallet Service<br />
2024 Fall Business Meetings & Call on Washington<br />
Washington, D.C.<br />
September 11-12<br />
Bridging Border Barriers<br />
Mississauga, Ontario<br />
Visit<br />
truckload.org/events<br />
for updates<br />
Cover Photo<br />
2024-25 TCA Chairman John Culp<br />
Photo courtesy of the Truckload Carriers Association<br />
Additional photography/Graphics<br />
Associated Press: 14<br />
iStock: 4, 6-7, 8, 10, 12, 13, 16-17, 18,19,<br />
20-21, 22-23, 46<br />
Jason Douglass: 33<br />
Linda Garner-Bunch: 32, 39<br />
Modern Transportation: 30, 31<br />
Truckload Carriers Association: 3, 24-25, 26,<br />
28, 29, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44<br />
46 Truckload Authority | www.Truckload.org TCA MAY/JUNE 2024
Truckload Carriers Association<br />
SAFETY &<br />
SECURITY<br />
MEETING<br />
June 2 - 4<br />
Indianapolis, IN<br />
LEARN MORE<br />
AND REGISTER<br />
TCA MAY/JUNE 2024 www.Truckload.org | Truckload Authority 47