The Star: March 14, 2024
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong> Thursday <strong>March</strong> <strong>14</strong> <strong>2024</strong><br />
<strong>14</strong><br />
NEWS<br />
Latest Canterbury news at starnews.co.nz<br />
Frenchwoman reunites with spinal<br />
unit carers 52 years after shock crash<br />
Dominique Vallette’s ambitious goal of tracking<br />
down Cantabrians who nursed her back to<br />
health after she suffered spinal injuries in a car<br />
accident in 1972 was fulfilled last week after her<br />
appeal was publicised by <strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong> in January.<br />
Chris Barclay witnessed an emotional reunion at<br />
Burwood Hospital<br />
MORE THAN half a century<br />
elapsed, but Dominique Vallette<br />
ultimately experienced the<br />
South Island scenic destinations<br />
on her itinerary after leaving<br />
Punakaiki’s Pancake Rocks<br />
during the winter of 1972.<br />
<strong>The</strong>n an 18-year-old on a<br />
study trip from her temporary<br />
home in New Caledonia, the<br />
Frenchwoman’s travel plans went<br />
awry when the Morris Mini<br />
she was driving slid off a gravel<br />
bend on the Haast Pass towards<br />
Wanaka and plunged 60 metres<br />
down a bank.<br />
She was freed from the<br />
wreckage and then endured<br />
a watchful two-day trip to<br />
Christchurch Hospital where she<br />
spent three months in traction<br />
with spinal injuries.<br />
Vallette returned to New<br />
Zealand last month for a sixweek<br />
trip which enabled her<br />
to take in Wanaka, Glenorchy,<br />
Kinloch, Queenstown,<br />
Arrowtown, Doubtful Sound,<br />
Twizel and Aoraki Mt Cook.<br />
“I’m glad I’ve seen them this<br />
time, finally,” she said.<br />
Yet Vallette’s favourite<br />
recollection, the sight she<br />
coveted above all others, was<br />
witnessed inside the spinal unit<br />
at Burwood Hospital.<br />
Seeing the smiling faces of a<br />
surgeon and staff who nursed<br />
her in ward 13B, plus a woman<br />
whose family accommodated<br />
Vallette during convalescence,<br />
was the truly unforgettable<br />
memory.<br />
“This is a celebration I’ve been<br />
thinking of for many years. <strong>The</strong><br />
main purpose of the trip was to<br />
come back to New Zealand to<br />
try and find the kind<br />
and talented people<br />
without whom I<br />
would never have<br />
had a normal<br />
life,” she said.<br />
“<strong>The</strong>re was<br />
a team of<br />
kindness and love around me,<br />
really a family, and I never forgot<br />
that.”<br />
Her plan for a reunion reached<br />
fruition last Thursday when she<br />
hosted a gathering with surgeon<br />
Dr Allan Bean, ward sister<br />
Beth Spiers, nurse Sue Ryan<br />
(née Osborne) and Rosemary<br />
Kraushaar (née Doherty).<br />
Once released from hospital,<br />
she stayed with the Doherty<br />
family, who learned of her plight<br />
because a relative, amateur<br />
(ham) radio operator Arnold<br />
Dacombe, had contacted<br />
Valette’s parents in Noumea<br />
after the accident.<br />
“<strong>The</strong>re was the physical part of<br />
MUSICAL DUO: Student nurse Sue Ryan (née Osborne)<br />
and Vallette played music to raise the Frenchwoman’s<br />
spirits.<br />
it (hospital treatment) and for<br />
the mental and spiritual part<br />
of it I was always kept in very<br />
high spirits by the Dohertys.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y were so kind and<br />
patient,” she said.<br />
While Rosemary was at<br />
the function, her mother<br />
Helen, now aged 93, also met<br />
Vallette last week.<br />
Vallette presented<br />
her Canterbury<br />
family with a<br />
special<br />
souvenir mug.<br />
<strong>The</strong> same design, devised<br />
by one of her three sons, was<br />
framed and presented to the<br />
unit, which relocated from<br />
Christchurch Hospital in 1979.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> fern is a symbol for New<br />
Zealand, and it also looks like a<br />
spine,” Vallette explained.<br />
“It is also like a staircase<br />
because I was on my way to<br />
recovery, on my way up to<br />
having a good life.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> numbers represented the<br />
year of the crash, the reunion<br />
and 52 years of gratitude.<br />
Before the afternoon tea Vallette<br />
had a private consultation<br />
with Bean, a junior member of<br />
her treatment team.<br />
“She is lucky she broke the<br />
second lumbar vertebrae (L2)<br />
rather than the first,” he said,<br />
explaining damage to the L2<br />
would not drastically impact on<br />
the spinal cord.<br />
Vallette suffered severe<br />
bruising and nerve damage; she<br />
was able to walk from hospital<br />
with only a back brace for<br />
support after avoiding life as a<br />
paraplegic by millimetres.<br />
“She’s very lucky it was below<br />
L1. When it’s damaged it usually<br />
crushes the spinal cord and she’d<br />
probably be in a wheelchair.”<br />
Now 90, still sharp and<br />
living in a Wigram retirement<br />
complex, Bean was told about<br />
Vallette’s trip by another<br />
resident.<br />
A friend also alerted Ryan, a<br />
student nurse whose rotation<br />
coincided with Vallette’s<br />
treatment.<br />
“It was very confronting<br />
(starting in the unit). I was quite<br />
traumatised for the first week,<br />
seeing these lovely<br />
young people<br />
coming into<br />
the ward and<br />
realising<br />
what their<br />
future was<br />
going to be,”<br />
she said.<br />
So<br />
Vallette’s positivity and<br />
resilience was a welcome coping<br />
mechanism.<br />
“She was a perfect patient,<br />
she was so relaxed. She was not<br />
afraid of what might happen.<br />
“We had a lovely rapport with<br />
each other. It was a busy ward<br />
so often I’d go after my shift and<br />
spend time with her.<br />
“I played a little bit of guitar<br />
in those days so we’d play Cat<br />
Stevens, Joni Mitchell, all those<br />
songs.”<br />
When, after three months<br />
in traction, Vallette felt a<br />
big toe twitch, doctors and<br />
physiotherapists thought the<br />
movement was a figment of a<br />
hopeful imagination.<br />
However, Ryan saw the wiggle<br />
with her own eyes.<br />
“It was so exciting, I could see<br />
it. It proved the bruising and the<br />
nerves were healing,” she said.<br />
Ryan, who lives in Weedons,<br />
lost touch after Vallette was<br />
Dr Allan Bean and Vallette<br />
at the reunion.<br />
PHOTOS: CHRIS BARCLAY<br />
CARE: Dominique<br />
Vallette (top right)<br />
reunited with<br />
Sue Ryan (top<br />
left), Rosemary<br />
Kraushaar (front<br />
left) and Beth<br />
Spiers.<br />
discharged so the get-together<br />
was a pleasant surprise.<br />
“I’m just thrilled. Dominique<br />
stayed over the other night. We<br />
just reminisced about old times.<br />
We can’t believe 50 years have<br />
gone by in a flash.”<br />
Vallette, who turns 70 on May<br />
1, started her trip in Auckland,<br />
reached Wellington in two<br />
days and then took the ferry<br />
to Picton, her journey south<br />
deliberately featuring another<br />
drive through Haast Pass.<br />
Although the road has been<br />
modified since her accident,<br />
Vallette easily identified her<br />
crash scene.<br />
“I found the precise place<br />
where I left the road. It’s the<br />
only place where there is that<br />
kind of curve, not far from the<br />
Makarora River,” she said.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re was no parking bay<br />
in the vicinity so Vallette<br />
was unable to stop to take a<br />
photograph, though the bend is<br />
clearly etched in her mind.<br />
“I was driving and I<br />
recognised it straight away, it<br />
was near the end of the Haast<br />
Pass. I think there were two<br />
Americans who met their deaths<br />
also in that precise place a few<br />
years ago. <strong>The</strong> road is much<br />
better now,” she said.<br />
“It’s a sealed road which has<br />
been widened and there’s a<br />
railing on the ravine side.”<br />
Vallette admitted there was<br />
some anxiety as she headed<br />
down the pass.<br />
“I was quite anxious at first but<br />
when I saw it (the crash scene) I<br />
didn’t even feel a pang.<br />
“I thought: ‘Well at least the<br />
road is very secure now, it won’t<br />
happen again’.”