The Maryland Nurse - nursingALD.com
The Maryland Nurse - nursingALD.com
The Maryland Nurse - nursingALD.com
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong><br />
Issue 2 Volume 3 August, September, October 2000<br />
Register Now for the 2000 MNA Convention<br />
“Healthy <strong>Nurse</strong>s 2000”<br />
Rocky Gap Lodge and Golf Resort<br />
Cumberland, <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
See details and registration form on pages 18 & 19<br />
Linda Stierle Named Executive Director<br />
and Chief Executive Officer of ANA<br />
Linda J. Stierle, MSN, RN, CNAA, a nurse leader with<br />
more than 30 years’ diverse management experience in<br />
health care operations, has been named executive director<br />
and chief executive officer of the<br />
American <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association<br />
(ANA). Stierle was most recently<br />
acting executive director and chief<br />
operating officer for ANA. She<br />
joined ANA in March 2000 following<br />
her retirement from the<br />
United States Air Force where she<br />
held the rank of Brigadier General.<br />
Ms. Stierle will develop and<br />
implement programs designed to<br />
meet the vision and goals of the<br />
association. She will also serve as<br />
executive director of the American<br />
Commission on the Crisis in Nursing Summit 2000<br />
On June 6, 2000, a statewide summit was held to discuss<br />
the current workforce crisis in nursing in the state.<br />
Over 600 nurses convened for this important event which<br />
was an out<strong>com</strong>e of legislation passed during this year’s<br />
legislative session in Annapolis. That legislation introduced<br />
in the Senate by <strong>The</strong> Honorable Paula Hollinger,<br />
a registered nurse delegate, and in the House by <strong>The</strong><br />
Honorable Marilyn Goldwater, also a registered nurse,<br />
and <strong>The</strong> Honorable Adrienne A. Mandel, called for the<br />
establishment of a 46 member Commission on the Crisis<br />
in Nursing and the convening of a Summit.<br />
Dr. Georges C. Benjamin,<br />
MD, Secretary of the Department<br />
of Health and Mental Hygiene, is<br />
named as the Chair of the<br />
Commission. Vice Chairs include:<br />
Nancy Adams, <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
Organization of <strong>Nurse</strong> Executives;<br />
Mary Beachley, <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s<br />
Association; Sharon Bernier,<br />
Montgomery College; Sue<br />
Donaldson, Johns Hopkins<br />
University School of Nursing;<br />
Charlene Hall, LPN Association;<br />
Kathryn Hall, Colleagues in<br />
Colleagues; Barbara Heller,<br />
Stierle<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s Foundation. “It’s truly an honor and a privilege to<br />
serve my chosen profession and help the American <strong>Nurse</strong>s<br />
Ramsay<br />
University of <strong>Maryland</strong> School of Nursing; Eleanor<br />
Walker, Bowie State University and Donna Dorsey,<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Board of Nursing.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Summit was a full day opening at 8:45 AM with<br />
greetings from Dr. Benjamin, Dr. David J. Ramsay,<br />
President of the University of <strong>Maryland</strong>, Baltimore and<br />
Dr. Barbara Heller, Dean of the University of <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
School of Nursing. <strong>The</strong> University of <strong>Maryland</strong> generously<br />
provided the meeting space for the summit in the<br />
Association achieve its vision of one, strong united voice<br />
for the profession of nursing,” said Stierle.<br />
Stierle had been a long-time member of the Texas <strong>Nurse</strong>s<br />
Association until February 2000 when she transferred her<br />
membership to the <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association. She<br />
was instrumental in the creation of ANA’s newest constituency<br />
for nurses in the uniformed services, the Federal<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s Association (FedNA).<br />
Her military awards include the Distinguished Service<br />
Medal, Legion of Merit with one oak leaf cluster,<br />
Meritorious Service Medal with three oak leaf clusters, Air<br />
Force Commendation Medal, Air Force Achievement<br />
Medal, and National Defense Service Medal with Bronze<br />
Star.<br />
Stierle earned a master’s of science in nursing from the<br />
University of California, San Francisco, a bachelor’s of science<br />
in nursing from Incarnate Word College, San Antonio,<br />
TX, and a diploma in nursing from Spartanburg General<br />
Hospital in Spartanburg, SC.<br />
School of Nursing’s newly constructed building and auditorium.<br />
Dr. Brenda Cleary, Executive<br />
Director for the North Carolina<br />
Center for Nursing was the invited<br />
speaker and gave an overview of<br />
some of the activities in the state of<br />
North Carolina directed to address<br />
the increasing shortage of nurses.<br />
Dr. Cleary suggested that it is<br />
increasingly difficult to forecast<br />
the need/demand for nurses<br />
beyond a year or two. She defined<br />
demand as “what the market place<br />
will buy;” need as “a clinical<br />
concept about the best practices for<br />
Cleary<br />
a population of patients” and supply as “the amount of<br />
labor available to work.” Dr. Cleary pointed out that while<br />
society is diverse, nursing is not. Only 10% of the nursing<br />
workforce is made up of minorities and less than 6% are<br />
male. She suggested that improving these percentages<br />
needed to be one of the focal points for addressing the<br />
workforce needs. “Employers,” according to Dr. Cleary,<br />
“are looking for faster transitions from novice to expert in<br />
the work setting.” “ Issues such as mandatory staffing will<br />
best be addressed by empowering nurses at the unit level<br />
and holding them accountable,” said Dr. Cleary. <strong>The</strong><br />
issues are <strong>com</strong>plex. Senator Paula Hollinger, in remarks<br />
she made to the group, said that “nurses are the worst people<br />
in the world when advocating for ourselves. <strong>The</strong>re are<br />
two times more licenses nurses than doctors in <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
and yet nurses are silent.”<br />
Beth Greenland served as a facilitator for the remainder<br />
of the day where the entire group of 600 participated in the<br />
identification of issues, the development of priorities, and<br />
ANA to Create Commission<br />
on Workplace Advocacy<br />
At a special session of the ANA 2000 House of<br />
Delegates (HOD), members voted overwhelmingly to<br />
support a bylaw amendment that will establish a<br />
Commission on Workplace Advocacy. Workplace advocacy<br />
is not a new focus for ANA – advocacy for nurses<br />
and their patients is part of the association’s 104 yearold<br />
history as well as its promise for the future. <strong>The</strong><br />
amendment will create a <strong>com</strong>mission that will advise<br />
and oversee the synthesis, translation and distribution<br />
of workplace advocacy information, programs, services,<br />
and products. Workplace advocacy is used successfully<br />
in various practice settings across the country to<br />
help registered nurses secure optimal working conditions<br />
and optimum patient care. <strong>The</strong> first meeting of the<br />
<strong>com</strong>mission is expected to occur in late September or<br />
early October. (See report on HOD meeting provided<br />
by the <strong>Maryland</strong> Delegation beginning on page 22)<br />
the discussion of strategies and solutions. Individual <strong>com</strong>ments<br />
were invited from attendees who had special perspectives<br />
to offer the group.<br />
A small group format was used to facilitate the overall<br />
productivity of the day. <strong>The</strong>se groups were assigned specific<br />
topic areas relative to the nursing workforce issues.<br />
<strong>The</strong> topic areas included: recruitment, retention, education<br />
and an other issues group.<br />
<strong>The</strong> top five issues identified in each of these topic<br />
areas included the following:<br />
Recruitment<br />
• Image<br />
• A lack of understanding of what motivates our<br />
youth, other career choices<br />
Crisis in Nursing Summit cont. on pg. 10<br />
Inside this issue....<br />
MNA Members in the News......................................4<br />
Workplace Violence: Part IV ..................................11<br />
A Mystery Solved....................................................12<br />
Public Health Nursing in MD: Our Roots ..............16<br />
MNA Convention ....................................................20<br />
ANA House of Delegates Report ............................26<br />
ANA Election Results 2000 ....................................30<br />
Medication Errors....................................................32<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Colleagues in Caring ..............................34<br />
Multistate Licensure Compact Bill Status ..............35<br />
MNA Membership Application ..............................38<br />
Poster Submission Form..........................................39
• PAGE P GE 2 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association<br />
to participate in <strong>Maryland</strong>’s<br />
Race for the Cure<br />
MNA is organizing a TEAM to participate in the “8th<br />
Annual Komen <strong>Maryland</strong> Race for the Cure.” <strong>The</strong> event<br />
will take place on Sunday, October 8, 2000 on Rash<br />
Field at Baltimore’s Inner Harbor. We are looking for<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s who are breast cancer survivors to lead our<br />
TEAM on this day, as well as nurses who are willing to<br />
take some time out of their schedules to walk with us and<br />
solicit support. Our team entry must be in no later than<br />
September 18, 2000 so please call MNA today and register<br />
with us to walk at 410-859-3000.<br />
PUBLICATION<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong> Publication Schedule<br />
Issue Material Due to<br />
MNA Office<br />
Feb/Mar/Apr Issue January 7, 2000<br />
May/June/July Issue April 7, 2000<br />
Aug/Sept/Oct Issue July 7, 2000<br />
Nov/Dec/Jan Issue October 7, 2000<br />
Please see Editorial Guidelines for Article Submission.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong> is the official publication of the<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association. It is published quarterly.<br />
Subscription price of $12.00 yearly. Postmaster: send<br />
change of address and correspondence and editorial and<br />
advertising copy to 849 International Drive, Suite 255,<br />
Linthicum, <strong>Maryland</strong> 21090.<br />
Guidelines for<br />
Article Development<br />
<strong>The</strong> editorial <strong>com</strong>mittee wel<strong>com</strong>es articles for publication.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re is no payment for articles published in<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>.<br />
1. Articles should be word-processed using a 12-point<br />
font.<br />
2. Articles should be double-spaced.<br />
3. Article length should not exceed five (5) pages 8 1/2<br />
x 11.<br />
4. All references should be cited at the end of the article.<br />
5. It is requested that articles be enhanced with photographs,<br />
drawings, tables etc. as much as possible.<br />
6. A photograph release form must be <strong>com</strong>pleted for any<br />
photograph or image where individuals are identifiable.<br />
Forms are available from MNA by calling (410) 859-3000.<br />
7. <strong>The</strong> author of the article should submit a picture of<br />
himself or herself along with two to three sentences that<br />
gives information about the author.<br />
8. Articles should be submitted with two hard/paper<br />
copies and a 3-1/2 inch disk with name of the article and<br />
the program used identified.<br />
Submissions should be sent to:<br />
Editorial Committee<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association<br />
849 International Drive, Suite 255<br />
Linthicum, <strong>Maryland</strong> 21090<br />
ADVERTISING<br />
Acceptance of advertising does not imply endorsement<br />
or approval by the <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association of the<br />
products advertised, the advertisers or the claims made.<br />
Rejection of an advertisement does not imply that a product<br />
offered for advertising is without merit, or that the<br />
manufacturer lacks integrity, or that this association disapproves<br />
of the product or its use. MNA and the Arthur L.<br />
Davis Publishing Agency, Inc. shall not be held liable for<br />
any consequences resulting from purchase or use of advertiser<br />
products. Advertisements will be accepted on a first<strong>com</strong>e,<br />
first-serve basis for preferred positions. MNA and<br />
publishers reserve the right to reject any advertising.<br />
FOR ADVERTISING RATES AND INFORMATION<br />
CONTACT THE ARTHUR L. DAVIS AGENCY, P.O.<br />
BOX 216, CEDAR FALLS, IOWA 50613, 319-277-2414.<br />
THE MARYLAND NURSES ASSOCIATION AND THE<br />
ARTHUR L. DAVIS AGENCY RESERVE THE RIGHT<br />
TO REJECT ADVERTISING. Responsibility for errors in<br />
advertising is limited to corrections in the next issue or<br />
refund of price of advertisement.<br />
EDITORIAL COMMITTEE<br />
Janet Cogliano, DNSc, RN,CS<br />
Karen Cowell, PhD, RN, C<br />
Cathy Cully Bennett, MS, RN, CNA<br />
Lynn Derickson, MS, RN, C<br />
Kathryn Hall, MS, RN, CNAA<br />
VISION STATEMENT<br />
Through our members, we touch the lives of other<br />
nurses and the people of <strong>Maryland</strong> everyday<br />
Our Vision<br />
To be a dynamic force in the advancement of nursing<br />
practice and advocate for the promotion of quality health<br />
care for all individuals.<br />
Our Values<br />
• Excellence in nursing practice<br />
• Respect for all individuals, groups and <strong>com</strong>munities<br />
• Cultural diversity<br />
• Universal access to affordable, quality health care<br />
• Quality of life<br />
Our Mission<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association will foster the development<br />
and advancement of nursing practice and will<br />
work to achieve quality health care for all the people of<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong>
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 3 •<br />
“Rodney Dangerfield, R.N.”<br />
by Rob Ross Hendrickson<br />
Rob Hendrickson, MNA attorney,<br />
long-time MNA Annapolis<br />
lobbyist and vehement advocate of<br />
Nursing submitted this article<br />
expressing his personal views from<br />
that unique perspective. In so<br />
doing, he requested that the longstanding<br />
open invitation to all<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Registered <strong>Nurse</strong>s to<br />
assist in MNA’s Annapolis activities<br />
be reiterated.<br />
Cicadian rhythms seemingly dictate<br />
a “Crisis in Nursing” every few<br />
Hendrickson<br />
years, each resulting from a<br />
“Shortage” of qualified Registered <strong>Nurse</strong>s. Dislocations<br />
and reallocations in a fluid health care delivery system, the<br />
latest being managed care’s resource rationing at a time of<br />
unprecedented employment opportunities elsewhere for<br />
women, are the generally perceived causes of our current<br />
crisis.<br />
Whatever we might wish, Registered <strong>Nurse</strong>s are still<br />
viewed institutionally as handmaidens. As the actual deliverers<br />
of hands-on patient care, RN’s have never taken<br />
advantage of their potential to force the health care system<br />
to recognized their worth and take them seriously. <strong>The</strong>y<br />
have always been, and allowed themselves to be, taken for<br />
granted.<br />
What is almost never mentioned (outside of RN’s eternally<br />
griping among themselves) is that despite their education<br />
and experience, RN’s GET NO RESPECT. Society<br />
truly values the services of RN’s and it needs to provide the<br />
resources and working conditions to attract and retain qualified<br />
persons. Everyone gives lip-service to this acknowledged<br />
maxim. It’s no wonder that the public is befuddled<br />
that its billions of health care dollars spent aren’t adequate<br />
to do this. <strong>The</strong> real reason is always obscured. Nursing has<br />
not only failed to effectively educate <strong>Nurse</strong>s but also the<br />
general public.<br />
Despite viewing themselves as professionals, Registered<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s are frequently treated as day laborers. <strong>The</strong>y are<br />
over-worked in understaffed workplaces; are required to<br />
make hurried split-second life or death decisions on patient<br />
care and be responsible for the consequences; are accountable<br />
for the actions or inactions of unlicensed personnel that<br />
<strong>com</strong>e with their positions; are subject to the condescension<br />
of physicians and business-types whose egos or budgets<br />
conflict with a RN’s expertise and advocacy of quality<br />
patient care; are required to be available on little notice no<br />
matter what personal or family plans are interfered with; and<br />
are haunted by nursing school and employer—inculcated<br />
fears of being viewed as “unprofessional”, or as having<br />
somehow “abandoned” their patients if they aggressively<br />
react negatively to these conditions. As a group, <strong>Nurse</strong>s suffer<br />
from acute “LEARNED HELPLESSNESS.” This is<br />
why RN’s who can leave their profession simply do and<br />
why the next generation of potential RN’s don’t enter in the<br />
first place. Registered <strong>Nurse</strong>s have not insisted on their<br />
rightful recognition as the single most important practitioner<br />
in patient care. It’s the workplace perception of this low<br />
professional esteem, (prevalent within Nursing itself) that<br />
allows this to continue. Physicians have long recognized<br />
this and take full advantage, as do many employers and even<br />
some RN’s. Those considering nursing schools are obviously<br />
only too well-aware of this. <strong>The</strong> only people who<br />
don’t really see this are patients and their families for whom<br />
the RN (or someone they think is an RN) is their best hope<br />
for recovery and caring treatment.<br />
<strong>The</strong> current crisis in Nursing offers yet again a true opportunity<br />
for RN’s to awaken, assert themselves, and unteach<br />
this learned helplessness. For once, RN’s need to stand their<br />
ground; insist that their colleagues support their proper<br />
actions; demand that schools of nursing and employers<br />
focus immediately on developing leadership and <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
among all RN’s and emphasize in every course or<br />
workplace program the independent role and responsibility<br />
of the Registered <strong>Nurse</strong>s; and finally emphasize to potential<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s and the public that Nursing will not put up with conditions<br />
as they are today. <strong>Nurse</strong>s must first be taught to <strong>com</strong>mand<br />
respect if they are to expect to receive it.<br />
In short, Nursing must be put aside its fears and internal<br />
bickering jealousies. RN’s singly and cohesively must take<br />
back their profession. Believe it or not, the public is with<br />
RN’s all the way and RN’s sheer numbers cannot be denied.<br />
No studies are needed. RN’s all know exactly what the<br />
problems are. <strong>The</strong> solutions are within each RN and they<br />
must cumulate this time to solve and not simply duck another<br />
crisis which then merely goes into remission maybe.<br />
Only from within Nursing will a real solution emerge.<br />
Money’s important, but no sane person has ever gone into<br />
Nursing for the bucks. Marketplace supply and demand<br />
(even blunted by Nursing’s woeful willingness to allow<br />
cheaper, unprepared persons to do what RN’s spend years<br />
being educated to do) has nonetheless worked to increase<br />
RN’s salaries – at least at entry level positions and the first<br />
few years of practice. Signing bonuses and referral fees are<br />
the order of the day, but they are short-term and short-sighted.<br />
Only those just graduating or in mid-or late career would<br />
choose these one-time payments as attractive momentary<br />
financial bumps-up in their positions as bedside caregivers.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re is no real progressive career-long financial future for<br />
RN’s wishing to remain in direct patient care. Prior to the<br />
current crisis, many RN’s dealt with this reality by going<br />
into “administration”. This became tokenism and virtually<br />
all of them are now gone, largely replaced by non-RN<br />
“human resources” bean counters who tellingly oversee<br />
Nursing, housekeeping and maintenance. With the cost-cutting<br />
abolition of even these former RN administrative positions,<br />
RN’s must, can and do now look elsewhere-mostly<br />
outside of hands-on patient care or Nursing altogether. This<br />
has not been lost on potential nursing students who see no<br />
reason to expend funds and years on Nursing degrees only<br />
to face a later look elsewhere for a career. <strong>The</strong>y are a lot<br />
smarter than some think and they’re sending a clear message.<br />
Tip O’Neil, a consummate Boston politician, was fond of<br />
saying “all politics is local.” All this is “politics” in its<br />
broadest and narrowest sense. Solutions here are also<br />
“local” from each individual RN, then to each’s workplace,<br />
then to <strong>Nurse</strong>s’ professional association (<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s Association), then through the MNA Legislative<br />
Committee which advocates Nursing interests before the<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Legislature in Annapolis, and distantly to the<br />
ANA in Washington,<br />
Solutions take gut and <strong>com</strong>mitment of time (and money).<br />
But guts and <strong>com</strong>mitment breed guts, <strong>com</strong>mitment and actual<br />
cures. <strong>The</strong>se bring RESPECT.<br />
For once, Nursing must take hold of the opportunity this<br />
crisis affords and, kicking and screaming, demand that the<br />
profession of Nursing be<strong>com</strong>e what it should be. For themselves,<br />
for RN’s that might follow and for the patients whose<br />
advocacy is Nursing’s highest calling, nothing else is important,<br />
Nothing.<br />
Wel<strong>com</strong>e New Members<br />
Assya Amatus-Salaam D2<br />
George S.J. Anderson D2<br />
Gail A. Bashore D5<br />
Naomi A. Blankenship D2<br />
Brenda L. Boggs D2<br />
Geneva S. Boyd D9<br />
Micke A. Brown D8<br />
Mary H. Codori D5<br />
Kimberly J. Elenberg D5<br />
Linda C. Goodman D8<br />
Oris L. Harris D2<br />
Dawn A. Hawkins D2<br />
Marie H. Hogarth D5<br />
Adrienne J. Hope D5<br />
Tammie L. James D2<br />
Janet Lee Jerge D4<br />
William R. Jones D5<br />
Sharon M. Kern D2<br />
Claudia M. Kim D3<br />
Kimberly J. Kodenski D2<br />
Peter A. LeBlanc D2<br />
Susan M. Marullo D5<br />
Kerse R. Mattox D4<br />
Ernestine Murray D2<br />
Cindy D. Myles D9<br />
Moira R. Namuth D2<br />
Bonnie Neibauer D5<br />
Jean A. Nicholas D5<br />
Reina S. Ocasio D2<br />
Catherine R. O’Neill D7<br />
Kathy Ann Palmer D8<br />
Valerie S. Parker D5<br />
Constance M. Pryor D2<br />
Teresa M.J. Putscher D3<br />
Sandra L. Sheldon D2<br />
Carol G. Smith D5<br />
Cynthia Ann Somers (White) D2<br />
Anita J. Tarzian D2<br />
Paula A. Trantas D2<br />
Mary D. Traver Ward D2<br />
Cathy D. Webb D1<br />
Tracey L. White D2<br />
Bernadette M. Wengert D2<br />
Mary J. Wise D8
• PAGE P GE 4 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
MNA Members in the News<br />
On Wednesday, May 31, 2000 five members of MNA were<br />
invited to attend Presidential Candidate, Al Gore’s plan for<br />
mental healthcare for children. With his wife Tipper, at his<br />
side, Vice President Al Gore came to the Friendship<br />
Heights Community Center in Montgomery County,<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> to tout his wife’s favorite cause – expanded care<br />
for mental illness – and to present his own view on care for<br />
children. MNA members who were invited to attend this<br />
announcement included Mary Beachley, President;<br />
Elizabeth Tordella, a staff nurse in psychiatry; Paul<br />
Kulp, a Psychiatric Advanced Clinical Specialist; Sue<br />
Roth, a staff nurse in psychiatry; and Diane Thompkins,<br />
President of MNA District 5 which covers Montgomery<br />
and Prince Georges Counties.<br />
Anita Tarzian, RN, PhD, (MNA District 2) Co-chair,<br />
MNA Center for Ethics and Human Rights represented the<br />
association through her participation in the Diane Rehms<br />
show a nationally syndicated radio talk show produced in<br />
Washington, DC and heard daily by over 750,000 listeners.<br />
<strong>The</strong> topic was hospice/end of life care. Kudos, Anita.<br />
Julie Pannell (MNA District 5)<br />
participated in the Beacon Heights<br />
Elementary School Career Day<br />
2000. Ms. Beth Frissell, Guidance<br />
Counselor and Career Day<br />
Coordinator called MNA to find a<br />
nurse speaker and Julie was an outstanding<br />
representative of MNA<br />
and of nursing. Mary Walker,<br />
Principal said of Julie, “Your <strong>com</strong>ments<br />
to our students were so<br />
appropriate, motivating and<br />
reminded the students of the impor- Pannell<br />
tance of working hard, staying in<br />
school and getting along with others. We feel so lucky that<br />
you chose to spend the morning with us.” Thank you Julie.<br />
Jacquelyn Campbell, PhD, RN,<br />
FAAN, (MNA District 2) professor<br />
and associate dean at <strong>The</strong> Johns<br />
Hopkins University School of<br />
Nursing, was named to the<br />
Department of Defense Task Force<br />
on Domestic Violence. Secretary<br />
of Defense William S. Cohen<br />
announced the appointment of<br />
members to the task force. <strong>The</strong><br />
Congressionally mandated task<br />
force will assess current domestic<br />
violence programs and policies<br />
within the Department of Defense<br />
and the military services.<br />
Kathleen M. White, RN, PhD,<br />
(MNA District 2, President)<br />
Associate Professor at <strong>The</strong> Johns<br />
Hopkins University School of<br />
Nursing has been appointed to a<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Health Care Commission<br />
steering <strong>com</strong>mittee charged to<br />
develop a system to <strong>com</strong>paratively<br />
evaluate the quality of care out<strong>com</strong>es<br />
and performance measurements<br />
of hospitals and ambulatory<br />
surgical facilities.<br />
Mary L. Beachley, RN, MS, CEN<br />
(MNA President) represented the<br />
association serving as the main<br />
guest of the Vicki Jones Talk Show<br />
out of Washington, DC. Ms.<br />
Beachley was asked to discuss the<br />
impact of the nursing shortage and<br />
to offer a response to the article in<br />
JAMA that discussed the shortage.<br />
Calling All<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong> Quilters!<br />
by Anne Marie Barentt, RNC<br />
President, District 9<br />
Campbell<br />
White<br />
Beachley<br />
I have an idea (vision) that I would like to share<br />
with fellow nurse quilters throughout the state of<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong>. More than ever, I have participated in discussions<br />
about the decrease in number of people<br />
applying to nursing programs and that the general public<br />
doesn’t really understand what nurses do. <strong>The</strong>re are<br />
campaigns all over, including newspaper advertisements,<br />
TV <strong>com</strong>mercials, radio <strong>com</strong>mercials, all aimed<br />
at telling people about what nurses do and why it is a<br />
rewarding career. That’s when I had an idea.<br />
I am a quilter and would like to gather a group of<br />
nurses who love to quilt like I do and put together a<br />
quilt that has many blocks that describe the many<br />
kinds of nursing practice and what nurses do to promote<br />
health, wellness, education, <strong>com</strong>fort, etc. Each<br />
block would represent areas of nursing such as, Acute<br />
Care, OB, Pediatrics, Long Term Care, Hospice, Home<br />
Health, etc. In the center of the quilt, I envision a<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> State emblem.<br />
I have scheduled an initial planning meeting for<br />
September 13th, 6-8 pm at MNA Headquarters in<br />
Linthicum. If you have a passion for both nursing and<br />
quilting, please plan to attend. If you have any questions,<br />
you can contact me in the evenings at (301) 475-<br />
8456.<br />
Medical Errors:<br />
Where’s the Blame<br />
by Mary Beachley, RN, MS, CEN<br />
MNA President<br />
According to recent research, medical errors kill<br />
more than 44,000 people in hospitals each year. Errors<br />
occur in every health care delivery setting and are not<br />
limited to hospitals. <strong>The</strong>re are more than 7,000 deaths<br />
from medication errors which occur in and out of health<br />
care facilities annually that exceeds the deaths from<br />
workplace injuries.<br />
<strong>The</strong> recently released policy paper by the Institute of<br />
Medicine (IOM), To Err is Human: Building a Safer<br />
Health System” has drawn the attention of Congress<br />
and the media to the seriousness of medical errors. <strong>The</strong><br />
debate surrounding this report with challenging arguments<br />
were reported in the Washington Post on July 5 th .<br />
This problem is not new or unknown to nurses or to risk<br />
managers and other health care managers. <strong>The</strong> investigations<br />
and corrective actions that have been taken to<br />
address the errors, mostly staff discipline, have not had<br />
much impact on reducing these errors. <strong>Nurse</strong>s are frequently<br />
caught up in the blame game.<br />
Dr. Lucien Leape in his lecture, “Stopping the Blame<br />
Game,” to the ANA 2000 Convention presented a different<br />
approach to preventing errors. Dr. Leape, from<br />
Harvard University, conducted some of the research and<br />
helped write the IOM report. He concluded from his<br />
research and investigations of medical errors that medical<br />
errors are <strong>com</strong>plex and not simply due an individual’s<br />
carelessness, in<strong>com</strong>petence, inattention, or lack of<br />
education but rather due to system failures. He presented<br />
a sound argument that health care professions, agencies,<br />
and facilities need to promote a blame-free environment<br />
in which practitioners feel free to report errors,<br />
including their own. In order to create such an environment,<br />
errors cannot be used in personal performance<br />
evaluations. Prevention of errors in health care is only<br />
possible if information about near misses and actual<br />
errors is willingly shared and analyzed and solutions are<br />
disseminated to prevent similar occurrences.<br />
According to Dr. Leape, all health care systems must<br />
adopt forcing functions that eliminate or significantly<br />
reduce the chance of error. Forcing functions were<br />
described as engineered safety mechanisms in the system<br />
that would prevent human error. For example,<br />
removing all IV potassium from unit supply and having<br />
Potassium mixed in IV solutions in the pharmacy would<br />
eliminate nurse medication errors that are caused from<br />
mistaken substitution of IV potassium for other drugs.<br />
He made a plea for giving up scared cows that take up<br />
time but are not effective in preventing errors such as<br />
double checking dosages, checking against<br />
MAR/orders, forbidding patients to manage their own<br />
medicines.<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s should seriously consider the recent research<br />
on medical errors and use a system performance<br />
improvement model rather than an individual performance<br />
improvement model to address errors in patient<br />
care. It is important to analyze errors for route cause<br />
and make appropriate changes in the system and not<br />
punish the individual. Discipline/punishment should<br />
be limited to impaired nurses and or behavior problems.<br />
This “new attitude” must begin in the workplace and<br />
extend to regulatory bodies and licensing boards. This<br />
change of approach in dealing with errors has broad<br />
reaching effects on how nursing care units are designed,<br />
procedures are written, roles are assigned and <strong>com</strong>petencies<br />
are assessed. <strong>The</strong> IOM report is a wake up call<br />
that our current methods of protecting patients from<br />
medical errors is not working, and seems to be out of<br />
control.
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 5 •<br />
One <strong>Nurse</strong>s Experience on an Educational and<br />
Professional Visit to Egypt<br />
by Marsha Zanger<br />
Marsha is the owner of a home infusion <strong>com</strong>pany in<br />
Cumberland, <strong>Maryland</strong>. She is a past president of MNA<br />
District 1 and currently is serving on the Convention<br />
Planning Committee for the 2000 MNA Convention.<br />
Marsha will be a speaker at this year’s convention on<br />
issues around workplace safety and needleless systems.<br />
Little did I know when I chose the nursing profession<br />
back in 1965, that I would have so many interesting opportunities<br />
<strong>com</strong>e my way. Nursing has changed dramatically<br />
since choosing this career so many years ago, but we<br />
won’t go there! However with some of the negative<br />
changes, there have also been some positive and interesting<br />
out<strong>com</strong>es as well. We now have opportunities for professional<br />
growth at our disposal that we never had before.<br />
I never dreamed that I would one day be a partner in a<br />
home infusion <strong>com</strong>pany, nor that I would be a member of<br />
a People to People delegation of intravenous nurses on a<br />
professional visit to Cairo and Luxor Egypt. Both have<br />
been rewarding experiences, however the latter was a<br />
dream <strong>com</strong>e true. I had always aspired to one-day see the<br />
Great Pyramids; little did I know I would see and experience<br />
this country in such a unique personal and professional<br />
way.<br />
During our stay in Cairo, we visited four hospitals:<br />
- <strong>The</strong> Dar al Fouad, affiliated with <strong>The</strong> Cleveland<br />
Clinic<br />
- Salem International<br />
- Kasr el Aini Teaching Hospital<br />
- <strong>The</strong> Cairo Fever Hospital, which cares for the HIV<br />
and TB patient population<br />
We were generally met with a little skepticism at first,<br />
but after brief dialogue with our fantastic delegation<br />
leader, Sharon Weinstein, the flood gates opened and our<br />
interchanges with them became animated and informative.<br />
Marsha enjoying her long awaited ride on a Ship of<br />
the Desert.<br />
After meeting with them and touring their facilities, they<br />
were so eager for more information that one Director of<br />
Nursing followed us to our bus wanting us to send a nurse<br />
back for a week of IV therapy training and another wanting<br />
us to <strong>com</strong>e back the following day to give a presentation to<br />
their staff. During our planned visit to the Higher Institute<br />
of Nursing, I gave a presentation to approximately 50 nursing<br />
students regarding safety IV catheters, needleless<br />
devices, and midline catheters. That was my introduction<br />
to lecturing via interpreter! Needless to say they were fascinated<br />
with all our needleless gizmos.<br />
In Luxor, we toured an orphanage run by a British<br />
woman named Pearl Smith, who while on a visit to Luxor<br />
learned of the plight of these children and returned to open<br />
the Sunshine International Project. We too could not get<br />
the faces of these precious children out of our minds. We<br />
could not help but admire the fortitude of this spirited little<br />
woman, doing God’s work in a very special way.<br />
Our final professional visit was to the Karnak Charity<br />
Hospital which was run by a most affable OB/GYN doctor,<br />
who in his very small facility consisting of a small operating<br />
room, exam room, two rooms for overnight stays and a small<br />
Marsha instructing Egyptian nursing students at<br />
the Higher Institute of Nursing<br />
pharmacy, he cares as best he can for the poor maternal population<br />
of Luxor. We all thought so highly of this man who<br />
enthusiastically showed us every inch of his facility; down to<br />
his small stock of IV antibiotics. As we sat having a Coca-<br />
Cola with him he shared his many needs with us; the most<br />
costly of which was an ultrasound. Sharon feverishly wrote<br />
down his list of needs to see what contributions of goods she<br />
might be able to find him. It was a humbling experience!<br />
In case you are thinking this sounds like all work<br />
and no play, I saved the best for last! I shall never forget the<br />
awesome feeling of standing at the foot of the great Cheops<br />
pyramid, the glittering wealth from Tut’s tomb, the mystery<br />
of the Sphinx, lunch on a Felucca sailboat as we sailed lazily<br />
down the Nile, the wonder of the Valley of the Kings, dinner<br />
in the home of a most hospitable Egyptian family, and of<br />
course my long anticipated ride on a Ship of the Desert - yes<br />
a camel ride! I returned home with a much greater appreciation<br />
for the things we take so much for granted, as well as,<br />
a heightened understanding of their culture than I ever could<br />
have gained as a mere tourist. I encourage all nurses to Seize<br />
<strong>The</strong> Day – Carpei Deum – there are so many opportunities<br />
out there.
• PAGE P GE 6 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
“I may not remember what happened, but I<br />
know when It happened….<br />
by Sharon Culliane<br />
Sharon Cullinane is the Project Director for the <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
Traumatic Brain Injury Demonstration Project. She holds<br />
a BSN from Kutztown University,<br />
PA and a MHS in health education/<strong>com</strong>munications<br />
from the<br />
Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene<br />
and Public Health. Along with a<br />
background in critical care and<br />
<strong>com</strong>munity health nursing, she<br />
has been a free-lance health<br />
writer for many years. She is a<br />
member of Sigma <strong>The</strong>ta Tau<br />
Nursing Honor Society and the<br />
American Public Health Cullinane<br />
Association.<br />
A survivor of Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) may not<br />
recall the events surrounding their injury—the seconds it<br />
took to flip their car, to fall off their roof, or to have a bullet<br />
pierce their skull—but they will always be able to tell<br />
you the month, day, year and hour of their injury. How can<br />
they recall such specifics and have no memory of the<br />
event? <strong>The</strong>y learn that date and time because that is the<br />
moment that their lives are forever changed. In one blink<br />
of an eye they have entered a world that can only be truly<br />
understood by those who have experienced brain injury<br />
first hand—either as a survivor or as a survivor’s loved<br />
one. <strong>The</strong> aftermath of brain injury leave individuals and<br />
families with challenges for a lifetime.<br />
What is the scope of the problem?<br />
A little more than 2% of the U.S. population currently live<br />
with the sequelae of brain injury:<br />
• Every 15 seconds one person in the U.S. sustains a<br />
Traumatic Brain Injury<br />
• Each year in <strong>Maryland</strong>, more than 6,000 adults sustain<br />
brain injuries severe enough to be hospitalized.<br />
• Each year 373,000 Americans are hospitalized for a<br />
TBI. Of that number, 99,000 individuals sustain moder<br />
ate-to-severe brain injury that result in lifelong dis<br />
abling conditions.<br />
• An estimated 5.3 million Americans (more than 2% of<br />
the population) live with impairments and disabilities<br />
resulting from TBI.<br />
• One million people are seen, treated and released from<br />
hospital emergency departments after sustaining a brain<br />
injury.<br />
• 56,000 people die each year as a result of TBI (22% of<br />
those injured).<br />
Can we predict who will sustain a brain injury?<br />
Not <strong>com</strong>pletely, but research shows that there are individuals<br />
who are most at risk for a TBI:<br />
• Males, ages 15 -24 are at highest risk for TBI.<br />
• Brain injury is the leading cause of death and disability<br />
for Americans under the age of 45.<br />
• Children under 5 years of age, and the elderly over the<br />
age of 75, are also at higher risk.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> National Pediatric Trauma Registry reports more<br />
than 30,000 children sustain permanent disabilities as a<br />
result of a TBI<br />
• Males are twice as likely as females to sustain a brain<br />
injury.<br />
• Shaken baby syndrome and child abuse is a rising<br />
cause of brain injury in this nation.<br />
What are the costs of traumatic brain injury?<br />
Although there is no way to fully quantify the costs of<br />
brain injury, both financially and emotionally, the following<br />
are estimates of the monetary costs of TBI:<br />
• It is estimated that more than $48 billion dollars are<br />
spent related to TBI each year.<br />
• Hospital costs for TBI are $31.7 billion each year.<br />
• TBI fatalities in the US cost 16.6 billion each year.<br />
How do traumatic brain injuries occur?<br />
<strong>The</strong> leading cause of TBI is motor vehicle crashes.<br />
Note—many brain injury survivors refuse to call these<br />
“accidents” as they are often preventable events caused by<br />
drug or alcohol use or careless driving.<br />
Source:<br />
Brain Injury Association, Inc. (Spring 1999). <strong>The</strong> Costs<br />
and Causes of Traumatic Brain Injury.<br />
http://www.biausa.org/costsand.htm<br />
Brain Injury Association, Inc. (April 14, 1999). Special<br />
Report: CDC Report Shows Prevalence of Brain Injury.<br />
http://www.biausa.org/costsand.htm<br />
Sports/Rec<br />
Firearms<br />
Falls<br />
CAUSES OF TBI<br />
Other<br />
Vehicular Crashes<br />
Falls<br />
Firearms<br />
Sports/Recreation<br />
Other<br />
Vehicular<br />
Crashes<br />
50%<br />
21%<br />
12%<br />
10%<br />
7%<br />
MARYLAND TRAUMATIC BRAIN INJURY<br />
DEMONSTRATION PROJECT:<br />
Purpose and Objectives<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> Traumatic Brain Injury Demonstration<br />
Project was designed to address some of the needs of individuals<br />
with brain injuries identified during <strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
Traumatic Brain Injury Demonstration Project—a one-year<br />
needs and resource assessment (1998 – 1999). A <strong>com</strong>mon<br />
need expressed by survivors, families and providers was<br />
for training and education about brain injury on all levels—<br />
from the acute care setting, through rehab and into the<br />
<strong>com</strong>munity. Another <strong>com</strong>monly reported need was that of<br />
increased support and services for survivors of brain<br />
injuries and their families.<br />
<strong>The</strong> primary purpose of the current project is to improve<br />
the lives of survivors, their families and caregivers individuals<br />
living with brain injury and those of their families<br />
and caregivers through education, training, public awareness<br />
and outreach activities. In accordance with this mission,<br />
the following objectives were developed:<br />
To improve understanding throughout the State about<br />
brain injury, its effects prevention, and the needs of those<br />
affected by brain injury, by increasing outreach and informational<br />
services to people with brain injuries, their families<br />
and the general public.<br />
To improve linkages among State agencies that serve, or<br />
could serve, people with brain injuries and their families by<br />
providing statewide training and information exchange<br />
programs about TBI to state, regional and local level representatives<br />
of designated State agencies and private<br />
organizations.<br />
To empower people with brain injuries and their families<br />
to be better advocates for their needs by providing<br />
training regarding self-advocacy, State and private<br />
resources, new programs and legislation related to brain<br />
injury.<br />
To improve the State’s capacity to serve diverse and<br />
under-served populations of brain injury survivors and<br />
families, as identified by the needs and resource assessments,<br />
such as cultural and linguistic minorities; people<br />
with low literacy levels; young children and their families;<br />
the elderly; people living in rural areas; and those in the<br />
criminal justice system.<br />
<strong>The</strong> objectives listed above are both lofty and achievable.<br />
Lofty, because when ac<strong>com</strong>plished, they will elevate<br />
the state of brain injury services and supports to a new<br />
level in this State; achievable because individuals, organi-<br />
zations and <strong>com</strong>munities working together can make it<br />
happen.<br />
How can you, as a nurse, be<strong>com</strong>e involved?<br />
Participate on a Work Group: Be<strong>com</strong>e involved by<br />
joining one or more of the work groups listed below. Or<br />
participate on a more limited basis by volunteering for<br />
specific work group activities.<br />
• Work Group for Education, Training,<br />
Public Awareness and Outreach.<br />
• Work Group for Building Community<br />
Capacity and Accessing Services<br />
• Work Group for Sustainability and<br />
Funding of Brain Injury Programs<br />
• Work Group for Definition and Data<br />
Collection Needs<br />
Support the Brain Injury Outreach Council in your<br />
region: If you know survivors or family members that<br />
would like to be<strong>com</strong>e a part of a growing outreach effort,<br />
encourage them to join the Outreach Council in their area.<br />
Council members represent other survivors and family<br />
members through support and advocacy as well as <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
outreach.<br />
Assist the Brain Injury Association of <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
(BIAM) Regional Representatives in your region: Each<br />
BIAM Region has one or two representatives who function<br />
as an extension of the BIAM by promoting brain<br />
injury prevention, research, education and advocacy.<br />
Some regions need additional representatives to serve in<br />
this capacity.<br />
Serve as a volunteer for BIAM or <strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
TBI Demonstration Project: Assist with various activities<br />
in the <strong>com</strong>munity or provide administrative support in<br />
the Association and Project offices.<br />
Assist in promoting public awareness of brain<br />
injury: Volunteer to staff the new BIAM tabletop display<br />
at health fairs and conferences; help plan and promote<br />
BIAM events or write articles about brain injury for<br />
HeadStand (BIAM Newsletter) or other publications.<br />
Join or start a support group: Attend your local brain<br />
injury support group and be<strong>com</strong>e involved in supporting<br />
others living with brain injuries in your locality. If there is<br />
no support group near you, learn from BIAM how to begin<br />
a group.<br />
Be<strong>com</strong>e a brain injury educator: Support education<br />
and training activities in <strong>Maryland</strong> by speaking at workshops<br />
or seminars on brain injury topics. Join the list of<br />
“faculty” willing to share their education, experience and<br />
knowledge.<br />
For more information contact:<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> Traumatic Brain Injury Demonstration<br />
Project<br />
2200 Kernan Drive<br />
Baltimore, MD 21207<br />
Tel: (410) 448-3922 Fax: (410) 448-3850<br />
email: mdtbiproject@erols.<strong>com</strong>
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 9 •<br />
District 1 News<br />
District #1 of Allegany and Garrett counties recently<br />
named Nancy Adams as the recipient of the annual <strong>Nurse</strong><br />
Recognition Award. This award is awarded to a nurse<br />
who shows evidence of promoting high standards innursing<br />
by helping to define the role of nursing, introducing<br />
new nursing roles, promoting nursing in the <strong>com</strong>munity,<br />
demonstrating excellence in nursing practice, contribuing<br />
to nursing education, nursing research, and participating<br />
in other areas that are beneficial to nurses.<br />
Nancy’s current role is Vice President of Patient Care<br />
Services for the Western <strong>Maryland</strong> Health System. She is<br />
also currently serving as President of MONE, and is Vice<br />
Chair to the Statewide Commission on thecrisis of the<br />
nursing shortage in <strong>Maryland</strong>. Her service to her <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
includes work on the Allegany County task force for<br />
AIDs, <strong>The</strong> League of women voters, <strong>The</strong> Allegany County<br />
Substance Abuse task Force., and <strong>The</strong> Family Crisis<br />
Resource Center. Nancy is a Nursing Graduate of<br />
Allegany College. She received a BSPA in Health Care<br />
Administration from St.<br />
Joseph’s College, an MBA<br />
from Frostburg State<br />
University and a Fellowship at<br />
Northwestern University in<br />
Healthcare Management from<br />
the Kellogg Graduate School<br />
of Management.<br />
Nancy has made numerous<br />
other contributions to health<br />
care and has served in many<br />
capacities on a variety of<br />
issues.<br />
This award was given at<br />
District 1 annual dinner meeting<br />
in May.<br />
District 1 has also been busy<br />
planning the MNA 2000<br />
Convention scheduled to be<br />
held at Rocky Gap Conference<br />
Center, November 8-10, 2000,<br />
titled Healthy <strong>Nurse</strong>s 2000.<br />
Please <strong>com</strong>e to Western<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> and enjoy our hospitality.<br />
Calvert, Charles, and St. Mary’s County<br />
Commisioners presenting <strong>Nurse</strong> Week Proclamation.<br />
district 9 president, Anne Marie Barnett far right.<br />
District 9 News<br />
by Anne Marie Barnett, RNC<br />
District President<br />
This May, District 9 celebrated National <strong>Nurse</strong>s Week<br />
with our Annual Dinner and Program. Our guest speakers<br />
this year were Kay Bensing, RN, MA, MJ, writer<br />
for Advance for <strong>Nurse</strong>s magazine, who spoke on the<br />
topic “Antique Lace and a New Young Face”, addressing<br />
past and current challenges in nursing. Mr. Vincent<br />
DeMarco, Executive Director for <strong>Maryland</strong> Citizens’<br />
Health Initiative, also spoke about the <strong>Maryland</strong> Health<br />
Care Coalition that he represents. We were fortunate to<br />
have County Commissioners from the tri-county area to<br />
deliver a <strong>Nurse</strong>s Week Proclamations. A large focus of<br />
our annual dinner and program recognizes outstanding<br />
nursing practice in the tri-county area. This year’s<br />
awards went to the following nurses: Grace E. Brown,<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong> Educator Award to Mrs. Annette Ragland, RN,<br />
MS, Nursing Instructor at Charles County Community<br />
College; Joanne Zwick Bedside <strong>Nurse</strong> Award to<br />
Joanne Hoffmaster, RN and Gail Kessler, RN, who<br />
are both volunteers at Health Partners Clinic in Waldorf;<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong> of the Year Award to Sara Western, RN<br />
Snookie Davis, Karen Shaffer, Dr. Ruth Kerschner (dinner speaker), Nancy<br />
Adams (award recipient), Dora Long and Nancy Shircliff at District 1 Awards<br />
Banquet<br />
Attendees of District 9 Annual <strong>Nurse</strong>s Week dinner<br />
and program<br />
office nurse who works for Dr. Louis Kaufman.<br />
District 9 also awarded a $1,000.00 Scholarship to<br />
Ms. Peggy Bird who will be entering her second year of<br />
the RN Program at Charles County Community College.<br />
In addition to all of these awards, District 9 also recognizes<br />
an Outstanding Nursing Student from an area nursing<br />
program and this year’s recipient of this award was<br />
Ms.<strong>The</strong>resa DiZebba, from Charles County Community<br />
College. This award was presented at the annual Pinning<br />
Ceremony.<br />
This past year, the tri-county area lost a well respected<br />
nursing leader with the death of Mrs. Mona Lea<br />
Potter, RN, MS. Mr. Lawrence Potter and family attended<br />
our annual dinner and were presented with the<br />
Leadership Award in honor of Mrs. Potter’s contributions<br />
to nursing.<br />
With all of this fun, there was even more! We hosted<br />
a fund raising event to raise monies to help support<br />
Colleagues in Caring, enjoyed a not-so-silent, silent auction,<br />
and there were many door prizes for attendees.<br />
District 9 will also help to sponsor a representative,<br />
our Delegate, Cathy Vestraci, RNC to this years national<br />
convention in Indianapolis. We will take a break for<br />
the summer and then start off this fall with our planning<br />
meeting and quarterly Newsletter. If any of you live in<br />
Charles, Calvert, or St. Mary’s Counties and have not yet<br />
joined MNA, but are interested, don’t hesitate to call me<br />
in the evening at (301) 475-8456.<br />
District 4 News<br />
by Deborah Cox, President<br />
District 4 celebrated <strong>Nurse</strong>s Week in May with a<br />
dinner program held at Shore Health Systems<br />
Education Center in Easton. <strong>The</strong> program, “Pain<br />
Management,” was presented by Chris Mullikin, RN<br />
C, MHS, CPP, current manager of the Pain and<br />
Management Palliative Care Program for Shore Health<br />
Systems. Chris is a certified Pain Management<br />
Practitioner and her information was timely in view of<br />
JCAHOS focus on pain management. <strong>The</strong> District<br />
recognized Louise Cole, RN, BSN, a retired member.<br />
Not only is she coping with a chronic illness, but also<br />
she is also waiting for a donor for her kidney transplant.<br />
Louise has remained a dedicated District member<br />
for many years.<br />
<strong>The</strong> District was pleased to begin sales of their<br />
cookbook in May. Sandy Bryan, RN C, MS, spearheaded<br />
this project, <strong>com</strong>piling the numerous contributions<br />
from District members.<br />
Celebrating Earth Day, on April 22, 2000, several<br />
members showed up to clean up our stretch of adopted<br />
highway leading into Oxford. Fueled by donuts, gratis<br />
of the State Highway Administration, Jane and Steve<br />
Escher, Gayle Hughes, Kay Wendowski and Debbie<br />
and Doyle Cox donned orange vests and hats to support<br />
the <strong>Maryland</strong> Highway beautification program.<br />
<strong>The</strong> District is currently beginning to plan the 2001<br />
MNA Convention to be held in Ocean City. So mark<br />
your calendars for October-November, 2001.<br />
Finally, we are requesting volunteers to serve on our<br />
District Board or Convention Planning Committee.<br />
Anyone who is interested should contact Deborah<br />
Cox, President.<br />
KUDOS to District members Kathy Foster, RN,<br />
MS and Sandy Wieland, RN, MS for <strong>com</strong>pletion of<br />
the Psychiatric Clinical <strong>Nurse</strong> Specialist post-graduate<br />
program through the University of <strong>Maryland</strong> in<br />
Baltimore. Sandy Bryan deserves credit for <strong>com</strong>pleting<br />
a thesis and receiving a Masters in Health Services.<br />
Mary Emma Middleton, Vice President, District 9<br />
presenting the <strong>Nurse</strong> of the Year Award to Ms. Sara<br />
Western, RN
• PAGE P GE 10 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
Crisis in Nursing Summit cont. from pg. 1<br />
• Cost of education vs. salary offered and related<br />
responsibility<br />
• Nature of the work with shifts, weekends<br />
and holidays<br />
• Physical labor<br />
Retention<br />
• Absence of career advancement opportunities,<br />
salary and benefits<br />
• Stress and staff burnout related to mandatory shifts<br />
and overtime<br />
• Unrealistic workloads and expectation to keep doing<br />
more with less<br />
• Lack of recognition and respect<br />
• Increased demands of regulatory and legislative <strong>com</strong><br />
pliance that results in a paper chase<br />
Education<br />
• Cost of education is too high<br />
• Lack of availability of flexible programs<br />
• Lack of preparation at the high school level for the<br />
science based curriculum<br />
• Lack of any business education in curriculum<br />
• High attrition rates<br />
Other Issues<br />
• Reimbursement is dictating services, cost containment<br />
hits nursing budgets first<br />
• <strong>Nurse</strong>s are not good mentors and often be<strong>com</strong>e our<br />
Own worst enemy “eating our young”<br />
• Need to promote a different kind of collaboration<br />
• <strong>Nurse</strong>s have not had enough involvement in the<br />
political arena<br />
• Stress<br />
A sample of some of the identified solutions in each of<br />
the issue areas include the following:<br />
Recruitment<br />
• <strong>Nurse</strong>s need to educate lawmakers<br />
about what nurses<br />
actually do<br />
• <strong>Nurse</strong>s need to clean up<br />
their professional appearance,<br />
image<br />
• <strong>Nurse</strong>s need to be an<br />
ambassador for the profession<br />
• Duplicate paperwork needs<br />
to be eliminated so attention<br />
can be directed to patient<br />
care<br />
• A more <strong>com</strong>petitive salary<br />
and benefit structure needs<br />
to be developed<br />
Retention<br />
• Dollars need to be focused<br />
on retaining current, experienced<br />
staff<br />
Left to right: Delegate Addie Eckart, Sanator Paula<br />
Hollinger, Dean Barbara Heller, Delegate Shirley<br />
Nathan-Polliam, Secrtetary Georges Benjamin, Dr. Sue<br />
Donaldson is seated directly behind Dr. Benjamin.<br />
• Stronger mentoring programs need to be developed<br />
• <strong>Nurse</strong>s must be included in the decision making and<br />
budget decisions<br />
• More autonomy<br />
• Re-evaluation of benefits<br />
Education<br />
• Better funding should be made available<br />
• Curriculum should focus on increasing critical<br />
thinking skills<br />
• Salaries should reflect educational level/experience<br />
• Educators need to be more up to date with practice<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> Board of Nursing has a <strong>com</strong>prehensive<br />
summary of the proceeding of the nursing summit. <strong>The</strong>y<br />
have also coordinated the gathering of names of persons<br />
who meet the criteria for appointment to the Commission.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Commission is charged with making a report to the<br />
Governor by the end of this year. Updates may be found<br />
on the Board of Nursing Web Site: www.mbon.org<br />
Auditorium view of participants during keynote address.<br />
A <strong>Nurse</strong>s View on<br />
the Summit on the<br />
Crisis in Nursing<br />
by Mary Zohlen, MSN, RN<br />
Long Term Care (LTC) is dealing with challenges,<br />
which are very different from those in Acute Care.<br />
<strong>The</strong>refore, the Commission should appoint a special <strong>com</strong>mittee<br />
to study the specific effects of the nursing shortage<br />
on the Long Term Care Industry. If the problem is to be<br />
permanently solved in LTC, this special <strong>com</strong>mittee will<br />
need to make re<strong>com</strong>mendations for Health Care reform to<br />
address issues unique to Nursing Homes.<br />
Nursing Homes are evolving into something very different<br />
from what they were a few years ago. Gone are the<br />
days of “warehouse” care for the end of life. Gone are the<br />
posey vests, foley catheters, and syringe feeding as the<br />
treatment of choice for confused and incontinent elderly<br />
people. Physical and chemical restraints have disappeared;<br />
replaced with innovative programs, which focus on whatever<br />
ability to function and enjoy life, the individual<br />
retains. <strong>The</strong> emphasis is on maintaining quality in the life<br />
still left to live.<br />
Today, almost half of the people admitted to LTC stay a<br />
short time and are discharged to a lesser level of care; to<br />
home or Assisted Living. Individuals (not necessarily elderly)<br />
are admitted to Nursing Homes for a variety of reasons.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y <strong>com</strong>e for rehabilitation therapy following a<br />
stroke, or a fractured hip, or a car accident. <strong>The</strong>y <strong>com</strong>e for<br />
IV antibiotic therapy, for TPN, for pain management, or for<br />
wound care. If they are unable to be cared for at home after<br />
hospitalization for any acute episode, they <strong>com</strong>e for follow-up<br />
care. Blood transfusions, chemotherapy, and renal<br />
dialysis are being administered in some Centers in<br />
response to the increased acuity. Nursing Homes have<br />
begun to meet the need for an institution other than a hospital<br />
to treat people with Cancer, AIDS, Sickle Cell, medical<br />
<strong>com</strong>plications of drug and alcohol abuse, and other<br />
“young people” diseases.<br />
LTC nurses are constantly striving to enhance the quality<br />
of life for the long-term residents. <strong>The</strong>y are likewise<br />
striving to meet the needs of the short stay persons with<br />
subacute medical conditions. <strong>Nurse</strong>s are doing this as they<br />
struggle with multiple health care industry challenges. <strong>The</strong><br />
requirement to <strong>com</strong>plete and electronically transmit MDS<br />
data at frequent intervals for all residents is time consuming.<br />
Managed Care has introduced younger, sicker residents.<br />
Increased technical skills, greater documentation<br />
requirements, and other “paperwork” and logistical <strong>com</strong>ponents<br />
have been added to the nurse’s shift by both<br />
Medicare and Managed Care.<br />
Enhanced regulatory requirements have created an<br />
adversarial <strong>com</strong>ponent to both the annual and <strong>com</strong>plaint<br />
survey process. It is true that some Nursing Homes give<br />
poor care, but most give very good care. <strong>The</strong> current<br />
process does not differentiate between the two. <strong>The</strong> nurse<br />
must add this additional stress to her already difficult job.<br />
It is my opinion that increasing the State survey to a twice<br />
a year event will not enhance the quality of care, and more<br />
frequent survey’s most certainly will not encourage nurses<br />
to stay in LTC. Negative press coverage with the resultant<br />
negative image issues discourage nurses from staying in,<br />
and from entering, the Nursing Home job market. This is<br />
a disservice to the many wonderful, capable nurses who<br />
give excellent care day after day in a very challenging<br />
environment.<br />
Serious financial issues are impacting the industry. Five<br />
of the seven largest Nursing Home chains are in bankruptcy.<br />
What are the financial implication on care delivery<br />
issues and staffing levels? Are the politicians aware of the<br />
implication of this crisis?
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 11 •<br />
Workplace Violence: Part IV<br />
Employer Responsibilities<br />
by Carol A. Distasio, RN, MSN,<br />
MPH, C, CS-P, CS-HH<br />
<strong>The</strong> statistics on workplace violence in general are<br />
grim: 10-15% of violence in the United States occurs in<br />
the workplace (1). Despite the fact<br />
that workplace violence is underreported,<br />
the data indicate that :<br />
• 25 million human beings/<br />
year are victimized by fear<br />
and violence in the workplace<br />
• Violence costs an estimated<br />
$4.3 billion annually<br />
• Homicide is the second leading<br />
cause of death in the<br />
workplace<br />
• Homicide is the leading<br />
cause of death in the workplace<br />
for women<br />
Distasio<br />
• Assaults and threats of violence number 2 million/year<br />
• <strong>The</strong>re are 1.5 million simple assaults/year<br />
• <strong>The</strong>re are nearly 400,000 aggravated assaults/year.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Occupational Safety and Health Administration<br />
(OSHA) has identified health care settings at workplaces<br />
at increased risk for violence (2). Between 1980-1990,<br />
106 workplace homicides occurred among pharmacists;<br />
physicians; registered nurses; nurses’ aides; and health<br />
care workers in other occupational classifications (2).<br />
Between 1983 and 1989, 69 registered nurses were<br />
killed at work, and homicide was the leading cause of<br />
traumatic occupational death among employees in<br />
nursing homes and personal care facilities (2).<br />
Healthcare providers, especially those who provide<br />
hands-on clinical services, are at higher risk for nonfatal<br />
assaults in the healthcare workplace across care settings<br />
(2). More assaults occur in the health care and<br />
social service industries than any other industry.<br />
Healthcare providers are at 16 times greater risk for violence<br />
than other workers (2), and nursing staff in all<br />
healthcare settings, particularly those in psychiatric settings,<br />
sustain the highest rates of nonfatal assaults per<br />
employee/year than all other health care provider categories<br />
(2). Healthcare providers in nursing & personal<br />
care facilities sustain nonfatal assaults at the rate of<br />
38 cases/10,000 workers and those in residential care<br />
facilities at the rate of 47 cases/10,000 workers, <strong>com</strong>pared<br />
to workers in private industry, who sustain only 3<br />
cases/10,000 workers. Clearly, the risks of workplace<br />
violence, which pose a serious threat to all healthcare<br />
providers, continue to increase in frequency and severity.<br />
What Are <strong>The</strong> Employer’s Responsibilities In<br />
Workplace Violence Prevention?<br />
OSHA’s General Duty Clause Section 5(a)(1) states<br />
that each employer shall furnish to each of his employees<br />
employment and a place of employment which are free<br />
from recognized hazards that are causing or likely to<br />
cause death or serious physical harm. This includes the<br />
prevention and control of the hazard of workplace violence.<br />
Enlightened healthcare employers recognize the<br />
need to initiate violence prevention programs that<br />
reduce violence, severity of employee injuries, and organizational<br />
risks. Employers who believe that assaults are<br />
“part of the job” expose their organizations to legal risks,<br />
e.g. tort actions, that may arise when staff are injured or<br />
killed at work in situations where the employer failed to<br />
<strong>com</strong>ply with OSHA’s General Duty Clause. Stated directly:<br />
employers who know, or who should have known, of<br />
risks of workplace violence owe a duty to protect against<br />
that risk (3).<br />
What Are <strong>The</strong> Components Of An Effective<br />
Violence Prevention Program?<br />
An effective violence prevention program is multidimensional,<br />
purposeful, evaluated, maintained by the<br />
employer with employee involvement, and contains the<br />
following five essential <strong>com</strong>ponents:<br />
• Management Commitment and Employee<br />
Involvement<br />
• Worksite Analysis<br />
• Hazard Prevention and Control<br />
• Training and Education<br />
• Recordkeeping and Evaluation of Program.<br />
Management Commitment and Employee<br />
Involvement<br />
<strong>The</strong> employer must make a <strong>com</strong>mitment to prevention<br />
of workplace violence that includes both management and<br />
employee involvement; visible involvement of top management;<br />
clear, announced, published policy statements<br />
of zero tolerance for violence in the workplace; a policy<br />
of no reprisals against employees who report violence or<br />
threats; and encouragement of employees to report all<br />
incidents and to suggest ways to reduce risks. Employees<br />
must be<strong>com</strong>e actively involved in violence prevention,<br />
e.g. promptly reporting all incidents and risks; participating<br />
in <strong>com</strong>plaint procedures about safety issues; <strong>com</strong>plying<br />
with the employer’s workplace violence prevention program,<br />
safety and security measures, etc.<br />
Management must develop and put in place a <strong>com</strong>prehensive<br />
program of medical and psychological counseling<br />
and debriefing for employees who have experienced<br />
and/or witnessed assaults or other violent incidents at<br />
work, so that recovery can be facilitated.<br />
Worksite Analysis<br />
Worksite analysis is a step-by-step evaluation of the<br />
workplace by a management-employee team (i.e. a threat<br />
assessment team) to identify potential risks of workplace<br />
violence and determine appropriate preventive interventions<br />
and actions to reduce workplace violence. <strong>The</strong> threat<br />
assessment team reviews all data pertaining to violent<br />
incidents to —<br />
• Identify assault patterns (e.g. units, shifts, day of the<br />
week, etc.<br />
• Identify victim characteristics (e.g. gender, age, clas<br />
sification, tenure, etc.)<br />
• Identify assailant characteristics (e.g. gender, age,<br />
alcohol/drug user, diagnosis, etc.)<br />
• Determine events that preceded the violence (e.g.<br />
escalation behaviors, warning cues, etc.)<br />
• Identify jobs with the greatest risk of violence (e.g.<br />
psychiatric units, emergency rooms)<br />
• Determine the out<strong>com</strong>es of each violent event (e.g.<br />
lost time, hospitalization, death, etc.).<br />
<strong>The</strong> threat assessment team also evaluates the effectiveness<br />
of existing security measures, including engineering<br />
control measures to determine if risk factors have<br />
been reduced or eliminated.<br />
Hazard Prevention and Control<br />
Engineering controls remove hazards from the workplace<br />
or create barriers between employees and hazards.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re are many types of engineering controls that employers<br />
may utilize, for example:<br />
• Metal and motion detectors<br />
• Alarm systems, panic buttons, cellular phones, handheld<br />
alarms, etc.<br />
• Closed-circuit video for high risk areas<br />
• Enclosed nurses’ stations<br />
• Safe rooms for employees during emergencies<br />
• Establishment of separate rooms for courtreferred/criminal<br />
patients<br />
• Locked access doors after visiting hours, consistent<br />
with applicable fire and safety codes<br />
• Rooms designed to facilitate hasty staff exits<br />
• Bright, effective lighting of indoor/outdoor areas, and<br />
so forth.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se and other types of environmental controls promote<br />
safety and security for all concerned — staff,<br />
patients, visitors.<br />
Administrative and Work Practice Controls<br />
Administrative and work practice controls are systems<br />
to minimize workplace violence and to respond effectively<br />
when incidents do occur. In addition to a well-publi-<br />
cized zero tolerance policy, these systems require all<br />
employees to report all incidents of workplace assaults or<br />
threats; establish liaisons with local law enforcement<br />
authorities in advance of any violent incident(s); and<br />
establish trained response teams to respond to emergencies.<br />
Post-Incident Response<br />
An effective violence prevention program includes a<br />
<strong>com</strong>prehensive post-incident response and evaluation<br />
for all staff who are direct victims of violence, and for<br />
indirect victims, i.e. staff who witnessed or who have been<br />
otherwise psychologically traumatized by the event.<br />
Serious incidents of violence cause shock waves throughout<br />
a healthcare organization, in the victim’s family and<br />
other relationships, among coworkers, among survivors,<br />
and in the larger <strong>com</strong>munity. Critical incident stress<br />
debriefing and post incident counseling can help the victims<br />
of serious workplace violence to recover emotional<br />
equilibrium and return to work more expeditiously.<br />
Training and Education<br />
All employees, both management and staff, should<br />
receive education and training in violence prevention;<br />
recognition of escalating situations; the concept of<br />
“Universal Precautions for Violence” (violence should be<br />
expected but can be avoided or mitigated through preparation);<br />
recognition of potential security hazards and ways<br />
to protect themselves; location and use of safety devices;<br />
the organization’s response plan for volatile or potentially<br />
violent situations, and so forth.<br />
Records of all workplace violence events should be<br />
maintained and analyzed for the purpose of ongoing monitoring,<br />
identification and elimination/reduction of workplace<br />
safety hazards and risks. Meeting minutes, incident<br />
records, OSHA’s Log of Injury and Illness (OSHA 200),<br />
medical reports, out<strong>com</strong>es, etc. should all be maintained,<br />
regularly evaluated, and revisions to the healthcare organization’s<br />
overall violence prevention plan made based on<br />
the data.<br />
Summary<br />
This article presented a summarized overview of the<br />
employer’s responsibility for violence prevention in the<br />
healthcare workplace. For a detailed discussion of OSHA’s<br />
violence prevention re<strong>com</strong>mendations, see OSHA’s<br />
Guidelines for Preventing Workplace Violence for Health<br />
Care and Social Service Workers (2). In the final analysis,<br />
workplace safety is everyone’s responsibility.<br />
If you experience violence and/or threats from anyone<br />
in the healthcare workplace, including patients, visitors,<br />
family members, significant others, coworkers, supervisors,<br />
or others, report all such events promptly, both verbally<br />
and in writing; and seek and expect assistance and<br />
support from your employer. No healthcare provider has<br />
to, or should, work for employers whose neglect of safety<br />
and security in the workplace places healthcare providers at<br />
risk of physical assaults, verbal abuse, threats and intimidation,<br />
emotional trauma, temporary/permanent disability,<br />
or any of the other myriad effects of workplace violence,<br />
including loss of life.<br />
References<br />
(1) Elliott, P. Violence in Health Care: What <strong>Nurse</strong><br />
Managers Need to Know. Retrieved March 26, 2000, from<br />
the World Wide Web<br />
http://www.springnet.<strong>com</strong>/ce/m712a.htm<br />
(2) Guidelines for Preventing Workplace Violence for<br />
Health Care and Social Service Workers. Washington,<br />
D.C: U.S. Department of Labor, Occupational Safety and<br />
Health Administration (1998).<br />
(3) Sheppard, Linda J. (1998). Workplace Violence:<br />
Employers’ Duties and Preventive Measures. Retrieved<br />
March 26, 2000, from the World Wide Web<br />
http://www.rbma.org/index.tat?_pi=2AD<br />
69223E24723CBBA89DA91
• PAGE P GE 12 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
A Mystery Solved<br />
(or who are those <strong>Nurse</strong>s in Annapolis)<br />
by Peggy Soderstrom<br />
and Rosemary Mortimer<br />
Two major factors affect the Registered <strong>Nurse</strong>. <strong>The</strong><br />
first is the dollar-driven Health care marketplace – the<br />
business of health care. <strong>The</strong> second<br />
is the laws and regulations<br />
defining Registered Nursing and<br />
determining what Registered<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s can and can’t do, their<br />
responsibilities and how they are<br />
required to go about their practices,<br />
whatever their workplace,<br />
the degrees and certifications they<br />
may have earned.<br />
Truly affecting the business of<br />
health care is, sadly, pretty much<br />
beyond the reach of nursing alone.<br />
However, joining with other other<br />
Mortimer<br />
Soderstrom<br />
care practitioner groups the<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association<br />
(MNA) has had some minimal<br />
impact. <strong>The</strong> reality is that most of<br />
these shots are called by big business<br />
interests and government<br />
bureaucrats, focused only on bottom<br />
lines, with unlimited financial<br />
and personnel resources available<br />
to protect and further their perceived<br />
best interests.<br />
On the other hand affecting<br />
State laws and regulations is the<br />
one area where MNA is a player. While federal programs<br />
are largely formulated in Washington and are dealt with<br />
the American <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association (ANA), <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
Legislative and government actions directly impact RN’s<br />
practicing here. Each <strong>Maryland</strong> RN’s practice is governed<br />
by our Legislature-enacted <strong>Nurse</strong> Practice Act and largely<br />
by regulations adopted by the <strong>Maryland</strong> Board of Nursing<br />
based on it. No <strong>Nurse</strong> draws a breath or takes a step not<br />
regulated by these primary sources. Any <strong>Nurse</strong> who is not<br />
intimately and currently familiar with what these sources<br />
require of her or him is risking a hand-earned professional<br />
career. Copies of the <strong>Nurse</strong> Practice Act and<br />
Regulations may be obtained from the Board of Nursing.<br />
MNA is the spokesman for <strong>Maryland</strong> RN’s before the<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Legislature which meets each year in Annapolis<br />
for 90 days beginning in early January to consider bills<br />
that impact <strong>Nurse</strong>s and our patients. <strong>The</strong> positions we<br />
take on bills (last year 126 out of almost 2400 bills<br />
reviewed) are determined by the MNA Legislative<br />
Committee.<br />
What is the MNA Legislative Committee?<br />
Created by By-Law, the Legislative Committee is<br />
charged with formulating positions on bills and assisting<br />
our Annapolis lobbyist (yes, we have a lobbyist) in making<br />
our case to Legislators.<br />
Who’s does the MNA Legislative Committee do?<br />
At present, 25 RN’s volunteer their time to meet twice a<br />
month in Annapolis while the Legislature is in session to<br />
review and take positions on bills as they are introduced.<br />
Off-season we meet monthly at MNA headquarters to<br />
review and provide directions to our lobbyist on issues<br />
important to RN’s. MNA publishes the “Legislative<br />
Update” (each <strong>Nurse</strong>s should subscribe) outlining MNA<br />
positions on bills. Committee members also contact<br />
Legislators in their voting districts in support of our lobbyist<br />
and MNA positions. <strong>The</strong> Legislative Committee also<br />
coordinates <strong>Nurse</strong>’s annual reception for Legislators in<br />
Annapolis.<br />
Who’s on the MNA Legislative Committee?<br />
Membership consists of members of MNA who represent<br />
various geographical and practice areas. Its meetings<br />
are open to all and the views of members and non-members<br />
alike are always wel<strong>com</strong>e. (Unfortunately, as with the<br />
general RN population, the Committee is aging-out and<br />
many long-time, experienced hands will be lost to<br />
retirement). While it takes time and effort to understand<br />
the issues presented by bills reviewed, members who stick<br />
with it have found their participation rewarding in their<br />
jobs, the friends they make and the knowledge of the law<br />
they absorb. <strong>The</strong> Committee fosters development of <strong>Nurse</strong><br />
leaders and members have gone on to run for and be elected<br />
to public office. We wel<strong>com</strong>e new blood and new perspectives.<br />
How can you help?<br />
Contact the MNA office and get the schedule of<br />
Legislative Committee Meetings. Come and JOIN US.<br />
No one has ever been turned-away. Whatever your viewpoint<br />
and concerns the Committee wel<strong>com</strong>es your input<br />
and assistance. Non-MNA members are also wel<strong>com</strong>e<br />
since once you see what the MNA Committee does, we are<br />
confident that you’ll join MNA.<br />
It is a mystery to some why this small group, year<br />
after year, works so hard to advance and protect the interests<br />
of the colleagues. We are all busy people. All have important<br />
pressing claims on their time and energies. Members of<br />
the Legislative <strong>com</strong>mittee are busier than most. Why do<br />
they devote the time and effort to Nursing Legislation? Each<br />
has his or her own answer to this. But aside from the knowledge,<br />
experience and friendship they develop, the most<br />
important is the satisfaction that for once RN’s played a crucial<br />
part in determining their practice futures as <strong>Nurse</strong>s - not<br />
simply having allowed others to do so.<br />
Rosemary Mortimer and Peggy Soderstrom are the<br />
outgoing Co-Chairs of the MNA Legislative Committee<br />
Annapolis 2000:<br />
Nursing Disaster<br />
Nursing had a devastating year in Annapolis this<br />
past session,<br />
• FAILED: Psychiatric Advanced Practice<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s still can’t prescribe medications<br />
when physician service is not available.<br />
• FAILED: <strong>Nurse</strong> Practitioners still will not be<br />
designated as primary care providers and<br />
received reimbursement through HMO’s.<br />
• FAILED: Control over nurse-patient ratios in<br />
nursing homes is still not established.<br />
• FAILED: <strong>Nurse</strong> in every school to maintain<br />
student well being and promote healthy<br />
behaviors.<br />
AND THE LIST GOES ON!<br />
Don’t let history repeat itself! Support the MNA-PAC<br />
so that we can support those legislators who will be a<br />
strong voice in Annapolis for YOU as a professional<br />
nurse.<br />
Mail Contributions to: MNA-PAC<br />
849 International Drive<br />
Suite 255<br />
Linthicum, MD 21090
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 13 •<br />
A Wellness<br />
Partnership<br />
by Larry J. Appel, BS, EMT-B<br />
I am your patient. I <strong>com</strong>e to you not by choice, but<br />
by unexpected circumstances effecting my health and<br />
well being.<br />
I am your patient. I seek rest and solitude while in<br />
your care so that my body and spirit may heal.<br />
I am your patient. Although I may not <strong>com</strong>prehend<br />
all of the medical knowledge you have been taught, I<br />
ask for your guidance, understanding and patience<br />
while I absorb the newness of my environment and all<br />
of the medical test and procedures that have been<br />
thrust upon me.<br />
I am your patient. Although you have many others<br />
like me to attend to, don’t forget I may be scared and<br />
feel alone in my New World. A simple, “hello, my<br />
name is… how are you feeling, can I get you anything<br />
to make you feel more <strong>com</strong>fortable?” would be nice.<br />
I am your patient. I understand you are human too<br />
with personal obligations and life’s little annoyances.<br />
When your personal problems are reflected in your<br />
tone of voice or body language, I also experience your<br />
troubles.<br />
I am your patient. I may not be able to <strong>com</strong>municate<br />
with you directly and my body may need cleansing,<br />
but remember, I still have my dignity.<br />
I am your patient. I am not an account number. I am<br />
a flesh and blood human being with feelings the same<br />
as you. I am not interference during your day or an<br />
intrusion into your break. I am the reason you are<br />
here.<br />
* * * *<br />
I am your caregiver. I am here to provide a healing<br />
and <strong>com</strong>passionate environment to you while you are<br />
in my care.<br />
I am your caregiver. I am here to support your physical<br />
and emotional needs and to respond to you if you<br />
are in distress.<br />
I am your caregiver. I understand that you are not<br />
here by choice and that you have a life outside this<br />
institution just as I. Keeping this in mind, I will be<br />
responsive and sensitive to the requests of your family<br />
and friends who <strong>com</strong>e to visit you.<br />
I am your caregiver. I subscribe to the standards of<br />
Service Excellence: Safety, Courtesy, Environment<br />
and Efficiency.<br />
I am your caregiver. Together, our goal will be to<br />
return you to a life of <strong>com</strong>fort and well being.<br />
I am _________________________R.N., L.P.N.,<br />
C.N.A., M.D., EMT, Technician, Manager<br />
A Wellness Partnership is reprinted with the permission<br />
of ADVANCE for <strong>Nurse</strong>s, Baltimore/Washington<br />
DC Metro Area<br />
Professionalism - How Do<br />
You Measure Up?<br />
by Barbara Kemerer,<br />
RN, MSN, MBA<br />
Assistant Professor of Nursing<br />
Faculty Advisor for the RN to BSN<br />
Program<br />
Shepherd College<br />
Shepherdstown, WV<br />
MNA Treasurer for District 8<br />
Take a look around you. Just<br />
Kemerer<br />
about now the nursing graduates of<br />
the new millennium are settling in<br />
the workplace and are taking and passing state boards.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se graduates don’t look any different than nursing graduates<br />
did five, ten, even twenty years ago. But let me<br />
assure you, they are very different than we were.<br />
Today’s graduates are energetic and enthusiastic, organized,<br />
armed with up to date information, open-minded,<br />
flexible, critical thinkers who aren’t afraid to take risks.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y are prepared to work in hospitals, nursing homes,<br />
home health, and any <strong>com</strong>munity setting you can imagine.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y are culturally aware, strong patient advocates, <strong>com</strong>mitted<br />
to life-long learning and give service in their <strong>com</strong>munities.<br />
In this era of nursing shortage they are the future<br />
of nursing, and it’s up to us to foster their growth, encourage<br />
and support them, and share with them our <strong>com</strong>mitment<br />
to the profession of nursing.<br />
So whether you graduated last year or thirty years ago,<br />
take a moment to reflect on your activities and ac<strong>com</strong>plishments<br />
and see how well you meet the characteristics of a<br />
“professional nurse”. Miller, Abbot, and Bell (1993) have<br />
identified several behaviors that nurses must attain in order<br />
to be considered professional.<br />
HIGHER EDUCATION - Are you a diploma or AD<br />
graduate? Consider going back to school part-time. <strong>The</strong>re<br />
are many programs locally, regionally, and nationally that<br />
are flexible and designed for the working RN. Maybe distance<br />
learning through the Internet would be a good choice<br />
for you. Some programs can be <strong>com</strong>pleted faster than others,<br />
but that doesn’t necessarily make them better, so shop<br />
around. Compare the total costs for the program not just<br />
cost per credit. Ask to talk to some graduates of the program<br />
so you can get the “real scoop”.<br />
AUTONOMY - Nunnery (1997) believes autonomy<br />
involves critical thinking, <strong>com</strong>munication, collaboration,<br />
and leadership. <strong>Nurse</strong>s have lots of autonomy. If you don’t<br />
agree with that, consider taking a course on power. Nursing<br />
autonomy is granted by the state board of nursing through<br />
its nurse practice act. If you don’t have a current copy, call<br />
for one. Nursing students learn about power in their leadership<br />
courses. Knowledge gives you power. Don’t be afraid<br />
to share your knowledge with others. Be proactive and<br />
seek out ways to broaden your power base and influence<br />
those around you. Use your power to effect positive<br />
change.<br />
CODE of ETHICS - <strong>The</strong> ANA Code for <strong>Nurse</strong>s (1985)<br />
guides us in our practice and we are required to adhere to<br />
its guidelines. Do you own a copy of it? Can you recite<br />
any of the criteria? <strong>The</strong>re are 11 standards and these should<br />
be reviewed periodically. <strong>The</strong> Code for <strong>Nurse</strong>s can be<br />
ordered from the ANA website www.nursingworld.org.<br />
CONTINUING EDUCATION/COMPETENCY - Have<br />
you taken time lately to identify your learning needs?<br />
Don’t wait for your employer to sign you up for a class.<br />
Assess where you are in your life-long learning. You<br />
might want to consider certification in a specialty or take<br />
that college <strong>com</strong>puter class you’ve been looking at.<br />
Increasing your knowledge is a must for ensuring <strong>com</strong>petency<br />
and can also be acquired through journal reading or<br />
surfing the net using one of the health search engines such<br />
as achoo.<strong>com</strong> or healthatoz.<strong>com</strong>.<br />
COMMUNICATION/PUBLICATION - One of the<br />
standards of the Code for <strong>Nurse</strong>s is that we must participate<br />
in activities that contribute to the ongoing development<br />
of the profession’s body of knowledge. Have you<br />
written any articles lately? You don’t have to publish your<br />
dissertation to contribute. Consider writing for <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>, or one of the local journals or newsletters.<br />
Consider joining a chat room (on the Internet) for<br />
nurses in your specialty area or one you’re interested in.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Nursing Spectrum has weekly chat rooms @ nursingspectrum.<strong>com</strong>.<br />
PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS - It’s not enough<br />
to pay your dues and belong to a professional organization.<br />
It’s a beginning, but make a <strong>com</strong>mitment to be<strong>com</strong>e actively<br />
involved. <strong>The</strong> American <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association is a great<br />
place to start. Not only do they represent nursing in the<br />
political arena, they are the front runners for many projects<br />
that shed a positive light on nursing to the general public.<br />
You can get actively involved at your district and state<br />
level where networking is both fun and rewarding.<br />
COMMUNITY SERVICE - <strong>Nurse</strong>s have always given<br />
to their <strong>com</strong>munities. When I’m introduced at parties my<br />
friends very proudly announce, “she’s a nurse”. Have you<br />
volunteered lately? Consider helping out with the scouts,<br />
4H, your church, or the local homeless shelter or food<br />
bank. Take time to promote nursing as a career choice in<br />
your local high schools. If you have the time and interest,<br />
organizations are always looking for members of the <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
to sit on their boards, or help with fundraising or<br />
program planning.<br />
RESEARCH INVOLVEMENT - Have you read any<br />
research-based studies recently? Your clinical practice<br />
may be outdated. Share what you find with your colleagues.<br />
Get involved in your institution’s quality<br />
improvement program, conduct a survey or study to look at<br />
patient out<strong>com</strong>es, or offer to collect data for a study in<br />
progress. You might start with something as simple as a<br />
client satisfaction survey.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re you have it, eight simple criteria for our<br />
profession that can be met in a variety of ways, all of which<br />
are challenging and exciting. <strong>The</strong> new nursing graduates<br />
of 2000 are ready for these challenges. <strong>The</strong>y will be looking<br />
to the rest of us for guidance and encouragement. How<br />
will you measure up?<br />
REFERENCES<br />
American <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association. (1985). Code for nurses<br />
with interpretive statements.<br />
(Publication No. G-56). Kansas City, MO: Author.<br />
Miller, B. K., Adams, D., Beck, L., (1993). A behavioral<br />
inventory for professionalism in nursing. Journal of<br />
Professional Nursing, 9, 290-295.<br />
Nunnery, R. K. (1997). Advancing your career:<br />
Concepts of professional nursing.<br />
Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Company.
• PAGE P GE 14 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
RSV: Not Just A Pediatric Problem<br />
by Carol J. Gallo, RN, MS<br />
Carol J. Gallo, RN, MS holds a part-time faculty position<br />
at Towson University Department of Nursing. In addition,<br />
she also works per diem on the pediatric floor at<br />
Franklin Square Hospital Center. Since 1979 Ms. Gallo<br />
has worked in several areas of pediatrics including PICU,<br />
NICU, and acute care, in addition to teaching in both the<br />
classroom and clinical. She is a member of Sigma <strong>The</strong>ta<br />
Tau and serves as Treasurer of the Iota Epsilon chapter.<br />
What is RSV?<br />
Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) is generally<br />
thought of as a respiratory virus of children; however,<br />
adults can be affected and pass the virus onto susceptible<br />
infants and children. In this article, the clinical course,<br />
treatment, transmission, and prevention of RSV among<br />
children is emphasized, but the nursing implications for<br />
adult practice will be discussed.<br />
RSV is a major cause of bronchiolitis and pneumonia<br />
in infants under one of year age and a leading cause of<br />
lower respiratory infection in young children. However,<br />
most children and adults infected with RSV have only<br />
upper respiratory tract involvement. Adults and older<br />
children who be<strong>com</strong>e infected with RSV usually have<br />
symptoms similar to having a mild to moderate cold.<br />
Younger children (preschool age) with RSV may exhibit<br />
what appears to be a mild to severe cold.<br />
Children between the ages of six weeks and two years<br />
old are most susceptible to RSV. Infants less than six<br />
weeks old seem to have protection from RSV due to<br />
active maternal antibodies. <strong>The</strong>re tends to be a strong<br />
correlation between age and the severity of symptoms.<br />
<strong>The</strong> younger the child the more severe the disease tends<br />
to be and mortality is highest between two to six months<br />
old (McMillan, DeAngelis, Feigin, & Warshaw, 1999). It<br />
is primarily infants younger than one year of age who<br />
require hospitalization. RSV accounts for the most hospitalizations<br />
and fatal out<strong>com</strong>es for acute respiratory<br />
problems in children younger than two years old. Among<br />
children who are hospitalized for RSV, 2%-5% develop<br />
respiratory failure (McMillan et al., 1999). Infants who<br />
are born prematurely or have low birth weight are at<br />
greatest risk for acquiring RSV and may require intensive<br />
care. One study (Brooks, McBride, McConnochie et al,<br />
1999) examined the presenting signs and symptoms of<br />
542 previously healthy full-term infants who where<br />
infected with RSV and admitted to the hospital. <strong>The</strong><br />
researchers <strong>com</strong>pared the initial signs and symptoms of<br />
infants who were able to remain on a general pediatric<br />
floor and those who needed to be transferred to the PICU<br />
and found no significant differences. In other words, predicting<br />
which infants will require intensive care was not<br />
possible based on presenting factors.<br />
Clinical course<br />
RSV occurs in annual epidemics worldwide. In the<br />
United States these epidemics usually begin in early fall,<br />
peak in winter, and continue until late spring. Children<br />
and adults of any age can be<strong>com</strong>e infected with RSV.<br />
Initially a child with RSV presents with rhinorrhea consisting<br />
of thick yellow green secretions, increased pulse<br />
and respiratory rate, retractions and nasal flaring. In some<br />
cases symptoms may include pharyngitis, irritability, poor<br />
feeding, lethargy and a low grade fever. A cough often<br />
develops in older children after one to two days of the illness.<br />
<strong>The</strong> young child has an immature respiratory system<br />
in both anatomical size and physiology, so the mechanism<br />
to create an effective cough is weak at best and often nonexistent<br />
in infants with RSV (Bowden, Dickey, &<br />
Greenberg, 1998). In young children, and in children who<br />
are developmentally delayed, the upper airway cannot be<br />
cleared by a forced cough or nose blowing, increasing the<br />
risk of partial or <strong>com</strong>plete airway obstruction from the<br />
thick secretions. Rhinorrhea continues throughout the<br />
course of the disease. Auscultation often reveals diffuse<br />
rhonchi and in some cases, wheezing.<br />
Children and adults with only upper respiratory tract<br />
involvement usually have mild symptoms and the disease<br />
resolves in approximately seven days. Symptoms may<br />
linger for several weeks for infants, young children, and<br />
those who have lower respiratory tract involvement.<br />
Infants and children are susceptible to re-infection, especially<br />
during epidemic periods.<br />
Most <strong>com</strong>monly, positive diagnosis is determined via<br />
laboratory assay of the RSV antigen in nasal secretions.<br />
This type of testing is widely preferred since the results<br />
are accurate and available in a few hours. <strong>The</strong> health<br />
care professional obtains nasal secretions by suctioning<br />
the nares and should send the specimen to the laboratory<br />
immediately. <strong>The</strong> suctioning causes temporary dis<strong>com</strong>fort,<br />
but usually has a result of helping to clear the nose of<br />
thick secretions, possibly creating less labored breathing.<br />
Other types of testing available are less desirable because<br />
these tests take several days to obtain results, are more<br />
invasive, and are not known to be more accurate than the<br />
preferred method.<br />
Treatment<br />
Most children only require treatment for symptom<br />
relief and airway clearance. Frequent suctioning is necessary<br />
to maintain a patent airway. Supplemental oxygen<br />
may be necessary to correct hypoxemia and to maintain<br />
an oxygen saturation level greater than 93%. Frequent<br />
pulse oximetry assessments are necessary. If cyanosis,<br />
dyspnea, and a respiratory rate over 60 breaths per<br />
minute, are assessed then blood gas values should be<br />
obtained. IV fluids are started to prevent or correct dehydration,<br />
however strict I&O is needed to prevent overhydration<br />
and edema. Adequate hydration also helps to<br />
loosen secretions.<br />
Currently Ribavirin (Virazole) is the only approved<br />
medication specific for treating RSV. <strong>The</strong> American<br />
Academy of Pediatrics has provided re<strong>com</strong>mendations<br />
determining which patients should receive Ribavirin therapy<br />
due to the high cost and problems with the administration<br />
of the drug (see www.aap.org). Ribavirin therapy<br />
is administered via aerosol or nasotrachial tube for a continuous<br />
duration of 12-20 hours per 24 hours over an<br />
average of three days of treatment. <strong>The</strong> length of treatment<br />
is individualized and terminated when clinical<br />
improvement has occurred. Ribavirin works by interfering<br />
with messenger RNA, thus inhibiting viral protein<br />
synthesis (Filippell & Rearick, 1993). Ribavirin forms<br />
large crystallized particles when aerosolized and is difficult<br />
to contain around the infected patient. <strong>The</strong><br />
aerosolized drug is irritating to the mucous membranes of<br />
those who are not infected. <strong>The</strong> particulate also can cause<br />
obstruction and internal damage to ventilators, especially<br />
if proper filters are not installed in the ventilator.<br />
Transmission<br />
<strong>The</strong> transmission of RSV typically occurs through<br />
direct or close contact with contaminated nasal secretions.<br />
<strong>The</strong> most <strong>com</strong>mon mode of transmission involves<br />
hand contact on the secretions and transferring the contaminant<br />
to the mucosa. RSV from acutely infected<br />
infants can survive on non-porous surfaces, such as crib<br />
rails and stethoscopes, for more than six hours and on<br />
porous surfaces, such as clothing and skin for 30-60 minutes<br />
(McMillan et al., 1999). Hospital staff can contribute<br />
to the spread of RSV through carelessness in hand<br />
washing and poor isolation techniques. During <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
epidemics children in intensive care nurseries and<br />
children’s rehabilitation hospitals are at greatest risk for<br />
RSV infection and death.<br />
RSV cont. on pg. 15
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 15 •<br />
RSV cont. from pg. 14<br />
Prevention<br />
<strong>The</strong> primary means of prevention involves measures<br />
to control the transmission of RSV. Meticulous hand<br />
washing of those caring for infants and young children is<br />
paramount. In adults, many viruses including RSV cause<br />
cold-like symptoms. Nevertheless, limiting exposure of<br />
infants and children to individuals (regardless of age)<br />
who have cold-like symptoms is highly re<strong>com</strong>mended.<br />
Hospitalized children infected with RSV are placed on<br />
isolation using gown, gloves, and mask when within<br />
three feet of the infected child for the duration of the illness.<br />
Children who have tested to be RSV positive<br />
should only share a room with other RSV infected children<br />
or a child highly suspected of harboring RSV.<br />
Children who are highly suspected of being RSV positive<br />
are placed in isolation while waiting for test results to<br />
decrease the transmission of RSV. Strict isolation is necessary<br />
for anyone receiving Ribavirin therapy.<br />
Currently there are two drugs available for RSV prophylaxis<br />
(see www.aap.org). <strong>The</strong> first drug is RSV intra-<br />
venous immune globulin (RSV-IGIV) which is administered<br />
to non-infected, infants or young children at high<br />
risk by monthly infusions throughout the RSV season<br />
with the first dose prior to the beginning of the season<br />
(Oertel, 1996). Monthly doses are needed to maintain<br />
protection. <strong>The</strong> child must be closely monitored during<br />
and post infusion due to the potential side effects of this<br />
blood product. RSV-IGIV was approved by the FDA in<br />
1996 for children less than 24 months old and who were<br />
born prematurely or who have a history of bronchopulmonary<br />
dysplasia. While the infant is receiving RSV-<br />
IGIV, measles and varicella vaccinations must be postponed<br />
(McMillan et al., 1999). In 1998, Palivizumab<br />
(Synagis) was approved by the FDA for RSV prophylaxis<br />
using similar criteria for use as RSV-IGIV.<br />
Palivizumab is an RSV monoclonal antibody that is<br />
administered IM and given monthly during the RSV season.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re is no need to postpone immunizations with<br />
Palivizumab which has fewer known side effects than<br />
RSV-IGIV (McMillan et al., 1999).<br />
<strong>The</strong> Bottom Line<br />
RSV pertains to all nurses and plays a significant role<br />
in areas other than pediatrics. <strong>Nurse</strong>s working with<br />
adults should be aware of RSV, so they might include this<br />
information with discharge teaching especially if the<br />
adult has a respiratory infection or any adult who has contact<br />
with newborns and young children.<br />
References<br />
Bowden, V. R., Dickey, S. B., & Greenberg, C. S.<br />
(1998). Children and their families: <strong>The</strong> continuum of<br />
care. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders.<br />
Brooks, A., McBride, J. T., McConnochie, K. M. et al<br />
(1999). Predicting deterioration in previously healthy<br />
infants hospitalized with respiratory syncytial virus infection.<br />
Pediatrics, 104 (3), 463-467.<br />
Filippell, M. B., & Rearick, T. (1993). Respiratory<br />
syncytial virus. Nursing Clinics of North America, 28<br />
(3), 651-670.<br />
McMillan, J. A., DeAngelis, C. D., Feigin, R. D., &<br />
Warshaw, J. B. (Eds.). (1999). Oski’s Pediatrics:<br />
Principles and Practice (3rd ed.). Baltimore: Lippincott<br />
Williams & Wilkins.<br />
Oertel, M. D. (1996). RespiGam: An RSV immune<br />
globulin. Pediatric Nursing, 22 (6), 525-528.
• PAGE P GE 16 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
Public Health Nursing in <strong>Maryland</strong>: Our Roots<br />
by Marlene H. Cianci, PhD, RN<br />
<strong>The</strong> author is a <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
health nurse, recently retired from<br />
the faculty of the College of<br />
Nursing and Health Science,<br />
George Mason University<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong>’s history of <strong>com</strong>mitment<br />
to public health can be traced<br />
to the early colonists, who in 1704<br />
enacted their first public law “for the<br />
protection of children from the ravages<br />
of wolves” (1). <strong>The</strong> Baltimore<br />
City Health Department was estab- Cianci<br />
lished in 1793, in an attempt to ward<br />
off a yellow fever epidemic raging in Philadelphia.<br />
Communicable diseases continued to plague the state,<br />
because of its central location for industrialization, <strong>com</strong>merce,<br />
and immigration.(2). By the end of the 19th century,<br />
tuberculosis was the leading cause of death, with a mortality<br />
rate in <strong>Maryland</strong> of 212.8:100,000 (3).<br />
Interior of the Healthmobile (well child services), c. 1940<br />
(Montgomery County Archives, Rockville, MD, U.S. Public<br />
Health Service Folder 3, 1939-1940).<br />
<strong>The</strong> Baltimore Instructive Visiting <strong>Nurse</strong> Association<br />
(IVNA), established in 1896 to provide bedside nursing<br />
care and health instruction to families in their homes, hired<br />
the first tuberculosis nurse in 1903 with funds raised by<br />
Mrs. William Osler (4). Tuberculosis work quickly reached<br />
such magnitude that it was transferred to the Baltimore<br />
City Health Department (BCHD) in 1910, and a Division<br />
of Tuberculosis was established, under the direction of a<br />
nursing supervisor (5).<br />
<strong>The</strong> Baltimore City Health Department inaugurated its<br />
nursing service in 1905, with the appointment of one nurse<br />
Lay midwives receiving instruction form a public health<br />
nurse, c. 1930s. (Montgomery County Archives, Rockville,<br />
MD. U.S. Public Health Service, Folder 2, 1939-1940).<br />
to the city’s public schools. Four additional nurses were<br />
hired the following year to expand the program to public<br />
and parochial schools (6). In 1915, a <strong>com</strong>municable disease<br />
program of preventive services, consisting of isolation,<br />
quarantine, and hygiene instruction in the homes of<br />
families with <strong>com</strong>municable diseases was established with<br />
three nurses. By 1919, with maternal, infant, and child<br />
services a major focus, the health department established a<br />
Bureau of Child Hygiene with 12 specialized nurses to<br />
visit all newborn infants. A specialized maternal hygiene<br />
service was added in 1921 (7). <strong>The</strong> BCHD took its first<br />
step toward generalized nursing services, in 1920, in<br />
response to fiscal realities and the obvious needs of the city<br />
in relation to available resources. Specialized <strong>com</strong>municable<br />
disease, school health, and tuberculosis nursing services<br />
were <strong>com</strong>bined into a generalized program, including<br />
specialty clinics. Nursing activities expanded to include<br />
Public Health Lay Council station wagon with driver<br />
Elizabeth Tipton (in dark flower print dress) and patients, c.<br />
1942 (Montgomery Conty Archives, Rockville, MD)<br />
Tuberculosis screening clinic, Miss Lucy Conklin, X-ray<br />
technician, c. 1940 (Montgomery County Archives, Rockville,<br />
MD, Records of Health Department TB Clinics & Christmas<br />
Seals Volunteers 1939-1950).<br />
dental clinics, Schick clinics, venereal disease clinics, ophthalmia<br />
treatment, typhoid culturing, psychiatry, and playground<br />
programs. Public health nurses enjoyed considerable<br />
autonomy while being responsible for quarantine for<br />
<strong>com</strong>municable diseases, placarding homes, excluding from<br />
school all children with the disease or who never had it,<br />
and instructing the family in care (8). <strong>The</strong> Bureau of<br />
Nursing assigned each of its public health nurses to spend<br />
six months at Sydenham Hospital for Communicable<br />
Diseases to learn care of patients and control of <strong>com</strong>municable<br />
diseases (9).<br />
<strong>The</strong> Eastern Health District, established in 1932 in a<br />
partnership between the City Health Department and Johns<br />
Hopkins School of Hygiene and Public Health served as a<br />
population laboratory for research, administration, and<br />
teaching. Public health nurses were the primary surveyors,<br />
collecting data on every household every three years, for<br />
the development of a <strong>com</strong>prehensive public health program.<br />
In addition, nurses “provided health education, interpreted<br />
physicians’ findings, gave instructions on isolation<br />
technique to families of tuberculosis patients, prepared<br />
admission forms to sanitoria, assessed home conditions<br />
before discharge of premature infants from the hospital,<br />
and, in emergency cases, gave bedside care.” Public health<br />
nurses were full partners in the Eastern Health District:<br />
nursing supervisors as well as physicians taught public<br />
health administration courses at the School of Hygiene<br />
(10), and an on-site training center was established in 1933<br />
to provide public health clinical training for and by nurses<br />
(7). Throughout the city, PHNs on home visits collected<br />
paint chips for analysis by the health department laboratories.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se studies led to national policies for the removal<br />
of lead from paint (9).<br />
Roots cont. on pg. 17
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 17 •<br />
Roots cont. from pg. 16<br />
Rural public health nursing began in 1903, with a<br />
visiting nurse provided by the IVNA to Baltimore County,<br />
and in 1910, with three IVNA nurses to Annapolis and<br />
points along the way of the Baltimore and Annapolis<br />
Railroad. <strong>The</strong> Anne Arundel County Chapter of the Red<br />
Cross Town and Country Service assumed home nursing<br />
services until 1949 (11). Gradually, IVNA services were<br />
turned over to the county health departments as they were<br />
established. (12) Washington County hired its first TB<br />
nurse at the behest of a group of public minded women in<br />
Hagerstown. A second nurse was hired for the county and<br />
both nurses provided general nursing services. So successful<br />
were they that Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and<br />
Public Health and the U.S. Public Health Service targeted<br />
the county for epidemiological studies, leading to the<br />
Hagerstown Health Studies. Again PHNs were the primary<br />
data collectors (13).<br />
<strong>The</strong> State Health Department initiated its public health<br />
nursing program in 1920, when a nursing supervisor was<br />
hired to develop public health nursing in the 23 counties.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Bureau of Child Hygiene was established in 1922 and<br />
four nurses were hired to cover the state. Field nurses were<br />
the first public health workers in many counties, preceding<br />
health officers by many years. By 1926, there was at least<br />
one PHN in each county. By 1934, <strong>Maryland</strong> had fulltime,<br />
county-wide services with a health officer, sanitarian,<br />
and a PHN in each county (14).<br />
<strong>The</strong> trajectory of rural public health nursing gained<br />
momentum as a result of State Department of Health and<br />
<strong>com</strong>munity efforts to meet local needs and expectations.<br />
Health care, when and where available, had been provided<br />
by country doctors, lay midwives, and a few public health<br />
and visiting nurses. Alliances among physicians, nurses,<br />
official and voluntary agencies, the Rockefeller<br />
Foundation, and the Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and<br />
Public Health brought public health programs to fruition.<br />
<strong>The</strong> rural nurse encountered many of the same health<br />
problems as did her urban sisters, with the added challenge<br />
Hand Washing on a prenatal home visit, c. 1935<br />
(Montgomery County Archives, Rockville, MD, U.S. Public<br />
Typhoid Immunizations, Crew of Stockley Road Camp,<br />
Calvert County, MD, 1915 (<strong>Maryland</strong> State Department of<br />
Health and Mental Hygiene).<br />
of fewer, or non-existent resources. Poverty, malnutrition,<br />
<strong>com</strong>municable diseases, prematurity, and venereal diseases<br />
were rampant, demanding public health measures (14).<br />
Rural nurses, in addition, were responsible for the instruction<br />
and supervision of as many as eight lay midwives<br />
(15).<br />
Rural public health nurses mobilized <strong>com</strong>munity partnerships<br />
to help identify and solve health problems and<br />
build on existing programs to foster health promotion and<br />
disease prevention.<br />
Public health nurses found the school population to be<br />
the “best captive group for health promotion and prevention”<br />
(16). <strong>The</strong> nurses coordinated with Boards of<br />
Education and civic organizations to maximize School<br />
Health Day in May for immunizations, health screening<br />
and education for students and families, and school roundup<br />
for fall (14). Similar activities were conducted during<br />
National Negro Health Week in April in Baltimore and all<br />
counties with large black populations, in response to the<br />
alarming morbidity and mortality rates among blacks and<br />
the appalling disparity of rates between blacks and whites.<br />
Special programs were planned for each day, promoting<br />
child, family, and environmental health, including medical<br />
examinations, dental clinics, immunization clinics, and<br />
<strong>com</strong>munity clean-up campaigns. So much interest was<br />
generated over the years that the week’s activities were<br />
reflected in public health programs throughout the year<br />
(17).<br />
<strong>The</strong> state Healthmobile was the most effective vehicle<br />
for delivering public health services to remote areas during<br />
the summer months. <strong>The</strong> unit was staffed by a physician,<br />
dentist, and chauffeur. County public health nurses and<br />
health officers organized, publicized, and assisted with<br />
mobile services. Films on dental care, immunizations,<br />
nutrition, and personal hygiene were shown in the school<br />
or church upon arrival. Families returned with their children<br />
the next day for physical and dental examinations,<br />
immunizations, vision and hearing screenings, and gross<br />
examinations for rickets (14).<br />
Lay health associations formed at the local level and<br />
responded to the priorities of the <strong>com</strong>munity. In some<br />
instances, private benefactors responded to obvious <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
needs, built health centers, furnished equipment<br />
and supplies, assisted with clinic services, and provided<br />
transportation for mothers and children. PHNs assessed<br />
the health needs of the <strong>com</strong>munity, <strong>com</strong>piling morbidity,<br />
mortality, and demographic statistics, identifying needs,<br />
resources, and expectations, and coordinating the volunteers.<br />
(In Anne Arundel County, five health centers are still<br />
owned and maintained by their respective lay health associations.)<br />
In more remote counties where the only organized<br />
groups were churches and schools, PHNs relied on<br />
PTAs, clergy, and parishioners for support (14).<br />
Support for public health nursing came from official,<br />
voluntary, and private foundations and individuals, which<br />
sometimes determined the availability. PHNs in county<br />
health departments supported by the Rockefeller<br />
Foundation, the USPHS, and Johns Hopkins School of<br />
Hygiene and Public Health practiced in demonstration<br />
programs involved in research and service, based on the<br />
most current knowledge and principles. <strong>The</strong> greatest impetus<br />
for public health nursing came from the New Deal<br />
Programs. Social Security funds enabled the state and<br />
counties to hire prepared supervisors, consultants, instructors,<br />
and additional staff nurses. Educational funds enabled<br />
nurses at all levels to continue their education at advanced<br />
levels (18). <strong>Maryland</strong> public health nurses strove to<br />
achieve and maintain practice within the definition and<br />
guidelines of the National Organization for Public Health<br />
Nursing and the Federal Emergency Relief Administration<br />
(19). APHA Appraisal Forms were used in some counties<br />
to evaluate services and plan improved programs (20).<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> public health nurses during the Great<br />
Depression provided a model and firm foundation for<br />
much of contemporary public health nursing today. <strong>The</strong>n<br />
as now public health nurses based their practice on 1) <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
strengths, needs, and expectations; 2) current sci-<br />
Sara Fetter, PHN, <strong>Nurse</strong> Midwife, Demonstrating transportation<br />
of a premature infant in a special carrier from<br />
home to hospital, 1947. (<strong>Maryland</strong> State Department of<br />
Health and Mental Hygiene)<br />
Health Service folder 2, 1939-1940). Roots cont. on pg. 18
• PAGE P GE 18 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
Roots cont. from pg. 17<br />
entific knowledge; 3) available resources; 4) accepted criteria<br />
and standards of nursing practice; 5) agency purpose,<br />
philosophy, and objectives, and 6) the participation, cooperation,<br />
and understanding of the population” (21). <strong>The</strong><br />
endeavors of our forebears, in the face of economic adversity<br />
, should give inspiration, guidance, and hope to<br />
today’s public health nurses, striving to improve current<br />
practice and to prepare for the future.<br />
References<br />
1. Annual Report of the State Health Department of<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong>, 1932. Hall of Records, Annapolis, MD. MdHR<br />
1110, location 2-7-6-5.<br />
2. Howard, W. T. (1924). Public health administration<br />
and the natural history of disease in Baltimore, <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
1797-1920. Washington, DC: Carnegie Institution of<br />
Washington.<br />
3. Riley, R. H. (n.d.). <strong>Maryland</strong>’s program for the control<br />
of tuberculosis. Baltimore: <strong>Maryland</strong> Tuberculosis<br />
Association.<br />
4. Brainard, M. (1922). <strong>The</strong> evolution of public health<br />
nursing. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders.<br />
5. Newman, J. B. (1924, April). Bureau of Nursing.<br />
Annual Report of the Health Department, 1925.<br />
Department of Public Safety Annual Report, Sub-<br />
Department of Health, to the Mayor and City Council of<br />
Baltimore for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 1925.<br />
6. Division of Public Health Nursing, <strong>Maryland</strong> State<br />
Department of Health. (n.d.). Public health nursing in<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong>, 1887–. Unpublished Manuscript.<br />
7. Sundberg, A. M. (1955).Fifty years of public health<br />
nursing, city health department: 1905-1955. Baltimore<br />
Health News. 32, 168-171.<br />
8. Important and interesting work is performed by City<br />
Health Department Bureau of Nursing (1927, November<br />
21). Baltimore Municipal Journal, 15 (22), 1, 3-4<br />
9. Sundberg, A. M. Personal <strong>com</strong>munication,<br />
September 23, 1996.<br />
Lead paint hazards, c. 1930. <strong>The</strong>re were as many as 17 layers<br />
of lead paint in some homes. (Baltimore City Health<br />
Department).<br />
10. Fee, E.(1987). Disease and discovery: A history of<br />
the Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and Public Health,<br />
1916-1939. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.<br />
11. Wohlgemuth, M. (n.d.). Papers of Margaret<br />
Wohglemuth. Anne Arundel County Health Department<br />
files.<br />
12. Visiting <strong>Nurse</strong> Association of Baltimore.(1994).<br />
Historical Highlights 1895-1994. Unpublished Document.<br />
Files of the author.<br />
13. Comstock, G. W. (1983, April). Hagerstown Health<br />
and Morbidity Studies. Papers of G. W. Comstock,<br />
Washington County Health Department.<br />
14. Annual Reports of the State Health Department of<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong>, 1931-1940. Hall of Records, Annapolis, MD.<br />
MdHR 1110, Location 2-7-6-5.<br />
15. Smith, K. S., personnel <strong>com</strong>munication, April 2,<br />
1996.<br />
16. Scholl, A. C. (1980). Review and re<strong>com</strong>mendations<br />
for <strong>com</strong>munity nursing systems. Draft prepared for the<br />
Baltimore City Health Department Study Group. <strong>The</strong><br />
Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and Public Health. Files<br />
of the author.<br />
17. Riley, R. H. (1934, January/March). Negro Health<br />
Week awards and cleanliness and neatness improvement<br />
contests. National Negro Health News, 2(1), 3.<br />
18. U.S. Public Health Service. (1937).<strong>The</strong> public<br />
health program under Title VI of the Social Security Act.<br />
Washington, DC: U. S. Government Printing Office.<br />
19. Federal Emergency Relief Administration. (1993).<br />
Rules and regulations No. 7 governing medical care provided<br />
in the home to recipients of unemployment relief.<br />
Washington, DC: U. S. Government Printing Office.<br />
20. Annual Report of Montgomery County Health<br />
Department, 1935-1947. Montgomery County Archives,<br />
Rockville, MD RG 7, Box, Folder 2.<br />
21. American Public Health Association, Public Health<br />
Nursing Section. (1996). <strong>The</strong> definition and role of public<br />
health nursing. Washington, DC: Author.<br />
Baltimore City public health nurse and car, 1908.<br />
(Baltimore City Health Department)<br />
Central trailer - Dr. Briger’s Trailer, Colesville Methodist<br />
Church, September 5, 1940 (Montgomery County Archives,<br />
Rockville, MD, Records of Health Department)<br />
A Day in the Life of a Rural<br />
Public Health <strong>Nurse</strong>, 1943<br />
It was autumn, in a rural isolated county on the Eastern<br />
Shore of <strong>Maryland</strong>. <strong>The</strong> public health nurse was assisting<br />
a lay midwife with the delivery of a premature baby. <strong>The</strong><br />
dilapidated house, lacking electricity and indoor plumbing,<br />
contained few material possessions. <strong>The</strong> nearest hospital,<br />
in the next county, was not equipped to care for premature<br />
infants. <strong>The</strong> nurse knew she must transport this<br />
baby to Johns Hopkins Hospital if he were to survive. She<br />
retrieved a pet carrier from her car, pumped water, heated<br />
it on the wood stove and filled empty pint whiskey bottles<br />
(which she had gathered from dumps during her travels<br />
throughout the county) with the hot water. She lined the<br />
carrier with blankets and the improvised hot water bottles,<br />
placed the newborn in the carrier, and began her journey.<br />
She drove a distance of some thirty miles to Kent Island,<br />
where she boarded the ferry for the four mile trip across<br />
the Chesapeake Bay to the Western Shore, and then continued<br />
her trip to Johns Hopkins Hospital, where the baby<br />
at least had some chance of survival. This was just a part<br />
of a day in the life of a <strong>Maryland</strong> public health nurse,<br />
whose important work may have saved a life, helped lower<br />
the extremely high infant mortality rate, and provided care<br />
and support to a needy family (K. S. Smith, personal <strong>com</strong>munication,<br />
April 2. 1996).<br />
A Day in the Life of a Balitmore<br />
City School <strong>Nurse</strong>, 1927<br />
Screening of school children for diseased tonsils and<br />
adenoids was routine. <strong>The</strong> Robert Garrett Hospital, at 27<br />
North Carey Street, reserved a clinic, operating room, and<br />
ward where T&As were performed by a specialist on<br />
Mondays and Thursdays, for a maximum fee of $5.00, or for<br />
free for families unable to pay. School nurses coordinated<br />
the care, obtaining parental written permission for surgery,<br />
and transporting the children to the hospital by late morning,<br />
for surgery to be performed in the afternoon. During the preoperative<br />
time, a nurse especially suited for the work entertained<br />
or kept the children amused with stories, puzzles,<br />
toys, and magazines. Health department nurses in the generalized<br />
nursing program were specially trained in surgical<br />
nursing, to administer anesthesia, and to assist in the operating<br />
room. <strong>The</strong> children received over night post-operative<br />
nursing care by their respective school nurses and were<br />
returned to their homes the following day, “in a closed automobile<br />
kept for this purpose and driven by a nurse who<br />
[was] an experienced driver.” <strong>The</strong> school nurse gave the<br />
“mother or guardian of each child the most careful instructions<br />
in taking proper care of the case.”<br />
(Important and interesting work is performed by City<br />
Health Department Bureau of Nursing (1927, November<br />
21) Baltimore Municipal Journal, 15(22), 1, 3-4.)
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 19 •<br />
Long Term Care<br />
Coalition<br />
by Anne Marie Barnett, RNC<br />
<strong>The</strong> Long Term Care Coalition is a group of professionals<br />
who represent an interest and expertise in caring for the<br />
resident in a long term care (LTC) facility. This group was<br />
formed in an effort to identify essential core functions for:<br />
the licensed nurse in charge of a unit; the Director of<br />
Nursing; the Nursing Home Administrator; and, the<br />
Medical Director. <strong>The</strong>se essential core functions are<br />
derived from the overall roles and responsibilities of contemporary<br />
long term care facilities and respective professional<br />
standards of practice for these professional<br />
groups/disciplines. A variety of roles and professionals as<br />
well as organizations are represented on the Coalition.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se include but are not limited to: registered nurses representing<br />
staff development, quality assurance, temporary<br />
nursing staffing agency, nurse psychotherapist, Directors<br />
of Nursing, Home Health, nurse recruiters and “charge”<br />
nurses. In addition, associations and educational institutions<br />
are represented such as the <strong>Maryland</strong> Association of<br />
Long Term Care Medical Directors, National Association<br />
of Directors of Nursing Administration Long Term Care -<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Chapter, <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association, LPN and<br />
RN associate degree nursing education programs and a<br />
Baccalaureate Nursing education program.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Coalition meets monthly and continues to work on<br />
identifying essential core functions as outlined above. If<br />
you have any questions regarding the Coalition, please<br />
contact me at (301) 475-8456.
• PAGE P GE 20 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
Official Registration Form<br />
Official Registration Form – Healthy <strong>Nurse</strong>s 2000<br />
November 8-10, 2000 * Rocky Gap Lodge * Cumberland <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
PLEASE PRINT<br />
Last Name _________________________First Name ____________________Credentials _________________<br />
Home Address _______________________________________________________________________________<br />
City ____________________________________State ___________________________Zip _________________<br />
Daytime Phone _______________________________________________________________________________<br />
Email Address________________________________________________________________________________<br />
MNA District___________________________________________________Membership # _________________<br />
Member rates apply to MNA members in good standing, members of MNA Affiliates, and other ANA state<br />
nurses association members with membership number or card.<br />
2000 Convention Rates<br />
Member Rate Full Time Others<br />
Undergraduate Student<br />
Full Convention (Includes all programs and meals as indicated Wed – Fri)<br />
____ $190.00 _____ $100.00 ____ $250.00<br />
Early Bird Discount ____ $165.00 _____ $75.00 ____ $225.00<br />
(Prior to Oct. 5th)<br />
Daily Rate<br />
Wednesday, Nov. 8th _____ $40.00 _____ $30.00 _____ $50.00<br />
Thursday, Nov. 9th _____ $110.00 _____ $50.00 _____ $190.00<br />
Friday, Nov. 10th _____ $50.00 _____ $30.00 _____ $60.00<br />
Business Meeting ONLY Open to MNA Members – no charge _______<br />
* Members 65 years and older, please call for rate information<br />
* Student Groups of 15 or more ac<strong>com</strong>panied by an instructor, please call for rate information<br />
Cancellations will be accepted until October 13, 2000. A $25.00 administrative fee will be charged for cancellations.<br />
Please Identify Session Selections on Convention Program form and return with registration form and check<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association<br />
849 International Drive<br />
Linthicum, <strong>Maryland</strong> 21090<br />
Phone 410-859-3000<br />
FAX 410-859-3001<br />
Convention Hotel<br />
Information<br />
<strong>The</strong> 2000 MNA Convention will be held at Rocky Gap<br />
Lodge and Golf Resort in Cumberland <strong>Maryland</strong>.<br />
Reservations can be made by calling 800-724-0828,<br />
please indicate you are with the <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s<br />
Association. Rates are $98.00 single or double.<br />
Guestrooms offer cable television, mini bars, telephones<br />
with data ports. <strong>The</strong>re is an indoor/outdoor pool, fitness<br />
center, tennis courts, gift shop, whirlpool, and golf. <strong>The</strong><br />
hotel sits on a beautiful lake and there are boat rentals also<br />
available.<br />
Directions:<br />
From Baltimore: Take I-70 West to I-68 West<br />
(Handcock, MD) proceed approximately 40 miles to exit<br />
50, Rocky Gap State Park , Take right off the exit, Hotel is<br />
visible from the road.<br />
From Washington: Take I-270 North to I-70 West. Take<br />
I-70 West approximately 60 miles to I-68 West. Proceed<br />
approximately 40 miles to exit 50, Rocky Gap State Park,<br />
Take right off the exit, Hotel is visible from the Road.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Department of Natural Resources has a few cabins<br />
that are near the hotel if you want to be more rustic. You<br />
can call 301-784-8403 for information. <strong>The</strong>re is also<br />
camping trailer hook ups available as well.<br />
ATTENTION<br />
People who are registering for the<br />
conference will need to fill out both<br />
the “Official Registration form” (below) and<br />
the “Convention Program Form” (next page).<br />
Bring Your Spouse<br />
or Family<br />
Western <strong>Maryland</strong> is beautiful in early November and<br />
there are lots of things to keep your spouse and families busy<br />
while you are in learning sessions.<br />
In addition to the many activities right at Rocky Gap,<br />
including boating, fishing, hiking golf and tennis.<br />
Cumberland is only a short 5 to 10 minute drive away.<br />
Shopping – Cumberland’s first shop was opened in 1749<br />
by Christopher Grist who erected a stockade and trading<br />
post. Since its inception, this historic city has offered travelers<br />
a chance to find anything from antiques to today’s hottest<br />
fashions<br />
Historic Cumberland Mall – a wide array of boutique,<br />
antique and specialty shops located in the heart of town.<br />
Antique Mall – numerous vendors with a variety of collectibles<br />
and furniture<br />
Country Club Mall – indoor shopping mall offering a<br />
wide selection of over 75 stores<br />
Farmers Market – “Fruit Bowl” where you can find fresh<br />
fruits and vegetables all year round, along with the most delicious<br />
baked goods and candies anywhere.<br />
Western <strong>Maryland</strong> Scenic Railroad – operates on weekends<br />
during November, but you may want to stay and extra<br />
day and take advantage of this wonder historic steam train<br />
excursion through the mountains.<br />
Falling Waters – One of the famous Frank Lloyd Wright<br />
homes is just about 1 hour away from Rocky Gap. It is<br />
worth seeing and if you are interested and let us know in<br />
advance we can arrange for your tickets. This may be fun to<br />
do early on Wednesday or Friday afternoon. Give us a call.<br />
<strong>The</strong> District One members will have more on site information<br />
when you arrive, however if you have some specific<br />
questions about planning to for your family, give us a call.
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 21 •<br />
Take A Hike<br />
<strong>The</strong> District One Convention Planning Committee<br />
invites you to join trail guide, Dora Long, RN, on<br />
November 9th at the<br />
MNA Convention for<br />
a leisurely walk<br />
(hike) around the<br />
lake shore trail at<br />
beautiful Rocky Gap<br />
Lodge. As you hike<br />
along the trail the<br />
pristine lake is<br />
always in view. You<br />
may see a loon or a<br />
migrating hooded<br />
merganser, not to<br />
mention a deer and a<br />
squirrel or two.<br />
Plan on wearing<br />
your jeans and bring<br />
a lightweight jacket,<br />
gloves, hat and good<br />
sneakers or hiking<br />
boots. <strong>The</strong> trail is<br />
challenging. You<br />
should be in good<br />
physical condition.<br />
Dora Long, “Take A Hike” Guide<br />
for November’s Convention and<br />
member of the District One<br />
Convention Planning Committee<br />
Hiking is one passion that Dora uses to keep in good shape.<br />
Western <strong>Maryland</strong> has been Dora’s home for all of her<br />
life and she is anxious to share a little bit of he backyard<br />
with all convention participants. <strong>The</strong>re will be a sign up<br />
sheet at the registration table when you arrive at Rocky<br />
Gap.<br />
P.S. Bring a camera<br />
Bring your Nursing<br />
Cap and wear your<br />
pin to dinner<br />
Thursday night<br />
HEALTHY NURSES 2000<br />
97th Annual Conference of <strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association<br />
Rocky Gap Lodge and Golf Resort<br />
Cumberland, <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
November 8 – 10, 2000<br />
Wednesday, November 8, 2000<br />
Dinner on Your Own<br />
6:00 PM Registration Opens<br />
6:30 – 7:30 PM Wel<strong>com</strong>e/Exhibits Open<br />
7:30 – 8:30 PM Indicate First and Second Choice, limited class size, assignments done on a first receipt basis<br />
_____ Massage <strong>The</strong>rapy, Biofeedback & Aroma <strong>The</strong>rapy Leah Yoder, RN, MST<br />
_____ Reflexology Ken & Debbie Unger<br />
_____ Osteoporosis<br />
(includes a <strong>com</strong>plimentary bone density study)<br />
Debbie Meyers, RN, MSN, CCRN<br />
_____ Acupuncture Dr. David Bohn, BS, OC<br />
8:30 – 9:00 PM Dessert<br />
9:00 – 10:00 PM Indicate First and Second Choice, limited class size, assignments done on a first receipt basis<br />
_____ Massage <strong>The</strong>rapy, Biofeedback & Aroma <strong>The</strong>rapy<br />
_____ Reflexology<br />
Leah Yoder, RN, MST<br />
Thursday, November 9, 2000<br />
8:00 AM Registration Opens<br />
_____ Osteoporosis<br />
(includes a <strong>com</strong>plimentary bone density study)<br />
Debbie Meyers, RN, MSN, CCRN<br />
_____ Acupuncture Dr. David Bohn, BS, OC<br />
8:15 AM Continental Breakfast<br />
9:00 – 9:05 AM Wel<strong>com</strong>e & Introductions Karen Shaffer, D-1 President<br />
9:05 – 9:50 AM Keynote “Survival For <strong>Nurse</strong>s” Melody Chenevert, MS, RN<br />
10:00 – 11:00 AM<br />
How to survive the challenges of today’s fast paced, ever changing health care environments.<br />
What to do when you feel the pressure cooker is about to explode.<br />
Concurrent Sessions ( Indicate First and Second Choice, See separate description)<br />
____ Herbal Medicines and their potential interactions with over-the-counter and<br />
prescription drugs: Willow Moore, D.C., N.D.<br />
____ “Safe Needles Save Lives”: Marsha Zanger, RN<br />
Workplace safety is a growing concern for all nurses. Learn about the ANA initiative and<br />
hear one nurse’s personal experience with the fiscal and personal cost of needlestick<br />
____ Aging and <strong>The</strong> Law: Counsel for <strong>Nurse</strong>s: Joan L. O’Sullivan, JD, University of <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
School of Law. Learn more about the issues of informed consent, surrogate decision<br />
making, end of life including assisted suicide and palliative care.<br />
11:00 – 11:15 AM Break<br />
11:15 – 12:15 PM Concurrent Sessions (Indicate First and Second Choice, See separate description)<br />
____ Healthy Communities 2010 Dr. Fred Tola<br />
Hear a discussion about what makes a healthy <strong>com</strong>munity.<br />
____ Parish Nursing Linda Santymire RN<br />
____<br />
Something old is new again. Impact of providing health care information in a<br />
spiritual <strong>com</strong>munity.<br />
Transplant: Alexandra Brock, RN, BS, BSN, <strong>Maryland</strong> Transplant Resource Center<br />
12:15 – 1:30 PM Boxed Lunch/Exhibits<br />
Introduction of Elected Officials<br />
Students will have a separate NCLEX review session with lunch - Debbie Dillon, RN, MS<br />
1:45 – 2:45 PM ____ Internet Access to Medical Information: Michelle Bealieu, RN<br />
____ <strong>The</strong> Genetics of Breast Cancer: Maimon Cohen, PhD and Karen Eanet, RN, MS<br />
What you should know about genetic research and counseling related to breast cancer<br />
____ Practice & Education “Workplace Violence” a growing issue for nursing<br />
Kathleen White, RN, PhD<br />
Participants will be invited at the end of the session to participate in the development of<br />
a white paper for MNA on workplace violence.<br />
2:45 – 3:30 PM 2000 Poster Session (Contact Hours available for posters)<br />
Exhibits/Door Prizes/Refreshments<br />
5:30 – 6:30 PM Evening Keynote: Linda Stierle, ANA Executive Director<br />
6:30 PM Dinner (Chose one: Anyone who does not identify a choice will receive Salmon)<br />
____ Hickory Smoked Prime Ribeye of Beef<br />
____ Pan Seared Beijing Salmon Filet<br />
7:30 PM Program (Please wear your nursing pin and if you have it bring your school cap)<br />
Announcement of 2001 Convention, District 4<br />
Friday, November 10, 2000<br />
8:15 AM Full Seated Breakfast<br />
8:45 – 9:30 AM Breakfast Speaker: Dr. Georges Benjamin, Secretary of the Department of Health and Mental<br />
Hygiene<br />
9:30 – 10:00 AM Awards Presentation<br />
10:15 AM – 12:15 PM Annual Business Meeting<br />
Special Requirements: Anyone requiring special ac<strong>com</strong>modations, requirements or meals must contact MNA no<br />
later than September 15, 2000, to ensure that we will be able to meet your needs.<br />
Accreditation: Contact Hours will be offered for all educational sessions and the poster session.
• PAGE P GE 22 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
Anatomy of a Consortium<br />
Debbie Kisner RN, MS, CNOR<br />
Debbie is a Clinical <strong>Nurse</strong><br />
Specialist and Educational<br />
Coordinator for the Surgical<br />
Services Line at Franklin<br />
Square Hospital Center. She<br />
has 22 years experience in<br />
perioperative services. She is<br />
a founding member and past<br />
chair of the Chesapeake<br />
Critical Care Consortium. She<br />
currently chairs the Kisher<br />
Chesapeake Bay Perioperative<br />
Consortium of which she is also a founding member.<br />
It has been my experience that my time has be<strong>com</strong>e<br />
more and more of a <strong>com</strong>modity in the workplace.<br />
Education departments are constantly inundated with<br />
requests for educational programs to bridge the gap from<br />
new grad to practicing RN. This is certainly no surprise<br />
knowing that it is near impossible for the nursing school<br />
curriculum to prepare new grads for each and every type<br />
of nursing in which they may choose to work.<br />
Additionally, there are many more opportunities available<br />
in today’s workplace other than bedside in-hospital nursing,<br />
and clinical rotation time can’t explore them all.<br />
<strong>The</strong> face of healthcare has also changed dramatically<br />
over the last decade. <strong>The</strong>se changes have made it necessary<br />
for many practicing nurses to develop new skills and<br />
<strong>com</strong>petencies. Consequently, educators are getting an<br />
equally staggering number of requests for educational programs<br />
to transition experienced nurses from one clinical<br />
specialty to another. To add to this growing demand, statistics<br />
show that we are in the throes of yet another nursing<br />
shortage. It is estimated that there is one nurse entering<br />
the workforce to replace every four that retire.<br />
Although not exclusive to any one area, the higher<br />
demands for skilled nurses have emerged in highly specialized<br />
areas such as critical care, and perioperative<br />
services.<br />
100<br />
Institutions have developed their own training 80<br />
programs for nurses in order to staff their special- 60<br />
40<br />
ty areas. While this process has been education- 20<br />
ally effective it has most certainly not been cost<br />
0<br />
effective. Frequently these programs are run for<br />
a handful of participants. Typical length for the<br />
didactic portion may be anywhere from several<br />
days to several weeks depending on the area.<br />
Your educator would be tied up with this program<br />
for the entire time and not be able to <strong>com</strong>plete or<br />
even work on any other projects until the students move on<br />
to the clinical portion, which is traditionally <strong>com</strong>pleted<br />
with a preceptor. This is usually not the best use of time<br />
for an educator. Some institutions do not have educators<br />
who can pull together such a specialty education package.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y must either pull expert staff away from patient care<br />
to fill this void or send employees to an outside program<br />
for big bucks, if such a program does even exist. <strong>The</strong> good<br />
news is the <strong>Maryland</strong> General Assembly has introduced<br />
emergency bills to create a Statewide Commission on the<br />
Crisis in Nursing to address the critical nursing shortage.<br />
<strong>The</strong> bad news is, this will not help us today. So, how do<br />
you do more with less?<br />
One way our institution has been able to work smarter<br />
rather than harder is through the use of specialty consortiums.<br />
Forming consortiums to assist with our already<br />
overloaded plates has proved to be an innovative and cost<br />
effective way to provide the needed education. By definition,<br />
a consortium is a coalition for a venture requiring vast<br />
resources. In practice, consortiums are multi-institution<br />
groups who band together with the <strong>com</strong>mon goal of providing<br />
specific education to a large number of individuals.<br />
6<br />
4<br />
2<br />
0<br />
Through consortiums you can provide quality education<br />
for a fraction of the time it would take to implement the<br />
entire program alone.<br />
I have had the unique opportunity to be in from ground<br />
level formation of two consortiums in this area, the<br />
Chesapeake Critical Care Consortium, and the Chesapeake<br />
Bay Perioperative Consortium. Both were formed in<br />
1994<br />
1996<br />
Figure 1<br />
Number of Classes per Year<br />
Critical Care Consortium<br />
Yr-1994 Yr -1995 Yr-1996 Yr -1997 Yr-1998 Yr -1999 Yr -2000<br />
Figure 2<br />
Average Attendance per Class<br />
Critical Care Consortium<br />
1998<br />
2000<br />
Class 1<br />
Class 2<br />
Class 3<br />
Class 4<br />
Class 5<br />
Class 6<br />
response to the growing demand for educational programs<br />
for their respective specialty areas.<br />
Church Hospital, Franklin Square Hospital Center,<br />
Harbor Hospital Center, <strong>Maryland</strong> General Hospital,<br />
Mercy Medical Center, Sinai Hospital, and Union<br />
Memorial Hospital with AACN as the sponsoring body<br />
formed the Chesapeake Critical Care Consortium in 1994.<br />
After our debut class in October 1994, we began offering<br />
a ten-day critical care course three times per year. Member<br />
institutions were allowed to send an unlimited number of<br />
participants. Diligent review of the course and evaluations<br />
allowed us to revise the content and decrease the course to<br />
nine days. With rising attendance and membership, we<br />
decided to increase the number of times the course was<br />
offered. As attendance and membership continued to rise,<br />
we continued to increase the number of class offerings (See<br />
Figure 1). When we reached six times per year, we could not<br />
go any higher. At this point we decided to limit the number<br />
of participants per member institution. We also noticed that<br />
we had higher attendance on the EKG days, so we started<br />
offering those days separately as a basic EKG course in addition<br />
to offering them as part of the nine day course. All of<br />
these efforts allowed us to continue to present a quality program<br />
yet keep the class size manageable (See Figure 2). In<br />
Consortium cont. on pg. 23
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 23 •<br />
Consortium cont. from pg. 22<br />
addition to the basic and EKG courses, we have also been<br />
able to offer advanced cardiac and respiratory programs. Our<br />
current membership has grown to 19 institutions and we have<br />
provided critical care education for more than 1100 nurses.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Chesapeake Bay Perioperative Consortium was<br />
formed in 1999 in response to a severe shortage of perioperative<br />
nurses. <strong>The</strong> program has been presented three<br />
times with class size in the 30-40 range. Our current<br />
membership boasts 18 member institutions. We began<br />
with a nine-day course in September 1999. Once again,<br />
conscientious review of the course and evaluations<br />
allowed us to decrease the didactic course to six days.<br />
Although we are in the infant stages of development, we<br />
have already provided perioperative education for over<br />
100 nurses. We plan to offer the course three times per<br />
year.<br />
Consortiums provide an excellent opportunity to share<br />
knowledge and expertise. You have the ability to provide<br />
content experts each and every class. Students get the<br />
most up to date knowledge designed to mirror national<br />
standards rather than institutional idiosyncrasies. You<br />
need to teach only a few hours rather than a few days or<br />
weeks. This frees up your time to do other projects. Never<br />
underestimate the ability to network. You have a direct<br />
contact with the outside world that allows you easy access<br />
to policies, <strong>com</strong>munity standards, employee and student<br />
job references, and educational programs. This is also a<br />
good place to survey for best practices. A final benefit I<br />
personally have reaped from consortium participation is<br />
friendship. I have had the privilege of working with some<br />
extremely talented and knowledgeable colleagues. We<br />
have a great team spirit in both consortiums, which has<br />
made our work successful and quite enjoyable.<br />
Although consortium participation has worked well for<br />
our institution, it may not be right for your institution. One<br />
downside is that you are <strong>com</strong>mitted to providing the same<br />
support (teaching hours) for each offering whether you<br />
send ten participants or zero. You will need to travel to<br />
various institutions for meetings and course presentations.<br />
You may not be able to present your favorite topic. <strong>The</strong>re<br />
is a lot of negotiation involved in content assignment.<br />
Some individuals may be more limited in their expertise<br />
and will have a smaller range of topics they can present.<br />
You need to be flexible and open minded. Just make sure<br />
that you understand what you are <strong>com</strong>mitting to before you<br />
sign on the dotted line to avoid confusion and hard feelings<br />
in the future.<br />
If you are interested in forming your own consortium,<br />
here are a few basics to get you started. First, talk with<br />
your colleagues to see if there is a need for the type of program<br />
you are looking for. Consortiums work best for<br />
longer programs that run over multiple days rather than<br />
several-hour workshops. Are there established programs<br />
out there? Is there a National curriculum? Who would be<br />
interested in participating? After you have established the<br />
need, get the group together and set down some formal<br />
ideas. Make sure you agree on your mission and vision<br />
before you jump into the course outline. Also be sure to<br />
include responsibilities for each member institution, such<br />
as meeting attendance, lecture hours, backup hours,<br />
development of handouts and test questions, reproduction<br />
of materials, hosting the course, chairing the group, and<br />
contract approval to name a few. Also consider how<br />
often you will offer the program, if there will be a fee and<br />
if so what the fee will be, if refreshments will be provided<br />
and by whom, if contact hours will be offered, and if<br />
you need to limit the number of participants. Keep in<br />
mind that all duties and responsibilities should be shared<br />
equally. You will also need to spell out the consequences<br />
of not fulfilling your obligations. Also, decide if and<br />
when you will take on new member institutions and how<br />
you will deal with outside participants (non-member<br />
institutions). All of these points need to be in writing.<br />
Signing of the contract will denote agreement.<br />
As you develop your course outline include the topics<br />
and their presentation times. Remember to include ample<br />
time each day for breaks and lunch. Consider the spacing<br />
between class days. You don’t want to overload the<br />
participants, yet you don’t want to space the classes so far<br />
apart that there is poor retention of material. If some of<br />
the material requires hands-on skills, you may want to<br />
space the didactic portions every other day so that the<br />
participants can practice the skill they learned about the<br />
next day while it is fresh in their minds. Unfortunately,<br />
you are most probably at the mercy of the conference<br />
room schedule, meaning you take what’s available.<br />
Don’t forget to include extra days and an emergency plan<br />
if your course is being offered during the snowy season.<br />
Decide how you will measure out<strong>com</strong>es. At a very<br />
minimum you will need to develop a program evaluation.<br />
If you will test participants, you will need to decide what<br />
will be tested, how the test will be constructed, when the<br />
exams should be inserted into the overall course outline,<br />
and what constitutes a passing score. Program evaluations<br />
and tests should be reviewed after each course<br />
offering so that revisions are made on an ongoing basis.<br />
A final word of advice is, keep things simple. Use<br />
the best practices from each institution rather than<br />
recreating the entire program. Look at established consortiums<br />
and learn from their mistakes. Your consortium<br />
doesn’t have to be a clone of them. This is your<br />
program, so make it work for the members of your<br />
group.
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 25 •<br />
This publication is provided to you by the <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association.<br />
Without MNA, this is what you would be reading to keep you informed about nursing<br />
Is this enough to keep you on top of nursing’s issues?<br />
MNA<br />
Working to assure quality healthcare for all people by protecting and enhancing<br />
professional nursing in all environments.<br />
Are you a member?<br />
Join us today... You can use the membership application found in this issue.
• PAGE P GE 26 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Delegation Travels to Indianapolis<br />
For ANA House of Delegates Meeting<br />
<strong>The</strong> ANA 2000 House of Delegates meeting took place in<br />
Indianapolis, Indiana, June 23 – 28, 2000, and <strong>Maryland</strong> was<br />
well represented and well prepared. <strong>Maryland</strong> had eight delegates<br />
attend this key ANA meeting. <strong>The</strong>y included Sandy<br />
Bryan (District 4), Fran Damratowski (District 3), Paul<br />
Kulp (District 5), Roberta Niklewski (District 8), Nayna<br />
Philipsen (District 2), Carlene Spangler (District 7),<br />
Catherine Vestraci (District 9) and MNA President Mary<br />
Beachley.<br />
This was a key meeting not only for ANA but also for<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> and other constituent members of ANA who do not<br />
actively engage in collective bargaining. Aspecial bylaws proposal<br />
was on the floor of the House that would establish a formal<br />
Workplace Advocacy structure within ANA. <strong>The</strong> adoption<br />
of these bylaws would elevate the importance of supporting<br />
nurses through means other than collective bargaining for<br />
those state associations who are not bargaining agents. In<br />
addition to this important issue, the House dealt with a number<br />
of other key concerns affecting the association and nursing.<br />
This was also an election year and the House voted on a number<br />
of ANA offices including the election of a new President.<br />
ANA House of<br />
Delegates Report<br />
One of the highlights of this<br />
years Convention was an address<br />
given by Tipper Gore, wife of<br />
Vice President and Presidential<br />
candidate Al Gore. Mrs. Gore<br />
serves as President Clinton’s<br />
mental health policy adviser.<br />
She gave a speech that focused<br />
on mental health concerns,<br />
telling the nurses in attendance<br />
that acceptance was still the most<br />
difficult thing to ac<strong>com</strong>plish with<br />
mental illness. She called for<br />
more information and education.<br />
Mrs. Gore mixed her serious<br />
message with some good humor,<br />
but declined to address her husband’s<br />
thoughts about a possible<br />
running mate. I wonder if it<br />
could be a nurse?<br />
Pictures in this “ANA House of Delegates Report” were provided by Delegate<br />
Fran Damratowski.<br />
by Mary Beachley<br />
MNA has been very influential in moving the agenda<br />
of the non-collective bargaining states within the ANA<br />
organization. Kathy Hall, executive director of MNA, has<br />
served as Chair of the Workplace Advocacy Coalition that<br />
represents more than 40 member states. <strong>The</strong>se states use<br />
workplace advocacy strategies as a means to address<br />
workplace issues for nurses. <strong>The</strong> Workplace Advocacy<br />
Coalition was successful in passing an ANA bylaws<br />
change to create the Commission on Workplace<br />
Advocacy during the ANA 2000 Convention in<br />
Indianapolis.<br />
<strong>The</strong> work of the ANA 2000 Convention delegates was<br />
very relevant to all practicing nurses. <strong>The</strong> House of<br />
Delegates heard hearings on topics of staffing levels, use<br />
of mandatory overtime, restraint of trade against advanced<br />
practice nurses, patient safety, reduction of the use of<br />
patient restraints, pain assessment, violent behavior of<br />
youth in schools and registered nurses as first assistants. I<br />
will summarize the out<strong>com</strong>e of the discussions on three<br />
major issues that were addressed, (1) mandatory overtime,<br />
(2) IOM report, and (3) threat to advanced practice nurses.<br />
More detail on these hearings is presented in other<br />
articles in this newsletter.<br />
Mandatory overtime:<br />
A reference hearing was held on the use of mandatory<br />
overtime as a staffing solution. Many nurses across the<br />
country are voicing concern about inadequate staffing and<br />
are struggling with unsafe overtime work hours to meet<br />
patient care needs. It was pointed out that recent research<br />
on fatigue supported the nurses concern that overtime can<br />
contribute to medical errors. <strong>The</strong>re are currently laws that<br />
regulate the number of hours that pilots and truck drivers<br />
can work. <strong>The</strong>se laws are based on the relationship<br />
between hours worked and fatigue. <strong>The</strong> goal is to reduce<br />
fatigue that contributes to human error. <strong>Nurse</strong>s are not<br />
flying planes or driving trucks but they are providing<br />
patient care that includes giving medications and using<br />
equipment that could be a threat to life or produce an<br />
undesired out<strong>com</strong>e for the patient if an error is made. As<br />
a result of this hearing, the House voted to oppose manda-<br />
Pre-House of Delegates meeting of the <strong>Maryland</strong> Delegation. Pictured left to right<br />
are: Paul Kulp, Carlene Spangler, Roberta Niklewski, Sandy Bryan, Mary<br />
Beachley, Cathy Vestraci and Kathy Hall<br />
MNA Involved in Creation of New ANA Structure<br />
tory overtime and directed the Board and ANA staff to<br />
work with appropriate organizations, agencies, and legislators<br />
to promote safe staffing levels while finding alternative<br />
solutions to staffing that does not include mandatory<br />
overtime.<br />
IOM Report:<br />
Patient safety as a vital <strong>com</strong>ponent of quality care was<br />
discussed in relation to the 1999 Institute of Medicine<br />
(IOM) report, “To Err is Human.” This topic was part of<br />
a reference hearing where re<strong>com</strong>mendations were made<br />
for ANA to support the specific IOM re<strong>com</strong>mendations<br />
and promote nursing research on patient safety. Also, a<br />
plenary session, “Stopping the Blame Game”, was devoted<br />
to the topic of errors. <strong>The</strong> emphasis of this session was<br />
on promoting blame-free work environments, which use<br />
quality improvement methods to improve the systems in<br />
order to eliminate errors. Many nurses from across the<br />
country working in various practice settings identified<br />
patient safety as a major concern.<br />
Threat to Advanced Practice <strong>Nurse</strong>s:<br />
<strong>The</strong> American Medical Association’s (AMA) Citizen’s<br />
Petition received an emergency hearing in the convention<br />
reference hearings. <strong>The</strong> AMA has sent this petition only<br />
to physicians (not to the public). <strong>The</strong> AMA intends to file<br />
these signed petitions with the Health Care Finance<br />
Administration (HCFA) to demand implementation of a<br />
system to ensure that Medicare reimbursement to <strong>Nurse</strong><br />
Practitioners (NPs) and Clinical <strong>Nurse</strong> Specialists (CNSs)<br />
is made only if the services are furnished in collaboration<br />
with a physician. <strong>The</strong> petition essentially pressures<br />
HCFA to adopt a much more stringent and restrictive<br />
approach to “collaboration” than is reflected in the current<br />
regulations. <strong>The</strong> AMA is defining collaboration as supervision.<br />
This petition is seen by ANA as part of a larger<br />
campaign by the AMA, which is to promote an agenda<br />
that is not based on concerns for patient safety or enforcement<br />
of existing laws; rather its goal is to restrict the<br />
scope of practice of advanced practice nurses as well as<br />
other providers who are not physicians. <strong>Nurse</strong>s view this<br />
action by the AMA as an attempt to restrain trade.<br />
<strong>The</strong>refore, the ANA delegates voted to accept the re<strong>com</strong>mendation<br />
to have ANA staff and the Board develop an<br />
immediate rebuttal to the AMA petition and present it to<br />
HCFA.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> delegation worked diligently through<br />
the sessions of the House of Delegates to promote the passage<br />
of the Bylaws change to create a Workplace<br />
Advocacy Commission within the ANA organizational<br />
structure and to amend certain re<strong>com</strong>mendations that<br />
were put before the house. <strong>The</strong> delegates, who have<br />
attended previous conventions, <strong>com</strong>mented that this<br />
House of Delegates was the most effective for collaborative<br />
action and <strong>com</strong>promise to define and set priorities<br />
that would benefit all nurses.<br />
If you would like more detail on the reference hearing<br />
out<strong>com</strong>es or the convention activities, please contact your<br />
district delegate or the MNA office.<br />
As you can see from the ANA Convention summary,<br />
this is a critical time for our nursing profession. We all<br />
need to be alert to the ongoing threats to our practice and<br />
act proactively as well as reactively to these threats.<br />
Information is power but only if it is current and, in this<br />
fast paced information age, information must be timely.<br />
Each of us can contribute to the future of our profession<br />
by being informed and acting through our professional<br />
nursing association. MNA needs your continued support<br />
through your membership as well as your support for your<br />
elected MNA leaders in the districts and the state.
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 27 •<br />
ANA House of Delegates Report<br />
Paul Kulp addressing ANA House of Delegates<br />
International Nursing:<br />
Developing NNA to NNA Partnerships<br />
by Carlene Spangler<br />
This proposal , submitted by the South Dakota <strong>Nurse</strong>s<br />
Association, challenges ANA to promote and strengthen<br />
nursing globally through greater involvement with other<br />
national nurses organizations. <strong>The</strong> report builds on the<br />
19991 house action that directed ANA to facilitate the<br />
establishment of relationships between other countries’<br />
nurses association and state nurses associations. This proposal<br />
meets all ANA core issues.<br />
In recent years, concerns over domestic issues within<br />
the ANA have overshadowed a parallel focus on international<br />
issues. International involvement is important and<br />
necessary for the association in fulfilling its mission both<br />
domestically and abroad in the future. This proposal may<br />
allow opportunities to seek solutions to some of the recurrent<br />
American nursing issues and could provide the structure<br />
and consultation for countries that wish to form professional<br />
nursing associations. <strong>The</strong> proposal includes re<strong>com</strong>mendations<br />
to: “Explore the feasibility of an exchange<br />
program or partnership with one or more NNAs,” and to<br />
“Engage in collaborative exchanges with nurses of the<br />
international <strong>com</strong>munity with focus on achievement, partnerships,<br />
flexibility, inclusiveness, and vision.”<br />
This proposal met with some concern in the House of<br />
Delegates due to finances. A delegate suggested that the<br />
goals of the proposal needed to be more focused with welldefined<br />
out<strong>com</strong>es and future expenses articulated in light<br />
of ANA’s current budget deficit. Members of the finance<br />
<strong>com</strong>mittee clarified the fiscal implications, stating that<br />
only $29,800 of new costs would be incurred. <strong>The</strong><br />
Director of the International Nursing Center stressed the<br />
need to address nursing issues at local, state, national, and<br />
international levels. She contended that ANA should pay<br />
attention to nursing and health concerns around the world.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> delegation was in agreement with this position.<br />
This proposal was approved with a final vote of: 414<br />
voting yes; 143 voting no, and 3 abstentions.<br />
Cathy Vestraci, Carlene Spangler, and Nanya<br />
Philipsen at <strong>Maryland</strong> Caucus meeting<br />
Caucus meeting in Indianapolis: Mary Beachley, Roberta Niklewski, Paul Kulp<br />
and Sandy Bryan<br />
Suspension of MIP<br />
by Carlene Spangler<br />
<strong>The</strong> Membership Incentive Program (MIP) was created<br />
at a time when Constituent Member Associations (CMA)<br />
were expending significant financial resources in the area<br />
of membership recruitment. <strong>The</strong> MIP created a financial<br />
partnership with ANA which allowed CMAs to keep a portion<br />
of their membership dues each year. Over the last few<br />
years, ANA has begun to experience financial difficulties.<br />
ANA has not had a dues increase since 1989 and inflation<br />
has increased by 32%. During these years, ANA has also<br />
<strong>com</strong>mitted considerable financial resources to membership<br />
recruitment and retention. <strong>The</strong> ANA Board of<br />
Directors had planned on bringing a proposal to the 2000<br />
House of Delegates for a dues increase. In April of 2000,<br />
however, ANA’s constituent members raised strong opposition<br />
to an increase in dues. Other steps became necessary<br />
to ensure ANA’s financial viability. This proposal,<br />
submitted by the President and the ANA Board of<br />
Directors, would reduce financial obligations. <strong>The</strong> re<strong>com</strong>mendation<br />
is to: “Suspend the Membership In Incentive<br />
Program to be<strong>com</strong>e effective with the 2000 dues year and<br />
to continue until such time as it is brought back to the<br />
House of Delegates for reinstatement.”<br />
Some delegates objected to this proposal citing ways in<br />
which the extra money had been helpful to CMA’s and<br />
expressing concern that lack of money night harm the<br />
smaller CMA’s. Most delegates, including the <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
Delegation, supported this proposal, feeling it represented<br />
sound financial management by ANA. It was decided to<br />
add an additional re<strong>com</strong>mendation to the proposal to<br />
“Develop alternatives for recruitment and association<br />
image enhancement.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> proposal was approved with a final vote of: 474<br />
voting yes, 66 voting no, and 7 abstentions.
• PAGE P GE 28 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
ANA House of Delegates Report<br />
Nanya Philipsen, Paul Kulp and Cathy Vestraci on House floor. <strong>Maryland</strong> Delegation in Indianapolis, It wasn’t all work.<br />
Building Safer Health Care Systems for Informed Patients<br />
by Bobbi Niklewski<br />
This is my third year as MNA District #8 delegate to the<br />
ANA Convention, and I can honestly say that this was the<br />
best House of Delegates I was ever a part of. <strong>The</strong> spirit of<br />
cooperation and <strong>com</strong>promise to make sure that the best<br />
interests of nurses and nursing were always the highest priority<br />
was the best I have ever witnessed. I was honored to<br />
be a part of this ANA Convention.<br />
Summary of Purpose: One of ANA’s core issues for<br />
year 2000 is “Patient Safety/Advocacy” with the potential<br />
to effect positive changes for patients by demonstrating the<br />
linkage between nurse staffing and the prevention of<br />
patient adverse events and errors. While errors may be<br />
more easily detected in hospitals, they occur in every<br />
health care setting, and using even the lower estimate,<br />
more people die of medical mistakes each year than from<br />
highway accidents, breast cancer, or AIDS (Centers for<br />
Disease Control, 1999).<br />
This re<strong>com</strong>mendation, “Building Safer Health Care<br />
Systems for Informed Patients,” was submitted by the<br />
ANA Board of Directors, and focused on the issue of errors<br />
as cited in the Institute of Medicine (IOM) report “To Err<br />
is Human: Building a Safer Health System” (Kohn,<br />
Corrigan, Donaldson, 1999). This major policy paper<br />
addressed the contributing factors, such as <strong>com</strong>plex systems<br />
and technology, inappropriate staffing, and unskilled<br />
workers, and has focused the attention of Congress, policy<br />
agencies, and the health care industry on the seriousness of<br />
these issues.<br />
ANA has long recognized this problem and has worked<br />
to address issues related to nursing care that enhance<br />
patient safety and out<strong>com</strong>es for many years. All speakers<br />
in Reference Hearing C on June 25th supported the report<br />
with only a few changes that urged ANA to take the lead<br />
regarding the importance of patient safety and not just support<br />
the IOM report.<br />
<strong>The</strong> final Re<strong>com</strong>mendation that was supported by<br />
the <strong>Maryland</strong> Delegation and approved by the HOD on<br />
June 28, 2000, at an estimated cost of $281,000 moved that<br />
the ANA:<br />
• Promote awareness among the public and<br />
policymakers about the effects of health care system<br />
downsizing, restructuring, and reorganization<br />
that undermines quality and safety of patient care.<br />
• Support the IOM re<strong>com</strong>mendations.<br />
• Promote passage of whistle blower legislation that<br />
protects the essential role of nurses in efforts to correct<br />
system errors.<br />
• Continue the implementation of strategies identified<br />
in the 1998 HOD action report “Shared<br />
Accountability in Today’s Work Environment.”<br />
• Promote nursing research on patient safety.<br />
• Educate nurses on the science of system safety and<br />
system safety issues.<br />
• Work with the Agency for Healthcare Quality and<br />
Research and other organizations to make quality of<br />
care and patient safety a priority.<br />
• Promote development and implementation of policies<br />
that support:<br />
- Development and utilization of safe standardized<br />
procedures for the use of medical devices.<br />
- Adequate and appropriate nurse staffing levels;<br />
- Improved information-sharing among practitioners<br />
treating the same patient;<br />
- Continuing education, enhancement of knowledge<br />
and technical skills of practitioners;<br />
- Demonstrated improvement of quality of care and<br />
reduction of errors through collection of data<br />
using nursing quality indicators.
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 29 •<br />
ANA House of Delegates Report<br />
Safer Staffing Levels/APRN Access to<br />
Medicare Reimbursement<br />
by Catherine Vestraci<br />
Hearing A consisted of two pre-scheduled action<br />
reports dealing with safer staffing issues and the addition<br />
of an emergency action report to oppose the<br />
American Medical Association’s (AMA) attempt to discredit<br />
APRN access to Medicare reimbursement. <strong>The</strong>se<br />
were very intense issues that the House of Delegates<br />
(HOD) was quite prepared to address. Many delegates<br />
spoke to endorse action and fine tune each re<strong>com</strong>mendation.<br />
<strong>The</strong> first action report about “Identifying Adequate<br />
and Appropriate Registered <strong>Nurse</strong> Staffing Levels<br />
Where Health Care Services are Delivered” was submitted<br />
by the Congress on Nursing Practice and<br />
Economics (CNPE). Much discussion ensued and<br />
numerous states proposed changes at both the hearing<br />
forum and HOD meetings that provided language to<br />
include staffing decisions based on nursing assessments<br />
and direct-care RNs participation. Massachusetts was<br />
instrumental in motions to hone the wording of the re<strong>com</strong>mendation,<br />
which passed with a strong 97.7%.<br />
Re<strong>com</strong>mendation 2, which was also introduced by<br />
the CNPE, probably elicited the most emotional discussion<br />
as it dealt with mandatory overtime as a staffing<br />
solution. <strong>The</strong> HOD unanimously decided that consideration<br />
of any model process for assignment of overtime<br />
was promotional, in nature, to the practice, and unacceptable<br />
as it would, in itself, endorse its continued use.<br />
Patient abandonment was the other concern in regards<br />
to a nurse’s decision to reject additional hours of work.<br />
Patient/ Workplace<br />
Safety<br />
by Paul Kulp<br />
<strong>The</strong> 2000 ANA HOD passed two Action Reports or<br />
motions relevant to patient and/or workplace safety.<br />
<strong>The</strong> first was “Reduction of Patient Restraint and<br />
Seclusion in Health Care Settings.” <strong>The</strong> House directed<br />
ANA to establish a policy paper on patient restraint and<br />
seclusion to provide direction for nursing practice in<br />
varied settings. Delegates made amendments to the<br />
original action report to ensure that such a policy would<br />
include principles of evidenced-based practice, assessment<br />
by an appropriately licensed practitioner (including<br />
a RN), and the protection of human rights. <strong>The</strong><br />
House also added that ANA should establish a position<br />
statement to provide direction for nursing practice in the<br />
use of chemical restraint.<br />
MNA President Mary Beachley making statement to the full ANA House<br />
Guides for nursing code, regulatory and case law,<br />
advisory opinions and position statements were cited as<br />
guides for defining patient abandonment for validation<br />
of nurses’ decision to reject mandatory overtime.<br />
Building on research to examine the relationship<br />
between hours worked and the ability to provide safe<br />
care was included, as well as providing a tool which<br />
defines a nurse’s rights and responsibilities when faced<br />
with overtime. <strong>The</strong> HOD clearly sought to strengthen<br />
the action report in an attempt to advocate for safe<br />
patient care by advocating safe nursing practice.<br />
Re<strong>com</strong>mendation 2 passed with a 97.8%.<br />
<strong>The</strong> last action report of Hearing A was an emergency,<br />
on-site, addition by ANA president, Mary Foley, to<br />
oppose the “AMA Citizens’ Petition to HCFA”. This<br />
petition is an AMA attempt to undermine APRNs ability<br />
to independently bill Medicare. Ohio and Maine APRN<br />
delegates repeatedly spoke to the severity of consequences<br />
from AMA’s recent effort. <strong>The</strong> HOD stood in<br />
full support of opposing such a petition of manipulation<br />
as it passed with a 92.8% vote.<br />
<strong>The</strong> HOD was impressively unified as it collectively<br />
did much work to have ANA stand firm in all three current,<br />
critical issues faced by nursing.<br />
During pre-convention discussions and on-site caucuses,<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> delegates endorsed each re<strong>com</strong>mendation<br />
of Hearing A. With our own participating legal<br />
counsel, N. Philipsen, we were able to be informed<br />
endorses when we voted on accepting guides for patient<br />
abandonment in relation to opposing mandatory overtime.<br />
<strong>The</strong> delegates of <strong>Maryland</strong> were in full support of<br />
proposed ANA directives to facilitate firm positions and<br />
promote the Workplace Advocacy issues.<br />
Violent Behavior of<br />
Youth in School<br />
Settings<br />
by Paul Kulp<br />
In a second Action Report, entitled “Nursing’s<br />
Response to Violent Behavior of Youth in School<br />
Settings,” <strong>The</strong> House directed ANA to address youth<br />
violence In the public schools by advancing nursing<br />
education in the identification of Youth violence and<br />
its root causes, by promoting multiple strategies including<br />
conflict resolution to address the issue, and by promoting<br />
adequate numbers of nurses in all school and<br />
educational systems. A MNA delegate attempted to add<br />
language supporting alternatives to incarceration as a<br />
response to youth violence and the provision of adequate<br />
<strong>com</strong>prehensive mental health services to this<br />
population, but the amending motion was defeated.<br />
RN First Assistant<br />
Nayna Philipsen<br />
<strong>The</strong> purpose of this action report was to emphasize<br />
the need for ANA to support federal activities supporting<br />
the role of the registered nurse surgical first assistant.<br />
Lack of Medicare reimbursement for RNFAs is a<br />
“significant barrier to their full scope of practice.”<br />
HCFA requires master’s preparation for direct reimbursement.<br />
HR 3911 was introduced to provide coverage<br />
under Medicare for RNFAs.<br />
<strong>The</strong> original re<strong>com</strong>mendation was for the ANA to<br />
“advocate” for federal legislative and regulatory<br />
actions that “support” the role and scope of practice of<br />
the RN as surgical first assistant. That was changed<br />
after hearing to “seek passage of federal and state legislation<br />
and regulatory actions that will “protect” the<br />
role and scope of practice of the RN as surgical first<br />
assistant.<br />
Also as part of the original re<strong>com</strong>mendation was for<br />
ANA to implement strategies to address threats to practice<br />
for the RNFA. That changed after hearing to “support<br />
the utilization of only appropriately credentialed<br />
RNFAs, qualified nurse practitioners, nurse midwives,<br />
clinical nurse specialists, physicians, and physician<br />
assistants as first assistants.” <strong>The</strong> House of Delegates<br />
accepted that wording, but deleting all wording after<br />
RNFAs.<br />
<strong>The</strong> original re<strong>com</strong>mendation was to amend ANA<br />
position statement on RNFA “qualifications” to include<br />
requirement for certification as registered nurse first<br />
assistant. That was changed after hearing to “Support<br />
collaboration with appropriate nursing organizations to<br />
develop and implement basic perioperative nursing<br />
curricula in schools of nursing and a masters degree<br />
program in RNFAs.” <strong>The</strong> proposal to support a master’s<br />
degree program was very contentiously debated<br />
by the House of Delegates. Supporting states argued<br />
that a master’s degree “might raise the bar” which they<br />
clearly did not want to do. <strong>The</strong>y argued that RNFA is<br />
an expanded role, not an advanced practice. Other delegates<br />
argued that enhancing <strong>com</strong>petence is our professional<br />
duty, and were concerned that “dumbing down”<br />
the substance of the RNFA’s preparation weakens ANA<br />
efforts to successfully promote legislation protecting<br />
exclusive practice, reimbursement, and safety. <strong>The</strong><br />
final re<strong>com</strong>mendation omitted the master’s degree program.<br />
<strong>The</strong> final re<strong>com</strong>mendations passed. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
delegation supported these re<strong>com</strong>mendations. <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Delegates also support demonstrated <strong>com</strong>petence<br />
<strong>com</strong>mensurate with responsibility. That includes<br />
encouraging the development of educational programs<br />
that maximize both professional <strong>com</strong>petence, and citizen<br />
confidence and safety.
• PAGE P GE 30 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
ANA Election Results 2000<br />
American <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association delegates elected Mary<br />
E. Foley, MS, RN to serve a two-year term as president<br />
of the nation’s leading professional organization representing<br />
the major health policy, practice, and workplace<br />
issues of registered nurses in the United States. Foley<br />
assumed the role of president in January 2000 when<br />
Beverly L. Malone, vacated the position to accept the<br />
position of Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Department<br />
of Health and Human Services. <strong>The</strong> full election results<br />
are as follows:<br />
President Mary E. Foley, MS, RN<br />
First Vice President Patricia W. Underwood, RN,<br />
PhD<br />
Second Vice President A. Louise Hart, RN, MSN,<br />
DNS<br />
Secretary Patricia S. Yoder-Wise, RN, C,<br />
EdD, CNAA, FAAN<br />
Treasurer Rebecca M. Patton, RN, MSN,<br />
CNOR<br />
Board of Directors Mary Lynn Behrens, BSN,<br />
MSN, FNPC, RN<br />
Christina L. Sieloff, RN, PhD,<br />
CAN<br />
Betty Smith Campbell, RN,<br />
ARNP, PhD<br />
Staff <strong>Nurse</strong> Board Positions Jan Bussert, RN<br />
Other elections include:<br />
Katheren Koehn, RN<br />
Chair of Constituent Assembly Mary Lou Burnnell,<br />
MSN, RN<br />
Chair of the UAN Cheryl Johnson, BSN,<br />
RN<br />
Congress on Nursing Practice and Economics:<br />
Joan M. Caley, RN, MS, CNAA, CS<br />
Naomi E. Ervin, PhD, RN, CS, FAAN<br />
Saul Josman, RN, BSN<br />
David R. Marshall, RN, BSN, JD<br />
Marva Wade, RN<br />
Nominating Committee:<br />
Patricia Ann DeShazer, RN, BSN<br />
Jujuan B. English, MSN, RN<br />
Miriam Gonzalez, RN, BS<br />
Sarah A. Liptak, RN, MSN<br />
NURSES FOR STATE OPERATED,<br />
JCAHO ACCREDITED<br />
PSYCHIATRIC HOSPITAL<br />
Registered <strong>Nurse</strong>s<br />
Starting salary $33,864 to $37,947<br />
depending on experience and<br />
credentials<br />
Licensed Practical <strong>Nurse</strong>s<br />
Starting salary $23,617 to $26,137<br />
depending on experience<br />
Full State of <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
benefits package<br />
Equal Opportunity Employer<br />
Contact Cathy Somerville,<br />
Director of Nursing<br />
Upper Shore<br />
Community Mental<br />
Health Center<br />
P.O. Box 229<br />
Chestertown, MD 21620<br />
410-778-6800 or call toll free<br />
888-784-0137, ext. 2109
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 31 •<br />
Letter to the Editor<br />
Dear Editor,<br />
I am starting to know how it must of felt in the west when<br />
the gold rush was over. Little by little your friends and<br />
neighbors packed it up and moved to some other town<br />
where new opportunities existed. Little by little there was<br />
no one left. Finally there were just ghost towns standing.<br />
Hospitals are feeling the shuffle of their workforce moving<br />
about like nomads grabbing up sign on bonuses. If your<br />
hospital does not pay your sign on bonuses you may be left<br />
in the ghost town.<br />
Are sign on bonuses the answer to the nursing shortage?<br />
From my lookout point I see people scrambling to go to<br />
work where the higher bonuses are, even if it means an extra<br />
hours drive to work. <strong>The</strong>y do that for a year then move onto<br />
another hospital still willing to pay even yet another sign on<br />
bonus. Sign on bonuses irritate established nurses who<br />
remain loyal to their hospital. <strong>The</strong>y create a disharmony<br />
between the efforts of retention and recruitment.<br />
I was very fortunate to start my nursing career on a nursing<br />
unit where I had a nursing leader who was very solid in<br />
her supervision but she was also skillful to gradually groom<br />
individuals to be<strong>com</strong>e autonomous. Nursing is not a job<br />
you can do alone. <strong>The</strong> greatest benefit in staying in one<br />
place for a long time is that you do be<strong>com</strong>e part of a team<br />
that represents a reliable place where the public can <strong>com</strong>e<br />
for care. Patients with chronic conditions grow to depend<br />
on continuity.<br />
It takes time for groups to unite and grow into thereaputic<br />
teams. Changing members of a work group because of<br />
turnover causes the groups to reform over and over. Just<br />
when you get into a predictable pattern someone leaves.<br />
Some of this turnover is expected but when it is excessive<br />
chaos can prevail.<br />
What would happen if hospitals just stopped giving sign<br />
on bonuses? Maybe some of the nomadic movement would<br />
end? Maybe some stability would emerge? What would<br />
happen if orientations were longer? <strong>The</strong> money used for<br />
sign on bonuses could be used instead on skillful staff<br />
development creating nurses that were more prepared to<br />
be<strong>com</strong>e autonomous to deal with the difficult job that nursing<br />
is.<br />
In my opinion the sink or swim mentality does not produce<br />
a good swimmer. Most people I know who were<br />
thrown in the water are just afraid of water. I feel the same<br />
thing applies to being thrown in with your idealistic nursing<br />
student mentality where theory and reality meet. Most people<br />
who are not adequately prepared for their new role are<br />
afraid of the reality. When they get in over their head or<br />
be<strong>com</strong>e frightened about making a serious mistake they<br />
leave the profession.<br />
So many times we speak about values. Taking care of<br />
patients is about producing a work force that understands<br />
the value of loyalty, responsibility, accountability, camaraderie,<br />
professionalism and caring about others as well as<br />
yourself. We have to care about our nurses, our physicians<br />
and all of the people who work to make health care a positive<br />
experience. <strong>Nurse</strong>s love their work when they are confident<br />
they are doing a good job and they are getting the<br />
support to make a difference. If you love your job you are<br />
more apt to stay.<br />
Sadly too, the nursing schools are having a difficult time<br />
recruiting students. This problem will take state and government<br />
interventions such as free tuition and room and<br />
board. <strong>The</strong> media could also help in the fight to foster a realistic<br />
image of nurses. I hope that our profession can work<br />
together to end the nurse shortage soon.<br />
Sincerely,<br />
Dora M. Long, RN
• PAGE P GE 32 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
Medication Errors<br />
by Georgia A. Martin,<br />
J.D., Ph.D., MSN, BSN, RN, CS-P<br />
With greater than 8,000 drugs to<br />
choose from, the most educated<br />
professional health care providers<br />
make medication errors, and somewhat<br />
less experienced providers<br />
<strong>com</strong>pound the problem. 1 <strong>The</strong><br />
Institute of Medicine’s report, To<br />
Err Is Human, indicated that<br />
approximately 3.75 billion drugs<br />
are administered annually to inpatients.<br />
In one large teaching hospital,<br />
the medication error rate was<br />
estimated to be 3.13%. However,<br />
acknowledged medication errors<br />
killed 7,391 people in 1993. 2<br />
Martin<br />
Ten <strong>com</strong>mon causes of medication errors are listed in<br />
Table 1. Other causes include infusion pump/parenteral<br />
administration errors, inadequate monitoring, faulty drug<br />
stocking or delivery methods, preparation errors, lack of<br />
standardization, and confusion about a patient’s identity.<br />
Table 1<br />
Ten Common Causes Of Medication Errors 3<br />
1. Sleep deprivation.<br />
2. Mental lapses and fatigue.<br />
3. Inadequate knowledge of drugs.<br />
4. Inadequate knowledge of a patient’s<br />
existing medical conditions.<br />
5. Use of multiple drugs<br />
6. Allergies.<br />
7. Deviations from medication rules and procedures.<br />
8. Faulty drug identification.<br />
9. Transcription and handwriting errors.<br />
10.Dosage errors.<br />
Legal Issues Regarding Medication Errors<br />
Of all malpractice claims filed, approximately 30%<br />
involve drug-related injuries. An average payment of<br />
$99,721 was made for 2,195 out of the 6,646 claims reported<br />
to the Physician Insurers Association of America during<br />
the period 1985 through 1992. 4 Anyone who manufactures,<br />
sales, distributes, prescribes, dispenses, or administers<br />
drugs, as well as, the health care facility that employees<br />
them or places the medication in their formulary can be sued<br />
for patient injuries. 5<br />
<strong>The</strong>ory of Liability<br />
If a health care provider sued for a medication error is<br />
found liable, it is generally under the theory of negligence.<br />
Negligence is a type of tort that arises from an injury caused<br />
by conduct that deviates from a “standard of care.” Medical<br />
malpractice is a type of negligence that denotes an injury to<br />
a patient caused by a health care provider’s conduct that<br />
deviates from professional standards of practice expected<br />
within the profession. In a malpractice claim based upon<br />
medication error, a jury assesses a healthcare provider’s<br />
conduct to determine whether it adhered to the professional<br />
standards of practice required by both his profession and the<br />
law. In determining the strength and weaknesses of the<br />
case, the plaintiffs and defendants hire expert witnesses<br />
with similar experiences and training in order to analyze the<br />
medical records and determine whether the health care<br />
provider’s actions were within acceptable standards of practice.<br />
Malpractice Defenses<br />
Defenses are legal justifications to escape liability from<br />
lawsuits. <strong>The</strong> traditional defenses to negligent medication<br />
injuries are discussed in Table 2.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Federal Tort Claims Act, which specifically protects<br />
federally employed health care providers from liability.<br />
Another defense deserving mention is the “learned<br />
intermediary” doctrine. Under this doctrine, drug manufacturers<br />
fulfill their duty to warn consumers about the hazards<br />
associated with their products by warning physicians of<br />
known risks, side effects, and contraindications. With limited<br />
exceptions, the prescriber determines which warnings<br />
to advise the patient of during the informed consent process.<br />
This doctrine implies that the manufacturer has accurately<br />
and <strong>com</strong>pletely informed the physician of all the risks<br />
associated with a particular drug. Some courts have refused<br />
to enforce the doctrine when the manufacturers’ warnings to<br />
physicians were inadequate or defective. A warning may be<br />
defective if it did not disclose safety and efficacy data to the<br />
FDA that should have been included in the product labeling.<br />
<strong>The</strong> adequacy of the warning depends on what risks are<br />
included on the label, whether the warnings were conveyed<br />
to the physician in an appropriate manner under the circumstances,<br />
and whether the risks were downplayed during<br />
aggressive marketing campaigns. 7<br />
Table 3<br />
Traditional Informed Consent Components<br />
1. <strong>The</strong> medical problem necessitating a proposed<br />
medication, treatment, or procedure.<br />
2. <strong>The</strong> therapy’s purpose, description, what is<br />
involved and probable out<strong>com</strong>e.<br />
3. Likely benefits.<br />
4. Probable <strong>com</strong>plications, temporary pain, or dis<br />
<strong>com</strong>fort.<br />
5. Probable permanent results, disfigurement, dis<br />
ability, scarring, and required care and related<br />
medical costs.<br />
6. Known, anticipated, or foreseeable material<br />
risks including possible death.<br />
7. Alternative procedures and treatments and their<br />
known side effects, risks, and benefits includ<br />
ing no treatment at all.<br />
8. <strong>The</strong> consequences and rights of the patient to<br />
refuse or withdraw consent for any reason.<br />
Informed Consent<br />
Prior to prescribing or administering new medications, as<br />
with all procedures or treatments, a health care provider<br />
must obtain the patient’s informed consent. Informed consent<br />
in this context involves the disclosure of the material<br />
risks, benefits, and alternatives to a medication. <strong>The</strong> adequacy<br />
of this disclosure often forms the basis of informed<br />
consent litigation. Traditional informed consent <strong>com</strong>ponents<br />
that need to be discussed with a patient are outlined in<br />
Table 3. Risks that usually need not be disclosed are those<br />
that are <strong>com</strong>monly known or remote unless the risk is<br />
deemed significant to the patient.<br />
<strong>The</strong> majority of states use the “reasonable practitioner”<br />
standard to determine the degree of disclosure required.<br />
This standard requires a practitioner to disclose the information<br />
that most practitioners in similar circumstances<br />
would disclose. Most of the remaining states use the “reasonable<br />
patient” standard which requires the practitioner to<br />
disclose the information that a reasonable patient in similar<br />
circumstances would want to know. A few states use the<br />
“subjective patient” standard which requires the practitioner<br />
to disclose that information which a particular patient<br />
would want to know. <strong>The</strong> courts do not generally accept<br />
this particular standard, however, because it is too susceptible<br />
to manipulation. 8<br />
<strong>The</strong> information in Table 4 can be used as a step-by-step<br />
guide for obtaining informed consent.<br />
Table 4<br />
Checklist for Obtaining Informed Consent<br />
✓ Use words, phrases, and language the patient<br />
understands.<br />
✓ Complete document of all discussions must<br />
be recorded in the medical record because<br />
these records may be used as evidence at trial.<br />
Documentation should include:<br />
• How much time was spent in the discus<br />
sion.<br />
• What was discussed.<br />
• Whether written information was provided.<br />
✓ Provide opportunities for the patient to ask ques<br />
tions.<br />
✓ Evaluate the patient’s level of understanding<br />
by asking questions and using a check sheet to<br />
be maintained as a permanent part of the medical<br />
record.<br />
Medical Errors cont. on pg. 33
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 33 •<br />
Medical Errors cont. from pg. 32<br />
Case Reviews<br />
In Harris County Hosp. Dist. v. Estrada, 9 a medical resident<br />
prescribed Bactrim for a 73-year-old patient. <strong>The</strong><br />
patient immediately had a reaction and died sixteen days<br />
later. <strong>The</strong> patient’s family sued the physician, the hospital,<br />
and the nursing, clerical and pharmacy staff. Prior to trial,<br />
the physician settled the claim against him for $230,000. At<br />
trial, it was learned that the defendants had relied on a <strong>com</strong>puter<br />
generated Medication Administration Record (MAR)<br />
which listed “no allergies” for the patient. <strong>The</strong> plaintiffs<br />
were able to show that the defendants had failed to thoroughly<br />
review the patient’s medical records for allergies or<br />
check the MARs for any inconsistencies. <strong>The</strong> court concluded<br />
that the defendant health care providers had failed<br />
their responsibilities to verify the appropriateness of the<br />
patient’s prescriptions and to bring potential problems to the<br />
attention of the prescriber. <strong>The</strong> plaintiffs were awarded<br />
$350,000 in damages.<br />
In Pellerin v. Humedicenters, Inc., 10 a patient was admitted<br />
to a hospital’s emergency department <strong>com</strong>plaining of<br />
chest pain. Following an evaluation by a staff physician, an<br />
intramuscular injection of Demerol and Vistaril was administered<br />
in the patient’s left hip. Subsequently, the patient<br />
sued when the site became irritated, painful, and red. At<br />
trial 10 years later, the defendant health care provider could<br />
not remember giving the injection. <strong>The</strong> patient’s medical<br />
records indicated that the provider had signed the medication<br />
administration sheet, but failed to document the time,<br />
location, or the injection technique. This lack of documentation<br />
allowed the jury to conclude that the injection had<br />
been administered improperly. <strong>The</strong> patient was awarded<br />
$90,000 in damages.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se cases illustrate that standards of practice for medication<br />
administration require health care providers to thoroughly<br />
assess the appropriateness of the proposed medication<br />
and to thoroughly document administration. In the first<br />
case, the failure of the defendant health care providers to<br />
assess for allergies caused the wrongful death of the patient<br />
and to a subsequent award to the surviving family members.<br />
In the second case, the failure of the provider to document<br />
the time, location, and injection technique led to a large<br />
award for the patient’s injuries.<br />
Risk Management: Prevention of Medication Errors<br />
Computer-based patient safety systems are currently<br />
being used by several hospitals to reduce medication errors.<br />
However, researchers warn that <strong>com</strong>puters are not errorfree,<br />
but create their own unique mistakes. Some hospitals<br />
have reduced their error rates by eliminating drugs with<br />
similar names, by standardizing drug orders, and revamping<br />
the process for ordering, dispensing, administering, and<br />
monitoring ¡drugs. Programming errors associated with<br />
<strong>com</strong>puterized patient controlled analgesia (PCAs) machines<br />
have been reduced by making user instructions short, clear,<br />
and easy to understand. Additional ways in which PCA<br />
related errors could be reduced would include decreasing<br />
the rates of machines that are infusing narcotics, and by frequently<br />
monitoring vital signs, oxygen saturation, capillary<br />
refill, and patient responsiveness. 11<br />
Some studies have shown that assigning pharmacists to<br />
patient care teams in medical intensive care units reduced<br />
medication prescription errors by 66% to 77%. 12 In addition,<br />
the direct involvement of pharmacists can help prevent<br />
medication errors by assuring that adequate stock levels<br />
of drugs are maintained on patient care units, and that<br />
health care providers are ordering patient medications during<br />
regular pharmacy hours.<br />
Certain individual medications, as well as certain classifications<br />
of medications, have been identified as having a<br />
higher potential for adverse drug reactions (ADRs). <strong>The</strong><br />
classifications in which most errors occur are antimicrobials<br />
(40%), cardiac, steroids, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory,<br />
and surgical medications. Common medications having<br />
a higher potential for ADRs include insulin, heparin,<br />
opiates, patient-controlled analgesia, and potassium chloride.<br />
It has been estimated that medication errors in hospitals<br />
can be reduced by 33 percent with respect to these medications<br />
alone. 13<br />
Teaching patients about their medications also helps to<br />
prevent medication errors. Table 5 lists helpful hints to<br />
Table 5<br />
Patient Teaching<br />
• Help patients familiarize themselves with the col<br />
ors and shapes of all their medications so they<br />
can better identify unfamiliar medications.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> patient should be encouraged to question<br />
healthcare providers when in doubt.<br />
• Urge patients to purchase a drug reference book<br />
for home use.<br />
• Provide them with Internet addresses of sites<br />
related to medications.<br />
• Instruct patients to keep current written records<br />
listing their prescription and nonprescription<br />
medications, as well as, any adverse reactions to<br />
individual medications and dyes used during<br />
diagnostic testing.<br />
• Instruct patients to use one pharmacy, to ask for<br />
written information about each of their prescrip<br />
tions, to review the information with their phar<br />
macist, and to insure that the pharmacist has a<br />
<strong>com</strong>puterized list of all the patient’s current med<br />
ications including over-the-counter drugs, as well<br />
as his or her allergies and medical conditions.<br />
assist in teaching patients about their medications.<br />
Summary<br />
Improving health care while preventing medication<br />
errors, attendant expenses and subsequent liability, requires<br />
an extensive knowledge of medications and due diligence<br />
in prescribing, dispensing, and administering medications.<br />
Legally, health care providers are responsible for understanding<br />
the medications they prescribe, dispense, and<br />
administer. <strong>The</strong>y must know the dosage ranges, possible<br />
adverse effects, toxicity levels, indications, and contraindications.<br />
Moreover, the provider is responsible for clarifying<br />
in<strong>com</strong>plete or ambiguous orders, for following routine<br />
safeguard procedures, and for notifying the primary health<br />
care provider of potential problems. Good <strong>com</strong>munication<br />
among all health team members, in addition to <strong>com</strong>plete<br />
documentation, patient assessment, and patient education<br />
are essential. 14<br />
Currently, there is no nationwide mandatory requirement<br />
to report medication errors. However, they may be voluntarily<br />
reported to the Institute for Safe Medical Practices-<br />
United States Pharmacopeial Convention Medication Error<br />
Reporting Program at (800) 233-7767, and to the FDA<br />
MedWatch program at (800) FDA-1088. 15<br />
References<br />
Lesar, T. et al. Medication Prescribing Errors in a<br />
Teaching Hospital, JAMA 1990: 263:2329-34<br />
Kohn LT, et. al. To err is human. Building a safer<br />
health system. Institute of Medicine; 1999; 27-34.<br />
Leape LL, et. al. System analysis of adverse drug<br />
events. JAMA 1995;274:35-43.<br />
Physician Insurers Association of America.<br />
Medication error study. Washington, DC: Physician<br />
Insurers Association of America; June 1993.<br />
Smith M. <strong>Nurse</strong>s and litigation: 1990-1997. Journal<br />
of Nursing Law. 5:2: 7.<br />
Benjamin DM. Defenses in professional negligence.<br />
Available at: http://<br />
www.channel1.<strong>com</strong>/users/medlaw/legal/prof.htm.<br />
Accessed October 28, 1999.<br />
Benjamin DM. <strong>The</strong> learned intermediary doctrine.<br />
Available at: http:// www.channel1.<strong>com</strong>/users/medlaw/prm/learned.htm.<br />
Accessed October 28, 1999.<br />
Mawn SV. Informed consent. Legal Medicine<br />
Open File. 1994; 1994-2, 1-6.<br />
Harris County Hosp. Dist. v. Estrada, 872 S.W. 2d<br />
759.<br />
Pellerin v. Humedicenters, Inc., 696 So. 2d 590.<br />
Bates DW. More than 80 percent of medication<br />
errors eliminated by <strong>com</strong>puterized physician order<br />
entry systems. Available at: http://<br />
www.mederrors.org/html/announce.html. Accessed<br />
September 2, 1999.<br />
Leape LL, et. al. Pharmacist participation on physician<br />
rounds and adverse drug events in the intensive<br />
care unit. JAMA. July 21, 1999. Vol. 282, No. 2, 267-<br />
270.<br />
See supra note 4.<br />
See supra note 5.<br />
See supra note 2, 74-86.
• PAGE P GE 34 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
Background information:<br />
In June 1996, <strong>Maryland</strong> was one of 20 project sites<br />
from across the nation to receive funding from the<br />
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation to address current<br />
and future nursing work force needs. Additional funding<br />
was awarded to <strong>Maryland</strong> in July 1999 to support<br />
the continuation of statewide project activities. Over<br />
the past four years, the <strong>Maryland</strong> Colleagues in<br />
Caring Collaborative has grown by leaps and bounds<br />
and is currently <strong>com</strong>prised of over 275 members who<br />
represent nursing employers, schools of nursing, insurers,<br />
and a variety of local and state agencies. It exists<br />
as a formal mechanism for determining work place<br />
needs and availability of an appropriate supply of<br />
qualified nurses for all regions of the state and all practice<br />
settings across the continuum of care and intends<br />
to continue its efforts to collect, interpret, and disseminate<br />
data about the work force supply and demand.<br />
Colleagues in Caring work group activity focuses on<br />
the following major themes:<br />
• Improving public image and knowledge of<br />
nurses’ role in health and health care<br />
• Improving accessibility of nursing education<br />
• Fostering appropriate utilization of nurses in<br />
practice<br />
• Building and strengthening partnerships between<br />
educational settings and practice settings<br />
For more information about the Colleagues in<br />
Caring project, contact Kathryn Hall, Project Director<br />
or Susan Veise-Berry, Project Assistant at 410-859-<br />
3000.<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Colleagues in Caring<br />
Regional Collaboratives for Nursing Work Force Development<br />
TODAY’S NURSE Campaign Update<br />
<strong>The</strong> TODAY’S NURSE campaign, which was officially<br />
launched in March 2000, is being made possible through<br />
the contributions of many! This is an opportunity to<br />
acknowledge and thank all those who have sponsored the<br />
campaign to date. <strong>The</strong>y are as follows:<br />
CORPORATE LEVEL SPONSORS<br />
** DIAMOND SPONSORS**<br />
$10,000 Contribution Level<br />
<strong>The</strong> Johns Hopkins Health System<br />
Mercy Medical Center<br />
University of <strong>Maryland</strong> Medical System/University of<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> School of Nursing<br />
GOLD SPONSORS<br />
$5,000 Contribution Level<br />
Anne Arundel Medical Center<br />
Helix Health-Med Star Health<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> Hospital Association, Inc.<br />
SILVER SPONSORS<br />
$2,500-$3,000 Level<br />
Greater Baltimore Medical Center<br />
Montgomery General Hospital, Inc.<br />
St. Joseph Medical Center<br />
BRONZE SPONSOR<br />
$2000 Contribution Level<br />
LifeBridge Health<br />
PEWTER SPONSORS<br />
$1,000 Contribution Level<br />
Association of Operating Room <strong>Nurse</strong>s<br />
Atlantic General Hospital & Health System<br />
FutureCare Health and Management Corporation<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> General Hospital<br />
Progressive Nursing Staffers<br />
Stella Maris, Inc.<br />
St. Agnes Health Care<br />
OTHER SPONSORS<br />
Anne Arundel Medical Center Unit A-4<br />
Anne Arundel Medical Center Unit A-5<br />
Chesapeake Society of Gastroenterology<br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>s and Associates<br />
District 4 - <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association<br />
Genesis Health Ventures<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Council of Directors of Associate Degree and<br />
Baccalaureate Nursing Programs<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> Organization of <strong>Nurse</strong> Executives<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> State Council Emergency <strong>Nurse</strong> Association<br />
INDIVIDUAL SUPPORTERS<br />
LOUISA PARSONS SPONSORS<br />
$250 and above<br />
Madeline Turkeltaub<br />
LILLIAN WALD SPONSORS<br />
$100 and above<br />
Wanda Brethauer Priscilla Mills<br />
Carloyn Buppert Marion Mulholland<br />
Catherine Crowley Karen Peddicord<br />
Fran Damratowski Virginia Pichler<br />
Noel Eller Joan Spear<br />
Linda Epstein Dianne Taylor<br />
Kathryn Hall Patricia Travis<br />
Mary Etta Mills Margo Zink<br />
OTHER SPONSORS<br />
Christina Barrick Sheryl Jacobs<br />
Joanna Basuray Joan Jordan<br />
Beth Anne Batturs Felicia Kendall<br />
Mary Beachley Vicky Kent<br />
Jan Black Mary Kraaij<br />
Marilyn Brown Lynn Kuebler<br />
Michelle Brusio Debra Lanham<br />
Janet Cogliano Mary Lashley<br />
Debbie Collins Lena Lee<br />
Linda Cook Lisa Malick<br />
Deborah Dang Kim McCarron<br />
Christine D’Angelo Evelyn Parsons<br />
Marcia Dawson Kathleen Parsons<br />
Lynn Derickson Cheryl Rappoport<br />
Ruth Ann Derr Rebecca Rice<br />
Carol Dignon Daria Rovinski<br />
Susan Fosbrook Linda Sayre<br />
Deborah Greener Betty Schweitzer<br />
Marilyn Halstead JoAnn Shelley<br />
Norma Hamilton Elaine Sparks<br />
Sandra Heeley Nancy Smith<br />
Elaine Jae Holman Susan Thompson<br />
Maureen Holtzman Connie Watson<br />
Susan Immelt Susan Veise-Berry<br />
<strong>The</strong> TODAY’S NURSE campaign contributions total<br />
$67,525 to date. This supported the production of the first<br />
TV segment that has been airing intermittently since<br />
March 2000. In addition to the TV segment, the<br />
TODAY’S NURSE Web Site has also been active. It can<br />
be accessed through the WBAL Web Site @<br />
www.wbaltv.<strong>com</strong>. <strong>The</strong> names of the TODAY’S NURSE<br />
Corporate Sponsors are identified and those at the higher<br />
support levels also have a direct link to their web sites.<br />
This has been beneficial to nurses who are seeking information<br />
about employment opportunities.<br />
<strong>The</strong> TODAY’S NURSE campaign has grown form a<br />
partnership with WBAl-TV and aims to enhance public<br />
perception about nursing as a profession and encourage<br />
the brightest and best students to pursue a career in nursing.<br />
Future TV segments will continue to highlight the<br />
importance of Nursing in the delivery of quality health<br />
care.<br />
Additional financial contributions are needed in order to<br />
sustain the TODAY’S NURSE campaign for the proposed<br />
12-month period. for more information about this<br />
statewide effort, please contact the Colleagues in Caring<br />
office at 410-859-3000.<br />
THE NEXT COLLEAGUES IN CARING CONSOR-<br />
TIUM MEETING WILL BE HELD ON MONDAY, SEP-<br />
TEMBER 18, 2000 FROM 9:30 A.M. - 11:30 A.M. AT<br />
THE HOWARD COUNTY GENERAL HOSPITAL<br />
WELLNESS CENTER IN COLUMBIA, MD. PLEASE<br />
CONTACT THE COLLEAGUE IN CARING OFFICE IF<br />
YOU WOULD LIKE TO BE ADDED TO THE MAIL-<br />
ING LIST.
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 35 •<br />
Multistate Licensure<br />
Compact Bill Status<br />
State Bill # Status Date of Effective<br />
Last Action Date<br />
Arkansas S 28 Signed by Governor 2/24/1999 7/1/2000<br />
Deleware H 439 To House Policy Analysis & Government 1/18/2000 N/A<br />
Accoutability Committee<br />
Idaho H 405 To Health & Welfare Committee 1/17/2000 N/A<br />
Iowa HF 2105 Signed by Governor 3/16/2000 7/1/2000<br />
Maine LD 2558 Legislature and Governor Have Empowered 4/12/2000 No later than<br />
the Board of Nursing to Enter a Written 9/1/2000<br />
Licensure Compact Through Rule-Making:<br />
Board Action Pending<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> S 590 Signed by Governor 4/27/1999 7/1/1999<br />
Mississippi H 535 Signed by Governor 4/22/2000 7/1/2001<br />
Nebraska L 523 Signed by Governor 2/15/2000 1/1/2001<br />
North<br />
Carolina S 194 Signed by Governor 7/2/1999 7/1/2000<br />
South<br />
Dakota H 1045 Signed by Governor 2/16/2000 1/1/2001<br />
Texas H 1342 Signed by Governor 6/19/1999 1/1/2000<br />
Utah S 146 Signed by Governor 3/14/1998 1/1/2000<br />
Wisconsin A 305 Signed by Governor 12/17/1999 1/1/2000
• PAGE P GE 36 • THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000<br />
A Day in the Life<br />
by Anne O’Reilly, RN<br />
Anne O’Reilly, RN has worked as a clinical coordinator<br />
for the Transplant Resource Center of <strong>Maryland</strong> since<br />
September of 1999. She has fifteen years of critical care<br />
experience, and began her nursing education at St.<br />
James’ University Hospital School of Nursing, Leeds,<br />
England.<br />
“Could you write an article from the point-of-view of the<br />
nurses involved in the donation process for <strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong><br />
<strong>Nurse</strong>?” “Sure, no problem,” I said. That should be easy,<br />
but then I started to think about all the people involved.<br />
<strong>The</strong> clinical coordinators, RN’s like myself, the ICU nurses,<br />
the secretaries on the units, the echo techs, the cath. lab<br />
staff, the OR staff, the clergy, the Medical Examiners, the<br />
specialists back at the Transplant Resource Center (TRC),<br />
the donor family, the surgeons - the list goes on. <strong>The</strong>re are<br />
many, many people involved in this process. Including<br />
them all in this article would create a book, but to not<br />
acknowledge them would be to do them a disservice. For<br />
donation to succeed it takes an incredible amount of team<br />
work. So with that acknowledgment, this is a day in the life<br />
of a clinical coordinator for the Transplant Resource<br />
Center of <strong>Maryland</strong>, Inc., the non profit organ procurement<br />
organization for the State of <strong>Maryland</strong>.<br />
It is a little after 09:00, and I am walking into the multi<br />
trauma ICU at University of <strong>Maryland</strong> Medical System’s R<br />
Adams Cowley Shock Trauma Center. Ben 1 is a 17-yearold<br />
white male who has been ejected from a car involved<br />
in an MVC (Motor Vehicle Collision), “shock trauma<br />
speak” for an MVA (they do not believe in calling them<br />
accidents). He was not wearing a seatbelt, and sustained a<br />
devastating head injury. He has returned from cerebral<br />
blood flow studies which demonstrated no blood flow to<br />
the brain. <strong>The</strong> results of this study and his clinical exam<br />
have given him the diagnosis of brain death 2 .<br />
Consent for donation has already been given to the coor-<br />
dinator, Dennis, who has been working with the staff and<br />
family through the night. He is still on site, and that is who<br />
I am looking for as I enter the unit. I find Dennis with the<br />
phone in one hand and a pen in the other. A large percentage<br />
of our time is spent on the phone. In fact, approximately<br />
200 phone calls will be made to facilitate this donation.<br />
Dennis quickly brings me up to date on the case.<br />
Death was declared at 06:45 and, shortly after, the attending<br />
physician informed the family. At 08:30 Dennis and<br />
his orientee, Donna sat down with Ben’s family to discuss<br />
the option of donation. Ben’s parents, like an increasing<br />
number of people, had already talked about donation, and<br />
Ben had made his wishes known by designating “donor”<br />
on his driver’s license. Informed consent was obtained for<br />
organs and tissues, for both transplant and research.<br />
<strong>The</strong> next step in the process is to obtain blood for serologies<br />
and to continue the evaluation phase started by<br />
Donna. She had arrived just before 01:00 following a call<br />
from the ICU to the <strong>Maryland</strong> Donor Hotline. <strong>The</strong>y called<br />
because Ben’s GCS (Glasgow Coma Scale) was less than<br />
five, he was on a ventilator, and he had experienced a neurological<br />
event, the three key factors needed to trigger a<br />
call to the Hotline. Donna had gone through Ben’s chart,<br />
not just to evaluate the potential for donation but also, to<br />
check on his lab work and clinical course to evaluate<br />
which organs and tissues he could potentially donate. In<br />
view of Ben’s age and lack of past medical history we<br />
were expecting to place the heart, lungs, liver, kidneys,<br />
pancreas, skin, corneas and bone, for transplantation.<br />
With that in mind I took over the case, allowing Dennis<br />
and Donna to go home and get some well deserved rest. A<br />
stat Bronchoscopy and an Echocardiogram were ordered<br />
to evaluate the heart and lungs. While waiting for them to<br />
be performed, I made contact with Ben’s nurse, Mark - a<br />
veteran of many donor cases who was taking everything in<br />
his stride. This is not always the case. Frequently this is<br />
the nurse’s first involvement in donor management. So we<br />
have an information sheet that walks the nurse through<br />
which labs and tests to order - when and why. Mark had<br />
already drawn the blood for the serologies, Hepatitis B and<br />
C, RPR 3 , CMV 4 , HTLV 5 , and HIV 6 . <strong>The</strong> blood is sent out<br />
and we are able to get the results back in about six hours.<br />
Although a positive serology may affect the case, only HIV<br />
and HTLV terminate it.<br />
My job now is to do a <strong>com</strong>plete physical assessment of<br />
the patient. Part of the purpose of this is purely clinical, (ie.<br />
heart sounds, breath sounds, pulses, surgical scars etc.), and<br />
part is examining for clues to high risk behaviors such as<br />
track marks and tattoos. My physical findings should<br />
match with the detailed medical social history taken from<br />
Ben’s parents - it does.<br />
It is now 12:30 and the Echocardiogram, Bronch, EKG,<br />
and Chest x-ray have all been performed at the bedside and<br />
reports have been written. During this time the Medical<br />
Examiner has been contacted and has placed no restrictions<br />
on the donation, nor does he require the body for autopsy.<br />
<strong>The</strong> information gathered so far is faxed into our In House,<br />
where Emily, the In House specialist, will now field a multitude<br />
of phone calls from recipient coordinators and surgeons.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y will be asking for more information, clarifying<br />
details and processing primary and backup offers.<br />
Meanwhile, we wait. Not the passive, feet up kind of<br />
wait, but the keep-the-donor-stable kind of wait. <strong>The</strong> goal<br />
is to correct the electrolyte imbalance and free water<br />
deficit, correct or maintain the acid base balance, and prevent<br />
or treat:<br />
• hypothermia,<br />
• diabetes insipidus,<br />
• disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC)<br />
• adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS),<br />
• neurogenic pulmonary edema<br />
and, at the same time, maintain perfusion to the organs and<br />
hemodynamic stability.<br />
Each donor presents his or her own unique set of problems<br />
and challenges. Some require additional time to opti-<br />
Day in the Life cont. on pg. 37
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 37 •<br />
Day in the Life cont. from pg. 36<br />
mize individual organs, thereby improving their chance of<br />
being accepted for transplant. Others may already be in<br />
their optimal state and would do best by proceeding quickly<br />
to the OR. A third and the most <strong>com</strong>mon group are those<br />
with individual organs at different states of readiness.<br />
Couple these challenges with those of mobilizing recipients<br />
and surgeons, and OR availability and it is easy to see<br />
why donation is such a rare and special event. <strong>The</strong>re were<br />
77 organ donors in <strong>Maryland</strong> in 1999.<br />
Meanwhile, Mark has worked hard. Ben was relatively<br />
stable, in fact his dopamine had been decreased from 6.5<br />
mcg/kg/min to 3 mcg/kg/min. His systolic blood pressure<br />
was <strong>com</strong>fortably above 100 mmHg, urine output was<br />
200cc/hr and with the help of a warming blanket his temperature<br />
was 98.2F. He had required several liters of 0.45%<br />
saline, and potassium, phosphorus and magnesium<br />
replacements earlier in the day, but now his IV was only at<br />
100cc/hr. Although this was not Mark’s only patient, frequently<br />
they are a “one-to-one.”<br />
At 16:20 the serology results were back. Ben was CMV<br />
positive, a <strong>com</strong>mon result that does not prevent transplantation.<br />
It does, however, need to be <strong>com</strong>municated to the<br />
recipient’s surgeon, so that the recipient receives appropriate<br />
follow-up care. We were ready for the OR. I was hoping<br />
to go at 18:00. I had already spoken to the OR charge<br />
nurse to give her a heads up.<br />
My pager went off, it was Emily. She and I had spoken<br />
on the phone throughout the day updating each other, but<br />
this particular call I had been expecting and dreading, a<br />
delay going to the OR. <strong>The</strong> reason - the potential lung<br />
recipient needed time to get to her hospital so, “could we<br />
change the OR to 23:30?” It was now 17:30 and I had to<br />
say yes. Ben was stable and I had no reason not to wait.<br />
Had he been unstable, we would not have waited. To do so<br />
would have put the other organs at risk.<br />
John was now Ben’s nurse, since Mark had left at change<br />
of shift. John helped with the transfer of Ben to the OR.<br />
<strong>The</strong> move to the OR gave me the surge of adrenaline I<br />
needed; this was the home stretch. <strong>The</strong> time in the OR<br />
varies depending on the number and type of organs being<br />
recovered. Ben was to donate seven organs. <strong>The</strong>re could be<br />
as many as ten surgeons involved working in four different<br />
teams, as well as the scrub nurse, circulator and TRC staff.<br />
So the bigger the OR room, the better. Ben’s organs were<br />
to be procured by just five surgeons working in two teams,<br />
thoracic and abdominal. I had also just found out that the<br />
lung recipient was actually going to be the heart recipient<br />
too, which decreased the number of potential surgeons<br />
greatly.<br />
My main job in the OR is to keep the lines of <strong>com</strong>munication<br />
open between the recovery surgeons and the potential<br />
recipient’s surgeons. Although the kidneys could wait<br />
greater than 24 hours until they were transplanted, the<br />
heart/lung recipient was already being prepped across<br />
town.<br />
<strong>The</strong> procedure went well, the heart had been stopped at<br />
03:20, and the anesthesiologist had been thanked and had<br />
left. A short while later the heart and lungs were out en<br />
bloc, details of their anatomy recorded, and the thoracic<br />
surgeons were on their way. Liver was next, followed by<br />
pancreas then kidneys. Again, my job was to document the<br />
anatomies as reported by the surgeon. <strong>The</strong> incision was<br />
closed and post mortem care was carried out. Copies of the<br />
chart, that had been created over the last 30 hours, were<br />
sent with each organ. It was time to leave.<br />
I walked out into the warm night air at 05:00, I was still<br />
on call for three more hours but something told me that my<br />
pager would not go off . . . donors don’t happen every day.<br />
1. <strong>The</strong> name has been changed.<br />
2. Brain death is defined as the irreversible loss of<br />
clinical function of the brain, including the brain stem.<br />
3. Rapid Plasma Reagin the test for Syphilis.<br />
4. Cytomegalovirus.<br />
5. Human T-Lymphotropic Virus.<br />
6. Human Immunodeficiency Virus<br />
Correction<br />
In the February, March, April 2000 issue of <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong> there was a wonderful article titled<br />
“<strong>The</strong> Gift of Life: Nursing Provides a Vital Link in the<br />
Organ and Tissue Donation Process.” <strong>The</strong> author of<br />
this important article was misstated and should have<br />
read Karen Kennedy, RN, CPTC, Director, Clinical<br />
and Hospital Services for the Transplant Resource<br />
Center of <strong>Maryland</strong>, Inc. Our apologies to Ms.<br />
Kennedy for this error. <strong>The</strong> Transplant Resource<br />
Center of <strong>Maryland</strong>, Inc. and their staff will be regular<br />
contributors to <strong>The</strong> <strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>.
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 39 •<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association’s 6th Annual Poster Session<br />
Deadline for Proposal - September 25th<br />
Presentations will be November 9, 2000<br />
2:45-3:45 PM<br />
All <strong>Nurse</strong>s, Nursing Students and Other Health<br />
Care Professionals: Share your creative nursing care<br />
approaches, research finds, clinical innovations or student<br />
projects with your colleagues. All convention participants<br />
are invited to submit a poster proposal on any aspect of<br />
their practice, research, or student activities.<br />
What is a poster?<br />
• <strong>The</strong> poster should be a summarization of a creative<br />
activity<br />
• It should fit on a poster board measuring approximately<br />
30” wide by 36” long<br />
• A poster should reflect an innovative aspect of nursing<br />
practice, education, or research<br />
• It may be supplemented by handouts<br />
• It should fit easily on an easel<br />
• <strong>The</strong> poster’s presenter must be available for the<br />
open poster session to address questions<br />
How to submit a poster proposal:<br />
• Complete the submission form at right (➔)<br />
• Mail or Fax your proposal, no later than September<br />
25, 2000, to:<br />
Convention Posters<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> <strong>Nurse</strong>s Association<br />
849 International Drive, Suite 255<br />
Linthicum, <strong>Maryland</strong> 21090<br />
Fax #410-859-3001<br />
You will be notified by October 13, 2000 regarding the<br />
acceptance of your poster. You do not have to be an MNA<br />
member to submit a poster, however all poster presenters<br />
must be registered Convention participants.<br />
Poster Policy:<br />
Posters must avoid <strong>com</strong>mercialism. Posters that constitute<br />
promotion and advertising will not be accepted.<br />
Statements made in posters are the sole responsibility of<br />
the author or presenter. Statements should not be viewed<br />
as, or considered representative of, any formal stance or<br />
position taken on any subject, issue or product by MNA.<br />
Selection Criteria<br />
Each poster submission will be reviewed for the following<br />
elements:<br />
• Quality<br />
• Broad appeal to the nursing <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
• Creativity<br />
• Timeliness<br />
• Uniqueness<br />
Poster Submission Form for MNA Convention<br />
Poster Title and Description ___________________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
Developers Name and Credentials ______________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
Objective Statement__________________________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
Mailing Address _____________________________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________________________________________<br />
___________________________________________________________Zip _____________________________<br />
Phone _______________________________________FAX __________________________________________
AUGUST UGUST, , SEPTEMBER, OCTOBER OCTOBER<br />
2000 THE MARYL MARYLAND<br />
AND NURSE • PAGE P GE 35 •<br />
Multistate Licensure<br />
Compact Bill Status<br />
State Bill # Status Date of Effective<br />
Last Action Date<br />
Arkansas S 28 Signed by Governor 2/24/1999 7/1/2000<br />
Deleware H 439 To House Policy Analysis & Government 1/18/2000 N/A<br />
Accoutability Committee<br />
Idaho H 405 To Health & Welfare Committee 1/17/2000 N/A<br />
Iowa HF 2105 Signed by Governor 3/16/2000 7/1/2000<br />
Maine LD 2558 Legislature and Governor Have Empowered 4/12/2000 No later than<br />
the Board of Nursing to Enter a Written 9/1/2000<br />
Licensure Compact Through Rule-Making:<br />
Board Action Pending<br />
<strong>Maryland</strong> S 590 Signed by Governor 4/27/1999 7/1/1999<br />
Mississippi H 535 Signed by Governor 4/22/2000 7/1/2001<br />
Nebraska L 523 Signed by Governor 2/15/2000 1/1/2001<br />
North<br />
Carolina S 194 Signed by Governor 7/2/1999 7/1/2000<br />
South<br />
Dakota H 1045 Signed by Governor 2/16/2000 1/1/2001<br />
Texas H 1342 Signed by Governor 6/19/1999 1/1/2000<br />
Utah S 146 Signed by Governor 3/14/1998 1/1/2000<br />
Wisconsin A 305 Signed by Governor 12/17/1999 1/1/2000<br />
Glen Meadows Retirement Community<br />
is Looking For:<br />
RNs or LPNs<br />
Skilled Nursing Unit<br />
7 - 3 every other weekend and 1 weekday<br />
RNs<br />
Skilled Nursing Unit<br />
11- 7 PRN with a strong need for every other<br />
Tuesday<br />
LPN<br />
Assisted Living Unit<br />
11 - 7 every other weekend and 2 weekdays for a<br />
total of 6 shifts every two weeks.<br />
Very nice rural setting Continuing Care Retirement<br />
Community in Baltimore County near Loch Raven<br />
Reservoir. Ten minutes from Cromwell Bridge Road<br />
and the Beltway. Great Benefits and Wages. To<br />
explore this fantastic opportunity fax your resume<br />
to 410-592-6175. Attention Tom McMahan.