23.02.2013 Views

Serbia Handbook for Legal Aid Providers Final

Serbia Handbook for Legal Aid Providers Final

Serbia Handbook for Legal Aid Providers Final

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

This includes various miscellaneous types of property problems; including KFOR occupation<br />

of property, temporary representative cases, property cases of significant value to judicial<br />

precedent.<br />

Client is an IDP living in Merdere. From 1999 until 2003 KFOR had occupied his<br />

farmland in Podujevo on the Kosovo boundary.<br />

He wishes to file a claim against KFOR <strong>for</strong> using the land and preventing him from<br />

using it.<br />

The approach to use in each case will depend on the type of problem the client is facing.<br />

The examples given in the breakdowns above should be a good guide on how to proceed<br />

with other types of cases.<br />

Section 5 – Making a complaint under the Anti-discrimination law<br />

During the intake of an application <strong>for</strong> legal aid the legal officer may become aware of an<br />

instance of discrimination directed against the claimant. It is important first to determine<br />

whether evidence exists to prove a claim of discrimination from a legal perspective. This<br />

requires documenting the in<strong>for</strong>mation provided by a complainant or complainants and their<br />

application of the legal test <strong>for</strong> discrimination.<br />

While Kosovo and Metohija does have an Anti-Discrimination Law (ADL) on paper and it<br />

was promulgated years ago, to date there has been little or no reference to actual<br />

implementation of this law. While the anti-discrimination law is broad and covers many areas<br />

the focus here will be housing and property related.<br />

Types of Complaints<br />

It’s important to note that there is often a detrimental effect tied to a discrimination claim. An<br />

access to justice complaint arises when a person or group of persons complain that they<br />

have encountered barriers in gaining access to courts. The complainant may face Tangible<br />

barriers (like lack of transportation, threats to safety or security or security, language or<br />

physical obstacles). The may also complain of intangible barrier (such as delay,<br />

uncertainty in the law, lack if confidence in the fair application of law, or limited in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

on the law and their legal rights).<br />

A civil rights complaint is a claim that a person has been discriminated against on a<br />

prohibited ground by infringement of a protected activity.<br />

The test summarised below is the test <strong>for</strong> discrimination under the European Convention on<br />

Human Rights, art. 14, but its elements are common to discrimination tests under most<br />

international human rights instruments as well as European Union law. It is important <strong>for</strong> the<br />

legal officer to understand and apply this test to field issues to identify potential<br />

discrimination issues.<br />

The Penultimate Question a legal officer should themselves ask is whether conduct on the<br />

part of governmental authorities could amount to arbitrary discrimination (versus permissible<br />

differentiation) on their part where both parties are in a comparable situation?<br />

28

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!