01.06.2013 Views

Tropical ginsberg

Tropical ginsberg

Tropical ginsberg

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

and new, as well as carefully and beautifully elaborated.<br />

It was exactly because of these startling similarities that I was<br />

compelled to research more about the dialogical relation which I thought<br />

existed between Ginsberg and the tropicalistas. Now, after so much<br />

work and research, I am convinced that I was right. Through the aid of<br />

the theoretical parameters established by Russian scholar Mikhail<br />

Bakhtin in his essay, “The Problem of The Text in Linguistics,<br />

Philology, and the Human Sciences: An Experiment in Philosophical<br />

Analysis,” I established a dialogical relation between Ginsberg’s texts<br />

and context, with the tropicalistas songs and context. According to<br />

Bakhtin,<br />

21<br />

The utterance (as a speech whole). […] is no<br />

longer a unit of language (and not a unit of<br />

“speech flow” or the “speech chain”), but a unit of<br />

speech communication that has not mere formal<br />

definition, but contextual meaning (that is,<br />

integrated meaning that relates to value[…]and<br />

requires a responsive understanding, one that<br />

includes evaluation). The responsive<br />

understanding of a speech whole is always<br />

dialogic by nature. 28<br />

For Bakhtin there are no “voiceless words that belong to no one.<br />

Each word contains voices that are sometimes infinitely distant.” 29 Texts<br />

generate meaning when they are related to their context, to what they<br />

talk about, and this meaning will always be produced by dialogical<br />

relations that we all make while trying to understand a text. Because<br />

Ginsberg’s poems and the tropicalistas’ songs have many elements in<br />

common, such as the confrontation element, and the provocative<br />

element, they end up entering into dialogic relations with each other.<br />

Bakhtin says that what matters,<br />

Is not elements of the text (units) of language<br />

system that have become elements of the text, but<br />

aspects of the utterance. The utterance as a<br />

semantic whole. The relationship to others’<br />

utterances cannot be separated from the<br />

28 Bakhtin, Mikhail M. Speech Genres & Other Late Essays. Trans. Vern W. McGee. Austin:<br />

University of Texas Press, 1986. 125.<br />

29 Ibid. 124.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!