21.06.2013 Views

HEADNOTE: Mario Rodriguez Gutierrez v. State of Maryland, No. 98 ...

HEADNOTE: Mario Rodriguez Gutierrez v. State of Maryland, No. 98 ...

HEADNOTE: Mario Rodriguez Gutierrez v. State of Maryland, No. 98 ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

too great to allow the evidence to be put before the jury. See id. at 237.<br />

Illinois also adopts this cautious approach. In People v. Bryant, 609 N.E.2d 910 (Ill.<br />

App. Ct. 1993), the Illinois appellate court permitted expert testimony on the customs <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Folks Gang, where lay witness testimony supplied a link between that gang and the murder<br />

for which defendant Bryant was on trial. There, fact witnesses testified that Bryant<br />

exchanged words with the deceased, Houston, and the deceased’s friend, Frazier, over the<br />

return <strong>of</strong> a friend’s pager. See id. at 913–14. When Frazier demanded the pager, Bryant<br />

turned to an alleged fellow gang member and said, “[Folks], give him that pager.” Id. at 913.<br />

The alleged gang member complied, tried to shake Frazier’s hand and then “[threw] up a<br />

pitchfork.” Id. Frazier returned the handshake, but did not “throw up a pitchfork[,]” to<br />

which Bryant responded, “[You’re] not right, you’re not right. I thought you were folks. .<br />

. . what the hell you doing coming around here if you’re not folks . . . you’ll get whooped like<br />

your boy.” Id. A physical fight ensued, and Houston joined in to aid his friend. See id. at<br />

913–14. Soon thereafter, as Frazier was fleeing the scene, he heard gunshots and looked<br />

back to see Bryant standing near Houston and holding a gun. See id. at 914.<br />

In addition to this eyewitness testimony, the <strong>State</strong> introduced, and the trial court<br />

permitted, the testimony <strong>of</strong> a Chicago detective who had dealt extensively with that city’s<br />

street gangs and was familiar with the gang that refers to themselves as “folks.” See Bryant,<br />

609 N.E.2d at 914. The detective explained that the pitchfork is a sign unique to the “folks”<br />

street gang, and that, in his opinion, “when an individual uses the hand signal <strong>of</strong> a pitchfork<br />

in an up position, that individual is affiliated with the ‘folks’ gang.” Id. at 914, 920. The<br />

14

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!