invit - Australasian Plant Pathology Society
invit - Australasian Plant Pathology Society
invit - Australasian Plant Pathology Society
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Go to<br />
Table of Contents<br />
RHIZOCTONIA SPECIES IMPLICATED IN ONION STUNT<br />
S.T. Anstis, B.H. Hall and T.J. Wicks<br />
A<br />
South Australian Research & Development Institute, Adelaide, SA. Email: simon.anstis@sa.gov.au<br />
ABSTRACT. Onion stunt is a soilborne root disease of onions caused by Rhizoctonia solani AG8 that results in patches of<br />
stunted plants with undersized bulbs. R. solani DNA soil analysis for AG’s 2.1, 2.2, 3, 4, 5 and 8 in addition to Rhizoctonia<br />
root isolations were performed on 6 onion paddocks with symptoms of stunting from Western Australia and 3 from South<br />
Australia. Rhizoctonia type fungi were isolated from 5 of 6 onion paddocks in WA and 3 paddocks from SA. R. solani AG4<br />
was only detected in WA. R. solani AG8 was only found in SA occurring in higher amounts in stunted patches compared to<br />
adjacent normal areas of onion growth. R. solani AG’s 2.2 and 3 were not detected in any soil sample while AG’s 2.1 and 5<br />
were detected sporadically and did not appear to have any relationship to disease. Pathogenicity testing of Rhizoctonia<br />
isolates demonstrated that AG8 in SA and AG4 in WA could be responsible for stunting. While pathogenic binucleate<br />
Rhizoctonia (BNR) were found in both SA and WA soils they were generally not as virulent as pathogenic R. solani isolates.<br />
Further work is needed on BNR to characterise their identity, determine their incidence of disease and whether management<br />
strategies suitable for R. solani apply to these fungi.<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
Onion stunt is a serious disease widespread among onions<br />
grown in the mallee of SA and is caused by R. solani AG8<br />
(Wicks et al 2011). The disease results in patches of stunted<br />
onions with retarded shoot growth and pruned roots with<br />
‘spear’ tipping.<br />
In 2011, onions planted in the Myalup area of WA<br />
showed patches of stunted growth similar to that found in<br />
South Australia.<br />
This paper reports the pathogenicity of Rhizoctonia<br />
isolates and soil Rhizoctonia DNA analysis from onion<br />
plantings in Western and South Australia to further<br />
understand the role of Rhizoctonia in causing Onion Stunt.<br />
MATERIALS AND METHODS<br />
Soil DNA Analysis Soils from both WA and SA were<br />
sampled from inside stunted patches and normal onion<br />
growth within 2 m of the patch edge and analysed for R.<br />
solani AG’s 2.1, 2.2, 3, 4, 5 and 8 by the SARDI Root<br />
Disease Testing Service (Urrbrae, SA).<br />
Pathogenicity testing Rhizoctonia were isolated from<br />
seedlings roots taken within stunted (3 pg DNA/g<br />
(data not shown). AG8 was found in SA and occurred at<br />
higher amounts in stunted patches compared to normal<br />
growth (Table 1).<br />
Pathogenicity testing Rhizoctonia were isolated from 5<br />
paddocks surveyed in WA and three paddocks in SA.<br />
Rhizoctonia isolates from WA were either non AG typed<br />
BNR or belonged to the binucleate AGA group while R.<br />
solani isolates fungi belonged to AG4. In SA soils<br />
reference AG8 isolates or had no effect on seedling growth<br />
(Figure 1). While BNR were detected in WA and SA soils<br />
they were generally not as virulent as AG8 or AG4.<br />
Table 1. R. solani AG DNA soil analysis (pg DNA/g)<br />
from onion paddocks in WA and SA. A - below detection<br />
limit, B – not tested.<br />
Paddock Sample AG2.1 AG4 AG8<br />
WA - 1 Normal 13 - -<br />
Stunt 17.2 1.4 -<br />
WA - 2 Normal - A 884 -<br />
Stunt - 623 -<br />
WA - 3 Normal - 2.9 -<br />
Stunt - 8.8 -<br />
SA - 1 Normal 58 - -<br />
Stunt 0.6 - -<br />
SA - 2 Normal - - 2.2<br />
Stunt - - 116<br />
SA - 3 Normal nt B nt 10.1<br />
Stunt nt nt 193<br />
4<br />
3<br />
2<br />
1<br />
0<br />
Figure 1. Effect of Rhizoctonia from either WA or SA on<br />
the growth of onion seedlings. Error bars indicate standard<br />
error.<br />
DISCUSSION<br />
In contrast to SA paddocks, onion stunting in WA was<br />
associated with AG4 and not AG8. There was no<br />
relationship of AG4 inoculum to disease incidence a subset<br />
of these fungi may be causing disease.<br />
Further work is needed to characterise pathogenic<br />
binucleate Rhizoctonia, determine the incidence of disease<br />
caused by these fungi in the field and if management<br />
strategies suitable for minimising loss caused by R. solani<br />
are applicable to these fungi.<br />
REFERENCES<br />
pathogenic AGA, AGK and R. solani AG8 were found. 1. Wicks, T. J. et al (2011). Onion stunting in South Australia<br />
With the exclusion of AG8 all groups of Rhizoctonia associated with Rhizoctonia solani AG8. <strong>Australasian</strong> <strong>Plant</strong><br />
isolated showed variation in pathogenicity compared to <strong>Pathology</strong> 40: 126-132.<br />
Fresh Weight (g/pot)<br />
Con<br />
AG8 (onion)<br />
AG8 (wheat)<br />
AGA<br />
AGA<br />
BNR<br />
BNR<br />
AGK<br />
AGK<br />
AG8<br />
AGA<br />
AGA<br />
BNR<br />
BNR<br />
AG4<br />
AG4<br />
AG4<br />
Con South Australia Western Australia<br />
7th <strong>Australasian</strong> Soilborne Diseases Symposium 45