Cover 1_rto4 - Illuminating Engineering Society
Cover 1_rto4 - Illuminating Engineering Society
Cover 1_rto4 - Illuminating Engineering Society
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
RETAIL LIGHTING<br />
Lighting Design + Application<br />
May 2001<br />
Flashy Furniture<br />
Disney’s Downtown Decór<br />
Show-Stopping Store<br />
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL<br />
Seminar Previews<br />
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL • MAY 29-JUNE 1 • LAS VEGAS
CONTENTS<br />
RETAIL LIGHTING<br />
“Must-See” Illumination 34<br />
The NBC Experience project took initial inspiration from other<br />
themed-environment stores, but modified the concepts substantially.<br />
Ron Harwood of <strong>Illuminating</strong> Concepts, discusses the project that<br />
garnered an Edwin F. Guth Award of Excellence for Interior Lighting Design.<br />
MAY 2001<br />
VOL. 31/NO. 4<br />
48<br />
DEPARTMENTS<br />
Fusion of Fashion and Furniture 42<br />
Ciel Home’s newest store needed an innovative lighting system to completely<br />
illuminate the products being displayed, while keeping the luminaires as<br />
hidden as possible. Arie Louie explains the design team’s<br />
philosophy in addressing this challenge.<br />
Progressive Hub to Disney’s Magic 48<br />
Downtown Disney links all the elements of the expanded Disneyland resort.<br />
Toni Page Birdsong provides the details on the lighting design<br />
that accompanied this newly created attraction.<br />
Today’s Shopping Malls 56<br />
Alfred R. Borden IV and Helen K. Diemer of The Lighting Practice<br />
trace the evolution of the shopping mall and the importance of lighting<br />
to developers and shoppers.<br />
LIGHT INTERNATIONAL<br />
Seminar Preview 60<br />
David Apfel, Addison Kelly, Brian Cronin, Anthony Long,<br />
Vesa Honkonen, Julle Oksanen, Harold Jepsen, Leslie North,<br />
Sandra Vasconez, Helmut O.<br />
Paidasch and Randall Whitehead<br />
provide some insight into the seminars<br />
they’ll be presenting at this year’s<br />
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL.<br />
4 Energy Concerns<br />
8 Specification Sales Strategies<br />
10 On Committees, Quills and<br />
Other Things<br />
11 2001 Progress Report<br />
Submittal Form<br />
14 Regional Voices<br />
16 Essay by Invitation<br />
18 Working with the Web<br />
21 IES News<br />
30 Photons<br />
82 Light Products<br />
84 Scheduled Events<br />
87 Classified Advertisements<br />
87 Ad Offices<br />
88 Ad Index<br />
ON THE COVER: Ciel Home opened its newest store in Newport Beach, Calif., with an<br />
innovative lighting system, based primarily in keeping the fixtures hidden. In fact, there are five<br />
distinct themes to the lighting design, each specially configured for the area in need of illumination.<br />
Each theme, or condition, was evaluated to ensure the lighting was not only functional,<br />
but visually pleasing, as well. Photo: Arie Louie<br />
2 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
Willard L.<br />
Warren,<br />
PE, LC,<br />
FIESNA<br />
We have a passion in this<br />
country for “numbers”<br />
and “metrics.” In school,<br />
there are grades, cumulative averages<br />
and SATs; pediatricians evaluate<br />
babies in percentiles; television<br />
shows get “ratings;” and movies,<br />
ENERGY<br />
CONCERNS<br />
hotels and restaurants get “stars.”<br />
In lighting there are metrics for illuminance,<br />
luminance, brightness,<br />
efficiency and efficacy.<br />
“But beauty,” said the poet,<br />
“lies in the eyes of the beholder.”<br />
Numbers don’t necessarily tell the<br />
whole story.<br />
Sensory perceptions like sight,<br />
hearing, smell and taste, once<br />
thought to follow logorithmic relationships,<br />
are not that predictable.<br />
Visual perception depends upon<br />
the variable factors of illuminance,<br />
task contrast, task size and time,<br />
and that the relationship between<br />
these variables and visual perception<br />
is like a visual cliff. As those<br />
variable factors are slowly improved,<br />
perception climbs quickly,<br />
and then levels off onto a plateau.<br />
If illuminance is increased too far,<br />
glare will develop and perception<br />
will start to decrease, which is<br />
analogous to the sensation of hearing,<br />
where pleasurable sounding<br />
music can get discomforting when<br />
played too load.<br />
The Energydesign Resources website<br />
(www.energydesignresources.<br />
com) devoted a recent issue to a<br />
new metric, “LER,” the Luminaire<br />
Efficacy Rating, described as an<br />
“objective comparison of energy<br />
miserliness among fluorescent luminaries.”<br />
The word, “efficacy” indicates<br />
lumens per watt. Incandescent<br />
lamps produce approximately<br />
10-20 l/w. Fluorescent and HID produce<br />
from 50-100 l/w. Efficiency, on<br />
the other hand, is the ratio of output<br />
divided by input, and because of the<br />
law of conservation of energy, is<br />
always less than 100 percent. LER<br />
combines those two factors — efficacy<br />
and efficiency — to provide this<br />
new metric of “energy miserliness.”<br />
Simply stated, a fluorescent lamp<br />
has a rated light output that’s measured<br />
in lumens. A ballast drives the<br />
fluorescent lamp at some percentage<br />
of that rated lumen output,<br />
which is called the “ballast factor”<br />
(BF). Dimming ballasts vary lamp<br />
lumens from 0 to 100 percent of<br />
their rated value. High/Low ballasts<br />
will give two (50 and 100 percent)<br />
or three (30, 50 and 100 percent)<br />
levels of light, while “standard”<br />
electronic ballasts deliver either 75,<br />
88, 92, 100, 115 or 125 percent of<br />
rated lumens. A ballast with too<br />
high a “BF” will overdrive the lamp<br />
and shorten its life.<br />
Luminaire “efficiency” is expressed<br />
as the measured output<br />
in lumens, divided by the input in<br />
lumens, and is expressed as a<br />
percentage.<br />
LER is defined as Rated Lamp<br />
output in lumens x Ballast Factor<br />
(percent) x Luminaire Efficiency<br />
Sensory<br />
perceptions<br />
like sight,<br />
hearing,<br />
smell and taste,<br />
once thought<br />
to follow<br />
logorithmic<br />
relationships,<br />
are not<br />
that<br />
predictable.<br />
(percent) divided by total luminaire<br />
input in watts. The units of LER are<br />
in l/w, which is why it is called<br />
Luminaire “Efficacy” Rating, and<br />
not “efficiency” rating.<br />
LER is used to compare the l/w<br />
President<br />
Martyn K. Timmings, LC<br />
Vice-President, Market Development<br />
Canlyte - The Genlyte Thomas Group<br />
Past President<br />
Ian Lewin, Ph.D., FIES, LC<br />
President<br />
Lighting Sciences, Inc.<br />
Senior Vice-President<br />
Pamela K. Horner, LC<br />
Manager, Technical Training<br />
OSRAM SYLVANIA<br />
Executive Vice-President<br />
William Hanley, CAE<br />
Vice-President—Educational Activities<br />
Mary Beth Gotti, LC<br />
Manager, Lighting Institute<br />
and Application Development<br />
GE Lighting<br />
Vice-President—-Member Activities<br />
Ronnie Farrar, LC<br />
Lighting Specialist<br />
Duke Power<br />
Vice-President—-Design & Application<br />
Douglas Paulin, LC<br />
Product Manager<br />
Ruud Lighting<br />
Vice-President—-Technical & Research<br />
Richard G. Collins<br />
Supervisor of the Photometry Laboratory<br />
OSRAM SYLVANIA<br />
Treasurer<br />
Patricia Hunt, LC<br />
Hammel Green & Abrahamson<br />
Directors<br />
Balu Ananthanarayanan<br />
Wisconsin DOT<br />
Claudia Gabay, LC<br />
Detroit Edison<br />
Donald Newquist, LC<br />
Professional Design Consultants, Inc.<br />
John R. Selander, LC<br />
Kirlin Company<br />
Fred Oberkircher, LC<br />
Texas Christian University<br />
James L. Sultan, LC<br />
Studio Lux<br />
Regional Vice-Presidents/Directors<br />
Jeff Martin, LC<br />
Tampa Electric Company<br />
Ralph Smith, LC<br />
Ralph Smith <strong>Engineering</strong><br />
2000-2001<br />
Board of Directors<br />
IES of North America<br />
4 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
of a luminaire to the l/w of a similar<br />
luminaire.<br />
There are 11 categories of commonly<br />
used fluorescent luminaires,<br />
and only units in the same category<br />
should be compared for their relative<br />
ability to squeeze out lumens.<br />
LER does not include any factor<br />
for the appropriateness of the photometric<br />
distribution curve, or the<br />
coefficient of utilization of the luminaire,<br />
nor does it take into account<br />
the dirt and dust depreciation of the<br />
luminaire, which is a matter of its<br />
construction. Use LER for what it<br />
was meant to be — a measure of<br />
the combined luminaire, ballast and<br />
lamp efficacy.<br />
The coefficient of utilization table<br />
indicates what proportion of the<br />
calculated illumination is coming<br />
directly from the luminaires and<br />
how much is coming indirectly, and<br />
how important the room finishes<br />
are in the production of inter-reflected<br />
light. The next time you do a<br />
lumen method illumination calculation<br />
look at the far right column of<br />
the CU chart, where the reflectances<br />
are 0 percent ceiling, 0<br />
percent walls, and 0 percent floor.<br />
Using that cu value will provide the<br />
direct component of light in the<br />
space.<br />
When the illumination is computed<br />
using the proper cu for the<br />
room’s finishes, the total direct and<br />
reflected light in the room can be<br />
derived. The inter-reflected component<br />
can be half the total illumination<br />
in the room. If room finishes are<br />
dark, it obviates all the benefits of<br />
choosing a luminaire with the highest<br />
LER in its category.<br />
Project update<br />
Last June, I wrote about the Bilevel<br />
relighting of the 746 public<br />
corridors at Starrett at Spring<br />
Creek in Brooklyn. There are two 13<br />
W CFLs in each luminaire; one lamp<br />
is always on, providing minimum<br />
code level lighting, and the second<br />
lamp is triggered on by an ultrasonic<br />
sensor located on the ceiling in<br />
the center of the corridor.<br />
When anyone enters the hallway<br />
from either their apartment or from<br />
the elevator or stairway, the sensor<br />
detects them and turns the second<br />
lamp on. The sensor holds the second<br />
lamp on for 16 minutes after<br />
there is no more motion detected in<br />
the hallway. Well, we finally installed<br />
a recording w/hour meter last<br />
month on the circuit of a typical<br />
floor with eight apartments. The<br />
recorder’s tapes indicated that the<br />
second lamp is only on for eight out<br />
of every 24 hours a day. That’s a<br />
saving of more than 30 percent in<br />
energy because of the sensors.<br />
When this project started, the<br />
27-year-old co-gen plant at Starrett<br />
was generating electricity, near<br />
capacity, for $.07 per kw-hr. The<br />
higher cost of natural gas has<br />
increased that to $.10/kw-hr. The<br />
13 W CFL lamp that is held off by<br />
the occupancy sensor, saves 16 W<br />
for 6,000 hrs per year (16 hours a<br />
day) at 10 cents/kw-hr or $9.60 a<br />
year. There are 11 fixtures per floor,<br />
so the annual savings in electricity<br />
are $ 105 which pays for the two<br />
sensors on each floor in 2.5 years,<br />
or fewer, if the cost of natural gas<br />
keeps climbing.<br />
We’re now working on a project<br />
which will use an electronic<br />
high/low (50/10 percent output)<br />
ballast in the stairways, with one<br />
lamp per fixture, which will give us<br />
the two proper lighting levels and<br />
extended lamp life. An ultrasonic<br />
sensor, circuit board and power<br />
pack and an emergency battery<br />
pack are all incorporated inside the<br />
luminaire.<br />
Some fluorescent fixture manufacturers<br />
plan to show “smart fixtures”<br />
at LIGHTFAIR INTERNATION-<br />
AL. Smart fixtures have self-contained<br />
occupancy and/or daylight<br />
harvesting sensors in each unit to<br />
adjust the light output of that fixture,<br />
or if they are at the start of a<br />
continuous row of fixtures, or at the<br />
beginning of a wiring “home run,”<br />
they can control all the luminaires<br />
downstream.<br />
There is an interesting aspect to<br />
energy conservation. The bad news<br />
is that energy costs keep rising; the<br />
good news is that the energy conservation<br />
measures we take will<br />
always pay for themselves in less<br />
time than originally projected.<br />
Publisher<br />
William Hanley, CAE<br />
Editor<br />
Chris Palermo<br />
Assistant Editor<br />
Roslyn Lowe<br />
Associate Editor<br />
John-Michael Kobes<br />
Art Director<br />
Anthony S. Picco<br />
Associate Art Director<br />
Samuel Fontanez<br />
Columnists<br />
Emlyn G. Altman • Brian Cronin<br />
Rita Harrold • Li Huang<br />
Louis Erhardt • Willard Warren<br />
Book Review Editor<br />
Paulette Hebert, Ph.D.<br />
Marketing Manager<br />
Sue Foley<br />
Advertising Coordinator<br />
Michelle Rivera<br />
Published by IESNA<br />
120 Wall Street, 17th Floor<br />
New York, N.Y. 10005-4001<br />
Phone: 212-248-5000<br />
Fax: 212-248-5017/18<br />
Website: http://www.iesna.org<br />
Email: iesna@iesna.org<br />
LD+A is a magazine for professionals involved in the art,<br />
science, study, manufacture, teaching, and implementation<br />
of lighting. LD+A is designed to enhance and<br />
improve the practice of lighting. Every issue of LD+A<br />
includes feature articles on design projects, technical<br />
articles on the science of illumination, new product developments,<br />
industry trends, news of the <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />
<strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North America, and vital information<br />
about the illuminating profession.<br />
Statements and opinions expressed in articles and editorials<br />
in LD+A are the expressions of contributors and<br />
do not necessarily represent the policies or opinions of<br />
the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North America.<br />
Advertisements appearing in this publication are the sole<br />
responsibility of the advertiser.<br />
LD+A (ISSN 0360-6325) is published monthly in the<br />
United States of America by the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong><br />
<strong>Society</strong> of North America, 120 Wall Street, 17th Floor,<br />
New York, N.Y. 10005, 212-248-5000. Copyright 2001 by<br />
the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North<br />
America. Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y.<br />
10005 and additional mailing offices. Nonmember subscriptions<br />
$39.00 per year. Additional $15.00 postage for<br />
subscriptions outside the United States. Member subscriptions<br />
$30.00 (not deductable from annual dues).<br />
Additional subscriptions $39.00. Single copies $4.00,<br />
except Lighting Equipment & Accessories Directory and<br />
Progress Report issues $10.00. Authorization to reproduce<br />
articles for internal or personal use by specific<br />
clients is granted by IESNA to libraries and other users<br />
registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC)<br />
Transactional Reporting Service, provided a fee of $2.00<br />
per copy is paid directly to CCC, 21 Congress Street,<br />
Salem, Mass. 01970. IES fee code: 0360-6325/86 $2.00.<br />
This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying<br />
for purposes such as general distribution, advertising or<br />
promotion, creating new collective works, or resale.<br />
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to LD+A, 120<br />
Wall Street, 17th Floor, New York, N.Y. 10005.<br />
Subscribers: For continuous service please notify LD+A<br />
of address changes at least 6 weeks in advance.<br />
This publication is indexed regularly by <strong>Engineering</strong><br />
Index, Inc. and Applied Science & Technology Index.<br />
LD+A is available on microfilm from University<br />
Microfilm, Ann Arbor, Mich.<br />
6 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
SPECIFICATION SALES<br />
STRATEGIES<br />
Li Huang<br />
Principal,<br />
FTC<br />
In the last issue, we discussed the<br />
range of professionals that make<br />
up the lighting specifier community.<br />
This diversity of backgrounds<br />
also exists within the lighting design<br />
community. Despite this, one does<br />
find that lighting designers and<br />
specifiers have common needs and<br />
wants. In this column, we will concentrate<br />
on the lighting design community<br />
and its specific needs.<br />
I recently conducted a small survey.<br />
The survey participants were<br />
lighting designers whose livelihood<br />
is lighting design only. The survey<br />
respondents (eight designers from<br />
seven well-known firms) come from<br />
diverse educational backgrounds.<br />
Their backgrounds are in architecture,<br />
theater lighting, industrial<br />
design, electrical engineering and<br />
architectural engineering. The<br />
seven design firms are located in<br />
Philadelphia, New York, and Boston.<br />
This group of participants is small,<br />
but I felt the quality of the results<br />
was high, due to the caliber of the<br />
participants involved.<br />
All participants said they are currently<br />
called on by numerous manufacturer<br />
sales representatives. All<br />
but one is also called on directly by<br />
manufacturers. This survey asked<br />
the participants to specify the services<br />
they would like to see from<br />
sales representatives during the<br />
specification period, the construction<br />
period and the post-construction<br />
period.<br />
During specification<br />
During the specification period,<br />
the most important services that<br />
respondents would like to see from<br />
sales are 1) accurate project pricing<br />
(with some asking for distributor<br />
net pricing) for project budgeting<br />
purposes; 2) access to samples for<br />
mock-ups in a timely manner; 3)<br />
close direct working relationships<br />
with the manufacturers when developing<br />
custom products; 4) up-todate<br />
product literature and information<br />
(through sales visits or lunchand-learn<br />
sessions); 5) help with<br />
solutions that will resolve challenging<br />
project situations; and 6) honest<br />
and timely responses to information<br />
requests.<br />
During construction<br />
The services the survey participants<br />
felt were most important during<br />
the construction period include<br />
1) respecting the specification (no<br />
“packaging” and product substitution);<br />
2) involving the sales representatives<br />
in the field to resolve<br />
issues; 3) keeping specifiers informed<br />
of the progress of the order;<br />
4) making available product installation<br />
details and shop drawings<br />
when needed; 5) keeping specifiers<br />
informed of delivery dates; 6) coordinating<br />
closely with the distributor<br />
and contractor, even for “out of territory”<br />
projects; 7) assisting in expediting<br />
delivery on fast-track projects;<br />
and 8) responding to information<br />
requests honestly and timely.<br />
During post-construction<br />
The services the survey participants<br />
felt were most important during<br />
the post construction period<br />
include 1) timely and pro-active<br />
response to any field issues; 2)<br />
commissioning help when applicable;<br />
3) follow-up on issues (i.e., do<br />
not drop the ball); and, again, 4)<br />
honest and timely responses to<br />
information requests.<br />
The survey also asked the participants<br />
to list services that they<br />
would expect from the manufacturers<br />
they specify often. These services<br />
include 1) timely and accurate<br />
responses; 2) no overbearing<br />
used-car sales mentality and behavior;<br />
3) making appointments ahead<br />
of time for a meeting (no “dropins”);<br />
4) honest answers (don’t tell<br />
the designer one answer and the<br />
contractor another); 5) greater<br />
comparisons with their competitors’<br />
products, so the designer<br />
knows how to defend the specification<br />
when facing challenges from<br />
contactor or owner; 6) respect the<br />
“no substitutions allowed” specification’<br />
7) help with the lead time of<br />
products specified; 8) project budget<br />
pricing, timely responses to<br />
information requests; and 9) facing<br />
up to issues when they arise (stand<br />
behind your product).<br />
When asked to rate the specification<br />
sales people who are currently<br />
calling on them from 1-10,<br />
with 10 as most satisfying, the<br />
results favored the fixture manufacturers’<br />
sales representatives with<br />
better ratings than the manufacturers’<br />
direct sales force. However,<br />
this could be based on the fact that<br />
more fixture sales representatives<br />
call on specifiers than manufacturers’<br />
direct sales people. Designers<br />
who are called on by manufacturers<br />
do not usually see their sales representatives<br />
as often either.<br />
A few additional issues surfaced<br />
in the general comments section<br />
from the specifiers:<br />
1) Better in-house coordination<br />
between the specification<br />
sales force and distributor<br />
sales force in the larger fixture<br />
sales agencies to help the<br />
specification survive the process<br />
is needed.<br />
2) The practice of pricing a<br />
project as a package has become<br />
popular. This practice of<br />
packaging is making lighting<br />
design more difficult, especially<br />
on “high-end” projects. Designers<br />
feel that they are often<br />
forced to evaluate equals when<br />
no true equals exist. Often<br />
times, the design quality gets<br />
sacrificed.<br />
3) Manufacturers direct sales<br />
representatives are becoming<br />
less visible to the design community.<br />
That situation is sometimes<br />
remedied using a quality<br />
toll-free customer service line.<br />
Although I was not surprised by<br />
any of the responses in the returned<br />
surveys, I was grateful for the participants’<br />
time and effort, for they<br />
made this article more complete by<br />
identifying the many issues facing<br />
lighting specifiers today. Many of<br />
these issues have been around for<br />
years. However, this discussion is<br />
not complete without also understanding<br />
the other side of the equation<br />
— the feelings and issues of<br />
the manufacturers. That will be a<br />
topic for a later issue.<br />
For now, our conclusion is this:<br />
Designers and manufacturers need<br />
each other to succeed. It is the<br />
challenge of the lighting industry to<br />
address the issues and concerns of<br />
every group together, in order to<br />
devise creative solutions that bring<br />
both parties to a middle ground.<br />
8 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
The day is approaching when<br />
we may contemplate throwing<br />
away the quills, felt tip pens,<br />
pencils, and whatever other old-fashioned<br />
writing implements we may<br />
have employed. This may not be<br />
appealing news to everyone, but<br />
many committee chairs have been<br />
asking for improved ways of communicating<br />
internally and with each<br />
ON COMMITTEES,<br />
QUILLS &<br />
OTHER THINGS<br />
Rita M. Harrold,<br />
FIES, LC<br />
Director,<br />
Educational and<br />
Technical<br />
Development<br />
other, reducing the number of faceto-face<br />
meetings (thereby saving<br />
travel dollars) and working more efficiently<br />
to create new publications,<br />
all through electronic means. You<br />
may have noticed the many significant<br />
improvements to the committee<br />
area of the IESNA website<br />
(www.iesna.org), but if you haven’t<br />
visited the site for a while, read on to<br />
find out what is new and different.<br />
The improvements are in the following<br />
areas and we ask for your<br />
help in ensuring that committees<br />
take full advantage of the new capabilities<br />
of specific parts of the site:<br />
• Feature: The list of committees<br />
and subcommittees has been<br />
updated and posted on the website.<br />
In the public area, the list appears<br />
with the individual committee<br />
scopes and members’ names, email<br />
addresses, and phone numbers.<br />
Functions: Anyone, both IESNA<br />
members and non-members, wishing<br />
to join a committee may select<br />
a specific committee and fill out an<br />
application form. An automatic<br />
email response is sent to the applicant,<br />
acknowledging receipt of the<br />
application. Adalisa Machado, committee<br />
administrator, will then follow<br />
up with the committee chairs in<br />
processing the application.<br />
When the chair and the Board of<br />
Directors accepts the application,<br />
the applicant will be moved from<br />
pending to active committee status.<br />
(Note: new committee membership<br />
applications only take<br />
effect following a Board meeting,<br />
since the Board of Directors<br />
approves all committee personnel.)<br />
Benefits: Having the list in the<br />
public area of the website gives visitors<br />
the opportunity to see the<br />
breadth of technical, application<br />
and program areas in which committees<br />
engage. The list also shows<br />
each committee’s scope of work,<br />
and chair contact information.<br />
• Feature: In the Members Only<br />
area of the website, members now<br />
have visibility in their individual profile<br />
area to a list of committees on<br />
which they serve.<br />
Function: The list appears automatically.<br />
Benefit: This provides an instant<br />
check about each member’s committee<br />
membership status. (Members<br />
who wish to withdraw from a<br />
particular committee may also<br />
make the request online.)<br />
• Feature: When members update<br />
their profile information (address,<br />
phone, fax, or email changes)<br />
online, the system now requires<br />
that the member initial the changes<br />
(by filling in a field at the end of the<br />
form) before the change can be<br />
accepted. Similarly if the change is<br />
made in the IESNA office by the<br />
technical department, the initials of<br />
the person who made the change<br />
will appear. The date on which the<br />
change was made is also indicated.<br />
Function: If the initial field is left<br />
blank, the system will not accept<br />
the change and gives a prompt to<br />
complete the process.<br />
Benefit: The indication of who<br />
made the change, and when, can<br />
help to remind the member that<br />
updating needs to occur (because,<br />
for example, the email address has<br />
changed since the last update)<br />
and/or it also lets members know<br />
that the IESNA office has taken<br />
action on a requested change.<br />
Member action item — we ask<br />
that each committee member take<br />
a moment to visit the site and verify<br />
that the profile information and<br />
the list of the committees on which<br />
he/she serves is correct.<br />
• Feature: Committees now<br />
have the ability to post draft documents<br />
on the website for review,<br />
comment and vote.<br />
Function: One person on each<br />
committee, with the role of administrator,<br />
can upload a document<br />
from his/her computer so members<br />
of that specific committee or subcommittee<br />
(but not others) can<br />
view work in progress. There is an<br />
area for members to make comments<br />
and see, in a string, the comments<br />
made by others. The administrator<br />
receives the comments,<br />
makes changes to the draft and<br />
reposts a revised version.<br />
Benefit: Review of publications<br />
can take place outside a face-toface<br />
meeting, saving agenda time<br />
at the next meeting, or maybe even<br />
negate the reason to hold that<br />
extra meeting.<br />
• Feature: Committee members<br />
may vote online.<br />
Function: In the Members Only<br />
area, a committee member will see<br />
a note in red if there is a document<br />
available for ballot from one or more<br />
of his/her committees. When the<br />
vote is cast, the notation disappears.<br />
If the member tries to vote<br />
again, the system will indicate that<br />
that the vote has been received,<br />
with a “thank you” note in red.<br />
Benefit: The administrator can<br />
see who has voted, and can remind<br />
the delinquents. We may be able to<br />
capture votes from all voting members<br />
of a committee in the future!<br />
• Feature: Committee administrators<br />
may now post announcements<br />
of meetings or other activities<br />
in their committee areas.<br />
Function: Easy posting of information<br />
in a template provided in<br />
that particular committee area.<br />
Benefit: Uncertain about the<br />
date or time of the next meeting?<br />
Check your committee area of the<br />
website.<br />
• Feature: This same area of the<br />
site can also be used for posting<br />
minutes of committee and subcommittee<br />
meetings with the same voting<br />
opportunity.<br />
Function: Minutes should be<br />
uploaded in the document area of<br />
the individual committee’s site.<br />
Benefit: Committees can save<br />
significant dollars in mailings. Large<br />
committees with multiple subcommittees<br />
generate voluminous minutes,<br />
which are becoming increasingly<br />
expensive to distribute. However,<br />
while savings are realized, the<br />
burden of printing is passed on to the<br />
10 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
individual member. It is suggested<br />
that the minutes be posted by subject<br />
area or by subcommittee so that<br />
members with only specific areas of<br />
interest may find the relevant material<br />
quickly and easily. Minutes should<br />
also be voted on in the same way as<br />
document voting occurs.<br />
Committee action item — each<br />
committee and subcommittee<br />
should assign one member with<br />
administration rights to post documents,<br />
minutes, announcements,<br />
and receive comments. Please notify<br />
Adalisa Machado (amachado@<br />
iesna.org) or me (rharrold@iesna.<br />
org) who that person is. We will<br />
then enable the system to assign<br />
the responsibility to that individual<br />
for that particular committee.<br />
While large committees with multiple<br />
documents/activities may<br />
wish to have more than one administrator,<br />
the number of administrators<br />
appointed should be as small as<br />
possible for control purposes and to<br />
avoid confusion of responsibilities.<br />
Note that only members of a particular<br />
committee may view draft<br />
documents, minutes of meetings<br />
and other committee information<br />
posted on that committee’s site. A<br />
committee member has access to<br />
the committee area through the<br />
Members Only part of the IESNA<br />
website by entering the membership<br />
number and password. (Non-members<br />
of the <strong>Society</strong> who serve on<br />
committees are given a special committee<br />
membership number. Contact<br />
Adalisa for that information.)<br />
A word to the worried<br />
To those of you who are wary<br />
about the impending electronic<br />
world, rest assured; we will not<br />
cease communicating with you.<br />
No committee member will be<br />
denied the opportunity to continue<br />
to receive paper copies of draft<br />
documents, minutes of meetings,<br />
announcements, and any other<br />
committee correspondence. Members<br />
who wish to receive paper<br />
copies of all materials should notify<br />
the chair of the committee, and<br />
chairs must ensure that those<br />
members are placed on a conventional<br />
mailing list.<br />
There are functions that are not<br />
available for committee use. Online<br />
changes to a committee member’s<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
status, such as, advisory member<br />
to member, member to chair and<br />
deletion from a committee, can only<br />
be made by the IESNA office. The<br />
reason is two-fold: 1) changes can<br />
only be made after Board approval,<br />
and 2) we want to protect the member<br />
from unauthorized changes.<br />
There are also functions that we<br />
have decided not to offer at the<br />
present time. The site will not<br />
enable committees to do broadcast<br />
emails - yet. We opted instead<br />
for the posting of information in the<br />
individual committee areas.<br />
IESNA Staff action item — we<br />
will be working over the next several<br />
months to try to ensure that<br />
the committee area of the site<br />
addresses each committee’s<br />
needs. There are always other functions<br />
and features that can be<br />
identified for addition at a later<br />
date (budget permitting). Your<br />
input, as always, is welcome.
Russ Owens,<br />
South Pacific<br />
Coast RVP<br />
As the newly elected regional vice-president for<br />
the South Pacific Coast Region, I am simultaneously<br />
overwhelmed, apprehensive and encouraged.<br />
The region was recently expanded to include<br />
three new Sections and the term of office was also<br />
extended to three years. Having been the Region’s secretary<br />
for the past three years, while serving on our<br />
REGIONAL<br />
VOICES<br />
local Section’s Board of Managers, I am aware of some<br />
of the work that is required to keep an organization like<br />
the IESNA moving.<br />
It is not a continuum that moves on its own without<br />
the need of volunteers at every level. From the president<br />
of the <strong>Society</strong> to the most bashful member of a<br />
Section that volunteers to make name tags for a<br />
Section meeting, we are all a part of the same team.<br />
I began my own membership a number of years ago<br />
during a career change, at a time when I saw the value<br />
and immediate need for networking with those in the<br />
industry that might be of benefit to starting a consulting<br />
business from scratch. I began to attend the local<br />
Board meetings, was recruited to help with education<br />
and took on a succession of positions leading to president<br />
of the Section. My involvement was always voluntary<br />
and certainly changed from self-serving interests,<br />
to seeing the larger need to provide programs and other<br />
venues for the education of those who wanted and<br />
needed to learn more about lighting.<br />
I have seen many of my predecessors burn out and<br />
virtually not be heard from again. New people are the<br />
lifeblood of any volunteer organization and the few that<br />
do step forward to help, often get rewarded with more<br />
duties than they bargained for. Some can’t wait to get<br />
their term of office over with and get away.<br />
I would like to offer some suggestions to help retain<br />
the seasoned people as advisors (they have a wealth of<br />
knowledge of the history of the Sections and usually are<br />
more patient in their approach to meeting goals) and<br />
get the “next generation” of lighting professionals<br />
involved at the local level.<br />
• Let’s take advantage of the numerous awards that<br />
the <strong>Society</strong> has established and begin to reward those<br />
who have served the Sections and Regions with years<br />
of loyal service (you know, the ones that seem to serve<br />
on the Board forever, always helping in small ways,<br />
those that always are at the meetings helping to make<br />
a difference, etc). Present them with an award at a<br />
Section meeting. Recognize longevity and service at<br />
the variety of levels we have awards for. Section officers<br />
— look in those Section Guides for the various awards<br />
and give credit where credit is due. People that serve<br />
don’t usually do it for the reward, but it is a huge stroke<br />
when your colleagues notice it and act upon it.<br />
• Let’s promote <strong>Society</strong> membership to people we<br />
work with — either in our offices or our clients — as an<br />
Agree or disagree,<br />
we are moving forward<br />
and need both fresh ideas<br />
as well as<br />
seasoned ones.<br />
organization that has provided them with something<br />
they might not even think about, but utilize every day.<br />
Our <strong>Society</strong> produces (through volunteer committees<br />
and alliances with other organizations) Design<br />
Guidelines, Technical Memorandums, Recommended<br />
Practices and other tools we use and quote every day<br />
in conducting business (i.e. How many roadways or<br />
sports facilities are designed to IES Standards?) During<br />
times when budgets decline, disposable income vanishes<br />
and memberships lose priority; however, they utilize<br />
the tools we have produced and they should be<br />
encouraged to consider supporting the organization<br />
that gives them those tools.<br />
• Let’s get the next generation, the “Young Guns”<br />
(gender inclusive) involved in education and serving in<br />
the local sections. Some have had lighting education in<br />
college, and some have not, but they can all benefit<br />
from the IESNA Education materials. Education classes<br />
are a great place to recruit the next leadership for the<br />
section. The energy and ideas that the younger industry<br />
members possess should be harnessed to bring the<br />
local sections, as well as the <strong>Society</strong> at large, along<br />
into the future. Let us not cling to paradigms that<br />
worked 10 years ago; we are in an age where technology<br />
is changing faster than the seasons, and we need<br />
to be able to embrace the wealth of new ideas the<br />
young people can bring.<br />
• With the awareness that corporate budgets have<br />
been cut, as past sources for funding of local mailings<br />
and publishing, local sections are now turning to the<br />
wonders of the electronic age, email and faxing. I am a<br />
proponent of these tools and they appear to be a great<br />
way to get Section Newsletters or meeting notices in<br />
from of a lot of people quickly, repeatedly and with a<br />
minimal investment of time and money. We should<br />
begin and or continue the use of these tools to contact<br />
our respective database of members and interested parties<br />
about meetings, etc. One drawback to only using<br />
the electronic method of communication is the potential<br />
of a lack of connectivity with the membership. It can<br />
become easy to hit the send button and miss the fact<br />
that we still are an organization of people and that<br />
human contact is what keeps us sane (some of us less<br />
than others). I think it is a good idea to initiate phone<br />
contact from time to time with the membership, so that<br />
the IES identity/connection is not relegated totally to<br />
the infamous line “you’ve got mail.”<br />
Agree or disagree, we are moving forward and need<br />
both fresh ideas as well as seasoned ones.<br />
14 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
Willard L.<br />
Warren,<br />
PE, LC,<br />
FIESNA<br />
Asophisticated new lighting<br />
control system that uses digital,<br />
rather than analog, signals<br />
to control the light output of a<br />
ESSAY<br />
BY INVITATION<br />
which particular lamps and ballasts<br />
are in need of replacement.<br />
The DALI system can be programmed<br />
to turn units on or off, or<br />
dimmed from 1-100 percent light<br />
output, by means of a simple low<br />
voltage control wire that loops<br />
through the building to every fixture.<br />
Further, when DALI is used in<br />
conjunction with a building management<br />
system, every lamp and<br />
ballast can be addressed to determine<br />
if the lamp or ballast is in<br />
working order. This status report<br />
can be gathered, either on-site, or<br />
at the central office of a maintenance<br />
contractor, to determine<br />
how many replacement lamps and<br />
ballasts are required, what kind<br />
It can<br />
feed back<br />
information<br />
on which<br />
particular<br />
lamps and<br />
ballasts are in<br />
need of<br />
replacement.<br />
Figure 1 — User interface<br />
Figure 2 — DALI software<br />
digital electronic ballast was recently<br />
introduced into this country<br />
The new digital electronic ballast<br />
and its control will replace the analog<br />
electronic ballast as the international<br />
standard in a few years<br />
because of its incredible versatility.<br />
The acronym for the new control<br />
protocol is “DALI,” which stands for<br />
“Digital Addressable Lighting Interface.”<br />
The beauty of DALI is that it<br />
allows the user to address every<br />
individual digital ballast, and program<br />
its lamp’s light output. And,<br />
because DALI is a two-way system,<br />
it can feed back information on<br />
they are, and where they are located.<br />
This saves time and money<br />
when servicing multiple sites in<br />
the same geographical area, like<br />
department stores, chain stores<br />
and supermarkets.<br />
The DALI system also allows digital<br />
ballasts to be controlled wherever<br />
they are in the ceiling, so if<br />
changes are made in the arrangement<br />
of departments on a floor,<br />
the lighting luminaires do not have<br />
to be re-wired, just re-addressed.<br />
Because the DALI system controls<br />
every individual ballast, it allows<br />
the user to assign every fixture to<br />
any one of 16 different groupings<br />
of luminaires in the space, and create<br />
multiple operating modes or<br />
scenes. Lighting levels can also be<br />
adjusted to respond to conditions<br />
like energy cutbacks, daylight harvesting,<br />
occupancy status, or the<br />
system can be used to turn any<br />
part of a large office into a conference<br />
area, with the ability to dim<br />
any fixtures needed to facilitate<br />
audio/visual presentations.<br />
The DALI system can be<br />
accessed either by a PC or a Palm<br />
OS device. Figure 1, the user-friendly<br />
PC screen, shows how easy it is<br />
to set the output of the ballast and<br />
assign it to one of 16 fixture groups.<br />
In the third step of the DALI program,<br />
the user selects the fade<br />
time and fade rate of each ballast.<br />
Figure 2 shows the control plan of<br />
three groups of luminaires, how<br />
they will be dimmed, and at what<br />
time. The user simply draws the<br />
fade and time curve with a PC<br />
mouse, and each group of ballasts<br />
creates the desired scene, as programmed.<br />
The PCs or Palm controllers<br />
can be located at several<br />
locations on the floor and changed<br />
at any time.<br />
Many American and European<br />
manufacturers have already signed<br />
on to provide hardware for this new<br />
16 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
technology, which is expected to<br />
grow in popularity in this country, as<br />
it already has in Europe. The lamps<br />
that can be controlled include the<br />
popular new fluorescent sources<br />
like the T5 and T5 HO, T8, 18 to 42<br />
W CFLs, and the 40 and 50 W long<br />
fluorescent PL (Biax) lamps, with<br />
more to come. The digital electronic<br />
ballast is wired for universal voltage<br />
(120 V or 277 V), it employs a<br />
soft start for long lamp life, it will<br />
start the lamp at any point in its<br />
dimming range, and will cut out the<br />
lamp at the end of its life.<br />
The DALI system is also ideally<br />
suited to deal with energy conservation<br />
and energy curtailment.<br />
Interestingly, the rolling blackouts<br />
last November in California occured<br />
from 6 to 8 p.m., when many offices<br />
were still open and homeowners<br />
were preparing dinner, watching<br />
television, and turning on Christmas<br />
lights. California now requires<br />
stores and malls shut their lights off<br />
power. That is why the versatile<br />
DALI digital ballast control system<br />
is so valuable. It can be programmed<br />
to automatically shed<br />
lighting load by dimming the lights<br />
in stages when an energy curtailment<br />
is required.<br />
The DALI digital ballast system<br />
comes with so many user benefits;<br />
fluorescent dimming, load shedding,<br />
luminaire grouping, scene<br />
control, lamp and ballast failure<br />
status, changing switch control<br />
without rewiring, integration of<br />
daylight harvesting, occupancy<br />
sensor control, and so many others,<br />
that the cost of the system<br />
will be less than the sum of all the<br />
parts needed to perform all these<br />
different functions. DALI, the “digital<br />
addressable lighting interface”<br />
is the lighting control of the<br />
future. It can be programmed to<br />
provide the proper lighting level<br />
when and where it is needed, and<br />
most economically.<br />
California<br />
now requires<br />
stores and malls<br />
shut their<br />
lights off<br />
when they close<br />
to keep<br />
electric demand<br />
down in the<br />
evening.<br />
when they close to keep electric<br />
demand down in the evening.<br />
Energy curtailment will be with<br />
us for a while in many parts of the<br />
country because of spot shortages<br />
of capacity. But even when<br />
we catch up with demand, we will<br />
still have to deal with higher costs<br />
of electricity, pollution controls<br />
and codes that restrict our use of<br />
www.iesna.org
Brian Cronin,<br />
Director of<br />
Business<br />
Development,<br />
Planetmouse,<br />
Inc.<br />
Basic research is what I am doing when I don’t<br />
know what I am doing.<br />
—Wernher von Braun<br />
Istumbled upon an online article describing a research<br />
study called The Consumer Daily Question Study. (If<br />
you want more information on this study, conducted<br />
by Lewis, Mobilio & Associates, on behalf of Keen.com,<br />
check out: www.keen.com/documents/corpinfo/<br />
pressstudy.asp). This study monitored about a hundred<br />
people over the course of a week and found Americans<br />
generate an average of four new questions every day.<br />
Participants spent nearly nine hours per week (online<br />
WORKING<br />
WITH THE WEB<br />
and off) looking for the answers. The primary resource<br />
was the Internet, followed by Friends & Family; Sales &<br />
Service Providers; Medical Professionals & Therapists;<br />
and Magazines. Surprisingly, several traditional sources<br />
— libraries, TV news, encyclopedias, dictionaries and<br />
maps — were tapped less often than in the past.<br />
Business Contacts came in dead last; so much for trusting<br />
your peers.<br />
Information access is a discovery process that will<br />
continue to evolve. Time is essential in finding answers,<br />
as is effort. But it is efficiency, the impact of both time<br />
and effort, that determines the course of action. We<br />
want our information faster and with less energy expended.<br />
Until time travel or human cloning become commonplace<br />
in the work environment, improving the informationgathering<br />
process must focus on the source. Increased<br />
efficiency hinges on improving access and the Internet is<br />
an obvious choice for fast, efficient data gathering.<br />
Conducting Research Online<br />
Web-based research is a fast, painless process. The<br />
three most commonly used online research tools are:<br />
search engines, directories and metacrawlers.<br />
Search Engines are one of the most popular research<br />
tools on the web. They direct users, based on<br />
specific topics, to the web pages that best suit them.<br />
The user punches in a request and the search engine<br />
automatically responds by or “crawling” the web to<br />
compile a relevant list of websites.<br />
• Lycos began as a search engine, depending on listings<br />
that came from spidering the web. Today, it uses a<br />
directory model similar to Yahoo. Lycos (www.lycos.<br />
com) also owns and runs HotBot (www.hotbot.com),<br />
another popular search engine.<br />
• Excite is one of the most popular online search services.<br />
It offers a large index and integrates non-web<br />
material such as company information and current<br />
events into its results. Excite also owns and runs<br />
Magellan and WebCrawler as separate search services<br />
(www.excite.com).<br />
• AltaVista is one of the largest search engines on the<br />
web, in terms of pages indexed. It offers extensive coverage<br />
and a wide range of search commands, making it<br />
a favorite among researchers (www.altavista.com).<br />
• AOL Search offers two search services: one for its<br />
members and one with general web access for nonmembers.<br />
This ‘external’ site (http://search.aol.com)<br />
does not list the AOL content available to its members.<br />
• Google is a search engine that uses link popularity<br />
to rank websites. The more links to a site, the higher<br />
the ranking. Yahoo supplements its results with those<br />
from Google (www.google.com).<br />
Directories, a little different than search engines, are<br />
often included under this grouping. A directory depends<br />
on human input for its listings. Individual websites submit<br />
a short description to the directory for the entire site<br />
or the directory editors create one for sites they review.<br />
A directory search looks for matches only in these<br />
descriptions. A well-designed site with quality content is<br />
more likely to be reviewed than a poor site.<br />
• Yahoo is the web’s heavyweight search service<br />
champ. Its reputation for helping people find information<br />
quickly and easily is well-earned. Yahoo is the<br />
largest human-compiled guide online, employing hundreds<br />
of editors to help categorize the web. Launched<br />
in 1994, Yahoo is also the oldest major website directory<br />
(www.yahoo.com).<br />
• LookSmart is another qualitative or human-compiled<br />
directory of websites. It also provides directory<br />
results to MSN Search, Excite and many other search<br />
engines, in addition to being a stand-alone service<br />
(www.looksmart.com).<br />
Metacrawlers function a bit differently than search<br />
engines and directories do. Rather than searching the<br />
web and building their own listings for each request,<br />
metacrawlers conduct a search on multiple sites all at<br />
once and then provides the compiled results. So, the<br />
user gets the best of multiple search engines and directories,<br />
rather than just one source. Metacrawler examples<br />
include: Go2Net /MetaCrawler (www.go2net.<br />
com/index.html); Mamma (www.mamma.com); and<br />
Dogpile (www.dogpile.com).<br />
Garbage in – garbage out<br />
The quality of the answer often depends on the quality<br />
of the question. Web-based research is no different. The<br />
key is knowing how to request information quickly and<br />
efficiently. Here are some basic tips for searching online<br />
(for the sake of time and efficiency, the term “search<br />
engine” also covers directories and metacrawlers<br />
Using + and -: You can instruct search engines to<br />
find web pages that must contain or exclude specific<br />
words and phrases. For example, if you want to list the<br />
top web pages containing both the words ‘dog’ and<br />
‘retriever,’ enter +dog +retriever into the search field. If<br />
you want only web pages that contain ‘dog,’ but exclude<br />
‘poodle,’ enter +dog –poodle.<br />
“Double Quotes”: Most search engines also allow<br />
you to search for exact phrases by using double quotes.<br />
For example, if you type in ‘classic cars,’ you will receive<br />
a list of pages that contain classic and/or cars. However,<br />
if you search for “classic cars,” your search will<br />
18 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
yield only those pages containing the specific phrase.<br />
Wildcard Matching: Some search engines will let<br />
you use an asterisk (*) to customize your search even<br />
further. This is called Wildcard Matching. Attaching ‘*’<br />
to the right-hand side of a word will return left side partial<br />
matches. For instance, if you type in ‘ball*’ versus<br />
‘ball,’ your search will return pages containing both the<br />
word ball and words containing ball, i.e. baseball.<br />
Capital Letters: Most search engines treat lower<br />
case search phrases as universal, but will perform a<br />
case sensitive search if you capitalize any letter. If you<br />
search for ‘baby,’ you will receive pages containing baby<br />
or Baby. But if you search for ‘Baby,’ only pages containing<br />
Baby will be returned.<br />
Document Field Restrictions: Some search engines<br />
can conduct searches of specific web page sections<br />
(such as titles, URLs images) by attaching one of the<br />
field operators to your search terms. By placing a field<br />
name in front of a word, it restricts the search to a certain<br />
section of a web page. Examples include: t: or title:<br />
- this restricts searches to document titles only, as in:<br />
martha stewart vs. t:martha stewart; u: or url: - will<br />
restrict searches to document URLs only, as in: amazon<br />
vs. url:amazon. Other field restrictions include: image,<br />
link, text, alt, domain, host (varies by search engine).<br />
Boolean Phrases: Most major search engines support<br />
Boolean searching. You can limit search result by<br />
including AND, OR and NOT according to Boolean logic.<br />
Search for dog AND retriever to find pages containing<br />
both words. Search for dog OR retriever for pages with<br />
one word or the other. Search for dog NOT retriever to<br />
find pages that have dog but not retriever.<br />
You might think you could get the same results<br />
using + or – signs, but Boolean phrases allow you to<br />
use multiple parameters. To find any page, which talks<br />
about dog and about retriever, but which, does not<br />
mention poodle or pitbull, just type in the search<br />
phrase: dog AND retriever NOT (poodle OR poodles OR<br />
pitbull OR pitbulls.).<br />
The Internet is an excellent information resource, but<br />
people use a variety of resources to find the answers<br />
they need, depending on the circumstances. Human<br />
assistance is still the most popular choice. But when<br />
your “meat-based” resources are limited and you’ve<br />
used up all your Phone-A-Friend and Ask the Audience<br />
lifelines, the World Wide Web may be the best way to<br />
find the answers. To learn more about online research<br />
or search engines, send me an email at brian@planetmouse.com.<br />
I will explore this topic in more detail later,<br />
when we talk about search engine site registration.<br />
Brian Cronin works with Planetmouse, Inc. — an<br />
Interactive consulting and development firm based<br />
in New York. Planetmouse is a team of developers,<br />
designers and strategists who provide Interactive<br />
business solutions and web-based design for a wide<br />
range of clients. You can learn more about Planetmouse<br />
by visiting www.planetmouse.com
Members in the News<br />
OSRAM SYLVANIA, Danvers, Mass.,<br />
announced that Greg Lowe was awarded<br />
the Commercial Engineer of the Year<br />
Award. Thomas Ciskoski received the<br />
Sales Representative of the Year Award<br />
and Sally Lee received the Sales Excellence<br />
of the Year Award.<br />
Vincent Lighting Systems, Inc. has<br />
promoted Jason Potts to the position of<br />
service manager in its Cleveland office.<br />
Potts joined Vincent Lighting Systems<br />
as an assistant project manager in May<br />
of 1999, after graduating from Kent<br />
State University in Kent, Ohio.<br />
Creighton Bostrom was appointed<br />
by W.A.C. Lighting, Garden City, N.Y.<br />
and Bostrom Lighting Sales, Raleigh,<br />
N.C. as its new representative. Bostrom<br />
Lighting Sales was established<br />
by Lars Bostrom, formerly of Bostrom-<br />
Hulett, Inc.<br />
Mac Warnell has announced his retirement<br />
from the position as Director<br />
of International Sales with SPI<br />
Lighting, Inc. Warnell has been involved<br />
with the lighting industry since<br />
1962. He became associated with SPI<br />
when it was a division of McGraw<br />
Edison, and has continued his affiliation<br />
with the company since its independent<br />
ownership in 1988.<br />
Crawford Lipsey has been named<br />
vice-president, sales and marketing, for<br />
the business unit for Holophane,<br />
Newark, Ohio. Since joining Holophane<br />
in June of 2000, Lipsey has served as<br />
vice-president of sales. In this newly<br />
expanded role he will be responsible for<br />
the management of the U.S. sales<br />
force as well as for all product development,<br />
marketing and engineering for<br />
Holophane.<br />
Alex P. Cheng, LC, a lighting specialist<br />
at Gannett Fleming, Harrisburg, Pa.,<br />
received the Technical Achievement<br />
Award from the Central Pennsylvania<br />
Engineers Week Council. In order to<br />
meet the evaluation criteria, Cheng<br />
had to demonstrate accomplishments<br />
in the areas of academic achievement,<br />
ILLUMINATING<br />
ENGINEERING<br />
SOCIETY<br />
NEWS<br />
VOLUME 31, NUMBER 5<br />
MAY 2001<br />
engineering and technical achievement,<br />
and citizenship. In addition, nominees<br />
were also required to not be a<br />
registered professional engineer, to be<br />
a good standing member of one of the<br />
Council’s member organizations, a resident<br />
of Pennsylvania, and a citizen of<br />
the US. Cheng was presented with the<br />
award during the Council’s National<br />
Engineers Week banquet celebration.<br />
This was the first year for the award.<br />
continued on following page<br />
See you<br />
in Ottawa<br />
at the<br />
IESNA<br />
Annual<br />
Conference<br />
August 5-8, 2001<br />
IESNA Calendar of Events<br />
May 29-June 1<br />
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL<br />
Las Vegas<br />
Contact: AMC, Inc.<br />
404-220-2221/2215<br />
www.lightfair.com<br />
June 7-10<br />
IESNA Maritime Regional Conference<br />
Halifax, Canada<br />
Contact: Lee Hiltz • 902-484-3008<br />
June 20-23<br />
IESNA Northeastern Regional<br />
Conference<br />
(Beacon of Light)<br />
Boston<br />
Contact: Doreen Le May Madden<br />
dmadden@luxlightingdesign.com<br />
781-237-1989<br />
August 5-8<br />
2001 IESNA Annual Conference<br />
Ottawa, Canada<br />
Contact: Valerie Landers<br />
212-248-5000, ext. 117<br />
vlanders@iesna.org<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
October 14-17<br />
IESNA Street & Area<br />
Lighting Conference<br />
Orlando<br />
Contact: Valerie Landers<br />
212-248-5000, ext. 117<br />
vlanders@iesna.org<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
October 22-25<br />
IESNA Aviation Lighting Seminar<br />
San Diego<br />
Contact: Baljit Boparai<br />
609-821-7756<br />
baljit.boparai@flysfo.com<br />
www.iesalc.org<br />
ASHRAE Updates<br />
Standard 90.1’s HVAC Section<br />
Addenda revising parts of the heating, ventilating and air-conditioning section<br />
of ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1-1999, Energy Standard for Buildings<br />
Except Low-Rise Residential Buildings, have been approved for publication.<br />
In total, 16 addenda, which consist of minor editorial changes, were approved<br />
for publication. Among the addenda impacting the HVAC section is an addendum<br />
that relates to the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) procedures.<br />
The approval for publication is subject to a 15-day appeal period. The<br />
addenda will be published by ASHRAE online in the spring.<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
LD+A/May 2001 21
Member News<br />
continued from previous page<br />
High-Lites, Inc., Waterbury, CT<br />
announced appointment of five new<br />
manufacturers’ independent sales representative<br />
agencies. Arizona Lighting<br />
Sales, Inc. now represents High-Lites<br />
products throughout the state of<br />
Arizona. Curtis H. Stout/Shreveport is<br />
now responsible for High-Lites products<br />
throughout the greater Shreveport,<br />
La. territory. Curtis H. Stout/<br />
Gulf Coast, Inc. is concurrently responsible<br />
for High-Lites products<br />
throughout Mobile, Ala. and the Florida<br />
panhandle. Stiles & Associates,<br />
headed by George Mays will represent<br />
High-Lites products throughout the<br />
Las Vegas area. United Associates will<br />
represent High-Lites products in the<br />
greater Charlotte, N.C. area.<br />
The Electrical Consulting <strong>Engineering</strong><br />
firm of Delan & Dustin, Inc.<br />
announced the appointment of James<br />
Knoerr as vice-president of the firm.<br />
Knoerr has been a project engineer<br />
with the firm since 1995. He is a registered<br />
professional engineer in the<br />
state of Wisconsin, Illinois, California,<br />
Mississippi and Louisiana, and has<br />
been certified by the National Council<br />
of <strong>Engineering</strong> Examiners. His new<br />
duties include production scheduling<br />
and director of employee educational<br />
programs as well as continuation of<br />
his present responsibilities as a project<br />
engineer. Knoerr was also a past<br />
president of the Milwaukee Section of<br />
the IESNA.<br />
Errata<br />
Lumenation Lighting Design was<br />
inadvertently left out of our March<br />
issue listing of Copper Sustaining<br />
Membership. The IESNA and LD+A<br />
regrets the error.<br />
e-mail a<br />
letter to the<br />
editor:<br />
cpalermo@iesna.org<br />
SUSTAINING<br />
MEMBERS<br />
The following companies have elected<br />
to support the <strong>Society</strong> as Sustaining<br />
Members which allows the IESNA to fund<br />
programs that benefit all segments of the<br />
membership and pursue new endeavors,<br />
including education projects, lighting<br />
research and recommended practices.<br />
The level of support is classified<br />
by the amount of annual dues, based<br />
on a company’s annual lighting revenues:<br />
Copper: $500 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $4 million<br />
(Copper Sustaining Members are listed in<br />
the March issue of LD+A, as well as in<br />
the IESNA Annual Report. There are currently<br />
233 Copper Sustaining Members).<br />
Silver: $1,000 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $10 million<br />
Gold: $2,500 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $50 million<br />
Platinum: $5,000 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $200 million<br />
Emerald: $10,000 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $500 million<br />
Diamond: $15,000 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues over $500 million<br />
IES SUSTAINING<br />
MEMBERS<br />
DIAMOND<br />
General Electric Co.<br />
Lithonia Lighting<br />
OSRAM SYLVANIA Products, Inc.<br />
Philips Lighting Co.<br />
EMERALD<br />
Holophane Corporation<br />
PLATINUM<br />
Day-Brite Capri Omega<br />
Lightolier<br />
Lutron Electronics Co, Inc.<br />
Ruud Lighting, Inc.<br />
GOLD<br />
ALP Lighting Components Co.<br />
Altman Lighting, Inc.<br />
Barth Electric Co., Inc.<br />
Detroit Edison<br />
Edison Price Lighting, Inc.<br />
Finelite, Inc.<br />
Indy Lighting, Inc.<br />
Kurt Versen Co.<br />
Lexalite Int’l Corp<br />
Lighting Services, Inc.<br />
Lightron of Cornwall, Inc.<br />
LSI Industries, Inc.<br />
Martin Professional, Inc.<br />
Matsushita Electric Works, Ltd.<br />
Musco Sports Lighting, Inc.<br />
Niagara Mohawk Power Corp<br />
Poulsen Lighting, Inc.<br />
Prudential Lighting Corp<br />
San Diego Gas & Electric<br />
SIMKAR Corp<br />
SPI Lighting, Inc.<br />
Steelcase, Inc.<br />
The Bodine Company<br />
The Kirlin Company<br />
United <strong>Illuminating</strong> Co.<br />
Visa Lighting<br />
SILVER<br />
Ardron-Mackie Limited<br />
Aromat Corp.<br />
Axis Lighting, Inc.<br />
Bartco Lighting, Inc.<br />
BJB Electric Corporation<br />
Canlyte, Inc.<br />
Carinci Burt Rogers Eng, Inc.<br />
Cinergy PSI Energy<br />
City of San Francisco Bureau of Light & Power<br />
Con Edison Co of New York<br />
Con-Tech Lighting<br />
Custom Lighting Services LLC<br />
Custom Lights, Inc.<br />
Day Lite Maintenance Co.<br />
EEMA Industries<br />
Elf Atochem North America Inc.<br />
Energy Savings, Inc.<br />
ENMAX<br />
Enterprise Lighting Sales<br />
ERCO Lighting USA Inc.<br />
Exelon Infrastructure Services<br />
Eye Lighting Industries<br />
Eye Lighting International of North America<br />
Factory Sales Agency<br />
Fiberstars, Inc.<br />
Focal Point<br />
Gammalux Systems<br />
H E Williams, Inc.<br />
HAWA Incorporated<br />
High End Systems, Inc.<br />
Hubbell Lighting, Inc.<br />
Kansas City Power & Light Co.<br />
Kenall Mfg Co.<br />
King Luminaire Co.<br />
Kirby Risk Supply Co, Inc.<br />
Ledalite Architectural Prdcts<br />
Lee Filters<br />
Legion Lighting Co.<br />
Leviton Mfg Co, Inc.<br />
Linear Lighting<br />
Litecontrol Corp<br />
Litelab Corp<br />
Litetronics Int’l, Inc.<br />
Lucifer Lighting Co.<br />
Multi Electric Mfg, Inc.<br />
Optical Research Associates<br />
Optima <strong>Engineering</strong> PA<br />
P & K Pole Products<br />
Paramount Industries, Inc.<br />
Portland General Electric<br />
Power Lighting Products, Inc.<br />
Prescolite, Inc.<br />
PSE & G<br />
R A Manning Co, Inc.<br />
Radiance, Inc.<br />
Reflex Lighting Group, Inc.<br />
Sentry Electric Corp<br />
Shakespeare Composites & Electronics Division<br />
Shaper Lighting<br />
Shobha Light Designers<br />
Southern California Edison<br />
Stage Front Presentation Sys.<br />
Stebnicki Robertson & Associates<br />
Sternberg Vintage Lighting<br />
Sterner Lighting Systems, Inc.<br />
Strand Lighting, Inc.<br />
TXU Electric & Gas<br />
Vestar Limited<br />
W J Whatley, Inc.<br />
WAC Lighting Co.<br />
Wiko, Ltd.<br />
Winnipeg Hydro<br />
Wisconsin Public Service Corp<br />
As of April 2001<br />
22 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
2001 IIDA Entries<br />
The following design projects were<br />
submitted to the IIDA program through<br />
respective sections of the IESNA, and<br />
reported to the IESNA office in New<br />
York. These projects will proceed<br />
through the IIDA judging process during<br />
the coming months, with final merit<br />
and international-level awards to be<br />
CANADIAN REGION<br />
(Jana Nor)<br />
Montreal Section (Roger Gervais)<br />
Lighting Chateau Frontenac: A.<br />
Guiholt, T. Guilhot, S. Laquerre<br />
Lighting the Foothbridge Straddling<br />
Aux Sables River: L. Fortin, J.<br />
Bouchard, R. Fay<br />
Sports Center – College Regina<br />
Assumpta: R. Savard<br />
National Capital Section<br />
(Gerry St. Michael)<br />
Canadian National War Memorial &<br />
Tomb of the Unknown Soldier: M.<br />
Conboy<br />
Human Resources Development<br />
Canada Management Centre: L.<br />
Lalande, D. MacLellan, J. Brown<br />
La Cité Collegiale – Technological<br />
Amphitheatre Fit Up: F. Dussault<br />
National Defense Control Centre: L.<br />
Lalande, A. Midgley, G. Moore, D.<br />
Brooks, A. Rankin, M. Tite<br />
Parliament Hill: P. Gabriel<br />
Personal Environmental Controls: I.<br />
Pasini<br />
Plaza Bridge: M. Conboy<br />
Software Development Lab: W.<br />
Needham, J. Salem<br />
Toronto Section (Jerry Mobillo)<br />
Bensimon Byrne Advertising: T.<br />
McDonnell<br />
Canary Wharf Wayfinding &<br />
Signage: K. Muller<br />
Casino Point Edward: F. Carinci, R.<br />
Hopkins, D. Morettin<br />
Christopher Ondaatje South Asian<br />
Gallery: S. Powadiuk<br />
CIBC Executive Boardroom: S.<br />
Powadiuk<br />
City Hall Redesign: D. Parks<br />
Geraldton Heritage Interpretive<br />
Centre: S. Powadiuk<br />
Private Residence: R. Forbes-Gray,<br />
G. Boccini<br />
Sterner Automation: R. Forbes-Gray<br />
Techspace: S. Powadiuk<br />
The Golden Rule: St. Michael’s<br />
College School: J. Gulino, C.<br />
Thacker, L. Kavanagh<br />
The Prince Arthur Mansions –<br />
Archway Lighting: W. Schelnman,<br />
D. Scappaticci<br />
Thunder Bay Charity Casino –<br />
Exterior Lighting: D. Nash, D.<br />
Scappaticci, K. Kapush<br />
Thunder Bay Charity Casino –<br />
Interior Lighting: R. Wong, D.<br />
Scappaticci, K. Kapush<br />
EAST CENTRAL REGION<br />
(Dave Safford)<br />
Blue Ridge (Leland Gammon)<br />
Roanoke College Campus Center<br />
Atrium Lighting: B. Alcorn<br />
Roanoke College Campus Center<br />
Wortmann Ballroom: B. Alcorn<br />
Maryland Section (Brian Walsh)<br />
Applied Physics Lab – Building 26:<br />
F. Lucas, L. Thomas-Kaonohi, E.<br />
Miller<br />
Saint Ignatius Church: B. Dunlop, J.<br />
Suttner, M. Murphy<br />
Philadelphia Section (David Safford)<br />
Bloomberg Financial: G.<br />
Golaszewski, K. Brooks<br />
Burdines – Florida Mall: A. Borden,<br />
M. Barber, W. Kader<br />
Caanan House University Museum:<br />
G. Kay<br />
City Hall Records Office: M. Alcaraz,<br />
J. Brown, B. Groch<br />
Francis Jerome Cosmetics: P. Pitzer<br />
Gymnasium Lighting Renovation: J.<br />
Camarota<br />
Inspector Sees What the Customer<br />
Sees: C. Watson, D. Rodstein<br />
J&B Software: K. Keilt, A. Hladio<br />
Loews Philadelphia Hotel: M.<br />
Komitzky, P. Helms, S. Cole<br />
Lucy the Elephant (EPRI): G. Kay<br />
Lucy the Elephant (Interior): G. Kay<br />
Modern and Contemporary Gallery:<br />
M. Alcaraz, B. Hahnlen, P.<br />
Whiden, M. Sheridan, J.<br />
Schlecter, A. Slavinskas<br />
Museum Shop: M. Alcaraz, B.<br />
Hahnlen, G. White<br />
PA Turnpike Commission Tuscarora<br />
Tunnel: C. Oerkvitz, G. Forstater,<br />
G. Schorn<br />
Philadelphia City Hall Façade<br />
Lighting Mock-Up: A. Borden, J.<br />
Panassow, J. Bryan<br />
Re-lighting of the Benjamin Franklin<br />
Bridge: D. Edenbaum, S. Stashik,<br />
R. Grenald<br />
Renovation & Expansion of WHYY:<br />
A. Borden, E. Friar<br />
Richmond Town Square Renovation:<br />
H. Diemer, J. Panassow, B.<br />
Cotter, D. Pasttison<br />
Schuylkill River Bridges: R. Grenald,<br />
C. Sarge<br />
Singapore Turf Club: M. Alcaraz, R.<br />
Cunningham, G. Golaszewski, R.<br />
Garman, R. Ghisu, J. Chase<br />
Sports Challenge Exhibit: M.<br />
Alcaraz, B. Hahnlen, R. Ghisu, W.<br />
Crimm<br />
St. Mary’s Steeple: G. Kay<br />
The First Presbyterian Church<br />
(EPRI): K. Keilt, A. Hladio<br />
The First Presbyterian Church<br />
(Interior): K. Keilt, A. Hladio<br />
Susquehanna Section<br />
(Sheila Martin)<br />
Delta Development Group: J. Balan<br />
Hagerstown Hampton Inn North: D.<br />
Blontz<br />
Norfolk Southern Intermodal<br />
Facility: A. Cheng<br />
Pinnacle Health System Fredrickson<br />
Outpatient (Exterior): S. Good<br />
Pinnacle Health System Fredrickson<br />
Outpatient (Interior): S. Good<br />
The Spartan Center – Elliptical Stair:<br />
K. Yancey, L. Cronin, S. Good<br />
The Spartan Center: K. Yancey, L.<br />
Cronin, S. Good<br />
Town Center Site Lighting: K.<br />
Yancey, L. Cronin, S. Good<br />
US Route 30: D. Strong, A. Cheng<br />
GREAT LAKES REGION<br />
(Jim Fowler)<br />
Cleveland Section (Rita Koltai)<br />
Big Fish Restaurant – Exterior: B.<br />
David<br />
Pioneer Standard/Keylink Systems:<br />
R. Koltai<br />
Progressive Insurance Building 3 –<br />
Open Offices: B. David<br />
St. Joseph Church – Exterior: D.<br />
Bacik, E. Radziszewski<br />
St. Joseph Church – Interior: D.<br />
Bacik, E. Radziszewski<br />
Indiana Section<br />
(Myron Martin, Sam Hurt)<br />
Hill-Rom Museum: M. Sommers, G.<br />
White, D. Goforth, M. Martin<br />
Indiana Repertory Theatre: S.<br />
McComas, S. Rowland<br />
Indiana War Memorial 151st Field<br />
Artillery Post of Command<br />
Exhibit: S. McComas<br />
LightSource: L. Donato, M. Martin<br />
Reis Nichols: S. McComas<br />
Resurrection Life Youth Center: E.<br />
Paget, D. Herscher, N. Ybarra, V.<br />
Phillips<br />
Michigan Section (Mark Gadzinski)<br />
Asarian Cancer Center – Healing<br />
Center: P. Wroblewski<br />
BMW Office Renovation: D. Rodi-<br />
Barczys<br />
Dickson Cyberexpress: K. Klemmer,<br />
R. Harwood, A. Wood, M.<br />
Huggins<br />
General Motors Tech Center: B.<br />
White, P. Ramin, D. Franklin<br />
announced at the IESNA Annual<br />
Conference (and spotlighted in the<br />
August issue of LD+A).<br />
This list contains all entries received<br />
by March 27, 2001. Listed in parenthesis<br />
are the regional IIDA chairs and<br />
the section chairs, respectively.<br />
The 2001 IIDA Committee consists<br />
of Zoe Taylor Paul, chair; Jim Zastovnik,<br />
secretary; Lorinda Walters Flores,<br />
Kevin Flynn, Renee Green, Jim Harpest,<br />
Howard Kosowky, Bob McCully, Jim<br />
Mewes, Jerry Mobilio, Donald Newquist,<br />
Phil Santia and Mary Tatum; and<br />
advisory members: Larry Ayers, Robert<br />
Carlson, William Hirons, Frank LaGiusa<br />
and Jerry White.<br />
Grosse Pte. United Methodist<br />
Church: R. Trudelle, C. Pappas<br />
Independence Elementary School:<br />
G. Ziegler<br />
Jackson National Life Headquarters:<br />
R. Manriquez, J. Gezwing<br />
Siemens Automotive: B. White, P.<br />
Ramin<br />
Stoney Creek High School: G.<br />
Ziegler<br />
Rochester Section (Philip Nelson)<br />
The Great Hall – Rush Rhees<br />
Library: T. Bucher, J. Durfee, C.<br />
Jensen, M. Pandolf<br />
Western Michigan Section<br />
(Greg Stein)<br />
Brandon Middle School (Exterior): H.<br />
Vines, T. Gasser<br />
Brandon Middle School (Interior): H.<br />
Vines, T. Gasser<br />
Designware Warehouse Lighting: W.<br />
Mayne, S. Thompson<br />
Porter Hills Presbyterian Village<br />
Wellness Center: H. Vines<br />
Western New York Section<br />
(Don Wrobel)<br />
Canisius College Montante Cultural<br />
Center: T. Fowler<br />
St. Stephen’s Roman Catholic<br />
Church: R. Soto<br />
SOUTH PACIFIC COAST REGION<br />
(Mark Seegel)<br />
Arizona Section (Greg Gapen)<br />
Anthem Country Club: W. Spitz, B.<br />
Shelly, B. Hawthorne<br />
Bethune Residence: A. Louie<br />
Biltmore Mountain Estates<br />
Residence: R. Schneider<br />
Coffin and Trout Jewelers: A. Louie<br />
Congregation B’nai Israel Sanctuary<br />
Remodel: S. Dent, R. Nordhaus<br />
Greenberg Residence Landscape: K.<br />
Wilde<br />
Prince of Peace Catholic: W. Spitz,<br />
M. Mueller<br />
Saint Joan of Arc Catholic Church:<br />
R. Hawthorne, W. Spitz<br />
The Shops at Gainey Village: R.<br />
Hawthorne, W. Spitz<br />
Uh-oh Clothing Boutique: A. Louie<br />
Virginia Piper Trust Foundation: A.<br />
Louie<br />
Golden Gate Section<br />
(Angela Lawrence)<br />
Amway Corporate Headquarters,<br />
Tokyo: D. Witte<br />
Berkeley Wireless Research Center:<br />
A. Lindsley, M. Shefren<br />
continued on following page<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
LD+A/May 2001 23
IIDA Entries<br />
continued from previous page<br />
Cannon Constructors S.F. Office: M.<br />
Souter, K. Coke<br />
Church of the Nativity: C. Ng<br />
Coca Cola Fan Lot at Pacific Bell<br />
Park: T. Becker, N. Schwab<br />
Experience Music Project – Lobby,<br />
Café, and Retail Areas: T. Becker,<br />
K. Roberson, N. Schwab, J.<br />
Holladay<br />
KTA Offices (EPRI): TJ. Towey, K.<br />
Komorous<br />
KTA Offices (Interior): TJ. Towey, K.<br />
Komorous<br />
Mary Stuart Rogers Music Hall: P.<br />
Glasow, S. Porter<br />
Men in Black Alien Attack –<br />
Interiors: N. Schwab, K.<br />
Roberson, T. Becker, D. Bowling,<br />
B. Malkus, J. Holladay, J. Fisher,<br />
P. Eisenhauer<br />
Palo Alto Westin Hotel: M. Souter,<br />
E. Huang<br />
The Plant Recording Studio – The<br />
Garden Mixing Room: T. Becker,<br />
C. Marcheschi<br />
Trader Vics: D. Hawthrone<br />
W Hotel – San Francisco: M. Souter,<br />
E. Huang<br />
W Hotel – Seattle: M. Souter, E.<br />
Huang<br />
Los Angeles Section (Mark Seegel)<br />
Boeing Building 043 Product Display<br />
and Training Facility: L. Reed<br />
Breeze Restaurant: K. Fuller, B.<br />
Shankar<br />
Callaway Gardens Discovery Center:<br />
K. Fuller, B. Shankar<br />
Carsdirect.com: K. Jones, A. Powell,<br />
C. Israel<br />
Chapman University BIT Building: J.<br />
Dunn, T. Brogden<br />
DisneyQuest, Chicago: P. Dinkel, C.<br />
Breakfield, S. Westbrook, L. Yates<br />
Dodgers Stadium Renovation: A.<br />
Powell<br />
Gaudi Bar: J. Cooper, M. Rosenberg<br />
Hollywood/Highland Metro Rail Station:<br />
T. Brogden, J. Nolan, S. Klein<br />
Hyatt Regency Lake Las Vegas: T.<br />
Nord, B. Shankar<br />
LAX Gateway Enhancement: D.<br />
Hollingsworth, J. Windle, E.<br />
Powell, P. Tzanetopoulos<br />
Legal Research Network: C. Israel,<br />
F. Feist<br />
Lutèce: P. Quigley, D. Fox<br />
Mandalay Bay – Bayside Buffet and<br />
Noodle Bar: J. Cooper, S. Whitaker<br />
Mandalay Bay – Hotel & Casino: J.<br />
Cooper, S. Whitaker<br />
Marriott Hotel at JR Tower: T. Nord,<br />
B. Shankar<br />
Norton Simon Museum Screening<br />
Room: L. Reed<br />
Oglivy & Mather: C. Israel, F. Feist<br />
Otaru Hilton: B. Shankar, K.<br />
Tanimura<br />
Skechers USA Concept Store: A.<br />
Jain<br />
Sky Harbor Terminal 3 Rockwork: E.<br />
Thomas, D. Hollingsworth<br />
Studio Walk at the MGM Grand<br />
Hotel & Casino: J. Cooper, I.<br />
Silbert, M. Rosenberg<br />
Sunset Station – Hotel & Casino: J.<br />
Cooper, M. Rosenberg<br />
Taj Mahal Hotel: K. Ganti, B. Shankar<br />
TRW Systems Federal Credit Union:<br />
L. Reed, F. Feist<br />
Tsunami Asian Grille: P. Quigley, D.<br />
Fox<br />
Wieden & Kennedy Agency<br />
Headquarters: T. Brogden, T.<br />
Aghassian<br />
Orange Section (Adrienne Kelly)<br />
Bear Street Bridge, South Coast<br />
Plaza: F. Krahe, J. Fox, J.<br />
Poulson, N. Ogle<br />
Calvary Chapel – Silverado Canyon:<br />
S. Arnold<br />
Disney Store – Exterior: T. Ruzika,<br />
B. Castaneda<br />
Disney Store – Interior: T. Ruzika, B.<br />
Castaneda<br />
Downtown Disney at Disneyland<br />
Resort: F. Krahe, J. Fox, P. Butler,<br />
P. Henshall, D. Manfredi, A.<br />
Mayer, M. Willie, W. Chao<br />
Old Bank Building Renovation: T.<br />
Ruzika, M. Finney<br />
PF Changs China Bistro at The<br />
Aladdin: K. Kosiba, J. Blonstein, J.<br />
Gamble, G. Crespo, J. Proctor, B.<br />
Stabstad<br />
Quiksilver Headquarters: F. Krahe, T.<br />
Givler, J. Bauer, A. Wiley, R.<br />
Hassel<br />
Schneider Residence: E. Reo<br />
The Block at Orange: F. Krahe, Y.<br />
Mendoza, K. Pavek, R. Allaire, B.<br />
D’Agostino, C. Izzo<br />
The Shops at Mission Viejo: F.<br />
Krahe, Y. Mendez, T. Givler, J.<br />
Fox, R. Altoon, G. Dempster<br />
Utah Section (Phillip Whisenhunt)<br />
Children with Special Health Care<br />
Needs Office: J. Good<br />
Ford Motor Building Adaptive<br />
Reuse: K. Garner, T. Higgins<br />
KTUX Broadcast Facility: J. Good<br />
Market Street Restaurant and<br />
Oyster Bar at the Cottonwood<br />
Corporate Center: K. Garner, T.<br />
Higgins<br />
Riley Elementary School: J.<br />
Martinez<br />
Salt Palace Expansion - Exterior: C.<br />
Feldman<br />
Salt Palace Expansion – Interior: C.<br />
Feldman<br />
Southtown Convention Center: J.<br />
Good<br />
Sutherland Moot Courtroom: J.<br />
Good<br />
Utah Department of Transportation,<br />
Operations Center: J. Good, C.<br />
Forrest<br />
MIDWEST REGION<br />
(Kathi Vandel)<br />
Black Hawk (David Shelley)<br />
Swiner Designer: J. Eman, M. Culver<br />
Chicago Section (Rick Kellen)<br />
Accenture: M. Sills, S. Riebe, P.<br />
Hagle, J. Seegers, K. Mikuta, C.<br />
Severson, S. Vignali, S. Andersen<br />
Amazon Rising: Seasons of the<br />
River: R. Shook, E. Klingensmith,<br />
A. Ackerman<br />
First United Methodist Church: M.<br />
Sills, S. Johnson<br />
General Growth Properties, Learning<br />
Mall: M. Sills, S. Riebe, C.<br />
Griffiths, M. Reinhart, G. Tadin, L.<br />
Leskaj, R. Houts, S. Andersen, M.<br />
Morga<br />
Happy Boys and Girls: W. Charter,<br />
D. Jennerjahn, C. McGrath<br />
Loop Lighting Improvement –<br />
Randolf Street: M. Maltezos, J.<br />
Stanley, S. Kinzie<br />
Loop Lighting Improvement – West<br />
Randolf Street: M. Maltezos, J.<br />
Stanley, S. Kinzie<br />
Northwestern Memorial Hospital<br />
Campus Streetscape Lighting: M.<br />
Pelikan<br />
Old St. Patricks Church: R. Shook,<br />
J. Baney, M. Urban<br />
Ourhouse.com: M. Sills, C. Lewis,<br />
M. Everts, H. Wasilowski<br />
Real Goods: W. Charter, S. Riebe, K.<br />
Lawson<br />
Second Street Bridge: R. Shook, J.<br />
Baney, E. Klingensmith<br />
Ten East Doty Lobby: M. Sills, D.<br />
Jennerjahn, E. Saltzman<br />
Union Station Multiplex: J. Knox, L.<br />
Boeke<br />
USG Solutions: M. Sills, C. Lewis,<br />
M. Everts, J. Valerio, R. Mattheis,<br />
H. Wasilowski<br />
Heart of America Section<br />
(Anne Lindberg)<br />
Baron BMW: J. Pierce, K. Vandel, C.<br />
Leech<br />
Birch Telecom Lobby and<br />
Conference Center at D.A. Morr:<br />
D. Porter, K. All<br />
Birch Telecom Open Office at D.A.<br />
Morr: D. Porter, K. All<br />
Delmonico’s Steakhouse: D.<br />
Kohnen, M. Frank<br />
Douglas County Jail: P. Robertson<br />
Golf Course Superintendents<br />
Association of America: K. Green<br />
Pony Express Bank: R. deFlon, M.<br />
Anthony<br />
River City Studio: D. Porter, A.<br />
Matlock<br />
Milwaukee Section (David Drumel)<br />
Brown County Courthouse Exterior<br />
Lighting Remodel: C. DeWaal<br />
DCI Marketing – Conference Room:<br />
M. Cooper<br />
Fluno Center for Executive<br />
Education: M. Cooper<br />
Kenosha Public Museum: J. Cody<br />
Legacy Lighting at the State<br />
Capitol: K. Kozminski, L. Davis, R.<br />
Nelson<br />
Offices of Eppstein Uhen Architects:<br />
L. Howard, S. Klein, TJ Morley<br />
Offices of Grunau Project<br />
Development: S. Klein, D. Drumel<br />
Playing with Food (EPRI): M. Peck<br />
Playing with Food (Interior): M. Peck<br />
Prairie Heaven: M. Colegrove<br />
Private Motor Yacht: L. Howard, S.<br />
Klein<br />
Seeing Green!: M. Colegrove<br />
Weber Residence: M. Cooper<br />
St. Louis Section (Sandy Frederich)<br />
Bass Pro Shops Prototype: R. Kurtz,<br />
R. Burkett, N. Clanton, D. Nelson<br />
Boeing Leadership Center: T.<br />
Kaczkowski<br />
Chicago Creative Partnership: M.<br />
Herman<br />
Civil Courts Floodlighting: T.<br />
Kaczkowski, D. Raver<br />
Commerce Bank: R. Kurtz, R.<br />
Burkett, E. MacKey, E. Crader, M.<br />
Englemohr<br />
Forest Park Twins: T. Kaczkowski,<br />
D. Raver<br />
Mansion House Lighting & Signage:<br />
S. Frederich, R. Wagstaff<br />
Nidus Center for Scientific Enterprise:<br />
D. Raver, T. Kaczkowski<br />
R.G. Brinkman Construction Co.: W.<br />
Gray, G. Wehmeier<br />
Research North Lobby at Ralston<br />
Purina: D. Raver<br />
SJI: M. Herman, B. Kaemmerlen<br />
Statue of St. Louis Floodlighting: T.<br />
Kaczkowski, D. Raver<br />
Ursas Café: A. Feddersen-Heinze, H.<br />
Testa<br />
Xtra Lease, Inc.: J. Meyer, S. Drake<br />
Twin Cities Section (Chad Watters)<br />
Accenture: J. Crosby, P. Koski, T.<br />
Messerli, G. Lecker, D. Mutcher,<br />
J. Thibault<br />
c’More Medical Solutions: A. Friend<br />
Corporate Cafeteria: T. Ham, I. Keer,<br />
M. Ostrom, A. Hillebregt<br />
D. Zimmerman, G. Behm, T.<br />
LaDouceur<br />
McNamara Alumni Center –<br />
Memorial Hall: L. Tredinnick, M.<br />
DiBlasi<br />
Minnesota Chapter of the ASID: A.<br />
Friend<br />
Notre Dame’s Main Administration<br />
Building: J. Dehnert, L. O’Connell,<br />
T. Ham, D. Zimmerman, G. Behan<br />
Pentair Executive Offices: G.<br />
Heumann, D. Thomas<br />
SOUTHEASTERN REGION<br />
(E. Frank Clements)<br />
Alabama Section<br />
(Stephanie Johnson)<br />
Jefferson County Courthouse: J. Gill<br />
Levy’s Fine Jewelry & Gifts: B.<br />
Herrington, F. McComb, S.<br />
Boomhover<br />
TSUM Clock Tower and Plaza: S.<br />
Adams<br />
Central Florida Section (Mike Cahill)<br />
IXL Client Center: D. Bowling<br />
Georgia Section (Morgan Gabler)<br />
A’Wow Presentation Space: R. Noya<br />
Colony Square: T. Bell<br />
Korean World Trade Center: P.<br />
Helms, J. Shimmin<br />
Soft Transparency: R. Noya<br />
Greater Triad Section<br />
(Katherine Doyle)<br />
GMAC Interactive Building Sign: D.<br />
Yanusz<br />
Mid-South Section (Robert Burris)<br />
Starabilias: L. Roper<br />
The Forth Bridge: R. De Alessi, T.<br />
Connor<br />
continued on following page<br />
24 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
IIDA Entries<br />
continued from previous page<br />
The Seattle Space Needle: R. De<br />
Alessi, C. Woods, B. Medsker<br />
Mississippi Section (Thomas Rhaly)<br />
Mississippi Memorial Stadium<br />
Renovation: M. Woolard, J.<br />
Browning<br />
Mississippi Trade Mart Renovation:<br />
J. Browning<br />
Northeast Florida Section<br />
(Michael Vranesh)<br />
Acosta Bridge/Skyway Express<br />
Neon: D. Laffitte, R. Richardson<br />
ADT Customer Service Center: D.<br />
Laffitte<br />
Southeast Florida (Keith Rosen)<br />
Ferrel Schultz Carter Zumpano &<br />
Fertel: R. Carlson, E. Holland, I.<br />
Garcia<br />
Holly Hunt Showroom – Miami: S.<br />
Bistrong<br />
Sky TV: M. Wolk<br />
Virgin Atlantic Airways – SF Lounge:<br />
S. Bistrong<br />
Tennessee Valley Section<br />
(Bob Harden)<br />
To Conserve a Legacy: M. Haggitt<br />
NORTHEASTERN REGION<br />
(Megan Carroll)<br />
Mohawk Hudson Section<br />
(Kenn Latal)<br />
A Modest 1930’s Troy Residence:<br />
N. Miller<br />
Lighting Research Center,<br />
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute:<br />
H. Brandston, D. Zuczek, J. Brons<br />
St. Mary’s / St. Paul’s Church: N.<br />
Miller<br />
Suny Postsdam Re-Lighting of<br />
Hosmer Concert Hall: M.<br />
Anderson<br />
New England Section (Rick Paradis)<br />
Adaptive Reuse of the MERCADO<br />
D’ABASTO: A. Kibbe, C. Ripman<br />
Autostadt: K. Abernaty, S. Rosen,<br />
M. Warner<br />
Boston University Student Village<br />
(BU Dorms) Public Areas: M.<br />
Loeffler<br />
Chandelier Restoration, University &<br />
Baker Halls: H. Moss, R. Zeitsiff<br />
Fort Trumball State Park: C.<br />
Ripman, C. Walsh<br />
Irving S. Gilmore Music Library: A.<br />
Kibbe, C. Ripman<br />
Lighting the Spires of Harvard:<br />
Memorial Church: C. Ripman, C.<br />
Walsh<br />
Lighting the Spires of Harvard: Memorial<br />
Hall: C. Ripman, C. Walsh<br />
MIT Building One Classrooms: I.<br />
Khan, S. Mahler, J. Berg, J. Sladen<br />
Nyanja! Africa’s Inland Sea: S.<br />
Rosen, M. Graves<br />
Terminal Expansion, Manchester<br />
Regional Airport – Exterior<br />
Lighting: C. Ripman, B. Morley<br />
Terminal Expansion, Manchester<br />
Regional Airport – Interior<br />
Lighting: C. Ripman, B. Morley<br />
The C. Bernard Shea Rowing<br />
Center: C. Ripman<br />
The Great Platte River Road<br />
Archway Monument: S. Rosen, K.<br />
Abernathy<br />
The New Music Building, The<br />
Lawrenceville School: C. Ripman,<br />
C. Walsh<br />
The Relighting of St. John’s Chapel:<br />
C. Ripman<br />
University of Pennsylvania Chiller<br />
Plant: R. Osten, J. Hamilton, J.<br />
Brown<br />
USPS Processing and Distribution<br />
Center: H. Gerber<br />
New York Section<br />
(Shoshanna Segal)<br />
Addison Circle Rond Point: S.<br />
Bernstein, D. Rogers<br />
American Museum of Natural<br />
History: C. Stone, H. Forrest, M.<br />
Toomajian<br />
Asian Spice at Resorts: P. Gregory,<br />
J. Nathan, D. Rockwell<br />
Audrey Jones Beck Bldg, Museum of<br />
Fine Arts: P. Marantz, R. Renfro,<br />
H. Forrest<br />
Bates USA: B. Horton<br />
Bergdorf Goodman – Plaza Level: R.<br />
Cooley, E. Monato<br />
Beyond Day Spa: M. Hay, B. Kuchler<br />
Brasserie 8 1 /2: P. Marantz, R.<br />
Schoenbohm, R. Gomez<br />
Bratton Theater, Chautauqua<br />
Institute: R. Davis<br />
Brian Clarke Cone, UBS AG<br />
Headquarters: S. Margulies<br />
Calvary Episcopal Church: C. Cosler<br />
Carnegie Science Center – E-motion<br />
Light Sculpture: M. Tanteri, S.<br />
Caan, N. Goldsmith<br />
Celebration Health: M. Harris, B.<br />
Horton<br />
Condé Nast Cafeteria: S. Margulies,<br />
F. Soler, S. Szynal<br />
Condé Nast Headquarters: S.<br />
Margulies, F. Soler<br />
Congregation B’nai Yisrael: A. Kale<br />
Conran Shop and Guastavino’s<br />
Restaurant at Bridgemarket: P.<br />
Marantz, S. Hershman<br />
District: P. Gregory, C. Cameron, J.<br />
Bosse, D. Rockwell<br />
Emerils: P. Gregory, A. Sebeshalmi,<br />
D. Rockwell<br />
Explorer Dining Room: P. Marantz,<br />
R. Schoenbohm, R. Manning<br />
George Washington Bridge Tower:<br />
D. Gonzalez, G. Gouls, A.<br />
Wadhwa, S. Buracksilapin<br />
Great Bazaar: J. Fisher, I.<br />
Eisenhauer, D. Rockwell<br />
Greenwich Hospital: S. Brady, A.<br />
Uysal<br />
H&M Flagship Store: P. Gregory, A.<br />
Sebeshalmi<br />
Hensel Hall - Ann & Richard Barsinger<br />
Center for Music: C. Cosler<br />
Hoboken Train Station Waiting<br />
Room: T. Thompson, R. Burns, J.<br />
Plumpton, S. Lyn<br />
Hotel Giraffe: B. Horton<br />
House for a Bachelor: G. Gordon<br />
International Business Technology<br />
Management Office: R. Prouse,<br />
B. Walter, R. Kliment, F.<br />
Halsband, A. Diez, S. Broughton,<br />
G. George, T. Solsaa<br />
International Center of Photography:<br />
C. Stone, E. Carrera, B.<br />
Mosbacher<br />
Iwataya Passage: M. Tanteri, J.<br />
Valgora, N. Goldsmith<br />
JFK Terminal One: D. Gonzalez, G.<br />
Gouls, M. Merza<br />
JP Morgan Arrakis Center: S.<br />
Margulies, J. Bailey<br />
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart: C. Stone, E.<br />
Carrera, B. Mosbacher<br />
Knoll Inc. Showroom: P. Gregory, D.<br />
Ades, L. Flores<br />
Light Threshold: J. Carpenter, R.<br />
Kress, M. Tanteri<br />
Loews 42nd Street Theatres: P.<br />
Gregory, B. Anderson, D.<br />
Rockwell<br />
LVMH Tower: P. Marantz, S.<br />
Hershman<br />
Meyers Midway Garage: J.<br />
Underwood<br />
Museum and Visitors Center Samuel<br />
FB Morse: F. Bettridge, M.<br />
Salzberg, A. Hibbs<br />
Mystic Aquarium and Institute for<br />
Exploration: F. Bettridge, D.<br />
Rogers<br />
NASDAQ Marketplace: A. Kale, C.<br />
Knowlton, S. Brill<br />
New York Institute: C. Cosler<br />
Newark Penn Station: D. Gonzalez,<br />
D. Tulchin, M. Merza<br />
Niagara Mohawk Headquarters<br />
Exterior Ltg.: H. Brandston, J.<br />
Halser, B. Rutledge, K. Simonson,<br />
B. Carter<br />
Nobu Vegas: P. Gregory, K.<br />
Donahue, D. Rockwell<br />
NOMI: D. Singer, M. Koyama, L.<br />
Ivanovska<br />
Nortel Networks Executive Briefing<br />
Center: S. Bernstein, D. Rogers<br />
Osmanthus Garden: T. Lin, C. Lien,<br />
W. Wong, W. Wen, S. Wu, P. Lin,<br />
M. Pon, K. Tseng, S. Lin<br />
Oxygen Media: S. Brady<br />
POD Restaurant: C. Johnson, J.<br />
Ning, D. Rockwell<br />
Pratt Institute – School of Architecture:<br />
D. Singer, M. Koyama<br />
Predictive: D. Singer, J. Gim<br />
Raleigh Durham Airport Parking<br />
Garage: F. Bettridge, D. Rogers<br />
Resorts: P. Gregory, J. Nathan, D.<br />
Rockwell<br />
Rosa Mexicano: P. Gregory, D.<br />
Rockwell<br />
Royal Promenade Oculus: C. Stone,<br />
R. Schoenbohm, L. Kirkland<br />
Sea Grill Restaurant: A. Kale, C.<br />
Knowlton<br />
Shanghai Lilly: D. Singer, R. Fernandez,<br />
M. Koyama, L. Ivanovska<br />
Shapiro Residence: D. Singer, M.<br />
Koyama<br />
Sony Theatres – Metreon: P. Gregory,<br />
B. Andersen, D. Rockwell<br />
Strip House: P. Gregory, L. Flores, D.<br />
Rockwell<br />
The Apartment: A. Kale, M. Hunter<br />
The Butterfly Conservatory: D.<br />
Clinaro<br />
The Lord Group: S. Brady, K. Loren<br />
The New 42nd Street Studio<br />
Building Façade: A. Militello<br />
The Tonic Restaurant: M. Kruger<br />
Trading Floor Expansion, New York<br />
Stock Exchange: M. Mehl<br />
Tribeca Grand Hotel: P. Gregory, B.<br />
Anderson, S. Spelninhauer<br />
U.S. Federal Courthouse: P.<br />
Marantz, S. Hershman<br />
United States Courthouse,<br />
Lafayette, Louisiana: F. Bettridge<br />
Warren Hall, Columbia Graduate<br />
School of Law & Business: K.<br />
Douglas, D. Mintz<br />
Winners Club: K. Goldstick<br />
Western New England Section<br />
(William Llewellyn)<br />
Exploration Place: W. Warfel, S.<br />
Schrager<br />
Yale University School of Art: G.<br />
Gordon<br />
NORTHWEST REGION<br />
(Ross Probert)<br />
British Columbia Section<br />
(Darren Luce)<br />
Burnaby Mountain Secondary<br />
School: J. Jay, D. Kaardal<br />
Coastal Forest Thematics Area: D.<br />
Welch, P. Hodson<br />
H2O + Store, Vancouver: G.<br />
Zbrizher, P. Gowland, B. North<br />
Moose Creek Village, at YVR: M.<br />
Graham, C. Curren<br />
NISGA’A USM Government Building:<br />
M. Graham, R. Pacheko<br />
Pender Place: E. Wormsbecker, K.<br />
Bunn, G. Zbrizher<br />
Richmond City Hall: M. Graham<br />
Thompson Community Centre: R.<br />
Hughes, C. Suvagau<br />
Vancouver City Council Chambers:<br />
P. Hodson, D. Welch<br />
Chinook Section (Jeff Bannard)<br />
Airport Corporate Center: L. Barone,<br />
B. Boucoek<br />
Bow Parkade: P. Fritz<br />
Calgary Exhibition and Stampede<br />
Roundup Centre - Exterior: R.<br />
Robertson, S. Mahler, B. Currie<br />
Calgary Exhibition and Stampede<br />
Roundup Centre – Interior: R.<br />
Robertson, S. Wappel, B. Currie<br />
Corus Entertainment: P. Mercier, M.<br />
Rajain, K. Creen<br />
Grabbajabba: G. Korenicki<br />
Hyatt Regency Hotel: H. Doornberg,<br />
D. Reitz, S. Martens<br />
Transalta T1 Floor Renovations: L.<br />
Barone<br />
Utilicorp Networks Canada Office –<br />
(EPRI): B. Maitson<br />
Utilicorp Networks Canada Office –<br />
(Interior): B. Maitson<br />
Wiebe Forest <strong>Engineering</strong> Offices: L.<br />
Barone, J. Bannard<br />
Northern Gateway Section<br />
(Ross Probert)<br />
Biological Sciences Research<br />
Growth Rooms: R. Rogers<br />
School of Business Lighting<br />
Upgrade: R. Rogers, W. Brenner<br />
26 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
Oregon Section (Stephanie Cissna)<br />
ArchCape Residence: A. Humphrey,<br />
E. Gerding<br />
Bertil Vallien at Bullseye Glass: V.<br />
Batho-Demelius<br />
Botsford Residence: M. Godfrey, V.<br />
Batho-Demelius, E. Levin<br />
Christiane Millinger Oriental Rugs at<br />
the Wieden and Kennedy<br />
Building: V. Batho-Demelius<br />
Classical Chinese Garden: R. Dupuy<br />
CNF ADTECH Center (EPRI): A.<br />
Humphrey, K. Davis, K. Andersen<br />
CNF ADTECH Center (Interior): A.<br />
Humphrey, K. Davis, K. Andersen<br />
EastBank Riverfront – Phase I & II:<br />
A. Viado, S. Smith, C. Mayer-Reed<br />
Hickox Salon & Spa: J. Davis<br />
Lane County Juvenile Justice<br />
Center: G. Hansen<br />
Molecular Probes: T. Adams<br />
Nike Parking Building “P”: M.<br />
Ramsby<br />
OSU Valley Library: M. Ramsby<br />
Pacific Continental Bank, West 11th<br />
Branch: G. Hansen<br />
Portland International Airport<br />
Canopy: M. Ramsby, C. Oty<br />
PSU IC Lab: C. Oty, S. Emmons<br />
Sandstrom Residence: E. Levin<br />
St. Anthony Catholic Church: J.<br />
Davis, J. Rogers<br />
University of Oregon Recreation &<br />
Fitness Center: G. Hansen<br />
Uvona/Rapidign: V. Batho-Demelius<br />
Washington State University Student<br />
Recreation Center (EPRI): A.<br />
Humphrey, K. Davis, B. Curry<br />
Washington State University Student<br />
Recreation Center (Interior):<br />
A. Humphrey, K. Davis, B. Curry<br />
West Hills Residence: V. Batho-<br />
Demelius<br />
West Linn High School: C. Oty<br />
Woodstock Library: C. Oty<br />
Puget Sound Section (Gloria Koch)<br />
Pacific Place: S. Darragh, J. Miller<br />
Reebok World Head: S. Darragh,<br />
J. Miller<br />
Café 9: D. Simpson<br />
F5 Networks: S. Rhodes<br />
Café 9 (exterior): D. Simpson<br />
LaGuardia Airport: G. Lunde<br />
SOUTHWESTERN REGION<br />
(Sean Gaydos)<br />
North Texas Section<br />
(Dave Comer, Sean Gaydos)<br />
“Chihuly, Inside and Out,” at the<br />
Joslyn Art Museum: E. Levin, V.<br />
Batho-Demelius, D Palin<br />
Abuelo’s Mexican Food Embassy: J.<br />
Whelan, M.Tresp<br />
American Light Facility Solutions<br />
Group Dallas Showroom: B.<br />
Graham, B. Lieber, R. Lee<br />
Business Jet Center (Exterior): R.<br />
Mapes, E. Levin, C. Roeder, G.<br />
McAnear<br />
Business Jet Center (Interior): R.<br />
Mapes, E. Levin, C. Roeder, G.<br />
McAnear<br />
Carlson Capital Office Space: P.<br />
Wilson<br />
Crockett Residence (Exterior): M.<br />
Maloney, V. Batho-Demelius, M.<br />
Godrey, E. Levin<br />
Crockett Residence (Interior): M.<br />
Maloney, V. Batho-Demelius, M.<br />
Godrey, E. Levin<br />
Driskill Hotel: M. Keilson<br />
Marriott South Beach Hotel: M.<br />
Keilson<br />
Miller of Dallas: J. Klores<br />
PANJA: T. Weiss, K. Weiss<br />
Parkland NICU: J. Klores<br />
Renovation of the French-Brown<br />
Showroom: T. James, S. Lawson<br />
Sacred Space Exhibit: P. Wilson<br />
Stonebriar Office Lobby: H. Hobbs<br />
Temerlin McClain (EPRI): A. Lang<br />
Temerlin McClain (Interior): A. Lang<br />
The Rocket – Republic Center: S.<br />
Oldner<br />
Rocky Mountain Section<br />
(Leo Mendoza)<br />
Republic Plaza Entry Lighting: M.<br />
Rudiger<br />
Telluride Conference Center: D.<br />
Barber, M. Stauth<br />
San Jacinto Section (Tim Carnes)<br />
American General Canopy: J. Bos, L.<br />
Gandy<br />
Brownsville Courthouse Exterior: J.<br />
Bos, B. Bowen<br />
Brownsville Courthouse Interior: J.<br />
Bos, B. Bowen<br />
Corbin Residence Exterior Architectural<br />
Illumination: M. Smith<br />
Dave Chindly Exterior Glass<br />
Sculpture: M. Smith<br />
IAH Terminal A South Concourse<br />
Art: J. Bos, L. Gandy<br />
Interior Parker Residence: R. Schiller<br />
One Briarlake Plaza – Exterior<br />
Illumination: M. Smith, R. Inaba<br />
One Briarlake Plaza – Interior<br />
Illumination: M. Smith, R. Inaba<br />
Private Residence: J. Bos, J.<br />
Youngston<br />
St. Vincent DePaul Catholic Church<br />
Gathering Space and Baptistry:<br />
M Smith<br />
St. Vincent DePaul Main Worship<br />
Space: M. Smith<br />
Steelwood Townhouse Exterior &<br />
Landscape Illuminate: M. Smith<br />
Steelwood Townhouse Interior<br />
Illumination: M. Smith<br />
INTERNATIONAL ENTRIES<br />
Costanera Sur “ A”: E. Diz<br />
(Argentina)<br />
Costanera Sur “B”: E. Diz<br />
(Argentina)<br />
David Jones Rundle Mall Store: B.<br />
Bauer, T. Herndon, W. Way<br />
(Australia)<br />
Decorative Art Illumination of the<br />
Buildings of Railway Station: G.E.<br />
Avetisov, T.G. Magia Di Luce: D.<br />
Passariello (France)<br />
Necropoli Vaticana: C. Ferrara, P.<br />
Palladino (Italy)<br />
Piazza Scala: C. Ferrara, P. Palladino<br />
(Italy)<br />
Awaji Yumebutai: T. Ando, M.<br />
Tanaka (Japan)<br />
Bankoku Shinryokan: M. Ishii<br />
(Japan)<br />
Daito Seiiki Hekiga at Yakushiji: T.<br />
Imazato, K. Nakaya, R. Hotta<br />
(Japan)<br />
Dominique Doucet: Y.Kato (Japan)<br />
Furano Theater Factory: M. Haraikawa,<br />
T. Katase, H. Kitamura<br />
(Japan)<br />
Gifu Prefectural Health Science<br />
Center: K. Arai, M. Obayashi, H.<br />
Asaoka, T. Kimata, M Kawaguchi,<br />
H, Kitamura (Japan)<br />
Japan Flora 2000: M. Ishii (Japan)<br />
K.K. Bestseller Headquarters: R.<br />
Chikada, D. Hagiwara (Japan)<br />
Latent Sound Sea: K. Tanaka, T.<br />
Shono, T. Osamura, S. Endo<br />
(Japan)<br />
Marine Pia Kobe Porto Bazar: T. Ito,<br />
T. Kanou, T. Tanaka (Japan)<br />
Masuko Memorial Hospital-Artificial<br />
Dialysis Room: T. Kume, T. Suzuki<br />
(Japan)<br />
Mediage: A. Kaneda, m. Noto, Y.<br />
Kobayashi (Japan)<br />
Mutsu Municipal Library: R. Chikada<br />
(Japan)<br />
Paruru Plaza Chiba (Elevator Hall on<br />
the 9th Floor) S. Sumiyama<br />
(Japan)<br />
P-Park 2: Y. Kato (Japan)<br />
Saitama Shintoshin East Entrance<br />
Area – Pedestrian Deck: M.<br />
Kakudate (Japan)<br />
Shorakuji: S. Sumiyama (Japan)<br />
The Kasumigseki Building: S. Shiina<br />
(Japan)<br />
The Resonance: Asahi-machi Eco<br />
Museum: R. Chikada, D.<br />
Hagiwara (Japan)<br />
The Secret Cave: Le Petit Bedon: R.<br />
Chikada (Japan)<br />
Togetsukyo, a Historical Bridge in<br />
Kyoto: H. Ide, S. Shiina, T.<br />
Morinaga (Japan)<br />
Toppan Koishikawa Building: M. Ishii<br />
(Japan)<br />
Toyota Car Terrace, Omori: M.<br />
Funakoshi, K. Ito, K. Takagi, H.<br />
Fujita, K. Kawamura (Japan)<br />
Toyota’s Sangokan Civic Center: Y.<br />
Horibe, S. Takahashi, H.<br />
Takimoto, H. Kitamura (Japan)<br />
Yachiyo Public Library: K. Nakamura<br />
(Japan)<br />
ZENT Kisogawa: Y. Kato (Japan)<br />
Chapultepec Castle: V. Palacio, C.<br />
Ortega (Mexico)<br />
La Giganta Museo Jose Luis Cuevas:<br />
G. Aviles (Mexico)<br />
Liberty In Bronze: G. Aviles<br />
(Mexico)<br />
Mexican Pavilion World Fair<br />
Hannover 2000: G. Aviles, K.<br />
Diederichsen (Mexico)<br />
Televisa Master Channel Center: G.<br />
Aviles, M. Torres (Mexico)<br />
Mind Zone at the Millennium Dome:<br />
R. van der Heide, J. Nielsen, B.<br />
van der Klaauw: (Netherlands)<br />
National Museum for Natural History:<br />
R. van der Heide, J. Nielsen,<br />
M. Duijzer (Netherlands)<br />
Temples of Abu Simbel: H. Hollands<br />
(Netherlands)<br />
Zanns Museum: R. van der Heide, J.<br />
Nielsen, M. Duijzer (Netherlands)<br />
Holzfachschule: C. Vogt, Z. Vogel<br />
(Switzerland)<br />
Visdome: C.Vogt (Switzerland)<br />
Avetisova, O.N. Babenko, S.V.<br />
Seresh (Ukraine)<br />
Alexander Graham Bell House,<br />
British Telecom Regional<br />
Headquarters (Interior): J. Speirs,<br />
G. Fraser (United Kingdom)<br />
Alexander Graham Bell House,<br />
British Telecom Regional<br />
Headquarters (Exterior): J.<br />
Speirs, G. Fraser (United<br />
Kingdom)<br />
Buchanan Street Public Realm<br />
Project: J.Speirs, G. Fraser, A.<br />
Mitchell, M. Innes, L. Nisbet, D.<br />
Hamilton, J. Fagg (United<br />
Kingdom)<br />
Grenville Shop and Library, British<br />
Museum: J. Speirs, C. Ball<br />
(United Kingdom)<br />
IBM E-Business Innovation Centre:<br />
J.Speirs, C.Ball (United Kingdom)<br />
Mills Mount Restaurant, Edinburgh<br />
Castle: A. Mitchell, G. Pyatt<br />
(United Kingdom)<br />
Paddington Station: M. Major, J.<br />
Speirs, L. Jones (United Kingdom)<br />
“The Glass Virgins,” Standard Life<br />
Headquarters: J. Speirs, G.<br />
Fraser, I. Ruxton, G. Laing<br />
(United Kingdom)<br />
UCI Cinema, Norwich: A. Mitchell,<br />
H. Milne, G. Pyatt (United<br />
Kingdom)<br />
Welcome Wing at the Science<br />
Museum: R. van der Heide, J.<br />
Nielsen, M. Duijzer (United<br />
Kingdom)<br />
New Website Offers Information<br />
on Recycling Lamps<br />
The National Electrical Manufacturers Association<br />
(NEMA) Rosslyn, Va., unveiled a new website, www.<br />
lamprecycle.org, which features information on lamp recycling<br />
for the thousands of U.S. companies who use fluorescent<br />
or high intensity discharge (HID) lamps. The website<br />
includes information about federal and state regulatory<br />
spent lamp management requirements, state regulatory<br />
contacts, lists companies that handle and recycle lamps,<br />
and describes the environmental benefits of mercury containing<br />
lamps and what the lamp industry has done to<br />
reduce its use of mercury contained in these lamps.<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
LD+A/May 2001 27
Public Review of the<br />
Draft American<br />
National Standard BSR E1.11<br />
Entertainment Technology — USITT DMX512-A, Asynchronous<br />
Serial Digital Data Transmission Standard for Controlling<br />
Lighting Equipment and Accessories, is available for<br />
public review and comment. This document is an updating<br />
and revision of the widely used DMX512/1990, which was<br />
originally developed by the United States Institute for<br />
Theatre Technology. The draft document can be obtained<br />
from the ESTA website (www.esta.org/tsp/) or from the<br />
USITT website (www.usitt.org). Comments are due by<br />
April 24, 2001.<br />
Live! Awards Announced<br />
Flying Pig Systems’ Wholehog II lighting console was<br />
voted 2001 Lighting Console of the year and Martin<br />
Professional’s new high-powered moving head, the MAC<br />
2000, was voted Best New Lighting Product by Live! magazine.<br />
An industry awards ceremony was held on February 8,<br />
2001 to honor those voted tops in their field in lighting,<br />
sound, staging, and other aspects of the production business.<br />
Live! Magazine is a UK trade publication for the entertainment<br />
industry.<br />
New Members<br />
Membership Committee<br />
Chair Jim Sultan announced<br />
the IESNA gained one Sustaining<br />
Member and 120<br />
Members (M), associate<br />
members and student members<br />
in March.<br />
SUSTAINING MEMBER<br />
Axis Lighting Inc. Montreal<br />
Canadian Region<br />
William Agnew (M), Hubbell Canada<br />
Inc., Pickering, Ontario<br />
Chris Linzel, Lightscapes, St.<br />
Catherines, Ontario<br />
Glenn Mooney (M), Duke Solutions<br />
Canada Inc., Nepean, Ontario<br />
Dale Parks, Lighting By Nature,<br />
Stouffville, Ontario<br />
Gerald Schreinert, The Specialty<br />
Lighting Company, Mississauga,<br />
Ontario<br />
Brian Thompson, TEK Consultants<br />
Ltd., Fredericton, New Brunswick<br />
Steven Wilcox, New Brunswick<br />
Power, Fredericton, New<br />
Brunswick<br />
Dirk Zylstra (M), Axis Lighting Inc.,<br />
Montreal<br />
Carleton University<br />
Chiara Camposilvan, Philip<br />
Goodfellow, Cu Ha<br />
East Central Region<br />
Cary Baird, Lutron Electronics,<br />
Whitehall, Pa.<br />
Pamela Brookes, Virginia<br />
Department of Transportation,<br />
Richmond, Va.<br />
Adam Carangi, Lighting Design<br />
Consultation, Philadelphia<br />
John Dukes (M), Pepco Energy<br />
Services, Washington, D.C.<br />
Karen Gleba, Lutron Electronics,<br />
Elkridge, Md.<br />
Peyton Glenn Jr., Ebony, Va.<br />
Melvin Hill, Holophane, Philadelphia<br />
Ian Rowbottom (M), Lutron<br />
Electronics Co., Inc.,<br />
Coopersburg, Pa.<br />
Joan Stein, Silver Spring, Md.<br />
Andrew Wakefield, Lutron<br />
Electronics, Allentown, Pa.<br />
Great Lakes Region<br />
Diana L. Bobo, Holophane Co.,<br />
PMWW, Newark, Ohio<br />
Jack Frost, NYSEG, Lockport, N.Y.<br />
James A. Hall, Central Supply Co.,<br />
Indianapolis, Ind.<br />
Kim Hourigan, Lightolier, Schiller<br />
Park, Ill.<br />
Tonya Hughes, Holophane Corporation,<br />
Summit Station, Ohio<br />
James Koryta, Indiana University,<br />
Bloomington, Ind.<br />
Gedra Mereckis (M), ALKCO,<br />
Franklin Park, Ill.<br />
Sandy Newhouse, Scott Electric,<br />
Youngwood, Pa.<br />
Kevin Newquist, ACS/Midwest,<br />
Naperville, Ill.<br />
Abigail Sorensen, Lightology,<br />
Chicago<br />
South Pacific Coast Region<br />
Al Black, Sylvania, Sandy, Utah<br />
Ed Ebrahimian, City of Los Angeles,<br />
Bureau of Street Lighting, Los<br />
Angeles<br />
Tom Grunwald, Holophane, Phoenix<br />
Keith Gunn (M), Designs for<br />
Business, Orinda, Calif.<br />
Erich Hendrickson, California Architectural<br />
Lighting, San Francisco<br />
Dennis Lamenti, HOK, Inc., San<br />
Francisco<br />
Catherine McGroarty, Lighting<br />
Design Alliance, Los Angeles<br />
John Myklebust (M), Lightshow,<br />
Altadena, Calif.<br />
Robert B. Ofsevit, Alamo Lighting,<br />
Concord, Calif.<br />
William Reed (M), Idaho Falls, Ind.<br />
Michael Shearer, Southern California<br />
Illumination, Agoura Hills, Calif.<br />
Loretta Sheridan, Horton Lees<br />
Brogden Lighting Design, San<br />
Francisco<br />
Meir Shetrit, Elite Electric, San<br />
Francisco<br />
Nina Visconti, Holophane Company,<br />
Fullerton, Calif.<br />
Frederick Wenzlaff, Terra Firma<br />
Architectural and Lands, Eagle<br />
Rock, Calif.<br />
University of Colorado Boulder<br />
Melissa Friedland, Craig Spring<br />
University of Southern California<br />
Khaled Al-Jammaz<br />
Midwest Region<br />
William Donald Breunig,<br />
Germantown, Wis.<br />
James Deeds IV, Pulley & Associates,<br />
West Des Moines, Iowa<br />
Edward S. Jakobsze, McGuire<br />
Engineers, Chicago<br />
Benjamin Jordan, University of<br />
Wisconsin, Madison, Wis.<br />
Judson College<br />
Andy Beach, Marc Book, Joe<br />
Buehler, Jason Burger, Joah Bury,<br />
Andrew Centanni, David Cryder,<br />
Stephanie Eggebeen, Brad<br />
Gehrig, Andrew Ivari, Bo Johnson,<br />
Jon Krager, Jon Lindstrom,<br />
Thaddeus Mack, Andrea Mandle,<br />
Stephen Mangeri, Rebecca<br />
Ritsema, Jacob Sertich, Stacy<br />
Snapp, Leanne Taylor, Isaac<br />
Turner<br />
Southeastern Region<br />
Whit Adams (M), Adco Electric Inc.,<br />
Jackson, Miss.<br />
Lisa Ballard, Parsons <strong>Engineering</strong>,<br />
Nashville<br />
John Kitson, Applied Energy<br />
Management, Greensboro, N.C.<br />
Steve Lafferty, Royale Resorts,<br />
Brandon, Fla.<br />
Peter H. Matecki (M), Shades of<br />
Color, Raleigh, N.C.<br />
Empe Medeli, Miami, Fla.<br />
Dean Nelson, Nelson Electrical<br />
Services, North Miami, Fla.<br />
Jacqueline Owens, JOLA Inc.,<br />
Gainesville, Fla.<br />
Eric Reid (M), Talbot & Associates,<br />
Charlotte, N.C.<br />
Barbara Trombetta, Audio Visual<br />
Innovations, Jacksonville, Fla.<br />
Guido Walther, Tridonic Inc.,<br />
Norcross, Ga.<br />
John Woodburn, Research Triangle<br />
Park, N.C.<br />
Northeastern Region<br />
Susan J. Arnold (M), Wolfers<br />
Lighting, Waltham, Mass.<br />
Daniel Beaudoin, Harvard School of<br />
Public Health, Boston, Mass.<br />
Joseph Cifaldi, Cooper Lighting,<br />
Cranbury, N.J.<br />
Stacy Holmen, Stacy Holmen<br />
Lighting Design, Wilton, Conn.<br />
Steven Laudati, Langan <strong>Engineering</strong>,<br />
Elmwood Park, N.J.<br />
Robert Lingard (M), OSRAM SYL-<br />
VANIA, Danvers, Mass.<br />
Bohdan S. Mishko (M), NYCTA, New<br />
York<br />
David Vassallo, Aztech <strong>Engineering</strong>,<br />
Hartford, Conn.<br />
Parsons School of Design<br />
Chad Groshart<br />
Northwestern Region<br />
Sheila Back, Lightolier, Seattle<br />
Sheri Clarke, Puget Sound Energy<br />
Into Light, Bellevue, Wash.<br />
Deborah Conway, DLR Group,<br />
Seattle<br />
Aleksandra Gorovaya, (M), HNTB,<br />
Bellevue, Wash.<br />
William Guy, Intel Corporation,<br />
Hillsboro, Ore.<br />
Linda K. Holte, Cierra Associates,<br />
LLC, Seattle<br />
Stephen A. Medley Sr., Western Oregon<br />
University, Monmouth, Ore.<br />
Ken Mehlenbacher, Puget Sound<br />
Energy, Bellevue, Wash.<br />
Randal Slade (M), Falcon<br />
<strong>Engineering</strong> Ltd., Victoria, British<br />
Columbia<br />
Portland Community College<br />
Sean Houghtaling<br />
Southwestern Region<br />
Don J. Ackerman, Ackerman<br />
<strong>Engineering</strong> Inc., Golden, Colo.<br />
Dave Comer (M), Hosley Lighting<br />
Associates, Dallas<br />
Leslie Dinn, Summit Consultants<br />
Inc., Fort Worth, Texas<br />
Erin E. Friar (M), University of<br />
Oklahoma, Norman, Okla.<br />
Juan J. Hernandez (M), Quality<br />
Lighting Inc., Dallas<br />
Stanton Humphries (M), Architectural<br />
<strong>Engineering</strong>, Avon, Colo.<br />
Danny Hyatt, Lighting Services,<br />
Carrollton, Texas<br />
Lisa Jackson, Enron Energy<br />
Services, Houston<br />
Josef Levy, SLI Lighting Solutions<br />
Inc., Carrolton, Texas<br />
Monte Riggs, Bos Lighting Design,<br />
Houston<br />
Mark Strauss, CED Dba Valmac<br />
Electric, McCallen, Texas<br />
Laura Weilert, Weilert <strong>Engineering</strong>,<br />
Denver<br />
Jim Whelan (M), American Light<br />
Inc., Fort Worth, Texas<br />
Foreign<br />
Rafael Basso, Brazil<br />
Praveen Kumar Sood, Linear<br />
Technologies India PVT., India<br />
28 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
Fashion in the Limelight<br />
Essentially, presentation and quality are the most important elements<br />
when it comes to fashion. However, in an ever-changing world,<br />
more designers look to light to enhance both the presentation and the<br />
perceived quality of the merchandise.<br />
The CFDA (Council of Fashion Designers of America), the organization<br />
that coordinated the The 7th on Sixth Fashion Shows in Bryant<br />
Park, New York, commissioned Levy Lighting to contribute to its new<br />
lobby appearance. For this year’s event — The 7th on Sixth/Mercedes<br />
Benz Fashion Week — Levy Lighting, Inc., designed custom architectural<br />
style fixtures to illuminate 8 ft diameter stretched Spandex<br />
disks which were provided by Reid Dalland and designed by A-Form<br />
Architecture.<br />
The design team used 1,500 W incandescent light sources in a custom<br />
box enclosure to illuminate each of the disks in the lobby. Knowing there were a number of challenges associated with lighting<br />
the disks, the crew of Levy Lighting, Inc. thought hard as to how to illuminate disks, while keeping the disks in a comfortable,<br />
warm and inviting setting.<br />
“Our approach was to keep the disks as close to the light source as possible without having too much of a hot spot,” said<br />
Ira Levy of Levy Lighting, Inc. “The roof tent had a pretty steep angle, so the disks that were not close too the peak began to<br />
make the area seem smaller if they were hung too far from the light source. We also needed to make sure the light level in the<br />
lobby was bright enough for someone to read a newspaper<br />
or a magazine.”<br />
Lighting levels were also changed from day to night,<br />
so dimming was essential. The system was programmed<br />
with specific levels for cocktail parties and other preshow<br />
gatherings, which took place during the course of<br />
the fashion week. All lighting luminaires, including<br />
Altman Shakespeare and Altman Star-PARs, were hung<br />
off existing tent architecture hanging hardware. The<br />
color temperature of the 1,500 W luminaires was 2700K<br />
and the color temperature on the Altman equipment was<br />
3200K. The Lekos and PARs were used to highlight sponsor<br />
signage and installation.<br />
As a primary sponsor, Mercedes Benz also had its own<br />
view of how the areas should be lighted. The Mercedes<br />
Benz area was similar to both a trade show booth and a<br />
museum installation, all in one package, and included an<br />
array of Mercedes Benz automobiles on display<br />
“The first point of concentration was to make sure the<br />
cars were lighted properly in a flattering, yet functional<br />
matter,” Levy said. “While the color change and the<br />
movement were important, we could not sacrifice the<br />
primary objective of the installation, which was to display<br />
product.”<br />
By utilizing an array of Altman Television Studio Fresnels,<br />
the cars were illuminated in white light. Since the crew did not want to ruin clean installation throughout the rest of the<br />
lobby by hanging truss, the team had to work with the existing architecture to find hang points for the equipment. At the same<br />
time, there were heating tubes to contend with, which could melt if the equipment was hung too close. Within the parameters,<br />
the fresnels worked perfectly.<br />
In order to compensate for the different distances of the luminaires, the crew utilized the flood/spot control on the back of<br />
the fixtures. The units that were further away were set to spot, while the ones hung closer were set to flood.<br />
The control allowed the team to get even light levels wherever it was desired. At the same time, the crew was able to make<br />
some areas brighter than others, so the cars would shine in certain areas. Altman PARs were added to the equation to create<br />
a multiple channel chase in different colors. Some of the colored light was focused directly onto the cars and some of it was<br />
built into the set-piece. The colored light reacted well to the silver color of the vehicles, while the lighting in the set helped to<br />
emphasize movement during the crossfades.<br />
—John-Michael Kobes<br />
P H O T O N S<br />
NOTES ON LIGHTING DESIGN<br />
PHOTOS: MICHAEL ANTON<br />
30 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
P H O T O N S<br />
NOTES ON LIGHTING DESIGN<br />
Appealing Lighting<br />
A symbolic environment, which reflects the scales of truth and justice,<br />
can seem intimidating to some, but can also be a sanctuary of comfort<br />
to others. Whether working or simply visiting, one cannot ignore the stunning<br />
uniqueness of the Federal Courthouse located in Brownsville, Texas.<br />
In taking on a project of such magnitude, Bos Lighting Design was forced to consider the monumental look necessary for a<br />
building of this kind, while still attempting to deliver the concept of a warm, gracious public space environment.<br />
“The architects expressed a desire for the building to be revealed at night as a testament to its importance as a Federal<br />
Courthouse, but at the same time, we wanted to keep the look from becoming too institutional, cold, impersonal and<br />
uncomfortable,” said Designers John Bos and Becky Bowen of Bos<br />
Lighting Design.<br />
The difficulty of this project was increased by the stringent energy,<br />
maintenance, and budget requirements that come with any federal project.<br />
In terms of maintenance, attention was paid to lamp life, and there<br />
was an attempt to standardize lamp types as much as possible, including<br />
beam spread and color temperature.<br />
“While the budget was a factor for the exterior lighting, what was more<br />
of a guiding factor was that the luminaires be of high quality,” said Bos<br />
and Bowen, “particularly when dealing with in-ground and other luminaires<br />
that are exposed to the extreme Texas weather and the high<br />
pedestrian traffic.”<br />
What was most cost-effective for the project was the installation<br />
quality of the luminaires, which would hold up for years to come.<br />
Hydrel luminaires were chosen for its value and its track record for<br />
holding up over time, and — as a bonus — it was not the most expensive<br />
line on the market.<br />
Uplighting was used throughout the exterior to emphasize vertical elements<br />
and to lift the eye upward. These color-corrected metal halide<br />
adjustable upliftings create a sense of grandeur. In contrast, low-glare<br />
bollards were selected to illuminate pedestrian pathways and guide foot<br />
traffic. A variety of light was also chosen to highlight built forms and different<br />
shades of foliage. Lavender filters were used to enhance the cool<br />
greens of the shrubbery, while straw/pale gold filters were used to<br />
uplight the palm trees, bringing out the warmth in the trunks and the<br />
green tones of the palm leaves.<br />
Given the nature of the building, there were concerns about on-site<br />
security. Bos Lighting Design illuminated the landscape and exterior<br />
architectural elements. Such areas included the benches, which have a<br />
step light underneath; the front columns that support the metal canopy in front, which act as a natural place for uplighting, and<br />
the colonnade walkways to the parking areas. Cut-off luminaires were also used in the parking areas, specifically, to not create<br />
light trespass, since Brownsville is still small and dark enough for evening stargazing.<br />
“With all the uplighting, it was important to control<br />
glare, which can be blinding, thus making it as much of a<br />
security issue as a lack of light,” Bos and Bowen said.<br />
To avoid this problem, well-shielded fixtures were chosen<br />
(with the lamp deeply recessed) and additional louvers/glare<br />
guards were added wherever necessary. Full<br />
shielded bollards were used to directly light the main<br />
pedestrian pathways into the building to highlight the area<br />
safely and without any glare.<br />
As both a civic landmark and a federally funded project,<br />
the Brownsville Courthouse required thoughtful design<br />
integrated with energy- and maintenance-sensitive lighting.<br />
By using color corrected metal halide and fluorescent<br />
sources to highlight the built forms and landscape elements,<br />
all of these objectives were thoroughly met<br />
throughout the project.<br />
—John-Michael Kobes<br />
PHOTOS: JUD HAGGARD PHOTOGRAPHY<br />
32 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
PHOTOS: ELLIOTT KAUFMAN<br />
“MUST-SEE”<br />
ILLUMINATION<br />
The NBC Experience project took<br />
initial inspiration from other<br />
themed-environment stores, but<br />
modified the concepts substantially.<br />
Ron Harwood, of <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />
Concepts, discusses the project that<br />
garnered an Edwin F. Guth Award<br />
of Excellence for Interior<br />
Lighting Design.<br />
INTERNATIONAL ILLUMINATION DESIGN AWARDS<br />
(opposite) Backlighted merchandise display cubes<br />
are used to visually expand the rather limited space.<br />
(below) Flourescent backlighted light boxes<br />
and illuminated display cabinetry, coupled with an<br />
intense color palette mimicking the colors in<br />
the NBC peacock is shown.<br />
The Retail Wars of the 1990s remind me of<br />
the many times I watched NASA space<br />
shuttle launches. First, there was the<br />
excitement surrounding the impending launch<br />
and the news coverage and television interviews<br />
that culminated in the final countdown. Then<br />
came the spectacle of watching the ignition and<br />
take-off, the fiery launch, the gantry breaking<br />
away and the ballet of watching a huge rocket<br />
slowly inching upward. Although cameras could<br />
never record these details, we were told of the<br />
increasing velocity and G forces as the main rockets were jettisoned and the secondary boosters kicked in.<br />
The NBC Experience is the newest example of how retailers have learned to “immerse” their customers in an environment<br />
infused with subliminal and tangible brand messages. It is the final stage, and perhaps, the Mars Lander of retail stores. To assume<br />
that the NBC launch team worked in a vacuum would be a misstatement, however. The lighting and FX designers at<br />
<strong>Illuminating</strong> Concepts drew on the extraordinary design work of three premier retailers. A brief overview is required to provide<br />
a perspective on the thought process used in the final design for NBC.<br />
The main retail rocket of the early ’90s was Disney. Designers showed retailers another side of marketing that had not previously<br />
been envisioned. They took<br />
a cartoon character and turned<br />
Mickey and friends into inspirational<br />
icons for the purpose of<br />
marketing products. By simply<br />
affixing character images to products<br />
and apparel, a multi-million<br />
dollar market broke loose from<br />
its theme park moorings.<br />
Lighting design for the “park<br />
stores” changed rapidly in the<br />
early ’90s. Form and function<br />
became inseparable as merchandise<br />
lighting took on museum<br />
quality aspects.<br />
Soon after, Warner Bros. created<br />
its Studio Store concept. There<br />
was wisdom in the ranks of the<br />
Hollywood studio company. They<br />
knew their characters appealed to<br />
a larger audience than even<br />
Disney. Not only did the kids still<br />
watch Bugs Bunny and friends,<br />
but they also knew that adults<br />
2000<br />
34 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
LD+A/May 2001 35
held on to their attachment to some of these characters. Thus, a<br />
store ambience was created that was far more sophisticated, in<br />
order to cater to adult tastes. An overview of the Disney and<br />
Warner Bros. prototypes would clearly reveal that their “brand<br />
equity” was character driven. Lighting design for the Warner<br />
Bros. Studio Stores took on a real studio look, so that the adult<br />
patrons could take home a piece of<br />
the Hollywood mystique.<br />
<strong>Illuminating</strong> Concepts was fortunate<br />
to be part of the creative efforts<br />
of these visionary retail adventures.<br />
Much was learned from having our<br />
team immersed in theme park and<br />
character-driven retailing. A few<br />
simple phrases still reverberate in<br />
our creative studio’s ethos: “If you<br />
have to see the fixture, it had better<br />
fit the theme,” and “Light is part of<br />
the illusion of entertainment.”<br />
In the mid ’90s Nike came<br />
“swooshing” onto the retail scene<br />
with Niketown. The challenge of<br />
creating a location-based outlet for<br />
the brand was greater than that of the<br />
two studio giants; essentially they<br />
had no characters, only a logo. From<br />
IC’s exercise with Nike emerged a<br />
new set of values upon which to<br />
establish a shopping environment.<br />
First, Nike’s image is technical as<br />
well as inspirational. Designing<br />
media delivery systems into their<br />
spaces, along with “morphing” and moving light added to the<br />
shopper’s sense that Nike is technically competent and visionary.<br />
Second, Nike’s interior design scheme wanted to ooze<br />
quality; a means of imparting tangible evidence that Nike’s<br />
products are also of the highest quality. For visible lighting<br />
component selections, industrial high tech, high quality fittings<br />
were the only choices. Concealing<br />
70 percent of the product and ambient<br />
lighting became the trick. This<br />
proved to be a complete reversal of<br />
the methods used by IC for Disney<br />
and Warner Bros.<br />
NBC was a completely different<br />
beast. There are no cartoon characters,<br />
no tangible products and the<br />
consumer base recognizes the network<br />
for its shows rather than for<br />
one cohesive brand. Working with<br />
Guy Pepper from NBC and Eric<br />
Ulfers of Production Design Group,<br />
the team at IC was briefed on the<br />
(top and bottom) Backlighted,<br />
peacock-shaped, ceiling recesses conceal<br />
the ambient light sources. Adjustable<br />
low voltage monopoints used to accent<br />
merchandise and intelligent lights<br />
that spring the space into motion,<br />
provide kinetic accent illumination.<br />
36 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
thematic elements of the space. The design goal was to create a<br />
vivid and dynamic lighting system that was essentially transparent<br />
from the exterior. Virtually no exposed fittings were to<br />
be seen from the street. The multi-colored LED globe was to<br />
dominate the facade, even though it sat well back in the space.<br />
The “brand equity” of NBC revolves, in part, on its history of<br />
dynamic news broadcasts. Past history has shown that viewers<br />
selectively choose their network news and morning shows,<br />
which drives “pull-through” for broadcasts that come later.<br />
Certainly, NBC wanted to show its history of great news broadcasters<br />
and coverage of news events, as well as the wealth of<br />
great specials and classic sit-coms. In general, the NBC<br />
Experience was to be designed around the luminous nature of<br />
studio broadcasting and, of course, the television.<br />
One of our biggest challenges was the highly reflective gage<br />
The interior of the space is dotted with massive column<br />
surrounds. The frequency of the surrounds is dictated by the<br />
fact that the space occupies the lower two floors of the historic<br />
G.E. Building in Rockefeller Center, directly across from<br />
the NBC Studio where the Today Show has been a familiar<br />
and inviting attraction for years. The columns needed to be<br />
worked in to the merchandising scheme. The design team<br />
decided to keep the reflective nature of the space flowing by<br />
backlighting the translucent panels with neon. Substantial<br />
testing regarding the location of the neon and the choice of<br />
translucent materials needed to be performed in order to<br />
reduce the columns to their minimum diameter, while not<br />
allowing streaks of neon to be visible.<br />
The IC team worked with the notable store merchandise<br />
designers at JGA in Southfield, Mich., to develop a lighting system<br />
that would complement the<br />
layout. The retail merchandise<br />
lighting plans were quite complicated,<br />
in that the ceiling heights and<br />
undulations varied dramatically.<br />
Moreover, the assortment of video<br />
monitors located throughout the<br />
space could only be properly<br />
Backlighted merchandise<br />
walls silhouette the merchandise<br />
without obscuring detail due to the<br />
proper balance of light levels on<br />
face-out soft goods.<br />
ceiling by Barrisol. It is a hybrid polymer material that has a<br />
reflective surface similar to a mirror. Special mounting conditions<br />
had to be considered. Our team chose to minimize the<br />
perforations to achieve the highest level of continuous, unobstructed<br />
reflections. Similarly, by illuminating the reflective<br />
portrait style floors, we were able to achieve a space that felt<br />
transparent and expansive.<br />
Creating proper levels of illumination, while continuing<br />
the illusion of transparency was very important. No direct<br />
sources were focused on the basketball-shaped LED globe in<br />
order to heighten the anticipation of color and animation on<br />
the exterior of this central feature. Contained within the<br />
globe is a theatre with dynamic sound and short films about<br />
the history of NBC. It was produced to invite all guests to<br />
partake in the full experience of the NBC brand and its evolution.<br />
viewed when there were no reflections<br />
from light sources. Dennis<br />
Vogel at IC worked diligently to<br />
develop precise details for all of the<br />
necessary mounting conditions<br />
required. The store’s merchandising<br />
scheme, as one would expect, was<br />
based on a cable and glass shelving<br />
system that required external illumination.<br />
Around most of the column<br />
merchandise the team used<br />
recessed Reggiani adjustable luminaires with narrow focus MR<br />
16s. For wall-mounted store fixtures and merchandise illumination,<br />
the team chose a Bruck VIA solid rod suspension system<br />
that used 50 W narrow flood MR 16 lamps. The VIA system<br />
mitigates sagging, a difficult problem prevalent with most<br />
cable systems where proper turnbuckles and strain bucks are<br />
not appropriate.<br />
There are many locations around the NBC Globe that are<br />
merchandised. The floors around the globe are cut away to<br />
allow for most of the globe to be seen from many places in the<br />
store. This meant that good “shots” directed at the merchandise<br />
could only be achieved from the ceiling of the floor above the<br />
globe. In some cases, reaching the merchandise with high<br />
quantities of focused light required using narrow beam AR 111<br />
lamps. In order to keep a flush ceiling plane, the designers<br />
chose an Indy recessed adjustable fixture for the AR 111 lamps.<br />
38 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
Keeping with the luminous nature of the store, the NBC<br />
design team desired glass floors for the bridge that allows access<br />
to the NBC Globe Theater. The bridge condition dictated a low<br />
floor to ceiling height. By up-lighting the glass panels from<br />
below, the area gained additional perceived height, and the<br />
merchandise gained an additional “space age” look. Michael<br />
Shulman, project designer for IC, along with Kenneth<br />
Klemmer, design director, studied the up-lighting requirements<br />
for the glass bridge and determined that an additional function<br />
was required in the equipment selection process. Specifically, a<br />
substantial amount of merchandise that needed illumination<br />
was located below the bridge on the first floor. The solution<br />
was self-evident.<br />
Shulman and Klemmer chose a Bruck High Line cable system<br />
with fixtures that were visually minimal. They were able<br />
to focus both upward toward the bridge underside and<br />
downward toward the merchandise. Construction details for<br />
this installation were extensive, as New York City electrical<br />
codes required that the low voltage feed conductors were to<br />
be protected. In general, construction management of this<br />
project was comprehensive. Shulman provided almost continuous<br />
management during the final weeks of fit-out, commissioning<br />
and programming.<br />
For the main floor, the major ceiling feature consisted of<br />
NBC peacocks incised above the general perceived ceiling<br />
plane. The peacocks are fabricated from a metal framework<br />
with colored translucent Plexiglas panels creating the feathers.<br />
These peacocks are massive in scale and perspective, leaving little<br />
space for fixtures that were needed to illuminate the floor<br />
merchandise. The IC team had two challenges: First, the need<br />
to perfectly modulate the backlighted peacock panels and second,<br />
to find a means to directly focus light on products.<br />
Calculations for the transmissive quality of the Plexiglas<br />
were extensive. With no back-of-house room for a second<br />
(Strand) dimmer rack, it needed to be correct on the first pass.<br />
To make things even more complicated, there was very little<br />
room separating the Plexiglas and the non-dimmable fluorescent<br />
tubes that the budget required.<br />
For focused light, the team chose to conceal monopoint fixtures<br />
matching those already specified in the Bruck VIA system.<br />
These were tucked neatly and consistently at the intersections<br />
of the feather outer edges.<br />
Besides the incredible moving LED surface of the NBC<br />
Globe, the second architectural feature of the space is certainly<br />
the magnificent spiral staircase to the second floor. Upon<br />
approaching the staircase, one can barely miss the backlighted<br />
“test pattern” forming the oculus above. This test pattern is<br />
essentially what one might consider a stained glass window,<br />
which forms the entire ceiling over the staircase. It was to be<br />
the only source of light.<br />
In order to reduce the amount of apparent light fixtures in<br />
the stairwell, the IC design team chose to rely on video display<br />
devices, which form an entablature, rising in a helix along the<br />
walls, as an ambient light source. Albeit a bit blue, but warmed<br />
by the selection of high color rendering fluorescent and quartzhalogen<br />
lamps, the video sources provide at least 20 percent of<br />
the ambient light in many areas.<br />
Past the midsection of the main floor, the designers desired<br />
to create a museum-quality atmosphere for the merchandise<br />
displays. Shaped like picture-tube apertures, the displays<br />
were backlighted with small fluorescent sources. To avoid<br />
flattening out the artifacts for sale, we specified MR 16 narrow<br />
focus lamps that were aimed to spread light across the<br />
mostly textured products, thereby enhancing the threedimensional<br />
qualities.<br />
Finally, in keeping with the “showbiz” nature of NBC’s brand<br />
image, a moving light system was specified to create a layer of<br />
animation and excitement. More than 30 Clay Paky Mini-Scan<br />
HPE moving lights were used throughout the space. A detail<br />
was created to conceal most of the moving fixture’s mass. High<br />
quality lithographs with various NBC logos were utilized, along<br />
with a selection of break-ups and appropriate patterns, to create<br />
a collage of moving images that were programmed to play<br />
across the floors and merchandise. The programs were stored<br />
in non-volatile memory cards, having been downloaded from a<br />
moving light desk.<br />
As if that were not enough, the designers wanted to leave a<br />
lasting impression on visitors who walked through Rockefeller<br />
Center in the evening. To that end, five High End Systems ES-<br />
1 moving lights were specified. The luminaires are mounted<br />
inside the building, quite close to the front window, projecting<br />
out onto the pavement in front of the store. These fixtures are<br />
loaded with NBC artwork, and are programmed to rotate and<br />
scroll through a number of slow-moving routines.<br />
Witnessing the success of the project has been reward for the<br />
immense effort put forth by the IC team. Receiving the Edwin<br />
F. Guth Award of Excellence for Interior Lighting Design made<br />
the project that much more special. Tourists and residents alike<br />
have marveled at the space.<br />
While awards are given to designers for creativity, this project,<br />
in particular, could not have been a success without the<br />
project management skills of Sheila Fitchett, whose work<br />
behind the scenes in coordinating the installation and information<br />
flow was invaluable.<br />
The designers: (top, left) Ron<br />
Harwood founded <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />
Concepts, Ltd. (IC) in 1981. IC is<br />
an international multi-disciplinary<br />
firm that blends architectural<br />
and theatrical lighting with<br />
acoustic design, projections systems<br />
and special FX of all forms.<br />
Harwood has been active in producing theatrical and<br />
musical performances in folk music and blues since 1963<br />
and was nominated for a Grammy in 1982. He has been<br />
an IESNA member for five years.<br />
Michael Shulman (top, right) is a lighting designer for<br />
<strong>Illuminating</strong> Concepts, Ltd. He has a BFA in Theatrical<br />
Design and Minors in Art History & Business from<br />
Marymount College — Manhattan. From road shows to<br />
television to live Broadway theatre, Shulman has experience in all areas of theatrical<br />
lighting and effects.<br />
Dennis Vogel (bottom) is a project manager at IC. His expertise is focused in<br />
the areas of specialization, such as retail, themed environments, office and hospitality<br />
design. He is a graduate of the Boston Architectural Center, Interior<br />
Design Program, where he holds an NCIDQ certification and is a registered<br />
interior designer.<br />
40 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
Ciel Home’s newest store needed an<br />
innovative lighting system to completely<br />
illuminate the products being displayed, while<br />
keeping the luminaires as hidden as possible.<br />
Arie Louie explains the design team’s philosophy<br />
in addressing this challenge.<br />
FUSION OF FASHION AND<br />
FURNITURE<br />
Ciel Home is an upscale furniture and home<br />
accessories store with branches located in<br />
Charlotte, N.C., Phoenix and Newport<br />
Beach, Calif. Ciel Home at Fashion Island in Newport<br />
Beach is the newest store in the chain. Ciel imports<br />
unique furniture from around the world. Larry Serge,<br />
owner of Ciel Home, understands the importance of<br />
lighting as an instrument of image and function.<br />
Architect Ilan Baldinger approached the design of<br />
the 5,000 sq ft store as an informal space, reflecting<br />
Southern California aesthetic sensibilities and its<br />
laid-back life style. The store is organized as a series<br />
of asymmetrically layered spaces defined by minimalist<br />
architectural elements. A curved wall containing<br />
display niches runs along the length of the<br />
store and is a unifying and organizing feature.<br />
Baldinger has collaborated with lighting designer<br />
Arie Louie, and his firm, Louie Lighting, on various<br />
other retail and corporate projects.<br />
“This prior work experience allows for a design<br />
synergy and shared understanding of design philosophies<br />
as they relate to the idiosyncrasies of diverse<br />
project requirements,” says Baldinger.<br />
Such design synergy is what allows for a full integration<br />
of the lighting with the architecture. In the<br />
case of Ciel Home, it allowed for unique solutions<br />
and creative ideas that allowed for great results at<br />
minimum expense.<br />
“Lighting design for a retail space is a very sensitive<br />
and crucial subject” says Louie. “Proper lighting solution<br />
is designed specifically for the store at hand. It<br />
draws the customer’s attention to a product display,<br />
enhances the product color and appearance and provides<br />
ultimately improved ambient lighting within<br />
PHOTOS: ARIE LOUIE<br />
(opposite, top) For the display niches, 3000K T8 fluorescent fixtures with electronic ballasts were<br />
placed in a concealed space specially designed for each display niche.<br />
(opposite, bottom) Black track lights carrying low voltage 50W MR 16 lamps were recessed<br />
above the ceiling within rectilinear cutouts.<br />
(above) Low voltage cable lighting systems with small 50 W MR 16 lamps stretch inconspicuously<br />
between wood beams highlighting individual groupings of furniture or “rooms.”<br />
42 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
LD+A/May 2001 43
the store. This will prevent flat, dull and uninviting spaces. The<br />
goal of retail lighting should always be improved merchandizing<br />
and higher sales.”<br />
The design of the Ceil Newport Beach store presented a<br />
unique lighting challenge to the design team. The store-layered<br />
space design and the mix of furniture displays and small accessories<br />
displays dictated a diverse approach to lighting. It was<br />
decided early on in the design process to downplay the source<br />
of light, in keeping with the minimalist design as a background<br />
to the products on display.<br />
The store features five distinct lighting themes. Theme one is<br />
designed to provide ambient and accent lighting within the<br />
hard gypsum board ceiling. Black track lights carrying low voltage<br />
50 W MR 16 lamps were recessed above the ceiling within<br />
rectilinear cutouts. The space above the cutouts was painted<br />
black to conceal the lighting luminaires. This solution allows<br />
for clean uninterrupted ceiling plan and at the floor level flexibility,<br />
brightness and fluidity. The lighting provides additional<br />
rhythm and sense of order.<br />
Under the exposed structure, displaying and lighting furniture<br />
required a different solution. Low voltage cable lighting<br />
systems with small 50 W MR 16 lamps stretch inconspicuously<br />
between wood beams, highlighting individual groupings of<br />
furniture or “rooms” in intensity, clarity and specificity unique<br />
to this lighting source. This solution allows for flexibility that is<br />
needed for the ever-changing display in the furniture store. It<br />
provides sparkle, creates intimacy in the space, adds interest<br />
and attracts patrons to explore the<br />
various displays.<br />
The third lighting condition<br />
responds to the need to provide<br />
flooded light localized within each<br />
recessed display niche. The designers<br />
looked for a cost effective solution<br />
that would be easy to maintain<br />
and would be low in heat generation.<br />
After reviewing different<br />
options, it was decided to use<br />
3000K T8 fluorescent fixtures with<br />
electronic ballasts, which were<br />
placed in a concealed space specially<br />
designed for each display<br />
niche. The end result is a soft light<br />
that floods the products without<br />
any glare.<br />
For the cash wrap area, the<br />
designers decided to introduce a<br />
different and contrasting light source. By spacing pendant<br />
lights over the uniquely shaped service island, a distinction is<br />
made between this area and the rest of the store.<br />
The fifth and last lighting condition is specific to the circulation<br />
corridor connecting between the various furniture display<br />
“rooms.” This 4 ft wide corridor is defined by steel columns<br />
and wood beams with a 4 in. void in between. luorescent strips with T8 lams<br />
and electronic ballasts were integrated into the void; the lamps are coated with<br />
color gel and the effect is a pattern of light, rhythm and color.<br />
Ciel Home at Fashion Island is attractive to patrons when viewed from the<br />
outside, and when they enter the store, the first impression is positive and the<br />
visual clarity is high. Patrons feel safe and comfortable due to balanced ambient<br />
lighting. The merchandise is well illuminated with enhanced colors.<br />
Lighting is layered and creates elements of interest that attract people to linger<br />
longer. According to Louie, “Good lighting design will enhance the look of the<br />
store while taking in consideration human feelings<br />
and physiological responses.”<br />
Ciel Home stands out among the stores at<br />
Fashion Island as an example of a welldesigned<br />
store that responds to the need for<br />
proper lighting. The lighting design for the<br />
store received an International Illumination<br />
Design Award of Merit.<br />
The designers: Arie Louie, LC is a<br />
lighting designer with numerous<br />
International Illumination Design<br />
awards. With more than 16 years of<br />
architectural lighting design experience<br />
and a background in theatrical<br />
and motion pictures lighting, his<br />
designs range from corporate and<br />
office spaces, to retail, hospitality and<br />
restaurants, historical sites, residential<br />
and landscape lighting. He has been a<br />
member of IESNA for seven years.<br />
Ilan Baldinger is a registered architect<br />
in the states of Arizona and<br />
California. In 20 years of architectural<br />
practice Baldinger has compiled a<br />
substantial body of architectural work, varying in scope<br />
from uniquely crafted residential projects to mix-use high<br />
rise urban complexes.<br />
(above) The product wall is illuminated by concealed<br />
3000K T8 fluorescent fixtures with electronic ballasts.<br />
(right) Inside a false wall, MR 16 ceiling detail provides product lighting.<br />
(opposite) For the cash wrap area the designers<br />
decided to introduce a different and contrasting light source.<br />
By spacing pendant lights over the uniquely shaped service<br />
46 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
PROGRESSIVE HUB TO<br />
DISNEY’S MAGIC<br />
Downtown<br />
Disney links<br />
all the<br />
elements<br />
of the<br />
expanded<br />
Disneyland<br />
resort.<br />
Toni Page<br />
Birdsong<br />
provides the<br />
details on<br />
the lighting<br />
design that<br />
accompanied<br />
this newly<br />
created<br />
attraction.<br />
The Rainforest Café has touches of<br />
Inca palace architecture, but is also<br />
inspired by an extraordinary<br />
concrete block house, La Minatura,<br />
built in California by Frank Lloyd Wright<br />
in the 1920s. With an interior overlay<br />
of Yucatan rainforest, the café offers a<br />
uniquely entertaining atmosphere.<br />
48 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org<br />
(right) The Wine Bar District<br />
is named for the vine-covered<br />
wine and tapas bar at its<br />
center. The area features<br />
Café Catal, by Patina, with<br />
a combination of Art Deco and<br />
Westood Village styles.<br />
(below) Yarriba! Yarriba!<br />
is Downtown Disney’s new<br />
Latin dining and entertainment<br />
concept. It is housed in a<br />
classical structure that draws<br />
on styles from Havana to<br />
Buenos Aires.<br />
Avery wise lighting luminary once said, “If you build it<br />
they will come. And, if you turn the lights on, they will<br />
be able to see it when they get there.”<br />
Okay, we made that up. But it’s a great start when setting out<br />
to examine the design moves behind Downtown Disney,<br />
Anaheim’s new retail, dining and entertainment esplanade at<br />
the heart of the Disneyland Resort. When the sun goes down,<br />
the curtain rises to showcase this entertainment district’s precise<br />
fusion of architecture, landscaping and lighting.<br />
“Downtown Disney possesses its own sense of place, evoking<br />
the feeling of stepping into a garden paradise,” says Walt<br />
Disney Imagineering Senior Vice-President and General<br />
Manager Timur Galen. “In plan, Downtown Disney links all<br />
of the elements of the expanded Disneyland Resort…<br />
Disneyland, Disney’s California Adventure, the Disneyland<br />
Hotel, Disney’s Paradise Pier Hotel and Disney’s Grand<br />
Californian Hotel through a lushly landscaped pedestrian<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
environment. In character, it embodies our vision for the<br />
guest experience that the entire complex offers.”<br />
Embedded in that “vision” however, was one of the development’s<br />
biggest design challenges: How to transition<br />
Downtown Disney’s 300,000 sq ft of space from a daytime to<br />
a nighttime experience.<br />
Because Downtown Disney is bookended by the Disneyland<br />
Hotel on the west and two theme parks — Disneyland and the<br />
new Disney’s California Adventure — on the east, and also<br />
serves as a hub for local residents, designers were tasked with<br />
making the space appealing to a very diverse patron mix. The<br />
Downtown Disney team of Imagineers decided early on that, to<br />
be successful, the area would have to transition from a relaxing<br />
resort experience during the day, to a more sophisticated entertainment<br />
destination at night.<br />
“We wanted to provide a different experience, so people<br />
would come back from visiting the theme parks during the day<br />
and discover a whole different sense of<br />
place at night. And, the key to implementing<br />
that strategy, for us, was with<br />
lighting,” says Walt Disney Imagineering<br />
Project Manager Dev Hawley.<br />
Different areas,<br />
different needs<br />
In determining the lighting needs,<br />
designers first had to understand the<br />
character of each of the separate districts<br />
within Downtown Disney, as<br />
well as the story of California’s diverse<br />
history and culture that Disney was<br />
telling. Just as landscape and architecture<br />
choices were made to reflect<br />
California culture, so too, unique tenants<br />
were selected for their individual<br />
contributions to that same culture.<br />
Downtown Disney’s architectural<br />
LD+A/May 2001 49
decor progresses east to west, from Craftsman to Art Deco to<br />
California Eclectic styles, and ultimately connects with the<br />
urban-modern design of the Disneyland Hotel on the far west<br />
end. So, the lighting had to psychologically support the visual<br />
changes taking place, said Francis Krahe, president and owner<br />
of Laguna Beach-based Francis Krahe and Associates, the lighting<br />
firm tasked with fitting Disney’s lighting needs.<br />
“We essentially created two districts,” said Krahe. “The east<br />
side Garden District has a Tivoli Garden feel and has the history<br />
of the Arts and Crafts movement reflected in the architecture.<br />
We used a lot of warm-tone, white light and tried to<br />
create a great deal of sparkle to reinforce the idea of a romantic,<br />
peaceful setting.”<br />
In this area, Xenon lights, or twinkle lights, are subtly positioned<br />
in the trees, and uplighting accentuates the canopy of<br />
50-year-old, transplanted ficus trees that line the walkway.<br />
Perhaps one of the most unique lighting elements that is carried<br />
throughout the development also starts here with the first<br />
of many leaf-shaped planters that double<br />
as seat walls.<br />
“Throughout the entire esplanade,<br />
we placed fiber optic lights within a<br />
groove beneath the seat walls. The<br />
lights change color depending on<br />
which district — or environment —<br />
you happen to be in,” said Krahe. “I<br />
think this was extremely effective in<br />
establishing one, integrated expression<br />
for Downtown Disney. The idea<br />
was to create atmosphere, not effect,<br />
with the lighting.”<br />
The seat walls begin in the Garden<br />
District and emanate a warm, white<br />
glow that changes hue with each step<br />
west toward the Wine Bar District and<br />
the more energized, tropical spaces of<br />
the Paradise Plaza and the West End<br />
District. Progressively, the seat walls<br />
project hues that complement the<br />
spirit of each area.<br />
In the Paradise Plaza area, ambers,<br />
yellows, oranges, blues and purples<br />
can be found within view of more<br />
vibrant venues such as Ralph<br />
Brennan’s Jazz Kitchen, The House of<br />
Blues and the Latin Jazz club, Yarriba!<br />
Yarriba! This area also begins to<br />
employ more neon lighting within signage and on facades,<br />
which along with the music spilling onto the walkway, also<br />
adds to the visual fiesta.<br />
Colorful west end<br />
A few steps away, the West End district of Downtown Disney<br />
is stage to a colorful hub of venues such as Lego Imagination<br />
Center, Rainforest Café and the ESPN Zone. Here, a last minute<br />
design decision to apply dramatic theater lighting to a 60 ft<br />
Sorcerer’s hat (representing Sorcerer Mickey of Fantasia fame)<br />
adds to the dimension and frivolity of the district.<br />
“We needed some soft accent lighting on the hat and we<br />
needed to apply it from sources that wouldn’t overpower our<br />
guests,” said Francis Krahe and Associates senior project manager,<br />
Paul Butler. “We applied two 1,000 W, narrow-beam,<br />
metal halide accent lights from the top of the adjacent ESPN<br />
building. The hat also was uplighted.”<br />
With landscaping as the dominant design element of<br />
(right) ESPN Zone is the country’s premier<br />
sports entertainment concept. It includes<br />
hi-tech satellite transmitters and receivers,<br />
video cameras, more than 165 video<br />
monitors and fully functional radio<br />
and live television broadcast facilities.<br />
(above) The World of Disney has one of the<br />
world’s largest collections of exclusive<br />
Disney merchandise. Its highly themed<br />
interior is colorful and lively, in keeping<br />
with playful Disney characters.<br />
50 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
Downtown Disney, it’s clear the landscape and lighting<br />
design teams had to work closely to achieve the ultimate<br />
visual symphony.<br />
“The lighting of Downtown Disney definitely plays up the<br />
structure of the landscaping and provides the mood and accent<br />
that defines the space,” according to Manager of Landscape<br />
Architecture for Walt Disney Imagineering Jeff Morosky. “The<br />
lighting was so important in telling our story that, before we<br />
would plant trees, we considered how we would punctuate<br />
a warm, romantic glow to spill forth. Moving west, color-corrected,<br />
high-pressure, sodium lights were focused on lamp<br />
posts to ensure a consistent glow. Quartz halogen landscape<br />
and building uplights were used as accent lights.<br />
“We applied neon and fiber optics to the buildings and hundreds<br />
of yards of fiber optics beneath the seat walls,” said Krahe.<br />
“There’s also a series of custom-designed, thematic lanterns<br />
throughout the project that were designed to embellish each<br />
individual building façade, and add ornamental, incandescent<br />
flood lighting, which draws people through the<br />
space by presenting a new focal point structure<br />
in the distance. It’s a pretty substantial, yet not<br />
overpowering, element of the entire environment.”<br />
Creating scale and a “sense of place” was a<br />
challenge that strategic lighting moves helped<br />
to solve. In addition to uplighting the taller<br />
trees to confine the environment, incandescent<br />
lights were used to trim the tops of the retail<br />
facades on the east end of the esplanade which<br />
easily could have been overpowered by the<br />
towering Disney’s Grand Californian Hotel.<br />
And, because most of the east portion of<br />
Downtown Disney is built over a parking structure<br />
for Disney’s Grand Californian Hotel, landscaping<br />
and lighting were used to give dimension<br />
to the flatness of the area.<br />
“Guests never should perceive they are on a<br />
deck,” noted Hawley. “We want them to feel<br />
like they’re walking through a garden. That<br />
means we had to do things like build concrete<br />
tree pits that are 20 x 20 ft and 6 ft deep. It<br />
was an enormous undertaking.”<br />
According to Graf, it wasn’t hard to conform to the lighting<br />
standards set forth by the Downtown Disney lighting design<br />
team. Metal halide downlights were used in the ceilings for<br />
general lighting with warm color and high ECI. In the low ceilings,<br />
Graf used compact florescent lamps and a combination of<br />
incandescent HIR lights with spots of halogen infrared. In addition,<br />
CDM metal halide spots were used in the window displays<br />
to create theatrical lighting. Color filters were used on the<br />
spotlights to create “visual amplifiers” to showcase products<br />
and graphics.<br />
Another store that conformed to the lighting specs in a creative<br />
way was Illuminations, a popular candle store.<br />
According to Gary Miller, vice-president of Visual Merchandising<br />
for Illuminations, the lighting challenge was<br />
unique since the product being displayed was candles, many<br />
of which were lighted.<br />
“We worked closely with the Disney lighting designers to<br />
meet both of our objectives,” said Miller. “We used PAR 36<br />
lighting throughout the store to create warm, soft light. It made<br />
our product look great without making the store look bright.<br />
These lights are very easy to direct and don’t wash onto the<br />
floor space. Our goal was to create lighting that inspired our<br />
customers since our product gives off what we call living light<br />
[candlelight].”<br />
To achieve the desired interior lighting, luminaires included<br />
recessed compact fluorescent downlights and wall washes,<br />
compact fluorescent downlights, recessed parabolic fluorescence,<br />
surface-mounted strip fluorescents and track luminaires<br />
in many areas.<br />
Exterior lights commonly used included metal halide, building-mounted<br />
color floodlights, column mounted up and<br />
downlights and recessed incandescents, among others.<br />
Frivolity was an intentional design element employed<br />
throughout Downtown Disney and is found in details such as<br />
underwater lighting along the walkway’s many fountains and<br />
the Micktorian (Disney for Victorian) lamp posts custom<br />
crafted with those famous mouse ears. Designers even customized<br />
programming for the twinkle lights in the trees to<br />
create an effect closer to the illusion of fire flies, which<br />
includes a slight fade-in and a slowed twinkle to accomplish<br />
precise lighting and mood.<br />
“We were striving for something magical and I think we<br />
achieved that with the combination of landscape, architecture<br />
and particularly lighting,” said Hawley. “Not a bad debut<br />
for an area that just three years ago used to be part of an<br />
asphalt parking lot.”<br />
The author: Toni Page Birdsong is a Los Angeles-based<br />
writer who has reported on business, politics, travel and<br />
themed entertainment for the past 12 years. She has been<br />
a researcher for the Hollywood Entertainment Museum,<br />
and has been a contributor to LD+A, most recently in the<br />
May 2000 edition with her piece on ABC’s Good Morning<br />
America studio.<br />
Two views of the Downtown Disney fountain. The bottom image is from the West Side<br />
to the Central Plaza. Island Charters and Illuminations are on the right.<br />
those spaces with light at night. We developed many of our<br />
landscape concepts in conjunction with the lighting concepts<br />
in order to make the most impactful statements.”<br />
Despite the grand scale of the project, the lighting fixture<br />
specification was kept fairly simple, said Krahe. “Disney gave<br />
us the mandate that the impression had to be a warm, garden<br />
setting, and that’s what directed the palate of light we<br />
would use throughout.”<br />
Pedestrian poles that pepper the area were custom-designed<br />
to house metal halide lights topped with copper hoods to allow<br />
Lighting retail stores<br />
To further maintain a seamless environment,<br />
Walt Disney Imagineering lighting standards<br />
were applied to 30 separate retail tenants.<br />
According to Hawley, tenants were given guidelines<br />
to follow and were assisted in achieving<br />
the warm hues established by the team.<br />
“Our tenants underwent full design reviews<br />
of their interior and exterior lighting,” said<br />
Hawley. “Once the lighting story was established,<br />
it became crucial not to break that story.<br />
We tried to create a dialogue between the exterior<br />
and the interior of buildings, and we did<br />
that by carrying the established lighting standard<br />
into the stores. Not only does this maintain story, it ultimately<br />
helps guests better engage with the retail space.”<br />
One of the most dramatic lighting statements at Downtown<br />
Disney was achieved by the World of Disney store. According<br />
to design director Stefan Graf of Illuminart, lighting within the<br />
enormous retail space served as a silent design partner.<br />
“Light was to be used as an attraction,” said Graf. “We’ve<br />
worked with Disney for many years and we’ve developed a<br />
technique for maximizing the visual impact with lighting to<br />
create excitement and attract attention to the displays.”<br />
52 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
PHOTOS: RTKL ASSOCIATES, INC.<br />
Arundel Mills is a new retail entertainment<br />
center near Baltimore. The project is quite<br />
large, and employs fanciful spins on local<br />
attractions as a basis for the graphic treatment<br />
in all public spaces.<br />
(left, top) An exterior view of one of the<br />
entrances. The shot shows the Row House Folly.<br />
The design team used exposed neon and<br />
concealed metal halide PAR lamps to bring out<br />
the textures in the structures.<br />
(left, bottom) An interior view of the Pinball<br />
Court. The team used programmable and<br />
theatrical luminaries to create both<br />
general lighting and a show sequence<br />
cued to a sound track.<br />
LIGHTING TODAY’S<br />
SHOPPING MALL<br />
Alfred R. Borden IV and Helen K. Diemer of<br />
The Lighting Practice trace the evolution of the<br />
shopping mall and the importance of lighting<br />
to developers and shoppers.<br />
Lighting design for retail applications<br />
is part theater, part therapy, and all<br />
about commerce. It must attract customers,<br />
make them feel good, encourage<br />
them to buy, and facilitate the sales transaction.<br />
And it must do this in an environment<br />
that changes with the seasons,<br />
has limited maintenance, and always<br />
wants to reduce operating expense.<br />
The retail industry thrives on change.<br />
Its constant churn keeps the buying<br />
experience fresh and attractive. New<br />
products are introduced; new styles are<br />
promoted; new concepts are launched.<br />
The pace is whirlwind fast and profit<br />
margins are tight, so the visual excitement<br />
must also be very cost-effective.<br />
From their earliest beginnings as<br />
open-air bazaars and marketplaces,<br />
shopping centers have become big business<br />
and a powerful social force. In a little<br />
more than 70 years — the first suburban<br />
center in the U.S. came on the scene<br />
in the late 1920s outside of Philadelphia<br />
at Suburban Square, Ardmore — shopping<br />
centers have assumed a dominant<br />
role in consumer retailing. Today, shopping<br />
centers come in many sizes and<br />
shapes, and fill different market niches:<br />
covered malls, open malls, vertical malls,<br />
regional malls, urban malls, strip centers,<br />
discount malls, factory outlet malls, offprice<br />
malls, megamalls, festival malls<br />
and convenience centers.<br />
Shopping malls construction intensified<br />
in the late 1960s and early 1970s.<br />
This new format seemed more customerfriendly<br />
than the old big-box shopping<br />
center or strip stores, because the public<br />
space between stores was covered and<br />
conditioned. The public mall was meant<br />
to function as a protected walkway that<br />
connected the shops. It served to move<br />
shoppers from store to store, attracted by<br />
the brightly lighted and decorated display<br />
windows.<br />
Interior courts, with their skylights,<br />
planters and benches, were planned as<br />
relaxation areas where shoppers could<br />
replenish their energy supply between<br />
forays. Since the public mall’s main function<br />
was to serve as a transition area<br />
between stores, it was only lighted to<br />
about 10 fc. With such a dim ambient<br />
light level, the brightly lighted signage<br />
band above each storefront was intended<br />
to dominate the shopper’s view.<br />
General lighting in the public mall was<br />
typically provided by a variety of incandescent<br />
sources, selected for their rich,<br />
warm color and point-source accents.<br />
During the late 1970s and 1980s,<br />
advances in lamp technology introduced<br />
the possibility of color-corrected mercury<br />
or metal halide sources for mall<br />
lighting. Unfortunately, the poor color<br />
rendition and color-shifting of these<br />
early-generation HIDs, and their large,<br />
bright ceiling apertures, made them<br />
unattractive to many mall operators.<br />
High-end malls continued to use only<br />
incandescent and halogen sources well<br />
into the 1990s.<br />
By current standards, mall designs<br />
from several decades ago suffer from<br />
dim, dreary interiors with few amenities<br />
or visual destinations, dark exterior<br />
entrances, and high energy consumption.<br />
Now, the role of the shopping mall<br />
has changed significantly, and consumers<br />
have different expectations for<br />
such facilities.<br />
56 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
During the 1980s and 1990s, the shopping mall became<br />
the central civic space for many communities. It is where people<br />
meet and socialize; where they eat, exercise and entertain<br />
themselves.<br />
Shopping malls provide an environment where the visitor is<br />
offered a broad variety of amenities and diversions, as well as<br />
retail shopping venues. A person might go to the mall for some<br />
reason other than to visit the stores, but the trip usually produces<br />
a few purchases.<br />
For the lighting designer, the new concept meant that the<br />
public mall was no longer just a corridor. It was a feature area,<br />
an exhibition space for specialty vendors, fairs and seasonal<br />
displays; a staging area for product demonstrations, concerts<br />
and shows; a meeting place for groups of all sizes; and, of<br />
course, a relaxing place for tired shoppers. The lighting<br />
design presents the space as attractive and open and full of<br />
opportunities.<br />
Retail’s tough competitive environment keeps merchants<br />
constantly searching for a new concept that will keep shoppers<br />
coming back to their location. In the 1990s the strategy of the<br />
public mall as a themed environment became a popular format<br />
for new malls and renovations of existing properties. The rationale<br />
behind it embraced the idea that the shopping trip<br />
expands into and becomes an entertaining adventure, and the<br />
“Retail Entertainment Center” came onto the mall scene.<br />
People came to the same stores to shop, but they found<br />
themselves in the midst of a theatrical scene — a garden, a jungle,<br />
a futuristic landscape. Often, one of the anchor tenants was<br />
a multiplex cinema or a themed restaurant, adding to the intensity<br />
of the entertainment experience. The lighting for the public<br />
space in this shopping venue becomes part of the show.<br />
4. Programmable luminaires:<br />
Automated gobo and color changer and beam shaper<br />
Moving lights: Automated pan and tilt<br />
Another concept that started growing in the 1990s is actually<br />
a return to the earliest retail forms — the open-air market.<br />
The new venues, called Main Streets or Town Centers, are very<br />
much like the old big-box strip centers. The difference is that<br />
all elements contributing to the shopper’s experience is controlled.<br />
In the past, shoppers would walk down the main street<br />
of their town and visit the toy store, the haberdasher, the shoe<br />
store, etc. Streets and parking places would be standard municipal<br />
issue and each storefront would look as different as the<br />
ownership of each store.<br />
New Town Centers provide the streets, the parking, the<br />
street furniture and storefronts to create an environment that<br />
is reminiscent of its ancestor, but all based on some unifying<br />
design concepts. In this way, shoppers have the variety of<br />
experiences they used to get, but with more comfort and<br />
without the confusion created by the old hodge-podge environment.<br />
The Town Center or Main Street can be outside or<br />
inside a mall; it can be an exterior component attached to an<br />
interior mall.<br />
The lighting design for these venues must address roadways<br />
and pedestrian sidewalks, signage structures and building<br />
facades, water features, and still create an entertainment feel-<br />
What makes lighting look theatrical?<br />
High contrast, visual textures, and saturated color<br />
What makes lighting feel theatrical?<br />
The Unexpected: The lighting effect or color wash that the<br />
average shopper never saw in a store before.<br />
Visual Animation: moving lights<br />
Appropriate Tools<br />
1. The same stuff you are using now:<br />
Adjustable accent luminaires<br />
Flood luminaires<br />
Exposed/concealed cathode<br />
2. Theater instruments:<br />
Ellipsoidal reflector<br />
Gobo projection<br />
Zip strips<br />
LEDs<br />
3. Color media:<br />
Theatrical gel<br />
Dyed glass<br />
Dichroic glass
PHOTOS: PETER RENERTS STUDIO<br />
Richmond Town Square is a renovated<br />
mall near Cleveland. It was built in the 1970s.<br />
The black-and-white image (top) is the original<br />
mall concourse; the middle image shows<br />
the renovated main concourse, and the bottom<br />
image shows the food court. This is a traditional<br />
mall design. The lighting treatments include<br />
cold cathode coves, ceramic metal halide<br />
downlights and a custom fluorescent pendant.<br />
true low-brightness reflectors.<br />
High lumen compact fluorescents,<br />
such as quad- and triple-tubes lamps can<br />
also be used in small aperture luminaires<br />
and have similar benefits of excellent<br />
color rendition, long life and low energy.<br />
These sources are rapidly replacing<br />
incandescent and halogen lamps in mall<br />
lighting designs.<br />
Mall exterior lighting has evolved similarly<br />
to interior lighting. The points previously<br />
mentioned about the new theatrical<br />
techniques also apply to exterior<br />
lighting. Usually, exterior lighting for a<br />
mall is limited to the entries and a few<br />
architectural features. Exterior lighting<br />
on Main Street projects is more extensive,<br />
but the same principles apply —<br />
create visual destinations with some element<br />
of entertainment.<br />
The authors: Alfred R. Borden<br />
IV, IALD, is president of<br />
The Lighting Practice, Philadelphia,<br />
and Helen K.<br />
Diemer, FIALD is vice-president.<br />
The Lighting Practice<br />
was founded 12 years ago<br />
and has grown into a diversified<br />
international practice in<br />
the application of lighting for<br />
architecture.<br />
Borden has more than 20<br />
years of experience in lighting<br />
design. He is a past president of the<br />
Philadelphia Section of IESNA, and is on the<br />
Executive Committee of the International<br />
Association of Lighting Designers. He has been an<br />
IESNA member since 1978.<br />
Diemer had 15 years experience as a lighting<br />
designer with firms in New York, Minneapolis, and<br />
St. Paul before joining The Lighting Practice. She is<br />
a past president of the IALD and was named a<br />
Fellow last year. She is also an active member of the<br />
Philadelphia Section of IESNA, and has been an<br />
NCQLP QUIZ<br />
1. What types of light sources were primarily used by high-end<br />
malls into the early 1990s?<br />
2. According to the authors, what makes lighting look theatrical?<br />
3. What theater instruments do the authors recommend using to create a theatrical<br />
feel?<br />
ing. The Main Street is a themed entertainment<br />
village, complete with architectural<br />
and lighting features that tie the<br />
buildings to a time period or locale, but<br />
with a theatrical spin.<br />
One of the best things to happen to<br />
retail in the 1990s was the introduction<br />
of low-wattage, high-color-rendering<br />
metal halide lamps, and high-lumen<br />
compact fluorescent lamps. The new<br />
generations of metal halide PAR lamps<br />
and ceramic arc tube metal halide lamps<br />
have an attractive warm color, very little<br />
color shifting, long life and low energy<br />
consumption. They are small and can be<br />
used in fixtures with small apertures and<br />
4. Due to their size, what types of fixtures can metal halide PAR lamps<br />
be used in?<br />
5. What are the benefits of high lumen compact fluorescents?<br />
Name___________________________________________________________________<br />
Address_________________________________________________________________<br />
City/State/Zip__________________________________________________________<br />
Phone__________________________________________________________________<br />
Fax_____________________________________________________________________<br />
Please return to NCQLP Quiz c / o LD+A, 120 Wall Street, 17th Floor, New York, N.Y. 10005<br />
by July 15, 2001. You may also fax to 212-248-5018.<br />
58 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
LIGHTFAIR<br />
INTERNATIONAL<br />
SEMINAR<br />
PREVIEW<br />
David Apfel, Addison Kelly, Brian Cronin,<br />
Anthony Long, Vesa Honkonen, Julle Oksanen,<br />
Harold Jepsen, Leslie North, Sandra Vasconez,<br />
Helmut O. Paidasch and Randall Whitehead<br />
provide some insight into the seminars<br />
they’ll be presenting at this year’s<br />
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL.<br />
Las Vegas will be the mecca for<br />
the lighting industry this<br />
coming May, when thousands of<br />
professionals descend upon the<br />
city, in search of the newest lighting-related<br />
equipment and accessories,<br />
as well as educational<br />
opportunities, provided through<br />
the 38 workshops and seminars<br />
offered at this year’s conference.<br />
With a little prodding, LD+A<br />
was able to convince the presenters<br />
of six seminars to discuss<br />
what they’ll be speaking about in<br />
Las Vegas.<br />
David Apfel and Addison<br />
Kelly will address the 11th hour<br />
fixes — the situations that arise,<br />
late in the construction process<br />
where redesign is simply not an<br />
option. This seminar will help<br />
participants to identify potential pitfalls, so they can save both time and money.<br />
Tying in to LD+A’s focus on retail store lighting, Helmut O. Paidasch’s seminar will discuss creating a<br />
more customer-friendly retail environment. He identifies the three key components of delivering such<br />
a lighting design: visual comfort, visual display and visual ambience.<br />
Three presenters —– Harold Jepsen, Leslie North and Sandra Vasconez — will pool their knowledge base<br />
to speak on the virtues of lighting control systems. In many cases, lighting controls can be more important<br />
than the actual luminaries specified, especially when needed to comply with energy code provisions.<br />
A series of projects, chosen for artistic value, will be discussed by Vesa Honkonen and Julle Oksanen.<br />
This seminar will discuss the poetry of lighting design — the power it can have over those viewing lighting<br />
projects — and even the poetry of lighting calculations.<br />
Brian Cronin, an LD+A columnist, and Anthony Long, present a seminar on the various benefits the<br />
Internet can provide to businesses. Whether it be through website design, or online research, or using<br />
the Internet as a marketing and branding tool, this seminar promises to enlighten even the most computer-savvy<br />
attendees.<br />
Randall Whitehead will be presenting a three-hour workshop at the conference, where attendees will<br />
learn to identify and incorporate the four functions of illumination — decorative, accent, task and ambient<br />
— into their own residential lighting designs.<br />
A special thanks is due to these authors, who willingly authored these seminar previews, both to whet<br />
the appetite of those attending the conference, and to allow those not fortunate enough to make the trip<br />
to still gain some knowledge from the presentation.<br />
Chris Palermo<br />
Editor<br />
60 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
The Functions of<br />
Illumination<br />
Randall Whitehead previews his extensive<br />
workshop on lighting residences. Attendees will learn<br />
to easily identify and incorporate the four functions<br />
of illumination into a flexible design for<br />
the home environment.<br />
TUESDAY, MAY 29, 2001, 9:00AM - 12:00 PM<br />
The new technologies and developments<br />
in lighting over the last that match our virtual reality, techno-<br />
We can now achieve lighting effects<br />
decade have created opportunities for magic world. Plus, we can do it within<br />
approaches to lighting only dreamed of a reasonable budget, without dramatically<br />
changing the way we live. At the<br />
in the past. The body of knowledge<br />
about lighting has greatly evolved from same time, we can increase the comfort<br />
the times of candles and gaslights, yet level in our living spaces, and increase<br />
many clients have not updated their convenience as well.<br />
thinking much beyond that.<br />
Lighting can be a tremendous force in<br />
design; it’s the one element that makes all<br />
the rest work together. Yet it has been the<br />
second-class citizen of the design world<br />
for so long, and the results have left many<br />
homes drab, uncomfortable and dark. Too<br />
often, the blame goes elsewhere, when<br />
improper lighting is the culprit causing<br />
the discomfort. Let’s take a leap from nineteenth-century<br />
lighting to the next<br />
plateau by welcoming new lighting possibilities<br />
and techniques and sending<br />
design into a new era of dramatic comfort.<br />
Light has four specific duties: To provide<br />
decorative, accent, task and ambient<br />
illumination. No one light source can<br />
perform all the functions of lighting<br />
required for a specific space. Understanding<br />
these differences will help you<br />
create cohesive designs that integrate<br />
illumination into your overall design.<br />
Getting your clients, contractors and<br />
other members of the design team to<br />
become comfortable with these terms<br />
will help a project gel more cohesively.<br />
Light performs these basic functions:
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
(left, before and middle &<br />
right, after) This dining room<br />
makes a fantastic transformation<br />
from dated 1970s box to Japanese<br />
Moderne. A lush paper lantern<br />
by Ingo Mauer hovers over<br />
the dining room table.<br />
Recessed adjustable fixtures<br />
by Lucifer Lighting punch up<br />
the painting, red metal<br />
sculpture, and the amber vase<br />
in the center of the table<br />
decorative, accent, task and ambient illumination<br />
— the well-integrated layering of<br />
the four within each space will create a unified<br />
design.<br />
Decorative light<br />
Luminaires such as chandeliers, candlestick-type<br />
wall sconces, and table<br />
lamps work best when they are used to<br />
create the sparkle for a room. They<br />
alone cannot adequately provide usable<br />
illumination for other functions without<br />
overpowering the rest of the design<br />
aspects of the space.<br />
For example, a dining room illuminated<br />
only by the chandelier over the table<br />
creates a glare-bomb situation. As you<br />
crank up the dimmer to provide enough<br />
illumination to see by, intensity of the<br />
light causes every other object to fall into<br />
secondary importance. This one supernova<br />
of uncomfortably bright light<br />
eclipses the wall color, the art, the carpeting,<br />
and especially the people. By<br />
nature, any bright light source in a room<br />
or space immediately draws people’s<br />
attention. They won’t see all the other<br />
elements, no matter how beautiful or<br />
expertly designed.<br />
Similarly, linen shades on table lamps<br />
draw too much attention to themselves.<br />
Consider using a shade with an opaque<br />
liner and perforated lid to direct the<br />
illumination downwards over the base,<br />
the tabletop and across your lap if<br />
you’re reading.<br />
Accent light<br />
Accent light is directed illumination<br />
that highlights objects within an environment.<br />
Luminaires such as track and<br />
recessed adjustable luminaires are used<br />
to bring attention to art, sculpture, tabletops<br />
and plantings. Just like any of the<br />
four functions, accent light cannot be the<br />
only source of illumination in a room. If<br />
you use only accent light, you end up<br />
with the museum effect, where the art<br />
visually takes over the room, while<br />
guests fall into darkness.<br />
Subconsciously, the people will feel<br />
that the art is more important than they<br />
are. Of course, some of your clients may<br />
feel that the art is more important than<br />
the guests are. Their desires must be<br />
taken into account, even if they seem to<br />
be incorrect. The truth is, they’re the ones<br />
that ultimately will live in the house, and<br />
their needs must be addressed. Sometimes,<br />
you will be able to compromise on<br />
a design that at least provides some ambient<br />
light. As a guest, you will just have to<br />
try to be witty or profound enough to<br />
compete with the art.<br />
The Museum Effect: When art becomes<br />
visually more important than people within<br />
the space. Even museums now add additional<br />
illumination beyond accent light to<br />
help reduce eye fatigue, by cutting contrast<br />
in the overall environment.<br />
Accent lighting thrives on subtlety. A<br />
focused beam of light directed at an<br />
orchid or highlighting an abstract painting<br />
above a primitive chest can create a<br />
wondrous effect. People will not notice<br />
the light itself; they see only the object<br />
being lighted, almost subliminally. The<br />
lighting effect achieves its magic through<br />
its very invisibility.<br />
In the movies, if we can tell how a special<br />
effect has been achieved, we feel<br />
cheated. We don’t want to know, because<br />
we want to think it’s magic. In lighting, it<br />
should be no less the case.<br />
We want to see the effects of light, but<br />
the method needs to remain unseen, hidden,<br />
or an optical illusion. That subtlety is<br />
what will give the design a cohesive<br />
wholeness, allowing the design, the architecture,<br />
the furnishings or the landscape<br />
to become the focus in a particular space,<br />
not the light luminaires or the lighted<br />
bulbs glaring out from within them.<br />
Task light<br />
This is illumination for performing<br />
work-related activities, such as reading,<br />
cutting vegetables and sorting laundry.<br />
The optimal task light is located<br />
between your head and your work sur-<br />
(left, before and right, after)<br />
This living room uses light layering to<br />
create a comfortable, inviting environment.<br />
The ambient light, which comes from the<br />
indirect lighting by Starfire, adds the<br />
much-needed fill light which softens shadows<br />
on peoples faces. Recessed adjustable low<br />
voltage fixtures by Lucifer Lighting<br />
highlight the art glass, paintings,<br />
greenery and table tops.<br />
62 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
face. That’s why lighting from above isn’t<br />
a good source of task light, because your<br />
head casts a shadow onto your book,<br />
computer keyboard or ransom note.<br />
Overhead lighting or incorrectly<br />
placed task lighting often contributes to<br />
the problem of veiling reflection. This<br />
occurs when light comes from the ceiling<br />
directly in front of you, hitting the<br />
paper at such an angle that the glare is<br />
Simply putting<br />
ambient light<br />
on one<br />
dimmer<br />
and<br />
accent<br />
lighting on<br />
another<br />
provides a<br />
whole range<br />
of<br />
illumination<br />
level<br />
settings.<br />
reflected directly into your eyes. This<br />
causes unnecessary eye fatigue. Veiling<br />
reflection is the mirror-like reflection of a<br />
light source on a shiny surface. The surface<br />
may be a magazine page, thermal<br />
fax paper, or any visual task that has<br />
shiny ink, pencil lead, or any amount of<br />
glossiness. The veiling reflection is a<br />
bright image that washes out the contrast<br />
of the print or picture.<br />
Another related term is photo-pigment<br />
bleaching. When you try to read a<br />
book or a magazine outside, sometimes<br />
www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
This plain home in<br />
Palm Springs, Calif. comes<br />
alive at night with the<br />
addition of color corrected<br />
lighting for the new<br />
plantings and facade.<br />
The dramatic lighting<br />
draws visitors to the<br />
front door without<br />
glaring in their eyes.<br />
the brightness of the page makes it difficult<br />
to read. You end up moving to a<br />
shaded spot or tilting the magazine until<br />
the sun isn’t hitting it directly.<br />
Veiling Reflection: This refers to the glare<br />
and eye fatigue resulting from overhead<br />
light hitting directly on white paper with<br />
black ink, as if you were trying to read<br />
through a veil.<br />
A reflective surface is always a reflective<br />
surface, which means you can’t eliminate<br />
glare if you are focusing light onto<br />
a mirror-like finish.<br />
What you can do is redirect that glare<br />
away from the normal viewing angle.<br />
That’s why a light coming in from one side<br />
or both sides of your direction of view is<br />
more effective. It redirects the glare.<br />
Portable tabletop luminaires with solid<br />
shades often do the best job for casual<br />
reading, because they better direct the<br />
light and do not visually overpower the<br />
room when turned up to the correct<br />
intensity for the job at hand. You may be<br />
thinking, “Well, that’s fine and dandy for<br />
some Euro-chic interior, but what about<br />
my Louis the Sixteenth library?”<br />
Well, a boullotte lamp does a great job<br />
of task lighting, as does a banker’s lamp.<br />
Fluorescent or incandescent linear shelf<br />
lights, too, are a good source of task illumination<br />
at a desk with a shelf above the<br />
work surface or in the kitchen mounted<br />
under the overhead cabinets.<br />
Ambient light<br />
Ambient light is the soft, general illumination<br />
that fills the volume of a room<br />
with a glow of light, and softens the<br />
shadows on people’s faces. It is the most<br />
important of the four functions of light,<br />
but it is often the one element that is left<br />
out of the design of a room or space.<br />
The best ambient light comes from<br />
sources that bounce illumination off the<br />
ceiling and walls. Luminaires such as<br />
opaque wall sconces, torchieres, indirect<br />
pendants and cove lighting can provide a<br />
subtle general illumination without<br />
drawing attention to them. You could<br />
call it the open-hearth effect, where the<br />
room seems to be filled with the light of<br />
a glowing fire.<br />
Just filling a room with table lamps is<br />
not an adequate source of general illumination.<br />
The space becomes a lampshade<br />
showroom, where the table lamps are the<br />
first thing people see as they enter. Let<br />
these portable luminaires be a decorative<br />
source, creating little islands of light.<br />
Using opaque shades and perforated<br />
metal lids can turn these luminaires into<br />
more effective reading lights. Utilizing<br />
other sources to provide the necessary<br />
ambient light lets the decorative luminaires<br />
create the illusion of illuminating<br />
the room, without dominating the design.<br />
This inclusion of an ambient light<br />
source works only if the ceiling is light in<br />
color. A rich aubergine ceiling in a<br />
Victorian dining room or a dark wooden<br />
ceiling in a cabin retreat would make<br />
indirect light sources ineffective, because<br />
the dark surfaces absorb light instead of<br />
reflecting it.<br />
One solution to this situation is to<br />
lighten the color of the ceiling. Yes,<br />
sometimes the answer is to alter the environment<br />
rather than change the light<br />
source. Instead of the whole ceiling<br />
being eggplant-colored, how about a<br />
wide border in that color with the rest of<br />
the ceiling done in a cream color or similar<br />
hue? Using a traditional chandelier<br />
with a hidden halogen source could<br />
complement the design, while adding a<br />
modern sensibility.<br />
A wooden ceiling could be washed<br />
with an opaque stain that gives it a more<br />
weathered look without taking away<br />
from the wood feel itself, as simple painting<br />
would do.<br />
Say that your clients are dead-set<br />
against changing the color. A second<br />
possibility would be to use a luminaire<br />
that essentially provides its own ceiling.<br />
One luminaire that has been out on the<br />
(left) Looking in towards the kitchen from the dining room,<br />
a tall rice paper lantern from Ambiente offers a decorative<br />
glow, as do the two tall candlesticks. The series of blown<br />
glass pendants by Lite Source add decorative/ambient light<br />
for this compact galley kitchen. Xenon Puk Lights by<br />
Lucifer Lighting provide task light for the counter tops and<br />
additional Puk lights in the base of the upper glass-faced<br />
cabinets help punch out the architectural detailing.<br />
(right) This compact living room/dining room uses light to<br />
create a greater feeling of space. The Chip wall sconces<br />
by Koch & Lowy cast a dramatic shadow pattern on the<br />
wall, while recessed fixtures illuminate the arrangement<br />
on the dining table and the objects on the banquette.<br />
64 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
market for many years is the RLM pendant.<br />
It has a white interior fitted with a<br />
silver bowl reflector lamp (such as a<br />
150A21SBIF). The illumination is<br />
bounced off the inside of the shade itself,<br />
instead of the ceiling, to provide an adequate<br />
level of ambient light.<br />
There are more modern versions of<br />
the RLM, such as Spectro by Boyd<br />
The best<br />
ambient light<br />
comes<br />
from sources<br />
that bounce<br />
illumination<br />
off the<br />
ceiling and<br />
walls.<br />
Lighting or the Spilla Vetro by Flos. The<br />
halogen source fitted within an integral<br />
reflector bounces light off the dishshaped<br />
reflector and down into the space<br />
below.<br />
Ambient light, too, just like the other<br />
three functions, should not be used by<br />
itself. What you end up with is the<br />
cloudy day effect, where everything is of<br />
the same value, without depth or dimension.<br />
Ambient light alone is a flat light. It<br />
is only one component of well-designed<br />
lighting.<br />
Light layering<br />
A lighting design is successful when<br />
these four functions of light are layered<br />
within a room to create a fully usable,<br />
adaptive space. Good lighting does not<br />
draw attention to itself, but to the other<br />
design aspects of the environment.<br />
Once you have a good understanding<br />
of the functions of light and have communicated<br />
it successfully to your clients,<br />
then you can decide which are needed<br />
for a specific area. An entryway, for<br />
example, desperately needs ambient and<br />
accent light, but may not need any task<br />
light, because no work is going to be<br />
done in the entry. However, there may be<br />
a coat closet, which would need some<br />
task-oriented illumination.<br />
What we often see is a house lighted<br />
for entertaining only: a very dramatic,<br />
glitzy look. Many of the design magazines<br />
also show this type of lighting<br />
design, nearly exclusively. Every vase,<br />
painting, sculpture and ashtray glistens<br />
in its own pool of illumination. Yet, the<br />
seating area remains in darkness. What<br />
are these people going to do for light<br />
when they want to go through the mail,<br />
do their taxes or put a puzzle together<br />
with their kids?<br />
Also, the design magazines don’t tell<br />
you that they often add lighting specifically<br />
for photographing the rooms.<br />
Those lights won’t be there when someone<br />
is living in the house, and the effect<br />
won’t be nearly as wonderful. What it<br />
does do is give clients a false sense of<br />
what type of illumination downlights<br />
alone can provide.<br />
Please remember that people entertain<br />
only part of the time. The rest of the time<br />
these rooms are used to do homework,<br />
clean and interact with other family members.<br />
This doesn’t mean that you should<br />
eliminate accent lighting; just don’t make<br />
it the only option. Simply putting ambient<br />
light on one dimmer and accent lighting<br />
on another provides a whole range of illumination<br />
level settings.<br />
As your clients become more sophisticated<br />
about what they want, you should<br />
have the knowledge to give them what<br />
they want and need.<br />
Once a project is finished and someone<br />
walks in and says, “Oh, you put in<br />
track lighting,” it means that the lighting<br />
system itself is the first thing seen. If<br />
they walk in and say, “You look great!”<br />
or, “Is that a new painting?” then you<br />
know the lighting has been successfully<br />
integrated into the overall room design.<br />
Subtle is good.<br />
Randall Whitehead is an affiliate president for<br />
Randall Whitehead International, in San<br />
Francisco.<br />
www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
If late one night, after everyone has<br />
gone home, you find yourself sitting<br />
on top of a 10 ft ladder with a can of<br />
spray paint and a roll of duct tape, you<br />
are most likely involved in an 11th hour<br />
fix. In some cosmic sense, you are probably<br />
being punished for sins committed<br />
earlier in the lighting project.<br />
Most of us love the design concept<br />
phase, tolerate the design documentation<br />
phase and delegate the project management<br />
phase. It is not surprising that<br />
things go wrong during the phase where<br />
we spend the least amount of quality<br />
time.<br />
Except for back luck, most of the<br />
things that can go wrong with a lighting<br />
project are identifiable and avoidable.<br />
Good communication and documentation<br />
throughout the project from concept<br />
to focusing will go a long way<br />
towards avoiding the things that can go<br />
wrong.<br />
Join Addison Kelly and David Apfel<br />
for an illustrated tour through a typical<br />
11th Hour Fixes<br />
Preempting disaster, by learning to sidestep the pitfalls<br />
of construction during the design process can save time<br />
and money. David Apfel and Addison G. Kelly will<br />
help designers avoid 11th hour fixes.<br />
FRIDAY, JUNE 1, 2001, 2:00 - 3:30 PM<br />
lighting design project. We will identify<br />
the potential pitfalls and where they<br />
occur in the project schedule. We will<br />
review each problem area and indicate<br />
the steps that can be taken to avoid 11th<br />
hour fixes. Listed below are just some of<br />
the things that can go wrong during the<br />
construction and focusing phases of a<br />
project:<br />
Construction Phase<br />
• Contractor refuses to order lighting<br />
equipment in a timely manner, hoping<br />
that a delivery crisis will allow him to<br />
substitute.<br />
• Lighting equipment manufacturer<br />
cannot meet schedule.<br />
• Poor documentation or construction<br />
site conditions result in relocated ductwork,<br />
tight ceiling plenum conditions,<br />
and light coves not correctly built.<br />
• Lighting equipment installed in the<br />
wrong location.<br />
• Wrong lamps are installed in the<br />
luminaires.<br />
• Wall washers are installed lighting<br />
out into the room.<br />
• At a pre-completion walk-through,<br />
before the finishing materials and furniture<br />
are in place, the space feels too<br />
bright or too dark.<br />
Focusing Phase<br />
• No one ever notified the lighting<br />
designer that the project was complete<br />
and the lights needed to be focused.<br />
• The contractor has left with his ladders,<br />
lifts and scaffolds. How do you<br />
reach the lighting equipment?<br />
• The luminaires are too hot to touch.<br />
• The rotation and pivot mechanisms<br />
are locked in place and will not move.<br />
• Lamps have burnt out in 30 percent<br />
of the luminaires.<br />
• The local electrical union will not<br />
allow the lighting designer to focus the<br />
lights.<br />
• Your hands get cut because of rough,<br />
unfinished, metal edges on the interior<br />
of a luminaire.<br />
• The luminaires are installed according<br />
to plan, but the furniture and art<br />
have moved.<br />
Also included are illustrated stories of<br />
the things that went wrong and how<br />
they were fixed by some of the most brilliant<br />
lighting designers of our day. Of<br />
course, names will be changed to protect<br />
the innocent and the guilty.<br />
The accompanying illustrations are<br />
examples of specular materials interacting<br />
with light sources in a manner never<br />
intended by the interior designer or the<br />
lighting designer. Join us and learn how<br />
to avoid the 11th hour fix.<br />
David Apfel is the owner of David Apfel<br />
Lighting Design in New York. Addison Kelly is<br />
a principal for US Lighting Design Consultants,<br />
also in New York.<br />
66 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
The Need for Control<br />
Deciding what types of lighting controls to use in an<br />
application is of primary importance. Harold Jepsen,<br />
Leslie North and Sandra Vasconez will provide<br />
help in making the decision easier.<br />
THURSDAY, MAY 31, 2001, 4:00 - 5:30 PM<br />
For most facilities, lighting systems management personnel value the<br />
are second only to HVAC systems in increased convenience in maintaining<br />
terms of energy usage. Controlling optimal building operations with automated<br />
controls. For occupants, the<br />
these systems is an inextricable part of<br />
the entire lighting equation. There are advantages of optimal lighting and<br />
some unavoidable reasons for controlling<br />
lighting, such as complying with comfort and satisfaction with personal<br />
adjustable light levels can lead to greater<br />
energy code provisions that require work environments.<br />
automated lighting controls in non-residential<br />
facilities.<br />
companies that are implementing light-<br />
While it’s clear to a growing number of<br />
However, beyond basic compliance, ing controls that there is great potential<br />
lighting control can provide a variety of for enhancing the operation of a facility,<br />
benefits for building owners, managers many also acknowledge that developing<br />
and occupants. For building owners and a lighting control project offers considerable<br />
potential for pitfalls. An inadequate<br />
managers, the potential energy savings<br />
involved with lighting control can be or ineffective controls system can create<br />
substantial — often 30 percent of total more obstacles than an absence of controls,<br />
as dissatisfied or frustrated electrical usage or even greater. Facility<br />
occupants<br />
may disable or destroy devices to<br />
resolve their concerns.<br />
“Control Me!” provides a roadmap<br />
through the design, selection, and<br />
implementation of lighting controls in a<br />
“real-world” context. Structured<br />
around real-life applications commonly<br />
found in commercial settings, this seminar<br />
provides attendees with a comprehensive<br />
overview about the entire lighting<br />
controls process, from a logistical<br />
perspective, as well as a results-oriented<br />
perspective.<br />
For instance, seminar leaders will<br />
explore common applications such as<br />
open office areas, private offices, conference/training<br />
rooms, restrooms, common<br />
areas and exterior lighting. In each<br />
setting, topics for consideration include<br />
what the needs of the user(s) are. This<br />
includes an assessment of who — if anyone<br />
— feels “ownership” of the space, as<br />
well as other factors, such as the presence<br />
of daylight. In addition to user<br />
needs, other topics include how to select<br />
a suitable control strategy, what application-specific<br />
challenges might appear,<br />
and results or insights gained from<br />
recent research or case studies involving<br />
similar applications.<br />
Before exploring each specific application,<br />
the seminar reviews some of the<br />
basics in beginning a lighting controls<br />
(left) In conference rooms, user needs include flexibility and ease-of-use for selected controls. Architectural dimming controls may be an<br />
appropriate solution. (right) In an open office setting, there is limited space “ownership” by occupants. There is a need for daytime lighting and the<br />
ability to override controls after hours. This is accommodated with scheduled control and the use of local “smart” switches.<br />
68 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
For restrooms, occupancy-based control is a natural selection. Lights turn on when the space is occupied,<br />
and turn off when the space is vacant.<br />
project. Control parameters need to be<br />
defined. This includes identifying the<br />
goals of lighting controls for that specific<br />
project and factors such as who will<br />
be maintaining the system and budgetary<br />
issues. Lighting control strategies<br />
(i.e., occupancy-based, time scheduled,<br />
light level control and load shedding)<br />
must be assessed.<br />
Another aspect the seminar leaders<br />
will explore is who will be involved in<br />
designing a lighting control system; who<br />
will actually do the design and how it<br />
will be communicated (i.e., through documents<br />
such as written specifications,<br />
schedules, and riser diagrams).<br />
At this point, the seminar begins to<br />
explore a “sample office building” to<br />
put into practice some of the topics<br />
already discussed. The leaders begin<br />
with a common application in commercial<br />
buildings: the open office application.<br />
In open office settings, there might<br />
be limited space “ownership” by occupants.<br />
In addition, there will be the<br />
need for daytime lighting and the ability<br />
to override controls after hours for<br />
individuals working late. This can be<br />
accommodated by scheduled control<br />
and the use of local “smart” switches. It<br />
can also be provided by daylighting<br />
controls, such as continuous dimming.<br />
These controls ensure that occupants<br />
always have the lighting levels needed<br />
for their tasks. At the Sacramento<br />
Municipal Utility District, a combination<br />
of these two control strategies was<br />
used to achieve the desired energy management<br />
objectives and to realize energy<br />
savings.<br />
In private offices, on the other hand,<br />
there is usually greater “ownership” by<br />
the occupant, coupled with the desire to<br />
control lighting in the space. For these<br />
reasons, suitable control strategies<br />
include occupancy-based control or personal<br />
dimming controls. Evidence that<br />
these strategies are well suited to this<br />
type of work environment was revealed<br />
by a seminal study conducted at the<br />
National Center for Atmospheric<br />
Research. This research indicated that<br />
employees preferred manual controls to<br />
automatic ones, and actively adjusted<br />
their own lighting for a variety of reasons.<br />
In fact, more than 70 percent of<br />
study participants used portable desktop<br />
dimmer switches to adjust lighting! And<br />
in many cases, workers indicated that<br />
they adjusted their lighting, not for energy<br />
saving reasons, but to make their<br />
environment more comfortable to perform<br />
computer work.<br />
Conference/training rooms may be<br />
smaller and occupant-intimate while<br />
accommodating multiple users and a<br />
wide range of activities. Here, user<br />
needs include flexibility and ease-of-use<br />
for selected controls. In this type of setting,<br />
architectural dimming controls or<br />
occupancy-based control may be appropriate<br />
solutions.<br />
For restrooms, which experience<br />
infrequent use and limited space ownership,<br />
occupancy-based control is a<br />
natural selection. With this strategy,<br />
lights will be on when the space is occupied<br />
and off when vacant. Other types<br />
of building spaces that have little or no<br />
ownership are the common areas such<br />
as lobbies and hallways. These spaces<br />
also demonstrate characteristics such as<br />
the need for egress and the frequent<br />
presence of daylight. For spaces like<br />
these, the control solution may be<br />
scheduled, daylighting, occupancybased<br />
or some combination.<br />
The primary factor in exterior lighting<br />
applications is usually protecting occupant<br />
safety and security. Design factors<br />
such as multi-phase loads, the presence<br />
of daylight, and the need to accommodate<br />
occupant schedules may also influence<br />
the ultimate control strategy that is<br />
selected. With factors like these, automated<br />
scheduled control that relies on<br />
either astronomic or photocell control is<br />
ideal for many exterior applications.<br />
Once the lighting control tour of the<br />
seminar’s office building is complete,<br />
attendees will have a deeper understanding<br />
of the issues involved in<br />
designing and implementing lighting<br />
controls. They will also have a number<br />
of control solutions to explore further in<br />
the context of their own facilities. The<br />
seminar will conclude with a brief<br />
exploration of emerging issues such as<br />
integrating lighting control and other<br />
building systems. This discussion will<br />
look at who the stakeholders are in systems<br />
integration as well as what the benefits<br />
and challenges are in the integration<br />
process. Seminar leaders will also<br />
touch on some of the communication<br />
standards and issues between systems.<br />
Harold Jepsen is a product line manager for The<br />
Watt Stopper, in Livermore, Calif. Leslie North<br />
is a senior lighting designer for OWP&P Engineers,<br />
Inc., in Chicago. Sandra Vasconez is a<br />
research assistant professor for the Lighting<br />
Research Center in Troy, N. Y.<br />
70 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
PHOTO: JUSSI TIAINEN<br />
Fiskars waterfall has been part of the village center for<br />
350 years. For years, it has given the sound to the night<br />
of Fiskars. Now the sound is combined with the<br />
new image of the lighted waterfall.<br />
Poetry in<br />
Lighting Design<br />
Vesa Honkonen and Julle Oksanen<br />
take attendees on a personal journey of projects,<br />
which demonstrate the artistic and<br />
poetic side of lighting design.<br />
It was a starry night in October, a few years ago. We were<br />
standing outside, in the small picturesque village of Fiskars,<br />
located in Southern Finland. Fiskars is a 350-year-old steel mill<br />
village. We had darkened the whole area; all the street lights<br />
were off. A small river with strong current runs through the village.<br />
The river has always been the heart of Fiskars.<br />
There are two small waterfalls in the very center of the village.<br />
We had built a lighting demonstration to one of the waterfalls<br />
as part of our commission to create a new lighting design<br />
for the village. We used just one small light caster to lift the<br />
waterfall from the darkness. Two men were with us: our client,<br />
the vice-president of Fiskars Company; and a quiet man who<br />
had lived in Fiskars for his whole life, and had helped us to<br />
build the demonstrations. The vice-president turned to ask his<br />
opinion. We were all surprised to notice that this local guy had<br />
tears in his eyes and he was staring at the waterfall. He said<br />
whispering, “All my life, I have just heard that water in the<br />
darkness. Now I can also see it after 50 years, and it is so beautiful.”<br />
This experience made us think about the power of light<br />
and our responsibility as designers.<br />
The power of light<br />
If we really think about it, it is impossible to work with the<br />
light itself. Light is meaningless before it meets something.<br />
Light earns its life when it starts to play with surfaces, materials,<br />
places, locations. On our way to be lighting designers we<br />
learn about light, lamps and fixtures, but we should pay even<br />
more attention to studying the environment, place, objects,<br />
which will be our true client. Lighting a city or a town, is an<br />
extremely demanding challenge. Part of the stories are written<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
THURSDAY, MAY 31, 2001, 2:00 - 3:30 PM
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
PHOTO: JUSSI TIAINEN<br />
with stone and concrete, some of them live in stories and<br />
books. Then there are hidden stories that carry enormous<br />
power within, the memories of the people — places to fall in<br />
love, places for the first kiss, places for joy and happiness, for<br />
loss and sorrow.<br />
Does a painting exist if no one is looking at it? Does a<br />
poem exist if no one reads it? These are eternal philosophical<br />
questions.<br />
I have started to realize that the place where our design gets<br />
its life and meaning is not where it physically exists. We are<br />
doing our design for people to experience and feel. The space<br />
with light is created inside people’s mind and soul. There, it has<br />
its final interpretation, People’s experience in our work is seen<br />
through all those personal layers of memories, education, feelings<br />
and connotations.<br />
Our design is created with steel, electricity and glass. With<br />
those materials, we create light. Our light meets the stones,<br />
concrete and wood the way we have determined. How well we<br />
succeed depends on our capability and sensitivity to understand<br />
the location and the stories written into common heritage<br />
of the site. We highlight some things, others we leave to<br />
darkness. We continue the tradition of the storytellers of the<br />
place, adding our new layer to the history of the site.<br />
How to be a good lighting designer<br />
Philosophy of light: No matter how weird, sentimental or<br />
scientific it is, you have to have it. You have to have your own<br />
personal point of view. Then you have to be able to analyze and<br />
read the place, and know your task. When you have all this,<br />
you still have to be able to tell the stories of places with light.<br />
You have to be able to master the techniques at the same time.<br />
The Fiskars Park bollard fixture creates spots of light in the darkness.<br />
People walk through intervals of light and darkness. The bollard’s<br />
material is rusted steel. The form language has its origins in one of the<br />
early Fiskars steel mill products — railroad track spikes.<br />
Due to these reasons, we believe that a good lighting designer<br />
should understand lighting, architecture, urban design, electrical<br />
engineering physics, psychology, semiology, history, etc.<br />
This is also the reason why we believe that lighting design is<br />
team work.<br />
In our team, we have the training of an experienced architect<br />
and an experienced electrical engineer with both having experience<br />
in lighting design; and even this is not enough. You have<br />
to be able to say: “I do not know, let me ask somebody.”<br />
With these resources, we might be able to create good lighting,<br />
which might rise to the level where we can talk about the<br />
Poetry of light. Spirit, the soul, creates the poem; cities and<br />
places are our paper and canvas; and light and darkness are<br />
our pen.<br />
The canvas of the lighting designer is dark black; that is<br />
where it all starts. Studies of light have made me think about<br />
the dualistic nature of things. Light and darkness, sound and<br />
silence, movement and stand still, the play of pairs. I call one<br />
the power part; the other part is the basic level.<br />
Darkness is the origin, the state of being without any life,<br />
without any concept of space. For some people, total darkness<br />
PHOTO: TAPIO VANHATALO<br />
The Fiskars Street fixture shows its directly aimed light best in rain and<br />
fog. The steel pole is vertical for the first 4 m. Then, it starts to lean back<br />
slightly. This move allows the light to attach to its own body. A small<br />
stripe of light on that leaning steel tube reveals the structure in the night.<br />
74 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
PHOTO: VESA HONKONEN<br />
is scary and threatening. For me, it means peace and rest. Light<br />
is the outburst of energy, life. It is always produced somehow.<br />
It will last as long as the reaction causing it is alive. Light has<br />
the concept of time built in it.Two separate lights can give a<br />
meaning or dimension. Time to darkness can be measured by<br />
marking the boundaries for the indefinable darkness, including<br />
an end and a starting point.<br />
This approach is easy to repeat with sound and silence. Total<br />
silence has no dimensions for our senses. Sound is an outburst,<br />
created with energy. Sound itself has a length, which can be<br />
measured both by time and quantity. Music contains many<br />
extremely powerful examples of the power of silence. Two<br />
notes, which mark the beginning and the end of a silence, are<br />
usually the most powerful moments of many symphonies. But,<br />
there are also quiet moments between two notes. During the<br />
wait for the next sound, you can almost feel the time and anticipation.<br />
Silence gets a meaning and a length.<br />
In order to see light, study darkness; in order to hear sound,<br />
study silence. This indicates the poetry in lighting design<br />
Poems in figures and calculations<br />
The history of electrical lighting is short, only some 100<br />
years. As always in culture, various factors direct the progress.<br />
We seldom realize that one of the biggest factors to our exterior<br />
lighting quality is the energy crisis in the 1970s.<br />
In order to achieve efficient lighting, lamp manufacturers<br />
started to concentrate on high pressure and low pressure sodium<br />
lamps. Sales were great but the quality was in question. As<br />
always, using those lamps was almost like a fashion. Yellow fog<br />
covered the quality aspects.<br />
Similar things have happened in many other fields also. The<br />
progress has been directed by technically orientated people,<br />
and it takes a while before design and visually orientated professionals<br />
get involved. Now it seems the time is right for high<br />
quality lighting. The lamp manufacturers have also noticed this<br />
progress. Light sources have become smaller, with greater<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
The Railway Station Plaza fixture in front of architect<br />
Eliel Saarinen’s station building.<br />
lm/W values, longer lifetime and excellent color properties.<br />
This has given new possibilities, as well as new challenges to<br />
lighting fixture design. The world is open for good design combined<br />
with high quality techniques.<br />
Let’s take a look at two examples, the Railway Station Plaza<br />
in Helsinki with Eliel Saarinen’s architecture and the Aura River<br />
in Turku, which is the oldest city of Finland. In both cases, the<br />
goal has been to combine design and high quality techniques<br />
in harmony. As always, when facing something new, people<br />
reject. We also met a reasonable amount of resistance and critics<br />
based on other arguments like; “we have never done it this<br />
way.” But in the end, the result speaks for it self.<br />
The Railway Station Plaza project was the result of a winning<br />
design competition entry, done in co-operation with<br />
Philip Gabriel. The place is culturally and architecturally<br />
important. After a long path of various design phases we<br />
came to the solution to light the plaza with just one type of<br />
luminaire, a 4.5 m tall indirect fixture. We used 150 W<br />
ceramic metal halide lamps. The pole was 140 mm thick. One<br />
lamp was located on the top part of the pole to take care of<br />
the indirect light and the other was inserted to height of 2.2<br />
m to create direct facade lighting.<br />
The battle for the right light distribution, lamp chamber
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
PHOTO: JUSSI TIAINEN<br />
100 trees with tree<br />
luminaires in Turku.<br />
The best possible indirect<br />
lighting fixture is located<br />
above the River and<br />
the moon.<br />
and optics was long. We had to hit the indirect reflector part<br />
with light exactly the right way. The maximum luminance of<br />
the reflector part is the same as full moon (average value<br />
1,100 cd/sq. with variation from 500-2,500 cd/sq). All the<br />
values were measured, E hor-, E vertical-, E hemispherical-,<br />
E semicylindrical- and symmetrical, in order to evaluate the<br />
quality of the minimized size lamp chamber and its light.<br />
One luminaire can cover a 30 x 16 m area with reasonable E<br />
hor values. Selected and summed up values for whole calculation<br />
area were the following: E hor average: 20 lx; E hor<br />
minimum average: 8 lx; and E semicylindrical minimum<br />
average: 1.2 lx. Elevations got 5 cd/sq.<br />
We put a lot of effort to minimize the glare. We evaluated the<br />
luminaire as post top and road lighting luminaire. All the measurements<br />
have shown that this luminaire achieves excellent<br />
values. When maximum L 0.25 values for post top luminaires<br />
which we have measured, have been 8,000 (extremely bright,<br />
3,000-7,000 is nowadays regarded as acceptable), our fixture<br />
was 600. After this, we were excited to study our luminaires<br />
glare values using the road lighting fixture measurements. The<br />
glare for the road lighting luminaire is presented with glare<br />
value G, nuisance glare, with values 1, 3, 5, 7, 9. In this table,<br />
1 is glary and 9 is unnoticeable. Our fixture achieved the theoretical<br />
value of 9.5.<br />
These evaluation tools, glare, uniformity, luminance, different<br />
illuminance values, are usually studied and evaluated separately<br />
and they do not affect one another.<br />
However, a fixture can produce a lot of light on the road even<br />
though it is fairly glary. That kind of fixture can be regarded as<br />
efficient and good one.<br />
At the same time, a luminaire, which creates less light and<br />
has no glare, is much more efficient, since the glare does not<br />
prevent our eyes to see clearly. We are saying that the glare values<br />
should be part of the formulas estimating the efficiency.<br />
Glare and light distribution should not be two separate things.<br />
There are many things to be studied. Our statement to this discussion<br />
can be seen at the Railway Station Plaza.<br />
The Aura River project included all the elements of a public<br />
space lighting with a great river area with bridges. One example<br />
is the story of how we lighted the trees.<br />
Usually trees are lighted either with underground luminaires<br />
or with floodlights. Both options create several glary light distribution<br />
surfaces with glare causing veiling luminance to<br />
observer’s eyes. Floodlights also create big visual elements to<br />
sensitive historical environment.<br />
We started to study a luminaire, which would be simple,<br />
effective and would not have any glare. The solution was to<br />
locate the light source to a height of 3 m with a 60 mm pole.<br />
The lamp chamber has 2 x 150 W ceramic metalhalide lamps.<br />
Lumen output is 30,000 lm. Each tree has its own fixture,<br />
always located on the same side of the tree. This creates the difference<br />
to the quality of light, depending on which direction<br />
you approach from.<br />
In the beginning of the project we had a demonstration<br />
with the luminaires at the site. An older couple came to us,<br />
stopped just under the fixtures, looked around and said:<br />
“What a beautiful light, but where does it come from?” We<br />
knew we had succeeded.<br />
Vesa Honkonen is an architect and lighting designer for Vesa Honkonen<br />
Architects in Helsinki, Finland. Julle Oksanen is a lighting designer for<br />
Teakon, also in Helsinki.<br />
76 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
Communicating at the<br />
Speed of e<br />
Brian Cronin and Anthony Long, of Planetmouse,<br />
Inc., hope to ease the wary minds of those skeptical<br />
of the power and benefits the Internet can<br />
bring to their business.<br />
FRIDAY, JUNE 1, 2001, 10:30 AM - 12:00 PM<br />
Why do I need to incorporate the<br />
Internet into my business? This<br />
is a good question, and representative<br />
of the synergetic, yet sometimes nebulous<br />
relationship between the burgeoning<br />
technology and the quintessential<br />
challenges associated with business. In<br />
our upcoming presentation on Interactivity<br />
at LIGHTFAIR INTERNA-<br />
TIONAL, Planetmouse will not only<br />
aim to shed light on the basic principles<br />
that govern interactivity, but will<br />
also reveal the potential of the Internet<br />
to transform both businesses and<br />
everyday reality.<br />
The Internet represents many things<br />
to many people. To some, it is a vast sea<br />
of information. To others, it is a conduit<br />
for communications. There are those<br />
who still envision tremendous e-commerce<br />
potential for the Internet, while<br />
many see it simply as a source of entertainment.<br />
In short, the Internet feeds<br />
heads of many different shapes, sizes,<br />
cultures and beliefs. With billions of us<br />
buzzing around this big, spinning rock<br />
with our heads reasonably intact, I’m<br />
guessing that interactivity will be here<br />
for a while.<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
So, what does “e” mean? Literally, “e”<br />
stands for electronic, which is a rather<br />
generic term these days, similar to the<br />
the Internet<br />
feeds<br />
heads of<br />
many different<br />
shapes,<br />
sizes,<br />
cultures<br />
and beliefs<br />
way folks toss around the word “digital.”<br />
If something isn’t digital, then it<br />
isn’t first-rate.<br />
Acquiring a fundamental understanding<br />
of interactive basics is a necessity<br />
today. This working knowledge will<br />
not only help to avoid confusion, but<br />
will allow for more effective strategic<br />
planning. While securing a grasp on the<br />
basics is a good place to start, it’s important<br />
to know how the Internet can support<br />
and enhance ongoing business<br />
plans. That’s why we are heading to Las<br />
Vegas in May. We can help you understand<br />
the advantages of harnessing<br />
interactivity.<br />
Getting Started: Interactivity is all<br />
about bringing business to the Internet<br />
and vice versa. This is what Planetmouse<br />
is all about. Since our inception in the<br />
mid-1990s, our primary purpose has<br />
been to help our clients understand,<br />
strategize and implement interactivity<br />
into their business plans. As a result, we<br />
plan to touch on the following at<br />
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL.<br />
• Plugging the Gaps: How the<br />
Internet can make your organization<br />
more effective.<br />
• Scope & Scale: Addressing both<br />
large and small web initiatives (the differences<br />
and similarities).<br />
• Experience vs. Inexperience: The<br />
goal is still the same — increased efficiency<br />
and productivity.<br />
• Resource Options: The Who, What,<br />
Where, When, Why and How of interactive<br />
resources.<br />
Staying Connected: The impact of<br />
online communications can be felt<br />
immediately upon implementation. If,<br />
for no other reason, companies must<br />
establish an interactive presence to fortify<br />
this essential business element. Topics<br />
will include:<br />
• Plugging In & Turning On:<br />
Accessing the Web for fun & profit.<br />
• Communication: Using email and<br />
other web-based tools to bolster communications<br />
efforts.<br />
LD+A/May 2001 77
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
• Basic Tools: Which options are right<br />
for your business?<br />
• For The Geeks: PDAs, Digital<br />
Wireless Telecom, Portable Web Access<br />
& Voice Over IP.<br />
Online Research: The Internet is a vast<br />
resource for information. Conducting<br />
research on an industry, specific markets,<br />
competitors, vendors and suppliers only<br />
takes a few clicks of the keyboard or<br />
mouse. Here, we will discuss things like:<br />
• Working with search engines<br />
• Information web resources<br />
• Competitive and market intelligence<br />
• Customer data<br />
• Web communities/peers<br />
Website Planning: Why do you need a<br />
website? How will a site enhance your<br />
overall business objectives? What makes<br />
a site effective? How do I avoid common<br />
mistakes? These and other questions<br />
regarding website planning, development,<br />
design and implementation will be<br />
discussed in this section.<br />
• Establish an high-impact interactive<br />
presence<br />
• Extending “reach” beyond geographic<br />
and market barriers<br />
• Information vs. design<br />
• Relevance and freshness<br />
• Function and form issues<br />
• Success criteria<br />
Website Construction: There are all<br />
sorts of tasks and issues to address before<br />
breaking ground on a website. Handling<br />
them properly can mean the difference<br />
between a smooth project and a rocky<br />
ride. These issues include:<br />
• User interface priorities<br />
• Domain name registration<br />
• Hiring an ISP/web host<br />
• “Beta” vs. “Final:” Content development<br />
• Breaking Ground: Professional<br />
design vs. Do-It-Yourself (DIY)<br />
Website Repair: As with any physical<br />
construction project, there are ultimately<br />
some components that either stray from<br />
spec or require re-tasking. The Internet is<br />
still in its infancy and will continue to<br />
evolve in its state of flux in the near<br />
future. A website should also be a fluid,<br />
adaptive appliance<br />
• Internal vs. external perceptions<br />
• “Small” vs. “large” changes<br />
• Evolving expectations<br />
• Driving improvements to results<br />
• Costs/budget tracking<br />
360 Degree Marketing and Online<br />
Branding: When marketing and promoting<br />
a business, choosing the right tools<br />
it’s important<br />
to know<br />
how the<br />
Internet<br />
can<br />
support and<br />
enhance<br />
ongoing<br />
business<br />
plans.<br />
for the job is key. Blending both online<br />
and offline efforts into a cohesive marketing<br />
plan will minimize cost and maximize<br />
the overall impact<br />
• Integration: Integrating interactive<br />
tools into your marketing mix.<br />
• Targeting: Strengthening the link<br />
between your customers, partners and<br />
vendors.<br />
• Branding: Analysis, strategy, building<br />
and tracking of your brand online.<br />
What Management Needs to Know:<br />
There are some basic decision-making<br />
issues for both large and small organizations<br />
to keep in mind. We will discuss<br />
some of the elements that make up a<br />
sound interactive game plan:<br />
• Marketing vs. Strategy: Who should<br />
drive the interactive bus?<br />
• Management Buy-In: Setting<br />
Goals… Evaluating Results<br />
• Project Management: Meeting timelines<br />
and managing the workflow<br />
• Content Management: Exceeding<br />
audience expectations<br />
• Cost and Budgeting<br />
Other Interactive Issues: Time permitting,<br />
we have some additional issues to<br />
consider when implementing an interactive<br />
strategy. Concepts like the Role of<br />
Multimedia and E-Business Best Practices<br />
cover a broad range of pertinent<br />
subject matter, including:<br />
• Audience/hardware sophistication<br />
• Connectivity issues<br />
• Shelf Life: Sizzle vs. substance<br />
• Transparency<br />
• Fast turnaround<br />
Our goal at LIGHTFAIR INTERNA-<br />
TIONAL is to foster an interactive dialogue<br />
with the audience during our presentation.<br />
If the group wants to chew on<br />
a specific topic for a while, we will gnaw<br />
away until everyone is satisfied.<br />
This is a quite a bit of ground to<br />
cover in a two-hour presentation.<br />
However, each component represents<br />
an important segment of the overall<br />
interactive puzzle. Missing or misplaced<br />
pieces can affect the performance<br />
of the entire endeavor and jeopardize<br />
its success. Function and Form<br />
must work in concert to provide the<br />
user with a stimulating and rewarding<br />
interactive experience.<br />
The business world is just as fierce,<br />
competitive and unforgiving as it was<br />
before the advent of the World Wide<br />
Web. Success will ultimately depend on<br />
preparation, creativity and cunning. If<br />
you can’t deliver the goods, someone<br />
else will.<br />
Anthony Long is president, and Brian Cronin is<br />
the director of business development for Planetmouse,<br />
Inc. in New York.<br />
78 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
Merchandising<br />
Retail Environments<br />
with Light<br />
Helmut O. Paidasch offers insight into creating a<br />
more customer-friendly retail environment, by addressing<br />
three aspects: visual comfort, display and ambience.<br />
THURSDAY, MAY 31, 2001, 8:30 - 10:00 AM<br />
In today’s competitive market, it is<br />
essential for every retailer, large or<br />
small, to consider all items of his store as<br />
an attraction to draw the attention of<br />
prospective customers.<br />
Architects and interior designers<br />
must capture the aesthetically pleasing<br />
surroundings coupled with captivating<br />
and imaginary interior design. Shopping<br />
centers and large department<br />
stores are no longer focused on single<br />
shopping activities, but have become<br />
centers of meeting places and emulate<br />
the plaza environment.<br />
Light is a fundamental prerequisite in<br />
the retail environment. It determines<br />
form, color and texture, and also creates<br />
ambience, which can enhance or detract<br />
from merchandising on display.<br />
In the ’80s and ’90s, the retail industry<br />
witnessed an exceptional increase in<br />
the development and application of<br />
lamps and luminaires (fixtures). In<br />
these years, shopping centers expanded<br />
with ever-increasing fervor, placing<br />
innovative demands on the skills of the<br />
lighting designer. Architectural designs<br />
for shopping malls and retail centers<br />
influenced by the continuous change in<br />
fashion trends, have contributed to a<br />
heightened recognition of the importance<br />
of lighting.<br />
It is now well established that good<br />
lighting is fundamental for successful<br />
salesmanship; it sets the mood and<br />
reflects the enterprising attitude of the<br />
retail outlet. It will give the retailer a<br />
competitive edge and can also create a<br />
corporate image.<br />
Technological advancements are now<br />
presenting the lighting designer with<br />
solutions to meet new challenges. These<br />
developments are augmented by the<br />
awareness of architects and store designers<br />
that good lighting not only contributes<br />
to the overall image of the retail<br />
outlet, but also attracts prospective customers<br />
to stop and shop.<br />
The lighting designer must consider<br />
and be aware at all times that the visual<br />
effect on customers is of paramount<br />
importance. Generally there are three<br />
aspects to consider: visual comfort, visual<br />
display and visual ambience.<br />
Visual comfort: suggests no glare, good<br />
color rendering and adequate illumination<br />
for the items on display. Glare mostly<br />
comes in two forms — disability glare<br />
or discomfort glare — and it can be<br />
direct or reflected. The most common<br />
manifestation of glare is produced by<br />
luminance directly within one’s visual<br />
field, and is greater than the luminance<br />
to which the eyes have already adapted.<br />
Glare causes reduced visibility, discomfort<br />
and irritation, not only to customers<br />
but sales staff as well. Glare in the shopping<br />
environment is attributed mainly<br />
from luminaries, lamps or both. In most<br />
cases, it can be corrected by aiming<br />
adjustments. The introduction of controlled<br />
glare in a lighting installation can<br />
contribute sparkle.<br />
Visual display: requires satisfactory<br />
lighting levels so that color, fabric and<br />
merchandise is easy recognizable. Fabric<br />
and texture may look the same under<br />
(left) An optimum level of visual comfort means no glare, with good color rendering and adequate illumination for the items on display.<br />
(right) Visual ambience is the overall impression the customers perceive when entering the store. Low, soft illumination should invite the shopper<br />
into the store, where more colorful, elegant displays await.<br />
80 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR PREVIEW<br />
Visual display requires satisfactory<br />
lighting levels so that color, fabric and<br />
merchandise is easily recognizable.<br />
The choice between various types of<br />
lamps should be made in terms of<br />
color rendering and color appearance.<br />
one source but entirely different under<br />
another light source. Metamerism is the<br />
term used to describe light sources of different<br />
spectral composition, but of the<br />
Low and<br />
soft<br />
illumination<br />
should invite<br />
the shopper<br />
into a<br />
friendly<br />
and<br />
colorful<br />
atmosphere<br />
same color appearance. Color samples<br />
may look the same under one light<br />
source, but different under another light<br />
source. For best results the choice<br />
between various types of lamps should<br />
be made in terms of color rendering and<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
color appearance. Good color rendering<br />
is especially beneficial when merchandise<br />
is selected by virtue of its color.<br />
Visual ambience: is the overall impression<br />
the customers perceive on entering<br />
the store. Low and soft illumination<br />
should invite the shopper into a friendly<br />
and colorful atmosphere where a<br />
world of enticing and elegant displays<br />
awaits. Merchandising should be<br />
offered on well-designed and illuminated<br />
display counters generating a powerful<br />
ambience.<br />
Lighting for the retail environment<br />
can be separated into three parts: ambient,<br />
background and display or accent.<br />
The simplest and most effective formula<br />
to illuminate this areas is” double and<br />
double.” It is a well-applied and proven<br />
method. With an ambient of 400 lx, the<br />
background illumination should be 800<br />
lx and accent illumination should be<br />
1600 lx. This combination will help to<br />
ensure that the shopper’s attention is<br />
directed to the merchandise of his or her<br />
choice.<br />
The ceaseless changes in the field of<br />
electronics should remind lighting<br />
designers what is state-of-the-art today<br />
might be outmoded tomorrow by new<br />
developments in either lamps, luminaires<br />
or control equipment. The lighting<br />
designer must maintain a vigil on all<br />
developments in his field of endeavor. It<br />
is obvious that to be proficient at<br />
“Merchandising the Retail Environment<br />
with Light” requires that the lighting<br />
designer has artistic skills, as well as<br />
astute technical awareness.<br />
With budget restrictions, all expenditure<br />
for lighting has to be justified and<br />
each of the following points demand<br />
serious consideration: capital outlay, utility<br />
consumption cost and annual maintenance<br />
cost. Designers must be alert to<br />
incorporate all three points when submitting<br />
a presentation.<br />
Although the final lighting installation<br />
is highly subjective, there is an interrelationship<br />
between the design and the<br />
profitability of the store. In the final<br />
analysis, it is the cash register that is the<br />
measure of success.<br />
Helmut O. Paidasch is a principal for HOP<br />
Illuminations & Associates, PYT LTD, Beecroft,<br />
Australia.
Circle 100 on Reader Service Card.<br />
elliptipar now offers very low profile<br />
compact luminaires in one- and<br />
two-lamp styles for lighting vertical<br />
surfaces, and a three-lamp style to<br />
add uplighting. Features include<br />
LIGHT<br />
PRODUCTS<br />
adjustable aiming; radial vertical<br />
blade baffle for 25 degree lengthwise<br />
shielding; integral electronic<br />
ballast (dimming and emergency<br />
optional); all aluminum and stainless<br />
steel construction and continuous<br />
rows with through wiring and<br />
quick connectors. The precise optical<br />
control of the T5 or T5HO fluorescent<br />
lamp in elliptipar’s high performance<br />
asymmetric reflector projects<br />
maximum peak candlepower<br />
down a vertical plane with exceptional<br />
uniformity.<br />
and top of the luminaires are made<br />
from an exclusive New Metal Crafts<br />
pattern. A four-leaf cup holds the<br />
lamps, and a crown of bronze leaves<br />
complete the design. The luminaire<br />
measures 44 in. in diameter (less<br />
lamps) x 38 in.<br />
Circle 98 on Reader Service Card.<br />
The new HIR XL Ultra Life PAR<br />
lamp from General Electric Company<br />
lasts three times (6,000<br />
hours) longer than standard halogen<br />
PAR, says the company. The product<br />
provides excellent color rendering<br />
and beam control in virtually alllighting<br />
applications. The HIR XL<br />
Ultra Life PAR is available in three<br />
wattages — 45, 55 and 90 — as<br />
well as 12 degree and 40 degree<br />
beam spreads.<br />
d’ac now offers ADA compliant<br />
wall sconces and ceiling luminaires<br />
through its Portholes and<br />
Crossroads line. Both styles share<br />
a bold, circular design with architectural<br />
detailing. A 16 in. diameter<br />
trim ring and 13 in. diameter<br />
lens protrude from each mounting<br />
surface a mere 4 in., creating<br />
visually striking, geometric design<br />
continuity in a fresh, contemporary<br />
aesthetic.<br />
Circle 96 on Reader Service Card.<br />
Kichler’s new luminaire is a resin<br />
frog figure holding a lite copper<br />
umbrella. In addition, the company<br />
offers a complementary standalone<br />
copper umbrella. Standing 23<br />
in. tall, the luminaire will develop its<br />
own natural patina over time and is<br />
supplied with a long-life Krypton<br />
18.5 W lamp.<br />
Circle 99 on Reader Service Card.<br />
Based on an early electric design,<br />
circa the 1900s, New Metal Crafts<br />
now offers a custom designed commercial<br />
metal luminaire chandelier.<br />
Finished in antique bronze, the<br />
chandelier features a center of<br />
hand-formed decorative acanthus<br />
leaves. Fronds of leaves reach out<br />
to a metal ring that holds 16 lamps,<br />
separated by decorative rosettes.<br />
Also, cast iron finials at the bottom<br />
Circle 97 on Reader Service Card.<br />
To better provide softly diffused<br />
ambient interior lighting in a contemporary,<br />
geometric design aesthetic<br />
for a range of commercial<br />
and upscale residential corridors,<br />
Circle 95 on Reader Service Card.<br />
Bartco Lighting introduced its new<br />
Slide by Side adjustable staggered<br />
low-profile luminaire. The design,<br />
an original of Bartco Lighting, is a<br />
two-lamp linear luminaire that can<br />
be adjusted to varied spaces and<br />
still provide a continuous glow. The<br />
T5 comes with a high output ballast<br />
option, while the T8 is available<br />
with a high output, emergency or<br />
dimming ballast. Both T5 and T8 linear<br />
fluorescent lamps are available<br />
in 120 or 277 V.<br />
82 LD+A/May 2001 www.iesna.org
shallow reflector to accent any<br />
urban boulevard, town square, commercial<br />
shopping district, park or<br />
college campus.<br />
Circle 91 on Reader Service Card.<br />
Circle 94 on Reader Service Card.<br />
Ledalite’s new Steelform family of<br />
steel linear lighting systems includes<br />
the Soleo, Venza and InCove<br />
product series, each with a range of<br />
T8 and T5HO fluorescent lamp<br />
options. Color choices for Soleo and<br />
Venza series include white and a<br />
natural steel color finish that<br />
comes with translucent end caps in<br />
seven different colors.<br />
Holophane now offers Lyon Series<br />
luminaires in new detailed literature.<br />
The luminaires are offered<br />
with IES Type II/4 way, Type III<br />
(asymmetric), Type IV (asymmetric),<br />
and Type V (symmetric) photometric<br />
light distributions for outstanding<br />
performance in any application.<br />
Designers may choose from<br />
high-pressure sodium, metal halide<br />
and mercury vapor lamps. Wattages<br />
range from 35 to 175. The<br />
Lyon series luminaires feature a<br />
Circle 90 on Reader Service Card.<br />
Infinity Lighting, Inc. introduces its<br />
new XO15 luminaire. The XO15<br />
provides a variety of lamp options in<br />
an all aluminium-extruded housing.<br />
It can be used for general application<br />
or as an architectural solution.<br />
The XO15 is offered in both octagonal<br />
and square shapes, and can<br />
house incandescent, HID, fluorescent<br />
and ICETRON lamps.<br />
Lithonia Lighting has introduced<br />
the Sculpture Series<br />
surfaced mounted fluorescent<br />
luminaires. Providing<br />
both direct and indirect<br />
Circle 93 on Reader Service Card. lighting, the new fixtures<br />
are appropriate for residential<br />
use, as well as for lighting commercial environments. The<br />
Sculpture Series features a distinctive frame in a choice of three<br />
low-profile designs. All are equipped with three 40 W compact fluorescent<br />
lamps and quiet, energy-efficient electronic ballasts.<br />
Circle 92 on Reader Service Card.<br />
Focal Point, LLC has announced the U.S. introduction of Smile, an<br />
indirect/direct luminaire design imported from Regent Beleuchtungskörper<br />
AG. Smile’s angular wings with reeded acrylic satin<br />
diffusers dispense soft, even indirect/direct illumination across<br />
ceilings and walls and into the workplace, contributing to user<br />
comfort, while adding highlight and definition to people and<br />
objects below. Ceiling-suspended and wall-mounted luminaires<br />
may be combined for design integration throughout a facility. Wallmounted<br />
variations are available in 2 ft and 4 ft lengths and have<br />
a high-quality extruded aluminum channel with matte-anodized finish<br />
for color-neutral integration in interior architecture.<br />
www.iesna.org