Our Children Our Future Our Vision - People for Education
Our Children Our Future Our Vision - People for Education
Our Children Our Future Our Vision - People for Education
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Our</strong> <strong>Children</strong>, <strong>Our</strong> <strong>Future</strong>, <strong>Our</strong> <strong>Vision</strong><br />
the exclusion of First Nations citizens who live off-reserve or who lack Indian registration from accessing<br />
critical First Nation schools or programs. 186 Funding levels and lack of support <strong>for</strong> training<br />
and ongoing development remain significant barriers to realizing full jurisdiction. 187<br />
Canada assumes jurisdiction over First Nation education through sections 114 to 122 of the Indian<br />
Act. 188 Some have argued that this legislative power brings with it a fiduciary obligation which<br />
requires Canada to act in the best interests of First Nations. 189 Simple revisions to the Indian Act<br />
are not acceptable means of ending paternalistic control over our education systems. Federal control<br />
over education has already been acknowledged to be an abysmal failure of epic proportions.<br />
There<strong>for</strong>e, the solution does not lie in Canada tinkering with the Indian Act or some other federal<br />
legislation to control our communities. No government will ever care about our children, our communities<br />
and our futures more than we do.<br />
First Nations jurisdiction is protected in several key ways. First of all, First Nations have an inherent<br />
right to be self-determining, which of course includes the right to control their own education<br />
systems. This right has not only been recognized in the federal Inherent Right Policy, which states<br />
that the inherent right to be self-governing is protected as an Aboriginal right in section 35 of the<br />
Constitution Act, 1982, but is also protected by UNDRIP. The right to education is further protected<br />
in our treaties which are also constitutionally and internationally protected.<br />
Even more than being a right that is specific to Indigenous peoples, the right to an education is a<br />
basic human right of all peoples. 190 Not only does education add meaning and value to one’s life<br />
but it also unlocks other key human rights like good health, security, economic well-being and<br />
participation in social and political life. 191 There<strong>for</strong>e, the denial of an education to First Nations<br />
through discriminatory laws and policies, inadequate funding <strong>for</strong>mulas, or by federal neglect and<br />
inaction is a violation of our fundamental human rights.<br />
While the federal and provincial governments rely on the Constitution Act, 1867 to point to their<br />
jurisdictional powers over education and Indians, they <strong>for</strong>get that our inherent right to be selfdetermining<br />
also encompasses education, and this is now protected in s.35 of the Constitution Act,<br />
1982. Canada simply cannot pick and choose which constitutional provisions will have legal effect<br />
and which will not. 192 So long as the educational authority or power is a delegated one, the govern-<br />
186 Ibid. at 16.<br />
187 First Nations <strong>Education</strong>al Jurisdiction, supra note 181 at 22.<br />
188 Indian Act, R.S.C. 1985 c. I-5 [Indian Act].<br />
189 If Not Now, Then When, supra note 1 at 17-21.<br />
190 Universal Declaration on Human Rights. online: at Article 26: “…elementary<br />
education shall be free and compulsory, and that higher levels will be equally available to all on the basis of<br />
merit.”<br />
191 Investing in the <strong>Future</strong>, supra note 175 at 17-18.<br />
192 M. Battiste, “Constitutional Reconciliation of <strong>Education</strong> <strong>for</strong> Aboriginal <strong>People</strong>s” (2009), online: AFN <br />
[Constitutional Reconciliation] at 3-5.<br />
Chiefs of Ontario<br />
46