Our Children Our Future Our Vision - People for Education
Our Children Our Future Our Vision - People for Education
Our Children Our Future Our Vision - People for Education
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Our</strong> <strong>Children</strong>, <strong>Our</strong> <strong>Future</strong>, <strong>Our</strong> <strong>Vision</strong><br />
(b) Adequate Funding<br />
“Program/resource funding is a joke – why shouldn’t our kids have<br />
same access to up to date curriculum/material as not native?”<br />
(University student)<br />
There is no doubt that many First Nations schools struggle to deliver programs and services because<br />
of the lack of sufficient funding and support frameworks. 201 Schools on reserves are clearly<br />
funded at per-student levels far below what most provinces pay to support their schools, despite<br />
the fact that needs and costs on reserve are significantly higher. 202 Funding <strong>for</strong>mulas also do not<br />
take into account regional differences in costs, salaries, construction or purchasing. 203 The average<br />
cost per student has increased 24% since 1997 which is much higher than the inflation rate or the<br />
2% funding cap on spending imposed by Canada since 1996. 204<br />
Gray and Beres<strong>for</strong>d argue that both Canada and the United States have embarked on ef<strong>for</strong>ts to<br />
make room <strong>for</strong> Indigenous control over their own education systems, but this “has proved more<br />
illusionary than real” because of restricted funding <strong>for</strong>mulas. 205 Despite years of studies and<br />
discussions and national panels, funding <strong>for</strong> the implementation of First Nation jurisdiction over<br />
education seems to be the most difficult barrier to overcome. 206 Funding is needed not just <strong>for</strong> the<br />
students, but also <strong>for</strong> infrastructure, development of language and culture curriculum, and <strong>for</strong><br />
general governance like policy development, training and oversight. 207<br />
The level to which First Nations education and programs are underfunded is shocking. Some<br />
estimates have placed band-operated schools at as much as 75% lower than provincial<br />
standards. 208 Yet, there is no excuse to under-fund First Nations education in a country which is<br />
recording record surplus budgets of over $14 billion. 209 The AFN has consistently identified funding<br />
<strong>for</strong> governance capacity and training is absolutely essential in any solution moving <strong>for</strong>ward. 210<br />
It is not enough <strong>for</strong> Canada to apologize <strong>for</strong> the assimilatory policies upon which residential<br />
201 Simon Management Services, “A Study of <strong>Education</strong>al Cost Drivers to First Nation <strong>Education</strong>: Final Report” (Ottawa:<br />
Report <strong>for</strong> the Joint AFN.INAC BOFF Working Group, 2006) [<strong>Education</strong>al Cost Drivers] at 6.<br />
202 B. Levin, “Aboriginal education still needs work” (2009) 90:9 Phi Delta Kappan 689 at 690.<br />
203 First Nations <strong>Education</strong> Council, “Supporting a Comprehensive and Equitable Funding Framework” (2009), online:<br />
at 11.<br />
204 Ibid.<br />
205 J. Gray, Q. Beres<strong>for</strong>d, “A ‘<strong>for</strong>midable challenge’: Australia’s quest <strong>for</strong> equity in indigenous education” (2008) 52:2<br />
Aus. J. Ed. 197-223.<br />
206 H. McCue, “First Nations 2 nd and 3 rd Level <strong>Education</strong> Services: A Discussion Paper <strong>for</strong> the Joint Working Group INAC-<br />
AFN” (Ottawa: Harvey McCue Consulting, 2006) at 5.<br />
207 Ibid. at 7.<br />
208 K. Reimer, “What other Canadian kids have: The fight <strong>for</strong> a new school in Attawapiskat” (2010) Native Studies Review<br />
120 [What other Canadians have] at 133.<br />
209 Ibid. at 132. See also: <strong>Our</strong> Dreams Matter Too, supra note 85.<br />
210 Investing in the <strong>Future</strong>, supra note 175 at 3.<br />
Chiefs of Ontario<br />
48