Canada (Attorney General) v. Bedford, 2012 ONCA ... - York University

Page: 5(3) Is the living on the avails provision arbitrary? ......................................... 98(4) Is the living on the avails provision overbroad? ...................................... 99(5) Is the living on the avails provision grossly disproportionate? .............. 103(6) Is the living on the avails provision a reasonable limit under s. 1 of theCharter? ......................................................................................................... 104(7) What is the appropriate remedy to address the s. 7 breach? ............... 104Does the prohibition against communicating for the purpose of prostitutionviolate the principles of fundamental justice? ................................................ 111(1) Legislative history and judicial interpretation ..................................... 112(2) Objectives of the communicating provision ....................................... 113(3) Is the communicating provision arbitrary? ........................................ 115(4) Is the communicating provision overbroad? ..................................... 117(5) Is the communicating provision grossly disproportionate? ............... 118(a) The application judge under-emphasized the importance of thelegislative objective of the communicating provision ............................... 122(b)The application judge over-emphasized the impact of thecommunicating provision on the respondents‟ security of the person..... 124CONCLUSION .................................................................................................. 131MacPherson J.A. (Dissenting in part): ............................................................... 133