City of Burnside Development Assessment Panel Minutes Held ...

Development Assessment Panel Minutes 2 April 2002Mr HF Le Messurier - Report No. PR 5450.2Development Application No: 180/147/02/C1Location: 134 Penfold Road, Wattle ParkProposal: Tree removal (1)P4025Councillor Gilbert moved that it be a recommendation to Council thatDevelopment Application No: 180/147/02 by Mr HF LeMessurier be refuseddevelopment approval and that the reasons for refusal are:That the tree forms a notable visual element to the landscape of the local area,andThe retaining wall is not considered to be a significant building or structure ofvalue.Seconded by Councillor HillierLost. A Division was called.ForCr HillierCr PalkCr GilbertCr BillsAgainstCr O’BrienCr CromptonCr CollinsCr MelickHer Worship the MayorThe Motion wasLOSTP4026Councillor Melick that it be a recommendation to Council that DevelopmentApplication No. 180/147/02/C1, by Mr HF Le Messurier be granted DevelopmentApproval subject to the following condition:1. That two (2) evergreen trees, Grey Box (Eucalyptus microcarpa) of at least1 metre in height at time of planting, be planted in the front of the propertywithin three (3) months of the date of approval.Seconded by Councillor O'BrienCARRIEDS:\Agendas and Minutes\Development Assessment Panel\Minutes\2002\dap042002minuteswebsite.doc 4