TPA-PPN-Full-with-gl..

Project Professional Notes27Additional Saliva Issues:1. Does one have to use dirt to clean a utensil after it has come in contact with dog saliva?First Opinion: A narration of Imaam AshShaafi‘ee and a narration of Imaam Ahmedboth state that it is not permissible to clean the utensil except with dirt.Proofs used by the Scholars:1. Narrated Abu Huraira : Allah's Apostle said, “If a dog drinks from your utensil(container), pour it out and wash it seven times using soil the first time or last time”(atTirmidhi).2. Narrated Abu Huraira : Allah's Apostle said, “The cleansing of a utensilbelonging to one of you, is to wash it seven times, using soil for cleaning the first time”(Muslim).Second Opinion: A narration of Imaam AshShaafi‘ee and a narration of ImaamAhmed states that it is permissible to use anything as long as it cleans/purifies it (i.e. soap).Proofs used by the Scholars:1. The purpose of washing is to clean the Najasa off.Third Opinion: A narration of Imaam AshShaafi‘ee states that if you have dirt, thenyou have to use dirt. If dirt is not available, then you can use anything else that cleans it. Shaykh Abdulbary told us a story about a woman who washed saliva of dogwith soap and with dirt. She found that dirt removed all the bacteria but with soap, someremnants were still left over. She converted to Islam because she considered it impossiblethat 1400 years ago, such information could be known without a Divine source.2. Does one have to wash a utensil seven times after it has come in contact with dog saliva?First Opinion: The majority of the scholars state that one has to wash utensils that comeinto contact with dog saliva seven times. Imam AshShaafi‘ee said that the same ruling ofwashing seven times for dog’s saliva applies to pigs also. With clothing, one doesn’t haveto wash it seven times if it comes into contact with dog saliva because the hadithspecifically mentioned utensils.Proofs used by the Scholars:1. Narrated Abu Huraira : Allah's Apostle said, “If a dog drinks from your utensil