TPA-PPN-Full-with-gl..

Project Professional Notes41NOTES:• Notice that in the first opinion, a reference is made to “Imaam Ahmed’s narration” and in the third opinion,reference is made to the “stronger narration of Ahmad.” Shaykh Yayha did not say that it was ImaamAhmad’s Mathab but his ‘narration’. The reason for this distinction is as follows:(1) His students always differed among themselves more than any other students from the othermathaahib.(2) Imaam Ahmad is the last of the four Imaams. If so, then why were his students confused andopinionated? His students never wrote what he said because he forbade them from doing so. Thiswas because he did not want people to concentrate just on his opinions only but on the Qur’an andSunnah. This then led to different opinions, some that were narrations while others were ‘stronger’narrations.• The majority of scholars, in the third opinion looked at all the ahadeeth. They concluded that if you areoutside or inside, there will always be mountains, buildings, hotels, and walls between you and the Qiblah.Therefore, it is permissible.واالله أعلم