13.07.2015 Views

A Glossary of Constitutional Terms: English / Nepali

A Glossary of Constitutional Terms: English / Nepali

A Glossary of Constitutional Terms: English / Nepali

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

prosecuted'! That suggests that the perpetrators have a duty to beprosecuted. That sign should actually say, 'They will be prosecuted'.The importance <strong>of</strong> words like 'shall' can also be illustrated by thisstory about the Kenyan Constitution. The Kenyan ConstituentAssembly members, charged with drafting a new Constitution,had the difference between 'shall' and 'may' drilled into them bylegal advisers but rejected 'must' as not being legal enough. Havingaccepted that 'may' implies that someone has a choice, they wouldnot accept 'no person may' (which means that no one has anyoption to; in other words, they must not) and insisted on 'no personshall.'What is a translator working on the new <strong>Nepali</strong> Constitutionto do about 'shall'? It is not for the translator to make decisionsabout the legal meaning <strong>of</strong> something. There being no distinctionin <strong>Nepali</strong> similar to that between 'the government will' and 'thegovernment shall' in <strong>English</strong>, it would be best to use whatever hasbecome customary in <strong>Nepali</strong> legal language to reflect 'shall' whenthat is found in <strong>English</strong>. 'May' should be translated by a word thatindicates a choice or discretion.Other examples <strong>of</strong> slightly—but perhaps importantly—differentphrases are:In consultation with;After consultation with;On the recommendation <strong>of</strong>;With, and in accordance with, the advice, as in 'The head <strong>of</strong>state shall act only with, and in accordance with, the advice<strong>of</strong> the National Executive Council' (from the Papua NewGuinea Constitution again).VIIA <strong>Glossary</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Constitutional</strong> <strong>Terms</strong>

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!