■Third-Party Imagespage (e.g., quarter page), or in inches (e.g., 5" × 4"), or in pixels(e.g., 2,000 × 3,500 pixels). Be sure that any size limitationencompasses <strong>the</strong> maximum size your use might require.Medium. The medium you will use to distribute your workmakes a difference. Photographers are well aware that digitalis more susceptible to unauthorized harvest and use thanprint, and <strong>the</strong>y charge accordingly.Each vendor can and does imposeits own limitations on use in avariety of forms.Quantity. Be sure that any quantity specified in a licensecomfortably covers at least your first print run (plus anyallowable overage), and be equally sure to go back and getlicense extensions before ordering a subsequent printing.Territory. Specifying world rights will certainly cover you,but it may mean paying for rights you don’t exploit. Determinedifferences in price and make your decision accordingly.Then don’t forget to go back for an extension if it turnsout that you want to exploit an export opportunity.Duration. Many licenses are described as perpetual orunlimited in time, but Rights Managed licenses have finitedurations, and even some Royalty Free licenses have finiteterms (e.g., seven or ten years or more) just to avoid openendedcommitments. Watch for <strong>the</strong>se and arrange forreminders to pop up in sufficient time for you to get an extensionor replace an image.Versions. If a license contains a limitation on versions,make sure <strong>the</strong> limit encompasses <strong>the</strong> maximum numberof design versions and editions, and any ancillary works inwhich <strong>the</strong> image will be used.Language. Look for limitations on <strong>the</strong> language of <strong>the</strong> textin <strong>the</strong> work that will include <strong>the</strong> image, and think not justabout <strong>the</strong> book’s language but also about <strong>the</strong> language(s) onWebsites that may feature it.Exclusivity. The meaning of nonexclusive is pretty straightforwardbut exclusive can be defined by any number of metrics. Makesure any exclusivity is clearly and unambiguously described.The way a license expresses limitations is critical. If you see aterm that is unfamiliar to you, consult <strong>the</strong> Picture LicensingUniversal System (PLUS) terminology glossary, developedby a coalition of associations representing photographersand o<strong>the</strong>r affected constituencies (useplus.com/useplus/glossary.asp). And when in doubt, add your own definitionsomewhere in <strong>the</strong> purchase documents.Limitation LocationsIt would be terrific if you could find limitations on yourlicense rights in just one place, but <strong>the</strong> terms of <strong>the</strong> deal areoften widely dispersed.Terms may appear in a pretransaction document that mightbe provided as a print or online form called a bid, a quote, anestimate, an assignment confirmation, or <strong>the</strong> like. Althoughsuch a document, in and of itself, is merely an invitation tonegotiate and not a binding contract, your acceptance of<strong>the</strong> offer—ei<strong>the</strong>r by issuing a purchase order or simply bymaking payment—will have <strong>the</strong> effect of incorporating <strong>the</strong>proposed terms, as well as any terms contained in any set of“Standard Terms” (or “Terms and Conditions”) attached to<strong>the</strong> offer document. (For some tips on how to counter <strong>the</strong>seone-sided terms, see “Add Power to Your Purchase OrderForm: A New Year’s Resolution Worth Keeping,” in <strong>the</strong> January2011 Independent.)Terms may appear in a formal license document. Especiallyif your transaction is effected online, you will probably beasked to click your assent to one of those documents as a partof completing your purchase. Don’t do this until you haveclosely examined <strong>the</strong> terms of that license that just flashed by.A photographer or stock agencymay elect to recover <strong>the</strong> profitsyou made from unauthorized useor <strong>the</strong> profits <strong>the</strong>y lost.And sometimes terms first appear in a post-transaction document,such as a delivery memo, change order, or invoice.Although you can’t be forced to accept <strong>the</strong>se terms if <strong>the</strong>y werenot disclosed prior to your commitment, you will likely haveassented to those after-<strong>the</strong>-fact restrictions if you pay <strong>the</strong> invoicewithout examining it and making or arranging for changes.Punishment PossibilitiesWhat happens if, despite your best intentions, a restriction8 | IBPA Independent | February 2013
Third-Party Images■escapes your notice and your lapse is detected by <strong>the</strong> photographeror stock agency? Well, about <strong>the</strong> best you can expectis that you will be deemed in breach of your contractual commitmentand held to account for what you should have paidfor <strong>the</strong> uses you actually made.“Nonexclusive” is prettystraightforward, but “exclusive”can be defined by any numberof metrics.More likely, <strong>the</strong> licensor will claim that you made an unauthorizedand infringing use of a copyrighted work outside<strong>the</strong> scope of any license you had. In this event, <strong>the</strong> copyrightowner has some very potent strategic advantages and remedies.You may have to:Pay actual damages. A photographer or stock agencymay elect to recover <strong>the</strong> profits you made from <strong>the</strong> unauthorizeduse or <strong>the</strong> profits <strong>the</strong>y lost because of your failure to takeand pay for a license.Pay statutory damages. In lieu of actual damages, aphotographer or stock agency may elect to ask <strong>the</strong> court foran award of statutory damages of up to $30,000 per workinfringed where <strong>the</strong> infringement was not willful and up to$150,000 per work infringed in cases of willful infringement.Pay <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>r side’s attorneys’ fees and costs. Ontop of actual or statutory damages, a photographer or stockagency may ask <strong>the</strong> court to award reimbursement of <strong>the</strong>irattorneys’ fees and costs (which can be quite substantial—a lawyers’ professional association reports that in 2010 <strong>the</strong>national average cost to try a small copyright infringementcase was $350,000).Obey an injunction. Plaintiffs may also ask <strong>the</strong> court toprovide injunctive relief by ordering you to stop <strong>the</strong> infringinguse and to surrender all infringing inventory and reproductivematerials for destruction.Bear indemnification obligations. Since copyrightinfringement is a “no-fault” offense that reaches virtuallyevery party who participates in <strong>the</strong> reproduction, distribution,adaptation, or public display of an infringing work,your printer and/or your ISP may be named as additionaldefendants, increasing your cost and exposure. (See “Printers’Terms: What <strong>the</strong> Boilerplate Means and <strong>Where</strong> There’sWiggle Room,” in <strong>the</strong> March 2011 Independent.)Bottom-line GuidanceIt’s said that you get what you pay for. When it comes to photography,that doesn’t necessarily mean that low price equalslow quality. Instead, a low price for reproducing a photographprobably means sharply limited rights. So look for agood price, but focus hard on <strong>the</strong> license terms, and makecertain <strong>the</strong>y cover what you need to avoid ending up in adamaging fight over photos. ■We cover all your needs from start to finish!Steve Gillen is a lawyer and partner in <strong>the</strong> intellectual property firm of Wood Herron & Evansand has focused his practice on publishing and media matters for 30 years. He is a memberof IBPA and a frequent contributor to <strong>the</strong> Independent. To reach him: sgillen@whe-law.com;513/241-2324, ext. 470.We cover your needsfrom start to finishRose IBPA ad.pdf 7/24/11 3:19:46 PMFrom 5 to 50,0001-Color to 4-ColorBook ProductionWeb • Sheetfed • Digital1-800-227-3725www.roseprinting.comIf There's a Book in Your Head...It's Time to Getit in Your Hands.Toll Free 1-877-705-9647Undergo a takedown. If your infringement is online, <strong>the</strong>photographer or stock agency may serve a takedown demandon your service provider, which will likely result in some orall of your Web site being disabled.Visit <strong>the</strong> IBPA Website at www.ibpa-online.org | 9