STOP
1PeMYu1
1PeMYu1
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
98 • Fifty Shades of Tax Dodging<br />
United Kingdom<br />
“While we want a tax system that is competitive for business, we also want a tax system where businesses pay their taxes.”<br />
David Gauke, Financial Secretary to the Treasury 1128<br />
Overview<br />
Tax has often dominated both the political and media<br />
agenda in recent years, and 2015 was no exception. This is<br />
perhaps not surprising since the UK occupies such a central<br />
location in international finance, through both the role of<br />
the City of London, and the Overseas Territories and Crown<br />
Dependencies that are constitutionally linked to the UK.<br />
In 2015 a range of issues were in the spotlight including;<br />
LuxLeaks, HSBC, Non-Dom status, the Diverted Profits Tax<br />
and devolving taxing rights to Scotland and Northern Ireland.<br />
Many more tax issues featured in the May 2015 General<br />
Election campaign, where tax was one of the big issues,<br />
helped by the Tax Dodging Bill campaign, which saw over<br />
80,000 people and over 20 NGOs and unions call on all<br />
parties to show a commitment to improving tax policy. 1129<br />
Polling continued to show public dissatisfaction with tax<br />
policy, with 85% thinking the election commitments on<br />
tax avoidance did not go far enough. 1130 While publicly all<br />
the focus was on domestic tax issues, all the main parties<br />
included specific commitments on ensuring tax policies<br />
deliver results in developing countries, a significant change<br />
from the previous elections in 2010. 1131 And while the UK<br />
was one of the countries blocking the creation of a UN tax<br />
body at the Financing for Development Conference in Addis<br />
Ababa, the development impact of tax does remain higher<br />
on the political agenda in the UK than in many EU Member<br />
States. The new Conservative Government created their<br />
own headlines with their July budget committing to cut<br />
corporation tax to 18% by 2020 and to new restrictions on<br />
those claiming to be non-domiciled for tax purposes – the<br />
so-called ‘non-doms’. 1132<br />
Tax policies<br />
The UK Government has continued to pursue what can at<br />
times appear to be a Janus-faced approach. On the one<br />
hand promising an increasingly intolerant approach to tax<br />
evasion and avoidance, and claiming to lead international<br />
cooperation. On the other hand, promising to ensure that the<br />
UK is the most competitive tax regime in the G20 through<br />
reductions in headline rates and supporting incentives such<br />
as the patent box regime. The UK’s aggressive participation<br />
in global tax competition has caused some controversy,<br />
with a professional tax advisor warning that the UK “upsets<br />
governments in the EU and the US who see the UK becoming<br />
a tax haven in relative terms.” 1133<br />
The most eye-catching policy from the UK in 2015 was<br />
perhaps the Diverted Profits Tax (DPT), or the ‘Google Tax’<br />
as it has been dubbed by many. This tax became effective<br />
from April 2015 and imposes a 25% charge on profits that<br />
are deemed to have been ‘diverted’ away from the UK by the<br />
use of contrived arrangements (e.g. through avoiding a UK<br />
taxable presence). 1134 Following the UK’s announcement,<br />
Australia has introduced its own version of the DPT, with<br />
other counties considering similar moves; 1135 there is also<br />
speculation that the DPT may have influenced Amazon’s<br />
decision to alter its structure in the EU. 1136<br />
While this was portrayed as an example of the UK<br />
Government taking tough action against tax avoidance,<br />
questions still remain on the influence of corporations on UK<br />
Government tax policy. A leading tax lawyer, who advised the<br />
Government on the Google Tax, publicly stated that, ”I don’t<br />
think in the last 20 years or so one can say that governments<br />
have driven corporation tax policy. It’s the large companies<br />
that have driven the direction of corporate tax policy.” 1137<br />
Beyond the DPT, most of the changes in tax policy have<br />
centred on either preparing the ground for the OECD’s Base<br />
Erosion and Profit Sharing (BEPS) proposals, or for further<br />
devolution of taxing powers to the nations of the United<br />
Kingdom. 1138