Humane-Slaughter-Guidelines

let as it leaves the end of the barrel when the firearm
is discharged. Muzzle energy is frequently used as an
indicator of a bullet’s destructive potential. The heavier
the bullet and the greater its velocity, the higher its
muzzle energy and capacity for destruction of objects
in its path.
Muzzle energy (E) can be expressed as the mass of
the bullet (M) times its velocity (V) squared, divided by
2. 83 However, to accommodate units of measure commonly
used in the United States for civilian firearms,
energy (E) is expressed in foot-pounds. This is calculated
by multiplication of the bullet’s weight (W) times
its velocity in feet per second (V) squared, divided by
450,450. The International System of Units expresses
muzzle energy in joules after the English physicist
James Prescott Joule (1818 to 1889).
Representative ballistics data for various types of
firearms are provided in Table 2. The muzzle energy
of commercially available ammunition varies greatly.
For example, the difference in muzzle energy generated
from a .357 magnum handgun loaded with a 180
grain compared with a 110 grain bullet may differ by as
much as 180 foot-pounds. 83 Velocity has an even greater
impact on bullet energy than bullet mass. Selection
of an appropriate bullet and firearm is critical to good
performance when conducting euthanasia procedures.
Lighter-weight, higher-velocity bullets can have high
muzzle energy, but decreased penetration, which can
be an issue when penetrating thick bones.
Whereas most slaughter using firearms is conducted
at close range, calculations of muzzle energy are useful
for determining which firearms are appropriate for
slaughter of animals of varying sizes. As the bullet travels
beyond the muzzle of the firearm, its energy gradually
begins to decrease. While this is not a concern for
the use of firearms in close proximity to the animal,
when attempting to shoot an animal from a distance, to
ensure accuracy and that an acceptable level of muzzle
energy is achieved, a high-powered rifle may be the better
choice for rendering an animal unconscious. In all
cases, the most important factors in ensuring a successful
shot are the experience and skill of the shooter.
Muzzle energy requirements
Muzzle energy required to render animals up to
400 lb (180 kg) unconscious is a minimum of 300 ft-lb
(407 J). For animals larger than 400 lb, firearms capable
of yielding muzzle energies of 1,000 ft-lb (1,356 J) are
required for satisfactory results. 62
As demonstrated by Table 2, handguns do not
typically achieve the muzzle energy required to euthanize
animals weighing more than 400 lb (180 kg), and
therefore rifles must be used to render these animals
unconscious.
Some would argue that the muzzle energies recommended
are well beyond what is necessary to achieve
satisfactory results. Anecdotal comment suggests that
the .22 LR is one of the most frequently used firearms
to shoot livestock with varying degrees of success. Additionally,
a Canadian study 84 found .22 LR standardvelocity
and .22 LR high-velocity bullets failed to yield
adequate penetration of the skull. 84 There is little doubt
that success or failure is partially related to firearm and
Table 2—Average muzzle energies for common hand guns and
rifles. (Adapted from USDA, 2004, National Animal Health Emergency
Management System Guidelines, USDA, Washington, DC.
Available at: www.dem.ri.gov/topics/erp/nahems_euthanasia.pdf
[Accessed Aug 27, 2009] and cited by Woods J, Shearer JK, Hill
J. Recommended on-farm euthanasia practices. In: Grandin T, ed.
Improving animal welfare: a practical approach. Wallingford, Oxfordshire,
England: CABI Publishing, 2010;194–195.)
Muzzle energy
Cartridge/firearm In foot-pounds In joules
Handguns
.40 Smith and Wesson 408 553
.45 Automatic Colt Pistol 411 557
.357 Magnum 557 755
.41 Remington Magnum 607 823
10-mm Automatic 649 880
.44 Remington Magnum 729 988
Rifles
.22 Long Rifle Rim Fire 117 159
.223 Remington 1,296 1,757
30-30 Winchester 1,902 2,579
.308 2,648 3,590
30-06 Springfield 2,841 3,852
bullet characteristics, but probably more so to selection
of the ideal anatomic site (ie, a site more likely to affect
the brainstem) for conducting the procedure. The
Humane Slaughter Association lists multiple firearms
for humane slaughter of livestock, including shotguns
(12, 16, 20, 28 and .410 gauges), handguns (.32 to .45
caliber), and rifles (.22, .243, .270, and .308). In general,
when comparing handguns with rifles, the longer
the barrel, the higher the muzzle velocity. Therefore, if
a .22 is used for humane slaughter, it is best fired from a
rifle. The .22 should never be used on aged bulls, boars,
or rams. 85
To improve safety and reduce dangerous ricochet
of bullets that either pass through the animal’s head or
miss the animal, many plant managers prefer the .22 LR
despite its low muzzle energy and inability to yield adequate
penetration of the skull. Some may prefer to use
a pistol because it can be held closer to the head and
many people find it easier to aim. Pistols must be larger
than a .22. There are two main differences between use
of a firearm in a slaughter plant and its use for on-farm
euthanasia. In a slaughter plant, gunshot is followed by
exsanguination, so it is not the sole agent used to cause
death. Another difference is an animal in a slaughter
plant is shot at a close range of 1 to 2 ft. (0.3 to 0.6
m). When slaughter is done in less controlled situations
out on the farm, a firearm larger than a .22 LR is
recommended. It is essential to aim the shot correctly
so that the brain is penetrated. If an animal is injured
and is not rendered unconscious with a single shot, it
is sometimes much more difficult to kill thereafter. The
nervous system may go into a state of arousal, and multiple
shots may fail. In one case, a a gilt was shot multiple
times with a captive bolt and firearm before it was
rendered unconscious. 86
Bullet selection
Bullet selection is quite possibly the most important
consideration for slaughter of livestock by gunshot.
There are three basic types of bullets pertinent
to this discussion: solid points, hollow points, and
30 AVMA Guidelines for the Humane Slaughter of Animals: 2016 Edition