01.06.2017 Views

JEP fin

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ous - -and wholly unnecessary -- use of the mercury-based preservative thimerosal in vaccines<br />

being given to millions of children and pregnant women here and around the world.” Since he<br />

did not state that thimerosal causes autism in this introduction, it would be fair to say that his role<br />

on the vaccine panel would be for the good of the people and their safety. But, later on he goes<br />

to say that “Thompson, who is still employed at CDC, says that for the past decade his superiors<br />

have pressured him and his fellow scientists to lie and manipulate data about the safety of the<br />

mercury-based preservative thimerosal to conceal its causative link to a suite of brain injuries,<br />

including autism.” Even after this he says that the “best science suggests that thimerosal’s complete<br />

removal from vaccines is likely to prompt a significant decline in autism.” This is what<br />

raises concerns about what effect Kennedy could have if the panel were created under the Trump<br />

administration.<br />

This source is helpful and will be used to look at what the Trump administration is possibly<br />

doing and what that means for the public. It is also helpful as it looks at what Andrew Wakefield<br />

is doing, and the role that he could possibly play in shaping the vaccine debate for a second<br />

time. We also get to see what role Robert Kennedy could play in this debate if he were indeed to<br />

chair a new federal panel on vaccine safety which would be about a dozen people, seeing as he<br />

is a vaccine skeptic, that would raise public concern. If this subject were to advance more, it is<br />

possible that I could follow up and look at, in depth, what the panel would do and the effect on<br />

vaccines it would have.<br />

Schuchat, Anne. “Science Summary: CDC Studies on Thimerosal in Vaccines.” Center for Disease Control and<br />

Prevention. Accessed 14 Mar. 2017.<br />

In this source from CDC that is a summary of the studies on thimerosal in vaccines. This is a<br />

compilation of nine studies that each, in some way, show that thimerosal is non toxic in vaccines<br />

and is instead just a preservative that has been used for decades to prevent contamination. They<br />

look at thimerosal exposure in the womb, infancy, early life, and longtime exposure, as well as<br />

the effects within children’s flu shots, neurodevelopmental disorders, certain health outcomes,<br />

and the outcomes with and without thimerosal. The last case in the table compared the outcomes<br />

with and without thimerosal in 1992 in Denmark and Sweden, when they stopped giving thimerosal<br />

vaccines. In comparison with the autism rates in both countries before removal, they found<br />

an increase in autism rates in the years between 1987 and 1999. If the claim that the vaccines are<br />

the cause of autism were true, then the rates in the study should have gone down, which they did<br />

48 TIME May 31, 2017

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!