MBR JULY ALL
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
MALTA<br />
BUSINESS REVIEW<br />
ISSUE 33 <strong>JULY</strong> 2017<br />
COVER STORY<br />
DRIVING COSTANT GROWTH<br />
<strong>MBR</strong> interviews Felipe Navarro, CEO of<br />
MAPFRE Middlesea about their brand promise<br />
06<br />
10<br />
26<br />
28<br />
CORPORATE INTERVIEW<br />
Accessibility, Affordablity and Excellence<br />
Unique joint interview <strong>MBR</strong> Editor Martin Vella talks with<br />
Melita CEO Harald Rösch and Vodafone Malta CEO Amanda Nelson<br />
7th EU COHESION FORUM<br />
Overcoming economic and political challenges together<br />
Exclusive interview with Günther Oettinger,<br />
European Commissioner for Budget and Human Resources<br />
Regions matter more than ever in a globalised world<br />
Exceptional interview with Michael Storper, Professor of<br />
Economic Geography at the London School of Economics
DRIVING COSTANT GROWTH<br />
<strong>MBR</strong> interviews Felipe Navarro, CEO of<br />
MAPFRE Middlesea about their brand promise<br />
ISSUE 33 <strong>JULY</strong> 2017<br />
CORPORATE INTERVIEW<br />
Accessibility, Affordablity and Excellence<br />
Unique joint interview <strong>MBR</strong> Editor Martin Vella talks with<br />
Melita CEO Harald Rösch and Vodafone Malta CEO Amanda Nelson<br />
7th EU COHESION FORUM<br />
Overcoming economic and political challenges together<br />
Exclusive interview with Günther Oettinger,<br />
European Commissioner for Budget and Human Resources<br />
Regions matter more than ever in a globalised world<br />
Exceptional interview with Michael Storper, Professor of<br />
Economic Geography at the London School of Economics<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
06 COVER STORY<br />
DRIVING CONSTANT GROWTH<br />
Martin Vella speaks to Felipe Navarro, CEO of<br />
MAPFRE Middlesea about their brand promise<br />
10 CORPORATE INTERVIEW OF<br />
THE MONTH<br />
ACCESSIBILITY, AFFORDABLITY AND EXCELLENCE<br />
Unique joint interview <strong>MBR</strong> Editor Martin Vella talks with<br />
Melita CEO Harald Rösch and Vodafone Malta CEO Amanda<br />
Nelson<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE:<br />
MALTA’S BEST ENTREPRENEUR<br />
OF THE YEAR AWARDS 2017<br />
12 E<strong>MBR</strong>ACING CH<strong>ALL</strong>ENGES, RECOGNISING VALUE<br />
Abigail Law, Malta’s Best Innovation in Product & Service<br />
Entrepreneur of theYear 2017, shares her thoughts and<br />
insights on Look Amazing Ltd<br />
20 CONTINUOUS LOOP TO INNOVATE<br />
Interview with David Abela, Managing Director at Eurobridge<br />
Shipping Services Ltd, winner of Malta’s Best International<br />
Trade Entrepreneur of the Year Award<br />
21 DRIVE FOR INNOVATION<br />
Meet Joseph Bigeni, Manager of Il-Logga Boutique Hotel<br />
06<br />
CONTENTS<br />
July 2017<br />
SPECIAL PULL-AND-KEEP<br />
SUPPLEMENT FEATURE:<br />
7th EU COHESION FORUM<br />
25 MY REGION, MY EUROPE, OUR FUTURE<br />
Address by the Hon Prime Minister of Malta Dr. Joseph Muscat<br />
26 OVERCOMING ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL CH<strong>ALL</strong>ENGES<br />
TOGETHER<br />
Exclusive interview with Günther Oettinger, European<br />
Commissioner for Budget and Human Resources<br />
28 REGIONS MATTER MORE THAN EVER IN A GLOBALISED<br />
WORLD<br />
Exceptional interview with Michael Storper, Professor of Economic<br />
Geography at the London School of Economics<br />
30 THE EU’S FUTURE FINANCES<br />
A rare interview with former Italian Prime Minister and EU<br />
Commissioner Mario Monti<br />
32 C<strong>ALL</strong>ING FOR STRENGTHENED COHESION, IMPROVED<br />
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES AND LIVING CONDITIONS<br />
Martin Vella interviews Corina Cretu, EU Commissioner for Regional<br />
Policy<br />
34 STUDENTS REPORT… ON INTERREG PROJECT IN MALTA<br />
A look at the Interreg Annual Meeting held in Malta<br />
BUSINESS INTERVIEWS<br />
44 SERVICE, DELIVERY, PERFORMANCE<br />
<strong>MBR</strong> interviews Brian Darmanin, Technical Director at J2 Group<br />
48 STRUCTURE FOR SUCCESS<br />
Claire Camilleri Gauci, Director at Aid Compliance, tells us just<br />
why keeping updated with regulations is essential for effective<br />
compliance<br />
FEATURE STORIES<br />
52 BOOST YOUR STRATEGIC THINKING<br />
Robin Cleland tells us why organisations should more<br />
customer-centric and data-driven in their approach digital<br />
53 INTERNATIONALISATION & MILITARIZATION: CHINA<br />
VS EU, WHO IS RIGHT?<br />
Anatole Baldacchino take a glimpse at the colonial times,<br />
and draws parallels between the EU and China<br />
PUBLISHER<br />
<strong>MBR</strong> Publications Limited<br />
OFFICES<br />
Highland Apartment - Level 1,<br />
Naxxar Road,<br />
Birkirkara, BKR 9042<br />
+356 2149 7814<br />
EDITOR<br />
Martin Vella<br />
TECHNICAL ADVISOR<br />
Marcelle D’Argy Smith<br />
SALES DIRECTOR<br />
Margaret Brincat<br />
DESIGN<br />
Eleonora Muratore, <strong>MBR</strong> Design<br />
ADVERTISING<br />
Call: 9940 6743 or 9926 0163/4/6;<br />
Email: margaret@mbrpublications.net<br />
or admin@mbrpublications.net<br />
CONTRIBUTORS<br />
Anatole Baldacchino; Antoine Bonello; George<br />
Carol; Robin Cleland; Jean Paul Demajo; Aude<br />
Rabault; G. A. Carol<br />
SPECIAL THANKS<br />
Demajo Dental; DOI; European Commissioner<br />
for Transport; EU/EP Plenary Session/<br />
Institutions – External Relations; GRTU; ICF<br />
MOSTRA; European Commission, 9 Ways<br />
Cohesion Policy Works For Europe; J2 Group;<br />
LinkedIN; MAPFRE Middlesea; Panorama/EU<br />
Commission<br />
PRINT PRODUCTION<br />
Printit<br />
MALTA BUSINESS REVIEW<br />
COVER STORY<br />
06<br />
10<br />
26<br />
28<br />
EDITORIAL<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Rising traffic congestion is an inescapable condition in every locality,<br />
town and village in Malta. Although I hate to talk about this subject, I<br />
felt I had to bring it up. It stems from the widespread desires of people<br />
to pursue certain goals that inevitably overload existing roads and<br />
transit systems every day. But everyone hates traffic congestion, and<br />
it keeps getting worse, in spite of half-hearted attempted remedies.<br />
Commuters are often frustrated by policymakers’ inability to do<br />
anything about the problem, which poses a significant public policy<br />
challenge. Although governments may never be able to eliminate<br />
road congestion, there are several ways how we can move to curb it.<br />
Traffic congestion is not primarily a problem, but rather the solution<br />
to our basic mobility problem, which is that too many people want<br />
to move at the same times each day. Why? Because efficient operation of both the economy and school<br />
systems requires that people work, go to school, and even run errands during about the same hours so they<br />
can interact with each other. That basic requirement cannot be altered without crippling our economy and<br />
society. The same problem exists in every major metropolitan area in the world. Our basic problem is that<br />
our road system does not have the capacity to handle peak-hour loads without forcing many people to wait<br />
in line for that limited road space. Waiting in line is the definition of congestion, and the same condition is<br />
found in all growing major urban regions.<br />
The second approach would be to build enough road capacity to handle all drivers who want to travel in<br />
peak hours at the same time without delays. But this “cure” is totally impractical and prohibitively expensive.<br />
Government would have to widen all major commuting roads by demolishing buildings, cutting down trees,<br />
and turning most of every locality into a giant concrete slab, and frankly we already have more than enough<br />
of that! There are many occasions when adding more road capacity is a good idea, but we simply cannot<br />
afford to build enough to completely eliminate peak-hour congestion, unless we ask the EU for special<br />
funding for such project.<br />
Although congestion can seem intolerable, the alternatives would be even worse. Peak-hour congestion<br />
is the balancing mechanism that makes it possible for Maltese to pursue other goals they value, including<br />
working or sending their children to school at the same time as their peers, living in low-density settlements,<br />
and having a wide choice of places to live and work. Traffic congestion is compounded by the fact that<br />
the police and local traffic wardens are rather inconspicuous by their absence. As a matter of fact, traffic<br />
wardens’ only role in our society is to go around densely populated parking areas and indiscriminately dish<br />
out as many parking contraventions as possible. It seems this is their only duty and obligation. Which is not.<br />
Traffic wardens should be there to patrol, control traffic congestions and solve traffic problems in hot spots,<br />
as well as help residents and not harass them with parking contraventions. Traffic congestion in almost all<br />
areas is here to stay. In fact, it is almost certain to get worse during at least the next few decades, mainly<br />
because of rising populations and wealth. This will be true no matter what public and private policies are<br />
adopted to combat congestion. But this outcome should not be regarded as a mark of social failure or<br />
misguided policies. In fact, traffic congestion often results from economic prosperity and other types of<br />
success.<br />
Although traffic congestion is inevitable, there are ways to slow the rate at which it intensifies. Several tactics<br />
could do that effectively, especially if used in concert, but nothing can eliminate peak-hour traffic congestion<br />
from major arteries. For the time being, the only relief for traffic-plagued commuters is a comfortable, airconditioned<br />
vehicle with a well-equipped stereo system, a hands-free telephone, and a daily commute with<br />
someone they like.<br />
10 10 26 28<br />
QUOTE OF THE MONTH<br />
“The question I ask myself like almost every day is, ‘Am<br />
I doing the most important thing I could be doing?’…<br />
Unless I feel like I’m working on the most important<br />
problem that I can help with, then I’m not going to feel<br />
good about how I’m spending my time. And that’s what<br />
this company is.”<br />
Disclaimer<br />
MARK ZUCKERBERG, CEO, FACEBOOK<br />
All rights reserved. No part of this work covered by copyright may<br />
be reproduced or copied and reproduction in whole or part is strictly<br />
prohibited without written permission of the publisher. All content<br />
material available on this publication is duly protected by Maltese<br />
and International Law. No person, organisation, other publisher or<br />
online web content manager should rely, or on any way act upon<br />
any part of the contents of this publication, whether that information<br />
is sourced from the website, magazine or related product without<br />
first obtaining the publisher’s consent. The opinions expressed in the<br />
Malta Business Review are those of the authors or contributors, and<br />
are not necessarily those of the editor or publisher.<br />
Congestion has become part of commuters’ daily leisure time, and it promises to stay that way!<br />
This month our team have worked on two unique special features, mainly regarding our highly successful<br />
trade registered gala event- Malta’s Best Entrepreneur of the Year Awards, which saw over 600 guests<br />
entertained in a highly charged emotional evening at the Verdala Palace in Buskett, Rabat, where <strong>MBR</strong><br />
Publications Ltd collected over Euro 3,000, which was handed to HE The President of Malta. The other<br />
interesting feature is about the 7th Cohesion Forum held recently in Brussels, which I was invited to attend<br />
and had the honour of moderating one of the plenary sessions.<br />
Enjoy the read.<br />
Martin Vella<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
30<br />
32<br />
Talk to us:<br />
E-mail: martin@mbrpublications.net<br />
Twitter: @<strong>MBR</strong>Publications<br />
Facebook: www.facebook.com/MaltaBusinessReview<br />
Malta Business Review’s editorial opinions are decided by its Editor, and besides reflecting the Editor’s<br />
opinion, are written to represent a fair and impartial representation of facts, events and provide a correct<br />
analysis of local and international news.<br />
Agents for:<br />
4 5<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
COVER STORY OF THE MONTH<br />
COVER STORY OF THE MONTH<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
DRIVING<br />
CONSTANT<br />
GROWTH<br />
“A STRONG BRAND PROMISE IS ONE THAT<br />
CONNECTS YOUR PURPOSE, YOUR POSITIONING,<br />
YOUR STRATEGY, YOUR PEOPLE AND YOUR<br />
CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE. IT ENABLES YOU TO<br />
DELIVER YOUR BRAND IN A WAY THAT CONNECTS<br />
EMOTION<strong>ALL</strong>Y WITH YOUR CUSTOMERS AND<br />
DIFFERENTIATES YOUR BRAND.”<br />
Martin Vella speaks to Felipe Navarro, CEO of<br />
MAPFRE Middlesea about their brand promise<br />
MV: Does your brand promise articulate<br />
what your target customers can expect in<br />
their interactions with you? What should<br />
they experience? How should they feel?<br />
And most importantly what do you promise<br />
that is unique?<br />
FN: Our brand promise is to be “your<br />
trustworthy insurance company“ and we do<br />
our utmost to fulfill this promise by providing<br />
peace of mind and being deserving of our<br />
clients’ trust. Peace of mind and protection<br />
is the essence of what we have to offer (we<br />
consider ourselves ‘people who look after<br />
people’ ) and this guides us in how we live<br />
our brand. Crafting this promise requires<br />
understanding of our values, interests,<br />
strengths, and our business philosophy.<br />
MV: Can you please elaborate on your<br />
mission, vision and values?<br />
FN: Our Vision is that of being the most<br />
trusted global insurance company. We intend<br />
to continue developing innovative solutions<br />
that safeguard people, with products<br />
designed to protect their property and<br />
savings, and securing their future. Our aim is<br />
to provide close support to clients whenever<br />
and wherever they need us, across all five<br />
continents.<br />
As a multinational team, our mission is to<br />
strive to improve our services and ensure the<br />
best possible relationship with our clients,<br />
distributors, providers, shareholders, and<br />
society in general.<br />
Our Values include solvency, integrity, vocation<br />
for service, innovation for leadership, and<br />
being a committed team. These values shape<br />
our operations and guide us as we work<br />
towards achieving our vision and delivering<br />
on our mission.<br />
MV: How would you explain these values to<br />
the reader?<br />
FN: Solvency is understood to mean financial<br />
strength and sustainable results over time,<br />
rendering us fully capable of meeting all<br />
obligations with stakeholders. All MAPFRE<br />
directors, employees, agents and partners,<br />
are required to conduct themselves ethically<br />
at all times, taking a socially responsible<br />
approach to all activities and long-term<br />
commitments. This is what we mean by<br />
integrity. We constantly strive to excel in all<br />
of our activities. When we refer to vocation<br />
for service, we mean that our performance<br />
is centered on ensuring the best possible<br />
relationship with clients. When we speak<br />
about Innovation for leadership, we identify<br />
differentiation as a key requirement to drive<br />
constant growth and improvement, putting<br />
technology at the service of our business and<br />
objectives.<br />
Our Vision is that of<br />
being the most trusted global<br />
insurance company<br />
MV: What are the advantages of being a<br />
global insurance company?<br />
FN: MAPFRE is a leader on the global<br />
insurance market. We operate in more than<br />
100 countries across five continents, and we<br />
At the heart of our<br />
operations are the more than<br />
37 million clients who place<br />
their trust in us.<br />
are the foremost multinational insurance<br />
group in Latin America and leaders in nonlife<br />
insurance in the region. We are among the<br />
top 10 insurers in Europe, and the undisputed<br />
leader in the non-life insurance in the Spanish<br />
market. We also feature in the top twenty<br />
vehicle insurance providers in the United<br />
States. All this places us in a position to deliver<br />
efficiently and effectively with regard to our<br />
clients’ insurance needs anytime, anywhere.<br />
At the heart of our operations are the more<br />
than 37 million clients who place their trust<br />
in us. We insure people, protecting their<br />
goods and managing their savings. We insure<br />
professionals and businesses, supporting<br />
them through challenging times. And we<br />
cover major risks, placing the emphasis on<br />
prevention.<br />
MV: How many people work for MAPFRE<br />
worldwide?<br />
FN: We are 37,000 employees in 5,400<br />
offices offering a comprehensive portfolio of<br />
products worldwide.<br />
MV: What is the main reason clients choose<br />
MAPFRE?<br />
FN: MAPFRE is synonymous with<br />
innovation. We seek solutions that address<br />
new challenges, and we respond efficiently<br />
in the event of major disasters. We provide<br />
our clients with full support by harnessing<br />
the latest technology. We help to drive digital<br />
transformation in the world via products<br />
designed to cater to future risks, even<br />
covering activities that do not yet exist.<br />
Commitment is a keystone of our business<br />
philosophy. It is our duty to establish a<br />
solvent and profitable business, but never at<br />
the expense of sustainable engagement with<br />
the environment around us. The CSR branch<br />
of the organisation, Fundación MAPFRE, not<br />
only helps provide shareholding stability,<br />
it also delivers on our mission of driving<br />
development in the communities within our<br />
footprint, taking action to enhance the quality<br />
of life for around 17 million people in 29<br />
countries. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
EDITOR’S<br />
Note<br />
Mr. Felipe Navarro López de Chicheri is<br />
President & Chief Executive Officer at<br />
Mapfre Middlesea Plc, Chairman at Bee<br />
Insurance Management Ltd., Chairman<br />
at Church Wharf Properties Ltd.,<br />
Chairman at Euro Globe Holdings Ltd.,<br />
Chairman at Euromed Risk Solutions<br />
Ltd., Chairman at Middlesea Assist<br />
Ltd. and Chairman at The Maltese-<br />
Spanish Chamber of Commerce. He<br />
is on the Board of Directors at Growth<br />
Investments Ltd. and MSV Life Plc.<br />
Mr. Navarro López de Chicheri was previously employed as<br />
Director & General Manager by Duero Pensiones EGFP SA. He<br />
also served on the board at Aseguradora Valenciana SA de Seguros y<br />
Reaseguros, Bankia Mapfre Vida SA, Bankinter Seguros de Vida SA<br />
de Seguros y Reaseguros, CatalunyaCaixa Vida SA d'Assegurances<br />
i Reassegurances, CCM Vida y Pensiones de Seguros y Reaseguros<br />
SA, Laietana Vida Cia Seguros de la Caja de Ahorros Laietana SA<br />
and Union del Duero Compaia de Seguros de Vida SA. He received<br />
his undergraduate degree from Universidad Complutense de Madrid<br />
and an MBA from Universida de Alcalá de Henares.<br />
6 7<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
CORPORATE INTERVIEW OF THE MONTH<br />
CORPORATE INTERVIEW OF THE MONTH<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Access,<br />
Affordability,<br />
and Excellence<br />
By Martin Vella<br />
An app will allow customers to be updated<br />
with the expected time of the technician’s<br />
arrival and enable a self-install service to<br />
all existing customers wishing to change a<br />
product.<br />
What we save can be reinvested<br />
in better products, services and<br />
experience for customers.<br />
can benefit from aggressive competition in<br />
the future, across mobile, fixed and TV.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Following the merger, will the type<br />
of solutions offered to business clients’<br />
change?<br />
AN: In the Enterprise segment, where<br />
currently the incumbent (GO) is the strongest<br />
player, there will be a real choice for business<br />
customers of all sizes. We will be able to<br />
deliver products and services currently not<br />
being offered.<br />
Vodafone Enterprise customers will gain<br />
access to a full suite of fixed services (such as<br />
fixed broadband and telephony, international<br />
connectivity and data centre services) with<br />
the convenience of having one account<br />
manager to manage it all.<br />
Business customers will also benefit from very<br />
high speed internet on both mobile and fixed<br />
by 2018, which will allow them to equip their<br />
workforces and, in turn, serve their customers<br />
in a highly agile and digital way. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
The recent Melita and Vodafone<br />
merger will benefit customers,<br />
competition and the country –<br />
for reasons more than one. In a<br />
unique joint interview <strong>MBR</strong> Editor<br />
Martin Vella talks with Melita<br />
CEO Harald Rösch and Vodafone<br />
Malta CEO Amanda Nelson to<br />
find out more about the merger<br />
and its advantages.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Can you assure a high level of<br />
customer service in the combined entity?<br />
AN: Definitely. A passion for excellent<br />
customer service will be at the core of the<br />
combined entity. Vodafone has a very high<br />
standard of customer service and has access<br />
to state of the art training on customer<br />
experience for all levels of staff and an<br />
accreditation process for all frontline workers.<br />
That training will be fully available to the<br />
combined entity and will be rolled out to<br />
Melita staff.<br />
Vodafone has also implemented a ‘SuperCare’<br />
promise, whereby customers are given a<br />
specific deadline by which their issue will be<br />
resolved – if this is not met, the customer<br />
is financially compensated. The combined<br />
entity will extend the ‘SuperCare’ promise<br />
to its entire portfolio of services, including<br />
Melita’s services.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: The number of operators in Malta will<br />
essentially go from three to two. What is the<br />
impact of the merger on competition?<br />
HR: Strong competition is precisely the main<br />
benefit for customers. In the fixed market,<br />
Malta has for a long time had only two<br />
competitors in GO and Melita. Nevertheless,<br />
the prices Maltese customers pay for fixed<br />
internet access are in line or cheaper than what<br />
one would pay in other Western European<br />
countries. This has been guaranteed by strong<br />
infrastructural competition between Melita's<br />
powerful broadband network and GO's fibre<br />
infrastructure.<br />
In the mobile market, economies of scale<br />
really matter. Malta is the smallest state in<br />
the EU and has arguably the highest cost<br />
per mobile subscriber of any EU country.<br />
Operators need to invest significantly more<br />
per inhabitant than the EU average to build<br />
mobile infrastructure.<br />
The merger will enable us to spread our<br />
investment over more customers. What we<br />
save can be reinvested in better products,<br />
services and experience for customers.<br />
Moreover, GO has massive advantages as<br />
the fixed line incumbent in Malta with a<br />
legacy network which neither Vodafone nor<br />
Melita have had. Vodafone and Melita have<br />
each invested significant amounts in their<br />
respective networks, and the merger provides<br />
the best means by which Maltese consumers<br />
Amanda Nelson, Vodafone Malta CEO<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What was the strategic objective<br />
behind the Vodafone Malta and Melita<br />
merger?<br />
HR: There has been a lack of real competition<br />
for Maltese consumers and businesses in the<br />
converged market (i.e. TV, telephone, internet<br />
and mobile services) for too long. Demand for<br />
converged services in Malta is more advanced<br />
than in most other countries in Europe,<br />
yet GO is the only operator able to offer 4G<br />
together with high speed broadband, denying<br />
real choice to consumers.<br />
Allied to that, we want to merge Melita and<br />
Vodafone Malta to enable us to invest in the<br />
next generation of telecoms services – Gigabit<br />
capable broadband and 5G. The choice for<br />
Malta is between having one provider set the<br />
pace at which we get these technologies that<br />
will help our economy and society, or enable<br />
two providers to compete to bring technology<br />
benefits to our country.<br />
The combination of Vodafone and Melita is<br />
a highly complementary one because the<br />
combined entity will be able to draw from<br />
the different sets of strengths of the two<br />
companies. Vodafone is the market leader<br />
in mobile with an award-winning network.<br />
Melita on the other hand is the market leader<br />
in fixed internet and TV, owning the best<br />
broadband network in Malta.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: The transaction is currently going<br />
through the regulatory approval process. If<br />
approved, would that mean that Vodafone<br />
will be leaving the island?<br />
There has been a lack<br />
of real competition for Maltese<br />
consumers and businesses<br />
in the converged market<br />
for too long.<br />
AN: No, Vodafone will not be leaving Malta.<br />
Vodafone will retain the largest possible<br />
minority stake in the combined entity (49%),<br />
and the expertise of its staff will transfer<br />
across to the combined entity.<br />
In fact, Vodafone has appointed its current<br />
CFO as the CFO of the combined entity.<br />
Melita customers can expect to start<br />
benefitting from Vodafone’s excellence in<br />
customer service, and the combined entity<br />
expects that GO customers will be tempted<br />
by the combination of Melita and Vodafone’s<br />
combined offerings.<br />
The entity’s mobile and enterprise business<br />
will operate under the Vodafone brand and<br />
distribute a wide range of services including<br />
Vodafone’s global portfolio of products<br />
and services and benefit from access to<br />
Vodafone’s extensive expertise in mobile and<br />
fixed operations worldwide.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Some people talk about merging or<br />
combining cultures, while others seek to<br />
create a new culture that is separate from<br />
those of the legacy companies. What will<br />
your approach be?<br />
HR: We will build a new culture based<br />
on elements that can be found in both<br />
companies. A drive for quality is one such<br />
building block. Vodafone is known for its<br />
excellent customer service and ever since<br />
Melita has changed shareholders in 2016, we<br />
have made significant investments in quality.<br />
And feedback from customers tells us that<br />
we have made great progress. We have the<br />
fastest and only published call waiting times<br />
in Malta. The commitment to delivering a<br />
service whereby calls are answered within<br />
30 seconds will apply to the combined<br />
entity. Melita’s Service Guarantees will be<br />
fully adopted, including installation within 48<br />
hours and repair in case of outage in 24 hours.<br />
Harald Rösch, Melita CEO<br />
8<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
9
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
MALTA<br />
BUSINESS REVIEW<br />
The Power<br />
of Purpose<br />
by Martin Vella<br />
We interview Dr. Joanna Delia, Aesthetic<br />
Physician , winner of Malta’s Best<br />
Healthcare Entrepreneur of the Year Award<br />
2017. <strong>MBR</strong> diagnosed the entrepreneur<br />
behind the doctor and how Dr. Delia juggles<br />
her duties on a day-to-day basis…<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What was your 30 second pitch<br />
to describe you during Malta’s Best<br />
Entrepreneur of the Year Awards 2017?<br />
JD: I was asked the question: Why is success<br />
the entrepreneur's drug. There are many<br />
interpretations of success and when I thought<br />
about what success means to me, I thought<br />
of 'happiness'... a legacy of happiness - happy<br />
clients, happy colleagues and a happy family!<br />
I am also very passionate about the struggles<br />
faced by career women in Malta and I strive<br />
to be some sort of inspiration for other<br />
women and mothers, to show them that<br />
it can all be done! Lastly I believe success is<br />
when you make your dreams come true,<br />
through hard work, even when you start from<br />
scratch with no financial backing, no family<br />
business backing, working 13 hours a day and<br />
answering emails at 3am while breastfeeding<br />
your baby! If that is success, then it is my drug!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: In healthcare, you have to identify<br />
one particular human need and address<br />
that really well. Do you agree?<br />
JD: I suppose healthcare is a human need<br />
in itself! When you are dealing with the<br />
intricacies of the functions of the human<br />
body, your job is so multi-faceted, it is<br />
impossible to identify any single 'need'! In<br />
my world, we deal with the exterior's ability<br />
to give a person confidence! Patients come<br />
to us with issues that are potentially making<br />
them feel unhappy and putting a dent in their<br />
confidence. They place their trust in us to<br />
treat them as individuals, and find a solution<br />
which is unique and which gives subtle but<br />
amazing results! They have to see that the<br />
world of cosmetic medicine is not the hypertransformations<br />
the media seems to portray<br />
it to be, but a repertoire of medical tools to<br />
address small aesthetic issues! Therefore<br />
there are plenty of human needs that need<br />
addressing in my line of work!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Why is it important to have the<br />
sense of empathy and belonging towards<br />
strangers you are dealing with and make<br />
them feel comfortable?<br />
JD: It is paramount to have empathy! I always<br />
tell my clients that I am honored every single<br />
time a patient sits in front of me and entrusts<br />
me with her or his face. Our job, essentially,<br />
is to couple the person's perceived, physical<br />
and cosmetic medical needs with her<br />
intrinsic, psychological needs. It takes a lot<br />
of deciphering. We study the effects of aging<br />
on the face, and the effects of other toils<br />
that time has on the face, such as the long<br />
term scars associated with acne, and plan a<br />
solution that will make the client happier and<br />
more confident. When all this is done with<br />
the client's ultimate satisfaction in mind, the<br />
client feels comfortable and our job is done<br />
well!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How did you decide to participate in<br />
Malta’s Best Entrepreneur Awards and what<br />
feedback can you give us about the event?<br />
JD: I was informed that I was nominated and<br />
shortlisted for the awards, and I have to say<br />
I was very surprised, humbled and happy for<br />
the recognition already at that stage. The<br />
event was wonderful in the sublime setting<br />
of the gardens at the Verdala palace and<br />
the vast range of awards meant that it was a<br />
networking opportunity with members of the<br />
business community from all of its corners.<br />
any entrepreneurial moves I<br />
make I make by instinct, driven<br />
by passion and excitement,<br />
wanting to improve<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How does it feel to win Malta’s Best<br />
Healthcare Entrepreneur of the Year Award?<br />
JD: I am a professional with no business<br />
training, and any entrepreneurial moves I<br />
make I make by instinct, driven by passion<br />
and excitement, wanting to improve<br />
circumstances for my team, and pledging<br />
to constantly improve facilities and services<br />
for our clients. To be validated through this<br />
award is an extraordinary feeling. It is a sigh of<br />
relief, pointing somehow that your decisions<br />
and struggles and the way you handled some<br />
of your challenges was heading in the right<br />
direction! It motivates you to keep pushing<br />
for excellency!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What were some key lessons-learned<br />
in getting from the idea to where you are<br />
now?<br />
JD: Wow! It has certainly been an interesting<br />
journey! I believe you never stop learning<br />
and whether I booked a course in Paris to<br />
learn about a new treatment from the best<br />
in the field or life threw a tough challenge my<br />
way, I find it exciting to know that I will gain<br />
knowledge and improve with every step! I<br />
have had to force myself to delegate, and<br />
therefore learn who to trust! I constantly try<br />
to improve my relationship with my team so<br />
that we have a relationship of mutual benefit<br />
and one which fosters a better experience for<br />
our patients! Another good lesson learnt is<br />
that a good, excited attitude is contagious and<br />
universally permeating through every aspect<br />
of the business!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: You are a doctor and hold several<br />
degrees so which kind of medicine are you<br />
most interested in?<br />
JD: After a stint working at St Luke's hospital,<br />
aspiring to be a surgeon, I realised I was far<br />
too empathic to handle the constant flow of<br />
patients troubled by serious medical issues,<br />
pain and the constant realization that life<br />
is an anti climax. I have so much respect for<br />
my friends and colleagues who face suffering<br />
and death on an hour by hour basis! I chose<br />
to specialise in cosmetic medical procedures,<br />
giving the best of my professional abilities<br />
to better people s lives through medical<br />
aesthetic improvements.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What can you tell us about The Medaesthetic<br />
Clinic you have founded?<br />
JD: It is an enterprise based on happiness<br />
:) The premises was designed to be both a<br />
home away from home for the staff, as well as<br />
a comfortable, inspiring and functional space<br />
for our patients! We have state of the art<br />
rooms dedicated to different treatments, as<br />
well as a spacious reception area and another<br />
area where both our children and client's<br />
children can play, watch cartoons on a wide<br />
screen, and where mothers can breastfeed!<br />
We perform about 7,500 treatments a year<br />
and we pride ourselves with client satisfaction.<br />
Every member of the team is professionally<br />
and regularly trained. We want to be as good<br />
as we can be.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What do you think are the most<br />
important factors that will make this clinic<br />
a success?<br />
JD: To run my own clinic was something of a<br />
dream up until a few weeks before I actually<br />
took the plunge! The ethos my team and I<br />
work by is to give any visitor an incredible<br />
experience, from our first communication<br />
to after the follow up! And we don't have to<br />
force this... we genuinely care about each<br />
and every person who walks through our<br />
door. Asides from investing in gold standard<br />
equipment and technique training, it gives<br />
us so much satisfaction to realise we have<br />
tools to make people happier. We want them<br />
to feel understood and satisfied above and<br />
beyond their original expectations! And their<br />
feedback and gratitude is priceless! That is<br />
why we say we treat People and not just Skin!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What words of advice would you<br />
give to other healthcare upcoming/student<br />
entrepreneurs?<br />
JD: Keep your minds open, find a niche that<br />
you love and work that will make you happy,<br />
allow you to be yourselves, and live the life you<br />
want to live. Almost anything can be achieved<br />
by hard work! Nothing comes easy but there<br />
is no better feeling than accomplishing your<br />
dreams and giving others the opportunity to<br />
do the same! <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
10<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
11
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Embracing<br />
Challenges,<br />
Recognizing<br />
Value By George Carol<br />
Abigail Law, Malta’s Best<br />
Innovation in Product &<br />
Service Entrepreneur of the<br />
Year 2017, shares her thoughts<br />
and insights regarding Look<br />
Amazing Ltd and her recent<br />
accomplishment, and on<br />
building a growing brand.<br />
market, our approach towards the business is<br />
what sets us apart from competition.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What is the key to success of Look<br />
Amazing, and what has made your business<br />
model work so well?<br />
AL: The success being achieved by the<br />
company is inherited from properly<br />
investigating our market. One does not simply<br />
decide to distribute a brand without doing the<br />
proper research first… What is new? What<br />
does the market need? What will make us<br />
different? How do we set the standard and<br />
the price? These are all questions we ask<br />
ourselves before investing. Our ranges are not<br />
considered cheap but we educate our clients<br />
to understand that we bring good value<br />
for money to their purchases and educate<br />
ourselves alike to be properly informed on<br />
each and every product. Education is the key!<br />
colleagues and trust earned from suppliers<br />
contributes to having a strong company that<br />
will generate more revenue.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What has been central to Look<br />
Amazing’s strategy or success?<br />
AL: Planning, planning and planning! Business<br />
success does not happen by chance. Different<br />
strategies are used but a business plan has<br />
always been used to make sure that most<br />
things are foreseen and we are as prepared<br />
as possible for the situations that will be<br />
presented. We take time to analyse and<br />
prioritise which business strategy applies the<br />
most for the project that will be undertaken.<br />
Different brands require different approaches<br />
(some would require more marketing while<br />
others would require more education,<br />
amongst other factors) but as long as they are<br />
planned for it increases the chance of success<br />
drastically.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How important is your career position<br />
and working had till your career growth?<br />
AL: I take my work very seriously and have to<br />
admit that I am quite a workaholic in fact! I<br />
actually cannot sleep if a task is unfinished.<br />
No matter what it takes to get a job done, I<br />
will do it. I try not to let my family suffer so<br />
there have been many occasions where I<br />
resumed working in the evening and worked<br />
the night away, but I am happy to do so if that<br />
is what is required. Having everything in good<br />
order gives me a piece of mind and a good<br />
vibe which is essential for me to continue my<br />
work! <strong>MBR</strong> All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
Abigail Law at Malta's Best Entrepreneur of the Year Awards 2017<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How does it feel to be recognised<br />
as a female business leader, especially in<br />
an industry that is so stereotypically male<br />
oriented and hard to crack?<br />
AL: As with most industries it is always<br />
difficult for women to juggle between work<br />
and family life however that does not make<br />
it impossible! There are many factors that<br />
contribute towards making it possible and in<br />
my case I have a director (a family woman<br />
herself) who literally kills herself to achieve<br />
so much and whose experience in the field is<br />
second to none! I have a team who contribute<br />
and strive to reach targets constantly – they<br />
are my backbone. And last but not least I<br />
have my husband – he’s the one who keeps<br />
me sane when things get crazy, the person<br />
who is always there to help me rationalise<br />
when in tough situations and attends to the<br />
kids when I am absent. So, to be recognised<br />
feels amazing but none of it would be possible<br />
without all the people involved behind the<br />
scenes!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What was your reaction after winning<br />
Malta’s Best Innovation in Product & Service<br />
Entrepreneur of the Year 2017?<br />
AL: I was ecstatic! When I see that the<br />
company is doing better and better, that<br />
already gives me personal satisfaction, but to<br />
actually be recognised for it by winning such<br />
a prestigious award then that is just the best<br />
feeling ever! I would never brag about how<br />
well I am doing so to have others notice your<br />
success is very rewarding. This great award<br />
has actually encouraged me further to set<br />
new goals and targets and I will work even<br />
harder to achieve more.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: To what do your attribute your<br />
success?<br />
AL: One word… “Teamwork”. The reason why<br />
the business is successful is because all of us at<br />
the office work so closely together. We share<br />
our opinions and discuss our differences and<br />
the results are evidently beneficial. No one<br />
person can be successful without a team that<br />
is always there to back them up. Of course,<br />
all the preliminary work was done by our<br />
director Gemma Fiorini, who strived so hard<br />
to get only the best brands to the company,<br />
visiting multiple companies and laboratories<br />
before deciding what the market needs and<br />
making sure that we are always one step<br />
ahead in this game!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How has your career evolved and<br />
which area do you lead today?<br />
AL: I started working with the company to<br />
break from my daily routine after having<br />
two children. At the time I was the director’s<br />
personal assistant, helping her with office<br />
tasks that I was very capable of doing after<br />
having my own business. Eventually, I started<br />
working on a daily basis and with our director<br />
being abroad so often since she owns other<br />
companies overseas, I automatically took the<br />
role of General Manager. I basically ensure the<br />
smooth running of the company and attend<br />
to all duties required as per my position.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What sets you apart from competition<br />
as Malta’s Best Innovation in Product &<br />
Service Entrepreneur of the Year?<br />
LA: At some point all companies face<br />
obstacles and challenges that sometimes<br />
feel as if they are impossible to overcome<br />
or achieve. Having an optimistic approach<br />
always gives a solution and a positive result.<br />
In this industry change is a constant and it is<br />
not easy to frequently adapt to new ideas but<br />
our drive to grow and learn is bigger than the<br />
challenges presented and we move forward<br />
by embracing challenges and recognize<br />
the value of failure, as this makes us gain<br />
perspective and grow as individuals. So, apart<br />
from the extraordinary brands we bring to the<br />
This great award has actually<br />
encouraged me further<br />
to set new goals and targets<br />
and I will work even harder<br />
to achieve more<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: There is a strong culture within Look<br />
Amazing. How do you make sure you do not<br />
lose that culture?<br />
AL: Ethics! Maintaining ethical standard not<br />
only when doing business deals but also<br />
towards other members of the company<br />
and customers alike. Respect earned from<br />
12<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
13
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017 SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
by Martin Vella<br />
Here at Aspen Limited, Josette<br />
Fenech and her sibling Liliana Borg<br />
enjoy discussing innovative projects<br />
and finalising on design schemes<br />
as much as they love art and<br />
travelling and spend hours updating<br />
themselves with the latest trends in<br />
décor. Recently winning the highly<br />
acclaimed Malta’s Best Real Estate<br />
and Property Entrepreneur of the<br />
Year Award, Josette and Liliana are<br />
poised to have a meteoric rise in<br />
business. We spoke with the devoted<br />
sisters about what makes them tick<br />
and about their plans for the future<br />
and dream projects.<br />
Aspen Limited: Josette Fenech and Liliana Borg receiving the award at Malta's Best Entrepreneur of the Year Awards 2017<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Would you tell us about the culture<br />
and background of Josette Fenech and<br />
Liliana Borg?<br />
LB: We are sisters! We are deeply entrenched<br />
in a family business culture where we have<br />
each other's interests at heart; shared, well<br />
considered interests that involve input,<br />
joined up thinking and planning from start<br />
to finish. Our father, Joe Grima, involved us<br />
both directly in the family hotel business and<br />
we worked from the bottom up, experiencing<br />
every aspect of business systems, operations<br />
and culture before taking this vast experience<br />
into our own business. We created Aspen<br />
with an eye firmly on customer service as<br />
we both feel the same way about how the<br />
customer is always omnipotent.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How would you define your roles and<br />
how do you reconcile different opinions?<br />
JF: As a well-functioning, yet thoroughly<br />
diverse team, Liliana and I, each work on<br />
separate aspects of the business. I am<br />
creative and customer focused as a sales<br />
oriented director, whilst Liliana delivers the<br />
financial and accounting arm of the business.<br />
Both aspects are essential and it is vital that<br />
both are efficient and well ordered in order<br />
to achieve the results we desire. We are both<br />
very flexible in our approach to problem<br />
solving and over the years, we have amassed<br />
a huge amount of experience that allows<br />
us to overcome issues and challenges. As<br />
a fluid team that focuses on delivering our<br />
client's needs, we sometimes have different<br />
opinions on a given subject. At this point,<br />
we both seek advice and do our research<br />
in order to strengthen each side of the<br />
argument. We then work hard, sat around<br />
the table in order to reach a satisfactory<br />
and progressive decision based on mutual<br />
respect, compromise and experience.<br />
We know our business, our area<br />
and our local culture thoroughly<br />
and this is key to the positive<br />
image we hold in the North<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What is it about your work that has<br />
made your job so special?<br />
JB: I (Josette) feel that the most special<br />
part of my working days are those exciting<br />
moments when, together with a client, we<br />
create the client's home. It is not about the<br />
sale but about achieving the client's dreams.<br />
Liliana suggests that she finds the successful<br />
completion of a project in an efficient and<br />
measured manner completely satisfying.<br />
Liliana has a keen eye for detail and the focus<br />
on getting it right, every time, is important<br />
to her. Indeed, working within an exacting<br />
budget for and with the client gives Liliana<br />
a great deal of satisfaction and it is always<br />
a vital part of any negotiation, which also<br />
dictates the creative aspect's scope. We are<br />
keen to express that we both have a shared<br />
enthusiasm for giving the customer exactly<br />
what they want and need.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: When customers walk into Aspen Ltd,<br />
are there certain elements that stand out<br />
and is there a specific niche market?<br />
LB: We like our customer's first impression to<br />
be that of professional calmness. Our offices<br />
are modern and carefully designed to make<br />
the client feel at home, yet they retain their<br />
functionality. If a client is comfortable when<br />
negotiating their requirements, they will<br />
be more likely to express their ideas so that<br />
together, we can create the home that they<br />
really want and we can then facilitate their<br />
dreams. In terms of a niche, we believe that<br />
working in our own town and surrounding<br />
areas gives us the edge over our competitors<br />
in the respect that we know the area and its<br />
culture from a unique perspective. We believe<br />
it is one of the keys to property development<br />
success, to know your area and our ability<br />
to help our clients create that vision of their<br />
dream home is based upon local cultural<br />
knowledge. Indeed, that all important aspect<br />
of almost instant accessibility in terms of<br />
viewing the properties and the developments<br />
as the projects move forward is vital for our<br />
business.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How much of a focus is developing<br />
business in the areas of planning, building<br />
and finishing a property?<br />
JF: As directors, we lead a team of highly<br />
skilled and highly experienced people and<br />
our collaborative efforts are highly focused<br />
upon each vital stage of planning, building<br />
and finishing a property. We have a tried and<br />
trusted formula that is successful whilst being<br />
open to change, adaptation and nuanced<br />
alteration, as a project requires. We both feel<br />
that in all areas, proper planning is vital to a<br />
smooth and efficient project completion. We<br />
do not always get everything right, but we do<br />
always learn from the experience and create a<br />
positive outcome for the client.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What does it take to be successful in<br />
the North of the Island?<br />
JF: We feel very strongly about our ethos of<br />
working closely with each client to provide<br />
them with the opportunity to create a<br />
home, rather than merely selling them a<br />
property. We have built a reputation based<br />
on professional customer care, integrity and<br />
client satisfaction. This also extends to our<br />
contractors and suppliers. In addition, we<br />
know our business, our area and our local<br />
culture thoroughly and this is key to the<br />
positive image we hold in the North.<br />
We have a tried and trusted<br />
formula that is successful<br />
whilst being open to change,<br />
adaptation and nuanced<br />
alteration<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Why has Aspen Limited has become<br />
one of the most respected property<br />
developers in the north of the island?<br />
LB: We feel the previous answer covers this<br />
question too but we could also add that our<br />
business is mainly built on the back of word<br />
of mouth; we consistently have positive<br />
referrals.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What is your feedback following<br />
the success achieved in Malta’s Best<br />
Entrepreneur of the Year Awards 2017 and<br />
how did you feel after winning Best Real<br />
Estate & Property Entrepreneur of the Year<br />
Award?<br />
JF: The feedback has been incredible; we have<br />
received more likes and viewing requests via<br />
the website and indeed, various solid queries<br />
that we are currently working on, following<br />
that wonderful evening. It was a wonderful<br />
experience for us both. We have always<br />
worked hard for our business success and<br />
whilst we remain humble and grateful to<br />
our team, we also felt a touch of pride to be<br />
honoured in such highly respected company.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Are you happy with where your<br />
product is today and are there changes<br />
clients can expect in the future?<br />
JF: We always remain innovative and we do<br />
enjoy researching and creating new concepts<br />
but at the end of the day, we are here to<br />
provide exactly what the client wants and<br />
needs. Thus, our innovation is customer<br />
focused, and driven, and it is often the<br />
customer who brings an idea and we do our<br />
very best to make that dream a reality. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
14 15<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Setting<br />
Higher Standards<br />
Malta Business Review interviews<br />
Gaetano Borg Bonaci, Director at Elia<br />
Borg Bonaci Ltd, who have guaranteed<br />
the highest quality standards in food<br />
products, confectionery and catering for<br />
over 60 years, and outright winners of<br />
Malta’s Best Catering Company of the<br />
Year Award and also Malta’s Best Family<br />
Business of the Year 2017.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Would you tell us about the culture<br />
and background of Elia Borg Bonaci Catering<br />
Ltd?<br />
GBB: We have always been a family business<br />
which has been run very much like an<br />
extended family, because we only employ<br />
workers who cherish and practice those values<br />
and quality traditions which have always been<br />
the hallmark of our family throughout the<br />
three generations. All family members are<br />
hardworking and committed to the company<br />
and this is conducive to a very positive work<br />
ethic throughout the organisation where<br />
mutual respect and cooperation are standard<br />
practice.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What led you to become involved in<br />
catering?<br />
GBB: My brothers and I took over the bakery<br />
in Villambrosa Street, Hamrun which was<br />
opened by our parents in 1953 and started<br />
offering outside catering. We are very focused<br />
on our business and we have always resisted<br />
diversifying into other sectors because<br />
beyond the business objectives, we always<br />
enjoyed working in what we can do best and<br />
constantly improving our service offering.<br />
This strategy has paid off because despite the<br />
efforts of very valid competitors, our company<br />
has managed to improve its market share.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How would you define your role<br />
today?<br />
GBB: Last year, my brothers and I gave way<br />
to our sons and daughters to manage the<br />
business and implement their own initiatives<br />
under a defined management structure<br />
and with full reporting and accountability.<br />
Therefore today, I have a ‘caretaker’ role with<br />
respect to management functions since the<br />
key management decisions are taken by the<br />
young team, which also includes non-family<br />
members. However, I am still very much<br />
involved in sales and customer relations.<br />
since 1953 this iconic coffee<br />
shop has always been a popular<br />
meeting place for people coming<br />
from all walks of life, both<br />
young and old<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What is it about your work that has<br />
made your job so special?<br />
GBB: I derive great pride from the very<br />
flattering reviews we receive from satisfied<br />
customers because I spend a lot of time<br />
assisting young couples planning a troublefree<br />
wedding reception. And thanks to my<br />
sales executives, we are also being inundated<br />
with new orders for corporate functions as<br />
a result of personal recommendations from<br />
existing customers.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: When customers walk into Elia Café,<br />
are there certain elements that stand out<br />
and is there a specific niche market?<br />
GBB: Elia Café is household name and not only<br />
for the Hamrun community. This is because<br />
since 1953 this iconic coffee shop has always<br />
been a popular meeting place for people<br />
coming from all walks of life, both young and<br />
old. This is where you can buy one of the<br />
many Elia confectionery products, prepared<br />
strictly according to the old traditional recipes<br />
and artisan processes. Apart from the many<br />
regulars we welcome a lot of occasional<br />
customers, including many young people,<br />
who appreciate our personalised service and<br />
the mouth-watering confectionery display<br />
and, of course, Elia Ice Cream.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How much of a focus on catering F&B<br />
to further develop your business are you<br />
presently concentrating?<br />
GBB: Today, outside catering is by far our main<br />
focus. We are still developing confectionery<br />
products for the coffee shop but at the same<br />
time we are boosting the product range for<br />
wedding receptions, corporate functions,<br />
family parties etc. Similarly, we have<br />
extended our range of cakes and gateaux for<br />
all occasions and with customised decoration.<br />
The new savoury dishes for the 2017 menu<br />
have been a great hit and we have now<br />
designed new menus for banquets which are<br />
becoming popular with corporate clients and<br />
foreign wedding couples. We are also setting<br />
higher standards of service by providing<br />
training and career incentives to waiters and<br />
chefs engaged in outside catering. At the<br />
factory we have invested in new technology<br />
for greater efficiency and improved quality<br />
control.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What does it take to be successful on<br />
an Island of our scale?<br />
GBB: According to our market research, our<br />
brand is as popular in the North as it is in the<br />
South because there is no such divide when<br />
it comes to people’s appreciation of reliable<br />
service and high quality products. You should<br />
Gaetano Borg Bonaci, Director at Elia Borg Bonaci Ltd, receiving the award for Malta's Best Entrepreneur of the Year Awards 2017 from Johan Zammit, NetRefer<br />
be creative, but also remember that you are<br />
a business. The art of catering is one of the<br />
most fun and important parts of the business<br />
and this is part of our success.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Why has Elia Borg Bonaci Catering Ltd<br />
become one of the most respected catering<br />
and wedding establishments?<br />
GBB: Our family business is now in its third<br />
generation and throughout all these years<br />
the company has earned a solid reputation<br />
of caring for the customer at all stages of our<br />
relationship: we spend time understanding<br />
their desires and advising them on practical<br />
issues and then we personally make sure<br />
that we deliver what we promise, always<br />
maintaining our high quality service. Family<br />
members are involved in every stage of our<br />
operations and this is highly appreciated by<br />
both personal and corporate customers.<br />
we only employ workers who<br />
cherish and practice those values<br />
and quality traditions which<br />
have always been the hallmark<br />
of our family throughout the<br />
three generations<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What is your feedback following<br />
the success achieved in Malta’s Best<br />
Entrepreneur of the Year Awards 2017 and<br />
how did you feel after winning Malta’s Best<br />
Catering Company of the Year Award and<br />
also Malta’s Best Family Business of the<br />
Year?<br />
GBB: We received many congratulations<br />
from our clients through social media as well<br />
as business associates and suppliers. The<br />
employees are also very proud of the awards.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: As a key leader in this space, is there<br />
anything you are working on that you are<br />
particularly proud or excited about?<br />
GBB: Yes, we are very proud of the success<br />
of our new venues, Giardini Lambrosa<br />
and Veranda in Rabat. The great variety<br />
of functions held there since the opening<br />
last year, meeting the needs for wedding<br />
receptions, private parties, corporate<br />
functions and other events, is testament to<br />
their versatility and popularity, and we are<br />
very excited about this. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
16<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
17
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017 SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIALISED KNOWLEDGE<br />
AND EXPERTISE<br />
by George Carol<br />
KE: I think it’s a great event and very well put<br />
together. There are a wide range of awards<br />
and it gives entrepreneurs the opportunity to<br />
receive recognition for their hard work, and<br />
motivation to continue forging their path to<br />
success.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What’s the feeling after winning<br />
Malta’s Best Young Entrepreneur of the<br />
Year?<br />
KE: I was quite surprised to have won, but<br />
I have to say that it’s inspired me to work<br />
harder than ever on the projects closest<br />
to my heart. In fact, I am now in the early<br />
stages of setting up a new project related to<br />
architecture, design, and investment.<br />
In our ongoing<br />
special feature,<br />
we speak with<br />
leading voices in the<br />
Maltese architecture<br />
community and learn<br />
about their work,<br />
development issues<br />
in our community,<br />
and good design<br />
practices and<br />
principals. Perit<br />
Karl Ebejer,<br />
Managing Partner,<br />
ME Architects, is<br />
a co-founder of<br />
ME Architects, an<br />
office positioned<br />
as a vehicle for<br />
collaboration<br />
between themselves<br />
and other designers,<br />
architects,<br />
fabricators, and<br />
most importantly,<br />
clients.<br />
ME Architects receiving the award for Malta's Best Entrepreneur of the Year Awards 2017<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Award-Winning Architect Odile Decq<br />
on Rethinking Architectural Education said,<br />
“We believe that today it is fundamental<br />
to totally rethink architectural education.<br />
Architecture must no longer be reduced to a<br />
professional or specialised education: it is a<br />
discipline that opens to the world, to a way<br />
of seeing the world and a capacity to act in<br />
the world.” Do you think Architecture today<br />
needs to have a more humanist ambition?<br />
KE: Most definitely. A lot of the time we tend<br />
to overlook the fact that with our specialised<br />
knowledge and expertise, architects have a<br />
social responsibility towards the community.<br />
It seems that as a group, architects get bogged<br />
down by fast-paced projects and forget about<br />
the bigger picture. We should be more aware<br />
of the positive impact our work can have on<br />
the community, whether it’s by creating new<br />
and innovative concepts with a humanitarian<br />
and ecological focus at their core, or by<br />
offering our services to aid organisations that<br />
look after vulnerable people and the less<br />
fortunate.<br />
It is essential that a student of<br />
architecture experiences<br />
first-hand what it means<br />
to transpose a design on<br />
paper to reality<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Can you tell us why you opened your<br />
own studio instead of working for a boss?<br />
KE: Some time ago, I was working full time<br />
with Valletta Rehabilitation Project and I was<br />
offered a few freelance jobs. With that, I had<br />
to choose between trying to juggle between<br />
both jobs, or officially going out to work on<br />
my own. I took a leap of faith and decided to<br />
focus my full attention and energy on my new<br />
clients and jobs. It was the best decision I ever<br />
made.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Could you name one project, that was<br />
important for your career and why?<br />
KE: My team and I were truly honoured to<br />
have led the design project on the John Taylor<br />
office on Tower road in Sliema. John Taylor is<br />
probably one of the most high-end property<br />
estate agents in the world. So, as you can<br />
imagine, we were quite anxious when we<br />
presented our ideas to them as we went<br />
in with a completely new and challenging<br />
concept, but the client was extremely<br />
responsive to our proposal and appreciated<br />
that it was different from other ideas that had<br />
been presented by competing architects.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What is the problem with architecture<br />
education today?<br />
KE: Unfortunately, there is no practical<br />
element within the cirriculum. During my<br />
years as a student representative, I had<br />
voiced my concerns about this on several<br />
occasions, mainly because we were hardly<br />
ever taken on site. It is essential that a student<br />
of architecture experiences first-hand what<br />
it means to transpose a design on paper to<br />
reality; where they are able to get the feel<br />
of materials, engage in carrying out a project<br />
as a team, and actually see buildings coming<br />
together before their own eyes.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: You said: “Architects need to become<br />
more entrepreneurial”. We think so too!<br />
Can you elaborate on that?<br />
KE: As I stipulated in my speech, while<br />
running an architecture firm must be borne<br />
from passion, it is essentially a business. As<br />
a firm, we must face regulatory bodies and<br />
entities from all spheres; and of course, our<br />
most important task is keeping our clients<br />
happy. And hopefully, you are also able to<br />
make some money by the end of it all, too!<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What feedback can you give us<br />
regarding Malta’s Best Entrepreneur of the<br />
Year Awards 2017?<br />
Go ahead – believe in yourself,<br />
dedicate yourself to your project<br />
and your clients, and listen to<br />
nobody but your gut.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Are business and entrepreneurship<br />
courses part of the curriculum?<br />
KE: For some reason, these two elements<br />
are completely excluded from the current<br />
curriculum, and this poses a very big problem.<br />
Modules in business, management and<br />
entrepreneurship should be compulsory<br />
at university - this would give young<br />
entrepreneurs more confidence and a solid<br />
foundation for bringing their plans to life. I’m<br />
sure it would even give those students who<br />
aren’t entrepreneurs a better skillset to deal<br />
with their day-to-day lives and jobs.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Do you have any advice for<br />
‘archipreneurs’ who are interested in<br />
starting their own business?<br />
KE: Firstly, I really like the word Archipreneurs<br />
and hope it sticks! My advice would be not<br />
to overthink it; if your instinct is to go for it,<br />
then you probably should. Go ahead – believe<br />
in yourself, dedicate yourself to your project<br />
and your clients, and listen to nobody but<br />
your gut.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How do you see the future of the<br />
architectural profession? In which areas<br />
(outside of traditional practice) can you<br />
see major opportunities for up and coming<br />
developers and architects?<br />
KE: The profession is becoming more<br />
specialised, and as of late clients are<br />
becoming more specific with their requests<br />
– to the point where clients want a team<br />
that can guide them through the whole scale<br />
and spectrum of a project. With so many<br />
existing developments, I see opportunities<br />
in refurbishment and rehabilitation of<br />
properties which are not necessarily very old,<br />
but of other very recent eras, as well new<br />
concepts focused on hubs and shared spaces<br />
for living and working. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
18 19<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Continuous loop<br />
to innovate<br />
by Martin Vella<br />
Drive for<br />
Innovation<br />
By George Carol<br />
David Abela, Managing<br />
Director at Eurobridge<br />
Shipping Services Ltd,<br />
winner of Malta’s Best<br />
International Trade<br />
Entrepreneur of the Year<br />
Award, believes that if<br />
you devote yourself to<br />
something for such a long<br />
time, you will inevitably<br />
become a master of your<br />
trade – and your legacy<br />
will pass even further…<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What has been the secret behind<br />
EUROBRIDGE’s success?<br />
DA: After all these years, I now feel that the<br />
three fundamental things one needs to be<br />
successful are work ethic, perseverance<br />
and the best team possible behind you.<br />
EuroBridge, particularly myself, have<br />
experienced various failures in the past and<br />
I am sure will continue to experience them<br />
again, but one cannot simply give up on<br />
achieving his dreams despite the difficulties<br />
he faces every day, whether these problems<br />
are small or big. That is where perseverance<br />
and work ethic come in, and if one wants to<br />
dream big, he cannot do that without the help<br />
of a great team that has the same common<br />
ambition to succeed.<br />
we will continue giving our<br />
best to innovate and be frontrunners<br />
in our industry<br />
David Abela receiving the award for Malta's Best Entrepreneur of the Year 2017 from Thea Saliba<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How do you define the EUROBRIDGE<br />
brand message and how critical is that to be<br />
consistent?<br />
DA: When I took over EuroBridge, it was still<br />
in its infancy. However, the name stuck with<br />
me especially the ‘Bridge’ part. I wanted to<br />
evolve the company into something where all<br />
connected to it felt part of something exciting<br />
and with a purpose. That is why besides<br />
the logo which shows a modern bridge in a<br />
continuous loop to innovate, I also introduced<br />
the motto ‘logistics people to count on’. This<br />
is a message goes to all out there working<br />
with us, be it suppliers or customers, that we<br />
are there for them and we will continue giving<br />
our best to innovate and be front-runners in<br />
our industry both locally and internationally.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Looking at the success and impact you<br />
had during Malta’s Best Entrepreneur of the<br />
Year Awards 2017, do you ever take time to<br />
reflect and step back and celebrate?<br />
DA: Unfortunately, not that much. I feel the<br />
company still has a lot of potential to grow so<br />
I cannot stop with the vision I have for it to<br />
catch up on what I have achieved yet, because<br />
we are simply not there yet! My wife says<br />
that this is something which I will continue<br />
saying forever, as I am always making new<br />
targets for myself and the company. To be<br />
fair, although I always worked hard, I have<br />
also always given myself time to enjoy my<br />
family and friends throughout these years.<br />
I understand that without my family, I could<br />
have never dreamed to reach such heights let<br />
alone actually achieve it. So, knowing that my<br />
family is happy for me and sharing this with<br />
them is celebration enough for me. For now.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How does winning Malta’s Best<br />
International Trade Entrepreneur of the<br />
Year Award feel?<br />
DA: It feels great, really great! Last year the<br />
company won ‘The Outstanding Industry<br />
Contributor Award’ so that makes two great<br />
awards in less than a year so this was more of<br />
a consolidation of our achievements after last<br />
year’s victory. To be recognised and rewarded<br />
by your fellow peers is the most beautiful part<br />
and I am certain I will continue making sure it<br />
was deserved. I was actually nominated for a<br />
total of five awards and that is really humbling.<br />
The target is now to be nominated and win<br />
even more in next year’s awards! <strong>MBR</strong><br />
Joseph Bigeni receiving the award for Malta's Best Entrepreneur of the Year 2017 from Margaret Brincat<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Can you tell us what is behind Il-<br />
Logga’s accomplishments?<br />
JB: Our accomplishments basically stem from<br />
our sense of togetherness. Since we are a<br />
family run company, and we are well aware<br />
of what each of us is most good at doing, so<br />
slotting ourselves into the different required<br />
roles was relatively easy. Our team is literally<br />
a family; we share our opinions freely and<br />
sometimes disagree, however our collective<br />
efforts are directed towards the best interest<br />
of ‘il-Logga’.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: You have studied both business and<br />
hospitality. How has this helped you to<br />
develop a successful business within the<br />
hospitality industry?<br />
JB: Prior to the creation of ‘il-Logga’, we<br />
have purposefully studied and worked at<br />
similar establishments to ensure that we<br />
have what it takes to run such an enterprise<br />
successfully. For instance, I graduated and<br />
worked in the accounts and business sector,<br />
as well as occupying an administrative role in<br />
a five-star hotel for an additional three years.<br />
Furthermore, my elder brother Christof is a<br />
qualified chef with nine years of experience at<br />
a handful of reputable restaurants. The blend<br />
of diverse though relatively rich accumulation<br />
of experiences complement each other<br />
seamlessly in our day-to-day operations, to<br />
address our clients’ reviews, and make key<br />
decisions.<br />
JB: Our typical day commences at 6am with our<br />
À la Carte breakfast preparations, welcoming<br />
our first residents at 8am. Whilst serving<br />
them, we assist them with their queries such<br />
as planning their holiday or suggesting places<br />
worth visiting. Our stipulated checkout time<br />
is 11am, where I am principally occupied with<br />
sorting out incurred bills and ensure that our<br />
guests were pleased. From there on, I usually<br />
manage bookings and check-ins, update our<br />
publicity and social media pages, exchange<br />
emails, and deal with our suppliers and client<br />
queries. Meanwhile, Christof would be<br />
sorting out goods delivered by our suppliers<br />
and preparing slow-cooking recipes, as the<br />
rest of the team would be handling all the<br />
cleanings. To my amazement, no matter how<br />
busy we could be, we barely finish on time<br />
to open our adjacent restaurant! Hence, we<br />
accelerate our final touches to serve dinner<br />
from 6pm till late.<br />
The blend of diverse though<br />
relatively rich accumulation of<br />
experiences complement each<br />
other seamlessly<br />
Joseph Bigeni is the Manager<br />
of Il-Logga Boutique Hotel,<br />
perched on top of a scenic hill<br />
at the outskirts of Xaghra,<br />
overlooking Marsalforn. He is<br />
an ambitious and driven young<br />
man, who would not settle for<br />
just an ordinary career path.<br />
He is from Gozo and has spent<br />
most of his career there. He has<br />
an in-depth understanding of<br />
the travellers’ culture and speaks<br />
their language. Perhaps, he<br />
understands the Maltese culture<br />
better than other Gozitans who<br />
are living and working in Gozo,<br />
or in the Maltese mainland.<br />
from an outsider’s point of view, as to it being<br />
a means of publicity for our boutique Hotel.<br />
This was a very big achievement for us so we<br />
definitely appreciate the opportunity that<br />
was given to us and celebrate it with family<br />
whenever we can.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How does winning Malta’s Best<br />
Boutique Hotel Entrepreneur of the Year<br />
Award feel?<br />
JB: The nomination in itself was already<br />
a great honour, let alone scooping such<br />
an award. This award meant a lot to us<br />
because it recognized our tireless efforts and<br />
decorated our brand with a highly prestigious<br />
label. Moreover, the event coincided with<br />
the maiden anniversary since our launch and<br />
therefore we could not have celebrated it any<br />
better. However, we are not resting on our<br />
laurels or allowing it to distract us from the<br />
determination that rewarded us with such<br />
success.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Competition has pushed independent<br />
hoteliers like yourself to think about what<br />
“boutique” means for a generation of<br />
travellers. What are the biggest challenges<br />
that you face today in improving the guest<br />
experience at the hotel?<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Looking at the success and impact you JB: Our concept of ‘boutique’ was born from<br />
had during Malta’s Best Entrepreneur of the<br />
our drive for innovation. However, this comes<br />
with an obligation that while customized<br />
Year Awards 2017, do you ever take time to<br />
service is a must, we are additionally ought to<br />
reflect and step back and celebrate?<br />
constantly update and renovate our services<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What does running your hotel involve; JB: Winning the Malta Best Entrepreneur and facilities to reflect expectations and<br />
what’s your typical day?<br />
award made us reflect and look at this award contemporary demands. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017 All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
20 21<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017 SPECIAL FEATURE: MBEOTYA 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Practical and Versatile<br />
By Martin Vella<br />
Perit Arielle Agius is the Director and Head Architect of ARCO DESIGN<br />
STUDIO, one of the foremost interior designers in Malta. She believes that<br />
her work revolves around a functional eclecticism. Established in 2012,<br />
the architecture and interior design company is firmly entrenched in the<br />
lead of the architectural market in Malta. Having projects ranging from<br />
residential designs to hospitality and commercial interiors, Arielle recently<br />
won the coveted Malta’s Best Architecture & Interior Design Entrepreneur<br />
of the Year Award.<br />
ARCO Design Studio at Malta's Best Entrepreneur of the Year Awards 2017<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What has been the secret behind<br />
ARCO DESIGN STUDIO’s success?<br />
AA: ARCO Design Studio is an architectural<br />
firm, founded in 2012. Since the very<br />
beginning my main objective was to strive<br />
for consistency in presenting excellent quality<br />
of work. Our firm is constantly thriving for<br />
great attention to detail in design, respecting<br />
deadlines, and always being up to date with<br />
Planning Authority laws and regulations. We<br />
take great care at keeping a close relation<br />
with our clients, and also follow up on their<br />
progress with regards to the commercial<br />
sector.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Leading a design studio, what’s<br />
the most important: the practical or the<br />
theoretical?<br />
AA: Being an entrepreneur means that<br />
one needs to be flexible in order to meet<br />
the vast demands of the office, colleagues,<br />
and customers. Although education does<br />
mentally prepare you to conquer challenges,<br />
experience is the true key to management.<br />
Being practical and versatile rather than<br />
theoretical.<br />
Although education does<br />
mentally prepare you to<br />
conquer challenges, experience<br />
is the true key to management<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How do you define the ARCO DESIGN<br />
STUDIO brand message and how critical is<br />
that to be consistent?<br />
AA: Realising that a designed space has much<br />
more to offer than just aesthetics, "Stepping<br />
Out Of The Ordinary" means creating<br />
particular and unique spaces reflecting our<br />
clients' needs and personalities. Obtaining<br />
a state of wellbeing within one's personal<br />
space, whether at home, work or during<br />
leisure time is crucial.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Looking at the success and impact you<br />
had during Malta’s Best Entrepreneur of the<br />
Year Awards 2017, do you ever take time to<br />
reflect and step back and celebrate?<br />
AA: Definitely! It is crucial for my team to be<br />
united and in high spirits. I firmly believe that<br />
the state of mental health and happiness is<br />
key for a successful office.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How does winning Malta’s Best<br />
Architecture & Interior Design Entrepreneur<br />
of the Year Award feel?<br />
AA: It definitely feels rewarding! I am lucky<br />
enough to have a very satisfying job, to see<br />
our projects being realised and our clients<br />
satisfied. This award has been that extra "pat<br />
on the back", and a recognition for all the<br />
hard work. It has certainly given us motivation<br />
to continue to improve our services. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
22 23<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
ARCHITECTURE<br />
Integrated Architecture<br />
MALTA<br />
BUSINESS REVIEW<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE<br />
By George Carol<br />
Photo Credits, Peter M. Mercieca/MJMDA<br />
At the core of MJMDA, there seems to<br />
be a determination to deliver ever more<br />
Integrated Design Projects. Since 2003,<br />
MJMDA has worked consistently at building a<br />
team of people that have at their core a desire<br />
to focus on a completed work of architecture<br />
as one whole. This approach is client oriented<br />
and strives to look at the end user of buildings,<br />
rather than thinking about the originators of<br />
the work. Although this sounds like a rather<br />
obvious way to work, it’s rather the opposite<br />
in many cases for architecture.<br />
‘Do we not use our buildings as a whole?<br />
Then so should our buildings be conceived<br />
and designed as a whole!’ founder, director<br />
and lead architect Matthew J. Mercieca<br />
posits. He insists this is nothing new across<br />
many of today’s advanced design systems.<br />
‘Take industrial design objects, a phone, a<br />
computer, a vehicle. All these objects have<br />
caught up with how the great designs can<br />
materialise.’ He stressed that the integration<br />
of structure, services and aesthetics<br />
constitute the architecture of the future.<br />
Challenges in the scale of buildings and lack of<br />
mass-production for architecture, makes this<br />
aim no mean feat he admits. ‘This approach<br />
may not suit every project type, and requires<br />
more effort and organization, but the benefits<br />
of such an approach creates longer term<br />
success in the performance and usability of<br />
these buildings.’ It is about aesthetics and<br />
beauty, but it is also about functionality and<br />
performance for the team MJMDA.<br />
Being technical and target driven however<br />
does not mean that MJMDA have lost their<br />
taste for passion, romance and poetry in their<br />
work. Quite the contrary, MJMDA seem to<br />
have acquired the skills to deliver solutions<br />
from simplest buildings (haiku) to the more<br />
complex (Iliad). Capability of complexity<br />
means that simplicity should be more<br />
reachable. But the inverse is less likely to be<br />
possible.<br />
MJMDA has a team of professionals spanning<br />
Architectural Design, Interior Design,<br />
Structural Engineering, Building Services<br />
Engineering and Project Management in<br />
order to make possible a closely co-ordinated<br />
response to building programs covering<br />
several sectors. MJMDA’s 18-strong team<br />
works on projects ranging from small homes<br />
with personal touches and detail, to high end<br />
villas to stun, to multipurpose buildings and<br />
rental apartments with a taste for the unique,<br />
great working spaces and offices, retail and<br />
food and beverage outlets. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
ADDRESS BY THE PRIME MINISTER<br />
DR JOSEPH MUSCAT<br />
Addressing the 7th Cohesion Forum in<br />
Brussels today, Prime Minister Joseph<br />
Muscat stated that “Cohesion Policy is<br />
synonymous with and the personification<br />
of European solidarity at its best”, and called<br />
for “simple yet solid rules that can be used in<br />
the current programming period, at a time<br />
when European economies are taking off”.<br />
Prime Minister Muscat maintained that<br />
the Cohesion Policy is at the heart of the<br />
Union’s work for its citizens, that it supports<br />
policies affecting people’s everyday life, and<br />
advocates for an improved quality of life<br />
across the European continent.<br />
The Prime Minister said that the Cohesion<br />
Policy’s primary objective is to ensure citizens<br />
are better off at the end of each programming<br />
period regardless of how diverse the socioeconomic<br />
situations of each member state<br />
are.<br />
While commenting on the principle behind<br />
the policy, Dr Muscat noted how Malta has<br />
made its own contribution to it by modifying<br />
the rules to guarantee additional assistance to<br />
Member States affected by natural disasters,<br />
demonstrating the EU’s willingness to stand<br />
by its citizens when they need it the most.<br />
The Prime Minister stated that the vision for<br />
the future of the Cohesion Policy is a policy<br />
that fulfils the needs of communities by<br />
turning opportunities into prosperity, and<br />
that supports the Union’s strategic projects.<br />
He remarked that his vision is one where<br />
rules are simplified so that even the smallest<br />
communities and businesses can benefit.<br />
Dr Muscat concluded by saying that it is<br />
ultimately government’s responsibility to<br />
create the right environment for the policy to<br />
work. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
Malta’s Prime Minister Joseph Muscat at the 7th Cohesion Forum in Brussels. Photos: OPM<br />
24 www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
25
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Overcoming<br />
economic and<br />
political challenges<br />
together<br />
Günther Oettinger, European Commissioner<br />
for Budget and Human Resources reflects on<br />
the future role for Cohesion Policy<br />
in the EU’s budget<br />
Communicating the results of Cohesion<br />
Policy in an effective manner is a must.<br />
It is a shared responsibility with the Member<br />
States, local and regional authorities<br />
How can the next financial period be<br />
more in tune with current political<br />
and economic challenges?<br />
This is exactly what the reflection process<br />
on the future of the EU at 27 launched by<br />
the Commission should tell us. Together<br />
with my colleague Commissioner Creţu, I am<br />
preparing a reflection paper on the future<br />
of the EU’s finances. It will contribute to the<br />
debate on the future of Europe together<br />
with other papers on the EU’s political and<br />
economic priorities: the social dimension of<br />
Europe, globalisation, defence and the future<br />
of the Economic and Monetary Union. It will<br />
present the various issues, options and tradeoffs<br />
which we might have to address based on<br />
which scenarios we choose for the future of<br />
the EU.<br />
I want this to be a positive debate. I believe<br />
this is possible: as long as the EU budget is<br />
better aligned with political priorities and<br />
focuses on programmes and policy areas<br />
with clear European added value. "No euro<br />
I am particularly encouraged by the<br />
common recognition of the key role the EU<br />
budget plays in the European construction,<br />
that it brings stability and is an expression<br />
of solidarity and the value of doing<br />
things together<br />
spent without EU added value" should be our<br />
guiding principle, reflecting that Europe can<br />
best overcome both economic and political<br />
challenges together.<br />
What role do you see for Cohesion<br />
Policy beyond 2020 in helping<br />
Europe's economy grow?<br />
Cohesion Policy has been a driver for<br />
economic growth and jobs and has helped<br />
many regions to develop. Therefore, it clearly<br />
has European added value. During and in<br />
the aftermath of the economic and financial<br />
crises it helped to prevent major disruptions<br />
in many regions. So, this policy should remain<br />
an important part of the future EU budget.<br />
But we should be thinking if we can further<br />
enhance its EU added value by focusing even<br />
more on projects that contribute strongly to<br />
EU priorities, notably growth and jobs. An<br />
important question is whether we should<br />
focus more on regions in need. We need<br />
to reflect how we can help regions that<br />
are strongly affected by globalisation and<br />
technological change. And finally, we need<br />
to be mindful to simplify its implementation<br />
rules in order to reduce the administrative<br />
burden for everyone.<br />
What I also find quite convincing, based on<br />
current experience, is that cohesion policy<br />
is most effective when combined with a<br />
national economic framework conducive to<br />
growth, i.e. where the necessary structural<br />
reforms are being carried out to ensure the<br />
relevant legal framework, administrative<br />
capacity and business environment are in<br />
place. So for me, the link between Cohesion<br />
Pol- icy and the larger economic governance<br />
agenda should be strengthened in the next<br />
financial framework.<br />
How would/can Cohesion Policy help<br />
the EU reconnect with its citizens?<br />
The best way Cohesion Policy can demonstrate<br />
its value to the EU citizens is by<br />
meeting their needs and expectations: deliver<br />
jobs and growth and contribute to addressing<br />
new priorities such as energy security,<br />
migration and defence and security.<br />
Of course, communicating the results of<br />
Cohesion policy in an effective manner is<br />
also a must. Communication is a shared<br />
responsibility with the Member States,<br />
local and regional authorities. But, while<br />
the regulations include a legal obligation<br />
to provide information about the projects<br />
funded by Cohesion Policy, it is important to<br />
find the right distribution channels and to<br />
target the right audience so as to ensure the<br />
message gets across about the benefits of<br />
European support.<br />
The concrete actions to be taken must use all<br />
the existing tools, engage with the national,<br />
regional and local authorities, and also<br />
balance the use of media and social media<br />
campaigns with public debates/events that<br />
both raise awareness and give people the<br />
opportunity to give their feedback.<br />
Various people and associations with<br />
different interests have expressed their<br />
own views on the future Multiannual<br />
Financial Framework (MFF). Do you<br />
see one or more common threads in<br />
those opinions and, if yes, which ones?<br />
I am particularly encouraged by the common<br />
recognition of the key role the EU budget plays<br />
in the European construction, that it brings<br />
stability and is an expression of solidarity<br />
and the value of doing things together. The<br />
demand to make the budget more responsive<br />
to changing political priorities and to bring it<br />
closer to the EU citizens is certainly a common<br />
thread.<br />
These are valid expectations of course, but<br />
there are different ways and views on how<br />
to achieve them. At this stage, I have no<br />
preconceived ideas on what the future MFF<br />
should look like... it is simply too early to say.<br />
Although I have my preferences of course, most<br />
importantly I remain open to all stakeholders'<br />
views and the results of the public debate on<br />
the future of the EU at 27. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
Creditline: European Commission, Panorama Spring<br />
2017<br />
26 www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
27
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
INTERVIEW WITH MICHAEL STORPER<br />
PROFESSOR OF ECONOMIC GEOGRAPHY<br />
AT THE LONDON SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS<br />
Regions matter<br />
more than ever<br />
in a globalised<br />
world<br />
Shortly before the Commission<br />
published the reflection paper on<br />
Harnessing Globalisation, it<br />
organised a high-level seminar<br />
on ‘Globalisation: Why regions<br />
matter’ to discuss the geography<br />
of growth, jobs and inequalities<br />
in Europe, as globalisation,<br />
technological change and<br />
sustainable development impact<br />
EU regions in different ways.<br />
Professor Michael Storper<br />
attended this seminar.<br />
You started your presentation by<br />
quoting The Economist saying:<br />
“Regional inequality is proving too<br />
politically dangerous to ignore”, and<br />
you go on to note that this inequality<br />
further accentuates the dilemma we<br />
have about whether to invest in more<br />
developed or less developed regions. So<br />
what is more important: efficiency or<br />
equity?<br />
For this high-level meeting I worked with<br />
my colleagues Simona Iammarino and<br />
Andres Rodriguez-Pose to prepare a study<br />
entitled ‘Regional Development at the<br />
Centre of Europe’s Economic Future’. We<br />
argue that there is no longer a simple tradeoff<br />
between efficiency and equity: this is an<br />
outmoded idea if by “efficiency” we mean<br />
that we concentrate everything in the highest<br />
income regions and expect that there will be a<br />
diffusion of benefits to all other regions.<br />
The mechanisms of diffusion have weakened:<br />
skills are becoming concentrated in<br />
fewer places; innovation is doing the same;<br />
migration is slowing down and becoming<br />
more selective, with one circuit for skilled<br />
people and another for the less skilled. This<br />
means that in the long-run, people who are<br />
being underutilised in many regions cannot<br />
develop their talents, it is more and more<br />
difficult to migrate, and entrepreneurs are<br />
not able to effectively enter the market.<br />
We want to get the benefits<br />
of concentration and specialisation,<br />
but we also want to spread these benefits<br />
to more regions by overcoming the<br />
barriers to innovation, entrepreneurship,<br />
skilling and mobility that exist<br />
Therefore, a policy that invests in the long term<br />
capabilities of people, firms and individuals in<br />
all regions will be more efficient than one that<br />
assumes that geographical concentration will<br />
benefit all people and all regions. At the same<br />
time, this is not an either-or: we must continue<br />
to support Europe’s world-class metropolitan<br />
regions and clusters in the face of ongoing<br />
global competition. This policy is based on<br />
a redefined notion of “equity”: it rejects the<br />
older notion of redistributing from the most<br />
successful regions to all other regions, and<br />
replaces it with a definition of equity that<br />
is based on stimulating development in all<br />
regions.<br />
Indeed, you mention talents, and you<br />
might already know that regional<br />
policy has introduced a new concept:<br />
smart specialisation. This basically<br />
means that we encourage regions to<br />
identify their own strengths, their<br />
comparative advantages, and invest<br />
in those areas. And you also introduce<br />
in your presentation a policy based<br />
on differentiation. Do you find<br />
similarities between the two?<br />
Yes, we propose to deepen the concept<br />
of smart specialisation and to give it some<br />
additional tools so that it can be more<br />
effective. Realistically, not every region can<br />
specialise in the same type of thing: thus,<br />
there's no point in pro- posing that every<br />
region should try to become a ‘little Silicon<br />
Valley’.<br />
Instead of a blanket approach to innovation<br />
and specialisation, we introduce the concept<br />
of ‘development clubs’ which refers to regions<br />
at different levels of per-capita income. The<br />
challenges and near-term goals for low-,<br />
middle- and high-income regions are very<br />
different. What is ‘smart’ is for regions to<br />
understand which development club they<br />
are in, and their realistic smart specialisations<br />
in the medium term. This notion gives<br />
additional precision to the concept of smart<br />
specialisation.<br />
Lastly, I would paraphrase the title of<br />
your presentation: Globalisation: do<br />
regions matter?<br />
In fact, globalisation has made regions matter<br />
more and more, because it turns out that<br />
while globalisation spreads wealth around<br />
the world, and there are 500 million Chinese<br />
who have now entered the global middle class<br />
because of it, at the same time within every<br />
country it concentrates wealth and income in<br />
metropolitan areas around the world, in every<br />
country. So, regions actually matter more<br />
than ever in a globalised world. In light of this,<br />
we want to get the benefits of concentra- tion<br />
and specialisation, but we also want to spread<br />
these benefits to more regions by overcoming<br />
the barriers to innovation, entrepreneurship,<br />
skilling and mobility that exist. These barriers<br />
are in some way being reinforced by current<br />
market trends, and diffusion mechanisms are<br />
too weak to do the job of spreading wealth<br />
and opportunity.<br />
To do this, we propose what we call ‘placesensitive<br />
distributed development strategies’<br />
(PSDDP), which are develop- ment strategies<br />
adapted to the precise but different needs<br />
of low-, middle- and high-income clubs of<br />
regions in Europe. Each of these clubs has a<br />
different strategic guiding principle and hence<br />
different mixes of policies and measures for<br />
each type of territory. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
Creditline: European Commission, Panorama Spring<br />
2017<br />
28 www.maltabusinessreview.net 29
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
The EU'S future<br />
finances<br />
The High-level group on own resources (HLGOR)<br />
was established in February 2014 to reflect<br />
on finding more transparent, simple, fair and<br />
democratically accountable ways to finance the<br />
EU. The Group was chaired by former Italian<br />
Prime Minister and EU Commissioner Mario<br />
Monti and comprises members designated by<br />
the European Parliament, the Council and the<br />
European Commission. The final report and<br />
recommendations were presented in the European<br />
Parliament and in the Council in January 2017.<br />
In your view, what are the major<br />
challenges for EU finances after 2020?<br />
The major challenges for EU finances<br />
are already here today and are similar to<br />
the challenges the EU itself faces: how<br />
can we regain trust from our citi- zens?<br />
How can we provide more legit- imacy to<br />
European spending? The EU has been hit<br />
by multiple crises in recent years, most of<br />
them highlighting new priorities: reinforce<br />
the competitiveness of the European<br />
economy, and in par- ticular address youth<br />
unemployment; secure our external borders<br />
and improve our cooperation on internal<br />
security and defence; fulfil our commitments<br />
to fight climate change and environmental<br />
deg- radation; and finally, ensure a smooth<br />
transition from EU-28 to EU-27 when the UK<br />
leaves the EU.<br />
These are the issues<br />
on which the EU is<br />
expected and being<br />
pressured to act on<br />
today, and yet they<br />
are often not part of<br />
its traditional core<br />
business, in particular internal and external<br />
security which remain within the realm of<br />
national sovereignty. Although recent annual<br />
budgets have used the flexibility tools, their<br />
implementation remains to be seen.<br />
What major changes are you proposing<br />
compared to the current system?<br />
Reforming the revenue system is part of this<br />
overall shift, because the current financing<br />
system – based on an over- whelming share of<br />
national contributions from Member States –<br />
EU policies, and notably<br />
cohesion, benefit to all countries,<br />
even the 'net contributors'<br />
favours the status quo and are a hindrance to<br />
focusing on new needs. Thus, in the High-level<br />
group on own resources’ report, we make<br />
nine recommendations conducive to change.<br />
Among these, I think the most likely to have<br />
a strong impact are the focus on expenditure<br />
with the highest European added value,<br />
the abolition of rebates in favour of certain<br />
countries, and the introduction of one or<br />
several new own resources linked to EU<br />
flagship policies. For example, own resources<br />
Future Structural Investment Funds<br />
will play a crucial part in our reform<br />
efforts because they have often been in<br />
the crossfire of criticism for financing<br />
too many projects with questionable<br />
European added value<br />
based on a common reformed VAT or a<br />
common corporate tax can be designed to<br />
contribute to a better functioning of the Single<br />
Market, to simplify the life of our companies,<br />
and to support the fight against tax fraud<br />
or evasion; environmental own resources<br />
can contribute to decarbonisation efforts<br />
and green growth. In my view, this latter<br />
recommendation represents how EU revenue<br />
can bring extra added value: the EU cannot<br />
levy taxes, but its revenue can contribute to<br />
achieving EU policies and objectives.<br />
What are the major obstacles to<br />
making those changes possible?<br />
The most obvious obstacle lies in the decisionmaking<br />
procedure applicable to the financing<br />
system, which imbeds an asymmetry of<br />
power between the European Parliament<br />
and the Council. The European Parliament<br />
is only consulted on own resources, while<br />
its consent is required for the multiannual<br />
financial framework, and it co-decides on the<br />
annual budget. In addition, decisions within<br />
the Council must be taken at unanimity and<br />
after ratification in all national parliaments.<br />
This is the heaviest procedure that exists.<br />
There are other obstacles linked to the fact<br />
that in most cases leaders who go through<br />
one negotiation are rarely present at a<br />
second, which dis- perses the memory and<br />
experience, or leads to misunderstanding<br />
about how EU finances work. A common<br />
fallacious argument used to reject real own<br />
resources, for example, is to consider that<br />
only national contributions allow for Member<br />
State control over EU finances, and that<br />
more autonomous own resources would<br />
lead to uncontrolled budget increases. This<br />
is not the case. Real own resources would<br />
change the composition of revenue (and<br />
lower national contributions). The volume<br />
of the budget is decided by the multiannual<br />
financial framework. And since the EU budget<br />
must be in balance and cannot resort to debt,<br />
revenue is automatically calculated once the<br />
expenditure is known – not the other way<br />
around.<br />
What place do you see for the<br />
European Structural and Investment<br />
Funds?<br />
Future Structural and Investment Funds<br />
will play a crucial part in our reform efforts<br />
Executive Summary &<br />
Recommendations available in 23<br />
languages: http://ec.europa.eu/<br />
budget/mff/hlgor/index_en.cfm<br />
because they have often been in the crossfire<br />
of criticism for financing too many projects<br />
with questionable European added value.<br />
This is particularly true in the more developed<br />
regions in the richer Member States.<br />
Moreover, their financing through national<br />
envelopes makes it a major feature of the<br />
focus on net balances.<br />
Future reform will have the difficult task of<br />
claiming back the legitimacy of EU action in<br />
many regions, by focusing on EU-wide public<br />
goods rather than local ones. It will also need<br />
to show the benefits they bring beyond<br />
the immediate beneficiaries. Crossborder<br />
benefits, spillover or leverage effects are<br />
currently ignored or hidden in budgetary<br />
negotiations, yet they provide a measure of<br />
European added value. This needs to change<br />
to make the budget more transparent,<br />
accountable and fair. EU policies, notably<br />
cohesion, benefit all countries, even the ‘net<br />
contributors’. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
Creditline: European Commission, Panorama Spring<br />
2017<br />
30 www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
31
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Calling for strengthened cohesion, improved<br />
employment opportunities and living conditions<br />
<strong>MBR</strong> interviews Corina Crețu, EU Commissioner for<br />
Regional Policy during the 7th Cohesion Forum in Brussels<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Your colleague spoke of a bottom<br />
up approach and another colleague also<br />
mentioned that the cohesion policy is one<br />
of the most controlled yet less understood.<br />
How does the EU intend to communicate<br />
the results of the cohesion policy in an<br />
effective way both on a local and regional<br />
scale, to insure that the mistakes of the past<br />
are not repeated?<br />
CC: As you rightly mention, it is very<br />
important to learn from our lessons and I<br />
am very pleased for the Maltese Presidency<br />
and how they handled most of the agenda,<br />
including the issue of the communication<br />
towards a common idea. We have discussed<br />
in Luxembourg and in Malta with all the<br />
ministers of this idea and I think it’s very<br />
important to raise awareness. Of course<br />
wherever I go, I try to visit very important<br />
project locations and institutions funded<br />
by European money. For instance I visited a<br />
hospital in Malta, which is a state of the art<br />
and it’s an example of high quality standard.<br />
I visited the Citadel in Gozo, which has been<br />
recently restored by European funding,<br />
giving to Malta a very important jewel back<br />
to its heritage. I try to do this in all countries<br />
but obviously one person cannot do what all<br />
the members of the states can do together!<br />
Cohesion policy needs to reflect<br />
on the demanding challenge<br />
of making Europe's economy<br />
more inclusive, competitive and<br />
resilient<br />
We have this proposal of alliances between<br />
member states, ministers, regional, local<br />
authorities and we have to be fair to one<br />
another of course, especially if it concerns a<br />
big investment funded by European money.<br />
Many mayors attempted to say that it is<br />
Corina Crețu, Commissioner Regional Policy and Martin Vella, <strong>MBR</strong> Publications Ltd.<br />
CORINA CREȚU<br />
by Martin Vella<br />
EU Commissioner (2014-2019)<br />
Regional Policy<br />
their achievement, which is true, but they<br />
should mention that European money was<br />
the catalyst and without it no project would<br />
have been made. There are countries like<br />
Greece for instance, where 75% of all public<br />
investments are done by European money<br />
and people still don’t know what happened<br />
to thousands of schools, bridges and now the<br />
temple Valley which is the tunnel of under<br />
Olympic mountain. Everything is done by<br />
European money so I really think we have to<br />
make a common effort, including with you<br />
journalists.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: And what is exactly the EU regional<br />
policy and how significant is this event?<br />
CC: EU regional policy is an investment policy.<br />
It supports job creation, competitiveness,<br />
economic growth, improved quality of life and<br />
sustainable development. These investments<br />
support the delivery of the Europe 2020<br />
strategy.<br />
The event is a milestone in the preparations<br />
for the post-2020 framework for the European<br />
Structural and Investment Funds. Cohesion<br />
policy needs to reflect on the demanding<br />
challenge of making Europe's economy more<br />
inclusive, competitive and resilient and must<br />
address the questions raised by the White<br />
paper on the future of Europe about the<br />
added value of EU policies, subsidiarity, and<br />
gaps between promise and delivery.<br />
The 7th Cohesion Forum is contributing to<br />
the reflection about the future design of the<br />
cohesion policy, and this in a context marked<br />
by profound and rapid changes affecting our<br />
European societies and the globalised world.<br />
Today, things are looking up: the EU's<br />
economy overall is in its 5th year of recovery.<br />
Private investment is picking up. EU GDP<br />
growth is expected to remain constant this<br />
year and next, at 1.9%.<br />
And employment is at its highest level ever<br />
with, in the first quarter of 2017, 234.2 million<br />
employed in the European Union.<br />
But, at the same time, as you just heard,<br />
globalisation and digitalisation are changing<br />
the way we live and work. We are in an era<br />
of rapid change, and our labour markets are<br />
feeling the pressure.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: So what opportunities exist with all<br />
these challenges?<br />
CC: While globalisation and digitalisation<br />
confront us with new challenges, they also<br />
offer abundant opportunities: For example:<br />
the value of the data economy is expected<br />
to increase to 739 billion euro by 2020. This<br />
is 4% of EU GDP – so, more than double its<br />
value today.<br />
Green Growth and the circular economy<br />
will also generate challenges but many new<br />
opportunities as well in many sectors such as<br />
energy efficiency or the automotive industry.<br />
These evolutions represent large new<br />
markets for EU companies and it is not only<br />
big corporations who benefit: over 80 % of<br />
European exporters are small and mediumsized<br />
enterprises.<br />
But I understand many Europeans also feel<br />
apprehensive. They see globalisation and<br />
digitalisation as synonymous to job losses and<br />
unfair conditions.<br />
To remain competitive, our companies will<br />
have to anticipate market changes and our<br />
people will have to gain the right skills for<br />
today's and tomorrow's jobs.<br />
The Commission has provided responses to<br />
these challenges in the European Pillar of<br />
Social Rights, and proposed options in the<br />
Reflections Papers on the social dimension of<br />
Europe and on harnessing globalisation.<br />
Our social goals are firmly<br />
anchored in Article 3 of the<br />
Treaty: calling for strengthened<br />
cohesion, improved<br />
employment opportunities and<br />
living conditions.<br />
On the world stage, the EU needs to work<br />
towards a sustainable global order, based<br />
on shared values, and an effective and<br />
enforceable global rulebook that addresses<br />
new global challenges in a fair manner, such<br />
as tax evasion or social dumping, for example.<br />
Within Europe, the combination of<br />
globalisation and digitalisation has increased<br />
the demand for skilled labour; but reduced<br />
the number of jobs for those with lower<br />
qualifications or executing simple and<br />
repetitive tasks. We must, therefore, take<br />
steps to increase the skills of all Europeans to<br />
enhance their employability and equip them<br />
with the necessary talents for innovation and<br />
competitiveness.<br />
This is the main objective of the New Skills<br />
Agenda for Europe launched one year ago,<br />
including the Digital Skills and jobs Coalition<br />
and a Recommendation on Key Competence.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How can the EU turn the New Skills<br />
Agenda for Europe into reality?<br />
CC: To turn the New Skills Agenda for<br />
Europe into reality, we need well targeted<br />
EU investments to empower people: to help<br />
them harness the potential of change, and<br />
protect them against any new risks.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What is the key to people<br />
empowerment?<br />
CC: The key to people empowerment is<br />
investment in human capital. This is the<br />
raison d'être of the European Social Fund. It<br />
helps prepare people for the labour market -<br />
which is the best vehicle out of poverty and<br />
exclusion.<br />
It helps create new and quality job<br />
opportunities – and, together with the<br />
Erasmus+ programme, it supports vocational<br />
training and apprenticeship empowering<br />
people to enter or stay on a quickly evolving<br />
labour market.<br />
Moreover, it encourages people to be mobile<br />
and available for whenever, wherever and<br />
whatever new jobs emerge, as a result of<br />
globalisation. Therefore we need to further<br />
develop what I would call the Single Labour<br />
Market, offering professional experiences<br />
and jobs opportunities beyond the national<br />
boundaries.<br />
Globalisation, digitalisation and Green<br />
Growth create opportunities and challenges,<br />
hopes and fears. Their benefits are neither<br />
automatic nor evenly distributed. So,<br />
reconciling economic and sustainable growth<br />
with social progress is ever more relevant<br />
today.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What about our social goals?<br />
CC: Our social goals are firmly anchored in<br />
Article 3 of the Treaty: calling for strengthened<br />
cohesion, improved employment<br />
opportunities and living conditions.<br />
And they are clearly echoed in the Rome<br />
Declaration on the Future of Europe where<br />
Member States have solemnly declared that:<br />
'Taken individually, we would be side-lined by<br />
global dynamics. Standing together is our best<br />
chance to influence them and to defend our<br />
common interests and values'.<br />
All levels need to work together to make our<br />
European social market economy resilient<br />
and sustainable in a globalised world.<br />
We need strong and targeted investment in<br />
people to meet our social goals - and to deliver<br />
the principles of fairness, social protection<br />
and equal opportunity - as espoused in the<br />
European Pillar of Social Rights. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
32 33<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
DATA POINT: 3 - OPEN DATA PLATFORM<br />
Communicating on ESIF performance: the<br />
growing importance of common indicators<br />
The need to monitor and report on performance<br />
must be a shared responsibility and an essential<br />
part of all meaningful debates on EU policy.<br />
he 2014-2020 programmes have seen improvements in the use of<br />
indicators to measure the outputs and results of the different ESI Funds<br />
– common indicators are a powerful tool to communicate aggregate<br />
policy achievements across Member States. These developments have<br />
accompanied other performance-related improve- ments, such as the<br />
more robust setting of objectives, clearer target setting, and the new<br />
performance framework linked to the performance reserve. One of the<br />
effects of a greater focus on performance is that indicators must no<br />
longer be the concern of a few technicians.<br />
The current system of indicators has been developed over the years<br />
based on experience and learning specific to each fund. Thus, the<br />
common indicators are common to the programmes under each<br />
TWO EXAMPLES FROM THE ESF AND ERDF BY END-2015<br />
ESF: Participant employment status<br />
Implemented: 2 707 055 participants<br />
Of which<br />
Unemployment supported: 1574509 participants<br />
Employed: 435 940 participants<br />
Inactive supported: 696 606 participants<br />
specific fund with indicators adapted to the fund- specific objectives,<br />
the target sectors and the intervention rationale applied.<br />
Two main concerns have influenced the choice of indicator concepts<br />
and the definition of common indicators:<br />
> Are the indicators a meaningful measure of the interventions and<br />
objectives of the specific fund?<br />
> Are the indicators readily available without creating excessive cost<br />
and burden for managers and beneficiaries?<br />
For the period 2014-2020, the answers to those questions were<br />
developed in partnership with stakeholders and experts from the<br />
Member States during several years of reflection.<br />
The most visible product of the current indicator system on the ESIF<br />
open data platform is the presentation of ‘achievement’ tiles for<br />
common indicators by fund and by theme.<br />
0<br />
2 500 000<br />
2 000 000<br />
1 500 000<br />
1 000 000<br />
500 000<br />
Other improvements include an expanded list of common indicators<br />
and better methodologies for collecting and reporting ERDF and ESF<br />
indicators.<br />
Are there too many indicators?<br />
This question has been raised at the highest level of the EU institutions,<br />
not least because it would be simpler to commu- nicate at the EU<br />
level with a few, easy-to-aggregate indicators. The European Court of<br />
Auditors also recently questioned the relevance and use of so many<br />
programme-specific indicators and the difficulty of their aggregation to<br />
the EU level.<br />
On the other hand, different stakeholders have different needs and<br />
propose a broad range of indicators, many of which are relevant for<br />
them and already available in their region or Member State.<br />
MANY COMMON INDICATORS BY FUND TRANSLATE<br />
TO A FEW INDICATORS BY ‘THEME’: THE ERDF CASE<br />
RTDI:<br />
6 indicators<br />
Energy Climate:<br />
5 indicators<br />
Social Infra:<br />
2 indicators<br />
Another explanation for the seemingly large number of EU common<br />
indicators is the very wide thematic scope of actions and sectors<br />
financed by the ESI Funds. For instance, there are 46 common<br />
indicators for the ERDF.<br />
ERDF: Firms receiving support<br />
Planned: 1 098 048 enterprises<br />
Decided: 137 463 Enterprises<br />
Implemented: 36 379 Enterprises<br />
Overview of programme targets<br />
ICT:<br />
1 indicators<br />
Environment:<br />
7 indicators<br />
URBAN:<br />
4 indicators<br />
Firms:<br />
9 indicators<br />
Transport:<br />
6 indicators<br />
Interreg:<br />
6 indicators<br />
Austria Malta Cyprus Romania Netherlands Latvia Denmark Croatia Slovenia<br />
Bulgaria<br />
Belgium<br />
Perhaps the right questions are: “Do the common indicators capture<br />
key achievements in the different thematic areas?” and “Are there<br />
areas where we do not capture key achievements?”<br />
Where to next?<br />
In the debate on the post-2020 EU multiannual financial framework<br />
and the future of shared management through the ESI Funds, the issue<br />
of performance and measuring achievement is a hot topic. The main<br />
questions are:<br />
> Can we improve the measurement of the funds’ performance while<br />
reducing the burden for stakeholders?<br />
> Can the different indicator concepts be rationalised across the funds?<br />
Do different stakeholders need different indicators?<br />
> Would there be benefits in the definition of common EU indicators<br />
across funds to measure and communicate achievements?<br />
> Should we focus on reducing the number of specific national<br />
indicators? Or is the quality of the indicators and their policy relevance<br />
more important?<br />
It may seem like a technical debate but it is a key one for the future of<br />
the policy. Watch this space or, better still, engage in it! <strong>MBR</strong><br />
Creditline: European Commission, Panorama Spring 2017<br />
FIND OUT MORE<br />
ESIF Open Data platform:<br />
https://cohesiondata.ec.europa.eu/ Select the "achievement" sections on the<br />
"Theme", "Country" or "Fund" pages:<br />
Open Data FAQ on “Achievements”:<br />
http://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/en/faq/about_open_data/<br />
ECA special report No 2/2017: The Commission’s negotiation of 2014-2020<br />
Partnership Agreements and programmes in Cohesion: http://www.eca.europa.eu/<br />
en/Pages/ DocItem.aspx?did=41008<br />
Finland<br />
Slovak Republic<br />
Czech Republic<br />
Germany Poland Hungary Ireland Italy<br />
Sweden<br />
Spain<br />
Portugal<br />
France<br />
Interreg<br />
United Kingdom<br />
Greece<br />
Estonia<br />
Overview of program implemented values (2015)<br />
Employed Inactive supported Unemployed supported<br />
Implementation Progress<br />
Cyprus Hungary Austria Croatia Luxembourg Slovenia Denmark Estonia Slovak Republic<br />
Sweden<br />
Netherlands<br />
United Kingdom<br />
Greece<br />
Poland<br />
Bulgaria<br />
Czech Republic<br />
Lithuania<br />
Finland<br />
Latvia<br />
Portugal<br />
Ireland Belgium Germany Italy France Spain<br />
0,0 % 20,0 % 40,0 % 60,0 % 80,0 %<br />
Planned Decided Implemented<br />
100,0 %<br />
34<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
35
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
9 WAYS COHESION POLICY WORKS FOR EUROPE<br />
MAIN RESULTS 2007-2013<br />
Cohesion Policy funding as<br />
a % of government capital<br />
investment 2007-2013<br />
EU28 = 6.5% Average<br />
60%<br />
50%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
57.1<br />
52.1<br />
52.1<br />
50.5<br />
42.5<br />
40.9<br />
38.7<br />
34.3<br />
39.4<br />
27.5<br />
25.1<br />
24.5<br />
EU Cohesion Policy investments in 2007-2013<br />
were a vital source of Finance for many<br />
Member States, representing up to 57% of<br />
government capital investment.<br />
20%<br />
18.9<br />
Cohesion Policy 2007-2013 was implemented in challenging times. Europe<br />
was hit by the economic and financial crisis, which limited public<br />
investment – making Cohesion Policy funds even more vital for growth<br />
and job creation.<br />
An independent expert evaluation of 2007-2013 funding found that<br />
Cohesion Policy investments had positive, tangible results ranging from<br />
job creation, positive impact on regional disparities and an increase<br />
in GDP.<br />
H<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
Lithuania<br />
Slovakia<br />
Latvia<br />
Malta<br />
Poland<br />
Estonia<br />
Bulgaria<br />
Czech Republic<br />
Portugal<br />
Romania<br />
Slovenia<br />
2. SMES GET THE SUPPORT THEY NEED<br />
Hungary<br />
7.1<br />
Italy<br />
Spain<br />
Cyprus<br />
Greece<br />
7<br />
4.4<br />
3.9<br />
2.5<br />
1.7<br />
1.1<br />
1.1<br />
France<br />
Finland<br />
Germany<br />
UK<br />
Sweden<br />
Austria<br />
Ireland<br />
Belgium<br />
1<br />
0.8<br />
0.7<br />
0.7<br />
0.4<br />
0.4<br />
0.2<br />
Denmark<br />
Luxembourg<br />
Netherlands<br />
€346.5 billion invested<br />
to reduce disparities between regions and to promote balanced and sustainable development.<br />
1. BENEFITS <strong>ALL</strong> EU COUNTRIES<br />
Every region and country in the EU benefits from Cohesion Policy, via the direct effects of the investments and/or the indirect<br />
effects like increased trade.<br />
€1 € €€€ €2,74<br />
€1 of Cohesion Policy investment during 2007-2013<br />
will generate €2.74 of additional GDP by 2023.<br />
€346.5 billion<br />
invested in 2007-2013<br />
Estimated return nearly €1 trillion<br />
of additional GDP by 2023<br />
121 400 start-ups were financially supported, as well as an estimated number of<br />
400 000 SMEs.<br />
Cohesion Policy is an essential pillar of the EU’s jobs and growth agenda.<br />
3. FINANCING AVAILABLE FOR BUSINESSES<br />
EU funding for financial instruments has increased considerably, rising from<br />
€1 billion in 2000-2006 to €11.5 billion allocated in 2007-2013 through the<br />
European Regional Development Fund (ERDF).<br />
Financial instruments played a crucial role in providing funding to SMEs during<br />
the credit crunch of the economic crisis – helping many firms stay in business.<br />
4. EXTENDS AND IMPROVES TRANSPORT NETWORKS AND MOBILITY<br />
EU funding has contributed to removing transport bottlenecks and reducing<br />
travel times.<br />
The investments led to the construction of 4900 km of roads, mostly<br />
motorways, of which 2400 km of TEN-T networks.<br />
€<br />
€<br />
1 million jobs<br />
created in 2007-2013<br />
1/3<br />
of net job creation<br />
during that period<br />
Funding also led to the construction or upgrading of 1500 km of TEN-T railway<br />
and supported the development of sustainable public transport.<br />
36 www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
37
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
5. PRESERVES THE ENVIRONMENT, SUPPORTS THE FIGHT AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE<br />
6. BOOSTS CULTURE AND TOURISM<br />
Better waste-management strategies have led to a substantial increase<br />
in the proportion of recycled waste, and to the closure of landfill sites<br />
below EU standards.<br />
Energy efficiency measures in public buildings reduced the<br />
consumption of fossil fuels considerably, which in turn helped to cut<br />
energy costs and contributed to fight global warming.<br />
Investments in infrastructure connected 6 million people to new or<br />
improved supplies of clean drinking water and 7 million people to new<br />
or upgraded wastewater treatment facilities.<br />
EU investments helped rebuild cultural and touristic sites, which<br />
increased the number of visitors and gave a boost to sustainable<br />
economic development and job creation in the concerned regions.<br />
Thus the investments supported local regeneration and fostered<br />
economic diversification, innovation and increased competitiveness.<br />
8. ENCOURAGES COUNTRIES TO ADDRESS COMMON CH<strong>ALL</strong>ENGES TOGETHER<br />
H<br />
9. THE LESSONS LEARNED ARE BEING APPLIED<br />
EU funding for cross-border programmes resulted in over<br />
6800 projects, including actions to:<br />
create and expand economic clusters,<br />
develop centres of excellence, higher education and<br />
training centres, and cooperation networks between<br />
research centres,<br />
establish cross-border advisory services for enterprises<br />
and business start-ups.<br />
About 1300 environmental projects focused on the joint<br />
management of natural resources such as sea and river<br />
basins.<br />
Funding also included support to help cross-border<br />
regions combat natural risks, respond to climate change,<br />
preserve biodiversity and set up initiatives to develop<br />
renewable energy.<br />
7. INCREASES THE QUALITY-OF-LIFE IN CITIES<br />
ERDF funding for urban development and social infrastructure 2007-2013 amounted to €29 billion,<br />
about 11% of the programme’s budget.<br />
About 4% was invested in urban development initiatives which included investments in deprived areas<br />
and support for economic growth, cultural heritage and strategy development.<br />
7% was allocated to social infrastructure and used to invest in health and education. This led to better<br />
access to educational and lifelong-learning services in combination with labour services.<br />
The funding programmes for 2014-2020 have been designed in a more<br />
result-oriented way, as the 2007-2013 programmes did not always focus<br />
enough on results.<br />
Programmes must now have more specific objectives and clear targets.<br />
Programmes are monitored closely during implementation to ensure welldefined<br />
goals are achieved.<br />
Programmes must report results and outputs regularly.<br />
To ensure quality delivery of programmes, there is now a performance<br />
framework linked to the release of a performance reserve.<br />
Investments concentrate on key themes.<br />
The broader use of financial instruments is more actively encouraged.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong><br />
Creditline: European Commission, 9 Ways Cohesion Policy Works For Europe<br />
38 39<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
Special<br />
Feature<br />
SPECIAL FEATURE: 7th COHESION FORUM, BRUSSELS 26-27 JUNE 2017<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Liam<br />
Sara<br />
Andrew<br />
Miguela<br />
Mauro<br />
Students report...<br />
on Interreg<br />
projects in<br />
Malta<br />
The Interreg Annual Meeting 2017 took place<br />
from 26-28 April in Malta. It was organised<br />
by the European Commission, Directorate-<br />
General for Regional and Urban Policy with<br />
the support of the Maltese Presidency of the<br />
Council of the European Union.<br />
During the event, participants had the opportunity to visit<br />
one of three projects:<br />
> Lithos cross-border project on the protection and<br />
valorisation of historical heritage;<br />
> CypFire transnational project on protecting the<br />
Mediterranean regions’ natural heritage against fire;<br />
> Malta south sewage treatment infrastructure.<br />
Students from the journalism school at the Malta College<br />
of Arts Science and Technology - MCAST were also invited<br />
to attend. These project visits were an opportunity for<br />
these young people to witness the concrete benefits of<br />
cooperation. Their impressions of the project visits are<br />
given below.<br />
Lithos<br />
This cross-border project between Malta and Sicily focuses<br />
on the protection and valorisation of the historical heritage.<br />
Speaking to Daphne Marie Fenech, the lead architect<br />
behind the Lithos project at the Inquisitor’s Palace in<br />
Vittoriosa, she explained that in essence the project focuses<br />
on the synergy between the historical profession of two<br />
nations (Malta and Sicily) and the ability to put it to use to<br />
restore building and structures that otherwise would be<br />
lost.<br />
One of the techniques in the forefront of the project is<br />
stereotomy, revolving around the geometrical knowledge<br />
of drawing and cutting the blocks of solid material. Fenech<br />
stated that the fact that the project’s results were tangible<br />
aided the process of receiving funds from the European<br />
regional fund. Consequently, a museum and training centre<br />
were erected with material, equipment and expertise not<br />
present in Malta but imported from Ragusa, Sicily.<br />
Speaking on the benefits of working with another EU Member<br />
State in a cross-border project, Fenech said the communication<br />
between parties is exceptional and a platform<br />
such as the EU helps in creating a pool of countries that<br />
seeks partners in similar projects.<br />
Apart from the rejuvenation of old structures and infrastructure,<br />
the project also aimed at the resurgence of masonry<br />
skills in Malta. Prior to this and similar initiatives local architects<br />
feared the death knell for masonry skills and other<br />
historical professions targeting architecture.<br />
The important role of MCAST was also highlighted during this<br />
informative meeting. The institution’s work in conjunction<br />
with Heritage Malta’s various research operations gave a<br />
new lease of life to a number of prospective masons.<br />
Liam<br />
40 www.maltabusinessreview.net 41<br />
CypFire<br />
On 27 April I had the chance to attend the CypFire project<br />
event held by the EU Commission. Prior to visiting some<br />
sites a talk was held at the local council of Mgarr where<br />
we were greeted by the mayor Paul Vella who introduced<br />
three more speakers – Roberto Tanti, Gianni Della Rocca<br />
and Eman Vella.<br />
Each spoke of their involvement in this project. Tanti started<br />
by stating the aim of this CypFire project: to suppress forest<br />
fires with a natural barrier, cypress trees. He talked about<br />
how the project came to be with the various experiments<br />
done in different countries and the general spreading of<br />
knowledge.<br />
Della Rocca spoke about the technical aspect of the project<br />
by going into scientific detail about the properties of the<br />
particular species of trees called Mediterranean cypresses.<br />
Lastly, Vella spoke of the input the Mgarr local council had<br />
in previ- ous experiments to determine the best species of<br />
cypress to use in this natural barrier. Mgarr was the best<br />
contender for planting trees as it has the best maintained<br />
rural area in Malta and plenty of space. The trees were<br />
planted in two sites – one near Gnejna and one in Ballut – in<br />
2006 and 2012, respectively. The monitoring of these trees<br />
is still ongoing even though CypFire has ended.<br />
Sara and Andrew<br />
Ta’ Barkat sewage treatment plant<br />
The annual meeting included a visit to the sewage treatment<br />
infrastructure known as Ta' Barkat, at Xgħajra, Malta, Stefan<br />
Cachia and David Sacco, engineers within Water Services<br />
Cor- poration, discussed the project’s aim and objectives,<br />
agenda and the treatment’s key infrastructure.<br />
Cachia opened up the discourse with CF116, one of the<br />
most iconic waste projects in Malta. This operational<br />
programme was originally submitted to the Commission<br />
in December 2007 and formally submitted in July 2010.<br />
According to Cachia, CF116 re-establishes the bathing<br />
water quality along with the Bathing Water Directive and<br />
eliminates extra raw waste water which is discharged into<br />
the sea. This project also aims to get rid of all bad odour<br />
emissions in raw waste-water discharge. Cachia said the<br />
project cost around EUR 80.1 million.<br />
Sacco discussed the project’s aim and objective with<br />
regards to the reduction in pressure on natural water<br />
resources to diversify the available water supply and<br />
increase the propor- tion of reclaimed water. He also stated<br />
that the water services facilitates 90 boreholes, 10 pumping<br />
stations and 3 sea-water reverse-osmosis plants in Malta<br />
and 44 boreholes and 2 pumping stations in Gozo.<br />
The Water Services Corporation aims to continue to invest<br />
in better quality of life which leads to an investment in the<br />
future of the Maltese people. The delegation then visited<br />
the plant.<br />
Miguela and Mauro <strong>MBR</strong><br />
Creditline: European Commission, Panorama Spring 2017
Malta Business Review<br />
DENTAL HEALTHCARE<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
ADDRESSING COMPLEX<br />
CASE SCENARIOS!<br />
By Dr Jean Paul Demajo<br />
In today’s dentistry aesthetics are as<br />
important as functionality. Many patients visit<br />
the dentist and tell them how happy they are<br />
that their bridge or implant they had done<br />
many years ago is still doing fine. What they<br />
are unhappy about are the poor aesthetics<br />
they carry. Most of this old dental work is<br />
heavily constructed using old techniques<br />
with possible visible metal. The frontal view<br />
often shows receeded darkened gums by the<br />
thin metal-ceramic edge of the border of the<br />
crown. Spaces appear in between the teeth<br />
and/or implants, again due to gum recession<br />
causing dark shadows and food packing.<br />
Food packing leads to plaque build-up and<br />
inflammation. Yes this may be kept clean but<br />
the aesthetics still leave much to be desired.<br />
The fact remains that in most cases a bridge<br />
or implant looks very good when inserted but<br />
10, 15 or 20years later it looks very poor and<br />
not in-keeping with the rest of the dentition.<br />
OPTIONS FOR TREATMENT<br />
1 Removal of the implant and adjacent tooth<br />
with poor prognosis followed by two new<br />
implants replacing the two missing teeth<br />
and two new crowns<br />
2 Modification of metal collar and provision<br />
of new implant crown<br />
3 Removal of implant and construction of<br />
new all-ceramic bridge in zirconia or lithium<br />
di-silicate replacing both teeth<br />
4 Gingival plastic surgery to cover the metal<br />
collar<br />
This is a tricky case scenario on a patient<br />
with high expectations. Each option<br />
carries advantages and disadvantages.<br />
Understanding that each option may bare a<br />
good but possibly a compromised result, the<br />
patient has opted for option 1. Here is the<br />
sequence of events:<br />
1 Explantation (removal of implant) and<br />
extraction of adjacent central incisor<br />
2 Simultaneous bone and gingival grafting<br />
plus provision of removable prosthesis.<br />
3 Placement of 2 new implants 3months<br />
post-removal of implant and tooth with<br />
further bone augmentation<br />
4 Fitting of new all ceramic intermediate<br />
implant-crown connections followed by<br />
a metal free all-ceramic superstructure<br />
4months post-implantation<br />
Intra-op pre treatment<br />
Intra-op showing two implants and two ceramic connections<br />
The above shows that there are many<br />
solutions to an aesthetic problem. What’s<br />
important is knowing what options are out<br />
there, explaining them to the patient and<br />
selecting the best option to address the<br />
patients wishes. Timeframes and costings<br />
must also be weighed out.<br />
Ask your dentist! <strong>MBR</strong><br />
A CASE SCENARIO<br />
Middle aged man is unhappy<br />
with an implant done<br />
12 years ago<br />
The implant has healed very well<br />
Fully satisfied with performance<br />
of implant but deeply unsatisfied<br />
with current aesthetics<br />
of tooth and gum<br />
Extra-op pre treatment<br />
Extra-op post treatment<br />
DR JEAN PAUL DEMAJO<br />
Dental and Implant Surgeon,<br />
Trained in London working in<br />
private practice in Malta<br />
42 43<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
IT INTERVIEW OF THE MONTH<br />
IT INTERVIEW OF THE MONTH<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Service, Delivery,<br />
Performance<br />
By George Carol<br />
Brian Darmanin,<br />
Technical Director at J2 Group<br />
"IT and Technology<br />
are the core of today's<br />
businesses but managing<br />
your technology should<br />
not be a time-consuming<br />
aspect of your business"<br />
maintains Brian<br />
Darmanin, Technical<br />
Director at J2 Group<br />
in this interview with<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Why did OSM decide to merge within<br />
J2 Software and what is the strategic fit<br />
here?<br />
BD: We value clients’ business and strive<br />
to give them the best level of products and<br />
services possible. As part of this ongoing<br />
commitment we have decided to invest<br />
further in another local IT firm namely J2<br />
Software, which is an established software<br />
house specialising in the retail sector,<br />
accounts, payroll and custom software for<br />
the past 20 years. Effective November 2016<br />
we have merged with J2 Software, forming<br />
a new group of companies under the brand<br />
name of J2 Group with main office located<br />
in Msida, Malta and branch office in Xewkija,<br />
Gozo. This merger means that we can now<br />
provide businesses a stronger competitive<br />
advantage bringing the customer to the<br />
forefront of today’s technological standards<br />
and demands.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Some people talk about merging or<br />
combining cultures, while others seek to<br />
create a new culture that is separate from<br />
those of the legacy companies. What was<br />
your approach?<br />
BD: This is a merger of two innovative and<br />
professional companies having a history of<br />
successfully working together for the last five<br />
years. Both companies have accomplished<br />
excellent results for customers, with an<br />
emphasis on personalised service and<br />
support. Clients can still rely on the same<br />
personal working relationships that they have<br />
had with us in the past. Customers will still be<br />
dealing with the same people and can depend<br />
on the same high quality service that we have<br />
always striven to give all our customers.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What benefits and synergies will this<br />
new merged team gain and what are the<br />
main benefits for your customers?<br />
BD: We understand that this merger<br />
represents a change in our company brand,<br />
name and logo. We also want to ensure our<br />
clients that our services will remain the same<br />
and will only grow stronger through this<br />
combined offering.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: With regard to J2 Group’s evolution,<br />
how do you see the company positioned for<br />
the future?<br />
BD: The Group will continue to focus on our<br />
core IT services and software products while<br />
keeping in mind client needs. We are currently<br />
investing in Microsoft solutions while we are<br />
also re-writing some of our core packages in<br />
order to keep up with the latest technologies.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What level of focus has J2 Group put<br />
on technology investments?<br />
BD: J2 Group is a dynamic company with<br />
a flair for technology and an emphasis on<br />
personalized service. Our team is made up<br />
of qualified and experienced personnel and<br />
more importantly made up of people who<br />
love technology. Thus our energetic team is<br />
committed in providing and recommending<br />
quality services and products which would<br />
best fit your business model, operating<br />
best technology available. J2 has more than<br />
20-years of experience understanding the<br />
business of the perioperative continuum.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Following the merger, have the type<br />
of solutions you offer today changed the<br />
client relationship?<br />
BD: This merger represents a growth in<br />
resources for the whole group and we want<br />
to ensure clients that our services will grow<br />
stronger through this combined offering.<br />
Our goal is to continue delivering all-round<br />
high-quality service and support in our<br />
current markets more efficiently than before.<br />
To accomplish this, we shall adhere to the<br />
established road-maps and service level<br />
agreements while simultaneously exploring<br />
opportunities to provide you with additional<br />
value in new areas. We are and will continue<br />
to be committed to growing your business<br />
and are sure that this merger shall prove<br />
beneficial to the level of service and coverage<br />
we offer you.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How has J2 Group’s focus shifted to<br />
help clients achieve better results?<br />
BD: We firmly believe that every customer<br />
is unique and has distinct requirements.<br />
Hence we take time to sit down together<br />
in order to examine your business needs<br />
before recommending the way forward. We<br />
appreciate the costs, time and investment<br />
that businesses invest in infrastructure and<br />
solutions and that’s why we treat every<br />
project as if it were our own. We thus focus<br />
all our energies into your business in order<br />
to guarantee professional service, delivery,<br />
performance, and above all cost effectiveness.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Will you discuss the critical role<br />
that technology plays within J2 Group’s<br />
business?<br />
BD: J2 Group is backed-up with strategic local<br />
and foreign partnerships, thus keeping us<br />
on the forefront of today’s technologies and<br />
business needs<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How critical has it been to<br />
communicate these changes internally so<br />
the employees understand it?<br />
BD: Our team is key for us and the team<br />
has been involved in the process and<br />
communication of this merger throughout.<br />
Since we have been working together for<br />
several years this was a very smooth transition<br />
for us. <strong>MBR</strong> All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
J2 VALUES<br />
QUALITY<br />
Quality should be the outcome of patient care systems &<br />
result from attention to process as well as individuals<br />
INTEGRITY<br />
Live an examined life subjecting motives and actions to<br />
the scrutiny of mind and heart; be principled and fair in<br />
business practices with colleagues and clients and assure<br />
results based on value, worth and commitment<br />
RESPONSIVENESS<br />
Be responsive to client needs and remain flexible in<br />
the face of their changing priorities; practice effective<br />
listening; be supportive of colleagues<br />
AFFIRMATION<br />
Affirm the knowledge, skill, dignity and humanity of<br />
clients, co-workers, and persons with whom we interact;<br />
maintain an organizational culture that respects quality of<br />
life concerns<br />
INNOVATION<br />
Innovation & creativity should be the hallmark of our<br />
efforts to design or enhance our services<br />
LEARNING<br />
Remain knowledgeable of current systems, trends, and<br />
environmental factors through continuous learning or<br />
acquisition of staff to complement our knowledge base;<br />
recognize that learning is dynamic not stagnant<br />
VITALITY<br />
Maintain an organizational style that brings vitality and<br />
energy to our product and efforts; remain open to new<br />
ideas and foster a work environment for risk-taking; affirm<br />
healthy living<br />
DIVERSITY<br />
Respect differences and appreciate that sameness is not<br />
only uninteresting but limiting<br />
44 45<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
BUSINESS INTERVIEW<br />
BUSINESS INTERVIEW<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
Discovering Innovative<br />
Lighting Solutions<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How and why did you become part of<br />
the Light Design Solutions Ltd design team?<br />
PC: The Company LIGHT DESIGN SOLUTIONS<br />
(LDS), whose showroom and offices are<br />
located in Birkirkara, has the primary objective<br />
of providing a specialised lighting design<br />
service that aims to enhance space and brings<br />
out the aesthetic and architectural features of<br />
the building. LDS was set up in 2008. I had<br />
worked in the lighting design sector, for other<br />
companies, for more than twelve years. I felt<br />
that attaining the potential of my abilities<br />
depended on others, besides the fact that<br />
people needed a better understanding of<br />
light usage and how light’s potential could<br />
be exploited to transform it into an artistic<br />
experience. The whole concept of the<br />
employees and exhibits at the offices and<br />
By G. A. Carol<br />
Peter Cutajar’s experience in the<br />
field helped him appreciate that<br />
Light Design Solutions (LDS)<br />
would have to collaborate with<br />
foreign partners around the<br />
globe, since this would offer good<br />
quality products consistent with<br />
the latest lighting technologies,<br />
which are incessantly<br />
revolutionising the lighting sector.<br />
In this interview with Peter, we<br />
learn more about LDS.<br />
showroom of LDS is founded on the mission<br />
to explain to our clients that lighting is not<br />
just the light source but the LIGHTING EFFECT<br />
that the source creates.<br />
A significant objective of LDS<br />
is to address the interaction<br />
between human needs and<br />
wishes; between architecture<br />
and aesthetics; between<br />
excellence, economics and<br />
budget constraints<br />
The decisive objective of LDS is the<br />
optimization of space and making it effusively<br />
functional. The presentation of light is central<br />
for LDS because light enriches the character<br />
Peter Cutajar, Light Design Solution (LDS)<br />
and aesthetic feature of the designated area;<br />
be it a house, a commercial environment,<br />
outdoor space or a place that provides<br />
entertainment. The motto of LDS is to enhance<br />
people’s wellbeing by creating an appealing<br />
and pleasant ambiance of the area they are<br />
in. The Company strives to help its clients live<br />
this experience. A significant objective of LDS<br />
is to address the interaction between human<br />
needs and wishes; between architecture and<br />
aesthetics; between excellence, economics<br />
and budget constraints. At LDS, we strive to<br />
create a harmony between such concepts by<br />
being imaginative, original and innovative,<br />
rational, finding consensus with the client’s<br />
needs and practical.<br />
Every interior and exterior project is a new<br />
challenge for LDS; even when the approach is<br />
identical and the final results were achieved by<br />
the employing the same techniques. Hence,<br />
the art of lighting design demands innovation<br />
and creativity because every project is unique.<br />
The Company’s mission lies in its strength<br />
to search and discover innovative and cost<br />
effective solutions for lighting plans and<br />
designs; project management; supervising<br />
the installation of energy efficient products<br />
and systems that the LDS is commissioned to<br />
execute.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What are your greatest moments<br />
or accomplishments personally and<br />
professionally?<br />
PC: Over the past years, LDS has been entrusted<br />
with important projects around the Maltese<br />
Islands and even abroad. One of the greatest<br />
moments and accomplishments of my career<br />
was working with the renowned Maltese<br />
Architect, Professor Richard England (FAIA)<br />
on the Dar il-Ħanin Samaritan Conference<br />
Centre Project in St. Venera, conceived as an<br />
overall series of open spaces aimed to engage<br />
the lay people in meditative sessions, in both<br />
its external and internal spaces. Professor<br />
Richard England (FAIA) wrote that the lighting<br />
designs for the above mentioned Conference<br />
Centre, as planned and executed by LDS, not<br />
only highlights the architectural features but<br />
also enhances the whole project. He goes on<br />
to state that roaming through the illuminated<br />
spaces of Dar il-Ħanin Samaritan provides an<br />
enchanting experience because it gives the<br />
architectural design an added layer of poetic<br />
quality. As an architect of the project I applaud<br />
the finished product.<br />
The Company’s goal is to create<br />
a design where people can<br />
enjoy the discernable aesthetic<br />
architectural features<br />
LDS was given a free hand by Professor<br />
England to design the appropriate lighting<br />
for this Conference Centre. It took us eight<br />
months to finalise the lighting designs and<br />
2 years to finish the lighting project. This<br />
project and working with Professor Richard<br />
England (FAIA) was a great milestone for LDS,<br />
as it was a living proof of what LDS stands for.<br />
The project demonstrated the Company’s<br />
capabilities and potentialities unswervingly<br />
and robustly.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: In your opinion, what sets you apart<br />
from other light design studios designers?<br />
PC: In my opinion, such projects as Dar il-<br />
Ħanin Samaritan Conference Centre lauded<br />
by Professor Richard England (FAIA) are<br />
proof of the Company’s credentials and the<br />
service that it offers its clients. LDS provides<br />
comprehensive service of professional<br />
lighting calculations, wiring plans indicating<br />
the precise position of the lighting fixture in<br />
tandem with the size and cut outs for the false<br />
ceiling contractor, together with 3-D images<br />
showing the lighting effect created for our<br />
clients. The service that LDS provides includes<br />
supervising the execution of the lighting<br />
design plans and the fixing of lighting fixtures<br />
on site.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: From idea to finished product – how<br />
does a design become a lighting fixture<br />
ready to go on the market?<br />
PC: The journey from the conception of the<br />
idea to the finished product goes through<br />
a number of stages. The initial stage of the<br />
project is that of a rudimentary design of the<br />
project. The Company’s design team then<br />
develops the simple idea and develops it into a<br />
sophisticated notion of the light effect that to<br />
be achieved. The Company’s team then sets<br />
about designing the product starting with the<br />
shape of the light fitting and finishing with the<br />
optics. In the process we collaborate and keep<br />
contact with our lighting manufactures in<br />
Italy and Germany who construct the design<br />
of LDS. Foreign Companies have placed the<br />
designs of Lighting Design Solutions in their<br />
Company’s official catalogue.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How would you characterize your<br />
design work in five words?<br />
PC: I would say that the design work of<br />
Lighting Design Solutions is: Professional,<br />
Comprehensive, Innovative, Imaginative<br />
and Practical.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What are your goals and what is on<br />
your professional bucket list?<br />
PC: My goal is to create the awareness that<br />
light design is as important as the architectural<br />
features and the interior designs employed.<br />
Unfortunately, many do not give light design<br />
the attention that it deserves. It could be<br />
that people consider the architectural design<br />
and the finishing materials required (such as<br />
bathrooms and tiles) for their new homes for<br />
their new home more important. I believe<br />
that individuals who spend thousands of Euro<br />
(whether it is for their home or a business<br />
enterprise) and do not give the necessary<br />
attention to lighting would simply become<br />
the owners of have a half-baked project.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What inspires your designs?<br />
PC: Our designs are inspired by the concept of<br />
beauty and how light can transform a simple<br />
structure into art, and as Professor Richard<br />
England (FAIA) stated, give the architectural<br />
design an added layer of poetic quality.<br />
Light plays a very important role in bringing<br />
out the architectural features at night. The<br />
Company’s goal is to create a design where<br />
people can enjoy the discernable aesthetic<br />
architectural features of the building not only<br />
during daytime, bathed by sunlight, but more<br />
importantly at night, illuminated by artificial<br />
lighting.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: With so much experience behind you,<br />
how do you see the lighting market in the<br />
future?<br />
PC: The experience that I have gained in<br />
the last nine years suggest that architects<br />
and interior designers are realising that light<br />
design is more complex than meets the eye. I<br />
think that the lighting market has a promising<br />
future because we have come to realise<br />
that these professionals are recognising<br />
the need to collaborate with lighting design<br />
professionals. The secret for our success is<br />
that if we want to create a particular light<br />
effect, we are capable of visualising the light<br />
fixture required that will produce the light<br />
effect imagined, and if it is not found on the<br />
market, we have the experience, expertise<br />
and ability to create it. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
46<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
47
Malta Business Review<br />
RISK MANAGEMENT<br />
RISK MANAGEMENT<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
structure<br />
for Success<br />
by George Carol<br />
CC: The tsunami of regulations that will<br />
continue to emerge from EU will make this<br />
difficult for the compliance department<br />
to follow and ensure that they are being<br />
properly complied with. Increased head<br />
count in compliance will still not solve the<br />
problem. Also the talent in compliance<br />
combining regulatory knowledge and<br />
practical implementation are rare. This will<br />
push the need for further development of<br />
compliance monitoring systems with artificial<br />
intelligence solutions. In the future the role of<br />
the compliance officer will be in the software<br />
development and integration of powerful IT<br />
systems. We will see a time when compliance<br />
will totally incorporate the digital evolution.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What does FINTECH stand for and<br />
represent?<br />
CC: FINTECH is the future of financial services<br />
whereby the operational processes and also<br />
controls are automated, partially or fully,<br />
through the use of technology. The pace of<br />
technology and its use is accelerating at a<br />
very fast rate. Use of artificial intelligence<br />
and robotics will become more a reality of<br />
financial services.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: The terminology and definition of<br />
compliance is extensive. Can you briefly<br />
describe BLOCKCHAIN, the regulators pace<br />
of evolvement, and the importance part of<br />
preservation of reputation?<br />
CC: Blockchain is the technology on<br />
which cryptocurrency has been built. This<br />
technology has the power to leave a trace of<br />
each process or asset as it moves hands. This<br />
will achieve a higher level of transparency but<br />
this technology has the power to facilitate<br />
transactions on a peer-to-peer level without<br />
the need of intermediaries such as banks. No<br />
wonder this technology is considered as the<br />
disruptive technology of the future.<br />
From what I have read, heard and<br />
experienced, the regulators seem to be<br />
sceptical about the use of this technology or<br />
cryptocurrency. In part, this may be due to the<br />
lack of understanding of how this technology<br />
really works. Also the regulators were too busy<br />
understanding and implementing all these<br />
regulations coming out of the EU. However,<br />
I still believe that appreciation of Blockchain<br />
and digitisation can also be the future tools<br />
of how regulators can monitor the industry<br />
more efficiently and effectively.<br />
Still it is important to keep in mind that Bitcoin<br />
has been linked with money launderers, drug<br />
traffickers and paedophiles. Yet, Blockchain<br />
cannot be avoided as it will be part of our<br />
lives. By properly regulating it, the technology<br />
is intended to be used for good and legitimate<br />
scopes. Such will preserve a country’s<br />
reputation – at least in part. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
All rights reserved / Copyright 2017<br />
Non-profit organisations are not immune to reputational damage.<br />
Recently we saw FIFA a major institution in football hindered by its<br />
corrupt members and bad governance. Community interest institutions<br />
or companies need to be transparent, have codes in place and effective<br />
controls. This has made compliance not a function for commercial<br />
entities but also for non-profit organisations as part of the presentation<br />
of the reputation and to keep the purpose of the organisation alive.<br />
Claire Camilleri personally considers compliance and good corporate<br />
governance as a mission and a passion at the same time. In this interview<br />
Claire Camilleri Gauci, Director at Aid Compliance, tells us just why<br />
keeping updated with regulations, networking staying close to reality<br />
are essential for effective compliance.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What can you tell us about the<br />
development of compliance and in what<br />
way compliance plays a major role in the<br />
control structure of an organisation?<br />
CC: Post financial crisis we have experienced<br />
a stream of directives and regulations from<br />
European Union and an increased role of<br />
EBA, ESMA and EIOPA, which have moved<br />
compliance from an operational role to a<br />
strategic function both physically and in spirit.<br />
Having said so, compliance has become an<br />
important part of the corporate governance<br />
mechanism but it is not the only component.<br />
Business to thrive need the right combination<br />
of strategy, internal control, positivity and<br />
enthusiasm.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How have things changed on the<br />
regulatory compliance, legal affairs and risk<br />
management fronts over the two decades<br />
you have been in compliance and at Aid<br />
Compliance?<br />
CC: Over 20 years I have seen the start of a<br />
single regulatory body in Malta and the final<br />
transposition stage of all EU regulations prior<br />
to Malta joining the European Union. At that<br />
time compliance was limited in scope.<br />
Nobody anticipated the devastating impact of<br />
the global financial crisis, the fall of Lehman<br />
Brothers or the Madoff scandal. Inevitably<br />
such events pressured legislators and<br />
regulators to introduce more regulations.<br />
Hefty fines by the regulators and reputational<br />
damage caused by ‘name and shame’ have<br />
underlined the risk of non-compliance as a<br />
financial burden that has to be avoided for<br />
the prosperity of the firm. All these elements<br />
have pushed the Compliance Office from<br />
back office or ‘behind the desk’ stereotype<br />
to the person that is part of the life of the<br />
executive meeting.<br />
this technology has the power to<br />
facilitate transactions on a peerto-peer<br />
level without the need of<br />
an intermediary such as banks<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How does this form part of the internal<br />
governance, especially where compliance is<br />
a risk area?<br />
CC: Compliance and legal risks should be seen<br />
as part of the risk management framework.<br />
When these areas are seen as a risk, one is<br />
able to effectively and efficiently determine<br />
which regulations effect the company, the<br />
financial impact of regulations as a result<br />
of non-compliance, and how these are<br />
effectively mitigated. If compliance is well<br />
managed it is the first line which can define<br />
and reinforce governance.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: What is the underlying rationale of<br />
the compliance function?<br />
CC: It is important to recognise that the<br />
compliance function deals with people. The<br />
Compliance Officer and the Department<br />
should advise, educate and inspire the<br />
culture and which reflects in fair, honest and<br />
professional dealings with the clients and<br />
rest of the society including regulators. Being<br />
practical is also critical to ensure the business<br />
remains in perspective.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Which industries or sectors is<br />
compliance gaining importance?<br />
CC: Compliance is gaining importance across<br />
various sectors not only financial services,<br />
listed companies and pharmaceuticals which<br />
are the classic examples. The Gaming sector<br />
is one example where it has seriously evolved<br />
Claire Camilleri Gauci, Director at Aid Compliance<br />
in terms of the need of compliance. This<br />
was pressured by anti-money laundering<br />
regulations, general data protection<br />
requirements and responsible gaming, just<br />
to mention a few. However, we are seeing<br />
compliance in other sectors such as sports, or<br />
in areas such as environmental compliance.<br />
At the end of the day, increased regulations<br />
have impacted every industry not as a result<br />
of the pressure exerted by policy makers or<br />
regulators but also by the public outcry for<br />
social responsibility.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: Can you tell us which areas or<br />
industries are maturing in terms of<br />
compliance?<br />
CC: Gaming is a sector which has matured not<br />
only in terms of compliance. We are seeing<br />
a steady increase in the engagement of<br />
professional and experienced non-executive<br />
directors who are able to bring the ‘control<br />
mindset’ on the board table. Also, internal<br />
audit is increasing in demand in case of large<br />
scale companies.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How do you define the AID brand, its<br />
achievements, and its future?<br />
If compliance is well managed it<br />
is the first line which can define<br />
and reinforce governance<br />
CC: AID Compliance has been developed<br />
to bring high-end professional compliance<br />
and internal audit in a practical manner. The<br />
team is composed of highly professional<br />
individuals with years of practical experience<br />
and different backgrounds. Innovation and<br />
business sensitivity has distinguished AID<br />
from others. Since its inception in 2014 the<br />
Company has become a renowned named<br />
in financial services and we are gaining<br />
momentum in gaming and cyber security<br />
audits. We are also developing other areas in<br />
compliance such as sport.<br />
<strong>MBR</strong>: How does technology influence and<br />
impacts compliance?<br />
48<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
49
Malta Business Review<br />
Committed to Providing the<br />
Best Education Learning Experience<br />
YACHTING AND AVIATION<br />
eie educational group<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
OUR MISSION<br />
To enhance the level of Academic<br />
training and Tuition of both pre and<br />
post graduate levels by:<br />
Learning a language or obtaining an academic<br />
qualification is more important than ever in<br />
the global economy. eie Educational Group<br />
provide students with a first-class educational<br />
teaching and training service at a fair price.<br />
Students ask for an excellent teaching<br />
environment so that they quickly progress<br />
through their course, but also that they will<br />
want to enjoy themselves whilst studying.<br />
At eie Educational Group, you will have a<br />
fantastic studying experience. eie encourage<br />
social interaction trough regular, fun and<br />
varied leisure programmes, as this improves<br />
a learning experience.<br />
eie Educational Group, was established in<br />
January 2000 and their success is built on a<br />
long-standing commitment to the specific<br />
needs of local and international students. eie<br />
constantly expands its worldwide networks,<br />
partners with established renowned<br />
organisations, invests in its facilities and in<br />
social commitments. The eie Educational<br />
Group is redefining the landscape of modern<br />
education.<br />
The eie Educational Group aims to develop the<br />
appropriate competencies and knowledge<br />
needed in planning, evaluation, research and<br />
development tasks in education and related<br />
fields in the midst of societal changes, both<br />
on local and global levels. This network gives<br />
eie the key to be competitive and to share<br />
the collective experience and continuous<br />
professional development with their cilients.<br />
In a fast moving world, challenges are<br />
demanding and change is constant.<br />
Tomorrow’s future depends on today’s<br />
knowledge. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
For more information about eie’s degree programmes,<br />
English language courses or other business related<br />
courses you can e-mail at info@eie-group.com,<br />
phone on +35621332804/5<br />
• Contributing actively towards the<br />
propagation of equal opportunities<br />
for all.<br />
• Continually engaging in the pursuit of<br />
excellence.<br />
• Continually investing in its own<br />
people.<br />
• Striving to afford the best service to all<br />
our clients.<br />
• Establishing itself as a leader in the<br />
international education field.<br />
• Contributing towards the social<br />
welfare of the community.<br />
Through its companies, the EIE EDUCATIONAL GROUP is able to<br />
offer the following services:<br />
Academic programmes<br />
Training programmes<br />
English Language courses<br />
Student Accommodation<br />
Internships<br />
Certificate, Diploma, Bachelor, Master degrees in various<br />
subjects for young and mature adults are offered through eie<br />
Institute of Education (Licensed by the NCFHE as an institute<br />
of Further and Higher Education – License Number 2005-TC-<br />
001);<br />
Business courses, thematic seminars for business excecutives<br />
offered through eie Mangement Centre;<br />
English courses at Beginner, Elementary, Pre-Intermediate,<br />
Intermediate, Upper-Intermediate, Business English and<br />
Advanced levels are offered through Unilang International<br />
School of Languages, Valletta (Licensed by the EFL Monitoring<br />
Board – License Number 249/MB16)<br />
Provision of quality accommodation around Malta ideal for<br />
students offered through eie Residences<br />
Organisation of Work placement and Internships for<br />
international students offered through eie internships.<br />
Commitment to<br />
EXCELLENCE<br />
The eie<br />
Educational<br />
Group<br />
eie Educational Group, Valletta Buildings, South Street, Valletta<br />
Tel: +356 21 332804/5 info@eie-group.com<br />
is an acknowledged leader<br />
in international education<br />
Higher Educational courses - eie Institute of Education<br />
(NCFHE License Number 2005 - TC - 001)<br />
English Language Courses - Unilang International<br />
School of Languages (EFL License Number 249/MB16)<br />
Executive and Business courses - eie Management<br />
Centre<br />
Internship services - eie Internships<br />
Student Accommodation - eie Residences<br />
International Educational services - eie International<br />
www.eieEducationalGroup.com<br />
50 www.maltabusinessreview.net 51
Malta Business Review<br />
STRATEGIC THINKING<br />
FOCUS: CHINA VS EU<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
BOOST YOUR<br />
STRATEGIC THINKING<br />
By Robin Cleland<br />
Organisations<br />
not only need to<br />
recognise the<br />
importance of<br />
strategic thinking,<br />
but also need to<br />
become more<br />
customer-centric<br />
and data-driven<br />
in their approach<br />
to formulating,<br />
tracking and<br />
adapting their<br />
strategy.<br />
Internationalization & Militarization:<br />
China vs EU, Who is right? [Part 1]<br />
By Anatole Baldacchino<br />
Robin Cleland, Managing Partner at 20/20 Strategy<br />
Strategy is about making choices and<br />
developing a deliberate plan of action to<br />
strengthen and enhance performance. It is<br />
fundamental to the success and sustainability<br />
of an organisation, whether you are operating<br />
in an emerging or mature category, or are a<br />
new or established brand. It forces you to<br />
think about your organisation’s capabilities<br />
and the mechanics of the industry in<br />
which you operate. It defines what your<br />
organisation stands for, and how you want<br />
to compete, and it sets the direction for the<br />
whole organisation.<br />
Bold strategic decisions and precise execution<br />
matter more now than ever before in today’s<br />
rapidly changing environment, where the<br />
world is less linear and more fluid, with fast<br />
changing customer behaviour and intense<br />
competition<br />
Effective strategy requires focus. Given<br />
resource constraints, strategic decisions must<br />
involve making trade-offs – Strategy is as<br />
much about what you choose to do, as it is<br />
about what you choose not to do. Therefore,<br />
to drive growth, you need to allocate<br />
resources to focus on those activities where<br />
you have a competitive advantage and that<br />
will deliver the highest impact.<br />
However, making the right strategic decisions<br />
on where to focus and allocate resources can<br />
be challenging. As a consequence, important<br />
strategic decisions often resort to being<br />
based on partial information and gut feel.<br />
Although intuition and gut feel are valuable as<br />
a starting point to strategy, it is risky to base<br />
the future direction of an organisation solely<br />
on this – you will either be lucky or wrong!<br />
Furthermore, an essential part of strategy is<br />
effective implementation, and it is hard to<br />
obtain a shared buy-in to the strategy based<br />
on one person’s gut feel.<br />
Bold strategic decisions and<br />
precise execution matter more<br />
now than ever<br />
For these reasons, a more structured and<br />
data-driven approach to strategy is required to<br />
manage complexity, obtain buy-in and support<br />
better strategic decisions. The approach must<br />
build alignment on the optimal strategy to<br />
pursue, and in doing so provide clear answers<br />
to the following questions:<br />
• What opportunities are there, how big are<br />
they, and how could they evolve?<br />
• Which opportunities should you prioritise<br />
for your brand?<br />
• How can you activate these opportunities?<br />
Answering these questions involves<br />
deconstructing the market to develop a<br />
deep understanding of underlying customer<br />
behaviour and segments, the market and<br />
competitor dynamics, and the drivers of<br />
brand performance. Furthermore, it is<br />
essential to assess how external market and<br />
competitive conditions could evolve going<br />
forward, as strategy involves understanding<br />
possible futures to inform present decisions.<br />
This approach ensures that strategic decisions<br />
are based on a clear understanding of the big<br />
picture, as well as the underlying detail.<br />
By thinking strategically and adopting a<br />
customer-centric and data-driven approach<br />
to strategy, you can uncover hidden<br />
growth opportunities, attract and retain<br />
your customers, adapt to changing market<br />
conditions, and make strategic decisions<br />
that will help your brand thrive and compete<br />
effectively. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
Robin Cleland is Managing Partner at 20/20<br />
Strategy, a boutique strategy consulting<br />
company, specialising in growth strategy.<br />
He advises leading global brands and new<br />
emerging brands across a range of sectors<br />
and countries.<br />
If we take a glimpse at the colonial times,<br />
western big hats, UK and France always<br />
looked to enhance their respective roles<br />
as expansionists. The Chinese on the other<br />
hand, were against this way of thinking of<br />
colonialism and instead they preferred to stay<br />
watching from the gallery.<br />
Europeans regarded colonies, “as part of their<br />
package” with all the benefits that comes<br />
with it, however the Chinese view of colonies,<br />
was that these countries were “outside<br />
civilization” and therefore unworthy of its<br />
protection.<br />
China does not aspire to run the world,<br />
because it already believes in itself as the<br />
“God of this World”.<br />
This is the reason why, China does not take an<br />
aggressive stance at world stage.<br />
However as time goes by, we analyze the<br />
present scenario and take a look at what<br />
Chinese youth thinking on International<br />
affairs and militarization. Youths were asked<br />
as what role China should play in International<br />
affairs. The following were the results,<br />
What role do you think China should play in<br />
International affairs?<br />
25% replied to leadership role as a regional<br />
great power. (At present)<br />
30% replied to leadership role as a regional<br />
great power (by 2028)<br />
21% replied leadership role a great world<br />
power (At present)<br />
47% replied leadership role as a great world<br />
power (by 2028)<br />
8% replied to take care of its own business<br />
only and little to International affairs (at<br />
present)<br />
4% replied to take care of its own business<br />
only and little to International affairs (by<br />
2028)<br />
2% only had no clear idea (At present)<br />
3 % only had no clear idea (By 2028)<br />
In accordance to the Center for arms control<br />
and Non-Proliferation in 2008, China spent<br />
122 Billion US dollars on military expenditure,<br />
whilst the European countries spent 289<br />
Billion US dollars.<br />
This scenario was overturned in 2016, in<br />
accordance to the Stockholm Peace Research<br />
Institute,<br />
Which states that China spent 216 Billion<br />
dollars in 2016 and the European countries<br />
spent 192 Billion US dollars by the same year.<br />
China is building up its military base year<br />
by year but remains non-aggressive. The<br />
EU’s view on militarisation is somehow<br />
more complicated as one may think. In fact<br />
militarization of Europe is highly regarded<br />
as a greater threat than Brexit. US led<br />
NATO deploying military assets around<br />
Russia puts more pressure on the EU for<br />
greater militarisation. Europeans view on<br />
militarization is surrounded by skepticism. A<br />
greater build up in Europe can push further<br />
vulnerable countries and can inflict further<br />
problems on the failed migration European<br />
policies. From the China youth survey a low<br />
8% of the respondents, claim that China<br />
should take care of its own house rather than<br />
its International affairs.<br />
This view in Europe is somehow the opposite<br />
as many EU citizens think that we should<br />
control our borders carefully to regulate the<br />
flow of migrants. NATO’s intent to extend its<br />
mission to the center of the Mediterranean<br />
creates further EU tensions. This is done<br />
in the name to fight against Isis. The other<br />
justification of militarization of Europe is the<br />
intervention of Russia in Ukraine. Russia is<br />
seen as an external threat to Europe. The EU<br />
pledged a 1.5 Billion fund a year by 2020 to<br />
boost the European defense system.<br />
China deploying its naval assets around<br />
the Spratly islands because China claims<br />
that these are part of its territorial waters.<br />
Vietnam, Malaysia, Philippines and Japan all<br />
claim part of these waters as well. (Article to<br />
be continued) <strong>MBR</strong><br />
52 53<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
BUILDING & CONSTRUCTION<br />
BUILDING & CONSTRUCTION<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
The Future looks<br />
Bright white<br />
by<br />
Antoine Bonello<br />
Solar Reflective coatings offer a powerful<br />
sustainability option for the restoration and<br />
maintenance of roofs in general.<br />
Many people here in Malta are now adopting<br />
the thermal reflecting membranes not only to<br />
waterproof but also to reduce the heat intake<br />
inside buildings by as much as 90%. A thermal<br />
roof coating also contributes to reduce the<br />
energy consumption for cooling and heating<br />
buildings by as much as 50%. An all year round<br />
product that can provide long term solutions<br />
to all waterproofing problems.<br />
Malta is an island with low rain fall and<br />
plenty of sunshine, needless to stress on<br />
the importance of solar panels, especially<br />
now that they can be in a position to absorb<br />
more UV rays and produce more electricity<br />
thanks to the thermal membrane reflective<br />
ability. Our recommendation is to avoid<br />
fixing the panels directly on the concrete<br />
surface, they should be mounted on slabs or<br />
elevated on proper metal structures that can<br />
be dismantled without damaging the roof<br />
whatsoever.<br />
A Good thermal reflective resin membrane<br />
have must have an SRI (solar reflective index)<br />
of at least 111% (ASMT E 1980) and a thermal<br />
ability of 91% (ASMT C 1371)<br />
Preparation and proper product application<br />
are the secret to prevent a piss poor<br />
performance. Waterproofing seems so easy<br />
on paper it is just a roller application. Well<br />
not exactly. A good amount of preparation is<br />
required in order to achieve a proper result<br />
that can last years. REMEMBER never let<br />
anyone experiment with your home especially<br />
when it comes to waterproofing. Over 80% of<br />
building damages are related to water intake.<br />
DIY is very popular here in Malta and to<br />
facilitate its application, a thermal resin<br />
membrane with micro fibres is now available,<br />
thus avoiding the need to implement any<br />
fibreglass reinforcment net. A good job is<br />
never enough if the materials applied are of<br />
poor quality. Always avoid plastics, acrylics<br />
and latex and cement based materials as they<br />
lack UV resistance and become brittle, most<br />
of them do not last a whole winter. Elasticity<br />
is also very important due to structural<br />
movements and so is resistance to water<br />
stagnation, which is something very common<br />
with our flat roofs. On the contrary carpet<br />
membranes increases heat intake by 80% and<br />
its bitumen properties starts to melt when the<br />
temperature exceeds 35 degrees, something<br />
very common here in Malta.<br />
Qualities and visible certifications a good<br />
waterproofing product must carry on the can<br />
• UV Resistance, Elasticity, VOC low, H2O, CE<br />
Mark, low impact on the Enviroment.<br />
Delicate works that involve the<br />
implementation of a fibre netting should be<br />
carried out by professionals and properly<br />
trained people. Always make sure that the<br />
persons to whom you commission the works<br />
are accountable, traceable and trustworthy. It<br />
is therefore recommended to make sure that<br />
they are affiliated with the Malta Professional<br />
Waterproofing and Resin Flooring Association.<br />
Always ask to see by Installers Card for more<br />
piece of mind. This way you can determine<br />
whether or not the person has the necessary<br />
knowledge to do a proper job.<br />
The Malta Waterproofing and Resin Flooring<br />
Association provide technical knowledge and<br />
professional formation to all Maltese installers<br />
who wish to improve their workmanship or<br />
start a carrier in the waterproofing business.<br />
The Association also assists its members<br />
by providing the services of a profession<br />
advisor when facing challenging situations<br />
or other difficulties during their works.<br />
The Association also provides its qualified<br />
members the Certified Installers Card. This<br />
is done to reassure the general public that<br />
the person is able to carry out the requested<br />
job at its best. All this is being made possible<br />
thanks to the Resin and Membrane Centre<br />
and NAICI International Academy. For<br />
further information with regards the Malta<br />
Professional Waterproofing and Resin<br />
Flooring Association visit our website on<br />
www.maltawaterproofing.com or call on<br />
27477647 <strong>MBR</strong><br />
54 55<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net
Malta Business Review<br />
YACHTING AND AVIATION<br />
Malta Business Review<br />
EQUIOM<br />
reaches new<br />
yachting<br />
and aviation<br />
milestone<br />
Equiom, the international professional<br />
services provider, has reached a new<br />
milestone of USD4 billion in assets under<br />
administration for its yachting and aviation<br />
portfolio.<br />
As one of the largest yachting and aviation<br />
departments in the corporate service sector<br />
globally, Equiom has a 30-strong yachting<br />
and aviation team worldwide. They provide<br />
ongoing support and advice to clients with<br />
dedicated teams for registration, structuring,<br />
tax, customs and legal matters relating to<br />
yachts and aircraft.<br />
Equiom’s Director of Yachting and Aviation,<br />
Edward Leigh commented: ‘We are pleased<br />
to have reached such a significant milestone.<br />
It is a true testament to the high calibre of<br />
our team and the breadth of our offering.<br />
We manage transactions for some of the<br />
highest valued yachts and aircrafts in the<br />
world, including helicopters, other types of<br />
aircraft, motor and sailing yachts. With larger<br />
superyachts and corporate aircraft currently<br />
in high demand, it will be interesting to see<br />
how the market develops over the next few<br />
years.’<br />
Equiom has been providing services to<br />
the yachting and aviation sectors for over<br />
ten years. In 2016, the company achieved<br />
Authorised Economic Operator (AEO) status,<br />
which is a globally recognised quality mark<br />
in the industry. This recognition affords<br />
certain benefits to clients in the yachting and<br />
aviation customs process, such as fast-tracked<br />
paperwork and fewer customs checks.<br />
Edward continued: ‘A number of new recruits<br />
in the team this year has enabled us to attend<br />
more and more industry events, Including<br />
the European Business Aviation Convention<br />
and Exhibition (EBACE) and the Monaco<br />
Yacht Show in September. We look forward<br />
to seeing existing clients and intermediaries<br />
and making new contacts as we continue our<br />
commitment to serving the industry.’<br />
Equiom Isle of Man Managing Director, Aidan<br />
Davin added: 'Recent changes have given us<br />
the opportunity to create a stronger team than<br />
ever before, united in their efforts to deliver<br />
the highest levels of service that clients have<br />
come to expect from Equiom. The growth<br />
in our assets under administration under<br />
Edward’s leadership is a great indicator of the<br />
importance of this service line not only to our<br />
Isle of Man but also our Jersey, Guernsey and<br />
Malta offices all of whom have contributed to<br />
this achievement.’<br />
For more information visit www.<br />
equiomgroup.com <strong>MBR</strong><br />
Creditline: Equiom Group (Europe) Limited<br />
Members of Equiom’s yachting and aviation<br />
team at Jubilee Buildings in the Isle of Man<br />
START THIS OCTOBER<br />
APPLY NOW!<br />
Applications open.<br />
No entry requirement needed.<br />
Course is recognised by the<br />
NCFHE at Level 3 and Level 5 of<br />
the Malta Qualification<br />
Framework and European<br />
Qualification.<br />
Small Classes Morning Sessions<br />
Twice a week from 9am till 1pm<br />
You do not have enough qualification<br />
to start your career?<br />
STARTING OCTOBER 2017<br />
Secretarial Course<br />
Business Finance Accounting Award +<br />
Accounting in Business Diploma<br />
70% REFUND FROM TAX CREDIT<br />
56<br />
1 April 2017-31 March 2018<br />
Malta<br />
TEL: 21443140/99443140<br />
info@learnkey.com<br />
www.maltabusinessreview.net<br />
57
Malta Business Review<br />
NEWSMAKERS<br />
Signing of EU<br />
Ministerial<br />
Declaration<br />
to put Europe<br />
as the lead<br />
market in 5G<br />
Photos: OPM_PS<br />
Parliamentary Secretary for Financial Services,<br />
Digital Economy and Innovation Silvio<br />
Schembri, together with other EU Ministers<br />
signed an EU ministerial declaration that<br />
confirms the willingness of member states<br />
to position Europe as the lead market for 5G.<br />
The signing took place during an informal<br />
meeting of ministers of competitiveness and<br />
telecommunications in Tallinn Estonia, which<br />
is now hosting the EU Presidency.<br />
The declaration indicates the steps member<br />
states have to take to foster the swift rollout<br />
of 5G infrastructure and related services<br />
across Europe. It emphasises on the need<br />
to create the right preconditions to leverage<br />
the full potential of 5G and proposes a<br />
strategic dialogue with stakeholders on 5G<br />
challenges. The declaration will be signed by<br />
telecommunications ministers of EU member<br />
states during the informal meeting in Tallinn<br />
Estonia next week.<br />
5G is a critical element to enhance connectivity<br />
and ensure that consumers and businesses<br />
can become more competitive in Europe. It<br />
is expected that future 5G infrastructure will<br />
serve a wide range of applications and sectors<br />
including professional uses such as assisted<br />
driving, eHealth, energy management,<br />
possibly safety applications.<br />
This meeting addressed the necessity to<br />
facilitate the data economy, especially<br />
with respect to the free flow of data, an<br />
essential element that will help the Maltese<br />
Government to develop and implement its<br />
planned blockchain strategy in various sectors<br />
of the economy. Having such a strategy<br />
will enable Malta to harness blockchain<br />
technology in several government areas such<br />
as facilitating trade between EU countries.<br />
The Maltese Government sees this economic<br />
strategy as a key opportunity for the creation<br />
of an innovative industry with great potential<br />
for the Maltese economy.<br />
Parliamentary Secretary Silvio Schembri<br />
said the Maltese Government agrees that<br />
actions should be taken at EU level in order<br />
to facilitate access to and reuse of data<br />
across different sectors and organisations<br />
in member states. This would improve the<br />
overall competitiveness and ensure that<br />
resources are used efficiently. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
Source: Parliamentary Secretariat For Financial<br />
Services, Digital Economy And Innovation<br />
EU Foreign Ministers adopt<br />
legislative amendments<br />
suggested by Malta aimed<br />
at disrupting migrant<br />
smugglers’ business model<br />
Minister Carmelo Abela, with Minister Jean<br />
Asselborn<br />
EU Foreign Ministers adopted legislative<br />
amendments, proposed, and negotiated by<br />
Malta during its Presidency of the Council of<br />
the EU, concerning the regime of restrictive<br />
measures aimed at stopping the supply<br />
of goods to smugglers of human beings in<br />
Libya. “This initiative, which targets goods<br />
used by smugglers such as dinghies and<br />
motors, is extremely important in disrupting<br />
the operations of traffickers and is fully in<br />
line with the actions envisaged by the Malta<br />
58<br />
Declaration of 3rd February, 2017”, Minister<br />
Abela said at the Foreign Affairs Council. He<br />
also called on the EU to consider how this<br />
initiative could be extended internationally.<br />
Through these measures, the direct or<br />
indirect sale, transfer, or export of such<br />
equipment by EU member state nationals<br />
or from the territories of member states,<br />
would be subject to prior authorisation by the<br />
competent authority of the exporting state.<br />
The ministers held a discussion on the political<br />
and security situation in Libya. Minister Abela<br />
expressed Malta’s continued concern at<br />
the political stalemate and stated that the<br />
ultimate goal remains that of all-inclusive<br />
dialogue based on the Libyan Political<br />
Agreement. The Minister reiterated Malta’s<br />
support to the efforts made by the United<br />
Nations to register progress on this priority<br />
and welcomed the appointment of Special<br />
Representative Ghattas Salame, adding that<br />
the EU and its member states should continue<br />
to put their weight behind these efforts and<br />
urge political and military powerbrokers to<br />
find a long-awaited solution. The ministers<br />
agreed that Libya should remain high on the<br />
EU’s agenda and adopted Council Conclusions<br />
on Libya.<br />
In this context, they also addressed the issue<br />
of migration with a particular focus on the<br />
Central Mediterranean Route - a discussion<br />
continued over lunch in the presence of the<br />
International Organisation on Migration (IOM)<br />
and the United Nations High Commissioner<br />
for Refugees (UNHCR). The ministers<br />
supported the various actions identified by<br />
the Malta Declaration, including projects<br />
for the development of Africa - through the<br />
Trust Fund for Africa and the newly adopted<br />
European Fund for Sustainable Development<br />
(the latter negotiated and concluded by the<br />
Maltese Presidency) - as well as support to and<br />
capacity building of the Libyan Coast Guard.<br />
The Council expressed solidarity with Italy and<br />
the ministers supported Italy and the work<br />
being done in the context of the humanitarian<br />
response. They stressed the importance of<br />
the EU continuing to work closely with the<br />
IOM and the UNHCR in a comprehensive way,<br />
including on adequate reception capacities.<br />
The evolving scenario in North Korea and its<br />
impact on regional and international stability<br />
was also addressed by the ministers, and<br />
the Council adopted Council Conclusions in<br />
this regard. The ministers had a discussion<br />
on the EU’s Global Strategy, focusing on the<br />
next steps concerning implementation with<br />
a view to identifying priorities for the coming<br />
months, and building upon progress already<br />
registered. <strong>MBR</strong><br />
Source: Ministry For Foreign Affairs And Trade<br />
Promotion