27.06.2018 Views

The Star: June 28, 2018

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong> Latest Christchurch news at www.star.kiwi<br />

Thursday <strong>June</strong> <strong>28</strong> <strong>2018</strong> 19<br />

Opinion<br />

Tanya Didham - I feel like I<br />

have been sharing my views quite<br />

a lot, both on my own behalf,<br />

and as co-chair of Greening<br />

the Red Zone. However, this is<br />

from me, personally. Suffice to<br />

say, there are very good reasons<br />

why Regenerate Christchurch<br />

took the out-of-river lake off<br />

the table. All those reasons (and<br />

all their technical reports and<br />

indicative business studies) have<br />

been laid out on their website<br />

since around July last year, (to<br />

inform the previous<br />

consultation.)<br />

<strong>The</strong> briefest glance<br />

at its findings show<br />

the out-of-river options<br />

to be: - Chiefly,<br />

ecologically damaging,<br />

and mainly<br />

because of impaired<br />

use of Horseshoe<br />

Lake as a key drainage area for<br />

the Cranford flood basin.<br />

- Disruptive to locals and infrastructure<br />

( more than 400,000<br />

truck movements) hugely<br />

expensive, both to make and to<br />

maintain.<br />

- Unlikely to draw big competitions<br />

away from their current<br />

venues of Lakes Ruataniwha<br />

and Karapiro and there is no economic<br />

benefit to New Zealand.<br />

From my perspective as a 20 year<br />

local and someone who has been<br />

talking a lot with people who<br />

love the river and the area - they<br />

want a beautiful green space with<br />

the river as the centrepiece and<br />

clean waterways, which tallies<br />

with the responses RC got in its<br />

previous consultation.<br />

<strong>The</strong> lake will cut the flow of<br />

the city to sea park in half and<br />

remove New Brighton Rd, it will<br />

treat our river like a drain, and<br />

will be at constant risk of contamination<br />

from groundwater (it<br />

will be partly fed from surficial<br />

aquifers and needs to use the<br />

deep aquifers to constantly flush<br />

it clean, 24/7). It will<br />

introduce an enormous<br />

body of water -<br />

around one and half<br />

million cubic metres<br />

- into the floodplain<br />

of a polluted urban<br />

river, in a high risk<br />

flood zone. In a high<br />

risk quake zone. I do<br />

not believe the East<br />

Lake Trust’s complaint against<br />

RC has any merit. To my knowledge<br />

RC been never been disingenuous,<br />

or less than rigorous in<br />

their research and consideration<br />

of ideas and none was more<br />

considered. My understanding<br />

is the lake advocates may take<br />

legal action potentially holding<br />

up decision-making on the red<br />

zone for years. This would be extremely<br />

disappointing. <strong>The</strong>ir actions<br />

seem to be designed to get<br />

their way, rather than contribute<br />

to finding the best solution.<br />

Learning quake lessons<br />

WHEN WE experience disaster,<br />

we can always learn lessons –<br />

what did we do well and what<br />

didn’t we do so well?<br />

It’s vital that we do this, and as<br />

a council, we are always putting<br />

the spotlight on what happened<br />

after every such experience. If<br />

we don’t look at what actually<br />

happened, then we could keep<br />

making the same mistakes over<br />

and over again.<br />

<strong>The</strong>re have been many<br />

reports done on aspects of what<br />

happened before, during and<br />

after the earthquakes. But they<br />

haven’t been brought together.<br />

<strong>The</strong> previous Government was<br />

all set to go on a symposium, but<br />

like the earthquakes themselves,<br />

it was to occur in an election<br />

year. <strong>The</strong>re was a genuine<br />

concern that it could be written<br />

off as a Government-sponsored,<br />

election year, whitewash if it only<br />

looked at the things that went<br />

well.<br />

<strong>The</strong> reality is that we often<br />

learn more from mistakes; the<br />

things that we wouldn’t want to<br />

be repeated. And that’s why it’s<br />

vital that we look back, not to<br />

blame, but to understand, and<br />

we need to be prepared to say<br />

what went wrong.<br />

This Government has agreed<br />

Mayor<br />

Lianne Dalziel<br />

DISASTER: <strong>The</strong> Canterbury Earthquakes Recovery<br />

Symposium will look at the lessons learnt from the quakes.<br />

PHOTO: MARTIN HUNTER<br />

to work collaboratively with the<br />

city council on the Canterbury<br />

Earthquakes Recovery<br />

Symposium and the workshops<br />

that will lead up to it, which<br />

means we will be sharing the<br />

costs.<br />

A lot of the city council’s share<br />

will be ‘in kind’ support, and<br />

the full amount will be disclosed<br />

when known.<br />

If we don’t do this well,<br />

then there is a risk that future<br />

governments will make the same<br />

mistakes, which would mean the<br />

costs could be much greater, and<br />

I’m sure no-one would want that<br />

to be our legacy.<br />

40 % off<br />

up<br />

to<br />

rrp<br />

all<br />

luggage<br />

just bag Z<br />

destination... live your dream!<br />

So-Lite Range<br />

Disney Range<br />

New Zealand<br />

Styles<br />

Travel<br />

Accessories<br />

Marvel Range<br />

Eminent<br />

Superlight<br />

High Sierra<br />

4 Wheel Duffle<br />

Wheel Grips<br />

Eminent TPO<br />

DressSmart Mall - 417 Main South Rd, Hornby | juliegriff@xtra.co.nz<br />

03 349 7887 | Open 10am-5pm, 7 days<br />

Samsonite<br />

Ranges<br />

just<br />

bagZ

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!