The Star: September 20, 2018
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
6 Thursday <strong>September</strong> <strong>20</strong> <strong>20</strong>18<br />
Latest Christchurch news at www.star.kiwi<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />
News<br />
Questions raised on location for<br />
A new multi-purpose<br />
arena is one step<br />
closer as $2<strong>20</strong> million<br />
of Government<br />
funding was approved<br />
by the city council<br />
last week. Stewart<br />
Barnett, a key player<br />
in the development<br />
of Dunedin’s Forsyth<br />
Barr stadium shares<br />
concerns about<br />
the Christchurch<br />
development and tips<br />
for success. Julia Evans<br />
reports<br />
FUTURE: A 25,000-seat covered stadium is being planned for Hereford, Tuam, Madras and<br />
Barbadoes Sts.<br />
A KEY player in the development<br />
of Forsyth Barr Stadium<br />
has questioned whether<br />
Christchurch’s proposed $500<br />
million stadium will be built in<br />
the right place.<br />
“Location is paramount,”<br />
Stewart Barnett says.<br />
Mr Barnett challenged whether<br />
the designated three blocks<br />
bound by Hereford, Tuam,<br />
Madras, and Barbadoes Sts was<br />
right.<br />
“Eight or nine years ago people<br />
with the best will in the world<br />
planned out a city after an earthquake,<br />
but that should be a living<br />
document, should evolve as our<br />
city evolves and should not be<br />
cast in stone.”<br />
“I do think there is<br />
a problem building a<br />
stadium in residential<br />
areas, just look at Eden<br />
Park. You’re creating<br />
problems,” he said.<br />
Now based in<br />
Christchurch, Mr Barnett<br />
was a trustee on the<br />
Carisbrook Stadium<br />
Charitable Trust and<br />
project director for the<br />
Rangi Ruru Girls’ School rebuild.<br />
In <strong>20</strong>16 he was made an Officer<br />
of the New Zealand Order of<br />
Merit.<br />
Stewart<br />
Barnett<br />
He was guest speaker at former<br />
Mayor Garry Moore’s Tuesday<br />
Club this week.<br />
He said the stadium’s design<br />
in the pre-feasibility<br />
study was also to be<br />
questioned.<br />
“Like most people I<br />
thought we were building<br />
a modern multipurpose<br />
stadium that<br />
would be used for sport<br />
and art and was basically<br />
a replacement of Lancaster<br />
Park. But when I look<br />
in the paper, it looks like<br />
a performing arts centre that will<br />
occasionally hold some sport.”<br />
Mr Barnett said the success<br />
of Forsyth Barr was that it was<br />
not designed to be an indoor<br />
stadium.<br />
“Otago was not looking for an<br />
indoor stadium at all, we set out<br />
to build an outdoor stadium with<br />
a fixed roof.”<br />
However, it was making sure<br />
the cost to the ratepayer was kept<br />
to a minimum drove the Forsyth<br />
project, he said.<br />
“We set out with a budget<br />
for $198 million all up and we<br />
wished to build the actual cost<br />
of the stadium for $165.4 million<br />
. . . we actually delivered at $167.9<br />
million which annoyed<br />
the hell out of me because it<br />
wasn’t precise, it was 1.3 per<br />
cent wrong. <strong>The</strong> reason you get<br />
annoyed is because its not your<br />
money, it’s the ratepayers’.”<br />
Mr Barnett said the simplest<br />
way of thinking about it was<br />
breaking the figure down into the<br />
cost of the stadium divided by<br />
seats – $500 million divided by<br />
25,000.<br />
“We monitored ourselves on<br />
price per seat. It is the most simple<br />
calculation. Basically Otago<br />
came in $7<strong>20</strong>0 per seat. Presently<br />
we’re looking at $<strong>20</strong>,000 per seat<br />
in Christchurch.”<br />
Forsyth Barr was funded by the<br />
Dunedin City Council, the Otago<br />
Regional Council, the Government,<br />
Otago University and the<br />
Otago Community Trust.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> regional council put in<br />
$37.5 million. <strong>The</strong>se stadiums are<br />
regional stadiums and basically<br />
we sold the stadium on Waitaki<br />
south. We had funding and<br />
support from Queenstown and<br />
Invercargill because they knew<br />
if they didn’t, they would have<br />
to travel to Christchurch to see<br />
any rugby or concerts or sport or<br />
anything.”<br />
“<strong>The</strong> DCC was required in<br />
the finish to fund $146.5 million<br />
so that was what the ratepayers<br />
funded. That’s a very important<br />
number when you look at what<br />
the project did and achieved.”<br />
THE LITTLE RIVER BAND<br />
Problems with mobility<br />
but don’t know what to<br />
look for? We do...<br />
JON STEVENS LEO SAYER ROSS WILSON<br />
MIDGE MARSDEN<br />
AUTOMATIC 80s<br />
PLUS GOLDEN KIWIS:<br />
PETER URLICH TH’DUDES HARRY LYON HELLO SAILOR<br />
RIKKI MORRIS CROCODILES CHERIE MATHIESON SOLA ROSA<br />
RICK BALL HELLO SAILOR TONY WAINE THE NARCS<br />
<strong>20</strong>19<br />
TICKETS ON SALE NOW<br />
ON THE DOMAIN LINCOLN 2 MARCH <strong>20</strong>19<br />
www.selwynsounds.co.nz<br />
Pegasus Pro<br />
Perfect for... people on the go<br />
Ideal for longer trips into town or<br />
afternoons driving around the park<br />
with your grandchildren, the Pegasus Pro<br />
is a powerful upgrade to the standard model.<br />
With enhanced battery performance and<br />
improved suspension, it is ideal for users<br />
who want improved all round performance.<br />
Contact us<br />
03 366 8815 | sales@mobilitysystems.co.nz<br />
www.mobilitysystems.co.nz<br />
DISTANCE (KM) - 52<br />
WEIGHT (KG) - 160<br />
TOP SPEED (KM/H) - 10<br />
Visit us<br />
29 Shakespeare Road<br />
Waltham, Christchurch<br />
(near Holland Suzuki Cars)<br />
Open Monday to Friday<br />
8:30am – 5pm<br />
or by appointment<br />
Parking available