The Star: October 21, 2021
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
• By Chris Barclay<br />
A COMMUNITY group has<br />
slammed Catherine Chu’s<br />
lax attendance at staff-led<br />
briefings but the city councillor<br />
is unrepentant, insisting the<br />
missed consultations were<br />
irrelevant.<br />
<strong>The</strong> first-term<br />
Riccarton Ward<br />
representative’s<br />
disdain<br />
for briefings<br />
– designed to<br />
update and<br />
inform councillors<br />
on issues<br />
– stretches back<br />
to September<br />
last year, where figures indicated<br />
she failed to attend half the<br />
maximum number.<br />
Chu is in the cross hairs again<br />
this week with the Avonhead<br />
Community Group emailing her<br />
Independent Citizens hierarchy<br />
and Mayor Lianne Dalziel to<br />
express “concern and dissatisfaction”<br />
with the 25-year-old’s<br />
performance.<br />
Group chair Professor Somnath<br />
Bagchi said Chu had only<br />
attended 34 of a possible 86<br />
council briefings from <strong>October</strong><br />
25, 2019 to June<br />
29, 20<strong>21</strong>.<br />
“An elected<br />
representative to<br />
the council, who<br />
is paid for using<br />
public money, is<br />
expected to pay<br />
full attention to<br />
the role. We are<br />
not confident<br />
that Cr Chu is<br />
attending meetings enough to be<br />
able to act in the interests of the<br />
public or represent her electorate<br />
effectively,” he said.<br />
Lacking the legal means to<br />
remove an elected representative<br />
“despite poor performance” the<br />
group urged Independent Citizens<br />
chair Jason Middlemiss to make<br />
briefings compulsory for Chu.<br />
Bagchi was seeking discussions<br />
with Middlemiss.<br />
Neither Middlemiss nor<br />
Dalziel were unable to respond<br />
to <strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong> yesterday.<br />
Although unhappy, the group<br />
did not seek Chu’s resignation<br />
before next <strong>October</strong>’s local<br />
government elections, with<br />
Bagchi estimating a by-election<br />
could cost more than $80,000.<br />
He said the group was also<br />
irked by Chu’s decision to stand<br />
Latest Canterbury news at starnews.co.nz<br />
– unsuccessfully – for National<br />
in Banks Peninsula at last year’s<br />
general election, eight weeks<br />
after she was voted on to council.<br />
City councillors are paid<br />
$114,130 a year.<br />
“For almost 5-6 months she<br />
was completely unavailable<br />
because she was busy with her<br />
electorate campaign. She should<br />
have declared her principal<br />
interest was somewhere else,”<br />
Bagchi said.<br />
Chu was adamant the council<br />
briefings were often unnecessary:<br />
“To be really blunt and honest, a<br />
lot of them are a waste of<br />
staff time.”<br />
She made an exception<br />
about a recent briefing on the<br />
implications of the Government’s<br />
controversial Three Waters<br />
reforms before the council sent<br />
their feedback to Wellington.<br />
However, she insisted many<br />
did not warrant attending, citing<br />
Tuesday’s schedule, which<br />
included an update on the council’s<br />
outdoor dining policy.<br />
“Staff are having to sit there<br />
the whole day, they’re getting<br />
paid so much money by<br />
NEWS 5<br />
City councillor unrepentant after being<br />
slammed again for poor attendance<br />
Catherine<br />
Chu<br />
Somnath<br />
Bagchi<br />
UNDER FIRE: Catherine Chu, third from left, pictured<br />
with the members of the Halswell Hornby Riccarton<br />
Community Board in November 2020.<br />
Thursday <strong>October</strong> <strong>21</strong> 20<strong>21</strong> <strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />
ratepayers to go over such basic<br />
things with us. It’s not worth<br />
it,” she said, arguing councillors<br />
already had received relevant<br />
information through email.<br />
Chu said some residents were<br />
sympathetic after she explained<br />
her stance.<br />
“Some said go, have a tick next<br />
to your name, and just leave. It’s<br />
not in my nature to do that,” she<br />
said.<br />
Others were concerned Chu<br />
would not be able to make<br />
informed decisions on their<br />
behalf by skipping briefings. She<br />
countered, urging the council to<br />
live-stream the proceedings.<br />
“If the council are so confident<br />
our briefings are efficient why<br />
aren’t we live-streaming for the<br />
public to see? <strong>The</strong>n they could<br />
truly see what a waste of time<br />
some of them are.”<br />
Independent Citizens<br />
councillor Sam MacDonald, who<br />
works with the Avonhead group,<br />
said it was not his place to defend<br />
Chu but he could see her point.<br />
“Some are really valuable but<br />
[with] others I feel like we sit<br />
there going through the motions.<br />
A lot of it does feel a lot like<br />
virtue signalling in a sense,”<br />
he said.<br />
bananas $ ............................................ 1 .99<br />
KG<br />
ASPARAGUS BUNCH .................... $ 2 .99<br />
each<br />
navel oranges $ .......................... 2 .99<br />
kg<br />
VINE SWEET CAPSICUMS<br />
175G ........................................................... $ 2 .99<br />
each<br />
WASHED AGRIA POTATOES<br />
5KG $ ............................................................ 5 .99<br />
bag<br />
BAGGED WINTERNELIS<br />
PEARS 1KG $ ........................................... 2 .99<br />
bag<br />
beef PORTERHOUSE<br />
STEAK $ ...................................................... 24 .99<br />
kg<br />
lamb loin chops $ ...................... 22 .99<br />
kg<br />
pork slices $ ..................................... 15 .99<br />
kg<br />
pork leg steak $ .......................... 12 .99<br />
kg<br />
SKIN ON CHICKEN BREAST $ ... 9 .99<br />
kg<br />
At<br />
we have...<br />
FRIDAY TO<br />
SUNDAY ONLY<br />
Lettuce $ 1 .99<br />
.................................. each<br />
Loose carrots $ 1 .49<br />
............. kg<br />
Boston $ 10 .99<br />
butt.................... kg<br />
Check our website for<br />
your local stores opening hours<br />
All our fresh meat is 100% NZ FARMED. specials VAlid<br />
18th <strong>October</strong> - 24TH <strong>October</strong> 20<strong>21</strong>.<br />
WHILE STOCKS LAST! ONLY AVAILABLE AT RAEWARD FRESH HAREWOOD RD, TOWER JUNCTION<br />
WWW.<br />
.CO.NZ<br />
Like us on<br />