einstein
einstein
einstein
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
even the middle class.<br />
There was one group that could be easily cast as the alien and dark force most responsible for the humiliation facing a proud culture.“People<br />
need a scapegoat and make the Jews responsible,” Einstein noted. “They are a target of instinctive resentment because they are of a different<br />
tribe.” 7<br />
Weyland, Lenard, and the Antirelativists<br />
The explosion of great art and ideas in Germany at the time, as Amos Elon wrote in his book The Pity of It All, was largely due to Jewish patrons<br />
and pioneers in a variety of fields. This was particularly true in science. As Sigmund Freud pointed out, part of the success of Jewish scientists was<br />
their “creative skepticism,” which arose from their essential nature as outsiders. 8 What the Jewish assimilationists underestimated was the<br />
virulence with which many Germans, whom they considered to be their fellow countrymen, in fact saw them as essentially outsiders or, as Einstein<br />
put it, “a different tribe.”<br />
Einstein’s first public collision with this anti-Semitism came in the summer of 1920. A shady German nationalist named Paul Weyland, an<br />
engineer by training, had turned himself into a polemicist with political aspirations. He was an active member of a right-wing nationalistic political<br />
party that pledged, in its 1920 official program, to “diminish the dominant Jewish influence showing up increasingly in government and in public.” 9<br />
Weyland realized that Einstein, as a highly publicized Jew, had engendered resentment and jealousy. Likewise, his relativity theory was easy to<br />
turn into a target, because many people, including some scientists, were unnerved by the way it seemed to undermine absolutes and be built on<br />
abstract hypotheses rather than grounded in solid experiment. So Weyland published articles denouncing relativity as “a big hoax” and formed a<br />
ragtag (but mysteriously well-funded) organization grandly dubbed the Study Group of German Scientists for the Preservation of a Pure Science.<br />
Joining with Weyland was an experimental physicist of modest reputation named Ernst Gehrcke, who for years had been assailing relativity with<br />
more vehemence than comprehension. Their group lobbed a few personal attacks at Einstein and the “Jewish nature” of relativity theory, then called<br />
a series of meetings around Germany, including a large rally at Berlin’s Philharmonic Hall on August 24.<br />
Weyland spoke first and, with the orotund rhetoric of a demagogue, accused Einstein of engaging in a “businesslike booming of his theory and<br />
his name.” Einstein’s penchant for publicity, wanted or not, was being used against him, as his assimilationist friends had warned. Relativity was a<br />
hoax, Weyland said, and plagiarized to boot. Gehrcke said much the same with a more technical gloss, reading from a written text. The meeting,<br />
reported the New York Times, “had a decidedly antiSemitic complexion.” 10<br />
In the middle of Gehrcke’s talk, there arose from the audience a quiet murmur:Einstein, Einstein. He had come to see the circus and, averse<br />
neither to publicity nor controversy, laugh at the spectacle. As his friend Philipp Frank noted, “He always liked to regard events in the world around<br />
him as if he were a spectator in a theater.” Sitting in the audience with his friend the chemist Walther Nernst, he cackled loudly at times and at the<br />
end pronounced the entire event “most amusing.” 11<br />
But he was not truly amused, and he even briefly considered moving away from Berlin. 12 His anger aroused, he made the tactical mistake of<br />
responding with a highly charged diatribe that was published three days later on the front page of the Berliner Tageblatt, a liberal daily owned by<br />
Jewish friends. “I am well aware that the two speakers are unworthy of reply by my pen,” he said, but then proceeded not to be restrained by that<br />
awareness. Gehrcke and Weyland had not been explicitly anti-Semitic, nor did they overtly criticize Jews in their speeches. But Einstein alleged<br />
that they would not have attacked his theory “if I were a German nationalist, with or without a swastika, instead of a Jew.” 13<br />
Einstein spent most of his piece refuting Weyland and Gehrcke. But he also attacked a more reputable physicist who was not at the meeting but<br />
had given support to the antirelativity cause: Philipp Lenard.<br />
Winner of the 1905 Nobel Prize, Lenard had been a pioneer experimenter who described the photoelectric effect. Einstein had once admired<br />
him. “I have just read a wonderful paper by Lenard,” Einstein had gushed to Mari back in 1901. “Under this beautiful piece I am filled with such<br />
happiness and joy that I absolutely must share some of it with you.” After Einstein had published his first spate of seminal papers in 1905, citing<br />
Lenard by name in the one on light quanta, the two scientists had exchanged flattering letters. 14<br />
But as an ardent German nationalist, Lenard had become increasingly bitter about the British and the Jews, contemptuous of the publicity<br />
Einstein’s theory was garnering, and vocal in his attacks on the “absurd” aspects of relativity. He had allowed his name to be used on brochures<br />
that were distributed at Weyland’s meeting, and as a Nobel laureate he had worked behind the scenes to make sure that Einstein was not awarded<br />
the prize.<br />
Because Lenard had refrained from showing up at the Philharmonic Hall rally, and because his published critiques of relativity had been<br />
academic in tone, Einstein did not need to attack him in his newspaper piece. But he did. “I admire Lenard as a master of experimental physics,<br />
but he has not yet produced anything outstanding in theoretical physics, and his objections to the general theory of relativity are of such superficiality<br />
that, up until now, I did not think it necessary to answer them,” he wrote. “I intend to make up for this.” 15<br />
Einstein’s friends publicly supported him. A group that included von Laue and Nernst published a letter claiming, not altogether accurately,<br />
“Whoever is fortunate enough to be close to Einstein knows that he will never be surpassed in his . . . dislike of all publicity.” 16<br />
Privately, however, his friends were appalled. He had been provoked into a display of public anger against those who should have remained<br />
unworthy of a reply by his pen, thus stirring up even more distasteful publicity. Max Born’s wife, Hedwig, who had freely scolded Einstein about his<br />
treatment of his family, now lectured, “[You should] not have allowed yourself to be goaded into that rather unfortunate reply.” He should show more<br />
respect, she said, for “the secluded temple of science.” 17<br />
Paul Ehrenfest was even harsher. “My wife and I absolutely cannot believe that you yourself wrote some of the phrases in the article,” he said. “If<br />
you really did write them down with your own hand, it proves that these damn pigs have finally succeeded in touching your soul. I urge you as<br />
strongly as I can not to throw one more word on this subject to that voracious beast, the public.” 18<br />
Einstein was somewhat contrite. “Don’t be too severe with me,” he replied to the Borns. “Everyone must, from time to time, make a sacrifice on<br />
the altar of stupidity, to please the deity and mankind. And I did so thoroughly with my article.” 19 But he made no apologies for flunking their<br />
standards of publicity avoidance. “I had to do this if I wanted to stay in Berlin, where every child recognizes me from photographs,” he told<br />
Ehrenfest. “If one believes in democracy, then one must grant the public this much right as well.” 20<br />
Not surprisingly, Lenard was outraged by Einstein’s article. He insisted on an apology, as he had not even been part of the antirelativity rally.<br />
Arnold Sommerfeld, chairman of the German Physical Society, tried to mediate, and he urged Einstein “to write some conciliatory words to<br />
Lenard.” 21 It was not to be. Einstein refused to back down, and Lenard ended up edging ever closer to being an outright antiSemite and later a<br />
Nazi.