The Bel - visit site - Bel Group
The Bel - visit site - Bel Group
The Bel - visit site - Bel Group
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
2011<br />
BUSINESS AND<br />
CORPORATE<br />
SOCIAL<br />
RESPONSIBILITY<br />
REPORT
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> basics<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s mission is to share smiles with families through the pleasure of dairy<br />
goodness. It’s a demanding mission undertaken by 11,400 employees<br />
who are guided by the <strong>Group</strong>’s fi ve core values: ethics, innovation, enthusiasm,<br />
competence, and cohesion.<br />
Present internationally in over 120 countries<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s cheeses are sold on six continents. To be closer to consumers, <strong>Bel</strong> maintains operations in all<br />
its main markets.<br />
Western Europe<br />
Eastern Europe<br />
Near and Middle East<br />
Greater Africa<br />
Americas, Asia-Pacifi c<br />
33<br />
countries<br />
with a <strong>Group</strong><br />
presence<br />
49<br />
nationalities<br />
within the<br />
<strong>Group</strong><br />
11,400<br />
employees<br />
27<br />
production<br />
<strong>site</strong>s around<br />
the world<br />
1 billion<br />
consumers<br />
in 2020<br />
Today, 400 million consumers<br />
around the world appreciate <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
products. By 2020, the <strong>Group</strong> aims<br />
to have one billion consumers.<br />
This goal, which is in line with <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
mission, is predicated on a drive<br />
for constant innovation, to make<br />
dairy goodness accessible to<br />
the greatest number of people.
An extraordinary<br />
brand portfolio<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>, the world specialist in single-serving cheese<br />
portions, possesses a unique brand portfolio comprised<br />
of 5 core global brands, including <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® ,<br />
Mini Babybel ® , Kiri ® , Leerdammer ® , and Boursin ® ,<br />
8 international brands like Apéricube ® and Picon ® ,<br />
and 17 national brands. In all, the <strong>Group</strong> has 30 brands<br />
adapted to various diets and eating habits around<br />
the world.<br />
5 pillars at the heart of the <strong>Group</strong>’s CSR policy<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> has made corporate social responsibility (CSR) the centerpiece of its development strategy and has asked<br />
all its employees to participate in this unifying, continuous improvement project. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> has based its<br />
approach on fi ve prioritized pillars involving all its stakeholders, namely consumers, employees, partners<br />
and suppliers, as well as all the communities where <strong>Bel</strong> has operations.<br />
Nutrition and<br />
responsible products:<br />
developing<br />
nutritionally benefi cial<br />
products adapted<br />
to consumer needs<br />
and accessible to<br />
the greatest number<br />
of people.<br />
Employer commitment :<br />
providing employees<br />
with the conditions<br />
for personal and<br />
collective growth.<br />
Responsible communication<br />
and consumption:<br />
giving consumers who put<br />
their trust in our brands the keys<br />
to responsible consumption.<br />
Environmental<br />
footprint: reducing<br />
the environmental<br />
footprint of all the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s activities,<br />
whether directly<br />
or indirectly related<br />
to the manufacture<br />
of our products.<br />
Partnerships<br />
and society:<br />
maintaining sustainable<br />
development<br />
partnerships with<br />
suppliers and civil<br />
society.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • III
02 Chairman’s message<br />
04 Corporate governance<br />
06 2011 Financial results<br />
08 Strategy and markets<br />
12 Brand review<br />
16 CSR strategy and process<br />
18 RESPONSIBLE BRANDS<br />
THAT BOND WITH CONSUMERS<br />
20 Multiplying smiles around the world<br />
22 Innovating on behalf of consumers<br />
24 Safety and consumer information<br />
26 A STATE OF MIND<br />
28 Employer commitment<br />
32 Involving our partners<br />
34 Sharing the <strong>Group</strong>’s values<br />
39 PRESERVING THE ENVIRONMENT<br />
40 Raw material and packaging<br />
42 Inside the production <strong>site</strong>s<br />
44 From the plant to the consumer<br />
46 FINANCIAL AND CSR<br />
KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS<br />
48 CSR key performance indicators<br />
60 Financial key performance indicators
PROFILE<br />
17 marques<br />
nationales<br />
8 marques<br />
internationales<br />
5 marques<br />
cœur<br />
Sharing smiles<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> is an international, family-controlled group that makes innovative products from traditional<br />
cheese. Delightful, healthy and adapted to a diverse range of eating habits, <strong>Bel</strong>’s products have<br />
attracted 400 million consumers in over 120 countries. <strong>Bel</strong>’s growth is derived from the power<br />
of its differentiated and universal brands. Among these are its fi ve core brands, including<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® , Mini Babybel ® , Kiri ® , Leerdammer ® , and Boursin ® . Backed by the enthusiasm<br />
and dedication of its 11,400 employees, the <strong>Group</strong> takes a long-term view of growth, favoring<br />
both sustainable peformance and international development. Its goal is to share smiles and dairy<br />
goodness with a billion consumers worldwide by 2020. In 2011, <strong>Bel</strong> generated consolidated sales<br />
of €2.5 billion, up 4.5% over the previous year, despite a turbulent environment.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 1
CHAIRMAN’S MESSAGE<br />
Our growth potential<br />
confi rmed by our<br />
performance<br />
Antoine Fiévet, Chairman and Chief Executive Offi ce of the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
Our international strategy<br />
has not only balanced out risks,<br />
but has, above all, continued<br />
to spur new growth opportunities.<br />
2 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s mission to share smiles with families<br />
was never more relevant than in 2011,<br />
a year marked by a continued economic<br />
slowdown in Western countries, a terrible<br />
earthquake in Japan and far-reaching<br />
geopolitical events.<br />
Despite the diffi cult environment, <strong>Bel</strong> once again<br />
achieved sales growth in 2011, versus prior years. It was<br />
a remarkable performance, one that underscores the<br />
direct contribution of the <strong>Group</strong>’s 11,400 employees,<br />
who merit our congratulations.<br />
While we generated further sales growth, our<br />
profi tability suffered from soaring raw material, energy<br />
and packaging prices, as well as unfavorable exchange<br />
rates. We were unable to fully pass those costs on in<br />
our selling prices, resulting in profi tability below targets<br />
that we had set for ourselves, although <strong>Bel</strong> was able to<br />
continue consolidating its fi nancial structure during<br />
the year. <strong>The</strong> performance, however, confi rmed the<br />
strength of our business model, which was reinforced<br />
by our balanced international market positions,<br />
allowing the <strong>Group</strong> to grow even in a time of economic<br />
uncertainty. 2012 looks to be another tough year.<br />
Undeniable strengths<br />
Today, <strong>Bel</strong> has all the strengths for successfully meeting<br />
the challenges of this new environment. I can name fi ve<br />
strengths that are part of the <strong>Group</strong>’s DNA, and which<br />
we must maintain and develop. <strong>The</strong>y are the specifi city<br />
and power of our brands, the proximity of our markets,<br />
our ability to innovate, the dedication of all our<br />
employees, and the social responsibility that guides<br />
our actions.<br />
With its fi ve core brands and 25 local brands, <strong>Bel</strong> has<br />
a portfolio without equal. <strong>The</strong>se brands have always<br />
been more than about just meeting a need. <strong>The</strong>y have<br />
forged close ties to consumers.
4.5%<br />
increase versus<br />
2010 sales<br />
€2.5<br />
billion<br />
in sales<br />
In 2011, the sales of all fi ve core-brands advanced.<br />
Considerable growth potential remains, however, and<br />
we must continue to cultivate the brands and the ties<br />
that bind them to our consumers around the globe.<br />
International expansion is also in the company’s genes,<br />
and today we can see the wisdom of the decisions<br />
made decades ago that enable us to market our<br />
products in over 120 countries. Our international<br />
strategy has not only balanced out our business risk,<br />
but has, above all, continued to lead to new growth<br />
opportunities. <strong>Bel</strong>’s organization evolved in 2011, and<br />
that change has brought decision-making centers even<br />
closer to market.<br />
To better serve our consumers<br />
To better serve our consumers, we depend on<br />
innovation, one of the <strong>Group</strong>’s core values and an area<br />
of progress particularly dear to my heart. New products<br />
are the most visible signs of innovation. In 2011,<br />
products launched within the last three years<br />
accounted for 8% of <strong>Bel</strong>’s consolidated sales. That<br />
percentage has grown year after year, and we expect to<br />
it to grow even further. Less visible, but contributing just<br />
as much to the <strong>Group</strong>’s growth are the constant efforts<br />
to improve the nutritional benefi ts and natural content<br />
of our recipes, notably through the development of<br />
new manufacturing processes, or the exploration of<br />
new distribution methods, among other innovations.<br />
Some long-term projects have led to true operating<br />
breakthroughs, and they contribute to advancing us<br />
toward our goal of attracting one billion consumers by<br />
2020, a goal that we have reiterated. We have decided<br />
to beef up the resources allocated to R&D. I have a<br />
great deal of hope for the projects already under way<br />
and for those still to come. <strong>The</strong>y are led by highly<br />
effective and enthusiastic teams.<br />
An enjoyable and inspiring place to work<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> is a family-controlled company, a company with<br />
11,400 employees who belong to just as many families.<br />
It is thanks to their efforts and dedication that <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
results are what they are, and that, in the face of the<br />
delicate situations we encountered in Africa and the<br />
Middle East, we were able to respond appropriately<br />
and move forward. It refl ects the essence of our human<br />
resources policy known as People First. I have always<br />
been convinced that companies where employees<br />
thrive professionally are those that offer the best<br />
environment for personal and team development.<br />
For such environments elicit the greatest dedication<br />
from their employees. <strong>Bel</strong>, its managers and all its<br />
employees must contribute to the common goal of<br />
making <strong>Bel</strong> an enjoyable and inspiring place to work.<br />
<strong>The</strong> People First social charter, issued to all teams<br />
this year, is an important step in assuming that<br />
collective responsibility.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> has big aims for growth. To that end, we have<br />
assigned as much importance to respecting our<br />
employees, our ecosystem and our stakeholders as<br />
we do to meeting our fi nancial profi tability targets.<br />
Respecting corporate social responsibility imperatives<br />
in our decision-making process will become a decisive<br />
force in the <strong>Group</strong>’s future.<br />
We are well aware of the uncertainties that face us.<br />
We understand, and we are developing the strengths<br />
that will enable us to pursue sustainable growth.<br />
Determined more than ever to sharing smiles with<br />
families by bringing the pleasure of dairy goodness,<br />
the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> is staying the course and it will continue<br />
to move forward.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 3
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE<br />
PATRICK LONGUECHAUD,<br />
Vice-President Human<br />
Resources and Organization<br />
GUILLAUME JOUËT,<br />
Vice-President Communications,<br />
Public Affairs and Corporate<br />
Social Responsibility<br />
Ensuring<br />
profi tability and<br />
independence<br />
Over 100 years old, <strong>Bel</strong> is a family-controlled group managed<br />
by the founders’ descendents. <strong>Bel</strong> takes the long-term view,<br />
in keeping with its policy of sustainable profi tability and growth.<br />
Its corporate governance refl ects this goal.<br />
Fromageries <strong>Bel</strong> is a French<br />
corporation (société<br />
anonyme) with a Board of<br />
Directors. It is listed on the<br />
Euronext Paris stock<br />
exchange. At December 31,<br />
2011, the Unibel holding company and<br />
members of the <strong>Bel</strong>/Fiévet family held<br />
a combined 71.2% of Fromageries <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
share capital.Unibel, 98.2% - owned by<br />
members of the <strong>Bel</strong>/Fiévet family group<br />
at December 31, 2011, is the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
holding company. Unibel sets the<br />
long-term vision and strategy to guide<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s growth and to ensure its<br />
profi tability and independence.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Board of Directors<br />
Fromageries <strong>Bel</strong> is managed by a Board<br />
of Directors whose Chairman is also the<br />
company’s Chief Executive Offi cer.<br />
4 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
<strong>The</strong> Board of Directors is assisted in its work<br />
by two specialized committees, the Audit<br />
Committee and the Appointments and<br />
Compensation Committee, which meet on<br />
average four times a year and may<br />
themselves be assisted by experts of their<br />
own choosing.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Board of Directors includes seven<br />
members, four of who are independent<br />
Directors in accordance with the<br />
Middlenext corporate governance code,<br />
which <strong>Bel</strong> uses for guidance in governance<br />
matters. <strong>The</strong> Board of Directors sets<br />
the company’s strategic directions<br />
primarily in the economic, social, fi nancial,<br />
and industrial realms, and ensures that<br />
those directions are implemented. It deals<br />
with all matters concerning the proper<br />
operation of the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong>.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Board of Directors voted to appoint<br />
FRÉDÉRIC NALIS,<br />
Vice-President <strong>Bel</strong><br />
Greater Africa<br />
Fatine Layt as a member of the Board,<br />
subject to the approval of the General<br />
Shareholders Meeting scheduled for<br />
May 10, 2012.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Audit Committee monitors the<br />
preparation of fi nancial information and<br />
the effectiveness of internal control<br />
systems, risk management, and the<br />
statutory auditing of the annual company<br />
and consolidated fi nancial statements by<br />
auditors. It also ensures the independence<br />
of auditors.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Appointments and Compensation<br />
Committee notably issues proposals to<br />
the Board of Directors concerning the<br />
selection and appointment of <strong>Group</strong><br />
managers, offi cers and directors.<br />
It makes recommendations to the Board<br />
of Directors about director’s fees, bonus<br />
JOE TAYARD,<br />
Vice-President<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> Near and<br />
Middle East
ANTOINE<br />
FIÉVET,<br />
Chairman<br />
and CEO<br />
ÉRIC DE PONCINS,<br />
Vice-President <strong>Bel</strong><br />
Americas,<br />
Asia-Pacifi c<br />
share and stock option awards and, generally,<br />
compensation for <strong>Group</strong> offi cers and<br />
managers. It also takes part in implementing<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s strategic plan for human<br />
resources management. <strong>The</strong> Appointments<br />
and Compensation Committee is currently<br />
assisted by an outside adviser.<br />
General management<br />
Antoine Fiévet has served as <strong>Bel</strong>’s Chairman<br />
and CEO since May 14, 2009. In accordance<br />
with French law, the Chief Executive Offi cer<br />
is invested with the broadest powers<br />
to act in all circumstances on behalf of<br />
Fromageries <strong>Bel</strong>, within the limit of the<br />
company’s legally stated purpose and the<br />
provisions spelled out in the Board of<br />
Director’s internal regulations. He is assisted<br />
by Bruno Schoch, Deputy General Manager,<br />
responsible primarily for <strong>Group</strong> fi nance,<br />
legal affairs, IT systems, and development.<br />
BRUNO<br />
SCHOCH,<br />
Deputy<br />
General<br />
Manager<br />
PEDRO<br />
FERNANDES,<br />
Vice-President<br />
Innovation<br />
and Brands<br />
<strong>Group</strong> Management Committee<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> Management Committee<br />
operates under the authority of CEO and<br />
Chairman Antoine Fiévet. Its membership<br />
includes the deputy general manager<br />
and eight vice-presidents, each one<br />
responsible for an activity, namely Human<br />
Resources and Organization,<br />
Manufacturing Operations, Innovation<br />
and Brands, and Communication,<br />
Public Affairs and Corporate Social<br />
Responsibility, or an operational region,<br />
namely Western Europe, Eastern Europe,<br />
Americas Asia-Pacifi c, the Near and Middle<br />
East, and Greater Africa. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
Management Committee assists general<br />
management in implementing<br />
the strategy put forth by the Board of<br />
Directors and ensures the coordination<br />
of <strong>Group</strong> activities.<br />
HUBERT MAYET,<br />
Vice-President<br />
<strong>Group</strong> Manufacturing<br />
Operations<br />
THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />
Antoine Fiévet, Chairman and Chief Executive Offi cer<br />
Michel Arnaud*, Director<br />
Philippe Deloffre, Unibel’s Permanent Representative<br />
James Lightburn*, Director<br />
Luc Luyten*, Director<br />
Florian Sauvin, Director<br />
Johnny Thijs*, Director<br />
AUDIT COMMITTEE<br />
Philippe Deloffre, Chairman<br />
James Lightburn*<br />
Johnny Thijs*<br />
APPOINTMENTS AND<br />
COMPENSATION COMMITTEE<br />
Luc Luyten*, Chairman<br />
Antoine Fiévet<br />
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER<br />
Bruno Schoch<br />
* Independent Director<br />
FRANCIS<br />
LE CAM,<br />
Vice-President<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> Western<br />
Europe<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 5
2011 FINANCIAL RESULTS<br />
Strong sales and<br />
fi nancial performance<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> once again grew its sales and further improved its fi nancial position in 2011. At the same time,<br />
complex economic and geopolitical conditions in certain countries and soaring raw material prices<br />
worldwide reduced earnings, compared with previous years.<br />
I<br />
n 2011, <strong>Bel</strong>’s sales volumes reached<br />
a record level, marking another year<br />
of growth. Consolidated sales<br />
exceeded €2.5 billion, up 4.5%<br />
overall and up 7% at constant<br />
exchange rates and scope of<br />
consolidation versus 2010. Despite diffi cult<br />
conditions, the growth was driven by the<br />
appeal of the <strong>Group</strong>’s iconic brands, its<br />
effective sales and marketing strategies<br />
and a successful innovation policy.<br />
Record volume in 2011<br />
By geographical region, sales in the Near<br />
and Middle East fell 9.2%, as a result of<br />
higher raw material prices and aggressive<br />
local and regional competition. In Eastern<br />
Europe, the sales downtrend tied to the<br />
region’s economic recession was halted<br />
with respect to sales at constant scope<br />
of consolidation. At the same time, the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s home market of Western Europe,<br />
and the powerful growth markets of the<br />
Americas, Asia-Pacifi c and Greater Africa<br />
regions all reported remarkable<br />
performances.<br />
6 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
Negative impact from spike<br />
in raw material prices<br />
Starting at the end of 2010, rising raw<br />
material prices signifi cantly impacted<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s earnings. To avoid penalizing<br />
consumers during troubled economic<br />
times, <strong>Bel</strong> continued its drive to improve<br />
productivity (in manufacturing, organization,<br />
purchasing, and other areas), and did not<br />
pass on the full increase of its production<br />
costs to selling prices. As a result, in 2011,<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s operating income came to<br />
€170 million, down 12.5% versus 2010.<br />
Balance sheet strengthened<br />
In 2011, consolidated net profi t,<br />
<strong>Group</strong> share, fell 17.4% on the back of a<br />
31% increase in fi nancial expense, mainly<br />
as a result of refi nancing operations,<br />
and foreign exchange losses on emerging<br />
country currencies. Conversely, the <strong>Group</strong><br />
confi rmed its ability to effectively manage<br />
working capital requirement and capital<br />
expenditure, continuing to deleverage<br />
during the year.<br />
33<br />
countries with a<br />
<strong>Group</strong> presence<br />
27<br />
production <strong>site</strong>s<br />
Over 120<br />
countries in which<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> products are<br />
distributed
Sales breakdown<br />
30<br />
international<br />
and local<br />
brands<br />
At end 2011, net fi nancial debt totaled €194<br />
million, down €46 million, or a decline of<br />
nearly 20% versus end 2010. Equity was<br />
also strengthened, from €1,009 million<br />
at end 2010 to €1,044 million at end 2011.<br />
2012 strengths<br />
<strong>The</strong> economic and geopolitical<br />
environment remained uncertain at<br />
the beginning of 2012, with no visible signs<br />
of easing price pressures in raw material<br />
markets. Nonetheless, the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
expects to grow its positions in the world<br />
market for branded cheeses, backed by<br />
its healthy balance sheet, its strong sales<br />
and marketing momentum, its drive<br />
for innovation in all world regions, and<br />
the dedication of its 11,400 employees.<br />
59%<br />
Western Europe 4%<br />
Eastern Europe<br />
11%<br />
Greater Africa<br />
11%<br />
Near And<br />
Middle East<br />
11,400<br />
employees<br />
worldwide<br />
49<br />
nationalities<br />
within<br />
the <strong>Group</strong><br />
15%<br />
Americas, Asia-Pacifi c<br />
116 195 2,418<br />
+4.5%<br />
96 170 2,527<br />
2010 2011<br />
Sales<br />
in millions of euros<br />
-12.5%<br />
2010 2011<br />
Operating income<br />
in millions of euros<br />
-17.4%<br />
2010 2011<br />
Consolidated net profi t<br />
<strong>Group</strong> share<br />
in millions of euros<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 7
STRATEGY AND MARKETS<br />
An international group<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> is the world’s third-largest branded cheese company, holding market leading positions in<br />
25 countries and ranking among the top-three branded cheese players in 45 others. Its growth<br />
potential remains strong, particularly with respect to its core brands. <strong>The</strong> race for size is not the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s goal, however. Its aim is to be the leader in all its markets and segments. To take better<br />
advantage of the growth potential of its many markets, <strong>Bel</strong> is organized into fi ve world regions.<br />
WESTERN EUROPE<br />
“Boosting volumes<br />
and market share were<br />
the priorities.”<br />
8 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
Francis Le Cam,<br />
Vice-President <strong>Bel</strong> Western Europe<br />
6.7%<br />
sales increase for <strong>Bel</strong><br />
Western Europe,<br />
versus the prior year<br />
In Western Europe,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s sales advanced<br />
6.7% in 2011, besting<br />
the already strong growth<br />
achieved in the region in 2010.<br />
Against a backdrop of lackluster<br />
market growth, that performance<br />
was nothing short of outstanding,<br />
ranking among the highest in the<br />
dairy segment and the broader<br />
consumer products sector.<br />
As in 2010, the priority for 2011<br />
was given to growing volumes and<br />
market share, with moderate and<br />
selective price increases to win<br />
customer loyalty in a period of<br />
declining purchasing power,<br />
to maintain close ties to retail<br />
partners through the growth<br />
momentum of <strong>Bel</strong>’s brands,<br />
and to keep the company’s<br />
plants operating at a high level<br />
of production. <strong>The</strong> market share<br />
of the <strong>Group</strong>’s core brands grew,<br />
consolidating their largely already<br />
established leadership positions<br />
in their respective segments.<br />
Leerdammer ® turned in a<br />
particularly robust<br />
performance and is now a leader<br />
in the sliced cheese segment,<br />
reporting strong growth in six<br />
major European countries. Other<br />
top performing brands included<br />
Kiri ® , Mini Babybel ® and Boursin ® ,<br />
whose usage range was extended<br />
to cheese platter, spreads,<br />
cooking cheese, salad cheese<br />
and, recently, cocktail cheese.<br />
<strong>The</strong> recovery begun in 2010<br />
for <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® , which<br />
celebrated its 90th anniversary<br />
in 2011, was confi rmed during the<br />
year with the launch of a new 3D<br />
advertising saga. Countries with<br />
the strongest sales momentum<br />
included Spain, up 21%, Germany,<br />
up 12%, France, the Netherlands,<br />
Switzerland, and the UK.<br />
New communication platforms<br />
helped spur the growth of most<br />
of the core brands, as did<br />
successful innovations like<br />
Leerdammer ® fl avored slices,<br />
Boursin ® ham rolls and Apéricube ®<br />
limited edition fl avors, jointly<br />
created with consumers<br />
via the Internet.
<strong>Bel</strong> Foodservice<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> Foodservice operates two<br />
businesses in Europe, including<br />
a catering activity aimed at the<br />
institutional and commercial<br />
catering segments, and the P.A.I.<br />
(intermediary food products)<br />
business, which sells <strong>Bel</strong> cheese<br />
brands to Europe’s food industry<br />
and fast food chains.<br />
In 2011, nutritional initiatives<br />
were furthered in the catering<br />
sector, with the launch of a new<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® recipe with 19.5%<br />
less fat content, the introduction of<br />
vitamin D-enriched versions of the<br />
Cantadou ® and Cantafrais ® brands,<br />
and even the launch of a newsletter<br />
aimed at dieticians in France.<br />
As for new products, three new<br />
references were added to the<br />
Boursin ® ingredient range.<br />
P.A.I.’s partners continued to show<br />
their interest in <strong>Bel</strong>’s brands as a<br />
way to set themselves apart from<br />
the competition and to create value.<br />
This was illustrated by the year’s<br />
product launches, which included<br />
ready-meal maker Fleury Michon ® ’s<br />
Boursin ® and <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
lunchboxes, fast-food chain Quick ® ’s<br />
Cheesy au Boursin ® and McDonald’s ®<br />
burger with Maredsous ® cheese.<br />
After several tough<br />
years in Eastern<br />
Europe, efforts to<br />
streamline production and<br />
adapt product ranges to<br />
national markets began to bear<br />
fruit, with the region reporting<br />
double-digit sales volume<br />
growth in 2011. Well anchored<br />
national brands such as Shotska ®<br />
in Ukraine and Karicka ® in<br />
Slovakia performed very well,<br />
but the growth of <strong>Bel</strong>’s core<br />
brands — a priority for <strong>Bel</strong> in<br />
Eastern European markets —<br />
was even more spectacular.<br />
<strong>The</strong> event of the year in<br />
the region was the launch of<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® in Ukraine,<br />
with strong market penetration.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> also began<br />
successfully marketing Kiri ® and<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® in Rumania<br />
with very encouraging results.<br />
But because weak purchasing<br />
power in these markets often<br />
makes it impossible to fully<br />
pass on higher cost prices to<br />
consumers, great care must<br />
be taken to ensure tight cost<br />
controls, while maintaining<br />
product quality.<br />
EASTERN EUROPE<br />
”<strong>The</strong> core brands<br />
remain the priority,<br />
in particular<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® .”<br />
Bruno Schoch,<br />
Deputy General Manager<br />
In 2011, national brands, which<br />
benefit from a recognition base<br />
that can be further developed,<br />
were strengthened, notably the<br />
Gervais range of fresh cheeses<br />
in the Czech Republic.<br />
However, the priority remains<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s core brands,<br />
particularly <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
in Ukraine to build on its<br />
successful launch, and<br />
Leerdammer ® in the Czech<br />
Republic and Slovakia, where<br />
the brand matches up well<br />
with consumer tastes and<br />
is growing. This strategy will<br />
be continued in 2012.<br />
€103<br />
million in sales<br />
in 2011<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 9
STRATEGY AND MARKETS<br />
10 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> Industries<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> Industries is the <strong>Group</strong><br />
division responsible for marketing<br />
and selling specially prepared<br />
dairy proteins to meet the needs<br />
of food industry customers, who<br />
make such products as ice cream,<br />
yogurt and other foods that use<br />
dairy products.<br />
In 2011, <strong>Bel</strong> Industries benefited<br />
from a 26% increase in whey<br />
powder commodity prices as a<br />
result of strong global demand.<br />
Sales to the ice cream segment<br />
were negatively impacted by<br />
unfavorable summer weather<br />
conditions in Europe and fall<br />
flooding in Thailand, which led<br />
to the temporary closing of ice<br />
cream factories. Conversely,<br />
export sales of proteins to other<br />
dairy segments accelerated.<br />
Sales momentum and extended<br />
product ranges bode well for<br />
a favorable upswing in global<br />
demand in 2012.<br />
7%<br />
advance<br />
in sales<br />
<strong>The</strong> Greater Africa region,<br />
formed in 2008, covers the<br />
entire African continent,<br />
where <strong>Bel</strong> operates three subsidiaries<br />
in North Africa and some 15<br />
distribution partnerships in sub-<br />
Saharan Africa and French overseas<br />
departments and territories. Following<br />
two consecutive years of double-digit<br />
sales growth, the region was negatively<br />
impacted by the Arab Spring uprising,<br />
instability in some sub-Saharan African<br />
countries and other geopolitical<br />
events. One extreme case was Libya,<br />
where sales were completely halted for<br />
seven months.<br />
Another growth weakening factor was<br />
the sharp increase in raw material<br />
prices, which could not be fully passed<br />
on to consumers in countries with low<br />
purchasing power and intense<br />
competition. Against this very<br />
particular backdrop, the Greater Africa<br />
region reported a very honorable 3%<br />
increase in volumes and a 7% advance<br />
in sales over 2010. Excluding Libya,<br />
volumes were up 11%.<br />
GREATER AFRICA<br />
”Growth was spurred<br />
by a strong increase<br />
in sales of core<br />
brands.”<br />
Frédéric Nalis,<br />
Vice-President <strong>Bel</strong> Greater Africa<br />
Strong momentum continued apace<br />
in Algeria and Egypt, while Morocco,<br />
sub-Saharan Africa, and French overseas<br />
territories and departments reported<br />
fi rm growth under political and<br />
macroeconomic conditions that were at<br />
times unstable. Libya was the only<br />
country to report a negative<br />
performance versus 2010.<br />
<strong>The</strong> region’s growth was propelled by<br />
a robust 10% increase in sales of the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s core brands, particularly<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® and Kiri ® .<br />
Despite the turbulent geopolitical<br />
conditions in the short term, the Greater<br />
Africa region continued to invest to<br />
develop its human resources through<br />
training and organizational buildup, its<br />
plants through capital expenditure to<br />
boost capacity, increase productivity<br />
and make improvements, and its<br />
distribution partners through sales<br />
force training programs.<br />
While 2011 was diffi cult year for Greater<br />
Africa, <strong>Bel</strong> remains confi dent in the<br />
long-term potential of the African<br />
continent, and it plans to capitalize on<br />
its leadership position<br />
in the region’s cheese sector.
NEAR AND MIDDLE EAST<br />
”Sales volumes<br />
have doubled in<br />
fi ve years.”<br />
Joe Tayard,<br />
Vice-President, <strong>Bel</strong> Near<br />
and Middle East<br />
<strong>The</strong> Near and Middle East region is home to three<br />
manufacturing <strong>site</strong>s in Turkey, Syria, and Iran, and<br />
three sales subsidiaries in Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and<br />
the United Arab Emirates. <strong>The</strong> region’s sales volumes have<br />
doubled in the past fi ve years, underscoring the strong growth<br />
potential into which <strong>Bel</strong> has been able to tap. In 2011, market<br />
conditions were notably complicated by growing business<br />
uncertainty, government-imposed selling-price ceilings despite<br />
higher raw material costs, and aggressive local and regional<br />
competition. Despite those diffi culties, <strong>Bel</strong>’s strategy of being<br />
close to its markets and consumers paid off, with market share<br />
maintained and growth in sales, even in Syria, where volumes<br />
advanced 8% in 2011.<br />
Kiri ® , the core brand with the region’s highest sales volume,<br />
performed very well in the Levant countries, particularly the local<br />
Labneh version and its range of cheese spreads. Kiri ® also did well<br />
in Iran, where Kibi ® , the Iranian name of the brand, was successfully<br />
launched and confi rmed in 2011. <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® was also<br />
introduced to Iran in 2011. Further, it benefi ted from a very<br />
effective advertising campaign in countries throughout<br />
the region on the www.albakara.com web<strong>site</strong>.<br />
In Turkey, the recovery of the subsidiary acquired in 2006,<br />
continued apace with manufacturing improvements, improved<br />
distribution and efforts to better target the core brands.<br />
In all Near and Middle Eastern countries, <strong>Bel</strong> took advantage<br />
of its regional brands like Regal Picon ® , and its strong national<br />
brands like Picon ® in Lebanon and Rouzaneh ® in Iran which<br />
complete its range.<br />
In early 2011, the<br />
Americas region was<br />
expanded to form the<br />
Americas, Asia-Pacifi c region.<br />
<strong>The</strong> region has kept the<br />
momentum going with sales<br />
advancing 11.9% in 2011. <strong>The</strong> core<br />
brands continued to develop at<br />
a brisk pace in the U.S. market.<br />
Mini Babybel ® sales climbed 21%,<br />
making the U.S. the brand’s<br />
largest market and justifying the<br />
decision to invest heavily in the<br />
construction of a new production<br />
plant by 2014.<br />
North America proved to<br />
be a strong growth market<br />
for Boursin ® , whose sales<br />
increased some 30%. Sales of<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® trended<br />
slightly down, particularly in the<br />
second half of the year versus<br />
2010, when the launch of three<br />
new <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® fl avors<br />
stimulated the market. <strong>The</strong> three<br />
variations continued to grow in<br />
2011, and their performances<br />
demonstrated U.S. consumer<br />
demand for new products —<br />
demand that <strong>Bel</strong> must meet.<br />
11.9%<br />
increase<br />
in sales<br />
AMERICAS, ASIA-PACIFIC<br />
” <strong>The</strong> region<br />
maintained its<br />
momentum with<br />
sales up 11.9%. ”<br />
Éric de Poncins,<br />
Vice-President <strong>Bel</strong> Americas, Asia-Pacifi c<br />
In Mexico, a partnership set<br />
up with a local retailer and an<br />
effective advertising campaign<br />
pushed awareness of the<br />
La Vaca que rie ® brand up 40%<br />
by end 2011, establishing a solid<br />
base on which to build future<br />
sales of <strong>Bel</strong> products in<br />
this country.<br />
In Asia-Pacific, one priority<br />
has been a market review to<br />
continue a sales offensive<br />
in high growth countries like<br />
Japan and Vietnam, and to<br />
define strategies for potentially<br />
high-growth markets such as<br />
China, South Korea and Australia.<br />
In 2011, Japan and Vietnam<br />
reported strong growth, building<br />
on consumption habits and<br />
several innovations for <strong>Bel</strong>cube ®<br />
and strawberry flavored Pik &<br />
Croq’ ® , auguring well for<br />
the development of sweet<br />
products in the region.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 11
12 • <strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong> 2011<br />
Brand<br />
review<br />
Western Europe<br />
Eastern Europe<br />
Near and Middle East<br />
Greater Africa<br />
Americas, Asia-Pacifi c<br />
● PORTUGAL<br />
Amanteigado ® ,<br />
a cheese with personality<br />
With the launch of Amanteigado ® in March 2011, Limiano ® ,<br />
Portugal’s leading cheese brand, successfully entered the<br />
uncooked pressed cheese market. <strong>The</strong> Portuguese teams<br />
have created a cheese with character, one with a soft<br />
texture, a mild yet intense taste,<br />
a practical format, a premium<br />
position, and an overnight<br />
success.<br />
● GERMANY<br />
FLAVORED LEERDAMMER ®<br />
VOTED PRODUCT OF THE YEAR<br />
Three new varieties of Leerdammer ®<br />
cheese slices were rolled out in 2011,<br />
including tomato and basil, garlic and<br />
fresh herbs, black pepper and spice.<br />
<strong>The</strong> new range quickly overcame<br />
its direct competitor and was voted<br />
”Product of the year” in the golden<br />
category by Lebensmittel magazine.<br />
● UNITED STATES<br />
Mini Babybel ® ’s<br />
largest market<br />
Mini Babybel ® is riding a healthy snack<br />
food wave in America, where its sales<br />
have grown so rapidly that the U.S.<br />
has now become the brand’s<br />
largest market.
● SENEGAL<br />
Closer to<br />
consumers<br />
In Senegal, the <strong>Group</strong>’s<br />
historical sub-Sahara African<br />
market, <strong>Bel</strong> teams organized<br />
a nutrition themed tour<br />
that mixed education and<br />
entertainment. <strong>The</strong> effort<br />
was a delightful way to<br />
strengthen ties to consumers<br />
and raise awareness about<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® ’s<br />
nutritional benefi ts.<br />
● FRANCE<br />
Boursin ® gets a new<br />
range for aperitif time<br />
Creamy and tasty Boursin ® rolled in a thin slice<br />
of ham is not only an original and delicious idea,<br />
but also a technical feat. Two recipes,<br />
garlic and fresh herbs, and pepper,<br />
were successfully launched in France.<br />
● RUMANIA<br />
”Joy every day”<br />
That’s the promise <strong>Bel</strong> made<br />
to the Rumanian market in a<br />
cooperative effort with<br />
Danone. <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® ,<br />
Kiri ® and Mini Babybel ® all<br />
received a very promising<br />
welcome from consumers.<br />
● APÉRICUBE ®<br />
Web-surfers have their say<br />
Over 120,000 fans of Apéricube ® participated in a unique<br />
and unprecedented ”fl avor search” contest to determine<br />
the best Apéricube ® fl avors to be made available<br />
as of March 2012. <strong>The</strong> contest was a way to reinvent the<br />
brand’s highly successful ”limited edition” range.<br />
● UKRAINE<br />
GAMBLE TO GO<br />
UPMARKET PAYS OFF<br />
In a market dominated by cheese<br />
blocks and entry-level products,<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® was positioned<br />
in the premium segment to highlight<br />
its quality, taste, texture, and<br />
user-friendly packaging.<br />
<strong>The</strong> short-term goal is to make<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® Cheese Blocks<br />
the market leader.<br />
● UNITED STATES<br />
BOURSIN ® MOVES<br />
INTO SNACK SEGMENT<br />
With Boursin Gourmet Tartine ® , <strong>Bel</strong> adapted<br />
to American eating habits, associating the<br />
fresh cheese with bread and crackers for<br />
enjoyment any time of the day. <strong>The</strong> launch<br />
of the spreadable Boursin ® range coincided<br />
with the brand’s fi rst nationwide TV campaign.<br />
● HONG KONG<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>cube ® targets women<br />
<strong>The</strong> latest <strong>Bel</strong>cube ® advertising<br />
campaign presented the brand as a<br />
unique and healthy snack that contains<br />
just 18 calories. It was aimed at young<br />
and active women concerned about<br />
their fi gures and health.<br />
● IRAN<br />
Kibi ® ’s success confi rmed<br />
A TV advertising campaign enabled<br />
Kibi ® , the Iranian version of the Kiri ®<br />
brand launched in 2010, to claim<br />
70% of the cheese portion market<br />
in just a few months.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 13
Brand<br />
review<br />
● CONGO<br />
A NOVEL<br />
DISTRIBUTION<br />
NETWORK<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> teams began supplying<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® to some<br />
500 ”Mapa Mamas”, who ply<br />
the streets of Kinshasa selling<br />
rolls stuffed with <strong>The</strong> Laughing<br />
Cow ® cheese. <strong>The</strong> new market<br />
access offers strong growth<br />
leverage for <strong>Bel</strong> in this central<br />
African country, which has<br />
71 million inhabitants. In 2011,<br />
sales volumes in the Congo<br />
advanced 51%.<br />
14 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
● BELGIUM<br />
Maredsous ® , a well<br />
guarded secret<br />
This famous creamy cheese, which is ripened<br />
in the cellars of the Maredsous Abbey, is now also<br />
offered in a spreadable version with two new<br />
recipes, fagotin and goat’s cheese.<br />
● ALGERIA<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® and Kiri ®<br />
get together for Ramadan<br />
Over the past four years, <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
Chef has become key cooking ingredient,<br />
particularly during Ramadan. In 2011,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> decided to promote the use of Kiri ®<br />
to prepare sweet dishes. As a result, Kiri ®<br />
sales in the month of Ramadan grew 33%.<br />
<strong>The</strong> two complementary brands were<br />
backed by a full advertising effort.<br />
● AUSTRALIA<br />
Cheez Dippers ® launched<br />
Launched in 2011, Cheez Dippers ® is an ideal<br />
lunchbox cheese for six to 12-year-olds thanks to<br />
its good nutritional balance. <strong>The</strong> brand exceeded<br />
its sales targets by more than 50%.<br />
● CANADA<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
promotes the<br />
Breakfast Club<br />
After observing that many Canadian<br />
youths arrive at school on an empty<br />
stomach, the Breakfast Club, a<br />
nonprofi t that advocates the benefi ts<br />
of breakfast, committed to distributing<br />
over 29 million breakfasts in Canadian<br />
schools. <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® partnered<br />
with Walmart to donate one Canadian<br />
dollar to the Breakfast Club for every<br />
round box of <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
cheese purchased. <strong>The</strong> program<br />
raised 25,000 Canadian dollars for<br />
the Breakfast Club.<br />
● WESTERN EUROPE<br />
Mini Babybel ® : With 98% milk,<br />
it serves us right!<br />
Mini Babybel ® ’s new European advertising campaign takes aim at both moms<br />
and children in a commercial titled ”C’est bien fait pour nous” (It serves us<br />
right). <strong>The</strong> humoristic scenes, set to an electro-rock tune, reinforce<br />
the modernity of a cheese that is 98% comprised of milk.
● MOROCCO<br />
90 years of nutrition<br />
<strong>The</strong> launch of <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
Calcivit, a vitamin D and calcium-enriched<br />
version of the cheese, was accompanied by<br />
an advertising campaign that had some fun<br />
with the famous red cow’s 90th anniversary<br />
with the slogan, ”<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® — helping<br />
to grow your children for the past 90 years.”<br />
● EGYPT<br />
Kiri ® is recognized<br />
by 99% of Egyptians<br />
In Egypt, Kiri ® ’s sales volumes<br />
have climbed 82% since 2008.<br />
● SYRIA<br />
To help all<br />
children grow<br />
<strong>The</strong> Régal Picon ® product range<br />
was enlarged with specially<br />
designed tub formats for<br />
families of very modest means.<br />
To ensure an affordable price<br />
in the target market, every step<br />
in the design, production and<br />
distribution of the product<br />
was optimized.<br />
● CZECH<br />
REPUBLIC &<br />
SLOVAKIA<br />
Leerdammer ®<br />
quickly takes the lead<br />
In just a few months’ time,<br />
Leerdammer ® became the leader<br />
in the sliced cheese segment.<br />
● NEAR AND<br />
MIDDLE EAST<br />
THE COW<br />
ONLINE<br />
<strong>The</strong> Internet is revolutionizing relations<br />
with consumers. <strong>The</strong> albakara.com<br />
web<strong>site</strong>, for example, offers 3D adventure<br />
games, goodies and ideas for family<br />
activities. Albakara is Arabic name for<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® . <strong>The</strong> <strong>site</strong> has been<br />
a phenomenal success with 9.5 million<br />
unique <strong>visit</strong>ors from the Near and Middle<br />
East region, as well as North Africa,<br />
who surf in to play with Karim, Sarah<br />
and <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® .<br />
● SOUTH KOREA<br />
THE LAUGHING COW’S ®<br />
FIRST KOREAN<br />
CAMPAIGN<br />
In its fi rst advertising campaign since<br />
entering the South Korean market,<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® is staring in a TV<br />
commercial and appearing at store events<br />
to familiarize families with the nutritional<br />
benefi ts the cheese can bring to children.<br />
● Celebrating<br />
90 years of<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
around the world<br />
<strong>The</strong> famous red cow’s<br />
anniversary was celebrated<br />
everywhere <strong>Bel</strong> is present, with<br />
contests to win birthday party<br />
snacks and trips, advertising<br />
campaigns to thank fans for<br />
their loyalty, dedicated<br />
web<strong>site</strong>s, and even a world<br />
record for the largest number<br />
of people disguised as cows<br />
and assembled in one place.<br />
● More than<br />
900 designers<br />
on hand<br />
Under the guidance of<br />
Jean-Charles de Castelbajac,<br />
some 900 young and<br />
contemporary designers from<br />
around the world redesigned<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® , while<br />
keeping the brand’s codes<br />
and values intact. <strong>The</strong> event<br />
showed once again that the<br />
brand is fashionable and<br />
intergenerational.<br />
www.lvqr.com<br />
<strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong> 2011 • 15
CSR STRATEGY AND PROCESS<br />
Building tomorrow’s<br />
company with CSR<br />
Corporate social responsibility plays a vital role at <strong>Bel</strong>, forming the core<br />
of the <strong>Group</strong>’s development strategy and fully participating in its mission.<br />
16 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> has built its corporate<br />
social responsibility policy<br />
around fi ve pillars to structure<br />
its commitment<br />
to sustainable development.<br />
<strong>The</strong> policy affects all<br />
company functions and prioritizes the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s actions with respect to its<br />
stakeholders, which include consumers,<br />
employees, partners and suppliers,<br />
as well as all the communities where<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> has operations.<br />
<strong>The</strong> process is based on the ISO 26000<br />
standard, which provides guidelines<br />
to any organization willing to assume<br />
responsibility and account for the various<br />
impacts of its decisions and activities.<br />
<strong>The</strong> fi ve pillars<br />
A structured network<br />
to deploy CSR throughout<br />
the company<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> established a CSR Department staffed<br />
by a team of 18 key-function CSR advisers<br />
from the <strong>Group</strong>’s service departments<br />
and set up a local network operated by<br />
local CSR correspondents from each of<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s regions and main countries.<br />
<strong>The</strong> regional correspondents are<br />
responsible for coordinating and guiding<br />
the deployment of the CSR policy in all<br />
countries under their responsibility.<br />
In 2012, their mission will consist of<br />
developing roadmaps as part of<br />
a medium-term business plan.<br />
<strong>The</strong> roadmaps are designed to identify<br />
Nutrition and responsible products: Developing nutritionally<br />
benefi cial products adapted to consumer needs and accessible<br />
to the greatest number of people.<br />
Responsible communication and consumption:<br />
Giving consumers who put their trust in our brands the keys<br />
to responsible consumption.<br />
Environmental footprint: Reducing the environmental footprint<br />
of all the <strong>Group</strong>’s activities, whether directly or indirectly related<br />
to the manufacture of our products.<br />
Partnerships and society: Maintaining sustainable development<br />
partnerships with suppliers and civil society.<br />
Employer commitment: Providing employees with the conditions<br />
for personal and collective growth.
priority areas of action to be taken in each<br />
region and to set targets to be reached<br />
by 2015. Beyond the structured approach<br />
and the establishment of the CSR network,<br />
all employees are asked to contribute<br />
and participate in making <strong>Bel</strong> a more<br />
socially responsible company.<br />
Guidance and assessment tools<br />
In 2011, under the guidance of the<br />
key-function CSR advisers, the CSR pillars<br />
were broken down into areas of progress<br />
and action, with specifi c and measurable<br />
performance indicators developed to<br />
track operating results and provide overall<br />
guidance for the actions undertaken.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se key performance indicators will<br />
enable the continuous improvement<br />
process to be evaluated.<br />
In this area, France’s Grenelle II law<br />
expanded the non-fi nancial reporting<br />
requirements for listed French companies,<br />
making independent, third-party<br />
verifi cation of the published information<br />
mandatory. Although the law does not<br />
apply to 2011, <strong>Bel</strong> decided to produce<br />
its fi rst trial report in 2012 based on an<br />
assessment of fi scal 2011.<br />
18<br />
key-function advisers<br />
helped defi ne<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s areas<br />
of progress<br />
interview<br />
A tremendous engine<br />
for change<br />
What characterizes <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
approach to CSR?<br />
First of all, it’s a very sincere effort.<br />
It’s not public relations posturing.<br />
Corporate social responsibility fi ts<br />
perfectly with <strong>Bel</strong>’s strategy, which<br />
calls for sustainable growth and<br />
respect for the environment and<br />
the company’s stakeholders.<br />
Our approach fully refl ects <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
mindset and values. This is not<br />
a model cut and pasted from the<br />
outside. It is based, in particular,<br />
on networking and market<br />
proximity. While the <strong>Group</strong><br />
has provided the CSR framework,<br />
each country is responsible for<br />
identifying its stakeholders’<br />
expectations and setting the<br />
priorities. Our approach is both<br />
ambitious and realistic. We know<br />
that we have a lot of progress<br />
to make, and that we need the<br />
enthusiasm and drive of everybody<br />
in order to be successful. But we<br />
are convinced that this policy is<br />
a tremendous engine for change<br />
within the <strong>Group</strong>, and it can spread<br />
to our partners, customers and<br />
consumers.<br />
France’s Grenelle II law<br />
imposes new non-fi nancial<br />
reporting requirements on<br />
listed French companies.<br />
How are you dealing with<br />
this constraint?<br />
We don’t view this requirement<br />
as a constraint but as a guidance<br />
opportunity. <strong>The</strong> key performance<br />
indicators enable us to assess the<br />
FRÉDÉRIQUE GAULARD, Head of <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> CSR<br />
progress we have achieved and<br />
the distance we have to go to meet<br />
our targets. <strong>The</strong>y can be used to<br />
make internal comparisons as well<br />
as comparisons with the outside<br />
world. <strong>The</strong>y are fundamentally<br />
guidance tools. <strong>The</strong> KPIs also show<br />
the results of individual and<br />
collective initiatives. <strong>The</strong>se results<br />
need to be shared and highlighted<br />
to inspire other initiatives,<br />
to develop pride in belonging to a<br />
<strong>Group</strong> that gets involved. <strong>Bel</strong>’s CSR<br />
web<strong>site</strong> www.smilesfortheplanet.com<br />
notably plays this role by offering<br />
concrete, fi eld-tested examples<br />
of all fi ve CSR pillars in all<br />
<strong>Group</strong> regions.<br />
What are your priorities<br />
for 2012?<br />
In 2011, we developed the tools<br />
with the key-function CSR advisers<br />
to deploy a unifi ed CSR policy<br />
across the <strong>Group</strong>. We now have<br />
a dedicated organization in all<br />
<strong>Group</strong> regions. We will be setting<br />
our 2015 targets and assessing<br />
the progress made each year.<br />
Lastly, we will encourage all<br />
employees to integrate CSR into<br />
their professional, managerial and<br />
— why not? — personal practices.<br />
+<br />
For more information about <strong>Bel</strong>’s CSR policy,<br />
go to the dedicated CSR web<strong>site</strong><br />
www.smilesfortheplanet.com<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 17
Responsible<br />
brands that bond<br />
with consumers<br />
Pleasure, conviviality and, of course, smiles form the core of<br />
the bond between <strong>Bel</strong>’s brands and its consumers. It’s a bond built<br />
over time and based upon trust and product quality with respect to<br />
taste, ease of use, food safety, nutritional benefi t, and accessibility.<br />
With its cheeses consumed by millions of people every day,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> places responsibility at the heart of its offering.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> optimizes<br />
the content of<br />
3 key nutrients<br />
in its cheese: calcium,<br />
fat and salt<br />
18 • 2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
400<br />
million<br />
consumers of <strong>Bel</strong><br />
products around<br />
the globe<br />
800 to<br />
1,200 mg<br />
is the recommended<br />
daily allowance of<br />
calcium for children
2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> • 19
RESPONSIBLE BRANDS<br />
Multiplying smiles<br />
around the world<br />
In a year marked by eroded purchasing power, dramatic natural disasters and political turmoil,<br />
consumers maintained their preference for <strong>Bel</strong> products. That observation underscores the<br />
strength of <strong>Bel</strong>’s brands, which combine healthy pleasure and nutrition with conviviality and<br />
close ties to families worldwide.<br />
I n<br />
2011, <strong>Bel</strong>’s sales performance<br />
continued to improve, with<br />
all fi ve core brands reporting<br />
positive growth. Sales volumes<br />
of Leerdammer ® and Mini Babybel ®<br />
were up more than 10% during<br />
the year. Under such diffi cult conditions,<br />
what explains the good success?<br />
No doubt it’s because <strong>Bel</strong>’s products meet<br />
consumer expectations in the Western<br />
world as well as the developing one,<br />
and that the <strong>Group</strong>’s mission of sharing<br />
smiles with families is today more<br />
fundamental than ever.<br />
Building trust<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> has been able to build a bond of trust<br />
with its consumers — an asset it must<br />
preserve. To that end, the <strong>Group</strong> must<br />
advertise responsibly. When targeting<br />
children, principles must be followed,<br />
because children often watch and indeed<br />
even act in <strong>Bel</strong> brand commercials.<br />
Those rules are spelled out <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
responsible communications charter.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> always takes care to<br />
Cliniclowns bring smiles to children<br />
with <strong>Bel</strong> in <strong>Bel</strong>gium.<br />
encourage responsible consumption<br />
and attitudes that respect the family<br />
environment. All <strong>Group</strong> subsidiaries<br />
adhere to the charter and share<br />
it with outside service providers<br />
to ensure compliance prior to<br />
the release of any advertising.<br />
<strong>The</strong> relationship of trust is also<br />
a great way to promote responsible<br />
behavior dear to many families.<br />
This is notably refl ected in the<br />
participation of <strong>Bel</strong>’s brands in<br />
actions of good citizenship and solidarity.<br />
For example, Mini Babybel ® has for many<br />
years participated in the Red Nose Day<br />
charity event, now an institution for<br />
the brand and its UK consumers.<br />
In the United States, <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
and Mini Babybel ® teamed up with<br />
the YMCA association to promote<br />
the importance of physical exercise.<br />
In <strong>Bel</strong>gium, <strong>Bel</strong> collected donations<br />
for Cliniclowns (see sidebar).<br />
All fi ve core brands have a social<br />
or societal role to play.<br />
Each year, <strong>Bel</strong>’s <strong>Bel</strong>gian subsidiary organizes an event to collect donations<br />
on behalf of nonprofi t organizations. In 2011, it selected Cliniclowns,<br />
a troupe of 17 clowns who entertain hospitalized and handicapped<br />
children with clownish fun and good humor. <strong>The</strong> program is a good<br />
fi t with the values, smiles and conviviality of <strong>Bel</strong>’s brands.<br />
Over a period of several weeks, a portion of the purchase price<br />
of <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® , Kiri ® and Mini Babybel ® is donated to Cliniclowns.<br />
Advertised to consumers via the products’ packaging, the operation<br />
also involved <strong>Bel</strong> employees in <strong>Bel</strong>gium, who sold Cliniclowns items<br />
on behalf of the organization.<br />
20 • 2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
$265,000<br />
donated by <strong>Bel</strong><br />
to the YMCA<br />
in 2011
Goal:<br />
One billion<br />
consumers<br />
by 2020<br />
Accessibility is at the heart<br />
of <strong>Bel</strong>’s mission and goal<br />
With 400 million consumers already,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> is aiming to bring dairy goodness<br />
to one billion people by 2020.<br />
Among potential new consumers are<br />
some with few means to keep themselves<br />
fed every day. Which is why it is so<br />
important for them to have access to<br />
the nutritional content they need.<br />
In developing countries with limited<br />
purchasing power, <strong>Bel</strong> is already marketing<br />
local brands that offer good nutritional<br />
quality at a more affordable price.<br />
Going even further, <strong>Bel</strong> teams have been<br />
working for several years on creating a<br />
new product called Goodi ® . Prepared in<br />
partnership with GAIN (Global Alliance<br />
for Improved Nutrition) to ensure the<br />
nutritional content is adapted to the<br />
targeted populations, a fi rst Goodi ® pilot<br />
project was launched in Vietnam in 2011.<br />
To better adapt the product to local tastes<br />
and to develop its distribution, Goodi ® will<br />
require further adjustments, but this fi rst<br />
initiative has created the conditions for<br />
new business models adapted to the<br />
neediest populations.<br />
interview<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> Access: To make our products<br />
truly accessible to the greatest<br />
number of people<br />
CAROLINE BRIDOUX, Business Development Manager<br />
In 2007, a cross-sector team was<br />
assembled to work on an exiting<br />
challenge: making dairy goodness<br />
accessible to people living on<br />
less than two dollars a day.<br />
Called Jefferson, after the U.S.<br />
president who appears on the<br />
two-dollar bill, the project gave<br />
rise to Goodi ® , a product launched<br />
in Vietnam in September 2011.<br />
<strong>The</strong> product’s entire components<br />
are new for <strong>Bel</strong>, including its recipe,<br />
manufacture, packaging,<br />
distribution method, etc.<br />
More than just a new product,<br />
the project amounted to the<br />
rollout of a new business model.<br />
To continue down this path,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> set up a dedicated team<br />
under the name <strong>Bel</strong> Access.<br />
Today, <strong>Bel</strong> Access has four team<br />
members under the management<br />
of Florian Sauvin, and we benefi t<br />
from the assistance of internal<br />
and external advisers, who are vital<br />
to this effort. To share in the<br />
audacious goal of reaching a billion<br />
consumers by 2020 requires<br />
creating new business models and<br />
thinking outside the box.<br />
Our mission is to select the raw<br />
materials, develop the manufacturing<br />
processes, set the selling prices,<br />
determine the distribution<br />
channels, and identify all other<br />
elements in the value chain<br />
between <strong>Bel</strong> and the consumer<br />
that can be reinvented.<br />
In this way, we can make products<br />
that meet basic nutritional needs<br />
accessible to the greatest number<br />
of people.<br />
+<br />
For more information, see the expert<br />
opinion “Malnutrition: solutions for<br />
effectively combating this affl iction”<br />
www.smilesfortheplanet.com<br />
2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> • 21
INNOVATING ON BEHALF OF THE CONSUMER<br />
Innovating and<br />
constantly improving<br />
Innovating is the basic act of creating and developing at <strong>Bel</strong>. Innovation concerns all 11,400 <strong>Group</strong><br />
employees and encompasses all sectors of activity.<br />
In 1921, the birth of <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
necessitated a multitude of successful<br />
innovations to bring dairy goodness<br />
to a wider population, including<br />
innovations in the recipe,<br />
the manufacturing process, the<br />
preservation method, advertising, etc.<br />
Today, all of these areas remain open<br />
at <strong>Bel</strong>, to continue innovating and<br />
to better fulfi ll its mission.<br />
Innovation in <strong>Bel</strong>’s DNA<br />
New recipes remain the most visible side<br />
of innovation. <strong>The</strong> brand review on pages<br />
12 to 15 of this report provides a few<br />
examples of innovations introduced<br />
in 2011, such as Leerdammer ® fl avored<br />
cheese slices or Boursin ® Apéritif.<br />
Often, these innovations are the result<br />
of years of research and development.<br />
In 2011, product innovations, i.e.,<br />
products launched within the past<br />
three years, accounted for 8% of<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s total sales.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> expects this share to grow in the years<br />
ahead. More broadly, innovations offer<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> a way to constantly improve its<br />
product offering and the benefi t<br />
for consumers.<br />
Nutrition according to <strong>Bel</strong><br />
<strong>The</strong> ”Nutrition and Responsible<br />
Products” pillar of the <strong>Group</strong>’s<br />
CSR process reflects <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
ongoing drive to design<br />
products whose nutritional<br />
benefits are adapted<br />
to consumer needs.<br />
At a time when consumers<br />
are increasingly concerned<br />
about the content and<br />
quality of the food they eat<br />
— and legitimately so —<br />
22 • 2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
nutrition is a vital<br />
challenge.<br />
One priority for <strong>Bel</strong><br />
is to optimize the<br />
nutritional quality and<br />
profile of its products<br />
aimed at children,<br />
regardless of brand.<br />
Three main areas of<br />
focus include lowering<br />
salt and fat content,<br />
while optimizing<br />
micronutrients like<br />
calcium and certain vitamins<br />
(see the interview on page 23<br />
and best practices on page 25).<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> has also invested heavily in raising<br />
awareness and providing information<br />
about nutrition, both internally through<br />
its marketing teams and externally through<br />
doctors, pediatricians, nutritionists,<br />
schools, and other partners involved in<br />
advising consumers.<br />
In another nutrition related area,<br />
the <strong>Group</strong> is also strengthening the natural<br />
qualities of its products by reducing the<br />
additives they contain, such as colorants,<br />
emulsifi ers and preservatives.<br />
Although without risk to consumers and<br />
controlled by regulations, additives are<br />
negatively viewed in some countries.<br />
In 2011, <strong>Bel</strong> was named<br />
“Manufacturer of the year”<br />
in the Nutrition-Health<br />
category by “Process<br />
Alimentaire” magazine.
8%<br />
of <strong>Group</strong> sales generated by<br />
innovations launched in<br />
the past three years<br />
Consumer-oriented<br />
manufacturing developments<br />
Against a backdrop of eroding purchasing<br />
power and soaring raw material prices,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> deployed programs to improve<br />
manufacturing effi ciency at its plants,<br />
to keep selling prices under control.<br />
Using the full weight of its manufacturing<br />
expertise, the <strong>Group</strong> demonstrated<br />
its effectiveness, know-how and ability<br />
to innovate, to make the streamlining<br />
and performance-enhancing projects<br />
a success.<br />
In 2011, the <strong>Group</strong> led several streamlining<br />
and performance-enhancing projects:<br />
BOOST, a program for testing and<br />
improving each step in the production<br />
process, was deployed at fi ve new plants<br />
following a pilot program at three <strong>site</strong>s.<br />
<strong>The</strong> program, which notably led to the<br />
establishment of key performance<br />
indicators for machine effi ciency, also<br />
helped encourage interaction and sharing<br />
among the <strong>Group</strong>’s production <strong>site</strong>s.<br />
Tempo is a project for streamlining<br />
manufacturing maintenance at the<br />
Boursin ® <strong>site</strong> in Pacy-sur-Eure, France.<br />
In 2011, it was deployed to seven French <strong>site</strong>s.<br />
In 2012, the project will be rolled out at<br />
plants in Chorzele, Poland, Michalovce,<br />
Slovakia, Cairo, Egypt, Tangier, Morocco,<br />
and <strong>site</strong>s in the Netherlands.<br />
Performance Formule is a program<br />
to develop recipes that use fewer raw<br />
materials, while maintaining the same<br />
qualities. In 2011, the main achievement<br />
was the modifi cation of the Kiri ® recipe<br />
in the Middle East, with the new recipe<br />
favorably received by consumers.<br />
Beyond the food safety the plants must<br />
ensure (see page 24), the production <strong>site</strong>s<br />
play a fundamental role in maintaining and<br />
improving the accessibility and nutritional<br />
benefi ts of <strong>Bel</strong>’s products.<br />
interview<br />
”Improving the nutritional<br />
quality of our products”<br />
CÉLINE RICHONNET-DUBUIS and SIMON BONNET,<br />
<strong>Group</strong> Nutrition Managers<br />
What is <strong>Bel</strong>’s strategy in<br />
the area of nutrition?<br />
According to a report issued by<br />
the Red Cross in September 2011,<br />
there are 1.5 billion overweight<br />
people in the world and 925 million<br />
undernourished people.<br />
Given the size of these challenges,<br />
the food sector has a role to play<br />
in helping to overcome them.<br />
Our responsibility is to offer<br />
products high in nutritional value<br />
and to encourage consumers<br />
to adopt healthy eating habits.<br />
At the same time, we have to<br />
maintain the taste and eating<br />
pleasure that make up the<br />
personality of our brands.<br />
We take all of these factors into<br />
account for each innovation or<br />
recipe renewal.<br />
What is the main focus<br />
of your work?<br />
Our priorities are working on the<br />
three key nutrients found in cheese<br />
by controlling fat and salt content<br />
and optimizing the calcium content<br />
of products targeted primarily at<br />
children. Next, depending on the<br />
specifi c needs of a given population<br />
— for example, seniors or children,<br />
or people in certain world regions<br />
— we adjust the micronutrient<br />
content. <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® sold<br />
in Africa and the Middle East is<br />
vitamin D and B12-enriched.<br />
For school cafeterias in France, Kiri ®<br />
is vitamin-D enriched. In Ukraine,<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® blocks, which<br />
are primarily eaten by families at<br />
breakfast, are enriched in vitamin A,<br />
D3 and E.<br />
Do public authorities<br />
participate in this challenge?<br />
Part of our role is sharing these<br />
advances with outside stakeholders,<br />
such as governments, national<br />
nutritional institutions, NGOs,<br />
consumer advocacy groups, etc.<br />
In France, for example, we made<br />
our recipe renewal goals offi cial by<br />
signing a voluntary charter to<br />
enhance the nutritional content<br />
of Kiri ® and <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® .<br />
+<br />
To learn about best practices for<br />
”Nutrition and Responsible Products”<br />
go to www.smilesfortheplanet.com<br />
2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> • 23
SAFETY AND CONSUMER INFORMATION<br />
Duty to consumers<br />
A company’s fi rst and foremost duty to its consumers is to ensure that all its processes, from<br />
upstream production to fi nal consumption, are strictly controlled to guarantee product safety.<br />
Further, it must provide clear information.<br />
W<br />
ith nearly 400 singleserving<br />
portions<br />
manufactured every<br />
second to keep pace<br />
with the 12 billion<br />
portions of <strong>Group</strong><br />
cheeses eaten annually, <strong>Bel</strong>’s reputation<br />
for providing tasty products with no health<br />
risks is at stake with each portion produced.<br />
Ensuring food safety<br />
and controlling quality<br />
It goes without saying that the safety<br />
measures taken by <strong>Bel</strong> upstream from<br />
its production <strong>site</strong>s, within its plants and<br />
downstream to the consumer are up to the<br />
challenge. <strong>The</strong> permanent drive for optimal<br />
quality applies to all <strong>Bel</strong> products.<br />
75%<br />
of <strong>Bel</strong>’s production <strong>site</strong>s<br />
are certifi ed,with a<br />
certifi cation target<br />
of 100% by 2015<br />
24 • 2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
<strong>The</strong> cheeses produced by the <strong>Group</strong><br />
and sold in over 120 countries worldwide<br />
naturally comply with public health<br />
demands and local regulations.<br />
Further, <strong>Bel</strong>’s products are subject<br />
to very strict internal standards and<br />
complete traceability over their entire<br />
life cycle. Numerous and rigorous<br />
controls are carried out in each step<br />
of the process to guarantee optimal<br />
quality for consumers.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s 27 production <strong>site</strong>s around the<br />
globe meet food safety and quality<br />
demands, and comply with such<br />
recognized international standards and<br />
benchmarks as ISO 9001, FSSC 22,000,<br />
BRC, and IFS.<br />
Clear and complete information<br />
Consumers are increasingly aware<br />
and demanding of information about<br />
the food they and their children eat.<br />
It’s one reason why <strong>Bel</strong> has multiplied<br />
the ways in which consumers can access<br />
information about the nutritional value<br />
of its products, via labeling smartphone<br />
apps, web<strong>site</strong>s and other means.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se constant efforts to improve<br />
communication allow consumers to
14%<br />
reduction in salt content<br />
for <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® Light<br />
in the U.S., with salt content<br />
lowered from 1,049 milligrams<br />
to 900 milligrams per<br />
100 grams of product<br />
learn precisely how many carbohydrates<br />
and how much fat, salt, calcium and<br />
other nutrients are contained in the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s products and their contribution<br />
to the recommended daily allowance.<br />
In France, <strong>Bel</strong> has signed charters with<br />
the Programme National Nutrition Santé<br />
(National Health and Nutrition Program)<br />
committing it to providing content<br />
information about every product<br />
sold in retail stores for all its brands.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> Foodservice, a <strong>Group</strong> subsidiary<br />
that supplies the institutional and<br />
commercial catering markets, regularly<br />
conducts nutritional information<br />
campaigns with healthcare professionals<br />
and catering companies.<br />
Compositional information for all<br />
its products can also be found at the<br />
www.belfoodservice.fr web<strong>site</strong>, along<br />
with full nutritional information and<br />
advice from dieticians.<br />
best<br />
practice<br />
Lower salt content is the fruit<br />
of a long-term effort<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> didn’t wait around for<br />
government measures<br />
against salt content in<br />
food to begin working on<br />
the problem. From 1977 to 2009,<br />
salt content in <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
in Western Europe was reduced<br />
in steps, by 32%. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> has<br />
since made further progress,<br />
and now expects to lower Western<br />
Europe <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® salt<br />
content another 4.7% by 2013.<br />
Likewise, <strong>Bel</strong> has lowered the salt<br />
content of <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
and <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
Light in the U.S. market.<br />
For <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® Light,<br />
which accounts for 90% of<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® sales in<br />
the U.S., salt content has<br />
been reduced 14%, from<br />
1,049 milligrams per 100 grams<br />
of product to 900 milligrams.<br />
<strong>The</strong> effort will be continued for<br />
flavored versions of the brand<br />
in the months ahead.<br />
While these reductions are<br />
significant, some may ask,<br />
“Why not do it all at once and<br />
why not do more?” <strong>The</strong> reason<br />
is because salt — like fat —<br />
contributes to the taste to<br />
which consumers have become<br />
accustomed. <strong>The</strong> solution is<br />
to make the change gradually,<br />
without necessarily promoting<br />
it on the packaging, in line<br />
with public authority<br />
recommendations.<br />
2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> • 25
A state of mind<br />
Smiles generate enthusiasm and optimism.<br />
Smiles also form the core of the <strong>Group</strong>’s human<br />
resource policy, because <strong>Bel</strong> believes that the<br />
well-being of its employees plays a key role in its<br />
performance. This mindset is also carried over<br />
in the relations the <strong>Group</strong> forges with its partners<br />
in the communities where it operates.<br />
26 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
69%<br />
of employees<br />
received training<br />
in 2011<br />
73%<br />
of employees<br />
answered the <strong>Group</strong>’s<br />
fi rst global employee<br />
opinion survey<br />
49<br />
nationalities<br />
within the <strong>Group</strong>
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 27
EMPLOYER COMMITMENT<br />
<strong>The</strong> glue of an<br />
international group<br />
To ensure its expansion and the global distribution of its<br />
products, <strong>Bel</strong> operates subsidiaries, plants or R&D centers<br />
in 33 countries. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong>’s organization and values provide<br />
the key leverage for working together more effectively.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> believes that its<br />
employees provide the<br />
foundation for sustainable<br />
growth. This conviction is<br />
refl ected in the name of its<br />
human resources policy,<br />
People First, a priority that has strong<br />
implications for a <strong>Group</strong> where smiles are<br />
the leitmotif and enthusiasm is a core<br />
value. <strong>Bel</strong>’s mission to share smiles to its<br />
customers must also apply inside with the<br />
company. To that end, common working<br />
conditions must be created to enable all<br />
employees to fi nd their career paths to<br />
professional development.<br />
Organization adapted to an<br />
international business model<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> is a resolutely international group,<br />
with operations in 33 countries,<br />
27 production <strong>site</strong>s and 11,400 employees<br />
worldwide. In all, 49 different nationalities<br />
A charter for all<br />
are represented within the <strong>Group</strong>.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> is organized into fi ve geographical<br />
regions that are consistent in terms of<br />
market, culture or consumption habits.<br />
As a result, decision-making centers<br />
are closer to market and benefit<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong>’s commitment to employees and management is based on four key areas.<br />
• Empower everyone: creating an appropriate environment to ensure that everyone has the feeling<br />
that he/she contributes to the entity in a committed, responsible and autonomous way.<br />
• Grow further: developing talent through experience, training and exposure to new opportunities.<br />
Share success: sharing value-created in a transparent and equitable way.<br />
•<br />
Enjoy our workplace: creating working conditions that make <strong>Bel</strong> a pleasant and friendly<br />
place to work.<br />
28 • <strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong> 2011<br />
69%<br />
of <strong>Group</strong> employees<br />
received training<br />
in 2011<br />
from strong familiarity with their<br />
localenvironments, enabling the <strong>Group</strong><br />
to respond more effectively to global<br />
consumer expectations and to<br />
develop its ability to anticipate<br />
those expectations.
”People First”,<br />
the social charter<br />
issued to all 11,400<br />
<strong>Group</strong> employees<br />
in 2011<br />
Overall strategy and large-scale projects<br />
remain the province of <strong>Bel</strong>’s corporate<br />
head offices. Networking between<br />
regions and countries is encouraged,<br />
as are internal job moves, which are a<br />
source of mutual enrichment. As a part<br />
of its “Talent Factory” program, the<br />
<strong>Group</strong> has made international job moves<br />
a key to its growth, with the goal being<br />
to transfer skills and build local talent<br />
nurseries. In 2011, 81 employees made<br />
internal, international job moves,<br />
up from 69 in 2010.<br />
A mutual commitment for growth<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> decided to draft a social charter<br />
for it 11,400 employees. <strong>The</strong> People<br />
First charter (see sidebar on page 28)<br />
is particular in that it spells out <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
commitments to its employees to<br />
ensure their development, as well<br />
as what it expects in return from<br />
its managers and employees.<br />
In this way, the charter explains the<br />
rights and duties of everyone within<br />
the <strong>Bel</strong> community.<br />
81<br />
international job<br />
moves in 2011<br />
<strong>The</strong> People First charter was prepared<br />
in accordance with <strong>Bel</strong>’s way of working.<br />
That is to say it was a collective effort<br />
involving the Human Resources<br />
Department and managers from various<br />
functions and regions. <strong>The</strong> charter was<br />
presented to all <strong>Group</strong> employees<br />
throughout 2011.<br />
At our Tangier plant, 95% of the team<br />
leaders appointed in the past two years<br />
previously worked at the plant as<br />
maintenance technicians.<br />
Frank-Yann Bourreau, Head of Technical Services for the <strong>Bel</strong> plant in Tangier, Morocco<br />
First BEST graduates<br />
In 2011, 84 operators from various<br />
European plants earned diplomas<br />
from the BEST (<strong>Bel</strong> Employee Shopfl oor<br />
Training) program. BEST arose from<br />
a vital need to develop a specifi cally<br />
dedicated certifi cation program that<br />
recognizes basic knowledge about the<br />
manufacturing process, food safety,<br />
accident prevention, the environment,<br />
and other skills. <strong>The</strong> training program<br />
was deployed in France, the Netherlands<br />
and Portugal in 2011, and is expected to<br />
be extended to other countries in 2012.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 29
EMPLOYER COMMITMENT<br />
Listening to employees<br />
For the first time ever, <strong>Bel</strong> conducted<br />
a global employee opinion survey<br />
covering its entire worldwide staff.<br />
<strong>The</strong> aim of the survey was to provide<br />
a point of departure for measuring<br />
employee perceptions over time with<br />
respect to the charter’s commitments.<br />
<strong>The</strong> results provided both a <strong>Group</strong><br />
level and a team level view of <strong>Bel</strong>.<br />
An independent outside company<br />
prepared the survey, in which 73%<br />
of <strong>Bel</strong> employees participated,<br />
and analyzed its results.<br />
<strong>The</strong> high rate of participation for an<br />
initial survey underscored employee<br />
interest and expectations with<br />
respect to the effort.<br />
<strong>The</strong> overall results and results by<br />
entity were released in September<br />
30 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
2011, and shared with <strong>Bel</strong> teams,<br />
with the analysis taking into account<br />
cultural differences.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> now has a point of departure<br />
from which it can prepare programs<br />
common to the entire <strong>Group</strong>, as well<br />
as local action plans, and will be able<br />
to measure the progress achieved<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Bel</strong> Care program is aimed<br />
at ensuring that all <strong>Bel</strong> employees<br />
around the world benefi t from basic<br />
healthcare coverage.<br />
Zofi a Sorokowska, <strong>Group</strong> Manager for Internal International Job Moves<br />
226<br />
managers and<br />
safety coordinators<br />
were trained in 2011 as part<br />
of ”the zero accidents”<br />
program<br />
when the survey is taken again in 2013.<br />
Among the strengths identified was the<br />
positive response to employee autonomy<br />
and empowerment. <strong>Bel</strong> was also judged as<br />
serious and active in the area of safety.<br />
Lastly, management at the <strong>Group</strong> level<br />
received favorable marks.
Two areas of concern emerged from<br />
the survey. Workers and technicians<br />
indicated that there was a lack of<br />
information about how the <strong>Group</strong>’s<br />
reward system worked, and all<br />
employees who responded<br />
to the survey said career development<br />
communication was lacking.<br />
Both points are now the subject of<br />
an improvement plan common to<br />
all <strong>Group</strong> entities. Further, entity<br />
managers along with their teams<br />
examined local action plans for making<br />
headway with respect to the guidance<br />
in the charter.<br />
Employer commitment<br />
While 2011 was marked by the rollout<br />
of the People First charter, <strong>Bel</strong> also<br />
pursued a number of other programs<br />
vital to “living well at work”.<br />
<strong>The</strong> “zero accidents” program was<br />
continued at all <strong>Group</strong> plants, with<br />
intensified efforts to raise awareness<br />
among local general managers and<br />
operators. Two-hundred and twentysix<br />
managers and safety coordinators<br />
were trained, and “safety behavior <strong>visit</strong>s”<br />
were set up to share ideas with operators<br />
and identify situations in need of<br />
corrective measures.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Bel</strong> Care program was deployed to<br />
take aim at setting a common standard<br />
for employee benefi ts such as healthcare<br />
and disability insurance, even when such<br />
benefi ts exceed local market practices.<br />
One of the goals also set by <strong>Bel</strong> was<br />
to hire more handicapped persons.<br />
In 2011, various initiatives were taken<br />
in France, including the signature of<br />
a two-year agreement with Agefiph,<br />
a nonprofit organization for<br />
handicapped employees.<br />
interview<br />
Deploying People First<br />
in Central Europe<br />
BOYAN NEYTCHEV, General Manager, <strong>Bel</strong> Central Europe<br />
How did the rollout of the<br />
People First charter go in<br />
Central Europe?<br />
From the start, the project was<br />
enthusiastically received by both<br />
managers and employees, who view<br />
the charter as a sincere and<br />
structured effort by <strong>Bel</strong> to develop<br />
teamwork and individual<br />
performance. Lot’s of people shared<br />
ideas and expectations and asked<br />
questions. It’s now up to us to<br />
integrate all of this into an action<br />
plan for implementation at our<br />
entity. One of the strengths of<br />
People First is its dynamic,<br />
participative and adaptive approach<br />
to local problems. <strong>The</strong> action plans<br />
are drawn up by the entities based<br />
on their local populations. We have<br />
already initiated some concrete<br />
measures. We now hold interactive<br />
meetings on a monthly basis with<br />
management and all employees in<br />
Prague to discuss company business<br />
and our results. We will also hold a<br />
Central Europe convention to<br />
strengthen ties between functions<br />
and the countries and to encourage<br />
greater teamwork.<br />
What’s your initial assessment<br />
of the deployment?<br />
People First is a long-term project<br />
that must be deeply integrated<br />
into our business culture and<br />
the mindset of our managers<br />
and employees. Everybody<br />
understands that it’s<br />
a gradual project, and that it<br />
will bear fruit only if everyone<br />
contributes to it. At our plant in<br />
eastern Slovakia, where we employ<br />
500 people, it’s already clear<br />
that People First is viewed as<br />
an advantage in the job market,<br />
and it is making <strong>Bel</strong> an increasingly<br />
attractive employer.<br />
What areas does your 2012<br />
action plan cover?<br />
<strong>The</strong> fi rst measures concern<br />
increasing understanding about<br />
how our compensation policy<br />
works, increasing idea sharing with<br />
employees, encouraging internal<br />
job moves over new recruits by<br />
making information about the<br />
job promotion process more<br />
widespread and through adapted<br />
training plans.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 31
INVOLVING OUR PARTNERS<br />
Involving our partners in<br />
sustainable development<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s corporate social responsibility policy is designed around fi ve key pillars that refl ect the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s commitments to its stakeholders. Just as <strong>Bel</strong> encourages its employees to get involved<br />
in its sustainable development project, it seeks to share its goals and convictions with its<br />
partners to support common efforts and broaden the positive impact.<br />
Each year, <strong>Bel</strong> buys 1.6 billion<br />
liters of milk directly from<br />
producers in the dairy basins<br />
where it operates, primarily in<br />
France and the Netherlands,<br />
but also in Portugal, Slovakia<br />
and Ukraine. As a major player in those<br />
markets, <strong>Bel</strong> works to build and maintain<br />
durable relations with its suppliers.<br />
1.6 billion<br />
liters of milk collected<br />
directly from producers<br />
in 2011<br />
32 • <strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong> 2011<br />
Maintaining relations<br />
with dairy producers<br />
In France in particular, the goal is<br />
to encourage a sustainable dairy<br />
production channel in which producers<br />
can improve the management of<br />
their dairy farms and better preserve<br />
the environment.<br />
All of the <strong>Group</strong>’s dairy suppliers adhere<br />
to the Best Farming Practices Charter,<br />
which was revised in 2011 to include<br />
new demands for personal safety<br />
and environmental protection.<br />
Long-term support<br />
As part of its commitment to dairy<br />
producers, <strong>Bel</strong> makes dairy production<br />
technicians available to producers<br />
to help them manage their farms.<br />
With their knowledge of best farming<br />
practices, the technicians can shed<br />
light on complementary dairy practices<br />
and technics for producers. In particular,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> encourages the use of a tracking tool<br />
that has been adopted by its suppliers in<br />
the Netherlands. Based on discussions<br />
with the producer, the tracking tool
can help defi ne action plans that take the<br />
farm’s specifi c environment into account,<br />
while providing guidance for a continuous<br />
improvement process.<br />
CSR at the heart of discussions<br />
with suppliers<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> seeks to promote sustainable<br />
development principles among all its<br />
suppliers, and to get them involved in<br />
continuous improvement actions with<br />
respect to the social and environmental<br />
challenges facing their activities.<br />
To that end, it drafted a Sustainable<br />
Purchasing Charter, which spells out<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s expectations vis-à-vis<br />
its suppliers.<br />
<strong>The</strong> charter is presented to current<br />
suppliers and to new ones during bids<br />
or at the beginning of business relations,<br />
to ensure compliance.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se expectations are expressed<br />
in several areas:<br />
Environmental: Practicing the<br />
precautionary principle, minimizing<br />
environmental impact, complying<br />
with safety standards.<br />
Human rights and labor standards:<br />
Banning child labor, eliminating forced<br />
or compulsory labor, creating an<br />
environment conducive to health, safety<br />
and employee development.<br />
Business ethics: Complying with laws<br />
and regulations, respecting intellectual<br />
property rights and fighting corruption.<br />
A charter compliance clause has<br />
been progressively integrated into<br />
all purchasing contracts. Depending<br />
on the sector, additional demands<br />
may also be included.<br />
Goal:<br />
Assess 350 suppliers<br />
according to CSR criteria<br />
by end 2012<br />
Assessment of 350 suppliers<br />
by end-2012<br />
<strong>The</strong> Sustainable Purchasing Charter<br />
is the cornerstone of a global program<br />
by the purchasing department that<br />
covers three other areas, including<br />
training for <strong>Group</strong> buyers, assessing<br />
supplier CSR performance and raising<br />
awareness among business partners.<br />
In 2011, the buyer training program<br />
Sustainable<br />
Purchasing<br />
Charter<br />
was expanded from headquarters<br />
to all local buyers.<br />
For supplier evaluations, <strong>Bel</strong>’s goal<br />
is to have assessed the 350 suppliers<br />
considered to be the most strategic,<br />
or whose activity carries potential CSR<br />
risk, by end 2012. At end 2011, nearly<br />
300 suppliers, representing 30% of<br />
purchases, excluding milk collection,<br />
had been evaluated. Some of the<br />
assessments revealed the need for<br />
corrective action plans, which were<br />
prepared jointly with <strong>Bel</strong> teams.<br />
Since the effort was launched, a quarter<br />
of the suppliers have been reassessed,<br />
with over half of them showing<br />
improvement. <strong>The</strong> results prove that<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s CSR effort can have a true ripple<br />
effect, and its results can be extended<br />
thanks to the involvement of the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s partners.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 33
SHARING THE GROUP’S VALUES<br />
On behalf of children<br />
and their well-being<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s Corporate<br />
Foundation<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s Corporate Foundation<br />
supports initiatives on behalf<br />
of children and their wellbeing<br />
everywhere in the world<br />
by encouraging balanced<br />
diets and environmental<br />
preservation, since a healthy diet is<br />
predicated on a healthy environment.<br />
Since its founding in 2008, the foundation<br />
has supported 63 projects worldwide,<br />
including 19 new projects in 2011.<br />
Employees, true foundation<br />
participants<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> also seeks to support initiatives<br />
sponsored by its employees. Since 2010,<br />
the <strong>Bel</strong> Foundation has awarded specifi c<br />
grants to charitable projects sponsored<br />
and monitored by <strong>Bel</strong> employees.<br />
In 2011, 11 such grants were awarded,<br />
bringing the total number of employee<br />
sponsored grants to 21.<br />
Developing philanthropy<br />
In July 2011, <strong>Bel</strong> signed<br />
the Corporate Philanthropy<br />
Charter established by Admical,<br />
a nonprofi t organization<br />
dedicated to developing<br />
philanthropy in France.<br />
34 • <strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong> 2011<br />
interview<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Bel</strong> – SOS Sahel<br />
partnership<br />
PHILIPPE LECOMTE,<br />
Chairman of SOS Sahel<br />
Can you tell us what SOS Sahel is all about?<br />
SOS Sahel is an internationally-recognized NGO<br />
and a member of the Charter Committee, created<br />
in 1976 following the drought that struck the African<br />
continent in the 1970’s. Its goal is to improve local<br />
living conditions by providing access to fundamental<br />
services, such as water, sewage, health, and<br />
education, and by developing sustainable farming. One of SOS Sahel’s<br />
particularities is that it contributes human resources for training<br />
and know-how to put a project in place, while project ownership and<br />
the responsibility for development are handled by local populations.<br />
What are some of SOS Sahel’s main achievements?<br />
Since its founding, SOS Sahel has supported 263 projects benefi ting<br />
1.5 million people in the Sahel region of Africa. Over 1,300 water supply<br />
points have been drilled close to a thousand villages, and 104,000<br />
hectares of previously arid land has been recovered to grow<br />
vegetation and to build an economy through various channels,<br />
such as shea butter, gum arabic, and sheep and beef production.<br />
Which project is supported by the <strong>Bel</strong> Foundation?<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Bel</strong> Corporate Foundation is helping SOS Sahel Burkina Faso to<br />
encourage food safety measures in three northern provinces of<br />
Burkina Faso. <strong>The</strong> contribution encompasses three areas, including<br />
the establishment of 20 school gardens to ensure a steady diet for<br />
5,400 school children, food donations for 4,400 malnourished<br />
pregnant women, nursing mothers and young children, and<br />
information addressed to mothers about how to use local foods<br />
to maintain a balanced diet for their children. It’s an exemplary<br />
project since it covers SOS Sahel’s three priorities: water, health<br />
and education. Indirectly, the project helps motivate children to go<br />
to school, if only initially to participate in developing the gardens.<br />
+<br />
To learn all about the projects<br />
supported by the <strong>Bel</strong> Foundation,<br />
go to www.fondation-bel.org
A patchwork<br />
of actions<br />
A child in hand / 2011 project<br />
In Vietnam, the <strong>Bel</strong> Foundation supported a<br />
project to help 900 children and 125 pregnant<br />
women by disseminating information,<br />
distributing food supplements, providing<br />
health checkups, and distributing medicines.<br />
www.unenfantparlamain.org<br />
Unis Cités / 2011 project<br />
In France, the <strong>Bel</strong> Foundation backed a pilot<br />
program called Les Vitaminés to help prevent<br />
child obesity in working class neighborhoods.<br />
www.uniscite.fr<br />
Couleurs de Chine / employee grants<br />
Couleurs de Chine seeks to encourage access<br />
to learning for the children of ethnic minorities<br />
in China. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Bel</strong> Foundation is providing<br />
funding for school equipment.<br />
www.couleursdechine.org<br />
+<br />
To submit an application for support,<br />
go to www.fondation-bel.org<br />
Uniting under the sail<br />
A human adventure shared<br />
with employees<br />
In 2005, when <strong>Bel</strong> decided to<br />
sponsor skipper Kito de Pavant,<br />
everybody knew that the<br />
partnership would not be a simple<br />
trade of funding for sticking a<br />
logo on a sail. That’s not the <strong>Bel</strong> way,<br />
and it’s not what Kito de Pavant was<br />
seeking. <strong>Bel</strong>’s ambassador and his<br />
red cow on the high seas, the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong> sailboat, have forged<br />
genuine ties to all the <strong>Group</strong>’s<br />
subsidiaries. So far, over 8,000 <strong>Bel</strong><br />
employees have left their thumbprints<br />
on the ship’s mast, to symbolize<br />
their support for the skipper<br />
when he’s racing at sea. Twelve<br />
subsidiaries and 14 production <strong>site</strong>s<br />
have welcomed Kito and shared<br />
their enthusiasm with him.<br />
Kito also participates in the<br />
company’s internal communication<br />
efforts when his presence can help<br />
spread an important message.<br />
In 2011, he participated in an<br />
internal fi lm dedicated to the<br />
”zero accidents” program.<br />
<strong>The</strong> fi lm shows the constant<br />
risk onboard the sailboat.<br />
Kito makes safety a constant<br />
concern, as all <strong>Bel</strong> employees<br />
must do in their professional<br />
environments.<br />
On the 2012 agenda, the <strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong><br />
yacht will <strong>visit</strong> the <strong>Group</strong>’s Algerian<br />
subsidiary for the fi rst time, a new<br />
“Sharing Smiles Regatta” will once<br />
again unite <strong>Bel</strong> teams from around<br />
the world, and, in a major event,<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong> will set sail from<br />
Sables-d’Olonne, France on<br />
November 10 for the Vendée Globe<br />
singlehanded yacht race around the<br />
world. Kito will be counting on the<br />
support of <strong>Bel</strong>’s 11,400 fans and<br />
their families.<br />
”Sharing Smiles Regatta”<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 35
SHARING THE GROUP’S VALUES<br />
Encouraging creativity<br />
<strong>The</strong> founding and iconic brand, <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® , has always projected the values of audacity,<br />
creativity and humor that Leon <strong>Bel</strong> instilled in his company in 1921. This same mindset can be<br />
found in Lab’<strong>Bel</strong>, an artistic endeavor established by <strong>Bel</strong> in 2010 to support contemporary art,<br />
and La Maison de La vache qui rit ® (<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow House), where the general public can<br />
rediscover the history of the world’s most famous cow.<br />
A house of culture, life and smiles at La Maison de La vache qui rit ®<br />
In the town center of Lons-le-Saunier,<br />
in <strong>Bel</strong>’s historical birthplace in the Jura<br />
department of France, stands La Maison<br />
de la vache qui rit ® , a place that<br />
incarnates the <strong>Group</strong>’s iconic brand.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow House lives and breaths<br />
conviviality and humor, with a wealth of<br />
walks and a diversity of spaces like no<br />
other in France’s Franche-Comté region.<br />
Since opening in 2009, this unique<br />
destination has welcomed more than<br />
110,000 <strong>visit</strong>ors, most of them families.<br />
Ninety percent of the guests polled said<br />
they were satisfi ed with their time at<br />
La Maison de La vache qui rit ® . But, more<br />
importantly, 50% said that the <strong>visit</strong> had had<br />
a positive effect of their view of the brand.<br />
36 • <strong>Group</strong>e <strong>Bel</strong> 2011<br />
A creative space<br />
While <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow House tells the<br />
great saga of a family and an industry,<br />
it’s much more than just a company<br />
museum. <strong>The</strong> attraction is also open to<br />
creations, experimentations and original<br />
and qualitative initiatives, which feed the<br />
creativity and fun linked to the brand.<br />
In 2011, four schools of art, design<br />
and graphics were commissioned to<br />
completely reinvent <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ®<br />
brand for an exhibit honoring the famous<br />
cow’s 90th anniversary. In addition,<br />
artwork resulting from a gathering<br />
of artists and handicapped persons<br />
was also displayed as part of an<br />
extraordinary collaborative effort<br />
with the nonprofit Orange Rouge<br />
organization. That initiative will soon be<br />
taken up again under the auspices of the<br />
Franche-Comté region and the Cultural<br />
Affaires Régional Offi ce. Through its<br />
approach to CSR, the <strong>Group</strong> also<br />
participated in the “N’en jetez plus !”<br />
(Stop trashing already!) exhibit dedicated<br />
to the environment, in partnership with<br />
La Cité de l’Architecture et du Patrimoine<br />
architecture museum in Paris.<br />
On the agenda for 2012<br />
This line of creativity will be continued in<br />
2012, by taking inspiration from the very<br />
nature of <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® , a food<br />
product. In the spring, La Maison de La<br />
vache qui rit ® will welcome Marc Bretillot,<br />
a famous food designer who makes food<br />
into works of art.<br />
What will <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® be<br />
transformed into? It’s a mystery!<br />
In the summer, <strong>visit</strong>ors will be able to<br />
see the “Ô lait !” exhibit, the latest Lab’<strong>Bel</strong><br />
creation. <strong>The</strong> fall and winter season will<br />
be dedicated to childhood, with an<br />
exhibit dedicated to toys that laugh.<br />
+<br />
To learn more about the activities offered<br />
by La Maison de La vache qui rit ® , go to<br />
www.lamaisondelavachequirit.com<br />
110,000<br />
people have <strong>visit</strong>ed<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® House<br />
since it opened in 2009
What will<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing<br />
Cow ® W<br />
TC9fIn<br />
look like<br />
90 years<br />
from now?<br />
In 2011, <strong>The</strong> Laughing<br />
Cow ® celebrated its<br />
90th anniversary,<br />
which of course was<br />
appropriately feted<br />
by La Maison de<br />
La vache qui rit ®<br />
(<strong>The</strong> Laughing CCow<br />
House). Working<br />
with Lab’<strong>Bel</strong>, four schools of art, design<br />
and graphics were given carte blanche<br />
to reimagine the famous red cow<br />
90 years from now. <strong>The</strong>se spectacular,<br />
moving and funny works were<br />
displayed at La Maison de La vache qui<br />
rit ® during the summer and at the Gaîté<br />
Lyrique in Paris at the end of the year.<br />
All the artwork showed the potential<br />
for inspiration and eternal youth<br />
contained in <strong>Bel</strong>’s founding brand.<br />
Sharing smiles through art<br />
Lab’<strong>Bel</strong>, the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong>’s artistic<br />
laboratory, was established in<br />
spring 2010 with the determined<br />
goal of getting the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
involved in a general interest<br />
policy of supporting<br />
contemporary art, much in the way that<br />
Léon <strong>Bel</strong> did when asked artist Benjamin<br />
Rabier to create the famous<br />
image of <strong>The</strong> Laughing<br />
Cow ® . Managed by<br />
Laurent Fiévet and<br />
Silvia Guerra,<br />
Lab’<strong>Bel</strong> engages<br />
artists, and<br />
movers and<br />
shakers of the<br />
contemporary art<br />
world with humor,<br />
eccentricity and<br />
irreverence, the three<br />
themes that form its<br />
identity.<br />
First projects outside France in 2011<br />
In 2011, Lab’<strong>Bel</strong> continued its close<br />
collaboration with La Maison de la vache<br />
qui rit ® , providing the curators for the<br />
“Même pas vielle !” (Not even old!)<br />
exhibit. For the third time, it was also<br />
active in the French city of Metz,<br />
for a video work by Ignacio Uriarte.<br />
In 2011, Lab’<strong>Bel</strong> also realized its first<br />
projects outside France. Selected to<br />
provide the curators for solo projects<br />
at the contemporary art fair<br />
in Barcelona, Spain, Lab’<strong>Bel</strong> organized<br />
the Art for Life exhibit, which presented<br />
works by laureates alongside works by<br />
other international artists in residence.<br />
Working with the Mies van der Rohe<br />
Foundation, Lab’<strong>Bel</strong> also asked Stefan<br />
Brüggermann decorate the German<br />
pavilion in Barcelona, to kick off a series<br />
of discussions on contemporary art<br />
and architecture.<br />
2012 agenda<br />
In early 2012, Lab’<strong>Bel</strong> will<br />
present the fi rst of its<br />
collection at the 5 d’Angers<br />
art gallery, as part of the<br />
“Touching the Moon” exhibit<br />
and will examine the cyclical and dynamic<br />
representation of milk in contemporary<br />
art over the summer as part of a new<br />
collaboration with La Maison<br />
de La vache qui rit ® .<br />
In autumn 2012, Lab’<strong>Bel</strong><br />
will go to European culture<br />
capital Guimaraes,<br />
Portugal, to participate<br />
in an exhibit of a series of<br />
bridges between plastic<br />
arts, music and literature.<br />
A fourth exhibit in Metz<br />
is also planned. With the same<br />
drive for sharing its enthusiasm<br />
for today’s artists and making their<br />
work more accessible to the greatest<br />
number of people, Lab’<strong>Bel</strong>’s art<br />
collection will be displayed in the spring<br />
at the fi ne arts museum in Dôle, France,<br />
where <strong>Bel</strong> operates a production <strong>site</strong>.<br />
It’s another way for the laboratory to<br />
strengthen its ties to the Jura, <strong>Bel</strong>’s<br />
historical birthplace.<br />
+<br />
To follow news of the <strong>Bel</strong><br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s artistic laboratory,<br />
go to www.lab-bel.fr<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 37
38 • 2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong>
Preserving<br />
the environment<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> is leading an ongoing effort to reduce the<br />
environmental impact arising from the manufacture,<br />
transport and storage of its products and packaging.<br />
In accordance with its comprehensive view of this<br />
responsibility, all stages of the product life cycle<br />
are taken into account, from raw materials supply<br />
upstream, to manufacturing and transport all<br />
the way to the consumer.<br />
9<br />
plants<br />
certifi ed<br />
ISO 14001<br />
at end 2011<br />
12.8%<br />
<strong>The</strong> decrease in water<br />
consumption in cubic meters<br />
per metric ton of cheese<br />
produced achieved<br />
<strong>Group</strong>-wide from<br />
2008 to 2011<br />
10 microns<br />
<strong>The</strong> thickness<br />
of the aluminum packaging<br />
wrapped around a Kiri ® portion<br />
produced in Lons-le-Saunier,<br />
France<br />
2011 <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> • 39
PRESERVING THE ENVIRONMENT — RAW MATERIALS AND PACKAGING<br />
Controlling the impact of<br />
upstream supply<br />
<strong>The</strong> company’s environmental impact is not limited to the product-manufacturing phase alone.<br />
Key factors upstream must also be controlled, such as raw materials selection and the conditions<br />
under which those materials are produced.<br />
5key stages in the life cycle of<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> products have a significant<br />
impact on the environment<br />
(see diagram).<br />
From raw material production<br />
to consumption<br />
<strong>The</strong> environmental impact of cheese<br />
making varies according to the recipe<br />
used for the cheese, how and where it is<br />
produced, and even the type of<br />
packaging it employs. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong><br />
conducted a Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) of<br />
its five core brands, enabling it to<br />
identify four main environmental<br />
Logistics and<br />
transport.<br />
40 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
Packaging<br />
end-of-life.<br />
<strong>The</strong> fi ve stages<br />
of <strong>Bel</strong>’s product<br />
life cycle<br />
that have an<br />
environmental<br />
impact<br />
impacts, including water consumption,<br />
non-renewable energy use, greenhouse<br />
gas emissions, and waste generation.<br />
Upstream dairy farming<br />
Raw materials production and delivery<br />
have the greatest environmental impact<br />
in <strong>Bel</strong>’s product life cycle, representing<br />
more than 60% of water consumption<br />
and non-renewable energy use, and 75%<br />
of greenhouse gas emissions. Aware of<br />
its responsibility and the role it can play,<br />
the <strong>Group</strong> encourages producers to<br />
improve their farming practices through<br />
its dairy policy. In particular, the <strong>Group</strong><br />
Raw materials<br />
production and<br />
delivery.<br />
Packaging<br />
raw materials<br />
production and<br />
transport to<br />
our plants.<br />
Cheese<br />
manufacturing<br />
and packaging.<br />
provides information about new<br />
environmental challenges and supports<br />
efforts to improve environmentally<br />
friendly techniques. <strong>Bel</strong> engineers and<br />
technicians work with dairy producers in<br />
the Netherlands, France, Portugal,<br />
Slovakia, and Ukraine, providing<br />
assistance and advice in the areas of<br />
sustainable production quality and<br />
environmental issues specifically related<br />
to the dairy industry. <strong>Bel</strong>’s dairy<br />
producers in France and the<br />
Netherlands, which together account for<br />
80% of the <strong>Group</strong>’s milk supply, have<br />
signed a charter of best farming<br />
Over 75%<br />
of greenhouse gas emissions<br />
are related to the production<br />
and delivery of raw<br />
materials
practices. In countries lacking such<br />
processes, the <strong>Group</strong> seeks to initiate its<br />
own charters, which take specific local<br />
conditions into account.<br />
Packaging<br />
Packaging plays a key role in <strong>Bel</strong> cheeses<br />
and the services the <strong>Group</strong> offers to<br />
consumers. Most of <strong>Bel</strong>’s retail products<br />
are presented in the individual portions<br />
format, which preserves the integrity of<br />
the cheese until it is eaten and offers<br />
just the right amount of product. <strong>Bel</strong><br />
actively works to optimize its packaging<br />
solutions, always remaining mindful of<br />
source reduction and materials<br />
selection, two key elements in its<br />
ecodesign process.<br />
- 200<br />
metric tons<br />
Western Europe reduced<br />
the amount of its paper and<br />
cardboard packaging by over<br />
200 metric tons in 2011<br />
CSR labels for<br />
Point of Sale (POS)<br />
displays<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> France decided to grade<br />
the impact of its POS displays<br />
from A to D, with A being the most<br />
environmentally friendly score.<br />
<strong>The</strong> longer-term goal is to use only A<br />
or B-rated POS displays. <strong>Bel</strong> is also<br />
studying POS display designs that<br />
are sturdy enough to be reused.<br />
interview<br />
What is <strong>Bel</strong>’s policy for<br />
ecodesign packaging?<br />
Our policy is based on a comprehensive<br />
approach that adheres to several sound<br />
principles. We have to remember that<br />
packaging plays a vital role, and <strong>Bel</strong> does<br />
not compromise on packaging where the<br />
preservation of its cheese and consumer<br />
user-friendliness are concerned. Our goal<br />
is to reduce the environmental impact of<br />
our products over their entire life cycles by<br />
optimizing our packaging. Our thinking and<br />
efforts cover the entire packaging system,<br />
not just the packaging seen by the<br />
consumer, but the packaging used for<br />
transport and storage as well. Last but<br />
not least, our approach gets internal<br />
stakeholders like marketing, development<br />
and manufacturing involved and<br />
empowers them, along with our suppliers.<br />
Is the single-serving portions<br />
concept the main obstacle<br />
to ecodesign?<br />
No. On the contrary, beyond its practical<br />
advantages, the portions format is a means<br />
for limiting food waste, which is a fi rstorder<br />
environmental challenge. According<br />
to the FAO*, dairy sector food waste<br />
amounts to 10% to 25% of production,<br />
depending on the geographical region.<br />
In developing countries, the losses occur<br />
mostly at the distribution stage.<br />
In industrialized countries, the waste is<br />
generated primarily on the consumer side<br />
through opened but unfi nished products,<br />
or exceeded expiration dates.<br />
Our portions packaging ensures that the<br />
cheese is preserved until it is consumed<br />
— often over long periods of time and often<br />
without the need to keep it cold —<br />
providing a real solution to the problem.<br />
* Food and Agriculture Organisation.<br />
A comprehensive approach<br />
to ecodesign packaging<br />
JEAN-PAUL DUQUET, Head of <strong>Group</strong> ecodesign packaging<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> produces 12 billion cheese portions<br />
annually. <strong>The</strong>y form the core of our<br />
business model. Our goal is to optimize<br />
our packaging solutions around this great<br />
concept, anticipate trends and invent<br />
the packaging of tomorrow.<br />
Can you give us an example of an<br />
achievement in 2011?<br />
We have been working on minimizing the<br />
amount of material used in our packaging<br />
for several years now. In 2011, we reduced<br />
the thickness of the aluminum foil used<br />
to wrap Kiri ® portions from 12 microns to<br />
10 microns. This decrease, made possible<br />
by the manufacturing teams at the<br />
Sablé-sur-Sarthe plant in France, enabled<br />
us to lower our aluminum consumption<br />
by 35 metric tons a year. In addition to the<br />
savings, the reduction has had a direct<br />
impact on the environment because it cuts<br />
resource usage at various life cycle stages,<br />
with less packaging to be produced and<br />
transported, and less waste to be<br />
processed. Of course our ecodesign<br />
efforts go beyond source reduction.<br />
We are also actively involved in aluminum<br />
recycling challenges. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> is<br />
a member of the CELAA club for light<br />
aluminum and steel packaging, through<br />
which we fi nance research and aluminum<br />
collection and recycling initiatives in<br />
France, including the aluminum foil<br />
wrapped around our portions.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 41
PRESERVING THE ENVIRONMENT — INSIDE THE PRODUCTION SITES ES<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s environmental<br />
efforts show up in local<br />
initiatives<br />
<strong>The</strong> actions taken by <strong>Bel</strong> at its manufacturing <strong>site</strong>s worldwide are aimed at preserving natural<br />
resources, primarily by reducing need and waste, and through recycling waste. Each plant has its<br />
own organization for preserving the environment and implementing environmental policy.<br />
Cléry <strong>site</strong> heated with<br />
biomass steam boiler<br />
<strong>The</strong> Cléry-le-Petit production <strong>site</strong> in<br />
the Meuse region of France employs<br />
some 300 persons and produces<br />
fl avored Leerdammer ® , Bonbel ® and<br />
Maredous ® cheeses. It operates with<br />
a steam power generator fi red<br />
primarily by wood.<br />
Well adapted to the Cléry region,<br />
where wood is plentiful, this solution<br />
refl ects a drive to use renewable<br />
energy resources. <strong>The</strong> new system<br />
replaced a fuel-oil steam generator<br />
that emitted 9,400 metric tons of CO2<br />
annually. To keep the biomass steam<br />
boiler supplied with fuel, some 10 new<br />
forestry jobs will be created<br />
around Cléry.<br />
42 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
An ongoing improvement<br />
effort to cut greenhouse<br />
gas emissions, reduce<br />
water and non-renewable<br />
energy consumption, and<br />
recycle waste is underway<br />
at all 27 <strong>Bel</strong> production <strong>site</strong>s. Each <strong>site</strong><br />
develops its own approach by<br />
integrating the local context into the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s goals. <strong>The</strong> targets set for key<br />
performance indicators in the 2008-<br />
2012 plan are mostly ahead of the mark.<br />
More detailed information about the<br />
targets, measures and investments is<br />
provided in <strong>Bel</strong>’s Registration Document,<br />
available at the www.groupe-bel.com<br />
web<strong>site</strong>.<br />
A common approach to<br />
cutting water and energy use<br />
To reduce water and energy<br />
consumption, and share the best<br />
available technologies, <strong>Bel</strong> developed<br />
the Esabel (Energy Saving <strong>Bel</strong>) and<br />
Wasabel (Water Saving <strong>Bel</strong>) programs.<br />
Launched in 2010, both methods are<br />
part of an effort to assess water and<br />
energy use at the production <strong>site</strong>s and<br />
to map out action plans based on a<br />
common model. <strong>The</strong> two programs are<br />
expected to be deployed at all <strong>Group</strong><br />
<strong>site</strong>s by the end of 2013.<br />
Wasabel<br />
<strong>The</strong> Syrian plant in Damascus has served<br />
as the <strong>Group</strong>’s pilot <strong>site</strong> for Wasabel<br />
over the past five years. Wasabel is now<br />
being deployed at all production <strong>site</strong>s,<br />
e.g. Koléa, Algeria, Tangier, Morocco and<br />
Cairo, Egypt, with a three-year goal of<br />
cutting water consumption by 2.5 liters<br />
to 3 liters per kilogram of <strong>The</strong> Laughing<br />
Cow ® cheese produced. <strong>The</strong> target<br />
represents a 30% decline in water usage.<br />
By the end of 2013, all <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>site</strong>s will be<br />
participating in the effort.<br />
100%<br />
of plants on track to<br />
be certifi ed ISO 14001<br />
by 2015
Esabel<br />
In 2011, Esabel was started up at 10 <strong>Group</strong><br />
<strong>site</strong>s. <strong>The</strong> three-year reduction targets<br />
look very promising. One concrete<br />
example of potential savings is an<br />
initiative to replace the vacuum pump<br />
model used in the packaging stage of the<br />
production chain. <strong>The</strong> new pump, which<br />
is 60% more energy efficient, will be<br />
deployed at all <strong>Group</strong> <strong>site</strong>s producing<br />
<strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® cheese. <strong>The</strong> new<br />
model pump is already operating at<br />
six <strong>Group</strong> plants. In 2012, it will be<br />
deployed at plants in Ulzama, Spain,<br />
Tangier, Morocco and Lons-le-Saunier,<br />
France.<br />
A key criterion for equipping plants<br />
Environmental friendliness is a<br />
fundamental part of the equation when<br />
replacing equipment, installing new<br />
production lines or building new plants.<br />
That principle was clearly applied when<br />
the <strong>Group</strong> opened a plant in Vietnam in<br />
2011. Lower water usage was integrated<br />
at the design stage of the project, and a<br />
biological wastewater treatment plant<br />
was also installed. Another project,<br />
a new Mini Babybel ® plant, will be<br />
operational in 2014, in the United States.<br />
<strong>The</strong> team in charge is seeking to make<br />
the new plant a model under the LEED<br />
(Leadership in Energy and<br />
Environmental Design) rating system<br />
for green buildings.<br />
interview<br />
New Vietnam plant opts<br />
for a biological wastewater<br />
treatment facility<br />
FRANÇOIS PONS, <strong>Bel</strong> Vietnam plant Director<br />
Under what conditions<br />
was the biological<br />
wastewater treatment<br />
plant launched?<br />
Environmental standards are<br />
very stringent in Vietnam, particularly for<br />
effl uents and treatment. To treat<br />
wastewater from the My Phuoc 3 plant<br />
inaugurated at end 2011, we opted for a<br />
biological treatment facility with vertical<br />
closed-loop reactors, in which organic<br />
matter is broken down by microorganisms<br />
niched inside millions of polystyrene<br />
beads. <strong>The</strong> water to be treated percolates<br />
by gravity around these beads, and air is<br />
blown against the current to maintain<br />
aerobic conditions. This ecological and<br />
economical system is a fi rst for the <strong>Group</strong>.<br />
What are the results so far?<br />
<strong>The</strong> plant has been producing since July<br />
2011. While the selection of the treatment<br />
facility was a bit of a gamble, it has proven<br />
to be an astute move, because the results<br />
are even better than expected. One of the<br />
main criteria is the amount of Chemical<br />
Oxygen Demand (COD). <strong>The</strong> maximum<br />
Environmental performance indicators<br />
Measurement<br />
unit 2008 2009 2010 2011<br />
Change from<br />
2010 to 2011<br />
Change from<br />
2010 to 2011<br />
Drinking water consumption* m 3 /t* 12.531 11.205 11.226 10.924 - 2.69% - 12.82%<br />
Fossil fuel usage mWh/t** 1.502 1.391 1.378 1.310 - 4.94% - 12.79%<br />
CO2 emissions t/t*** 0.342 0.318 0.317 0.296 - 6.67% - 13.49%<br />
Share of sorted waste**** % 73 67 71 74 + 3 + 1<br />
* Cubic meters of water per metric ton of cheese produced.<br />
**Megawatt hours of lower heating value (LHV) per metric ton of cheese produced.<br />
*** Metric tons of CO2 per metric ton of cheese produced.<br />
****Share of waste sorted or processed for incineration with energy recovery.<br />
standard allowed is 100 milligrams per liter.<br />
Our discharges range from 15 milligrams<br />
to 30 milligrams per liter. In addition,<br />
the treatment facility consumes very little<br />
power.<br />
How does this project tie into the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s overall environmental<br />
policy?<br />
Beyond the biological process, which is<br />
particularly environmentally friendly, we<br />
have also set reduction targets for water<br />
consumption and effl uents discharged<br />
into the public sewer system. After<br />
six months of operation and a progressive<br />
ramping up of activity, we currently use<br />
six cubic meters of water and discharge<br />
4.5 cubic meters of wastewater per metric<br />
ton of cheese produced. We are working<br />
on solutions to reach maximum water<br />
consumption of four cubic meters and<br />
three cubic meters of wastewater per<br />
metric ton of cheese produced.<br />
<strong>The</strong> savings will have a direct impact<br />
on our water usage, as well as our<br />
wastewater treatment costs.<br />
+<br />
To learn more about water stress,<br />
see our expert opinion at<br />
www.smilesfortheplanet.com<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 43
PRESERVING THE ENVIRONMENT — FROM THE PLANT TO THE CONSUMER<br />
Alternative<br />
transport solutions<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> uses a transport and warehouse grid to make its products available to consumers. In addition,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> employees must travel to and from the workplace. Reducing transport is a good way to lower<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s environmental impact.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> has always based<br />
the selection of its plant<br />
locations on two key<br />
factors, including raw<br />
materials availability, i.e.<br />
dairy producing regions for<br />
supplies of fresh and primary processing<br />
products, and nearness to markets,<br />
to limit the distance between its plants<br />
and consumer catchment areas.<br />
Closer to consumers<br />
Getting products to the end consumer<br />
requires a cold transport and storage<br />
organization, which by its very nature<br />
can be energy intensive. However, along<br />
44 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
with its retailers and supply chain<br />
service providers, the <strong>Group</strong> has<br />
identified simple and effective solutions<br />
for lowering greenhouse gas emissions.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se solutions are based on optimizing<br />
truck fill rates and delivery frequency,<br />
as well as alternative transport<br />
initiatives. Working together with its<br />
partners has led to steady and<br />
meaningful improvement.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> gets involved in<br />
multimodal transport<br />
Multimodal transport involves a<br />
combination of several types of<br />
transport to get from one point to<br />
another, such as so-called piggyback<br />
solutions that use both rail and road<br />
transport. This solution was successfully<br />
tested to move products from plants in<br />
western France to a warehouse in Lyon,<br />
with corresponding CO2 emissions cut<br />
by 33%. In addition, a program was<br />
launched a year ago to transport<br />
Leerdammer ® from the Netherlands to<br />
Italy (see best practice on page 45) via<br />
an alternative solution. <strong>The</strong> idea was to<br />
maintain the same flexibility offered by<br />
road transport (and even improve it),<br />
while taking advantage of the lower<br />
energy and environmental costs<br />
offered by rail.<br />
85%<br />
of Leerdammer ® cheese<br />
transport fl ows from Rotterdam,<br />
Netherlands to Milan, Italy are<br />
now provided by rail
33%<br />
reduction in CO2 emissions<br />
from plants in western France<br />
to a warehouse in Lyon<br />
Everybody’s business<br />
Designed for adoption by all <strong>Group</strong><br />
employees, <strong>Bel</strong>’s approach to Corporate<br />
Social Responsibility is particularly<br />
relevant with respect to environmental<br />
policy. <strong>Bel</strong> UK began encouraging<br />
car-pooling some years ago, making it<br />
a pioneering subsidiary in this area.<br />
Along with the town of Lons-le-Saunier,<br />
France, where a <strong>Bel</strong> plant employs more<br />
than 500 persons, the <strong>Group</strong> has been<br />
advocating sustainable travel by offering<br />
environmentally friendly driving courses,<br />
providing better information about<br />
public transport options and facilitating<br />
car-pooling. More generally, initiatives<br />
are growing at <strong>Bel</strong>’s plants and offices<br />
around the world to introduce<br />
environmentally friendly practices that<br />
save energy, water, paper, and other<br />
resources in the workplace and even<br />
at home. When extended to a <strong>Group</strong><br />
population of 11,400 families, such<br />
initiatives can have a real impact.<br />
Without my car!<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> employees in Prague and Zeletava,<br />
the Czech Republic, and Michalovce and<br />
Bratislava, Slovakia were asked to leave<br />
their cars in the garage for a day and use<br />
more ecological means of transport to<br />
get to work, including public transport,<br />
car-pooling, bicycling, and even walking.<br />
Everybody took part in the initiative,<br />
which offered a good example of how<br />
changing habits can help the<br />
environment.<br />
best<br />
practice<br />
Combined transport proves<br />
to be both more ecological<br />
and economical<br />
Leerdammer ® is <strong>Bel</strong>’s most<br />
popular cheese brand in<br />
Italy. <strong>The</strong> production plant<br />
that supplies the Italian<br />
market, however, is located in<br />
Schoonrewoerd, Netherlands, and<br />
the road transport means from the<br />
plant to the Italian warehouse was<br />
lacking in effi ciency, prompting<br />
to a review of the operation.<br />
Combined transport (a/k/a<br />
multimodal transport) proved to<br />
be the most effective alternative<br />
solution. Over a distance of more<br />
than 1,000 kilometers, the cheese<br />
is now trucked no more than a<br />
total of 130 kilometers, including<br />
the trip from the plant to the<br />
Rotterdam train station and the<br />
journey from a train station near<br />
Milan to the Italian warehouse.<br />
For the remaining 900 kilometers,<br />
the cheese is shipped by rail.<br />
In this case, rail transport offers<br />
several advantages. It allows<br />
8,500 metric tons of<br />
Leerdammer ® to be shipped to<br />
Italy each year, while saving<br />
300,000 kilometers of road<br />
transport.<br />
It also lowers CO2 emissions<br />
because rail transport does not<br />
directly produce any such gases.<br />
It is also signifi cantly cheaper and<br />
poses no greater delay risks than<br />
“all road” transport.<br />
+<br />
To learn more about multimodal<br />
transport challenges,<br />
see our expert opinion at<br />
www.smilesfortheplanet.com<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 45
CSR and fi nancial<br />
key performance indicators<br />
48 CSR commitments and outlook<br />
60 Summary management report<br />
62 Consolidated income statement,<br />
vs. prior year<br />
63 Consolidated balance sheet,<br />
vs. prior year<br />
64 Consolidated cash fl ow statement<br />
46 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 47
Corporate governance<br />
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
Areas of progress MAIN ACHIEVEMENTS AT END 2011<br />
Establishing a network<br />
and tools to support<br />
the deployment of<br />
the CSR process<br />
Measuring, guiding<br />
and reporting on<br />
the progress of<br />
the CSR process<br />
Mobilizing employees<br />
to integrate CSR<br />
progressively into<br />
all professional and<br />
managerial practices.<br />
Guiding the process<br />
and management<br />
systems to ensure<br />
that sustainable<br />
development<br />
challenges are<br />
taken into account<br />
48 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
• A network of 18 function advisers from marketing, innovation, communication, manufacturing, human<br />
resources and other corporate departments, was set up. <strong>The</strong>se key-function CSR advisers are responsible<br />
for bringing the <strong>Group</strong>’s CSR process to their respective areas of expertise.<br />
• In several major <strong>Group</strong> countries, such as France, Germany and Morocco, local CSR correspondents were<br />
appointed to carry the torch and implement the CSR process locally.<br />
• Several tools were developed to help structure and deploy the process at <strong>Group</strong> entities, primarily:<br />
- <strong>The</strong> CSR Reference Guide, which structures the process’s fi ve pillars and shows entities how to self-assess<br />
with respect to each area of action;<br />
- <strong>The</strong> reporting protocol, which defi nes all the <strong>Group</strong>’s CSR key performance indicators;<br />
- A dedicated guide to held <strong>Group</strong> operating entities design a CSR roadmap.<br />
• A social charter, an environmental policy paper, a policy paper on health and safety, an ecodesign packaging<br />
manual and other specifi c reference documentation were issued to the concerned staff to help structure<br />
their CSR goals by function.<br />
Key performance indicators were defi ned to measure, guide and report on the progress of the CSR process<br />
(see “Reporting Protocol” above).<br />
• Function-specifi c training programs were established to integrate environmental, social and societal<br />
challenges into professional and managerial practices. For example, the <strong>Group</strong> structured and initiated the<br />
fi rst training sessions specifi c to nutrition for its marketing teams, while buyers were trained in responsible<br />
purchasing practices.<br />
• Dedicated CSR web<strong>site</strong>, smilesfortheplanet.com, was launched in both French and English, to keep<br />
employees informed about the <strong>Group</strong>’s CSR commitments, achievements and best practices.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> retained a single certifi cation entity, namely SGS, to streamline certifi cation efforts for<br />
all its <strong>site</strong>s and certifi cations.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> number of manufacturing <strong>site</strong>s with certifi ed management systems for quality, food safety,<br />
environmental protection, and personnel safety continued to grow, with two additional <strong>site</strong>s certifi ed<br />
and the launch of the certifi cation process at four others.<br />
• All <strong>Bel</strong> production <strong>site</strong>s worldwide meet food safety and quality demands set by the <strong>Group</strong>, in keeping<br />
with recognized international standards and benchmarks.<br />
- 75% of <strong>site</strong>s had at least one certifi cation.<br />
- Manufacturing <strong>site</strong> certifi cation at end 2011:<br />
- 50% certifi ed according to a standard recognized by the GFSI food safety authority<br />
- 11% were certifi ed OHSAS 18001 for human health and safety<br />
- 32% were certifi ed ISO 14001 for the environment<br />
- 68% were certifi ed ISO 9001 for quality<br />
• Environmental, social and societal challenges are now taken into consideration in the <strong>Group</strong>’s investmentproject<br />
decision-making process.
OUTLOOK FOR 2012 AND BEYOND<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> plans to strengthen the network and broaden the reach of tools to help develop the CSR process among operating and corporate teams.<br />
- By end 2012, each region will have an identifi ed CSR correspondent, with correspondents progressively named in main <strong>Group</strong> countries.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will give CSR goals greater visibility in its policies for nutrition, upstream dairy and other functions.<br />
- Internal access to these documents will be facilitated by the www.smilesfortheplanet.com web<strong>site</strong>.<br />
As of 2012, the <strong>Group</strong> will have the necessary KPIs to internally guide and externally report on the progress of its CSR process.<br />
- In 2012, all <strong>Group</strong> operating regions will be asked to identify their main challenges, assess their progress and develop a CSR roadmap and<br />
corresponding actions plans.<br />
- Further, each region will be required to develop numerical improvement targets for 2015 for the areas of action they deem as priorities.<br />
- An internal CSR scorecard will help guide and track the achievement of these consolidated goals.<br />
- A trial audit of <strong>Bel</strong>’s CSR key performance indicators will be conducted by an outside party in 2012, to prepare the <strong>Group</strong> for mandatory CSR<br />
reporting under French law in 2013 (on the basis of fi scal 2012).<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> will encourage all its employees to place corporate social responsibility at the center of its growth strategy.<br />
- Ethical behavior forms the core of the CSR process. Accordingly, a Code of Best Business Practices, presenting the values and principles that all<br />
employees must follow in the course of their professional activities, will be gradually rolled out as of 2012, along with a whistleblowing process to<br />
signal any unethical behavior.<br />
- Since early 2012, a dedicated CSR training program has been progressively rolled out for managers. All managers from grades one to three are<br />
expected to be trained in CSR by 2013.<br />
- Marketing, human resources and other function-specifi c training courses will be gradually modifi ed to include CSR, to factor CSR into all managerial<br />
and professional practices.<br />
- Since 2012, a CSR component has been factored into the bonus compensation system for managers.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will continue to deploy management systems and processes to ensure that sustainable development challenges are taken into<br />
account in managerial and professional practices.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> number of certifi ed production <strong>site</strong>s is expected to grow. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong>’s goal is to have all its production <strong>site</strong>s certifi ed according to<br />
a GFSI-recognized standard by 2014 at the latest, and ISO 14001 and OHSAS 18001 standards by end 2015 at the latest.<br />
- Further, the <strong>Group</strong>’s policy is to have all new <strong>site</strong>s, whether built or acquired, certifi ed GFSI FSSC 22000, ISO 14001 and OHSAS 18001<br />
no later than two years after their integration into the <strong>Group</strong>.<br />
- Lastly, the <strong>Group</strong> will ensure that all internal processes encourage the taking of sustainable development challenges into account.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 49
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
Areas of progress MAIN ACHIEVEMENTS AT END 2011<br />
Ensuring product<br />
quality and safety<br />
Improving the<br />
nutritional quality<br />
of our products<br />
Strengthening the<br />
natural qualities of<br />
the <strong>Group</strong>’s products<br />
Developing a range<br />
of products accessible<br />
to the greatest number<br />
of people<br />
50 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
Nutrition and responsible products<br />
Developing nutritionally benefi cial products adapted to consumer needs and<br />
accessible to the greatest number of people.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> prepared food safety reference documents, which were disseminated internally through the local<br />
CSR correspondents network.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> mapped out its quality policy.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> regularly kept track of local regulatory changes and implemented active monitoring measures as<br />
part of its continuous improvement process.<br />
• Several formulas were renewed in 2011, including:<br />
- Vitamin B12-enriched <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® in the Middle East and North Africa;<br />
- Vitamin A, D3 and E-enriched <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® blocks in Ukraine;<br />
- Calcium fortifi ed <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® in the Czech Republic;<br />
- <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® Light, with lower salt content in the United States;<br />
- A specifi c formula for <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® was tailored for school cafeterias (fat, calcium and vitamin D)<br />
on behalf of <strong>Bel</strong> Foodservice.<br />
• Stakeholders acknowledged the <strong>Group</strong>’s progress in the nutrition area:<br />
- <strong>Bel</strong> France made its commitments offi cial by registering a voluntary charter to enhance the nutritional<br />
content of Kiri and <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® .<br />
- French magazine Process Alimentaire named the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> ”Manufacturer of the Year” in the healthnutrition<br />
category.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> continued to strengthen its nutritional expertise:<br />
- <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> initiated a vast bibliographic review of eating habits and drivers among children<br />
(taste development, education, sharing, pleasure, fun).<br />
• R&D programs were pursued to reduce and even eliminate emulsifying salts in processed and fresh cheeses.<br />
• Several renewed formulas were introduced in 2011, including:<br />
- A new <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® formula with one less additive in Slovakia and the Czech Republic;<br />
- <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® Light and <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® Garlic and Fresh Herbs with one less additive in Canada;<br />
- A new <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® formula with two less additive for <strong>Bel</strong> Foodservice Europe;<br />
- A cheddar Mini Babybel ® formula without preservatives, launched in countries where this product is sold.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> Boost, Tempo and Performance Formule programs were rolled out at <strong>Group</strong> plants to lower pressure<br />
on selling prices in an era of soaring raw material costs.<br />
• In Vietnam, <strong>Bel</strong> sponsored a study on calcium and vitamin D defi ciencies in young children and women<br />
of childbearing age, conducted by Vietnam’s National Institute for Nutrition.<br />
• A fi rst ”hybrid” product experiment combining dairy and another ingredient was conducted in Vietnam.<br />
Launched in September 2011, the dairy and rice-based range of products was specifi cally adapted<br />
to the nutritional needs of Vietnamese children, with added vitamins, iodine and zinc.<br />
• Exploratory projects were initiated to identify the most relevant countries for developing comparable models.
OUTLOOK FOR 2012 AND BEYOND<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will continue to make improvements in this key area of progress to ensure tight control over all processes that ensure<br />
the quality and safety of its products.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will optimize the nutritional composition of its products, with priority given to those targeted at families with children<br />
and those for which the nutritional benefi t is underscored, regardless of brand.<br />
- All <strong>Group</strong> operating regions will have prioritized their renewal plans to 2015, to improve formulas.<br />
Each year, the <strong>Group</strong> will assess the program’s progress and adjust its action plan as necessary.<br />
- R&D projects will be launched to support renewal plans. <strong>The</strong> fi rst consumer surveys will validate the organoleptic performance<br />
of the formulas under renewal.<br />
- Newly optimized formulas will be launched as of 2012, notably in Western Europe, Ukraine, the Czech Republic, the U.S.,<br />
and Morocco, and for <strong>Bel</strong> Foodservice.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will further strengthen its expertise in eating habits, with a particular focus on the role of the individual portion<br />
Consumers in ”hyperconsumption” countries increasingly expect products to be more natural. In view of such demand,<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> will continue its policy of reducing additives in its formulas.<br />
- All <strong>Group</strong> operating regions identifi ed priority formulas to be renewed based on local conditions as well as 2015 targets<br />
(number of E numbers per formula). Each year, the <strong>Group</strong> will assess the program’s progress and adjust its action plan as necessary.<br />
- R&D programs will be pursued.<br />
- Consumer surveys will be taken to validate the organoleptic performances of the formulas with fewer additives.<br />
As of 2012, several tests will be carried out in Europe.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> will continue its on-<strong>site</strong> and in-the-fi eld efforts to develop nutritionally benefi cial products accessible to the greatest number<br />
of people, despite soaring raw material prices.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> Boost, Tempo, Performance Formule, and other programs will continue to be rolled out at <strong>Group</strong> production <strong>site</strong>s.<br />
- Local brand optimization and development will be pursued.<br />
- In Vietnam, the Goodi ® product will be optimized, in partnership with the NGO Gain (Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition).<br />
- Lastly, by 2015, new ”hybrid” products aimed at populations with weak purchasing power may be introduced in several countries<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 51
1<br />
2<br />
Areas of progress MAIN ACHIEVEMENTS AT END 2011<br />
Facilitating<br />
consumer access<br />
to information<br />
Incorporating the<br />
<strong>Group</strong>’s commitment<br />
to CSR in our brands’<br />
promotional-offer<br />
campaigns<br />
52 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
Responsible communication<br />
and consumption<br />
Giving consumers who put their trust in our brands the keys<br />
to responsible consumption.<br />
• Nutritional information<br />
- <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> mapped out its nutritional labeling policy and shared it with the operating regions to assist them<br />
in implementing labeling renewal plans.<br />
- <strong>Bel</strong> France made its nutritional labeling commitments offi cial by registering a voluntary charter to enhance<br />
the nutritional content of Kiri ® and <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® .<br />
- In Senegal, a van carrying a nutritional message and a nutritionist <strong>visit</strong>ed 15,000 persons in 10 cities, to talk<br />
about nutrition and to distribute a brochure spelling out the nutritional benefi ts of <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® .<br />
• Environmental information<br />
- In France, <strong>Bel</strong> continued its work within the dairy profession to draft a reference guide that specifi es<br />
methods for calculating and measuring the environmental impact of dairy products.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> Responsible Communications Charter, which refl ects the <strong>Group</strong>’s commitment in the area of<br />
communication, was appended to all contracts with communication agencies. Advertising was subject<br />
to a strict internal validation process to ensure compliance with the charter.<br />
• Local good citizenship actions were taken in the name of the <strong>Group</strong>’s brands, including:<br />
- Mini Babybel ® ’s renewed support for Comic Relief’s Red Nose Day in the UK;<br />
- Support for Cliniclowns nonprofi t in <strong>Bel</strong>gium by <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® , Kiri ® and Mini Babybel ® ;<br />
- A partnership initiated by <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® with the YMCA in the U.S. to encourage physical activity.<br />
- A partnership signed by <strong>The</strong> Laughing Cow ® with the SOS Villages d’Enfants in France.<br />
• Consumer views of the societal role of <strong>Bel</strong>’ brands were included in a tracking survey conducted in<br />
all major <strong>Group</strong> markets. <strong>The</strong> fi rst wave - point zero – took place in 2011.<br />
• France: Ecodesign rules for Point-of-Sale (POS) ads were established and presented to all French team<br />
marketers. A <strong>Bel</strong>-specifi c POS label was created to measure and improve the environmental impact of<br />
<strong>Group</strong> POS displays.
OUTLOOK FOR 2012 AND BEYOND<br />
In countries where the <strong>Group</strong>’s products are sold, <strong>Bel</strong> will continue its efforts to facilitate consumer access to transparent and relevant product<br />
information through packaging labels, web<strong>site</strong>s, smartphone apps, and other means.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will continue to improve the nutritional labeling of its products.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will continue to work with the French dairy sector, to be able to provide reliable environmental information about dairy products.<br />
- To respond to unanswered consumer questions, the <strong>Group</strong> is seeking to enhance its dedicated consumer services<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will progressively introduce societal missions for each of its fi ve core brands to ensure that the commitments feed into the brands’<br />
respective positioning.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> entities will identify the most relevant brand or brands in their portfolios to refl ect the <strong>Group</strong>’s commitment to CSR.<br />
- Local good citizenship actions will be pursued and progressively integrated into the framework of defi ned societal missions.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 53
Areas of progress MAIN ACHIEVEMENTS AT END 2011<br />
1 Reducing the<br />
environmental<br />
footprint related<br />
to the manufacture<br />
of our products<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
Reducing the<br />
environmental<br />
footprint related<br />
to the transport<br />
and storage of<br />
our products<br />
Reducing the<br />
environmental<br />
footprint of<br />
our packaging<br />
Reducing the<br />
environmental<br />
footprint of our<br />
employees<br />
54 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
Environmental footprint<br />
Reducing the environmental footprint of all the <strong>Group</strong>s activities,<br />
whether directly or indirectly related to the manufacture of our products.<br />
• Ongoing efforts to lower environmental impact generated signifi cant results from 2008 to 2011,<br />
particularly in four targeted areas:<br />
- Water consumption in cubic meters per metric ton declined 12.8%;<br />
- Fossil fuel usage in NCV MWh per metric ton decreased 12.8%;<br />
- Greenhouse gas emissions in kilogram equivalent of CO2 per metric ton fell by 13.5%;<br />
- Only landfi ll waste increased, rising 10.1% as a result of a more accurate measure of generated waste.<br />
• Lastly, the <strong>Group</strong>’s plants continued to progressively replace ”R22” refrigerants with more environmentally<br />
friendly ones.<br />
• <strong>Bel</strong> developed Wasabel and Esabel, two programs to accelerate improvement efforts:<br />
- By end 2011, 16 <strong>site</strong>s were operating Wasabel water consumption reduction programs. Among those, nine<br />
plants had already prepared action plans to signifi cantly cut water usage.<br />
- Ten <strong>site</strong>s initiated Esabel programs to lower energy consumption.<br />
• In addition to the efforts under way to lower energy usage, <strong>Bel</strong> initiated studies to replace non-renewable<br />
energy sources:<br />
- In France, the Cléry plant installed a biomass steam boiler to replace non-renewable energy sources.<br />
<strong>The</strong> installation is expected to cut CO2 emissions by 9,400 metric tons per year<br />
• A method for calculating transport CO2 emissions from plants to warehouses was introduced in Western Europe.<br />
• Multimodal transport pilot projects were set up in Western Europe:<br />
- <strong>Bel</strong> partnered with STEF-TFE to put together a combined rail-road transport solution to ensure the distribution<br />
of Kiri ® and Mini Babybel ® in southeastern France. <strong>The</strong> program takes 260 trucks off the road, representing a<br />
reduction of 120 metric tons of CO2 per year.<br />
- Through a partnership with Netherlands-based H.Z. Transport, rail now accounts for 85% of Leerdammer ®<br />
cheese transport from Rotterdam, Netherlands to Milan, Italy.<br />
• Stakeholders recognized the <strong>Group</strong>’s progress in the logistics area.<br />
- <strong>Bel</strong> Netherlands was the recipient of the 2011 Lean and Green Award, for its efforts to lower the environmental<br />
impact of its logistics activities, and in particular for the advances it made via its participation in the<br />
government’s sustainable logistics program.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> strengthened the means dedicated to deploying and implementing its ecodesign policy for packaging:<br />
- An ecodesign packaging expert was recruited.<br />
- An ecodesign guide for packaging developers, marketing teams and packaging buyers was prepared<br />
and distributed.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> building of a database was initiated to track packaging environmental performance indicators, such as<br />
packaging weight per 100g of product and the percentage of recycled or renewable materials used.<br />
• Source reduction projects were initiated or pursued.<br />
- Western Europe reduced the amount of its paper and cardboard packaging by over 200 metric tons during the year.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> thickness of the aluminum foil used to wrap a signifi cant share of Kiri ® portions was reduced from 12 to<br />
10 microns. As a result, 35 metric tons of aluminum per year were saved, while the same cheese preservation<br />
properties were maintained.<br />
• Several initiatives were undertaken to lower the environmental impact of materials.<br />
- Throughout 2011, <strong>Bel</strong> participated in the fi nancing of three test <strong>site</strong>s in the Lot, Var and Alpes-Maritimes regions<br />
of France as part of a program with CELAA (Club du recyclage de l’Emballage Léger en Aluminium et en Acier),<br />
an organization dedicated to improving the collection and recycling of discarded light packaging in France,<br />
to encourage citizens to sort micro aluminum waste and to demonstrate the economic viability<br />
of this business model to concerned stakeholders.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> is seeking to encourage its employees to adopt more environmentally friendly behaviors:<br />
- A guide to environmentally friendly practices was prepared. Local CSR correspondents are expected to adapt<br />
the guide to take into account each entity’s specifi c environment.<br />
• Numerous initiatives were set up at various <strong>Group</strong> <strong>site</strong>s.<br />
- At <strong>Group</strong> headquarters, paper consumption was factored into the calculation of employee profi t sharing in 2011.<br />
- In France, the Lons-le-Saunier <strong>site</strong> is encouraging employees to use transport means other than private cars as<br />
part of sustainable intra-company travel plan.<br />
- An “In town without my car” operation was undertaken in Slovakia and the Czech Republic in September 2011.
OUTLOOK FOR 2012 AND BEYOND<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will continue its ongoing efforts to reduce major environmental impacts.<br />
- Wasabel water reduction and Esabel energy reduction programs will be started at all <strong>site</strong>s by 2013.<br />
- At the same time, all <strong>site</strong>s will be encouraged to come up with innovative projects of their own to reduce their environmental footprint.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will continue to pursue identifi ed areas of progress, where the environmental footprint related to the transport of its products<br />
can be reduced, including:<br />
- Optimizing truck and container fi ll rates;<br />
- Optimizing transport fl ows and delivery frequency;<br />
- Looking at alternatives to road transport that produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions;<br />
- Progressively introducing performance indicators across the <strong>Group</strong> to calculate CO2 emissions of road, sea and air transport modes,<br />
to measure and guide paths for progress.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will develop tools to globally measure optimization of the primary, secondary and tertiary environmental footprint of its packaging<br />
over the packaging’s entire life cycle.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> implementation of the packaging database will continue.<br />
- In addition, a tool will be developed to measure and track more complex environmental impact indicators for packaging, such as greenhouse<br />
gas emissions and water usage.<br />
- Environmental impact reduction targets for packaging by brand and packaging type (e.g., aluminum, tubs, cardboard, etc.)<br />
will gradually be set, with action plans mapped out for all <strong>Group</strong> operating regions.<br />
- Source reduction projects will be pursued and new projects will also be initiated.<br />
- An expected summary report on the experiments conducted with CELAA will be presented to the relevant stakeholders in France.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will continue efforts to raise employee awareness about environmentally friendly practices.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> guide to environmentally friendly practices will be deployed at all <strong>Group</strong> subsidiaries.<br />
- In France, regulatory mandated carbon scorecards for headquarters and the plants are expected to raise employee<br />
awareness about their environmental impact.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 55
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
Areas of progress MAIN ACHIEVEMENTS AT END 2011<br />
Promoting the<br />
development of<br />
a sustainable<br />
dairy channel<br />
Sharing our CSR<br />
commitments<br />
with suppliers<br />
and clearly stating<br />
our expectations<br />
Involving <strong>Bel</strong><br />
in actions of<br />
good citizenship<br />
and solidarity<br />
56 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
Partnerships and society<br />
Maintaining sustainable development partnerships<br />
with suppliers and civil society.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> main upstream challenges facing the <strong>Group</strong>’s dairy-based production were identifi ed by the food<br />
purchasing department. After taking into account respective local conditions, priority action plans were<br />
identifi ed for deployment in the various collection basins, notably the Netherlands and France, which<br />
together account for 80% of the <strong>Group</strong>’s direct milk collection.<br />
• In 2011, the <strong>Group</strong> continued to assess the CSR performance of its strategic suppliers, under a program<br />
initiated in 2009. In line with <strong>Group</strong> targets, nearly 300 suppliers deemed strategic or whose activity posed a<br />
potential CSR risk, were evaluated over a three-year period, representing 30% of purchases excluding milk<br />
collection.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> Sustainable Purchasing Charter was systematically disseminated to existing suppliers and to new<br />
suppliers at the start of business relations. Supplies were asked to commit to complying with the charter<br />
during the bidding process or when contracts were signed.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> took actions to develop internal purchasing and procurement practices:<br />
- A how-to guide was issued to all buyers to help them analyze EcoVadis ® assessments and to prioritize<br />
the corrective measures to take;<br />
- All buyers were trained in responsible purchasing.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Bel</strong> Foundation continued its efforts.<br />
- Since its founding in 2008, the foundation has supported 63 projects on behalf of children and their welfare.<br />
- In 2011, the foundation backed 19 new nonprofi t projects in 12 countries around the world, and awarded<br />
11 grants to local initiatives on behalf of children by <strong>Group</strong> employees.<br />
• In line with its philanthropic efforts, the <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> signed Admical’s Corporate Philanthropy Charter in 2011.<br />
• At the same time, various <strong>Group</strong> entities took part in good citizen and solidarity programs:<br />
- <strong>Bel</strong> Switzerland donated food to the most disadvantaged;<br />
- <strong>Bel</strong> Portugal sponsored bone marrow donations.
OUTLOOK FOR 2012 AND BEYOND<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong>’s aim is to encourage the societal, environmental and economic performance of its dairy suppliers.<br />
Two collection basins have been made a priority:<br />
- In the Netherlands, the goal is to have all dairy farmers join the Cow Compass integrated tracking process by 2015;<br />
- In France, the <strong>Group</strong> will deploy a specifi c tracking tool now being developed for dairy producers.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> will continue to improve its internal purchasing and procurement practices and to evaluate and monitor the CSR performance of its suppliers.<br />
- Suppliers assessed as high or medium risk by EcoVadis ® will be asked to implement corrective action plans and will be re-evaluated<br />
in 12 to 18 months.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> EcoVadis ® assessment of <strong>Group</strong> supplier CSR performance will be extended: Decentralized buyers will be asked to identify local suppliers<br />
to be assessed in priority.<br />
- Efforts to improve internal purchasing and procurement practices will continue by raising awareness and providing sustainable development<br />
training, taking ”responsible” suppliers into account in the pre-qualifi cation and selection process, integrating a sustainable development<br />
clause into <strong>Group</strong> tenders and contracts, and raising awareness among clients.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> is seeking to strengthen its good citizen and solidarity actions and to extend its mission of “sharing smiles with families”<br />
by helping the neediest populations.<br />
- It plans to do this through the <strong>Bel</strong> Foundation, which will continue to support nonprofi t projects on behalf of children and their well being;<br />
- By encouraging its employees to take on initiatives themselves through employee grants;<br />
- And via the <strong>Group</strong>’s entities, which will be encouraged to steer their philanthropic actions toward children and their welfare.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 57
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
Areas of progress MAIN ACHIEVEMENTS AT END 2011<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong>’s social charter was issued to all employees in 2011. <strong>The</strong> charter spells out <strong>Bel</strong>’s commitments to its employees in the four areas<br />
listed below, and what <strong>Bel</strong> expects of its managers and employees in return.<br />
• An employee opinion survey was conducted in every <strong>Group</strong> country, with 73% of employees answering the questionnaire.<br />
<strong>The</strong> survey’s overall results and the breakdown by entity in the four key areas listed below were progressively made available to employees.<br />
Ensuring employee<br />
well-being in<br />
the workplace<br />
58 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
Empowering everyone<br />
Sharing our success<br />
Developing talent<br />
Employer commitment<br />
Providing employees with the conditions for personal and collective growth.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong>’s ”health & safety” policy was deployed with the rollout of key performance indicators at all <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>site</strong>s.<br />
- In France, 226 managers and safety coordinators were trained in “safety behavior <strong>visit</strong>s”.<br />
• <strong>Bel</strong> continued its efforts on behalf of well-being at work:<br />
- Some managers were given the opportunity to work from home under certain circumstances, notably in<br />
France and Germany.<br />
- <strong>Bel</strong> USA was named one of the “Best and Brightest Companies to Work for” .<br />
• <strong>Bel</strong> offers guides and assessment materials through an IT system to assist supervisors with performance<br />
reviews, to provide employees with clear and constructive feedback for improving their performance.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> employee opinion survey gave <strong>Bel</strong> positive marks in the area of autonomy and empowerment.<br />
At the same time, the survey showed a poor understanding of the decision-making process,<br />
even though management at the <strong>Group</strong> level received a favorable opinion.<br />
• <strong>Bel</strong>’s policy of compensation is designed to recognize individual and collective performance without<br />
discrimination. At the same time, the employee opinion survey showed a perceived lack of recognition<br />
and information about how the compensation system works.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> developed the <strong>Bel</strong> Care program aimed at ensuring a <strong>Group</strong> standard for benefi ts regardless<br />
of local market practices. An audit of employee benefi ts, such as death and disability coverage, healthcare<br />
insurance for employees and their families, and paid vacation, was conducted and actions plans were<br />
prepared for 33 <strong>Group</strong> countries.<br />
• In 2011, the fi rst actions were taken to standardize disability schemes in France, with same contributions for all.<br />
• A collective employee profi t-sharing system was set up in Germany, <strong>Bel</strong>gium and the UK.<br />
• <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> continued its training policy to meet job vacancy and career development needs.<br />
- In 2011, 69% of <strong>Group</strong> employees took part in at least one training day.<br />
- Training sessions in basic cheese-making technology, product quality and safety, the environment,<br />
and knowledge about the <strong>Group</strong> were held at plants in France, Portugal and the Netherlands. Employees<br />
successfully completing the training were awarded BEST (<strong>Bel</strong> Employee Shopfl oor Training) certifi cates.<br />
• Reducing discrimination was a main area of focus.<br />
- In France, an action plan to promote the hiring of handicapped persons was set up. In 2011, a two-year<br />
partnership agreement was signed with the Agefi ph nonprofi t for handicapped employees.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> Michalovce plant has employed 13 handicapped persons since 2009.
OUTLOOK FOR 2012 AND BEYOND<br />
• Three major priorities have been identifi ed for 2012, including simplifying operating methods, improving feedback and recognition capability,<br />
and providing greater career development outlook for all <strong>Bel</strong> employees.<br />
• Actions plans based on the survey’s results will be prepared and put into place by the <strong>Group</strong>’s subsidiaries as of 2012.<br />
A new opinion survey will be conducted in 2013 (i.e., once every two years).<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will strengthen action plans aimed at improving the working conditions that already make <strong>Bel</strong> a pleasant and friendly place to work.<br />
- Efforts to prevent and control on-<strong>site</strong> risks will remain a priority at <strong>Bel</strong> to reduce accidents. Employee health and safety efforts will be enhanced.<br />
Training will be continued.<br />
- In France, the “Living well at work” program is expected to lead to related rules and raise awareness about psychosocial risks among managers.<br />
A three-year action plan on physical hardship will also be prepared.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will endeavor to create an environment where all employees feel they contribute to the company’s success in an autonomous,<br />
responsible and dedicated way.<br />
Particular focus will be placed on increasing performance review frequency, with a minimum of once a year for managers and once every<br />
two years for non-managers.<br />
- All group supervisors will be offered feedback training as part of the <strong>Group</strong>’s talent management policy.<br />
- A common program to improve understanding of the decision-making process will be implemented at all entities.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will beef up its communications with employees to support its efforts to share value created in a transparent and fair way.<br />
- A common program to improve understanding of compensation systems will be implemented at all entities.<br />
- A monitoring system will be set up to ensure non-discriminatory compensation practices, especially as regards equitable wages<br />
between men and women.<br />
- Efforts to align a basic package of employee benefi ts, such as death and disability coverage, healthcare insurance for employees and<br />
their families, and paid vacation, will continue in 33 countries.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will encourage subsidiaries to structure their wage scales based on going market rates.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will continue its goal of developing talent through experience, training and attractive career opportunities,<br />
while maintaining respect for the diversity of the <strong>Bel</strong> community.<br />
- Training projects will be continued.<br />
- <strong>The</strong> <strong>Group</strong> will take action to ensure non-discriminatory recruiting efforts and to encourage the employment of handicapped persons<br />
in certain countries.<br />
- A common program to improve the visibility of the <strong>Group</strong>’s career development policy will be implemented at all entities.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 59
SUMMARY MANAGEMENT REPORT<br />
Balance sheet<br />
is strengthened<br />
Meeting March 22, 2012, the Board of Directors approved the consolidated fi nancial statements<br />
for the year ended December 31, 2011.<br />
Volume and<br />
sales continue<br />
to advance.<br />
60 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011<br />
In 2011, the <strong>Group</strong> continued to achieve<br />
sales and volume growth, despite<br />
diffi culties in some markets.<br />
Organic sales, i.e., sales excluding foreign<br />
exchange fl uctuations and changes in the<br />
scope of consolidation, were up 7.0%,<br />
compared with an increase of 7.3% in<br />
2010. <strong>The</strong> steady growth refl ects the<br />
effectiveness of sales and marketing<br />
strategies and the success of innovations<br />
developed for the <strong>Group</strong>’s iconic brands.<br />
Operating income totaled €170 million,<br />
down 12.5% versus the previous year.<br />
Fiscal 2011 was marked by a sharp,<br />
across-the-board increase in raw material<br />
prices and geopolitical instability in some<br />
<strong>Group</strong> regions.<br />
Sales price adjustments and measures<br />
undertaken to improve operating<br />
effi ciency were not enough, however,<br />
to fully overcome the aggregate negative<br />
impact of those events, especially in<br />
markets affected by the Arab Spring<br />
uprising.<br />
Net fi nancing costs stemmed from the<br />
impact of non-recurring refi nancing costs<br />
and foreign exchange losses on emerging<br />
country currencies.<br />
After income tax expense of €47 million,<br />
down from €57 million in 2010,<br />
consolidated net profi t, <strong>Group</strong> share,<br />
totaled €96 million, versus €116 million<br />
in the previous year.<br />
<strong>Bel</strong>’s balance sheet was once again<br />
strengthened during the year.<br />
At December 31, 2011, the <strong>Group</strong>’s total<br />
equity stood at €1,044 million, compared<br />
with €1,009 million a year earlier, while<br />
net fi nancial debt came to €194 million,<br />
down €46 million versus the prior year.<br />
Against a backdrop of high raw material<br />
prices and robust volume growth, this<br />
result refl ects tightly managed working<br />
capital requirement and capital<br />
expenditure.
Dividend<br />
On March 22, 2012, the Board of Directors<br />
voted to propose a dividend of €5.00<br />
per share, payable as of May 16, 2012.<br />
<strong>The</strong> dividend is subject to the approval<br />
of the Annual General Meeting scheduled<br />
for May 10, 2011.<br />
Outlook for 2012<br />
<strong>The</strong> economic environment at the start of<br />
2012 remains under pressure in some<br />
<strong>Group</strong> territories in the Near and Middle<br />
East region, with continued economic<br />
uncertainties in Europe and no sure signs<br />
of easing raw material prices.<br />
2 418<br />
+4,5%<br />
2 527<br />
2010 2011<br />
Sales<br />
in millions of euros<br />
Despite these uncertainties, the <strong>Group</strong>—<br />
backed by a healthy balance sheet,<br />
the commitment of its employees<br />
and a growing international presence<br />
— will fortify its drive for creativity and<br />
innovation to further advance its positions<br />
in the world cheese market in a<br />
sustainable and profi table way.<br />
Earnings impacted by<br />
the sharp rise in raw<br />
material prices.<br />
195<br />
-12,5%<br />
170<br />
2010 2011<br />
Operating income<br />
in millions of euros<br />
116<br />
-17,4%<br />
96<br />
2010 2011<br />
Consolidated net profi t<br />
<strong>Group</strong> share<br />
in millions of euros<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 61
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT AT DECEMBER 31, 2011,<br />
VS. PRIOR YEAR<br />
(In thousands of euros) December 2011 December 2010<br />
Sales 2,527,100 2,417,511<br />
Cost of goods and services sold (1,808,488) (1,662,870)<br />
Gross margin 718,612 754,641<br />
Sales and marketing expense (359,050) (366,125)<br />
Research and development expense (14,461) (15,614)<br />
Administrative and general overhead expense (160,888) (162,401)<br />
Other operating income and expense 482 438<br />
Income from ordinary activities 184,695 210,940<br />
Other non-recurring income and expense (14,275) (16,165)<br />
Operating income 170,420 194,775<br />
Income from cash and cash equivalents 2,796 1,816<br />
Cost of gross fi nancial indebtedness (21,528) (19,059)<br />
Cost of net fi nancial indebtedness (18,732) (17, 242)<br />
Other fi nancial income and expense (7,655) (2,847)<br />
Pre-tax profi t 144, 033 174,685<br />
Income tax expense (47,115) (56,942)<br />
Net profi t of the consolidated <strong>Group</strong> 96,918 117,744<br />
Minority interest (815) (1,363)<br />
Consolidated net profi t - <strong>Group</strong> share 96,103 116,381<br />
Earnings per share (in euros) 14.05 17.03<br />
Diluted earnings per share (in euros) 14.01 16.96<br />
<strong>The</strong> full consolidated fi nancial statements are available at the <strong>Bel</strong> web<strong>site</strong>, www.bel-group.com<br />
62 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET AT DECEMBER 31, 2011 VS. PRIOR YEAR,<br />
BEFORE APPROPRIATION OF EARNINGS<br />
ASSETS<br />
(In thousands of euros) December 2011 December 2010<br />
Non current assets<br />
Goodwill 387,897 389,187<br />
Other intangible assets 303,096 305,623<br />
Property, plant and equipment 529,868 539,988<br />
Assets available for sale 53,150 51,884<br />
Other fi nancial assets 1,279 3,975<br />
Loans and advances 9,224 7,178<br />
Trade and other receivables 74 79<br />
Deferred tax assets 11,215 11,128<br />
Total 1,295,803 1,309,042<br />
Current assets<br />
Inventories and work-in-progress 243,525 223,923<br />
Trade and other receivables 436,402 410,255<br />
Other fi nancial assets 1,094 498<br />
Loans and advances 351 290<br />
Current tax assets 18,079 33,723<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 141,408 139,939<br />
Total 840,859 808,628<br />
TOTAL ASSET 2,136,662 2,117,670<br />
EQUITY AND LIABILITIES<br />
(In thousands of euros)<br />
December 2011 December 2010<br />
Share capital 10,308 10,308<br />
Additional paid-in capital 21,967 21,967<br />
Reserves 1,002,392 958,203<br />
Treasury shares (6,182) (7,390)<br />
EQUITY - <strong>Group</strong> share 1,028,485 983,088<br />
Minority interest 15,681 25,596<br />
Equity 1,044,166 1,008,684<br />
Non current liabilities<br />
Provisions 9,463 10,577<br />
Employee benefi ts 41,269 38,789<br />
Deferred tax liabilities 156,645 151,546<br />
Liabilities related to assets held under fi nance lease - over one year 1,068 1 ,180<br />
Long-term borrowings and fi nancial liabilities 256,580 323,142<br />
Other liabilities 32,404 36,344<br />
Total 497,429 561,578<br />
Current liabilities<br />
Provisions 14,913 17,520<br />
Employee benefi ts 2,350 2,264<br />
Liabilities related to assets held under fi nance lease - less than one year 365 0<br />
Short-term borrowings and fi nancial liabilities 68,904 49,754<br />
Other fi nancial liabilities 30,618 12,320<br />
Trade payables and other liabilities 455,199 421,696<br />
Due tax liabilities 13,881 37,765<br />
Current bank facilities and other borrowings 8,837 6,089<br />
Total 595,067 547,409<br />
TOTAL EQUITY AND LIABILITIES 2,136,662 2,117,670<br />
<strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011 • 63
CONSOLIDATED CASH FLOW STATEMENT<br />
AT DECEMBER 31, 2011<br />
(In thousands of euros) December 2011 December 2010<br />
Cash fl ow from (used in) operating activities<br />
Pre-tax profi t 144,033 174,685<br />
Adjustments for:<br />
Depreciation and write-downs 78,874 92,272<br />
Capital gains (losses) on disposals 1,712 (370)<br />
Reclassifi cation of dividends and borrowing costs 19,862 18,191<br />
Other non-cash items on the income statement 4,376 5,506<br />
Cash fl ow 248,857 290,284<br />
Increase (decrease) in inventories, current receivables and payables (19,121) (7,097)<br />
Increase (decrease) in non-current receivables and payables (677) 3,106<br />
Income taxes paid (47,087) (44,946)<br />
Net cash fl ow generated by operating activities (1) 181,972 241,347<br />
Cash fl ow from (used in) investing activities<br />
Acquisition of activities 580 (2,956)<br />
Disposal of activities 270<br />
Acquisitions of tangible and intangible assets (74,682) (63,856)<br />
Disposals of tangible and intangible assets 693 2,533<br />
Investment grants received 111<br />
Acquisitions of fi nancial assets (3,927) (3,554)<br />
Disposals of fi nancial assets 3,135 2,134<br />
Interest received (61)<br />
Dividends received 1,228 916<br />
Net cash fl ow from (used in) investing activities ( 2) (72,923) (64,513)<br />
Cash fl ow from (used in) fi nancing activities<br />
Dividends paid (48,418) (40,112)<br />
Interest paid (21,090) (19,107)<br />
Increase (decrease) in capital 35<br />
Repayment of debt resulting from fi nance lease contracts (358) (80)<br />
Increase (decrease) in current accounts with entities outside the scope of consolidation 9,603 (6,875)<br />
Borrowings and fi nancial liabilities issued 67,723 25,655<br />
Repayments of borrowings and fi nancial liabilities (119,619) (109,882)<br />
Net cash fl ow from (used in) fi nancing activities ( 3) (112,124) (150,401)<br />
Net increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents (1) + (2) + (3) (3,075) 26,433<br />
Net cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the period 133,668 107,724<br />
Effect of foreign exchange rate variations 1,829 (489)<br />
Other items with no effect on cash<br />
Net cash and cash equivalents at the end of the period 132,422 133,668<br />
At the closing date, net cash and cash equivalents comprised the following:<br />
Marketable securities and money market instruments 86,773 99,162<br />
Cash on hand and balances with banks 54,486 40,595<br />
Current used bank facilities including overdrafts and accrued interest (8,837) (6,089)<br />
TOTAL 132,422 133,668<br />
64 • <strong>Bel</strong> <strong>Group</strong> 2011
FOR MORE INFORMATION ABOUT BEL<br />
www.bel-group.com<br />
AND THE CSR POLICY OF THE GROUP<br />
www.smilesfortheplanet.com<br />
BEL GROUP CONTACT INFORMATION<br />
• Guillaume Jouët – VP Communications, Public Affairs and Corporate Social Responsibility<br />
Tel. +33 (0)1 40 07 72 50 – e-mail: communication@groupe-bel.com<br />
• Frédérique Gaulard – Head of CSR<br />
Tel. +33 (0)1 40 07 72 50 – e-mail: rse@groupe-bel.com<br />
• Fromageries <strong>Bel</strong><br />
Headquarters: 16, boulevard Malesherbes 75008 Paris - Tel. + 33 (0)140 07 72 50<br />
French corporation (société anonyme) with a share capital of €10,308,502.50 - RCS Paris B 542 088 06<br />
Design and production: Tel. +33 (0)1 53 23 35 35; photo credits: Virgile Dureuil,<br />
Philippe Noisette, Guilain Grenier, Gérard Uféras, Getty Images, Photothèque groupe <strong>Bel</strong>, DR.<br />
This annual report was printed by an Imprim’vert printer using paper<br />
that meets PEFC environmental standards.<br />
<strong>The</strong> PEFC (Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certifi cation) label certifi es<br />
that forests are managed according to sustainable management requirements.