13.01.2013 Views

summary of moody's jda for banks - Bad Request

summary of moody's jda for banks - Bad Request

summary of moody's jda for banks - Bad Request

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Contents<br />

What Has Happened Since<br />

February 23? _______________ 2<br />

The Final BFSR/JDA<br />

Methodology ______________ 3<br />

Our Evaluation Of The New<br />

Methodology ______________ 7<br />

FAQ _______________________ 8<br />

Complete New Ratings Lists _ 9<br />

Reactions By S&P And Fitch _ 13<br />

Author<br />

Alexander Plenk, CFA<br />

+49 89 378-12429<br />

alexander.plenk@hvb.de<br />

Bloomberg<br />

HVCA<br />

Internet<br />

www.hvbmarkets.de<br />

Sector Report<br />

SUMMARY OF MOODY'S JDA FOR BANKS<br />

THROUGH THE BARRICADES<br />

� When Moody's first presented its JDA <strong>for</strong> <strong>banks</strong> methodology at the end <strong>of</strong><br />

February, there was a lot <strong>of</strong> criticism, which led the agency to revise its new<br />

approach in mid-March. Following the so-called refinements, which basically<br />

include less weight on implicit support than initially applied, Moody's rolled<br />

out the new ratings against continued market criticism. Was Moody's right<br />

in struggling through the barricades, or has it lost much <strong>of</strong> its credibility?<br />

� In this Sector Report, we summarize all major JDA related aspects, in order to<br />

assemble the many pieces <strong>of</strong> an interesting puzzle into a complete picture.<br />

� We would like to stress the most important aspect at the very beginning: from a<br />

fundamental point <strong>of</strong> view, nothing has changed. What actually has changed is<br />

Moody's methodology <strong>of</strong> rating bank credit risk. Moody's main point is that<br />

rating agencies (including Moody's itself) have underestimated the impact <strong>of</strong><br />

implicit support <strong>for</strong> decades.<br />

� In its new mechanism, Moody's first grants the BFSR (ranging from A-E),<br />

translates this into the default rating scale, utilizes it as the baseline rating, and<br />

then derives the default rating by adding external support factors.<br />

� We regard the following JDA features as positive:<br />

– Well-written, in-depth papers on both the BFSR and JDA methodology,<br />

covering the assessment <strong>of</strong> inherent financial strength and external support.<br />

– Detailed scorecard <strong>for</strong> the deviation <strong>of</strong> the BFSR rating and the support level<br />

leads to consistent and structured methodology.<br />

– Handy excel-based tools which allow <strong>for</strong> rating drivers sensitivity analyses.<br />

– Structured, easy to read Credit Opinions.<br />

� The shortfalls <strong>of</strong> the new framework include less predictability than in the initial<br />

methodology, subjective scorecard points and weights, some sub-optimal<br />

assumptions regarding support quantification, and a tricky final calibration.<br />

� Overall, the positive features outweigh the shortfalls, in our view.<br />

� Going <strong>for</strong>ward, there will be no significant impact on secondary market spreads<br />

nor on primary market activity.<br />

� Inside (pages 9-12), we provide the amended ratings <strong>of</strong> the <strong>banks</strong> in our core<br />

coverage universe. For better comparison, we prefer to show the ratings as <strong>of</strong><br />

the JDA implementation date, not considering changes since then.<br />

� Both S&P and Fitch, as we expected, said that the importance <strong>of</strong> support they<br />

factor in their ratings is not subject to change. Moreover, Fitch released a<br />

detailed list <strong>of</strong> support rating floors (please refer to page 13); at the same time,<br />

Fitch made clear that there was no change in criteria.<br />

© Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

WHAT HAS HAPPENED SINCE FEBRUARY 23?<br />

Start on February 23 On February 23, Moody's published two documents, (i) revising its BFSR<br />

methodology, and (ii) introducing its Joint-Default Analysis <strong>for</strong> deposittaking<br />

<strong>banks</strong>. While at a first glance, these methodology papers looked like a<br />

more detailed description <strong>of</strong> what has been done ever since, the resulting<br />

rating changes published the same day were pretty hefty. In a nutshell, all<br />

<strong>banks</strong> which are too big to fail were rated Aaa or Aa1 at that time. Too big to fail<br />

does not relate to the absolute size <strong>of</strong> the bank, but to its relative size when<br />

compared to the home economy. This applied also to the three Icelandic <strong>banks</strong><br />

(Glitnir, Kaupthing, Landsbanki), which had been rumored to have liquidity<br />

problems only some months ago. Moody's planned to roll out JDA <strong>for</strong> all <strong>banks</strong><br />

globally within eight weeks time, and to conclude this process in mid-April. The<br />

market strongly opposed the new methodology.<br />

Revision announcement on<br />

March 9<br />

Revisions postponement on<br />

March 16<br />

Refinements and new time<br />

schedule published on March<br />

30<br />

New implementation started<br />

on April 3 …<br />

On March 9, Moody's stated that it is contemplating changes to JDA <strong>for</strong><br />

<strong>banks</strong>. The revision would particularly include <strong>banks</strong> whose default rating<br />

significantly deviates from the Bank Financial Strength Rating (BFSR) as well as<br />

the notching mechanism <strong>for</strong> subordinated paper. JDA ratings granted so far<br />

might be changed as a result. Moreover, a new schedule <strong>for</strong> the roll-out would<br />

be released on March 16.<br />

On March 16, Moody's postponed the revision, and set the new release date<br />

<strong>for</strong> March 30. Following the heavy negative market reaction, we think that<br />

Moody's wanted to avoid any inaccuracy when presenting its revision and hence<br />

postponed the release by two weeks. In a brief announcement, Moody's stated<br />

only the following: (i) The impact <strong>of</strong> support on long-term ratings will be limited;<br />

(ii) The notching <strong>for</strong> subordinated paper will be reviewed; (iii) JDA revised<br />

ratings published so far will be reassessed; (iv) There will be a new schedule <strong>for</strong><br />

the country by country roll-out. The new time frame looked like this: (i) and (ii)<br />

on or be<strong>for</strong>e March 30; (iii) targeted <strong>for</strong> April 10; (iv) on or be<strong>for</strong>e March 30,<br />

with completion <strong>of</strong> the roll-out on May 18.<br />

On March 30, Moody's published the "refinements" including a new roll-out<br />

schedule. The adjustments included a lower implicit systemic support<br />

assumption, stronger notching <strong>for</strong> weak <strong>banks</strong>, and generally more scope <strong>for</strong><br />

rating committee judgment. As a result <strong>of</strong> these amendments, Moody's expected<br />

the average JDA implied rating upgrade not to exceed one notch compared to<br />

the previous methodology, more closely reflecting Bank Financial Strength<br />

Ratings, which is far below the Aaa inflation seen under the initial JDA<br />

implementation.<br />

On April 3, Moody's placed under review <strong>for</strong> downgrade 46 <strong>of</strong> the 210 <strong>banks</strong><br />

<strong>for</strong> which original JDA had been applied. Moody's also reviewed <strong>for</strong> upgrade<br />

capital securities <strong>of</strong> twelve <strong>banks</strong>. On April 10, Moody's announced the<br />

respective rating changes. Moody's downgraded 44 <strong>banks</strong> (29 by one notch, 12<br />

by two notches, and 3 by three notches compared to the initial JDA application)<br />

and confirmed two <strong>of</strong> them. Moreover, following the respective review<br />

announced one week be<strong>for</strong>e, Moody's upgraded the junior securities <strong>of</strong> 13<br />

<strong>banks</strong>.<br />

… and was finalized on May 11 On May 11, Moody's concluded the JDA <strong>for</strong> bank implementation. All<br />

respective Credit Opinions (including the details <strong>for</strong> each rating action) are set to<br />

be published by the end <strong>of</strong> May, according to the agency.<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

2


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

The risk <strong>of</strong> a bank going into<br />

default has always been a<br />

combination <strong>of</strong> its inherent<br />

strength and the likelihood <strong>of</strong><br />

receiving support<br />

Moody's increased the impact<br />

<strong>of</strong> implicit support on its<br />

default ratings<br />

Moody's new approach is much<br />

more structured than be<strong>for</strong>e<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

THE FINAL BFSR/JDA METHODOLOGY<br />

We would like to stress the most important aspect at the very beginning:<br />

from a fundamental point <strong>of</strong> view, nothing has changed. What actually has<br />

changed is Moody's methodology <strong>of</strong> rating bank credit risk. The risk <strong>of</strong> a<br />

bank going into default has always been a combination <strong>of</strong> its inherent strength<br />

and the likelihood <strong>of</strong> receiving support if it were to fail to meet its obligations on<br />

a stand-alone basis. Support could be provided by large shareholders, other<br />

<strong>banks</strong> (due to mutual support systems or acquisitions), and the sovereign or subsovereign,<br />

with the main reasons being not to lose a sound franchise and/or to<br />

avoid a shock to the overall economic stability <strong>of</strong> the bank's home country.<br />

Moody's, S&P, and Fitch reflect this in their methodologies, with Moody's<br />

providing a Bank Financial Strength Rating (BFSR), and Fitch an Individual<br />

Rating, a Support Rating and a Support Rating Floor in addition to the long-tem<br />

rating.<br />

Moody's main point is that rating agencies (including Moody's itself) have<br />

underestimated the impact <strong>of</strong> implicit support <strong>for</strong> decades. Hence, bank<br />

ratings have consistently been too low, which had to be adjusted, in Moody's<br />

view. As S&P and Fitch view their methodologies and support impact<br />

assumptions as appropriate, JDA has led to many split ratings, with some <strong>of</strong><br />

them being substantial.<br />

While fundamentals, except <strong>for</strong> the higher weight <strong>of</strong> support, have not changed,<br />

Moody's new approach is also much more structured than be<strong>for</strong>e, as a scorecard<br />

<strong>for</strong> both BFSR and JDA has been introduced. In its new mechanism, Moody's<br />

first grants the BFSR (ranging from A-E), translates this into the default<br />

rating scale (see table below), utilizes it as the baseline rating, and then<br />

derives the default rating by adding external support factors, both explicit<br />

and implicit ones.<br />

RATING SCALES IN COMPARISON<br />

Moody's BFSR Moody's Default S&P/Fitch Default<br />

A Aaa AAA<br />

A- Aa1 AA+<br />

B+ Aa2 AA<br />

B Aa3 AA-<br />

B- A1 A+<br />

C+ A2 A<br />

C A3 A-<br />

C- Baa1 BBB+<br />

C- Baa2 BBB<br />

D+ Baa3 BBB-<br />

D+ Ba1 BB+<br />

D+ Ba2 BB<br />

D- Ba3 BB-<br />

E+ B1 B+<br />

E+ B2 B<br />

E+ B3 B-<br />

E Caa1 CCC+<br />

E Caa2 CCC<br />

E Caa3 CCC-<br />

Source: Rating agencies; Global Research (HVB)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

3


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Five factors <strong>for</strong> BFSR<br />

determination<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

The BFSR includes five factors, which have different weights: franchise value<br />

(20%), risk positioning (20%), regulatory environment (5%), operating<br />

environment (5%), and financial fundamentals (50%). Within each <strong>of</strong> these<br />

categories, there are sub-factors (see scorecard below).<br />

MOODY'S BFSR SCORECARD WEIGHTS FOR BANKS IN MATURE MARKETS<br />

Qualitative<br />

Factors<br />

50%<br />

Financial<br />

Factors<br />

50%<br />

Franchise<br />

Value<br />

Risk<br />

Positioning<br />

Regulatory<br />

Environment<br />

Category<br />

Weight<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

4<br />

Overall<br />

Weight<br />

40% 20% − Market share and sustainability<br />

− Geographical diversification<br />

− Earnings stability<br />

− Earnings diversification<br />

40% 20% − Corporate Governance<br />

− Controls & Risk Management<br />

− Financial Reporting Transparency<br />

− Credit Risk Concentration<br />

− Liquidity Management<br />

− Market Risk Appetite<br />

Sub-<br />

Factor<br />

Weight<br />

25%<br />

25%<br />

25%<br />

25%<br />

16.7%<br />

16.7%<br />

16.7%<br />

16.7%<br />

16.7%<br />

16.7%<br />

Overall<br />

Weight<br />

5.0%<br />

5.0%<br />

5.0%<br />

5.0%<br />

3.3%<br />

3.3%<br />

3.3%<br />

3.3%<br />

3.3%<br />

3.3%<br />

10% 5% − Regulatory Environment 100% 5.0%<br />

Operating<br />

10% 5% − Economic Stability<br />

33.3% 1.7%<br />

Environment<br />

− Integrity and Corruption<br />

33.3% 1.7%<br />

− Legal System<br />

33.3% 1.7%<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>itability 15.75% 8% − PPP % Avg RWA<br />

50% 3.9%<br />

− Net Income % Avg RWA<br />

50% 3.9%<br />

Liquidity 15.75% 8% − (Market funds – Liquid Assets)<br />

36% 2.8%<br />

% Total Assts<br />

64% 5.1%<br />

− Liquidity Management<br />

Capital<br />

15.75% 8% − Tier 1 ratio (%)<br />

50% 3.9%<br />

Adequacy<br />

− Tangible Common Equity % RWA 50% 3.9%<br />

Efficiency 7 % 4% − Cost/income ratio 100% 3.5%<br />

Asset Quality 15.75% 8% − Problem Loans % Gross Loans<br />

− Problem Loans % (Equity + LLR)<br />

Lowest Score 30 % 15% − Assigned to lowest combined<br />

financial factor score<br />

Source: Moody's; Global Research (HVB)<br />

50%<br />

50%<br />

3.9%<br />

3.9%<br />

100% 15.0%


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Support is more than state<br />

support<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

In its support probability methodology, Moody's not only includes sovereign<br />

support, but also support from sub-sovereigns, large shareholders, and mutual<br />

support systems. Moreover, support is not purely defined as a plain-vanilla<br />

capital injection, but includes things such as behind-the-scenes arrangements,<br />

e.g. to catalyze a merger process. For all Western European countries, Moody's<br />

deposit rating ceiling remains Aaa, also when the sovereign rating is lower, as<br />

support by the European Union can be expected <strong>for</strong> large <strong>banks</strong>.<br />

MOODY'S BANK RATING METHODOLOGY<br />

Financial<br />

Strength<br />

Rating<br />

(A – E)<br />

Issuer<br />

Baseline Risk<br />

Assessment<br />

(Aaa – C)<br />

Operating<br />

Parent Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Operating<br />

Parent Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Operating<br />

Parent Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Source: Moody's; Global Research (HVB)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

5<br />

Stage 1<br />

Output<br />

(Aaa – C)<br />

Cooperative<br />

Group Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Cooperative<br />

Group Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Cooperative<br />

Group Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Stage 2<br />

Output<br />

(Aaa – C)<br />

Regional/Local<br />

Government<br />

Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Regional/Local<br />

Government<br />

Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Regional/Local<br />

Government<br />

Rating<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Stage 3<br />

Output<br />

(Aaa – C)<br />

Local<br />

Currency<br />

Deposit<br />

Ceiling<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Local<br />

Currency<br />

Deposit<br />

Ceiling<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Local<br />

Currency<br />

Deposit<br />

Ceiling<br />

(Aaa-C)<br />

Local<br />

Currency<br />

Deposit<br />

Rating<br />

(Aaa – C)


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

New notching mechanism with<br />

up to four notches<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

Moody's also published a criteria report titled "Guidelines <strong>for</strong> Rating Bank<br />

Junior Securities", whose purpose is to explain Moody’s rating practices <strong>for</strong><br />

junior securities issued by <strong>banks</strong> (known as “notching”) as outlined in the March<br />

2007 JDA <strong>for</strong> <strong>banks</strong> methodology report. While leaving the general notching<br />

mechanism <strong>for</strong> subordinated paper unchanged (one or two notches down from<br />

the senior rating, depending on the degree <strong>of</strong> subordination), Moody's stated<br />

that it may add one or two additional notches <strong>for</strong> weaker <strong>banks</strong> (BFSR <strong>of</strong> D+ or<br />

lower). Once again, the scope <strong>for</strong> rating committee judgment has increased,<br />

making rating <strong>for</strong>ecasts harder. The notching mechanism <strong>for</strong> subordinated<br />

paper has also been adjusted in a way that reflects each sovereign's possibility<br />

to impose the depreciation <strong>of</strong> such paper. The mechanism now ranges from one<br />

to four notches, with up to three notches having been applied so far.<br />

MOODY'S NOTCHING MECHANISM FOR BANK CAPITAL<br />

Typical<br />

Regulatory<br />

Treatment*<br />

Subordinated Lower Tier II<br />

and Tier III**<br />

Junior<br />

Subordinated<br />

Preferred shares<br />

and other Hybrids<br />

with preferred<br />

treatment in<br />

bankruptcy<br />

and/or deeply<br />

subordinated debt<br />

Hybrids with<br />

meaningful<br />

triggers***<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

6<br />

Most Common Characteristics BFSR <strong>of</strong><br />

A, B or C<br />

Dated, no interest<br />

deferral language,<br />

subordinated to<br />

senior and ahead <strong>of</strong><br />

jr. sub. in bankruptcy,<br />

and preferred. Tier III<br />

subject to maturity<br />

extension.<br />

Upper Tier II Undated, with<br />

interest deferral<br />

language, cumulative,<br />

could be subordinated<br />

or pari passu to LT2<br />

but ahead or<br />

preferred.<br />

Tier I Interest deferral<br />

language, cumulative<br />

or non-cumulative,<br />

ranking ahead <strong>of</strong><br />

equity.<br />

Upper Tier II<br />

or Tier I<br />

Principal<br />

writedown<br />

outside <strong>of</strong><br />

liquidation<br />

Principal<br />

writedown<br />

outside <strong>of</strong><br />

liquidation<br />

Notches below senior<br />

BFSR<br />

<strong>of</strong> D<br />

BFSR <strong>of</strong> E<br />

-1 -1 -1<br />

-1 -1 -2<br />

-1 -2 Closer to the BFSR<br />

implied rating<br />

-2 -3 Closer to the BFSR<br />

implied rating<br />

-2 -3 Closer to the BFSR<br />

implied rating<br />

up to -2 up to -3 Closer to the BFSR<br />

implied rating<br />

* Notching is based on differences in expected loss rather than on regulatory capital treatment because the<br />

regulatory specifications <strong>for</strong> such instruments vary across jurisdictions.<br />

** Tier III instruments are rated according to priority <strong>of</strong> claim (typically subordinated). The risk in such instruments<br />

<strong>of</strong> a maturity extension or interest deferral tied to meeting minimum capital requirements does not<br />

significantly affect expected loss.<br />

*** Meaningful triggers are those set at a level such that they would be breached when one <strong>of</strong> the following<br />

occurs: 1) the issuer is just beginning to experience financial distress (be<strong>for</strong>e it is in severe financial distress) or<br />

2) at a time when issuer may cut or eliminate its common dividend.<br />

Source: Moody's; Global Research (HVB)


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

OUR EVALUATION OF THE NEW METHODOLOGY<br />

Two general problems In our view, the fact that the likelihood <strong>of</strong> implicit support cannot be<br />

quantified, generates two problems:<br />

Positive features outweigh<br />

shortfalls, in our view, …<br />

… even if the shortfalls cover<br />

more space <strong>for</strong> explanation<br />

– Moody's new ratings are criticized <strong>for</strong> being subjective as there is no<br />

historical or objective data base which explains the applied support<br />

assumptions (however, this is the same as <strong>for</strong> the other agencies, which do<br />

not publish their quantified assumptions).<br />

– No one can honestly tell whether Moody's or the others are right. This might<br />

be possible in five or ten years, when actual default rates can be compared to<br />

assigned ratings.<br />

Regarding Moody's new approach itself, there is both good and bad news. On<br />

the positive side, we see the following features:<br />

– Well-written, in-depth papers on both the BFSR and JDA methodology,<br />

covering the assessment <strong>of</strong> inherent financial strength and external support.<br />

– Detailed scorecard <strong>for</strong> the deviation <strong>of</strong> the BFSR rating and the support level<br />

leads to consistent and structured methodology.<br />

– Handy excel-based tools which allow <strong>for</strong> rating drivers sensitivity analyses.<br />

– Structured, easy to read Credit Opinions.<br />

The shortfalls <strong>of</strong> the new framework include:<br />

– Rating committees have been given larger scope <strong>for</strong> judgment, as this is<br />

needed to adjust the scorecard process <strong>for</strong> special situations and nonquantifiable<br />

inputs; however, this makes rating <strong>for</strong>ecasts harder, as there is a<br />

range <strong>of</strong> scorecard points <strong>for</strong> each set <strong>of</strong> data (particularly regarding support).<br />

– In both BFSR and JDA, limits and ranges are subjective and are not explained<br />

by historic or objective data.<br />

– Moody's might be right in granting more importance to support mechanisms.<br />

It makes two basic assumptions: (i) it derives the general probability <strong>of</strong> a<br />

country to support its <strong>banks</strong> from the strength <strong>of</strong> the banking system, its<br />

importance to the economy, and the history <strong>of</strong> bank defaults in a very static<br />

manner. The problem we see here is that history is not necessarily a good<br />

indicator <strong>for</strong> the future; also, Moody's assumption that financial strength is<br />

negatively correlated to the support probability is questionable. (ii) Moody's<br />

estimates the probability <strong>for</strong> each bank to be supported depending on the<br />

bank's market share and importance to the financial system's stability. While<br />

the implied positive correlation is generally correct, there are two flaws, in<br />

our view. First, the probability brackets mentioned above are the same <strong>for</strong> all<br />

countries and the categorization follows a very static approach, with huge<br />

impacts on the final default rating. This does not recognize the fact that there<br />

are differences from country to country. Second, if a bank is small, the<br />

likelihood <strong>of</strong> it being rescued might be high, as it is easy to do it, mitigating<br />

the positive correlation; we should remember that support also includes<br />

things such as behind-the-scenes arrangements, e.g. to catalyze a merger<br />

process.<br />

– The final calibration (transition <strong>of</strong> scorecard points into rating) is problematic,<br />

in our view, as small assumption changes lead to huge rating differences.<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

7


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Going <strong>for</strong>ward, there will be no<br />

significant impact on secondary<br />

market spreads …<br />

… nor on primary market<br />

activity<br />

It has not become much easier<br />

to <strong>for</strong>ecast Moody's ratings<br />

JDA application to other<br />

industries would take at least<br />

one year<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FAQ<br />

What is the implication <strong>for</strong> secondary market spreads?<br />

Following increased volatility after the big bang on February 23 (and even<br />

be<strong>for</strong>e that date), the situation has calmed when Moody's announced to revise its<br />

approach in mid-March. Going <strong>for</strong>ward, the market will not adjust to spreads<br />

completely reflecting the new ratings <strong>for</strong> two reasons: First, there have always<br />

been spread differences between similarly rated <strong>banks</strong>, as the agencies' view is<br />

not 100% shared by the market. In the current case, the new ratings derive from<br />

a new methodology, and not from changed fundamentals, and are also based on<br />

an old story (too big to fail). Second, there are other rating agencies whose view<br />

is different, and which are also recognized by market participants. In this<br />

respect, we are interested to see the effects on Moody's Market Implied Ratings,<br />

which were introduced to shed some light on the differences between rating<br />

implied and actual spreads. Moreover, there are three other implications: (i) the<br />

number <strong>of</strong> split ratings increased, as has uncertainty about fair pricing; (ii) some<br />

small <strong>banks</strong>, as already happened, could terminate contracts with other rating<br />

agencies in order to improve their rating pr<strong>of</strong>ile and save costs and time at the<br />

same time; (iii) new investor groups have been allowed to invest, as certain<br />

rating hurdles (which impose investment limitations) have been cleared.<br />

Is there an impact on primary market activity?<br />

Moody's new ratings coincided with the market correction at the end <strong>of</strong><br />

February, abruptly stopping issuance activity, caused by both market<br />

uncertainty and hope <strong>for</strong> better finance conditions (induced by better ratings).<br />

Going <strong>for</strong>ward, however, we do not expect any further impact.<br />

Has it become easier to <strong>for</strong>ecast Moody's ratings?<br />

Not really. Although Moody's provides much insight into its scorecard weights<br />

<strong>for</strong> qualitative and quantitative criteria, there are numerous decisions whose<br />

individual result can only be <strong>for</strong>ecast in a certain range. However, their effect on<br />

the notching scale heavily depends on the actual outcome (which to a large part<br />

depends on the rating committee's decision), and in combination could lead to a<br />

completely different picture when compared to the alternative outcome.<br />

Will JDA be applied <strong>for</strong> other industries?<br />

Limited Basel II implications What about Basel II?<br />

We think that the discussion<br />

about Moody's credibility will<br />

soon come to an end<br />

While not having concrete plans, Moody's can imagine to apply JDA to other<br />

sectors, such as insurance or industrials. However, it would first publish<br />

proposals with request <strong>for</strong> comments by market participants.<br />

In the standardized approach, <strong>banks</strong> have to consider the second best rating if<br />

there are two or three ratings. In the advanced approaches, the bank has to<br />

make its own assessment anyway; the better Moody's rating could serve as an<br />

argument only when discussing the internal ratings with the auditor and<br />

regulator. Hence, a strong impact is limited to the standardized approach when<br />

there is only a Moody's rating.<br />

Has Moody's lost its credibility?<br />

Although there has been much criticism (both justified and unjustified, in our<br />

view), we dare the <strong>for</strong>ecast that the credibility issue will cease to exist in a few<br />

months time, following Moody's adjustment <strong>of</strong> its methodology.<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

8


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

COMPLETE NEW RATINGS LISTS<br />

Our core coverage only On the following pages, we provide the amended ratings <strong>of</strong> the <strong>banks</strong> in our<br />

core coverage universe. For better comparison, we prefer to show the ratings<br />

as <strong>of</strong> the JDA implementation date, not considering changes since then. In all<br />

tables, BFSR refers to Bank Financial Strength Rating, and LTR to the respective<br />

long-term rating, whatever its <strong>of</strong>ficial definition (e.g. issuer default etc.)<br />

US BANKS AFFECTED BY MOODY'S JDA REVISION (MARCH 2)<br />

United States Company<br />

Ticker<br />

Country Moody's<br />

old BFSR<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

9<br />

Moody's<br />

new BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

old LTR<br />

Moody's<br />

new LTR<br />

(JDA)<br />

S&P LTR Fitch LTR<br />

BANK OF AMERICA CORP BAC US -- -- Aa2 Aa1 AA AA<br />

CITIGROUP INC C US -- -- Aa1 Aa1 AA AA+<br />

JPMORGAN CHASE & CO JPM US -- -- Aa3 Aa2 AA- AA-<br />

Source: Rating agencies; Bloomberg; Global Research (HVB)<br />

SCANDINAVIAN BANKS AFFECTED BY MOODY'S JDA REVISION (APRIL 10)<br />

Scandinavia Company<br />

Ticker<br />

Country Moody's<br />

old BFSR*<br />

Moody's<br />

new BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

old LTR<br />

Moody's<br />

new LTR<br />

(JDA)<br />

S&P LTR Fitch LTR<br />

AB VOLVOFINANS VOLVAB SE C C A3 A3 -- --<br />

AKTIA SAVINGS BANK PLC AKTSAV FI C C A3 A1 -- --<br />

DANSKE BANK A/S DANBNK DK A- B Aa1 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

DEN NORSKE BANK ASA DNBNOR NO B B Aa3 Aaa -- --<br />

DNB NORBANK ASA DNBNOR NO B B- Aa3 Aa1 A+ A+<br />

FIH ERHVERVSBANK A/S KAUP DK C+ C+ A1 A1 -- --<br />

FOKUS BANK ASA DANBNK NO C C Aa2 Aa2 -- --<br />

GLITNIR BANKI HF GLBIR IS C C A1 Aa3 A- A<br />

JYSKE BANK-REG JYBC DK B- B- A1 Aa2 A --<br />

KAUPTHING BANK KAUP IS C C A1 Aa3 -- A<br />

LANDSBANKI ISLANDS HF LANISL IS C C A2 Aa3 -- A<br />

LANDSHYPOTEK AB LANHYP SE C+ C+ -- A2 BBB+ A+<br />

LANSFORSAKRINGAR BANK LANSBK SE C- C A3 A2 A --<br />

LEONIA CORPORATE BANK SHAMPO FI -- -- Aa2 Aaa -- --<br />

NORDEA BANK AB NBHSS SE B B Aa3 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

NORDEA BANK DANMARK A/S NBHSS DK B- B- Aa3 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

NORDEA BANK FINLAND PLC NBHSS FI B B Aa3 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

NORDEA BANK NORGE ASA NBHSS NO B- B- Aa3 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

NORDEA BANK SWEDEN AB NBHSS SE -- -- Aa3 Aa1 -- --<br />

NORGESKREDITT AS-PFD NORKRE NO -- -- A1 Aa1 -- --<br />

OKO BANK PLC-A OKOBK FI B+ C+ Aa2 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

SAMPO BANK PLC DANBNK FI B- B- Aa2 Aa1 AA- --<br />

SKANDINAVISKA ENSKILDA BAN-A SEB SE B B- Aa3 Aa2 A+ A+<br />

SPAREBANKEN MIDT-NORGE SPBKMI NO C C+ A3 Aa3 -- A-<br />

SPAREBANKEN NORD-NORGE SPBKND NO C C+ A3 Aa3 -- A-<br />

SPAREBANKEN OST SEDG NO C C A3 A1 -- --<br />

SPAREBANKEN ROGALAND SPAROG NO C+ C+ A2 Aa3 -- A<br />

SPAREBANKEN VEST SVEG NO C C A3 A1 -- A-<br />

STOREBRAND BANK ASA STOBRA NO C- C- Baa2 A2 BBB+ --<br />

SVENSKA HANDELSBANKEN-A SHS SVSKHB SE A- B -- Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

SWEDBANK AB - A SHARES SWEDA SE B B Aa3 Aa1 A+ A+<br />

SWEDBANK HYPOTEK AB SWEDA SE -- -- Aa3 Aa1 -- --<br />

SYDBANK A/S SYDBK DK C+ C+ A2 Aa3 -- --<br />

Source: Rating agencies; Bloomberg; Global Research (HVB)


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

BENELUX BANKS AFFECTED BY MOODY'S JDA REVISION (APRIL 10)<br />

Benelux Company<br />

Ticker<br />

Country Moody's<br />

old BFSR*<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

10<br />

Moody's<br />

new BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

old LTR<br />

Moody's<br />

new LTR<br />

(JDA)<br />

S&P LTR Fitch LTR<br />

ABN AMRO HOLDING NV AAB NL -- -- Aa3 Aa2 -- --<br />

ABN-AMRO BANK NV AAB NL B B- Aa3 Aa2 AA- AA-<br />

BANQUE & CAISSE EPARGNE ETAT BCEE LU B C+ Aa1 Aaa AA+ --<br />

DEXIA BANK BELGIUM DEXGRP BE B B- Aa2 Aa1 AA AA+<br />

DEXIA BANQUE INTL A LUXEMBOU DEXGRP LU B B- Aa2 Aa1 AA AA+<br />

DEXIA CREDIT LOCAL DEXGRP FR B+ B+ Aa2 Aa1 AA AA+<br />

FORTIS BANK NEDERLAND HLDG FORTIS NL B- B- Aa3 Aa2 AA- AA-<br />

FORTIS BANQUE - BANK - AUC FORTIS BE B B- Aa3 Aa2 AA- AA-<br />

FORTIS BANQUE LUXEMBOURG FORTIS LU B B Aa3 Aa2 AA- AA-<br />

FRIESLAND BANK FRIES NL C C A3 A2 -- A<br />

GARANTIBANK INTERNATIONAL NV GARAN NL C- C Baa2 A3 -- --<br />

ING BANK NV INTNED NL B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA AA<br />

ING BELGIUM SA/NV INTNED BE B B Aa2 Aa1 AA AA<br />

KBC BANK NV KRCP BE B B- Aa3 Aa2 AA- AA-<br />

KBC GROEP NV KRCP BE -- -- A1 Aa1 A+ AA-<br />

NIBC BANK NV NIBCAP NL C C -- A3 A- A<br />

POSTBANK GROEN NV INTNED NL -- -- Aa2 Aaa -- --<br />

RABOBANK RABOBK NL A B+ Aaa Aaa AAA AA+<br />

SNS BANK NV SNSBNK NL C+ C+ A2 A1 A A+<br />

SNS REAAL SNSGRP NL -- -- A3 A2 A- --<br />

Source: Rating agencies; Bloomberg; Global Research (HVB)<br />

ITALIAN, PORTUGUESE, AND SPANISH BANKS AFFECTED BY MOODY'S JDA REVISION (APRIL 13)<br />

Spain Company<br />

Ticker<br />

Country Moody's<br />

old BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

new BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

old LTR<br />

Moody's<br />

new LTR<br />

(JDA)<br />

S&P LTR Fitch LTR<br />

BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTA BBVASM ES B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

BANCO SANTANDER CENTRAL HISP SANTAN ES B B Aa3 Aa1 AA- AA<br />

CAJA DE MADRID CAJAMM ES B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

LA CAIXA CAIXAB ES B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

Italy<br />

BANCA MONTE DEI PASCHI SIENA MONTE IT B- C+ A1 Aa3 A A+<br />

CAPITALIA SPA CAPIM IT C C- A2 A1 A A<br />

INTESA SANPAOLO ISPIM IT B B- Aa3 Aa2 AA- AA-<br />

UNICREDITO ITALIANO SPA CRDIT IT B- B- A1 Aa2 A+ A+<br />

Portugal<br />

BANCO COMERCIAL PORTUGUES-R BCPN PT B- C+ A1 Aa3 A A+<br />

BANCO ESPIRITO SANTO-REG ESF PT B- C+ A1 Aa3 A- A+<br />

CAIXA GERAL DE DEPOSITOS-REG CXGD PT B C Aa3 Aa1 A+ AA-<br />

Source: Rating agencies; Bloomberg; Global Research (HVB)


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

AUSTRIAN, IRISH, SWISS, AND UK BANKS AFFECTED BY MOODY'S JDA REVISION (APRIL 20)<br />

Austria Company<br />

Ticker<br />

Country Moody's<br />

old BFSR<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

11<br />

Moody's<br />

new BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

old LTR<br />

Moody's<br />

new LTR<br />

(JDA)<br />

S&P LTR Fitch LTR<br />

BANK AUSTRIA CREDITANSTALT CRDIT AT B- C+ A2 Aa2 A+ A<br />

BAWAG P.S.K. BANK FUER ARBEI BAWAG AT E+ E+ A3 wn A3 wn -- --<br />

ERSTE BANK DER OESTER SPARK ERSTBK AT C+ C A1 Aa3 A A<br />

HYPO ALPE ADRIA BANK INTL AG HAA AT D- D- A2 A2 -- --<br />

HYPO TIROL BANK AG LANTIR AT C C Aa1 Aa1 -- --<br />

INVESTKREDIT BANK AG AUSTVB AT C- C A2 A1 -- --<br />

OESTERREICH VOLKSBANKEN-PART AUSTVB AT C C A2 A2 -- A<br />

PFANDBRIEFSTELLE DER OESTERR POLH AT -- -- Aaa Aaa -- --<br />

RAIFFEISEN ZENTRALBNK-PART A RZB AT C+ C A1 Aa2 A+ --<br />

VORARLBERGER LANDES HYPOBK-P VORHYP AT C C Aa1 Aa1 -- --<br />

Switzerland<br />

CREDIT SUISSE GROUP CS CH -- -- Aa3 Aa2 A+ AA-<br />

UBS AG-REG UBS CH B+ A- Aa2 Aaa AA+ AA+<br />

UK<br />

BARCLAYS BANK PLC BACR GB A- B+ Aa1 Aa1 AA AA+<br />

HBOS PLC HBOS GB -- -- Aa2 Aa2 AA- AA<br />

BANK OF SCOTLAND PLC HBOS GB B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA AA+<br />

HALIFAX PLC HBOS GB B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA AA+<br />

HSBC HOLDINGS PLC HSBC GB -- -- Aa2 Aa2 AA- AA<br />

HSBC BANK PLC HSBC GB B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA AA<br />

LLOYDS TSB GROUP PLC LLOYDS GB -- -- -- -- AA- AA+<br />

LLOYDS TSB BANK PLC LLOYDS GB A B+ Aaa Aaa AA AA+<br />

ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP RBS GB -- -- Aa2 Aa1 AA- AA+<br />

ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND BANK RBS GB A- B+ Aa2 Aaa AA AA+<br />

NATWEST PLC RBS GB A- B+ Aa1 Aaa AA AA+<br />

STANDARD CHARTERED PLC STANLN GB -- -- -- -- A A+<br />

STANDARD CHARTERED BANK STANLN GB C+ C+ A2 A2 A+ A+<br />

Ireland<br />

ALLIED IRISH BANKS PLC AIB IE B B- Aa3 Aa2 A+ AA-<br />

ANGLO IRISH BANK CORP PLC ANGIRI IE C+ C+ A2 A1 -- A+<br />

BANK OF IRELAND BKIR IE B B- Aa3 Aa2 A+ AA-<br />

EBS BUILDING SOCIETY EBSBLD IE C+ C+ A2 A1 -- A<br />

IRISH LIFE & PERMANENT ILP IE B- C+ A1 Aa3 A+ --<br />

IRISH NATIONWIDE BLDG SOCTY IRNWID IE C C- A3 A3 -- A<br />

Source: Rating agencies; Bloomberg; Global Research (HVB)<br />

GREEK BANKS AFFECTED BY MOODY'S JDA REVISION (APRIL 24)<br />

Greece Company<br />

Ticker<br />

Country Moody's<br />

old BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

new BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

old LTR<br />

Moody's<br />

new LTR<br />

(JDA)<br />

S&P LTR Fitch LTR<br />

ALPHA BANK A.E. ALPHA GR C C A3 A1 BBB+ A-<br />

EFG EUROBANK ERGASIAS EUROB GR C+ C+ A2 Aa3 pos. A- A<br />

NATIONAL BANK OF GREECE NBG GR C C+ A2 Aa3 BBB+ A-<br />

Source: Rating agencies; Bloomberg; Global Research (HVB)


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FRENCH AND GERMAN BANKS AFFECTED BY MOODY'S JDA REVISION (MAY 11)<br />

Germany Company<br />

Ticker<br />

Country Moody's<br />

old BFSR<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

12<br />

Moody's<br />

new BFSR<br />

Moody's<br />

old LTR<br />

Moody's<br />

new LTR<br />

(JDA)<br />

S&P LTR Fitch LTR<br />

BAYERISCHE HYPO-UND VEREINSB CRDIT DE D+ C- A2 A1 A A<br />

BAYERISCHE LANDESBANK BYLAN DE D+ C- Aa2 Aa2 A A+<br />

BREMER LANDESBANK KREDITANS NDB DE C C A1 Aa2 -- A<br />

COMMERZBANK AG CMZB DE C+ C+ A2 Aa3 A- A<br />

DEKABANK DEUTSCHE GIROZENTR DEKA DE C C Aa3 Aa2 A A-<br />

DEUTSCHE APOTHEKER- UND AERZ DAA DE C+ C+ A2 A1 A+ A+<br />

DEUTSCHE BANK AG-REGISTERED DB DE B- B Aa3 Aa1 AA- AA-<br />

DEUTSCHE POSTBANK AG DPW DE C+ C+ A1 Aa2 A A<br />

DRESDNER BANK AG ALZ DE C C A1 Aa2 A+ A<br />

DZ BANK AG DEUTSCHE ZENTRAL- DZBK DE C- C- A2 Aa3 A+ A+<br />

HSH NORDBANK AG HSHN DE C C A1 Aa2 A A<br />

IKB DEUT INDUSTRIEBANK AG IKB DE B- C+ Aa3 Aa3 -- A+<br />

LANDESBANK BADEN-WUERTTEMB LBBW DE B- C+ Aa1 Aa1 A+ A+<br />

LANDESBANK BERLIN AG LBBER DE D+ D+ A1 A1 dev. -- BBB+<br />

LANDESBANK HESSEN-THURINGEN HESLAN DE C C- Aa2 Aa2 A A+<br />

LANDESBANK SAAR BYLAN DE C- C- Aa2 Aa2 -- A+<br />

LANDESBANK SACHSEN GIROZENTR LBSACH DE C- C- A1 Aa2 BBB+ A+<br />

LRP LANDESBANK RHEINLAND-PFA LBBW DE C C Aa2 Aa1 NR A<br />

NORDDEUTSCHE LANDESBK GIROZ NDB DE C- C- Aa3 Aa2 A A<br />

WESTLB AG WESTLB DE D- D- A1 A1 A- A-<br />

WGZ-BANK AG WESTDEUTSCHE GE WGZ DE C C A2 Aa3 -- A+<br />

France<br />

BNP PARIBAS BNP FR B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA AA<br />

CREDIT AGRICOLE SA ACAFP FR B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA- AA<br />

SOCIETE GENERALE SOCGEN FR B+ B Aa2 Aa1 AA AA<br />

Source: Rating agencies; Bloomberg; Global Research (HVB)


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Neither S&P nor Fitch intend to<br />

change their methodologies<br />

S&P's comment from February<br />

27, 2007<br />

Fitch published support rating<br />

floors <strong>for</strong> all <strong>banks</strong> it covers<br />

Support Rating Floor is the<br />

lowest IDR a bank could get<br />

based on the current level on<br />

assumed support<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

REACTIONS BY S&P AND FITCH<br />

One <strong>of</strong> the most frequently asked questions over recent weeks was related to<br />

the other agencies' reaction. Both S&P and Fitch, as we expected, have<br />

stated that the importance <strong>of</strong> support they factor in their ratings is not<br />

subject to change. Moreover, Fitch released a detailed list <strong>of</strong> support rating<br />

floors; at the same time, Fitch made clear that there was no change in criteria.<br />

The first paragraph <strong>of</strong> S&P's seven page comment reads like this: "Potential<br />

external support from the government or the private sector has long been a<br />

basic and positive element <strong>of</strong> Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services’ credit ratings<br />

on <strong>banks</strong>. Nonetheless, we do not believe it possible to rigorously quantify the<br />

probability that a government will support a private-sector bank and ensure<br />

timely repayment <strong>of</strong> all its unsecured debt obligations. Our credit ratings reflect<br />

fundamental analysis <strong>of</strong> institution-specific and environmental factors, including<br />

external support."<br />

Fitch, the only agency that provides Support Ratings (on a 1-5 scale), aims to<br />

increase transparency in its move to publish its support rating floors<br />

(without changing its criteria). Fitch said, "The Support Rating Floor is<br />

expressed on the traditional 'AAA' long-term scale. It clearly indicates the level<br />

below which Fitch would not lower its Issuer Default rating ("IDR") in absence <strong>of</strong><br />

any changes to the assumptions underpinning the bank's Support rating. In<br />

addition to the 'AAA' scale, there will be one additional point on the scale - "No<br />

Floor" - which indicates that in Fitch's opinion, there is no reasonable likelihood<br />

<strong>of</strong> potential support being <strong>for</strong>thcoming. In practice, this approximates to a<br />

probability <strong>of</strong> support <strong>of</strong> less than 40%."<br />

The following pages are filled with Fitch's support rating floor list. IDR is the<br />

Issuer Default Rating (long-term rating), Support Rating ranges from 1 (high) to<br />

5 (low), and Support Rating Floor is the lowest IDR a bank could be assigned<br />

based on the current level on assumed support.<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

13


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (AS OF MARCH 16, 2007)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

Andorra Andorra Banc Agricol Reig A 3 BB+<br />

Andorra Banca Privada d'Andorra BBB 3 BB<br />

Andorra Credit Andorra A 3 BB+<br />

Australia Australia & New Zealand Banking Group AA- 2 BBB+<br />

Australia Bank <strong>of</strong> Queensland BBB 4 B+<br />

Australia Bendigo Bank Limited BBB+ 4 B+<br />

Australia Commonwealth Bank Of Australia AA 2 BBB+<br />

Australia Macquarie Bank Ltd. A+ 4 B+<br />

Australia National Australia Bank AA 2 BBB+<br />

Australia St.George Bank Limited A+ 3 BB+<br />

Australia Suncorp-Metway Limited A 3 BB+<br />

Australia Westpac Banking Corporation AA- 2 BBB+<br />

Austria Bank Austria Creditanstalt AG A 1 A-<br />

Austria Erste Bank der oesterreichischen Sparkassen A 1 A-<br />

Austria Volksbanken Verbund A 2 BBB+<br />

Belgium Dexia AA+ 1 A-<br />

Belgium Dexia Bank Belgium AA+ 1 A-<br />

Belgium Euroclear Bank AA+ 1 A-<br />

Belgium Fortis Bank AA- 1 A-<br />

Belgium ING Belgium AA 1 A-<br />

Belgium KBC Bank AA- 2 BBB+<br />

Bermuda Bank <strong>of</strong> N.T. Butterfield & Son Limited A 3 BB-<br />

Canada Bank <strong>of</strong> Montreal AA- 1 A-<br />

Canada Bank <strong>of</strong> Nova Scotia AA- 1 A-<br />

Canada Canadian Imperial Bank <strong>of</strong> Commerce AA- 1 A-<br />

Canada Home Capital Group, Inc. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

Canada Home Trust Company BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

Canada National Bank <strong>of</strong> Canada A+ 2 BBB-<br />

Canada Royal Bank <strong>of</strong> Canada AA 1 A-<br />

Canada Toronto-Dominion Bank AA- 1 A-<br />

Cyprus Bank <strong>of</strong> Cyprus Public Company Ltd A- 2 BBB<br />

Cyprus Hellenic Bank Ltd. BBB 2 BBB<br />

Cyprus Marfin Popular Bank BBB+ 2 BBB<br />

Denmark Danske Bank AA- 1 A-<br />

Denmark Nordea Bank Danmark AA- 1 A-<br />

Finland Nordea Bank Finland AA- 1 A-<br />

Finland OKO Bank plc AA- 1 A-<br />

Finland OP Bank Group AA- 1 A-<br />

France Agence Francaise de Developpement (AFD) AAA 1 AAA<br />

France Banque Federale des Banques Populaires A+ 2 BBB+<br />

France Banque Federale Mutualiste BBB 5 No Floor<br />

France Banque Federative du Credit Mutuel (BFCM) AA- 2 BBB+<br />

France BNP Paribas AA 1 A-<br />

France Caisse Centrale de Credit Immobilier de France (3CIF) (Groupe CIFD) A+ 2 BBB+<br />

France Caisse des Depots et Consignations (CDC) AAA 1 AAA<br />

France Caisse Nationale des Caisses d'Epargne et de Prevoyance ( CNCE ) AA 1 A-<br />

France Credit Agricole AA 1 A-<br />

France Credit Agricole S.A. AA 1 A-<br />

France Credit Immobilier de France Developpement (CIFD) A+ 2 BBB+<br />

France Dexia Credit Local AA+ 1 A-<br />

France Groupe Banque Populaire A+ 2 BBB+<br />

France Groupe Caisse d'Epargne AA 1 A-<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

14


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

France Rothschild & Cie Banque A 5 No Floor<br />

France Societe Generale (SG) AA 1 A-<br />

Germany Aareal Bank AG A- 3 BB<br />

Germany Allgemeine Hypothekenbank Rheinboden BBB- 2 BBB-<br />

Germany Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG A 1 A-<br />

Germany Bayerische Landesbank A+ 1 A+<br />

Germany Bremer Landesbank A 1 A<br />

Germany Commerzbank AG A 1 A-<br />

Germany Debeka Bausparkasse AG A- 3 BB+<br />

Germany DekaBank - Deutsche Gironzentrale A- 1 A-<br />

Germany Deutsche Bank AG AA- 1 A-<br />

Germany Deutsche Postbank A 1 A-<br />

Germany Dresdner Bank AG A 1 A-<br />

Germany Duesseldorfer Hypothekenbank AG BBB+ 3 BB+<br />

Germany DZ BANK AG Deutsche Zentral-Genossenschaftsbank A+ 1 A<br />

Germany Genossenschaftlicher FinanzVerbund A+ 1 A<br />

Germany HSH Nordbank AG A 1 A<br />

Germany Hypo Real Estate Bank AG A- 2 BBB<br />

Germany KFW AAA 1 AAA<br />

Germany Landesbank <strong>Bad</strong>en-Wuerttemberg A+ 1 A+<br />

Germany Landesbank Berlin AG A 1 A<br />

Germany Landesbank Saar A+ 1 A+<br />

Germany Landesbank Sachsen Girozentrale A+ 1 A+<br />

Germany Landeskreditbank <strong>Bad</strong>en-Wuerttemberg - Foerderbank AAA 1 AAA<br />

Germany Landwirtschaftliche Rentenbank AAA 1 AAA<br />

Germany LRP Landesbank Rheinland-Pfalz A 1 A<br />

Germany Norddeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale A 1 A<br />

Germany NRW.BANK AAA 1 AAA<br />

Germany S - Finanzgruppe Hessen-Thueringen A+ 1 A+<br />

Germany Sachsen-Finanzgruppe A+ 1 A+<br />

Germany Sal. Oppenheim jr. & Cie. A 4 B+<br />

Germany WestLB AG A- 1 A-<br />

Germany Wuestenrot Bausparkasse AG A- 3 BB+<br />

Greece Agricultural Bank <strong>of</strong> Greece (ATEbank) BBB+ 2 BBB+<br />

Greece Alpha Bank A- 2 BBB<br />

Greece Aspis Bank BB+ 5 No Floor<br />

Greece Efg Eurobank Ergasias A 2 BBB<br />

Greece National Bank <strong>of</strong> Greece A- 2 BBB+<br />

Greece Piraeus Bank BBB+ 3 BB+<br />

Hong Kong Bank <strong>of</strong> China (Hong Kong) A 2 BBB+<br />

Hong Kong Bank <strong>of</strong> East Asia A- 3 BB+<br />

Hong Kong Chong Hing Bank Limited BBB+ 3 BB<br />

Hong Kong Citic Ka Wah Bank BBB+ 3 BB<br />

Hong Kong Dah Sing Bank A- 3 BB<br />

Hong Kong Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation AA 1 A-<br />

Hong Kong Wing Hang Bank Limited A- 3 BB<br />

Iceland Glitnir Banki (Formerly known as Islandsbanki) A 2 BBB<br />

Iceland Kaupthing Bank hf. A 2 BBB<br />

Iceland Landsbanki Islands A 2 BBB<br />

Iceland Straumur-Burdaras Investment Bank hf. BBB- 3 BB-<br />

Ireland Allied Irish Banks, p.l.c. AA- 1 A-<br />

Ireland Anglo Irish Bank Corporation PLC A+ 3 BB+<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

15


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

Ireland Bank <strong>of</strong> Ireland AA- 1 A-<br />

Ireland DEPFA BANK plc AA- 3 BB+<br />

Ireland EBS Building Society A 3 BB+<br />

Ireland Irish Nationwide Building Society A 3 BB<br />

Italy Banca Carige A 3 BB<br />

Italy Banca di Credito Popolare BBB 3 BB-<br />

Italy Banca IFIS S.p.A. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

Italy Banca Lombarda e Piemontese A 3 BB+<br />

Italy Banca Monte del Paschi di Siena A+ 2 BBB+<br />

Italy Banca Popolare Vicenza A- 3 BB<br />

Italy Banca Popolare dell Emilia Romagna A- 3 BB+<br />

Italy Banca Popolare di Intra BB 3 BB<br />

Italy Banca Popolare di Milano A- 3 BB+<br />

Italy Banca Popolare di Sondrio A 3 BB<br />

Italy Banca Popolare di Verona e Novara A+ 3 BB+<br />

Italy Banca Popolare Italiana BBB 3 BB+<br />

Italy Banca Popolare Unite A 3 BB+<br />

Italy Banca UBAE BB+ 5 No Floor<br />

Italy Banco Desio e Della Brianza A- 4 B+<br />

Italy Capitalia S.p.A. A 2 BBB+<br />

Italy Cassa Depositi e Prestiti AA- 1 AA-<br />

Italy Cassa di Risoarmio di Firenze A- 3 BB<br />

Italy Cassa di Risparmio della Provincia di Chieti Spa BBB- 3 BB-<br />

Italy Credem - Credito Emiliano S.p.A. A 3 BB<br />

Italy Intesa Sanpaolo AA- 1 A-<br />

Italy Meliorbanca BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

Italy UniCredito Italiano A+ 1 A-<br />

Italy Veneto Banca A- 3 BB<br />

Japan 77 Bank, Ltd. A- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Aichi Bank Ltd. BBB+ 4 B<br />

Japan Akita Bank Ltd. BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Aozora Bank A- 3 BB+<br />

Japan Ashikaga Bank BBB- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Awa Bank Ltd. A- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Bank <strong>of</strong> Fukuoka BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Bank <strong>of</strong> Ikeda Ltd. BBB- 4 B<br />

Japan Bank <strong>of</strong> Iwate Ltd. A 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Bank <strong>of</strong> Kyoto Ltd. A- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Bank <strong>of</strong> Nagoya Ltd. BBB+ 4 B<br />

Japan Bank <strong>of</strong> Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ A 1 A-<br />

Japan Bank <strong>of</strong> Yokohama A 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Chiba Bank A- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Chugoku Bank Ltd. A 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Chuo Mitsui Trust & Banking Company BBB+ 2 BBB+<br />

Japan Daishi Bank Ltd. BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Daiwa Securities Group Inc. BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

Japan Eighteenth Bank, Ltd. BBB 3 BB-<br />

Japan Fukui Bank Ltd. BBB- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Gunma Bank BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Hachijuni Bank A- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Higashi-Nippon Bank Ltd. BBB- 4 B<br />

Japan Higo Bank Ltd. A+ 2 BBB-<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

16


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

Japan Hiroshima Bank BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Hokkaido Bank Ltd. BBB- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Hokkoku Bank Ltd. BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Hokuetsu Bank Ltd. BBB- 3 BB-<br />

Japan Hokuriku Bank BBB- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Hyakugo Bank Ltd. (The) A- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Hyakujushi Bank Ltd. BBB- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Iyo Bank Ltd. A 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Joyo Bank A- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Juroku Bank, Ltd. BBB 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Kagoshima Bank Ltd. A+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Keiyo Bank Ltd. BBB+ 3 BB-<br />

Japan Kita-Nippon Bank Ltd. BBB- 3 BB-<br />

Japan Kiyo Bank Ltd. BBB- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Mitsubishi UFJ Trust and Banking Corporation A 1 A-<br />

Japan Miyazaki Bank Ltd. BBB 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Mizuho Bank A 1 A-<br />

Japan Mizuho Corporate Bank A 1 A-<br />

Japan Mizuho Financial Group A 1 A-<br />

Japan Mizuho Trust & Banking A 1 A-<br />

Japan Momiji Bank Ltd BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Musashino Bank Ltd. BBB 4 B<br />

Japan Nanto Bank Ltd. BBB 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Nikko Cordial Corp BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

Japan Nikko Cordial Securities Inc BBB+ 4 B<br />

Japan Nishi-Nippon City Bank Ltd (The) BBB- 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Nomura Holdings Inc BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

Japan Nomura Securities Co., Ltd A- 4 B<br />

Japan North Pacific Bank Ltd. BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Ogaki Kyoritsu Bank Ltd. BBB- 3 BB-<br />

Japan Oita Bank Ltd. BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan San-In Godo Bank Ltd. A 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Sapporo Bank Ltd. BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Shiga Bank Ltd. BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Shinsei Bank, Ltd BBB+ 3 BB+<br />

Japan Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation A 1 A-<br />

Japan Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group A 1 A-<br />

Japan Sumitomo Trust & Banking Company A- 2 BBB+<br />

Japan Suruga Bank Ltd. BBB+ 4 B<br />

Japan Tochigi Bank Ltd. (The) BBB 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Toho Bank Ltd. BBB 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Yamagata Bank Ltd. A 3 BB-<br />

Japan Yamaguchi Bank Ltd. BBB+ 2 BBB-<br />

Japan Yamanashi Chuo Bank Ltd. (The) A- 2 BBB-<br />

Luxembourg Clearstream Banking, Luxembourg AA 1 A-<br />

Luxembourg Dexia Banque Internationale a Luxembourg AA+ 1 A-<br />

Luxembourg Espirito Santo Financial Group A- 5 No Floor<br />

Luxembourg Fortis Banque Luxembourg SA AA- 1 A-<br />

Luxembourg Investcorp SA BBB 5 No Floor<br />

Malta Bank <strong>of</strong> Valletta A- 2 BBB+<br />

Malta Fimbank BB 5 No Floor<br />

Netherlands ABN AMRO Bank AA- 1 A-<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

17


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

Netherlands Bank Nederlandse Gemeenten AAA 1 AA<br />

Netherlands F. Van Lanschot Bankiers N.V. A 4 B+<br />

Netherlands Fortis Bank Nederland AA- 1 A-<br />

Netherlands Fortis Bank Nederland (Holding) AA- 1 A-<br />

Netherlands Friesland Bank A+ 3 BB+<br />

Netherlands ING Bank NV AA 1 A-<br />

Netherlands LeasePlan Corporation NV A 4 B+<br />

Netherlands NIBC Bank N.V. A 5 No Floor<br />

Netherlands Rabobank Group AA+ 1 A-<br />

Netherlands SNS Bank N.V. A+ 3 BB+<br />

Norway DnB NOR Bank A+ 1 A-<br />

Norway Eksportfinans AAA 1 AAA<br />

Norway Nordea Bank Norge AA- 1 A-<br />

Norway Sparebanken Midt-Norge A- 3 BB+<br />

Norway Sparebanken Nord-Norge A- 3 BB+<br />

Norway Sparebanken Rogaland A 3 BB+<br />

Norway Sparebanken Vest A- 3 BB+<br />

Norway Teller AS BB+ 3 BB<br />

Portugal Banco BPI A+ 2 BBB-<br />

Portugal Banco Comercial Portugues A+ 2 BBB<br />

Portugal Banco Espirito Santo A+ 2 BBB-<br />

Portugal Banco Privado Portugues BBB 5 No Floor<br />

Portugal Banif - Banco Internacional do Funchal BBB+ 4 B+<br />

Portugal BPN SGPS, SA* BBB 5 No Floor<br />

Portugal BPN-Banco Portugues de Negocios, S.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

Portugal Caixa Economica Montepio Geral A- 4 B+<br />

Portugal Caixa Geral de Depositos AA- 1 AA-<br />

San Marino Cassa di Risparmio della Repubblica di San Marino A- 3 BB+<br />

Singapore DBS Bank AA- 2 BBB+<br />

Singapore Oversea-Chinese Banking Corp AA- 2 BBB+<br />

Singapore United Overseas Bank AA- 2 BBB+<br />

Spain Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria (BBVA) AA- 1 A-<br />

Spain Banco Cooperativo Espanol A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Banco de Sabadell A+ 3 BB+<br />

Spain Banco Guipuzcoano A- 3 BB<br />

Spain Banco Popular Espanol AA 2 BBB<br />

Spain Banco Santander Central Hispano AA 1 A-<br />

Spain Bankinter A+ 3 BB+<br />

Spain Bilbao Bizkaia Kutxa A+ 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caixa de A<strong>for</strong>ros de Vigo, Ourense e Pontevedra (Caixanova) A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caixa d'Estalvis de Catalunya A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caixa d'Estalvis de Girona A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caixa d'Estalvis de Sabadell A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caixa d'Estalvis de Tarragona A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caixa d'Estalvis de Terrassa A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caixa d'Estalvis del Penedes A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caixa d'Estalvis Laietana A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros de Asturias (Caja Asturias) A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros de Castilla La Mancha A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros de Galicia (Caixa Galicia) A+ 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros de la Inmaculada de Aragon A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros de Murcia A+ 3 BB+<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

18


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros de Valencia, Castellon y Alicante (Bancaja) A+ 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros de Vitoria y Alava (Caja Vital) A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros del Mediterraneo A+ 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros y Monte de Piedad de Cordoba (CajaSur) A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros y Monte de Piedad de Extremadura A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros y Monte de Piedad de Las Baleares (Sa Nostra) A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros y Monte de Piedad de Madrid AA- 2 BBB<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros y Monte de Piedad de Navarra A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros y Monte de Piedad del Circulo Catolico de Obreros de<br />

Burgos<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

19<br />

A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja de Ahorros y Pensiones de Barcelona (la Caixa) AA- 2 BBB+<br />

Spain Caja Espana de Inversiones, Caja de Ahorros y Monte de Piedad A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja General de Ahorros de Canarias A 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja General de Ahorros de Granada A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Caja Laboral Popular A+ 3 BB<br />

Spain Caja Rural de Navarra A- 3 BB<br />

Spain Caja Rural del Mediterraneo, Ruralcaja Sociedad Cooperativa de Credito A- 3 BB<br />

Spain Caja Rural del Sur, Sociedad Cooperativa de Credito A- 3 BB<br />

Spain Caja Rural Intermediterranea, Sociedad Cooperativa de Credito<br />

(Cajamar)<br />

A 3 BB<br />

Spain Caja San Fernando de Sevilla y Jerez A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Confederacion Espanola de Cajas de Ahorros AA- 2 BBB<br />

Spain Instituto de Credito Oficial AAA 1 AAA<br />

Spain Monte de Piedad y Caja de Ahorros de Huelva y Sevilla (El Monte) A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Monte de Piedad y Caja General de Ahorros de <strong>Bad</strong>ajoz A- 3 BB+<br />

Spain Montes de Piedad y Caja de Ahorros de Ronda, Cadiz, Almeria, Malaga y<br />

Anteq. (Unicaja)<br />

A+ 3 BB+<br />

Sweden Landshypotek AB A+ 3 BB+<br />

Sweden Nordea Bank AB AA- 1 A-<br />

Sweden Skandinaviska Enskilda Banken A+ 1 A-<br />

Sweden Svenska Handelsbanken AA- 1 A-<br />

Sweden Swedbank AB A+ 1 A-<br />

Switzerland Credit Suisse AA- 1 A-<br />

Switzerland Credit Suisse Group AA- 5 No Floor<br />

Switzerland EFG International A 5 No Floor<br />

Switzerland Pictet & Cie AA- 5 No Floor<br />

Switzerland UBS AG AA+ 1 A-<br />

UK Close Brothers Limited A 5 No Floor<br />

UK Co-Operative Bank (The) A 3 BB+<br />

UK Crown Agents Bank Limited A 2 BBB-<br />

UK Investec Bank (UK) Ltd BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

UK N M Rothschild & Sons A 5 No Floor<br />

UK Schroders A+ 5 No Floor<br />

UK Standard Chartered Bank A+ 3 BB+<br />

UK Barclays Bank PLC AA+ 1 A-<br />

UK HSBC Bank plc AA 1 A-<br />

UK HSBC Holdings Plc AA 5 No Floor<br />

UK Lloyds TSB Bank plc AA+ 1 A-<br />

UK Lloyds TSB Group plc AA+ 5 No Floor<br />

UK National Westminster Bank AA+ 1 A-<br />

UK Royal Bank <strong>of</strong> Scotland Group plc (The) AA+ 5 No Floor<br />

UK Royal Bank <strong>of</strong> Scotland plc (The) AA+ 1 A-<br />

(Continued on next page)


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

UK Abbey National plc AA- 2 BBB+<br />

UK Alliance & Leicester AA- 3 BB+<br />

UK Bank <strong>of</strong> Scotland Plc AA+ 1 A-<br />

UK Brad<strong>for</strong>d & Bingley A 3 BB+<br />

UK Britannia Building Society A+ 3 BB+<br />

UK Chelsea Building Society (The) A 3 BB<br />

UK Coventry Building Society A 3 BB<br />

UK Halifax PLC AA+ 1 A-<br />

UK HBOS plc AA 5 No Floor<br />

UK Nationwide Building Society AA- 2 BBB+<br />

UK Newcastle Building Society A 3 BB<br />

UK Northern Rock PLC A+ 3 BB+<br />

UK Portman Building Society A 3 BB+<br />

UK Principality Building Society A 3 BB<br />

UK Skipton Building Society A 3 BB<br />

UK West Bromwich Building Society A 3 BB<br />

UK Yorkshire Building Society A+ 3 BB+<br />

USA Amcore Financial Inc. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Amcore Bank, N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA American Express Company A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA AmeriServ Financial, Inc BB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA AmeriServ Financial Bank BB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Associated Banc-Corp A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Associated Bank, National Association A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Associated Trust Company, National Association A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Astoria Financial Corporation BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Astoria Federal Savings & Loan BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> America Corporation AA 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> America Cali<strong>for</strong>nia, National Association AA 1 A-<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> America Georgia, N.A. AA 1 A-<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> America Oregon, National Association AA 1 A-<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> America Rhode Island, National Association AA 1 A-<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> America, N.A. AA 1 A-<br />

USA FIA Card Services, N.A. AA 1 A-<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Guam BBB 4 B<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Hawaii Corp A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Hawaii A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> New York Company, Inc. (The) AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> New York (The) AA- 2 BBB+<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> New York (Delaware) AA- 2 BBB+<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> New York Trust Company N.A. AA- 2 BBB+<br />

USA BankAtlantic Bancorp, Inc. BB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA BankAtlantic FSB BB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA BankUnited Financial Corporation BB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA BankUnited FSB BB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA BB&T Corporation AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Branch Banking and Trust Company AA- 4 B<br />

USA Bear Stearns Companies Inc. A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA BOK Financial Corp A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Oklahoma, N.A. A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bremer Financial Corporation BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bremer Bank, Alexandria (MN), N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

20


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

USA Bremer Bank, Brainerd (MN), N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bremer Bank, Fargo (ND), N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bremer Bank, Grand Forks (MN), N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bremer Bank, International Falls (MN), N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bremer Bank, Menomonie (WI), N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bremer Bank, South St. Paul (MN), N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bremer Bank, St. Cloud (MN), N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Brown Bros. Harriman & Co. A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Capital One Financial Corp. BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Capital One Bank BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Capital One, FSB BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Capital One National Association BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA North Fork Bancorporation, Inc. BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA North Fork Bank BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Cathay General Bancorp BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Cathay Bank BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Central Corporate Credit Union AA- 4 B<br />

USA Central Credit Union Fund A 4 B<br />

USA Central Pacific Financial Corp. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Central Pacific Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Charles Schwab Corporation A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Chevy Chase Bank, F.S.B. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Chittenden Corporation A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Western Massachusetts (The) A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Chittenden Trust Company A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Flagship Bank and Trust Company A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Maine Bank & Trust Company A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Ocean National Bank A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Citigroup Inc. AA+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Citibank (Banamex USA) AA+ 1 A-<br />

USA Citibank (South Dakota) AA+ 1 A-<br />

USA Citibank, N.A. AA+ 1 A-<br />

USA Citizens Republic Bancorp BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA CB Wealth Management, National Association BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Citizens Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA F&M Bank-Iowa BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA City National Corporation A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA City National Bank A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Colonial BancGroup, Inc. (The) BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Colonial Bank, N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Columbia Financial, Inc. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Columbia Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Comerica Incorporated A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Comerica Bank A+ 4 B<br />

USA Commerce Bancorp, Inc. A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Commerce Bank, N.A. A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Commerce Bank/North A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Commercebank Holding Corporation BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Commercebank, NA BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Community Bank System, Inc. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Community Bank, N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Compass Bancshares, Inc. A- 5 No Floor<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

21


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

USA Compass Bank A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Constitution State Corporate Credit Union A+ 4 B<br />

USA Countrywide Financial Corporation A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Countrywide Bank, N.A. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Cullen/Frost Bankers, Inc. A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Frost National Bank A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA CVB Financial Corp. BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Citizens Business Bank BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Dime Community Bancshares, Inc. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Dime Savings Bank <strong>of</strong> Williamsburgh BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Doral Financial Corporation B+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Doral Bank BB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Eastern Bank Corporation BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Eastern Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Eastern Corporate Federal Credit Union. AA- 4 B<br />

USA Emigrant Bancorp, Inc. BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Emigrant Bank BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Emigrant Mercantile Bank BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Emigrant Savings Bank - Bronx/Westchester BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Emigrant Savings Bank - Brooklyn/Queens BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Emigrant Savings Bank - Long Island BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Emigrant Savings Bank - Manhattan BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Fannie Mae AAA 1 AAA<br />

USA Fifth Third Bancorp AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Fifth Third Bank (Michigan) AA- 4 B<br />

USA Fifth Third Bank (Ohio) AA- 4 B<br />

USA First BanCorp BB 5 No Floor<br />

USA FirstBank Puerto Rico BB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Commonwealth Financial Corporation BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Commonwealth Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Corporate Credit Union AA- 4 B<br />

USA First Horizon National Corporation A 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Tennessee Bank, N.A. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Interstate BancSystem, Inc. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Interstate Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Midwest Bancorp, Inc. BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Midwest Bank, N.A. BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA First National <strong>of</strong> Nebraska, Inc. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First National Bank (Fort Collins) BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First National Bank (North Platte) BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First National Bank <strong>of</strong> Omaha BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Niagara Financial Group, Inc. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Niagara Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Niagara Commercial Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Republic Bank BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA FirstMerit Corporation A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA FirstMerit Bank, N.A A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Freddie Mac AAA 1 AAA<br />

USA Fremont General Corporation CCC- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Fremont Investment & Loan CCC 5 No Floor<br />

USA Fulton Financial Corporation A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Columbia Bank (The) A 5 No Floor<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

22


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

USA Fulton Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Lafayette Ambassador Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Lebanon Valley Farmers Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Resource Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA The Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Greater Bay Bancorp, Inc. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Greater Bay Bank, NA BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Huntington Bancshares Incorporated A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Huntington National Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Independent Bank Corp. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Rockland Trust Co. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA IndyMac Bancorp Inc. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA IndyMac Bank, F.S.B. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Investors Financial Services Corp. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Investors Bank & Trust Co. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA JPMorgan Chase & Co. AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Chase Bank USA, N.A. AA- 1 A-<br />

USA JPMorgan Chase Bank, NA AA- 1 A-<br />

USA KeyCorp A 5 No Floor<br />

USA KeyBank N.A. A 4 B<br />

USA Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Marshall & Ilsley Corporation A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA M&I Bank FSB A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA M&I Marshall & Ilsley Bank A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Southwest Bank <strong>of</strong> St. Louis A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Mellon Financial Corporation AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Mellon 1st Business Bank, N.A. AA- 3 BB+<br />

USA Mellon Bank, N.A. AA- 3 BB+<br />

USA Mellon Funding Corp AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Mellon Trust <strong>of</strong> New England, N.A. AA- 3 BB+<br />

USA Mellon United National Bank AA- 3 BB+<br />

USA Members United Corporate Federal Credit Union AA- 4 B<br />

USA Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Mid-Atlantic Corporate Federal Credit Union AA- 4 B<br />

USA Morgan Stanley AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA National City Corporation AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA National City Bank (Cleveland) AA- 4 B<br />

USA National Consumer Cooperative Bank A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA New York Community Bancorp BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA New York Commercial Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA New York Community Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Northern Trust Corporation AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Northern Trust Company, The AA- 3 BB+<br />

USA Old National Bancorp BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Old National Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Partners Trust Financial Group, Inc BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Partners Trust Bank BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA People's Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA PNC Financial Services Group Inc. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Annapolis Banking & Trust Co. A 4 B<br />

USA Citizens National Bank A 4 B<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

23


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

USA Farmers & Mechanics Bank A 4 B<br />

USA Marshall National Bank & Trust Company A 4 B<br />

USA Mercantile County Bank A 4 B<br />

USA Mercantile Eastern Shore Bank A 4 B<br />

USA Mercantile Peninsula Bank A 4 B<br />

USA Mercantile Southern Maryland Bank A 4 B<br />

USA Mercantile-Safe Deposit & Trust Company A 4 B<br />

USA National Bank <strong>of</strong> Fredericksburg A 4 B<br />

USA PNC Bank, Delaware A 4 B<br />

USA PNC Bank, N. A. A 4 B<br />

USA PNC Funding Corp A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Westminster Union Bank A 4 B<br />

USA Popular, Inc. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Popular North America, Inc. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Banco Popular de Puerto Rico A 4 B<br />

USA Banco Popular North America A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Provident Bankshares Corporation BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Provident Bank <strong>of</strong> Maryland BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA R&G Financial Corporation BB 5 No Floor<br />

USA R-G Crown Bank BB 5 No Floor<br />

USA R-G Premier Bank BB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Regions Financial Corporation A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Regions Bank A+ 4 B<br />

USA Sky Financial Group, Inc. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Sky Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Sky Trust, National Association BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Southeast Corporate Federal Credit Union AA- 4 B<br />

USA Southwest Corporate Federal Credit Union AA- 4 B<br />

USA State Street Corporation AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA State Street Bank and Trust Company AA- 2 BBB+<br />

USA Sterling Bancshares, Inc. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Sterling Bank (TX) BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Sterling Financial Corporation BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Sterling Savings Bank BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA SunTrust Banks, Inc. A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA SunTrust Bank A+ 3 BB-<br />

USA Synovus Financial Corp. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Athens First Bank & Trust Co. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Coweta A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Nashville A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> North Georgia A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Pensacola A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Bank <strong>of</strong> Tuscaloosa A 5 No Floor<br />

USA CB&T Bank <strong>of</strong> Middle Georgia A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Citizens Bank & Trust <strong>of</strong> West Georgia A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Citizens First Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Coastal Bank <strong>of</strong> Georgia A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Cohutta Banking Company A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Columbus Bank & Trust A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Commercial Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Community Bank & Trust <strong>of</strong> Southeast Alabama A 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Commercial Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

24


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

USA First Commercial Bank <strong>of</strong> Huntsville A 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Community Bank <strong>of</strong> Tifton A 5 No Floor<br />

USA First Nation Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA First National Bank <strong>of</strong> Jasper A 5 No Floor<br />

USA First State Bank and Trust Company <strong>of</strong> Valdosta A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Georgia Bank & Trust A 5 No Floor<br />

USA National Bank <strong>of</strong> South Carolina A 5 No Floor<br />

USA National Bank <strong>of</strong> Walton County A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Peachtree National Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Sea Island Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Security Bank & Trust Co. <strong>of</strong> Albany A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Sterling Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Sumter Bank & Trust Company A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Synovus Bank <strong>of</strong> Tampa A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Tallahassee State Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Trust One Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Vanguard Bank & Trust Company A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Taylor Capital Group, Inc. BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Cole Taylor Bank BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA TCF Financial Corporation A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA TCF National Bank (MN) A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA The South Financial Group BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Carolina First Bank BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Mercantile Bank BBB- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Trustmark Corporation A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Trustmark National Bank A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA U.S. Bancorp AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA U.S. Bank N.A. AA- 3 BB-<br />

USA U.S. Bank N.A. ND AA- 3 BB-<br />

USA U.S. Central Federal Credit Union AAA 1 AA<br />

USA UCBH Holdings Inc BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA United Commercial Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA UMB Financial Corporation A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA UMB Bank, National Association A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA UnionBanCal Corporation A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Union Bank <strong>of</strong> Cali<strong>for</strong>nia, NA A+ 4 B<br />

USA W.T.B. Financial Corporation BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Washington Trust Bank BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Wachovia Corporation AA- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Wachovia Bank <strong>of</strong> Delaware, NA AA- 2 BBB-<br />

USA Wachovia Bank, NA AA- 2 BBB-<br />

USA World Savings Bank, FSB AA- 2 BBB-<br />

USA World Savings Bank, FSB (Texas) AA- 2 BBB-<br />

USA Washington Federal Inc. A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Washington Federal Savings A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Washington Mutual Inc. A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Washington Mutual Bank A 3 BB-<br />

USA Webster Financial Corporation BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Webster Bank, N.A. BBB 5 No Floor<br />

USA Wells Fargo & Co. AA 5 No Floor<br />

USA Wells Fargo Bank Northwest, NA AA 2 BBB-<br />

USA Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. AA 2 BBB-<br />

(Continued on next page)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

25


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

FITCH'S SUPPORT RATING FLOORS (CONTINUED)<br />

Country Issuer Name IDR Support Rating Support Rating Floor<br />

USA Westamerica Bancorporation A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Westamerica Bank A 5 No Floor<br />

USA Whitney Holding Corp. BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Whitney National Bank BBB+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Wilmington Trust Corporation A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Wilmington Trust Company A+ 5 No Floor<br />

USA Zions Bancorporation A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Amegy Bank NA A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Cali<strong>for</strong>nia Bank & Trust A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA National Bank <strong>of</strong> Arizona A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Nevada State Bank A- 5 No Floor<br />

USA Zions First National Bank A- 5 No Floor<br />

Source: Fitch; Global Research (HVB)<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch See last pages <strong>for</strong> disclaimer.<br />

26


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

DISCLAIMER<br />

This analysis was prepared by Mr. Alexander Plenk, CFA (Analyst, HVB), and was published the first time on May 29, 2007.<br />

Responsibility <strong>for</strong> its preparation lies with:<br />

a) Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, Am Tucherpark 16, 80538 Munich, Germany,<br />

Responsibility <strong>for</strong> its distribution pursuant to §34b WpHG: Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, Am Tucherpark 16, 80538 Munich, Germany.<br />

Regulatory authority: "BaFin" - Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht, Lurgiallee 12, 60439 Frankfurt, Germany.<br />

b) Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch (HVB Milan), Via Tommaso Grossi, 10, 20121 Milano, Italy.<br />

Regulatory authority: “Banca d’Italia”, via Nazionale, 91 – 00184 Roma, Italy and Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht, Lurgiallee 12, 60439 Frankfurt,<br />

Germany.<br />

Recommendation rules: "Consob Rule n. 11971/1999, art. 69-quinquies and Consob Comm. n. DME/6027054 28th March 2006<br />

Other important notices:<br />

Key 1a: Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG and/or a company affiliated with it pursuant to § 15 AktienG (German Stock Corporation Act) owns at<br />

least 5% <strong>of</strong> the capital stock <strong>of</strong> the company.<br />

Key 1b: The analyzed company owns at least 5% <strong>of</strong> the capital stock <strong>of</strong> Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG and/or a company affiliated with it<br />

pursuant to § 15 AktienG (German Stock Corporation Act).<br />

Key 2: Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG and/or a company affiliated with it pursuant to § 15 AktG (German Stock Corporation Act) belonged<br />

to a syndicate that has acquired securities <strong>of</strong> the analyzed company within the twelve months preceding publication.<br />

Key 3: Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG and/or a company affiliated with it pursuant to § 15 AktG (German Stock Corporation Act)<br />

administers the securities issued by the analyzed company on the stock exchange or on the market by quoting bid and ask prices.<br />

Key 4: The analyzed company and Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG and/or a company affiliated with it pursuant to § 15 AktG (German Stock<br />

Corporation Act) concluded an agreement on services in connection with investment banking transactions in the last 12 months, in return <strong>for</strong><br />

which the Bank received a consideration or promise <strong>of</strong> consideration.<br />

Key 5: The analyzed company and Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG and/or a company affiliated with it pursuant to § 15 AktG (German Stock<br />

Corporation Act) have concluded an agreement on the preparation <strong>of</strong> analyses.<br />

Company Key:<br />

Deutsche Bank 2,3; HypoVereinsbank 2,3; BANCO POPULAR ESPANOL 2,3; Royal Bank <strong>of</strong> Scotland Group 2; Bayerische Landesbank 2; Santander<br />

Central Hispano 2,3; WL-BANK Westfälische Landschaft Bodenkreditbank AG 2,3; Deutsche Genossenschafts Hypothekenbank AG 2,3; RCI Banque<br />

S.A. 2; HSBC Bank plc. 2; Mediobanca-Banca di Credito Finanziario SpA 1,3; NIBC Bank N.V. 2; NRW Bank 2,3; JPMorgan Chase & Co. 2;<br />

CITIGROUP 2; Allied Irish Bank 2; Société Générale 2,3; OBERBANK AG 1; Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena 3; Berlin-Hannoversche<br />

Hypothekenbank AG 2,3; UNIPOL 4; ICO - Instituto de Credito Oficial 2; Alpha Bank 2; Bank <strong>of</strong> America Corp. 2,3; BANK FÜR TIROL U.<br />

VORARLBERG AG 1; Banca Intesa S.p.A. 2,3; Stadtsparkasse Düsseldorf 2; SEB Hypothekenbank AG 2,3; WestLB AG 2; Deutsche Hypothekenbank<br />

2; Erste europ. Pfandbriefe- u. Kommunalkreditbank AG 2; AyT Cédulas Cajas 2; Caixa Geral de Depositos 2; Allgemeine Hypothekenbank Rheinboden<br />

AG 2; BANCA POPULARE DI VERONA E NOVARA 3; ERSTE BANK DER ÖSTERREICHISCHEN SPARKASSEN 2,3; Anglo Irish Bank 2; BNP<br />

Paribas 2,3; Credit Agricole 2; BBVA 2; Hypo Tirol Bank AG 2; VORARLBERGER LANDES- U. HYPOPOTHEKENBANK AG 2; HSH Nordbank AG 2,3;<br />

Europäische Hypothekenbank S.A. 2; Eurohypo Aktiengesellschaft 2,3; Banco Santander Central Hispano 2; Hypothekenbank in Essen AG 2,3; KFW<br />

2,4; Münchener Hypothekenbank eG 2,3; Australia and New Zealand Banking Group 2; HSBC HOLDINGS 2; HBOS 2; DEPFA BANK plc. 2,3; Hypo<br />

Real Estate Holding AG 2,3; Lloyds TSB Bank plc 2; Capitalia 3; UBS AG 2; Unicredito Italiano Bank 2; Bank Austria Creditanstalt 1,2,3; Landesbank<br />

<strong>Bad</strong>en-Württemberg (LBBW) 2,3; BKS Bank AG 1; Hypo Alpe-Adria Bank AG 2; Kommunalkredit Austria AG 2,3; Düsseldorf Hypothekenbank AG 2;<br />

DEUTSCHE APOTHEKER- und Ärztebank 2; L-Bank Landeskreditbank <strong>Bad</strong>en-Württemberg 2; Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA 2,3; LRP<br />

Landesbank Rheinland-Pfalz Girozentrale 2; Aareal Bank 2,3; ALLIANCE & LEICESTER PLC 2; Mediolanum 3; Banco de Sabadell 2,3; Royal Bank <strong>of</strong><br />

Canada 2; ABN Amro Bank N.V. 2,3,4; RAIFFEISEN INTL BK-HO. 3; Bank <strong>of</strong> Ireland Mortgage Bank 2; DnB NORBank ASA 2; IM Cedulas 2,3;<br />

Cedulas TDA 2; Deutsche Hypothekenbank Hannover 2,3; EFG EOBK ERG. EO 2,95 WKN:919700 2; Niederösterreichische LB Hypobank AG 2;<br />

Deutsche Schiffsbank 2; JYSKE Bank 2; Caixa Catalunya 2; BNL INVESTIRE IMPRESA 4; Banca Italease 2,3; Dexia Kommunalkreditbank AG 2;<br />

Banque Federative du Credit Mutuel 2; Hypo Pfandbriefbank International 2,3; Rabobank Nederland 2; Nederlandse Waterschapsbank 2; Commonwalth<br />

Bank <strong>of</strong> Australia 2; Hamburger Sparkasse 2; FHB Land Credit & Mortgage Bank 2; The Korea Development Bank 2; Caja Madrid 2,3; Banca Sella 2;<br />

Banca Populare Italiana 3; Banca Generali S.P.A. 1; The Export-Import Bank <strong>of</strong> Korea 2; Central Coop Bank AD ComStk 1; <strong>Bad</strong>en-Württemberg<br />

Landeskreditbank- Förderbank 2; Stadshypotek Bank 2,3; Unione Banche Italiane 4; Morgan Stanley 2; Goldmann Sachs 2; SLM CORP. 2; LEHMAN<br />

BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. 2; Merrill Lynch & Co. Inc. 2,3,4; Wüstenrot & Württembergische AG 1; DAB Bank 1; Dresdner Factoring AG 3; Allianz<br />

1,2,3,4; AEGON 2; ERGO 1; Uniqa Versicherungen AG 3; Swiss Re 2; Münchener Rück 2,4; AXA 3; ASSICURAZIONI GENERALI S.P.A. 1,3,4;<br />

ALLEANZA ASSICURAZIONI S.P.A. 1,3; CA IMMOBILIEN ANLAGEN AG 1,2,3; DIC Asset AG 3; IVG Immobilien AG 2; Colonia Real Estate 2; Adler<br />

Real Estate 2,3; Rücker Immobilien AG 2,3; Deutsche REIT AG 3;<br />

Significant financial interest:<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG and companies affiliated with it regularly trade shares <strong>of</strong> the analyzed company. Analyses may refer to one or<br />

several companies and to the securities issued by them. The author’s remuneration has not been, and will not be, geared to the recommendations or views<br />

expressed in this study, neither directly nor indirectly. In some cases, the analyzed issuers have actively supplied in<strong>for</strong>mation <strong>for</strong> this analysis. To prevent<br />

or remedy conflicts <strong>of</strong> interest, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG has established the organizational arrangements required from a legal and<br />

supervisory aspect, adherence to which is monitored by its Compliance department.<br />

The prices used in the analysis are the closing prices <strong>of</strong> the Xetra system or the closing prices <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>ficial trading on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange or the<br />

closing prices on the relevant local stock exchanges. In the case <strong>of</strong> unlisted stocks, the average market prices based on various major broker sources<br />

(OTC market) are used.<br />

Our recommendations are based on in<strong>for</strong>mation available to the general public that we consider to be reliable but <strong>for</strong> the completeness and accuracy<br />

<strong>of</strong> which we assume no liability. We reserve the right to modify the views expressed herein at any time and without notice. Moreover, we reserve the right<br />

not to update this in<strong>for</strong>mation or to discontinue it altogether without notice. The investment possibilities discussed in this report may not be suitable <strong>for</strong><br />

certain investors depending on their specific investment objectives and time horizon or in the context <strong>of</strong> their overall financial situation. In particular<br />

the risks associated with an investment in the securities or the financial instruments under discussion are not explained in its entirety. This in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

is given without any warranty on an “as is” basis and should not be regarded as a substitute <strong>for</strong> obtaining individual advice. Please contact your<br />

bank’s investment advisor <strong>for</strong> individual explanations and advice. Provision <strong>of</strong> this in<strong>for</strong>mation shall not be construed as constituting an <strong>of</strong>fer to enter<br />

into a consulting agreement.<br />

You will find an overview <strong>of</strong> the breakdown in absolute and relative terms <strong>of</strong> our investment ratings on our website www.hvb.de under the heading<br />

“Disclaimer.”<br />

Our investment ratings are in principle judgments relative to an index as a benchmark. Our ratings are as follows:<br />

Issuer level:<br />

Marketweight: We recommend to have the same portfolio exposure in the name as the respective reference index (the iBoxx index universe <strong>for</strong> high-grade<br />

names and the ML EUR HY index <strong>for</strong> sub-investment grade names)<br />

Overweight: We recommend to have a higher portfolio exposure in the name as the respective reference index (the iBoxx index universe <strong>for</strong> high-grade<br />

names and the ML EUR HY index <strong>for</strong> sub-investment grade names)<br />

Underweight: We recommend to have a lower portfolio exposure in the name as the respective reference index (the iBoxx index universe <strong>for</strong> high-grade<br />

names and the ML EUR HY index <strong>for</strong> sub-investment grade names)<br />

Instrument level:<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

Core hold: We recommend to hold the respective instrument <strong>for</strong> investors who already have exposure.<br />

Sell: We recommend to sell the respective instrument <strong>for</strong> investors who already have exposure.<br />

Buy: We recommend to buy the respective instrument <strong>for</strong> investors who already have exposure.<br />

Note on the bases <strong>of</strong> valuation <strong>for</strong> interest-bearing securities:<br />

Trading recommendations <strong>for</strong> fixed-interest securities mostly focus on the credit spread (yield difference between the fixed-interest security and the<br />

relevant government bond or swap rate) and on the rating views and methodologies <strong>of</strong> recognized agencies (S&P, Moody’s, Fitch). Depending on the type<br />

<strong>of</strong> investor, investment ratings may refer to a short period or to a 6 to 9-month horizon.<br />

Please note that the provision <strong>of</strong> securities services may be subject to restrictions in certain jurisdictions. You are required to acquaint yourself with local<br />

laws and restrictions on the usage and the availability <strong>of</strong> any services described herein. The in<strong>for</strong>mation is not intended <strong>for</strong> distribution to or use by any<br />

person or entity in any jurisdiction where such distribution would be contrary to the applicable law or provisions.<br />

Notices required by CONSOB:<br />

Analyst Declaration<br />

The analyst/the analysts involved in the preparation <strong>of</strong> this document is/are not the beneficial owners <strong>of</strong> the securities mentioned in this document.<br />

All estimates and opinions included in the report represent the independent judgment <strong>of</strong> the analysts as <strong>of</strong> the date <strong>of</strong> the issue. It does not represent<br />

the views or opinions <strong>of</strong> the management <strong>of</strong> Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch (“HVB Milan”) or any other company in or affiliated<br />

to the groups <strong>of</strong> which they <strong>for</strong>m part. It is possible that individuals employed by HVB Milan or any other such company or affiliate may disagree with<br />

the opinions in this report.<br />

Important Disclosure<br />

This document has been prepared by Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch, Via Tommaso Grossi, 10, 20121 Milano, Italy, duly<br />

authorized by the Bank <strong>of</strong> Italy to provide investment services. The company belongs to the UCI Group. Regulatory authority: “Bank <strong>of</strong> Italy”, Via<br />

Nazionale 91, 00184 Roma, Italy and Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht, Lurgiallee 12, 60439 Frankfurt, Germany.<br />

General Disclosure<br />

This document is being distributed on an irregular basis by electronic and ordinary mail to pr<strong>of</strong>essional investors and may not be redistributed,<br />

reproduced or published in whole or in part. This document is <strong>for</strong> in<strong>for</strong>mation purposes only and is not intended as an <strong>of</strong>fer or solicitation <strong>of</strong> an <strong>of</strong>fer to<br />

sell or to buy any financial instrument. Recipients should conduct their own investigation and analysis <strong>of</strong> the companies and securities referred to in<br />

this document and make their own investment decisions without undue reliance on its contents.<br />

In<strong>for</strong>mation, opinions, estimates and <strong>for</strong>ecasts contained herein have been obtained from, or are based upon, public sources such as press and<br />

branch publications, financial statements, current and periodic reports, as well as meetings and telephone conversations with company<br />

representatives believed by HVB Milan to be reliable. However, no representation <strong>of</strong> warranty, express or implied, is made, and no responsibility or<br />

liability is accepted by HVB Milan, or any <strong>of</strong> their directors, <strong>of</strong>ficers, employees or shareholders <strong>for</strong> loss or damage <strong>of</strong> whatsoever nature in any way<br />

relating to reliance upon this In<strong>for</strong>mation.<br />

In<strong>for</strong>mation, which is not reflected in this document, may there<strong>for</strong>e be available to persons connected to HVB Milan.<br />

Coverage policy and frequency <strong>of</strong> reports and updates<br />

The companies are covered at least once a year, usually in occasion <strong>of</strong> the quarterly earning releases or the presentation <strong>of</strong> a new industrial plan and<br />

any time that the recommendation changes. Each analyst is assigned a group <strong>of</strong> companies belonging to the same sector. Some sectors (like <strong>banks</strong>),<br />

where the number <strong>of</strong> companies under coverage is particularly high, are covered by more than one analyst.<br />

Valuation methodology<br />

The methodologies used <strong>for</strong> the valuation <strong>of</strong> the credit quality (i.e. rating) evolution <strong>of</strong> a company are similar to those adopted by the main<br />

international rating agencies (S&P, Moody’s and Fitch). The final aim <strong>of</strong> these methodologies i s to estimate the probability <strong>of</strong> default <strong>of</strong> the issuer and<br />

the recovery value <strong>of</strong> its financial liabilities. The analysis is composed <strong>of</strong> different phases: 1) the business pr<strong>of</strong>ile assessment, aimed at estimating the<br />

volatility <strong>of</strong> future cash flows and, hence, the level <strong>of</strong> risk <strong>of</strong> the company’s asset; 2) the financial pr<strong>of</strong>ile analysis, aimed at estimating the company’s<br />

financial equilibrium and its ability <strong>of</strong> facing its liabilities redemptions and charges with the cash flow generation; 3) the liquidity analysis, aimed at<br />

estimating the company’s ability <strong>of</strong> facing its short-term debt with its liquid or easily cashable assets. For a better definition <strong>of</strong> a company’s credit<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>ile, its current and expected credit metrics (financial ratios measuring the company’s credit quality) are compared with the peers’. Similar credit<br />

metrics levels and expected evolution should correspond to a similar rating.<br />

Our recommendations on eurobonds focus on our <strong>for</strong>ecasted future movement <strong>of</strong> the credit spreads, that is to say the difference between the yield to<br />

maturity <strong>of</strong> the security and a risk free rate (swap or government bond rate) referable to the same maturity. The key driver <strong>of</strong> this movement is the<br />

evolution <strong>of</strong> the company’s rating. A comparative method is adopted: different securities having the same maturities, issued by companies that<br />

operate in the same sectors, with the same rating level and outlook should pay a similar credit spread. The advantage <strong>of</strong> the comparative method is<br />

that it incorporates the current market assessment <strong>of</strong> the value <strong>of</strong> the company’s peers. The weakness <strong>of</strong> the comparative method is the risk that the<br />

valuation benchmark may be mispriced. In addition to the rating evolution, other factors act on the future direction <strong>of</strong> credit spreads: the dynamics <strong>of</strong><br />

government bonds interest rates; the liquidity <strong>of</strong> the system; the issuance <strong>of</strong> new Eurobonds; the <strong>of</strong>fer <strong>of</strong> other alternative assets; investors’ risk<br />

appetite and other factors, different from the rating, that might change the demand-<strong>of</strong>fer conditions. Together with the rating level and outlook, these<br />

additional factors are always considered, depending on their importance, when a recommendation on a Eurobond is given.<br />

Key to Investment Rankings<br />

Our investment ratings are in principle judgments relative to an index as a benchmark. Our ratings are as follows:<br />

Issuer level:<br />

Marketweight: We recommend to have the same portfolio exposure in the name as the respective reference index (the iBoxx index universe <strong>for</strong> high-grade<br />

names and the ML EUR HY index <strong>for</strong> sub-investment grade names)<br />

Overweight: We recommend to have a higher portfolio exposure in the name as the respective reference index (the iBoxx index universe <strong>for</strong> high-grade<br />

names and the ML EUR HY index <strong>for</strong> sub-investment grade names)<br />

Underweight: We recommend to have a lower portfolio exposure in the name as the respective reference index (the iBoxx index universe <strong>for</strong> high-grade<br />

names and the ML EUR HY index <strong>for</strong> sub-investment grade names)<br />

Instrument level:<br />

Core hold: We recommend to hold the respective instrument <strong>for</strong> investors who already have exposure.<br />

Sell: We recommend to sell the respective instrument <strong>for</strong> investors who already have exposure.<br />

Buy: We recommend to buy the respective instrument <strong>for</strong> investors who already have exposure.<br />

Organizational and Administrative Arrangements to avoid and prevent conflicts <strong>of</strong> interest<br />

Conflicts <strong>of</strong> interest arising between the activities in which HVB Milan engages, are managed by legal and physical and non-physical barriers<br />

(collectively referred to as “Chinese walls” designed to restrict the flow <strong>of</strong> in<strong>for</strong>mation between one area/department <strong>of</strong> HVB Milan and another. In<br />

particular, Investment Banking units, including corporate finance, capital market activities, financial advisory and other capital raising activities, are<br />

segregated by physical and non-physical boundaries from Trading units and Sales Units, as well as the equity research department. Within the<br />

Group, the fund management and corporate, retail and private banking arms operate through different legal entities, which rein<strong>for</strong>ces the containment<br />

<strong>of</strong> in<strong>for</strong>mation between entities. Disclosure <strong>of</strong> publicly available conflicts <strong>of</strong> interest and other material interests is made in the research. Analysts are<br />

supervised and managed on a day-to-day basis by line managers who do not have responsibility <strong>for</strong> Investment Banking activities, including<br />

corporate finance activities, or other activities other than the fixed income and macro economic research. The remuneration <strong>of</strong> the analyst(s)<br />

responsible <strong>for</strong> covering the securities in this report is not tied to investment banking transactions or services per<strong>for</strong>med by HVB Milan or by the<br />

Group.<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

Distribution in other countries<br />

This document may not be distributed in Canada or Australia.<br />

Notice to U.K. residents:<br />

This report is intended <strong>for</strong> clients <strong>of</strong> Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG and Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch who are market<br />

counterparties or intermediate customers (both as defined by the “FSA”, the Financial Services Authority) and is not intended <strong>for</strong> use by any other person,<br />

in particular, private customers as defined by the FSA Rules. This report is not to be construed as a solicitation to buy or an <strong>of</strong>fer to sell any securities. The<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation in this publication is based on carefully selected sources believed to be reliable, but we do not make any representation with respect to its<br />

completeness or accuracy. All opinions expressed in this report reflect our assessment at this time and are subject to change without notice.<br />

We and/or other members <strong>of</strong> Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank Group may take a long or short position and buy or sell securities mentioned in this<br />

publication. We and/or members <strong>of</strong> Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank Group may act as investment bankers and/or commercial bankers <strong>for</strong> issuers <strong>of</strong><br />

securities mentioned, be represented on the board <strong>of</strong> such issuers and/or act as “market makers” <strong>for</strong> such securities. The Bank and its affiliates may also,<br />

from time to time, have a consulting relationship with a company mentioned in this report.<br />

The investment opportunities discussed in this report may be unsuitable <strong>for</strong> certain investors depending on their specific investment objectives and financial<br />

position. Investors are recommended to obtain the advice <strong>of</strong> their banker/broker about investments prior to entering into them.<br />

This document has been approved <strong>for</strong> distribution in UK by Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG London branch, regulated by the FSA <strong>for</strong> the conduct <strong>of</strong><br />

Investment Business in the UK. The HVB London Conflicts Management Policy is available upon request.<br />

Notice to U.S. residents:<br />

This report is intended solely <strong>for</strong> persons who qualify as "major US institutional investors" (as defined in Rule 15a-6 under the U.S. Securities<br />

Exchange Act <strong>of</strong> 1934, as amended) as such term has been interpreted by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Each U.S. recipient <strong>of</strong> this<br />

report represents and agrees, by virtue <strong>of</strong> its acceptance there<strong>of</strong>, that it is such a "major U.S. institutional investor" and that it understands the risks<br />

involved in executing transactions in such securities. Any U.S. recipient <strong>of</strong> this report that wishes to discuss or receive additional in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

regarding any security or issuer mentioned herein must contact a registered representative <strong>of</strong> HVB Capital Markets, Inc. (“HVB Capital”).<br />

Any transaction by U.S. persons (other than a registered U.S. broker-dealer or bank acting in a broker-dealer capacity) must be effected with or<br />

through HVB Capital Markets.<br />

The securities <strong>of</strong> non-U.S. issuers referred to in this report may not be registered <strong>for</strong> sale in the U.S. or subject to U.S. reporting and/or other<br />

requirements. Available in<strong>for</strong>mation regarding such non-U.S. issuers may be limited, and such non-U.S. issuers may not be subject to the same<br />

auditing and reporting standards as U.S. issuers.<br />

The in<strong>for</strong>mation contained in this report is intended solely <strong>for</strong> certain "major U.S. institutional investors", and may not be used or relied upon by any<br />

other person <strong>for</strong> any purpose. Such in<strong>for</strong>mation is provided <strong>for</strong> in<strong>for</strong>mational purposes only and does not constitute a solicitation to buy or an <strong>of</strong>fer to<br />

sell any securities under the Securities Act <strong>of</strong> 1933, as amended, or under any other U.S. federal or state securities laws, rules or regulations. The<br />

investment opportunities discussed in this report may be unsuitable <strong>for</strong> certain investors depending on their specific investment objectives, risk<br />

tolerance and financial position.<br />

In jurisdictions where HVB Capital is not registered or licensed to trade in securities, commodities or other financial products, transactions may be<br />

executed only in accordance with applicable law and legislation, which may vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction and which may require that a<br />

transaction be made in accordance with applicable exemptions from registration or licensing requirements.<br />

The in<strong>for</strong>mation in this publication is based on carefully selected sources believed to be reliable, but HVB Capital does not make any representation<br />

with respect to its completeness or accuracy. All opinions expressed herein reflect HVB Capital's judgment at the original time <strong>of</strong> publication, without<br />

regard to the date on which you may receive such in<strong>for</strong>mation, and are subject to change without notice.<br />

HVB Capital may have issued other reports that are inconsistent with, and reach different conclusions from, the in<strong>for</strong>mation presented in this report.<br />

These publications reflect the different assumptions, views and analytical methods <strong>of</strong> the analysts who prepared them. Past per<strong>for</strong>mance should not<br />

be taken as an indication or guarantee <strong>of</strong> future per<strong>for</strong>mance, and no representation or warranty, express or implied, is provided in relation to future<br />

per<strong>for</strong>mance.<br />

HVB Capital and any company affiliated with it may, with respect to any securities discussed herein: (a) take a long or short position and buy or sell<br />

such securities; (b) act as investment and/or commercial bankers <strong>for</strong> issuers <strong>of</strong> such securities; (c) act as market makers <strong>for</strong> such securities; (d) serve<br />

on the board <strong>of</strong> any issuer <strong>of</strong> such securities; and (e) act as paid consultant or advisor to any issuer.<br />

The in<strong>for</strong>mation contained herein may include <strong>for</strong>ward-looking statements within the meaning <strong>of</strong> U.S. federal securities laws that are subject to risks<br />

and uncertainties. Factors that could cause a company’s actual results and financial condition to differ from expectations include, without limitation:<br />

political uncertainty, changes in general economic conditions that adversely affect the level <strong>of</strong> demand <strong>for</strong> the company’s products or services,<br />

changes <strong>for</strong>eign exchange markets, changes in international and domestic financial markets and in the competitive environment, and other factors<br />

relating to the <strong>for</strong>egoing. All <strong>for</strong>ward-looking statements contained in this report are qualified in their entirety by this cautionary statement.<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch


Global Credit Research<br />

Financial Institutions<br />

May 29, 2007<br />

Sector Report - Summary <strong>of</strong> Moody's JDA For Banks<br />

CONTACTS<br />

GLOBAL RESEARCH*<br />

Thorsten Weinelt, CFA, Global Head <strong>of</strong> Research & Chief Strategist (HVB)<br />

+49 89 378-15110<br />

thorsten.weinelt@hvb.de<br />

GLOBAL CREDIT RESEARCH<br />

Luis Maglanoc, CFA, Head (HVB)<br />

+49 89 378-12708<br />

luis.maglanoc@hvb.de<br />

Credit Strategy & Structured Credit<br />

Dr. Jochen Felsenheimer, Head (HVB)<br />

+49 89 378-18188<br />

jochen.felsenheimer@hvb.de<br />

Markus Ernst (HVB)<br />

Structured Credit<br />

+49 89 378-14213<br />

markus.ernst01@hvb.de<br />

Dr. Philip Gisdakis (HVB)<br />

Quantitative Credit Strategy<br />

+49 89 378-13228<br />

philip.gisdakis@hvb.de<br />

Agnes Kitzmüller (HVB)<br />

Credit Strategy & Structured Credit<br />

+49 89 378-11294<br />

agnes.kitzmueller@hvb.de<br />

Dr. Marco Krohn (HVB)<br />

Structured Credit<br />

+49 89 378-12250<br />

marco.krohn@hvb.de<br />

Gianna Julia Wisser (HVB)<br />

Credit Strategy<br />

+49 89 378-13229<br />

giannajulia.wisser@hvb.de<br />

Financials Credit Research<br />

Luis Maglanoc, CFA, Head (HVB)<br />

Banks<br />

+49 89 378-12708<br />

luis.maglanoc@hvb.de<br />

Franz Rudolf, CEFA, Deputy Head (HVB)<br />

Covered Bonds<br />

+49 89 378-12449<br />

franz.rudolf@hvb.de<br />

Andrea Crepaz (HVB)<br />

Insurance, Banks<br />

+49 89 378-11432<br />

andrea.crepaz@hvb.de<br />

Florian Hillenbrand (HVB)<br />

Covered Bonds<br />

+49 89 378-12961<br />

florian.hillenbrand@hvb.de<br />

Christian Meidinger (HVB)<br />

Sub-Sovereigns & Agencies<br />

+49 89 378-16296<br />

Christian.meidinger@hvb.de<br />

Alexander Plenk, CFA (HVB)<br />

Banks<br />

+49 89 378-12429<br />

alexander.plenk@hvb.de<br />

Publication Address<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG<br />

Global Research<br />

Arabellastrasse 12<br />

D-81925 Munich<br />

Tel. +49 89 378-12759<br />

Fax. +49 89 378-16237<br />

Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG, CA IB International Markets AG, Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch<br />

Corporate Credit Research<br />

Dr. Felix Fischer, CFA, Co-Head (HVB)<br />

General Industries, Construction & Materials, Tobacco<br />

+49 89 378-15449<br />

felix.fischer@hvb.de<br />

Dr. Sven Kreitmair, CFA, Co-Head (HVB)<br />

Automobiles & Parts, Industrial G&S, Aerospace & Defense<br />

+49 89 378-13246<br />

sven.kreitmair@hvb.de<br />

Jana Arndt, CFA (HVB)<br />

Basic Resources, Industrial G&S, Packaging<br />

+49 89 378-13211<br />

jana.arndt@hvb.de<br />

Alejandra Diez (HVB Milan)<br />

Utilities<br />

+39 02 8862-2036<br />

alejandra.diez@hvb.de<br />

Stephan Haber (HVB)<br />

Telecoms, Media, Technology<br />

+49 89 378-15192<br />

stephan.haber@hvb.de<br />

Carmen Hummel (HVB)<br />

Food & Beverage, Travel & Leisure,<br />

Personal & Household Goods, Retail<br />

+49 89 378-12252<br />

carmen.hummel@hvb.de<br />

Christian Kleindienst (HVB)<br />

Utilities, Oil & Gas<br />

+49 89 378-12650<br />

christian.kleindienst@hvb.de<br />

Jochen Schlachter (HVB)<br />

Chemicals, Healthcare<br />

+49 89 378-13212<br />

jochen.schlachter@hvb.de<br />

Dietmar Tzschentke (HVB)<br />

+49 89 378-12960<br />

dietmar.tzschentke@hvb.de<br />

Bloomberg<br />

HVCA<br />

Internet<br />

www.hvbmarkets.de<br />

*Global Research is the joint research department <strong>of</strong> Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG (HVB), CA IB International Markets<br />

AG (CAIB), and Bayerische Hypo- und Vereinsbank AG Milan Branch (HVB Milan).

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!