PDF file: Drama - Higher - Lovers - Education Scotland
PDF file: Drama - Higher - Lovers - Education Scotland
PDF file: Drama - Higher - Lovers - Education Scotland
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
INTRODUCTION<br />
In 1993 Scottish CCC published a series of <strong>Higher</strong> <strong>Drama</strong> background<br />
information packs about <strong>Lovers</strong> and eight other prescribed plays. Under<br />
the impetus of the <strong>Higher</strong> Still development programme, these packs<br />
are now supplemented by a series of learning and teaching guides to the<br />
prescribed plays. The new material has been written both as a resource<br />
for teachers and as a study aid for students working on Unit 2 (Study of<br />
a Text in its Theatrical Context) of <strong>Higher</strong> <strong>Drama</strong>.<br />
Section A provides a list of the features of each key scene or episode in<br />
<strong>Lovers</strong> which would be important in any production of the play. It also<br />
provides space for the student to record why each key scene would be<br />
important in his/her intended production.<br />
Section B provides a directory of possible acting pieces in terms of<br />
casting, suitable length and specific challenges to the actor.<br />
All textual references are to the recommended edition of the text,<br />
<strong>Lovers</strong> by Brian Friel, published by The Gallery Press (1984).<br />
Other resources for teaching this unit include the following:<br />
• The Arrangements for <strong>Drama</strong> published in 1997 contains detail of<br />
content, suggested learning and teaching approaches, guidance on<br />
assessment and unit descriptors.<br />
• The Subject Guide for <strong>Drama</strong>, the first instalment of which was<br />
published in 1997, includes guidance on learning and teaching in<br />
general, bi-level teaching, differentiation, workshop approaches to<br />
the text, health and safety guidelines, and ensuring appropriate<br />
access for students with special education needs.<br />
• The National Assessment Bank packages published in 1998 for each<br />
unit of <strong>Drama</strong> include all checklists, task sheets, marking instructions<br />
and guidance necessary to carry out the internal assessment of each<br />
unit.<br />
• A video published in 1998 exemplifies standards of practical<br />
performance for Investigative <strong>Drama</strong> (Unit 1) and for Acting in both<br />
Study of a Text in its Theatrical Context (Unit 2) and Contemporary<br />
Scottish Theatre (Unit 3).<br />
DRAMA 1
2<br />
Note<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
Winners and Losers by Brian Friel are two short, complementary<br />
plays contained in <strong>Lovers</strong>. For the purpose of <strong>Higher</strong> <strong>Drama</strong> they<br />
should be regarded as forming one play with two complementary<br />
halves. Candidates should take care to consider both halves in<br />
their responses to exam questions. Failure to do so may penalise<br />
candidates.<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
SECTION A<br />
Winners<br />
EPISODE ONE<br />
(pages 11-31)<br />
Why would Episode One be important in any production of<br />
the play?<br />
Provides context of the play and gives background to the action/<br />
storyline<br />
• We note the period – 1967, ‘The present in Ireland’, a place of social<br />
divisions and changing identity. The play is firmly set in the Republic<br />
of Ireland. The dominant and almost exclusive faith was and still is<br />
Catholicism. The Catholic Church exerted powerful control over<br />
every aspect of Irish life. The Church’s control in rural communities<br />
would have been even more pronounced. Ireland prohibited divorce,<br />
abortion and contraception. Sex before marriage was a sin.<br />
• <strong>Lovers</strong> is firmly set in the Catholic community.<br />
• The Commentators are in their late fifties and are used as a symbolic<br />
juxtaposition when seen against the young protagonists. The fact that<br />
they give details in the past tense in a formal, unemotional and<br />
detached manner gives the impression that we are listening to an<br />
inquest. The Commentators represent the repressive, straight-laced<br />
community that Mag and Joe both live in. The fact that Friel<br />
establishes these two characters first suggests that this repression is<br />
the norm.<br />
• We learn that Mag lives in an affluent part of Ballymore.<br />
• We learn that Joe lives in a run-down, working-class area of Ballymore.<br />
• We learn that Mag is a pupil at a strict Catholic grammar school for<br />
girls which is run by nuns.<br />
• We learn that Joe is a pupil at a strict Catholic grammar school for<br />
boys which is run by priests.<br />
• We learn that Mag and Joe have to get married as Mag is two months<br />
pregnant. Mag and Joe are young, their predicament is a metaphor<br />
and shows how helpless the new generation felt towards the old<br />
hierarchical order.<br />
DRAMA 3
4<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• We see the influence and controlling effect of the Catholic Church on<br />
Joe and Mag. This influence permeates every aspect of their lives both<br />
at school and in the community in which they live.<br />
• We can clearly see the young lovers’ isolation – isolation from each<br />
other and isolation from society.<br />
• Mag and Joe’s alienation is compounded by the delivery of the<br />
Commentators’ narrations. Friel has been influenced by Brecht’s<br />
alienation technique here. The Commentator narrations reinforce<br />
the action of the play and break the illusion of reality as they bring us<br />
back to the present. They directly address the audience to emphasise<br />
key points/moments in the action.<br />
Begins plot<br />
• Mag and Joe arrive at Ardnageeha to study for their final school<br />
examinations.<br />
• They stay at the top of Ardnageeha from 10am to 2pm.<br />
• The ‘impartial’ Commentators provide detailed information which<br />
encourages the audience to form opinions. This device is used to<br />
provide dramatic irony throughout Winners.<br />
• The dialogue of the young lovers gives us clear impressions of a<br />
variety of ‘off-stage’ characters who live in Ballymore. Most of these<br />
characters have antagonised Mag and Joe.<br />
• We begin to appreciate how Mag and Joe feel about their life in a<br />
close-knit, repressive, rural, Irish Catholic community.<br />
• We are immediately introduced to the overbearing attitude of the<br />
nuns at Mag’s school.<br />
• It is ironic that the nuns who run Mag’s school are from the Order of<br />
Mercy – clearly no mercy was shown. This scene introduces a number<br />
of value judgments on the church.<br />
• We immediately gain an insight into Mag’s romantic nature and Joe’s<br />
conformist nature.<br />
• Mag’s rebellious nature is also revealed. She smokes. She and Joe<br />
have had sex before marriage.<br />
• We see the difference in attitude between Mag and Joe with regard to<br />
their studies: Joe is serious and Mag lacks concentration.<br />
• We observe mimicry. Their mimicry is used to get back at their<br />
tormentors. Through mimicry, we see them vent their anger and<br />
frustration. This allows us to see a different side to Joe’s nature – the<br />
side of his nature that doesn’t conform to society’s repressive<br />
expectations.<br />
• These are carefree, young and rebellious 17-year-olds. Their mimicry<br />
is also used as a comic device which helps us deal with the more<br />
serious moments in the play. The mimicry is the first real<br />
introduction of what caused the sparks of attraction between Mag and<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Joe. They both have a totally zany sense of humour and together form<br />
a hysterically comic double act. This is one of the reasons why Mag<br />
loves Joe.<br />
• Mag’s dissatisfaction with her parents as role models emerges.<br />
• We hear about Mag’s parents’ reaction to her pregnancy. ‘My God, the<br />
things they said to me – they seared my soul forever.’<br />
• The Commentators reveal the huge class differences between the<br />
Brennans and the Enwrights.<br />
• We discover that Mag’s twin brother Peter died in his cot five days<br />
after he was born.<br />
• We learn that Mag’s mother has suffered from clinical depression ever<br />
since the tragedy of Peter’s death. The revelation of Mrs Enwright’s<br />
depression and the relationship between Mag and her mother brings<br />
us naturally to the relationship between Mag and her father. It is<br />
obvious he wants to help her as much as possible and that she adores<br />
him. ‘It’s only that Papa’ll be lonely without me.’ ‘. . . the first time<br />
he’ll ever have been separated from me, even for a night.’ ‘Besides, I<br />
can wheel the pram over every afternoon.’<br />
• We learn that Peter’s death has had consequences for Mag.<br />
• Mag pretends to go into labour. The false pains are used deliberately<br />
to control Joe and gain his sympathy. This reveals Mag’s insecurity.<br />
• We gradually see that Mag is not as confident about the future as her<br />
early dialogue indicates.<br />
• By the end of the scene we clearly see the tensions between Mag and<br />
Joe. Joe feels he has been ‘trapped’.<br />
• We learn of Mag and Joe’s disappearance. We are encouraged to<br />
speculate about what happened in the hours after they left<br />
Ardnageeha. This heightens the dramatic tension of the scene. Mag<br />
and Joe’s deaths are shrouded in mystery.<br />
Develops characters and relationships<br />
Mag<br />
• Mag is one of the four ‘<strong>Lovers</strong>’. Friel’s notes at the start of the play<br />
describe her clearly: ‘Mag is seventeen, bubbling with life, inclined to<br />
be extreme in her enthusiasms. Although she is not beautiful, her<br />
vivacity gives her a distinct attraction. Whatever she likes, she loves;<br />
whatever she dislikes she hates – momentarily. She is either very<br />
elated or very depressed, but no emotion is ever permanent.’<br />
• The scene establishes her flighty, romantic, witty, comical, energetic,<br />
effervescent, angst-ridden nature.<br />
• She is full of doubts now that she is pregnant and persona non grata<br />
in the eyes of the church and the community.<br />
• She is worried about the future. How will her father cope without<br />
her? She believes that her marriage will not be like that of her own<br />
DRAMA 5
6<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
parents. Her speeches reveal the importance of religion in her life.<br />
We see that she is deeply in love with Joe. We see her contradictions<br />
and experience her isolation.<br />
Joe<br />
• Joe is used as a contrast to Mag. Friel states the following: ‘Joe is<br />
seventeen and a half. He is a serious boy, a good student, interested<br />
in his books. He is at the age when he is earnest about life; and he has<br />
a total and touching belief in the value and importance of education.’<br />
• This scene establishes Joe’s character. He is quiet and reflective in<br />
comparison to Mag. He shows that he is proud and independent. He<br />
is conformist.<br />
• He has started to find practical solutions to their problems.<br />
• His mimicry reveals the frustration that he feels at living in a<br />
restrictive environment.<br />
• We see flashes of rebellious youth in the slaughterhouse sequence<br />
when he pretends to shoot the pillars of his community.<br />
Man/Woman<br />
• The Man/Woman (The Commentators) are used as a catalyst for the<br />
dramatic irony in Winners. Their formal, unemotional, impersonal,<br />
impartial style is in complete contrast to Mag and Joe’s lively<br />
naturalistic interaction.<br />
• They are used as an alienating device which builds dramatic tension.<br />
• They are also a symbolic representation of the restrictive, repressive,<br />
rural Irish society in which Mag and Joe live. We are told that they are<br />
in their fifties. The fact that they are so much older than Mag and Joe<br />
is significant. This age gap helps to reinforce their symbolic<br />
representation.<br />
Establishes central themes and issues<br />
• Frustrated love: Mag’s pregnancy has forced the young lovers to<br />
conform to society’s expectations. Mag’s romantic rhetoric contrasts<br />
with Joe’s pragmatic attitude towards his studies. Mag has doubts<br />
about marriage to Joe and her future happiness. She needs<br />
reassurance. Mag gives an insight into the dysfunctional marriage of<br />
her parents and is determined not to end up like them. Joe’s angry<br />
outbursts reveal a deep-rooted resentment at finding himself caught<br />
in the predicament of having to get married because of Mag’s<br />
pregnancy.<br />
• Frustrated Christianity: Mag and Joe live in a Christian community<br />
and yet the majority of people in this community have shown them<br />
no benevolence, understanding or sympathy. They get little in the<br />
way of support outside their families. They are ostracised by their<br />
schools and by certain factions in their community.<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• The inevitability of repression: Mag and Joe are forced into marriage.<br />
• Moral responsibility: Joe accepts that it is his duty to look after Mag.<br />
• Overbearing rigidity and domination of a restrictive environment:<br />
Mag’s stories of nuns, Joe’s mimicry of Old Kerrigan, the sequence<br />
with them shooting (the President of St Kevin’s/Sister Paul/Philip<br />
Moran’s mother/Skinny Skeehan/Mother Dolores) reveal that they live<br />
in such an environment. Friel paints a highly negative picture of Irish<br />
society.<br />
• The influence of the Catholic religion: the nuns at Mag’s school are<br />
depicted as dogmatic, authoritarian and inflexible. Interestingly the<br />
priests in Joe’s school are shown in a slightly better light than the<br />
nuns. His school is run by the clergy of the diocese – not by an order<br />
– so the implication is that they are marginally more human and open<br />
minded.<br />
• Uncertainty about the future: Mag’s doubts. Her need for reassurance<br />
from Joe. Mag’s concern about her father’s loneliness. Mag’s own<br />
loneliness comes across in her wild imagination and the ridiculous<br />
stories she tells for effect. She is desperate for attention. Why? Joe<br />
indicates that he does not share Mag’s romantic views about a flat<br />
which looks into the slaughterhouse yard.<br />
• Hope: Mag’s constant romantic views of married life with Joe. Joe’s<br />
assertion that he will get a degree and become a teacher.<br />
• Imposed divisions: Mag goes to a school for girls. Joe goes to a school<br />
for boys. Mag lives in a better area of Ballymore than Joe. The class<br />
division between Mag and Joe. The theatrical representation of the<br />
Commentators compared to the theatrical representation of Mag/Joe.<br />
Why would Episode One be important in your production of<br />
the play?<br />
• As a director, how will you ensure that your audience will understand<br />
the social and political background to the play? How will you get<br />
across the notion that the period of the play is significant?<br />
• How will you bring out the rural Irish Catholic attitude towards Mag’s<br />
pregnancy?<br />
• As a director how will you establish the mood you want to create?<br />
• How will you get across the isolation that the couple feels?<br />
• How will you communicate the restrictive, repressive, environment<br />
that they live in?<br />
DRAMA 7
8<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• Will you retain the play’s non-naturalistic setting? What type of staging<br />
will you use? Why?<br />
• How will it demonstrate your own directorial concepts? What are<br />
they?<br />
• How will you get the actors to portray the Commentators? What do<br />
you want the audience to think and feel when the Commentators<br />
speak? Could you use theatrical effects to contribute to these feelings?<br />
If so, what effects would you use?<br />
• How do you want the audience to feel towards Mag? How will this<br />
affect the acting of the character? Is she a complex character? Do you<br />
want the audience to have any sympathy for her? How will you get the<br />
actress to deliver the long monologues. How will you try to ensure<br />
that the audience’s attention does not wander?<br />
• How do you want the audience to feel towards Joe? How will this<br />
affect the acting of the character? Is he a complex character? Do you<br />
want the audience to have any sympathy for him?<br />
• What kind of relationship between Mag and Joe would you want the<br />
actors to create?<br />
• How will you show the contrast between Mag and Joe?<br />
• How will you convey the imposed divisions between Mag and Joe and<br />
between Mag/Joe and the Commentators?<br />
• As a director how will you build and realise the dramatic tension in<br />
this Episode?<br />
• How will you show the contrast in the delivery of the Commentators<br />
with the naturalistic interaction of Mag and Joe?<br />
• How will you get Mag and Joe to do their mimicry? How will this get<br />
across the feelings of resentment and unhappiness that they have<br />
towards some of the people in their community?<br />
• How will you get across the importance of the Catholic religion in the<br />
play?<br />
• How will you bring out the humour of the play?<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Notes<br />
DRAMA 9
10<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Winners<br />
EPISODE TWO<br />
(pages 32-49)<br />
Why would Episode Two be important in any production of<br />
the play?<br />
Develops plot<br />
• June and July 1966 were the warmest and driest on record. Ballymore<br />
had been suffering from drought conditions. The audience are<br />
therefore further encouraged to speculate on the mystery of Joe and<br />
Mag’s deaths. If Loch Gorm was so still how could they have died?<br />
• We learn that a local boy discovered Mag and Joe’s bodies. They had<br />
drowned.<br />
• Joe reveals his strong feelings of love for Mag.<br />
• Joe expresses his dissatisfaction with his parents as role models.<br />
• We gain an insight into Joe’s dysfunctional relationship with his<br />
father.<br />
• We discover that Mr Brennan secretly idolised his son and was very<br />
proud of his achievements.<br />
• The episode shows an increased bickering between Joe and Mag. We<br />
are increasingly made more aware of the issues that separate rather<br />
than unite them. We are encouraged to contemplate their future<br />
married life if they had lived.<br />
• Joe reveals his touchiness at the social class difference between him<br />
and the Enwrights.<br />
• Mag and Joe’s deaths are further shrouded in mystery when the post<br />
mortem and the inquest confirm that there was no conclusive<br />
evidence with regard to the circumstances that surrounded their<br />
deaths. We are told that they both died of asphyxiation and that there<br />
were no signs of violence. An open verdict was recorded.<br />
• We are informed that Mag and Joe were buried in separate graves.<br />
• The structure of this episode is in contrast to the first Episode. Joe<br />
has three long monologues and Mag has none. The juxtaposition<br />
between the Commentators and Mag/Joe is more pronounced.<br />
• We are left to contemplate the irony of the title of the first half of<br />
<strong>Lovers</strong>. How could Mag and Joe conceivably be regarded as ‘Winners’<br />
DRAMA 11
12<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
when they died so tragically? Although they promised each other<br />
happiness, their deaths by drowning save them from a more likely<br />
destiny.<br />
• After Joe and Mag’s deaths life in Ballymore carried on as usual.<br />
Further illustrates central themes of the play<br />
• Frustrated love: Mag and Joe die. We gain an insight into the<br />
dysfunctional marriage of the Brennans. Joe indicates that as married<br />
people get older they hardly love each other, yet stick together out of<br />
loyalty. We are made increasingly aware of the big differences<br />
between Mag and Joe. We see flashes of bitterness and doubt between<br />
them.<br />
• Uncertainty about the future: We ask ourselves if Mag and Joe would<br />
have ended up like countless couples before them – couples whose<br />
love is gradually diluted to the point where they stay together merely<br />
out of loyalty and propriety? We sense that Mag and Joe would have<br />
had marriage problems. The decisions that their family, church and<br />
community forced upon them would have come back to haunt them.<br />
Joe’s bitterness at the sacrifices he would have had to make coupled<br />
with his lack of intellectual fulfilment would have been further<br />
sources of conflict.<br />
• The inevitability of repression: Joe is forced to leave school by Father<br />
Kelly. Joe’s mimicry of Father Kelly’s rebuke emphasises the shame<br />
and dishonour that he and Mag must have endured. However,<br />
despite the fact that Father Kelly asked Joe to leave school, he was<br />
still prepared to let Joe sit his exams. The impression is that he was<br />
very annoyed at Joe for being in this situation. The strength of<br />
character of Joe’s mother is shown: ‘Because of your mother’s<br />
pleadings on your behalf we have decided to allow you to return to<br />
sit for your examinations.’ It must have taken a lot for a woman in her<br />
position to do that. This dramatic situation emphasises the power of<br />
the priest in the community.<br />
• Moral responsibility: Joe forsakes his career and ambitions to stay in<br />
Ballymore and marry Mag.<br />
• Overbearing rigidity and domination of a restrictive environment:<br />
Joe’s stories of Skinny Skeehan, Mr O’Hara and his own parents<br />
further reveal his frustrations at living in such a restrictive<br />
environment.<br />
• The influence of the Catholic religion: Father Kelly is depicted as<br />
dogmatic, authoritarian and inflexible.<br />
• Hope: Joe’s ambition is to be a Bachelor of Science. He is determined<br />
that his ‘daughter’ will be a prodigy. He wants to emulate Mr<br />
Enwright. Mag’s romantic view of life in their flat also reflects the<br />
theme of hope.<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• Imposed divisions: The difference in class between the Brennans and<br />
the Enwrights. Mag and Joe are buried in separate graves, each in a<br />
family plot. People learn nothing from their deaths. Divisions remain,<br />
in death as in life. The families stay apart from each other. Not too<br />
many questions are asked. Why did they die? How did they die?<br />
Develops characters and relationships<br />
Joe<br />
• We are immediately reminded in Joe’s opening speech that he is a<br />
hardworking, industrious pupil who takes his studies seriously. He<br />
actually enjoys preparing for his examinations. His character is in<br />
direct contrast to Mag’s and this is clearly emphasised in this Episode.<br />
This Episode also points up fundamental differences between Joe and<br />
Mag. He has ambitions and wants to leave rural Ballymore. Mag<br />
doesn’t have the same outlook on life.<br />
• We sense his resentment at having to settle for a boring job in Skinny<br />
Skeehan’s office.<br />
• Joe uses mimicry to avoid facing the uncomfortable truth that he is<br />
willing to compromise and do what society expects him to do.<br />
• We see Joe’s naivety and lack of worldly knowledge in his second<br />
speech when he looks up the definition of ‘Caesarean’.<br />
• Joe clearly loves Mag. ‘I am crazy about Maggie Enwright . . .’ He feels<br />
guilty about his outbursts.<br />
• He also feels guilty about Mag’s predicament. His guilt forces him to<br />
conform.<br />
• We see that he is selfish, protective, caring, responsible and<br />
pragmatic.<br />
• We see that Mag’s ‘romanticism’ has infected Joe. He begins to fall<br />
into her trap of painting a rosy picture of his ‘daughter’s’ future.We<br />
see Joe’s vulnerability and sense of isolation.<br />
• We gain an insight into the dysfunctional relationship he has with his<br />
father. He is different from his father. Joe is hardworking and<br />
ambitious. We can see that he wants to be closer to his father. They<br />
are unable to communicate with each other.<br />
• By the end of this episode Joe accepts his fate. ‘A married man with a<br />
family has more important things to occupy his mind besides books.’<br />
Mag<br />
• Mag is hurt and frightened. She is vulnerable. She loves Joe. She<br />
needs to know that he loves her. Mag cannot afford to lose Joe.<br />
She needs him to stand by her.<br />
• Mag has doubts about her future married life with a husband who<br />
feels he has been ‘trapped’.<br />
DRAMA 13
14<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• She seeks reassurance.<br />
• She is not in the same league as Joe intellectually. She reverts to<br />
attacking Joe’s class as a way of balancing the scales.<br />
• As in Episode One, Mag goes through the gamut of emotions. In this<br />
episode she is huffy, resentful, happy, doubtful, angry, spiteful,<br />
loving, romantic, positive, carefree and elated!<br />
• At times she feels isolated from Joe. Towards the end of the Episode<br />
we learn of her isolation from her school mates.<br />
• Mag ends the Episode in a romantic mood. ‘The flat’ll be lovely and<br />
cosy at night.’<br />
• In our last glimpse of Mag we see her joie de vivre.<br />
Why might Episode Two be important in your production of<br />
the play?<br />
• How does this Episode develop your overall directorial<br />
interpretation?<br />
• How will you balance the comedy with the pathos of the play?<br />
• How will you point up the irony of the play?<br />
• What does this Episode tell us about Friel’s attitude to love? How is<br />
this shown in Mag and Joe’s exchanges?<br />
• What development in his character would you want to show in the<br />
acting of Joe? How will you show his internal conflict? (His anger and<br />
frustration, his love for Mag, his ambivalent attitude towards his<br />
father, the love and respect he has for his mother, his hopes for the<br />
future, his love of learning, his lack of experience, his vulnerability?)<br />
• Joe has three monologues in this Episode. How will you get the actor<br />
to deliver these to maintain the audience’s interest and to enable<br />
them to gain an insight into the internal conflict mentioned above?<br />
• What developments in her character would you want to show in the<br />
acting of Mag? How will you show her increasing sense of isolation?<br />
Her vulnerability? Her dependency on Joe? Her hopes for a<br />
successful, married family life?<br />
• How will you point up the division between Mag and Joe?<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• As a director how will you build and realise the dramatic tension in<br />
this Episode?<br />
• How do you want the audience to feel at the end of this Episode?<br />
Notes<br />
DRAMA 15
16<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Losers<br />
EXTRACT ONE<br />
(pages 51-60)<br />
Why would this Extract be important in any production of<br />
the play?<br />
Provides context of the second half of <strong>Lovers</strong> and gives background<br />
to the action/storyline<br />
• We note the period is still 1967. Irish society expected the younger<br />
generation to look after the elderly. It was quite common for older<br />
relatives to be living with younger members of their family.<br />
• The Catholic Church’s views on the sanctity of the family would have<br />
been ingrained into the conscience of all Catholics.<br />
• Sex before marriage was regarded as a sin.<br />
• Andy and Hannah live in the same insular, repressive, rural, Irish<br />
Catholic community as Joe and Mag.<br />
• In 1960s Ireland the younger generation wanted to break free from<br />
the restrictive traditions and the rigid moral codes of past<br />
generations. They found it difficult to break free, however. What<br />
could they replace the old order with? The Catholic Church exerted<br />
such a powerful influence, an influence which permeated every area<br />
of their lives from the cradle to the grave. There were rituals and<br />
protocols in abundance. Traditions from the past were strictly<br />
respected by the older generation.<br />
• The title of this half of the play, Losers, immediately engages our<br />
attention and we begin to make direct comparisons with Mag and<br />
Joe’s predicament in Winners. We question the irony of both titles.<br />
What is Friel saying about love and marriage? What is he saying about<br />
these two sets of lovers in particular? What is he saying about the<br />
kind of community that demands and enforces such high moral<br />
expectations? In Winners we clearly see the effect this repressive<br />
community has on Mag and Joe. Right at the start of Losers we learn<br />
that Andy and Hannah have also suffered from living in a repressive<br />
environment.<br />
• Andy’s narration is used to take us backwards in time. Most of the<br />
story happens in the past.<br />
DRAMA 17
18<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Begins plot<br />
• Andy opens the play isolated. Isolated from his family and trapped<br />
into conforming to the ritual acted out by Hannah’s father before<br />
him. He sits outside in the back yard staring at a wall to escape from<br />
the women inside. When he takes refuge here he is ‘allowed’ to sit in<br />
peace and quiet without being disturbed. His environment, the back<br />
yard, ‘is a grey, grimy, gloomy, sunless place’, a visual reminder of<br />
Andy’s isolation and an immediate indication to the audience that<br />
things have not turned out well for him.<br />
• This half of <strong>Lovers</strong> is an anecdotal tale. Andy supplies the anecdotes.<br />
He sets the scene and describes past events. He gently draws the<br />
audience in and helps them to make sense of the sequence of events<br />
that are about to unfold.<br />
• Andy and Hannah have been married for over three years.<br />
• In describing the character of Hannah’s father, Andy is really giving<br />
the audience a character description of himself.<br />
• Mr Wilson worked the night shift as a stoker in the general hospital<br />
for fifty years. We suspect he did so to avoid spending time with his<br />
wife and daughter. He only saw Hannah at the weekend.<br />
• We find out that when Hannah’s father died her mother, Mrs Wilson,<br />
collapsed with shock and has been bedridden ever since.<br />
• Andy and Hannah’s courting had been seriously affected by these<br />
circumstances. They couldn’t have the same kind of courtship as<br />
other couples. They were expected to look after Mrs Wilson. Mrs<br />
Wilson’s needs were more important in the eyes of the community.<br />
• Andy reveals that his early courting days ‘were’ passionate. We note<br />
that his relationship with Hannah is anything but passionate now.<br />
• We go back in time to a scene which took place when Andy and<br />
Hannah were first courting. There is initially a strained formality<br />
between them. We see the diffidence between the couple and see the<br />
awkwardness that both Andy and Hannah felt, partly due to the fact<br />
that they were middle-aged and partly due to the ubiquitous presence<br />
of Mrs Wilson and St Philomena up above. In this situation, they find<br />
it difficult to communicate, to interact and to simply be themselves in<br />
one another’s company.<br />
• Hannah expresses her resentment at having to look after her invalid<br />
mother. She has become a martyr to the ‘needs’ of a dependent<br />
mother.<br />
• We question the seriousness of Mrs Wilson’s illness. She is bedridden<br />
yet she has a healthy appetite. She is alert to everything that is going<br />
on in her house. She rarely saw her husband on a daily basis as he<br />
worked the night shift for fifty years, yet his death has had a profound<br />
and lasting effect on her health.<br />
• We learn that Mrs Wilson is suspicious about what goes on downstairs.<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
When there are silences she rings a bell. Andy puts this down to Mrs<br />
Wilson having a ‘wild dirty imagination’.<br />
• We learn of Andy and Hannah’s scam for allaying the old woman’s<br />
suspicious mind. Andy recites a poem, Grey’s ‘Elegy’, all thirty-two<br />
verses of it! Friel uses this device to heighten the comedy.<br />
• Hannah takes the initiative in the passionate embrace. She is very<br />
passionate. Andy is taken aback by the ferocity of her passionate<br />
kissing. He is however easily drawn in to take part. Hannah throws<br />
herself at Andy because she needs to reassure herself of the depth of<br />
their love.<br />
• By the end of this extract Andy indicates that the passion and<br />
intensity of his relationship with Hannah did not last. Hannah was<br />
soon to be ‘turned into the image of her mother’.<br />
• No other character appears in this scene other than Andy and<br />
Hannah. Mrs Wilson makes her presence clearly felt however. She<br />
rings her bell and Hannah jumps to attention. Friel deliberately hides<br />
Mrs Wilson from view until later in the play. This structural dramatic<br />
device gets the audience to conjure up an image of Mrs Wilson based<br />
on Andy’s biased comments.<br />
• Andy describes the scene reenacted each night in Mrs Wilson’s<br />
bedroom, the ritual of the Rosary. Andy feels trapped in this situation.<br />
He doesn’t have the same religious conviction as Mrs Wilson and<br />
Cissy. He describes how he got caught up in the cloying, feminine<br />
atmosphere of Mrs Wilson’s household.<br />
• Andy informs us that he was aware of Mrs Wilson’s ‘ulterior motives’<br />
and her ‘plotting’ right from the beginning, yet he felt powerless to<br />
do anything about his predicament for fear of upsetting Hannah.<br />
Introduces key characters<br />
Andy<br />
• Friel’s notes on Andy are quite specific. ‘He is a man of fifty, a joiner<br />
by trade, heavily built. His work mates look on him as a solid, decent,<br />
reliable, slightly dull man. Because his mind is simple, direct,<br />
unsubtle, he is unaware of the humour in a lot of the things that he<br />
says.’<br />
• He is in essence a likable, if slightly boring man. Andy has conformed<br />
to society’s expectations. Is he the kind of man that Joe (in Winners)<br />
might have become if he had lived?<br />
• He is weak in not standing up to the old woman.<br />
• He doesn’t rock the boat; instead he accedes to the wishes of Hannah<br />
and Mrs Wilson as he seeks a quiet life.<br />
• He has inherited the position previously held by Mr Wilson. ‘And yet<br />
by all accounts the civilist and decentest wee man you could meet.’<br />
DRAMA 19
20<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Andy has inherited his role in the world from the previous<br />
generation. He has become the victim of imposed propriety.<br />
• We clearly see that he is not a passionate man. He is pleasantly<br />
surprised when Hannah pounces.<br />
• Right at the start of the play he is unhappy with the way things turned<br />
out in his relationship with Hannah. Their relationship has become a<br />
dysfunctional one; as dysfunctional as Mr and Mrs Wilson’s had been.<br />
• The style of Andy’s narration is direct contrast to the style used by the<br />
Commentators (in Winners). The function of the narration is similar –<br />
to provide lots of biographical information and propel the action of<br />
the play forwards. Andy’s style, however, is informal, intimate and<br />
anecdotal. His narration is a form of theatrical alienation. By using<br />
this device Friel breaks away from the convention of traditional<br />
proscenium arch productions. ‘The fourth wall’ is crossed as Andy<br />
engages in eye contact with the audience and we (the audience) are<br />
therefore aware that we are in the theatre watching a story unfold.<br />
The fact that the story is being told to us in the past tense accentuates<br />
the alienation effect. This alienation effect doesn’t strictly adhere to<br />
the model used, for example, by Bertold Brecht. His actors would<br />
have come out of character to speak to the audience.<br />
• This extract immediately introduces us to Andy’s predicament. He<br />
starts the play isolated, isolated from his wife and mother-in-law. He<br />
is married but not happily so. The failure of Andy and Hannah’s<br />
relationship is not in doubt right from the beginning.<br />
Hannah<br />
• Friel’s notes on Hannah are also quite specific. ‘She is in her late<br />
forties. She works in a local shirt factory, lives alone with her invalid<br />
mother, and until Andy came on the scene had not been out with a<br />
man for over twenty years. And this sudden injection of romance into<br />
a life that seemed to be rigidly and permanently patterned has<br />
transformed a plain spinster into an almost attractive woman. With<br />
Andy she is warm: with her mother she reverts to waspishness.’<br />
• Hannah has had little experience of men. She rarely saw her father as<br />
he worked night shifts. She is uncomfortable with Andy partly because<br />
she doesn’t know how to cope with being alone with him.<br />
• Like Andy, Mag and Joe, she too has suffered from being isolated. She<br />
has dutifully looked after her mother and in the process she has<br />
sacrificed her independence and personal happiness.<br />
• Her choices have been restricted due to the expectations of the<br />
community that she lives in. Her religious upbringing has reinforced<br />
this expectation. Guilt can be debilitating, and we see the effects it<br />
has on Hannah. Until Andy came on the scene she must have been a<br />
very lonely woman.<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• She communicates her frustration in this Extract. She is angry with<br />
the position she has been forced into, yet she is unwilling to make<br />
the brave decision to do anything about her predicament.<br />
• Friel paints a positive, assertive picture of Hannah in this Extract.<br />
When the audience first meets her she is going through a renaissance<br />
in her personality. She has made the most of her appearance and in<br />
this Extract she displays a feisty eagerness to escape her ‘prison’.<br />
• She is in love. She is very passionate, and we see her take the<br />
initiative in the kissing sequence. Her approach to the kissing and<br />
courting comes across as quite comical on the one hand, yet tragic on<br />
the other. Here is a middle-aged couple who are made to feel guilty<br />
about kissing and courting in the room below Hannah’s mother’s<br />
bedroom. Indeed their cunning plan to allay the old woman’s<br />
suspicious mind emphasises this sense of guilt at doing something as<br />
innocent as kissing. It is important to note that kissing is all that is<br />
indicated in the love-making sequences. The script does not indicate<br />
anything more than kissing. Their sense of propriety would not have<br />
allowed this particular middle-aged couple to go any further.<br />
Illustrates central themes and issues<br />
• Frustrated love: A couple who suffer from the kind of repression that<br />
Andy and Hannah suffer from cannot have a healthy love. Andy and<br />
Hannah have a dysfunctional marriage. We discover this in Andy’s<br />
opening monologue. Andy takes us backwards in time to show us why<br />
this has happened. Hannah has to look after her invalid mother. She<br />
has conformed to society’s expectations. If Hannah was to put her<br />
invalid mother into a home she would suffer from guilt and society’s<br />
disapproval would compound this feeling. This is a complex<br />
predicament. Hannah is bound to feel very mixed emotions. This is<br />
her mother, the woman who gave her life and brought her up in the<br />
Catholic faith. She would have been all too aware of her<br />
responsibilities and of the sanctity of the family. She is also bound in<br />
some ways to be very close to her mother; after all she rarely saw<br />
much of her father when he was alive. Her mother would have had a<br />
big influence in her formative years. Indeed you could almost say she<br />
brought Hannah up single-handedly. Hannah does feel trapped<br />
however. She has become a martyr to the needs of her mother and is<br />
weary and tired. We know that she has not had a man in her life for<br />
over twenty years. She is in love with Andy and doesn’t want to lose<br />
him. She wants time to be alone with him and to be loved. She is in<br />
her late forties. There could not have been many eligible bachelors in<br />
this community and Andy represents a reasonably good catch. He is<br />
of the same social class as Hannah. He has a job as a joiner. He has his<br />
own cottage. Andy is pleasantly surprised by Hannah’s strength of<br />
DRAMA 21
22<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
feeling for him. He wants to marry Hannah and settle down in his<br />
cottage, ‘Riverview’. He doesn’t like Mrs Wilson. She drives a wedge<br />
between him and Hannah. He reluctantly acquiesces to Mrs Wilson’s<br />
wishes but is clearly uncomfortable at being made to go through the<br />
ritual of the Rosary every night. Andy and Hannah are frustrated every<br />
time Mrs Wilson’s bell rings. They rarely get the opportunity to be<br />
alone. As soon as they get passionate they are interrupted. This<br />
happens regularly.<br />
• Frustrated Christianity: They worship (in Andy’s case he is forced to<br />
worship) a plaster-cast saint. St Philomena represents the Church.<br />
The ritual of placing St Philomena at the heart of the proceedings<br />
when they go through the ritual of the Rosary highlights Cissy and<br />
Mrs Wilson’s dependency on ‘Churchianity’ 1 . The references to Father<br />
Payton’s dogmatic maxims further help to point up their dependency<br />
on Churchianity. Cissy and Mrs Wilson use their Churchianity as a<br />
powerful weapon to maintain the status quo and keep the moral high<br />
ground. Andy and Hannah are not shown any kind of warmth,<br />
understanding or caring Christianity by Cissy or Mrs Wilson. They<br />
consequently suffer from the harshness of a cold, calculated, brutal,<br />
dogmatic and inflexible Christianity.<br />
• Uncertainty about the future: We clearly see as we go back in time<br />
that Hannah wanted to break free from her mother yet couldn’t find a<br />
way of achieving this aim. Andy wanted her to break free also. He<br />
wanted her to be his wife and for them to lead their own life without<br />
interference. But he lacked the strength of character to give Hannah<br />
an ultimatum. Andy conformed to society’s mores as much as Hannah<br />
did. The uncertainty of their future only becomes certainty in<br />
hindsight. Andy’s narration indicates a bleak future as far as his<br />
relationship with Hannah is concerned. They will still be married out<br />
of propriety, but they will not enjoy the passionate relationship they<br />
once knew.<br />
• The inevitability of repression: Hannah conforms to society’s<br />
expectations and is unable to escape her predicament. Andy is unable<br />
to show Hannah a way out. They are both trapped. They are not in<br />
control of their destiny. They are obliged to forgo their own<br />
happiness out of duty.<br />
• Moral responsibility: Hannah is all too aware of her moral<br />
responsibilities. Society expects her to put the needs of her widowed,<br />
invalid mother before her own.<br />
1 Churchianity is a frustrated view of Christianity as perceived by certain narrowminded<br />
clergymen and their followers.<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• Overbearing rigidity and domination of a restrictive environment:<br />
The play opens with Andy sitting in the gloomy back yard. This is an<br />
immediate indication that he is trying to escape from a restrictive<br />
environment. The scene in the kitchen, the room which is under Mrs<br />
Wilson’s bedroom, is a further visual reminder that they are caught<br />
up in such an environment. This is Mrs Wilson’s house. As long as<br />
Andy and Hannah live under her roof they have to put up with her<br />
rules and her sense of propriety.<br />
• The influence of the Catholic religion: Mrs Wilson is a deeply<br />
religious, pious, old woman. Andy informs us that she gathers Cissy,<br />
Hannah and himself around her bed every night at ten to say the<br />
Rosary. Mrs Wilson’s has her shrine to St Philomena. Her bedroom<br />
has been turned into a place of worship. There are flowers. There are<br />
candles which are lit each night when she goes through the Rosary.<br />
Andy’s portrayal of Mrs Wilson depicts a woman who is dogmatic,<br />
authoritarian and inflexible.<br />
• Hope: In this extract we see that Hannah longs to be free from her<br />
mother. She wants to escape from her ‘prison’. Andy in turn wants to<br />
be master in his own home.<br />
• Imposed divisions: Andy is exiled to the back yard. Mrs Wilson has her<br />
‘centre of operations’ upstairs. Thus Mrs Wilson comes between Andy<br />
and Hannah.<br />
Why would this Extract be important in your production of<br />
the play?<br />
• Will you retain Friel’s non-naturalistic setting? He recommends that<br />
the acting area has three equal divisions. Would this work in your<br />
intended theatre, studio or acting space? If so, how would this work?<br />
If not, then what type of staging will you use? Why?<br />
• How will this staging further develop and demonstrate your<br />
directorial concepts as outlined in Winners? Will your directorial<br />
concepts be the same or will they be different for Losers?<br />
• As a director how will you establish the mood of the opening<br />
sequence with Andy and the binoculars?<br />
• What do you want the audience to think and feel as they see Andy<br />
sitting staring at a brick wall? How will you get across Andy’s isolation?<br />
• How will you want the audience to feel towards Andy? How will this<br />
affect the acting of this character? Is Andy a complex character? Do<br />
DRAMA 23
24<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
you want the audience to have any sympathy for him and his<br />
predicament? How will you get your actor to portray the comedic<br />
elements of this scene? Andy has a number of monologues. How will<br />
you get the actor who portrays Andy to deliver these?<br />
• How will you want the audience to feel towards Hannah? How will<br />
this affect the acting of this character? Is Hannah a complex character?<br />
Do you want the audience to have any sympathy for Hannah’s<br />
predicament? If so, how will you elicit this sympathy from the<br />
audience? How will you get the actress to portray the comedic<br />
elements of this scene? How will you get the actress to communicate<br />
Hannah’s frustration and resentment at being a skivvy to her mother?<br />
• What kind of relationship between Andy and Hannah would you want<br />
the actors to create?<br />
• How will you show the contrast between Andy and Hannah?<br />
• How will you get across the theme of frustrated love?<br />
• How will you get across the ubiquitous ‘presence’ of Mrs Wilson even<br />
though she is not in the scene?<br />
• How will you create the imposed divisions between Mrs Wilson<br />
upstairs and Andy and Hannah downstairs?<br />
• How will you communicate the restrictive, repressive, environment of<br />
Mrs Wilson’s house and back yard?<br />
• How will you get across the changing moods in this Extract?<br />
• How will you build and realise the dramatic tension in this Extract?<br />
• How will you get across the importance of the Catholic religion in the<br />
play?<br />
• How will you convey the warped nature of Christianity as portrayed in<br />
Losers?<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Notes<br />
DRAMA 25
26<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Losers<br />
Extract Two<br />
(pages 61-67)<br />
Why would this Extract be important in any production of<br />
the play?<br />
Develops plot<br />
• Cissy makes an entrance. She has a ‘proprietary air’ in Mrs Wilson’s<br />
house.<br />
• Cissy has arrived to go through the nightly ritual of the Rosary.<br />
• Hannah is despondent about being trapped and having to look after<br />
her mother.<br />
• Andy offers to let Mrs Wilson live with him and Hannah in his cottage<br />
when they get married.<br />
• Hannah rejects his offer. She indicates that she wants to be free from<br />
the burden of caring for her mother.<br />
• Andy’s suggestions of ‘hospitalisation’ for Mrs Wilson and ‘residency<br />
in a home run by the Nazareth nuns’ are both rejected by Hannah.<br />
Hannah reveals that her mother is ‘. . . not sick enough for hospital’<br />
and that Mrs Wilson would be unhappy at being looked after by this<br />
particular order of nuns.<br />
• Hannah hints to Andy that he should live under Mrs Wilson’s roof.<br />
• Andy completely rejects this suggestion. Their situation seems futile.<br />
• Andy consoles Hannah as she dissolves into tears. This leads to a<br />
passionate courting session which is interrupted once more by Mrs<br />
Wilson’s bell. Both of them air their anger and frustration at this<br />
untimely intrusion.<br />
• We are introduced to Mrs Wilson. She is not quite what we expected.<br />
She is ‘a tiny woman’; ‘She looks angelic’.<br />
• We soak in the atmosphere of Mrs Wilson’s bedroom. The bedroom<br />
has been turned into a place of worship. There is a make-shift altar,<br />
there is a statue of St Philomena and the candles get lit.<br />
• We see Mrs Wilson take charge of the ritual of the Rosary.<br />
• We see Andy’s discomfiture at having to go through with the pretence<br />
that this is a meaningful and spiritual ritual.<br />
DRAMA 27
28<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Further illustrates central themes and issues<br />
• Frustrated love: Hannah and Andy get little opportunity to be alone<br />
or to have the same kind of romantic courtship as any other couple.<br />
Their time together is constantly interrupted by Cissy’s nightly visits<br />
and Mrs Wilson’s bell whenever she wants attention or if she is<br />
suspicious of what Andy and Hannah are up to downstairs. Hannah<br />
doesn’t want to take up Andy’s offer of having Mrs Wilson to live in<br />
his cottage because she knows that her mother will not settle for<br />
anything less than being the head of the house in her own home. But<br />
this in turn gives Mrs Wilson continued influence and power over<br />
Andy and Hannah. Andy doesn’t want to be caught in this particular<br />
trap. A future in Mrs Wilson’s household would be one of servitude<br />
and strict adherence to Mrs Wilson’s social and religious doctrines.<br />
• Frustrated Christianity: Mrs Wilson uses the ritual of the Rosary to<br />
extend her control and dominance over Andy and Hannah. We see<br />
her manipulate Andy and Hannah. We don’t see any real comforting<br />
communion or fellowship between caring Christians. We do see Andy<br />
being forced to take part in the Rosary. We witness a lack of truthful<br />
spirituality. The proceedings are a sham.<br />
• Uncertainty about the future: If Hannah won’t live at ‘Riverview’ and<br />
Andy won’t live at Mrs Wilson’s, this raises the question, ‘What kind of<br />
future do they have?’ Until Andy arrived on the scene Hannah’s future<br />
was one of drudgery. Now she has a golden opportunity to escape<br />
this sort of life, but she is not able to see a way forward out of her<br />
predicament.<br />
• The inevitability of repression: Andy and Hannah are forced to go<br />
through the ritual of the Rosary. Although Andy isn’t happy at<br />
participating in this particular charade each night, he does so for a<br />
quiet life. His rhetoric downstairs does not match his actions once he<br />
is in Mrs Wilson’s lair. We see the influence that Mrs Wilson exerts.<br />
Mrs Wilson is depicted as dogmatic and authoritarian. We begin to<br />
appreciate the kind of hold that Mrs Wilson has over her daughter<br />
when we see how she treats her in this particular scene.<br />
• Moral responsibility: Although Hannah ‘. . . clumps around the room,<br />
doing her chores with an ungracious vigour and with obvious ill-will’,<br />
she does do them. Hannah has been aware of her moral<br />
responsibilities ever since she was born. She hasn’t abandoned her<br />
mother although she does have good reason to. She is trapped.<br />
• Over-bearing rigidity and domination of a restrictive environment:<br />
Mrs Wilson’s bedroom is representative of this kind of environment.<br />
Andy is very uncomfortable at being in this room. He is forced to<br />
accept Mrs Wilson’s dictates and must go through the Rosary ritual.<br />
He feels hemmed in by the two old women. Hannah likewise is<br />
affected by this environment. She waits on her mother and is forced<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
to set the room up as a place of worship and ‘fellowship’. Mrs Wilson<br />
insists that there is an order for everything that happens in her house<br />
and in her bedroom in particular.<br />
• The influence of the Catholic religion: Mrs Wilson insists on the<br />
nightly ritual of the Rosary. She has created a place of worship with<br />
visual reminders of her faith. Mrs Wilson blindly follows her faith and<br />
continually expresses her devotion to St Philomena. She has latched<br />
on to the teachings of Father Peyton and recites his maxims ad<br />
nauseam. Her mantra – ‘The family that prays together stays together’<br />
– is a constant reminder to Hannah of her duty in the eyes of the<br />
Church.<br />
• Imposed divisions: Mrs Wilson as matriarch continually works at<br />
driving a wedge between Andy and Hannah. She has imposed her<br />
own exile to the inner sanctum of her bedroom. Her bedroom is<br />
above the kitchen and its position in the house has symbolic religious<br />
overtones – up above is the kingdom of heaven. Throughout their<br />
exchanges Andy and Hannah physically have to look up above. This<br />
reinforces Mrs Wilson’s status as well as her apparent ‘goodness’. Mrs<br />
Wilson has the moral high ground in the eyes of the community and<br />
the Church.<br />
Develops characters and relationships<br />
Cissy<br />
• Friel’s notes on Cissy are clearly stated just before her entrance: ‘Cissy<br />
is a small, frail wisp of a woman in her late sixties. She lives next door,<br />
is a daily visitor, and because of the close friendship between herself<br />
and Mrs Wilson she has a proprietary air in the house. A lifetime spent<br />
lisping pious platitudes has robbed them of all meaning. The sickly<br />
piousity she exudes is patently false.’<br />
• Cissy is obviously an unlikable, cold, waspish character. We are not<br />
meant to like her or empathise with her position.<br />
• She is most certainly a symbolic representation of the restrictive,<br />
repressive, rural Irish society in which Andy and Hannah both live.<br />
• She is supposedly a devout Christian yet she shows no warmth or<br />
kindness towards Andy or Hannah. On the contrary, she compounds<br />
the guilt that Hannah feels as she reminds Hannah of the needs of her<br />
poor, sickly mother who is all alone in the world. Cissy doesn’t offer<br />
any moral support to Hannah and her role emphasises the irony that<br />
Hannah lives in a devout Catholic community which has condemned<br />
her to a lonely, empty life.<br />
• Friel points out that Cissy is a shallow character. Here is a woman<br />
who constantly gives her thanks to God yet has forgotten the basic<br />
lessons of the Bible. She shows no Christianity in her relationship<br />
DRAMA 29
30<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
with Andy and Hannah. She does, however, conform to a narrow view<br />
of Christianity. She visits Mrs Wilson every night at 10 o’clock for the<br />
Rosary. This has become a routine. She is expected to do this out of<br />
propriety. She doesn’t cheer Mrs Wilson up or try to confront Mrs<br />
Wilson’s unreasonable behaviour.<br />
• She adds to the gloom of the repressive environment of Mrs Wilson’s<br />
bedroom.<br />
• She blindly supports Mrs Wilson, and Friel uses her to point up the<br />
hierarchy of the status of each of the women. Mrs Wilson has the<br />
highest status, then Cissy as an elderly friend and neighbour, then<br />
Hannah. Andy as the outsider (and a man) has the lowest status in<br />
this female-dominated environment.<br />
Mrs Wilson<br />
• Friel’s notes on Mrs Wilson are also clearly stated: ‘Like Cissy, she is a<br />
tiny woman, with a sweet, patient, invalid’s smile. Her voice is soft<br />
and commanding. Her silver hair is drawn back from her face and tied<br />
with a blue ribbon behind her head. She looks angelic.’<br />
• This is not quite the vision that we expect. The impression we get of<br />
this formidable woman right from the beginning of Losers is supplied<br />
by Andy. He informs us that Mrs Wilson ‘keeps Hannah on the hop’<br />
for little reason other than to exert her authority and position. Andy<br />
paints a cynical picture of a pious old woman who is suspicious and<br />
manipulative. This description is confirmed once we eventually see<br />
Mrs Wilson and watch her interact with the other characters.<br />
• In truth Mrs Wilson is frightened of losing Hannah and of being left<br />
an isolated, lonely old woman. She doesn’t want Andy to take Hannah<br />
away from her. She doesn’t want to leave the home that she has lived<br />
in all her married life. Her house is her power base. She is<br />
comfortable there and can do as she pleases. As long as she lives<br />
there she is the one who is in control and can thus exert power over<br />
Andy and Hannah. Morally they have to conform to her wishes. This<br />
is perhaps why she feigns illness. As long as she overplays her ‘illness’<br />
she has a stronger hold on Hannah.<br />
• Mrs Wilson is a symbolic representation of the Catholic church. She is<br />
the embodiment of Mother Church. Friel uses this character to<br />
convey the influence that the Catholic church has in this religious<br />
community. We also see the blind obedience that Mother Church<br />
commands from her followers. Mrs Wilson’s demanding illness is an<br />
indication of the unbearable weight of responsibility that the Church<br />
can put on people in the name of religion.<br />
• Mrs Wilson echoes the guilt feelings the Church can elicit from each<br />
individual conscience, the restrictions these impose, the rituals, the<br />
unquestioning belief that all true followers of the Catholic faith<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
should have, the rigid adherence to church laws and papal edicts, the<br />
obligations, devotions and traditions.<br />
• Mrs Wilson selects the elements of her faith that she needs to assert<br />
her dominance. She hides behind the platitudes of righteous and<br />
saintly living.<br />
• She deliberately and powerfully suppresses Hannah and Andy as they<br />
threaten her comfortable status quo.<br />
• Her chief ally is Cissy. Cissy is subservient to Mrs Wilson. This<br />
reinforces what one would expect from the older generation, blind<br />
obedience to the Catholic faith. Remember Cissy symbolises a pious,<br />
repressive community and her relationship with Mrs Wilson (who<br />
symbolises the power and influence of the Church) has wider<br />
significance than that of two lonely, cynical and bitter old women.<br />
The combined force and influence of these two women proves too<br />
much for Andy and Hannah to overcome.<br />
• It is ironic that this embodiment of Christianity shows so little charity,<br />
mercy or Christianity towards Hannah or Andy. Mrs Wilson is utterly<br />
selfish and self-centred.<br />
Andy<br />
• This Extract emphasises the futility of Andy’s position.<br />
• His solutions to Hannah’s problems with her mother are rejected.<br />
• He lacks the strength of character to give Hannah any kind of<br />
ultimatum.<br />
• He doesn’t stand up to Cissy or Mrs Wilson.<br />
• He conforms to society’s expectations.<br />
• He knows that he has to keep on the right side of Mrs Wilson as he is<br />
not a match for her; he is not brave enough, he is not energetic<br />
enough and he is not articulate enough.<br />
Hannah<br />
• This Extract also emphasises the futility of Hannah’s position.<br />
• She is at a low ebb and clearly worn out from all the running around<br />
that she has to do.<br />
• She rejects Andy’s solutions to her predicament as she cannot ignore<br />
her mother’s needs.<br />
• She is unable to rise above society’s expectations of a loving<br />
daughter.<br />
• She wants to be free from the drudgery of her life in her mother’s<br />
house, yet she is unable to make the difficult decision to abandon her<br />
mother.<br />
DRAMA 31
32<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Why would this Extract be important in your production of<br />
the play?<br />
• How does this key Extract develop your overall directorial<br />
interpretation?<br />
• As a director how do you feel Cissy should be portrayed? Is she a<br />
complex character or a caricature? How will she make her entrance?<br />
How will you want the audience to feel towards her? How will all<br />
these aspects affect the acting of this character?<br />
• How will you establish Cissy’s status in this Extract?<br />
• Who is made to feel an outsider? Why? How will you show this?<br />
• How will you build the tension between Cissy and Andy?<br />
• How will you show Hannah’s frustration in this Extract?<br />
• As a director, how do you want Andy and Hannah to relate to each<br />
other in this Extract?<br />
• How will you handle the passionate embrace between Andy and<br />
Hannah this time? What do you want the audience to feel by the end<br />
of this sequence?<br />
• As a director how do you feel Mrs Wilson should be portrayed? Is she<br />
a complex character or a caricature? How will you want the audience<br />
to feel towards her? How will these aspects affect the acting of this<br />
character?<br />
• What kind of relationship does Hannah have with her mother? How<br />
will you get your actors to communicate this relationship to the<br />
audience?<br />
• What kind of relationship does Andy have with Mrs Wilson? How will<br />
you get your actor to communicate this?<br />
• What kind of atmosphere will you create in Mrs Wilson’s bedroom?<br />
How will you achieve this?<br />
• How will you show the dominance and status of the different<br />
characters?<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• What design elements would help you highlight the moods and<br />
tensions within this Extract?<br />
• What design elements will you use to show that this bedroom has<br />
been transformed into a sacred place of worship?<br />
• How will you show Andy’s discomfiture in this Extract?<br />
Notes<br />
DRAMA 33
34<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Losers<br />
Extract Three<br />
(pages 68-77)<br />
Why might this Extract be important in your production of<br />
the play?<br />
Develops plot<br />
• We have returned to Andy in his sanctuary in the back yard. He has<br />
brought us back to the present to give us further anecdotes and he<br />
prepares us for the climax of the play. He gives us a blow-by-blow<br />
account of his downfall. He reveals that things started to go wrong for<br />
him as soon as he got married. For starters he was hoodwinked into<br />
moving into Mrs Wilson’s house after his honeymoon was over.<br />
• Andy reveals that one of the reasons that he got married was to<br />
dodge being sent to Northern Ireland by his firm.<br />
• Andy reveals that he noticed a big change in his relationship with<br />
Hannah as soon as they got married. ‘The spirit seemed to drain out<br />
of her from the very beginning.’<br />
• Andy gives an insight into his married life and we cannot help but<br />
compare this to the earlier passionate courting sequences. It is ironic<br />
that once they get married Mrs Wilson only rings her bell when Andy<br />
and Hannah start to speak. When they were courting she would ring<br />
her bell if there was a long silence! We get the impression that Andy<br />
and Hannah’s marriage has become one of long silences.<br />
• Andy reveals that when he initially moved into Mrs Wilson’s house he<br />
refused to join in the nightly ritual of the Rosary. This was his protest<br />
at not being in his rightful place, in his own home, ‘Riverview’. He<br />
reveals that Mrs Wilson is not happy with this protest.<br />
• Andy reveals that he made a mess of exacting his revenge on Mrs<br />
Wilson once he discovered that the Vatican proclaimed that there<br />
should be no further devotions to St Philomena. He got drunk and<br />
‘bollixed it’. This sets us up for the big confrontation between Andy<br />
and the women. The fact that he has warned us about what is about to<br />
be shown increases the dramatic tension and provides further<br />
dramatic irony.<br />
DRAMA 35
36<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
• We go back in time to the moment just before Andy returns home. It<br />
is 10.30pm and a late time of the night for Andy to be out. This in<br />
itself is uncharacteristic of Andy. Hannah is very worried about Andy.<br />
‘She has been crying for some time.’<br />
• Cissy and Mrs Wilson try to comfort Hannah. They start the Rosary.<br />
• We hear Andy before he makes his drunken entrance into Mrs<br />
Wilson’s bedroom. The women are horrified by this lapse of character<br />
and by Andy’s transformation.<br />
• The alcohol has freed Andy from his inhibitions. He is rude and<br />
offensive. He confronts his tormentors and desecrates Mrs Wilson’s<br />
place of worship. We have reached the hilariously comical climax of<br />
the play and revel in Andy’s bluntness, his rudeness and his vulgarity.<br />
• The women escape to Cissy’s house. Hannah’s parting words sound<br />
very ominous. ‘You’ll regret this day as long as you live!’ ‘By God,<br />
he’ll pay for this!’<br />
• Andy takes us back to the point in time that the play started. He hints<br />
at what could have been when he informs us that he has tenants in his<br />
cottage, a retired accountant and his wife. He paints a romantic<br />
picture of this couple who have ‘rose trees in the front and vegetables<br />
in the back’. He on the other hand sits in a gloomy back yard and<br />
‘kills an hour or two’. He has lots of time to kill. He has been<br />
ostracised by the three women, they have not forgiven him his past<br />
sins. Andy reveals that he once more takes part in the nightly ritual of<br />
the Rosary. There is no likelihood that things will change in the<br />
foreseeable future.<br />
• Andy reveals that Hannah no longer sleeps with him. She sleeps in<br />
Mrs Wilson’s bedroom in case her mother takes ill during the night.<br />
Andy and Hannah’s marriage has become a dysfunctional one.<br />
• Andy’s life has become one of passive acceptance.<br />
• Mrs Wilson has managed to stay in her own house with her daughter<br />
still waiting on her hand and foot. Her son-in-law is kept in his place<br />
and she is in overall control. ‘The family that prays together stays<br />
together.’<br />
• As the play comes to an end we once again question the irony of the<br />
title of each half. All four lovers have the will to live and love, but all<br />
of them are set against circumstances that frustrate them. These<br />
circumstances are all representations of everyday repression and it is<br />
the individual who suffers. Do Mag and Joe escape the fate of Andy<br />
and Hannah?<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Further illustrates central themes and issues<br />
• Frustrated love: We know that Andy and Hannah’s relationship is<br />
doomed as soon as Andy reveals that he was persuaded to live in Mrs<br />
Wilson’s house. We question the true depth of Andy’s love when he<br />
reveals that a big reason for marrying Hannah was to avoid being sent<br />
to Belfast. His relationship with Hannah changed as soon as they got<br />
married. ‘But somehow the spirit seemed to drain out of her from the<br />
very beginning.’ This is an ominous sign and indicates that the<br />
passion they had was to disappear. Once they were married Hannah<br />
did not show the same intensity of anger towards her mother.<br />
• Frustrated Christianity: The fallibility of the Catholic church, as<br />
exemplified in the relegation of St Philomena, highlights the<br />
pointlessness of some of the outdated rituals. Mrs Wilson and Cissy’s<br />
strict adherence to their very narrow view of Christianity conjures up<br />
the medieval view of ‘Heaven and Hell’. Their Christianity has been<br />
made a thing of drudgery not love.<br />
• Uncertainty about the future: Uncertainty has become certainty. We<br />
know that there is little likelihood of any significant change in Andy’s<br />
circumstances. Mrs Wilson could go on for many years. So Andy<br />
returns to his refuge and stares at a brick wall to kill time. He doesn’t<br />
even share the same bed as Hannah. This is a bleak future for both<br />
Andy and Hannah.<br />
• The inevitability of repression: As soon as Andy disgraces himself he<br />
contributes to his own demise and his repression is complete.<br />
Hannah has the justification that she needs to side with her mother<br />
and conform to the loving daughter role that is demanded of her. She<br />
has the moral high ground. She is disgusted by Andy’s crass, vulgar<br />
behaviour. She returns to her mother with a clear and righteous<br />
conscience. The irony of course is that she has played into the hands<br />
of her mother. Hannah’s repression is complete. She continues her<br />
life of servitude.<br />
• Moral responsibility: Divorce is not an option for Andy. He conforms<br />
to the role of a supportive husband. His life has become one of quiet<br />
acceptance. Hannah continues with her obligation to look after her<br />
mother.<br />
• Overbearing rigidity and domination of a restrictive environment:<br />
Andy has no chance of being freed from Mrs Wilson’s house as long as<br />
she lives. He no longer has Hannah as an ally. She has sided with her<br />
mother and Cissy. Hannah now helps Mrs Wilson to impose her rigid<br />
and restrictive regime. Andy will follow the example of Mr Wilson<br />
before him.<br />
• The influence of the Catholic religion: The devotion to St Philomena<br />
stops, Father Peyton no longer gets mentioned by name, but Mrs<br />
Wilson ‘still has the altar and she still lights the candles and has the<br />
DRAMA 37
38<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
flowers in the middle’. We end the play with the clear affirmation that<br />
the enduring and pervading influence of the Catholic church<br />
continues to have a firm grip on Andy.<br />
• Hope: Andy has his dreams. The cosy picture that he paints of the<br />
accountant and his wife reflects what he wants for himself.<br />
• Imposed divisions: Hannah now sleeps in her mother’s bedroom.<br />
Andy sleeps alone.<br />
Develops characters and relationships<br />
Andy<br />
• Andy reveals that he is a pragmatist rather than a romantic when he<br />
informs us that one of the reasons he married Hannah was to avoid<br />
being sent to Belfast.<br />
• Andy is easily duped by Hannah and her mother. He doesn’t take a<br />
stand against going back to Mrs Wilson’s house after his honeymoon.<br />
• His monologue at the beginning of this Extract consolidates his role<br />
as the outsider.<br />
• His relationship with Hannah has changed. He is now a lonely,<br />
ostracised middle-aged man who would have been happier remaining<br />
a bachelor and living in his own cottage.<br />
• Andy manages to have one chance to get back at his mother-in-law.<br />
He is given the ideal ammunition to use. He lacks the moral fibre to<br />
reveal his devastating news about St Philomena in a sober state. His<br />
glorious drunken attack provides the climax of the play and proves to<br />
be his undoing.<br />
Hannah<br />
• We see Hannah in a state of distress at the beginning of this Extract.<br />
She is worried about her husband. She is given moral support by her<br />
mother and Cissy. ‘Trite words of consolation are being spoken. And<br />
one gets the sense of feminine solidarity and of suffering<br />
womanhood.’<br />
• Once she realises that Andy is drunk she is devastated. In her eyes<br />
Andy has descended to the depths of depravity and his moral decay<br />
has an instant effect.<br />
• She sides with her mother against Andy. She can now justifiably do<br />
this with a clear and righteous conscience.<br />
• Our final stage picture of Hannah is one of an unattractive, cold<br />
woman who has lost any passionate interest in her husband. ‘Her<br />
coldness is withering.’<br />
• We are reminded of her earlier courtship when Andy offered her the<br />
clove rock. Her rejection of his peace offering is symbolic of the<br />
emptiness of their married life.<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Mrs Wilson<br />
• Whilst Hannah is in despair over Andy’s lateness and subsequent<br />
drunken behaviour, Mrs Wilson takes control of the situation.<br />
• She momentarily loses her composure when Andy utters his tirade<br />
against her. This is a big shift in power and control. The alcohol has<br />
liberated Andy and we are delighted at the effect that his home truths<br />
have on the tyrant who has repressed and dominated him. Now it is<br />
Mrs Wilson’s turn to be dominated and feel helpless.<br />
• The balance of power soon shifts however, and by the end of the play<br />
the status quo has been restored. Mrs Wilson has managed to secure<br />
her dominance once more. Andy can no longer avoid going upstairs<br />
to go over the Rosary and this reasserts Mrs Wilson’s position as the<br />
head of the house. ‘By God you’ve got to admire the aul’ bitch. She<br />
could handle a regiment.’<br />
Cissy<br />
• Cissy is initially in her element when she supports Hannah through<br />
her crisis.<br />
• She is shocked to the core when Andy comes home drunk. Andy’s<br />
attack on Cissy is an attack on the sensibilities of the repressive<br />
community that has helped to keep him trapped in Mrs Wilson’s<br />
house. She is shown up and put in her place. She cannot cope with<br />
Andy’s lapse in character. His attack confirms her very dim view of<br />
men.<br />
• We delight in her discomfiture. She has no defence against Andy’s<br />
brutal and vulgar attack; her only recourse is to flee to her own house<br />
with Mrs Wilson and Hannah.<br />
• By the end of the play she has regained her composure. She will<br />
never let Andy forget his degenerate behaviour. She forcibly asserts<br />
her dominance and status when she confronts Andy, ‘You robbed us<br />
of Saint Philomena but you’ll never rob us of this one, you’ll never be<br />
told who it is!’<br />
DRAMA 39
40<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Why might this Extract be important in your production of<br />
the play?<br />
• How does this Extract conclude your overall directorial<br />
interpretation of the play?<br />
• How will you build the dramatic tension prior to Andy’s drunken<br />
entrance? What is the mood that you want to create at this point?<br />
How does the mood change throughout the rest of this sequence?<br />
How will this affect the pace and delivery of the lines that each<br />
character speaks?<br />
• How will you direct the uproariously funny climax of the play?<br />
• How will you show Andy’s temporary domination of the women?<br />
• How will you want the audience to react to Andy’s drunken tirade<br />
against ‘The Dolly Sisters’?<br />
• What message do you want the audience to take away? How do you<br />
want them to feel at the end of the play? How will you achieve this?<br />
• What mood will you want to create in Andy’s final monologue? How<br />
will you achieve it?<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Notes<br />
DRAMA 41
42<br />
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
DRAMA
OVERALL DIRECTORIAL INTERPRETATION AND DRAMATIC COMMENTARY<br />
Note on the Rosary<br />
There are many references to the Rosary in Losers. The following<br />
explanatory notes are given to enable you to appreciate the significance<br />
this ritual has in the context of the play.<br />
The Rosary is a form of religious meditation in which a sequence of<br />
prayers is recited using a string of beads or a knotted cord, each bead or<br />
knot representing one prayer in the sequence. The sequence of one Our<br />
Father, ten Hail Marys and one Glory be to the Father constitutes a<br />
decade of the Rosary repeated fifteen times in the full version or five<br />
times in the shorter version. Each decade is associated with a particular<br />
‘Mystery’ or meditation on an aspect of the life of Christ or the Virgin<br />
Mary. The prayer sequence dates from the fifteenth century. The fifteen<br />
mysteries are:<br />
Five Joyful Mysteries<br />
- the Annunciation<br />
- the Visitation<br />
- the Nativity<br />
- the Presentation<br />
- finding the child Jesus in the Temple<br />
Five Sorrowful Mysteries<br />
- the Agony in the Garden<br />
- the Scourging at the Pillar<br />
- the Crown of Thorns<br />
- the Carrying of the Cross<br />
- the Crucifixion<br />
Five Glorious Mysteries<br />
- the Resurrection<br />
- the Ascension<br />
- Pentecost<br />
- the Assumption<br />
- the Coronation of Our Lady in Heaven<br />
DRAMA 43
44<br />
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
Acting roles<br />
DRAMA<br />
SECTION B<br />
Mag<br />
A strong female role well suited to a young actress. The danger with the<br />
portrayal of this character is that it is all too easy to show her mood<br />
swings and fall into the trap of presenting a two-dimensional character<br />
by over-acting. Mag is a complex character. The actress should<br />
endeavour to show her hidden depths. Mag is a lively, vibrant character<br />
and there is plenty of opportunity to use movement to get across her<br />
changing moods. Movement could also be used to good effect in the<br />
sequences where she uses mimicry to get back at her oppressors.<br />
Ideally, Mag should have an Irish accent. The language Mag uses in the<br />
play adds to her appeal as it is full of romantic imagery and has a likable,<br />
Irish quality to it.There is a great deal of humour in the lines that Mag<br />
delivers. Mag’s lines also demonstrate her maddening contradictions as<br />
well as her insecurity. Her assertions may well be irksome at times, and<br />
there is evidence of an immature Mag. However, we do also gain a<br />
sympathetic view of her when she reveals her naive, fretful, innermost<br />
thoughts. Mag and Joe are in love. The actress has to be able to convey<br />
this powerful emotion. There are many occasions in the play where this<br />
could be demonstrated through close physical contact. The actress has<br />
to feel comfortable with this and not show any kind of embarrassment.<br />
Mag wants to be loved and cared for by Joe and to know that he will not<br />
abandon her but stick by her.<br />
Joe<br />
A strong male role well suited to a young actor. The danger for the actor<br />
here is to underplay the part to the point that Joe is overshadowed by<br />
Mag. This appears to happen to a certain extent in the script. However,<br />
Joe does have plenty of opportunities to make his presence felt. Joe is a<br />
big contrast to Mag. He too is a complex character. The actor has to<br />
show his quiet bookish nature, his conformist side, his vulnerability, his<br />
insecurity; and yet the actor must also deliver the histrionic sequences<br />
where he uses mimicry to get back at his oppressors. (Joe can be as<br />
much of a madcap as Mag. This is one of the reasons why she has fallen<br />
in love with him.) The mimicry sequences are the ideal places for the<br />
actor to use a range of movement skills to create the caricatures of Mr<br />
Kerrigan, Father Kelly et al. Ideally, Joe should have an Irish accent.<br />
There are a number of very tense, angry exchanges between Joe and
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
Mag. The actor needs to convey his frustration at not being able to fulfil<br />
his ambitions. Joe loves Mag dearly and this serves as a counterbalance<br />
to the angry exchanges. The actor should be able to show the<br />
tenderness and gentleness of Joe’s feelings for Mag. The actor needs to<br />
feel comfortable with these very romantic moments in the play.<br />
Andy<br />
Comedy can look easy to pull off, but in practice it requires a delicate<br />
balance of performance skills. This role is very easily over-acted. The<br />
actor must avoid merely presenting Andy as a comical buffoon.<br />
Remember Friel states that Andy is regarded as ‘a slightly dull man’ and<br />
that he is ‘unaware of the humour in a lot of the things that he says’. If<br />
you play the role of Andy for laughs and deliver his lines as rehearsed<br />
‘gags’, then you are missing the point. In many ways Andy is quite a<br />
gentle character. He is gauche and inexperienced. He is uncomfortable<br />
in the company of women. The strained conversation between Andy and<br />
Hannah gives a clear insight into this aspect of his character. Ideally,<br />
Andy should have an Irish accent. His lines give the actor plenty of<br />
scope to use a variety of voice techniques. The actor must not overplay<br />
the comedy of his lines and ensure that due attention is given to comic<br />
timing. The difficulty for a young actor is getting across that Andy is<br />
middle-aged. This is particularly pertinent when it comes to portraying<br />
Andy in movement terms. Fifty is not old. But, it is Andy’s age that helps<br />
to work the comedy of the courting sequences. The audience is shocked<br />
and embarrassed as they don’t expect to see this middle-aged couple<br />
courting in the way that they do in the play. These sequences are<br />
certainly farcical, yet they should get the audience to consider the<br />
sadness of the ridiculous ploy that two middle-aged lovers have to use.<br />
Remember their ploy is used in order to do something as innocent as<br />
kissing. The difficulty for a young actor is to be able to deliver the<br />
balance of comedy and pathos. He needs to avoid presenting Andy as a<br />
ridiculous caricature. Andy is concerned about what others in his strict<br />
Catholic community think of him. He is a conformist. He needs these<br />
people to see him as a ‘decent’ and ‘civil’ man.<br />
Hannah<br />
A challenging female role. We have to see the change in Hannah’s<br />
character from passionate middle-aged lover and begrudging house<br />
servant to the devoted daughter, ‘the image of her mother’, who spurns<br />
her husband due to his drunken outburst. Hannah is uncomfortable in<br />
the company of men. We know in part that this is because she has had<br />
little contact with men, including her own father. We sense that her<br />
mother is suspicious of men. Ipso facto Hannah is suspicious of men.<br />
After all she has not had the attentions of a man for over twenty years.<br />
DRAMA 45
46<br />
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
(This helps to explain her awkwardness and diffident relationship with<br />
Andy near the beginning of Losers.) In all this time she has been ‘forced’<br />
to look after her invalid mother. Having met Andy she has grabbed what<br />
is possibly her last chance of romance. She is the one who takes the<br />
initiative in the courting sequences. She is desperate for love and<br />
affection. She is eager to escape her life of loneliness and daily<br />
drudgery. When we first see Hannah she sides with Andy against her<br />
mother. We see her attend her mother ‘with an ungracious vigour and<br />
obvious ill-will’. The actress playing this role has to create a believable<br />
character. This is not a two-dimensional comedy part. Hannah is of<br />
course integral to the comic action. It is the ferocity of her passionate<br />
embraces with Andy, coupled with the comic device of reciting the<br />
poem, that fuels a large chunk of the comedy in Losers. The actress<br />
must also deliver Hannah’s anger and frustration at being forced to look<br />
after her mother. Towards the end of Losers we see that passionate<br />
relationship with Andy has vanished and that ‘her coldness to him is<br />
withering’. Hannah should have an Irish accent. The exchanges between<br />
Andy and Hannah need a careful balance of timing for maximum comic<br />
effect.<br />
Mrs Wilson<br />
A very dominant female character part. She is a heightened caricature.<br />
She has an Irish accent. We start to get an impression of Mrs Wilson<br />
before we even see her. She is manipulative and has managed to have<br />
things her own way until Andy arrives on the scene and threatens her<br />
comfortable position. She uses her ‘illness’ as a weapon against Andy.<br />
The actress has to be able to portray the transparency of Mrs Wilson’s<br />
‘suffering’ as well as her steely determination to continue to have things<br />
her own way. Mrs Wilson uses religion to assert her position and<br />
dominance. She represents Mother Church. Friel paints a negative<br />
picture of Mrs Wilson, as she does with Cissy. ‘Like Cissy, she is a tiny<br />
woman, with a sweet, patient, invalid’s smile’. She is a stereotypical old<br />
widow who is frightened of being left on her own. She is in her early<br />
seventies and bedridden. She is harsh and unfeeling. Like Cissy she<br />
offers no benevolence to Andy and Hannah. This is a very good part<br />
offering humorous opportunities.<br />
Cissy<br />
A highly comic female character part. Cissy is a heightened caricature.<br />
She is a blatantly false character who exudes false piousness. Friel paints<br />
a very negative picture of Cissy. She is the symbolic representation of<br />
the straightlaced society that Andy and Hannah live in. Cissy also<br />
personifies a certain type of religious person who shows no benevolence<br />
towards her fellow men and women, especially in the case of Andy and<br />
DRAMA
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
Hannah. This is a gift of a role to an actress who can get across Cissy’s<br />
waspish, interfering nature. Cissy is a stereotypical old spinster, ‘a small,<br />
frail wisp of a woman’. She has an Irish accent. We sense that she is<br />
afraid of men and doesn’t like being in their company. She is a woman<br />
in her late sixties, close to Mrs Wilson, her chief ally. There is plenty of<br />
opportunity in this role for comic interaction with the other characters<br />
in the play. The audience relishes her reaction to Andy’s verbal attack in<br />
the drunken climax to Losers.<br />
DRAMA 47
48<br />
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
Recommended acting pieces<br />
Winners, Episode One<br />
Page reference: 14-18<br />
Opening line: JOE: ‘Come on! Cut it out, will you! That’ll do!’<br />
Closing line: MAG: ‘A holy-cost, by God.’<br />
Casting: 1 male and 1 female<br />
Characters: Mag and Joe<br />
Approximate length: 8 minutes<br />
Comments: A good scene for two actors. It offers the opportunity<br />
to use accent, movement and mimicry. This scene establishes the<br />
relationship between the young lovers, Mag and Joe. We see the<br />
contrast in their personalities and gain an insight into their<br />
predicament. Mag is pregnant. Both she and Joe have been<br />
expelled from school. They meet on the top of Ardnageeha to<br />
study for their final exams which they have been allowed to sit<br />
despite the disgrace that they have brought upon themselves. We<br />
are introduced to their oppressors: the Church, their teachers,<br />
their parents, and the people who live in their straightlaced<br />
community.<br />
DRAMA
Winners, Episode One<br />
Page reference: 21-26<br />
Opening line: MAG: ‘Joe, d’you think my legs have got thick, my<br />
body gross, my facial expression passive to dull,<br />
and my eyes lack-lustre?’<br />
Closing line: JOE: ‘What in the name of God does it mean?’<br />
Casting: 1 male and 1 female<br />
Characters: Mag and Joe<br />
Approximate length: 8 minutes<br />
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
Comments: Mag’s prattle is indicative of her insecurity. We clearly<br />
see her vulnerability as well as the love that she feels for Joe. Joe<br />
on the other hand lashes out at Mag and challenges her romantic<br />
view of the future. This reveals his confusion and anger at the<br />
prospect of being forced into marriage and becoming a father at<br />
the age of 17 when he has aspirations to do something more with<br />
his life. We see his vulnerability. Their argument is quickly curtailed<br />
as Mag pretends to go into labour. We see Mag use her false labour<br />
pains to manipulate Joe in order to exert control over him. Once<br />
Joe recovers from his shock he buries himself in his books. Mag<br />
goes back to her melodramatic tales. We finish this Episode with a<br />
picture of Joe’s conformity and Mag’s romanticism.<br />
DRAMA 49
50<br />
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
Losers, Extract One<br />
Page reference: 54-59<br />
Opening line: ANDY: ‘Well, Hannah.’<br />
Closing line: HANNAH: ‘Shut up, will you.’<br />
Casting: 1 male and 1 female<br />
Characters: Andy and Hannah<br />
Approximate length: 9 minutes<br />
Comments: This is a good comic scene for two able actors. The<br />
important thing in this Extract is to convey the diffident, awkward<br />
relationship between the middle-aged lovers. There is plenty of<br />
scope for comic action with the formality at the start contrasting<br />
with the antics on the couch. The secret in playing this scene well<br />
is to slightly underplay the comedy at the start. The timing of the<br />
lines is crucial. There is a stilted, strained quality to the dialogue to<br />
begin with, which gives way to a fast and furious pace when Andy<br />
starts to recite the poem. This sequence conveys the couple’s<br />
uncertain approach to lovemaking. They are both very<br />
uncomfortable in each other’s company. They don’t know how to<br />
have a natural conversation. Andy is clumsy and tactless. When<br />
Hannah pounces she is making the most of her opportunity as she<br />
is desperate for a little love and affection. The audience should<br />
find the extract very funny, but they should also feel pity for this<br />
couple who have had to resort to duplicity to do something as<br />
innocent as kissing.<br />
DRAMA
Losers, Extracts Two and Three<br />
Page reference: 60-67<br />
Opening line: HANNAH: ‘Look at – the invalid tray!’<br />
Closing line: OTHERS: ‘As it was in the beginning, is now and<br />
ever shall be, world without end, Amen.’<br />
Page reference: 71-75<br />
Opening line: MRS WILSON: I promise you, dear: he’s all right. I<br />
know he is.<br />
Closing line: HANNAH: ‘He’ll pay for this. By God, he’ll pay for<br />
this!’<br />
Casting: 1 male and 3 females<br />
Characters: Hannah, Andy, Cissy and Mrs Wilson<br />
Approximate length: 12 - 18 minutes<br />
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
Comments: If you combine these Extracts you have enough<br />
material to assess all four characters. In the first Extract Mrs<br />
Wilson’s part falls short of the time requirements. One possible<br />
solution to this problem is to have a brief pause and/or a blackout,<br />
to denote the passage of time, and then continue with Extract<br />
Two. Combining both Extracts gives each actor more opportunities<br />
to show a range of acting skills, especially those playing Cissy and<br />
Mrs Wilson.<br />
Pages 60-67<br />
This is a deceptively straightforward Extract. There is a variety of<br />
mood and strong contrasts among the four characters. We see the<br />
interplay between the characters and witness the stranglehold that<br />
the Church and the community have over Andy and Hannah. To<br />
begin with it is Cissy who establishes her authority and domination<br />
over Andy. We should cringe at her piousness. The hypocrisy of<br />
her character should also be evident throughout. To begin with<br />
Andy is flippant towards Cissy and tries to send her up. We see<br />
Hannah’s frustration; she is at a low ebb. The futility of Hannah and<br />
Andy’s predicament is emphasised in this Extract. Once we are in<br />
Mrs Wilson’s bedroom the Extract highlights Mrs Wilson’s<br />
domination and clearly shows the control that she exerts over<br />
Andy and Hannah.<br />
DRAMA 51
52<br />
DIRECTORY OF ACTING PIECES<br />
Pages 71-75<br />
This Extract quickly brings Losers to its uproariously funny climax.<br />
To begin with the atmosphere is very tense as Hannah frets about<br />
Andy’s lateness. We revel in Andy’s entrance and his drunken<br />
tirade. There are plenty of comic opportunities in this scene –<br />
from the exaggerated indignation and shock of the women to<br />
Andy’s uncharacteristic honesty as he delivers a few home truths<br />
with the dutch courage of alcohol. Andy’s manner is bellicose as he<br />
confronts Mrs Wilson. We see that the balance of power has<br />
switched. We enjoy watching Cissy and Mrs Wilson’s distress. Andy<br />
has won a temporary victory.<br />
DRAMA