PIETRO MARIA BARDI - THE VICARIOUS ARCHITECT: THE ... - FAU
PIETRO MARIA BARDI - THE VICARIOUS ARCHITECT: THE ... - FAU
PIETRO MARIA BARDI - THE VICARIOUS ARCHITECT: THE ... - FAU
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
1 5 th INTERNATIONAL PLANNING HISTORY SOCIETY CONFERENCE<br />
<strong>PIETRO</strong> <strong>MARIA</strong> <strong>BARDI</strong> - <strong>THE</strong> <strong>VICARIOUS</strong> <strong>ARCHITECT</strong>:<br />
<strong>THE</strong> IMPORTATION OF ITALIAN FUTURISM TO BRAZIL<br />
ANNETTE CONDELLO, PhD<br />
Department of Architecture and Interior Architecture,<br />
School of the Built Environment, Curtin University, Perth, Australia<br />
a.condello@curtin.edu.au<br />
ABSTRACT<br />
Italian-Brazilian Lina Bo Bardi’s modern architecture has received considerable<br />
attention. Her urban projects in Brazil, however, are rarely discussed as having<br />
been influenced by her husband’s thoughts. Consequently, they merit renewed<br />
critical attention through this lens. Pietro Maria Bardi’s urban experiences and<br />
architectural collaborations in pre-war Italy and Brazil informed his reflections<br />
upon Italian Futurist manifestoes and drawings. His urban novellas, criticism of<br />
Italy’s State Architecture and unrealized collaborations, specifically with Pier<br />
Luigi Nervi on E’42 in Rome for Rationalist planner Marcello Piacentini, express<br />
ways for considering the importation of the underlying Futurist design traits in<br />
Brazil. This paper illuminates the lesser-known Italian Futurist links with Lina<br />
Bo Bardi’s projects and tracks their origins to Pietro Maria Bardi. This<br />
argument draws upon Olivia de Oliveira’s interview with Lina Bo Bardi, her<br />
last. Pietro Maria Bardi was a vicarious architect and urban Futurist. He<br />
subconsciously conceptualized designs with Lina Bo Bardi within an unrestricted<br />
Futurist framework, imported from Italy and transformed in Brazil.<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
How might one discuss the origins of Sao Paulo’s Futurist architectural<br />
dimension? The Futurist aspirations found in Pietro Maria Bardi’s writings and<br />
his collaborative works with Italian engineer Pier Luigi Nervi – the E’42’s<br />
pavilions for Rationalist planner Marcello Piacentini in Rome offer points for<br />
considering these insights into how Futurism impacted modern Brazilian<br />
architecture. This was accomplished through his wife Lina Bo Bardi’s works.<br />
“Despite or due to her experience of Fascism,” philosopher Eduardo Subarits<br />
notes, she “believed in the urgency to reconsider that willingness of rupture<br />
and renovation that had inspired European artists and intellectuals of the first<br />
years of Italian Futurism.” 1 Lina Bo Bardi “experimented” with Italian Futurist<br />
Antonio Sant’Elia’s “free forms,” 2 which is important as it demonstrates how<br />
Pietro Maria Bardi might have inspired or collaborated with her on the San<br />
Paulo museum design in the 1950s.<br />
1 Eduardo Subarits, “Writing and cities,” in Cruelty and Utopia: Cities and Landscapes of<br />
Latin America, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2003, p.93.<br />
2 My translation. Refer to Eduardo Subirats, “Lina Bo: ‘Un’epoca nuova e gia cominciata’”<br />
in Antonella Gallo (ed.) Lina Bo Bardi Architetto, Venezia: Marsilio, 2004, p.27.
Cities, nations and regions in planning history<br />
This paper argues how Pietro Maria Bardi’s urban aspirations unveiled Futurist<br />
links in Italy. Then, it briefly explains how they permeated through certain<br />
parts of Lina Bo Bardi’s architecture in the city of Sao Paulo. The Museum of Art<br />
of São Paulo (MASP; 1957-68) and the Pompeia Leisure Centre (SESC-POMPEIA;<br />
1977-86) are sites illustrating these links. These buildings are celebrated today<br />
amongst architects for their blatancy and brusqueness rather than their<br />
Futuristic ties.<br />
Pietro Maria Bardi (1900-1999) had a tenuous affinity with the Futurists. He was<br />
recognized as a prominent Italian curator, theorist of art and architecture in<br />
Italy in the 1930s before his departure for Brazil, with Lina Bo, in 1946. He<br />
knew the Futurist poet Filippo Tommaso Marinetti as well as the Italian dictator<br />
Benito Mussolini. 3 Bardi is lesser known for his urban-type novellas – for these<br />
comprise of Futuristic elements.<br />
The 1930s in particular struck an architectural/urban chord with Bardi. In 1933<br />
he curated an Italian architecture exhibition in Buenos Aires, Argentina, with<br />
another showing in Brazil. Then, he met an Italian journalist who was living in<br />
Rio de Janeiro and whom invited him to visit Brazil again some other time. 4 In<br />
1935, Bardi said that the definition of “Futurist architecture” followed after<br />
Rationalism and he “campaign[ed] for an architecture that would directly<br />
represent fascist politics [which] galvanized contemporary Italian architectural<br />
publications.” 5 That same year he wrote a Futurist-type novella, La Strada e il<br />
Violante (The Roadway and the Steering Wheel). This novella described his<br />
inadvertent thoughts about Italian urbanism that related to Marinetti’s Futurists<br />
Manifesto (1909), described in this paper.<br />
Before leaving Italy, Lina Bo was exposed to Futurism on her own accord at an<br />
exhibition in Rome, curated none other than by Pietro Maria Bardi himself. Lina<br />
Bo (1914-1992) was an Italian architect and contributed designs, photomontages<br />
and articles for magazines such as Habitat with Pietro Maria Bardi whom<br />
possibly discussed Italian Futurist works. Much earlier at the age of 15, when<br />
she was still an art student at the Liceo in Rome, Lina Bo’s peer Orestano (a<br />
friend of Mussolini’s) organized an art show at the Galleria d’Arte di Roma,<br />
curated by Pietro Maria Bardi. At the show, Bo recalls in a 1991 interview with<br />
Olivia De Oliveira that Orestano’s son said to Lina:<br />
“His excellency Marinetti, the capo del futurism, is to open the exhibition!” I<br />
told him, “he’s not going to like it. It’s an absolute shamble.” I remember<br />
Orestano presented his work, “Project for a Macaroni Factory”…What an idea!<br />
He made the building tutto green, spinach-green, chiaro. So Marinetti opened<br />
3 Terry Kirk described Benito Mussolini as a “Futurist-type agitator.” Terry Kirk, The<br />
Architecture of Modern Italy. Volume 11: Visions of Utopia, 1900-Present, New York:<br />
Princeton Architectural Press, 2005, p.53.<br />
4 This was Lina Bo Bardi’s recollection stated in her last interview. Refer to Olivia de<br />
Oliveira conducted the interview with Lina Bo Bardi on 27 th September 1991 in Sao Paulo.<br />
See Olivia de Oliveira, “Interview with Lina Bo Bardi” in Lina Bo Bardi: Built Work, 2G,<br />
no.23-24, 2003.<br />
5 See David Rifkind, “Quadrante and the Politicization of Architectural Discourse in Fascist<br />
Italy, “Doctorate dissertation, Columbia University, New York, 2007, pp.1,5.
1 5 th INTERNATIONAL PLANNING HISTORY SOCIETY CONFERENCE<br />
the show and said, “Excellent! You’ve made a factory, with actual spinach<br />
macaroni. It’s green!” 6<br />
The significance of this event was a sort of architectural premonition for Lina<br />
Bo Bardi. No doubt, Marinetti must have left a distinctive impression on her, a<br />
Futurist one at that, to design “green” buildings in the form of reworking<br />
abandoned factories in Sao Paulo in the future. A few years after this<br />
impressive show, she studied architecture under the direction of Marcello<br />
Piacentini at La Sapienza University in Rome, graduating in 1940. While she was<br />
still a student, Bo worked with Piacentini on his E’42 project for Fascism’s new<br />
capital city in Rome, gaining urban experience. 7 The preoccupation with<br />
Futurism and Rationalist planning experience would have impacted her<br />
architectural approach years later in Brazil since Pietro Maria Bardi was one of<br />
the proponents of Rationalism in Italy.<br />
Bo and Bardi had therefore met each other in a gallery in Marinetti’s presence.<br />
From this point onwards, both Marinetti and Pietro Maria Bardi were to guide<br />
her critical thinking and architecture. After the Bardis were married in Italy,<br />
they visited Rio de Janeiro. 8 Fortunately, they remained in Brazil and later<br />
became Brazilian citizens. In the process, they experimented with the free<br />
architectural forms of Futurism, such as the MASP design in Sao Paulo.<br />
ITALIAN FUTURISM AND <strong>PIETRO</strong> <strong>MARIA</strong> <strong>BARDI</strong><br />
At the turn of the twentieth century, an influx of Italian immigrants and visitors<br />
sailed from the port of Naples to Brazil (as the Bardis did forty years later).<br />
They soon began to change the city’s image from the Beaux-Arts traditions into<br />
a sort of “subtropical” modern Rome. Italo-Russian architect Gregori<br />
Warchavchik, for instance, had earlier worked with Italian Rationalist Marcello<br />
Piacentini and then migrated from Rome to Sao Paulo in 1923. Pietro Maria<br />
Bardi first visited Sao Paulo and Rio de Janeiro in 1933 to promote Italian<br />
architecture and was well acquainted with Warchavchik and Piacentini. By<br />
1935, the Brazilian government invited Piacentini, architect of the University of<br />
Rome district, to visit Rio de Janeiro and advise them of a university project<br />
there. 9 When Piacentini returned to Italy from Brazil, he entered a competition<br />
- the E’42 (the universal exposition) project for Fascism’s new capital city in<br />
6 Olivia de Oliveira conducted the interview with Lina Bo Bardi on 27 th September 1991 in<br />
Sao Paulo. See Olivia de Oliveira, “Interview with Lina Bo Bardi” in Lina Bo Bardi: Built<br />
Work, 2G, no.23-24, 2003, pp.234-235.<br />
7 Olivia de Oliveira notes that Lina Bo Bardi worked on the E-42 competition with Marcello<br />
Piacentini. This note is mentioned in a letter to Carlo Pagani from Lina Bo on 26 th<br />
September 1939 in Pagani, Allegati alle considerazioni sul “Curriculum Letterario”;<br />
personal archive of Carlo Pagani. Olivia de Oliveira, “Interview with Lina Bo Bardi” in Lina<br />
Bo Bardi: Built Work, 2G, no.23-24, p.231 and see footnote 1.<br />
8 There, the Bardis visited the Ministry of Health and Education (MES) building (1936-1943)<br />
in Rio de Janeiro and the Copacabana Hotel, and staged two architectural exhibitions.<br />
9 Refer to Emilio Faroldi and Maria Pilar Vettori, “Italia Brasile: Dialoghi di Architettura”<br />
in Abitare, No.374, June 1998, p.58; and see Fraser, Valerie. Building the New World:<br />
Studies in the Modern Architecture of Latin America 1930-1960, Verso, New York: 2000,<br />
pp.200-201.
Cities, nations and regions in planning history<br />
Rome (1938). 10 As noted earlier, both Pietro Maria Bardi and Lino Bo worked on<br />
this exposition, separately.<br />
Meanwhile, one of Sao Paulo’s main axes of the city, Paulista Avenue, had<br />
transformed from a traditional to a modern hub. “Important changes to the<br />
area also resulted from a master plan for Sao Paolo designed by the engineer<br />
Prestes Maia (Plano de Avenidas, 1930), based on Daniel Burnham’s model for<br />
Chicago.” 11 The city’s modern architecture and urban layout further changed<br />
into a subtropical modern Rome first featuring Italian Rationalism and<br />
thereafter by Italian Futurism through Pietro Bardi’s influence.<br />
In Italy, Marinetti presented a new idea of Italian society “based on images of<br />
modern cities, mechanized industries and new transport systems” 12 in 1909. He<br />
announced that “a new era would be characterized by energy, speed, and<br />
technological vision” in his Futurist manifesto. 13 Marinetti suggested that the<br />
citizens of Italy should “destroy reactionary institutions like museums” and<br />
instead “open the mysterious shutters of the impossible,” 14 in other words, an<br />
“anti-museum.” By 1914, Marinetti collaborated with Antonio Sant’Elia who was<br />
inspired by “American factories and skyscrapers” 15 and then created a series of<br />
drawings of a visionary city called La Citta Nuova (The New City; fig.1). This<br />
city featured vertical and horizontal skyscraper configurations in the form of<br />
ribbons or massive bridges. Such configurations would inform Turin’s built<br />
architecture.<br />
10<br />
Refer to Emilio Faroldi and Maria Pilar Vettori, “Italia Brasile: Dialoghi di<br />
Architettura’”in Abitare, No.374, June 1998, p.58. Between 1938 and 1939, Piacentini<br />
returned to Sao Paulo. During this time, he designed a lavishly appointed house for<br />
Italian-Brazilian industrialist Francisco Matarazzo on Avenida Paulista.<br />
11<br />
Zeuler Lima, “Lessons from Sao Paolo,” p.30.<br />
12<br />
Donna Goodman, A History of the Future, New York: The Monacelli Press, 2008, p.55<br />
13<br />
Donna Goodman, A History of the Future, New York: The Monacelli Press, 2008, pp.55-<br />
56.<br />
14<br />
Donna Goodman, A History of the Future, New York: The Monacelli Press, 2008, p.55.<br />
15<br />
Donna Goodman, A History of the Future, New York: The Monacelli Press, 2008, p.56.
1 5 th INTERNATIONAL PLANNING HISTORY SOCIETY CONFERENCE<br />
Figure 1 – Detail of Antonio Sant’Elia’s open-air street of La Citta Nuova (1914). Esther da<br />
Costa Meyer, The Work of Antonio Sant’Elia: Retreat into the Future, 1995, New Haven<br />
and London: Yale University Press, 1995, p.105.
Cities, nations and regions in planning history<br />
Figure 2 – Giacomo Matte-Trucco, FIAT factory roof test track (1914-1923), Turin, Terry<br />
Kirk, The Architecture of Modern Italy. Volume 11: Visions of Utopia, 1900-Present, New<br />
York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2005, p.60.<br />
The same year Antonio Sant’Elia’s La Citta Nuova was created, an open-air<br />
street was constructed on the roof of a horizontal skyscraper in Turin, a<br />
renowned Italian Futurist design. Engineer Giacomo Matte-Trucco was<br />
commissioned by Giovanni Agnelli to design the FIAT (the Factory of Italian<br />
Automobiles of Turin) Lingotto plant, completed in 1923 (fig.2). Terry Kirk<br />
considered Matte-Trucco’s elevated test track building as a Futurist urban<br />
vision. 16 FIAT’s Futurist roof-scape exemplifies Sant’Elia’s open-air road in<br />
reality.<br />
The FIAT factory construction recalls a horizontal skyscraper found earlier in an<br />
American utopian novel called Roadtown. Edgar Chambless’ Roadtown (1910)<br />
outlines the linear city of the future to improve the well-being of citizens in the<br />
vast landscape between major cities; all transportation would take place on the<br />
roofs of the attached dwellings above. Chambless wrote:<br />
Lay the modern skyscraper on its side and run the elevators and the pipes and<br />
the wares horizontally instead of vertically… I would extend the blotch of<br />
human habitations called cities out in radiating lines. I would surround the city<br />
worker with the trees and grass and woods and meadows and the farmer with<br />
all the advantages of city life – I had invented Roadtown. 17<br />
16 Kirk, Terry, The Architecture of Modern Italy. Volume 11: Visions of Utopia, 1900-<br />
Present, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2005, pp.57-62.<br />
17 Edgar Chambless, Chapter IV The Roadtown Plan of Construction in Roadtown, New<br />
York: Roadtown Press, 1910, p.20.
1 5 th INTERNATIONAL PLANNING HISTORY SOCIETY CONFERENCE<br />
Perhaps Matte-Trucco must have known about Roadtown because the owner of<br />
the FIAT plant, Agnelli, had travelled to the Unites States to observe the<br />
current architectural designs of automobile factories. And yet after its<br />
completion, Le Corbusier visited the FIAT plant in 1925. 18 (For Le Corbusier,<br />
“Lingotto was Europe’s most advanced factory building” and an “’American<br />
factory,’ a talisman of European modernism.” 19 ) Four years after Le Corbusier’s<br />
visit Pietro Maria Bardi wrote his first urban novella called The Life of the<br />
Automobile where the driver is depicted as a type of “futuristic” being.<br />
The FIAT factory was an important source for Pietro Maria Bardi as he was later<br />
contracted by Agnelli to write another urban novella in 1935 to promote the<br />
company. This novella was written after he had travelled to Brazil in 1933 and<br />
assumedly his urban experiences in both Rio de Janeiro and Sao Paulo might<br />
have influenced his architectural writings as well.<br />
Critics, however, pay little attention to Bardi’s Futurist-type novellas produced<br />
at the beginning of his architectural/urban career (apart from Jefferey T.<br />
Schnapp). According to Schnapp, Bardi published The Life of the Automobile<br />
(1929) and La Strada e il Violante (The Roadway and the Steering Wheel; 1935).<br />
In the latter novella in particular, Schnapps suggests how Matte-Trucco’s FIAT’s<br />
Lingotto factory is hinted in the text, especially with its rooftop raceway. The<br />
Roadway and the Steering Wheel was in fact “published under direct FIAT<br />
sponsorship,” 20 and as the title suggests, it takes cues from Chambless’ utopian<br />
novel. The urban nature of Bardi’s writing reveals his fervour for fusing Futurist<br />
aspirations of roadways with architecture. Bardi wrote:<br />
Along the ribbons that tie together our cities, that traverse the<br />
countryside, that cross our mountains, they represent a presence that we can<br />
no longer dissociate from the land itself: the Revolution as a permanent<br />
uniform, as founding fact of our nation’s life. 21<br />
Here one can see the deliberately urban nature of the Futurist-type text – the<br />
would-be bituminous bands connect from one city to the next through the open<br />
landscape. Moreover, Bardi’s text is somewhat similar in style to Marinetti’s<br />
18 Fernando Perez Oyarzun, “Le Corbusier in South America: Reinventing the South<br />
American City,” in Le Corbusier and the Architecture of Reinvention, London:<br />
Architectural Association, 2003, pp.146-148, 153. And see Terry Kirk, The Architecture of<br />
Modern Italy. Volume 11: Visions of Utopia, 1900-Present, New York: Princeton<br />
Architectural Press, 2005, p.61.<br />
19 Terry Kirk, The Architecture of Modern Italy. Volume 11: Visions of Utopia, 1900-<br />
Present, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2005, pp.61-62. Roadtown most<br />
certainly would have inspired Le Corbusier’s sketch for a master plan for Rio de Janeiro<br />
(1929). The sketch expressed as an exaggeration of the open-air Futurist condition.<br />
Through his drawings of continuous bands of multi-storey buildings as road bridges, they<br />
are depicted as suffering the impacts of humidity, connecting the languid landscape to<br />
the spry sugar loaf mountain in the distance. Valerie Fraser noted the sketch was “a pathbreaking<br />
building,” Valerie Fraser, Building the New World: Studies in the Modern<br />
Architecture of Latin America 1930-1960, Verso, New York: 2000, p.152.<br />
20 Jeffrey T. Schnapp, “Driven,” in Qui Parle, Vol.13, No.1 (Fall/Winter 2001), p.142.<br />
21 Pietro Maria Bardi quoted in Jeffrey T. Schnapp, “Driven,” in Qui Parle, Vol.13, No.1<br />
(Fall/Winter 2001), p.147.
Cities, nations and regions in planning history<br />
manifesto of Futurism, but only in terms of the absence of human habitation of<br />
the open spaces:<br />
We shall sing the great crowds excited by work, by pleasure, and by unrest.<br />
We shall sing the multi-colored polyphonic tides of revolution in the modern<br />
capitals […with] factories hung on clouds by the crooked lines of their smoke,<br />
bridges that stride the rivers like gymnasts […and] adventurous steamers that<br />
sniff the horizon. 22<br />
Bardi possibly acted as an urban designer in some respects as his text<br />
demonstrates the thrill of urbane architecture and speed. For Schnapp, Bardi<br />
“functioned as a ‘fellow traveller’ of the second and third generation Futurists,<br />
yet his longstanding conviction that Futurism was already of the past was<br />
shared by the majority of Italian exponents of modernism.” 23 The 1935 novella,<br />
and its similarity to Marinetti’s style, provides evidence of Bardi’s contribution<br />
as an architect and as a latent Futurist.<br />
Linking the visionary work between Pietro Maria Bardi and Sant’Elia, David<br />
Rifkind links argues that Bardi was the first Italian critic to chart architecture’s<br />
philosophical role. Together with Massimo Bontempelli, Bardi co-founded the<br />
cultural journal Quadrante in 1933. 24 Their aim was to “construct an<br />
environment in which modern architecture could flourish in Italy.” 25 Before<br />
Bardi, Rifkind continues, there was one critic who discussed the problem of a<br />
“state architecture” in a 1929 essay by Fillia (or Luigi Colombo, leader of the<br />
Turinese Futurist group). Fillia made suggestions about Italian Futurism.<br />
Referring to Sant’Elia, Rifkind notes that Filia “wanted [the Futurists] to remain<br />
uniquely Italian, balancing lyricism and rationality while expressing the passion<br />
of our race and the luminosity of our land.” 26 Three years before Filia’s essay<br />
was written Bardi owned the Galleria Bardi in Milan (1926), where architectural<br />
exhibitions were held. 27 And stifled by Filia’s nationalist tone to his thoughts on<br />
Sant’Elia and the staid and traditional gallery venue, it is probable that Bardi<br />
was ready to leave Italy and promote a new strain of Italian Rationalism<br />
elsewhere, by venturing to other countries in 1932, such as Russia and Brazil –<br />
the places Marinetti visited as well. Fillia must have triggered one of Pietro<br />
Maria Bardi’s thoughts to build up the idea of an “anti-gallery” for Brazil.<br />
Critiquing the state of Italian architecture in the early 1930s, Bardi referred to<br />
Sant’Elia’s works, whose projects were exhibited in Roman galleries, and<br />
22 th<br />
Marinetti’s manifesto, 20 February, 1909, quoted in Terry Kirk, The Architecture of<br />
Modern Italy. Volume 11: Visions of Utopia, 1900-Present, New York: Princeton<br />
Architectural Press, 2005, p.51<br />
23<br />
Jeffrey T. Schnapp, “Driven,” in Qui Parle, Vol.13, No.1 (Fall/Winter 2001), footnote<br />
10.<br />
24<br />
David Rifkind, The Battle of Modernism: Quandrante and the Politicization of<br />
Architectural Discourse in Fascist Italy, Venice: Marsilio, 2012, pp.11-12.<br />
25<br />
David Rifkind, The Battle of Modernism: Quandrante and the Politicization of<br />
Architectural Discourse in Fascist Italy, Venice: Marsilio, 2012, p.17.<br />
26<br />
David Rifkind, The Battle of Modernism: Quandrante and the Politicization of<br />
Architectural Discourse in Fascist Italy, Venice: Marsilio, 2012, p.38.<br />
27<br />
Bardi also owned another one, the Galleria d’Arte di Roma in 1930. David Rifkind, The<br />
Battle of Modernism: Quandrante and the Politicization of Architectural Discourse in<br />
Fascist Italy, Venice: Marsilio, 2012, p.16.
1 5 th INTERNATIONAL PLANNING HISTORY SOCIETY CONFERENCE<br />
sponsored by Mussolini, alongside other major modern architects in Europe.<br />
Sant’Elia’s designs dealt with “the traffic problems of modern cities” 28 and this<br />
urban problem prompted Bardi with new sensibilities in formulating<br />
Rationalism. He praised Antonio Sant’Elia’s Futurist Cittā Nuova. 29 Yet for Bardi,<br />
“Rationalists accused the Futurists of being scenographers whose lyricism<br />
functioned well on paper but could not be translated into architecture.” 30<br />
Sant’Elia’s projects made Pietro Maria Bardi rethink the public spaces of large<br />
buildings to accommodate for large crowds.<br />
Nevertheless, when Pietro Maria Bardi published “Architettura. Arte di stato,”<br />
which was addressed to Mussolini, he “chose not to share publicly his fellow<br />
Rationalists’ disdain for the Futurists.” 31 It appears as though Bardi rethought<br />
about the architectural discrepancies between Futurism and Rationalism and<br />
the only way he could begin express this, architecturally, was to collaborate<br />
with Nervi on the E’42 pavilions. In 1938, Pietro Maria Bardi worked together<br />
with Nervi on the Pavilion Type B project and then in 1939 the Pavilion of<br />
Italian Culture. 32 Additionally, the Quadrante journal published a range of<br />
visionary projects Nervi and collaborative projects for Rome’s E’42. 33<br />
(Intriguingly, some of Nervi’s projects are Rational and yet quasi-“Sant’Elian.”)<br />
Overall, Marinetti was subconsciously instrumental on Pietro Maria Bardi’s work.<br />
Pietro Maria Bardi’s urban-type novellas, his criticism about Sant’Elia’s work<br />
and architectural collaborations with Nervi reinforce this argument; he acted as<br />
a vicarious architect and urban Futurist. The visionary collaborative projects for<br />
Rome’s E’42 are therefore significant in the Futuristic sense; Lina Bo worked<br />
with Piacentini and Pietro Maria Bardi worked with Nervi. Although overt<br />
Futuristic forms were not evident in the plans, visually, they did begin to<br />
pervade later in the Brazilian projects in the form of interior elevations.<br />
FUTURISM IN BRAZIL<br />
Returning to Pietro Maria Bardi’s 1933 trip to South America, however,<br />
“Futurism was at once everywhere and nowhere on the South American<br />
scene.” 34 When Marinetti visited Sao Paulo in 1926 (and later in 1936), he tried<br />
28<br />
Donna Goodman, A History of the Future, New York: The Monacelli Press, 2008, p.57.<br />
29<br />
Esther da Costa Meyer 191 Esther da Costa Meyer, The Work of Antonio Sant’Elia:<br />
Retreat into the Future, 1995, New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1995,<br />
p.191.<br />
30<br />
Esther da Costa Meyer 191 Esther da Costa Meyer, The Work of Antonio Sant’Elia:<br />
Retreat into the Future, 1995, New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1995,<br />
p.194.<br />
31<br />
David Rifkind, The Battle of Modernism: Quandrante and the Politicization of<br />
Architectural Discourse in Fascist Italy, Venice: Marsilio, 2012, p.41.<br />
32<br />
See Olmo and Chiorino, eds. Pier Luigi Nervi: Architecture as Challenge, Milano: Silvana<br />
Editoriale, 2010.<br />
33<br />
David Rifkind, The Battle of Modernism: Quandrante and the Politicization of<br />
Architectural Discourse in Fascist Italy, Venice: Marsilio, 2012, p.19.<br />
34<br />
Schnapp, Jeffrey T. and de Castro Rocha, Jao Cezar, “Brazilian Velocities: on<br />
Marinetti’s 1926 trip to South America,” South Central Review, Vol.13, no.2/3 (Summer,<br />
Autumn, 1996), 106.
Cities, nations and regions in planning history<br />
to indoctrinate Brazilians with his Futurist writings since his ideas in Italy had<br />
provided one way to tackle poverty and unemployment amongst the working<br />
class. 35 Cultural historians Schnapp and Jao Cezar de Castro Rocha summarize<br />
Marinetti’s Brazilian experience:<br />
Disembarking in Brazil imagined himself entering an ideal world – a Futurist<br />
paradise combining raucous publicity, and industrial noise, a paradise inhabited<br />
by friends and fellow travellers such that the coupling of poet and bay finds its<br />
immediate counterpart in the “affectionate” encounter between Italian<br />
Futurism and South American Futurism. 36<br />
Marinetti thought he would expose his Futurist Manifesto in Brazil with huge<br />
success. Though his vision did not prove to be so grand, Italian Futurism at that<br />
time was considered “absurd” amongst Paulista art and literary circles because<br />
it seemed backward to them. 37<br />
Twenty years later, when the Bardi’s were living in Sao Paulo, they were able<br />
to combine their talents and commence their Futurist endeavour as a couple.<br />
In Sao Paulo, Pietro Maria Bardi met with the entrepreneur Assis Chateaubriand<br />
and proposed a new museum of contemporary art. Like Marinetti, Bardi must<br />
have assumed that Sao Paulo would be a Futurist mecca for Italian architects.<br />
When the Bardi’s were settled in Sao Paulo, they invited Nervi to “spend a few<br />
weeks” with them and asked him to present talks on his concrete structures. 38<br />
Then, Nervi was Lina Bo Bardi’s engineering consultant for the São Paolo Art<br />
Museum (MASP). Prior to the MASP construction, Nervi and his son Antonio<br />
collaborated with Bo Bardi on the Taba Guaianazes complex (1954). 39 Although<br />
the multi-storey project was unrealized, it prompted the Bardis to observe<br />
other Latin American structures then under construction, for instance, the<br />
building of Brasilia. Lucio Costa’s Sant’Elian-type Bus Station in Brasilia (1957)<br />
could also be categorised under the rubric of Brazilian Futurist links along with<br />
the Bardis and Nervi’s collaborations. So one of the first true exponents of<br />
Brazilian Futurism that adapted urban scenarios deriving from Marinetti’s<br />
manifesto into architecture was Lina Bo Bardi via her husband’s influence.<br />
35 Jeffrey T. Schnapp and Jao Cezar de Castro Rocha, “Brazilian Velocities: on Marinetti’s<br />
1926 trip to South America,” South Central Review, Vol.13, no.2/3 (Summer, Autumn,<br />
1996), 119.<br />
36 Schnapp, Jeffrey T. and de Castro Rocha, Jao Cezar, “Brazilian Velocities: on<br />
Marinetti’s 1926 trip to South America,” South Central Review, Vol.13, no.2/3 (Summer,<br />
Autumn, 1996), 135.<br />
37 Pietro Maria Bardi, New Brazilian Art, New York: Praeger Publishers, 1970, pp.22-23.<br />
38 Zeuler Lima, “Nelson A. Rockerfeller and Art Patronage in Brazil after World War II:<br />
Assis Chateaubriand,” The Museu de Arte Moderna (MAM), the Rockerfeller Archive<br />
Centre-Research Report, 2010. Thank you to Zeuler Lima for granting me permission to<br />
use this report.<br />
39 Refer to Lina Bo Bardi, “Taba Guaianases,” in Habitat, No.14, January-February, 1954:<br />
4-10. Thank you to Zeuler Lima for providing me with this source. As a latent Futuristtype<br />
building, the Taba Guaianases, project later inspired Nervi’s collaboration with Gio<br />
Ponti on the Pirelli Tower design in Milan.
1 5 th INTERNATIONAL PLANNING HISTORY SOCIETY CONFERENCE<br />
INSTANCES OF FUTURISM IN LINA BO <strong>BARDI</strong>’S WORKS<br />
As a result of this paper’s argument about Pietro Maria Bardi as a vicarious<br />
architect, Sant’Elia and Marinetti’s ideas were only implemented in Brazilian<br />
architecture from the early 1940s onwards. In the case of Sao Paulo’s<br />
architecture, Futurism was imported directly from Italy and its architecture<br />
evolved further via its tropical context, allowing the scale of buildings to<br />
expand into two scenarios, horizontally and vertically.<br />
It is possible that Pietro Maria Bardi subconsciously paved the way for a future<br />
architectural vision for the city of Sao Paolo, to create the idea of the MASP<br />
building as a horizontal “anti-museum.” 40 Lina Bo Bardi’s design of MASP’s<br />
picture gallery was also informed by Nervi’s structures in Italy.<br />
MASP’s Futurist scenario is created by the large public space beneath the<br />
massive trusses emerging from two pools of water where crowds can congregate<br />
– an open-air Marinetti-type of theatre for the masses underneath the floating<br />
plinth. For Carlos Eduardo Comas, the “perforated pleated slab” is in fact based<br />
on Nervi’s Turin Motor Show, Hall B (1948-50). 41 The “anti-museum” metaphor<br />
would then be open to the possibility of key links to urbanism since it was to be<br />
transparent or in the words of Lina Bo Bardi a “greenhouse,” 42 because of its<br />
Trianon Park surroundings (fig.3). The “anti-museum” was one type of Futurist<br />
building realized in Brazil: through the building’s transparency and horizontal<br />
skyscraper configuration. It imported parts of Turin’s FIAT factory and Motor<br />
Show (Hall B), specifically the road test roof-scape, and the elevated open-air<br />
street sections deriving from Sant’Elia’s New City.<br />
Marinetti’s text possibly informed the SESC-POMPEIA’s Futurist scenario.<br />
Marinetti’s lines - the “crooked lines of smoke” - have been integrated into Lina<br />
Bo Bardi’s main structure by connecting the seven elevated catwalks to the<br />
tower (fig.4). In addition, “bridges that stride the rivers like gymnasts” – here<br />
she designed the towers to house a gymnasium. Perhaps she might have also<br />
been thinking about Pietro Maria Bardi’s text from The Roadway and the<br />
Steering Wheel – by building the “traversing ribbons” between the new parts of<br />
the construction. The Y or U-shaped bridges are even reminiscent of Nervi’s<br />
structures laid out horizontally.<br />
As far as her Pompeia trademark design is concerned, Lina Bo Bardi replaced<br />
the plumes of smoke with flowers billowing out of the chimney. This trademark<br />
emphasizes the importance of the effect that Marinetti had on her from an<br />
early age in Rome, noted at the beginning of this paper. Furthermore,<br />
Marinetti’s remark about the “green factory” was realized when she designed<br />
the rough and greenish tinge to the Chame-Chame House (1958-1964) built in<br />
40 Curiously, Olivia de Oliveira uses “an anti-museum,” or a museum beyond bounds” as a<br />
title in a section of her book. See Olivia de Oliveira, Olivia. Subtle Substances: The<br />
Architecture of Lina Bo Bardi, Barcelona: Gustav Gili and Romana Guerra Editora Ltda,<br />
2006, p.275<br />
41 See Carlos Eduardo Comas, “Lina 3 x 2,” ARQTEXTO, 14, 2009, 152.<br />
42 See Olivia de Oliveira, Olivia. Subtle Substances: The Architecture of Lina Bo Bardi,<br />
Barcelona: Gustav Gili and Romana Guerra Editora Ltda, 2006, p.266.
Cities, nations and regions in planning history<br />
Salvador, now demolished. Marinetti’s remark would later inspire architects<br />
today concerned with the issue of architecture and sustainability.<br />
Figure 3 – Lina Bo Bardi’s preliminary urban plan of MASP, Sao Paulo in Antonella Gallo<br />
(ed.) Lina Bo Bardi Architetto, Venezia: Marsilio, 2004, p.108.<br />
Figure 4 – Lina Bo Bardi’s aquarelle of SESC Pompeia’s possible future (1983), San Paulo in<br />
Antonella Gallo (ed.) Lina Bo Bardi Architetto, Venezia: Marsilio, 2004, p.53.
1 5 th INTERNATIONAL PLANNING HISTORY SOCIETY CONFERENCE<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
For the Bardis, Brazil became a sort of “Futurist resort,” a place where they<br />
could localize free forms emanating from Italy: to release Matte-Trucco’s FIAT<br />
factory from its industrial landscape and shake off Marinetti’s manacles.<br />
Subsequently, Pietro Maria Bardi promoted and published the works of Brazilian<br />
artists, architects and landscape architects internationally, such as The Tropical<br />
Gardens of Burle Marx (1964) and New Brazilian Art (1970). Back in Italy he<br />
published Viaggo nell’architettura (1971). New Brazilian Art in particular not<br />
only published art but “Brasilia and the new architecture” and also featured<br />
Lina Bo’s MASP Building. Within the latter book there is one image worth<br />
mentioning as it pinpoints the absurdity of Paulista Futurism, a look at the 1922<br />
Art Exhibition held in the city, which, at the time, was a backlash against<br />
Italian Futurist art. At the Trianon Park club (or Clube dos Artistas e Amigos da<br />
Arte), the place where the Bardi’s use to socialise in San Paulo in 1950 and<br />
before the MASP building was conceived, Lina Bo Bardi organised a ball entitled<br />
“Outskirts.” She probably borrowed the title from Boccioni’s street-painting<br />
series of Milan, for example, States of Mind. In any case, Pietro Maria Bardi<br />
describes the club’s interior as a salvage yard:<br />
“Décor consisted of all the staple commodities of the rubbish dump: empty<br />
cans, twisted metal, rusty tins, scrap-metal, broken dolls, broken bottles, rags,<br />
dilapidated objects, rotten rope, and rusty wire-a veritable example of trash<br />
bin aesthetics.” 43<br />
Lina Bo Bardi was indeed ahead of her time and her aesthetic sensibilities were<br />
somewhat similar to the Surrealist/Mexican architect Juan O’Gorman. As a<br />
result of Pietro Maria Bardi’s publications and architectural collaborations, he<br />
most certainly influenced his wife’s career in Brazil. He did this by exposing her<br />
architecture internationally. As Subirats has asserted, the city of Sao Paulo<br />
comprises a “heavy Futurist dimension” because it comprises “the unavoidable<br />
presence of ruins and industrial waste.” 44 Since the city has risen, and as it<br />
continues to rise, the Bardis laid the architectural foundations for Futurism to<br />
develop: into something that can be salvaged, rustic-Futuristic.<br />
43<br />
Pietro Maria Bardi, New Brazilian Art, New York, Washington and London: Praeger<br />
Publishers, 1970, p.86.<br />
44<br />
Quoted in Richard J Williams, Brazil, London: Reaktion books 2009, p.196. Eduardo<br />
Subirats, “Arquitetura e Poesia: Dois Exemplos Latino-Americano,” Projecto, 143 (July<br />
1991), pp.75-9.
Cities, nations and regions in planning history<br />
REFERENCES<br />
Bardi, P. M. New Brazilian Art, New York, Washington, London: Praeger<br />
publishers,1970.<br />
Bo Bardi, L. “Taba Guaianases,” in Habitat, No.14, January-February, 1954: 4-<br />
10.<br />
Chambless, E. Chapter IV. The Roadtown Plan of Construction in Roadtown,<br />
New York: Roadtown Press, 1910.<br />
Comas, C. E. “Lina 3 x 2,” ARQTEXTO, 14, 2009, 146-189.<br />
Crispolti, E. “The Idea of Architecture and Urban Space in Futurism,” in Studio<br />
International, Vol.186, No.960, November 1973.<br />
Da Costa Meyer, E. The Work of Antonio Sant’Elia: Retreat into the Future,<br />
1995, New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1995.<br />
Da Silva Pereira, M. “The Time of the Capitals. Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo:<br />
Words, Actors and Plans,” in Planning Latin America’s Capital Cities<br />
1850-1950, ed. Arturo Almandoz, London: Routledge, 2009.<br />
De Oliveira, O. ed. Lina Bo Bardi: Built Work. 2G, Barcelona: Editorial Gustav<br />
Gili, 2003.<br />
De Oliveira, O. Subtle Substances: The Architecture of Lina Bo Bardi,<br />
Barcelona:<br />
Gustav Gili and Romana Guerra Editora Ltda, 2006.<br />
Faroldi, E. and Vettori, M. P. “‘Italia Brasile: Dialoghi di Architettura” in<br />
Abitare, No.374, June 1998, pp.54-61.<br />
Fraser, V. Building the New World: Studies in the Modern Architecture of Latin<br />
America 1930-1960, Verso, New York: 2000.<br />
Goodman, D. A History of the Future, New York: The Monacelli Press, 2008.<br />
Kirk, T. The Architecture of Modern Italy. Volume 11: Visions of Utopia, 1900-<br />
Present, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2005.<br />
Lima, Zeuler R. M. A., “Nelson A. Rockerfeller and Art Patronage in Brazil after<br />
World War II: Assis Chateaubriand,” The Museu de Arte Moderna (MAM),<br />
the Rockerfeller Archive Centre-Research Report.<br />
http://www.rockarch.org, accessed 18.10.2011<br />
Lima, Zeuler R.M.A. and Pallamin, V. M. “An Uncommon Common Space,” in<br />
Encountering Urban Places: Visual and Material Performances in the<br />
City, eds.
1 5 th INTERNATIONAL PLANNING HISTORY SOCIETY CONFERENCE<br />
Lars Frees and Lars Meier, England: Ashgate Publishing Ltd., 2007.<br />
Lima, Zeuler, “Architecture and Public Space: Lessons from São Paulo,” in<br />
Places 19 (2), 2007, 28-35.<br />
Lima, Zeuler, “Lina Bo Bardi, entre margens e centros,” in ARQTEXTO, 14,<br />
Junho 2009.<br />
Olmo, C. and Chiorino, C. eds. Pier Luigi Nervi: Architecture as Challenge,<br />
Milano: Silvana Editoriale, 2010.<br />
Oyarzun, Perez F. “Le Corbusier in South America: Reinventing the South<br />
American City,” in Le Corbusier and the Architecture of Reinvention,<br />
London: Architectural Association, 2003.<br />
Rifkind, D. “Quadrante and the Politicization of Architectural Discourse in<br />
Fascist Italy,” Doctorate dissertation, Columbia University, New York,<br />
2007.<br />
Rifkind, D. The Battle of Modernism: Quandrante and the Politicization of<br />
Architectural Discourse in Fascist Italy, Venice: Marsilio, 2012.<br />
Schnapp, J. T. “Driven,” in Qui Parle, Vol.13, No.1 (Fall/Winter 2001).<br />
Schnapp, J. T. and de Castro Rocha, J. C. “Brazilian Velocities: on Marinetti’s<br />
1926 trip to South America,” South Central Review, Vol.13, no.2/3<br />
(Summer, Autumn, 1996), 105-156.<br />
Subarits, E. “Writing and cities,” in Cruelty and Utopia: Cities and Landscapes<br />
of Latin America, New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2003.<br />
Subirats, E. “Arquitetura e Poesia: Dois Exemplos Latino-Americano,” Projecto,<br />
143 (July 1991).<br />
Subirats, E. “Lina Bo: ‘Un’epoca nuova e gia cominciata’” in Antonella Gallo<br />
(ed.) Lina Bo Bardi Architetto, Venezia: Marsilio, 2004.<br />
Williams, R. J. Brazil, London: Reaktion books 2009.