01.01.2014 Views

Why are Mexican mayors getting killed by traffickers? The dynamics ...

Why are Mexican mayors getting killed by traffickers? The dynamics ...

Why are Mexican mayors getting killed by traffickers? The dynamics ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

not receive illegal profits (b=0), and there <strong>are</strong> no killings (k=0). This would only be the case if<br />

he places a lot of value into virtue and has the force to control <strong>traffickers</strong>’ violence. Under this<br />

circumstance, there will be not illegal profits because trafficking would be controlled. It won’t<br />

be worth for <strong>traffickers</strong> to go into illegal business because the state is too powerful and virtuous.<br />

Result 5: When M > 0, k = 0 if and only if b = M is a viable equilibrium;“Silver and<br />

no-lead”<br />

If organized crime is in business, political violence will only be absent (k = 0) if the corrupt<br />

state is powerful enough as to take all of the illegal profits for itself. Recall that <strong>traffickers</strong> always<br />

have an incentive to kill either to (a) reduce the price of bribes, or (b) keep their reputation.<br />

Killing thus will only be zero in the very extreme case that <strong>traffickers</strong> <strong>are</strong> unable to kill. This<br />

is not easy given than even weak <strong>traffickers</strong> may get lucky at times. Only a very powerful state<br />

will be able to have a peaceful drug market yet, this requires the state to be strong enough as<br />

to extort criminals. Such strong state can decide between eradicating crime at all, or take all<br />

illegal profits for itself. This is the case of a potentially extortionist state (i.e. b=M is a viable<br />

equilibrium)<br />

Results 4 and 5 have important implications for the quality of politicians. When running for<br />

office, politicians know that if trafficking is in place is because either there has been a corruption<br />

agreement (b > 0), or because politicians <strong>are</strong> too sc<strong>are</strong>d to (fully) enforce against crime (result<br />

4).<br />

Result 6: When M > 0, only corrupt A’s will take office, unless b = M is a viable equilibrium;<br />

“To be completely virtuous, one need to be able to be completely corrupt”<br />

Those politicians who take office at corrupted places know they will be bribed because otherwise<br />

they will be <strong>killed</strong>. Because of result 6, we know that the only chance for political violence<br />

to be absent, given that traffic is present, is to have a very powerful state. Rational politicians<br />

deny running for office if they have a positive probability to be <strong>killed</strong> 5 . Weak politicians who<br />

decide to enforce have a positive probability to be <strong>killed</strong>. Thus, we will only have non-corrupt<br />

candidates if the incumbent is powerful enough as to be completely corrupt. Quiet drug markets,<br />

like the US, require politicians to be potential extortionists 6 .<br />

5 <strong>The</strong> rationality of politicians may be debatable as it may be affected <strong>by</strong> the value that they put into virtue.<br />

A very virtuous politician could be argued, will take office even if it is to be a martyr. I do not discard this<br />

possibility but find it improbable given that, if the ultimate motivation of a virtuous politician is to reduce<br />

crime, his assassinated will not put him any closer to achieve his goal. Nobody can change the world from the<br />

grave. Martyrs though may still give their live for a uncertain, further ulterior purpose. A politician may think<br />

that even if <strong>killed</strong>, his assassination will generate international attention and a increase in retaliation against<br />

crime.<br />

6 Enforcement <strong>by</strong> a weak politician is only possible if such enforcement does not really hurt <strong>traffickers</strong>, at<br />

16

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!