Report - London Borough of Hillingdon
Report - London Borough of Hillingdon
Report - London Borough of Hillingdon
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Education Overview & Scrutiny Committee<br />
Thursday 16 th October 2003<br />
Meeting to be held at 7.00pm in Committee Room 6<br />
at the Civic Centre, Uxbridge<br />
Committee Administrator : Guy Fiegehen Tel : 01895 277733<br />
Press Enquiries Roy Mills Tel : 01895 250534<br />
Councillors on the Committee<br />
Bruce Baker<br />
Ann Banks<br />
Richard Barnes<br />
Keith Burrows<br />
Ge<strong>of</strong>f Courtenay<br />
Catherine Dann<br />
Brian Crowe<br />
John Hensley<br />
David Payne<br />
Reverend Doug Cave<br />
Tony Little<br />
Ge<strong>of</strong>f Cooper<br />
Vacant<br />
Vacant<br />
Peter Ryerson (Chairman)<br />
Peter Curling (Vice-Chairman)<br />
Substitute Councillors<br />
Santokh Dhillon<br />
Frank Filgate<br />
Janet Gardner<br />
Paul Harmsworth<br />
Phoday Jarjussey<br />
Richard Lewis<br />
Mike Gettleson<br />
Paramjit Sethi<br />
John Major<br />
John Oswell<br />
Jill Rhodes<br />
Andrew Vernazza<br />
Other Voting Representatives<br />
<strong>London</strong> Diocesan Board for Schools<br />
Westminster Diocesan Board<br />
Secondary School Parent Governor<br />
Primary School Parent Governor<br />
Special School Parent Governor<br />
You are invited to attend the above meeting. Papers for the meeting are attached.<br />
David Brough<br />
Head <strong>of</strong> Democratic Services<br />
Smoking is not allowed in the Committee Room<br />
Please ensure that all mobile phones are switched <strong>of</strong>f<br />
Parking is available to the public attending meetings – entrance in High Street, Uxbridge<br />
DESPATCH DATE: 10 th October 2003
EDUCATION OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY COMMITTEE 25 TH<br />
SEPTEMBER 2003<br />
AGENDA<br />
PART 1 – MEMBERS, PUBLIC AND PRESS<br />
1. Apologies for Absence and to report the attendance <strong>of</strong> any substitute members.<br />
2. Notes <strong>of</strong> meeting held on 8 th July 2003 and copies attached (Page 1).<br />
3. Declarations <strong>of</strong> Interest in matters coming before this meeting<br />
4. Exclusion <strong>of</strong> Press and Public - To confirm that the items <strong>of</strong> business marked Part 1 will be<br />
considered in public and that any items <strong>of</strong> business marked Part 2 will be considered in<br />
private.<br />
5. <strong>Report</strong> <strong>of</strong> the <strong>of</strong>ficers, copy attached<br />
1. Review <strong>of</strong> Schools' Budgets<br />
- update on schools' deficits:<br />
Martyn Callister, Principal Accountant - Schools<br />
- evidence from Douay Martyrs (secondary) and<br />
Wood End Park (primary) schools<br />
2. The Committee’s Work Programme Page 3<br />
3. Standards at Key Stage 3<br />
- Key Stage 3 strategy:<br />
Mike Merva, KS3 Strategy Manager<br />
4. Date <strong>of</strong> next meeting<br />
Tuesday 25th November 2003, starting at 7.00 p.m.<br />
PART 2 – PRIVATE, MEMBERS ONLY<br />
6. Any business transferred from Part
EDUCATION<br />
OVERVIEW & SCRUTINY COMMITTEE – 25 TH SEPTEMBER 2003<br />
DECISIONS SHEET<br />
Members Present<br />
Cllrs Peter Ryerson (Chair), Brian Crowe, Peter Curling, Mike Gettleson, John Hensley,<br />
David Payne and Paramjit Sethi<br />
Other Voting Representatives Rev’d Doug Cave & Tony Little<br />
Officers Present Michael Dennison, Roger Turner, Mike Merva, Dave Thomson, Tom Murphy,<br />
Chris Scott & Guy Fiegehen<br />
Decisions Sheet for the meeting held on 2 nd September 2003<br />
Agreed.<br />
Matters arising<br />
1. As Ge<strong>of</strong>f Cooper again was not at the meeting, Democratic Services would contact him about<br />
whether he wished to continue in his role.<br />
2. The Committee asked to hear evidence directly from schools about their budgets. It was agreed<br />
to invite the Chair <strong>of</strong> Governors and Headteacher from a small number <strong>of</strong> schools to give evidence<br />
at a future meeting. It was also agreed that<br />
(i) the meeting should start earlier than the usual time <strong>of</strong> 7.30pm<br />
(ii) at such meetings the Committee will in future devote up to the first half hour considering the<br />
questions it wished to ask witnesses.<br />
Declarations <strong>of</strong> interest<br />
All members <strong>of</strong> the Committee are school governors or have a similar role.<br />
It was agreed that the business <strong>of</strong> the meeting would be conducted in public.<br />
1 Review <strong>of</strong> Standards at Key Stage 3<br />
1. The Committee thanked Michael Dennison for his report and agreed the proposed methodology.<br />
They asked for a list <strong>of</strong> schools they could visit and protocols/procedures they should observe.<br />
Members also asked that planning for a possible further investigation, shown in the proposed<br />
timetable for December, should be brought forward to the November meeting.<br />
2. The Committee thanked Dave Thomson for his presentation and asked to see detailed analysis<br />
<strong>of</strong> gender differences in attainment. The Committee were concerned that schools should make use<br />
<strong>of</strong> the statistical data available to them and asked for a report on how this could be improved.<br />
3. The Committee were concerned that schools may not value Key Stage 3 sufficiently, noting<br />
evidence that suggested 20% could have been entered for higher level tests in Year 9. The<br />
Committee asked to see information on the mechanisms and criteria schools use to decide the<br />
levels at which to enter students and how far these enabled all students to achieve their fullest<br />
potential. Members also asked for evidence, including any projections based on individual data, on<br />
the extent to which Key Stage 3 performance is linked to GCSE outcomes.<br />
PART 1 – MEMBERS, PRESS AND PUBLIC<br />
Education Overview & Scrutiny Committee 16 th October 2003 Page 1
4. The Committee questioned the impact <strong>of</strong> changing school at age 11 and asked to see evidence<br />
on whether 11 is the best age at which to do this and on the steps schools take, and are advised to<br />
take, to help students adapt to the very different environment <strong>of</strong> secondary school.<br />
2 Review <strong>of</strong> Engage Youth<br />
1. The Committee thanked Tom Murphy for his report and presentation. They noted that youth<br />
services were also the subject <strong>of</strong> a Best Value review and that Cabinet would be considering a<br />
development plan on 27 th November.<br />
2. The Committee welcomed the principle <strong>of</strong> consulting young people about the services they<br />
wanted but were concerned about how a balance <strong>of</strong> all views could be obtained. They welcomed<br />
the suggestion that Members would be invited to the event EYL is arranging. They also asked<br />
Democratic Services to identify other consultation routes that might be help in gathering views e.g.<br />
from young people who don’t use existing services.<br />
3. Members were concerned about how the targets at Objective 3 had been set and how realistic<br />
they were e.g. spending £100 per 13-19 year old. Members also asked for a report on the extent <strong>of</strong><br />
existing voluntary provision - and Council support for it - and the scope for doing more.<br />
3 Committee membership<br />
This had been covered under ‘Matters Arising’.<br />
Next Meeting<br />
Thursday, 16 th October 2003. (Starting time half hour earlier than usual at 7.00pm)<br />
Meeting closed at 10.15 pm<br />
This is a summary <strong>of</strong> the Education Overview & Scrutiny Committee proceedings. If you wish for more detailed<br />
information on any <strong>of</strong> the information please contact Guy Fiegehen on 01895 277733.<br />
Circulation <strong>of</strong> this decisions sheet is to Members <strong>of</strong> the Education Overview & Scrutiny Committee, Members<br />
<strong>of</strong> the Coordinating Overview & Scrutiny Committee, Chief Whips, Leaders, the Cabinet Portfolio Holder and<br />
appropriate Officers.<br />
PART 1 – MEMBERS, PRESS AND PUBLIC<br />
Education Overview & Scrutiny Committee 16 th October 2003 Page 2
THE COMMITTEE’S WORK PROGRAMME ITEM 2<br />
Contact Officer<br />
Guy Fiegehen 01895 277733<br />
SUMMARY<br />
This report sets out the Committee’s current and future work programme<br />
for the two major reviews which the Committee have agreed to complete<br />
during this Council year<br />
- Standards at Key Stage 3<br />
- Engage Youth<br />
and for their additional enquiry on school budgets<br />
RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
(1) That the Committee note the report.<br />
(2) That the Committee confirm the timetable, reports and agenda items for<br />
future meetings.<br />
INFORMATION<br />
1. The Committee have to date agreed to the following work programme.<br />
Democratic Services comments are also added.<br />
Major Review: Standards at Key Stage 3<br />
Date Action Comment<br />
Meeting on<br />
16 October<br />
a. Presentation by Mike Merva to include<br />
- activities funded by the National Strategy<br />
- progress in the first year <strong>of</strong> the strategy<br />
- priorities for further action<br />
ON THIS<br />
MEETING’S<br />
AGENDA<br />
16 October to<br />
11 December<br />
Meeting on<br />
25 November<br />
b. Presentation by schools’ Key Stage 3<br />
coordinators on managing the strategy, its<br />
strengths and weaknesses in <strong>Hillingdon</strong><br />
c. Agree programme and protocols for<br />
Members’ visits to secondary schools<br />
a. Members’ visits to schools following<br />
agreed protocols<br />
b. Presentations by schools’ Key Stage 3<br />
coordinators, curriculum deputies or heads<br />
<strong>of</strong> department on raising standards<br />
Planning for possible further investigation<br />
(brought forward from 11 th December at<br />
Committee’s request)<br />
NOT ON AGENDA.<br />
COMBINE WITH<br />
ITEM b. BELOW?<br />
DETAILS MUST<br />
BE AGREED AT<br />
THIS MEETING TO<br />
MEET REST OF<br />
TIMETABLE<br />
EYL TO ARRANGE<br />
PART 1 – MEMBERS, PRESS AND PUBLIC<br />
Education Overview & Scrutiny Committee 16 th October 2003 Page 3
25 November<br />
to 8 January<br />
Meeting on<br />
11 December<br />
11 December<br />
until five clear<br />
working days<br />
before<br />
January<br />
meeting<br />
Meeting on<br />
8 January<br />
8 January<br />
until five clear<br />
working days<br />
before<br />
February<br />
meeting<br />
Meeting on<br />
10 February<br />
Possible further investigation<br />
a. <strong>Report</strong> back from presentations and<br />
school visits and discussion <strong>of</strong> findings and<br />
recommendations<br />
b. Decisions on drafting <strong>of</strong> report. Working<br />
party commissioned to draft report for next<br />
meeting<br />
Working party writes first draft <strong>of</strong> report<br />
a. <strong>Report</strong> back from possible further<br />
investigation and discussion <strong>of</strong> findings and<br />
recommendations<br />
b. Consideration <strong>of</strong> first draft <strong>of</strong> report and its<br />
recommendations<br />
Working Party revise draft and include<br />
findings and recommendations from possible<br />
further investigation<br />
a. Final report is submitted, amendments<br />
and recommendations agreed<br />
CONSIDER<br />
DELAYING DATE<br />
OF JANUARY<br />
MEETING<br />
b. Review and evaluation process is<br />
finalised, together with implementation<br />
strategy for the recommendations<br />
IMPLEMENTATION<br />
STRATEGY<br />
RESPONSIBILITY<br />
OF CABINET<br />
RATHER THAN<br />
SCRUTINY?<br />
2. Other identified items to be timetabled<br />
a. detailed analysis <strong>of</strong> gender differences in attainment<br />
b. report on how schools can improve their use <strong>of</strong> the statistical data available<br />
to them<br />
c. report on the mechanisms and criteria schools use to decide the levels at<br />
which to enter students and how far these enable all students to achieve<br />
their fullest potential<br />
d. report on evidence, including any projections based on individual data, on<br />
the extent to which Key Stage 3 performance is linked to GCSE outcomes<br />
PART 1 – MEMBERS, PRESS AND PUBLIC<br />
Education Overview & Scrutiny Committee 16 th October 2003 Page 4
e. report on the impact <strong>of</strong> changing school at age 11, evidence on whether 11 is<br />
the best age at which to do this and on the steps schools take, and are<br />
advised to take, to help students adapt to the very different environment <strong>of</strong><br />
secondary school.<br />
3. A copy <strong>of</strong> questions the Committee have been considering is attached.<br />
Major Review: Engage Youth<br />
4. The Committee have noted that Youth Services are also the subject <strong>of</strong> a Best Value<br />
review, and that Cabinet is considering a development plan on 27 th November (EYL<br />
104).<br />
5. The Committee have identified the following items they wish to consider<br />
a. report on how a balance <strong>of</strong> all young people’s views can be obtained about<br />
the development <strong>of</strong> youth services, including those who don’t use existing<br />
services<br />
b. report on how the targets at Objective 3 have been set and how realistic they<br />
are e.g. spending £100 per 13-19 year old<br />
c. report on the extent <strong>of</strong> existing voluntary provision - and Council support for it<br />
- and the scope for doing more.<br />
6. These items could be considered by the Committee on 25 th November.<br />
7. A copy <strong>of</strong> questions the Committee have been considering is attached.<br />
Additional enquiry on school budgets<br />
8. The Committee are considering two items at this meeting<br />
- update on schools' deficits<br />
- evidence from Douay Martyrs (secondary) and Wood End Park (primary)<br />
schools.<br />
9. The Committee have agreed to consider at the start <strong>of</strong> this meeting the questions<br />
that need to be addressed to witnesses.<br />
10. The Committee also need to agree any further consideration they wish to give to<br />
this issue and whether to refer the problems identified to the Cabinet for resolution.<br />
Other meetings<br />
11. The Committee also have meetings set for 11 th and 30 th March 2004.<br />
PART 1 – MEMBERS, PRESS AND PUBLIC<br />
Education Overview & Scrutiny Committee 16 th October 2003 Page 5