22.01.2015 Views

UKWA FOR WEB - United Kingdom Warehousing Association

UKWA FOR WEB - United Kingdom Warehousing Association

UKWA FOR WEB - United Kingdom Warehousing Association

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Health & Safety 15<br />

IN THE COURTS<br />

Tesco fined<br />

for scissor<br />

lift injury<br />

Supermarket giant Tesco<br />

has been fined a total of<br />

£25,000 after a faulty lift<br />

in a Sheffield store<br />

knocked an employee<br />

unconscious.<br />

The incident happened<br />

when the hydraulic arm of<br />

a scissor lift struck the<br />

employee on the head -<br />

four days after it had<br />

been reported as defective<br />

by a council safety inspector.<br />

But despite the defect<br />

being reported, the lift<br />

was still in use. Although<br />

the hydraulic arm had<br />

been tied down and a 'do<br />

not use' sign had been<br />

stuck on it, this was not in<br />

place at the time of the<br />

incident.<br />

Tesco admitted breaching<br />

health and safety legislation<br />

at Sheffield<br />

Magistrates Court. The<br />

firm was fined £20,000<br />

for failing to protect the<br />

safety of their employees<br />

and £5,000 for allowing<br />

a defective lift to be used<br />

without a thorough examination.<br />

Both fines were the<br />

maximum allowed in a<br />

magistrates court and the<br />

supermarket was told their<br />

discount for entering a<br />

guilty plea was not having<br />

the case sent to Crown<br />

Court, where fines are<br />

unlimited.<br />

Full court costs were<br />

awarded to Sheffield<br />

Council, who brought the<br />

case.<br />

Ian Ashmore, Sheffield<br />

Council's head of environmental<br />

regulation, said:<br />

“Michelle Garrigan, the<br />

investigating officer, highlighted<br />

that the lift was<br />

found to be defective four<br />

days before the accident<br />

occurred. A lift engineer<br />

had wanted to condemn<br />

the whole lift and carry<br />

out the repair work there<br />

and then.”<br />

He added:<br />

“Unfortunately, a decision<br />

was taken that the lift<br />

wouldn't be taken out of<br />

use and a temporary sign<br />

and strapping was put on,<br />

which soon started being<br />

taken off and on to make<br />

it easier to use the lift.<br />

This ultimately resulted in<br />

the accident.”'<br />

Transport<br />

firm loses<br />

its appeal<br />

A transport firm fined<br />

for safety failings that<br />

led to a worker being<br />

seriously injured has<br />

lost its appeal against<br />

the penalty. Harris<br />

Transport Ltd failed in<br />

its 2 June bid at<br />

Southampton Crown<br />

Court to overturn the<br />

£28,000 fine imposed<br />

in January 2008. The<br />

company now has to<br />

pay the fine in full and<br />

has incurred additional<br />

court costs of<br />

£5,300.<br />

Lee McMahon suffered<br />

severe injuries<br />

to both legs when he<br />

was run over by a<br />

forklift truck whilst<br />

working at Harris<br />

Transport in<br />

Southampton.<br />

A Health and Safety<br />

Executive (HSE) investigation<br />

discovered a<br />

breakdown in the<br />

firm's health and safety<br />

management. Ray<br />

Kelly, the HSE prosecuting<br />

inspector, said:<br />

“This case illustrates<br />

how easily normal<br />

workplaces can<br />

become incident<br />

scenes when health<br />

and safety management<br />

systems breakdown.<br />

Some 15<br />

months after the incident,<br />

Mr McMahon is<br />

still in great pain,<br />

unable to work, and<br />

never likely to again.<br />

The HSE were very disappointed<br />

that Harris<br />

Transport Ltd felt the<br />

need to challenge the<br />

original penalty, which<br />

had followed a very<br />

serious incident,<br />

resulting in the permanent<br />

disablement<br />

of one of their<br />

employees.”<br />

Freight firm<br />

fined for<br />

lorry driver<br />

death<br />

A transport firm has been<br />

fined £22,000 after a<br />

lorry driver was killed.<br />

Martyn Simm, 45, was<br />

killed in March 2006<br />

when a defective sliding<br />

metal gate weighing 0.4<br />

tonnes fell onto him as he<br />

was closing it, at the company's<br />

site in Chesterton,<br />

Newcastle-under-Lyme.<br />

Berser International<br />

Cargo Services Ltd was<br />

also ordered to pay costs<br />

of £18,000 having pleading<br />

guilty at an earlier<br />

hearing to a breach of the<br />

Workplace Health, Safety<br />

& Welfare Regulations<br />

1992.<br />

The company admitted<br />

failing to “maintain equipment<br />

and devices (including<br />

the access gates to the<br />

premises) in efficient<br />

working order and in<br />

good repair.”<br />

HSE inspector Rachel<br />

Bradshaw commented:<br />

“Basic maintenance of<br />

equipment is often<br />

ignored by employers and<br />

lives are put at risk as a<br />

result. There was a very<br />

obvious defect on this<br />

gate that a simple visual<br />

check would have identified.<br />

A few moments work<br />

and simple modifications<br />

would have prevented this<br />

tragedy from occurring.”<br />

At least twice as many<br />

people die from fatal<br />

injuries at work than<br />

are victims of<br />

homicide, a new report<br />

has revealed.<br />

Academics Professor<br />

Steve Tombs and Dr<br />

Dave Whyte found that<br />

at least 1,300 people<br />

died as a result of<br />

fatal occupational<br />

injuries in 2005-06 in<br />

England and Wales,<br />

compared with 765<br />

homicide deaths.<br />

January 2007<br />

www.ukwa.org.uk June 2008

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!