UKWA FOR WEB - United Kingdom Warehousing Association
UKWA FOR WEB - United Kingdom Warehousing Association
UKWA FOR WEB - United Kingdom Warehousing Association
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Health & Safety 15<br />
IN THE COURTS<br />
Tesco fined<br />
for scissor<br />
lift injury<br />
Supermarket giant Tesco<br />
has been fined a total of<br />
£25,000 after a faulty lift<br />
in a Sheffield store<br />
knocked an employee<br />
unconscious.<br />
The incident happened<br />
when the hydraulic arm of<br />
a scissor lift struck the<br />
employee on the head -<br />
four days after it had<br />
been reported as defective<br />
by a council safety inspector.<br />
But despite the defect<br />
being reported, the lift<br />
was still in use. Although<br />
the hydraulic arm had<br />
been tied down and a 'do<br />
not use' sign had been<br />
stuck on it, this was not in<br />
place at the time of the<br />
incident.<br />
Tesco admitted breaching<br />
health and safety legislation<br />
at Sheffield<br />
Magistrates Court. The<br />
firm was fined £20,000<br />
for failing to protect the<br />
safety of their employees<br />
and £5,000 for allowing<br />
a defective lift to be used<br />
without a thorough examination.<br />
Both fines were the<br />
maximum allowed in a<br />
magistrates court and the<br />
supermarket was told their<br />
discount for entering a<br />
guilty plea was not having<br />
the case sent to Crown<br />
Court, where fines are<br />
unlimited.<br />
Full court costs were<br />
awarded to Sheffield<br />
Council, who brought the<br />
case.<br />
Ian Ashmore, Sheffield<br />
Council's head of environmental<br />
regulation, said:<br />
“Michelle Garrigan, the<br />
investigating officer, highlighted<br />
that the lift was<br />
found to be defective four<br />
days before the accident<br />
occurred. A lift engineer<br />
had wanted to condemn<br />
the whole lift and carry<br />
out the repair work there<br />
and then.”<br />
He added:<br />
“Unfortunately, a decision<br />
was taken that the lift<br />
wouldn't be taken out of<br />
use and a temporary sign<br />
and strapping was put on,<br />
which soon started being<br />
taken off and on to make<br />
it easier to use the lift.<br />
This ultimately resulted in<br />
the accident.”'<br />
Transport<br />
firm loses<br />
its appeal<br />
A transport firm fined<br />
for safety failings that<br />
led to a worker being<br />
seriously injured has<br />
lost its appeal against<br />
the penalty. Harris<br />
Transport Ltd failed in<br />
its 2 June bid at<br />
Southampton Crown<br />
Court to overturn the<br />
£28,000 fine imposed<br />
in January 2008. The<br />
company now has to<br />
pay the fine in full and<br />
has incurred additional<br />
court costs of<br />
£5,300.<br />
Lee McMahon suffered<br />
severe injuries<br />
to both legs when he<br />
was run over by a<br />
forklift truck whilst<br />
working at Harris<br />
Transport in<br />
Southampton.<br />
A Health and Safety<br />
Executive (HSE) investigation<br />
discovered a<br />
breakdown in the<br />
firm's health and safety<br />
management. Ray<br />
Kelly, the HSE prosecuting<br />
inspector, said:<br />
“This case illustrates<br />
how easily normal<br />
workplaces can<br />
become incident<br />
scenes when health<br />
and safety management<br />
systems breakdown.<br />
Some 15<br />
months after the incident,<br />
Mr McMahon is<br />
still in great pain,<br />
unable to work, and<br />
never likely to again.<br />
The HSE were very disappointed<br />
that Harris<br />
Transport Ltd felt the<br />
need to challenge the<br />
original penalty, which<br />
had followed a very<br />
serious incident,<br />
resulting in the permanent<br />
disablement<br />
of one of their<br />
employees.”<br />
Freight firm<br />
fined for<br />
lorry driver<br />
death<br />
A transport firm has been<br />
fined £22,000 after a<br />
lorry driver was killed.<br />
Martyn Simm, 45, was<br />
killed in March 2006<br />
when a defective sliding<br />
metal gate weighing 0.4<br />
tonnes fell onto him as he<br />
was closing it, at the company's<br />
site in Chesterton,<br />
Newcastle-under-Lyme.<br />
Berser International<br />
Cargo Services Ltd was<br />
also ordered to pay costs<br />
of £18,000 having pleading<br />
guilty at an earlier<br />
hearing to a breach of the<br />
Workplace Health, Safety<br />
& Welfare Regulations<br />
1992.<br />
The company admitted<br />
failing to “maintain equipment<br />
and devices (including<br />
the access gates to the<br />
premises) in efficient<br />
working order and in<br />
good repair.”<br />
HSE inspector Rachel<br />
Bradshaw commented:<br />
“Basic maintenance of<br />
equipment is often<br />
ignored by employers and<br />
lives are put at risk as a<br />
result. There was a very<br />
obvious defect on this<br />
gate that a simple visual<br />
check would have identified.<br />
A few moments work<br />
and simple modifications<br />
would have prevented this<br />
tragedy from occurring.”<br />
At least twice as many<br />
people die from fatal<br />
injuries at work than<br />
are victims of<br />
homicide, a new report<br />
has revealed.<br />
Academics Professor<br />
Steve Tombs and Dr<br />
Dave Whyte found that<br />
at least 1,300 people<br />
died as a result of<br />
fatal occupational<br />
injuries in 2005-06 in<br />
England and Wales,<br />
compared with 765<br />
homicide deaths.<br />
January 2007<br />
www.ukwa.org.uk June 2008