Who-Stole-Feminism.-How-Women-Have-Betrayed-Women

222 WHO STOLE FEMINISM?cases the campaign of alarmism arouses exasperation of another kind. Inan article in the New York Times Magazine, Katie Roiphe questioned Koss'sfigures: "If 25 percent of my women friends were really being raped,wouldn't I know it?" 52She also questioned the feminist perspective onmale/female relations: "These feminists are endorsing their own Utopianvision of sexual relations: sex without struggle, sex without power, sexwithout persuasion, sex without pursuit. If verbal coercion constitutesrape, then the word rape itself expands to include any kind of sex awoman experiences as negative." 53The publication of Ms. Roiphe's piece incensed the campus feminists."The New York Times should be shot," railed Laurie Fink, a professor atKenyon College. 54"Don't invite [Katie Roiphe] to your school if you canprevent it," counseled Pauline Bart of the University of Illinois. 55GailDines, a women's studies professor and date rape activist from WheelockCollege, called Roiphe a traitor who has sold out to the "white malepatriarchy." 56Other critics, such as Camille Paglia and Berkeley professor of socialwelfare Neil Gilbert, have been targeted for demonstrations, boycotts, anddenunciations. Gilbert began to publish his critical analyses of the Ms./Koss study in 1990. 57Many feminist activists did not look kindly onGilbert's challenge to their "one in four" figure. A date rape clearinghousein San Francisco devotes itself to "refuting" Gilbert; it sends out massesof literature attacking him. It advertises at feminist conferences with greenand orange fliers bearing the headline STOP IT, BITCH! The words are notGilbert's, but the tactic is an effective way of drawing attention to hiswork. At one demonstration against Gilbert on the Berkeley campus,students chanted, "Cut it out or cut it off," and carried signs that read,KILL NEIL GILBERT! 5 8Sheila Kuehl, the director of the California Women'sLaw Center, confided to readers of the Los Angeles Daily Journal, "I foundmyself wishing that Gilbert, himself, might be raped and ... be told, tohis face, it had never happened." 59The findings being cited in support of an "epidemic" of campus rapeare the products of advocacy research. Those promoting the research arebitterly opposed to seeing it exposed as inaccurate. On the other hand,rape is indeed the most underreported of crimes. We need the truth forpolicy to be fair and effective. If the feminist advocates would stop muddyingthe waters we could probably get at it.High rape numbers serve the gender feminists by promoting the beliefthat American culture is sexist and misogynist. But the common assumptionthat rape is a manifestation of misogyny is open to question. Assumefor the sake of argument that Koss and Kilpatrick are right and that the