THE WEB AND IRAN | Digital DialogueAttempting to Silence Iran’s ‘Weblogistan’‘Iran’s filtering and blocking regime has been described by various experts assecond only to China’s.’BY MOHAMED ABDEL DAYEMHardly a week goes by withoutIran being featured prominentlyin the news. Usually thenews is about the country’s PresidentMahmoud Ahmadinejad’s inflammatoryrhetoric or its nascent nuclearprogram. But Iran is not the monolithicentity it is often portrayed to be inWestern, and especially U.S., media.While the Iranian governmentretains a monopoly on all televisionand radio broadcasting, the countrycontinues to have an independent,though reduced in size and severelybattered, print media. Although manyindependent and reformist newspaperswere launched during the years ofthe Khatami presidency (1997-2005),hardliners in Iran have shut downmore than 100 of those publicationsand jailed dozens of journalists inthe process.It is perhaps no surprise then thatduring those years Iranians began takingto the Internet in droves. Between20 and 25 million Iranians have regulardigital access, giving the countrythe highest Internet penetration ratein the region. According to researchby the Berkman Center for Internet& Society, the Iranian blogospherecurrently boasts some 60,000 regularlyupdated blogs of virtually everypolitical stripe. Others estimate thatthe number is closer to 100,000. EvenIran’s president and supreme leadermaintain blogs. “Weblogistan,” asIranians casually refer to the teemingand diverse world of Farsi blogging,Blogging in IranSeptember 2001—First Iranian blogappears on the Internet.November 2001—Blogger HosseinDerakhshan develops a step-by-stepguide to blogging in Farsi.April 2003—Journalist Sina Motalebibecomes first Iranian blogger to beimprisoned. After more than threeweeks in solitary confinement, Motalebiwas released on bail. By year’send he sought asylum in Europe.August-November 2004—Iranian authoritiesdetain upward of 20 bloggersand online journalists. After beingreleased, many of the imprisonedbloggers provided detailed accountsof mistreatment and torture while incustody.January 2005—Government ordersInternet service providers to filter anumber of the most popular Persianblog-hosting platforms.August 2006—President MahmoudAhmadinejad launches a personalblog.October 2006—Farsi becomes one ofthe 10 most used blogging languages,according to blog indexing serviceTechnorati.July 2008—Draft law being discussedin parliament adds the creation of Websites and blogs that promote “corruption,prostitution and apostasy” to alist of criminal offenses punishable bythe death sentence.November 2008—Hossein Derakhshanis detained, allegedly in connectionwith comments he made about religiousfigures. No official charges have beenfiled against the blogger. Authoritiesdenied holding Derakhshan untilDecember 30, 2008.February 2009—Bloggers and onlinewriters Roozbeh Mirebrahimi, OmidMemarian, Javad Gholamtamimi, andShahram Rafizadeh, all of whom weremistreated while in custody in 2004,are sentenced to multiyear prisonterms, flogging and monetary fines.This happens in spite of a pledgeby the chief of Iran’s judiciary thattheir abuse would be investigated andpunished.March 2009—Blogger OmidrezaMirsayafi, who was sentenced to a30-month prison sentence in December2008 for insulting religious andpolitical figures, dies in prison undersuspicious circumstances. He had justbegun serving his sentence a monthearlier. 42 <strong>Nieman</strong> Reports | Summer 2009
Digital Dialogueis alive and well despite a seeminglyendless barrage of legal (and at timesextralegal) persecutions.The rate at which the Iranian blogospherehas grown can be attributed toa host of factors, but two stand out.1. The ability of women, ethnic minorities,and other otherwisemarginalized groups—notto mention print journalistswho have lost their jobs dueto newspaper closures—to expressthemselves with relativefreedom cannot be overstated.There is also a growing numberof mainstream journalists whowrite online what they knowwill not be tolerated by thecensors in traditional media.Additionally, the anonymityof writing online has largelyeliminated a number of religious,social, and class-centereddistinctions that have traditionallysegregated society into segmentsthat rarely interacted inthe past.2. High rates of Internet penetrationcoupled with a highly literate andvery young population (70 percentof Iran’s population is under 30 yearsof age) have also contributed to theburgeoning of blogging.Government Clamps DownInitially, the government did notimplement any systematic measuresto regulate the Iranian blogosphere.That soon changed when bloggers whodiscussed political, social, religious andcultural affairs—frequently in waysthat were unimaginable in the traditionalmediums of print or broadcastjournalism—began to proliferate atbreakneck speed.In 2003, the government createda committee whose membership isdrawn from various law enforcement,intelligence and legislative bodies andtasked it with designating and filtering“illegal” Web sites, which include butare not limited to Iranian blogs. Iran’sfiltering and blocking regime has beendescribed by various experts as secondonly to China’s. In late 2008, the governmentboasted that this committeehad filtered upward of five million sites,though most independent observersbelieve that this number is inflated.A cybercrimes law introduced by thegovernment in 2006 effectively put allforms of expression on the Interneton the same footing as other formsSince the turn of the century, whenblogging started taking a footholdin Iranian society, Tehran hasdetained dozens—and possiblyhundreds—of bloggers. Somewere held for months before beingacquitted, but others have had toserve lengthy prison terms.of journalism, which are governed byIran’s restrictive and highly punitivepress law of 2000.Since the turn of the century, whenblogging started taking a foothold inIranian society, Tehran has detaineddozens—and possibly hundreds—ofbloggers. [A timeline of blogging is onpage 42.] Some were held for monthsbefore being acquitted, but others havehad to serve lengthy prison terms.What is most peculiar is that thosewho feel the wrath of the state oftendon’t fit the mold of the pro-Western,anticlerical youth. For instance, theologystudent and blogger MojtabaLotfi was sentenced to a multiyearprison term after he posted a sermonby renowned theologian Hossein AliMontazeri in 2004.The Fate of Two BloggersThe cases of bloggers Hossein Derakhshanand Omidreza Mirsayafi (detailedbelow) illustrate that what the stateperceives as subversive is constantlychanging. Both men found themselvesin the government’s crosshairs, and inboth cases the reasons for their detentionremain nebulous at best.Hossein Derakhshan: In 1999, HosseinDerakhshan was a print journalist atthe reformist newspaper Asr-e Azadegan(Age of the Free People). Whenthe popular publication was shut downin 2000, Derakhshan turned tothe Web. He began to regularlywrite online in 2001, becomingone of Iran’s first bloggers. Whatpropelled him to fame, however,was his development of a guideand a piece of software thatenabled Farsi speakers to blogin their native tongue withouthaving to resort to transliterationin the Roman alphabet. To thisday many Farsi-language bloggerspay him homage by referringto him as the “blogfather.”Derakhshan’s blog—written formany years from Canada—cannotbe accessed inside Iran. Hisarticles have been published bymany international publications,including The Guardian and TheNew York Times.The Iranian judiciary confirmedin a December 30th press conferencein Tehran that Derakhshan had beenarrested and is in the investigativecustody of a Revolutionary Court.The reason given for his detentionis remarks he allegedly made on hisblog about a key Shi’a cleric and thethird infallible Imam of Shi’ism. Theexact date of his arrest remains unknown,but Derakhshan’s last post onhis blog is dated October 30, 2008.News of his detention first appearedon November 17th on Jahan News, anews Web site that is reportedly closeto the Iranian intelligence apparatus.Until December 30th, authorities haddenied that Derakhshan was in theircustody; his whereabouts remainsunknown to date.Derakhshan rarely got into troublewith the authorities despite adoptinga reformist editorial line for years.More recently, however, Derakhshanhad written an increasing numberof articles praising certain policiesby President Ahmadinejad. Why thegovernment arrested Derakhshan<strong>Nieman</strong> Reports | Summer 2009 43
- Page 1: N ieman ReportsTHE NIEMAN FOUNDATIO
- Page 4 and 5: The Web and Iran: Digital Dialogue4
- Page 6 and 7: Iran: Can Its Stories Be Told?On a
- Page 8 and 9: Iranmeeting. But the person she was
- Page 10 and 11: IranThe income “good” journalis
- Page 12 and 13: IranGiant placards of the former an
- Page 14 and 15: IranTraditional women in Hormozgan
- Page 16 and 17: IranWhen Eyes Get Averted: The Cons
- Page 18 and 19: IranIn late April, with Roxana Sabe
- Page 20 and 21: Iranjust meet them in their offices
- Page 22 and 23: IranAN ESSAY IN WORDS AND PHOTOGRAP
- Page 24 and 25: IranFABRIC STORE, IRAN, 1979For mon
- Page 26 and 27: IranIRAN, 1980, AYATOLLAH KHOMEINIA
- Page 28 and 29: IranFilm in Iran: The Magazine and
- Page 30 and 31: IRANIAN JOURNALISTS | Women Reporte
- Page 32 and 33: IranUnfortunately, in a society tha
- Page 34 and 35: IRAN | VIEW FROM THE WESTSeven Visa
- Page 36 and 37: IranNo Man’s Land Inside an Irani
- Page 38 and 39: IranA young girl wore a headband an
- Page 40 and 41: IranIran: News Happens, But Fewer J
- Page 42 and 43: IranWhen the Predictable Overtakes
- Page 46 and 47: Iranafter he had softened his posit
- Page 48 and 49: IranThe Virtual Iran Beat‘Speakin
- Page 50 and 51: Iranwas president, the media remain
- Page 52 and 53: 21st Century MuckrakersThe Challeng
- Page 54 and 55: 21st Century Muckrakerslitical part
- Page 56 and 57: 21st Century MuckrakersFish and Mer
- Page 58 and 59: 21st Century Muckrakerspolice and t
- Page 60 and 61: 21st Century MuckrakersMining the C
- Page 62 and 63: 21st Century MuckrakersThere is no
- Page 64 and 65: 21st Century Muckrakersto keep an e
- Page 66 and 67: 21st Century Muckrakerswith examini
- Page 68 and 69: 21st Century Muckrakersthan two-doz
- Page 70 and 71: 21st Century Muckrakersof the legis
- Page 72 and 73: 21st Century MuckrakersGoing to Whe
- Page 74 and 75: 21st Century Muckrakersone of the S
- Page 76 and 77: 21st Century MuckrakersWatchdogging
- Page 78 and 79: 21st Century Muckrakersspecial dist
- Page 80 and 81: WORDS & REFLECTIONSObjectivity: It
- Page 82 and 83: Words & ReflectionsWorshipping the
- Page 84 and 85: Words & ReflectionsWhen Belief Over
- Page 86 and 87: Words & Reflectionsthat its practit
- Page 88 and 89: Words & Reflectionsthem like trophi
- Page 90 and 91: Words & ReflectionsA young woman in
- Page 92 and 93: Words & ReflectionsThe Dublin Fish
- Page 94 and 95:
Words & Reflectionsfied), pro-milit
- Page 96 and 97:
Words & Reflectionsabundantly appar
- Page 98 and 99:
Words & Reflectionssaid, ‘but I
- Page 100 and 101:
Nieman Notesmoney for the arrest an
- Page 102 and 103:
Nieman Notesfrom The Tennessean. Sh
- Page 104 and 105:
Nieman NotesKirstin Downey’s book
- Page 106 and 107:
Nieman NotesThe PRI series, edited
- Page 108:
VOL. 63 NO. 2 SUMMER 2009 IRAN: CAN