The victim of the crime is called the private offended party, but is properlyconsidered merely as the principal witness to the crime, assuming he orshe is alive and/or competent to testify. There are crimes, however, whereinthere is no private offended party and are called public crimes, such asillegal possession of firearms or illegal drugs.A criminal case is instituted with the help of either a police officer or aprosecutor (fiscal). If the offender was caught en flagrante delicto (aboutto commit, in the act of committing or has just committed a crime), thepolice conducts custodial investigation and afterwards decides whetheror not to file an information before the court. Otherwise, the institution of acriminal case is done after the conduct of inquest or preliminary investigationby a prosecutor. The victim can approach a prosecutor directly, or reportan abuse first to a police officer who in turn conducts an investigation andthen refers the case to a prosecutor if merited.The case has to be filed before a court with jurisdiction over the area wherethe crime was committed. Annex B provides an overview of the variouscourts in the Philippines.If the imposable penalty is equal to or below 6 years imprisonment, the caseis heard by a municipal trial court, metropolitan trial court or municipal trialcourt in a city (MTC). If the imposable penalty is above 6 years imprisonment,a regional trial court (RTC) hears the case. However, if the charge is violationof R.A. 9262 (Anti-VAWC Act), the case is heard by a Family Court.In a criminal case, the standard of proof for an accused to be pronouncedguilty is “beyond reasonable doubt”. If convicted, the accused will bepenalized. The penalty may be a mere censure, fine or imprisonmentdepending on the gravity of the crime committed. It should be noted that thedeath penalty has been abolished in the Philippines and has been replacedby life imprisonment as the ultimate penalty.Civil SuitsCivil cases, on the other hand, are caused not by conduct prohibited bylaw but by personal dealings, which give rise to certain obligations such asbeing part of a certain relationship, or entering into a contract. Civil casesare also caused by acts or omissions, which result in damages (injuriesor financial loss) to another.A civil case is heard either by a MTC or RTC, depending on the nature andgravity of the case. To illustrate, if the claimed damages equal or are lessthan P200,000.00 (outside Metro Manila) or P400,000.00 (within MetroManila), then a MTC hears the case; if the damages are greater, then aOVERVIEW OF AVAILABLE REDRESS INTRODUCTION MECHANISMS 27
RTC hears the case. Further, family cases (such as support, annulmentand custody proceedings) are heard by family courts.NATURE OF CASEFamily cases (annulment of marriage, legal separation,support, custody, etc.)Ejectment cases (unlawful detainer, forcible entry, etc.)Cases involving Properties Value is not morereal property located within than P50,000Metro Manila Value is more thanP50,000Property Value is not morelocated outside than P20,000Metro Manila Value is more thanP20,000Cases involving Case is within Value is not morecollection of debt Metro Manila than P400,000or damagesValue is more thanP400,000Case is outside Value is not moreMetro Manila than P200,000Value is more thanP200,000COURT WITHJURISDICTIONFamily Court, orRTC in the absenceof a Family CourtMTCMTCRTCMTCRTCMTCRTCMTCRTCA civil case is filed in the docket section of the appropriate court andinvolves the payment of a filing fee by the complainant or petitioner. If thecivil case involves real property, the case has to be filed in a court withjurisdiction on the property location. If not, the plaintiff (complainant orpetitioner) has a choice where to file the case, either where the plaintiffresides, or where the respondent resides or may be found.The standard of proof required to win a civil case is “preponderance ofevidence” which is lower than what is required in a criminal case.Unlike criminal cases, civil cases do not result in the imposition of a penalty.The usual result is the payment of damages. Damages may be:■Table 2: Jurisdiction over civil casesActual or compensatory – what is adequate compensation forthe pecuniary loss of the victim28 SEEKING REDRESS FOR HIV-RELATED VIOLATIONS OF HUMAN RIGHTS