Joint Appendix (Part 1)

EXHIBITCCLAIM CHART OF DEFENDANTS' AND PLAINTIFF'S TOBACCO PIPES·CLAIMS OF THE '936 PATENT DEFENDANT PLAINTIFF1. A metal tobacco pipe 1 in its assembly comprising L La manifold 2 having a body fonnation fonning a port Pand a chamber C COmnllUl.icating with said port and a L Lrecess in the body fonnation ofsaid port,a stem 3 having a bore 4 through which tobacco smoke isinhaled, said stem communicating with said chamber, L La turret 5 having a plurality of magazines 6 rotatablymounted on said manifold, each of said magazines L Lcommunicable and alignable with said port and chamberby rotation ofsaid turret to said manifold,means for filtering tobacco smoke 7 from tobacco in analigned one of said magazines to said port and chamber L Lseated in said recess,means co-extensive in and between said turret and manifoldforming a cavity 8, and L Lmeans joining together said turret and manifold disposedin the cavity, L Lsaid joining means comprising a member 9 having a firstbearing surface 10 fonned therein, a second bearingsurface 11 fonned in said turret abutting said first L Lbearing surface,whereby the abutment between said first and secondbearing surfaces provides a non-binding relationship L Lbetween said turret and manifold, andmeans 12 below said first bearing surface for fastening L L1 Designations refer to literal infringement (L); infringement under the doctrine ofequivalents(DIE); and infringement where asserted in the alternative (L;D/E).PLAINTIFF 000261-A202-