BusinessDay 24 May 2017
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>24</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Wednesday <strong>24</strong> <strong>May</strong> <strong>2017</strong><br />
Financial Inclusion<br />
& Innovation Weekly<br />
Supported<br />
ANALYSIS<br />
Targeted solutions needed to break<br />
financial inclusion gender gap<br />
PATRICK ATUANYA<br />
A<br />
recent World Bank report<br />
presents evidence<br />
that policy measures to<br />
increase financial inclusion<br />
need to be countryspecific,<br />
based on each country’s<br />
gender gap and specific challenges<br />
and opportunities.<br />
To eliminate the persistent gender<br />
gap and expand access to financial<br />
services for both women and men,<br />
policies should be adapted and integrated<br />
in national financial inclusion<br />
strategies and other policy initiatives.<br />
Alliance for Financial Inclusion<br />
(AFI) and Women’s World Banking<br />
developed a study to examine the<br />
experience of Nigeria, where there<br />
are currently many approaches to<br />
gender-focused financial inclusion<br />
policies.<br />
Nigeria is the largest country in<br />
Africa, with a population of 177.5<br />
million, which is almost double the<br />
population of the second most populous,<br />
Ethiopia.<br />
With a per capita GDP of $3,203<br />
(significantly higher than Ghana<br />
and Kenya), Nigeria is classified as a<br />
lower-middle income country, however<br />
much lower oil prices continue<br />
to pose challenges for public finance<br />
at all levels of government.<br />
A 2013 household survey revealed<br />
the per capita national poverty rate<br />
(based on the official poverty line)<br />
was 33.1 percent, but a large share<br />
of Nigeria’s population live not far<br />
above the poverty line.<br />
According to Global Findex data,<br />
Nigeria has made some progress in<br />
increasing the percentage of women<br />
who have access to an account in a<br />
financial institution.<br />
However, the gender gap has<br />
increased significantly in the last<br />
three years, from 7.3 percent to 20.7<br />
percent (see table).<br />
NEWS<br />
BALA AUGIE<br />
Businesses and banks in<br />
Africa’s most populous<br />
nation will save money<br />
to a tune of N2.60 trillion ($8.53<br />
billion) from digital financial<br />
service through reduced theft,<br />
error and improved cash management,<br />
according to McKinsey<br />
Global Institute (MGI).<br />
This figure is equivalent to 1.30<br />
percent of the country’s gross<br />
domestic product of N150.02 trillion<br />
($495 billion), based on the<br />
exchange rate of N305/$.<br />
The September 2016 report<br />
by the global institute says financial<br />
institution will save<br />
through reduced account costs,<br />
cash in, cash out CICO costs,<br />
transaction costs, loan issuance<br />
costs, and opportunity costs of<br />
currency.<br />
Savings in each category<br />
With banks perceived as less accessible<br />
to women, the expansion of<br />
mobile financial services is seen as a<br />
particularly valuable opportunity to<br />
foster financial inclusion for women.<br />
Although Nigeria has challenges—<br />
a vast population, geopolitical divisions<br />
and social norms that constrict<br />
women’s activities—it has seen<br />
meaningful policy change under the<br />
2012 National Financial Inclusion<br />
Strategy (“the Strategy”).<br />
Digital financial services can save Nigeria N2.60 trillion<br />
showed the country will save<br />
N260.77 billion ($791 million) in<br />
reduced shrinkage, N91.50 billion<br />
($300 million) in improved<br />
cash management, N238.81 billion<br />
($783 million) in accounts<br />
cost reductions, N2.01 trillion<br />
($6.81 billion) in CICO costs<br />
reduction.<br />
The role of digitalization in<br />
saving costs for financial institutions<br />
and companies cannot<br />
be overemphasized as lenders<br />
have lost huge sums of money<br />
to fraud.<br />
This ranges from bank robberies<br />
across the length and breadth<br />
of the country.<br />
According to a 2015 report by<br />
the National Deposit Insurance<br />
Corporation (NDIC), banks lost<br />
N18 billion to fraud. The corporation<br />
said there is an increase in<br />
the cases of ATM fraud.<br />
An explicit focus on women was<br />
undertaken recently with a Special<br />
Interventions Working Group of the<br />
Technical Committee implementing<br />
the National Financial Inclusion<br />
Strategy.<br />
With numerous changes underway,<br />
the coming years are expected<br />
to be one of significant policy change,<br />
particularly in terms of the regulation<br />
of mobile financial services.<br />
The World Bank report notes that it<br />
From year 200 to 2014 alone,<br />
Nigerian banks have lost a total<br />
of N199 billion to e-fraud between,<br />
mostly due to inappropriate<br />
and reckless management of<br />
customers’ data.<br />
Nigeria and emerging markets<br />
use cash for transaction<br />
will be important to focus on mobile<br />
financial services and outreach to<br />
rural women (mutually reinforcing<br />
objectives) if more progress is to be<br />
made in expanding financial services<br />
to Nigerian women.<br />
However in Nigeria’s fragmented<br />
market, the use of digital financial<br />
services has not yet become popular.<br />
While there are now 21 fully licensed<br />
mobile money operators<br />
(MMOs) able to offer mobile financial<br />
compared with countries in the<br />
Europe, Asia and the United<br />
States of America (USA).<br />
According to the Central Bank<br />
of Nigeria (CBN), digital financial<br />
services are estimated to<br />
reduce the cost of providing<br />
financial services by 80 to 90<br />
services, mobile money usage is still<br />
extremely low (0.3% when the Strategy<br />
was being prepared and only 0.8% by<br />
2014),and is primarily limited to bank<br />
account users who use mobile money<br />
as an additional product.<br />
Development financial institutions<br />
such as the Bank of<br />
Agriculture provides opportunities<br />
to reach out to women, and the MSME<br />
Development Fund, an initiative of<br />
the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN),<br />
also has programs aimed at women.<br />
The informal sector is an important<br />
part of Nigeria’s financial inclusion<br />
landscape. According to the National<br />
Financial Inclusion Strategy, 17.4<br />
percent of Nigerians (14.8 million<br />
people) only use informal financial<br />
services, such as esusu (rotating savings<br />
and credit groups), village savings<br />
groups and savings collectors, with<br />
slightly higher percentages of women<br />
using these services.<br />
The report notes that as they currently<br />
stand, none of the financial<br />
institution models in Nigeria are a<br />
driving force of financial inclusion<br />
for women.<br />
One explanation for the persistent<br />
gender gap is that progress in financial<br />
inclusion to date has been with groups<br />
who have been traditionally easier to<br />
reach—primarily urban men.<br />
Efforts to expand financial inclusion<br />
now face, in the words of one<br />
interviewee, “stubborn demographics,”<br />
with overall trends moving in<br />
the right direction, but there is now<br />
a need to focus on more difficult to<br />
reach groups, especially women in<br />
rural areas.<br />
In addition to the geographical<br />
distinction, women represent a large<br />
percentage of the young, have less<br />
education and lower incomes.<br />
The report concludes that this<br />
calls for different tactics to close the<br />
gender gap.<br />
percent compared to the cost of<br />
a traditional bank branch.<br />
Digital financial service can<br />
also help break the barriers to<br />
financial inclusion and promote<br />
economic growth through the<br />
creation of millions of jobs.<br />
“Digital financial services can<br />
also bring about substantial<br />
benefits for financial services<br />
providers, and the economy as<br />
a whole, beyond financial inclusion.<br />
It can boost a country’s<br />
GDP significantly and more sustainably,”<br />
said Godwin Emefiele,<br />
Nigeria’s central bank governor.<br />
“It can boost a country’s GDP<br />
significantly and more sustainably.<br />
For instance, the same<br />
McKinsey study postulates that<br />
digital financial services can<br />
increase Nigeria’s GDP by 12<br />
percent or US$88 billion by the<br />
year 2025,” said Emefiele.