Film Journal January 2018
- No tags were found...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
CONCESSIONS<br />
TRENDS<br />
VALUE PROPOSITIONS<br />
Sizing Up Refillable<br />
Popcorn Tubs and Drink Cups<br />
by Larry Etter, Concessions Editor<br />
In an era of expanding concession items, heartier<br />
menus remain one of the biggest challenges to<br />
convincing theatre patrons that concession<br />
snacks are a good value. One means of<br />
creating a value proposition is offering<br />
refillable vessels. Some cinemas chains have<br />
toyed with the idea of creating a value<br />
proposition of annual refillable vessels, such<br />
as popcorn tubs. Purchase the large bucket<br />
for a higher price and receive unlimited<br />
refills for the remaining calendar year. The<br />
question is: How do theatre operators<br />
make this work? Is the aim to build higher<br />
per-capita sales? Is the aim to create a<br />
loyalty program that invites patrons back<br />
to the concession stand for added value? Is<br />
the promotion aimed at making the consumer<br />
visit the concession stand working?<br />
All of these considerations lead to the<br />
concept of value proposition. “I will spend more<br />
today, but my total concession purchases for the<br />
extended period of a year will be less” is the predominant<br />
viewpoint of the participants in these programs.<br />
Many theatre owners offer a refillable vessel, whether it<br />
be for beverages or popcorn, as an incentive to buy into the<br />
snack options at the concession stand. Nearly all proprietors<br />
that use this system tend to add the combo effect to<br />
this application. The overall intent is to meet or exceed<br />
customers’ expectations about the theatre experience.<br />
Some theatre circuits have implemented the ultimate<br />
value system by promoting the “annual popcorn tub<br />
purchase.” The customer is able to buy a popcorn tub at a<br />
higher price than a large popcorn and they get refills at a<br />
huge discount for the remaining visits thoughout the year.<br />
Example: Purchase the 170-oz. large plastic vessel for $20<br />
and get it refilled on any return visit for $2. In comparison,<br />
a typical 170-oz. tub might sell for $8 on a single visit. The<br />
patron may see the first purchase as “sticker shock,” yet they<br />
believe that as a regular moviegoer and popcorn connoisseur<br />
this will make sense and make for a real savings with multiple<br />
visits to the theatre.<br />
Wally Helton, VP of merchandising and promotions for<br />
Cinemark USA, has extensive experience in this arena of<br />
value offerings and is considered by his peers an expert on<br />
the subject. “I started selling refillable popcorn containers<br />
and drink cups in 2000 at United Artists Theatre Circuit and<br />
have sold them at Cinemark since 2009,” he notes. “This<br />
was just an early version of a loyalty program. Once the<br />
guest buys the vessel at your theatre, they need to return to<br />
your theatre in order to use them. Then our guests enjoy a<br />
discounted price for the rest of the year.” This mechanism<br />
of refillable tubs serves a win/win proposition for guests and<br />
theatre operators.<br />
Neely Schiefelbein, VP of sales at Cinema Scene, reports<br />
that the success of the refillable tub has led to many more<br />
circuits employing this strategy. “We’ve seen many customers<br />
adopt the refillable tub concept. Some do it with 85-ounce or<br />
130-ounce, while others use larger sizes like the 170-ounce<br />
and 190-ounce. While it’s been done in many different ways—<br />
standalone purchase, paired with combos, etc.—it’s proven<br />
successful at many circuits across the country. People like the<br />
idea of saving money on return visits. And loyal customers will<br />
buy into this type of promotion knowing they will be back to<br />
their favorite theatre with the incentive of a deal!”<br />
The theatre owner should proceed<br />
with caution, as there are outside<br />
complications to this promotion.<br />
First, after the initial sale of popcorn<br />
in what is typically a plastic tub, how<br />
sanitary is the vessel? Has the patron<br />
kept the tub in the trunk of their car<br />
and do they pull it out on their return<br />
visit to the theatre? Does the local<br />
health department require certain<br />
administration to insure sanitary<br />
conditions for repeat uses of the food<br />
vessels? While the idea of extra value<br />
by buying a refillable vessel has merit,<br />
is the theatre operator aware of the<br />
health risk that they will inherit when<br />
offering such promotions?<br />
In similar conditions, theatre owners are<br />
offering a collector cup for beverages. In many<br />
cases, these cups highlight a particular franchise<br />
film or even the company brand. These vessels are great—<br />
they commit the patron to the brand. Sometimes the drink<br />
vessel has a long-term refillable option—i.e., all-year refills at<br />
one dollar, or sometimes free refills on the day of purchase.<br />
Here is the issue: What if the patron buys the specialty<br />
drink cup on Tuesday, then returns on Saturday with the<br />
same cup and asks for a “free refill” when in fact he/she did<br />
not purchase anything that day on that visit? How does the<br />
concession cashier know the difference? That is why some<br />
suggest a limited-time-only “collector cup” selling out after<br />
100 hours of operation; this way, the concessionaires know<br />
the vessel was not sold on that particular day.<br />
The other option that is emerging is the collectible<br />
popcorn tin. The graphics are incredible. The stability of a<br />
metal vessel is longer than the plastic competitor. The metal<br />
vessel also serves as a multi-use container for the purchaser<br />
after the consumption of the popcorn snack. Patrons can use<br />
the popcorn tins for their home use when popping microwave<br />
popcorn and watching TV sitcoms. The tins themselves are<br />
more expensive, yet theatre operators should understand this<br />
type of retail effect allows the movie lover to attach themselves<br />
to the franchise film. They can take ownership in the movie and<br />
it becomes a reminder of their movie experience, encouraging<br />
repeat visits to the cinema for more “take home” memories.<br />
Larry Etter is senior vice president at Malco Theatres<br />
and director of education at the National Association<br />
of Concessionaires.<br />
12 FILMJOURNAL.COM / JANUARY <strong>2018</strong><br />
008-016.indd 12<br />
12/19/17 4:10 PM