You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
www.columbusmessenger.com<br />
<strong>December</strong> 20, <strong>2020</strong> - GROVEPORT MESSENGER - PAGE 9<br />
Too much glitz and glamour in “e Prom”<br />
Celebrities, whether they hail from the<br />
entertainment industry, the music industry,<br />
or the sporting world, are often criticized<br />
for speaking out for a cause.<br />
Much of this criticism is directed by socalled<br />
fans who are unhappy their fave has<br />
an opposing view or an alternative life<br />
experience, but some of it comes from the<br />
non-celebrities within the cause who are<br />
skeptical that their support is only being<br />
done for positive press.<br />
Netflix’s “The Prom” tries to examine<br />
the latter phenomenon in a cheekier and<br />
less serious way, but while doing so it<br />
becomes unaware that directorial choices<br />
to focus on the star-studded aspect of the<br />
story nudges the film into that category<br />
despite its best intentions.<br />
This decision, however unconsciously<br />
made, gives off a faint whiff of self-importance<br />
in an otherwise sweet story about<br />
self-discovery and genuine activism.<br />
The film, which is adapted from a Tonynominated<br />
Broadway musical, begins in a<br />
small town in Indiana at a Parent-Teacher<br />
Association meeting.<br />
Its chair, Mrs. Greene, (Kerry<br />
Washington) has called an emergency<br />
meeting at the school, complete with the<br />
local press, to discuss one student’s desire<br />
to bring her long-term girlfriend to the<br />
upcoming prom. Scandalized by this idea,<br />
which she considers to be an abomination,<br />
she encourages the association to cancel<br />
One of the most cherished Christmas<br />
television specials is, “A Charlie Brown<br />
Christmas.”<br />
It first aired in 1965 and was groundbreaking<br />
for its time - with its mix of profound<br />
Christian philosophy expressed by<br />
Linus’ speech about the first Christmas<br />
contrasted with the secular commercial<br />
trappings that inch into the observance of<br />
the holiday.<br />
I am joyfully thrust back decades in<br />
time whenever I see this show.<br />
Three years before Charlie Brown aired,<br />
Mr. Magoo celebrated the holidays in 1962<br />
with his own vision-challenged version of,<br />
“A Christmas Carol.”<br />
While he does not draw the same devotion<br />
or notoriety as Charlie, Mr. Magoo is<br />
worth the hunt to watch his version of<br />
Ebenezer Scrooge during <strong>December</strong>.<br />
Speaking of Scrooge–and I will argue<br />
this until Rudolph’s red nose no longer<br />
blazes a path through the night–there is<br />
only one glorious cinematic version of<br />
Charles Dickens’ masterpiece - the 1951<br />
black and white film version starring<br />
Alistair Sim.<br />
It is as if Dickens wrote the timeless tale<br />
with Sim in mind, framed against the gray<br />
While “The Prom” is not a perfect<br />
film by any stretch of the<br />
imagination – it could have used<br />
some fine tuning of the dialogue<br />
and been trimmed by 20 minutes,<br />
at least...<br />
the festivities in order to be “fair to all students.”<br />
When they do so, outrage is felt<br />
throughout the LGBTQ community, their<br />
allies, and the student body.<br />
The latter’s displeasure and anger, however,<br />
is directed at out lesbian Emma (newcomer<br />
Jo Ellen Pellman) who only wants to<br />
have a nice evening with her girlfriend and<br />
classmates.<br />
While this is happening in the Midwest,<br />
outrage is also brewing in New York City,<br />
but this comes from a slew of Broadway<br />
actors who are mystified that critics had<br />
negative things to say about their latest<br />
play “Eleanor! The Eleanor Roosevelt<br />
Musical.” Frustrated by the response<br />
which called them unlikeable squirming<br />
worms, former big-name stars Dee Dee<br />
Allen (Meryl Streep) and Barry Glickman<br />
(James Corden) set off to find something to<br />
“make their brand more appealing.”<br />
Despite a few alcoholic beverages to get<br />
the ideas flowing (and the sadness at a<br />
manageable level), they come up with no<br />
bleakness of London of<br />
the 1840s. Sim is the<br />
consummate Scrooge,<br />
full of iconic smugness<br />
in his devoted pursuit<br />
of penny pinching and<br />
financial gain.<br />
Sim blurs the line<br />
between actor and role<br />
as he becomes the quintessential<br />
curmudgeon,<br />
using his height to lurk<br />
over the less fortunate<br />
with a craggy<br />
face that runs the<br />
gamut from hardened<br />
miser to compassionate<br />
uncle.<br />
Scrooge’s redemption at the hands of a<br />
trio of spirits showcases Sim’s dynamic acting<br />
chops in a role made for the actor and a<br />
holiday gift I unwrap year after year. If you<br />
only have time to watch one holiday classic,<br />
make it this version of “A Christmas<br />
Carol.”<br />
ideas on how to make themselves more<br />
marketable or likeable, the former deemed<br />
more important than the latter. While<br />
drowning in their sorrows, they learn from<br />
fellow struggling actors (but with less<br />
name and face recognition) Angie<br />
Dickinson (Nicole Kidman) and Trent<br />
Oliver (Andrew Rannells) about the goings<br />
on in that small Indiana town.<br />
Being a gay man, Barry can empathize<br />
with Emma’s plight and being considered<br />
one of the great “gay positive icons,” Dee<br />
Dee can too, in her own way.<br />
Knowing they can make a difference<br />
from their celebrity, the pair, alongside<br />
Angie and Trent, set off for small-town<br />
Indiana to “change the minds of those bigoted<br />
monsters” and snag some positive<br />
press in the process.<br />
Though the story is largely centered<br />
around Emma and the challenges she and<br />
her closeted girlfriend, Alyssa Greene,<br />
(Ariana DeBose) face, the film’s primary<br />
focus is on the more well-known cast of<br />
characters played by actors Streep,<br />
Kidman, Corden and, to a lesser degree,<br />
Rannells.<br />
As I have not seen the Broadway play in<br />
full — I did catch their showcase at the<br />
Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade that,<br />
ironically, drew heavy criticism when it<br />
featured a scene with the two female leads<br />
kissing — I do not know if that is the case in<br />
that medium as well but the film version<br />
Likewise, Irving Berlin’s homage to the<br />
holidays– “White Christmas” –is another<br />
gift I give myself.<br />
The ending alone - where all the stage<br />
trappings are pulled away to showcase the<br />
snow falling outside as the four lead actors<br />
waltz around in the most amazing holiday<br />
costumes ever - is another cinematic<br />
Christmas card.<br />
“White Christmas” whirls around the<br />
screen in glorious color, song, and dance<br />
under the stewardship of Bing Crosby, Danny<br />
Kaye, Rosemary Clooney and Vera Ellen.<br />
Yes, it is a classic boy meets girl, boy<br />
loses girl and everyone is happy in the end<br />
story, but it is oh so much more. It is also<br />
poignant, a tale of doing something nice for<br />
someone who gave so much, full of hope.<br />
Will it or won’t it snow? It is also filled with<br />
songs that have stood the test of time.<br />
The Reel Deal<br />
feels slightly less<br />
disingenuous with its<br />
focus on them. Yes,<br />
they are the funniest<br />
parts of the musical<br />
and, yes, to its credit,<br />
it does show their<br />
characters trying to<br />
grow as fully realized<br />
Dedra<br />
Cordle<br />
narcissistic adults,<br />
but the film could<br />
have done a better job<br />
at balancing the two topically important<br />
stories.<br />
While “The Prom” is not a perfect film<br />
by any stretch of the imagination — it could<br />
have used some fine tuning of the dialogue<br />
and been trimmed by 20 minutes, at least —<br />
it is a brightly enjoyable look at two<br />
teenage girls finding their inner strength<br />
through their love for each other, a mess of<br />
adults trying to improve their behaviors to<br />
better themselves and the world, and a possible<br />
future where the lights on Broadway<br />
can shine once again.<br />
Grade: C+<br />
Dedra Cordle is a <strong>Messenger</strong> staff writer<br />
and columnist.<br />
Let’s talk about Christmas television specials and films<br />
Places<br />
entertainment<br />
Linda<br />
Dillman<br />
“White Christmas” whirls<br />
around the screen in glorious<br />
color, song, and dance under the<br />
stewardship of Bing Crosby,<br />
Danny Kaye, Rosemary Clooney<br />
and Vera Ellen.<br />
What more could you ask for?<br />
Unless it happens to be Rankin and<br />
Bass’ stop-motion 1964 animation classic<br />
“Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer,” another<br />
case of boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy<br />
finds friends and a snow monster and gets<br />
girl. Or, if you rather, Santa makes a big<br />
mistake. Rudolph saved Santa’s reputation,<br />
the Island of Misfit Toys, and<br />
Christmas.<br />
My list of holiday cinematic happiness is<br />
not complete without mentioning my modern<br />
favorites – “A Christmas Story,”<br />
“Emmet Otter’s Jug Band Christmas,”<br />
“Christmas Vacation,” “Elf,” “Jingle All the<br />
Way,” and “The Polar Express” (the ending<br />
makes me cry every single time).<br />
So, drag along a millennial or two, grab<br />
a cup of hot cocoa (topped with marshmallows,<br />
of course) and join me in the pursuit<br />
of the classics - holiday style.<br />
Linda Dillman is a <strong>Messenger</strong> staff writer.