ATN #418

More documents

Recommendations

Info

LAW PATH Customers stronger together Collectively bargaining alongside competitors can affect transport costs NATHAN CECIL is a partner and JOANNE JARY is a special counsel at Holding Redlich Agroup of freight brokers made a notification recently to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) to collectively negotiate with freight carriers for a term of six years. The ACCC has not objected to this notification, meaning that, instead of having to negotiate one-on-one with freight carriers, the freight brokers can consolidate their bargaining power and negotiate as a bloc. Ordinarily, businesses requiring transport services will negotiate one-on-one with a carrier or logistics provider. How good a deal they get will largely depend on the level of competition in the marketplace and the relative bargaining power of the business vs that of the carrier or logistics provider. It is almost universally true that the more volume you have to ship, the more buying power you have and, therefore, the more bargaining power you can exercise in negotiations – resulting in better rates or terms of service. WHAT IS COLLECTIVE BARGAINING? Collective bargaining is where a number of competitor businesses requiring transport services band together on one side of the negotiating table, across from a single carrier or logistics provider on the other side. Typically, businesses seek to band together and collectively bargain to enhance their individual buying and bargaining power. WHY NOT ALL COLLECTIVELY BARGAIN? The Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (Act) generally requires businesses to act independently of their competitors when making decisions such as setting prices and terms and conditions for the provision of services. Collective bargaining is, therefore, generally considered to be anti-competitive, in that competitor businesses work together to negotiate joint price or service terms, rather than competing with each other to extract the best price or service terms. Depending on the extent of such collective action, this may constitute cartel conduct, concerted practices or other restrictive trade practices, which may be prohibited and punishable under the Act. Penalties for such prohibited conduct can, if viewed as cartel conduct, result in individuals facing either criminal (up to 10 years jail) or civil penalties (up to $500,000 per civil contravention). In the case of corporations, penalties for criminal or civil contraventions can be up to $10 million and, in some cases, even higher. HOW TO COLLECTIVELY BARGAIN Businesses can apply to the ACCC for an exemption from the competition provisions of the Act for collective bargaining through either the process for authorisation or notification. For authorisation, depending on the nature of the conduct to be engaged in, the ACCC may grant authorisation where: the proposed conduct would not be likely to substantially lessen competition; or the likely public benefit from the conduct outweighs the likely public detriment. Notification is an alternative process to authorisation for seeking legal protection to engage in collective bargaining, which may be faster than seeking authorisation. The ACCC will assess a notification on whether any benefit to the public is likely to outweigh any potential public detriment. If authorisation is granted, or the notification is not objected to by the ACCC, businesses that act within the scope of that authorisation or notification cannot be prosecuted for breach of competition laws. WHAT HAPPENED IN THIS CASE? The freight brokers made a notification to the ACCC to collectively bargain with freight carriers to obtain more favourable rates and terms that the freight brokers could then offer to their customers. Presumably, the freight brokers hope that the favourable rates and terms that they are able to negotiate will provide them with a competitive commercial advantage over other competitors that are not part of their collective bargaining group. The ACCC considered that the arrangement would be anti-competitive, in that competition between the competitor freight brokers would be reduced by permitting them to bargain together. However, the ACCC further considered that the public benefits outweighed the detriments caused by this reduction in competition. Specifically, the ACCC considered that the overall reduced negotiating costs and improved (and slightly more equal) negotiating standing obtained by the freight brokers outweighed any detriment. The ACCC further noted that the freight brokers only comprised a relatively small percentage of the market and agreed to permit other freight brokers to join their group who were otherwise forced to negotiate solo against some very large freight carrier businesses. Balancing the above considerations, the ACCC did not object to the notification for the collective bargaining. The ACCC decided to allow the notification to remain in force for a period of six years. 42 <strong>ATN</strong> July 2021 FULLYLOADED.COM.AU
Powered by AUSTRALIA’S #1 TRUCKING MARKETPLACE * BUY More than 25,000 trucks, trailers, buses, forklifts and cranes, and parts and accessories listed for sale SELL Unlimited stock listings on TradeTrucks.com.au plus <strong>ATN</strong>’s Fullyloaded.com.au, OwnerDriver.com.au, TradeEarthmovers.com.au, TradeFarmMachinery.com.au and TradePlantEquipment.com.au for $360 per month www.TradeTrucks.com.au * Based on stock items for sale as at March 2020
Page 1 and 2: FOR FLEET OWNERS & MANAGERS FOR FLE
Page 3 and 4: ISUZU SERVICE AGREEMENTS Zero-stres
Page 6 and 7: Gemma Pilbeam: at home in a Western
Page 8 and 9: NEWS Dogs & Chains 3 One of the con
Page 10 and 11: NEWS Inside the Industry TRIO IN $4
Page 12 and 13: NEWS Inside the Industry WA CATTLE
Page 14 and 15: NEWS Inside the Industry FMH ACQUIR
Page 16 and 17: NEWS Inside the Industry deliver th
Page 18 and 19: NEWS Inside the Industry INFO RELEA
Page 20 and 21: NEWS Inside the Industry strict VIC
Page 22 and 23: NEWS Inside the Industry SCOTT AND
Page 24 and 25: NEWS Inside the Industry Barnaby Jo
Page 26 and 27: OPEN ROAD In it together Border con
Page 28 and 29: INDUSTRY VOICE Arming for the futur
Page 30: SPONSORED CONTENT MaxiTRANS STANDIN
Page 33 and 34: Hard-won young driver awards with s
Page 35 and 36: eastern Australia operations for th
Page 37 and 38: MAXIMISE your audience reach with 5
Page 39 and 40: for Big W, Baiada Poultry and Ampol
Page 41: ecause safety comes before fuel sav
Page 45 and 46: otherwise, is debateable. But when
Page 47 and 48: If you buy a quality product, you d
Page 49 and 50: Get 12 issues of FOR JUST $ 79 .99!
Page 51 and 52: It was no surprise that a major upg
Page 53 and 54: the heavier-duty Allison 4440 serie
Page 55 and 56: tare weight and loadshare (twin) st
Page 57 and 58: uilding trucks here at Dandenong in
Page 59 and 60: produce up to that same torque to s
Page 61 and 62: “It definitely pays to drive cons
Page 63 and 64: It’s about making sure that we ca
Page 65 and 66: free Wi-Fi and TV with Netflix. For
Page 67 and 68: M REIMAGINING THE SUPPLY CHAIN E L
Page 69 and 70: and convenience, all at the ex-GM L
Page 71 and 72: feels every bit of it, pulling stro
Page 73 and 74: in 2014, it has struggled to fulfil
Page 75 and 76: Isuzu’s after-sales offering is i
Page 77 and 78: SPECIFICATIONS Ford Ranger XLT 2.0
Page 79 and 80: The Ford Ranger XLT is definitely t
Page 81 and 82: vehicle. Forward visibility is impr
Page 83 and 84: Cannon-L’s straight-line advantag
Page 85 and 86: than a Ranger XLT and wears chunky
Page 87 and 88: ottom of the screen, depending on w
Page 89 and 90: SPECIFICATIONS Ford Ranger Raptor J
Page 91 and 92: Jeep warranties the Gladiator Rubic
Page 93 and 94:
COMPARISON Eleven utes from Ford, G
Page 95 and 96:
SCORE: 8.5/10 FORD RANGER RAPTOR Th
Page 97 and 98:
HEAVY VEHICLES - MONTHLY SALES WEST
Page 99 and 100:
FLIR Night vision MAKING DRIVING AT
show all

ATN #418

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?