Statesman V. 29, n. 01.pdf
Statesman V. 29, n. 01.pdf
Statesman V. 29, n. 01.pdf
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
-- E.itial - -X-----<br />
-<br />
ctorlal<br />
Dube Should<br />
process<br />
by students in support of the lecturer's right to ,<br />
and even the history of the process is kept<br />
The inner workings of the university's academic<br />
from public view;- but the general concensus given<br />
tenure process are generally shielded from the academic freedom. o to<br />
Even the first part of the tenure process seemed t<br />
<strong>Statesman</strong> was that it is an unusual occurance<br />
public, which is done sensibly to avoid outside<br />
for administration officials to overturn the decision<br />
pressure and questioning in a private faculty eva- to continue the trend of campus-based support for<br />
of both faculty tenure committees.<br />
luation. Yet, simply by looking around the edges of Dube. The first academic committee, which was<br />
We believe the possibility for outside influence<br />
the tenure denial to Africana Studies lecturer Ern- appointed by the Arts and Sciences Dean Robert<br />
in<br />
Neville, compiled Dube's tenure file and recom- i<br />
the administration's denial of tenure to Dube is<br />
est Dube, it seems outside influence wielded great<br />
mended that he be granted tenure and promotion. (<br />
clearly present and dangerous to academic free-<br />
power in the final decision. Unfortunately, the very<br />
The second committee of elected faculty members (<br />
dom. It would be unfortunate if groups and publi-<br />
privacy that is supposed to prevent outside influ-<br />
did no recommend granting Dube a promotion but ( cations that are alien to Stony Brook could<br />
ence in tenure decisions equally prevents the pub-<br />
did give an approval for tenure. These committees<br />
influenced i an academic tenure decision. We<br />
lic from finding out whether or not such influence<br />
scanned Dube's entire academic history before<br />
believe I in the presence of this outside pressure<br />
did exist.<br />
making their decisions, and spent more time on;<br />
and encourage Dube to pursue an appeal to t4e<br />
Dube was certainly the most visible and contro-<br />
the tenure process than any other involved body. decision. r It is difficult to say exactly what form this<br />
versiai faculty member on campus after linking<br />
Although these two faculty committees granted appeal may take; asking Marburger to review tne<br />
Zionism with racism in his 1983 summer course,<br />
Dube tenure the decision was surprisingly over- itenure<br />
decision again is one route. Yet, as much as<br />
The Politics of Race. His tenure review was, widely<br />
anticipated by many campus and community turned by the three administration officials who iwe<br />
hope to see this situation remain centered on<br />
organizations and the possibility for outside pres- had the final say. University President John Mar- icampus,<br />
we hope that Dube will take any course<br />
sure in the case was constant, with a flow of anti- burger, Provost Homer Neal and Neville reversed<br />
cois-<br />
Dube editorials and denounciations of Dube's the decision of the two faculty committees. Even<br />
teaching '»i many local religious leaders and even stranger is the fact that Neville disagreed with the 'Letters & Viewpoints Policy<br />
Governor Mario Cuomo himself.<br />
very committee that he had appointed to spend statesman encourages all students, faculty, staff<br />
members and community residents to submit their views<br />
However, with this continued opposition to hours reviewing the case.<br />
and ideas to us and our readers in the form of letters to the<br />
Dube also came widespread support from his true Seeing as how Marburger, Neal and Neville editor and viewpoints.<br />
peers: the faculty and the students of Stony Brook. were the only ones specifically named in the Both should be typed, triple spaced and include the<br />
name, address, and phone number of the writer. Letters<br />
The University Senate exonerated Dube of any tenure decision, they would be the ones most sus- should not be in excess of 350 words and viewpoints<br />
academic wrongdoing and asserted that he ceptible to outside pressure. These three adminis- should bot be in excess of 1000 words.<br />
remained within the bounds of academic freedom trators are the only ones in the process who must Letters and viewpoints are printed ont the basis of<br />
space availability and time considerations. The editorial<br />
and it is hard to remember a time, other than the answer to organizations unconnected with SUNY board reserves the right to withold publication of any<br />
drinking age hike and the campus apartheid pro- and consequently they were the only three to deny letter or viewpoint. <strong>Statesman</strong> will not print unsigned<br />
tests, when so many students stood unified Dube tenure.<br />
letters.<br />
I%<br />
around an ideal. 'I am Dube" buttons were worn It is extremely hard to get details on the tenure<br />
Vice President for Student Affairs<br />
Fred Preston, when asked his Christmas<br />
wish by a <strong>Statesman</strong> reporter<br />
last December, said "I want to see a<br />
completed Rathskellar for Stony<br />
Brook students." Yet the longawaited<br />
project has gotten bogged<br />
down by disagreements between the<br />
Faculty Student Association (FSA),<br />
which plans to build the project, and<br />
the Union Advisory Board (UAB),<br />
which is responsible for overseeing<br />
space allocation in the Stjudent<br />
Union.<br />
While these two groups bicker over<br />
whether to put a beverage center in<br />
the top floor of the old Barnes and<br />
Noble bookstore, and whether a coffee<br />
shop is a viable alternative to a<br />
quiet student lounge, the rathskellar,<br />
the centerpiece of this project, is<br />
being "held hostage," to quote<br />
Preston.<br />
All parties involved agree on one<br />
thing: there should be a rathskellar in<br />
the basement. The space is large<br />
enough so that a creative floor plan<br />
Appeal~~c<br />
-- Letters--<br />
can make the rathskellar an enjoyaible,<br />
diversified creation for the students<br />
at Stony Brook.<br />
The proposal submitted by the FSA<br />
is sound and will offer the students a<br />
choice: they can use the upstairs coffee<br />
shop for mornings and quiet<br />
times, and the rathskellar for more<br />
adventurous activity.<br />
But if the problems between what<br />
the FSA and the UAB want to see in<br />
the upstairs area continue, it cannot<br />
be allowed to hold up the start of<br />
3nure Denial<br />
Bicker Later, Build R a t hskellar Now<br />
A Plea to College<br />
Legislatures<br />
construction or. the rathskellar. Now<br />
is the time to begin. Stony Brook officials<br />
and the FSA have been calling<br />
for the rathskellar for almost four<br />
years!<br />
Preston has shown the strongest<br />
support for the rathskellar, at least<br />
among the administration. He has<br />
the power to push' this proposal<br />
through. He should use that power<br />
now, before he has to wish again this<br />
December for a completed rathskellar<br />
at Stony Brook.<br />
$2,000 or about ot their tunding. describing the vehicle I was on as<br />
When the second semester rolls such. You had no written letter<br />
STATESMAN<br />
around, the building will be left dry from Mr. Barnes [Director of Public<br />
FALL 1 985<br />
in more ways than one. Activities Safety) describing my vehicle as a<br />
George Bidermann, Editor-in-Chief<br />
To The Editor:.<br />
that do not involve alcohol are more wheelchair because Gary Barnes<br />
M itchell Horowitz, Managing Editor<br />
When we all left the responsibili- expensive and more<br />
Raymond Rhodes, Business Mnageor<br />
time consum- never passed the word about the<br />
ties of Stony Brook and ventured off<br />
Scott Mullen, Deputy Managing Editor<br />
ing to plan, not necessarily more wheelchair. as he said he would. I<br />
DIRECTORS<br />
to the Hamptons, work, camp, etc., dull. Each of us who has ever am a disable student at this univer-<br />
Jeff Leibowitz. News Director<br />
the Legislature passed Chapter<br />
sipped a semi-cold beer from a foamy sity and have as much right to<br />
Walter Fishon, Alternatives Director<br />
274 of the Laws of 1985 which Bud keg in d hot building party is<br />
John Buonora, Sports Director<br />
transport myself to classes as<br />
raised the legal minimum age for<br />
Sondra Mateo, Photo Director<br />
not happy with this new law The .<br />
purchasing<br />
anyone does.<br />
Tim Lapham. Editorial Pege Director<br />
alcoholic beverages goal is to enjoy in a manner that will I wish you didn't send a letter to<br />
Dave Owen, Assistant Business Manager<br />
from 19 to 21 years, effective quench your thirst the first semes- Student Affairs concerning my<br />
EDITORS<br />
December 1, 1985. So, everyone, ter, and still not run your funds dry<br />
Rachel Pine, Jeanne Kane {News)<br />
welcome back<br />
'attitude problem" as you describe<br />
to the reality of the second<br />
Lisa Micelli. (Sports)<br />
semester.<br />
Stony Brook. The<br />
it. All I did was to try and explain to<br />
End of the<br />
Stuart Abrahams, Dan Smith (Photo)<br />
Bridge<br />
Eric Levine you and the other two officers who<br />
ASSISTANT EDITORS<br />
will remain open both semesters,<br />
Polity President stopped me was that the vehicle I<br />
Warren Scott Friedman, Richard Mallot (Arts)<br />
the Whitman Pub will close the<br />
Jackie Fiore, Jeif Eisenhart, (Sports)<br />
second semester and the most A Wheelchair By Any was operating was a motorized<br />
BUSINESS<br />
valued resource of Stony Brook, the Name<br />
wheelchair and that I needed it to<br />
James Mackin, Executive Director<br />
"Building Party" To The Editor:<br />
travel to class. I do not need to reg-<br />
Bryna Pitt, Advertising Artist<br />
will cease to exist<br />
ister this vehicle as it is a wheel-<br />
Alan Golnick, Production Managor<br />
-the second semester.<br />
is This a letter to describe the<br />
Diane Butler, Office Manager<br />
So, where are we all left, since<br />
chair and the letter I had from the<br />
h ap p e n e d t o m e o n<br />
the building legislatures spend<br />
ident that<br />
Suffolk County Offices of Handi-<br />
8/28/85 on the campus while I<br />
roughly $70,000 was<br />
capped Services should have made<br />
<strong>Statesman</strong> is a not for- proft corporation with offices located in the basement of<br />
a year on that operating a vehecle that I use<br />
.as<br />
this clear to you and the other offic-<br />
the Stony Brook Student Union Our mailing address is P 0 Box Af Srony favorite liquid refreshment - beer. MY motorized wheelchair.<br />
Brook NHY 7J90 For information on display advertising. contact Raymond<br />
To Sgt.<br />
ers who pulled over my wheelchair<br />
Rhodes lBusiness Manager) or James Mackin (Executive Directori weekdays a It would be verveasy, speaking as a<br />
Robert Marge, Dept. of<br />
246 3693 For information on classified advertising catl 246 -3690 weekdays 1C former legislature chairman, to<br />
I am a test driver for other types of<br />
AM- 5 PM For all other inquiries calJ 246-3690 weekdays Ediortais represen<br />
Public Safety I deeply : regret that wheelchairs and would appreciate<br />
, htp maloriy opinion of the Editorial Board and are written by one of0its members blow every penny on party after<br />
you didn't recognize my vehicle as a<br />
or designee<br />
party with beer blasts. What I<br />
it if in the future you would think<br />
wheelchair. The<br />
%.________-----------fact<br />
is that I am more about the needs of the dis-<br />
,q<br />
I wo wulu suggest Is thatnthe leges not<br />
confined to a wheelchair<br />
--- spend more than<br />
and<br />
60%<br />
had<br />
of their<br />
abled on campus.<br />
such documentation on My person<br />
1 2 STATESMAN Tuesday, September 3, 1985<br />
Brian Tigerman' Henschel