final version - Columbia University

HMU 6:9©B85KMB ;357U86DBD5K2S0S6:57M= M C9©B @!4¤5^4R6:0SBD9?4TMR;39F ¡©a@C[cP1C9©B8=39©F"PA@CUTXBD9©@b6:9U86T5K= 3039©=3[9
@
9B 6:PS9 [FE@CU8UD57J39©B ¥ P39©B89 576L^ ;35KU8[©BD574T57=A@b6D5KM=
FK9©@CBD=S5K=3Xw>3B8M23FK94TU¦¡
©@@51Q1CMFK@- R 9©57FE@-"@C=3; ©C92A@CBD@- "H""C2 ¤ 6DM+X9©=S9©B:@bFK5dc903>HM= UD0S>3> MCB86 9[6DMB?4 @C[cPS5K=39U
¢
MUD9B 96-@CF ¡^- "" } - MCB86:9U @b=3; P @C>3=35Z1 - "H" G -P @b>3=35d1]- "H" B ¤ ¡
¢
;35KU8[©B85K4¤5K=A@b6D5KM= @CBD9"904157U86:57=3X6:9[cP3=35KQ 039U9-R6:P3B8M03XP 6:P357UBD9©U89@CB8[cPU- ¥ 9"PA@ 9 9 4R6:9©=S;39©;
6:B8M>L^
@C>3>3F75K9; 6DP39©4u57= @b= 57= 6D9©B89©U86D5K=3X!=39 ¥ ¥W@^ ¡ N P39 >3B85KMB ¥ MBM1j57U ;35KU8[©03U8UD9©; 5K= /19©[ /
@C=3;
¡D a@C=3; M0SB [M=L6:BD57230S6D5KM=3U @CB89 ;396c@C57FK9©;T5K=¤6:P39"GIMFKF7M ¥ 57=3X [cPA@C>S6D9©B8U ¡ W-9BD95- ¥N9 23BD579 3^
6:57M=
MCG%6DP39*1b9^ [©M=L6:B85K23016:5KMC=3U MCG]6:P39B89©U89@CB8[cP 6DM UD96Z6:PS9 U86:@CX9 GIMCB"6DP39FE@ 6:9©B
P357XP3FK57XPL6"UDM4¤9
RfaY!S ¥ 9©BD9 9 4S>SFK5K[©@b6:9;?5K= ;396c@C57F ¡ N P3@b6 >A@C>H9©BV>3B8M>HMUD9UW6:P399 416D9©=3U85KM= 9[©5 JA[©U"@CB89ZM4¤576D6D9©; ¡ ©C9©2A@CBD@ ¢}b~~ #L@ ¤ GI03B_/
GIMBW0SUD9
6:9©=L6 Rba Y @C=3;_>SBDM R5K;39UV4TMB89 ;396c@C57F ¡ \ = 6DP35KU 6:P39UD5KU8- ¥ 9>3BDM>HMU89 @=39¦¥
6:PS9©BV9041>3F7MBD9UWFE@
6:9©=L6 Rba Y b@CB85E@b6D5KM=A@bF%2 M0S=3;35K=SX6:9©[cPS=35KQ 039 6DPA@b6 >3B8M 157;39©U @A@CB:@b4T96:9©B-9©U 6:5K4T@b6D5KM= @CU@ 4¤5K=3574 @ 4
@C=3;
¡ %Z03B @b>3>3BDM@C[cP§5KUZ>SBD5K=S[©5K>SFK9©;@C=3; M03BZ;S9©BD5 b@b6:57M=3UZ@bBD9>3B89©U89©=L6:9; 5K= GI03FKF ¡ N P39
>3B8M23FK94
¥2 M0S=3;35K=SX 6:9[cP3=357QR0S9>3BDM R5K;S9©U @ X0A@CBD@C=L6:9©9 MCG[M= 9©B8X9©=S[©96:M @ F7M1[©@CFKF ^ M>S6D5K4T@CF
=39
¡ UDMCFK0S6D5KM=
¢}C~C~ #L@ ¤ @CFKU8MM¨ 9BDU%6:PS9VUD03XXC9©U86D5KM=¤MCG @4TMCBD9V9£¢¤[5K9©=L6 M>S6D5K4¤5dc©@b6:57M=a6D9©[cP3=357Q 039
©C9©2A@bB:@
@ FE@b6D9©=L6!RfaY 4¤5^4R6:03B89 MCGN` @C03U8UD5E@b=3U ¡ N P39 57=L6:9©=L6 ¥N@CUZ6DM >3BDM R5K;S9 @ U86:@CB86D5K=3X >HM57= 6
GIMB
¤
M C9©B"90415KU 6:5K=SX 6D9©[cP3=S5KQ 039©U8-H@CU ¥ 5KFKF 2 9 U8P3M ¥ = ¡
X9=39©BD@CFK5Zc@b6D5KM=
MT@C[cP3579¦C9"6 / C - ¥ 9 [©M42S5K=39FK@CBDX9 4 @CB8X5K=_;S5KUD[BD574T57=A@b6:57M= ¥ 5 6:P?X9=39©BD@b6:5 9 4TMR;/
N
P39 [03BDB89©=L6 BD9UD9@bBD[cPw5K4¤>3BDM C9©U 6DP39 U 6c@b6D90/ MbG / 6:PS90/ @bB86 MCB86c@b= 6 ¥N@^1U¦¡
N
P3M0SXP 403F76D5^/ 1C9©B8=39©FOFK9©@CBD=357=3X3-sFK@CBDXC94 @bBDX57=[©FK@CUDU857JA[©@b6:57M=U-s@b=3; 5K=3;399©; 4T@L415K4034 9©=/
N
UD9[6D5KM=3U¦¡
= ©@C@51Q1CMFK@-CR 9©57FE@-p@C=S; ©C92A@CB:@ ¢ "H"H"C2 ¤ 6:P39 57;39@CU MCG 4T@L415K4034g9©=L6:B8M>L^ ;35KU8[©B85K4¤5^/
\
GIMBGI03B 6:P39B ¥ MB21]-¢¥ PS5K[cP ¥N@CU 57=3;399©; B89©Q 0357BD9©; ¡ ¡
9T[©M4¤>3FK96:9F7^§B890/ ;S9©BD5 9; 6:PS9 03>H;A@b6D9
9©Q 0A@ 6:5KMC=3UOGIMBO@-U89©Q 039= 6D5E@CF14T57=35K4T@CFbM>S6:574T5Zc@b6D5KM= O /3R %!S ¢\%FE@b686 - "H"" ¤ @CFKXMCBD576DP34 GIMCBO6:PS9