final version - Columbia University

@CB89©U"> MRMBDF ^ M=S>A@CBD9=L6:F7^5-AGIMBV6:P39UD9a6:@CU21 U8- 6:PS9
1C9BD=39FO[M42357=A@b6D5KM=_G
039©=3[9'1C9©B8=39©F ^1579©F7;3U@C=+942H9©;3;357=3X ¥ 5 6:P+@ FK@CBDXC9©B$4 @CB8X5K= 6:P3@C=+;3MR9©U 6DP39 U86DBD03[6:03B89
UD9Q
¡ MCBd4 @C=L^MbG16DP39 `:% 6:9BD4¤U 57= 5KX0SBD9 } ¡ } - 6:PS9 PS5KXP39U86¢§ % 57Ud=3MC6 @C[cPS5K9¦C9©; @b6 @
M>S6D5K4T@CF
~ ¡ W-M ¥N9 9B9-L5K=9 9B8^$[@CU895- 6:P39;35 9BD9©=S[©92 96 ¥N99©= 6DP3903= ¥N95KXPL6D9©; U8034 § %
FKMCXVB:@b6D5KMVMCG
9U86 >HMUDU85K23F79 § % 5KUWQ 035 6:9U84 @CF7F`- M=_6:PS9MBD;39BVMCG ~ ¡~+ ¡ 03B 6:P39BD4¤MBD9.-1GIMBV@b= ^
@C=3;_6DP392
FKMXBD@b6:57M3-6:P39BD9-@CBD9"UDMC4T9V6:9BD4¤U%6:PA@b6 >H9©B GIMBD4 ¥ MB8UD9-6DPA@C= 6:P39"03= ¥ 9©5KXCP 6D9©;_@ C9©B:@bX9
J419©;
U8M4T9a6:PA@b6 >H9©B GIMBD4g2 96D6D9©B ¡ N P 03U9- 5KXC03BD9 } ¡ } U803XX9U86:U6DPA@b6$@CF 6:P3M0SXP§@C= M>S6D5K4T@CF
@C=3;
4¤5KXCP 6 2 9@C23FK9a6:M JA=S;!2H9686:9B 1C9BD=39F ¥N95KXPL6:UZ6DPA@C=6DP3903= ¥ 9©5KXCP 6D9©;
FK9©@CBD=S5K=3XT>3BDMR[©9;303BD9
9B:@CX9.-36:P357UVPL^1>HMC6DP396D5K[@bFs4T96:P3MR;)O S ¥NM0SFK;_PA@ 9 6:M6:@51C9 57= 6DM [©M=SUD5K;S9©B:@ 6:5KMC=_=3MC6 ¤803U 6
@
1C9BD=39FV4 @b6DBD57[©9©Ua230S6¤@CF7UDM 6DP39?` % 6D9©B84yFK@C2 9FKU8-%@C=3; O } S ¥ M03FK;+U 6:57FKF> 9B8GIMB84yMC=3F7^
6:PS9
P39 B89©U803F76DUaGIBDMC4 MC03BaJAB8U866 ¥ M9 4S>H9©B85K4¤9©=L6:U 2 9X 6:P39TQ 039©U 6:5KMC= I ¥ P ^ 2 Mb6:P39B ¥ 576DP 6:PS9
N
9BDP39©@C; MbG ¥ 9©57XPL6:9; 1b9©BD=S9©F%[©MC4235K=3@b6:57M=3U ¥ PS9©= 6:P39 03= ¥ 9©5KXCP 6D9©;!UD034
[©MC4T>3016c@b6D5KM=A@bFOM
9FK5K=SX ¡ ¡ 9 6:P39= 4T9©@CUD03B89©; P3M ¥ 6DP39>H9©B8GIMCBD4T@C=3[©9 MCGM0SBT6 ¥ Me1C9©B8=39©F [©M42S5K=A@b6D5KM=
FE@b2
@CUV6DP39 =R0S42 9B MCG]=SM5KU89 1b9©B8=39©F7U"57=3[©B89@CU89©U¦¡
4¤96:PSM1;3UV[cP3@C=3X9U
P39 B89©UD0SF76:U@CBD9TUDP3M ¥ = 5K= 5KX0SBD9 } ¡D ¡ \ = 6DP39 JAX0SBD95-%XCBD9©9= [©B8MUDU89©U [MBDB89©UD>HM=3; 6DM
N
¥ 5 6:PT=3Ma=SM5KU89:1b9©BD=S9©FKU¦¡ N P39©U89Z>HM5K=L6:U ¥ 9©B89-6:P 03U X9©=S9©B:@ 6:9©; 5K=¤M03B%JABDU 6
[©FK@CUDU857JA9BDU6:BD@C5K=39;
~
9©= 6:P3M0SXP_6:P39 FE@ 6D6:9BV>3BDM R5K;S9©U 2 96D6D9©B X9©=S9©B:@bFK5dc©@b6:57M= >H9©B GIMBD4T@C=3[9 ¡
1C9BD=39F`-A9
^$-W5 6 5KU 5K=L6:9BD9©U 6:57=3X 6:M+[M=3U85K;39B ¥ P396DP39©B_6DP3903= ¥ 9©5KXCP 6D9©; UD034 MCG!1C9BD=39FKU_57U
5K=3@CFKF
UDF75KXPL6DF7^T2 96D6:9BV6:PA@C=?6:PS9$0S= ¥ 9©57XPL6:9; UD0S4 MCGC1C9©B8=39©F7U ¡
¢¡¡ ¨¡¡ © " ! ¢¡ § ¡£ "© ¡" !# $ £ § !#¢¡ $
MCG 1b9©BD=S9©FKU > 9B8GIMB84TU-2 96D6:9B ¢
\ = 6:P39 6DP35KB8;9041>H9©B85K4¤9©=L6 - ¥N9 ;394TMC=3U86DB:@b6D9 R5E@ U85K40SFE@b6D5KM=
UD5 6:0A@b6D5KM=_57= ¥ P35K[cP?6:P39 ¥ 9©57XPL6:9©; UD0345KUV=39[©9©U8U:@CB ^ ¡
@
M [©@CBDB ^ M0S66DP35KU%9 41> 9BD5K4¤9©=L69- ¥N9 [©B89@b6D9©;T@[©MF7FK9©[6:57M=MCG 8=3MC5KUD9 71C9BD=39FKU ¡ N PS9©UD9-@CB89
N
U86DBD03[6:03B89 1C9BD=39F`- ¥ 5 6:P >H9©B840S6D9©; B8M ¥ U%@C=3;a[©MB8BD9©U8> MC=3;35K=SXZ[©MF7034¤=3U ¡
UD574T>SF7^[M>35K9U]MCG16:P39
P39 BD9UD03F 6:57=3X?4 @b6DBD57[©9©UZ@CBD9 U86D5KF7F 1C9BD=39FKU8- 2S0S6 6:P39 9©=L6DBD5K9U =3M?FKM=3XC9©BZ[MBDB89©UD>HM=3;!6:M_6:PS9
N
9041>H9©B85K4¤9©=L6 -3;S9©UD[BD572 9; @b2 M 9 ¡ R MU86 MbG 6DP39>HM5K=L6:U G @CFKFH2 9FKM ¥ 6:P39F75K=39 ¦
§ -S5K=3;357[@b6D5K=3X
[©F79@CB8F7^ 6:P3@b6 6:P39 03= ¥N95KXPL6:9; 1b9©B8=39©FV[M42357=A@b6:57M= >H9©B GIMBD4¤U2H9686:9©B6DPA@C= 6DP39 ¥N95KXPL6D9©;