final version - Columbia University

BD@C=316:9U86 2 96 ¥N99©=j@CFKFGIMC03Ba>3@C5KB8UaMCGW4T96:P3MR;3U ¡ N P39TBD9UD03F 6:Ua^R579©FK;!6:P39¤GIMFKF7M ¥ 5K=3X
UD57X=39;/
6DM./ ¥ MBDU 6WBD@C=31 5K=3XaMCGd4¤96DP3M1;SU I 03= ¥ 9©57XPL6:9©;?U8034 MCG 1C9BD=39FKU9-1U86DBD03[6:03B89 1C9BD=39Fd@CFKMC=395-
2H9©U86_/
9©5KXCP 6D9©;?UD0S4MCG 1C9BD=39FKU8-A@C=3;?UD9Q 039©=3[9!1C9©B8=39©Fp@bFKM=39 ¡ \ =_6:P357UNBD@C=31 5K=3X-16:PS9FE@CB8X9©U 6!O 5 ¡9 ¡Z-
¥
S]>/ C@bFK039V57U ~ ¡ ~~ ¤2H96 ¥ 9©9=T6DP39-U 6:B803[6D03BD9 1C9BD=39F @bFKM=39 @b=3;¤6DP39 ¥N95KXPL6D9©;
FK9©@CU86U85KX=S57JA[©@C=L6
MbG31C9BD=39FKU¦¡ N P 03U]5 6]@b>3> 9©@CBDUp6:P3@b6][M42357=35K=SX"U89©Q 039=3[©9 @C=S; U86DBD03[6:03B89N[©@C= 2H9 PS9©FK>1GI03F`-
UD0S4
¥ PS9©= 0SUD5K=SX 6DP39 03= ¥N95KXPL6D9©; U8034 MCG 1C9BD=39FKU ¡
230S6"M=SF7^
9©5KXCP 6D9©; U8034 5KUU803BD>3B85KU85K=3X3-R=3MC6 FK9©@CU86 2H9©[@b03UD9-[©M=3U85K;39B:@C2SFK9"9 MB86 PA@CU 2 99©= 9 4S>H9©=S;39©;
¥
b@CBD57M03UVBD9UD9©@CBD[cPXCBDM03>SU"6DM¤;S9¦9FKM>S6D5K4¤5dc©@b6:57M= 6:9[cP3=3MF7MXC^ 6DMTU8MF C96:P357U 6 ^R>H9
2L^
R C £+>3B8M23F79©4 ¡ N PS9©BD9GIMBD9.- ¥ 9 UD9FK9[6:9; @ UD0S23UD96MCG6DP39a6D9©BD4¤U-GIB8M4M03B"2 9=3[cP34T@CB21
MCG
¤89©[6:9©;T6:P394|6:MGI03B 6:P39B 57= 9©U 6:57XL@b6:57M= ¡/1> 9[©5 JA[@CF7F7^5- ¥N9"UD9FK9[6:9;T6DP39 ~ 6:9©B84TUGIMCB
@C=3;¤UD0S2
P357[cP 6:P39$;35 9BD9©=S[©9 57= § % 2H96 ¥ 9©9=6:P39aU86DBD03[6:03B890/ MC=3F7^