final version - Columbia University

%
§
;35K4¤9©=SUD5KMC=3U ¡ N PS5KUWP357XP39B_/ ;S5K4¤9©=3U85KM=A@bFHU8>A@C[95KUW[©@CFKF79©; 6DP39 =#5E > = K £ ! =0-S@C=3;_5K=T6:P357U
C9©B8UD5KMC=§MCG%6:P39/P!R@bFKXMB8576DP34 JA=3;3U-6:P394T@L415K4 034 4 @bBDX57= PL^R> 9BD>3FK@C=3957= 6:PS9
=39FK5dc9©;
6:03B89 UD>A@C[95- UD574T>3F ^S6D5K4¤5dc©@b6:57M= >SBDM23F79©4g03UD57=3XA@bB:@b6D5K=3X$PL^1>H9©B8>3FE@b=39
%
@_;A@ 6c@_UD966:PA@b6 ¥N@CU >3B89¦R5KM0SUDF7^ 5K=3U89©>A@bB:@C23F79 ¡ C 9BD=39FKU4T@^§@CF7UDM?@CF7FKM ¥ 03UZ6:M?9©=S[©MR;39
5K=
=3M ¥ FK9;3X9 @C2 MC0S6 6:P39 ;A@b6:@- UD03[cP@CUV6:P39 1 =3M ¥ FK9©;SX9$6DP39$>A@C5KB¥ 5KU89$[MBDB89©FK@b6:57M=3U @CB89
>3B85KMB[1
¡ \ =_6DP39[©03B8BD9= 6 ¥ MBM1 -APSM ¥ 9¦C9©B8-¤¥ 9$@CBD9 >A@CB86D5K[03FE@CB8F7^ 57= 6D9©B89©U86D9©;HMB86:@C=L6
@CU @ ¥N@^ 6DM9©=3[M1;S9 UD574T57FE@CB8576D5K9©U @C4¤M=3X =SM=/ C9©[6:MB @C=3; P396:9BDMX9=39©MC03U;A@b6:@
GI03=3[6:57M=
UD96:U¦¡
¥ 9Z=3MC6D9 6:PA@ 6 @CF76DP3M03XCPT6:PS9Z;35KU8[©03U8UD57M= 6:P 03UWG @CB PA@CUNGIMR[©0SUD9©;?M= C9©[6:MBW;3@b6c@-S@
5KB8U869-
GI03=3[6:57M= [@b=_2 9-;39JA=S9©;_GIMBW@b= ^ @CB823576DB:@CB85KF7^[©M4¤>3FK9 4T;A@b6c@aM2 ¤89©[6 ¡ N P 03U8-I1C9©B8=39©F7U
1C9BD=39F
9§2H9©9= ;39JA=S9©; GIMB Y76"e.@C=S; >3BDMC6D9©57= UD9QR0S9©=3[9©U9- >3BDMC6D9©57=/ >3B8MC6:95K= @b=3; 4¤96c@b2 MF75K[
PA@
¥NMBM1 U9- >3PL^RFKMX9=396D5K[6:B89©9U9-A96D[ ¡£¢6-M23F795- }C~~ # ¤ e UVFKMC=3X @CUVM03BV[MFKF79©[6:5KMC= MCGO;A@b6c@ [©@C=
=396
0A@CBD9"1C9BD=39F]4T@b6:B85^4-36:P39=§@C=L^'1C9BD=39F]4¤96DP3M1; [@C= 2 9a@C>3>SFK5K9;3B89©UD9=L6:9©;!@CU-@TU8Q
;A@b6:@ ¡ N P39 1b9©BD=S9©FN4T@b6DBD5^4§5KU 6:P 03U @3B89©UD9=L6:5K=SX§;35 C9©BDU89
6:PS9
¥ M§MB$4TMB89V1C9©B8=39©F GI03=3[6D5KM=SU ¡bR @C=L^!4 @ 6:P394 @b6D5K[©@CFM>H9©BD@b6:57M=3Ua@CBD9¤[©F7MUD9; 03=3;39B
5K=SX3BDMC> 9B86 ^ ¡ N P39¤4¤MU86 574T>HMB86:@C=L6UD0S[cP M>H9©BD@b6:57M= 5KU @C;3;S576:57M= I 5 G ¥©@b=3; ¥ §
6:PS9
GI0S=3[6D5KM=3U8- 6DP39©= ¥N9¤[@C= >3BDM C9T6:P3@b6 ¥ Ö §©S ¦ ¥©9O §©S ¢ ¥ § Ö §©!3S 57U
@CB89T2HMC6:P)1C9BD=39F
¡ N P357U M>H9©B:@ 6:5KMC= 5KU 4T@b6:PS9©4T@b6:57[@CF7F7^§9QR0S5 b@CFK9=L6 6:M§[©MC=3[@b6D9©=A@ 6:5K=SX 6DP39 9[6DMB
@1C9BD=39F
}E
6[©M=L6:@C5K=3UMC=39 ;35K4¤9©=SUD5KMC= GIMB9¦C9©B ^§>A@C57BZMCG ;35K4¤9©=SUD5KMC=3UZ5K=6DP39 5K=S>30S6 UD>3@C[©9 ¡
904S@C4¤>3F795-s5
P357U*1C9BD=39FN[©@C= 6:P 03Ua[@C>16:03B89 >A@C57B ¥ 5KU89T[MBDB89©FK@b6:57M=3U 2 96 ¥N99©=+57=3>30S6 C@bBD5E@b23FK9U ¡_e 1C9©B /
N
1C9BD=39FdGI03=3[6D5KM= ¡
¢¡£ ¢¡¡ ¢ ¤£ "! "!¦¥¨§ !# ¡ $
^R> 9U-MbG];A@ 6c@ ¡ 6
4T@b6:PS9©4T@b6:57[©U$MCG 1C9BD=39FKU @CF7FKM ¥ U$03U 6:M ;39©B85 9 =39¦¥ 1C9BD=39FKU2L^ [©M4 235K=/
/19©[M=3;U-%6DP39
6:@b6:57M=3U"MCG 6:P396 ¥ MT;A@ 6c@ > MC5K=L6:U 5K= 6DP39GI9@b6D03BD9 U8>A@C[©9U-;S9JA=39; 2L^¥©W@C=3; ¥ § ¡
BD9>3BD9UD9=
P35KU 4T@b6:PS9©4T@b6:57[@CF GIMBD4T@CF75KUD4 >3B8M 157;39©U 03U ¥ 5 6:P @ U 6:BD@C5KXPL68GIMB ¥N@CBD; ¥N@^ 6:M [©MC4235K=S9
N