final version - Columbia University

¡ N PS5KU B89©UD9©@CBD[cP @CF7UDM+904S@C4¤5K=S9©; 6DP39§9 9©[6?MCG$4T57UDUD57=3X ;A@ 6c@ ¥ 5 6:P,1C9BD=39F
M>S6D5K4¤5dc©@b6:57M=
¡ ¡ 9TGIM03=3;+6:P3@b6 6:P39_U85K4¤>3FK9T03= ¥N95KXPL6D9©;j[©M42S5K=A@b6D5KM= ¥W@bU¤Q 035 6:9 B8M2303U 6
[©MC4235K=3@b6:57M=
4T57UDU85K=3X!;A@b6:@ ¡ N P35KU¤U86D03;S^ 4 @^ 9=3[©M0SB:@CX9 9041>H9©BD574T9=L6c@CF75KU86DU 6:M 6DB8^jUD574T>SFK9 1C9BD=39F
6:M
6:9[cP3=357QR0S9©U ¥ PS9©= MC>S6:574T5Zc@b6D5KM=T5KUV9©5 6:P39BV5K=39 ¢¤[©5K9=L6-MCBV03=A@ b@C5KFK@C23FK9 ¡
[©MC4235K=3@b6:57M=
930S23FK57[©F7^ @ b@C5KFK@C23FK9"GIMB @C[©@C;39©4¤5K[0SUD9 ¡
¥
¡ 9W230357FK;03>HM= @ZXCBD9@ 6 ¥ 9@CF 6:P MCG B89©[©9=L6 ¥NMBM1 57= 6:P39W@CBD9©@CUMCG]1b9©BD=S9©FA4¤96:PSM1;3U ¢/R[cP
4TMR;39©F75K=3X @C=3;_57=SGI9©B89©=3[9 ¢\ 9@CB8F`- "H" B - ©CMBD;3@C=_96"@CF ¡Z- "H"" ¤ -S@C=3;_M>16:5K4¤5dc©@L/
>3B8M2A@C2357FK57U86:57[
¢ M ^R;?@C=3; P @C=3;39= 2 9BDXP39.- }C~C~ - \%FE@b686 - "H"" ¤ ¡ N P39©B89 PA@CU 2 99©= 9 41>3FKMU85 C9 >3B8MXBD9UDU8-
6:57M=
@CF7F%MCGW6DP39 @C2HM 9 @CBD9©@CU ¡ N P357U 4T@51C9U 4T@C[cP35K=S9¤F79@CB8=35K=SX @C=S; 576DU @C>S>3FK57[@b6D5KM=
MCGVFK@b6:9.-O57=
9041[576:57=3X JA9FK;U-23016¤@CFKU8M§4 @51b9©U 5 6 ;35 ¢¤[03F76a6:M U86:@ ^ @CP39©@C; MCG 6:P39 ¥N@ 9357BD57[@CFB89©U803F76DU@C=3;!6:P39 AMRM1;!MCGV;3@b6c@ ¡ N P39TJA9FK;!PA@CUaBD9©U8> MC=3;39©; 5K=!UD9¦C9©BD@CF
[@bF
^RU¦¡F%Z=39 5KU 6:M_;39 9©F7M>G @CU 6:9©B @C=3;§4¤MBD9a@C[[©9©U8UD5723FK9U8MCG 6 ¥N@CBD96DM_@C;3;3B89©U8UZ6:P39a=39©9;3UMCG
¥N@
¢ ©@@.11bMFE@ @C=S; W-@C03U8UDFK9B9- "" B - ©@@.11bMFE@96 @CF ¡^- "H""@-[5- N @CUM1b@bB 96 @CF ¡^- }C~C~ -Ce-F76D03=
;A@b6:@
¡^- }C~~ - N UDMR[cPA@C=L6:@CBD57;35KU96 @bF ¡^- }C~~ #3- ©C9©23@CB:@- }C~~ #L@ ¤ ¡/1M4¤9 @C>3>3B8ML@C[cP39U$G @C[5KF7576c@ 6:9
96$@bF
MCG 6:PS9©UD9?XM@CFKU8-6:M 4 @.1C9 6:BD@C[6:@C23F79_@C>3>3B8M 4S574 @ 6:9_@CF7XMB8576:PS4TU 6:PA@ 6 UDMF 9_[©MC4T>3F7904
2HMC6:P
¢YZ9©4¤>3U 6:9©BV96-@CF ¡^- " ¤ ¤-©CMB8;A@C=?96-@CF ¡Z- "H"H"-©C9©2A@CBD@- }C~~ #L@ ¤ ¡
>3B8M23FK94TU
03[cP MCGV6DP39 [©0SBDBD9=L6 9©=L6:P 03U85E@CU84U 6:9©4¤U GIB8M4@ XBD9©@b6B89©[©9=L6 6:BD57034¤>3P 57= 4T@C[cP35K=S9
R
6 C9©[6DMB 4T@C[cP357=39 O /P7RTS ¢ MCUD9©B-96 @CF ¡^- "H" } - MB86D9©U-@C=3; P @C>3=35Z1 -
FK9©@CBD=S5K=3X3-36DP39$UD03>3>HMB
"H" G -P @C>S=35d1]- "" B - B85KU 6:5E@b=35K=35]@C=3; /1PA@ ¥ 90/ N @^RFKMB8- }C~~~¥¤ ¡ N M?03=3;S9©BDU 6c@C=S; 6:PS9 UD5KXC=357G /
6:PS9 /QP!R - ¥ 9 U8P3M03F7;j6:@51C9 @!2SBD5K9G F7M1M51 @b6 6:PS9?J39©FK;j>3B85KMB6DM 5 6:U ;357UD[©M C9©B8^ ¡
5K[©@C=3[9SGW@C=3;+/R4TMFK@- }b~~L}¥¤ -pFE@CB8X9 4 @bBDX57=§[©FE@bUDUD5 JA[@ 6:5KMC= ¢P @C>3=S5d1]- "H" B¥¤ -
XBDM ¥ 5K=SXa;A@ 6c@ BD9©>HMU8576:MCBD5K9U ¢\%FK@b6D69- "H"H"- ©CML@C[cP3574TU8- "H" B¥¤ ¡
>3BD@C[6D576:57M=39BDU6:M$9¦b@CF70A@b6D9V9¦9B_/
=SMC6:P39BZ5KU"6:M_57=3[©B89@CU89 6:P39 [©M4¤>3FK9 41576 ^