final version - Columbia University

6:M¤;A@b6c@¤UD96:UZ[M4T>SBD5KU89©; MCG b@CBD5K@C23F790/ F79©=3Xb6:P_U86DBD57=3XU9-¤9[6DMBDUZMbG%BD9©@CFp=R0S42 9BDU8-
X9=39©BD@CFK5Zc©9
=396 ¥NMBM1 U ¡ M=3U89©Q 039©=L6DF7^$-S403[cP B89©[9©=L6 ¥ MB21 P3@CU GIMR[©0SUD9©;TM= 6:P39";39¦C9©F7M>34¤9©=L6
6:B89©9UN@C=S;
6c@b6D5KU 6:5K[©@CF @C=3;T[©M4¤>30S6:@b6:57M=A@CFS4T96:P3MR;3U6:PA@b6N@CB89-[©@C>A@C23F79-MbGs;3BD@ ¥ 57=3X 57=SGI9©B89©=3[9©U GIBDM4
MCGdU
UD96:U ¡
FE@bBDX9.-3P396D9©B8MX9©=S9©M03U"2357MFKMXC5K[@bFH;3@b6c@
P39©=S[©9 ;3BD@ ¥ 5K=SGI9BD9=3[©9UaGIBDMC4 ;35 C9©BDU89T6 ^R>H9©UMCGW;A@b6c@ ¡ e 1b9©B8=39©F 4T96:P3MR; B89©>3B89©U89©=L6:U
@C=3;
;3@b6c@_M2 ¤89[6DUa2L^ 03U85K=3X3BD@C[6D5K[95-S6DP35KUV4¤9@C=SU
6:P3@b6
[MFKF79©[6:5KMC= MCG¡ M2 ¤89[6:U [@C=2H9U80 ¢¤[©5K9=L6:F7^3B89©UD9=L6:9©; R5E@T@C=¢ '/ 2L^Q/£ 4T@b6:B85^4
6:P3@b6@
5KU89 1b9©B8=39©F b@CFK039U ¡ N P35KU 1C9BD=39FO4T@b6DBD5^4-3PS9©=3[95-H>3BDM R5K;39U @ UDMCB86-MCG=3MCBD4T@CF GIMB84 I
MCG]>A@C5KB¥
@CUW@ b@CF75K; 1C9©B8=39©FsGI0S=3[6D5KM=_[©@C=?2 9;39JA=39;H95-S6DP39©=SBD9©U89©=L6:9; @CU-@ 1C9BD=39FO4T@b6DBD5^4 ¡ C 9BD=39FO4¤96DP3MR;3U @bBD9a@CFKXMCBD576DP34¤UN6:PA@ 6
;A@b6:@TU896-[@C=
M='1C9BD=39Fp4 @b6DBD57[©9©U8-3B:@ 6:P39B 6DPA@C=?M=?6:P39 BD@ ¥);A@b6:@ MC2 ¤89©[6:U 6:P394TU89©F C9©U¦¡
M>H9©BD@b6:9
^!G @CB$6DP39 2H9©U 6M/ 1R=SM ¥ = 1b9©BD=S9©FN4¤96DP3MR; 5KU 6:P39 UD03>3>HMB 6 9[6DMB4T@C[cP35K=S9TO /P!RTSa@CF^/
¢ MUD9B 96@CF ¡Z- "" } -IP @C>3=35Z1]- "H" B - BD57U86D5E@C=357=35d@C=S; /1PA@ ¥ 90/ N @^RFKMB8- }C~C~~ ¤ ¡ N P39
XMB8576DP34
UD03>H9©BR5KUD9; [©FE@bUDUD5 JA[@ 6:5KMC= @CF7XMB8576:PS46:PA@ 6ZFK9©@CBD=SU 2L^ 9 4S@C4T>SFK9 6:M ;357UD[BD5K4¤5K=3@b6:9
/P7R5KU-@
6 ¥ M MBW4¤MBD9 X5 C9©=_[©FK@CUDU89©UVMCG ;A@ 6c@ ¡ ¡ 5 6:P357= [©M4¤>30S6:@b6:57M=A@CFH2357MFKMXb^$-1/P!RH95- @b=3; 6:PS9 1C9BD=39FS4T@b6:B85K[©9U]40SU862H9N[M42357=39©;@CFKX923B:@b5K[@bFKF7^ ¡ MBO9 4S@C4T>SFK95-
9@b[cP
RFK57;35KUD=0E 5A¥¤T03U89©;!6:P357U @C>3>3B8ML@C[cP 6:M3B89©U8UD5KMC= ;A@b6:@ @b=3;
\]@
>3B8MCJAF79©U 5K=!@C= 03= ¥ 9©5KXCP 6D9©; G @bUDP357M=U-p@C>3>SF7^R5K=3X?4T@b6:PS9©4T@b6:57[@CFOM> 9B:@b6DMBDUZ6DM
>3PL^RFKMXC9©=396:5K[
/P7R M= ¥ 576DP35K=/ ;A@b6:@L/ U896[©MCBDBD9FE@b6D5KM=SU@C4TMC=3XGI9@b6D03BD9U ¥ P357FK9 5KXC=3MBD57=3X[©MCBDBD9FE@L/
GIMR[©03U6:P39
2 96 ¥N99©= ;A@b6:@-U896:U ¢\O@ RF75K;357UO96%@CF ¡Z- }C~~E - }C~~L}¥¤ ¡ e =03= ¥ 9©57XPL6:9©; U8034wMCG]1C9BD=39FKUPA@bU
6:57M=3U
GI03FKF ^ 57= 6:P39 >3BD9;35K[6:5KMC= MCG >3BDMb6:9©57=/ >SBDMC6D9©5K=T5K=L6:9B:@C[6:57M=3U ¢ 9=/ W"03B
@CF7UDM2H9©9=SGN96 @CF ¡^- ""H" ¤ >3B8M 157;39¤@SBD5K=S[©5K>SFK9©;§4¤9@b=3U6:MSBD9©U89©=L6
;S96:9[6D5KM=U-36:@C=3;394 4T@CUDUVU8> 9[6:B8M4¤96:B ^SFK5K[5K=3X
=TMCBD;39B6:M$@C>3>3F ^ @C=T/P7R 6DM$@ PS96:9BDMXC9©=39M03U ;A@b6c@U896 -Q1b9©BD=S9©FKU40SU862H9";S9JA=39;¤GIMCB
\
@C=3;b6-MC23FK9.- }C~~AG ¤ ¡